Latest / Property Investment & Wealth Creation Australia | The Michael Yardney Podcast / The Truth Behind 15 Popular Property Investment Claims | Dorian Traill
Transcript
- 0:00Imagine being told that an area has a housing shortage,
- 0:02or the vacancy rate is low, or a new train line is coming,
- 0:05and the property that you're going to be looking at is below market.
- 0:08Now these sound reassuring, which is exactly why they work so well,
- 0:12but over the years I've watched many hard- working Australians hand over their
- 0:16deposits on the strength of words like these,
- 0:19and plenty of them are still waiting for their property investment to perform.
- 0:22Today we're going to translate the marketing language that gets used on property investors
- 0:27into what it actually means in practice.
- 0:29So by the end of today's episode,
- 0:31you're going to know how a vacancy rate could mislead you,
- 0:34why a new housing estate can look like it's growing strongly when established homes
- 0:38nearby haven't moved, or what a rental guarantee really could cost.
- 0:42Now you're going to hear a brand new sales pitch that's now come out after
- 0:46the 2026 budget that the Spruikers are starting to come up with as well,
- 0:51but I don't think many investors have picked up on yet.
- 0:54And you're going to finish with a handful of simple questions that
- 0:56you can ask before you sign anything,
- 0:59which could save you years of frustration and a lot of money.
- 1:02My guest today is Dorian Traill,
- 1:04Senior Wealth Planner at Metropole.
- 1:06And a conversation he recently had with an investor prompted this episode.
- 1:10He asked me to bring it up to you and that's what we're doing.
- 1:13Hi, I'm Michael Yardney and welcome to the Michael Yardney podcast.
- 1:17And you probably as a regular know that after 50 years of investing,
- 1:21I know how easy it is to be distracted by these confident predictions
- 1:26or these impressive numbers. And that's why twice a week I share with
- 1:29you strategies and conversations that help you make better decisions
- 1:33and build your wealth safely. So let's get on with the show.
- 1:41Dorian, welcome back to the podcast.
- 1:43Thank you, Michael. Always a pleasure to be here.
- 1:45Well, we chat regularly and you were discussing a client conversation
- 1:50you had recently that led to the discussion we're going to have today.
- 1:54Tell us what happened.
- 1:55Well, this was a an interesting situation because the clients had come to
- 1:59us for some advice. They were bit confused with where to get advice
- 2:03and where they could find a trusted source.
- 2:05and their background was that they had come over from the UK around eight years ago.
- 2:11they didn't really understand how the Australian property market worked.
- 2:14They didn't know they didn't have a group of advisors around them
- 2:16to get accurate and trustworthy information and were
- 2:20were a little bit stuck.
- 2:21A lot of people seem to be stuck and it's not just beginning investors.
- 2:24We find a lot of intelligent people, successful people, professionals,
- 2:29doctors, engineers, business owners end up buying poor investment properties
- 2:33or making in retrospect, silly investment decisions.
- 2:37Why is that happening?
- 2:38Well, a lot the time they're time poor and they're they really want a done
- 2:42for you solution. So they go to usually some show or webinar
- 2:47or seminar or something like that,
- 2:48and they get excited by the bright lights.
- 2:50they're used to being competent in their own field,
- 2:52they assume that they'll be able to spot a bad deal if it comes up.
- 2:55and they tend to trust people who are similar professionals or look like similar profess similar professionals.
- 3:01and who are able to articulate and use the financial language
- 3:04and property language to come across as being credible.
- 3:07the marketeers who do this sort of stuff have very slick presentations.
- 3:11they use a lot of sales tools where they encourage scarcity in the marketplace,
- 3:17you know, only three left to buy,
- 3:19urgency, buy before rates fall, social proof.
- 3:22Our clients have bought, 500 properties in the in the
- 3:25in this particular development.
- 3:26they have a lot of awards, they have a lot of you know slick advertising stuff that
- 3:30makes them look really good. interesting one at the moment is that a
- 3:33lot of there's a couple of groups that are trying to sell off the plan stuff
- 3:37in Brisbane who are advertising it as take advantage of the Brisbane Olympic boom,
- 3:42which is a bit ironic because they probably missed the timing in the market anyway.
- 3:46Mm.
- 3:46and newcomers in the Australian market are especially exposed because they don't
- 3:50know the difference between a licensed advisor,
- 3:52a buyer's agent or a salesperson with a an investment consultant title
- 3:57who in most of these guys don't actually have a license.
- 3:59They don't need to.
- 4:01Well, that's right. A financial planner needs special
- 4:04licensing to give advice, but not so in real estate.
- 4:07you can get a subagents or agents representative license with just
- 4:11a weekend course in some states.
- 4:13And so therefore you don't really need to understand about investment.
- 4:18you just have to understand how to make a property transact.
- 4:21So it's important, I think, to understand where these people that you're getting advice from sit.
- 4:26in the hierarchy. W what's a question investors should be asking first
- 4:31to get an idea of what these people actually do that you're getting advice from?
- 4:35First question is who pays? that's always the
- 4:37That's a good one.
- 4:38yeah, absolutely. At the end of the day, somebody is paying
- 4:41Mm-hmm.
- 4:42this person for their advice.
- 4:44Now, if you're not paying as a as a out of your own pocket,
- 4:48then somebody is, or they're they wouldn't be in business,
- 4:51they wouldn't be able to operate.
- 4:52and a lot of these free property advice groups are actually being funded
- 4:57by the developer's commission.
- 4:59which makes it a sales process.
- 5:00The investor usually pays that commission indirectly through higher purchase prices.
- 5:05a lot of the commissions on these transactions are very rarely disclosed.
- 5:08Some of them are really big. generally speaking,
- 5:11the worse the property is, the bigger the commission is to the sales people
- 5:15to encourage them to sell the property.
- 5:17Yeah.
- 5:18and the advisors are paid by the developers.
- 5:22They don't necessarily want to sell you the best property.
- 5:24They just want to sell you whatever is on their stock list.
- 5:27and that may just be one, that might be a group of house and land packages
- 5:31in various different locations.
- 5:32It might be just one development in a high-rise market.
- 5:35You just don't know because you d you don't get to see their entire stock list.
- 5:39but the simple the simple answer,
- 5:41the simple question to ask is how are you being paid and by whom?
- 5:44if we buy a property and
- 5:45if they hesitate or try and deflect the question or something like that,
- 5:50then you gotta have a good hard look at it and s and say,
- 5:52well, what are you trying to hide?
- 5:53Somebody recently told me about a seminar just recently on the Gold Coast where
- 5:57there were lots and lots of investors,
- 5:59hundreds, and they sold out a whole new development on the Gold Coast.
- 6:03Now, I'm not saying if it's a good or bad investment,
- 6:05but it's couldn't be that everyone in the room,
- 6:08at various levels in their journey,
- 6:10some beginners, some who may have had a number of investments,
- 6:13some coming close to retirement,
- 6:15that particular investment complex in that particular location.
- 6:21could have suited everybody. And then of course,
- 6:24if it's only investors who are there,
- 6:26imagine what the owners corporation meetings are going to be like when things
- 6:30go wrong and you've got to pay money or when all the properties come on
- 6:33the market at the same time. So they thought they were getting free advice
- 6:36and well it wasn't. There was a big cost that's come to it.
- 6:40And some of them probably won't realize it until when they eventually come
- 6:43to settle this off the plan property and maybe it doesn't work out like
- 6:47They think. So, what I'd like to talk to you about now is just some of the words that
- 6:53are used in marketing. Again, there are some very good professionals
- 6:57out there l looking after investors,
- 7:00and we don't want to belittle them,
- 7:03but let's talk about some of the ways that investors can get a bit bamboozled.
- 7:08And vacancy rates are often used.
- 7:10At the moment, they're saying vacancy rates are so low they're less than 1%.
- 7:15So that means your rent's going to go up.
- 7:17What would you say to that, Dorian?
- 7:19Generally speaking, and when we're talking about property spruikers
- 7:23and in particular the ones who are not necessarily doing the right thing,
- 7:27and as you mentioned a minute ago,
- 7:28there's a whole bunch that are doing the right thing,
- 7:30and there's a b there's a bunch that aren't.
- 7:32So we don't want to taint everybody with the same brush.
- 7:34But and I've seen examples of this in my own eyes.
- 7:37I mean, I went to one about ten years ago when there was a construction boom in
- 7:42In Brisbane and a lot of high rises were coming out of the ground.
- 7:44I went to a launch of one of these and the they were running through
- 7:48the numbers for how the development was going to work.
- 7:51And the marketer or marketeer group turned around and said that
- 7:56in this particular high rise, the Brisbane vacancy rate is below three percent.
- 8:01So that's that's normal, that's great,
- 8:02that's you know, that that'll mean it'll be easily rented.
- 8:05I was thinking about that for a minute and I thought,
- 8:07well, hang on a minute. I know this area.
- 8:09I knew that the vacancy rates were a lot higher than that.
- 8:11And I my impression was they were more like five and a half to six percent.
- 8:15So I did a quick search on one of the tools we use,
- 8:18and I was right, the vacancy rate was over five and a half percent.
- 8:22But you had to listen carefully to what he said.
- 8:25He didn't talk about the vacancy rate for this type of property
- 8:29in this particular location. He said
- 8:32the Brisbane average. So he lumped everything in Brisbane together
- 8:35and said it's under three percent when it was if you look at a specific property,
- 8:40it was a it was considerably higher.
- 8:42And they're the sort of things that you need to try and pick up when
- 8:45you when you're going through these guys because they're not they're
- 8:48not necessarily lying as such,
- 8:49but they're not giving you the whole truth.
- 8:51That's a good way of putting it.
- 8:53That's correct. So they're not lying,
- 8:55but they leave out bits. So the relevant vacancy rate really is
- 8:59for that property type because it's different for houses,
- 9:01for units, for townhouses, and what is it in that suburb or that street
- 9:06or that estate at the time? another thing that property marketers
- 9:10are talking about is, hey, there's a construction boom here.
- 9:14Look at all the cranes. That's proof that the area is booming.
- 9:18But what does that phrase tell investors,
- 9:20Dorian? Construction boom is a considerably different thing from a capital growth boom.
- 9:26Now, what investors want is the word boom,
- 9:29but associated with capital growth.
- 9:31When it comes to a construction boom,
- 9:34and these there are examples of this in Brisbane,
- 9:36Sydney, Melbourne, Perth, they're all over the place.
- 9:38And they're generally areas where there's a hell of a lot
- 9:41of development happening in usually inner city locations,
- 9:44and a lot of developments are happening all at the same time.
- 9:47Now the word construction boom, the word construction is the part that worries me.
- 9:52That generally means that they're gonna there's gonna be a lot of development
- 9:55in the area and that will mean a lot of new supply coming on to hit the market.
- 9:59And that will generally oversupply a particular segment,
- 10:03which is such as apartments coming off the plan,
- 10:05and can hold back both rents and values for years.
- 10:08And we've seen this over and over again in those sorts of locations.
- 10:12We saw it in Brisbane.
- 10:13Ten years ago we saw it in Melbourne,
- 10:14in Docklands, in South Bank,
- 10:17where there was an oversupply of properties and a lot of people there
- 10:21was actually it was a terrible flow on effect because a whole bunch were bought
- 10:24originally and some people's circumstances had changed and when
- 10:28the development finished, some of them had to sell it 'cause they couldn't afford
- 10:32it anymore. But they were now competing with secondhand properties against
- 10:36the building next door, which was still building new stuff.
- 10:39And so they had to discount the price to sell a secondhand property
- 10:43in that situation. And that caused the valuations in the next building to
- 10:47go down as well. So when they were finished,
- 10:50they were undervaluing and people had to tip in more money or they risked being
- 10:55in default of the contract as well.
- 10:56So an oversupply of construction can be an absolute disaster for
- 11:00for an entire market. I mean, think of a
- 11:02Think of a high-rise apartment where maybe 200 apartments have been sold
- 11:06to investors. They're all finished at once.
- 11:09All the properties are being rented or being advertised for rent
- 11:12at the same time. Tenants have a choice of one of 200 properties.
- 11:16I mean, first one at the bottom
- 11:16Yep. Okay. wins. It's you know, i how do you get a tenant in there?
- 11:21and a lot of these a lot of these situations are solved by developers putting in
- 11:27Rental guarantees and rental guarantees are usually valid for either
- 11:32the first 12 months or the first tenant,
- 11:35whichever is the shorter. So if a tenant goes in there and rents for six months,
- 11:40then that's it. It comes back to market rate.
- 11:42And depending on how many are still vacant,
- 11:44you're you've now got a secondhand property competing against new ones.
- 11:47And of course, the developer puts the cost of the rental guarantee
- 11:50and the marketing into the cost of the property.
- 11:53Now, people should understand that salespeople and marketers have got a role
- 11:58in this world. We've got no issue about it,
- 11:59but they should be transparent with whom they're working for.
- 12:03And you don't always know what their commissions are,
- 12:05just like you don't know what the car salesman is going to make when he sells
- 12:09you a car. But we see it because we get
- 12:11Promotions all the time, don't we? On our inboxes saying,
- 12:14hey, at Metropole, you've got lots of clients.
- 12:16We're prepared to give you twenty,
- 12:18thirty, forty, fifty thousand dollars just to refer a client across to
- 12:22buy one of our properties. So the commissions that are built into the cost
- 12:27of a lot of the new developments are huge.
- 12:29But then investors are hearing,
- 12:30hey, there's a housing shortage.
- 12:32So I can't go wrong. What do you think about that?
- 12:36A national housing shortage is it's a great background,
- 12:39isn't it? It's a it's a wonderful story.
- 12:40It's it's it's something that the new newspapers love to report on,
- 12:43especially when they're beating up the politicians who aren't doing anything about
- 12:46it. So but in on the grounds,
- 12:49buyers and tenants choose properties in their in their local market,
- 12:53which is one of the interesting side effects of the recent budget changes
- 12:57because a lot of now that now if
- 12:59investors want to get negative gearing on a property,
- 13:00they have to buy a property that's adding to supply.
- 13:02So they're pushing out for the outer suburbs into the greenfield projects.
- 13:06But that's not necessarily where tenants want to live.
- 13:09so by doing that, they're actually building a lot more rental properties
- 13:13in the wrong places and they're they're you know they're
- 13:16not necessarily where people want to go. you need
- 13:18Well, others are saying things like, hey, this is a high capital growth area.
- 13:21I think this is one of the most common phrases in property marketing.
- 13:25What's wrong with that?
- 13:26High capital growth is another one where you need to look at
- 13:30the underlying real estate, not the new development.
- 13:33And we see this time and again in the greenfield suburbs where if you look
- 13:38at an established property in that area,
- 13:40and we'll we'll leave the new stuff out of the way for a minute,
- 13:43there's an established three-bedroom house in that area,
- 13:46the growth might have happened in the area because of the house and land sales
- 13:50of the new stuff.
- 13:51But the $300,000, because the new stuff might be selling for five
- 13:54or six hundred thousand dollars.
- 13:56So it affects the median house price fairly significantly once a couple
- 13:59of sales are done. And that's when they turn around and go,
- 14:02the area's gone up by 50% in the last 12 months.
- 14:04Well, no, it hasn't, because the underlying existing three-bedroom house that
- 14:09is not in the new development may not have changed at all.
- 14:12It's it's an artificial figure.
- 14:14So you need to look at how
- 14:16the capital growth is happening in the area to the existing properties,
- 14:19not without being influenced by the new stuff.
- 14:22So a better question really is what's the capital growth in this location over
- 14:26the last twenty years for this type of property that's on offer?
- 14:30But in newer estates, as you say,
- 14:32there's a bit of a trap because newer homes are built,
- 14:35more expensive homes are being built,
- 14:37so they're selling for more, but that doesn't necessarily mean that
- 14:41the capital growth through established properties has moved at all,
- 14:45as you suggested. And with the new tax rules,
- 14:48in fact, in those areas
- 14:50where people are chasing tax benefits,
- 14:52or some investors are, secondary sales of properties if they have
- 14:56to sell suddenly aren't new anymore and that will put a dampener on prices
- 15:00as it limits the potential purchasers.
- 15:03Yeah, absolutely. And this is one of the big concerns that we've got with
- 15:06the change in the budget rules is that properties that were built specifically
- 15:11for the investment market, and that could be anything from,
- 15:14you know, student accommodation duplexes in outer suburbs with high rental
- 15:19yields, it could be just a fairly cheap constructed investment house.
- 15:25All of those types of properties don't appeal to owner occupiers.
- 15:28So now that no investor or very few investors are looking
- 15:31to buy established properties,
- 15:33there's no real resale market for that sort of stuff.
- 15:36So if you're buying something that is you know built for investment,
- 15:40not to be confused with an investment grade property,
- 15:43then you may have a real problem trying to resell it.
- 15:46And as we've touched on before,
- 15:47if you go to resell property
- 15:49A an investment property or a house that's been built in one
- 15:52of these greenfield areas, it's now a secondhand property.
- 15:56And if you bought a house and land package for $800,000,
- 15:59as soon as a tenant moves in, it's secondhand.
- 16:01If you if something goes wrong and you have to sell it within a year or two,
- 16:05and they're still developing all the suburbs around it,
- 16:08why would somebody pay $800,000 for a secondhand property when they can still
- 16:12buy a new one a couple of streets away for $800,000?
- 16:15So I want to make it clear that we're not suggesting that established properties
- 16:20are bad investments. It depends where they are located.
- 16:23So if they're located in the inner and middle ring suburbs where there's
- 16:27a wide demand from owner occupiers who aren't chasing the tax benefits.
- 16:32But actually chasing the benefit of living in an area with good amenity,
- 16:37with walkability, with good schools.
- 16:39those established properties, th there's always a strong market for those.
- 16:43Yes, absolutely. The problem is if you have to sell one in an area where they're
- 16:48still doing developments and it's because you're a secondhand property competing
- 16:51with new properties at the same price bracket,
- 16:53how much do you have to discount the property to make it saleable in the new market?
- 16:57And that's always a concern, particularly if they're if the capital growth
- 17:01is artificially manufactured because of the sales process,
- 17:05and there is no actually no growth there.
- 17:06Well,
- 17:07we've spoken a bit in the past about the most recent budget,
- 17:11which changed the rules for investors.
- 17:13We're not going to go into how that's changed it.
- 17:16Everyone who's listening to this would know.
- 17:18But I think what's come from it is new sales pitches that we're seeing
- 17:23on social media, on Instagram,
- 17:25TikTok. I'm seeing them. I'm getting them in my inbox as well.
- 17:28What are you seeing of some of these new sales pitches that the spruikers, the marketers are
- 17:34Sharing. Well, they're really a lot of these guys always come back to
- 17:39the negative gearing benefits.
- 17:40And in the short term, negative gearing is a fairly substantial thing,
- 17:44particularly for people who are in the top tax bracket.
- 17:47but after the budget there was other changes as well with SMSFs when they actually
- 17:52passed the legislation through the Senate,
- 17:54Eligible new builds remain exempt and keep both negative gearing and
- 17:58the 50% capital gains discount.
- 17:59But the predictable pitch here is that the government wants you to buy a new house.
- 18:03So buy the off-the-plan apartment or buy a house and land package
- 18:07in the outer suburbs. The catch is that the new build exemption
- 18:10is only available for the first investment purchaser,
- 18:14and subsequent buyers for the same property aren't eligible for negative gearing
- 18:19or the 50% capital gains tax discount.
- 18:21And that's come feeds back to that problem that we were talking about is
- 18:25Yes.
- 18:25that the tax advantage stays with the first buyer.
- 18:27If for some reason you have to sell that property in the future,
- 18:31is there actually a market for it?
- 18:32Because is it a place where owner occupiers are desperate to buy?
- 18:36And I would suggest that in most fairly large greenfield sites,
- 18:40the owner occupiers already bought new off the plan.
- 18:43so I think there'll probably be a very limited market,
- 18:45particularly in inner city high rise apartments where there's just there's more
- 18:49coming out of the ground that you can poke a stick at.
- 18:51So you've got to be very careful that you're not getting yourself into
- 18:54an investment that's gonna be very hard to move on in the future.
- 18:57Of course, tax implications are important and we're not going to give
- 19:01tax advice here, so you've got to speak with your advisor about it.
- 19:04But negative gearing or tax deductions for interest haven't disappeared.
- 19:10They've been deferred. So you can only claim a limited amount in the early years,
- 19:16but as rents go up as you're making more money in your properties,
- 19:20you can then eventually claim them,
- 19:22or when you sell the property.
- 19:24So Really what you've got to do is do all the sums and work out what is
- 19:28the end result and the return on your funds,
- 19:31the return on your money. And that's what I know you do as a wealth strategist
- 19:35and your team do at Metropole using very powerful software.
- 19:40So it's easy to have a gut feel that yes,
- 19:43the negative geared property is going to be better for me or the
- 19:46new property is going to be but when we put all those figures in,
- 19:50including stamp duty, including
- 19:52costs when selling and make realistic assumptions.
- 19:55Sometimes buying an established property in a good area with better capital growth
- 20:00is a better result for the investor than a new property,
- 20:04despite the fact that you've got negative gearing,
- 20:06Dorian. Yes, this is true. the concern,
- 20:09well, there's a couple of concerns regarding that at the moment.
- 20:12obviously it's without getting the negative gearing,
- 20:15it will cost a little bit more out of your own pocket.
- 20:17We don't
- 20:18Yes.
- 20:18know we don't know exactly how much because they haven't finalised that legislation
- 20:22yet. So we don't know which parts they're leaving in,
- 20:25which parts they're leaving out,
- 20:26and how it's how the rent is going to be taxed,
- 20:29combining it with your own individual income.
- 20:31So there's a few there's a few bits to play out in that.
- 20:34in that space. But if you're somebody with really good cash flow,
- 20:37and this often applies to people who are self-employed as well,
- 20:39there are there are mechanisms for buying perhaps in a company rather than
- 20:44in an individual's name. so the company gets the benefit of the negative gearing
- 20:47and then finding another income source to offset that as well.
- 20:51So there's there's more than once we know what the rules are,
- 20:54there's gonna be ways of maximizing what's there.
- 20:58and being able to buy good quality properties in the right areas with
- 21:02the right structures and still getting the advantage of the capital growth
- 21:06in the really good areas without necessarily having to go and buy
- 21:09a new property straight off the plan.
- 21:10So tax deductions won't make a bad investment a good investment.
- 21:15and when we look at how you make your money out of property,
- 21:18it's out of capital growth. And in fact,
- 21:20at the end, when you eventually retire or stop working or start living
- 21:24off your portfolio, most of your asset base isn't going to be the rent you've saved
- 21:28or the tax you've saved or the income you've got.
- 21:31It's actually going to be the tax-free capital growth that has happened.
- 21:35But as I was starting to say, you make your money out of capital growth,
- 21:38out of rental returns, out of deductions,
- 21:41and also using leverage. And we also like the concept
- 21:45of manufacturing capital growth.
- 21:47Now, if you haven't listened to the last episode I did with Dorian,
- 21:51he explained a number of ways in this new environment where
- 21:54you can actually manufacture capital growth through renovations
- 21:58or development and then all of a sudden get a lot of the tax benefits as well.
- 22:02So Wherever you're watching or listening to this,
- 22:04hey, if you don't subscribe, first of all click the subscribe or follow button
- 22:08and the automatic downloads button so you get our show regularly.
- 22:11But also go back to have a listen to the last chat with Dorian,
- 22:14who explains some of the options that are still available to investors
- 22:18at the moment. But if you'd actually like to have a chat with Dorian
- 22:21as a wealth strategist, I'll leave a link in the show notes.
- 22:24Go to metropole.com.au because the world is changing.
- 22:28The tax rules have changed, the financing has changed,
- 22:31but the fundamentals, the underlying fundamentals haven't.
- 22:35And there are other countries where the tax rules have changed where
- 22:38you can't get negative gearing.
- 22:40but property has been a great source of wealth for the people there as well.
- 22:45So Dorian. I'm gonna leave a link in the show notes so people can have a chat with you.
- 22:49But what else do you see spruikers pivot on?
- 22:52at the moment there's all those changes with SMSFs and they're suggesting people
- 22:57invest in commercial property.
- 22:58Now I've got a substantial commercial property,
- 23:00but it's not always appropriate for everybody, is it?
- 23:03No, it's not. And there are there are different risks when looking
- 23:07at commercial and obviously at the moment self-managed super funds
- 23:11are not allowed to borrow money to buy residential property.
- 23:14That was one of the changes that the Greens brought in when they brought in the
- 23:17legislation. An SMSF still can invest in property but without borrowing.
- 23:21But not a lot of people have a big enough super fund balance
- 23:25to really entertain that idea and whether that's an appropriate
- 23:29decision is another story as well because the rental yield on a property wouldn't
- 23:33be as much as what you would get on a share portfolio for example.
- 23:36So you would need to, with appropriate advice,
- 23:40we're not financial planners, with appropriate advice you could model that out,
- 23:43but I would think it's probably not worth the effort.
- 23:45From a commercial property point of view, the spruikers who specialise
- 23:50in self-managing super funds, yes,
- 23:51they the obvious avenue is come and buy a commercial or industrial property.
- 23:55But the problem with that stuff is that also comes with a lot of risk.
- 24:00Commercial properties, not all commercial properties are good.
- 24:03Some of them and you can see this at the moment,
- 24:05this is following on from COVID and a lot of retail sales going to online.
- 24:11You know, you can drive down old shopping precincts and have shop after shop after
- 24:15shop with For Lease signs on them that have been that way for years.
- 24:18Now If you buy a commercial property and it's the wrong type of commercial property
- 24:23and it's not desirable at the moment or not useful,
- 24:25and you lose the current tenant,
- 24:28it can take a very long time to put another one in there.
- 24:30And
- 24:31Yes.
- 24:31unless you have those sorts of buffers in place,
- 24:35then holding that property could be an extremely expensive hobby.
- 24:39That's not to say that it's some commercial properties are great
- 24:42in self-managed super funds, particularly
- 24:44for or can be great, obviously,
- 24:46again, financial planning advice.
- 24:47You know, some people who have their own business,
- 24:50perhaps buying a commercial property that they can run their business
- 24:53out of might be a something that's worth talking to their advisor.
- 24:56But a one-off investment as a commercial property in a self-managed superfund,
- 25:02I would be very nervous about.
- 25:04One of the other things I'm seeing is spruikers are coming up with,
- 25:07hey, we've got artificial intelligence powered suburb selection.
- 25:11We can actually tell you what's going to be a great investment because we use AI.
- 25:15But algorithms trained on price momentum,
- 25:19on days on market, on vendor discounting,
- 25:21on the recent prices, they all look at the rear vision mirror and they actually just
- 25:26in my mind automate the hotspot thing where they just keep
- 25:31pushing people into the same areas.
- 25:33And that's been happening in especially in regional markets where investors have
- 25:38driven prices above what the fundamentals would justify and locals aren't prepared
- 25:44to pay. So good data is valuable,
- 25:46but it needs to be combined with local knowledge and understanding.
- 25:49We've often spoken about the concept that property investment is part
- 25:53art and part science. So the science is the data,
- 25:56but the art is understanding
- 25:58What makes that particular property an investment grade property?
- 26:02What makes it scarce? I mean, if AI finds a particular street in Sydney
- 26:07is high value but it doesn't know that the properties on the north side have
- 26:11got magnificent views of the Sydney Harbor Bridge and the water,
- 26:14but the properties on the south side have got magnificent views of the houses
- 26:18on the north side that have got good views.
- 26:20And so it is not at this point yet able to differentiate it.
- 26:23So be careful of that particular spruiker claim as well.
- 26:28Another one is, hey, properties double every seven to ten years.
- 26:31And on average they do, but averages can't tell you,
- 26:36Dorian, whether a particular area or a particular property in that area
- 26:41is suitable for you.
- 26:42Yeah, and that's that's part of understanding the market.
- 26:45And I always find I always find it funny when you hear this all
- 26:48the time with property spruikers, and this comes back to the artificial growth
- 26:52in a in a particular area and they say,
- 26:54Well, you know, need to buy into this market because it's gone up sixty,
- 26:57seventy percent in the last, you know,
- 26:59five years. if it's already gone up fifty or seventy percent,
- 27:02then you've probably already missed the growth.
- 27:04I tend to find that you want to
- 27:06You want to get into a place that hasn't started growing rather than
- 27:09one that's gone a long way in the journey.
- 27:11And but you need to have a really good look at the property market.
- 27:14You need to find out how accurate their data,
- 27:16where their data's from, where's the starting point,
- 27:19and get them to produce independent evidence to substantiate the claim. historic averages don't as
- 27:25we've discussed, don't generally tell you when a particular property will double
- 27:29in value. because it has to do with supply and demand forces,
- 27:32it has to do what the government's doing,
- 27:34it has to do with how stable the market is,
- 27:37public sentiment, all those sorts of things,
- 27:39which can have a big effect on how quickly things go up and down.
- 27:43So you really want to test the purchase against holistic
- 27:46holding costs and a range of possible outcomes rather than
- 27:49one growth assumption because the markets generally don't repeat themselves word
- 27:53for word every market cycle.
- 27:55No, they don't. Now, you and I have both been investing in property for a long,
- 27:59long time and we've seen each generation of spruiker come up with its own products.
- 28:04I remember in the nineteen nineties when Gold Coast apartments were the big thing.
- 28:08Now there's no doubt that over the last decade or so the Gold Coast
- 28:13has become a very established market,
- 28:16not just a holiday location. And the Gold Coast has done well,
- 28:19even though at the moment the prices are falling because of overdevelopment.
- 28:23But in the nineties it was Gold Coast apartments that the spruikers came up with.
- 28:27Then there was mining town properties in the resources boom,
- 28:31NRAS properties, that's all disappeared.
- 28:33SMSF properties, and nothing wrong with buying a property in an SMSF,
- 28:37it suits you, but they were putting the wrong properties in there
- 28:41for the wrong people. So each time I've seen these,
- 28:44there was a unique and a time-limited opportunity.
- 28:47But many people who bought into these spruiker claims made little or no
- 28:51Capital growth. And in fact, I know some who've lost money.
- 28:54So the products change, but the tactics of scarcity,
- 28:58urgency, inflated yields, and borrowing credibility stay the same.
- 29:03So I think knowing this, and that's part of why we wanted to have this chat today,
- 29:08understanding this history will help investors recognize the next pitch.
- 29:13Of course, there's the other pitches we're hearing at the moment too.
- 29:17Dorian, where the doom merchants are coming out and saying there's going
- 29:20to be a crash. Now it's the people who said it for the last ten years
- 29:24and they were wrong. At the moment they are right.
- 29:27Property values are falling, but I can't see them crashing.
- 29:30The thirty percent or so predictions are unlikely to come about, are they?
- 29:35No, and I agree with you. I it look at the end of the day the budget
- 29:39has caused a lot of fear and apprehension in the marketplace,
- 29:42but they haven't fundamentally altered supply.
- 29:45And that's everything in property comes back to supply and demand.
- 29:48And what we have is too much demand and not enough supply.
- 29:52Just by limiting investors from buying existing properties and pushing them
- 29:56out into the new areas, that it doesn't change the fundamentals of the marketplace.
- 30:01And Two-thirds of buyers anyway are owner occupier buyers.
- 30:05So if you're looking for good quality property in owner occupied areas,
- 30:09then there's always going to be interest in those properties and
- 30:12and capital growth because they haven't fundamentally added to supply by
- 30:17in any of the budget measures whatsoever.
- 30:19So while we're having a period where the market is uncertain
- 30:24and people are sitting on their hands and not doing anything,
- 30:26Michael. we both think that's a fairly temporary measure
- 30:31and will probably sort itself out within six or twelve months because ultimately
- 30:35once the media gets onto the next exciting piece of news and
- 30:39all this stuff recedes into the background and owner occupiers start coming
- 30:43out again and buying and selling properties,
- 30:46we're gonna have a situation where the supply isn't there
- 30:49and there's still competition in the marketplace.
- 30:50So the long term drivers, the long I mean there's nothing
- 30:55There's nothing structurally wrong with the market to suggest it's gonna fall
- 30:59off a cliff. So I can't see why it wouldn't keep increasing when
- 31:02the market comes back to a bit of a normal public consumer sentiment.
- 31:04I agree with you. Only
- 31:06yesterday I was asked by a journalist from the Australian to give
- 31:10a summary because I've he said you've written thousands of articles,
- 31:13hundreds of thousands of words,
- 31:15and you've been through these cycles.
- 31:17Can you give me a summary, in short?
- 31:19And I said, Yes. Things get better slowly.
- 31:22That's what's always happened.
- 31:24this too shall pass, and it's never as bad as it seems.
- 31:28But I think the message we're trying to give today
- 31:30is get independent, conflict free advice from somebody who's paid by you,
- 31:36not by the vendor, the marketer,
- 31:38the seller. So if you'd like conflict-free independent advice,
- 31:42the team at Metropole has helped thousands of Australians grow,
- 31:45protect, and pass on their wealth.
- 31:47We're paid by our clients, never by developers.
- 31:49We don't have any properties to sell.
- 31:51And we always start by putting a strategic plan together and then helping
- 31:55you implement the plan. So while property is
- 31:57the vehicle, strategy's the driver, it's going to direct you.
- 32:01Go to metropole.com.au, I'll leave a link in the show notes, and
- 32:05get somebody like Dorian to help you plan to become the investor you plan to become.
- 32:10Dorian, thank you very much for your time.
- 32:12I hope listeners take from this conversation that they should actually slow down
- 32:17long enough to test the numbers,
- 32:20look behind the assumptions before
- 32:22they make any big decision. By the way,
- 32:24if you've got some benefit from today's show and you don't currently subscribe,
- 32:28please click the follow or subscribe button.
- 32:31But also do Dorian and me a favour and send the show to just one person
- 32:35who you think would get benefit from to hear Dorian's message of warning.
- 32:39Look forward to catching up with you again soon,
- 32:41Dorian. Thank you, Michael. I'll speak to you soon.
- 32:43Cheers.
- 32:50Each show I leave you a trivia question,
- 32:51a chance to win one of three books I give away every week.
- 32:55And everyone who enters at propertytrivia.com.au gets a free property report.
- 33:02Following on from my conversation with Dorian,
- 33:04the question: true or false? Under the 2026 budget changes,
- 33:08if you buy a brand new property as an investor and then you later sell
- 33:11it to another investor, that second investor can also negatively gear it.
- 33:16True or false? You
- 33:17can pass on the negative gearing benefit to a second investor.
- 33:20Go to propertytrivia.com.au, leave us your answer.
- 33:23Hey, it doesn't matter if you listen to the show a little bit late,
- 33:26your answer will still count.
- 33:38Today I'd like to take a look at seven things you can't control.
- 33:41And that may actually make your life a bit easier because you should only
- 33:46be focusing on things you can control and not on things you can't.
- 33:49So the first thing you can't control is time.
- 33:52One day you're going to wake up and realize there's not enough of it.
- 33:55So my suggestion is don't waste your time and energy on forced interactions with
- 34:00people you don't like. The second thing you can't control
- 34:02is other people's reactions. Never trade authenticity for approval.
- 34:06Trying to make everyone happy is a soul draining exercise that's only going to leave
- 34:10you empty. Instead, invest your energy in people that matter.
- 34:14The third thing you can't control is being richer than someone else.
- 34:17You're never going to be satisfied with more money.
- 34:20Money in itself is worthless. It's only valuable because it can
- 34:23get you something you want. Money is meant to be exchanged.
- 34:26So I suggest you use it to connect with people and invest in invaluable experiences.
- 34:33The fourth thing you can't control is you can't expect there to be a
- 34:35day when those who've hurt you suddenly show up and apologize.
- 34:38Holding onto anger is only prolonging your own pain and unhappiness.
- 34:42So I suggest you learn to forgive.
- 34:44You deserve your peace. The fifth thing you can't control is overthinking.
- 34:48Overthinking can create problems that aren't even there.
- 34:52So I suggest you focus your imagination on things that are brilliant
- 34:57and make you feel good. Of course,
- 34:59you can't control the world around you.
- 35:01When I was young, I wanted to change the world.
- 35:03Then I realized... The world changed when I did. And the last of the seven things that
- 35:07you can't control is your past.
- 35:09You can't restart the next chapter of your life if you keep reading the last one.
- 35:14No matter how dirty your past is,
- 35:17your future is spotless. So thank your past for all the lessons
- 35:20and acknowledge how it's strengthened you.
- 35:23So there are seven lessons, seven things to look at,
- 35:26things you can't control. So don't let them...
- 35:30take over your mind, instead concentrate on what you can control.