Latest / Kentucky Tonight / Kentucky Legislation on LGBTQ+ Youth
Transcript
- 0:12WELCOME TO "KENTUCKY TONIGHT."
- 0:13I'M RENEE SHAW.
- 0:16THANK YOU SO VERY MUCH FOR
- 0:17JOINING US.
- 0:18OUR TOPIC TONIGHT: KENTUCKY
- 0:19LEGISLATION ON LGBTQ+ YOUTH. THE
- 0:22KENTUCKY GENERAL ASSEMBLY
- 0:24RECESSED LAST THURSDAY AND WILL
- 0:25RETURN MARCH 29TH FOR TWO DAYS
- 0:27TO CONSIDER OVERRIDING ANY
- 0:28VETOES FROM GOVERNOR BESHEAR.
- 0:32BEFORE RECESSING, LAWMAKERS
- 0:33PASSED SENATE BILL 150. THAT
- 0:35BILL DOES SEVERAL THINGS.
- 0:38THAT WE'LL TALK ABOUT TONIGHT.
- 0:39IT BANS GENDER-AFFIRMING MEDIC
- 0:42CARE FOR TRANS YOUTH. IT ALLOWS
- 0:43TEACHERS TO USE A STUDENT'S
- 0:44GENDER PRONOUN AT BIRTH, EVEN IF
- 0:45THAT MEANS IGNORING THE
- 0:47STUDENT'S WISHES. IT BANS
- 0:49SCHOOLS PROVIDING INSTRUCTION OR
- 0:50PRESENTATION ON SEXUAL
- 0:53ORIENTATION, GENDER IDENTITY OR
- 0:54GENDER EXPRESSION WITH STUDENTS.
- 0:58AND IT KEEP SCHOOL BOARDS FROM
- 1:00ALLOWING TRANSGENDER KIDS FROM
- 1:02USING RESTROOMS, LOCKER ROOMS
- 1:03AND SHOWERS THAT ARE DIFFERENT
- 1:05FROM THEIR BIRTH sex. THE BILL
- 1:06GENERATED FIERCE, SOMETIMES
- 1:07ANGRY DEBATE IN
- 1:10FRANKFORT LAST WEEK WITH CRITICS
- 1:12APRILING THESE POLICIES WOULD
- 1:13HURT TRANSGENDER YOUTH AND LEAD
- 1:14TO MORE discusses. TO DISCUSS
- 1:17THAT BILL AND OTHER LEGISLATION
- 1:19AFFECTING THE LGBTQ+ COMMUNITY,
- 1:20WE ARE JOINED IN OUR LEXINGTON
- 1:20STUDIO BY: STATE SENATOR GEX
- 1:26WILLIAMS, A REPUBLICAN FROM VER
- 1:27CHRIS HARTMAN, EXECUTIVE
- 1:28DIRECTOR OF THE FAIRNESS CAMPAI
- 1:30RICHARD NELSON, FOUNDER AND
- 1:31EXECUTIVE DIRECTOR OF THE
- 1:32COMMONWEALTH POLICY CENTER. AND
- 1:34JACKIE MCGRANAHAN, POLICY
- 1:36STRATEGIST FOR THE ACLU OF KENT.
- 1:41WE CERTAINLY WANT TO HEAR FROM
- 1:43YOU tonight SEND US YOUR
- 1:44QUESTIONS BY TWITTER @KYTONIGHT
- 1:46SEND AN EMAIL TO KYTONIGHT@KET.
- 1:49OR USE THE WEB FORM AT KET.ORG/.
- 1:57OR YOU MAY SIMPLY GIVES US A ca
- 1:59AT 1-800-494-7605.
- 2:026 WELCOME TO ALL OF YOU.
- 2:03I KNOW YOU'RE STILL RECOVERING
- 2:05FROM A VERY ROBUST SESSION SO I
- 2:07THANK YOU FOR BEING HERE ON THIS
- 2:10VERY IMPORTANT CONVERSATION.
- 2:10I WANT TO BEGIN WITH YOU,
- 2:12SENATOR WILLIAMS.
- 2:12AT THE BEGINNING OF THIS SESSION
- 2:14THERE WAS LEADERSHIP WHO SAT IN
- 2:15THE SAME SEATS THAT YOU ALL ARE
- 2:17OCCUPYING TONIGHT WHO SAID THAT
- 2:18THIS WOULD BE A SESSION OF
- 2:20TWEAKING, THAT YOU WOULD LOWER
- 2:22THE PERSONAL INCOME TAX RATE
- 2:23AGAIN BY ANOTHER HALF PERCENT
- 2:25AND MAYBE DO DISASTER RELIEF,
- 2:28BUT WITH ALL THE EDUCATIONAL
- 2:29CONCERNS ABOUT LEARNING LOSS
- 2:30FROM COVID, ABOUT LITERACY
- 2:34PROFICIENCY, ABOUT DISASTER
- 2:35RELIEF, HOW DID THIS ISSUE RISE
- 2:37TO THE LEVEL OF PROMINENCE AND
- 2:40PRIORITY FOR THE
- 2:41REPUBLICAN-CONTROLLED
- 2:42LEGISLATURE AND WHY?
- 2:45>> WELL, I THINK IT'S PROTECTING
- 2:47CHILDREN, BUT I CAN TELL YOU THE
- 2:50BIGGEST CHUCKLE I GOT IN THE
- 2:52SENATE WAS SAYING AFTER 24 YEARS
- 2:53OF BEING OUT OF THE GENERAL
- 2:55ASSEMBLY THAT I ACTUALLY
- 2:56BELIEVED PEOPLE SAYING THAT
- 2:57NOTHING SUBSTANTIAL WAS GOING TO
- 2:58COME OUT OF THIS GENERAL
- 2:59ASSEMBLY BECAUSE IT NEVER
- 3:00HAPPENS THAT WAY.
- 3:01WE ALWAYS START OUT SAYING IT'S
- 3:04AN OFF-YEAR, WE'RE GOING TO
- 3:05TWEAK.
- 3:06IT CHANGES.
- 3:06AND I THINK THE OVERARCHING
- 3:08SUPPORT WAS THE COMPARE AND
- 3:09CONCERN FOR PARENTS AND
- 3:10CHILDREN, AND THAT'S REALLY THE
- 3:13PROTECTION OF CHILDREN WAS A PRY
- 3:17MYER PRIMARY FOCUS THAT PROCEEDS
- 3:18TO THE TOP IN THIS INSTANCE.
- 3:20THERE'S A NUMB OF THEY ARE
- 3:22THINGS WE DID BUT THAT WAS WHAT
- 3:23THE GENERAL ASSEMBLY WAS ABOUT,
- 3:25PROTECTING CHILDREN, PRESENTING
- 3:26THEIR PARENTS.
- 3:26>> WERE YOU HEARING FROM
- 3:29CONSTITUENTS AND YOUR OTHER
- 3:31COLLEAGUES, WE HEARD KENTUCKY
- 3:32PARENTS WERE TALKING ABOUT THESE
- 3:34ISSUES?
- 3:34IS THAT WHERE THE GROUNDSWELL
- 3:36CAME FROM?
- 3:36>> I THINK WHY YOU ENDED UP
- 3:38HAVING OVER 80% IN THE SENATE
- 3:40VOTING FOR IT AND OVER 75% IN
- 3:42THE HOUSE VOTING FOR THESE
- 3:43THINGS.
- 3:44THEY DON'T JUST COME DOWN HERE
- 3:45AND DECIDE TO VOTE ON THINGS
- 3:47THEMSELVES.
- 3:48THEY, LIKE ME, HEARD FROM THEIR
- 3:51CONSTITUENTS.
- 3:51>> SO I WANT TO GO TO YOU NOW,
- 3:56MR. HARTMAN.
- 3:56THERE ARE AGE MIMMS FOR LOTS OF
- 3:57ACTIVITIES, TO PURCHASE CAPITOL
- 4:00AND TOBACCO YOU HAVE TO BE 21,
- 4:0218 TO JOIN THE MILITARY.
- 4:0417 TO VOTE.
- 4:06THOSE ARE TO PROTECT MINORS FROM
- 4:09THE CONSEQUENCES OF ACTIONS THEY
- 4:10MAY NOT FULLY UNDER THE BREADTH
- 4:13OF.
- 4:13WHY ISN'T IT REASONABLE TO
- 4:15PROTECT KIDS FROM
- 4:17GENERAL-ALTERING SURGERIES AND
- 4:18TREATMENTS.
- 4:18>> FIRST OF ALL LET ME SAY
- 4:20SURGERIES ARE NOT HAPPENING AT
- 4:20LEAST UNDER THE AGE OF 18 AT
- 4:22LEAST IN COMMONWEALTH OF
- 4:23KENTUCKY AND WE DON'T SUPPORT
- 4:24THEM HAPPENING.
- 4:25IT'S SO DISINGENUOUS TO SAY
- 4:27SENATOR WILLIAMS SAY THIS WAS A
- 4:28SESSION ABOUT PROTECTING PARENTS
- 4:30BECAUSE ALL THEY DID WAS SUBVERT
- 4:32PARENTS' RIGHTS.
- 4:33KIDS GOTTEN TO DON'T MAKE THE
- 4:35DECISION TO PURSUE
- 4:38GENDER-AFFIRMING SURGERIES WITH
- 4:40THEMSELVES THEY MAKE THEM WITH
- 4:43PARENTS, IN CLOSE CONSULTATION
- 4:44WITH PHYSICIANS.
- 4:45IT'S WHY GENDER-AFFIRMING
- 4:47THERAPY IS APPROVED BY EVERY
- 4:49MAJOR U.S. MEDICAL ASSOCIATION.
- 4:50>> SO WHY, IF IT'S NOTE
- 4:52HAPPENING IN KENTUCKY,
- 4:54SENATOR WILLIAMS, WAS THERE A
- 4:55NEED FOR A LAW TO BAN IT?
- 4:56>> WELL, THE DRUGS ARE THE KEY
- 4:57PART OF IT.
- 4:59WE HAVE 30 OR 40 TRILLION CELLS
- 5:01IN OUR BODY AND THE DRUGS ARE
- 5:03BEING ADMINISTERED.
- 5:04THAT IS HAPPENING IN KENTUCKY.
- 5:06AND PARENTS, IF YOU WANT TO LOOK
- 5:09AT WHY THE NUMBER OF STUDENTS IN
- 5:11PUBLIC SCHOOLS IS DOWN NOW AS
- 5:13OPPOSED TO COVID, ONE OF THE
- 5:15REASONS IS PARENTS ARE CONCERNED
- 5:17ABOUT THIS.
- 5:20I HAVE A FOURTH GRADE PATIENT
- 5:21CHILD WHO WAS IN FOURTH GRADE
- 5:21WHO WAS ASKED BY THE NURSE HOW
- 5:24SHE IDENTIFIED.
- 5:25AND THERE WAS NO REASON FOR
- 5:28THAT.
- 5:28THE PARENTS TOOK HER OUT OF
- 5:29SCHOOL.
- 5:30AND THAT'S AN ISSUE.
- 5:31>> RENEE, I WOULD SAY THAT WHEN
- 5:33CHILDREN HAVE THE SUPPORT OF
- 5:35THEIR PARENTS, WHEN TRANS
- 5:37CHILDREN HAVE THE SUPPORT OF THE
- 5:38PARENTS, IT IS ABSOLUTELY THE
- 5:39PARENTS' RIGHTS AND THE CHILD'S
- 5:40RIGHTS, THE STUDENT'S RIGHTS TO
- 5:42HAVE THEIR GENDER IDENTITY,
- 5:45THEIR PRONOUNS, THEIR CHOSEN
- 5:46NAME RESPECTED IN THE SCHOOL
- 5:48ENVIRONMENT AND NOT DOING SO
- 5:49LEADS TO THAT INCREASED LEVEL OF
- 5:52DEPRESSION.
- 5:52AND UNFORTUNATELY SUICIDEALITIY
- 5:54THAT NONE OF THE SENATORS WANT
- 5:55TO TALK ABOUT OR GIVE ANY
- 5:58CREDENCE TO EVEN THOUGH IT IS
- 5:59WELL DOCUMENTED, SENATOR , AND
- 6:00YOU KNOW IT.
- 6:01>> WHAT I KNOW IS THIS BILL HAS
- 6:03NOT PASSED AND THE SUICIDE RATES
- 6:04HAVE BEEN INCREASING BECAUSE OF
- 6:06THE GENDER-CONFUSING CARE.
- 6:08THAT IS THE PROBLEM.
- 6:10IS GENDER-CONFUSING CARE, NOT
- 6:12AFFIRMING IT.
- 6:13IF YOU'RE AFFIRMING YOUR GENDER,
- 6:14YOUR AFFIRMING WHAT THE 30 OR
- 6:1740 TRILLION CELLS IN YOUR BODY
- 6:19SAY THAT YOU ARE AND WHEN YOU
- 6:20TRY TO FIGHT THAT WITH DRUGS OR
- 6:22ANY OTHER WAY, YOU'RE GOING TO
- 6:24END UP WITH PROBLEMS.
- 6:24>> WHEN I WAS GOING TO SAY IN
- 6:26THE BEGINNING IS IT ALSO BANS
- 6:30PUBERTY BLOCKERS FOR KIDS UNDER
- 6:30THE AGE OF 18.
- 6:32>> NOT COMPLETELY BECAUSE ARE
- 6:34THERE PREPUBESCENT ACTIVITY THAT
- 6:35WILL DELAY IT AND IT'S FDA
- 6:37APPROVED FOR SOME PERIOD OF TIME
- 6:38THAT.
- 6:39THAT'S PERMITTED.
- 6:39>> I WANT TO GO TO YOU RICHARD
- 6:41NELSON WITH THE COMMONWEALTH
- 6:42POLICY.
- 6:43YOU'RE ALSO A PRO INNOCENT OF
- 6:45SMALL GOVERNMENT AND LIBERTIES.
- 6:46>> ABSOLUTELY.
- 6:46>> HOE HOW DOES THIS BILL, THIS
- 6:48LEGISLATION NOT RUN AFOUL OF
- 6:49THOSE PRINCIPLES?
- 6:50>> GOOD QUESTION.
- 6:50I'M ALSO FOR -- I'M ALSO FOR
- 6:53PROTECTING THE WELL-BEING OF
- 6:56CHILDREN FOR THEIR BIOLOGICAL
- 6:57INTEGRITY, AND WE'RE TALKING
- 6:59ABOUT, TO TAKE IT LITTLE FURTHER
- 7:01THE POINT THAT YOU MADE, THERE
- 7:03ARE CERTAIN THINGS UNDER
- 7:05KENTUCKY LAW THAT WE DON'T ALLOW
- 7:06CHILDREN TO DO.
- 7:07THEY CAN'T GET A TATTOO UNTIL
- 7:1016, CAPITOL UNTIL THEIR 21,
- 7:12CAN'T VOTE UNTIL THEY'RE 18.
- 7:13THE REASON WHY WE HAVE THOSE
- 7:15LAWS IN PLACE IS BECAUSE THEY
- 7:17CANNOT CONSENT TO THINGS.
- 7:18THEY DON'T HAVE THE MENTAL
- 7:19CAPACITY TO UNDERSTAND THE
- 7:20DECISIONS THAT THEY ARE MAKING.
- 7:24THEIR FRONTAL LOBE IS NOT FULLY
- 7:25DEVELOPED UNTIL THEY'RE IN THEIR
- 7:28MID-20s.
- 7:28IT'S IMPORTANT THAT WE
- 7:30INTERCEDE, IF YOU WILL, FOR
- 7:31CHILDREN WHO ARE SUFFERING FROM
- 7:33GENDER FIS OVERPHORIA, AND WE
- 7:35NEED TO BE COMPASSIONATE TO
- 7:38THOSE CHILDREN, WHICH BY THE WAY
- 7:39GENDER DYSPHORIA JUST TO HAVE A
- 7:41DEFINITION WAS THIS IS WHERE THE
- 7:42MENTAL STATE IS INCONGRUENT WITH
- 7:45THE BIOLOGICAL REALITY, AND IT'S
- 7:47SOMETHING JUST A FEW YEARS WALK
- 7:4815, 20 YEARS AGO WASN'T AN
- 7:50ISSUE, CERTAINLY WASN'T IN THE
- 7:53MAINSTREAM AND BIEBER DATED.
- 7:55WE HAVE MANY CHILDREN SUFFERING
- 7:56FROM DYSPHORIA.
- 7:57IN THE SENATE CHILDREN AND
- 7:59FAMILIES COMMIT BY
- 8:00DETRANSITIONERS, TWO YOUNG GIRLS
- 8:01IN PARTICULAR SAID THAT THEY
- 8:02WENT THROUGH THE HORMONE THERAPY
- 8:06AND TRANSITION SURGERY AND THEY
- 8:07REGRETTED IT.
- 8:08NOT ONLY DID THEY REGRET IT, BUT
- 8:10THEY ARE SUFFERING PHYSICAL HARM
- 8:11FROM THE TRANSITIONS THAT THEY
- 8:12DID WHEN THEY WERE TEENAGERS.
- 8:14>> SO WE'LL COME BACK TO THAT
- 8:15POINT.
- 8:16DO YOU AGREE WITH THAT
- 8:17DEFINITION OF GENDER DYSPHORIA,
- 8:18THIS SIDE OF THE GROUP,
- 8:21MR. HARTMAN WHAT HE SAID?
- 8:23IS THAT THE CLINICAL DEFINITION
- 8:24THAT YOU ALSO UNDERSTAND?
- 8:25>> I DON'T AGREE WITH MUCH THAT
- 8:27RICHARD SAYS EVEN THOUGH WE GET
- 8:29ALONG WELL WITH ONE ANOTHER.
- 8:29I THINK IT'S MUCH MORE NUANCED
- 8:33THAN THAT.
- 8:34YOU'RE TALKING ABOUT BIOLOGICAL
- 8:36REALITIES.
- 8:36SEX IS A VERY COMPLICATED
- 8:38THING.
- 8:39IT'S NOT JUST VISIBLE BY THE
- 8:40EYE.
- 8:41THERE ARE SO MANY FACTORS,
- 8:43CHROMOSOMAL, HORMONAL FACTORS
- 8:44THAT GO INTO SEX.
- 8:45SO, NO, IT IS NOT AS SIMPLE AS
- 8:47RICHARD IS TRYING TO MAKE FOLKS
- 8:48THINK THAT IT IS.
- 8:49>> JACKIE MCGRANAHAN, I WANT TO
- 8:51COME TO YOU FINALLY.
- 8:53IT'S TAKEN JUST A MOMENT.
- 8:54TUT THE AC L.A. HAS MADE ITS
- 8:57POSITION AND STAKE ON THIS
- 8:59CLEAR, AND IT'S EVEN TALKED
- 9:00ABOUT POSSIBLE LEGAL ACTION
- 9:01SHOULD THIS BECOME LAW.
- 9:03TELL US THE OPPOSITION AND ARE
- 9:04YOU READY TO FILE A LAWSUIT?
- 9:05>> SO FIRST I WANT TO SAY THAT
- 9:09TRANSGENDER KENTUCKIANS AND
- 9:11TRANSGENDER PEOPLE ALL ACROSS
- 9:13THE COUNTRY HAVE ALWAYS BEEN
- 9:15AROUND.
- 9:15WHAT'S DIFFERENT NOW IS THAT
- 9:18TRANSGENDER PEOPLE ARE NOW MORE
- 9:20VISIBLE.
- 9:22AND, OF COURSE, WE AT THE ACLU
- 9:24OF KENTUCKY, WE COMPLETELY
- 9:26OPPOSE ALL OF THE LEGISLATION,
- 9:28ESPECIALLY SENATE BILL 150.
- 9:32AND ESPECIALLY THEY HEALTH CARE
- 9:34BAN IN SENATE BILL 150.
- 9:36AND OUR LEGAL TEAM, WE'RE
- 9:38RESEARCHING CURRENTLY TO SEE HOW
- 9:40THIS BILL IS GOING TO AFFECT
- 9:44TRANS CHILDREN AND THEIR
- 9:46FAMILIES, AND THEY'RE EXPLORING
- 9:48WHAT THE BEST PATH FORWARD IS
- 9:49FOR LITIGATION, AND THAT MAY
- 9:52MEAN ONE LAWSUIT OR IT COULD
- 9:54MEAN SEVERAL.
- 9:55>> WHY WOULD IT MEAN SEVERAL?
- 9:58>> BECAUSE THERE ARE SEVERAL
- 10:00UNCONSTITUTIONAL PIECES TO
- 10:03SENATE BILL 150 AND THE PORTIONS
- 10:04THAT WERE ADDED ON LAST MINUTE.
- 10:08AND WE AREN'T SURE WHEN, BUT THE
- 10:12ACLU WILL REMAIN COMMITTED TO
- 10:15TRANSGENDER FAMILIES AND
- 10:16ENSURING THAT TRANS YOUTH CAN
- 10:19ACCESS THE HEALTH CARE THAT THEY
- 10:20NEED.
- 10:21>> SO IS THERE A PARTICULAR AGE
- 10:24BY WHICH MR. HARTMAN, YOU THINK
- 10:26THAT IT IS TOO YOUNG FOR A CHILD
- 10:28TO UNDERGO ANY TYPE OF
- 10:31GENDER-AFFIRMING THERAPIES,
- 10:32WHETHER THAT'S MEDICATIONS OR
- 10:34SURGERY?
- 10:34>> WELL, WE'RE ALSO TALKING
- 10:35ABOUT GENDER-AFFIRMING THERAPY,
- 10:39WE'RE TALKING ABOUT MEANT HEALTH
- 10:41CARE, WE'RE TALKING ABOUT
- 10:43COUNSELING.
- 10:43I THINK THE MAJORITY PARTY I GO
- 10:45IN ORDER TO ONE OF THEIR OWN
- 10:46CAME BEFORE THE COMMITTEE TO
- 10:48TESTIFY, FORMER STATE
- 10:49REPRESENTATIVE JERRY MILLER WHO
- 10:52CAME TO SHARE THAT IT IS
- 10:52UNDENIABLE THAT HIS
- 10:53SEVEN-YEAR-OLD GRANDCHILD IS
- 10:55TRANSGENDER, AND THAT IS
- 10:56SOMETHING THAT IS APPARENT FROM
- 10:59AN INCREDIBLY EARLY AGE.
- 11:00AND GEN THIS IS IN
- 11:02CONSULTATION.
- 11:03YOU'RE WORKING NOT JUST WITH
- 11:05YOUR PUSHING BUT ALSO YOUR
- 11:08MENTAL HEALTH CARE PROVIDERS WHO
- 11:09ALL SUPPORT GENDER-AFFIRMING
- 11:11THERAPIES FORE TRANS YOUTH.
- 11:12S THERE IS NO EARLIEST AGE TO
- 11:14KNOW WHEN A CHILD IS TRANS, BUT
- 11:16YOUR DOCTOR AND YOUR MENTAL
- 11:18HEALTH CARE PROVIDERS AND YOUR
- 11:19PARENTS WILL KNOW WHEN IT IS
- 11:20RIGHT FOR A CHILD TO BEGIN SOME
- 11:22TYPE OF GENDER-AFFIRMING
- 11:25THERAPIES WHICH COULD INCLUDE
- 11:25WHAT YOU'RE REFERRING TO,
- 11:28PUBERTY REGULATORS OR HORMONE
- 11:29REPLACEMENT THERAPY.
- 11:29>> SO WE'VE GOT LOTS OF FEEDBACK
- 11:31COMING IN THIS EVENING AND I'M
- 11:33GOING TO TRY TO SHORTEN SOME OF
- 11:34THESE COMMENTS.
- 11:36THIS COMING FROM FRANKFORT.
- 11:38THEY LIVE IN YOUR DISTRICT,
- 11:41SENATOR WILLIAMS.
- 11:41THEY'RE A PUBLIC EMPLOYEE,
- 11:42HEALTH CARE PROFESSIONAL AND A
- 11:44PATIENT A TRANSGENDER CHILD.
- 11:45IN THE INTERESTS OF PRESENTING
- 11:45MY CHILD, THIS PERSON SAYS, I'M
- 11:48EXERCISING MY PARENTAL RIGHTS BY
- 11:49ACTIVELY MAKING PLANS TO LEAVE
- 11:51KENTUCKY AS QUICKLY AS POSSIBLE
- 11:52WHILE IT SADDENS US STOOD SO MY
- 11:55CHILD HAS BEEN SHOWN NOTHING BUT
- 11:57LOVE AND SUPPORT FROM HER
- 11:58FAMILY, FRIENDS AND COMMUNITY
- 11:59BUT WE WON'T LOSE ANY SLEEP OVER
- 12:00THE DECISION.
- 12:02THE KENTUCKY GOP SEEMS
- 12:03DETERMINED, THEY SAY, ONE WAY OR
- 12:05ANOTHER TO ELIMINATE TRANS KIDS
- 12:06IN KENTUCKY.
- 12:07SO ALLOW ME TO BE THE FIRST TO
- 12:09SAY CONGRATULATIONS.
- 12:10CAN YOU RESPOND TO YOUR
- 12:12CONSTITUENT.
- 12:12>> YES.
- 12:15QUITE FRANKLY, THE CONSTITUENTS
- 12:17THROUGHOUT THE STATE OF
- 12:18KENTUCKY, THIS IS THEIR
- 12:19POSITION.
- 12:20IT'S NOT THE POSITION THE
- 12:22GENERAL ASSEMBLY.
- 12:23IT'S THE POSITION OF THES VAST
- 12:25MAJORITY OF OUR CONSTITUENTS.
- 12:26NOW, THAT DOESN'T MEAN THERE'S
- 12:27NOT CONSTITUENTS LIKE HER THAT
- 12:29HAVE A DIFFERENT OPINION OF WHAT
- 12:29TO DO.
- 12:30BUT WE CLEARLY BELIEVE THAT WE
- 12:33ARE ON THE SIDE OF OUR
- 12:35CONSTITUENTS.
- 12:35AND THIS IS KENTUCKY VALUES.
- 12:38THAT'S WHAT WE ARE ESPOUSING.
- 12:41THAT'S WHAT WE'RE HEARING FROM
- 12:43OUR CONSTITUENTS.
- 12:44THAT'S WHAT WE WILL CONTINUE TO
- 12:45WORK ON.
- 12:45AND I'M SADDENED THAT SHE'S
- 12:48LEAVING KENTUCKY.
- 12:49IT FEELS LIKE SHE HAS TO.
- 12:50BUT WE HAVE TO GO WITH THE
- 12:52MAJORITY.
- 12:53AND WE ALL ARE DOING THIS
- 12:54BECAUSE WE LOVE THESE CHILDREN.
- 12:56WE LOVE HER CHILDREN.
- 12:57WE WANT TO CARE FOR HER CHILD.
- 12:59WE DON'T WANT TO SEE ANY
- 13:04KENTUCKY FACE A LIFETIME OF
- 13:05DRUGS TO FIGHT THEIR OWN BODY.
- 13:07>> MR. MR. NELSON WE DID HEAR ON
- 13:10THE FLOOR FROM THE HOUSE
- 13:11COMMENTARY ABOUT THIS THAT
- 13:12PEOPLE, NOT JUST TRANSGENDER
- 13:15FOLKS, WILL LEAVE KENTUCKY BUT
- 13:16FOLKS HOR SYMPATHIZERS WITH
- 13:18THEIR CAUSE AND THEIR POSITION,
- 13:20SO THIS COULD CAUSE AN EXODUS OF
- 13:22SORTS FOR KENTUCKY.
- 13:22ARE YOU CONCERNED ABOUT THE
- 13:24ECONOMIC IMPACT THIS COVET
- 13:25STATE?
- 13:25>> I REALLY DON'T THINK THERE'S
- 13:27AN ECONOMIC IMPACT.
- 13:28I THINK THE GREATER CONCERN
- 13:30SHOULD BE PLACED ON VULNERABLE
- 13:31CHILDREN WHO ARE SUFFERING FROM
- 13:33WHAT WAS ONCE CONSIDERED A
- 13:35MENTAL ILLNESS.
- 13:36WHEN THE MEDICAL COMMUNITY
- 13:39COOPERATES WITH MENTAL ILLNESS
- 13:39INSTEAD OF ADVOCATING FOR
- 13:41VULNERABLE CHILDREN, AGAIN, WE
- 13:43DID NOT ALLOW CHILDREN TO MAKE
- 13:45DECISIONS FOR THEMSELVES, SO,
- 13:48RENEE, WHEN THERE IS ANOREXIA,
- 13:50FOR EXAMPLE, THE PROFESSIONAL
- 13:53COUNSELING COMMUNITY HELPS THE
- 13:53YOUNG PERSON OR THE PERSON
- 13:55SUFFERING FROM ANOREXIA TO
- 13:58ACCEPT THE CONDITION OF THEIR
- 13:59BODY.
- 13:59THEY DON'T GO ALONG AND
- 14:01ENCOURAGE THEM AND SAY THAT
- 14:03THEY'RE OVERWEIGHT.
- 14:03THEY DON'T SAY YOU NEED TO GO ON
- 14:04A DIET.
- 14:05THAT IS NOT HELPING THE PERSON.
- 14:07THERE ARE OTHER MENTAL
- 14:09CONDITIONS WHERE IT'S IMPORTANT
- 14:10FOR COUNSELORS TO ADVOCATE FOR
- 14:12THEM TO HELP THE PERSON
- 14:15SUFFERING TO SEE THE TRUTH OF
- 14:16THE MATTER, AND THE TRUTH OF THE
- 14:18MATTER IN GENDER DYSPHORIA IS
- 14:19THAT THERE IS AN INSISTSY --
- 14:23INCONSISTENCY BETWEEN THE MENTAL
- 14:25STATE AND THE BIOLOGICAL
- 14:26REALITY.
- 14:26>> SO YOU'RE CALLING AT A MENTAL
- 14:28ILLNESS.
- 14:28>> WELL, AND THAT'S WHAT THE
- 14:30AMERICAN PSYCHIATRIC ASSOCIATION
- 14:31WAS CALLED IT UNTIL REASONABLE.
- 14:32THAT WAS IN THE DSM-5 UNTIL 2013
- 14:36I BELIEVE IT WAS WHEN THEY
- 14:37DOWNGRADED IT.
- 14:41THERE'S ANOTHER EXAMPLE, RENEE,
- 14:43AND I'M TRYING TO THINK OF THE
- 14:45TERM.
- 14:45IT'S A BODY DISASSOCIATIVE
- 14:47SYNDROME, I BELIEVE.
- 14:48IT'S WHERE SOMEBODY BELIEVES
- 14:50THEY HAVE A HEALTHY BODY PART
- 14:51THAT SHOULD NOT BE ON THEIR BODY
- 14:53WHETHER IT'S A HAND OR A FOOT OR
- 14:55A FINGER, AND THIS IS ACTUALLY A
- 14:59CONDITION, AND NO DOCTOR WOULD
- 15:00SAY, WELL, WE'RE GOING TO
- 15:02AMPUTATE.
- 15:03NO DOCTOR SHOULD BE ALLOWED TO
- 15:04PRACTICE MEDICINE TO SAY THAT.
- 15:06AND YET WE'RE TALKING ABOUT THIS
- 15:07WHEN IT COMES TO GENDER
- 15:11DYSPHORIA.
- 15:11WE HEARD TWO TESTIMONIES IN A
- 15:12SENATE COMMITTEE WHERE E. THERE
- 15:14WERE YOUNG GIRLS THAT HAD TOP
- 15:16SURGERY AND THEY'RE SUFFERING
- 15:17FROM IT TODAY.
- 15:18>> AND WE'LL HEAR FROM LUKA HAN
- 15:21ON THAT IN JUST A MOMENT.
- 15:22I DOUGH WANT TO GO TO YOU,
- 15:25MR. HARTMAN.
- 15:26>> FIRST IT DOESN'T SURPRISE ME
- 15:27THAT RICHARD IS STUCK A DECADE
- 15:29BEHIND THE LESS OF US.
- 15:30YOU CAN STAY THERE FOR ALL I
- 15:32CARE.
- 15:32WE'D LOVE TO YOU COME FORWARD AT
- 15:33SOME POINT IN TIME.
- 15:34THIS IS NOT A MENTAL ILLNESS.
- 15:36THIS IS A REALITY FOR FOLKS.
- 15:38AND I REALLY WANT TO QUICKLY SAY
- 15:40THAT SENATOR WILLIAMS HAS TOLD
- 15:41ANOTHER LIE TONIGHT.
- 15:43THIS IS NOT THE OPINION OF THE
- 15:45MAJORITY OF YOUR CONSTITUENTS OR
- 15:46THE REST OF THE STATE.
- 15:47THERE'S ONLY BEEN ONE POLL
- 15:50THAT'S BEEN DONE ON SENATE BILL,
- 15:5250 OR THE PROVISIONS OF WITHIN.
- 15:54IT WAS DONE BY MASON DIXON
- 15:56POLLING, AND THAT IS A 71-70 --
- 15:59HE DOESN'T WANT YOU TO HEAR THIS
- 16:01NUMBER -- 71% OF KENTUCKY VOTERS
- 16:04OPPOSE TO STATE GOVERNMENT
- 16:05OVERRULING PARENTS' RIGHTS TO
- 16:06OBTAIN TREATMENT FOR THEIR
- 16:08TRANSGENDER CHILDREN.
- 16:09SHOW ME A BETTER NUMBER.
- 16:10SHOW ME A DIFFERENT NUMBER.
- 16:12DID YOU DO A POLL?
- 16:14>> DAVID MEADE SHARED A POLL.
- 16:15IT SAID THIS --
- 16:16>> A NATIONWIDE POLL, NOT A
- 16:18KENTUCKY POLL.
- 16:19>> TO PROVIDE A HYPER WITH
- 16:21PRESCRIPTIONS FOR SURGERY TO
- 16:22AFFIRM THEIR CHOSEN GENDER, 66%
- 16:24OF KENTUCKIANS SAID IT SHOULD
- 16:27BE.
- 16:27PARENTS SHOULD NOTE HAVE THE
- 16:28RIGHT TO DO THAT.
- 16:3090% OF REPUBLICANS SAID IT
- 16:31SHOULD BE.
- 16:3264% OF INDEPENDENTS.
- 16:3457% OF MODERATE DEMOCRATS.
- 16:36>> AND, QUITE FRANKLY, I WISH WE
- 16:37WOULD GO BACK A DECADE OR TWO
- 16:39WHEN WE DIDN'T HAVE THE THE
- 16:41SUICIDE PROBLEM THAT WE HAVE
- 16:42TODAY BECAUSE WE'RE TREATING
- 16:44SOME UNDERLYING PSYCHOLOGICAL
- 16:45PROBLEMS, BUT NOW WE HAVE A
- 16:48MULTI-BILLION DOLLAR INDUSTRY TO
- 16:50TREAT WITH DRUGS AND WITH
- 16:51SURGERY THAT HAS GROWN AS A
- 16:53SUICIDE RATES HAVE GROWN.
- 16:54LET'S GO BACK TO TREATING IT
- 16:57WITH COUNSELING AS A MENTAL
- 17:01ILLNESS AND LET KIDS GET PASSED
- 17:02IT.
- 17:03IF YOU DON'T GET BILLIONS OF
- 17:05DOLLARS FROM IT.
- 17:07>> 17-YEAR-OLD JERRY MILLER, WE
- 17:08SHOULD BE COMPASSIONATE BUT DO
- 17:10YOU THINK HE SHOULD BE ON
- 17:13HORMONE THERAPY?
- 17:14THAT'S NOT THE AGE SOMEONE
- 17:15STARTS HORMONE THERAPY.
- 17:17YOU CLEARLY HAVE NO IDEA WHAT
- 17:18YOU'RE TALKING ABOUT.
- 17:19AGAIN, IN CONSULTATION WITH
- 17:21THEIR PHYSICIAN RIGHT AROUND THE
- 17:23TIME PUBERTY IS GETTING READY TO
- 17:23HIT IS WHEN YOU GO TO PUBERTY
- 17:26REGULATORS AND YOU DON'T START
- 17:27HORMONE REPLACEMENT THERAPY
- 17:28UNTIL LATE TEENS.
- 17:29THAT IS THE TYPICAL TREATMENT.
- 17:30ONCE AGAIN, THEY HAVE NO IDEA
- 17:32WHAT THEY'RE TALKING ABOUT
- 17:32BECAUSE THEY JUST WANT TO SCORE
- 17:34CHEAP POLITICAL POINTS, AND
- 17:35THAT'S ALL THIS IS AT THE END OF
- 17:36THE DAY, THE SCORN CHEAP
- 17:38POLITICAL POINTS ON THE LIVES OF
- 17:40CHILDREN.
- 17:41SENATOR, YOUR VOTE IS GOING TO
- 17:43KILL KENTUCKY KIDS AND YOU
- 17:44COULDN'T CARE LESS ABOUT IT.
- 17:45>> AND THAT'S WHY WE'RE DOING IT
- 17:47BECAUSE YOU'RE KILLING THEM
- 17:48ALREADY.
- 17:48>> UNBELIEVABLE.
- 17:48>> SO WE'RE GOING TO TAKE A
- 17:50LITTLE BREAK RIGHT HERE AND
- 17:51WE'RE GOING TO SHARE WITH YOU A
- 17:54CONVERSATION THAT I HAD WITH
- 17:55JENNIFER BIRD POLLAN WHO IS A
- 17:58LEXINGTON MOTHER WHO HAS A
- 18:00TRANSGENDER CHILD NAMED WICK AND
- 18:01SHE TALKED TO US ABOUT HER FEARS
- 18:03ABOUT SENATE BILL 150 THAT SHE
- 18:04FEARS WILL HAVE UNTOLD HARM
- 18:06CONSEQUENCES ON CHILDREN LIKE
- 18:09HER CHILD.
- 18:10LISTEN.
- 18:10>> AND FROM MY PERSPECTIVE, A
- 18:11LOT OF THE RHETORIC AROUND THESE
- 18:13BILLS HAS BEEN ABOUT PARENTS'
- 18:16RIGHTS, AND I JUST FIND THAT SO
- 18:18OFFENSIVE AS A PARENT OF SOMEONE
- 18:19WHO FULL ENDORSES AND EMBRACES
- 18:21MY KID AND THE CHOICES THAT
- 18:22THEY'RE MAKING THAT REALLY
- 18:24WHAT'S JUST HAPPENED WITH THIS
- 18:26LEGISLATION IS MY KID'S SCHOOLS
- 18:28HAVE BEEN TOLD THAT THEY DON'T
- 18:28HAVE TO RESPECT MY RIGHTS WITH
- 18:31RESPECT TO THE PRONOUNS MY KID
- 18:32USES OR THE BATHROOM THEY WANT
- 18:35TO USE AND I'M NOT ALONE IN
- 18:36THIS.
- 18:37A LOT OF PARENTS FEEL THAT OUR
- 18:40VULNERABLE CHILDREN ARE THE ONES
- 18:41WHO ARE TARGETED, AND WE AS
- 18:42PARENTS HAVE HAD RIGHTS TAKEN
- 18:44AWAY FROM US TO PROTECT OUR
- 18:46CHILDREN IN THE WAY THAT WE SEE
- 18:47FIT.
- 18:48>> CAN YOU TALK TO US ABOUT
- 18:51WICK'S JOURNEY AND WHEN THEY
- 18:52EXPRESSED TO YOU THAT THIS IS
- 18:55HOW THEY IDENTIFIED AND HOPED
- 18:57YOU WOULD UNDERSTAND?
- 18:59FOR PARENTS WHO WONDER, LIKE I
- 19:00DON'T UNDERSTAND ANY OF THIS,
- 19:02WERE YOU EVER THERE?
- 19:03>> OH, ABSOLUTELY.
- 19:06SO THIS WAS AN EVOLUTION OF
- 19:08WICK'S THINKING ABOUT THINGS
- 19:10BETWEEN MIDDLE SCHOOL AND HIGH
- 19:11SCHOOL, AND IT CAME TO US AND
- 19:13SAID THIS WAS A CHANGE THEY
- 19:14WANTED TO MAKE ABOUT THEIR
- 19:17OUTWARD PRESENTATION.
- 19:17I WILL ALSO SAY FOR MY PARENTS
- 19:19AND MY BAND'S PARENTS IT'S BEEN
- 19:22HARD BUT THEY RECOGNIZE THAT THE
- 19:23MOST -- YOU DO NOT HAVE TO
- 19:25UNDERSTAND WHAT'S GOING ON WITH
- 19:26YOUR KID.
- 19:27I MEAN, I WAS SO MOVED BY
- 19:31REPRESENTATIVE MILLER'S
- 19:31TESTIMONY ABOUT HIS OWN
- 19:32EXPERIENCE AS A GRANDPARENT.
- 19:35IT IS NOT THE RESPONSIBILITY OF
- 19:36PARENTS AND GRANDPARENTS ALWAYS
- 19:38TO UNDERSTAND EXACTLY WHAT'S
- 19:39GOING ON IN OUR KIDS' LIVES.
- 19:43THE REALITY IS THAT TIMES
- 19:44CHANGE.
- 19:45THINGS ARE DIFFERENT THAN WHEN
- 19:46WE WERE IN SCHOOL.
- 19:47IT FEELS LIKE MY PRIMARY
- 19:49RESPONSIBILITY TO SUPPORT MY KID
- 19:50IN THEIR DECISION.
- 19:52SO ABSOLUTELY WHEN IT FIRST
- 19:53HAPPENED WE MADE MISTAKES WITH
- 19:55PRONOUNS AND NAMES.
- 19:56WOULD I SAY THAT STILL HAPPENS
- 19:57IN OUR OWN HOUSE BUT WITH OTHER
- 19:59PEOPLE TALKING TO US ABOUT OUR
- 20:01KID.
- 20:02BUT THIS YEAR WE ALSO GOT
- 20:03CHRISTMAS CARDS THAT WERE
- 20:04ADDRESS TODAY ALL OF OUR FAMILY
- 20:06MEMBERS BY NAME INCLUDING WICK
- 20:08BY NAME, AND THAT MEANS A LOT
- 20:09WHEN YOUR COMMUNITY AND FAMILY
- 20:11EMBRACE THE EXPERIENCES OF YOUR
- 20:12KID.
- 20:13I THINK IT'S A REAL SHOWING OF
- 20:14SUPPORT, AND WE HAVE HAD THAT IN
- 20:15LEXINGTON AND WITH YOUR FAMILY,
- 20:17WITH OUR FRIENDS.
- 20:18>> IT SOUNDS LIKE THAT YOU AND
- 20:19WICK, YOU KNOW, YOU FOUND THAT
- 20:21COMMUNITY THROUGH THE SCHOOL,
- 20:22THROUGH THE SCHOOL SYSTEM,
- 20:24THROUGH THE SCHOOL -- THE
- 20:26EDUCATORS THERE WHERE THEY WERE
- 20:28EMBRACING, BUT WE KNOW THAT
- 20:29THERE ARE PLACES WHERE KIDS,
- 20:31THIS CAN HAVE PERHAPS A
- 20:34DETRIMENTAL IMPACT ON HOW THEY
- 20:35VIEW THEMSELVES AND WILL
- 20:37IDENTIFY THEMSELVES OR -- AND
- 20:39EVEN THEIR VALUE OR THEIR
- 20:41WORTH.
- 20:41>> HEATER.
- 20:44THAT'S RIGHT.
- 20:45THE BEST DECISION-MAKERS AND THE
- 20:47BEST PROVIDERS OF SUPPORT ARE
- 20:48THE PEOPLE THAT ARE CLOSE TO
- 20:50CHILDREN, NOT PEOPLE IN
- 20:52FRANKFORT WHO BY THEIR OWN
- 20:53ADMISSION DON'T UNDERSTAND
- 20:54WHAT'S GOING ON.
- 20:54HOW MANY OF THEM YESTERDAY SAID,
- 20:56HOW MANY OF THEM IN THE SESSION
- 20:58SAID THEY DIDN'T UNDERSTAND.
- 20:59THEY SAID THEY DIDN'T
- 21:00UNDERSTAND.
- 21:01AND THEN THEY VOTED FOR A
- 21:04BILL -- VOTED FOR A BILL THAT
- 21:06HARMS CHILDREN, THAT THE MEDICAL
- 21:08ASSOCIATION SAYS HARMS CHILDREN,
- 21:10THAT THE CHILDREN AND PARENTS
- 21:11AND FAMILIES SAID WOULD HARM
- 21:12THEM, AND THEY VOTED FOR IT
- 21:13ANYWAY.
- 21:14IT'S SO DISHEARTENING.
- 21:16THE IDEA THAT THIS IS, YOU KNOW,
- 21:18RUNNING RAMPANT ACROSS THE STATE
- 21:20SUCH THAT WE NEED LEGISLATION TO
- 21:23PREVENT IT, IT'S JUST -- IT'S
- 21:26JUST NOT TRUE.
- 21:27IT'S JUST NOT TRUE.
- 21:28AND SO FOR THE KIDS FOR WHOMS
- 21:29THIS IS THE APPROPRIATE
- 21:31RESPONSE, THE FACT THAT NOW THEY
- 21:33CAN'T GET THAT FROM A DOCTOR WHO
- 21:35THEY KNOW AND TRUST, WHO THEY'VE
- 21:37BEEN WITH FOR YEARS AND NOW
- 21:40MAYBE TO THE EXTENT THEIR
- 21:40PARENTS CAN PROVIDE THIS FOR
- 21:42THEM, THEY'RE GOING TO LEAVE THE
- 21:44STATE TO GET TREATMENT, SEE A
- 21:45NEW DOCTOR, MAYBE HAVE TO DO IT
- 21:46AWAY FROM HOME, THAT'S, AGAIN,
- 21:49IT'S NOT LETTING THE PEOPLE WHO
- 21:52KNOW BEST WHAT IS BEST FOR THIS
- 21:53KID MAKE THOSE DECISIONS.
- 21:56>> Renee: SO WE APPRECIATE THE
- 21:58INTEREST IN TONIGHT'S TOPIC AND
- 21:59THANK YOU ALL WHO HAVE TWEETED
- 22:01OR eMAILED OR TEXTED US.
- 22:03AND WE'LL TRY TO GET TO MANY OF
- 22:05YOUR RESPONSES AS POSSIBLE ON
- 22:07TWITTER.
- 22:08WE HAVE BONNIE HUGHES HUBER SAY,
- 22:10NO CHILD UNDER THE AGE OF 18
- 22:11SHOULD BE ALLOWED ANY TYPE OF
- 22:13GENDER SURGERY OR MEDICATIONS.
- 22:14IT IS OUR DUTY AS PARENTS AND
- 22:16GRANDPARENTS AND AUNTS AND
- 22:17UNCLES TO BE STRONG AND TO
- 22:18PROVIDE CONSULTATION AND TO
- 22:21UNDERSTAND.
- 22:21THIS HAS GOTTEN WAY TOO FAR OUT
- 22:22OF HAND.
- 22:23BEFORE WE GET MORE COMMENTARY, I
- 22:25DO WANT TO BRING UP THAT THERE
- 22:26WAS A STATEMENT RELEASED BY THE
- 22:28KENTUCKY MEDICAL ASSOCIATION
- 22:29ABOUT SENATE BILL 150 THAT THEY
- 22:31SAY THEY REMAIN EXTREMELY
- 22:33PROBLEMATIC, SUCH AS LIMITATIONS
- 22:36ON SAFE MEDICATIONS, THAT CAN BE
- 22:37USED TO TREAT GENDER DYSPHORIA.
- 22:41KMA SUPPORTS THE EVIDENCE-BASED
- 22:42STANDARDS OF CARE FOR THE
- 22:44TREATMENT OF GENDER DYSPHORIA
- 22:47INCLUDING NON-IMAGERY SURGICAL
- 22:49TREATMENT.
- 22:50SUCH STANDARDS FOR APPROPRIATE
- 22:51CARE HAVE BEEN DEVELOPED AND
- 22:52RECOGNIZED BY THE NATION'S
- 22:53LEADING HEALTH CARE
- 22:54ORGANIZATIONS AND HAVE PROVEN
- 22:55EFFECTIVE.
- 22:57AS SUCH, THE ASSOCIATION KMA
- 22:58REMAINS OPPOSED TO THE
- 23:00LEGISLATION.
- 23:00ARE YOU NOT RUNNING AFOUL OF
- 23:01WHAT THE MEDICAL COMMUNITY AND
- 23:03YOUR ON STATE IS SAYING WHAT
- 23:04SENATE BILL 150.
- 23:05>> I WILL SAY MY BROTHER-IN-LAW
- 23:06IS A DOCTOR, AND SENATOR DON
- 23:11DOUGLAS ASK A DOCTOR AND THEY
- 23:13BOTH SUPPORT THIS LEGISLATION.
- 23:14AND THERE ARE A LOT OF
- 23:15PHYSICIANS THAT SUPPORT THIS
- 23:16LEGISLATION.
- 23:18THE KMA POLITICAL ARM, I AGREE
- 23:20WITH THEM ON SOME THINGS.
- 23:21I DISAGREE WITH THEM ON OTHER
- 23:23THINGS.
- 23:24BUT I AM FOLLOWING DOCTORS THAT
- 23:26I TRUST, THAT ARE PHYSICIANS,
- 23:28THAT ARE CONCERNED ABOUT THE
- 23:30CHILDREN.
- 23:31AND I'D LOVE TO HAVE DR. DOUGLAS
- 23:33ON HERE.
- 23:34YOU WOULD HAVE A GREAT
- 23:36DISCUSSION BECAUSE HE DID A
- 23:36GREAT JOB A EDUCATING OUR CAUCUS
- 23:40ON MANY OF THESE ISSUES AND
- 23:43WHAT'S IMPORTANT AND WHAT'S A
- 23:45MYTH AND WHAT'S MEDICALLY
- 23:47SOUND.
- 23:48SO I'M WITH THE PHYSICIANS THAT
- 23:50I KNOW AND TRUST.
- 23:53>> MS. MCGRANAHAN, ANYTHING YOU
- 23:54CARE TO ADD AT THIS PARTICULAR
- 23:56JUNCTURE?
- 23:57>> I WANT TO ADD FOR SURE THIS
- 23:59HAS BEEN ONE OF THE MOST
- 24:01TRAUMATIC LEGISLATIVE SESSIONS
- 24:04THAT I'VE BEEN A PART OF.
- 24:07EACH COMMITTEE THAT ONE OF THESE
- 24:09BILLS PASSES OUT OF, YOU SEE
- 24:12COUNTLESS PARENTS IN THE
- 24:14HALLWAYS, IN THE COMMITTEE ROOMS
- 24:17SCREAMING AND CRYING AND
- 24:19PLEADING FOR LEGISLATORS TO
- 24:22LISTEN TO THEIR CONCERNS FOR
- 24:25THEIR CHILDREN, SO WHAT I DON'T
- 24:29UNDERSTAND IS HOW THESE PARENTS
- 24:30CAN BE IGNORED.
- 24:33>> WELL, A QUESTION THAT HAS
- 24:35COME IN FROM A VIEWER, WILL THE
- 24:37KENTUCKY GENERAL ASSEMBLY
- 24:38PROVIDE MORE COUNSELING FOR
- 24:40CHILDREN WHO ARE STRUGGLING WITH
- 24:41THESE REAL ISSUES?
- 24:44SO HAS THE KENTUCKY GENERAL
- 24:46ASSEMBLY ADEQUATELY FUNDED
- 24:47MENTAL HEALTH SERVICES FOR
- 24:49KENTUCKY'S YOUTH?
- 24:49>> ONE OF THE THINGS THAT
- 24:51SENATOR CARROLL WHO IS ON THE
- 24:52FAMILIES AND CHILDREN SAID THAT
- 24:55THIS, ONE OF THE THINGS HE SAID
- 24:56THE BILL DID DO THAT WE PASSED,
- 24:59THE SOUTH DAKOTA BILL THAT HAS
- 25:01BEEN PASSED AND IN SEVERAL OTHER
- 25:02STATES, HE SAID IT DID ALLOW FOR
- 25:04ADDITIONAL COUNSELING.
- 25:05OKAY?
- 25:06HE STILL VOTED AGAINST IT.
- 25:07HE WAS THE ONE REPUBLICAN WHO
- 25:08VOTED AGAINST IT BUT HE
- 25:10ACKNOWLEDGED THAT THE BILL DOES
- 25:11ALLOW FOR MORE COUNSELING THAN
- 25:13IT DID BEFORE, AND WE NEED
- 25:15COUNSELING, NOT GENDER CONFUSING
- 25:17COUNSELING, BUT COUNSELING FOR
- 25:19CHILDREN.
- 25:20THE FUNDING, IF THERE'S A NEED
- 25:21FOR IT, THAT'S WHAT OUR NEXT
- 25:23BUDGET SESSION WILL BE THERE
- 25:24FOR.
- 25:24>> ARE YOU COMMITTED TO THAT?
- 25:26>> I'M --
- 25:28>> COMMITTED TO THE FUNDING FOR
- 25:29MENTAL HEALTH SERVICES FOR
- 25:31CHILDREN WHO MAY HAVE, AS WOULD
- 25:33YOU CALL IT, GENDER CONFUSING
- 25:35IDENTITIES.
- 25:35>> WE'LL TAKE A LOOK AT IT.
- 25:36I BELIEVE ALREADY THROUGH OUR
- 25:37INSURANCE AND THROUGH OUR
- 25:39MEDICAID, FOR THOSE WHO CAN'T,
- 25:40WE HAVE FUNDING FOR THIS.
- 25:42BUT I DON'T WANT TO FUND
- 25:45GENDER-CONFUSING THERAPY.
- 25:45I WANT TO AFFIRM THERAPY THAT
- 25:47WILL GIVE THEM THE UNDERLYING
- 25:49MEDICAL HELP THEY NEED AND
- 25:51COUNSELING THEY NEED TO GET PAST
- 25:53THIS CONFUSING THAT'S
- 25:55HAPPENING.
- 25:55>> MR. RICHARD NELSON, A
- 25:57COMMENT, IT'S INTERESTING THAT
- 25:58HERE FROM A VIEWER, THAT HERE
- 26:00YOUTH ARE TOO YOUNG TO CONSENT
- 26:02BUT NOT WITH PREGNANCY, THAT
- 26:05FOREVER CHANGES ONE'S BODY.
- 26:07IT SEEMS HIPPO CRITICAL.
- 26:09>> I THINK WHEN WE TALKING ABOUT
- 26:10I'M DIGNITY AND BODILY INTEGGERY
- 26:13WE PROTECT LIFE.
- 26:13THAT'S THE PRINCIPLE THAT YOU
- 26:14WORK FROM, WHETHER THAT'S LIFE
- 26:16IN THE WOMB ORE TWO-YEAR-OLD
- 26:17CHILDREN AS SENATOR BERG
- 26:19TESTIFIED IN COMMITTEE THAT SHE
- 26:21THOUGHT HER TWO-YEAR-OLD AS
- 26:22GENDER DISFORIC OR JERRY MIL
- 26:25AREA SEVEN-YEAR-OLD.
- 26:25WE SUPPORT LIFE.
- 26:27WE GET BEHIND THOSE WHO ARE
- 26:29STRUGGLING WITH LIFE BUT WE DO
- 26:30NOT ALLOW CHILDREN WHO MAKE
- 26:34LIFE-IMPACTING DECISIONS THAT
- 26:34THEY CANNOT FULLY APPRECIATE.
- 26:36A SEVEN-YEAR-OLD OR A
- 26:3912-YEAR-OLD OR A 15-YEAR-OLD
- 26:42CANNOT CONSENT IN THEIR RIGHT
- 26:44MIND TO HORMONE THERAPY OR
- 26:47PUBERTY BLOCKERS OR TRANSITION
- 26:48SURGERIES, AND I THINK THAT
- 26:49THOSE ON THIS SIDE, AND THE
- 26:51GENERAL ASSEMBLY HAS
- 26:52ACKNOWLEDGED THIS, MOST PARENTS
- 26:53UNDERSTAND THERE ARE LIMITS TO
- 26:55WHAT CHILDREN CAN DECIDE, BUT
- 26:56THERE'S ALSO LIMITS TO WHAT
- 26:57PARENTS CAN DECIDE TOO.
- 26:59THIS IS ABOUT BODILY INTEGRITY.
- 27:01IT'S ABOUT STANDING IN THE GAP
- 27:02FOR CHILDREN WHO DON'T HAVE
- 27:05ANYBODY TO STAND IN THE GAP FOR
- 27:06THEM.
- 27:06I THINK A LOT OF PEOPLE ARE
- 27:07CONVINCED THAT THIS IS THE RIGHT
- 27:08THING FOR CHILDREN, AND I WOULD
- 27:10SAY THAT IT'S WRONG, AND THAT'S
- 27:11WHAT WE HEARD AGAIN BY SEVERAL
- 27:13OF THE TESTIMONIES.
- 27:14THAT'S WHAT WE'RE SEEING ACROSS
- 27:15THE COUNTRY, RENEE.
- 27:16THERE ARE LAWSUITS AGAINST
- 27:18GENDER TRANSITION CLINICS FROM
- 27:20YOUNG PEOPLE.
- 27:21IT WAS JUST IN THE NEWS
- 27:21YESTERDAY OR THE DAY BEFORE
- 27:23WHERE THERE'S A LAWSUIT AGAINST
- 27:28AGAINST -- I'M TRYING TO SEE
- 27:30WHERE IT IS.
- 27:30ONE OF THE BIG HEALTH CARE
- 27:31PROVIDERS.
- 27:32BUT IT'S THERE.
- 27:33BUT WE'RE SEEING THIS AND WE'RE
- 27:35SEEING, CHRIS, A ROLLBACK IN
- 27:36EUROPEAN COUNTRIES, IN SWEDEN,
- 27:38IN NORWAY AND 234 GREAT BRITON.
- 27:41THE TAVISTOCK CENTER IS ROLLING
- 27:42BACK THEIR GENDER-AFFIRMING
- 27:45CARE.
- 27:45IN FACT THERE WAS A CLASS ACTION
- 27:47LAWSUIT THAT IS UNDERWAY AGAINST
- 27:50THEM BECAUSE THE HIGH COURT IN
- 27:52GREAT BRITAIN FOUND ON BEHALF OF
- 27:54A MINOR CHILD WHO PURSUED GENDER
- 27:57TRANSITION AND THEY FOUND THE
- 28:04STAPH STOCK CENTER.
- 28:05>> WE DON'T HAVE ANY DOCTORS
- 28:06FROM KENTUCKY COMING TO TESTIFY
- 28:08AGAINST -- OR FOR THIS STUFF.
- 28:09ALL THEY'RE DOING IS IGNORING
- 28:13EVERY COMPETENT MEDICAL
- 28:13PROFESSIONAL AND PROFESSIONAL
- 28:16ORGANIZATION THAT ARE ALL UNITED
- 28:17ON THIS FRONT.
- 28:19YOU KNOW, RICHARD WILL PROTECT
- 28:20YOUR LIFE AS LONG AS IT'S UNBORN
- 28:22BUT AFTER THAT YOU'RE ON YOUR
- 28:25OWN.
- 28:25YOU HAD ONE PHYSICIAN TESTIFY.
- 28:27I HAD A LINE OF PHYSICIANS OUT
- 28:30THE DOOR, SENATOR.
- 28:30WAS THAT PHYSICIAN FROM
- 28:31KENTUCKY?
- 28:33>> DR. DOUGLAS.
- 28:33>> IS HE A MEMBER OF THE
- 28:35KENTUCKY--
- 28:35>> MY BROTHER-IN-LAW.
- 28:37I COUNSELED WITH HIM.
- 28:38A NUMBER OF OTHER PHYSICIANS
- 28:40THAT ARE KENTUCKY TEXANS.
- 28:42>> FROM LINCOLN COUNTY WE HEAR
- 28:44THIS, THAT THE GENERAL ASSEMBLY
- 28:45WANTED TO PROTECT CHILDREN WERE
- 28:47NOT UTILIZE RESOURCES AND TIME
- 28:48TO COME UP WITH A PLAN FORT
- 28:51FOSTER SYSTEM WE HAVE.
- 28:52WE HAVE CHILDREN STAYING IN
- 28:53STATE OFFICES DUE TO NOT HAVING
- 28:55ENOUGH PLACEMENT OPTIONS,
- 28:56ESPECIALLY IN OUR BIGGIER
- 28:59CITIES.
- 28:59FRANKFORT JUST DOES NOT GET IT.
- 29:01AND THEN THERE'S THIS QUESTION
- 29:02FROM HARDIN COUNTY.
- 29:05WILL SB 150 BAN COLLEGE AP
- 29:07COURSES AND RISK AP
- 29:09CERTIFICATION OR DUAL CREDIT,
- 29:11LORIS COURSES LIKE PSYCHOLOGICAL
- 29:12AND ANATOMY BRIEFLY DEAL WITH
- 29:15GENDER AS A SOCIAL CONCEPT,
- 29:16HUMAN DEVELOPMENT AND SEXUAL
- 29:19ORIENTATION.
- 29:19THIS IS A QUESTION FOR YOU,
- 29:21SENATOR WILLIAMS.
- 29:23DOES THIS AFFECT COLLEGE
- 29:24PLACEMENT?
- 29:25>> I BELIEVE SO.
- 29:26>> IT DOESN'T ADDRESS THAT AT
- 29:27ALL.
- 29:27>> THIS HAS TO DO WITH CHILDREN
- 29:30AND PRIMARILY OBJECT 16TY,
- 29:33CHILDREN AND SEXUALLY
- 29:35INAPPROPRIATE MATERIALS.
- 29:36NOT COLLEGE COURSES.
- 29:38>> WHY WOULD HE KNOW?
- 29:39THE BILL WAS RAMMED THROUGH IN
- 29:41THE FINAL HOURS OF THE LAST
- 29:42DAY.
- 29:42NOBODY HAD AN OPPORTUNITY TO
- 29:43READ IT.
- 29:44AND SO AT THE END OF THE DAY
- 29:46EVEN THE MAJORITY DOESN'T HAVE A
- 29:49CLUE WHAT THE BILL ACTUALLY DOES
- 29:50AT THE END OF THE DAY, BUT WHAT
- 29:52IT'S GOING TO DO IS MARGINALIZE
- 29:54TRANS KIDS, TAKE RIGHTS AWAY
- 29:55FROM TRANS KIDS, PARENTS, AND
- 29:57IT'S GOING TO UNFORTUNATELY KILL
- 29:58TRANS KIDS.
- 30:05>> THERE'S NO OBSCENITY CLAUSE
- 30:06IN THIS BILL.
- 30:07>> I WANTED TO GO TO SENATE BILL
- 30:095 IS ABOUT OBSCENE MATERIALS OR
- 30:11OBJECTIONABLE MATERIALS BUT THAT
- 30:12IS NOT PART OF SENATE BILL 150
- 30:14ALTHOUGH THAT CAN BE A PART OF
- 30:16THE DISCUSSION.
- 30:17>> IT IS PART OF THE DISCUSSION
- 30:18BECAUSE --
- 30:19>> WOULD YOU CONSIDER OBSCENITY
- 30:21TO BE A PART OF THE CONVERSATION
- 30:25IN WHICH SECTION OF THE BILL.
- 30:27>> RYE, IN SEXUAL CONFUSION
- 30:29BECAUSE OF THE OBSCENITY AT THE
- 30:31VERY YOUNG AGES THE BECOMING
- 30:36CONFUSEDDERS AND THERE ARE MANY
- 30:38MATERIALS SHA THAT SHOULD NOT BE
- 30:39PRESENTED TO K THROUGH 4, 5
- 30:42CHILDREN.
- 30:43>> MR. NELSON, WAS THE REGRET
- 30:44PRATE FOR GENDER-AFFIRMING
- 30:45CARE.
- 30:46>>
- 30:46>> THAT'S A REALLY GOOD
- 30:47QUESTION.
- 30:48ACCORDING TO PAUL McCUE THEY
- 30:53OF CHIEF SKY AT ANY RATE JOHNS
- 30:53HOPKINS WHICH THEY USED TO DO
- 30:55GENDER TRANSITION SURGERIES,
- 30:57THEY FOUND WHAT IS NOT HELPING
- 30:58THE PARENTS IN THE LONG RUN.
- 31:01SOMEWHERE UPWARDS OF 80% OF
- 31:03CHILDREN SUFFERING FROM GENDER
- 31:05DYSPHORIA ACCEPT THEIR
- 31:06BIOLOGICAL REALITY INTO
- 31:08ADULTHOOD, MID-20s, UPPER
- 31:0920s.
- 31:10SO WHY WOULD WE WANT TO IMPOSE
- 31:13HORMONE REGIMEN ON THEM, PUBERTY
- 31:16BLOCK ORES RADICAL SURGERIES ON
- 31:17THEM WHEN THEIR MINDS EVENTUALLY
- 31:18LINE UP WITH THEIR BIOLOGICAL
- 31:19REALITY.
- 31:20>> AND SO TO THAT POINT, LUCCA
- 31:22HEIN WHO WE TALKED TO TODAY BY
- 31:25SKYPE, SHE IS NOT A KENTUCKIAN.
- 31:27SHE TALKED TO US FROM A HOTEL IN
- 31:28NEBRASKA.
- 31:29BUT SHE'S TESTIFIED QUITE A BIT
- 31:30ON SENATE BILL 150 AND THE BILL
- 31:32470, HOUSE BILL 470 THAT IS
- 31:36SIMILAR, SHE WAS BORN A FEMALE
- 31:38AND SHE SAYS HE WAS TOO YOUNG
- 31:40AND SUFFERED MENTAL HEALTH
- 31:41ISSUES, AND AT THE IMAGE A 16
- 31:45SHE HAD A DOUBLING MASTECTOMY.
- 31:47HERE'SER MANUFACTURE OUR
- 31:48CONVERSATION.
- 31:48>> YOU KNOW, I WAS A YOUNG
- 31:49TEENAGER WHO HAD A HISTORY OF
- 31:53MENTAL HEALTH ISSUES, A ROUGH
- 31:55HOME LIFE AT THE TIME, AND I HAD
- 31:56ALSO BEEN HEAVILY, HEAVILY
- 32:01PREYED UPON AND SEXUALLY
- 32:03SOLICITED ONLINE OAT POINT THAT
- 32:04THE AUTHORITIES GOT INVOLVED,
- 32:06AND I SORT OF SPIRALED INTO THIS
- 32:08HATRED OF MYSELF AND MY BODY TO
- 32:12THE POINT THAT I FOUND THESE
- 32:14ONLINE SPACES THAT REALLY TOLD
- 32:16ME, OH, YOU DON'T HATE YOUR
- 32:19CHEST BECAUSE YOU'RE
- 32:20UNCOMFORTABLE BECAUSE IT'S A
- 32:21NORMAL TEENAGE THING OR BECAUSE
- 32:23YOU HAVE TRAUMA AROUND IT.
- 32:25IT'S BECAUSE YOU'RE A BOY IN THE
- 32:27WRONG BODY.
- 32:27AND OBVIOUSLY AS SOMEONE WHO WAS
- 32:30YOUNG AND VULNERABLE AND REALLY
- 32:32JUST TRYING TO FIND ANYTHING TO
- 32:35GRASP ONTO AT THE TIME, THAT
- 32:39FIT, AND I TRULY BELIEVED THAT.
- 32:43AND AS A RESULT, YOU KNOW, I
- 32:45TOLD SOME MENTAL HEALTH
- 32:48PROFESSIONALS AT THE TIME, WE
- 32:49NEED TO TELL YOUR PARENTS SO
- 32:51THEY CAN GET YOU THE HELP THAT
- 32:53YOU NEED, AND THE ISSUE IS THAT
- 32:55THEY ONLY AFFIRMED THIS, NO ONE
- 33:00QUESTIONED WHY, YOU KNOW, ALL OF
- 33:03A SUDDEN AS A TEENAGER THESE
- 33:05FEELINGS POPPED UP.
- 33:06THEY ONLY AFFIRMED IT.
- 33:08THEY KIND OF BULLIED MY PARENTS
- 33:12AND SCARED THEM, YOU KNOW, WITH
- 33:14THE LINE OF, DO YOU WANT A DEAD
- 33:16DAUGHTER OR A LIVING SON?
- 33:18WHICH IS NOT WHAT A DOCTOR
- 33:19SHOULD SAY 37 THAT'S THE LINE OF
- 33:21AN ACTIVIST.
- 33:23IT'S ALSO BLATANTLY NOTE TRUE.
- 33:28FROM THERE I WENT DOWN TO THE
- 33:30MEDICAL PATH THAT WAS REALLY THE
- 33:33ONLY OPTION WE WERE PRESENTED,
- 33:36AND MY VERY FIRST MEDICAL
- 33:38INTERVENTION I WAS DOUBLE
- 33:39MASTECTOMY AT 16.
- 33:40THEN A FEW MONTHS LATER I WAS
- 33:43PUT ON PROCESSED HORMONES WHICH
- 33:46WAS TESTOSTERONE, AND I TOOK
- 33:48THAT FOR FOUR YEARS UNTIL I
- 33:50REALLY GREW UP AND I STARTED
- 33:52GETTING THINGS TOGETHER AND
- 33:54REALLY THINKING ABOUT WHAT I
- 33:55WANT FOR MY LIFE AND REALIZING
- 33:58THAT I DEFINITELY WAS NOT IN A
- 34:00PLACE WHERE I COULD CONSENT TO
- 34:02THAT.
- 34:02I COULDN'T CONSENT TO THE
- 34:03LONG-TERM IMPACTS.
- 34:04I COULDN'T CONSENT TO BEING A
- 34:06MEDICAL PATIENT FOR REST OF MY
- 34:07LIFE IN THIS WAY, NOT TO MENTION
- 34:11THE PHYSICAL DAMAGE, STUFF LIKE
- 34:14TESTOSTERONE HAS DONE TO ME
- 34:17WHERE I HAVE JOINT MAIN, MY
- 34:20VOCAL CLOSED ACHE.
- 34:21I HAVE WATCHES ALL OF MY MUSCLE
- 34:23MAGS WASTE AWAY.
- 34:24I'VE WATCHED PART OF MY BODY
- 34:25ATROPHY AWAY.
- 34:26I DON'T KNOW IF I'LL EVER BE
- 34:27ABLE TO CARRY A CHILD.
- 34:29ALL THIS STUFF THAT THEY LOOKED
- 34:31ME IN THE EYES AT 16 AND TOLD ME
- 34:33THIS WAS CARE, AND, YOU KNOW,
- 34:38I'M TO THE POINT WHERE I GREW UP
- 34:41A LITTLE BIT AND I CURRENT
- 34:44FEELTENTIALY ABANDONED BY THE
- 34:46MEDICAL PROFESSIONALS THAT DID
- 34:47THIS.
- 34:48>> HOW OLD ARE YOU NOW, LUKA?
- 34:50>> I'M NOW 21.
- 34:52>> SO YOU'VE HAD -- SO YOUR
- 34:57FIRST -- THE FIRST MEDICAL
- 34:58SERVICE THAT YOU WERE PROVIDED,
- 35:00WAS THAT BEFORE 16 OR AT 16?
- 35:03>> AT 16.
- 35:04>> AT 16.
- 35:06AND MASS CONNECT ME, WAS THAT
- 35:09YOUR CHOICE?
- 35:10MASTECTOMY?
- 35:11YOU FEEL YOU WERE FORCED UPON TO
- 35:12MAKE THAT DECISION?
- 35:13>> I FEEL LIKE I WAS A MENTALLY
- 35:18ILL TEENAGER THAT HATED MY CHEST
- 35:20WHO WAS BINDING MY CHEST EVERY
- 35:21DAY TO THE POINT I HAD RIB AND
- 35:25SPINE DAMAGE, AND I WAS SEEN AS
- 35:29THIS KIND OF MAGICAL, LIKE IT
- 35:30WILL FIX YOUR PROBLEMS THING.
- 35:32THAT IS HOW THE TRANS COMMUNITY
- 35:33PRESENTED IT TO ME.
- 35:37THAT'S HOW THEY PRESENT TO IT A
- 35:38LOT OF YOUNG PEOPLE, IS THAT
- 35:39THIS WILL CURE YOUR DYSPHORIA.
- 35:43YOU KNOW, WHERE I CAN'T THINK OF
- 35:46ANYTHING ELSE.
- 35:48WE'RE HERE HAVING A MENTAL
- 35:49HEALTH ISSUE.
- 35:51A DOCTOR WILL RECOMMEND YOU CHOP
- 35:53OFF BODY PARTS.
- 35:54>> SO CHRIS HARTMAN, I WANT TO
- 35:56GO YOU TO RESPOND TO HER
- 35:58EXPERIENCE.
- 35:58>> LUKA'S TALE IS TRAGIC, IT'S
- 36:01TRUE, AND EVERY PHYSICIAN THAT
- 36:03I'VE SPOKEN WITH HAS SAID THAT
- 36:04SHE DID NOT RECEIVE THE STANDARD
- 36:07OF CARE THAT IS THE STANDARD OF
- 36:08CARE FROM ALL OF THE MAJOR
- 36:11MEDICAL ASSOCIATIONS.
- 36:12AND SHE'S NOT A KENTUCKIAN,
- 36:15WHICH I HAVE CONTINUED TO DRIVE
- 36:16HOME.
- 36:16THE FOLKS THAT WE HAVE BROUGHT
- 36:18TO TESTIFY IN OPPOSITION TO
- 36:20THESE BILLS ARE KENTUCKIANS WHO
- 36:22ARE BEGGING FOR LIFE-SAVING
- 36:26MEDICALLY SUPPORTED EVER
- 36:27SUPPORTIVE TREATMENT, AND WHAT
- 36:28THE LEGISLATURE HAS DONE IS BUT
- 36:30DOCTORS IN KENTUCKY IN AN
- 36:32IMPOSSIBLE POSITION WHERE THEY
- 36:33EITHER HAVE TO VIOLATE THEIR
- 36:34STANDARDS OF CARE AND THEIR
- 36:36MEDICAL ETHICS OR THEY HAVE TO
- 36:38VIOLATE THIS UNJUST LAW AND LOSE
- 36:41THEIR MEDICAL LICENSE IN THE
- 36:42COMMONWEALTH OF KENTUCKY.
- 36:43>> SO I DO WANT TO JUST CLARIFY
- 36:45THAT POINT IN THE BILL, THAT ARE
- 36:47THERE ARE PUNITIVE ACTIONS
- 36:49AGAINST DOCTORS WHO PERFORM
- 36:51THESE SURGERIES OR ADMINISTER
- 36:53THERAPIES.
- 36:53>> CERTAINLY, IF THEY DO THAT
- 36:55BUT I WANT TO SAY SHE ALSO
- 36:57TESTIFIED THAT SHE DIDN'T FEEL
- 36:58COMPLETELY SAFE COMING BACK TO
- 36:59KENTUCKY.
- 37:00DO YOU KNOW WHY?
- 37:02SHE SAID THAT?
- 37:03>> TELL ME WHY, SENATOR.
- 37:05DO YOU KNOW WHY?
- 37:05>> I DON'T.
- 37:06>> BECAUSE SHE WAS ASSAULTED.
- 37:09OKAY.
- 37:09BY A MEMBER OF YOUR COMMUNITY
- 37:12WHO WAS IN POWER, AND SHE FELT
- 37:14SHE WAS ACCOSTED AND COULD NOT
- 37:16COME BACK HERE.
- 37:17>> THIS IS AN ACCUSATION THAT
- 37:19HASN'T COME OUT UNTIL NOW.
- 37:20>> THIS IS ALSO WHY A NUMBER OF
- 37:23MEMBERS IN KENTUCKY WON'T
- 37:25TESTIFY, BECAUSE THEY FEEL THEY
- 37:26WILL BE -- THERE WILL BE
- 37:28RETRIBUTION EITHER FIRING FROM
- 37:30THEIR JOBS OR CRITICISM WITHIN
- 37:32KENTUCKY OF THIS, AND THAT'S WHY
- 37:33WE HAD PEOPLE FROM OUTSIDE OF
- 37:36KENTUCKY, BECAUSE PEOPLE --
- 37:38>> SOWED KENTUCKIANS, MINORS WHO
- 37:40ARE KENTUCKIANS WHO HAVE HAD
- 37:41THIS EXPERIENCE THAT ARE
- 37:43DETRANSITIONING.
- 37:44YOU KNOW OF THOSE PEOPLE.
- 37:46>> RENEE --
- 37:46>> YES OR NO, DO YOU KNOW OF
- 37:49THOSE PEOPLE WHO ARE KENTUCKIANS
- 37:51WHO ARE DETRANSITIONING.
- 37:51>> YES.
- 37:52THE FIRST IS JENNET COOPER WHO
- 37:56DIRECT PARTNERS FOR ETHICAL
- 37:57CARE.
- 37:58SHE TESTIFIED SHE HAS A NUMBER
- 37:59PARENTS IN HER GROUP WHOSE
- 38:01CHILDREN TRANSITIONED.
- 38:02THEY WERE AFRAID TO COME AND
- 38:03TESTIFY PUBLICALLY ABOUT THEIR
- 38:05STORY BECAUSE THEY'RE AFRAID OF
- 38:06BEING BULLIED OR HARASSED AND
- 38:08THEY'RE ALREADY DEALING WITH A
- 38:09LOT OF PAIN.
- 38:09THE OTHER THING, TOO, THAT'S
- 38:10IMPORTANT TO MENTION THE
- 38:12JENNIFER DECKER THE SPONSOR OF
- 38:14HOUSE BILL 470 TESTIFIED THERE
- 38:17WERE NOSE IN THE MEDICAL
- 38:18COMMUNITY IN FRANKFORT THAT
- 38:19WOULD HAVE TESTIFIED IN FAVOR OF
- 38:20HOUSE BILL 470 BUT THEY WERE
- 38:22AFRAID TO DO SO BECAUSE THEY
- 38:24WOULD HAVE LOST THEIR JOBS.
- 38:28SHE TESTIFIED UNDER OATH.
- 38:29>> YOU'RE MISTANK GO PASSION --
- 38:31>> LET MIME FINISH.
- 38:32>> RENEE, I WAS IN TWO OF THE
- 38:34COMMITTEE MEETINGS AND I'LL SAY
- 38:35THIS, THERE WAS A LOT OF PAIN,
- 38:37THERE WAS A LOT OF PEOPLE WHO
- 38:38WERE DEEPLY HURT AND MOVED, BUT
- 38:40THERE WAS ALSO FEAR.
- 38:41I WAS AFRAID FOR MYSELF, TOO,
- 38:43BASE WAS MINORITY IN ONE OF
- 38:45THESE COMMITTEES.
- 38:45IT WAS HOSTILE.
- 38:47THERE WERE PEOPLE BEHIND ME IN
- 38:48THE SENATE, FAMILIES AND
- 38:50CHILDREN COMMITTEE WHERE THEY
- 38:52WERE TALKING ABOUT IN A
- 38:54OBSTRUCTING THE TESTIMONY, AND I
- 38:55SIMPLY TURNED AROUND A COUPLE
- 38:56TIMES AND ASKED THEM TO BE
- 38:58QUIET, AND IT WAS THREATENING
- 38:59TOWARDS ME, CHRIS.
- 39:00THE COMMITTEE CHAIRMAN DANNY
- 39:02CARROLL SAID, THIS SAYS NOT
- 39:03HELPING THEIR CAUSE.
- 39:05HE WAS INTERRUPTED A NUMBER OF
- 39:07TIMES.
- 39:07AND THERE WAS A THREATENING MOOD
- 39:09THAT I HAVE EXPERIENCED AND I
- 39:11THINK THAT IT'S -- IT'S BEEN
- 39:12SEEN ACROSS THE STATE.
- 39:13>> SO I DON'T WANT TO DIVERT TOO
- 39:14MUCH FROM THE CONTENT OF WHAT
- 39:16WE'RE TALKING ABOUT TO THAT
- 39:17POINT, BUT WHEN THE BILL DID
- 39:18PASS THE SENATE, MR. HARTMAN,
- 39:20THERE WERE PEOPLE IN THE GALLERY
- 39:21WHO SHOUTED OBSCENITIES AT
- 39:25SENATOR LINDSEY TISCHNER AND
- 39:26OTHERS AND THAT'S NOT
- 39:27NECESSARILY THE BEHAVIOR THAT IS
- 39:30DESERVING OF THE INSTITUTION AND
- 39:31OF THAT CHAMBER.
- 39:32YOU WOULD AGREE WITH THAT,
- 39:33CORRECT?
- 39:33>> ABSOLUTELY, THAT WAS
- 39:34INAPPROPRIATE.
- 39:35>> SO LET'S TALK ABOUT THE
- 39:37CONTENT.
- 39:38MS. MCGRANAHAN, WHEN YOU HEAR A
- 39:39STORY LIKE YOU HEARD FROM LUKA,
- 39:41HOW DOES THAT STRIKE YOU?
- 39:43>> WHAT HAPPENED IS AWFUL, AND
- 39:47IT'S TRAGIC, AND -- BUT THESE
- 39:50ARE NOT STANDARDS OF CARE.
- 39:54THE CARE THAT SHE GOT, IT DIDN'T
- 39:57HAPPEN IN KENTUCKY.
- 39:58AND WHEN WE'RE TALKING ABOUT
- 40:00WHAT WE'RE ASKING FOR IS FOR A
- 40:04FAMILY, IF YOU HAVE A TRANS
- 40:09CHILD THAT YOU ARE PERMITTED TO
- 40:10GO TO A DOCTOR AND RECEIVE
- 40:12HEALTH CARE, THAT'S ALL.
- 40:14THAT'S ALL.
- 40:15WE ARE NOT ASKING FOR MORE
- 40:19RIGHTS OR ADDITIONAL RIGHTS,
- 40:21JUST EQUAL RIGHTS AND PROTECTION
- 40:23UNDER THE LAW FOR ALL KENTUCKY
- 40:25FAMILIES.
- 40:25>> SO I DO WANT TO ASK TO THE
- 40:28POINT THAT YOU'RE MAKING ABOUT
- 40:30PARENTAL DECISION, IF A PARENT
- 40:32CHOSE TO LEAVE KENTUCKY TO GET
- 40:33GENDER-AFFIRMING CARE FOR THEIR
- 40:35CHILD AND CAME -- AND RETURNED
- 40:37BACK TO KENTUCKY, WOULD THEY
- 40:39FACE ANY KIND OF CRIMINAL
- 40:40PENALTIES?
- 40:40ANSWER THAT QUESTION FIRST.
- 40:42>> WHAT I WILL SAY IS PRIOR TO
- 40:44THIS BILL A PHYSICIAN COULD HAVE
- 40:45DONE THAT TO LUKA AND NOT HAVE
- 40:47BEEN PENALIZED.
- 40:48WITH THIS BILL, IF THEY DID IT
- 40:50IN KENTUCKY, THEY WILL BE
- 40:52PENALIZED.
- 40:53WE ALL AGREED THAT WHAT WAS DONE
- 40:55TO HER SHOULD HAVE PENALTIES.
- 40:58IT'S NOT MEDICAL CARE AND THAT'S
- 40:59WHAT THIS BILL DOES.
- 41:00AND IF THEY COME BACK TO
- 41:02KENTUCKY, THERE'S A DE-- IF
- 41:04THEY'RE ON DRUGS, THEY'RE GOING
- 41:05TO GET IT SOMEWHERE ELSE.
- 41:06THERE'S NO PENALTY ON THE
- 41:07PARENTS OR ANYTHING ELSE.
- 41:10IF THERE'S SURGERY, THERE'S
- 41:11SURGERY.
- 41:12IT'S NOT GOING TO HAPPEN IN
- 41:13KENTUCKY.
- 41:14BUT THEY CAN'T CONTINUE TO
- 41:16PRESCRIBE CERTAIN DRUGS IN
- 41:18KENTUCKY WOULD IT, BUT THEY CAN
- 41:20SCALE BACK ON THEM IF THEY'RE
- 41:21GOING TO COME BACK AND LIVE
- 41:23HERE, AND THAT'S VERY BROAD
- 41:26WITHOUT BEING, SPECIFIC, THAT
- 41:28THEY NEED TO REDUCE THE USE OF
- 41:31THOSE DRUGS AS THEY
- 41:33DETRANSITION.
- 41:34IF SOMEBODY JUST MOVES HERE,
- 41:35THEY CAN DETRANSITION OFF THE
- 41:37DRUGS.
- 41:39THAT'S PART OF WHAT'S
- 41:40HAPPENING.
- 41:41THAT'S IN THE BILL.
- 41:41IT'S NOTE TAKEN CARE OF.
- 41:42IT'S NOTE ILLEGAL TO COME BACK
- 41:44HERE AND BE DETRANSITIONING.
- 41:45>> THANK YOU FORE CLARIFYING
- 41:47THAT.
- 41:48THERE WERE EXCEPTIONS ON PAGE 8
- 41:49OF THE BILL, AND IT TALKS ABOUT
- 41:53PROCEED HIGGINS OF THIS
- 41:53SUBSECTION SHALL NOT LIMIT OR
- 41:55RESTRICT THE PROVISIONS TO A
- 41:57MINOR WITH MEDICALLY VERIFIABLE
- 41:59DISORDER OF SECONDS DEVELOPMENT
- 42:00INCLUDING EXTERNAL BIOLOGICAL
- 42:02SECONDS CHARACTERISTICS THAT ARE
- 42:03IR RESOLVEBLY AMBIGUOUS.
- 42:05>> ACTUALLY, I'VE GOT A GOOD
- 42:08FRIEND, ARE THERE GENETIC
- 42:10ANOMALIES THAT THIS BILL TAKE
- 42:12CARE OF.
- 42:13THERE ARE GOOD REASONS FOR DOING
- 42:14THESE THINGS MEDICALLY BECAUSE
- 42:16IT CAN BE XXY, XYW, THERE'S A
- 42:20NUMBER OF DISORDERS, SMALL
- 42:22PERCENTAGES BUT STILL A LOT OF
- 42:23PEOPLE AND THEY CAN BE TAKEN
- 42:25CARE OF.
- 42:26SOME BECOME WOMEN.
- 42:27SOPH THEM BECOME MEN.
- 42:30AND THERE'S DIFFERENT HORMONAL
- 42:31THINGS.
- 42:31ALL THOSE TREATMENTS CAN OCCUR.
- 42:33THAT WAS ONE OF THE THINGS I WAS
- 42:34VERY STRONG ON BECAUSE I HAD A
- 42:36GOOD FRIEND WHO HAS A LOVELY
- 42:38DAUGHTER, AND THEY RAISED HER AS
- 42:40A DAUGHTER.
- 42:40SHE WILL NEVER HAVE KIDS, BUT
- 42:42THAT WAS THE WAY IT WENT.
- 42:43SOME OF THOSE KIDS ARE RAISED AS
- 42:45MALES.
- 42:46ACTUALLY MORE OF THEM ARE RAISED
- 42:49AS MALES THAN MALES, BUT
- 42:50DEPENDING UPON WHAT DISORDER,
- 42:52ACTUAL PHYSICAL DISORDER YOU
- 42:53HAVE, YOU CAN GET THE CARE FOR
- 42:54THAT.
- 42:55>> YOU DON'T DISAGREE WITH
- 42:56THAT.
- 42:56>> ACTUALLY, DO I.
- 42:58SENATOR WILLIAMS WILL APPROVE OF
- 43:00HAVING LIFE-ALTERING SURGERIES
- 43:03ON BABIES.
- 43:05THE SABERI SEX COMMUNITIES FIND
- 43:06THIS INCREDIBLY PROBLEMATIC.
- 43:10THE PREVAILING STANDARDS OF CARE
- 43:11FOR BABIES WHO ARE BORN INTERSEX
- 43:12IS NOT TO HAVE A MEDICAL
- 43:14INTERVENTION UNTIL THEY ARE OLD
- 43:16ENOUGH TO MAKE THEIR OWN.
- 43:19>> I NEVER --
- 43:20>> WHAT YOU DO YOU THINK THEY DO
- 43:22TO INTERSEX BABIES WHEN THEY ARE
- 43:23BORN?
- 43:24YOU JUST ADVOCATED FOR IT.
- 43:24>> DID I NOT.
- 43:25>> HE SAID THIS IS ALLOWED TO
- 43:28HAPPEN AT THE DIRECTIONS OF THE
- 43:29PARENTS AND THE CHILD INVOLVED.
- 43:30>> .
- 43:33RENEE, IF I COULD ADD SOMETHING,
- 43:34I THINK THERE'S BEEN AN
- 43:36ASSUMPTION THAT SURGICAL
- 43:37INTERVENTIONS ARE NOT HAPPENING
- 43:39IN KENTUCKY.
- 43:41COORDINATED TO JENNET COOPER,
- 43:41AGAIN SHE TESTIFIED IN FRONT OF
- 43:43THE SENATE CHILDREN AND FAMILIES
- 43:44COMMITTEE, THAT THEY HAVE A
- 43:45PARENT WHO RECORDED A CALL WITH
- 43:47A CLINIC THAT OFFERED TO DO A
- 43:49DOUBLE MASTECTOMY ON HER
- 43:5015-YEAR-OLD DAUGHTER.
- 43:51SHE SAID THAT UNDER TESTIMONY.
- 43:54SHE'S OFFERED THAT TO THE
- 43:54LEGISLATORS THERE.
- 43:55THERE IS A GENDER CLINICAL, A
- 43:58GENDER TRANSITION CLINIC IN
- 44:00BOWLING GREEN, JUST WAS IN THE
- 44:02NEWS RECENTLY THAT THEY OPENED
- 44:03UP.
- 44:04I'M NOT SURE IF THAT'S WHO THEY
- 44:06CALLED.
- 44:07BUT THAT'S PROBLEMATIC THAT ANY
- 44:08CLINIC WOULD DO A DOUBLE
- 44:11MASTECTOMY ON A MINOR CHILD.
- 44:13IS THAT SOMETHING YOU ARE IN
- 44:14FAVOR OF, CHRIS?
- 44:15>> ABSOLUTELY NOT AND NO ONE HAS
- 44:17COME FORWARD TO TELL US THAT IT
- 44:18HAS HAPPENED AND THAT IS NOT
- 44:19WHAT WE'VE ADVOCATED FOR, RENEE,
- 44:21THIS ENTIRE SESSION.
- 44:22WE SAID YOU CAN BAN SURGERIES
- 44:24UNDER THE AGE OF 18, BUT IF YOU
- 44:27TAKE AWAY PURELY REGULATORS AND
- 44:27HORMONE THERAPY, YOU'RE GOING TO
- 44:29DILL KILL KIDS.
- 44:30>> THEY'RE ALREADY KILLING
- 44:31THEM.
- 44:31>> DR. ANDREW VAN LAW SAID
- 44:34TRANSITION AFFIRMING MEDICAL
- 44:37INTERVENTION ACTUALLY IMPERILS
- 44:38RATHER THAN HELP ALREADY AT RISK
- 44:40GENDER DYSPHORIA YOUTH.
- 44:41SUCH INTERVENTIONS ARE NOT
- 44:44PROVEN FECK, NOT PROVEN SAVE AND
- 44:46DO NOT STOP SUICIDE.
- 44:47>> THIS CAME OUT WITHOUT A
- 44:49PERSON SAYING IT SHOWING THE
- 44:53ALTERNATE -- GENDER AFFIRMING
- 44:54SURGERY IS LESS THAN 1%.
- 44:56>> THAT'S NEWS TO ME.
- 44:57I'M NOT FAMILIAR WITH IT.
- 44:58>> DOES THAT LINE UP WITH WHAT
- 45:00YOU UNDERSTAND TO BE FACTUAL,
- 45:02MR. HARTMAN?
- 45:02>> ABSOLUTELY.
- 45:04THE STORIES WE HAEFER FOLKS TO
- 45:07DETRANSITION DO IT FROM SOCIETAL
- 45:08PRESSURE, FROM BULLYING,
- 45:11HARASSMENT, AND DISCRIMINATION
- 45:12THEY FACE FOR BEING TRANS.
- 45:14THOSE ARE TON STORIES WE EVER
- 45:16END UP HEARING.
- 45:17LESS THAN 1%?
- 45:19COMPLETELY CONSIST.
- 45:21>> SENATOR WILLIAMS, DOES THIS
- 45:23BILL GO FAR ENOUGH FOR YOU?
- 45:24AND WHAT ELSE COULD COME?
- 45:25>> I THINK THIS BILL IS A GREAT
- 45:29BILL.
- 45:29I BELIEVE THAT IT IS A SOUND
- 45:32BILL THAT CAN BE DEFENDALLED ALL
- 45:34THE WAY TO THE SUPREME COURT.
- 45:35I BELIEVE THE EMPHASIS IS ON
- 45:38PROTECTING CHILDREN.
- 45:39THAT IS THE KEY, PROTECTING
- 45:42CHILDREN, GIVING THEIR PARENTS
- 45:43SOME RIGHTS FOR THE EDUCATION OF
- 45:46THE CHILDREN IN THE SCHOOL
- 45:48SYSTEMS, BUT I DON'T SEE A
- 45:50COMPELLING REASON TO DO ANYTHING
- 45:52ELSE BEYOND THIS.
- 45:53THIS IS GOOD.
- 45:54WE'LL SEE HOW IT WORKS OUT.
- 45:55IT'S FINE.
- 45:57>> AND SO THIS, ALONG WE WILL
- 45:58WITH THE TEN MINUTES REMAINING,
- 46:01TALK ABOUT DID ABOUT SENATE BILL
- 46:035 THAT ADDRESSES WE HAVE CALLED
- 46:04IT OFTEN THE BOOK-BANNING BILL
- 46:06BUT IT ADDRESSES OBSCENE
- 46:08MATERIAL, PROGRAMMING ACTIVITIES
- 46:09AT SCHOOL THAT PARENTS MIGHT
- 46:11FIND OBJECTIONABLE.
- 46:12TALK TO US ABOUT THAT A LITTLE
- 46:14BIT.
- 46:14AND I WANT TO HEAR FROM THIS
- 46:17SIDE.
- 46:17THERE THERE BE A LAWSUIT FILED
- 46:18ON THAT ONE?
- 46:18>> IT'S DEALING WITH WHAT WE
- 46:20CLEARLY WOULD SAY IS OBSCENE,
- 46:23AND I THINK RICHARD HAS SOME
- 46:24EXAMPLES THAT YOU PROBABLY CAN'T
- 46:25SHOW ON THIS SHOW.
- 46:26>> CAN YOU JUST EXPLAIN THEM
- 46:29THAT THEM IN A G-RATED AUDIENCE
- 46:31WAY.
- 46:32>> SO A GROUP PARENTS WERE
- 46:34CONCERNED ABOUT THE BOOKS THAT
- 46:35WERE IN JEFFERSON COUNTY
- 46:37SCHOOLS.
- 46:37THERE IT WAS A PETITION DRIVE.
- 46:39THEY ASKED PARENTS TO COME IN
- 46:41FRONT OF THE SCHOOL BOARD.
- 46:42AND THE PARENT -- SCHOOL BOARD.
- 46:43AND THE PARENT 40 WANTED TO READ
- 46:45GENDERQUEER WAS TOLD SHE-
- 46:48COULDN'T DO IT.
- 46:48ACTUALLY HAVE A -- I HAVE GOT AN
- 46:50EXCERPT FROM ONE OF THE BOOKS.
- 46:52IF I HAD SHOWN THIS TO YOUR
- 46:54CAMERAS AND IF THIS WAS AIRED
- 46:55YOU'D GET AN FCC VIOLATION.
- 47:00UNFORTUNATELY IN THE CASE OF
- 47:01JEFFERSON COUNTY SCHOOLS THEY
- 47:02DIDN'T LISTEN TO THE PARENTS,
- 47:03AND THAT WAS WHY THINK BILL CAME
- 47:05FORWARD BECAUSE PARENTS NEEDED
- 47:07RECOURSE TO GET OBSCENE
- 47:09PORNOGRAPHIC BOOKS OUT OF THEIR
- 47:10SCHOOLS, AND THAT'S WHAT SENATE
- 47:11BILL 5 DOES.
- 47:12>> YOUR RESPONSE, MR. HARTMAN
- 47:14AND MS. GRAN HAN, TO THAT.
- 47:16>> WELL, THIS IS ANOTHER
- 47:18MECHANISM TO FURTHER
- 47:21MARGINALIZED LGBTQ FOLKS.
- 47:23AND THIS -- THESE TYPE OF BILLS,
- 47:26IT'S NOT A PARENT'S RIGHTS
- 47:28BILL.
- 47:28IT ONLY SERVES ONE TYPE OF A
- 47:31PARENT.
- 47:32AND THERE ARE ALREADY SYSTEMS IN
- 47:34PLACE FOR -- THERE ARE SITE
- 47:36BASED COUNCILS, THERE ARE SCHOOL
- 47:38BOARDS, AND WHAT WE'RE GOING TO
- 47:39DO IS OVERBURR AND ALREADY
- 47:45OVERWORKED, UNDERPAID SCHOOL
- 47:47EMPLOYEES DURING A MASSIVE
- 47:48TEACHER SHORTAGE IN KENTUCKY,
- 47:50AND WHERE IS THE LINE?
- 47:52WITNESS WE START DOING THIS, DO
- 47:54WE START BANNING IDEAS, BANNING
- 47:56OTHER THINGS THAT WE DON'T
- 47:57LIKE?
- 47:58>> HAVE YOU LOOKED AT SOME OF
- 47:59THE PICTURES IN THESE BOOKS,
- 48:00KIDS HAVING SEX WITH KIDS AND
- 48:02WITH ADULTS.
- 48:03VA GRAPHIC.
- 48:04WHEN I WAGS DOING MY HOMEWORK
- 48:05FOR THIS SHOW, I WAS WONDERING
- 48:07WHAT IN THE HECK AM I DOING
- 48:08LOOKING AT THIS.
- 48:09ARE THERE ANY THINGS THAT SHOULD
- 48:11NOT BE ALLOWED IN THE PUBLIC
- 48:12SCHOOLS?
- 48:12WHERE DO YOU DRAW THE LINE?
- 48:14>> WHERE DO YOU DRAW THE LINE?
- 48:16>> DEFINITELY RIGHT HERE.
- 48:18DEFINITELY KEEPING OBSCENITY AND
- 48:20PORNOGRAPHIC MATERIAL OUT.
- 48:21AND I DRAW THE LINE WITH
- 48:23PARENTAL RIGHTS, TOO.
- 48:23PARENTS SHOULD HAVE --
- 48:24>> PARENTS SHOULD MAKE THOSE
- 48:26DECISIONS.
- 48:27I THINK THAT THERE'S A
- 48:29SITE-BASED COUNCIL THAT MAKES
- 48:29THOSE DECISIONS, A SCHOOL BOARD
- 48:31THAT'S MAKING THOUGH DECISIONS,
- 48:34AND I WENT TO PUBLIC SCHOOLS.
- 48:36I WENT TO -- AND I TRUST MY KIDS
- 48:40WENT TO PUBLIC SCHOOLS.
- 48:41I TRUST THE TEACHERS.
- 48:43I TRUST THE SYSTEMS THAT ARE AT
- 48:45PLAY THERE.
- 48:45>> THAT'S THE KEY.
- 48:46WHEN PARENTS ARE SEEING THESE
- 48:47KIND OF MATERIALS, THAT TRUST
- 48:49HAS BEEN BREACHED, AND I THINK
- 48:50THAT'S WHY YOU'RE SEEING THE
- 48:52DECLINING ENROLLMENT IN SOME
- 48:54PUBLIC SCHOOLS, BECAUSE OF THE
- 48:55BREACH OF TRUST WITH THE PARENTS
- 48:57OVER THE LAST FEW YEARS.
- 49:00>> CAN YOU SPEAK AT TO MATERIAL
- 49:00THAT'S BEEN OBJECTIONABLE IN
- 49:04NCPS.
- 49:04>> FOR PARENTS TO MAKE AN
- 49:05APPEAL, IT'S NOT, YOU PARENT,
- 49:07IT'S A PUBLIC APPEAL AND
- 49:09DISCUSSION.
- 49:09THAT'S WHAT WE'RE ABOUT, HAVING
- 49:11A PUBLIC DISCUSSION.
- 49:13BEFORE THESE THINGS WERE DONE IN
- 49:15PRIVATE AND THERE BEATENS AN
- 49:16APPEALS PROCESS FOR MOST OF
- 49:17THEM.
- 49:17>> JUST LIKE JACKIE SAID, NAME
- 49:20FROM YOUR SCHOOL DISTRICT THAT
- 49:22DOESN'T HAVE A PROCESS TO GET
- 49:24OBJECTIONABLE MATERIALS OUT OF
- 49:25THE SCHOOL LIBRARY OR OUT OF THE
- 49:27SCHOOL CURRICULUM.
- 49:28THEY EXIST ALL ACROSS THE
- 49:30BOARD.
- 49:30AND JUST LIKE JACKIE SAID BE
- 49:31WITH NONE OF US UP HERE ARE
- 49:33EDUCATIONAL PROFESSIONALS.
- 49:34NONE OF US HAVE A DEGREE IN
- 49:36LIBRARY SCIENCES.
- 49:36I TRUST THE PROFESSIONALS, WHICH
- 49:39IS WHO THE JEFFERSON COUNTY
- 49:40PUBLIC SCHOOL BOARD RELIED
- 49:42UPON.
- 49:43THE FOLKS WHO ARE MAKING THOSE
- 49:45DECISIONS ARE WELL VERSED AND
- 49:48WELL-TRAINED IN WHAT IS AND IS
- 49:48NOT APPROPRIATE FOR STUDENTS OF
- 49:50CERTAIN AGES.
- 49:51>> GOING BACK TO SENATE BILL 150
- 49:54THIS QUESTION FROM DONNIE
- 49:57WILKERSON, WE KNOW THE PENALTY
- 49:58FOR DOCTORS WHO VIOLATE THE BILL
- 49:59BUT WHAT IS THE PENALTY FOR
- 50:00TEACHERS WHO VIOLATE THE BILL?
- 50:02BECAUSE PART OF SENATE BILL 150
- 50:04TALKS ABOUT MATERIALS THAT NEED
- 50:04TO BE PRESENTED TO PARENTS WHEN
- 50:07IT COMES TO ASSUME SEXUALITY,
- 50:09ET CETERA.
- 50:10SO IS THERE A PENALTY FOR
- 50:11TEACHERS?
- 50:13OR ADMINISTRATORS?
- 50:14>> I DON'T THINK SO.
- 50:16>> IF ANYTHING, RENEE, IT
- 50:19PROTECTS TEACHERS FROM BEING
- 50:21FORCED TO USE GENDER PRONOUNS OF
- 50:23STUDENTS AND KEEPING IT HIDDEN
- 50:25FROM PARENTS.
- 50:26THERE IS A PUBLIC SCHOOL PROGRAM
- 50:28IN ANDERSON COUNTY THAT LEFT HIS
- 50:29JOB BECAUSE HE'S BEEN TOLD BY
- 50:31THE SUPERINTENDENT THAT HE HAD
- 50:32TO USE GENDER PREFERRED PRONOUNS
- 50:34OF THE STUDENT AND HE WAS NOT
- 50:35SUPPOSED TO TELL THE PARENTS,
- 50:37AND HE COULD NOT IN GOOD
- 50:39CONSCIOUS CONTINUE TO BE THE
- 50:40PRINCIPAL THERE.
- 50:42IT PROTECTS TEACHERS FIRST
- 50:44AMENDMENT RIGHTS AND PROTECTS
- 50:44THEIR INTEGRITY AS WELL IN THAT
- 50:46THEY DON'T HAVE TO HIDE
- 50:47SOMETHING FROM THE PARENTS.
- 50:48>> I DARE THEM TO TRY TO ENFORCE
- 50:50THIS, TO TRY TO ENFORCE REFUSING
- 50:52TO ALLOW TEACHERS TO TALK ABOUT
- 50:55GENDER IDENTITY, TO TALK SEXUAL
- 50:57ORIENTATION AT ALL GRADE
- 50:58LEVELS.
- 50:58THE BILL SAYS AT ALL GRADE
- 51:00LEVELS.
- 51:01YOU'RE TRYING TO DETERIORATE A
- 51:02CHILLING EFFECT TO ERASE LGBTQ
- 51:04EXISTENCE FROM BUBBLE SCHOOLS, I
- 51:06MEAN, FROM EVERY AREA OF
- 51:07SOCIETY, BUT FROM PUBLIC SCHOOLS
- 51:09SPECIFICALLY.
- 51:10>> ALL GRADE LEVEL WILL BE
- 51:12INCLUDED IN DISCUSSION.
- 51:13>> NOW YOU'RE FOR PARENTS
- 51:16RIGHTS, SENATOR WILLIAMS.
- 51:17IT'S A SITUATIONAL THING WITH
- 51:18YOU, ISN'T IT?
- 51:20>> I'M FOR PARENTS BEING
- 51:24INVOLVED IN THEIR DISH.
- 51:25>> BUT NOT WHEN IT COMES TO
- 51:27MEDICAL CARE FOR THEIR
- 51:29CHILDREN.
- 51:29>> WHEN I LOOK AT PAGE,,
- 51:31SUBSECTION D IT'S LINES 10
- 51:32THROUGH 14, ANY CHILD REGARDLESS
- 51:35I GRADE LEVEL ENROLLED IN THE
- 51:36DISTRICT DOES NOT RECEIVE ANY
- 51:37INSTRUCTION, PRESENTATION THAT
- 51:38IS HAS THE GOAL OF OR PURPOSE OF
- 51:41STUDENTS I SAIDING GENDER ONLINE
- 51:47AT, GENDER SEXUAL EXPLORATION.
- 51:48>> HOW IS THAT IS NOT
- 51:49EVERYTHING?
- 51:49>> IN K THROUGH FIT PROHIBITS
- 51:51ANY SECONDS ED.
- 51:52>> HE'S NOT TALKING ABOUT K
- 51:54THROUGH 5.
- 51:54>> THAT'S THE FOLLOWING PART OF
- 51:56THAT.
- 51:56BUT THAT'S WHAT I JUST READ DOES
- 51:59EXIST IN THE MEASURE.
- 52:00AND THAT SAYS FOR ANY GRADE
- 52:02LEVEL.
- 52:03ANY CHILD REGARDLESS OF GRADE
- 52:04LEVEL.
- 52:05>> AGAIN, WHY DOES IT NOT
- 52:07SURPRISE ME DON'T HAVE A CLUE
- 52:09WHAT'S IN THE BILL.
- 52:10>> IT KEEPS OUT GENDER IDENTITY,
- 52:12PROMOTING LGBTQ OUNCE IN THE
- 52:13PUBLIC SCHOOLS.
- 52:14>> THEY JUST THREW EVERYTHING
- 52:16THEY COULD FIND IN THIS BILL.
- 52:18>> CHILDREN GRADE 5 AND BELOW DO
- 52:21NOT RECEIVE ANY -- HUMAN
- 52:25SEXUALITY OR --
- 52:26>> THERE'S A PARENTAL OPT-IN.
- 52:27MY OLDER SON IS IN THE
- 52:29MILITARY.
- 52:30THE KIDS TO GO A TEXAS SCHOOL
- 52:32AND THEY HAVE OPT-IN THERE WHERE
- 52:34THE PARENTS HAVE TO LOOK AT THE
- 52:35CURRICULUM AND, QUITE FRANKLY,
- 52:36HE LOVED THE CURRICULUM THEY HAD
- 52:38ON THEIR SEX EDUCATION OPTING
- 52:41EVERYBODY IN BECAUSE IT WAS
- 52:42GREAT CURRICULUM.
- 52:43THE PARENTS SHOULD BE ABLE TO
- 52:45LOOK EVEN AT THE TEENAGERS, OKAY
- 52:47AND BE ABLE TO OPT IN.
- 52:49>> OPT IN.
- 52:50>> OKAY.
- 52:51THAT'S WHAT THEY HAVE THIS
- 52:52INCOMES.
- 52:52AND THEY HAVE A GREAT CURRICULUM
- 52:54BECAUSE OF THAT.
- 52:56HE DIDN'T HAVE TO OPT OUT.
- 52:58SO WE HAVE OPT IN.
- 52:59I THINK THAT'S INVOLVED WIN
- 53:01OPT-IN IN THIS WHERE THEY HAVE
- 53:02TO BE ABLE TO OPT INTO IT.
- 53:04AND F. THEN THERE'S NO -- IF THE
- 53:07CHILD -- THEY DON'T WANT THE
- 53:08CHILD TO SEE IT, THEY DON'T HAVE
- 53:11TO.
- 53:12THAT'S WHAT I THINK THAT'S
- 53:13CONNECTED WITH.
- 53:14>> RIGHT.
- 53:14OKAY.
- 53:15REAL QUICKLY, THREE MINUTES
- 53:16REMAINING I WANT TO TALK ABOUT
- 53:18THE BILL DEALING WITH DRAG
- 53:20SHOWS, AND SO WE THINK THAT'S
- 53:23DEAD, SENATOR WILLIAMS.
- 53:23>> THEY'RE GOING TO PASS IT ON
- 53:25THE LAST DAY JUST TO DO IT.
- 53:26>> AND YOU HAVE INTEL TO THAT
- 53:28EFFECT?
- 53:28>> THEY GAVE IT A FIRST READING
- 53:30IN THE HOUSE ON THURSDAY, THE
- 53:31LAST DAY, SO THEY'RE GOING TO
- 53:32PASS IT ON THE THE LAST DAY OF
- 53:34THE SESSION.
- 53:34>> AGAIN,NESS ABOUT PROTECTING
- 53:36CHILDREN.
- 53:36THAT'S OUR INTEREST IN IT.
- 53:37>> SO EXPLAIN TO THE VIEWERS
- 53:39WHAT THIS PARTICULAR BILL DOES
- 53:41REAL QUICKLY.
- 53:41>> THIS HAS TO DO -- SO ACTUALLY
- 53:42I CALL IT A SEXUAL EQUALITY BILL
- 53:46BECAUSE THERE'S ACTUALLY THINGS
- 53:49THAT A MALE IMPERSONATING A
- 53:51FEMALE CAN DO BEFORE CHILDREN
- 53:52THAT WOULD GET A FEMALE IN
- 53:54TROUBLE EXPOSING THEMSELVES.
- 53:57BUT IT WASN'T CLEAR THAT A MALE
- 53:59WHO IS IMPERSONATING A FEMALE
- 54:01WOULD GET THAT THAT TROUBLE.
- 54:02ALL OF THIS HAS TO DO WITHIN THE
- 54:04PUBLIC BEFORE CHILDREN, YOU CAN
- 54:06STILL HAVE YOUR ADULT SHOWS,
- 54:07EVERYTHING IS FINE.
- 54:08YOU CAN STILL HAVE, AND THEY
- 54:10DON'T TALK -- DRAG IS NOT IN THE
- 54:12LANGUAGE.
- 54:13THEY TALK ABOUT MALE AND FEMALE
- 54:15IMPERSONATORS EQUALLIY.
- 54:16IF YOU'RE A MALE OR FEMALE
- 54:18IMPERSONATOR AND NOBODY REALLY
- 54:20KNOWS AND YOU'RE NOT DOING
- 54:22THINKING THAT IS OBSCENE UNDER
- 54:24OUR OBSCENITY LAWS OR PUREIENT
- 54:27INTEREST.
- 54:27>> THAT ALONE NOT GOING TO RUN A
- 54:28FUEL OF THE LAW.
- 54:29>> NO.
- 54:30YOU CAN HAVE THIS STUFF.
- 54:31BUT WHEN YOU START APPEALING TO
- 54:34THE PUREIENT INTERESTS OF A
- 54:36CHILD.
- 54:36>> DEFINE FOR A US
- 54:38PURCHASEIENT.
- 54:39>> I CAN BARELY PRONOUNCE IT.
- 54:41>> QUITE FRANKLY, WHEN YOU LOOK
- 54:42AT THE DEFINITION OF IT, I HAD
- 54:44IT HERE.
- 54:45I DON'T EVEN PIKE LIKE TO TALK
- 54:47ABOUT WHAT'S IN THE DEFINITION.
- 54:49GO LOOK IT UP.
- 54:51>> BECAUSE HE DOESN'T KNOW.
- 54:52>> I DO AND I'VE SEEN IT BUT
- 54:55IT'S NOT NICE LANGUAGE.
- 54:56>> YOU DON'T WANT TO USE NOT
- 54:58NICE LANGUAGE WITH A MINUTE AND
- 54:5936 SECONDS.
- 55:00>> THE REASON IS BILL IS
- 55:02NECESSARY IS BECAUSE SEXUALLY
- 55:04ORIENTED PERFORMANCES HAVE BEEN
- 55:05TAKING PLACE IN PUBLIC AREAS IN
- 55:06BOWLING GREEN LAST SUMMER.
- 55:08>> THAT'S A LIE REMEMBER
- 55:09RICHARD.
- 55:10A BOLD-FACE LIVE LIE.
- 55:14YOU'RE TALKING ABOUT BOWL GREEN
- 55:15PRIDE WHICH HAS NET HAD -- RENEE
- 55:17THIS IS A PARTLY A MULTI-ROCKED
- 55:22NATIONAL TO CREATED A CHILLING
- 55:23EFFECT ON THE PLACES WHERE WE.
- 55:27>> I'VE SEEN PICTURES OF
- 55:28PERFORMANCES AND I THINK YOU
- 55:30WOULD AGREE WITH ME THEY WERE
- 55:32SEXUAL ORIENTED PERFORMANCES,
- 55:34AND THAT'S WHAT SENATE BILL 115
- 55:36RESTRICTS AND IT KEEPS CHILDREN
- 55:37AWAY FROM THAT.
- 55:38IT DOES NOT BAN DRAG.
- 55:39IT DOES NOT BAN THE PAGEANTS OR
- 55:41THE SHOWS OR THE PRIDE EVENTS
- 55:43BUT IT DOES BAN SEXUALLY
- 55:45ORIENTED PERFORMANCES.
- 55:46>> WE'RE GOING TO LEAVE IT THERE
- 55:47AND WE WILL WATCH ESCAPEE WHAT
- 55:48HAPPENS COME MARCH 29th AND
- 55:50MARCH 30th AEROTHE LAST TWO
- 55:51DAYS OF THE SESSION.
- 55:52WE'LL SEE IF SENATE BILL 150
- 55:53GETS ACROSS THE FINISH LINE AND
- 55:55WHAT HAPPENS AFTER THAT.
- 55:58VETO ACTION BY THE GOVERNOR
- 56:00IS POSSIBLE.
- 56:01WE'LL SEE you NEXT MONDAY AT
- 56:028:00, SEE CHILD ABUSE & NEGLECT:
- 56:03A KET SPECIAL REPORT.
- 56:06YOU'LL HEAR FROM SURVIVORS,
- 56:07PARENTS, SOCIAL WORKERS AND sta
- 56:11OFFICIALS WORKING TO PROTECT
- 56:12KIDS IN DANGER AND TO PREVENT
- 56:12ABUSE BEFORE IT STARTS. BE SURE
- 56:14TO JOIN US EACH WEEKNIGHT AT
- 56:156:30 EASTERN, 5:30 CENTRAL FOR
- 56:16"KENTUCKY EDITION."
- 56:19WHERE WE BREAK DOWN ALL OF THESE
- 56:20ISSUES AND STORIES IN YOUR
- 56:22HOMETOWN MOST LIKELY EACH WEEK
- 56:24NIGHT AT 6:30/5:30 CENTRAL.
- 56:28I'M RENEE SHAW.
- 56:29THANK YOU FOR WATCHING TONIGHT