Latest / This is Oregon / S3E2: "We Know How to Build for This." Diego Melgar on Earthquake Preparedness
Transcript
- 0:02Welcome to This Is
- 0:03Oregon, a podcast where we take you inside research happening
- 0:07at the University of Oregon and show you how it applies to your daily life.
- 0:11I'm Natalie Hurd, your host for this episode.
- 0:14We're going to be talking today with Diego Melgar,
- 0:17associate professor of earth sciences and director of the Cascadia
- 0:22Region Earthquake Science Center here at the U of O.
- 0:25Diego studies how earthquakes rupture and generate
- 0:28tsunamis, and works on Early Warning Systems designed to give people
- 0:32precious seconds of notice before the shaking hits.
- 0:35Work that's especially relevant here in earthquake country.
- 0:39Welcome, Diego. Great to be here.
- 0:41So tell us, what drew you first to this work of earthquake sciences?
- 0:45It was happenstance, a little bit.
- 0:48I was in a degree in engineering geophysics,
- 0:52which is a pretty uncommon discipline.
- 0:55And it's not necessarily a discipline that is associated with earthquakes,
- 0:59but through the course of my undergraduate career, I came across
- 1:04a passionate professor, as is often the case, who offered me the opportunity
- 1:09to work with her over the summer
- 1:10and do fieldwork in pretty remote places of Mexico.
- 1:14I didn't know anything about earthquakes, seismology, that kind of thing.
- 1:19But fieldwork was great, really difficult,
- 1:22but I saw some really amazing things while I was there.
- 1:25And then throughout the year, I had the opportunity to work on the data
- 1:29that we had collected from sensors we deployed in the field, and that was it.
- 1:33Before I knew it, I was on a path to becoming an earthquake scientist.
- 1:37And there's also a component in that being from Mexico, natural hazards,
- 1:42earthquakes, volcanoes, they're part of our day-to-day lives.
- 1:46So it also felt like a natural extension of the world around me.
- 1:50Very damaging earthquakes in Mexico when I was growing up, when I was a young
- 1:54boy and a teenager, so it just felt like
- 1:58something, natural to go into.
- 2:01I loved, physics and math, and so this also felt like a great opportunity
- 2:06to combine that interest in the physical world with being outside.
- 2:10There's a lot of being outside
- 2:11in the earth sciences, and, yeah, it was just a great combination
- 2:14that I had no idea existed or could be a career for me.
- 2:17You talked about growing up in Mexico, and seeing
- 2:21what the aftermath of an earthquake looks like.
- 2:24Paint that picture
- 2:25for those of us who aren't used to living in an earthquake-prone environment.
- 2:30Mexico has a big scar from one earthquake in particular:
- 2:34the 1985 earthquake, which happened offshore Mexico, offshore
- 2:38your favorite beach resorts there, had enormous impacts in Mexico City.
- 2:4320,000 people lost their lives, hundreds of collapsed structures,
- 2:47some even argue that it led to the collapse of our political system
- 2:51in that country because of the response by the government was so poor,
- 2:54but it was a generational event.
- 2:56When I was growing up, I was too young to remember the earthquake.
- 2:59I was only one year old, but the collapse structures remained for a long time.
- 3:03And so I vividly remember driving with my parents to and from their office
- 3:08and seeing multiple collapsed 10-, 15-story buildings, oftentimes right next
- 3:14to the places where my parents worked, and they were just normal.
- 3:18You know, this idea of seeing the damage in the landscape of that event
- 3:24was pretty common, and so that made earthquakes very real for me.
- 3:29I forgot about them.
- 3:30It's not like I was thinking of becoming
- 3:31an earth scientist throughout most of my childhood.
- 3:33I was thinking of other things, you know, video games and being outside.
- 3:37Of course.
- 3:37But it made it such that when that career came up
- 3:40as an opportunity for me, I very naturally connected with it.
- 3:43And it's so different from us here in Oregon, and I know we have listeners
- 3:47from all over the place, but,
- 3:48you know, we don't often get reminders of earthquakes, right?
- 3:52But we live somewhere where we kind of should be thinking about earthquakes.
- 3:57Talk a little bit about the risk of our seismic situation here.
- 4:01The Pacific Northwest is pretty unique that way and different even from places
- 4:05closer to us, like California, or even Alaska, where people feel
- 4:10small earthquakes all the time, almost weekly in some places.
- 4:14Definitely monthly, definitely a few times per year Californians can say, “Oh,
- 4:18I felt that magnitude 3.2.” The Pacific Northwest is unique in that
- 4:23we have a very well-documented
- 4:24history of enormous earthquakes like truly, mind-bogglingly enormous.
- 4:28A Magnitude 9 earthquake is something that's hard to fathom.
- 4:31It's much larger than anything that would ever fit
- 4:34in the entire San Andreas fault, so truly large.
- 4:37But we don't get those small earthquakes for reasons
- 4:40that are scientifically interesting,
- 4:41and that's part of the research that we do here at the University of Oregon, but
- 4:45because we do not get those
- 4:47small earthquakes, there is none of these constant reminders
- 4:50that earthquakes are something that we should really be concerned with.
- 4:55And that makes the work of, preparing for them
- 4:57a little bit more challenging, because to people,
- 4:59they can feel like an abstract notion, something that is, you know,
- 5:03maybe I've heard about it in, in books and news
- 5:06articles and TikToks, but it's not something I have felt.
- 5:10Ask your Oregonian friends, whenever you meet them, if they felt an earthquake.
- 5:14And odds are that if they're lifelong Oregonians, the answer is no.
- 5:19If you pull your Californian friends, almost all of them have felt an
- 5:22earthquake.
- 5:23And so it just makes that sense of urgency that we need to get it together
- 5:27to prepare for earthquakes.
- 5:28It makes it a little harder to come by.
- 5:30That has significantly changed in my time in Oregon, and mostly thanks to
- 5:36the New Yorker article by Kathryn Schulz—Pulitzer Prize winning article
- 5:40that really shook people's imagination because she very vividly
- 5:45reported on what could happen and what we expected to happen.
- 5:48And I think we can draw a straight line from that article to increased
- 5:52funding for resilience, preparedness and research.
- 5:55So even though there's been a difficulty with coming to grips
- 5:59with what can happen in the Pacific Northwest,
- 6:01we've made enormous strides and I do want people to keep that in mind.
- 6:04We are learning every day with alacrity.
- 6:07We're learning so, so much and all our state agencies,
- 6:10our engineers, our partners, emergency managers, they're all on top of it.
- 6:14We all know what we need to do.
- 6:16It's just that the mountain we have to scale is pretty tall,
- 6:19and so it's going to take a while
- 6:20before we get to a place where we could say we're truly prepared,
- 6:24we're truly resilient.
- 6:25And that is really the focus of your work, and the University of Oregon
- 6:28is really kind of sitting at the center of some of this earthquake preparedness.
- 6:33You do a lot of work not only on earthquakes,
- 6:36but of course the impact and the tsunamis.
- 6:38And you work with so much data, can you point us a picture
- 6:42of what it is that you do and why it matters?
- 6:46Sure.
- 6:47One of the beauties of our earth science fields
- 6:49is that they're so data-rich and from a variety of places, folks work
- 6:55in the field collecting rock samples, sometimes looking at fossils.
- 7:00Fossils can tell stories about what happened because of a tsunami
- 7:03or an earthquake, but we can go from there all the way to space.
- 7:07We worked with satellite and remote sensing data right after an earthquake.
- 7:10The Earth moves so much that we can literally see it from space.
- 7:14It requires some special processing and techniques,
- 7:17but we can measure those movements from space. Wow.
- 7:20We can see tsunamis over the open ocean with satellites as well.
- 7:24And so we get this incredibly rich, variety of data that we can pick apart
- 7:30and that can help us to understand any earthquake that happens,
- 7:32but also any historical earthquake that has happened in the past
- 7:36so we can begin to put the pieces of this jigsaw together.
- 7:39We also work with real-time machine learning enabled data sets.
- 7:44For example, for the Earthquake Early Warning problem.
- 7:47The University of Oregon runs part of ShakeAlert,
- 7:49the national Earthquake Early Warning system.
- 7:51We run it on behalf of the federal government, the U.S.
- 7:53Geological Survey, and that requires extremely advanced
- 7:58algorithms and processing techniques so that we can decide without a human
- 8:02being involved, a big earthquake is happening
- 8:05and be able to send out an alert to millions of people.
- 8:07It's really a technological marvel.
- 8:09So the earth sciences have this just beautifully rich diversity,
- 8:12from being in the field, looking at rocks to computational models
- 8:17and machine learning to really try to save people's lives.
- 8:20Wow, it sounds like your work is so varied and the ShakeAlert system,
- 8:24I think we should talk more about it.
- 8:26It's something that is in place here in Oregon and across the country.
- 8:31Like you said, that we don't always get to experience—I've experienced it
- 8:35recently—there was a tsunami and I believe we got a ShakeAlert warning.
- 8:40So talk about that technology, and why it's so important.
- 8:46When we think about preparing for earthquakes, there’s many ways
- 8:49in which we can prepare so that we can minimize the impacts of a large event.
- 8:54One of those ways is we could have really good building codes
- 8:57so that we can build buildings that can withstand the shaking,
- 9:00we can have great tsunami evacuation maps so that we can move out of harm's way.
- 9:04Another way is by having Earthquake Early Warning systems.
- 9:06These are systems that tell you with 30, 40, 50,
- 9:0960 seconds of warning, “Hey, an earthquake just happened.
- 9:13You're going to feel really strong shaking.
- 9:15You need to take action.” That can mean sheltering in place, it can mean
- 9:19evacuating a space, it can mean stopping, getting out of an elevator.
- 9:23It can also impact automated systems.
- 9:25In the Bay Area, for example, the BART mass transit system,
- 9:29the trains stop automatically because of Earthquake Early Warning.
- 9:33So it's really about measuring the earthquake as quickly as possible,
- 9:37and then letting people take action so that we can minimize casualties
- 9:41and loss of life and also economic impacts.
- 9:44If we could stop an electrical generating station
- 9:48before it feels shaking and is damaged, that means that
- 9:52electrical generating station comes back online faster after the earthquake.
- 9:55So it's not just about the immediate moment,
- 9:58but it's about how we can rebound faster thanks to this technology.
- 10:02And it's really novel—when I started my career here at the UO
- 10:05in 2017, we did not have Earthquake Early Warning.
- 10:08This has happened in the last six years.
- 10:10Amazing, and I think it's really become part of folks lives now.
- 10:16You know, just like you said in the last six years where agencies and
- 10:20different entities are getting access
- 10:23to this system, are we supposed to still stop, drop and roll?
- 10:26Like, what do people know that's fires right there.
- 10:29And drop, cover and hold on, drop, cut.
- 10:31See, it's been a long time since I've had a drill.
- 10:34What should folks know if we were to experience an earthquake?
- 10:38I'll give you the official answer and then I'll give you my opinion.
- 10:42The official ShakeAlert branded answer
- 10:45across the US West Coast is drop, cover, and hold on.
- 10:48And that means right now, you know, we have this very sturdy table here.
- 10:51If we got an Earthquake Early Warning,
- 10:53all three of us would
- 10:54get underneath the table and ride it out, and there's really good reasons for that.
- 10:57Most of the injuries
- 10:59from earthquakes come from what we call nonstructural components.
- 11:02We tend to build pretty good buildings, by and large, in the United States.
- 11:06So it's not so much that the building is going to collapse,
- 11:09it's that these light fixtures and microphones are going to fall on us
- 11:12and hurt us, right. So we're trying to shelter from that.
- 11:14Now that's the official answer and I endorse it.
- 11:18Okay.
- 11:19In the Pacific Northwest, there's a detail which makes it complicated
- 11:22because we did not know or we forgot that we had really large earthquakes here.
- 11:27And we rediscovered that fairly recently.
- 11:29I think about the 90s or 2000s,
- 11:31this when we really came to grips again with the notion of earthquakes here.
- 11:34We have a lot of buildings, unreinforced masonry, call them
- 11:37brick buildings, many of them in the UO campus—we're not alone in this.
- 11:40There's tens of thousands of them in the Pacific Northwest.
- 11:43These buildings are really precarious, and research has shown, and experience
- 11:48throughout the world shows, that brick buildings
- 11:50are really terrible at withstanding shaking. Wow.
- 11:54So if you're in an unreinforced masonry building, you are in peril
- 11:58during an earthquake,
- 11:59and some people have argued that then the advice should be different.
- 12:03You should really be trying to get out of the building.
- 12:05Yeah.
- 12:05Now, the reason we don't tell people that is because we
- 12:08people are not qualified structural engineers. Right.
- 12:11They don't walk into a building
- 12:12and can immediately say, “Oh, I'm in this URM type structure.
- 12:16So now my actions are going to be different.”
- 12:18So we give you the simple message of dropping, covering and holding on,
- 12:21but reality is a little bit more complicated.
- 12:23Right, right, and if you get an early warning system
- 12:26and you know that maybe you're in an old building,
- 12:29maybe it would be best to get out?
- 12:31Depends, because again, it’s so tricky, right?
- 12:34Because going outside during shaking can also also be dangerous, right?
- 12:39Windows and bricks are flying and you're
- 12:42in a very potentially dangerous situation there too.
- 12:45So on average, the best message is drop, cover and hold.
- 12:49Okay. “The Big One.”
- 12:52What is the
- 12:53latest research around where we currently sit?
- 12:57Yeah, this is where the Pacific Northwest is different from our friends
- 13:02down in California.
- 13:03“The Big One,” what we know now to be true is that the last time
- 13:07we had a really big one is January 26th of the year 1700.
- 13:11Wow. Really a remarkable story of scientific discovery that we can pin
- 13:15such an old earthquake down to the day and probably down to the hour. Wow.
- 13:19It has to do with detective work of Japanese written accounts
- 13:22of a tsunami with no earthquake,
- 13:24and a lot of geological clues throughout the Pacific Northwest.
- 13:27But what we know for sure is that that event was really large, a magnitude
- 13:319, and that it had a very large tsunami and really strong
- 13:36shaking throughout the region, and that those kinds of earthquakes
- 13:39happen roughly every 500 years.
- 13:42Okay, I'm doing the math. That's right.
- 13:44You're thinking, “It's been 326 years.” Okay, thank you!
- 13:48326 years. I wasn't really doing the math!
- 13:50And they happen every 500 years.
- 13:52So maybe it's getting to be about time.
- 13:55But in reality, earthquakes are so complex and so complicated.
- 14:00What we see in geology is that these really large earthquakes,
- 14:03yeah, they happen on average every 500 years,
- 14:05but sometimes they cluster together very closely in time,
- 14:09and they might happen every 200 years, and then there might be a 2000 year
- 14:12long period with nothing. Okay.
- 14:14A really quiet period, and then “boom, boom, boom,” some more large
- 14:17earthquakes, and sometimes, they might be really regular.
- 14:20You know, they took their fiber supplements and they're really regular,
- 14:23but we can never tell whether we're in one of these regular periods
- 14:27or one of these chaotic, complicated periods.
- 14:30So what we know for
- 14:31sure is that it was really large and that it's going to happen again,
- 14:34but we're very far away from knowing when it's going to happen again.
- 14:38So now our homework, as Cascadians, is to prepare,
- 14:41to make sure our building codes are good, that we have Earthquake Early
- 14:44Warning systems that our emergency management services
- 14:47are up to snuff, just that we know what to do.
- 14:50Okay.
- 14:50And I'll say that large earthquakes need not be humanitarian catastrophes.
- 14:55In Japan, in 2011, magnitude 9 earthquake—no
- 15:00collapsed buildings because the Japanese have such great building codes.
- 15:04We know how to build for earthquakes.
- 15:06There's no reason why we can't do the same here in the Pacific Northwest.
- 15:10The situation is: it's going to take us a little while
- 15:13to replace our older building stock with newer building stock.
- 15:16So I have no reason to believe that we won't get there.
- 15:20We will. It's just going to take a little bit.
- 15:22Yeah, and funding, and I know that there has been an effort to at least
- 15:25get certain certain facilities like our K-12 schools.
- 15:28Right.
- 15:29There's been a lot of grant money and a lot of public schools
- 15:31that have been seismically upgraded. Right.
- 15:34Which is a good thing.
- 15:35Right, and so the earthquake problem shares many commonalities
- 15:39with climate change.
- 15:41We know now that we're going to have some flavor of climate change.
- 15:45And so now the name of the game is what we call “adaptation.” How are we going
- 15:49to change the way we behave as a society to just accommodate what is happening?
- 15:54The same thing is true in the earthquake problem.
- 15:56Our coastal towns and societies,
- 15:59they don't need to totally move out of the way, but maybe over time
- 16:02we need to move schools and firehouses and hospitals.
- 16:06Maybe some of them need to be relocated or strengthened.
- 16:09That takes time, effort and money.
- 16:11And so what we need is just to not let up.
- 16:14We don't have to fix everything right away.
- 16:17We can do it bit by bit, but we should be doing it bit by bit
- 16:20every single day so that eventually it adds up to something significant.
- 16:25And I will say that
- 16:26generally the awareness now in the Pacific Northwest of this problem is very good.
- 16:30We just need to keep with it.
- 16:32This is “Tracktown.” We're used to running.
- 16:34This is not a sprint.
- 16:36It's not even a 400 meter race.
- 16:38This is an “ultramarathon.” “Ultramarathon.”
- 16:39It's going to take a long time.
- 16:41We have to keep going. That’s right.
- 16:42And one of the pieces that is encouraging, I think,
- 16:46and maybe a little controversial, is AI.
- 16:49Can you just briefly touch on what
- 16:52that might do for the earthquake prediction realm?
- 16:55Yeah.
- 16:56I want to be very clear that earthquake prediction means being able to say
- 17:01that an earthquake is going to happen, hours, days, weeks in advance,
- 17:05and being able to tell you it's going to be this big and it's
- 17:08going to be offshore Washington, Oregon, British Columbia, that's prediction.
- 17:12We're very, very far away from being able to do that.
- 17:15What we can do now with Earthquake Early
- 17:16Warning is detect it quickly, characterize it quickly, warn people quickly.
- 17:20Okay, so early warning is what we can do, prediction is what we cannot do.
- 17:24And it's what we wish we could do. Right.
- 17:26Every seismologist that has ever existed wishes that we could do prediction,
- 17:31because that's the way in which we truly make a difference.
- 17:34As we discussed throughout this episode, the earthquake
- 17:36phenomenon is really complicated, and that's what makes prediction hard.
- 17:39Perhaps we'll get there one day, perhaps we won't, I don't know, but,
- 17:43machine learning and AI has had an impact in our field
- 17:47because we're so data-rich and because we require
- 17:50algorithms and systems that can operate without human interaction.
- 17:54And as we discussed, machine learning
- 17:56and AI has been vilified in many spaces, and rightfully so.
- 17:59But what I want people to remember
- 18:01is that technologies are neither good or bad on their own.
- 18:04It's the people that wield the technologies that wield them for good
- 18:08or for bad,
- 18:09and in this case, machine learning and AI can have a real positive impact
- 18:13and has already begun
- 18:14to have a real positive impact in our field and will continue to do so.
- 18:17Indubitably.
- 18:19And just to wrap us up, what is one thing that you would want people
- 18:23to take away from this episode?
- 18:24And you know,
- 18:25I know people think about “the big one,” and it can be it can be scary,
- 18:29you know, what's something that that we can take away from today?
- 18:32You don't need to be afraid.
- 18:34Or rather, don't let the fear paralyze you.
- 18:38We just need to learn to live with earthquakes.
- 18:41Everywhere that a human has ever lived, there has been a hazard.
- 18:45Whether it's a blizzard, frost, a storm, hurricanes, landslides,
- 18:50all of our ancestors that have lived before us, and all of our children
- 18:53that will live after us will live with a hazard.
- 18:56All we have to do is learn how to live with them, and in the case of earthquakes,
- 19:00we know how to live with them.
- 19:01We know how to build for earthquakes.
- 19:03We know how to deploy technology to keep us safe.
- 19:06There is no reason why earthquakes need to be catastrophes,
- 19:10as long as we're serious about it and we get ready.
- 19:12I think we feel good knowing that you are doing
- 19:14some of this research here, Diego, at the University of Oregon.
- 19:17That's Diego Melgar, associate professor of earth sciences
- 19:20and director of the Cascadia Region Earthquake Science Center.
- 19:24Thank you so much for joining us today. Thank you.
- 19:27And if you're interested in learning more, you can check out the links
- 19:29in the episode description, and don't forget to follow
- 19:32This Is Oregon for more stories from the University of Oregon.
- 19:35We will see you on the next episode.
- 19:38This Is
- 19:39Oregon is produced by the Division of University Communications.
- 19:42For more of the latest University
- 19:44of Oregon research and news, visit news.uoregon.edu,
- 19:48or find us on your favorite social media platform using the handle @uoregon.
- 19:53Thanks for listening, and Go Ducks!