Latest / eMotors: Electric Revolution / UK Electric Vehicle Mileage and Charging Taxes
Transcript
- 0:09Welcome back to the Deep dive. You know, this is where we
- 0:12tackle those really complex shifts, policy tech and try and
- 0:16boil them down for you. And today, well, it's a
- 0:18fascinating 1A real paradox, actually.
- 0:21Electric vehicles, EVs, there's supposed to be the clean green
- 0:25answer, right? But their very success is
- 0:28creating this enormous, frankly unavoidable financial headache
- 0:32for governments, especially those relying on, you know, old
- 0:35school fuel taxes. It really is a case of success
- 0:38creating new challenges. And the UK, well, they're lining
- 0:41up what looks like a pretty aggressive solution, a new
- 0:44mandatory paper mile tax specifically aimed at EV's,
- 0:47basically to plug this looming fiscal black hole.
- 0:51The black hole. OK.
- 0:52And our sources, they're confirming this isn't just talk
- 0:55anymore. Policy work is speeding up
- 0:57because, well, the revenue crunch happening right now.
- 1:00Right. So just so you the listener, get
- 1:02the picture, what kind of money are we talking about here?
- 1:03How big is this black hole? We're talking about a, well, a
- 1:06fundamental problem for funding public services.
- 1:09Right now you've got motoring taxes, that's fuel duty mainly,
- 1:13and vehicle excise duty or VED. Together they pull in around 35
- 1:18billion every single year for the UK Treasury. 35 billion.
- 1:23Wow. Yeah.
- 1:24And fuel duty is the big chunk of that, maybe 28 billion or?
- 1:27So £35 billion? I mean, just for context, that's
- 1:30enough to cover the entire policing budget for England and
- 1:32Wales, plus all the local Rd. repairs.
- 1:35With billions leftover, that's a staggering amount of income to
- 1:38just disappear. It is, and the Office for Budget
- 1:41Responsibility, the OBR, they confirm it.
- 1:43As internal combustion engine cars, ICE vehicles decline, this
- 1:47loss is well, it's inevitable. They reckon.
- 1:50Fuel duty revenue is peaking pretty much now 2024-2025 at
- 1:54around 30 billion. So it's already started.
- 1:56Pretty much right from here on, basically every EV sold speeds
- 1:59up that decline. They're calling it a very real
- 2:01problem for funding. You know, hospitals, schools,
- 2:03roads all within the next 10 years or so.
- 2:06So moving to a new system, it's not really an if, it's a when
- 2:09and how. OK, so that sets our mission for
- 2:12today pretty clearly using the material you shared with us, and
- 2:16we're diving into the specifics. What's the actual proposed tax?
- 2:20How on earth can they track mileage without everyone
- 2:23screaming about privacy? And crucially, how do you make
- 2:26it fair, especially for, you know, people in rural areas or
- 2:29key workers who just have to drive?
- 2:31Exactly. It's not just about the money,
- 2:33the fiscal need, it's about the politics, the complexity of
- 2:36getting it right. Right, let's kick off with the
- 2:38current system then, because while the government needs the
- 2:41cash, our sources are pretty clear that reform isn't just
- 2:44about plugging a gap. The current system has some
- 2:47pretty big flaws itself, doesn't it?
- 2:49Quite unfair in some ways. It is, yeah.
- 2:52And part of the problem is that the unfairness is kind of hidden
- 2:55fuel duty. You pay it per liter of fuel you
- 2:57buy, and that tax is just mixed into the price you see at the
- 2:59pump. There's no transparency.
- 3:02Most people honestly have no real idea how much they pay each
- 3:05year. They either guess way too high
- 3:07or way too low. And that's where the mechanism
- 3:09itself starts to bite the people who can least afford it, right?
- 3:12Paying per liter? How does that hit lower income
- 3:16drivers harder? Well, it comes down to the car's
- 3:18efficiency. If you're driving an older car,
- 3:21maybe it only does, say, 30 miles to the gallon.
- 3:24You're buying a lot more petrol and paying that hidden tax more
- 3:28often to cover the same distance as someone in a newer car doing
- 3:32maybe 60 miles per gallon, right?
- 3:35So effectively, the less efficient your car, the more tax
- 3:37you end up paying for every mile you drive.
- 3:39That really clarifies it. So the system we have now
- 3:43encourages newer, more efficient cars, which, let's face it, tend
- 3:48to be bought by wealthier households, and at the same time
- 3:50it puts a heavier burden on drivers stuck with older, less
- 3:54efficient vehicles. Exactly which actually makes the
- 3:56case for a distance based system rather than a fuel based one
- 4:00seem, well, intrinsically fairer from the start.
- 4:03It lays the groundwork for change.
- 4:04Yeah, OK, let's move on to the proposed fix then.
- 4:07The UK government has actually put a number out there, an
- 4:11estimated 3 pence per mile charge just for fully electric
- 4:15vehicles, probably starting around 2028.
- 4:17That's the figure being talked about, yes. 3P in hybrids.
- 4:21They're in the mix, too. Yeah, the expectation is they'll
- 4:23be taxed too, but probably at a lower, maybe variable rate.
- 4:27It's still a bit fuzzy. OK, so that three P figure,
- 4:29let's put it in context for people listening.
- 4:32How does that compare to what drivers pay now?
- 4:34Well, the average petrol or diesel driver right now pays
- 4:38roughly £600 a year in fuel duty.
- 4:41That's kind of the benchmark they're trying to replace
- 4:43revenue wise. So how does the three P EV tax
- 4:46stack up against that £600? It really depends on how much
- 4:49you drive. If you do about 12,000 miles a
- 4:52year, which is pretty average, that 3P tax works out to about
- 4:55£360.00 a year. OK.
- 4:57So less than the current average.
- 4:58Yeah, if you're a lower mileage driver, maybe doing 8000 miles,
- 5:02that's only £240 a year. You'd have to be a really high
- 5:05mileage driver, maybe a fleet car doing 20,000 miles to hit
- 5:08that £600 mark under this proposal.
- 5:10What's really interesting there though, is even with this new
- 5:12tax, EVs still sound like they'll be way cheaper to run
- 5:16overall. Oh, absolutely.
- 5:17That's the crucial context here. Even factoring in the three P
- 5:21tax, running an EV, charging it up maintenance, it cost
- 5:24somewhere between say 10P and 12P per mile.
- 5:27Right now, petrol or diesel, you're looking at significantly
- 5:29more, probably 19 P to 21 P per mile, right?
- 5:33So this tax, yeah, it makes sure EV drivers contribute to Rd.
- 5:37cost, but it definitely doesn't wipe out that big economic
- 5:40advantage of switching. Which makes the pushback from
- 5:43some parts of the industry a little surprising.
- 5:46You mentioned bodies like the SMMT warning could slow down the
- 5:49EV transition, especially for fleets, but if a cost gap is
- 5:53still that big, why the strong opposition?
- 5:55Well, I think it's partly about visibility and certainty.
- 5:59Fleets calculate their total cost of ownership TCO very
- 6:02carefully. Introducing a new, very visible
- 6:05tax, even if it's ultimately lower than the hidden fuel duty,
- 6:08just adds complexity and, well, uncertainty for their planning.
- 6:12OK, the admin headache. And probably consumer perception
- 6:15too. They worry it kind of bursts the
- 6:18tax free bubble that's encouraged some people to
- 6:20switch. Then on the flip side you've got
- 6:22people saying well hang on, it is fairer this way, everyone who
- 6:26uses the roads pays. Plus there's that argument that
- 6:30EVs being heavier because of the batteries and having that
- 6:33instant torque might actually cause more Rd.
- 6:36Wear and contribute more to non exhaust pollution like from
- 6:40tires and brakes. That's definitely part of the
- 6:42pro tax argument, yeah. And we also saw in the sources a
- 6:45lot of concerns, specifically from plug in hybrid owners.
- 6:49They're worried they might get caught in the middle, paying the
- 6:51old fuel tax when they use petrol and the new EV mileage
- 6:55tax when they run on electricity.
- 6:56Yeah, like a double whammy. Exactly.
- 6:58A kind of confusing, potentially unfair double taxation.
- 7:02That's something the policy design really needs to sort out
- 7:04quickly. Definitely.
- 7:05OK, let's pivot to maybe the biggest hurdle, public
- 7:08acceptance. You know, whenever politicians
- 7:10even whisper Rd. pricing, the assumption is it's political
- 7:13dynamite. Hugely unpopular, but the
- 7:17research you shared this felt like the big aha moment.
- 7:20The public view. It's actually quite nuanced,
- 7:22maybe even movable. Yeah, this was really striking
- 7:25and probably the most hopeful finding for reformers.
- 7:29OK, yes, initial reaction, there's resistance, but dig
- 7:32deeper. 3 out of five people, 60% already agree the current
- 7:36tax system needs fixing. That's a solid base. 60% agree
- 7:39reform is needed. OK.
- 7:41And even better, when people actually engaged with the
- 7:43arguments, you know, when the unfairness of the current system
- 7:46was explained and the different policy options were laid out,
- 7:48support for switching to a pay as you drive system actually
- 7:51jumped by 8 percentage points, up to 49% overall, nearly half.
- 7:56Wow, an 8 point swing just from explaining it properly.
- 8:00So the opposition isn't necessarily to the idea of
- 8:02paying for Rd. use, it's more about the fear of how it might
- 8:07work out in practice. If opinion can shift like that,
- 8:11what's the absolute core issue they need to solve to get people
- 8:14on board? It boils down almost entirely to
- 8:17fairness. Specifically fairness for people
- 8:20who don't really have a choice but to drive.
- 8:23The number one reason people gave for being against it, cited
- 8:26by 63% of those initially opposed, was exactly that
- 8:30belief. Paper mile is just unfair to
- 8:32those who must drive. Right, like you said, the rural
- 8:35commuter, maybe a care worker going between appointments,
- 8:38someone working night shifts when there's no public
- 8:40transport. Exactly.
- 8:41Those people see it as potentially penalizing
- 8:43necessity. And that burden is already
- 8:45higher for some groups. There was a pretty stark
- 8:47statistic in the sources about rural drivers, wasn't there?
- 8:50Yes, really Stark. On average, rural households
- 8:52already spend about 14% of their disposable income just on
- 8:56transport. 14%. Compared to only 10% for urban
- 8:59households, that 4 percentage point gap, it's huge.
- 9:04It basically makes transport costs like a massive unavoidable
- 9:07second rent payment if you live outside a big town or city.
- 9:11OK. So any new system that doesn't
- 9:13explicitly account for that difference is going to be seen
- 9:16as deeply unfair, potentially regressive.
- 9:19Absolutely. It has to be baked into the
- 9:21design from the start. So what specific ideas did work?
- 9:25What fairness mechanisms actually seem to resonate with
- 9:27the public and, you know, move the needle on support?
- 9:30The single most popular idea across the board was the concept
- 9:33of a tax free mileage allowance. Like the first chunk of miles
- 9:36you drive each year are free. Exactly.
- 9:38People like that because it gives them a sense of control
- 9:41over their costs. And crucially, the sources
- 9:43suggest this allowance could be varied very geographically,
- 9:47specifically to tackle that rural urban divide we just
- 9:49talked about. Meaning OK, so a driver in a
- 9:52remote area who maybe has to drive miles just to get milk or
- 9:55see a doctor could get a higher allowance, say 3000 free miles a
- 10:00year, while someone in the city with loads of buses and trains
- 10:03available might get a lower allowance, maybe 1000 miles.
- 10:06Precisely. That's the concept.
- 10:08Of course, implementing that fairly, that's the challenge.
- 10:12How do you define rural for tax purposes without creating
- 10:16endless arguments and loopholes? It sounds simple, but it's
- 10:19bureaucratically tricky. Yeah, I can see that.
- 10:22What else helped build support? Investing in the alternatives, A
- 10:26really big majority, 69%, said they'd be much more supportive
- 10:29if public transport was made significantly cheaper and better
- 10:32connected before this tax comes in.
- 10:34Makes sense. If you want people to drive
- 10:35less, give them a viable option. Right.
- 10:37And about half also backed the idea of targeted discounts or
- 10:40maybe higher allowances for specific groups, people like
- 10:44disabled drivers, key workers, those who absolutely need their
- 10:47car for their job. There's a public understanding,
- 10:50it seems, that a fair transition needs practical alternatives
- 10:52alongside the tax. That seems logical.
- 10:55OK, let's get into the really naughty stuff now.
- 10:57Implementation. This is where the policy
- 11:00ambition meets messy reality and technology.
- 11:04Deciding what to charge per mile is one thing.
- 11:07Figuring out how to actually monitor everyone's mileage
- 11:10without sparking mass panic about Big Brother surveillance?
- 11:14That feels like the main event. It's definitely the most complex
- 11:17hurdle, yeah. The idea of just asking people
- 11:19to self report their mileage, the sources basically called
- 11:22that comically naive, impossible to enforce properly.
- 11:26Right, you need something reliable.
- 11:27You do so if the tax is going to work, they need systems that are
- 11:30robust but also crucially, seen as noninvasive by the public.
- 11:34So where did the public draw the line?
- 11:36What level of monitoring were they actually prepared to accept
- 11:39in return for this potentially fairer tax system?
- 11:42Well the simplest and by far the most popular method was just
- 11:45checking the cars odometer reading during its annual MOT
- 11:48tests. The yearly checkup.
- 11:50Exactly. That avoids any kind of live
- 11:52tracking, which hits the main privacy worry head on.
- 11:55But it's basic. It wouldn't allow for any smart
- 11:59variable charging. OK, so for a smarter system you
- 12:02need tech. What tech did people find?
- 12:04Maybe grudgingly acceptable. And what were the conditions?
- 12:08They were kind of split, but very conditional.
- 12:10Using the car's built in telematics or GPS that got 46%
- 12:14support. Using a separate plug in device
- 12:16like a little dongle, 44% support.
- 12:18But, and this is a huge but, that support was totally
- 12:21dependent on an absolute guarantee.
- 12:23The tech must only track mileage.
- 12:25Nothing. Else no location, no speed, no
- 12:28destination data. Absolutely not.
- 12:30That was a deal breaker. People explicitly rejected
- 12:32anything that tracked where they went or how fast, and things
- 12:35like roadside cameras constantly scanning number plates are using
- 12:38insurance style black boxes. They were deeply unpopular, seen
- 12:42as far too invasive, creating a feeling of constant state
- 12:45monitoring. So the technology choice really
- 12:47dictates the policy options available and the sources laid
- 12:51out three potential ways this could roll out sort of phases.
- 12:54We should probably give them clear names for listeners.
- 12:56Good idea. How about option one, the simple
- 12:58EV tax, option 2 the flat rate for all, and option 3 the full
- 13:02smart system? OK, I like that.
- 13:05Option one, simple EV tax. Option 2, flat rate for all.
- 13:10Option 3, full smart system. Let's start with the end goal.
- 13:14Option three What's the full smart system?
- 13:16Right, Option 3, The full smart system is really seen as the
- 13:20long term ideal because it has the potential to be the fairest
- 13:23and most efficient. It relies completely on that
- 13:26tracking technology we just discussed, but it uses it to
- 13:30vary the charge per mile, not just based on the vehicle's
- 13:33emissions, but crucially based on where you're driving and even
- 13:36when you're driving time of day. So dynamic pricing.
- 13:39Exactly, this is how you best tackle that core fairness issue.
- 13:43A driver in a rural area with no train line nearby?
- 13:46They could payless per mile. Someone driving right into
- 13:49central London during morning rush hour adding to massive
- 13:51congestion. They pay more.
- 13:53It tackles revenue and congestion.
- 13:54But it requires the tracking technology that makes people
- 13:56nervous. So what are the stepping stones?
- 13:58Option 1 and 2. Right.
- 14:00Option one, the simple EV tax is just that basic 3P per mile
- 14:05charge only for EVs we talked about earlier.
- 14:08It's simple. It starts plugging the revenue
- 14:10gap quickly, but it's not very sophisticated or fair across all
- 14:13drivers. OK.
- 14:14And option 2, a flat rate for all.
- 14:17Option 2 is maybe the crucial interim step or even a long term
- 14:21alternative for people who hate tracking.
- 14:23This would replace fuel duty and VED for everyone.
- 14:27Petrol, diesel, electric. The charge would be based on
- 14:30your vehicle type. Maybe it's emissions band.
- 14:32But, and this is key, it would only require checking the
- 14:34odometer at the MOT. So no live tracking needed for
- 14:38option 2. Correct.
- 14:39It avoids the constant tracking issue while still moving
- 14:41everyone to a cleaner, simpler attack structure based on
- 14:44vehicle impact, not just fuel used.
- 14:45Got it. And one last implementation
- 14:47piece. Yeah, fitting this new national
- 14:50system together with all the existing local charges like
- 14:52London's congestion charge or clean air zones and other
- 14:54cities, that seems vital to avoid total confusion.
- 14:57Oh, absolutely critical. The public were really clear on
- 14:59this. There was strong support, 42%
- 15:02for rolling all those existing local schemes into the single
- 15:05national system, maybe allowing cities to add a specific local
- 15:08top up if needed. But fundamentally drivers want
- 15:12one account, one bill, one system.
- 15:14That makes sense. Yeah, not juggling filling 5
- 15:16different apps and charges just to drive across the country.
- 15:19Nobody wants that. OK, let's try and pull this all
- 15:21together then. The core tension seems crystal
- 15:23clear. This kind of tax reform is
- 15:25becoming fiscally unavoidable, and the basic idea paying for
- 15:29the roads you actually use seems to have decent underlying
- 15:32support conceptually as being fair.
- 15:34But the design absolutely has to shield those people who drive
- 15:37out of sheer necessity, not choice.
- 15:39That's the tightrope they have to walk politically.
- 15:42That's everything. And what's fascinating from the
- 15:44sources is the debate really has moved on.
- 15:46It's less about if some form of Rd. pricing is coming and much
- 15:50more about how it gets done. And the public, perhaps
- 15:53surprisingly to some politicians, seems more open to
- 15:56this huge change than often assumed.
- 15:58Provided these are big provisos. Provided the system is genuinely
- 16:03revenue neutral overall, so it doesn't become a stealth tax
- 16:06rise, just replacing the 35 billion currently raised.
- 16:09And secondly, it has to be incredibly transparent.
- 16:12People need to understand clearly why they're being
- 16:14charged, what they're being charged.
- 16:16But drilling down into those options, the real key to
- 16:18unlocking political acceptance might lie in giving people a
- 16:22genuine choice right that way to handle the privacy concern.
- 16:26That feels like the crucial take away.
- 16:27Yeah, the public showed they might accept the smart tracking
- 16:30needed for option 3. The flexible system, but only if
- 16:33they have a clear guaranteed way to opt out so.
- 16:36You could offer option 3, the full smart system with its
- 16:38variable rates based on time and place.
- 16:40But allow any driver who says Nope, I don't want tracking
- 16:43period to instead choose option 2.
- 16:46Pay a higher fixed annual charge based purely on their car type,
- 16:51verified only by the MOT Odometer check.
- 16:55So it boils down to this privacy comes at a fixed potentially
- 16:59higher price flexibility and potentially lower costs require
- 17:02accepting some form of mileage tracking.
- 17:04Does offering that straightforward choice hold the
- 17:06key to making this massive, inevitable reform political
- 17:09possible? That's probably the question for
- 17:11you to chew on as we all start thinking about the future of how
- 17:13we pay for our roads.