Latest / Tech IPO Conversations with Fexingo: Public Software Companies and Capital Markets / How Post IPO Companies Manage Their First Earnings Report
Transcript
- Lucas: So we're about a month away from the end of Q3, and for a handful of freshly public tech companies, that means they're about to file their very first quarterly report as a public company. And that first earnings release is a different beast from any that follows. Luna: Different how? I mean, the numbers are the numbers. You either beat or you miss. Lucas: Right, but the numbers are almost secondary. The real test is whether management can tell a coherent story about what those numbers mean. Because investors aren't just judging the quarter, they're judging whether they can trust this management team to run a public company for the next decade. Luna: So it's a trust-building exercise disguised as a financial report. Lucas: Exactly. And that's why, before we dive into the mechanics, I want to take a quick honest moment here. This show is ad-free, and it stays that way because a small group of listeners chips in a few dollars a month through buy me a coffee dot com slash fexingo. If these conversations help you think about markets or your own company, that's the only reason we're able to do this. No pressure, just knowing it's appreciated. Luna: Yeah, and we genuinely read every note people leave there. It keeps us honest. Lucas: Okay, so back to that first quarterly report. Let's start with the timing. A company that IPOs in, say, June will usually have to file a 10-Q for the quarter ending in September, and that's their first real public-facing financial statement. Luna: And what's the actual stakes? I mean, is it just about the stock going up or down? Lucas: Well, the stock reaction matters, but it's more about setting the template. The Street is watching to see how management frames their own numbers, how they answer questions, how they handle the unexpected. That first call shapes the analyst consensus for the next several quarters. Get it right, and you buy yourself goodwill. Get it wrong, and you're fighting skepticism for a year. Luna: So what does 'right' actually look like? Give me a concrete example. Lucas: Take Palantir. They went public in late 2020, and their first few quarters were a masterclass in managing expectations. They consistently guided conservatively, then beat, then raised. That 'guide low, beat high' pattern became their signature. It frustrated some analysts who wanted more aggressive guidance, but it built a reputation for under-promising and over-delivering. Luna: And that's a strategy any company can use, right? Just sandbag the numbers. Lucas: It's not that simple. If the Street catches on that you're always sandbagging, they'll just bake that into their models, and then a beat doesn't impress anyone. The trick is to be predictable, not just conservative. Palantir's board had a reputation for being extremely disciplined about guidance, and that consistency became the asset. Luna: Okay, so predictability matters more than the actual beat. Lucas: Right. And that's why the whisper number is such a big deal for post ipo companies. The whisper number is the unofficial consensus that traders talk about in chat rooms and on Twitter, and it's often higher than the official analyst consensus. So a company might beat the published estimate by two cents and still see the stock drop because the whisper number was three cents higher. Luna: So you're not just managing against the analysts' published numbers, you're managing against an informal market sentiment. Lucas: Exactly. And for a new public company, there's no history of how the market interprets their numbers. So that first call is also about teaching investors how to think about the company's seasonality, its cost structure, its growth levers. Luna: Let's talk about the structure of the call itself. What should listeners expect to hear differently from a post ipo company's first earnings call versus a seasoned one? Lucas: The big difference is the amount of time spent on 'business overview' versus 'quarterly results'. A mature company might have a couple of slides on new initiatives, but a post ipo company will often spend twenty minutes just explaining what the company does, how it makes money, and why the unit economics are sound. It can feel like a sales pitch, but it's necessary because many analysts on the call are covering the company for the first time. Luna: And they're not all tech analysts either, right? I mean, a lot of generalist funds are taking a look at the IPO. Lucas: Right, so you have a mixed audience. Some analysts have deep industry knowledge, others are just trying to understand the basics. The management team has to calibrate their language so that the educated ones don't feel talked down to, while the newcomers can still follow along. Luna: That sounds like a high-wire act. Give me an example of a company that mishandled their first earnings call. Lucas: One classic example is Rivian, the EV maker. They went public in late 2021, and their first earnings call was in early 2022. The numbers themselves were fine; they beat on revenue, but the call was marred by a series of production guidance cuts and a defensive tone from management when analysts pressed on the supply chain. The stock dropped sharply after hours, and it took months for them to regain credibility. Luna: So it wasn't the numbers, it was the demeanor and the guidance cuts that spooked people. Lucas: Exactly. And you can contrast that with a company like Airbnb, which also went public in late 2020. Their first earnings call was notably more polished. They leaned into their recovery narrative and gave clear, quantified guidance. Even though the pandemic was still wreaking havoc on travel, investors came away feeling like management had a handle on the situation. Luna: So the difference is really about control. Whether they're in control of the narrative, not just the numbers. Lucas: Right. And that control shows up in the smaller details too. The press release length, the choice of non gaap metrics, the wording in the shareholder letter. A company that is deliberate about those details signals that they're thoughtful about how the market perceives them. Luna: Let's talk about the non gaap metrics. That's always a controversial topic, especially for post ipo companies that might be burning cash. Lucas: Yeah, you'll see a lot of 'adjusted EBITDA' or 'adjusted gross margin' adjustments, and sometimes they're legitimate, like adding back stock-based compensation, which is a non-cash expense. But sometimes they go further, adding back things like acquisition costs or restructuring charges that seem a bit aggressive. Luna: And that's where the SEC starts paying attention, right? Lucas: It can be. There have been cases where the SEC has pushed back on overly aggressive non gaap metrics, and for a young public company, an SEC inquiry is the last thing you want. It raises questions about governance and transparency. Luna: So what's the takeaway for investors listening? How should they approach a post ipo company's first earnings report? Lucas: First, ignore the headline beat or miss for the first quarter or two. Focus on the guidance and how management frames the business. Second, listen to the Q&A carefully. That's where you hear how they handle tough questions, which is a good proxy for how they'll handle future crises. And third, look at the quality of the non gaap adjustments. If they're adding back a lot of stuff that seems like real operating expenses, that's a red flag. Luna: And what about the stock reaction? Should investors just ignore that entirely? Lucas: Not entirely, but don't overreact to a one-day swing. The stock move on earnings day is often more about positioning and sentiment than about the actual quarter. For a post ipo company, the real signal comes from watching how the analyst estimates evolve over the next few weeks. If estimates drift higher, that's a good sign. If they drift lower despite a beat, that tells you something about the quality of the earnings. Luna: So it's a longer-term signal than just the immediate market reaction. Lucas: Exactly. And that's why I think the first earnings report is less about the numbers and more about establishing a pattern of behavior that will define the company's relationship with the market for years to come. Luna: Well, that's a good way to think about it. Any final thoughts for our listeners? Lucas: Just that if you're investing in post ipo tech, pay close attention to the first couple of earnings calls. They can tell you a lot about the management team's temperament and their attitude toward shareholders. And that's often more important than any single quarter's result.