Latest / Insights Now / Credit vs. Duration, where should you spend your risk budget?
Transcript
- 0:03Welcome to insights.
- 0:04Now,
- 0:05a series of conversations designed to shine a light of clarity on the complex world of investing.
- 0:10So far.
- 0:11This year,
- 0:11investors have had to contend with the implications of regional banking crisis.
- 0:15A still hawkish fed and rising expectations for a near term recession with economic risks elevated.
- 0:21The challenge for debt investors is to strike the right balance between risk and return in portfolios while maintaining a focus on credit quality.
- 0:28These two risks,
- 0:30interest rate risk and credit risk can have important implications for bond performance in an environment where the fed may soon pivot to rate cuts but like in response to us recession.
- 0:39So on today's episode,
- 0:41I've invited Andrew Morelli portfolio manager for several multi sector fixed income strategies here at JP Morgan Asset management to dive into the outlook for the economy and interest rates and what all this means for striking the right balance between credit and duration in fixed income portfolios.
- 0:54So Andrew,
- 0:55welcome to insights now.
- 0:56Oh,
- 0:56thanks for having me,
- 0:57David.
- 0:57It's great to be here.
- 0:58So let's start by talking a bit about the economy.
- 1:01We've seen a pretty mixed bag when it comes to economic data so far this year.
- 1:05But generally,
- 1:05it does seem like the economy is continuing to accelerate here.
- 1:09And particularly concerning,
- 1:10I think is what we're beginning to see in the labor market with the recent rise in unemployment claims.
- 1:14So what are your thoughts on the balance of risk for the economy right now?
- 1:18I concur with what you just said and I think the rise in unemployment claims and the,
- 1:24let's call it a gentle trend downwards in nonfarm payrolls actually understates the what what I perceive to be actual uh weakness in the labor market that's weaker than what the FED would,
- 1:35would communicate.
- 1:36And uh and,
- 1:38and those two high frequency data points would,
- 1:40would communicate.
- 1:41I think the trajectory is,
- 1:42is generally weaker.
- 1:44Um We can get into if you want some of the specifics of what I'm looking at in the labor market.
- 1:48But I felt that way coming into March and the regional bank frictions that occurred during that month.
- 1:55And I think after the regional bank frictions,
- 1:58things are clear to me.
- 1:59One is that the regional banking balance system balance sheet of the regional banking system needs to shrink and the balance sheet of the commercial banking system in general probably needs to derisk.
- 2:10And because of those two things layered on top of a very tight monetary policy environment,
- 2:17we already found ourselves in which is getting tighter by the day as the FED continues to hike the trajectory for the economy is,
- 2:23is even in my view tilted more downward after the almost inevitable credit contraction,
- 2:31that's going to follow the regional bank frictions.
- 2:33Ok.
- 2:34Um Well,
- 2:34as I say,
- 2:35we're probably in agreement on that,
- 2:37I suppose on the positive side,
- 2:39from a fixed income perspective,
- 2:40we have seen a fairly sustained disinflation trend so far this year.
- 2:45But there are some measures of inflation,
- 2:46particularly core services housing which still are too high for the fed's comfort.
- 2:51Do you expect inflation to continue to fall for the rate of this year?
- 2:54This year?
- 2:55I do.
- 2:56Um And there are as you,
- 2:57as you hinted at several different lenses through which to look at inflation.
- 3:02And for now,
- 3:03even after the um encouraging CP I report that we got for the month of March,
- 3:08uh members of the FO MC,
- 3:10notably not Jay Powell uh have have continued to emphasize what they perceive to be really uh hot inflation conditions and I just don't agree with that.
- 3:21So for example,
- 3:22John Williams said core services inflation has not budged,
- 3:26that's a direct quote.
- 3:28But notice he said core services inflation and that includes housing and for reasons you've probably covered in your podcast before we understand that o and primary rent,
- 3:39the housing components of CP I are very laggy.
- 3:43So those statistics right now which I believe starting with the March report have begun a durable downtrend those those statistics are vastly overstating the actual housing inflation that's going on in real time in the economy.
- 3:58So if you strip those out and get to what Powell would call core services,
- 4:02shelter and he really means housing because he doesn't care about hotels.
- 4:06But core services housing,
- 4:08if you want to take a pessimistic look at it,
- 4:11you could say that it is flat lining around,
- 4:13let's say 0.3 on average per month and that's a series that BLS does not publish,
- 4:18but we can back out what the numbers are 0.3 on average over the last several months.
- 4:23So call that,
- 4:24you know,
- 4:24a little over 3.5% annualized.
- 4:27But wage growth has been decelerating for the better part of a year.
- 4:31Whether you look at the average hourly earnings on sequential,
- 4:34the employment cost index on sequential,
- 4:37which is only quarterly,
- 4:38we'll get another look at that at the end of the month or even the Atlanta fed wage tracker,
- 4:41which is really a year on year.
- 4:42Number a wages have been trending downward and wages tend to lead core services housing.
- 4:49So for example,
- 4:50if the wage for your barber is no longer going up,
- 4:52the price of the haircut is unlikely to continue rising.
- 4:55So we have a pretty good leading indicator for core services housing,
- 4:59which is absolutely moving in the right direction.
- 5:01And then let's look at inflation in the following lens.
- 5:04So going back to something I said a moment ago,
- 5:06housing inflation is vastly overstated in the CPI statistics.
- 5:09If we take the entire CPI basket and remove only housing which we accept is overstated.
- 5:16The entire rest of the basket including volatile categories like airfare,
- 5:20used cars,
- 5:21medical care,
- 5:21whatever outlier a would want to point out the whole basket housing is running a three month moving average of 1.9%.
- 5:32So in other words,
- 5:33excluding the two categories which we know are flawed,
- 5:36inflation over the last quarter has been back to target.
- 5:40And that's completely at odds with the,
- 5:41the commentary that we hear out of the fed.
- 5:43So they are likely to,
- 5:44to hike again.
- 5:46But I think the totality of what I've said indicates that the feds in the middle of a hawkish policy error and probably making the economic outcomes worse.
- 5:54Well,
- 5:54I can see this,
- 5:55we're not going to disagree much in this podcast,
- 5:57but I really share your view on the economic outlook and the inflation outlook.
- 6:03But putting that to one side,
- 6:05what do you think the Federal Reserve will do at its upcoming meeting and for the rest of this year and indeed going into 2024?
- 6:11Ok.
- 6:12I think they will hike uh next Wednesday May the third.
- 6:15And do I think they should hike?
- 6:16No,
- 6:17but that doesn't matter.
- 6:18I think they will hike and the reason they will hike is they are choosing to communicate viewing inflation through the most conservative possible lens if they view the big risk as under tightening and when they communicate that they cause the market to price in a nearly 100% chance of them hiking next week,
- 6:37I think it's about 90%.
- 6:38Last time I looked.
- 6:39And so when the market is allowing them to hike,
- 6:42and some subset of the committee has communicated,
- 6:45they intend to hike a,
- 6:47the easiest thing for them to do is to go ahead and hike 25.
- 6:50And then in the statement,
- 6:51communicate some degree of pause.
- 6:55And what I think they'll do the rest of the year is I do think they are going to cut in September.
- 6:59So the final hike is in May that leaves them pausing for the June and July meeting.
- 7:04There is no August meeting.
- 7:06So then start cuts in September and the market is trying to start to price that but not a full cut.
- 7:13It's priced in,
- 7:13it's sort of a gentle sort of 1/8 to 1 half cut in the meetings in the second half of the year.
- 7:20But the reason I feel that way about September cuts is because I do think between now and then we're going to see a significant deterioration in the high frequency hard data and pay less attention to the leading indicators that we're looking at today.
- 7:32And so if we,
- 7:34I mean,
- 7:34I think he's sort of hinting at the idea,
- 7:36we might see a negative payroll read at some stage over the summer or going into the fall.
- 7:40And that,
- 7:41that,
- 7:41that certainly could change the perception of the economy.
- 7:45But let's move forward to 2024 if the economy does stumble into recession here,
- 7:52do you think the Federal Reserve has the tools to reinvigorate it?
- 7:55I absolutely do.
- 7:56So if we are concerned about credit conditions tightening in the banking system because we have one or more zombie banks that have negative net net interest margins because they're funding assets at high cost liquidity facilities because they had deposit flight.
- 8:10I know that's a lot of because is there but that is the case rate cuts fix that you need a kind of a lot of rate cuts and rapid arrival of them.
- 8:19But those capital erosive situations in the banking system which is inevitably going to cause credit creations to tighten as we speak,
- 8:27they get made better and to the extent we have frictions in the commercial real estate market because new construction of affordable housing or even medium to high end multifamily properties have been put on hold because funding is not available because funding typically came from regional banks in the CMBS market.
- 8:46Those things are improved rather significantly by looser monetary policy.
- 8:51I do think the Fed has the tools to fix it and and even though I'm cautious pessimistic on the economic outlook and I think monetary policy is too tight current,
- 9:01I don't think the Fed will have to cut all the way back to zero.
- 9:03And I don't think the FED will have to restart QE in order to stem economic contraction if it occurs.
- 9:09I do think that they'll be able to do it.
- 9:12If this is,
- 9:12if we get a recession,
- 9:13it's monetary policy caused.
- 9:15And so it can be monetary policy fixed.
- 9:17So that's somewhat hopeful in terms of their ability to fix things if they do manage to push the economy off the rails.
- 9:23But let's back up to sort of the here.
- 9:25And now we have had as you alluded to a fair amount of regional backed turmoil.
- 9:30What's the risk that that further fed hike on May 3rd causes additional deposit outflows across the financial system.
- 9:37And what do you think that means for financials in general?
- 9:39I don't know what the risk is because why should you know 5.05% money market yield be the tipping point where 4.8% wasn't?
- 9:49But at some level,
- 9:51there is a rate differential between deposit interest rates and money market yields that will cause a waterfall of deposit outfight.
- 10:00Do I think 505 does it?
- 10:02No,
- 10:03however,
- 10:04it's getting closer.
- 10:05And if we agree that interest rate differential between money markets and deposit accounts was at least a partial cause of the deposit flight.
- 10:13Why on earth is the fed going to widen that differential?
- 10:16And so that's,
- 10:17that's actually a key element of why I think the fed shouldn't hike.
- 10:21Uh,
- 10:21but,
- 10:22but they are very likely to do so as,
- 10:24as we said.
- 10:24So,
- 10:25um,
- 10:25I do think there will be incremental deposit flight and from some troubled banks that we've heard from their management teams only in the last few days,
- 10:34um,
- 10:35there isn't a whole lot of room left for deposit flight so that they with remaining assets on their balance sheet that they can fund at the discount window or federal home loan banks or the B FTP.
- 10:47So more deposit flight from troubled banks would likely result in more FDIC takeovers which is not a good look for the market or for the economy.
- 10:57So given all of that,
- 11:00what are your,
- 11:01what are your thoughts on,
- 11:02you know,
- 11:02going forward for us this year on credit versus duration?
- 11:06I think it is a sequencing trade.
- 11:09So the environment we've discussed over the past 15 minutes is one in which duration is your friend and partially.
- 11:17That's because I think that the correlation between high quality bonds and stocks has reverted back to right way negative correlation.
- 11:26So if the economy suffers and inflation is trending downward,
- 11:30then bad economic data will result in the market pricing in more cuts.
- 11:35And so that revives the classical correlation where duration is a is an asset hedge.
- 11:40So for example,
- 11:41in the portfolios,
- 11:42I manage the duration posture and the composition of that duration is very different than it was in 2022.
- 11:48And in a word longer.
- 11:50Um,
- 11:50so duration is your friend credit.
- 11:52On the other hand,
- 11:53um,
- 11:54I will say that other than financials and I've,
- 11:57I've sort of hinted at my bearishness on financials as other than financials.
- 12:01Uh,
- 12:01credit fundamentals are,
- 12:03are pretty good,
- 12:04especially in the high corporate bond market where leverage ratios are,
- 12:07are generally low better than they have been in prior recessions.
- 12:10You had credit cleansing in 2020 with defaults,
- 12:13you had a well timed refunding of debt coming due and spreads were tight and rates were low during COVID.
- 12:21So there's a lot of,
- 12:21there's a lot of positives on credit,
- 12:23but credit tends to peak and spread during the recession.
- 12:27So for the like 40 or 50 year life of the high yield bond market spreads always peak in the recession.
- 12:32They don't stay there for long.
- 12:33But the short answer is,
- 12:35I think we're going to have better opportunities to add credit if our macro view is borne out.
- 12:41So we're underweight credit overweight duration if I paint with a broad brush in the portfolios that I help to manage?
- 12:47So can we can we try a slightly finer brush here?
- 12:51I mean,
- 12:51obviously in the in the area of credit,
- 12:54we've talked about some of the challenges facing uh the banking banking industry because of these increase in short term interest rates.
- 13:02But do you think that there are some high grade Corporates that would be appropriate right now?
- 13:07Yes.
- 13:08So let's call it industrials.
- 13:10Um or maybe even single A IG credit and maybe high,
- 13:17triple big credit.
- 13:18That's not financials because it's perfectly reasonable to assume that if we do get an economic downturn,
- 13:25treasury yields will decline by more than the spreads widen.
- 13:29So in other words,
- 13:30you're getting a carry pick up in higher quality IG credit compared to treasuries.
- 13:35And even in a recession,
- 13:37the all in yields actually decline and bond prices stay the same or go up.
- 13:41So you may underperform treasuries where the,
- 13:43where the actual optimal thing to do would be to buy all treasuries.
- 13:47Let treasury yields decline then rotate into it credit.
- 13:51That is a harder yield to thread.
- 13:53So I think that uh investors can feel comfortable that the bond price is unlikely to get a whole lot cheaper in uh high quality fixed income kind of no matter what happens in the,
- 14:06the the recession outlook.
- 14:08The thing that would kill it is a surprising rise in inflation.
- 14:11Um But that's not my view.
- 14:13And I,
- 14:14you know,
- 14:14we can,
- 14:14if we have time to talk through the reasons,
- 14:16but based on the more high probability economic outcomes,
- 14:20I think that investors will do considerably better in high quality fixed income maybe than equities.
- 14:27I think,
- 14:28uh you know,
- 14:28I think you and I,
- 14:29we agree on this,
- 14:31the inflation outlook.
- 14:32We both I think,
- 14:33think that a strong revival in inflation is unlikely here,
- 14:36but I have to,
- 14:38you know,
- 14:38end on a slightly ominous question that I'm getting asked more and more in the last few days,
- 14:43which has to do with the debt ceiling.
- 14:45Uh,
- 14:46is there a greater risk this time rather we actually,
- 14:49you know,
- 14:49uh reach the state and go,
- 14:52you know,
- 14:52and,
- 14:53and,
- 14:53uh,
- 14:53have some defaults like event.
- 14:57Um,
- 14:58and what would the short and long term consequences be for the bond market if we defaulted on our debt?
- 15:02I was kind of hoping you were gonna ask me about that.
- 15:04But,
- 15:05um,
- 15:05if you asked me a week ago or two weeks ago,
- 15:08I would have said we're very unlikely to cross the X date.
- 15:12And if we do cross the X state,
- 15:14then Yellen will put in place this great glass in case emergency of prioritizing debt payments over all other federal expenditures including salaries of congress members and to avoid a technical fault on debt.
- 15:28I still think that's the most likely case.
- 15:30However,
- 15:30a few things have happened,
- 15:31the Republicans are trying to and I think to get a bill through that would codify prioritization of debt payments as explicitly legal because it's not clear that it is explicitly legal.
- 15:42It's not clear it's illegal.
- 15:44Either.
- 15:44It does seem like a rational thing for the treasury to try to do defaulting on bonds would be considered an actual credit event.
- 15:50Whereas defaulting on payments to suppliers or defense contractors probably wouldn't in a traditional bond that wouldn't.
- 15:58But the documents governing treasuries don't contemplate things like cross defaults or,
- 16:02or,
- 16:03or acceleration because that's just not a thing that happens in un default government bonds.
- 16:08So it would be legal limbo.
- 16:10I still think even though the administration has said a default on any federal obligation is a default,
- 16:17not just bonds.
- 16:18So therefore,
- 16:19we're not considering prioritizing debt payments.
- 16:21I think behind the scenes,
- 16:22they probably are because it's the most rational thing to do.
- 16:24I think the probability that we surpass the state is greater than it was a couple of weeks ago,
- 16:29just,
- 16:30just reading the rhetoric and the further we get from Silicon Valley Bank and the the crisis that that caused for a period of time with depositors and SVB didn't know what they were,
- 16:41whether they would get their money back the greater the time after that period of chaos,
- 16:45the lower the calls to congress members begging them to stop creating crises and the debt.
- 16:51If we defaulted,
- 16:51it would be a crisis one quick comment.
- 16:54And then I'll talk about briefly the long term implications.
- 16:57There is this idea that the 14th amendment to the United States prohibits a default.
- 17:01So the words are the validity of the public debt of the United States shall not be questioned the short sentence.
- 17:09And in the past presidents have used that 14th amendment as a reason to go ahead and just pay the debt or either through privatization or even running an overdraft at the Treasury General account with the FED that would get questioned as well.
- 17:25So there,
- 17:25there,
- 17:25there are avenues I think the most likely of which is debt prioritization.
- 17:30But the long term implications for risk assets would be a significant because what whether it's correct or not the market would,
- 17:40would,
- 17:41would once again question the reserve currency status of the dollar and the reserve currency status of the dollar enables essentially foreign debt financed prosperity.
- 17:50Incrementally,
- 17:51at least in the United States,
- 17:52which is baked into the earnings power of our public companies.
- 17:56It would be a pretty tough risk off period.
- 17:59What happens to treasury yields is less clear an academic would tell you well,
- 18:04treasuries are going to go down in price yields higher because the US defaulted and therefore we should run more term premium.
- 18:11However,
- 18:11any,
- 18:12any default that does occur is going to get cured may be cured with extra interest.
- 18:17And that market would recognize that instantly.
- 18:21And treasury does have treasury securities do have a big uh flight to quality and would retain much of it in a big risk off.
- 18:29So,
- 18:29gun to my head,
- 18:30I think treasury yields actually go lower in a debt ceiling debacle,
- 18:34passing the state threatening default.
- 18:36What's the probability?
- 18:37I'll give it 45% a little less than 50 50 getting to the state without a resolution.
- 18:42And that's up from 15% 2 weeks ago,
- 18:46that is a,
- 18:47that's a scary thought.
- 18:48Well,
- 18:48let,
- 18:48let us hope it doesn't come to that.
- 18:50Obviously,
- 18:51it would be and an extraordinary,
- 18:53um,
- 18:54own goal for us to default on our debt.
- 18:56So let's hope it doesn't come to that.
- 18:57But Andrew,
- 18:58thank you again for your,
- 19:00uh,
- 19:00I know you've been with us before in this podcast and it's always illuminating to hear your thoughts on the outlook.
- 19:06So,
- 19:06thank you very much for participating today and thank you all for listening.
- 19:09It's been a real pleasure.
- 19:10Thank you,
- 19:10David.
- 19:11Please tune into our next episode where I'll be joined by fixed and portfolio manager.
- 19:15Rick Tamina for a conversation on the outlook for municipal bonds other than I invite you to read or listen to my notes of the week ahead podcast where every Monday,
- 19:23I share a comment on the latest in the markets of the economy to help you stay informed for the week ahead for even more timely insights.
- 19:29You can also follow and subscribe to my content on linkedin.
- 19:32This content is intended for information only based on assumptions and current market conditions and are subject to change.
- 19:38No warranty of accuracy is given this content does not contain sufficient information to support investment decisions.
- 19:44It is not to be construed as research,
- 19:46legal regulatory tax,
- 19:48accounting or investment advice,
- 19:50investments involve risks.
- 19:51Investors should seek professional advice or make an independent evaluation before investing the value of investments and the income from them may fluctuate including loss of capital,
- 20:00past performance and yield are not indicative of current or future results forecasts and estimates may or may not come to pass.
- 20:07JP Morgan Asset Management is the asset management business of JP Morgan Chase and company and its affiliates worldwide.