Latest / Saigalseatrade Podcast / The Oil Market Beneath the Surface
Transcript
- 0:11Hello, everyone, and welcome back to the Cycle Sea Trade
- 0:14podcast. I'm research Analyst Shruti,
- 0:17your host today. And today we're going to be
- 0:19discussing one of the most lingering questions at the
- 0:22moment, what could be the most geopolitical premium, and with
- 0:26that, other topics as well. So I would request all our
- 0:29listeners to brace for a very insightful conversation and I'm
- 0:34joined by none other than Mr. Sandesh Ghandat, our in house
- 0:37shipping and commodities expert and also my colleague Smith Raj.
- 0:41So welcome back to the podcast. Thanks, Shruti.
- 0:44Thanks for welcome and today we have a lot to unpack to.
- 0:48Thanks Shruti, Thanks for having me on the show as well and
- 0:51definitely we are going to discuss and give our listeners a
- 0:54lot of insights. So Sandesh, let me start with a
- 0:57simple question to you. Oil prices are looking calm
- 1:00right now, but the freight has just exploded.
- 1:03Insurance costs, a screaming risk, and the geopolitical
- 1:06tension. Don't get me started.
- 1:07It's higher than it was a month ago.
- 1:09So what the real question for traders or shipowners listening
- 1:13right now is that the is the market actually relaxed or is it
- 1:17quietly bracing for something much bigger?
- 1:19And please tell us, does this moment matter more than the flat
- 1:23price suggests? Well, Shruti, this moment right
- 1:26now matters because the oil market is kind of lying to, you
- 1:30know, anyone who only looks at the screen price and flat prices
- 1:35is kind of behaving like a headline.
- 1:37So we have the physical system, which you know, underneath is
- 1:41behaving like a warning siren. So let's start with the
- 1:45contradiction. So you have got the geopolitical
- 1:48risk, it pushing crude higher. And when I say the geopolitical
- 1:52risk, I'm specifically talking about the Iran US tension.
- 1:56And then earlier, I will say 6-8 weeks back we have Venezuela.
- 2:01At least it was an uncertainty that time.
- 2:03But now things are quite moving ahead.
- 2:05And then right now we have a Middle East fret it's blowing
- 2:09out and at the same time, you won't believe it.
- 2:13The inventories they are rising and balances say the market is
- 2:17long. So that combination almost never
- 2:20lasts. We have US crude inventory data
- 2:23just released by EIA and it says the inventories surge about
- 2:2916,000,000 barrels in a single week, the biggest or I would say
- 2:34the one of the biggest build in roughly 3 years.
- 2:37So we have 14,000,000 barrels rise in Gulf Coast and then the
- 2:412 million barrels rising elsewhere and that flipped the
- 2:45inter inventories from 9 million barrel deficit versus the 10
- 2:49year seasonal average of 4 million barrel surplus in just a
- 2:53week. So on paper that screens the
- 2:56comfortable supply, I would say that this is particularly
- 3:00important and this is deliberately done because the
- 3:03term is going to do something. So that's my assumption.
- 3:07We don't know what will be going to happen, but it's not just a
- 3:10bluff, at least it is whatever we are looking right now.
- 3:13The things they are kind of changing ahead.
- 3:16We don't know what exactly happened and we will definitely
- 3:19say that something going to happen.
- 3:21We hope that it won't be a massive escalation and we hope
- 3:26there won't be any impact on the energy and oil specifically from
- 3:32the freight and supply point of view.
- 3:36But having said that, we have to layer freight on a top because
- 3:43we know that cost to move 2 million barrels on the Middle
- 3:45East to China is now brushing around $200 per day.
- 3:50And then if you take in terms of AG West Coast India, it is
- 3:56around two $80,000 per day. And you know what, that's not
- 3:59just a war noise, that's a fear of getting priced into the
- 4:03logistics. So you have got the barrels,
- 4:06those are now available, but then moving this particular
- 4:10barrels is suddenly expensive and it's not just expensive,
- 4:13it's risky also because you don't have that much vessel
- 4:17availability and there is expectation that this hormous
- 4:20trade will get close. So all the risk that has already
- 4:24accumulated by ship owners and that's why we are seeing the
- 4:28high rise in the freight level specifically for the VLCCS and
- 4:33that's why this matter. So because when the logistics
- 4:36and even the insurance for the both cargo and freight and for
- 4:40the ship and as well as in addition to the geopolitics, it
- 4:43overall disconnects from the inventory and the price signals,
- 4:47they stop being a clean and The Dirty signals are where the
- 4:50traders get hurt. You're right, we are bracing for
- 4:52something much bigger and taking cues from that, let's go
- 4:55straight to Iran. Everyone keeps saying Iran risk
- 4:58premium, but the market can't seem to decide if it believes in
- 5:02its own story. So is the oil market actually
- 5:04pricing a real supply disruption from Iran or is this just paper
- 5:08traders reacting to headlines? Well, Shruti, the market is
- 5:13pricing Iran, I would say emotionally and not a
- 5:17mechanically and I would say that that's a dangerous place to
- 5:20be because on the surface Iranian crude exports, they are
- 5:23not falling. So in fact they are surging this
- 5:26that's exactly opposite what they are doing.
- 5:28So between February 15 to February 20, exports out of Krug
- 5:33Island is spiked towards 7 million barrels per day, roughly
- 5:372X the pace of the prior six weeks.
- 5:41And then the countries that expect a deal, you know it is
- 5:44not happening with the Iran. So this look like a front
- 5:47running risk. But then here is the key
- 5:49understanding or I will say that key misunderstanding.
- 5:52So Iran risk isn't just about the barrels disappearing, it's
- 5:56about the systems breaking because you know, around 31% of
- 6:01global crude or roughly 13 million barrels per day.
- 6:05So this is I'm just talking about crude, not the products.
- 6:08So it moves through the Strait of Hormuz and you don't need to
- 6:11kind of a full blockade to cause any chaos.
- 6:14You just need, you know, certain uncertainty and this could lead
- 6:19to the war risk premium, higher insurance deductible.
- 6:22So owners they are kind of a refusing voyage unless get paid.
- 6:26And then there is another layer nobody is talking about and that
- 6:31is kind of for theory. That is the Iran's power grid.
- 6:35And I think Smith could highlight more onto that.
- 6:38So definitely send us we have to talk about the power grid.
- 6:42So I would say that Iran runs a massive Bitcoin mining
- 6:45operations on the subsidized electricity.
- 6:48The electricity is priced roughly around I would say oh
- 6:51point, oh, oh, $5 per kilowatt and mining cost around $13120
- 6:57per Bitcoin, which they are selling at around $68,000.
- 7:01That's all almost 50 times gross margin and Iran controls an
- 7:06estimates of 2 to 5% of global Bitcoin hash rate.
- 7:09So having said that, you know, Shruti, a military campaign that
- 7:13takes out power infrastructure doesn't just hit civilians, it
- 7:17just collapses the entire revenue stream.
- 7:20And you don't have to bomb those mining rigs.
- 7:23You just hit the grid and it eliminates almost 30 to 50% of
- 7:27power of mining entirely. So you know what the oil markets
- 7:31are pricing Iran, but the Bitcoin markets aren't as both
- 7:35are tied to the same infrastructure and which is why
- 7:38we see Irans risk isn't binary, it's layered and the market is
- 7:43underpricing how nonlinear consequences could be.
- 7:47Well, certainly, Smith, I think I agree with you, and I do see
- 7:51that the consequences are going to be nonlinear.
- 7:54But now let's shift gears a little bit and talk about
- 7:57Venezuela. So Sandesh, for a while it felt
- 8:01like the market forgot about heavy crude altogether.
- 8:04So why is Venezuela suddenly back on the radar?
- 8:07And why should refiners and ship owners care about it, especially
- 8:11right now? So yes, you are rightly said
- 8:16that Venezuela suddenly back on the radar because you know
- 8:19Venezuela uncertainty which was there 6-8 weeks back and it kind
- 8:25of eased bit now, but still it remains lingering because we
- 8:29don't know what will happen ahead.
- 8:30So Venezuela uncertainty matters because we have a Iranian heavy
- 8:36barrels, they will become a politically toxic again if there
- 8:40won't be result into ongoing stretch between Iran, US
- 8:44relations and a kind of possible war like situation.
- 8:47So if that happens again, refiners will start scrambling
- 8:51for substitute and you know what that push up demand for the
- 8:55freight, for the blending economies and for the arbitrage
- 8:57barrels from the places like Brazil or West Africa.
- 9:00And even for the matter of fact for the West Western Canadian
- 9:03select grade is also kind of important here.
- 9:06And then from the freight perspective, if VLCC lifting
- 9:10from Brazilian heavy grade into Asia, it kind of a look more
- 9:13expensive right now because you know, the competitiveness has
- 9:18deteriorated fast. So Venezuela oil volatility
- 9:22doesn't just affect oil, you know it reshapes the global
- 9:25shipping flows. Then coming back to your second
- 9:28question, why should refiners and ship owners care right now?
- 9:31Because you know, the Trump policies and the Trump's you
- 9:35know, the decisions with respect to Venezuela, its policies and
- 9:40its oil industry. So it all suggesting that
- 9:43Venezuela oil can be available at market price and they are
- 9:48sanction free. So we have Indian refiners, we
- 9:51have some of the Southeast Asian refiners and even some of them
- 9:55are in the you know Europe also. So they also want to take
- 9:59Venezuelan crude. But the winning chapter or the
- 10:03the refineries those are kind of you know want to run the higher
- 10:07grades or want to run heavy grades.
- 10:10Those are specifically situated in the West Coast of India and
- 10:14they all have a very better Nelson complexity index and they
- 10:18can run this particular code with the edition or with the
- 10:23replacement of other basket or they can adjust or Indian
- 10:27refiners they can adjust these particular barrels in their
- 10:33crude basket and they can run it.
- 10:35So they will have high end products or heavy distillate
- 10:39products. And since they have the
- 10:42adjusting oil facilities, they can have a very valuable grades
- 10:47from this heavy distillates. So overall we can say that
- 10:52Indian refiners like Reliance and some of the PSU companies,
- 10:56they will start receiving Venezuelan oil soon.
- 10:59We have news from the market that one of the cargoes will be
- 11:03arriving India by mid-May and it is the first such sort of cargo
- 11:08after an year or so. So for the favorable mechanism
- 11:12present, but from the VLCC point of view will be a kind of
- 11:16mechanism for the Indian refiners where you know they
- 11:20have to spend more on the freight cost and which will be
- 11:24weighing in their refinery margin.
- 11:26So yes, refiners and ship owners, they have to care.
- 11:29Right now the refiners have possible substitute that's
- 11:33available in the market and they can get it freely and fairly and
- 11:38the freight will remain supportive for VLCC Momentum in
- 11:42the coming days. That was quite an explanation,
- 11:45Sandesh. And we cannot do a podcast
- 11:49without discussing freight. VLCC is right now, as you said,
- 11:52at around $200 per day. So what is freight really
- 11:57telling us right now? Please tell us.
- 12:00Well, you know what freight is kind of a truth serum of the oil
- 12:03market I would say. And when VLCC rates $200 per day
- 12:092-3 days before. So I thought that's not just
- 12:14about the supply and demand balance, it should be about the
- 12:17fear. So that was my first thought and
- 12:21then I have thought about the, you know the war is premium or
- 12:25we can say insurance and about the root optionality which is
- 12:30kind of disappearing right now. So you know what should they we
- 12:33have about 20% of global sea bone crude that moves to the
- 12:37hormones and even the hint of disruption it send owners
- 12:42demanding the compensation. So you know what why I have put
- 12:46the hint of disruption because from my point of view, whatever
- 12:50the reason, there won't be any such thing that we can call it
- 12:55as a closure of the state of Hormuz.
- 12:57The possibility of Iran closing, you know, state of Hormuz, in my
- 13:02opinion a kind of a myth because this has never been happen in
- 13:07the modern era and this won't be happen.
- 13:09And I have reason to believe that this won't happen because
- 13:12there is very much support for the trade route for the global
- 13:17point of view. We have seen in the past and
- 13:19even now also the largest US Armada present there and we have
- 13:25Indian Navy present there. We have French Navy present
- 13:28there and several different navies are present there.
- 13:31And then there is a consortium in the Bahrain, which you know
- 13:34kind of to protect the global shipping routes, they will also
- 13:38act on that. And then the important question
- 13:41is that how they will close this entire state of Hormuz because
- 13:46it is around 21 miles long and most of the depth water or is in
- 13:53the Omani waters and the shallow water is belong to Iran and the
- 13:59water with the depth that belongs to Oman.
- 14:01So to close the Hormuz Strait, they have to, you know, taken
- 14:05over the Oman because they have to close entire Omani waters and
- 14:09they don't want to, you know, disappoint their allies, which
- 14:14is Oman. Because we all know that Oman
- 14:16initiated the talks right now, which is taking place first
- 14:20round, second round in Switzerland and then the third
- 14:24round in the Norway. So we are not seeing any even
- 14:28for the matter of fact, it's not, you know, kind of in favor
- 14:32of Iran to close the Hormuz Strait because lot of Iran's
- 14:37import through China, they are going through this particular
- 14:40Strait. And then the oil that is going
- 14:43outside Iran, it is going from the Strait only.
- 14:45And if they close the Strait, they will be kind of
- 14:49disappointing their own nemesis or their own partner which is
- 14:54China. So the possibility of closure of
- 14:57Hormuz is very, very few. I will say less than one or two
- 15:01percent possibility that they will close the entire Strait.
- 15:05But then having said that, it is not complete in favor that the
- 15:11geopolitical this premier present for this particular
- 15:14thing and whenever there is a talk of or the hint of
- 15:17disruption, it send owners demanding the compensation that
- 15:21we have talked about. And then the sanctions
- 15:23enforcement is again pushing the barrels back onto the compliant
- 15:27fleet and overall this is tightening effective a VLCC
- 15:32supply. And then you have to add in the
- 15:34ownership concentration like Sino core which is going in the
- 15:39market like anything they are now controlled around 100 plus
- 15:43vessels. So controlling that means they
- 15:46are kind of having operational as well as control with respect
- 15:51to the ownership. So as a ownership they are
- 15:53control lesser vessel but as a operator they are controls more
- 15:58than 100 plus vessels and they are hunting new vessel in the
- 16:01global market. They have asked this week itself
- 16:042-3 vessel owners for bagging rights of ownership and the
- 16:09recent purchase that we have came to know last week.
- 16:13So it came up to three days back that the owner is indeed the
- 16:17Sino core. So overall you wait that and
- 16:20then you reduce the odds of freight collapse specifically in
- 16:23the freight for the vessels those are coming out of AG.
- 16:26And then meanwhile the freight movement is also seen in the
- 16:30Swiss Max sector. So Swiss Max is also started
- 16:33increasing. The benchmark route is around
- 16:36$150,000 per day and this was specifically AG forest route.
- 16:43And then Aframax is also becoming a new story, not more
- 16:49right now, but they will also trying to go the momentum
- 16:53because you know the one sector is kind of pushing the
- 16:58sentiments towards the lower or the low size vessel segment.
- 17:03So this is kind of inheritance Swiss Max inheriting from VLCC
- 17:08and then now Aframax started inheriting from the Swiss Max.
- 17:12So I would say the shipping cost they are kind of inflationary
- 17:15and the geopolitical cooling would be a deflationary.
- 17:19So which one wins decides the next move.
- 17:22Now, before we move ahead, Sandesh, let me ask this to you.
- 17:26We have recently heard about the Jaima terminal disruption.
- 17:30Do you see an impact on the Indian sentiment there?
- 17:33Well, you know, Saudi Aramco has kind of a suspended shipment of
- 17:39LPG from the Juma terminal in Rashtanura and the disruption is
- 17:45for about four to five weeks or four to six weeks for the
- 17:51specifically because the repairman work will be going to
- 17:56last that amount time. This was due to the majorly
- 17:59because their export infrastructure was damaged and
- 18:02they have released the statement around it just few days back.
- 18:07So you know what it's a key export facility for propane and
- 18:11butane and it suffered a significant damage due to an
- 18:15unspecified incident. And like I have said, the LPG
- 18:20deliveries will be halted for next 4 to 5 weeks.
- 18:23And for a scale, the trestle at JAMA is 9 kilometer long with
- 18:28the beer at the end. And Aramco, they told the
- 18:32clients that a portion of the trestle collapse just two days
- 18:35ago. So Saudi Aramco's GMR facility,
- 18:38you know, it's a major LPG exporter and they handle around
- 18:433.7% of global propane and butane supply.
- 18:47And they halted the shipment after a trestle collapse on
- 18:51February 23 on on a keynote Shruti.
- 18:55It will affect the Asian markets specifically like India and
- 18:59China because this particular incident is kind of a real
- 19:02operational disruptions and the larger contact is India will be
- 19:08affect a lot because I have a data for Indias LPG imports from
- 19:14GMR Terminal. So in the current month, that is
- 19:18month to date February, let's say for the 26 days, we have
- 19:23seen around 233 thousand worth of imports.
- 19:26And in the January 2026, that is the last month, we have seen one
- 19:30of the higher imports in last 6-7 months and those imports
- 19:35were around approximately 340 thousand tons per month.
- 19:40So you know this particular movement is equivalent to the 8
- 19:45VLGC's. And since we are now seeing the
- 19:49entire facilities will not be available for next one month, we
- 19:53may see a possible disruption of this 8 VLGC's.
- 19:56So for India, it kind of a major impact because around 6070% of
- 20:03total exports happening to this particular.
- 20:06Port will be going to India and less 30 to 35% they will going
- 20:11for the China. So very few impact for China
- 20:14again the sizable impact around 1 VLGC per month.
- 20:17But then the country which suffers a lot will be India.
- 20:22Even for the Indian perspective, a lot of vessels those will be
- 20:26going to the load from this particular terminal were under
- 20:29the time charter employment. So most of the vessels they will
- 20:33have to look for other alternative locations.
- 20:36So overall this particular repairs, they will take 3 to 5
- 20:41weeks and from the record we have seen about Aramco, we
- 20:46expect this particular facility will be coming online by the end
- 20:50of the fourth week and several impact will be there.
- 20:55There will be an impact on Indian LPG flows, but at the
- 20:59same time it will kind of increase NAFTA LPG spread
- 21:04because the availability will be getting declined for the LPG.
- 21:08And so it kind of a proposed opportunity for Indian LR2
- 21:14vessel employers to move NAFTA from Sikka to Japan because the
- 21:19petrochemical plants or kind of a steam crackers, they typically
- 21:25take base feedstock of NAFTA and you know, this particular
- 21:30crackers, they can also take LPG because you know, it is a kind
- 21:35of a swing feed for them. So there are also the crackers
- 21:39that can take ethane gas, oil and hydroax, but you normally
- 21:42can't replace LPG with this feedstock directly.
- 21:45So to replace LPG, the only option the steam crackers have
- 21:49and the only option that can be preferred for the steam crackers
- 21:53is NAFTA. So loss of LPG means the
- 21:57increased demand for NAFTA into the forest specifically in the
- 22:00Japan and Korea region in the Far East with the worries of
- 22:03supply disruption stemming from Iran as well as the increased
- 22:08geopolitical premium. So we may see that NAFTA market,
- 22:13the momentum or the demand for this particular commodity will
- 22:17be surging in the Far East. And this will propose, like I
- 22:21said, a significant opportunity for Southeast Asian refinals as
- 22:25well As for the India to employ LR2 and transfer this particular
- 22:29NAFTA to Far Eastern region. So yes, this is the situation
- 22:34where you know one side it would create a disruption.
- 22:37So this is a classic example actually that on one side where
- 22:41we are seeing a commodity disruption and then another side
- 22:45we are also seeing the opportunity for some part of the
- 22:48world. Well, thank you, Sandesh for
- 22:51debriefing that for us and explaining that situation so
- 22:54well. Now moving on, my question to
- 22:55you, Smith, is that the dollar has been softer and some people
- 22:59say that it supports the crude prices, while others are saying
- 23:03it's flashing macro stress. So which is it exactly?
- 23:06Is dollar weakness bullish oil or a warning signal?
- 23:09What is it? So Shruti, I would say that
- 23:11dollar weakens actually supports the oil until it doesn't.
- 23:15So let me just explain you this very briefly that a weaker
- 23:18dollar mechanically lifts the commodity prices because oil is
- 23:23dollar denominated. And then that part is simple.
- 23:26But when the dollar weakens because of global risk,
- 23:29perceptions are shifting, that's very different.
- 23:32And right now the freight inflation is actually real
- 23:35shipping. Shipping costs fed into
- 23:37delivered crude prices have a two or three months of lag and
- 23:41that shows up in refined product prices as well.
- 23:43Sushruti, you see that the Feds are also looking at the headline
- 23:47inflations, but the shipping is quietly repricing everything
- 23:51it's underneath. Sushruti, you have got the Saudi
- 23:53Arabia cutting crude prices to five year lows while the freight
- 23:57is at pandemic era highs. One hand it gives and the other
- 24:01it takes. That's not just bullish comfort,
- 24:04that's a stress redistribution. And for the matter of fact, I
- 24:07have a question for you, Shruti. I want to talk about the product
- 24:10market. The gasoline looks strong
- 24:13physically, but it's very weak on paper.
- 24:15NAFTA is actually tight in the East and the distillates have
- 24:19just spiked on weather. So where are these physical
- 24:22market diverging the most from paper right now?
- 24:25I think Smith gasoline is the perfect example of why paper can
- 24:29lie so physically. Gasoline is tight in key
- 24:32regions, refinery outages, seasonal maintenance, logistics
- 24:36friction. But paper markets are skeptical
- 24:39because inventories look fine on aggregate.
- 24:41Now that we know that in the East, NAFTA is genuinely tight.
- 24:45But the LPG losses are again pushing incremental demand into
- 24:48NAFTA. So the Iran risk has added to
- 24:51supply anxiety and that's why the NAFTA East, West and pro
- 24:54NAFTA E spreads are moving in the same direction.
- 24:57So the arbitrage windows open and close, not because demand is
- 25:01exploding, but because freight and risk premiums distort
- 25:04economics. So now distillates have seen a
- 25:07weather driven spike. The coal SNAP are mattering, but
- 25:10now the debate is heating oil versus gas oil.
- 25:13But is it structurally short or just weather noise?
- 25:16I think this debate isn't settled yet and it's going to
- 25:18take some time. But then again, fuel oil has a
- 25:21higher convection tone. But it's not, it's not a full
- 25:24bulk case. The floor looks solid, but the
- 25:27ceiling here still needs confirmation.
- 25:29So that's the product market reality check right now.
- 25:33Thank you for giving us such a reality check, Shruti, and
- 25:36definitely we'll see that distillates debate is going to
- 25:39settle or not. So now towards the end, I think
- 25:43for everyone who is listening right now, the summary would be
- 25:46to watch freight before flat price, watch insurance before
- 25:50inventories, and watch logistics before headlines.
- 25:53Because if hormones risk cools, oil deflates fast, and if it
- 25:57doesn't, freight becomes a stealth tax on every barrel.
- 26:00So the market is looking calm, but the sea lanes are expensive
- 26:04underneath. And that's where I think the
- 26:06signal really lies. So that's all for this episode.
- 26:10Thank you to all our listeners who have tuned in and do not
- 26:13forget to share and subscribe to our podcast.
- 26:16Until next time, navigate safely and stay tuned.