Latest / Forgotten Hollywood / Episode 188 Author Scott Eyman and His Book "Charlie Chaplin vs America"
Transcript
- 0:01You're listening to You've Forgotten Hollywood with Doug Hess here on Jljmedia. Hello everyone,
- 0:22and welcome to Forgotten Hollywood, your podcast and memories of Yesteryear. My
- 0:26name is Doug Hes and if you're tune into Forgotten Hollywood for the first time,
- 0:30what I do on this podcast is take you on a journey back in
- 0:33time and share with you pieces of Hollywood that you may or may not know
- 0:36about. And in this episode we have a very special guest with us today,
- 0:40author Scott Iiman in his latest book, Charlie Chaplin in America When Art,
- 0:46Sex and Politics Collided. Scott, Welcome to Forgotten Hollywood. Thanks Doug,
- 0:51it's good to be here. Ah, it's a pleasure having you on
- 0:54and we really appreciate you spending a few minutes with us today. Talk about
- 0:58your latest book on Charlie chap So, maybe just kind of give a quick
- 1:02overview to start what the book is about for the audience. Well, it's
- 1:06about in the bulk of the book is about twelve years in the life of
- 1:11Charlie Chaplin from about nineteen forty to about nineteen fifty two when he was kicked
- 1:17out of America. There's a prologue in which I kind of get about the
- 1:23speed. I can't assume that, you know, people in the twenty first
- 1:26century know about Charlie Chaplin's backstory. His childhood is entering of the movie,
- 1:32vaudeville career, entering into the movies, et cetera, et cetera. So
- 1:34there's you know, I had to take time to do that, and there's
- 1:37an equivalent section at the back of the book where I finished the story.
- 1:41Take them, you know, take him to for the rest of his life,
- 1:44because he was fifty when he left the country. He was sixty three
- 1:49years old, and he lived another twenty four years, so I had to
- 1:53also conclude the story. But the bulk of the book takes place between nineteen
- 1:59forty and nineteen fifty two. No, I have to agree with you.
- 2:02I think a lot of people know about him being an actor and a great
- 2:07director, but there was a lot more controversy with his life. Like you
- 2:13said, the kind of the backstory that really makes him a very interesting individual.
- 2:19Needless say, yeah, yeah, yeah. He lived about half a
- 2:23dozen lives in one basically, from a life of extreme property as a child
- 2:29to being a vaudeville star by the time he was twenty twenty one to being
- 2:34an international movie star at twenty five, and basically he stayed legendary for the
- 2:38rest of his life sixty sixty more years. So it's not a life that
- 2:44has a lot of court, a lot of competition in terms of longevity,
- 2:47in terms of a vibrant career, in terms of creating an archetype you know,
- 2:53you were talking about, you know, in the nineteen forties with the
- 2:59political situation, it's not really that much different in today's environment when it talks
- 3:06about politics and the divide, and people were after him for his political beliefs,
- 3:13kind of like what you're seeing today. And I don't want to get
- 3:15too political in this, but you can see a lot of parallels in today's
- 3:20environment. Well, what I'm writing about essentially is what devolved into the Blacklist
- 3:24era, Right, It start out that way, but after the war is
- 3:29when it picked up speed. And certainly by nineteen forty seven when he brought
- 3:32out my Sugardo, the Blacklist was in full sway. And I in my
- 3:38mind he's the most prominent victim of the Blacklist really because nineteen fifty two it
- 3:45was just starting to wind down. I and Carl Foreman were the last major
- 3:50players to enter exile. Chaplin was involuntarily exiled, Foreman was voluntarily exiled.
- 3:59Foreman went to England. I'm chaplain had his re entry permit revoked when he
- 4:02was on the Queen Elizabeth going to London from New York City, at which
- 4:08point he was in the middle of the Atlantic Ocean. So he had to
- 4:12improvise the rest of his life basically, and for a third act that he
- 4:17had planned on sting in California for the rest of his life. He had
- 4:21a young wife, he had four kids, they eventually had eight, and
- 4:27he was not ever going to leave because he had his studio, he had
- 4:30the life he wanted that he sculpted piece by piece over forty years, you
- 4:36know. And he was also very he was not a person prone to radical
- 4:43change, radical shifts. That's why he made two silent movies in the nineteen
- 4:46thirties, City Lights and Modern Times, at a time when you know,
- 4:50silent movies were obliterated by sound, right, yeah, absolutely, And if
- 4:56I remember correctly, he was on the he was on the ship, like
- 5:00you said, in the middle of the Atlantic Ocean. And that's when jaeg
- 5:03Or Hoover basically pulled the stunt, pointed citizenship, right, Is that correct?
- 5:11Well almost, No, he wasn't a citizen. He was not an
- 5:15America. That's true. You're right. My apologies, which actually was a
- 5:18source of part of his trouble because it was generally that generally the fact that
- 5:25he never became an American citizen somehow translated into being an American or being hostile
- 5:30to American ideals. Actually it was a misinterpretations. His friend Max Eastman said,
- 5:36people didn't understand Charlie. He said he was born in England and became
- 5:41rich and famous in America. If the reverse had been the case, that
- 5:44he'd been born in America and became rich and famous in England, he would
- 5:47never have taken out English citizenship either. His basic premise was that nationalism,
- 5:54national pride, et cetera, et cetera, was intrinsically absurd and taken to
- 5:59a lot of extremes, led to World War Two, led to Nazism,
- 6:02led to Hitler, and he considered himself his phrase was a citizen of the
- 6:06world. Yeah, apologize to that, because I did know he wasn't a
- 6:11US citizen, and that was part of his trouble, and I misspoke there
- 6:15in terms of let's get kind of move on to you know, title the
- 6:19book a sex his life. When it comes to women, he was very
- 6:24fond of women. He had numerous affairs, He was married four times,
- 6:29had children. Did that get him in a lot of trouble with the studios?
- 6:33His fans didn't really affect his relationship with his fans, and he owned
- 6:41his own studio on Libray Avenue so he didn't have to worry, and he
- 6:45self financed his own films, so he wasn't someone who could be effectively blackballed.
- 6:49By the end, he was part of the industry, but he was
- 6:54apart from the industry at the same time, so they couldn't really touch him,
- 6:59which I'm sure as a source of great discontent, because yeah, he
- 7:05liked girls, He liked women. He liked girls and women. And see,
- 7:13part of his problem was he didn't really care as just generally, he
- 7:15didn't care what other people thought. He was not interested in, you know,
- 7:19the opinions of Rando's if he had the Internet, he wouldn't have been
- 7:24interested in reading the comments section. You know, he just had no interest
- 7:28in it, and he'd never gossiped about people. He wasn't interested in anybody
- 7:30else's sex life. So I think he probably incorrectly assumed that people's interest in
- 7:36his sex life was irrelevant, and actually it wasn't irrelevant. It cost him
- 7:41a lot, eventually cost him a great deal of his public in America anyway,
- 7:45not in Europe. In Europe, I suspect his sex life was considered
- 7:48a plus. But there there's always been a huge difference between the American attitude
- 7:55towards sex and European attitudes towards sex. And he was a birth the European
- 8:01so there you go. Yeah, absolutely, you know. And that's probably
- 8:05one thing that I admire the most about Charlie is that he was kind of
- 8:11secure in his own skin. And that's not something that a lot of people
- 8:15are really don't give a crap what other people think. Most people actually are
- 8:24obsessed with what other people think about themselves. And I think that was one
- 8:28of his strong points is that he really didn't carry He walked his own walk
- 8:33and did what he wanted to right or wrong, good or bad. To
- 8:37me, that was a plus for him. I think that's true. I
- 8:39think that's true. But the key to him almost everything that in order to
- 8:46understand him, you have to understand his childhood and his response to his childhood,
- 8:50what his childhood taught him, and what he took. The takeaway for
- 8:54him from his childhood was the society in general can't be trusted. That you're
- 8:58on your own, You can't depend on anybody but yourself. And if you
- 9:01can find one or two other people in your life that you can count on,
- 9:05absolutely you're ahead of the game. And that's reflected over and over again
- 9:11in his films where the Tramp is it's not that the Tramp is met with
- 9:18hostility, he's met with indifference. You know, the society and mass really
- 9:24doesn't care about people who aren't in their equivalent level of society. They're just
- 9:30they're living their own life. My favorite seeing one of my favorite moments in
- 9:33modern times. We open with the assembly line. Everybody's you know, working
- 9:37to death on the assembly line and it's going faster and faster and they're trying
- 9:41to keep up. And then we cut to the president of the corporation and
- 9:45he's sitting at his desk working a jigsaw puzzle. And it's not that he's
- 9:50not an evil capitalist, he's just he's trying to fill up his day.
- 9:54His day isn't terribly filled with anything else. So he's working a jigsaw puzzle,
- 10:00and he's not really invested in the lives of the people down in the
- 10:03basement making the widgets, you know. And that was Chaplain's view of the
- 10:07world because he was thrown at a very early age into the tender mercies of
- 10:13the Victorian childcare system. And it was a nightmare for which the term de
- 10:16kenzie was embedded. And it wasn't that the Victorians thought of themselves as cruel
- 10:22or looked or despised the underclass. They just didn't really want to be bothered
- 10:28with them, you know. And that's universal human characteristic. And so Chaplain,
- 10:33for very early on came to the conclusion that he couldn't depend on anybody
- 10:37but himself. And the corollary to that is why should I care what anybody
- 10:41else thinks of what I'm doing? Right? Yeah, man? And it
- 10:46served him well to a degree. I mean, I think we could say
- 10:48that as well. Well. When it didn't, he functioned. I Mean,
- 10:54the thing about Chaplain is I refer to him as an invulnerable in the
- 10:58book because the child that he went through would generally you're going to be a
- 11:03career criminal or associate path or something. You know you're not going to get
- 11:07away scott free, is it wor sorry for the pun, No, yeah,
- 11:11But and he was damaged in some ways, there's no question about it.
- 11:15Sure, but he functioned on a very high level as an artist,
- 11:20very high level. And that is something unusual because very few artists have that
- 11:26kind of childhood. A lot of great, great artists come out of fairly
- 11:30bourgeois comfortable environments from also on down Renoir or you know, Bainters, writers,
- 11:35whatever. They rarely come out of the underclass the way Chaplain did.
- 11:41Did anything surprise you during your research of this book? Oh god, yeah,
- 11:46some of the stuff I found in the Chaplain archives, the intimate relationship
- 11:54between Chaplain and his brother Sydney surprised me because Sidney had a career of his
- 11:58own in the Silent era, he never made a sound film, he retired
- 12:01to the South of France. Nobody's full but I mean they were very close
- 12:09emotionally, psychologically, practically. Whenever Charlie was in trouble, he'd called for
- 12:13Sidney. Whenever Charlie needed help with gags, he calls Sydney whenever. I
- 12:18mean, they were just very very close. And Sydney would write these seven
- 12:22and eight page single space letters to his brother regularly. Sidney loved to write
- 12:26letters Charlie. You had to hold a gun to his head to write a
- 12:28letter. He just he wrote very few letters. He didn't like to write
- 12:31letters. So Sidney is constantly writing these long, long intimate letters to Charlie
- 12:37and they always close with I'd love to hear from you sometime. You know,
- 12:41it kills me to get a Christmas card from the Chaplain Studios, inc.
- 12:46That kind of thing, and Charlie never really there are some letters from
- 12:52Charlie to Sydney, but not a lot, not a lot. There are
- 12:54a lot more letters from Sydney to Charlie. So like that gave me really
- 12:58insight into his family relationships, his feeling about his brother. His brother was
- 13:05one of really only two or three really intimate relationships he had in his life.
- 13:09Another was Douglas Fairbanks Senior, and of course the other was the last
- 13:13one would have been his wife, Unafe and his fourth wife, to whom
- 13:18he was absolutely devoted and it was mutual. But he was not a man
- 13:22who did intimacy casually. He was not a typical actor, you know,
- 13:26chat who could go on a talk show and chat up and give a performance
- 13:33on a talk show. He wasn't that guy. He was actually extraordinarily shy
- 13:35as a person, and he had to kind of act to do an interview.
- 13:41He had to perform the interview. He couldn't he couldn't just go on
- 13:43and be relax and be himself because that wasn't he who he was. Yeah,
- 13:48kind of reminds me in present day times, somebody like a Johnny Carson.
- 13:52I had heard stories that, you know, he could get up and
- 13:54perform in front of a million people, but get him in a room with
- 13:58five people and he was very uncomfor powle And and to me, that sounds
- 14:03a lot like how he was as well as an individual. Well, comedians
- 14:05as a class are generally rather shy people. And when Chaplin was in a
- 14:11social situation, he would do what most comedians do. He'd do bits,
- 14:16you know, he would, he would, he would perform, But emotional
- 14:20intimacy was something he did not do on a casual basis. Very few people
- 14:24really, he let very few people in close, let very few people in
- 14:28on an intimate basis. Yeah, and if you got into that inner circle,
- 14:33it was it was a plus. Oh sure, because he was extremely
- 14:37loyal and extremely generous. I mean when the when when the Jewish refugees came
- 14:43over from Germany and Belgium and when Hitler took over the countries. Uh,
- 14:48he was very generous in supporting some of the refugees, some of the literary
- 14:52based refugees. Sokover Tael she'd come over in the in the late twenties,
- 14:56actually with her husband. Uh. But the few twangers he wrote Jesus.
- 15:05Uh. He was very close with a lot of the German uh Viennese refugees
- 15:09and and helped him out financially as well towards uh Champlain's later in life.
- 15:16Did did he ever mellow or was he pretty much hardcore to the end?
- 15:20A lot of times when people get older sometimes they will relax a little bit.
- 15:24Did did Did you see any of that in him? Yeah? He
- 15:28did, he did. He got much less socially involved. He didn't make
- 15:35any He was angry for a long time about America, about the rent permit
- 15:39thing, as he as he said, I quote him in the book saying,
- 15:43I wouldn't go back there if Jesus Christ was president. So yeah,
- 15:48was he angry, Yeah, he was maybe just a little, just a
- 15:52little, but he got over it, uh and he but it took him
- 16:00a long time, and as a person he mellowed a little bit. He
- 16:06was always very work oriented. It was hard for him. He never wanted
- 16:10to go on vacation. Una would say, the kids need to get out
- 16:14of the house, we need to go someplace, and she would have to
- 16:17put a chain around him and yank him practically to get him to take the
- 16:19family on a vacation because he was all writing something or working in a script
- 16:23or working on his memoirs, or doing some writing something, composing music,
- 16:29whatever it was. And he didn't like to go away from his work.
- 16:33You know. That was how he defined himself. He didn't define himself as
- 16:36a husband, he didn't define himself as a father. He defined himself as
- 16:40a filmmaker. And for a filmmaker, it's twenty four to seven if you're
- 16:45really the kind of filmmaker he was, because it's the kind of filmmaker that
- 16:48Stanley Kubrick was. He's the kind of filmmaker that Christopher Nolan is there's no
- 16:56off hours. We're always working. It's in their blood. One thing I
- 17:00wanted to ask you and kind of dvate just a little bit. But several
- 17:03years ago, there was a movie Champlain that had Robert Downey Junior in him,
- 17:10and I understand, and I completely understand that when it comes to Hollywood
- 17:15and doing a bio that it's not one hundred percent. But overall, did
- 17:18you think it was a pretty good portrayal of his life? It was okay,
- 17:23it was it was okay. The only real thing that was wrong with
- 17:26it was there they tried to tell his entire life story in two and a
- 17:30half hours, which is almost impossible. Yeah, it can't be It can't
- 17:34be done. You start, it starts off okay, and he gets into
- 17:37Hollywood and that's okay, and that starts hopscotching, you know, and your
- 17:42and your your, there's not It doesn't build up a lot of dramatic impact
- 17:47because it doesn't stay long enough. Because he's trying to get eighty eight years
- 17:51into a two and a half hour movie and it can't be done. It
- 17:52would have made more sense of rad Rich was directed by Richard Attenborough was one
- 17:56of his dream projects. If he had focus, I think one specific area
- 18:02of ten or twenty years, you know, Blacklist era, the Silent era,
- 18:07the childhood and then becoming famous in Hollywood something, rather than trying to
- 18:11shoot everything in. Yeah. And I thought Robert Downey Junior did a pretty
- 18:15good job of betraying yeah, you know, I mean he looked a lot
- 18:18like him, and he did pretty well with the physical stuff. But of
- 18:22course he's not. He's not as limber as Chaplain was because he's a Chaplain
- 18:26was doing was was on the stage from Nerli from the time he was eight
- 18:29or ten years old, so his body was a finally tuned instrument that could
- 18:33do any kind of physical comedy. And Robert Downey's not that person. He's
- 18:37an actor. So he had to act the physicality of Chaplain's body and he
- 18:42got close enough that you kind of bought it. And he looked a lot
- 18:45like him, yeah, to where you could say it past you know,
- 18:49the test. Yeah, But overall thought he did a pretty good job of
- 18:53that. For what did you deal with it? All? Right? Well,
- 18:59Scott, I wanted to thank you for coming on. I know we're
- 19:00here very close on time, but I wanted to say thank you again,
- 19:03and really encourage our listeners to go out and get a copy of your book,
- 19:07Charlie Champlain Versus America, When Art, Sex and Politics Collided. It's
- 19:11out there. You can buy it at oh anywhere you buy your books,
- 19:18ambus On, etc. Go out and get a copy of Scott's book,
- 19:22and like I said, you're not going to be disappointed again. Scott,
- 19:25thank you so much for spending some time with us today. Thank you Doug
- 19:27anytime, well, thank you for listening to this episode of Forgotten in Hollywood.
- 19:30You search for Doug Hester Forgotten Hollywood. You can also find me on
- 19:33Twitter, Instagram at hes Doug fourteen. If you listen to this podcast on
- 19:37iTunes and another podcast service, please subscribe or rate and review this episode.
- 19:41Tune in next time for LED's episode or Forgotten in Hollywood. Thank you for
- 19:45listening and we will see you then.