Latest / Shades of Jade Podcast / Nostr: The End of Algorithms That Own You
Transcript
- 0:10Hey everyone, my guest today is Valter Constant.
- 0:13Valter is an historian, a technology researcher, and a
- 0:16Noster Co founder. Welcome to the show Valter.
- 0:20I was wondering if you could tell the audience about Noster
- 0:24and a little bit about yourself and what you do.
- 0:27OK, So, well, as, As for me, I guess the, the, the little intro
- 0:34would be that my, my, my formal background, like in academia
- 0:37would be history, economic history in terms of like my
- 0:42career or job experience. My, my, my first and only proper
- 0:46job was into what's called IoT or like sense sensor networks,
- 0:50radio networks, that type of stuff.
- 0:53But for the most part, I I have a background in my main
- 0:57interest, which is what's called distributed computing or
- 1:01decentralized computing systems. So in the olden days, this would
- 1:04be things like torrents downloading, downloading things,
- 1:10RSS, which is still the basis for podcasting and all kinds of
- 1:15different protocols and systems that have gone come up along the
- 1:18way. I guess the the biggest one
- 1:21would be and I spent most of my time in the past years would be
- 1:26Bitcoin, which is the largest decentralized computing network
- 1:28out there. And in more recent times, it's a
- 1:32it's Noster, which is a an open protocol for publication and
- 1:37maintaining social networks. OK.
- 1:41What does a typical day look like working on that?
- 1:44For me, well, I, I do a couple of things.
- 1:46So I, I'm trying to write a book about the, about the subject.
- 1:53I do podcasts, podcasts like this.
- 1:57More recently, I'm with a couple of other guys.
- 2:01I'm trying to set up a foundation called the Web of
- 2:05Trust Foundation, where we try to build out a protocol on top
- 2:11or a system on top of Nostra with the aim of providing a safe
- 2:17and adequate Internet environment geared toward
- 2:20children or younger people. And The thing is, it's a, it's,
- 2:27it's an open protocol. Nobody owns it.
- 2:29They're just some guy in 2019 wrote, wrote up a description of
- 2:34the, of the thing and things progress from there.
- 2:38But there, there's no organization or, or business or
- 2:41whatever behind it. So, you know, I'm, I'm involved
- 2:48just with a whole bunch of other people and it's a, it's pretty
- 2:50chaotic, chaotic, unstructured process for the most part.
- 2:56OK, how do you think that this, does this solve social media
- 3:01censorship issues or, and, and how do you, how do you solve
- 3:07that while also keeping kids safe?
- 3:09I know that I noticed that there's a lot of concern with
- 3:12like AI and children and accessibility to certain things.
- 3:18All right, so maybe we can touch on the, on the, on the the kids
- 3:23stuff later and as well as the AI as well as many other
- 3:27aspects. But the yeah, so the the main
- 3:31idea behind Noster initially was to create a censorship resistant
- 3:36form of social networking. And initially it actually was
- 3:41just more like building a Twitter type thing.
- 3:45And the, the, the main, the main idea behind by Noster is what
- 3:52you can call it censorship resistance, which is a technical
- 3:55term which we, we distributed compute type people like to like
- 3:59to use. But you could, you could also
- 4:01phrase it in a positive manner being freedom of association.
- 4:06So we, we want to create a system that provides freedom of
- 4:09association, but also provides another thing that is crucial,
- 4:13which is network effect. Because network effect is this
- 4:18notion where in a network, the more nodes you have in a network
- 4:21or in the more people, the value of the network grows in an
- 4:25exponential manner in relation to the amount of people that are
- 4:28actually part of the network. So the, the most simple example
- 4:31would be phones. If you're, if you're the only
- 4:33person in the world with a phone, they're absolutely
- 4:35useless. If they're not two people with a
- 4:38phone that that's nice, right? You can call this one person,
- 4:42but you can, you can start to see that the more people start
- 4:45to join the phone network, the more value having a phone
- 4:49actually has because you now have access to more and more
- 4:51people. So the, the basic notion of
- 4:54network effect is that everybody's there because
- 4:56everybody is there. And this is the main, this is
- 5:00the main core of the success of these social media platforms
- 5:04that we, that we use is that they initially they had, they
- 5:10basically won the game for capturing network effect.
- 5:14And that's the reason why companies like Meta with
- 5:17Facebook or Instagram, but also Twitter and our called X.
- 5:22We only have like a handful of platforms that most of the
- 5:25people in the world actually use.
- 5:26And this is, this is the reasons because everybody's there
- 5:29because everybody's there, right?
- 5:31You want to, you want to be seen, you want to find people.
- 5:35So you go to the place where the most set of eyeballs are to, to
- 5:40look at you or you can look at the most very, very things
- 5:46available to you because everybody is already there.
- 5:48So this is, this is the core of the core of the matter.
- 5:52Because when we're talking about censorship resistance or this
- 5:54notion of freedom of association, that's something
- 5:57that the Internet itself already provides.
- 6:00So the Internet is also an open protocol and it initially was
- 6:08designed from a military perspective to provide this
- 6:12notion of censorship resistance in order to maintain
- 6:15communications even in a hostile environment, let's say.
- 6:19So you want to, you want to have a communication network that is
- 6:21not easily shut down. And after some development, this
- 6:27became the, the public Internet that we know where all these
- 6:30computers are connected with each other.
- 6:32And the idea here is that you, you already have censorship
- 6:38resistance because it's, it's not that complicated to host
- 6:41your own website, right? And this is something that
- 6:45people do, right? People get banned off a
- 6:47platform, they go to maybe a marginal platform.
- 6:50So let's say you're, you're kicked off of YouTube, you go to
- 6:52Rumble, for example. So it's just another video
- 6:55platform or you host your own website and you post your videos
- 6:59there, which is all well and good.
- 7:01Now technically you, you have censorship persistence.
- 7:04You, you found a way to keep your skipping your signal alive.
- 7:09The problem is, is you lost your network effect.
- 7:12So you, you're, you're effectively self marginalizing
- 7:15the moment you leave these platforms because you, you don't
- 7:20have the network effect. You're not there where everybody
- 7:22else is. So the the the fundamental crux
- 7:26of Nasser is providing both. So at the same time providing
- 7:29network effect as well as censorship resistance.
- 7:34OK, yeah, I, I had wondered in the past, or still do I guess,
- 7:41why you hear a lot of people talking about the censorship
- 7:46that happens on platforms like YouTube.
- 7:49And then it's like, well, why don't why don't you move over to
- 7:52Rumble then? Which, yeah, that would that
- 7:55would be a cost. But I've kind of wondered why
- 7:58all these people didn't band together and just say, no, we
- 8:01won't be on YouTube at all. We will only be on on Rumble.
- 8:05And if a lot of people did it, I.
- 8:09Well, that's a correct story. I mean, that's a coordination
- 8:11problem. Now you have to coordinate all
- 8:12these individual agents, yeah, to say, OK, let's let's go to
- 8:17this particular place. And the problem there is like,
- 8:21OK, are you going to Rumble? Are you going going to go to
- 8:23Odyssey? Are you going to go to, I don't
- 8:25know, there, there are probably tons of websites out there or
- 8:28platforms that you're you're able to go to.
- 8:31So how are you going to, how are you going to agree on what
- 8:34platform you're going to go to whether when organically
- 8:38initially everybody already agreed that they were going to
- 8:40go to YouTube. So this is this is this is The
- 8:43thing is that creating these network effects or in order to
- 8:48be the winner, let's say of this, of this, of this process
- 8:52is very difficult. It's very hard to to get to such
- 8:56a point. And once a decision collectively
- 9:00has been made, which in this case it's like it is YouTube.
- 9:05And in terms of like videos, it's, it's a, it's a particular
- 9:07thing because video hosting is expensive.
- 9:11So it's actually hard to, to create alternatives.
- 9:13But there are other examples, for instance, instant messaging
- 9:17or private messaging. Pretty much depends on where you
- 9:21are in the world. But in like for here, I'm, I'm
- 9:24in Netherlands here, WhatsApp is pretty popular.
- 9:26I know that I think, you know, regions in South America,
- 9:29WhatsApp is really popular. Yeah.
- 9:32You also have Telegram, but it kind of depends on the on what
- 9:36region you are. I think in, in the US, you, you
- 9:40the iPhone is pretty popular there.
- 9:42So yeah, the iPhone provides a messaging system.
- 9:46So even even even in different environments, these things, you
- 9:51know, they, they as a result of of some collective process
- 9:56people ultimately in an uncoordinated fashion, they
- 10:00coordinate towards one particular result and from there
- 10:04on it's very difficult to to move past to something else.
- 10:08Right, right. I had that.
- 10:12I don't know, a while ago I was very anti Facebook in it.
- 10:16I mean, it's really like turning into a crap platform in my
- 10:18opinion. But maybe I'm just not using it
- 10:20right, You know, liking the the right things or whatever.
- 10:23But you go on there to see what your friends are posting and
- 10:26it's all ads. And we, we had a huge issue with
- 10:33people's accounts getting hacked and like selling fake items and
- 10:37whatever. I knew a lot of people who did
- 10:39it. And so some people were leaving
- 10:42Facebook, but then no one's using anything else like that.
- 10:47Like I love X, but but none of my family uses it.
- 10:51And and then there's the Facebook marketplace.
- 10:54And yeah, it's a it's really hard to compete, I guess.
- 10:59Well, and they're they're you touching something pretty
- 11:01interesting. It's by now it goes under this
- 11:04phrase of shitification where this idea is that these these
- 11:10platforms over time or these Internet services, these web
- 11:13services, they shitify over time, they become more crappy.
- 11:17And that's actually been baked in right from the start.
- 11:21So how how this went? Because I'm, I'm saying it's
- 11:23like, OK, there was this organic process in, in ultimately
- 11:27getting into a decision is where we're going towards.
- 11:30That's half true. But the other half that story is
- 11:32that they're financed into that, into that position.
- 11:35So because like, like I said, YouTube hosting videos is a very
- 11:41expensive operation. But basically for all these
- 11:45platforms, creating an account is free, right?
- 11:48So who's paying for who's, who's paying the cost for all these
- 11:52users that are signing up? And this was the question right
- 11:54from the start. So, and you even you can see
- 11:57this in, in different areas that are not necessarily social
- 12:02media. You also see it in clothing
- 12:03websites or, or marketplaces more broadly.
- 12:09Like Amazon is a pretty good example.
- 12:10Actually. The thing is, is that because
- 12:13you're in this competition for network effect that you, you
- 12:18have this winner takes all or winner takes most dynamic.
- 12:21So the message towards investors always was is like, OK, we're
- 12:25going to subsidize our growth and we're going to do it into
- 12:29the foreseeable future only to the point where we are the what
- 12:34we are where, where we are the winner.
- 12:35Let's say everybody's there because everybody's there.
- 12:38And the moment everybody's there, we got them because now
- 12:41we well, first we undermined all our competition in, in the way
- 12:46there. So they're not around anymore.
- 12:48And from that moment on, we can start to leverage the, the, the
- 12:53position that we have in order to start making money, which
- 12:57ultimately just results in this whole shedification process
- 13:01because now you're now the pressures are on.
- 13:03It's like, OK, how are we going to fleece these sheep, right?
- 13:06It's how, how we're going to get our wool.
- 13:08So, so now the frictions are starting occur, The ads are
- 13:11starting to occur. The, the incentives as to what
- 13:14kind of content is, is suggested to you starts to shift this type
- 13:20of things. So, but that was already baked
- 13:23in from the start. That was already baked in the,
- 13:26the investor page right from the start.
- 13:27It's like, give us your money. We'll, we'll become the biggest
- 13:32and the moment we're the biggest, we can close the gates
- 13:35and then we can start making, then we can start getting our
- 13:37money back because people don't really have an alternative
- 13:40anymore because because of this notion of network effect.
- 13:44So this is a, this is a it. It's not actually a surprise
- 13:48that we are. We're in this situation.
- 13:50Yeah, I'm, I'm going to start using that word.
- 13:54I'm going to say should a fight as well.
- 13:58I think it's a paper. It's, it's, it's a, it's a
- 14:00phrase from an actual paper. I think it's from 2019 or
- 14:03something. Really.
- 14:04Yeah, I like that. So it's, it's an observed
- 14:06phenomena, but even you could have come to that conclusion,
- 14:11you could have seen it coming, all right.
- 14:13Right. Yeah, yeah.
- 14:16So yeah, I guess we kind of discussed like the real, is that
- 14:21the the real problem with social networking platforms or are
- 14:25there are there other major problems with social networking
- 14:29platforms? I think there are, there are,
- 14:31there are, there are various kinds of issues, be that be that
- 14:34censorship or the the shit ification, as I mentioned, or
- 14:38whatever you whatever it is. But I think fundamentally it
- 14:42boils down to this notion that it's the problem is that there
- 14:49are centralized platforms. So now we, we've, as we
- 14:51discussed, we have this, we it's a, there's network effect is
- 14:54captured by a single entity. So let's say Facebook, for
- 14:59example, they have a growth problem because they basically
- 15:03already captured the entire global population for the most
- 15:05part. So there are still people
- 15:09getting onto the Internet because they weren't on the
- 15:11Internet before. But even there the limits are
- 15:17being reached. So only the newborn people are
- 15:21are are new. Customers for.
- 15:23For Facebook, so they thought the whole point is that now
- 15:29Facebook is responsible to facilitate all these services
- 15:33for all these people. And here an interesting problem
- 15:36occurs because these platforms, they are private companies, but
- 15:42because, because of how we interact with these platforms,
- 15:47how we behave and these network effects of everybody's there
- 15:51because everybody, because everybody's there, they, we're,
- 15:55we treat them as if they are public spaces.
- 15:58So we plea, we treat them as if they are the public square, as
- 16:01if they are these places that we have political discussions and
- 16:06all kind of, let's say civil functions that are facilitated
- 16:11by these private companies. This becomes a problem because
- 16:15now these platforms don't only have to deal with all the varied
- 16:18interests of their users, which is as varied as there are users
- 16:22and they already captured everybody, but they also have
- 16:24to, they have their own interests as a business.
- 16:27They have the interest that they have to cater to of their
- 16:30advertisers, which is are their real customers.
- 16:34But now because we are using them as the public square, there
- 16:37are now also public interest involved.
- 16:39And that's where government's coming because governments are
- 16:41looking at this, this stuff. And there's like, wait, we're
- 16:45treating it as if it's the public square.
- 16:46The these are public interest. This is our domain.
- 16:50So we have an opinion about this stuff.
- 16:52But because it's global, it's becomes a geopolitical problem
- 16:56because we don't have a world government.
- 16:58We have the United States as an opinion.
- 17:00We have your European Union as an opinion.
- 17:02Turkey has an opinion, China has an opinion.
- 17:05So all these different countries now also have the opinions.
- 17:07So you can imagine we have this single platform and this tug of
- 17:13war going on between all these fairy parties, which are the,
- 17:17all the different users, the, the corporate interest itself,
- 17:20the advertiser interest, and now all these different geopolitical
- 17:23interests that are all tugging on to what the policy ought to
- 17:26be of this single particular platform.
- 17:32So, and that's where I think all the, all the problems start to
- 17:36occur. It's because there is no
- 17:37solution to to this issue, right?
- 17:40There is no clear solution to everybody being involved in
- 17:44this. I don't know five way tug of war
- 17:46going on. So I guess that's that's at the
- 17:50core of the core of the matter and that's why with Nasser, the
- 17:56whole point is decentralization. So we were no longer relying on
- 18:01A1 particular platform to provide all these services for
- 18:05us. We can we're able to
- 18:06decentralize it and in order to explain, then we have to look at
- 18:11these central platforms and see what is it actually that they're
- 18:13doing right? They are there are some of the
- 18:16biggest corporations on this planet.
- 18:18So they're obviously facilitating some surface,
- 18:21right? They're doing something right.
- 18:23What is it that they're doing? Well, you can you can cut that
- 18:26into three different categories. So the first one would be
- 18:29identity and and network. So this is your account and this
- 18:32is the the people that you follow and the people that
- 18:35following you, right? You're what's called the social
- 18:36graph or your, your social network that, that you have.
- 18:41The second part is what you call hosting.
- 18:44So this is actually making your content available.
- 18:48So you you post a video or you post a tweet that that has to be
- 18:51stored on a server, right? There are physical machines out
- 18:54there on this world that has to store the store that data and
- 18:58have a good enough connection in order to if if somebody else
- 19:00wants to see it, they can actually download it from those
- 19:03servers. And the third part would be what
- 19:07you could call it indexing. And this is stuff like search,
- 19:11search functionality, suggestion algorithms, so old stuff that is
- 19:15there in order for you to make sense of this vast amount of
- 19:18data that is out there. And that gives you the ability
- 19:21to get into contact with people that you did not know before,
- 19:26right? So you have your, your group of
- 19:27friends, that's nice, but you also want to see other content
- 19:31from people you have not interacted with before or you
- 19:34want to look stuff up and find things.
- 19:37So that's, that's the third category.
- 19:39And what Noster does is as a protocol, it breaks that up.
- 19:44So now these three functions are no longer at one place anymore.
- 19:50They reside in, in different locations, you could say.
- 19:53So to start with the first, it's this notion of identity.
- 19:57What Noster What Noster uses is cryptographic key pairs.
- 20:01So this is similar as to what Bitcoin uses, for example, the
- 20:06whole, the whole notion with Bitcoin is that you can just
- 20:08generate what is called a cryptographic key pair.
- 20:11It's a pair because there is a public key and a private key,
- 20:15which you could, you could in the Bitcoin sense, you could say
- 20:17like the, the public key is your account and the, the private key
- 20:20is your key to that, to that account or to that lock box in
- 20:24the nostril sense, it's your, your name and the, and is the
- 20:29public key. And the private key would be
- 20:31your, your, your way to prove that you are the owner of that
- 20:36name. And what, what, what, what
- 20:38happens in Nasser is that you, everything that you publish, you
- 20:41provide with the what's called a cryptographic signature.
- 20:45And you can, you can just pretty much map this to this analog
- 20:49notion of just signing everything that you publish with
- 20:52your own signature, right? And that way you, you can
- 20:58locally verify that something came from a particular person.
- 21:02So that means that this goes into the second notion of
- 21:06hosting that it doesn't matter where stuff is hosted anymore.
- 21:11Because currently if you look at Instagram, for example, you can
- 21:17question, you can ask yourself what is an Instagram post?
- 21:20An Instagram post is something that resides on instagram.com.
- 21:25instagram.com is a domain, it's a specific place.
- 21:28And the Instagram post does not exist outside of instagram.com.
- 21:34The validity of the Instagram post does not exist outside of
- 21:39the authority of declaration of Instagram that it's actually a
- 21:43real Instagram post. So whatever, What I mean by this
- 21:46is that you, let's say somebody takes a screenshot of an
- 21:51Instagram post and I see the screenshot, I will have the only
- 21:54way for me to verify that that thing actually exists.
- 21:57And it's not somebody that just made something up in Photoshop
- 22:01for me to go to instagram.com and look up that particular
- 22:04post. And with Nasser, it's different
- 22:07because every user provides everything that they publish
- 22:11with their own cryptographic signature.
- 22:14The moment I get that post from you, let's say it's a picture.
- 22:18You signed it and I'm able to locally, I'm able to run the
- 22:21math and locally verify that was actually you that published it.
- 22:25And this means that I'm no longer required to go to 1
- 22:28particular place in order to ask for verification.
- 22:31Is is this thing real though? I can locally verify that this
- 22:34thing is actually real and therefore it can come from
- 22:39whether it's instagram.com, let's say, or Flibity flop dot
- 22:42web, or it's somebody printed it out, put it in a in a glass
- 22:47bottle and it's washing up to shore.
- 22:48And I just find it or or find it under my pillow.
- 22:52It doesn't matter. It's just in the data itself
- 22:55that I can verify that this thing is actually authentic.
- 22:58And this means that I'm no longer tied to one particular
- 23:01server anymore. I can host my stuff wherever I
- 23:04wanted to host and all that my followers are required or are
- 23:08able to figure out where the stuff is that I where it is that
- 23:12I host my stuff. But they don't need to be at a
- 23:16particular place in order to verify that my stuff is actually
- 23:19real. And then the last part would be
- 23:22this indexing notion of these algorithms.
- 23:25And that's just a function that everybody could run.
- 23:30And it's probably going to open up to some marketplace because
- 23:33if I have like a very, very fancy computer at home, I would
- 23:37be able to run those, those types of algorithms myself.
- 23:41But maybe if I'm on my phone, I will just make use of a
- 23:45particular service that does it for me.
- 23:48And then the market is entirely open as to what type of
- 23:52algorithm that you're currently running, because now you're,
- 23:54you're, you're beholden to whatever decision Facebook makes
- 23:59in terms of what the algorithm is, right?
- 24:01Or when YouTube, when YouTube decides what the algorithm is,
- 24:04etcetera. So we've to, in relation to
- 24:09these three things, it's like identity, it's, it's hosting
- 24:11where the stuff is. And the, this indexing is that
- 24:14you take control over the identity yourself as a user.
- 24:19You're not relying on anything or anyone anymore in order to
- 24:23declare a, an identity, which could be one identity could be
- 24:26like 1000 in terms of hosting, we, we started out with these it
- 24:32all being at the central place, be it instagram.com or
- 24:36facebook.com, which is now decentralized.
- 24:38It's no longer relying on a particular place anymore.
- 24:41And we, we open up the possibility to run whatever type
- 24:46of algorithm or suggestion algorithm or search that we,
- 24:50that we want. And the effective result is that
- 24:58I, when I, this comes back to this notion of censorship
- 25:02resistance. Why am I censorship resistant?
- 25:04Well, the moment I'm, I'm making use of 1 server, which in Nostra
- 25:09is, is called a relay. So just a little tidbit, Nostra
- 25:13stands for notes and other stuff transmitted by relays, the notes
- 25:17and OTES and other stuff. So this is idea like the node
- 25:22would be like a tweet and the other stuff is basically hinting
- 25:25towards it doesn't have to be tweets, it can be anything and
- 25:29transmitted by relays would be this notion of like it's, it's
- 25:33carried by these various servers and where was it going?
- 25:40Oh yeah. So as a user, I now just, I'm
- 25:44able to create my own identity. I create a post, a publication,
- 25:49I sign it cryptographically, I put it towards whatever relay.
- 25:53And the moment that particular relay, which is still a server,
- 25:57it's still a machine that it's owned by somebody, which is,
- 26:00which is still a private entity that that hasn't changed.
- 26:03The thing is that when that private entity decides that he
- 26:07no longer wants to service me for whatever reason, which might
- 26:10be because I have some fringe political opinion or because he
- 26:14doesn't like me for whatever reason or or by sheer error or
- 26:20his his computer got struck by lightning.
- 26:22Whatever it is, it's like it's not functioning for me anymore.
- 26:25I'm still able to just go to another relay.
- 26:29And the, the way software works that were pretty, it can pretty
- 26:33easily be automated where the people that follow you can also
- 26:37follow you wherever your stuff is hosted.
- 26:39So the moment you're banned, you're still being able to ban
- 26:42somewhere, but it doesn't matter because the people that follow
- 26:46you, they follow you and they're still able to figure out it's
- 26:49like what? OK, this stuff is hosted
- 26:51somewhere else. I was just able to fetch it
- 26:53there. So, and that's, that's why it,
- 26:56it facilitates this notion of freedom of association is that
- 26:59we don't have to come to agreement as to what the
- 27:02policies ought to be because we rely on this, this thing for
- 27:07civil function. Let's say like, no, just throw,
- 27:11throw that out of the window. There is no, we don't have to
- 27:14come to agreement on what, what a Commons or what type of
- 27:16Commons or how, how we have to handle things.
- 27:20No, everybody can just decide for themselves what their
- 27:22policies are and let the chips fall where they may.
- 27:25And as a user, I have the flexibility in order to just
- 27:28switch to whatever place is willing to accommodate me,
- 27:31including hosting myself, which is not actually as complicated.
- 27:35We just, it's probably as easy or, or as complicated, however
- 27:40you want to see it as hosting a website.
- 27:43So if, if, if I'm, if I run a lot of censorship risk, right,
- 27:47because I'm a fringe political person, I'm able to just, I'll
- 27:51just run my own relay in order to get some Peace of Mind as to
- 27:57not being censored. But the whole notion is that my
- 28:01followers follow me and they're able to find me there wherever
- 28:04I'm hosting my stuff. The thing to, to, to end it
- 28:09there, The last part is that whatever software people are
- 28:14using is also open. So you right now you have the, a
- 28:19Twitter app or you have the X app and you have a Facebook app.
- 28:22And these are all separate apps and you have all separate
- 28:25accounts on these apps. So if you're a social media
- 28:29person, you create, you go to like link tree, which is like
- 28:32another website. And there you list all the
- 28:34places where you, where you have an account.
- 28:38So you have like a list of five different accounts and people
- 28:40will have to use five different apps in order to interface with
- 28:43these five different places. What Nostra does is that it, it,
- 28:48it throws that all out the window because you just have one
- 28:51account, let's say, and whether you are posting videos or you're
- 28:56posting tweets or you're posting articles or whatever it is that
- 29:00your, your, your activity is and your publications are, I'm
- 29:03following you and I'm just able to get that stuff.
- 29:06And maybe they are, maybe I use different apps to interface with
- 29:09that. You can imagine that scrolling
- 29:11tweets is different than scrolling pictures is different
- 29:14than scrolling videos. That's fine.
- 29:17I'll just use a different app for that.
- 29:19The problem The thing is, is that I can use it.
- 29:22I'm not restricted in what type of app that I use.
- 29:25So to make it concrete, I like I can.
- 29:28I can. I can name four different phone
- 29:31apps right now which are large and well developed.
- 29:34There are more there. There are more than 4, but four
- 29:38are actually very well functioning and they're
- 29:40completely interchangeable. So you just, you download the
- 29:43app, you put in your, your, your key pair and it just immediately
- 29:47gives you, your, gives back your profile.
- 29:50It, it generates your feed based on the people that you follow.
- 29:53Everything is just there automatically.
- 29:55So the friction in order to switch apps is has become
- 30:00marginal. And also you get this effect
- 30:03where if I started out using like a Twitter like app and now
- 30:09I go to a picture type app where I'm going to look at pictures or
- 30:13an article type app. Is that the the social network
- 30:16that I've created using or tweeting about still exists when
- 30:22I'm in this this picture sphere or article sphere.
- 30:25So whenever I'm following a particular person because of
- 30:28their tweets, the moment I log into a an article app, I
- 30:32immediately see their feed of articles if they're also
- 30:35publishing articles or I can also immediately see their
- 30:38videos. Because the whole notion is, is
- 30:40that I'm not, I'm not on a platform following a particular
- 30:44feed of a particular account of a particular of a person on a
- 30:47particular place. No, I'm just following that
- 30:49person. And whatever app I decide to use
- 30:52is the the the view I get of whatever it is that that that
- 30:55person posts. So people don't have to use the
- 30:59same app anymore. You could be.
- 31:01We could be using completely different apps and we could
- 31:03still interface with each other. OK, so that.
- 31:07Makes sense. So I gave you a whole lot, but.
- 31:11This is the basic rundown. I'm not great with technology
- 31:14either, but it I think hopefully I'm going to ask some questions
- 31:19and hopefully they'll help the listeners as well.
- 31:23OK so so let's say if I hook everything up to Noster and I'm
- 31:33posting on SO then can you link that with like Facebook,
- 31:38Instagram? No.
- 31:40So unfortunately not because that OK, that will require them
- 31:43to adopt the Noster protocol. OK.
- 31:46And then that makes sense. So then if I'm comparing, so
- 31:52like I'm kind of comparing this to certain tabs you have where
- 31:55you can do like the for you tab or the followers tab.
- 32:00When you're talking about whether you want to see images,
- 32:03articles or tweets, notes, is it kind of like that where you just
- 32:10kind of, OK, this is what I want to look at.
- 32:13I want to read some articles. So click on articles, everyone
- 32:15you follow those pop up. Is it kind of like that where
- 32:19you're how you enter into different areas?
- 32:23Well, that's, that's, that's the thing.
- 32:24It just depends on the app. So most of the so the four, four
- 32:29apps that I that I refer to, those are like what we call
- 32:32everything apps. They don't actually support
- 32:36everything, but they will support a whole bunch of things,
- 32:37which would be the tweets and the videos and the pictures and
- 32:41the articles. So they're in, in that app.
- 32:43Yes, I can just browse articles or browse pictures or or or
- 32:49whatever it is. What the feed consists of is how
- 32:53I construct my feed. So it could be just a feed of
- 32:55the people that I follow, or I can make use of a service that
- 33:01provides me a feed of things that are popular, let's say, or
- 33:08because there are, there's also a very there's also a very good
- 33:13Bitcoin integration. So I could only, for instance, I
- 33:16could just have a feed of the stuff that that has been given
- 33:20the most amount of money or the most amount of Bitcoin in the
- 33:22last 24 hours. You can basically everything
- 33:25that you can imagine is potentially a possible type of
- 33:29feed that you can create for yourself.
- 33:32So, so you're, you're not restricted there another,
- 33:35another way. It's, it's, it's not necessarily
- 33:40trivial to, to wrap your head around this, but I'm going to,
- 33:42I'm, I'm going to make an attempt.
- 33:44So these relays that I, that I mentioned these servers, the
- 33:49whole crux of Noster is that it doesn't matter.
- 33:52The relays don't matter. And they, they are all that
- 33:54matters. So what I mean with that is that
- 33:57they don't matter in the sense of what I explained in terms of
- 34:00censorship resistance and the, the signatures and the fact that
- 34:03it doesn't matter where, where stuff comes from, right?
- 34:05So you could, if you, your article, you could post an
- 34:08article, you could store it on five different relays.
- 34:11It doesn't matter on what particular relay I get it from,
- 34:13because what matters is the, the data itself, the article itself.
- 34:18At the same time, if I'm not necessarily interested in a
- 34:22particular person, so let's say you, but I'm interested in a
- 34:27topic or group of people, this relay could be like a forum or
- 34:34a, a website geared toward a specific group of people or a
- 34:37specific interest. And the policy of that relay is
- 34:41we only accept, we only, we only accept discussions around frogs,
- 34:47let's say. So it's, it's a, it's a frog
- 34:49relay, right? So only, we only accept
- 34:51discussions about frogs. And if you're not talking about
- 34:53frogs, we're not, we're not going to accept your, your
- 34:56messages. So that means that if I'm
- 34:58interested in frogs, I go to that particular relay and just
- 35:01ask the relay. Just just give the, get the
- 35:03lowdown, give me whatever is on there.
- 35:05And I'll, I'm, I'm not browsing all these things about frogs.
- 35:10And let's say you're, you're, you're, you're a frog
- 35:12aficionado. So I find you on there.
- 35:15And I find that your posts on frogs are particularly
- 35:17interesting. So I decide to follow you.
- 35:20Now, the moment I follow you, I'm not necessarily dependent on
- 35:24the frog relay anymore in order to have a connection with you.
- 35:27So because, so that let's for instance, say that you are
- 35:31starting to have French heterodox opinions about frogs
- 35:37that are not appreciated on the frog relay.
- 35:40So they decide to, to kick you off.
- 35:45I, I don't lose sight of you anymore, right?
- 35:48I use the frog relay, this particular domain of, of content
- 35:53in order to find you. But the moment I found you and I
- 35:55follow you, you could be banned from the frog relay, but I still
- 35:59able to see whatever it is that you're posting because from that
- 36:03moment on, I'm not, I'm just following you and I'm able to
- 36:06get get your content. It's not I'm not reliant on the
- 36:09on the frog relay anymore. It's kind of a silly example,
- 36:12but you hopefully you, you catch my drift.
- 36:15So. This is where.
- 36:16So this is where this whole notion of it's like the relay
- 36:19matters and it doesn't matter at the same time.
- 36:21So it matters in terms of like, if I want to, it matters in the
- 36:24sense that people are free to run their own policy, which is,
- 36:29which is an important notion. I'm not talking about some
- 36:32communal kumbaya. We're, we're relying on the
- 36:36goodwill of, of people in order to be nice and, and, and
- 36:40cooperate with each other. No, it's, these are all private,
- 36:43private environments and people, whatever interest that they
- 36:46have, it could be a business interest for profit.
- 36:49It, it could be a communal interest, it could be a charity,
- 36:51for example, or just because somebody likes frogs a lot and
- 36:55he decides to put in the effort to, to host a frog relay.
- 36:59Whatever the, the incentive or reasoning is for somebody to
- 37:02host a particular server, that's all fine.
- 37:05But they, they, because they have the, they still have
- 37:10control over what that server does and what is accepted and
- 37:12not accepted. So we're not in this tug of war
- 37:16anymore as to what the policy ought to be.
- 37:19The owner of the server decides what the policy is.
- 37:20And if you don't like it, well, too bad.
- 37:22You, you, you are able to go somewhere else.
- 37:24And that's the, that's the problem with the current
- 37:26paradigm. You're practically not able to
- 37:29go somewhere else. Technically you are, you can go
- 37:31to rumble, but now you're, you're marginalized and you,
- 37:34you're, you're, you lost the network effect because all the
- 37:37subscribers that you had are gone.
- 37:40Whereas in this nostril context, they're not gone.
- 37:42They're still there. They're just, they're following
- 37:45you and you're now, you're now on a different server.
- 37:47That's fine. You, you haven't lost your
- 37:49subscribers, you haven't lost your subscribers and your
- 37:52subscribers are also able to find, they're watching your
- 37:55videos and now they're also able to find your articles and your
- 37:58tweets because it's not in these different silos and different
- 38:01accounts and whether it's acts for your tweets and Instagram
- 38:05for your pictures, etcetera, etcetera.
- 38:06I know it's just stuff that is signed by you.
- 38:11So we're not stuck in the silos anymore.
- 38:15So now we are, we still, we maintain network effect while
- 38:19still having censorship resistance.
- 38:21So we have both and we actually have more network effect because
- 38:24we're not stuck in the silos of the tweets are in on X, the the
- 38:30pictures are on Instagram. The, the, the videos are on
- 38:33YouTube. Those are all vertically
- 38:36vertical network effects, let's say, whereas we in this Noster
- 38:39context, we're able to horizontally integrate all these
- 38:42networks. So potentially the networks
- 38:45effects are actually bigger than they are that they are right now
- 38:48because what what, what, what's happening right now is basically
- 38:50all these platforms are trying to become everything.
- 38:52Yes, I've noticed that. Yeah, you have the, you have the
- 38:56the Chinese example where it's fully integrated.
- 39:01But you you see the same thing with X.
- 39:03It's just like it started out with tweets and now it's also
- 39:06does video streaming and and long form videos and all types
- 39:10of stuff. It tries to tries to integrate
- 39:12all these things into their own platform, but the The thing is
- 39:18with Noster is like, OK, is that you're still stuck with a
- 39:22particular app, right? So now do you, do you still like
- 39:25your do you still like your X app when it starts to also give
- 39:29you videos? Is that the nicest app to watch
- 39:31videos with? Maybe not where with Noster you
- 39:34can use whatever app and it doesn't.
- 39:36Matter. So you can use a very fancy,
- 39:38nice video app, and if you don't like that app, you just use a
- 39:40different app, etcetera. Sorry to interrupt, I just
- 39:43wanted to tell you about my sponsors real quick.
- 39:49Sometimes I get on a roll cleaning or gardening and I need
- 39:51a boost but don't have time for a meal.
- 40:09Products come in a variety of delicious flavors including Thai
- 40:12green Curry and Maple and brown Sugar for the meat options and
- 40:15gangster and Chicago Fire for the sauces.
- 40:18I personally think the original flavor of the pork jerky hits
- 40:21just right after tackling a big chore.
- 40:23It's a little salty and very flavorful.
- 40:26My discount code gives you 20% off your entire order, and it's
- 40:29currently the best deal available.
- 40:31Just visit bigforkbrands.com and enter in my promo code, JADE.
- 40:35That's JADE at checkout. Are you looking for a gift for
- 40:42music lover? Or maybe some apparel to show
- 40:44off your quirky side? Old Glory has he covered.
- 40:46With over 300,000 officially licensed items covering music,
- 40:50sports, entertainment and pop culture, you're guaranteed to
- 40:53find the perfect item. They even have seasonal gear.
- 40:56My husband enjoys The Beatles and Led Zeppelin apparel and I
- 40:59love the Billy Idol apparel. I even found items for my fellow
- 41:02plant enthusiasts. This family owned superstore is
- 41:05known for their quality and customer service, offers free
- 41:08standard shipping on all orders, and orders are shipped the same
- 41:12day you purchase. My discount code gives you 15%
- 41:15off your entire order and it's currently the best deal
- 41:17available. Just visit oldglory.com and
- 41:20enter in my promo code JADE. That's JADE at checkout.
- 41:27Looking for a game changing way to improve your health?
- 41:29Zevo Life is the world's most nutrient dense whole plant
- 41:33packed with over 50% plant protein, essential amino acids,
- 41:36fiber and antioxidants. Harnessing the best nature has
- 41:40to offer, Zevo Life nourishes your body while driving your
- 41:43performance, vitality and overall well-being.
- 41:47Each serving is a concentrated source of clean, well balanced
- 41:50nutrition designed to support modern lifestyles.
- 41:53And just one teaspoon a day supports your gut, boosts energy
- 41:57and promotes healthier skin and hair.
- 41:59It's no wonder that it's receiving rave 5 star reviews.
- 42:02Step into a healthier future with a 30% discount and a 30 day
- 42:06risk free guarantee by visiting ZIVO dot Life and using my promo
- 42:12code to support my show and to receive 30% off your entire
- 42:16order. And to my promo code JADE,
- 42:18that's JADE at checkout right? So to me, to me, it sounds like
- 42:24it's safer for for users as far as their own content like it is.
- 42:32It sounds like it's harder to hack into is kind of what I'm
- 42:36trying to say if with their unique signatures on each post,
- 42:41is that a correct assumption? Well, so.
- 42:46It's it's mostly a trade off that that is occurring here.
- 42:49We're we're we're not we're not proposing any magic.
- 42:52So what the difference is is that with these platforms, they
- 42:59have the power to in some Stalin esque, move on person you as if
- 43:04you and remove you from history as if you never existed, right,
- 43:09Because you have an account there with Noster, you create
- 43:13your own profile and you're able to do that to to yourself,
- 43:16basically. So.
- 43:18You have to, because what's the whole, this whole notion of
- 43:22these, these cryptographic key pairs?
- 43:24It's, it's a secret. It's just a, it's just a random
- 43:27number that you have to keep secret.
- 43:29And if you lose track of your own secret, well, too bad,
- 43:33right? Nobody can help you.
- 43:35And perhaps worse, if somebody else gets a hand on their secret
- 43:39now, now they can pretend to be you.
- 43:41OK, there are things that we that are there to, to mitigate
- 43:45it, but fundamentally it's, it's just a trade off.
- 43:48It's like, OK, now you're, you've gained you, you've gained
- 43:51the freedom, but you also get with that freedom also comes the
- 43:55same amount of responsibility that otherwise would have been.
- 43:58But the platforms where if you lose your login, you could
- 44:02always call the company and say, well, you know, it's actually
- 44:05me. Can you please give me give me
- 44:08access back? Yeah.
- 44:10So it's a, it's a trade off occurring there.
- 44:13Yeah. And so also, it sounds to me
- 44:17like you kind of can save some time by finding all the content
- 44:23on one platform instead of switching back and forth like
- 44:27you were saying. If you just want to go to one
- 44:29person's page, you can see everything that they've posted.
- 44:33Yeah, correct. So, and this is this is from
- 44:35from both the the user as well as the content creator
- 44:39themselves, right? Yeah.
- 44:42Because now currently as a as an online character, let's say as I
- 44:46mentioned with the link tree is like this long list of all these
- 44:49various platforms. And maybe you're you're posting
- 44:53your videos on Rumble and you're posting them on YouTube and
- 44:55you're posting them on Odyssey there that it's already 3
- 44:58different places that you. Have to put your video to.
- 45:01And maybe you're you're posting your articles on Medium and
- 45:04you're posting them on sub stack and whatever place you are.
- 45:07So that's that's almost a full time job in itself in order to,
- 45:12to juggle all these various platforms in order to, in order
- 45:16to, to have reach, let's say. Whereas if we assume like a
- 45:20nostrified context, yeah, it becomes a lot, lot more
- 45:23straightforward because it's just you.
- 45:25You create the thing, you sign it, you throw it out there, and
- 45:28then people can fetch it. Right.
- 45:31And and that's the user, same thing, right?
- 45:33I don't have to switch from my X app to my Instagram app to my
- 45:40YouTube app in order to see one particular thing or another.
- 45:44As long as my app supports all those all those features, I'm
- 45:47just able to look at them right right then and there.
- 45:51Yeah, So I all right, So I have this problem where people will
- 45:57send me things that I'm uninterested in, but I don't
- 46:00realize I'm uninterested in them until I've opened the video and
- 46:04then suddenly the algorithm, the algorithm thinks that I'm
- 46:08interested in something I'm not. So it sounds like Noster offers
- 46:16a way to avoid that issue. Is that because you're
- 46:20controlling your own algorithm, correct?
- 46:22Correct. Yes.
- 46:24That would be so nice. So now if you.
- 46:26So now if you for most apps, right, the, the the base
- 46:32algorithm, the default algorithm would be reverse chronological
- 46:35order of the people that you follow.
- 46:38So it's just the just the people that you follow.
- 46:39And you just see the late, the latest stuff is at the top.
- 46:42And then if you Scroll down, you see previous post, like I said,
- 46:48kind of depending on the on the app, you also have this notion
- 46:51of relay feed. So you just go to a particular
- 46:54relay and you just say, just show me what, what you have
- 46:57there. Now interesting stuff can happen
- 46:59there because there for example, and I hope I'm, I'm hopefully I
- 47:05can, I can explain this in a, in a way that people understand
- 47:08what's going on. Nothing about this relay stuff
- 47:11is defined. So people are free to do
- 47:14whatever they, they want because the relay is in charge as to
- 47:18what is written to the relay and who is able to read from the
- 47:21relay. And other than that, it just,
- 47:24it's just a, a simple storage of, of data.
- 47:29But what can happen is that a group of people can decide, OK,
- 47:35we're going to run a relay together.
- 47:37And what we're going to do is that we're just going to do our
- 47:40day-to-day interactions on on Noster, We're going to like
- 47:43post, we're going to watch stuff this type of this type, I'm
- 47:48going to funnel people, etcetera, these type of things.
- 47:50And what happens from the relay perspective is that everybody
- 47:54has shares, let's say in the relay and all these actions that
- 47:59they're performing in terms of likes or replying, those are
- 48:03votes. And just by the share activity
- 48:07of this group of people, you end up with a group of a group of
- 48:13like a, a batch of stuff, right? A batch of tweets that were
- 48:16liked that are now that are now accessible on this relay, that
- 48:22relay decides, OK, we're going to host this stuff.
- 48:24Because apparently this group of people in relation to the
- 48:27shares, in relation to the votes that they cast just based on the
- 48:30action that their everyday action that they are performing,
- 48:33apparently this is what this group of people finds
- 48:36interesting. So now this is the just a
- 48:38derivative of the activity of that group of people.
- 48:44It's the stuff that actually lands on that relay.
- 48:46So now I'm able to connect to that relay and I just get this
- 48:49derivative feed of what the actual activity of this group of
- 48:53people was. So that's, that's a way of, of,
- 48:57of, of generating a particular feed.
- 49:00Another way would be to just connect to a particular service.
- 49:03And that service just describes to you what they're what they're
- 49:07going to show you. So the most popular things in
- 49:09the last 24 hours or the, the most popular things in the last
- 49:1312 hours, stuff about frogs. I don't, I like whatever,
- 49:19whatever, which way. It's just a, it's just where
- 49:22it's important to, it's where it's important to understand
- 49:25that we, where we have this phrase in, in, in Nasser is that
- 49:30there is no global. And because the, and this is
- 49:33important for people to understand when they're, when
- 49:35they're starting to interact on Nasser, because they, they have
- 49:38been tricked into thinking that there is such a thing as a
- 49:41global feed. They because you, when you're,
- 49:45when you're on, on sorry, when you're on Twitter, for example,
- 49:49or an X, you have this notion of trending, right?
- 49:51The same thing with with YouTube, you have this notion of
- 49:54trending where the assumption is, is that every what is on X
- 49:58is everything that exists in the world.
- 50:01And this is the most popular stuff.
- 50:03That's everything that's there in the world.
- 50:05But it's a lie, right? It's not.
- 50:06Right. Right.
- 50:07That it's not X is not the be all end all of all content.
- 50:11So that confuses people when they go to nostril because there
- 50:14it's very explicit that there is no such thing as a global feed.
- 50:19And then they're like, well, this, this sucks.
- 50:21I'm going back to X because there I have a global feed.
- 50:23No, you don't have a global feed.
- 50:25You have the the opinion of what of X, right, as to what the
- 50:29content is. And when, let's say for somebody
- 50:33posts a tweet, I can take the link of that tweet, go to Reddit
- 50:37post, make a Reddit post, link to the tweet.
- 50:39And we can have a whole discussion about that tweet that
- 50:43nobody is ever aware of on Twitter, right?
- 50:45There is entire, this entire discussion going on around a
- 50:47particular tweet that is not on, that is not on Twitter.
- 50:51So this this, this notion of global is actually a trick
- 50:56that's being played on people. It's like it's not actually the
- 50:58case today. And it's, it's also not the case
- 51:03on Nasser, right? People could could be having
- 51:05conversations about stuff that you are not necessarily aware
- 51:08of, right, Or, or or you are aware of or you don't want to be
- 51:12aware of and then you close yourself off to it.
- 51:15You're in control. You're basically in control as
- 51:17to what you want to see. Yeah, so.
- 51:23Do you, I don't know if you're old enough for this.
- 51:26Do you have a Facebook? I I have a residual Facebook
- 51:31account somewhere that has been. Scraped.
- 51:35Yeah, so I remember when Facebook first came out, not
- 51:40every university even had it. Wasn't it just like the Ivy
- 51:43League university students were able?
- 51:46To. I think it was attached to to to
- 51:49the university e-mail domain, something like that.
- 51:50Yeah, and then and then I remember it open.
- 51:54It expanded to all universities. And I remember I was at a
- 51:57Community College at the time and I couldn't get on Facebook.
- 52:00It's just funny how it's morphed into something completely
- 52:05different that people who who like don't own a computer who
- 52:10can barely do much with technology at all.
- 52:14They're on on Facebook everyday. It's just interesting to see how
- 52:18things have have changed over the years.
- 52:23And they, they and, and, and rely on Facebook for there are
- 52:26businesses on Facebook. There are, depending on the
- 52:30country that you are you, you're like driving down the street and
- 52:32the restaurant. There's like a restaurant.
- 52:34And if you want to, if you want to order food, you can order the
- 52:37food via their Facebook page. There are church groups that
- 52:41organize themselves via Facebook pages, right.
- 52:44And this is what I mean is that we're, we're kind of using it
- 52:47as, as if it's like the public square.
- 52:48We're building out all these things on top of it, whether
- 52:52it's business businesses or churches or whatever civic
- 52:55function. We, we start to, we, we start to
- 52:59use this infrastructure because, because it has network effect.
- 53:04And it's like, OK, I'm, I'm, I'm a restaurant.
- 53:06I'm going to use Facebook. Well, one, because it's easy, so
- 53:09I don't have to host my own website.
- 53:10So it facilitates a whole bunch of stuff for me.
- 53:13And every already, everyone already has a Facebook account.
- 53:16So my customers are it's, it's, it's low friction for my
- 53:20customers as well. Yeah.
- 53:21So yeah, it it, it is very interesting.
- 53:24But the the other, the other side of that, that, that coin is
- 53:27that it was a good pitch to investors that apparently the
- 53:31investors also picked Facebook, right?
- 53:33Yeah, yeah. So what would it look like for
- 53:38like, would Noster be a a good place for businesses to
- 53:41advertise? Well, the honest answer right
- 53:45now is it. It very much depends, but
- 53:49probably not because not a lot of people are on there, but
- 53:54there are, but there are businesses.
- 53:56So the as to what the sheriff uses is it's, there is a lot of
- 54:02Americans on there. Then then there are a bunch of
- 54:06Europeans. Interestingly enough, there is
- 54:08also this Japanese contingent that there are that are just
- 54:11completely doing their own stuff for two reasons.
- 54:16The first reason is that they tend to lock down their relays
- 54:19on geolocation. So if you're, if you have like
- 54:23an outside IP, you're just you're not able to connect to
- 54:25their servers. And the other reason is that
- 54:28they, they have their own perspective on how things should
- 54:31work and how things operate, which is completely fine.
- 54:36I mean, they, they can do that, but it's very interesting that,
- 54:38that these that a bunch of Japanese people started to adopt
- 54:43A nostril in this way. But and it, it was born out of
- 54:49Bitcoiners. So the, the, the person that
- 54:53came up with it was a Bitcoin developer.
- 54:56Of course, his friends are also Bitcoin developers.
- 55:00So the initial group basically that starts to to, to colonize
- 55:04the, the protocol, let's say, was all a bunch of Bitcoiners.
- 55:07And then you get derivative things where there are, there
- 55:13are certain health, like health nuts and, and food.
- 55:18So they're they're now beef tallow businesses on Noster or
- 55:24that type of stuff that are actually they're they're doing
- 55:27pretty well because you know, their their customer base is on
- 55:30is on Noster. And what they're basically doing
- 55:34is that they, they found a place where they minimize the, the
- 55:39rock. They don't have a rock pool
- 55:40risk, right? They cannot be nothing can be
- 55:43pulled. The wall kind of nothing can be
- 55:45pulled underneath from them. Where if they, if they would
- 55:48have run their business on, on on Instagram, for example, by
- 55:53advertising, by sharing the pictures, like if at the moment
- 55:56Instagram decides for whatever reason could be error to delete
- 56:00their account. Now their business is gone.
- 56:02And this happens to me. There are there are plenty of
- 56:04you can go online and look for plenty of articles in there
- 56:08cutesy little knitting shops or whatever that that just get
- 56:14banned from from Instagram and now their business is gone.
- 56:17So yeah, those, those people are on there.
- 56:19Musicians is also interesting thing because Spotify is very
- 56:24dominant, but musicians are barely making any money off
- 56:28Spotify. And now there are, there is this
- 56:32little movement going on of getting people getting musicians
- 56:36on to a noster where because Bitcoin is very tightly
- 56:39integrated, it's very low key to just actually send them money in
- 56:44this, this model, this value for value model.
- 56:51Adam Curry, which is the, the, the, the pot father is, is his
- 56:55nickname, right? The, he's one of the main guys
- 56:57behind this notion of podcasting And, and his, his notion is that
- 57:04I, I produce value by creating this podcast.
- 57:06So my question to my audience is like, what type of value are you
- 57:10going to give back? Are you going to help me out or
- 57:13are you going to send money or are you going to give me some
- 57:15interesting information or that type of stuff?
- 57:20And the same, same model applies for these musician musicians.
- 57:23And however little money it is, they're already making more
- 57:27money on Noster then they would have bought at Spotify.
- 57:32So the, the whole, the whole crux of the matter is like
- 57:34where, where is your audience? And if you, if you have your,
- 57:38this is another notion on the Internet is that if you, all you
- 57:41need is like 1000 dedicated followers.
- 57:45And if you have 1000 people that are really interested in you and
- 57:49are, are, are willing to, to send you 5 bucks.
- 57:52Well, I mean that then you were there, right?
- 57:54You were able to just do your thing and grow from there.
- 57:58So as long as you, you're able to capture those thousand
- 58:01people, then you're good to go. And if you do it on Noster, you,
- 58:07that's the last place you you're going to have to set up shop
- 58:09because you're not you're you're you've insured yourself against
- 58:15the risk that somebody's going to undermine your ability to to
- 58:18run your business and get between you and your audience,
- 58:22right? You're now, you know you have a
- 58:23method where you always able to get into stay in contact with
- 58:26your audience and your audience audience being able to stay in
- 58:29contact with you. Right, Yeah, yeah, I like the
- 58:33sounds of it. You know, I've, I've seen people
- 58:37lose everything they that they have with those, with those
- 58:40Facebook hacking things. Like my brother-in-law still
- 58:42can't get back on Facebook. He's like, I just want
- 58:44marketplace, you know, but but yeah, you were saying you could
- 58:49just go to do a different, different relay if something
- 58:52like that were to happen. Yeah, if, if, if somebody, if,
- 58:55if a relay decides to to cut you off, then yeah, as to if you
- 59:00were to lose your keys, that's a a different question.
- 59:03There are, there are two, there are two things here.
- 59:06So 1, is that because we're using cryptographic key pairs,
- 59:11which for a lot of people will be perhaps a little bit rough
- 59:17to, to start out with, right? Because it's a, it's a random
- 59:19string of numbers like what, what do I do with this?
- 59:24The bottom line is just, it's, it's a secret you have to keep
- 59:26safe. And I'm, I think most people
- 59:28ultimately will have to be able to have the intuition as to how
- 59:31to keep the secret safe. But it's also cryptography and
- 59:37we're able to do a whole bunch of cryptographic magic, let's
- 59:40say, where we're able to split this thing up and distribute it
- 59:43among different people that now can cooperate in order to to
- 59:47produce those signatures for you without them necessarily being
- 59:51able to run off with with your identity.
- 59:56And the other, the other part is what this notion of with notions
- 1:00:01of web of trust where if I lose my identity or my identity gets
- 1:00:06stolen. The, the, the, the point is, is
- 1:00:11that I, I have my, my social network is just a reflection of
- 1:00:15the social network that I actually have in the physical
- 1:00:18world. So like if I, if I live together
- 1:00:22with my partner and I see my friends every day and etcetera,
- 1:00:27then I'm able to just I'm, I'm this is not necessarily there
- 1:00:31yet, but this is stuff that we're working on where it's
- 1:00:33like, well, if I'm just able to just generate a new profile and
- 1:00:38tell to my partner or my wife, let's say, it's like, OK, well,
- 1:00:41I'm now running on there this new identity.
- 1:00:43And the same with my friends and the people I interact with in
- 1:00:46the daily basis, not necessarily online, but in the physical
- 1:00:49world or I'm able to just call them via other channels.
- 1:00:52Then I'm pretty quickly able to just rebootstrap my identity.
- 1:00:57OK, so these are, these are things that we're, that we're
- 1:01:01working on. But as I mentioned, it's like
- 1:01:03the same, the same thing goes for you.
- 1:01:06Have you run a risk where you lose things on, on the central
- 1:01:09platforms where you're not in control and here you you're more
- 1:01:12in control, but it also implies responsibility of of what the
- 1:01:17what those consequences are? Right, right.
- 1:01:22So how does this tackle the problem of online identities?
- 1:01:29Yeah. So this is interesting because
- 1:01:33there are it's a hot topic, especially because now we have
- 1:01:36various governments coming in introducing digital identities.
- 1:01:41The thing there is that the identity, the thing with the
- 1:01:46difference between those types of identities and the identities
- 1:01:50we're talking about in, in Noster as well as what's the,
- 1:01:58what's this notion? Oh yeah.
- 1:01:59Like stuff like social credit scores, let's say, which is
- 1:02:04which is tied to this, this this problem of, of digital identity
- 1:02:09is the fundamental difference between the two types of
- 1:02:13entities is with Nasser, you create that identity yourself
- 1:02:18and you're also in control as to what that identity means, Right.
- 1:02:21I could be pirate man 999, right?
- 1:02:26If, if that's the identity that I, that I want to express, then
- 1:02:29then it's pirate man 999. And I can make a separate one
- 1:02:33that is about to constant, which is going to be my everyday or
- 1:02:39my, my real persona, let's say. And I'm able to, so I'm, I'm in
- 1:02:45control as to, to what and generating these identities
- 1:02:49myself. And I'm in control as to what
- 1:02:50they mean instead of them being it being imposed on me where
- 1:02:58that identity has been given to me, which is like, this is your
- 1:03:01formal name. And now you're required to use
- 1:03:03it in all these places in order to sign in for, in order to sign
- 1:03:08in on X or in order to sign in on Discord or whatever it is,
- 1:03:12you're going to have to show your, your government approved
- 1:03:14digital identity. That's that's a totalitarian
- 1:03:20measure in order to ensure that they have this supposed
- 1:03:23watertight system as to combat fraud or anything.
- 1:03:29But the problem is that, yeah, that's also very restrictive.
- 1:03:32I mean, we have this notion of pen names for for centuries
- 1:03:35right there. There are a lot of poets and
- 1:03:38writers that publish things under, under, under, under a
- 1:03:42name that was not their actual formal name.
- 1:03:45And they did that for a reason. And that's something that we,
- 1:03:49we, we have to, we have to protect, right?
- 1:03:52That ability to do that. And that's something that Nasser
- 1:03:55allows, right? That's what it like I said this,
- 1:03:57if I want to be pirate man 999, I am pirate man 999.
- 1:04:01And associated with that is this notion of social credit course,
- 1:04:06let's say, where you can still have this notion of a, of a
- 1:04:12social credit score. It's, it's might not be the
- 1:04:15right phrase, but when you create these social networks and
- 1:04:19these social graphs, people have opinions on each other, right?
- 1:04:24So, but the problem is, is that the the thing with the social
- 1:04:30credit score, it's this supposed objective thing.
- 1:04:35It's not, it's not objective. It's just one, one, one opinion,
- 1:04:38which is the central West opinion.
- 1:04:41Where as with Noster or these types of systems where the
- 1:04:46freedom of identity, they are subjective.
- 1:04:49So my score of you, my opinion of you could be very negative
- 1:04:54and then somebody else could have an opinion of you that is
- 1:04:57very positive. And then the third person will
- 1:05:01have to figure out is like, OK, how am I going to judge Samantha
- 1:05:03just based on what all the other opinions of the people around
- 1:05:07Samantha are and the and if for some reason you screwed up and
- 1:05:13everybody hates you, that's too bad.
- 1:05:16Well, you just create a new identity and just just try
- 1:05:19again, right? You're not, you're not doomed.
- 1:05:21Where is if you were just handed one single government issue
- 1:05:26identity and they control what your score is and you somehow
- 1:05:32screwed up because they don't like you or or thought you did
- 1:05:35things well, now you're condemned.
- 1:05:37You're you're, you're, you're, you're now you're now in
- 1:05:40damnation because you're now in a position where you kind of get
- 1:05:42out of anymore. Yeah, because you're tied to
- 1:05:45this one particular identity. And you, you cannot create
- 1:05:48Samantha 2 in order to just try again and and have some
- 1:05:53redemption arc going on, right? Right, so.
- 1:05:56That's that's that's that's in relation to to identity, What
- 1:06:01what the main dynamics. Yeah.
- 1:06:03OK. Yeah, I, I was kind of.
- 1:06:06So we don't have so far, we don't have to deal with that too
- 1:06:11much here, But I know other countries are starting to get,
- 1:06:15you know, the social credit scores and tracked a lot more.
- 1:06:21And I, I always wonder like, so if you pay a fine, can you, can
- 1:06:25you get back in the good graces of the government or I'm curious
- 1:06:30as to how that any of that works.
- 1:06:32I I hope I never have to deal with it.
- 1:06:35Yeah. And it's and, and obviously it's
- 1:06:38like it's, it's going to be corrupt in some way, right?
- 1:06:41Yeah. So this is The thing is you it
- 1:06:45runs on this assumption that it's watertight if it wants then
- 1:06:48under this assumption that it's neutral and neither of those
- 1:06:51things is going to be true. So, so yeah.
- 1:06:55And the what the, the political will that allows for these
- 1:07:01things is understandable, whether it's abuse or like
- 1:07:10blatant, like blatant fake stuff.
- 1:07:13We have this notion of fake news, right?
- 1:07:14And there are there are a lot of problems with the, with the
- 1:07:17notion of fake news itself, right?
- 1:07:18If you have like an open discourse, but you there, the
- 1:07:22other part is that especially now with AI, it's very trivial
- 1:07:26to just produce stuff that is just completely fake, right?
- 1:07:29So policy makers and, and, and certain interest groups,
- 1:07:35etcetera, that they are very nervous around this notion of AI
- 1:07:39and they're, they, their knee jerk reaction is like, OK, well,
- 1:07:42we need this watertight system of government IDs in order to
- 1:07:45get a grip on this because otherwise it's just going to be
- 1:07:48going to be an absolute nightmare.
- 1:07:50Whereas the, the Nasser response would be like, no, we, we're
- 1:07:55able to create our own webs of trust, right?
- 1:07:58Like I, I, I, I now have this podcast interaction with you.
- 1:08:01I'm pretty certain you're not an AI.
- 1:08:03The moment, the moment, the moment we, we connect on Noster
- 1:08:07is like, OK, now, now we have a connection.
- 1:08:09And you, you now have a, you're 1 now step removed from what my
- 1:08:14direct network is. So to what extent do you trust
- 1:08:18my ability to judge who I put in my first layer of trust?
- 1:08:23Yeah. And that way we're able to
- 1:08:26hopefully just create these robust webs of trust that they,
- 1:08:29as they're, as they're called to keep a lot of the bullshit out.
- 1:08:33Because that bullshit just relies on people being able to
- 1:08:37create an account and just spam a whole bunch of bullshit.
- 1:08:40And you know, I'm, I'm not going to, I'm not going to follow or
- 1:08:44add, add, add a bot to my friend list that just spams out AI
- 1:08:48crap. Right, right.
- 1:08:50So. It becomes very difficult for
- 1:08:51those types of attacks to to penetrate well established trust
- 1:08:55trust networks. Yeah, yeah.
- 1:08:58And that's. Also an answer right?
- 1:08:59So it's like I see the problem, that's not the issue.
- 1:09:02The issue is that that not in identifying the problem.
- 1:09:05The issue is like what? What the opinion is to have this
- 1:09:08problem should be solved and I see a lot of initial and
- 1:09:13secondary and and and tertiary order effects, negative effects
- 1:09:18as to the the route that these that a bunch of governments are
- 1:09:21are are are going into. Yeah, yeah, I, I will get some
- 1:09:27bot comments on my TikTok and it's like, I will see real
- 1:09:31people arguing, you know, And then the bot never responds.
- 1:09:34And it, it's like, should I point out that this is just a
- 1:09:37bot or let them keep going because it's getting comments on
- 1:09:41my content, You know, I don't know what to do about it.
- 1:09:46But like, there's no way to as far as like certain platforms
- 1:09:51like TikTok, there's no way to really stop them from continuing
- 1:09:55to, to comment. And I think it's hard for people
- 1:10:00to recognize it unless they see it over and over again that it's
- 1:10:03fake. But but yeah, if you are in a
- 1:10:07trusted network where you know everyone's real then then that
- 1:10:12would eliminate the problem. Unless you're adding random
- 1:10:16people you don't know. Right, right.
- 1:10:18So the, the, the notion is the, the fundamental notion is
- 1:10:21relevance. And this is interesting because
- 1:10:24you said it's like, OK, I'll just leave these people going
- 1:10:26because they're, they're, they're generating traffic and
- 1:10:30the, the, the TikTok algorithm likes the traffic.
- 1:10:33So you know, I'll just keep it going.
- 1:10:35But it's, it's fake, right? It's, it's bullshit.
- 1:10:37They're there. There's no relevance to any of
- 1:10:39that stuff going on. But there is something
- 1:10:44contributing a, a score to that thing that is absolutely
- 1:10:47irrelevant. So it's a in, in philosophical
- 1:10:50terms, it's like, well, you, you have the ontology and the
- 1:10:53epistemology. Like how do you figure out what
- 1:10:56is, what is real? And now we're relying on the
- 1:11:01judgement of decentralized platforms and they're absolutely
- 1:11:03terrible at it. And basically what we're
- 1:11:07proposing is we're, we're going to base it on the distributed,
- 1:11:13on a distributed notion of sense making, right?
- 1:11:18It's, it's a, a collection of, of my ability to make sense as
- 1:11:22well as your ability to make sense of, of things.
- 1:11:25And there could be a billion comments under this podcast done
- 1:11:30by bots. But if nobody finds those bots
- 1:11:32relevant, the conclusion is that those comments are not relevant.
- 1:11:37And why should you care? Nobody should care because they
- 1:11:39are irrelevant, right? It's like.
- 1:11:41Oh. No, they're not taking into
- 1:11:42account. It's like, yes, they're indeed.
- 1:11:44They're not taking into account because they are not relevant,
- 1:11:47right. And what what relevance means is
- 1:11:49a is a is completely a subjective notion.
- 1:11:52Yeah. If I if I'm some researcher
- 1:11:54interested in what bot activity is, then maybe for me it is
- 1:11:58actually relevant. Right, right.
- 1:12:00Yeah. Well, it seems, it seems to me
- 1:12:03like this is a good way to kind of save social media cuz I mean,
- 1:12:08it just seems like it's getting uglier and uglier with the
- 1:12:13usage, but there's so much good that can that can come out of
- 1:12:18social media. You can make so many important
- 1:12:20connections. So, yeah, I'm, I, I'm would like
- 1:12:26to see this grow, you know, and. See more people.
- 1:12:29That's that's exactly what we're aiming for.
- 1:12:31Right. Yeah, that's why you're here,
- 1:12:32right? Yeah, that's why I'm here.
- 1:12:35Well, hopefully I can help you out a little bit, but yeah, is
- 1:12:39there anything else that you want to that you want the
- 1:12:43audience to know? I didn't.
- 1:12:44I did see that. It looks like it's somewhat easy
- 1:12:47to sign up and easy to navigate. So in.
- 1:12:53In terms of that, so I'm not the onboarding guy.
- 1:12:58I'm, I'm, I'm, I'm the spreading the message guy, right?
- 1:13:02Yeah, there, as you mentioned, the, the situation with with
- 1:13:06social media platforms and the web in general is terrible.
- 1:13:10And it can feel like we're doomed because there is no
- 1:13:13alternative, which is all this network effect stuff that I
- 1:13:17mentioned, right? And it's very hard.
- 1:13:18And what you said, it's very hard to coordinate people to get
- 1:13:21go somewhere else and free ourselves from these, from these
- 1:13:25stupid platforms. So, so the core of my message
- 1:13:28here is, is hope right there, people, there is hope.
- 1:13:32Don't despair because there are a bunch of people working on
- 1:13:37this stuff. It is, it is real, right?
- 1:13:40There are apps, there are a lot of apps that you can run in your
- 1:13:43browser, that you can run on your desktop, that you can run
- 1:13:46on your tablet, that you can run on your phone, be that Android
- 1:13:49or iOS. But you have to be aware that
- 1:13:54you know, the core notion of this thing is social.
- 1:13:58So what is your reason to to be there?
- 1:14:01And a large part of that reason is the people that you find
- 1:14:05interesting. So if you're, if you're having a
- 1:14:09hard time finding the people that you're, that you think are
- 1:14:12interesting, be that your friends or, or, or some other
- 1:14:15stuff, you're not going to have a lot of reason to to be on
- 1:14:19Nasser. Let's say so.
- 1:14:24And that's that's why I'm I'm, I'm not the onboarding guy.
- 1:14:26It's like I'm not here to to tell you that it's your time, be
- 1:14:31that you specifically Samantha or whomever in the audience that
- 1:14:35it's it that it's your time to, to be on Nasser also, because
- 1:14:38it's currently we're very much in what is called like an early
- 1:14:42adopter stage. So things are in development.
- 1:14:46Things have improved a lot like over the last year.
- 1:14:50But to to give the brief, brief summary, at the end of 2019,
- 1:14:55some guy published like a little paper describing this stuff.
- 1:15:00At first he convinced like his, his developer buddies to, to
- 1:15:04have a look at that, at this. And they thought this was
- 1:15:07interesting and cool and they started to tinker.
- 1:15:10And after, after a while there was something there.
- 1:15:16Then there is this entire story where it caught the attention of
- 1:15:18Jack Dorsey, where that kicked off a lot of more things.
- 1:15:24But for the most part, it's like the current web is, let's say,
- 1:15:2820 years old. And there are the largest
- 1:15:31multinational corporations with thousands of employees building
- 1:15:36this stuff over over the past 20 years.
- 1:15:38So that's the experience that you're used to, right?
- 1:15:41And here it's, let's say three years with a handful of, of
- 1:15:49startups that have like a handful of people working on
- 1:15:52them. So you know, that's, that's,
- 1:15:55that's the comparison, right? So if you're, if you're, if you,
- 1:16:00if your demand is that it's just utterly smooth and you, you're
- 1:16:04not going to experience any hiccup, that's completely fine.
- 1:16:07We'll see. We'll, we'll see you in three
- 1:16:09years or in five years or, or. Whatever.
- 1:16:11Time it is right if you're more adventurous and, and I everybody
- 1:16:18can just have a look right and just see how far it can go.
- 1:16:22The, the direction that I'm going to send them towards is
- 1:16:23noster.com, which is not the official website because there
- 1:16:28is no official website, but it's just the the person that owns
- 1:16:32that domain was nice enough to create that as like a resource
- 1:16:38that enforce people as to what what, what Noster as a protocol
- 1:16:42is and a whole bunch of different apps that they could
- 1:16:45start that they could start using and when people do so my
- 1:16:51advice would be to just create a post and use the hashtag
- 1:16:55introductions because that's a that's a hashtag that people on
- 1:17:00our side right the the onboarding guys keep an eye out.
- 1:17:04It's like, OK, here's a little little duck duckling that is
- 1:17:08alone, alone in the Noster world.
- 1:17:11Let's let's pick them up and and get get them on the right path.
- 1:17:15The same same goes for the hashtag ask Noster.
- 1:17:18Is is is another example. It's like if you have a
- 1:17:20question, just just that type of stuff or browse, browse that,
- 1:17:24that hashtag in order to see like what type of questions
- 1:17:27people asked and what type of answers they've gotten and see,
- 1:17:31see if you're able to latch on to, to social networks, like to,
- 1:17:37to other people that you find interesting.
- 1:17:38And there, there, there are already a whole bunch of
- 1:17:41different people, but it's going to take a little bit of effort
- 1:17:44in order to, to snuff them up and to, to find them in order to
- 1:17:47connect with them. And it's not going to be handed
- 1:17:50to you on a, on a silver platter where you download the app and
- 1:17:54there is some highly sophisticated algorithm with
- 1:17:56access to millions and millions and millions of videos that it's
- 1:17:59just going to give you endless scroll feeds of, of content.
- 1:18:05It's just, it's simply not there yet.
- 1:18:06So I'm, I'm just expectation managing here.
- 1:18:09I would encourage everybody to, to, to have a look, but I'm also
- 1:18:12not, I'm not here to, to have like a forceful call of action.
- 1:18:18There are other people that, that do that stuff and they're
- 1:18:20there help you out. And maybe if you look at YouTube
- 1:18:22there are some tutorials out there, but at at this stage I'm
- 1:18:27better off just pointing people explaining what the things is
- 1:18:31pointingpeopletowardsnoster.com. And if they are the type of
- 1:18:34person to to end up on Noster and actually stay for a while,
- 1:18:40they'll they'll figure it out on their own.
- 1:18:42Yeah, Yeah, that, I mean, that makes sense.
- 1:18:45It's I mean nothing, nothing just is big overnight, you know,
- 1:18:50it takes some work and some time.
- 1:18:53So yeah, that sounds. I'm going to check it out.
- 1:18:56Cool, we'll see see if I make an account.
- 1:18:59And, and if you have any questions, I mean, you're,
- 1:19:01you're, you're free to ask. And I'm like, I'll be your on
- 1:19:04boarding guy. That's all right.
- 1:19:06But it's, it's like I, I focus on on trying to, to explain and
- 1:19:11hopefully people get some broad sense as to what the, what this
- 1:19:15thing is and and why it is relevant.
- 1:19:18Yeah. Well, I like the idea that.
- 1:19:22I actually like the idea that you're getting on and it is
- 1:19:26you're not already given stuff to follow though.
- 1:19:29Like it like when I deleted a Facebook account and recreated
- 1:19:32it, it was like, oh, do you want to be friends with all these
- 1:19:34people from high school? It's like, how did you even know
- 1:19:37that I graduated from there? But it must have still like
- 1:19:40maybe because they, they stored the information from the my
- 1:19:44e-mail address or something. But it's like, no, that's not
- 1:19:48what I got back on here to do. Connect with people from high
- 1:19:51school. I want to connect with the
- 1:19:53people around me, you know, So I like the idea of being able to
- 1:19:57just kind of start fresh and control what you're seeing a
- 1:20:01little bit more. And, and those options are
- 1:20:03there, right? Probably not your, your, your
- 1:20:05immediate high score or whatever.
- 1:20:07But there are, there are these notions of follow packs, which
- 1:20:11is like groups of people in relation to a particular
- 1:20:14interest. So if you like, if you like
- 1:20:16gardening, there is like a follow pack for gardening.
- 1:20:19And then you, you, you immediately follow all these
- 1:20:21people. Yeah.
- 1:20:23And you're not tied to one follow list.
- 1:20:27You can have multiple different follow list where you're like,
- 1:20:30now these are my my close friends, or this is like the
- 1:20:35gardening follow list for my gardening interest or whatever
- 1:20:38type of interest that you have. So these are all options.
- 1:20:41But this is so old stuff that, and the same goes for for
- 1:20:44various types of relays that I explained.
- 1:20:48But this is all stuff for for people to explore and when, when
- 1:20:53they are exploring, they have to be.
- 1:20:54What I do think is important to mention is that you're not stuck
- 1:20:59with the app that you picked out initially.
- 1:21:02So if you find an app that works pretty well, that's fine.
- 1:21:05They use it for a week and then decide to check out another app
- 1:21:09And also and then experience what, how this frictionless
- 1:21:12switch to another app actually is right that you, you've built
- 1:21:16your feed, you're looking at stuff, you're now logging into a
- 1:21:18different app and all the sudden everything is there.
- 1:21:23And for the first time I experienced that there was a
- 1:21:26very, very interesting sensation because it's like, it's, it's
- 1:21:29this notion of freedom that you immediately guess like, oh,
- 1:21:33wait, this, this is for this app.
- 1:21:35It's also for this other app. And now on a daily basis, I use
- 1:21:38five different apps on a daily basis.
- 1:21:41And I, some of them are, are are on my browser when I'm on my
- 1:21:44desktop and I just as easily switched to my phone and it's
- 1:21:48seamless and they're all different applications and it
- 1:21:51depends on what it is I'm doing at that particular time when I'm
- 1:21:55interfacing with, I'm just using that that app that is best for
- 1:21:58that use case. Yeah, that makes sense.
- 1:22:01Sounds easier than all these different accounts.
- 1:22:05So that's terrible. I mean, the that that's funny,
- 1:22:07right? I'm doing this, this podcasting
- 1:22:09tour, let's say. Yeah.
- 1:22:11And they're all asking for my socials.
- 1:22:13It's like I don't have any. Social.
- 1:22:14Yeah, yeah, that is the one. That is the one thing.
- 1:22:19Well, thank you for being here, and I will keep in touch and let
- 1:22:22you know when the episode's out. All right?
- 1:22:25Thank. You for having me, Samantha.
- 1:22:27Of course.