Latest / I Love You Keep Going with George Haas / Mary Main
Transcript
- 0:01You're listening to the I love you.
- 0:02Keep going podcast with George Hoss.
- 0:05For more information, please visit our website at
- 0:07www.medicare.gov org. That's www.a.
- 0:12Me ta GR oup dot-org. So welcome everybody.
- 0:19This is I love you. Keep going.
- 0:21It is January 12 2023. It's 7:30 8:00 p.m. 8:00 p.m.
- 0:28Pacific time and Before the recording started, we were
- 0:36talking about, self-generated emotion and regulating emotion
- 0:40and cognitive function. But I wanted to talk about
- 0:45something else tonight. So I think I'm going to change
- 0:49the topic. Mary Mae, and I don't know if
- 0:52you know who Mary main is. She died on the sixth of few
- 0:59days ago. And because this is an
- 1:03attachment focus group. I wanted to honor her by talking
- 1:08about her a little bit. She was one of the seminal feet,
- 1:16Seminole mines in the development of attachment
- 1:21Theory, and her discovery of disorganized attachment was and
- 1:27I think will be one of the most significant contributions to
- 1:35psychology as we know it and also incredibly helpful to
- 1:40people in terms terms of understanding why it is that
- 1:46their lives are difficult in a way that really nothing else had
- 1:54before that Managed. Here, I'm creating a fairly High
- 2:01bar talking about what she was able to do and she did this
- 2:11first with Mary Ainsworth. Who as you may recall, in the
- 2:14attachment world was associated with John Bowlby, the originator
- 2:19of the theory and and she marry Mains, husband do, Eric has see
- 2:25who I was involved in all this. They worked out of you see at
- 2:32Berkeley The other thing that she did, which was so
- 2:38significant was, she was part of the group that developed the
- 2:43adult attachment interview, which is the assessment tool
- 2:47that determine that allows us to determine what your attachment
- 2:53conditioning is. I think it's very exciting.
- 2:58That we live in a time where these kinds of discoveries are
- 3:04being made. Because when you couple that,
- 3:07with the efforts of Dan Brown, and his group to develop
- 3:12strategies, that actually can repair attachment, The the
- 3:19discovery of what it is that's wrong and also the discovery of
- 3:24what you can do to repair, it is remarkable.
- 3:33My grandmother. who died at 95 and I guess maybe 89 or 90
- 3:48something like that. used to say when we were growing up that You
- 3:56need to pick somebody who comes from a good family because it
- 3:59doesn't matter how much you love a person.
- 4:01If they don't come from a good family, they really won't be
- 4:05able to support you in the relationship.
- 4:08They really won't be able to support a family and I think
- 4:11that that was the wisdom of understanding that there are
- 4:16certain things that happen to people in their early lives.
- 4:19That there is no way to undo until This.
- 4:28So it's going to be interesting to see.
- 4:33I was talking to Mary about this, I don't know.
- 4:38How long ago? Maybe 8 years ago or something.
- 4:47And she said that. because there was no reliable way to repair
- 4:58adverse attachment conditioning that she preferred to think
- 5:02about it in terms of what we could develop and offer parents
- 5:07so that they could parent their children in a way that the
- 5:10children would be secure and I do think that that's a wonderful
- 5:17approach if we could intervene in such a way that children, An
- 5:22old children really developed in a secure way, the way that they
- 5:27would be able to function as adults would be quite different
- 5:29than what we see in the world. Now that takes a lot of
- 5:33resources. We don't obviously live in a
- 5:37society where that seems to be a priority And I, but I think also
- 5:46that she was making that expression because there wasn't
- 5:52something that could reliably affect attachment conditioning
- 5:57and move it toward earned security.
- 6:05But these are marvelous contributions that it's it's
- 6:08interesting. To really understand that.
- 6:17In our very complex society with the values, the way that they
- 6:21are, there are people doing this fundamental work, that actually
- 6:27is going to be so useful to all of us.
- 6:36John Bowlby came of age between the first and second World War.
- 6:45The war to end all wars, and the next war, after the war to end
- 6:50all wars. The psychoanalytic Community.
- 6:56Had moved from the being centered, in Vienna, to being
- 6:59centered in London because there was So much pressure on the
- 7:07Jewish communities in that period between Wars and so they
- 7:12fled. And so he grew up in that
- 7:15environment where The idea that what actually happened to you
- 7:28pause, these things was was secondary to actually your
- 7:33interpretation of them. Partly.
- 7:37This is because Freud back down about that his famous 1894 paper
- 7:48because he was getting so much pressure from from saying that
- 7:54adverse childhood experiences caused psychological problems.
- 8:01The parent group did not want to hear that.
- 8:06And so they pressured him into withdrawing that idea.
- 8:12One of the things that Bowlby thought was that actually it was
- 8:18those conditions that caused the difficulties in adult lives,
- 8:24adverse childhood conditions, and his he was interested in
- 8:28examining that during the second world war when Germany bombed
- 8:35London, But the idea that they would break the morale of the,
- 8:45the British people, so that they would Surrender by bombing
- 8:51civilian targets. The government responded by
- 8:55removing children from the East End of London and putting them
- 9:00into foster care in the countryside.
- 9:02That was a common practice at the time particularly important.
- 9:09poor families children were removed and placed in public or
- 9:13orphanages ordinarily when a new baby came into the household so
- 9:17that the the mother could bond with The new baby.
- 9:23And then after six weeks, the the other children in the home
- 9:27were brought back into the home. After the second world war
- 9:36Bowlby was tasked by the British government to evaluate whether
- 9:39the children being separated from their caregivers and placed
- 9:44in foster care that Countryside would cause harm to the children
- 9:48that then the government would have to be, would have to
- 9:51provide services for in the end valuating that discovered that.
- 9:59Yes, it's likely that there's lifelong harm caused by that
- 10:02separation and and then the practice of separating children
- 10:09ordinarily from their families with the Entry of a new infant
- 10:15in the family's was ended because it was part of this.
- 10:22Recognition. Follow me wanted because he was
- 10:27a psychiatrist to have empirical data about the nature of these
- 10:31things and also to understand what was happening.
- 10:33And so he hired a researcher, you put an ad in the paper.
- 10:37Mary Ainsworth was an American, her husband was a diplomat and
- 10:41she was in London and she answered the ad and in
- 10:45collaboration with Bova created, the strange situation.
- 10:50The Strain situation is a way of evaluating children to see What
- 10:55their attachment response is and as young as 10 months old,
- 11:01they're taken into the this strange situation for evaluation
- 11:06which is a room for some chairs. A small room filled with toys
- 11:10and they watch the interaction of child and parent at eight
- 11:14points in this. Stranger enters a strange.
- 11:18Relieves the caregiver leaves the child and they watch how the
- 11:24Yaks. And Bobby began to recognize
- 11:29these three patterns is securely secure pattern anxious avoidant
- 11:35pattern. Anxious, ambivalent pattern.
- 11:41But he wanted to understand the nature of that.
- 11:44And so Ainsworth. And her team of researchers went
- 11:51into the homes of the people that investigated and began to
- 11:54watch the patterns of that. And so documented, the different
- 12:01kinds of behaviors that parents do with their children, that
- 12:04then produces these outcomes and then her husband moved and she
- 12:13repeated that in Africa and then she returned to the u.s.
- 12:18continuing her collaboration with bull be at a distance ended
- 12:23up at John Hopkins. It's a sometimes, it's hard to
- 12:33imagine where we are now in terms of the progress that we
- 12:36made, what that must have been like for a woman to attempt to
- 12:41go into a research University that was so male dominated and
- 12:53seek a place of equal standing in that environment, Mary main
- 12:59said, Imagine this Mary Ainsworth his on the faculty of
- 13:07John Hopkins, but The Faculty Club does not allow women in the
- 13:14building. So Ainsworth approach to this
- 13:21was to get dressed up looking pretty nice walk past, the
- 13:25maitre d, and sit herself down or to table and the The Faculty
- 13:30Club, and the faculty clubs response to.
- 13:33This was simply to ignore her that that had happened.
- 13:37So, she went on a Monday and they ignored her.
- 13:40She stayed for the whole lunch and then she got up and left.
- 13:43Then she came on Tuesday. They ignored her and ignored her
- 13:48on Wednesday and Thursday. And on Friday, as the waiter was
- 13:54walking by, she asked him for a glass of water and he brought
- 13:58her a glass of water. And so the precedent of a woman
- 14:01being sir, Faculty Club was broken.
- 14:07By that gesture. So politeness wins out in the
- 14:13end. But then you have Mary main who
- 14:20is looking for a doctor, a Ph.D program in linguistics, applying
- 14:27to different academic programs and being turned down all across
- 14:34the country. In that particular field, one
- 14:37year and then another And her advisors saying, listen, what
- 14:44you need to do is apply to women who have the ability to bring in
- 14:51PhD students because that's the only way that you're going to
- 14:54get in, and it doesn't matter what the curriculum is.
- 15:00Once you get in, you'll have more maneuverability Mary main
- 15:05wanted to study Linguistics, but she applied around and the only
- 15:10person that was interested in her was Mary Ainsworth.
- 15:19No, she went And she joined the program.
- 15:27They did this strange situation in the analysis of the strange
- 15:30situation. So, this is a film or a
- 15:32videotape of the the Interactions between parent and
- 15:40child and researcher. There was a Clear presentation
- 15:49of a secure child clear. Presentation of an anxious of
- 15:52wooden child, a clear presentation of an anxious
- 15:56ambivalent child the secure child seeks proximity to their
- 16:02caregiver. They look to their caregiver for
- 16:06Assurance that the environment is safe and once they have the
- 16:09assurance that the environment is safe, they begin to explore
- 16:13if they feel threatened, they Retreat and seek protection from
- 16:18The caregiver there, they settled pretty easily an
- 16:21avoidant child, doesn't seek proximity to to the caregiver.
- 16:28They seem to operate independently without that need
- 16:31for attention or reassurance, in an anxious, ambivalent child is
- 16:37clingy and finds it very hard to settle.
- 16:40Very hard to explore in those patterns were quite clear.
- 16:44There was a group of kids though that they couldn't pattern
- 16:47didn't fit into either one of those and they set those aside.
- 16:57One of the things that they were interested in understanding is,
- 17:01did the attachment strategy of the caregiver influence?
- 17:05The attachment strategy of the child?
- 17:09And so, Mary Main and her group began to devise different ways
- 17:18of trying to test the attachment strategy of the caregiver that
- 17:23would be predictive of what the attachment strategy of the child
- 17:27became, that makes sense. So they're evaluating in the
- 17:35exploring, the attachment strategy of the caregiver to see
- 17:40if it had a predictive nature to the attachment strategy of the
- 17:44child. And they so they devised the the
- 17:52adult attachment interview of the I think Mary said that one
- 17:56of her graduate students did most of it and then they began
- 18:00to test it. And what they found was that the
- 18:03a eyes 85% predictive of what your child's attachment
- 18:07strategy. Was that they began to research
- 18:09it in different ways. In fact, the attachment strategy
- 18:14is handed down generation to generation.
- 18:20You have a 70% chance for instance, of having the same
- 18:23attachments, your attitudes, your great-grandmother, so
- 18:25that's four generations of transmission of the same
- 18:29attachment strategy. So we really do learn from our
- 18:32caregivers in the way that they relate to us, the nature of
- 18:38attachment. At some point, they decided that
- 18:42they would look at the attachment.
- 18:46The strange situation interviews that did not fall into those
- 18:49three categories. And that's through that
- 18:52investigation discovered, the disorganized category which is I
- 18:58think One of these. Phenomenal, breakthroughs of
- 19:06the, don't know it at the moment, but it turns into that.
- 19:13So for the work that we do here at better group, so much of her
- 19:20contribution is some things that we use with the students here to
- 19:26evaluate and help repair attachment.
- 19:30And I just wanted to mark that marker passing.
- 19:36Such a lovely person. Really had this eye out for
- 19:43helping all of us, which is, I think remarkable. it's also
- 19:49interesting, when you think about this, through the Buddhist
- 19:52lens about the nature of karma, Her interest in linguistics was,
- 20:01actually the saying that cracked the code but in the beginning it
- 20:04looked like she was going to have to abandon her interest in
- 20:07linguistics and and go with the limitations that the national
- 20:15and local cultures. Imposed.
- 20:21Dan used to say that if you live an ethical life, the things that
- 20:27happen can be viewed as good karma.
- 20:31But often what happens is, they're not what you want.
- 20:35And we have a tendency to to orient, our understanding around
- 20:40the nature of karma, as in terms of getting what we want, or not
- 20:43getting what we want. And that the the interesting
- 20:50aspect of Of exploring, the experience that you're having is
- 20:54that, if you live this ethical life, the things that happen are
- 20:59the Good Karma. And how then do you begin to
- 21:03understand that? So that you're not rejecting,
- 21:08what's happening, you're really pulling in what's happening and
- 21:11being present for what's happening.
- 21:13I think that that her story is a marvelous illustration.
- 21:24Christian. Was Mary main tracking or
- 21:30corresponding with Dan Brown through like the three pillars
- 21:33development? Well. my recollection of the
- 21:43talking to the two of them is that they had not met more than
- 21:47for a cursory introduction at a conference and that Mary main
- 21:55was on the research side and she actually asked people not to use
- 21:59the research on the political side.
- 22:03Until they were actually sure about it.
- 22:09And so, they did not correspond in that way.
- 22:20The research side and the clinical side are quite
- 22:23different terms of the motivation for things.
- 22:28The research side is just looking at what it is and what's
- 22:32happening in the clinical side is looking for things that might
- 22:35be effective in, changing it and creating a particular outcome.
- 22:42So you move through a lot of iterations of what might or
- 22:45might not work. I think that Dan said that he
- 22:49thought his His group had spent 20 years developing the method
- 22:53that they did that. Eventually worked.
- 23:00Errol. Yeah I noted that Mary Ainsworth
- 23:05died in about 1999. Did Mary Mains, stay active all
- 23:11these 22 years since Mary, Main and Mary.
- 23:16Ainsworth were great. Great friends in stayed in
- 23:20contact the whole time, as I understand.
- 23:22Uh-huh. But I was wondering about, was
- 23:25she active in the last 20 years since Ainsworth died in 1999?
- 23:30nine Mary main you mean, Yes. Yeah, she's been working at
- 23:36Berkeley. Continuing the research since
- 23:39then. Wow.
- 23:41The whole time. Jake.
- 23:50Did she decide that this is a solid research and then we can,
- 23:57you know, it can be applied to clinical practice your she ever
- 24:00involved in that? Or was she just purely doing
- 24:03research and go beyond provide? Just did the research wasn't
- 24:08her? Area.
- 24:12She was fascinated by it though. We did talk about it quite a
- 24:16bit. Can you add something since you
- 24:21gave us all her story? Can you tell us about your story
- 24:25with her? Well, really it was, I met her
- 24:31doing the adult attachment in Institute, which I did a couple
- 24:36of times and then I saw her at a conference Prince.
- 24:42So during the enduring, The Institute you have lunch and I
- 24:50had quite a few lunches. With her in The Faculty Club.
- 25:05So, and asking these kinds of questions, have you not thought
- 25:09of doing clinical practice? Now, it's not my thing.
- 25:14I'm just interested in the research and actually thinking
- 25:19that the resources would be better spent on developing
- 25:24interventions for families while children are young so that they
- 25:27can develop secure attachment, which I think is happening.
- 25:33If you could go in to a family and teach the caregivers, just
- 25:38around the attachment question. What they need to do it is
- 25:45easier than say undoing all times.
- 25:50Time of 4 attachment conditioning, I quite liked her
- 25:58and I quite liked Eric, her husband and their primary
- 26:02research for colleague, Naomi surname.
- 26:13Were you able to share with Mary?
- 26:16The kind of works that you've been doing this synthesis of
- 26:22meditation and attachment theory.
- 26:26Yes, I was and we talked about it quite a bit.
- 26:29She was she marveled at it and incense and was delighted that
- 26:36there was something that could be done.
- 26:40When? But it was also to understand
- 26:45the nature of her mind and the openness of it and support.
- 26:50She allowed me to go to The Institute twice as a meditation
- 26:54teacher, not as a psychology professional.
- 27:00I wrote, I knew that it was going to be hard to get into the
- 27:03Institute initially. And so I spent a few days
- 27:07writing what I thought was a great cover letter which I sent
- 27:14and got no reply. So then I rewrote the letter and
- 27:19sent it to a different group that was also offering the the
- 27:24training and they wrote me back and said that they would be
- 27:29happy to accept me to The Institute.
- 27:31But why wouldn't I just go to The Institute in California
- 27:35instead of traveling halfway across the country and I said
- 27:39because they wouldn't let me in and they said tell you what will
- 27:43forward your letter to them and say that we've talk to you and
- 27:47me think that you're sincere and so and I heard back from them
- 27:52that they would be willing to let me in. now, some of you may
- 28:02remember, but I had this full beard down to my belly and this
- 28:06long hair, when I went up there and so I was quite different
- 28:12than In the first Institute one, half of the room were basically
- 28:19psychiatrists and the other half of the room or basically career
- 28:24civil servants working in public Mental Health.
- 28:32One of the things about the assessment is that it's very
- 28:36time and skill, intensive have to train to be able to do it.
- 28:40And so it isn't at least in our culture the way that we operate
- 28:47now. Something that is a very going
- 28:49to be available because it's too It's too hard for our culture.
- 29:04and then, The the level of skill that you have to develop in
- 29:11order to be able to do it, give the interview and score.
- 29:15It yourself is really high. It's a high bar in.
- 29:17So it's a kind of training that is in a couple of weekends and
- 29:24It's also way more effective. And then, in the second
- 29:29Institute, it was more oriented toward psychology people in, in
- 29:37practice Private, Practice, who were thinking, that this would
- 29:41be a good thing. But I think that that's also
- 29:43the, the time we're in, it takes a long time for these ideas,
- 29:49permeate into culture, really 30 to 40 years for a discovery that
- 29:57actually Just swell in holds up to become widely understood in a
- 30:03culture and then the process of trying to create some way of
- 30:09utilizing it in the culture, takes longer than that.
- 30:14So we're just really at the beginning of this process of
- 30:19understanding. The effects of a attachment
- 30:25conditioning and then how to unwind it.
- 30:29So, will be interesting to see how that unfolds.
- 30:35I know that from our approach which is a meditation approach.
- 30:39Not a psycho therapy approach, who used the ideal parent figure
- 30:43to remap that. But that was always a meditation
- 30:46approach from the Tibetan Bond practice of bomb mudra.
- 30:53We don't do the mentalization Based training in a therapeutic
- 30:59psychotherapeutic frame. We do it as a meditation
- 31:02practice. Using a metaphor posten, a
- 31:05structure and then we don't do the, the psychoeducation using
- 31:10the therapeutic bond between therapists and client.
- 31:16We do it in a class structure, we do a psycho education, that's
- 31:23a group a group setting for where we offer the information.
- 31:29It took a while to convince Dan Brown, that this was going to
- 31:32be. be a usable approach but when he we worked on a study
- 31:38together when he saw the outcomes of the study, he
- 31:42recognized that it was a useful approach which is gratifying So
- 31:55she was 80 when she died, she's a good long life.
- 32:00Well spent And I'm so appreciative of of that.
- 32:07Effort. And The Serendipity of of karma.
- 32:22so, it is, you know, the thing, actually that I really liked
- 32:32about her is that she was game, dude.
- 32:35You know what I mean by that? She was up for it, she's up for
- 32:40her life. She was up for what was
- 32:43happening. Well, let's do a little
- 32:56practice. What do you think?
- 33:00I had a one quick question I mean to me George you're your
- 33:06synthesis of these techniques is Cutting Edge and you know
- 33:12obviously very effective and people have been noticing that
- 33:17are there. Other people who have figured
- 33:20this out In the similar way. Well, I don't know that there's
- 33:27another meditation group that does it the way that we do
- 33:33there, there is dance group that does the, the three pillars
- 33:39approaches is psychotherapy based thing, and there are
- 33:43different groups that do different aspects of it, but it
- 33:47is it all together, for instance, the Anthony Bateman
- 33:51Peter Fonda gate group out of Tavistock in London.
- 33:56Are the Anna Freud Center has MBT, which works. in terms of,
- 34:09reducing the, the Symptoms of different kinds of personality
- 34:15disorders. But I don't know that it that
- 34:20it, it earns people security, using the AI As the metric for
- 34:26that Beyond a dance group. I don't know of another group
- 34:33that does. but I think that that's because where we are in
- 34:41terms of the timeline of this entering into our culture, I
- 34:45don't know that that while these approaches work and they're
- 34:49effective and that other approaches won't come along, I
- 34:58don't know. What will happen really?
- 35:04I do wish that we would as a society begin to address these
- 35:13conditions. One of the things that I don't
- 35:18know if you're aware of this, but addiction isn't it.
- 35:21We think of addiction as an attachment disturbance.
- 35:24And certainly the the legal approach to addressing this is
- 35:31of no value. And it's very expensive.
- 35:35You know what other one other program that was a complete
- 35:40failure. When you fund year, after year,
- 35:43after year. If it wasn't making everybody so
- 35:46much money. Who's providing the services
- 35:51that don't work? Are you talking about 12 steps?
- 35:5512 steps know, I'm talking more about the criminal justice
- 36:00system and the making the drugs, illegal, all of that, all of
- 36:07those consequences. I mean, there's There's law
- 36:13enforcement, there's the prison system, there's the judicial
- 36:16system, there's the medical system.
- 36:20The 12-step world is really useful but it also is not hugely
- 36:29effective. But one of the things that's
- 36:34happened with, with the elite illegality of all of this, is
- 36:39that it's pushed the manufacturers of illicit drugs
- 36:44into producing substances, which are fundamentally harming.
- 36:49So the, the P2P meth the Fentanyl and now, they call it,
- 36:59I think tarp, but it's a, it's a tranquilizer for livestock,
- 37:06which is now being mixed in with fentanyl or and and anyway, it
- 37:15causes Terrible damage to the body so that we have super
- 37:29addictive drugs that cause permanent harm the people that
- 37:35use them. And and because of the legal
- 37:41wedge that we use to push them into the place where they have
- 37:45no options. Just a catastrophe that is
- 37:53unfolding now. Anyway, I'll stop its ups.
- 37:59It's a it upsets me and that we can't just recognize that.
- 38:05These are people that need treatment, not incarceration.
- 38:12and that if we can begin to look at this as through the
- 38:16attachment lens, we might be able to help Christian.
- 38:29Georgian in terms of other modalities.
- 38:32Hopefully, I'm not mr. Remembering but I believe
- 38:34transference Focus Psychotherapy has had some good outcomes in
- 38:38terms of Shifting attachment, but I think it's a pretty long
- 38:41term. I think it's a pretty long term
- 38:44approach. I well, they did have some
- 38:48studies that showed that 10 years of Psychotherapy with the
- 38:51same psychotherapist if there was a good therapeutic
- 38:54relationship could shift attachment In our society,
- 39:03considering that 70% of the population could use some
- 39:06attachment work. What do you think the likelihood
- 39:09is that? We're going to provide 10 years
- 39:11of psychotherapy different. I would put the chances at zero
- 39:22The D, what about the use of Ayahuasca and some of the other
- 39:26so-called more natural mind-altering substances, you
- 39:34know that are used in the shaman, shamanistic world, have
- 39:37those proven to be helpful in any Arena that you're involved
- 39:42in. I don't know.
- 39:44I think that in that for people that have a very rigid sense of
- 39:51self and Very hard reality that they're very useful in prying
- 39:56that open. But I don't know.
- 40:03My, you know, the it's certainly very popular now, I don't know
- 40:14that the Hardly. We have to wait and see what the
- 40:21long term effect is and partly. We have to study it in a way
- 40:25that we can actually get some information about it.
- 40:28I don't know. You know, long-term meditator
- 40:34thinks that meditation is, will provide provide all of the
- 40:39insights that you can get from psychedelics and that it's more
- 40:44stable. But if you could take a pill and
- 40:55be instantly, Enlightenment, would you take it?
- 40:57That's the question. Well, sometimes it's a portal or
- 41:02window to what what's possible with our capacity?
- 41:07May hold. And I do find reports.
- 41:10I haven't had it myself, but reports of people who experience
- 41:13that that have gone on the path of meditation because they had
- 41:19an enlightening experience. Yeah.
- 41:21But that would be a I think it's super useful outcome.
- 41:26Yeah. Yeah I think so too.
- 41:35Loving kindness. How's that?
- 41:44That's good. Good.
- 41:51I have to admit that at first, that while I was sitting images
- 41:56of the cake that you brought over kept floating
- 42:15Anything else you wanted to say? Hey, I felt like there was that
- 42:22the concentration was building and then it would fade and then
- 42:27it would come back. Then.
- 42:29I would fade and it felt like it was kind of building.
- 42:33Nice. And my body got really hot and
- 42:38then it and then there were sensations of kind of ship,
- 42:44shoot, you know, the what's that word?
- 42:48Kind of shivery feelings. Yeah, so that's what happened.
- 42:59I can share. Yeah, I seem to be and you can
- 43:08of course give me some suggestions on this but I seem
- 43:12to be resonating with imagining a person who I feel loving
- 43:21kindness with. And by the way, there's been a
- 43:23couple incidences where I felt it during the week and I'm like,
- 43:27oh, that must be it. So it's, yeah.
- 43:31It just generates a warm feeling in my heart energy and just So I
- 43:38was able to access that with two different people during the
- 43:42practice and I wondered what to do with it.
- 43:49After that, of course I get distracted.
- 43:51I go off on narrative so that I coming back and saying oh yeah
- 43:55remember and one of them was you know, Rick Hanson, the neuro
- 44:01Dharma guy so he gave a talk last night and and his look of
- 44:06loving kindness. It's when he just sits there,
- 44:08he's so kind of quirky, but there's something about his
- 44:11look, that is just so endearing and makes my heart open.
- 44:15And since it was last night, I had that feeling at the end of
- 44:19his talk as he just stares into the camera with all this juicy
- 44:24loving-kindness. So I was able to access that and
- 44:28then I wondered What do you mean by then right view?
- 44:34Like I'm at am I on the right track to just sort of feel it
- 44:40and going back to it. Yeah when you notice the how
- 44:44does conceptual reality look to you?
- 44:45Does it look differently conceptual reality versus what?
- 44:53So one can when you have the mindset of loving-kindness how
- 44:56does everything appear? And when you don't have the
- 45:01mindset of loving-kindness, how does it appear?
- 45:03And can you see the difference? And the way that self and World
- 45:07appear? Well, I have to figure out what
- 45:11you mean by conceptual because for me it's just a feeling
- 45:15energy and maybe a little bit of visualization.
- 45:19Yeah. So the Ultimate Reality
- 45:23experience is the pure sensing and then we make it into solid
- 45:26self solid world. But when we make it into solid
- 45:29self solid work, The mindset of review that were holding affects
- 45:33the way things appear, and so we're trying to track is the
- 45:37differences in the way things appear to us, depending on what
- 45:40mind state were holding or whether the mind is equanimous
- 45:44in the moment. Uh-huh.
- 45:50But I would also say you're making progress in this because
- 45:53you're able to identify the state in the body.
- 45:56Now, we just need you feeling tone in response to pulling up.
- 46:02I don't know if you called this conceptual thought of this
- 46:05person who I had the feeling with last night, yeah, right.
- 46:10So now the idea is to expect to explore.
- 46:13How does self and World appear to you when you're in that
- 46:16state. It feels great, it's light and
- 46:19buoyant and beautiful and all that.
- 46:23And then when you're not in that state, how does the world look?
- 46:26Kind of mix kind of like whatever comes along and rolls
- 46:32rocks. My boat the wrong way, or the
- 46:34right way, or whatever. Then you're beginning to
- 46:36understand the differences in view.
- 46:40One view is, is sort of neutral, maybe, the other view, has this
- 46:47Lively disc to it. All right, so good.
- 46:52Progress. Yes thank you affection is too
- 46:58hard so we're not going to that hit the target.
- 47:08Yeah. So what else?
- 47:12Yeah when you ask that question of how does the conceptual
- 47:17reality of self and World seem when you're in in that?
- 47:21State of Mind, State and discuss what, you know, I hadn't thought
- 47:28about it, you know? But as you ask the question,
- 47:31what came up for me is that I just there was a real lack of
- 47:39opposition or there was very no tension or no opposing forces.
- 47:46It just was very As is or relaxed with it.
- 47:52A deep acceptance of that good. Yeah, hope and I would call that
- 47:57open. Okay.
- 48:00Wonderful. Yeah, so but it's like, oh, I
- 48:06don't feel like anything is opposing me.
- 48:08That's nice, the good. Thanks Casey.
- 48:21Hi, George. So I'm kind of embarrassed to
- 48:25admit this, but I'm going to anyway.
- 48:28I don't really have an easy person.
- 48:32I must have like, only complicated relationships and
- 48:38like, I sometimes can find like my friends baby or right.
- 48:42What about could I could I use like like the moon rise or could
- 48:48I could I not use a person? So are you able to identify
- 48:53loving kindness? Yeah.
- 48:56So if you don't have an easy person, what that means is
- 49:00you're going to have to use somebody who's not easy, but
- 49:02that you do, hold the mindset of love and kindness for and you're
- 49:06just have to push all of the other mind states that you have
- 49:09associated with that person out of the way and focus on the
- 49:13loving-kindness aspect. Okay, the reason we say he's the
- 49:18reason said I was teaching easy and if you had somebody where
- 49:23that was the only mindset Associated that when you thought
- 49:26of them that might say, would just come up because that's the
- 49:28only one you have. But not everybody has an easy
- 49:30person, you know. it's really just about learning to identify
- 49:40the Mind State, then moving on, to being able to zoom in on that
- 49:44mindset in association with the more complex pattern of people
- 49:49that, you know, better Okay, yep.
- 49:53I can do that. Thanks so much.
- 49:55Good. And then, hopefully that becomes
- 50:00easy for everybody and then everybody becomes an easy
- 50:03person. Someone else it is the aim to
- 50:13drop the phrase. May I be peaceful or may be
- 50:17peaceful? and drop that completely and
- 50:20just go into the feeling reviewer.
- 50:26Well, there's a few reasons for the phrase.
- 50:28Mainly it's to fill up water trees thinking.
- 50:30So, auditory thoughts, don't distract you.
- 50:34But also, if you do get into a high concentration state, for
- 50:38instance, the first met John is its unstable and you pop out but
- 50:43it's easy to be disoriented and not really know what you're
- 50:47doing when you pop out of that that level of concentration then
- 50:52you hear the phrase that it reminds you what you're doing so
- 50:54you can come back faster. It's quite easy to get altered
- 50:59when you get into high concentration States.
- 51:02Then you'll pop out and it'll just be sort of blissful and so
- 51:06you just hang out in the Blissful state.
- 51:10Me back, use the phrase. Again, when you pop out or what,
- 51:16will you pop out? And you're a little disoriented
- 51:19little Blissful and then you hear the phrase you do?
- 51:23Yeah, I'm doing better. I'll come back and reset because
- 51:27if you don't have the phrase and you pop out, you could literally
- 51:30sit there for 20 minutes space out, I think that's helpful.
- 51:39It doesn't happen. So these periods are pretty
- 51:41short but when when we used to do this against the stream, we
- 51:45would sit for 15 minutes for an hour and it was very ordinary
- 51:48for people to get quite blitzed out by it. and then for 20
- 51:54minutes afterwards, everybody sort of bumping into each other
- 51:57because there are altered All right.
- 52:07Thank you for being here and listening to me.
- 52:12Rattle on about Mary made, who I just adored And feel quite sad
- 52:18about. We are doing a level one on
- 52:23Saturdays. So last week was the first one.
- 52:27There's three more of those. It's from nine, until either 115
- 52:32and co-teaching with stas, fetch in, we're going to be talking
- 52:40about emotional regulation and then describing Secure
- 52:47attachment, I think, and then that's on Saturday, we have a
- 52:53level 2 class starting in February.
- 52:55Take a look at that if you're interested in that, Else.
- 53:03We still have the retreat set up in who tracked in June.
- 53:10So anyway, so on the website, I offer this class freely but I do
- 53:18hope that you'll consider making a donation.
- 53:20There's a link on the website to do that.
- 53:22The donation, helps support me. And also the work that medic
- 53:25group is doing really appreciate your practice.
- 53:27I hope to see you soon and Have a good night, bye.
- 53:36Thank you Jorge. Good night.
- 53:39Happy New Year, George. Thanks.
- 53:44I,