Latest / This is VANCOLOUR / #205 - Dustin Godfrey / Mario Canseco / Kyla's Court with Kyla Lee
Transcript
- 0:02Check podcasts. This is Van Color. Hey folks, my name is Mohamare
- 0:23and this is Van Color. British Columbia's Bonified Culture and Politics TV talk show
- 0:27Tonight is all about crime in BC. Kyla Lee will be here to discuss
- 0:32whether recent federal bail reform will actually make a difference in reducing crime. Plus,
- 0:38journalist Dustin Godfrey will be here to discuss how the media can impact our
- 0:44perception of crime. But first, speaking of perceptions, a majority of British
- 0:49Columbians believe that crime is on the rise, but does this feeling actually match
- 0:54up with the crime stats. Helping us explain it all is one of my
- 0:57favorites, Polster extraordinary. The president of search Co. He is Mario Conseco.
- 1:03Mario, always a pleasure, always an honor to see you. It's
- 1:06my pleasure. So when it comes to the anxieties that British Columbians are feeling
- 1:11when it comes to crime, what are you seeing in your polling data?
- 1:15The last year we've seen a significant rice. Now we have fifty nine percent
- 1:19of BC residents who feel that crime is on the rise in their communities.
- 1:23This is up eight points. It has been consistently rising, but not never,
- 1:27never something as significant as this from from year to year. So the
- 1:32temperature is rising and as you said, a very keyword is this is how
- 1:36British Columbians feel. But how does this match up with actual crime stats or
- 1:41even you know, when when you're polling British Columbians about if they if they've
- 1:46experienced crime, do these two things actually match up? It doesn't match up
- 1:49at all. I think that is one of the really craziest findings when we
- 1:53look at the numbers, because you know, people are exposed to crime,
- 1:57they read about it, they see what is going on, they feel that
- 1:59it is is getting closer to their homes. But when we ask them if
- 2:02they've actually called somebody because something happened, if they've reported something to the police,
- 2:07the numbers are steady. It's usually one in five people who have experienced
- 2:09that. So it's ultimately really perceptions. It's not something that they're facing day
- 2:15to day. So is that one in five number of British Columbians that have
- 2:17experienced crime? Has that stayed pretty stagnant? It's been stagnant since we started
- 2:23asking back in twenty eighteen. It's been eighteen percent nineteen percent, twenty percent,
- 2:27never higher than that, and yet we see the numbers rising. Sometimes
- 2:30you have forty four percent saying crime is on the rise. This year is
- 2:32fifty nine. So it's not something that is definitely in touch with reality.
- 2:38So there's obviously a disconnect here, right, British Columbians are feeling like crime
- 2:42is on the rise, but British Columbians aren't actually experiencing a rise in crime.
- 2:46How do you account for this disconnect? Well, one of the reasons
- 2:51for this is media coverage. You know, a lot of disco blaming the
- 2:54media. Mario is that's what we're doing fake news. It's not even fake
- 2:59news. It's the fact that you see something happening nearby. Belitz you to
- 3:02believe that this is something that could happen to you, and it's not something
- 3:07that we see in the statistics. You know, in a way, it's
- 3:09similar to what happened after ninety eleven in the US. You know, terrorists
- 3:13are coming to get you. We don't know who they are, we don't
- 3:15know what is happening, and that rises the idea that something as horrific as
- 3:19what happened that day might be happening again. It hasn't. But if you
- 3:22go back to the moment you were feeling back in October of two thousand and
- 3:27one, maybe November of two thousand and one, all of that nervousness,
- 3:30all of that anxiety, that is similar to what we're seeing here. And
- 3:34so I wonder if and I maybe we're already seeing this. Political parties will
- 3:38start tuning into this, and whether it's real or not, they're going to
- 3:40say, well, you know, people respond to tough on crime policies,
- 3:46right, this is the key to the exercise. So, because you're going
- 3:49to have a lot of discussions about crime, housing is a complex issue to
- 3:53solve very quickly. Economy and job seem to be doing very well. Healthcare
- 3:57is more complicated. But you have now a significificantly larger proportion of residents who
- 4:01are worried about crime. And of course you're going to have people saying this
- 4:04is all Davy. Davy's fault. He's a lawyer, he should do something
- 4:08different. BC United is going to come out saying we would do a much
- 4:11better job with all of these things. And it doesn't help when you're knocking
- 4:15on somebody's door and somebody answers and says you know, I am really worried
- 4:18about the situation right now. Crime is on the rise. I don't see
- 4:24candidates saying, well, man, listen, it's not really rising. There's
- 4:28nothing to worry about. When that becomes part of the discourse, you need
- 4:30to deal with it, even if you're out with those stats. So it's
- 4:34going to be complicated for the government because one of the things that we're seeing
- 4:39now is more people blaming the system for what is going on. The courts
- 4:43aren't doing a very good job with this. We're not happy with the way
- 4:46this is being handled. So the onus is on the government for that one.
- 4:48Particularly when we think about popularity for the police, I wonder if it's
- 4:54been aving an inflowing, because certainly there was a movement, you know,
- 4:58to defund the police with had those conversations in the media as well. Where
- 5:02does the police's popularity kind of stay is it? Has it been stagnant?
- 5:08Has it also been increasing with these increasing anxieties about crime. It's really complicated
- 5:14because we have so many police forces operating and don't let's not get started on
- 5:17sorry, because we'll be here about four minutes. But it's it's a very
- 5:21delicate situation because people seem to be very trustworthy and they look at the police
- 5:27as somebody who's actually helping them. But you also read all of the other
- 5:30stories about how they have misbehaved in other moments, right, So it's a
- 5:32similar scenario. If you don't trust the police, you're going to remember those
- 5:36moments and say this isn't something that we should be doing. If you're worried
- 5:40about crime, you're going to recall those moments and say, my city is
- 5:44not safe. But overall police popularity, are you seeing anything in the polling
- 5:46data that with suggest it's going up or down roughly the same? You know,
- 5:49you don't have a situation that has changed over the past few years.
- 5:54We've asked this for many years now, and it's not a situation where people
- 5:57are saying let's defund the police. That that hasn't had a majority support.
- 6:01But more than anything, it's how do we deal with the situation that we
- 6:04have in front of us. A lot of it has to do with overdoses,
- 6:08and there's not a lot of situations out there where people are happy with
- 6:11what they see. They want a more holistic way to look into this,
- 6:15and what you have is people screaming safe supply no no, no voluntary treatment,
- 6:18no no, no mandatory treatment. People want a combination with all of
- 6:20those things, right, Mario, this has been fascinating. I appreciate your
- 6:25work and I look forward to tracking where these trends go in the future.
- 6:28So thanks so much for your time tonight, anytime. Absolutely, folks,
- 6:31that was poster extraordinary Mario Conseco. Now, after some business we just discussed,
- 6:36you know, is crime skyrocketing in Vancouver? Is Vancouver dying? Well,
- 6:41let's talk about the role that the media plays in shaping our perceptions about
- 6:45crime. We'll talk about it up next. Welcome back to this as Van
- 6:53Color. We're talking about crime in BC tonight. But what role does the
- 6:57media play and how we perceive crime? Here to explain as a freelance journalist
- 7:01based in the Vancouver area. Last month they released their video essay is Vancouver
- 7:08Dying? A definitely non exhaustive review, which you can now find on YouTube.
- 7:13They are Dustin Godfrey and this conversation is supported by shelter Point single malt
- 7:17whiskey distinctly Vancouver Island, uniquely shelter Point, Hi, Dustin, that's a
- 7:25good it's going good thanks for being on the show tonight. So you've done
- 7:29a lot of research into this is Vancouver dying because of out of control crime
- 7:33rates. The thing is, if you hone in on very specific data for
- 7:40very specific crimes, for very specific time periods, you will find justification for
- 7:45the narrative that you're looking for, not specifically, but that some people have
- 7:49put out there exactly. And so you will see people claiming that things like
- 7:54robbery in twenty twenty two was up twenty one percent in the first quarter compared
- 8:00to the average of three pre pandemic years. Okay, but if you zoom
- 8:05out a little bit and look at the entire year, that difference flattens to
- 8:09about about half of what it was at ten point seven percent. And then
- 8:13if you zoom out even further and look at the years that they didn't include,
- 8:16so say twenty twenty one, that difference was even further. So you're
- 8:22really not seeing this steady rise in crime recently, or in robberies at least.
- 8:28What you're seeing is little fluctuations over years. And in fact, if
- 8:31you zoom out even further, robberies in twenty twenty one are the we're according
- 8:37to police statistics the lowest in the entirety of the last twenty one years.
- 8:43Right, So it sounds like there's lies, damn lies and statistics exactly exactly,
- 8:48and so like it's not just saying that there aren't areas where there have
- 8:52been rises in crimes. If you look at things like property crime, starting
- 8:56in the early to mid twenty tens and until about twenty nineteen, there were
- 9:01you know, notable increases in things like theft of personal property or theft from
- 9:07auto and that kind of reached a sort of fever pitch, I guess in
- 9:13the about twenty nineteen and then just kind of dropped off a cliff during the
- 9:18pandemic. Interesting, but even at it's kind of height in around twenty nineteen
- 9:22or around that area, it still wasn't really at the point that it was
- 9:26in the early to mid two thousands, which were kind of compared to today
- 9:31a bit of a heyday for crime. Okay, And I guess we should
- 9:35also be clear that we're not diminishing, you know, victims of crime,
- 9:39but it is important to be truthful and somewhat realistic about how serious and how
- 9:46serious crime is in terms of its increase or decrease. Right, yeah,
- 9:50absolutely, And you know, horrific crimes are exactly that, they are horrific.
- 9:56But I don't think you really do much of a service to solving the
- 10:01issues of crime when you're not talking about it in a way that is either
- 10:05honest or maybe just not reflective of what we're actually seeing in the data.
- 10:11So if you look at things like bail reform, people when people talk about
- 10:20bail reform, often they're talking about it, they don't pair it with a
- 10:24sort of horrific you know, anecdote of somebody losing their bicycle, and you
- 10:30know, that was the kind of thing that we were seeing a rise of
- 10:31and people are you know, sort of like really feeling or experiencing, you
- 10:37know, more of prior to the pandemic. What they often pair it with
- 10:41is a really sort of shocking story about a horrific crime, and it kind
- 10:48of winds up being used to justify without really being backed up in statistics narrative.
- 10:54That kind of winds up being sort of a backlash to Movements from that
- 11:00sort of got their starts, or at least really sort of started to gain
- 11:03momentum in the mid twenty tens with things like harm reduction, and you know
- 11:07into twenty twenty with things like you know, justice reform and things like defending
- 11:13the police. And the kind of funny thing about that is that it winds
- 11:16up being sort of a backlash two things that you know, the policies that
- 11:20are being talked about from those circles are not really being meaningfully implemented, and
- 11:28yet they're kind of being used as scapegoats to push back on towards things like
- 11:37bail reform, right, and talking about bail reform, like there is consensus
- 11:41amongst Canadian premiers, you know, asking the federal government for bail reform,
- 11:46and so certainly that consensus and that advocacy from premiers is coming from some sort
- 11:52of anxiety about crime, right, And you hear the things about repeat offenders
- 11:56and that this is a big problem. So ultimately, is there any truth
- 12:01to repeat offenders and you know, them being a source of increased crime.
- 12:07Yeah, I don't know. I can't really speak too much to the issue
- 12:09of like repeat offenders per se, Like, I mean, they do exist
- 12:11obviously, But I think kind of what winds up happening here is that people
- 12:16have these real frustrations with things like property crime, and those have been seeing
- 12:20real increases, at least according to police reported statistics, and that kind of
- 12:26winds up getting conflated with a sort of violent crime as being this sort of
- 12:33like monolith, and so people's like real experiences and real frustrations are being used
- 12:39to sort of justifying that this monolith of crime is skyrocketing, or crime is
- 12:46out of control, or Vancouver is dying. Right, Yeah, Dustin your
- 12:50journalist, I'm a talk show host. We're part of the media. Mario
- 12:54Conseco is just on the program and he said that it's it's partially the media's
- 12:58fault in terms of either aim or perhaps the frequency in which crime is reported
- 13:01or how it's reported. So I want to ask you, is news media
- 13:05to blame? Are we the batties? You know, I do think that
- 13:11there is some truth to that, for sure, because you look at the
- 13:13way that you know, media reports on say news releases from police services or
- 13:20police forces, and it's often really sort of uncritical when they issue a new
- 13:26news release for something like a new crime. And you know, when people
- 13:31talk about things like media bias, often they're talking about it in terms of
- 13:35left or right, or liberal or conservative or things like that, right,
- 13:39they're talking about a partisan or political bias, right. But I think the
- 13:43thing that there's a little bit more evidence for is a sort of institutional bias
- 13:50where there's a little bit more trust put into institutions like policing. And it
- 13:54gets to a point where you know, if you're covering council, you will
- 14:00on a particular issue, you will hear from the mayor, You'll hear from
- 14:03a certain councilor who's maybe aligned with the mayor. You'll hear from a Green
- 14:07council, you're here from a one city council, ABC councilor. And when
- 14:11it comes to covering police news releases, that just regularly is not the case.
- 14:18They are published uncritically and with the police being the only source in many
- 14:24many cases. But we trust them with guns, why can't we trust them
- 14:28with stats? And that's the thing. These are, you know, institutions
- 14:35that we're supposed to be holding to accounts right now, that's fair and so
- 14:41yeah, I don't know, there is an issue where if you see news
- 14:45releases coming from the police, and you know, maybe there's more news releases
- 14:48from police about crimes this month then another month, people might get the impression
- 14:54that crime is on the rise, even if that isn't reflected in the statistics,
- 14:58Right, that's fair covering crime. Do you think that there is a
- 15:01bias towards sort of the sensational crime like stranger attacks versus things like domestic violence,
- 15:07which actually might be more widespread but just less covered because of the nature
- 15:11of it's of that crime. Yeah, and it's not even just like more
- 15:16sensational crimes necessarily. You look at why, say, shoplifting is covered all
- 15:20the time and or you know, talked about all the time, I should
- 15:22say, and maybe not waves theft, right, but yeah, to get
- 15:26to your sort of point, I think there also actually is a very good
- 15:28reason that we don't talk as much about domestic violence because when you report,
- 15:37when people report to domestic violence to police, there is already sort of an
- 15:41increased risk of them being revictimized or being you know, you know, victim
- 15:46again to things like retribution from their abuse of partner or parent or whatever it
- 15:52is, right, right, And so I think just by sort of like
- 15:54raising that even further in the media, that the you know, sort of
- 16:02increases i think risk for those individuals. So there is reason to be sort
- 16:07of conscious in the way that you talk about things like domestic violence. But
- 16:11on the other hand, you know, we do see that in I think
- 16:14twenty nineteen, domestic violence was about eleven percent of all calls calls of violence
- 16:21to police in Canada in twenty nineteen. Okay, and we know that also
- 16:27domestic violence is among the least likely types of calls to actually be made.
- 16:33People who experience domestic violence are far less likely to actually call them into police
- 16:37than even like other types of violence. Yeah, and so you know that
- 16:44is very much an understated statistic, and so there is very much a case
- 16:51to be talking more about this particular type of violence. Yeah, fascinating,
- 16:53Dustin. I appreciate your work. Great job on the video essay and thanks
- 16:57time tonight. Yeah, thank you. Make sure you check out their video
- 17:00is Vancouver Dying a definitely non exhaustive review now available on YouTube. They are
- 17:06Dustin Godfrey and big thank you to Shelter Point Single Malt Whiskey for supporting local
- 17:11conversations and local content now up next. After some criticism from Canada's premiers and
- 17:18opposition parties, the federal government introduced a bill to make it more difficult for
- 17:22repeat violent offenders to be granted bail. But will this bill reduce crime?
- 17:27We'll talk about it. Kyla's Court with Kyla Lee is up next. Welcome
- 17:37back to this as van color. Last month, the Trudeau government introduced a
- 17:41bill to amend the criminal Code so that repeat violent offenders will find it more
- 17:47difficult to be granted bail. But what does this federal bail reform actually accomplish?
- 17:53Here to discuss is my counterpart on the Soapbox Social Panel, which you
- 17:56can find on CBC Radios on the Coast with Gloria mc ranko. One of
- 18:00BC's most high profile criminal defense lawyers representing Acumen Lashi is Kyla Lee, and
- 18:06this is Kyla's Court. Hi, Kyla Himo, thanks for having me back,
- 18:21absolutely, thanks for being here. Listen, the federal government has introduced
- 18:25this bill to fix this issue with repeat offenders and catch and release policies.
- 18:29I don't understand it. Can you explain it to me and maybe the viewers
- 18:33what this bill is and what it's changing. Okay, So the bill doesn't
- 18:36actually change that much. Essentially, all the bill does is change who bears
- 18:41the burden of proving that somebody shooters should not get bail, Okay. So
- 18:45for a lot of instances, with some exceptions, if you are seeking to
- 18:49have bail, the crown has to prove why you should be detained. This
- 18:52bill creates a reverse onus, meaning you have to prove why you should be
- 18:56released in very limited circumstance circumstances of previous incidents of intimate partner violence where a
- 19:03person received a discharge, some additional circumstances involving a firearm that weren't covered in
- 19:08earlier legislation, circumstances where an individual has a previous conviction for a violent offense
- 19:15involving a weapon within the last five years. But now by putting the onus
- 19:19on the criminal, doesn't that create barriers for them to get the bail that
- 19:23they want. Not necessarily, because you can come to court and show the
- 19:27judge that you have a good bail plan and good reasons why you should be
- 19:30released and how you're going to manage yourself in the community, and a judge
- 19:34has a constitutional obligation to grant reasonable bail if it can be achieved. But
- 19:40I feel like the federal government touted this as like a big thing that was
- 19:45going to reduce violent crime in particular. Are you saying that it's going to
- 19:48affect violent crime. It's not even going to affect the majority of the people
- 19:52that we think about when we think about these repeat offenders, it's people who
- 19:56are previously on bail. Those people were already facing a verse onus, right,
- 20:00So this lot doesn't change anything. It actually just adds the same provisions
- 20:03that are already in place for a select few number of other people. So
- 20:07it's bullshit, basically, you can say it. I mean, I won't
- 20:10say it, but that's the legal term, right. The legal term is
- 20:12it's not effective accomplishing its goal, and it's political pandering to a select group
- 20:18of very vocal people, which would be the conservatives and the people who are
- 20:22concerned about repeat offenders. But a lot of those people are also people who
- 20:26are concerned about property crime, and this bill doesn't deal with the property crime
- 20:29at all. So it is bullshit. Yes, it's pandering. Okay,
- 20:33well, Kyla, Hey, I appreciate your legal expertise on this. That
- 20:37was a very concise explanation, so thank you so much. And yeah,
- 20:41I hope people recognize this bill for what it is me too, which is
- 20:47which is pandering. Kyla. Thanks so much, folks, that's our show.
- 20:52Thank you so much to Mario Conseco, Dustin Godfrey, and my buddy
- 20:57Kyla Lee for crime Time. I'm on Primetime right here on check of course.
- 21:03If you want more fined, this is Van Color on Apple Podcasts,
- 21:06Spotify, Check Media's YouTube channel, and the Check plus app. For now,
- 21:11though, this is Van Color and I'm oamire telling you that in a
- 21:14province where you can be anything, be colorful. Peace