Latest / Dark Murder: True Crime Cases / Episode 91
Transcript
- 0:06Dark murder True crime cases five four, three, two, one one one.
- 0:27Welcome back. I'm your host, Jordan Lee. I'm sure you are
- 0:31all ready to dive into some dark, creepy stories, so let's get started.
- 0:39A motiveless murder, the Murder of Susan Cohen. Before the outbreak of
- 0:46World War One, many people were trying to leave the oppression of Russia,
- 0:51trying to escape the harsh conditions of the Tsarist regimes. One such man was
- 0:56Isidore Cohen, who immigrated to the country of South Africa. He quickly learned
- 1:00the language and decided to open a furniture store in Cape Town. Using his
- 1:06earnings, he took a risk and began to buy up large tracts of land
- 1:10that stretched to the Atlantic Ocean. He was gambling that when the cities expanded,
- 1:15the land would be worth a great deal more than he bought it for.
- 1:19Lucky for him, he was right, and when he sold it he
- 1:22became a millionaire. Isidore, in his life, married and had a son,
- 1:27Ronald. Hoping to instill the same values he himself had learned, Isidore
- 1:33insisted that Ronald make his own way in the world, just like he had
- 1:38as the son of a wealthy parent, he was given a leg up on
- 1:41many of the other boys around him. He was sent to one of the
- 1:44best high schools in the country before attending and graduating from the University of Cape
- 1:49Town. After graduation, Ronald took a trip to Paris, France, where
- 1:53he met a woman by the name of Marlette Brand. The couple was married
- 1:59in nineteen fifty four, but the couple would only last four years before filing
- 2:02for divorce and falling out of touch with one another. Three years later,
- 2:07Ronald met a beautiful girl by the name of Susan Johnson. Already thirty one
- 2:12years of age, he was fourteen years susan senior, but the two were
- 2:16madly in love. Susan's parents told Ronald they would agree to the wedding as
- 2:22long as he was willing to wait until Susan turned eighteen. If they still
- 2:25wanted to get married at that point, then they would have their blessing.
- 2:30Meanwhile, Ronald was far from sitting on his hands when it came to making
- 2:35something of himself. He began as a clerk in a local hardware store,
- 2:39but quickly was able to work his way up to being an executive in the
- 2:43firm. He, like his father, branched out his interests and bought one
- 2:47of the top department stores in all of Cape Town, known as Fletcher and
- 2:52Cartwrights. He continued to buy up different businesses, and it wasn't long before
- 2:57he owned more than a dozen successful companies. Just as his father hoped he
- 3:01would, Ronald made himself into a multi millionaire. Ronald and Susan did stay
- 3:07together and were married in nineteen sixty six. The couple welcomed their first child,
- 3:13a son, to the world. Tragedy would strike before he turned one,
- 3:16though in his crib, he managed to wrap something around his neck and
- 3:21strangled himself. The death of a child was hard on both parents, but
- 3:25they managed to come together and make it through the tragedy together. As part
- 3:30of the coping process, Ronald focused hard on his business ventures, working almost
- 3:36all the time. During this period, Susan gave birth to two more children,
- 3:42who were loved deeply by both of their parents. To house the family
- 3:46he adored, Ronald built what many considered the nicest home in the entire city
- 3:51that sported extravagant furnishings, a formal garden and a swimming pool to keep up
- 3:57with the work of the home. Susan also had the help of four full
- 4:00time staff. Everything in their lives seemed perfect until the night of April fifth,
- 4:06nineteen seventy. Yvonne Mary, the housekeeper, was lying in her bed
- 4:12reading when Ronald began shouting for her. When he burst into her room,
- 4:16she saw that his shirt was covered in blood and making claims that someone had
- 4:19broken into their home. Once she had recovered from the scare sheet received,
- 4:26Yvonne made her way to the library, where she found Ronald kneeling beside the
- 4:29body of the now dead Susan. Part of the back of the woman's head
- 4:33had been crushed, and her nose and jaw were obviously fractured. The blow
- 4:39to the head had been so violent that the right ear had been nearly torn
- 4:43completely off. She also noticed the doors to the outside terrace were open and
- 4:47it was raining outside. Ronald told Yvonne to call the police and wake his
- 4:53two children, and to hide in the powder room, since it was the
- 4:56only place in the home without any windows to her it's It seemed that Ronald
- 5:00was afraid that whoever had killed Susan might still be inside their home. When
- 5:05investigators arrived, They began going over the library and questioning a still distraught Ronald.
- 5:12He informed them that he and Susan had been reading in the library when
- 5:15he left to use the bathroom. When he came back, he saw Susan
- 5:19and a blond man who he guessed was between twenty seven and thirty years old,
- 5:24engaged in a struggle in the middle of the room. He told police
- 5:28he grabbed a ram's head that had been sculpted out of bronze and ran to
- 5:31his wife's aid. To their surprise, Ronald could not remember whether or not
- 5:35he had actually hit the intruder with the statue. He claimed. The next
- 5:41thing he remembered after running towards them was waking up on the floor and finding
- 5:45Susan dead behind the couch. Police were skeptical of his explanation for a number
- 5:49of reasons. When they asked Ronald about what the man's hands looked like,
- 5:55he summoned up that he had been wearing gloves at the time, something he'd
- 5:59failed to mention during their initial questioning. The state of the room was also
- 6:03a bit odd, given the fact a life and death struggle had apparently occurred
- 6:08there. Other than a single overturned chair, and the blood that had seeped
- 6:13into the rug. Nothing seemed out of place. There were also the scratches
- 6:17on Ronald's arms that he claimed came from Susan when the three of them were
- 6:20struggling. Other bits of physical evidence didn't back up the story either. The
- 6:27only place that the intruder could have gotten in was the terrace. Due to
- 6:31the reign, it would make sense that there would have been footsteps leading up
- 6:34to the house in the mud outside, but none existed. Also missing inside
- 6:41were any traces of mud or scuffs from the intruder anywhere in the library.
- 6:46After taking all this into account, police didn't believe there had ever been an
- 6:49intruder, but Susan had been attacked by Ronald himself. He was quickly arrested
- 6:56and charged with murder. After being released on bail and awaiting trial, Ronald
- 7:00Cohen still maintained his innocence. During a visit to a tailor, he and
- 7:05his wife's killer apparently spotted one another at the same time, prompting Ronald to
- 7:11give chase. After losing the blonde man in a crowd, he stopped and
- 7:15asked an elderly woman if she'd seen a blond man run past. She pointed
- 7:20him in the direction of Adderley Street, but he was unable to catch him.
- 7:25When police asked to speak to the elderly woman, he put out advertisements
- 7:29for her to come forward, but like the blonde man, she couldn't be
- 7:32located either. Cohen even went so far as to hire a painter to make
- 7:38a portrait of the man who he claimed killed his wife, based on the
- 7:42description he gave. Copies of the picture were spread all over the place and
- 7:46a large reward was offered, but nothing came of that either. With no
- 7:51reason to dismiss the charges, Robert Cohen's murder trial began on August twenty fourth,
- 7:57nineteen seventy. Due to the and it was a highly publicized affair,
- 8:03the prosecution was attempting to prove that Ronald had lied about the intruder to cover
- 8:07up the fact that he murdered Susan himself in hopes of not having to pay
- 8:11for his crime. The case against him was entirely circumstantial, but in the
- 8:16end the presiding judge stated that there was enough to convict him of Susan's murder.
- 8:22In South Africa, the punishment for murder is death, that is,
- 8:26unless there were some sort of extenuating circumstances involved. The defense had only a
- 8:33couple of days to find evidence that would be able to save Ronald's life.
- 8:37This was made more difficult since Ronald still maintained he was innocent to do this.
- 8:43They hired a psychiatrist to examine Cohen. After conducting interviews with him,
- 8:48he testified that he found Ronald to be a responsible man whose life was centered
- 8:52around rules and regulations, which, in his opinion, Ronald strictly followed.
- 9:00No one believed the crime to be premeditated, and so the doctor assumed that
- 9:03something happened in the library that compelled Cohen to lash out at his wife,
- 9:07an action that went completely against his personality. The judge was moved by the
- 9:13report given by the psychiatrist and the fact that it didn't appear that Cohen had
- 9:18planned to kill Susan, since there was a firearm easily available for him to
- 9:22use if he wanted her dead. In the end, he was sentenced to
- 9:26twelve years imprisonment. To this day, no one really knows what happened in
- 9:31that library that night to cause Ronald to kill Susan. Or if there really
- 9:37was an intruder. Ronald maintained his innocence and remained mute on further details of
- 9:43that night.