Latest / Carbon Weekly News / Inside Europe's Largest Biomass Storage Deal | CWN EP4
Transcript
- speaker-0: The German government actually found out that 30 or more projects didn't really exist. speaker-2: nothing be happening, we kind of need to create the conditions of the Egyptian graves, so to say. speaker-1: That's encroaching on grass and cutting the tree back so the grass can grow. We do the opposite. We cut the grass so that the tree can grow. ⁓ but similarly, right, out of a hundred-year durability. speaker-0: Hello everyone. You're live or almost live back at CWN. I'm super happy to have Dan with me again today. The new dream duo. Hey Dan, how's it going? speaker-1: Great. Feeling very excited for this. speaker-0: Excited, well rested or not. speaker-1: Not well rested, but very excited. speaker-0: That's that's all we need. Good vibes. So let's quickly look at the topics we have for today. And the first one is basically actually something about about Zenken, when we signed a big off take with carbon sate ⁓ over like fifty thousand tons over the next years. And I'm also super excited to have Fabian on the show just in a bit. So we will talk a little bit more about biomass storage and the deal in in general. I think There's lot to learn. There are not a lot of projects in biomass storage, but I think it's it's growing. ⁓ then we will talk about that BZO ⁓ publish the X ante ratings of 14 Microsoft backed removal projects. I'm not sure, Dan. Are you also in there? speaker-2: and speaker-1: We are not. ⁓ I saw Brazil was left off than the countries. And so I also don't have a B0 account, so I can't log in to report. But ⁓ you tell me. I'm pretty sure we're not in there. They saw what I saw on the list of projects and countries. speaker-0: I have an account. Yeah, yeah, yeah. I I was wondering. but yeah, so that that's something we're gonna talk about. Then I'm not sure if you heard about it, but the Germans probably did. There were a couple of carbon projects for like a German carbon scheme that actually found these were like just shadow projects. They're like forged documents, fake audits. bribery and so on, mind blowing. It's not in the voluntary carbon market. So that's really important to mention here. So they follow a completely different structure and auditing ⁓ structure. But still I think crazy to to still read these kind of headlines. And then also the last topic is we talking a little bit about ⁓ Google's applic ⁓ open application for the carbon removal and superpollutant R D. ⁓ awards which I think is quite interesting. Cool. Let's dig in. Let's let's start with with Karmsate. so super exciting. I think what what I'm really excited about this is obviously that it's in Southern Africa. No. because you know I'm ⁓ in in South Africa but speaker-1: Love it. speaker-0: In general about that pathway, right? So I think a lot of people always then ask me like, ⁓ it's biochar. Well I said, no, no, it's it has some similarities, biomass storage. And in the past it was always called biomass burial, but I think that sounded maybe a little bit weird. So I think the community agreed upon that it should be called biomass storage. And so it's not biochar, it also uses biomass ⁓ but it is a little bit different. Right. So instead of like paralyzing ⁓ the the feedstock and therefore get the biochar, it actually is different to an extent that you also use biomass, ⁓ in this case like encroaching bushes, and then you bury them in their different kind of ways to do it. They're in mining pits and so on and so forth. And then you store them there for for a long while. I re I read from another project that compared it a little bit with Egypt and the pharaohs, where they said, look, ⁓ this got also got buried and after like thousands of years, they actually uncovered it and everything was in really good ⁓ condition. So this is a little bit the thinking, how you can picture that. I'm not sure if have you come across any of these projects then. speaker-1: Yeah. I I think as a as a carbon project developer that is focused on building forests and growing biomass, I often am a little bit hesitant on this one because I sort of say, wait, shouldn't we just be leaving the biomass standing above the ground and can't we and get the most benefit of just keeping it growing? But of course you travel to all parts of the globe and you see people with massive burn piles just lighting biomass on fire to make room for a new crop. ⁓ whatever it might be, all you know, all over the place. And so clearly figuring out something better than burning to do with a lot of this biomass is super important. ⁓ so yeah, I've I've seen, you know, Charm Industrial to some extent is a version of this, if you think about it. There are obviously a lot of biochar projects that you could also think about different, but ⁓ you know, we can get into those distinctions a little bit, right? But what do we do with this waste biomass? Right. And so and then I've also looked a little bit at graphite. So another project that's building, you know, that that's burying speaker-0: We also looked at it and also obviously it was the first one with a rating. It I think it first got an A rating, then it even got upgraded to double A on on B zero. Obviously that's always exciting because there are not that many projects, ⁓ especially in C D R with ratings. And so we talked to them a couple of times. speaker-1: Yeah. I think the projects are, you know, particularly from the standpoint of how do we find the right balance between durability and price point, seems like these projects have a unique opportunity to to bridge that gap. ⁓ I think they obviously they they are significantly different in from a durability standpoint from some of these long-term, long storage approaches, like charm perhaps where you're taking something and turning it into an oil and then pumping that oil underground. But of course the the benefit here is cost, right? If we can find a way to do this at a much more attractive cost, ⁓ then we have a relatively high durability and and relatively low cost credit. And I think that's the really exciting part about this. speaker-0: Yeah, I think one thing that we really have to look out for is and I mean a lot of people ask us exactly that is around the life cycle of that that feedstock, right? Because in ⁓ comparison to to biochar, it's it's not like a full on cycle, right? ⁓ so we really have to look like where's the feedstock coming from and so on and so forth. That doesn't mean Like bioch is always the better decision because it really depends like where is the the feed stock like financing perspective, how distributed is it, and so on and so forth. ⁓ but yeah, so really exciting ⁓ to talk about that actually with the ⁓ farmland CEO of of Carbon Sate, ⁓ who we have on the show today. Fabian, nice to meet you, nice to have you. Or meet you not. I met you a couple of times, but nice to see you. ⁓ speaker-2: Yes, it's great. Thanks for having me. Great to meet you, Dan as well. Yeah, happy to jump right in. speaker-0: Yeah, cool. Cool. Like let's let's get that started. How you actually got into this. Like how did you get into the world of carbon and how did you get to start a company from Germany with a project in Namibia? It's quite a stretch. speaker-2: Yeah, that's true. mean, it all started basically already during my research. I think all of my projects are very research focused. I'd like to read papers and then stumble across this idea, which seems promising, but hasn't been done in a commercial way. And this was basically exactly like that. I read this paper of this American professor who conceptualized this process, not in Egypt, but in very similar like burial sites in Europe or North America where they have found wood thousands of years old. And then I thought, well, this seems very elegant. We should do this in a commercial scale. So we set out to founded carbon state, look for biomass opportunities in Europe and Germany, which there are many, but founded to be kind of difficult because the biomass market is very saturated already in these, or at least in Europe. And then we kind of stumbled across this opportunity of biomass availability in Namibia with this encroaching bush. And then of course we didn't have any contacts. We reached out to people doing biochar projects in Namibia, which are of course the obvious first, the obvious subjects for these kinds of things. So we talked to them and through a longer process. then kind of got in contact with our now project partner. And of course, Namibia is by history also a country that has ⁓ a longer standing, not only positive connection to Germany. So there was already also the connection of a big German community in Namibia, which we then encountered, which we were all very interested in this as well. So yeah, this is how we ended up there in Namibia for now. speaker-0: Fantastic. speaker-1: What's the life cycle for this specific feedstock? Like what what is the land being cleared of that feedstock to make way for, you know, just to understand. I know there are always a lot of questions around sourcing of feedstock. Is it really a waste? What would otherwise be happening to it? Talk to me a little bit about this. speaker-2: I mean, this opportunity is very unique in the sense ⁓ that ⁓ it's kind of, it's called an encroaching bush, but it is not necessarily an invasive species that we would understand like an eucalyptus tree in South America is invasive, but it is growing excessively in the savanna. Like usually a savanna is a ⁓ place where you have some larger trees, some bushes, and then a lot of grass. And this is grass is also what all the animals eat that we ⁓ love to see in the savanna. But now the bush is overgrowing out of that, so there's almost no grass left. The animals don't eat this thorny bush, and the bush is sucking up a lot of groundwater, and it's not helping the water that is falling to actually penetrate into the ground and go into the groundwater, but it's running off quicker. So there are a lot of ecological problems with this encroaching bush. which has of course also been caused by the humans in the past by overgrazing the land. So now the farmers have always been looking for ways to remove this and there are of course ways to do this the right way, selectively taking out the right bushes, not just taking everything. ⁓ So this is what we are now partnering with the experts in, basically the farmers who know how to really restore their land. but they have always had the problem of this bush is just this thorny material which has no economic value for construction or anything else. So they mostly just pyburn it. And so, yeah, this is the biomass narrative. speaker-0: When you started a project d did you ever consider like doing a biochap project, or was it just not like an an option in that specific setup? speaker-2: I mean, it was always, we were always going to do a biomass storage and of course a great biomass storage fan. And this is the technology kind of we came not up with, but we spearheaded. So there was never even the thinking of doing a Biochar project, but I'm definitely not opposed to Biochar projects, especially also in Namibia. There are a lot in the biomass narrative for Biochar projects in Namibia is obviously the same as for us. So they're also very good. speaker-1: How do you compete against those biochar projects? What's your selling point to a buyer when they're wondering why they shouldn't just be supporting the the biochar project down the street? speaker-2: Yeah, I mean, I would say the difference is that we, of course, take a kind of 100 % of the carbon that is in the original biomass and store that 100%. We don't lose anything during the pyrolysis process. So I think this is of course a big efficiency and like this carbon removal efficiency point, which motivates me to do a biomass storage instead of biochar. And why then we of course lose some potential co-benefits for the use of the biochar downstream. I think it always depends on can the biochar actually be used in the region where it is produced. And I think also there Namibia has some limitations of using a lot of biochar in agriculture. So I always see this more as a nod either or. biochar or biomass storage by the combined effort. A biochar should use biofeedstock which is more liable, more ⁓ prone to decomposition because they are the sharing process actually makes a difference. You create something which is more durable afterwards. If you have woody feedstock which is already in itself very resistant to decomposition especially under the conditions in Namibia from the ⁓ efficiency standpoint, it doesn't make any sense to turn this into a Biochar from my perspective to just then kind of also store it underground because there's ⁓ just limited usage for the Biochar. So this is my stance. But yeah, I'm not saying that we shouldn't do Biochar. We should definitely do that as well. And but yeah. speaker-0: And on the MRV perspective, like I'm always thinking, but maybe I'm wrong, you you can tell me, or maybe then you also have the thinking on that. But isn't it easier to do MRV on how much carbon is still buried compared to the biochar that you maybe spread on agriculture and after a hundred years speaker-2: Definitely. ⁓ we have all the biomass combined in one big space and we can check if it's still there. We have our sensors that sit within the biomass to see if it is decomposing and to what extent. We can just go there visually and see is it still there. While with Biochar, of course, you can't do any of that. ⁓ that is definitely an advantage, although of course Biochar is inherently more stable than the original kind of biomass, so they might not need to do that that much. But I think that's the of the trade-off, of course. But yeah, thereby we can also provide more visible feedback to customers, of course, to show them here. This is the project that you financed. You can go there, look at the biomass basically, which is underground, of course, but You can stand on it. A biochar project that's very distributed, you don't really know where is the biochar exactly. speaker-1: It's a lot of interesting parallels and maybe like reversals to what we do in a reforestation project, right? You're taking a tree that's encroaching on grass and cutting the tree back so the grass can grow. We do the opposite. We cut the grass so that the tree can grow. ⁓ but similarly, right, kind of 100-year durability based on being able to physically inspect the thing, which also kind of begs this question of. How do you foresee that looking eighty years from now when, you know, we get asked this question? How do you guys answer that question of eighty years from now, if you're not the one that is managing that ⁓ crypt, or I'm sure you have a better word for it than ⁓ underground storage space, how d how do you justify to a buyer that it will still be there many decades from now? speaker-2: Yeah. I mean, I think this is the biggest challenge for most CDR approaches, right? How can we prove permanence in a world where we don't even know what happens next year to tell them that we know that it's really there for the next hundred years? And I think it all comes down to what Adrian was saying in the beginning, we need to create these conditions where it is inherently stable so that we don't need to actively manage it to be safe. So as long it... It is dry and there is no oxygen getting through the biomass. will nothing be happening. We kind of need to create the conditions of the Egyptian graves, so to say. And then kind of make the storage site so independent of our action that it kind of stays there forever. ⁓ It ideally without anybody knowing kind of in the sense that no one, yeah, that it just continues to be there forever. then. There's really not much I can see going wrong. Legally, of course, also, but... speaker-0: figure that out, right? Especially like for forests, maybe it's hundred years. But I always think about like what if you at a certain point have to prove it for a thousand years. speaker-2: I mean, I think the legal aspect is very difficult because as mentioned, we don't really know what happens in the next 10 years legally also. So how can we assure that there's a legal system operating in Namibia and or anywhere around the world in a hundred or even a thousand years, right? And this might be the part that You might want to cut out later, but my stance on this is basically if we don't have a legal system ⁓ in place in a hundred years or in a thousand years, that we also don't need carbon removal anymore. this is as long as we have a society where we want to survive as a society and have a functioning ⁓ system, we will have legal measures keeping those storage sites safe. And if the society collapses and we don't have any ⁓ loss anymore, then why do we need to cover and remove it? speaker-0: Let's not go too much into ⁓ still have a a world in in hundred years, but rather let's say okay, we still have a legal system and we still have countries and governments. speaker-2: I mean, believe in that. All the legal requirements are met, but yeah, it's just very hard to foresee a future where I can tell somebody now, yeah, we will definitely have a legal system in a thousand years, which will prevent anybody from doing anything that we set up now in a contract. yeah. And therefore I would always argue, speaker-0: Yeah. speaker-2: we can rely on a legal system to protect our storage sites. We need to design them in a way that they are safe even without legal system in place because ⁓ this would obviously make it even better. speaker-1: Does that does one of the shapes that that take mean that it doesn't use up land? I these are these storage sites actively using land and preventing it from being used for other use cases, right? That's one of the challenges with a forest. I would just I would imagine you could either go underneath agricultural land. So you're again you're not taking up kind of useful space. Maybe you're taking up ⁓ if someone wanted to come and mine there, that might be the biggest impediment to your long term storage. But I I'm not sure. Tell me a little bit about how you how does this work with the space that it uses? speaker-2: Yes. This is definitely exactly how it is. So we design our storage spaces to be able to be used afterwards for basically anything except for mining. And of course, before that select spaces where there won't be any mining happening. ⁓ especially there in Namibia, the land is very vast and our storage sites compared to that are very small, even though they can potentially hold tens of thousands of tons. ⁓ They are in places where no one will ever build anything and they can have cattle on it still. They can even do solar farms. You could even build houses on it if you wanted to. I wouldn't recommend it necessarily, but ⁓ you can do basically anything so that even in the future, if people want to repurpose the land, they will not have a reason to disturb the storage site. speaker-0: Let's not talk about a hundred years from now, but rather like f f let's say where where is Fabian and Carbon Sate in in three years? speaker-2: ⁓ Still in Namibia, delivering your credits. speaker-0: I mean I'm I'm visiting in October, so you better be there in October. speaker-2: I definitely will be. And we are looking of course already now in other regions where there is a lot of biomass available beyond Namibia. Of course we have the obvious contenders like Botswana and South Africa where we see a lot of biomass opportunities where we are engaging with project opportunities also in Mozambique, I think general south of Africa is very interesting, but of course South America as well. Our vision is to utilize, as you mentioned, Dan, all these pits laying around the world, all these piles of biomass laying around to potentially use them all. ⁓ And that is kind of what we're working towards now starting in Namibia. speaker-0: Cool. Fabian, thanks so much for coming over. And I'm I'm very excited for it. Obviously, I'm I'm involved now. I'm I'm can't I can't be objective. Yeah. ⁓ so I wish you all the best. speaker-2: Yeah, thank you. speaker-1: Yeah, thanks so Phoebe. Good to meet you. And good luck. speaker-0: Yeah, have a good one. Cheers. Bye. Right. Then let's get to the next point, which is about Microsoft and B Zero. So basically, BZero publishes well published fourteen pre-issuance ratings from Microsoft Carbon Removal Portfolio. So basically, I mean, we've been with B Zero for quite a while. It's quite important for our customers ⁓ to compare the ratings from B Zero, Severa, and so on. And I would say ninety-nine count nine percent of all the ratings on B0 are X post. So basically about ⁓ projects that already issued credits and then they got rated. So ⁓ these are ex ante, so pre-issuance ⁓ ratings and they're not a lot. So because I just went into the platform quickly before to check what is the list of projects, and I think it's basically all the projects. that you see that ⁓ pre issuance. And ⁓ I mean, I I think quite interesting. I saw obviously, I just scrolled through it quickly, that ⁓ a lot of them ranked really well. Right. There's a lot of like a double A A and so on. Didn't go into detail. But I think ⁓ yeah, it's just quite interesting to now to see pre issuance ratings, which obviously have a little bit of a different weight, I would say, than ex post rating. But then as a project developer, like what what's your opinion on on ratings? Are you with Mombak? Did you ever like interact with with rating agencies? speaker-1: Yeah, well, first off, I think it this I would hope that most of the projects are getting really high ratings or all of the projects are getting really high ratings. ⁓ you know, obviously Microsoft does quite a deep due diligence process with suppliers that doesn't necessarily involve ⁓ the ratings agencies directly. But the fact that the ratings agencies are aligning with the work that Microsoft independently is doing and finding that the projects are of high quality is is obviously reassuring for For us as a supplier to Microsoft who has not yet been rated, ⁓ we were not a part of this initial fourteen. So we'll see if they if they come for us next, although ours will now be ex post because of speaker-0: about to say you're you're too late. speaker-1: Yeah, exactly. Yeah. We we have thought a lot about ratings over the years. I think the it's always been a question as to whether we should ⁓ seek a rating. A lot of our buyers, again, like a Microsoft, have often done their own independent diligence and hired some group to support them in technical diligence. And so it hasn't been as critical for a lot of those early buyers to have a rating. But particularly as projects approach the spot market or look to smaller buyers, ⁓ broader market access, I think there clearly is is some benefit to being rated. And so it's something that now that the project is is ex post or would would be getting an ex post rating, we are also still trying to to go through that process. So I think we're we're a little apprehensive of dropping a big check to pay to accelerate the process of rating, which is how a lot of these ratings ratings agencies are now interacting with developers. ⁓ that that just often has not felt right to me that we would need to pay for it to be rated or to to get accelerated. At the same time, we want to be able to provide deeper diligence materials and support a ratings agency through a process. So I can I can understand it, but again, it's just been a little bit ⁓ you know, it's been something that's held us back from from paying to get the project rated at this stage or earlier in the in the game. speaker-0: I mean my honest opinion is I I don't think you need a rating because I think there are two reasons why someone should get a rating. It's either you as a project developer haven't got the authority and the trust and the standing within the corporate world especially to sell your credits and scale the project. Right? Then a rating is fantastic. Because you can say, hey guys, I'm new to the market. ⁓ but hey, there is someone third party that said I have an A rating and I know from experience that a corporate immediately puts you in a different bucket, even though they haven't heard about you. If you come to the table and say, like I have now rating, I'm completely new or hey, I'm could also be the other way around. Like I've been on the market for a while, but I have a very bad rating. ⁓ there's just it's it's you you kick off the conversation ⁓ on a on a at a different from a different point, right? So that's that's a one reason why why you should get a rating. ⁓ and the other thing the other reason why you should get a rating is I have seen procurement processes ⁓ where rating is a is a must, actually now. A couple of times where they say, like, hey, the rating needs to be at least double B and better, triple B and better. ⁓ and why is that the case? I think that the team running it, the the the RFP or the whatever it is, they would not need it. But the moment they have to present different kind of project choices to the leadership, they understand ratings. So they say, like, look. These two projects have the same price. This one has a rating, this doesn't. They don't de sometimes don't look any deeper. They just say, like, let's go with the one with the rating, because I understand ratings and I feel a little bit more secure. Sure. So that's definitely something we've seen because I always say, like, look, you already worked with Zencken. We do the due diligence and we go in like first of we're not being paid for it because we always say like you only pay when a transaction went through. and the other thing is we also go deeper on like things like biodiversity and so on. I think ⁓ the the ratings go really deep into the actual carbon, like permanence, additionality, leakage and so on. ⁓ but I still encourage some projects and say, like, hey, I think a rating could could help us in this process. So even I, even though we say we do due diligence. But To be honest, like if you as a monbuck, you're in a different position already, I I wouldn't necessarily say it would give you that much from my standpoint. speaker-1: Yeah. We've similarly seen some RFPs come through where there is a rating required or they ask if you're open to getting a rating if you don't already have one. So ⁓ yeah, I I think it's I think for very early stage projects, especially my if there might be something novel about the project and you need validation, it'll help with that first initial screen, even with an experienced buyer, right? It'll just it'll get you in the door faster. even if you're gonna have to do deeper diligence because of the fact that you could have a a carbon removal curve validated or a biodiversity approach validated or or something like that, which I do think there is can be some value to you. But you know, we've been through too many ⁓ deep diligence processes now from many different entities that yeah, it it's it they end up feeling very similar. ⁓ And you sort of wish you could just democratize the knowledge that one of these groups has because they've been very deep in the project, but it's always, you know, closed door off just for a specific buyer or something like that. So it'll be interesting to see how this evolves as we have more projects coming online now and you know, more more projects issuing credits. ⁓ because I imagine ratings will play a a stronger part as the market evolves. speaker-0: ⁓ Yeah, I think it's really important to for scaling the market, right? It's it's way easier for ⁓ a strategy G procurement and so on team to go through even a thousand projects. But ⁓ if there are suddenly like ten thousand, twenty thousand projects on the market and you really have to figure out like, okay, how do how do these compare? I think it it's it's quite nice. And also for pricing. I think it's quite interesting to ⁓ put the correlation of ratings with pricing together. And I've seen that like two years ago there has has been no correlation. And only over the last twelve months you can see it on like ⁓ Sebara, B zero, ⁓ Calyx Global. I think they also have with with clear blue ⁓ like an in index that over the last year there's like a massive gap. They have like triple like for instance ARR, triple B and better and ARR and double B and less, like it goes like this, ⁓ on the curve like this. ⁓ so I think that is quite an interesting thing for me to see. speaker-1: It's good to see some things working the way they're supposed to. speaker-0: Exactly, exactly. But also crazy that there was nothing in the past. ⁓ so basically the market was just like, This is a project, great, here's a price. Like, give me any price for ARR. ⁓ cool. All right. ⁓ coming from quality to not so much quality, I I think I I was completely shocked when I seen this headline. It was all over the German news. Well ⁓ the German government actually found out that thirty or more projects actually yeah didn't really exist, didn't really have impact ⁓ from like a national scheme that is called UER Upstream Emission Reductions and This is really crazy. This is like really important to say. This is not the voluntary carbon market. It's completely different system. It has way less like stringent standards that you follow. There is there are auditors involved, like even like TÜV and so on, to check it ⁓ on these things. But ⁓ yeah, I I think still crazy to see these kind of headlines. and for me it shows that maybe things like ⁓ like ratings or players like us in general are still very important, even though I think it is getting tougher and tougher to do these kind of ⁓ fraudulent things in in the voluntary carbon. speaker-1: Yeah, it's it is a shame to s to see. I mean, we obviously there have been a number of whether it's a Guardian article or a carbon plan piece on some of the challenges in the carbon market over recent years, ⁓ with projects that made claims, whether it was for additionality or one thing or another, that or even the the method underpinning ⁓ that that had some big gaps in it. And ⁓ you know, as you said, this is this is compliance market. ⁓ We always think compliance is supposed to be, I don't know, at least in my mind, I have this image of compliance being a higher quality standard. Regulated, like, shouldn't a regulated thing be better? But but of course, as you said, right, you have a lot of third party audits and checks and so on, maybe in the compliance market that are just different from those that happen in the voluntary market today and and more players looking into these things. And and you could imagine also if it's compliance, you sort of speaker-0: Yeah. speaker-1: glaze over that because you say, ⁓ somebody else must be taking care of it. Maybe I don't need to do the same degree of checks. But you know, nevertheless, it is, it is a challenge. ⁓ I do think that in the voluntary market today, as we look at some of the newer methodologies and newer registries, it seems like this is going to have to reduce over time. You know, if you're if you're doing a reforestation project with isometric as we are, they're doing Checks as well as a third party doing checks using remote sensing to see where the planting is happening and to check the additionality. And the project developer is not even doing any of that work. It's actually being done entirely by the registry and then checked by a third party body. So it would be really hard, for example, to not plant a tree and claim that you had done some reforestation project and to send in a bunch of faulty measurements. You just you wouldn't end up being able to generate a credit. That would have been possible in a more manual system as many of the registries previously had with their methodologies. But you know, ⁓ similar things are happening now in other methodologies too. I just speak about the reforestation as an example. So I again I I have to imagine that we're gonna see less of this going forward, but it it does not help, ⁓ it doesn't help market momentum. speaker-0: Yeah, but it's exactly what you said. Like I think also of in the past, I even had some ⁓ buyers, some customers of ours now, that instead of buying carbon credits from the voluntary market, they bought ⁓ the allowances from the EU ETS because they said, Hey, this is a compliance scheme, this is 100% right, and so on. There's also not this ⁓ UER. ⁓ but They literally then think it's compliance, it's governmental, it's hundred percent right. But I actually think the scrutiny on the voluntary carbon market over the last couple of years made this market ⁓ a really good market, like from a quality perspective, right? Obviously there's still old projects in the market, but I think with the new standards it's so tough. Something like this could never happen, right? Because these were literally projects that didn't happen at all. ⁓ 30 of them I think in China and overall 45 ⁓ projects couldn't happen at all because you would have some kind of MRV, you would have some kind of ⁓ like censoring and so on and so forth, which under these kind of standards apparently, even though it's a compliance scheme, was was not mandatory. So I I I think it's I think we have to get loose from that kind of connotation that compliance Is better than voluntary. And we also know these two are merging anyways kind of, right? speaker-1: Yeah, exactly. I think I've talked to a bunch of folks who operate in the compliance markets in Australia with projects, soil carbon projects and some forestry projects as well. And in addition to the fact that ⁓ there can be significantly more relaxed rules, as you're saying, for you know as a result of how the methodologies develop, which is completely independent of the voluntary market methodologies. Pricing often can be quite challenging in some of those markets. And so there are actually a number of projects in Australia that are now thinking, hey, we had been reliant upon this compliance market and thought, look at us, we're so far ahead of the rest of the world. We've got a compliance market that's already operating. But now they're seeing I can't differentiate even if I'm doing a really good project as a result of that. I'm not really getting a good price. For what is a high quality project. And so they're actually looking at, ⁓ maybe I should take this project off of the compliance registry and send this back to a voluntary registry because there I'll be able to differentiate to have my MRV and so on if I'm doing a real project. Because there are there are a bunch of methods, for example, in some of these schemes where the thing is completely model based and it's basically pick your point on the map and I will tell you how many credits per year you're gonna get if you do a practice. I'm basically not monitoring at all to come and check to see if you've done it. And so it's, as you said, leaves the room open for, you know, a project that just says, okay, I've got the paperwork to file. I'm at this spot. But if there's no sort of check of that, I can I can get by you know much more easily. I can skirt by the the system. So ⁓ not to say that that's happened specifically in Australia, but, you know, again, I think the the voluntary market has really worked hard in recent years to improve the the MRV processes and the the checks that are being put in place to make sure stuff like that doesn't happen. speaker-0: Fantastic, yeah. All right. Think it's a little bit like a roller coaster today. We go from quality to not quality and now to some exciting things again, which is about the Google Climate R D awards for carbon removal, they they call it. Which I think is amazing. And what they're basically doing is they're offering research awards of up to five hundred thousand dollars per project. across like carbon removal and superpollutant mitigation. And then they also have some like perennial agriculture category offering up to 800,000. This is like your your home turf from from back in the days. But I think it's just this is I think something great. And I'm always like there I have this proper envy to the US as a European, you know, where I'm like a European company would not do this somehow. Or like They would do this way too late. Whereas ⁓ Google ⁓ is doing this right now. And I I I think it's super exciting that they are basically trying to bring this market forward, right? Because I think these are like areas where you are either really dependent on grants, maybe even dependent on VC money, ⁓ or of some kind of buyer that just gives you like a or has has too much trust into you. I don't know. But ⁓ like these kind of things can can really help. So I'm I'm I'm very excited about it ⁓ for these kind of things. I'm not sure is is Google a a Mombuck customer? speaker-1: Hmm, good question. ⁓ we we are a supplier. We're actually their largest supplier. I think that still holds ⁓ across any of the pathways. ⁓ but they yeah, I've been very impressed to see the way that they're stepping into helping fund early research. We we do have a pretty amazing system in the US for this, is just as you're saying, I think, and we've seen it even in the carbon market, right? Groups like Frontier. ⁓ have had research awards, effectively research awards in the sense that they were doing pre-purchases for very high per credit dollar amounts of projects that were yet to actually get to ⁓ to viability. And and so, you know, effectively this is like grant money. and ⁓ also cascade. I think Google had stepped in with Cascade to announce a set of RD grants previously ⁓ and in the enhanced rock weathering space, there have been a number of these. So, you know, it's been really great to see that this is not something that just has to be government or university funded. I think we're at this very interesting moment where the companies are actually the ones that need the fastest action and the fastest iteration from the project developer community. And project developers also are taking on this really interesting hybrid role where they are having to be research organizations at the same time that they are. you know, industry players and they're trying to balance this sort of how do I supply a credit today while also make tomorrow's credit cheaper? And because that's what they're being demanded of, right? speaker-0: It's almost the same as the LLMs, right? Like ⁓ Anthropic, OpenAI and so on, having to be research labs, but also having to like give a good enough product to the world and basically have industry clients and so on. I never thought about it, it just popped up, but it's is a it's an interesting comparison, right? speaker-1: Yeah. No, absolutely. I think obviously there's been some good and some bad to this as well, you could say, in the sense that there have been a bunch of developers who got funding early on, either from a combination of grants and then big off takes that were signed where those methods have not yet been able to scale. And that's then cast doubt on entire pathways or entire approaches. And so we saw. We you know, we've seen this happen with a bunch of of suppliers in the durable CDR space where just too too much too early from a promise perspective. But of course, grants are grants, right? These are not loans, these are not recoverable financing systems. So it's I think it's a a great recognition of hey, we know we're actually putting money into early projects that could fail. And I think that's actually a better approach than these kind of pre off takes because speaker-0: There is expectation. There is expectation. If you if you sign an off take and it's basically a masked research ⁓ grant, it's it's it's not a proper fit. speaker-1: Yeah, I think that's right. So do a research grant and then on the back of a grant have an off take or a research grant alongside of an off take and I'm really clear that hey, I'm I've got a pathway today. You're paying three hundred dollars per ton today for this thing. And I'm gonna work on some research that if I'm successful, I'm gonna bring your price down to a hundred and fifty because I'm and you're you're funding that breakthrough research with me. So I can try to get you there in our next offtake. But let's Let's not pay, you know, $2,000 for all these credits and expect I'm going to get credits from this new thing because that new thing might not work. So I think that's a really important feature of recognizing that these are awards and grants and stuff like that. speaker-0: Yeah, no, definitely. I also see these are the areas that we also talked to ⁓ talked about before that ⁓ still a little bit early on the maturity, like ocean alkalinity enhancement, where we know okay, that in theory there's a lot of potential, but how do we measure ⁓ that that sink? ⁓ which is quite interesting. And then they also look at which I found interesting to to nature-based side. to look at mangroves and basically their protection against sea level rise and leakage and so on and additionality, durability and so on. So I think that's it's goes through all like they have quite knowledge what is what are the the gaps in the market, I guess. ⁓ they looked at a lot and knowing okay, where do I have to deploy that money to basically place research bets. ⁓ that will also then help us in the future. So it's it's nice. But I also see that ⁓ they have super pollutants in there, right? I mean superpollutants a little bit like a a hype word over the last year it feels like because these kind of credits have been on the market before, right? ⁓ it's not like methane abatement and so on ⁓ hasn't had ⁓ credits on the market. I think ⁓ in my opinion was create marketing to put it under the umbrella term super pollutants because it sounds fantastic. ⁓ I don't want to talk like or make a case against that they're not important. I think especially for like short term impact they're quite important. But I find interest ⁓ I found it interesting as as this ⁓ term popped up. so I'm I'm also curious what comes out of that kind of research part. 'Cause for me it always felt like it's already quite quite researched, so to say. speaker-1: I I agree with you. I think ⁓ it's great. It is great marketing. ⁓ and there have been people have been capping gas wells and, you know, all kinds of other projects to abate methane. People have been thinking about doing projects to reduce methane emissions from ⁓ enteric ⁓ emissions of of cows, right? There's a lot of different methods that have been explored here. ⁓ there's been research actually in the last few years showing that tree bark is actually ⁓ removing methane. So maybe there'll be some superpollutant removal credits because if that happens and forest can generate those, then we're gonna, you know, Momak will be a unicorn overnight. But ⁓ this is ⁓ you know speaker-0: Except if you have a lot of elephants because elephants they take down the bark. Massive problem in the Kruger Park at the moment in South Africa. speaker-1: Not a lot of elephants in the Amazon in Brazil. So I think we maybe we have our match there. But but no, I think, you know, obviously I'm I'm a firm believer in an all of the above strategy. We have to explore every possible pathway here. I think part of the challenge with the superballutin buzz and focus is the question of okay, size of the prize, how do we start to how do we How do we separate our investments in these near-term things and also the long-term stuff? And are we are we giving up on the long term? Are we really putting equal focus on both at the same time? What's the right way to to fund programs across the board that that are gonna give us the most ⁓ removal ⁓ over overall? And so obviously from a warming perspective, trying to help solve these near-term emissions makes sense. ⁓ and You know, we do need we actually do need global reduction in warming as fast as we can. And so from that perspective, again, you should be going after methane. But ⁓ maybe maybe a reforestation project will have multiple ways to get there if we can if we can figure out this tree bark thing. So speaker-0: Everything everywhere all at once. Cool then. So coming to the end of the episode, ⁓ excited to yeah, to kick the ball with you around the topics and ⁓ yeah, I think already looking forward to the next one. speaker-1: Exactly. We didn't reveal any big secrets this time from our personal lives. Maybe on the next one we'll we'll find another way to to weave the speaker-0: I would think about it, ⁓ I I I have one for you right now. ⁓ which is I won the national championship in golfing when I was twelve in Germany, but I only started a year before because I played football and my father never watched football with me or like watched my games and he was always playing golf and then I said, Okay, I'll play golf and then you can't watch speaker-1: Did he watch you win? speaker-0: You watched me win. speaker-1: Right. Well that's good. That's great. I I'm horrible at golf, but I ⁓ speaker-0: I have I I played it maybe five times since then. I immediately stopped afterwards. speaker-1: You just wanted to prove that it was possible. You're like ⁓ is it the the the founder of of Google Brain did the same thing in chess. He was like a world chess champion and then he won one masters or something like that and said, Okay, I I proved that it's possible, now I'm out. speaker-0: Literally. Yeah, no. I actually I actually dislike it. I'm not ⁓ I d I don't enjoy g doing it. I'm more like a football, tennis, surfing kind of stuff. speaker-1: Yeah, makes sense. Makes sense. All right. I'll I'll think of a good one for for the next one. My brain is not working very well after staying up for two days in a row, flying with young children internationally. So speaker-0: ⁓ you're you're on next time. Yeah. Chef. speaker-1: Cheers.