Latest / Meet My Business with Baird Media / What Your Recruiter Won’t Tell You About Getting Hired
Transcript
- 0:00JANICE: A client contacted me. They'd been struggling to fill their IT executive positions — it was taking anything from six months to a year to fill a vacancy. I was able to assist them with that.
- 0:13HENDRIK: Welcome to Meet My Business, the podcast where real businesses tell their real stories. My guest today is Janice Wagner from Edge Executive Search. Janice, welcome. Tell me who you are.
- 0:39JANICE: I actually studied to be a chartered accountant — because my maths teacher said my maths was so bad I'd never be one. After ten years at Coopers, I realised I didn't want to be a chartered accountant. And I find myself now in executive search.
- 0:55JANICE: My day is long. Up at four, gym for my me-time — half my clients are from the gym anyway. At work by eight, interviewing candidates all day. I say I speak nonsense all day, because I'm always talking to people. Then I box in the evening.
- 1:18HENDRIK: And the people closest to you — what do they say you do? JANICE: That I'm living my best life, because I get to speak to people all day. I love people, I love to hear your stories. I like to listen.
- 1:37JANICE: I was burnt out in auditing, and I'd never learned sales — the brand I worked for sold itself. When I started, no one wanted coffee with me, because who was I? It took nine months to get my first meeting. I never thought this would be what I did. I started my own business about 15 years ago. Many a day I wished I was still an auditor rather than starting on zero every month. But I love what I do.
- 2:23JANICE: It's recruitment, but I only do executive search — the headhunting. I look at your competitors. It's like sport: you give me a role, and when I place it, I feel like I scored the winning goal. We've also got a contracting desk and do middle management, but I do execs.
- 2:54JANICE: I've learned more in this industry than in ten years in audit, because every day I'm meeting new people and new industries — mining, financial services, FMCG. I'm learning every day.
- 3:14JANICE: On Mandela Day we put 400 graduates through training on how to get a job. It's much harder for youth now, with little guidance. There should be guidance from high school on what to study, because you need to know where the gaps are. In our day there were apprenticeships. And in the last year and a half, the ATS — the system that screens your CV — has changed a lot.
- 4:22JANICE: An ATS is a tracking system big corporates use. Submit your CV, and if it doesn't have the specific words from the spec, you're rejected. It doesn't read blocks or pictures. Kids need to be on LinkedIn, learning to network and build their brand. If there are 100 applicants, why would they choose you? You can practise to get a job — practise your strengths, your weaknesses, taking the interviewer on a journey.
- 5:28JANICE: The biggest early challenge was money — I started on none. I said to my family, give me nine months. No staff, just me, and the cats had recently died. I started in the loft, and I put a suit on every day so the mindset was right. My lucky break came that December: a client said, work the holidays and bring me CVs in January, and if it works, it works. And that's what I did.
- 6:16JANICE: What was harder than expected was building my own brand. Barriers to networking, barriers to entry — why would somebody want to work with you, how do you build that trust? And this was 15 years ago: no AI marketing, and LinkedIn was new. A very different environment.
- 6:50HENDRIK: Was there a point you thought of giving up? JANICE: Every entrepreneur thinks that every year. What keeps me going is passion — and my staff, because you realise you have an impact not just on that person but on the families behind them. If I give up, what about those families?
- 7:20JANICE: About a year in, I landed a large contract — 100 admitted attorneys to look after at any time. I coordinated with smaller businesses who became part of mine, and then we started hiring. A great project, and a real catalyst.
- 7:52JANICE: I've just turned 50. What I've learned is to control my emotions — give it time before you respond, don't sweat the small things. The big lesson this year was letting go. Everyone says work on your business, not in it; I resisted, thinking my clients want me alone. We're doing much better now I've got someone running ops who does it better than me. It's about trusting your staff with those relationships. I'll always quality-check everything, even spelling — but that's been my greatest learning.
- 9:17JANICE: What surprised me is that I'm still here. Covid was hard — South African industry had never interviewed online. The industry stopped, but you still had salaries to pay, and I'd just taken on graduates. So we pivoted: the staff offered a disinfecting service, just to keep the business alive. And we're still here 15 years later.
- 10:07JANICE: The client has a vacancy. First I need to understand the organisation — I like to walk the floors, because a candidate right for me may not be right for you. What problem are you solving with this person? Why did the last person leave? Then I map the market — that used to take weeks, now a couple of hours — and approach candidates. I still like to interview in person, to read body language. I have two clients: my candidates and my clients. Sometimes I'll send just one CV, if it's the right one. Then I help negotiate, and I check in over three, six, twelve months.
- 11:51JANICE: My ideal client lets me into their business and wants to partner — not just send a spec. I want to walk the floors, meet the players, hear what the top three people think the role is. I become your brand custodian, going to market telling people about you. The more I know about what differentiates you, why someone would leave a bigger player for you, the better.
- 12:50JANICE: On the candidate side, I do as many exploratory chats as I can — people reach out before there's even a vacancy. It's about building rapport and keeping the relationship going. One candidate told me his next move was CEO. It took us 11 years, but he's a CEO in a big hospitality group now. Eleven years — but the relationship lasted.
- 13:46JANICE: For the employer, in many cases you need to get on the PSL, the preferred supplier list. Then I touch base monthly — what's happening with the team, has someone left, what's coming in the next six months. I like to be ahead of the curve, pipelining a role before the vacancy opens, so we bring the time from order to placement down. My clients get measured on time-to-fill too.
- 14:44JANICE: What makes me different is my network. I've been blessed — an Uncle Dan took me to my very first client meeting, and those people are still in my life. One client took me from South Africa to Zimbabwe. I care about my clients and candidates, and they've stayed in my corner for 15 years.
- 15:22JANICE: Our industry has a bad name, because we don't get back to people. I try to change that — give candidates feedback on a Friday, even just to say you're still in play, rather than letting them hang. We've forgotten the industry is about people. It's become about commission. We should be honest — tell a candidate this isn't the organisation for you — and send a client three right candidates, not bombard them with 20. What's missing is the people element.
- 16:24JANICE: Solving unemployment is going to be about SMEs. There should be larger tax breaks for them — it's hard being an SME with the same labour laws as big corporate. Make labour laws a little easier and SMEs would take on more people. And we throw money at SMEs instead of training them to run a business and read a balance sheet. Let's build sustainable businesses, then they can take on staff — and measure how many graduates actually stay.
- 18:11JANICE: My clients know I interview candidates in person and I'm hard on vetting. I'm never going to send you a lot of candidates — I've got a brief now where I sent one CV, the perfect candidate. What I sell is trust. After so many years I know my companies, and I know what's a fit — yes or no.
- 18:46JANICE: A client just texted to say the interview is going well. I'm an A-type, so I'm always stressing. I take criticism hard — I'm working on it. But I'm the type who'll keep working a brief, even for a year, until I make the placement.
- 19:17JANICE: Talent planning: say there's a shortage of a technical skill. What a client should do is let us interview those candidates ready for you — you meet them, they like you as a brand, and you find reasons to stay in touch, invite them to events every three to six months. Then when the vacancy comes, you've got a pool of hard-to-find skills and can make the offer, because you really know the candidate.
- 20:09JANICE: I'd love a reference — but I love referrals even more, much stronger than someone answering an advert. That I was professional, fast, managed the whole process, understood the business, found the top candidate. We're also bringing skills back into Africa — taking Zimbabweans sitting in South Africa back to Zimbabwe for digital transformation.
- 21:05HENDRIK: So you work mainly with SMEs? JANICE: No — mainly corporate South Africa. HENDRIK: So what's the corporate environment like now, with the economy, the petrol price, the rand-dollar exchange?
- 21:30JANICE: I'll be controversial: since before Covid, this is probably our best year. Everyone thinks the market is busy January to March, but your busiest period is October to mid-December, and those placements are for the next year. We've been busy all year. If recruitment is happening, there's money and growth. There's been a lot of executive movement in government too. I disagree with the pessimism — I see South Africa on a great trajectory. Best year I've had since 2018.
- 22:41JANICE: Still put your CV on job boards, but if you can build a relationship with a recruiter, do that. Apply to LinkedIn adverts, but don't be upset if you get no response — it's not you, it's everyone; there might be two humans behind that ad. Do your own targeted search: go to a company's website, set reminders, see if you know someone. I'm big on branding and networking. What's your brand? Is your LinkedIn complete? Are you putting out thought leadership? How are you showing up?
- 24:24JANICE: There'll be basic jobs that AI can do. But if you take AI on — learn as much as you can, do a free certificate — you're a step ahead. If you know how to use AI and you've got your studies or experience, you're in a better position. I don't think we should fear it. I think we should take it on board.
- 25:05JANICE: For new grads: don't wait for January. If your degree ends in December, start looking in September — graduate programmes advertise then. I've already done two audit-firm intakes for 2027. Get on LinkedIn, fix your photo and profile. Go to networking events — it's easier to get a job through someone you know. One young woman at a graduate programme had a side hustle, found me, gave me a sample, connected that evening and followed up. I've already placed her for next year. She made herself memorable.
- 26:48JANICE: Does a placement ever go wrong after six months? It happens. On paper somebody looks great — which is why knowing the organisation matters. We had someone using the company vehicle for their own purposes; you won't see that on a CV, the references were good, no criminal record. For that we give a credit note or replace the candidate free of charge. It's the people element you can't see in a CV or interview.
- 27:44JANICE: You can't know everyone — that's the problem. References are key, but only if the person tells the truth, and a lot won't say why they really let someone go or why the person left.
- 28:12JANICE: Back to the opening story: it took a year. I mapped the market — honestly it's how I got into IT, now about 60% of our work. I interviewed everyone in the market; they became contacts. The client came in every Friday to interview the candidates I'd rated eight and above. We kept data, touched base every six months, organised events. He filled the whole structure — and it was great learning, because I was honest: I said, I don't know what an enterprise architect does.
- 29:13JANICE: Because I was an accountant, everyone assumed I'd understand financial services — I knew nothing. But I was honest: I'd say, I don't know what private banking is, and they taught me. That's why I've learned more doing this than in many years in the audit profession — because I've had to learn along the way.
- 29:52JANICE: I do this work because I love meeting people. I have a part of the business that looks after candidates living with disabilities — probably my favourite people to place, because you're making a real difference. I love seeing people progress. I feel like I'm part of your story, and I want to be — to remember you, to see you grow.
- 30:33JANICE: A lot of people reach out via LinkedIn, but I prefer email, so I can look at the CV and see if it fits something I'm working on. I'm on LinkedIn, and the business is Edge Executive Search. Most employers come through relationships built over the years — we get a lot less from marketing.
- 31:25JANICE: For job seekers: know your pitch, practise with your family, take the interviewer on a journey, build rapport. Research the client and ask something intelligent — don't ask about salary or team size, everyone does. And when they ask your weakness, don't say 'I'm a perfectionist' — 90% of South Africa says that. For the retrenched: stay positive, don't get desperate, people feel your energy. The tide is turning; I see a sea change coming for South Africa.
- 32:49HENDRIK: And for the employer? JANICE: Don't believe in the brain drain. We have top talent in South Africa — just look further. It might look different to how you thought, but the talent and the hard workers are here.
- 33:19HENDRIK: Janice, it's been a pleasure. The website is edgexec.co.za. And that is why stories like this need to be told. Every guest we've had on Meet My Business — business name, episode number and direct link — lives in one place: baird.media/meet-my-business.