Latest / Ensombl Advice Australia / Insurance Podcast #11 - Yvonne Chu
Transcript
- 0:00The Ensemble podcast is intended for professional financial advisors.
- 0:03This content is created in partnership with our sponsor, Zurich Australia Limited, ABN 9200 010 195 AFSL 232 510 and is limited to publicly available information.
- 0:14Before acting on any general advice, you should consider whether appropriate and obtain financial advice from a qualified financial advisor.
- 0:20Ensemble does not hold an AFS license and does not provide any financial advice or services or endorse any general advice.
- 0:30Thank you.
- 0:50Each episode features real conversations with the people who live and breathe this work every day, uncovering the lessons, processes, and the stories that help advisors lift confidence, capability, and client outcomes.
- 1:01Whether you write two policies a year or 200, this podcast is here to help you deliver better protection, build stronger businesses, and ultimately serve more Australians.
- 1:10Let's jump in.
- 1:13Zurich is proud to be supporting this episode.
- 1:16Experience Zurich and OnePath advisor portals with new and improved digital capabilities and an enhanced range of self-service functionality, helping make your business more efficient, saving you time and removing complexity.
- 1:30It's everything you need in one place.
- 1:32Partner with us today.
- 1:36Hi, everybody, and welcome.
- 1:39With me today is Yvonne Chu, Head of Technical and Power Planning at Australia's largest licensee group, Entirety.
- 1:46Welcome to the show.
- 1:47Thank you, Ben.
- 1:48It's an absolute pleasure.
- 1:49Thank you, because it's normally being an advisor inside Entirety, when I'm calling you, I'm not sure if it is a pleasure, because there's lots of technical, difficult questions that we run through.
- 1:57No, you know I love those.
- 1:59Yeah.
- 2:00Can you give me, please, and I know we've sort of spoken about this on and off, but I don't know a huge amount about it.
- 2:05Can you give me your background, how you got into advice, where the expertise comes from, how long you've been here, what you've done previous, all that sort of thing?
- 2:12Yep.
- 2:13I've been in the industry financial planning for more than 20 years.
- 2:16I spent a long time as a tech co, 20 years of experience at tech co.
- 2:20So tech co in terms of helping advisors with strategies, with technical strategies, deciphering tax, super insurance included, et cetera, et cetera.
- 2:30I was the head of technical Australian Unity since 2018 and prior to that, senior technical manager at Colonial First States award-winning first tech team.
- 2:39And at Australia Unity, I also look after the professional development area as well.
- 2:45And in the last two and a half years with entirety, since it's acquisition of Australia Unity's financial planning arm, I also look after a large team of power planners.
- 2:56So I do see a lot of...
- 3:00plans, including insurance plans that come through the team within the network, as well as I talk to advisor on a daily basis on strategies and in particular, an area of insurance, what to do if a client suffers an event and how we invest the money and what need to be mindful of.
- 3:18So yes, do this all the time.
- 3:20Right.
- 3:20So your experience, just based on that, I would call you top five in the country.
- 3:24So how many SOAs are you and your crew generating on a weekly basis?
- 3:28Yeah.
- 3:30Oh, let's have a count.
- 3:31The number flatuates, I reckon, 100 plus a week.
- 3:35Far out.
- 3:36Wow.
- 3:37That is phenomenal.
- 3:38Well done.
- 3:40Yeah, okay.
- 3:41That's great.
- 3:41I'm a bit blown away by that.
- 3:43And if you were to break it down between, again, the type of conversation, insurance versus all the other stuff, what would that look like?
- 3:51Technical-wise, look, I reckon it would probably be 80% super tax aged care estate planning.
- 3:59Insurance probably 20%.
- 4:01Insurance are typically going to the ownership structure, the taxation of it, as well as estate planning implications.
- 4:11A little bit of business insurance, not too much, you know.
- 4:15Yeah.
- 4:15Okay.
- 4:16And is that reflective of the wider pool, do you think, across, for example, entirely, right?
- 4:211,600 advisors.
- 4:22You think about one-fifth of the advice would be related to insurance or you think it's less than that or?
- 4:28It's hard to say because within the network, I think industry-wide, you have a very small group of risk-only advisors.
- 4:36So currently- Legends.
- 4:39Statistically, about 190 to 200 just risk-only advisors, and we have a few of those.
- 4:45They tend to be very in-depth, deep risk specialists who have spent many years in the space, knows the product, knows the insurer, knows a client, have very schmick
- 4:59processes and they are very successful in that space as well.
- 5:05But then I also see probably next 30%, 40% of all advisor groups and our network reflects that who dabbles into insurance.
- 5:16They are comprehensive providers.
- 5:17risk, comprehensive advice, holistic advisors.
- 5:22But if a need arises, if a client that identify insurance need, they will not shy away from it.
- 5:29They don't actively just look for insurance clients.
- 5:33But if a client has a need or if a client's children needs insurance, they will still offer the service.
- 5:39And then we have perhaps the next 20, 30% here that probably only do a – they have a back book.
- 5:47They don't actively want to write new insurance business, but if they really, really have to, then they may refer to another risk specialist.
- 5:55Or if it's simple, they do it themselves.
- 5:57But I see that poor advisor kind of shrinking more and more advisor either –
- 6:02completely don't want to do insurance at all, which is fine.
- 6:06And then for those advisors, we require them to refer to a specialist.
- 6:10Because when you look at the ethical obligations, FASIA Ethic Code of Ethics, you also look at best interest duty.
- 6:18If they identify a need, just because an advisor, for whatever reason, doesn't want to provide risk advice, they can't just ignore it.
- 6:27They have to refer the client on it.
- 6:29So, there's definitely a group of advisors who just... Can I ask, on that point there, right, where an advisor's choosing to scope out risk for whatever reason, do you see those SOAs come in?
- 6:40Yes.
- 6:43What are the sort of mistakes that are made...
- 6:46What are the tips and tricks around?
- 6:47Yeah, good question.
- 6:48So because in PowerPoint, we also, you know, first line of defence, we look at the compliance aspect.
- 6:53So when scoping, we know we can't 100% trust the client's word.
- 7:00If a client goes, I don't want insurance, an experienced advisor should at least ask why not.
- 7:07Is it because you can't afford it?
- 7:09If that's the case, then maybe an advisor should explore ways that insurance may be affordable, perhaps in size super or without jumping to solutions.
- 7:19Or is it because the client has health conditions?
- 7:22Or at least an advisor should explore why the client doesn't need insurance and document that they need to have evidence.
- 7:29And in fact...
- 7:30You know, if you look at past cases, Ravsky, it was a very prominent case where there was a nap where the advisor took the word of the client, the client goes, cancel insurance.
- 7:40The advisor didn't just cancel it.
- 7:42And without asking why you cancel it or explore other alternatives, then in the end, the advisor have to pay a part of the potentially policy that could have been.
- 7:53Yeah.
- 7:54So I think what we definitely with scoping, it's not good enough just to take the client's word for it.
- 8:00You have to explore and you have to understand.
- 8:03But sometimes, yes, like there could be a valid reason why there's no insurance, then that's fine.
- 8:08Okay.
- 8:09All right.
- 8:09So that's where a client says, I don't want insurance.
- 8:11What about if you're seeing a – so a client's seeing a holistic advisor and this holistic advisor is one of the guys that doesn't want to do insurance but there's a clear need –
- 8:20How does an advisor go about scoping that out of their advice and then referring the risk to someone else?
- 8:27So the advisor should make it clear to the client that they don't have expertise in this area.
- 8:33And it's up to the advisor whether they want to do a needs analysis or not.
- 8:38Sometimes they do and identify exactly what insurance needs they have and then refer on to a… Just quickly, does that seem a little crazy?
- 8:49Like if you're an advisor and you don't want to do it while you're doing a needs analysis, wouldn't you be better off just passing the client…
- 8:54It's optional.
- 8:55It's optional, but it also depends on the client circumstance.
- 8:58It depends on the need, because everyone's circumstance is different.
- 9:01Some client may have a huge amount of debt and young dependent children.
- 9:06It's more burning than perhaps someone who is in a much better financial position.
- 9:12Yeah.
- 9:13So, of the 100 SOAs a week.
- 9:17how often are you picking up errors or mistakes?
- 9:22You know, how often are you picking up exposures to the advisor on the compliance as it relates to life insurance?
- 9:28Actually, not as much as people think, to be honest.
- 9:33Obviously, in your power planning team, the advice hasn't been provided.
- 9:36We see mistakes.
- 9:37Don't get me wrong, we see mistakes.
- 9:39We see mistakes in the wrong quote have been prepared.
- 9:42It's just careless error.
- 9:43Right.
- 9:44I think I'm pretty guilty of that.
- 9:45So I've just had a red flush.
- 9:47Thank you.
- 9:48Everyone's human, right?
- 9:49Yeah, yeah.
- 9:49You know, that's why you use a good powerpoint service that can pick things like that up.
- 9:53Yeah.
- 9:54And this is actually reflective of all complaints overall.
- 9:59There's actually hardly any complaints when you look at AFCA or FSPC about wrong insurance advice.
- 10:09Usually where it falls down is where things won't get explained properly or there's implementation error or there's, you know, various other traps along the way in the, you know, the handover, the application process or whatever it may be.
- 10:26Then, yes, we do definitely see mistakes.
- 10:28We see sometimes advisors wrongly want to exclude insurance or they just don't want to cover it without adequate fine note explaining.
- 10:41Sometimes we see premiums going through super that's way too high.
- 10:47So just, sorry, I just want to go back.
- 10:48So where the client, sorry, where the advisor has excluded insurance advice and your team's picking up on that, what is the response back to the advisor?
- 10:58Is it a question of, we'll make, like, we've identified this risk and you haven't.
- 11:02You either need to be referring it or addressing it.
- 11:04Is that the sort of response that you have to that?
- 11:06Yep, yep.
- 11:06Yeah, we're not auditing, but then we know what's expected of the audits.
- 11:11A lot of time, it's actually just the advisor haven't had good documentation.
- 11:18So very often the advisor, oh, it's because XYZ.
- 11:21They've had the conversation, but they just didn't make it to the finite.
- 11:25Then that's a very easy solution, right?
- 11:28Well, you know, improve your finite.
- 11:31Because a lot of times that's what we found.
- 11:34It's not that advisors, to be honest, we don't have any dodgy advisors.
- 11:38I've rarely come across any dodgy advisors.
- 11:41No advisor intentionally want to do wrong things.
- 11:45But usually advisor can fall on the fine noting, the details of it.
- 11:50But nowadays with technology, fine note, AI, it is improving.
- 11:55But at the end of the day, you have to have that trade-off conversation.
- 11:58Yeah, I've got a family member who's a lawyer and they did a lot of work, I think, with NAB and the remediation following the Royal Commission.
- 12:04And they ended up calling it not, what was it, no service or fees for no service, but it was more fees for no file notes.
- 12:11So the advisor saying, yes, I did it.
- 12:12And they're like, well, there's no documentation.
- 12:14So too bad.
- 12:15Yeah, yeah.
- 12:16And that extends to a lot of things, even needs analysis, right?
- 12:20Advisor may have a needs analysis, but it may not be complete.
- 12:23It may be a little bit too brief, you know, where a third party looking at it couldn't figure out where that 1.2 million sum in show comes from.
- 12:35And then when you go back to the advisor, they'll be like, oh, it's easy.
- 12:39Or, you know, cover the debt, provide for the family.
- 12:42And these are the assumptions.
- 12:43Well, there you go.
- 12:44That's the gap, right?
- 12:45So, yes, we see little gaps.
- 12:48But we don't see major catastrophic wrongdoings.
- 12:52Yeah.
- 12:52There's heaps to unpack there.
- 12:54So, the first thing I want to ask about, and again, thank you for being a trooper.
- 12:59I know you're unwell.
- 12:59So, thank you for coming in, Harby.
- 13:01I was going to ask about the needs analysis.
- 13:03So...
- 13:04There's a million different ways to calculate sums insured.
- 13:08Do you include debt?
- 13:08Yes, no, medical, final expenses, all the rest of it.
- 13:12What do you see as a best practice or what do you see, and especially focusing on those financial advisors that are only riding a little bit of risk, how are they going about their needs analysis and how could they improve that?
- 13:24That's a very good question.
- 13:26Obviously ASIC doesn't prescribe a specific methodology.
- 13:30So whatever's reasonable.
- 13:32My suggestion is if an advisor, if they don't have a need and assess calculator, go get one.
- 13:40You know, insurers, almost all of them have a decent calculator.
- 13:45And then spend some time.
- 13:47It won't take you more than an hour or two.
- 13:48Sit down in the practice with other advisors in the practice.
- 13:51Come up with your own insurance philosophy.
- 13:54Because once you have insurance philosophy documented, there's abundant resource on the market.
- 14:00I mean, Zurich had their cost of care, which she can leverage to figure out, you know, what's the cost of potential medical expenses to allow for.
- 14:09And then document the philosophy and stick to it, be consistent, because when you look at all paths, legal, whatever, not just insurance everywhere, consistency tells a lot where you have to defend your actions.
- 14:23And then it doesn't need to be overly complicated, to be honest.
- 14:27What I've seen is nowadays the challenge with insurance need analysis is
- 14:34Advisors need to always keep in mind if you can't explain it or if you can't back it up or if the amount comes out exorbitantly high, you're at risk because the client could say, well, you're overinsuring me.
- 14:47It's costing me a hell of a lot more than it should be.
- 14:50But then if you come to a figure that's really low, then you run the risk of complaining yet again for under insurance.
- 14:57So a proper needs analysis, you need to bring – the advisor needs to have kind of own philosophy at the back of mind.
- 15:04Yeah.
- 15:05But then need to have the client in front of them and it should be a two-way discussion.
- 15:10Yeah.
- 15:11It shouldn't be a one-size-fit-all because different client of different age will have different needs.
- 15:19Yeah.
- 15:20Just on building a philosophy, right, with the Ensemble crew, I ran a couple of risk workshops for advisors that don't do much risk.
- 15:27And building that philosophy, Cain Learson schooled me from regional and he basically went into Clawed and he built an insurance philosophy around 30 seconds, right?
- 15:36And again, no client data, so we're using Clawed just for that sort of stuff.
- 15:38So that was absolutely brilliant.
- 15:39I did it and it's, again, just floored by how fast Copile and all the rest of it can do this stuff.
- 15:45With needs analysis specifically, I've seen various ones that take into account things like children's expenses, right?
- 15:52And they go, right, the child's in grade seven, so times an additional five years of private school, blah, blah, blah, blah, blah.
- 16:00My philosophy behind that is the client's income is X, so we just want to be able to replace X.
- 16:06Because if we replace X, they can afford all the stuff that they're going to do.
- 16:10Is there a – like, do you have a differentiator or is that –
- 16:14comfortable to do?
- 16:15Personally, Ben, I agree with you.
- 16:18Yeah.
- 16:18Because I've actually seen sometimes a virus that they'll fully cover all debt and then they will provide their surviving spouse, we're talking about death, their surviving spouse, their current living expense all the way to 65.
- 16:32Hmm.
- 16:33And then on top of that, they add private school cost.
- 16:39To me, that's way too much.
- 16:40Because if nothing happened to that person, you're not going to earn that much, right?
- 16:45You will earn your income, which will cover your debt, your children's education, and all that.
- 16:51So, to me, I will question the validity of that.
- 16:57That seems to be a little bit too excessive, especially in the current environment where premiums are very, very high.
- 17:04I'm with you.
- 17:05Keep it simple.
- 17:06Yeah, keep it simple.
- 17:08Cover your income.
- 17:10Maybe a little bit extra, perhaps...
- 17:12For TPD, a spouse may need to take some time off to care for the person, perhaps allow for some medical expenses.
- 17:21And private school fee, at the end of the day, you know, the question is, can you actually even afford it now?
- 17:29Well, I know I can't.
- 17:30So, you know, a lot of people, if you currently are struggling, that's like the child may be two and they already try to determine I'm going to send them to private school by the time in high school.
- 17:41But half the time, the parents probably realize, well, I can't afford it, right?
- 17:45Yeah.
- 17:46It may not transpire.
- 17:47Yep.
- 17:47I guess it's fine.
- 17:48If a client is happy to pay for it, then that's fine.
- 17:52But a lot of time what we found is advisor come up with figure based on all the good to have.
- 17:59And then get some quote and insurance print comes back and the advisor and the client just bulkhead it.
- 18:04Like, yeah, it's too much.
- 18:06That too much sound.
- 18:07And then it's okay.
- 18:08It's not the end of the day.
- 18:09What do you do?
- 18:09Then you slowly back pedal, pedal back.
- 18:13Do we really need that part of the show?
- 18:14Okay, two ways of doing this, right?
- 18:15And I'm curious to see what your feedback is on this.
- 18:18So the one that I've seen is where the client will, sorry, the advisor will complete the needs analysis, come out with a couple of million dollars worth of insurance, prepare the SOA, give it to the client, and the client says, whoa, that's crazy, right?
- 18:31But then what you end up doing is changing the ATP, so the authority to proceed, and the client is saying, hey, you've recommended five, but I'm going to take two, right?
- 18:39So you go, cool, it's safe.
- 18:41for the advisor and it does whatever it may be.
- 18:44The other side of it is the advisor comes back as part of the strategy discussion before the SOA to basically say, right, I've calculated that you need five.
- 18:52I understand the premiums may be too much.
- 18:54So here's a quote at four and three where we pair back.
- 18:57Is there a preferred methodology for us or is one safer than the other?
- 19:02Should advisors be, yeah, what should they be doing?
- 19:04What should they be thinking about?
- 19:06We don't really have a preferred.
- 19:07I think licensee traditionally perhaps prefer the first one.
- 19:12But at the end of the day, either method, as long as there's proper documentation and evidence, it will be a lot more defendable.
- 19:19So we...
- 19:20got to also circle step back while we're doing all this, right?
- 19:23Why does this question arise is in the event of claim, the client is in the grave, their surviving widow is going, hang on, it should be two million wives, only one.
- 19:34And then the advisor go, but I had a conversation with my husband, we had all this discussion and we agree it was costing too much, hence reduced to one.
- 19:43And then the next question, well, what's the evidence of that?
- 19:45So if there's clear evidence, whichever method, how that figure, whether low or high, is derived, then it's a lot more defendable.
- 19:55That's the key.
- 19:56I mean, I've seen false philosophy where the advisor starts off asking client, well, out of your total income, what percentage are you realistically willing to pay?
- 20:05And you work backwards from that.
- 20:08So, again, there's no absolute black and white right or wrong answer.
- 20:14The key is you always link the amount back to the client's goals and objectives.
- 20:20And then you've got to bring the client.
- 20:22Ideally, if I know you want to write down in the client's exact word, you know, what you asked, what the client answers are.
- 20:28And this is how it was agreed.
- 20:30Yeah.
- 20:31And, of course, you can have review, right?
- 20:34This is the importance of review.
- 20:35You know, has anything changed?
- 20:37And perhaps you want to go up or down or whatever it may be.
- 20:41Okay.
- 20:41So, the goal, build your philosophy, get your goals and objectives, have your insurance needs analysis that's consistent, then have a conversation with the client.
- 20:48And provided that it's evidenced heavily through file notes, emails, whatever it may be, you're going to be okay.
- 20:54Generally.
- 20:55Generally.
- 20:56I mean, you're probably going to be okay about –
- 21:01from issues of question about the sum in short.
- 21:05Yeah.
- 21:06But then there's many other potential traps for this insurance.
- 21:09Yeah.
- 21:10Can I ask quickly, you touched on before about the advisors that approach advice from a percentage of income.
- 21:16What's your take on that?
- 21:17So two, three, four, is it a reasonable way of starting a conversation?
- 21:21Because it feels like, you know, what was 2% of your income?
- 21:24The same cover is now 5% of your income with the way the premiums are moving.
- 21:27Yeah.
- 21:28Look, it's just an opening.
- 21:32Yep.
- 21:32Right?
- 21:33We always need to remember that in front of a court, a financial advisor is always deemed to be in a position of knowledge.
- 21:41Just because a client say, I want 5% and the advisor didn't explore, didn't probe further, at least you've got to ask why 5%.
- 21:49Yep.
- 21:50At least, you know, then it comes like with insurance.
- 21:54Again, it's about risk, right?
- 21:56It's about managing risk.
- 21:58It's about, okay, you're willing to pay 5%, but is your wife comfortable that if something happened to you, only 30% of the debt is reduced and they're left with a huge mortgage and two young kids?
- 22:11Yeah.
- 22:12Then the conversation that, well, actually, is she sitting in the room?
- 22:16Ideally, we know I don't think I want that, right?
- 22:18Then that 5% will need to be adjusted.
- 22:21It's just a beginning point.
- 22:23Yep, okay.
- 22:24And it comes down to what client prioritize.
- 22:27You know, we definitely do have clients, they are willing to take on the risk and they prioritize their other wealth building strategies.
- 22:35They prioritize building for retirement or reduce debt through repayment of debt and rather pay insurance.
- 22:42And that's fine.
- 22:43So that just needs to be discussed and understood on both ways and documented.
- 22:50Yeah.
- 22:50Okay.
- 22:50So the key here, again, methodology, philosophy, as long as it's consistent and it's evidenced, if you're an advisor, you should be able to get through 99% of this relatively simply as it relates to life insurance.
- 23:02In terms of some insurance.
- 23:03Yeah.
- 23:04All right.
- 23:05Now go back to the complaints thing, right?
- 23:07So AFCA.
- 23:08Yeah.
- 23:09I'm interested.
- 23:10So we always say that the percentage of claims or complaints that go through AFCA is quite low.
- 23:17Now, I had this conversation with Jack Standing from WT and his response was, yeah, that's because AFCA's jurisdiction ends at $1.2 million in terms of client detriment.
- 23:26And so if the sums insured stick above that, the client's effectively going to bypass AFCA and go straight to court.
- 23:32Straight to court, yeah.
- 23:34Yeah, what's your take on that?
- 23:37I don't really have a take on that.
- 23:39That's just the way it's designed.
- 23:42At the end of the day, look, complaints-wise, there will always be complaints.
- 23:47But I think we focus too much on the numerator of the small number of complaints, whether through court or AFCA or whatever it may be.
- 23:55We don't look at the denominator.
- 23:58I mean, there's 15,000-plus advisors and half of them providing risk advice.
- 24:03And we look at the numbers and...
- 24:05the percentage of actual complaints is still relatively low.
- 24:08However, having said that, insurance does worry advising general a bit more because in the event of claim, if- There's some insurance.
- 24:17Yeah, there's some insurance much bigger.
- 24:19The actual cost can be bigger.
- 24:20We can't show away from that.
- 24:22Yeah.
- 24:22And yeah, that's definitely- So again, so the statistics would tell you that invariably, life insurance advice is relatively safer to be providing than other kinds of advice.
- 24:35Oh, I think it's quite serious.
- 24:37So she said, yes, that's great.
- 24:38Thank you, next question.
- 24:40Well, I think it's hard to come to the conclusion because if you look at the current AFCA cases in recent years, it's all crowded by Dixons, crowded by First Guardian, right?
- 24:50Yeah, yeah.
- 24:51I don't think it's a true reflection of what many of our normal advisors do.
- 24:57Yeah.
- 24:57But look, it's not…
- 24:59What we do and how we do things is not 100% dictated by complaint, right?
- 25:04Most advisors do things.
- 25:06They're still out of trying to do the best things for the client.
- 25:09And reducing risk is just for the advisor, just part of the process here.
- 25:15Okay.
- 25:16So if an advisor has then made the decision, they're going to be doing risk advice, they've built all the philosophy and all the rest of it.
- 25:22As an advisor and you're engaging with a power planning crew to prepare the advice, what are the common mistakes you see?
- 25:31What are advisors not doing consistently?
- 25:34Like is replacement advice?
- 25:35Yeah.
- 25:36Well, replace an advisor.
- 25:37A advisor doesn't like to always tend to forget to get the like for like for the existing product.
- 25:43Yeah.
- 25:44That's very painful.
- 25:45So just explaining that quickly.
- 25:47So can you – yeah, so what is it?
- 25:49If you're replacing a $2 million product with a –
- 25:52I don't know, with a new $3 million product, you need to get the existing...
- 26:08And, yeah, so it's cumbersome.
- 26:10You had to go to sometimes the industry funds and a good policy.
- 26:13You still have to get the policy.
- 26:16So frustrating.
- 26:17Yeah.
- 26:17So that's a common mistake.
- 26:20Another common mistake is actually forgetting to do this, because nowadays about 80% of insurance are inside super, forgetting to look at the long-term impact of insurance on super balances.
- 26:35Yeah.
- 26:35That is something that's required by ASIC.
- 26:37ASIC called that out a couple of years ago.
- 26:40But the licensee will obviously have standard rules on, you know, what portion of premium should, as part of the overall contribution, if you're over a certain threshold, advisors should actually recommend a client to do more top-up.
- 26:54contribution to counter the impact of insurance.
- 26:58So it's not saying you can't take insurance.
- 27:00It's saying, okay, if it's going to cost you, then what other measures can we do to do that?
- 27:05Is it a 10-year projection, five-year projection?
- 27:08Does ASIC matter?
- 27:0910-year.
- 27:09Okay, right.
- 27:10And I'm going to guess in the projections you have to take into account growth rate and all the rest of it of super tax.
- 27:15Yeah.
- 27:16Okay.
- 27:16Yeah.
- 27:17And premiums, yeah.
- 27:18So, and I mean, one thing to do wrong is just look at the first year premium.
- 27:22And in fact, look, I think any advisor will be quite silly just telling the client first thing, because if you look at the complaints of the last couple of years, and because the insurance premium have increased so much, a lot, a reasonable amount of complaints relating to how premium has gone up too much.
- 27:40And then when you go back to those files, because the advisor hasn't explained how insurance premium can really increase and why they increase and all those sort of stuff.
- 27:50So if you have made the right disclosure, you have explained it well, then that reduced the risk of complaint aid to order.
- 27:55Yeah.
- 27:56There was a recent case, I think in May, it was released by AFCA where a client's level premium increased by 49%, which again begs the question how did they come up with the name level?
- 28:08Yeah.
- 28:09So I'm really struggling as an advisor with projections and the idea of including them even in the quote projections, the SOA projections, because in my mind, they don't mean anything anymore because it doesn't feel like the insurers know how to price their products.
- 28:26I agree.
- 28:26Because if you even, if you look back, if you look at the previous, you know, we have always been doing projections and yeah, it doesn't really reflect what transpired, right?
- 28:38But at least it's better than nothing.
- 28:41Yeah.
- 28:42At least you've told the client it will increase and here's the impact and it's kind of best endeavor.
- 28:49Different licensee have different rules.
- 28:51We have one licensee where it used to be that you have to incorporate actual premiums from the insurance quote.
- 29:00Yep.
- 29:01And then vast majority licensure will assume an indexed amount, although it'll be a rate higher than CPI because we all know.
- 29:10Don't increase that's ridiculous, right?
- 29:13So I think, look, there's no perfect answer.
- 29:16I think even the insurer, if they can control it, they'd rather premium don't go up.
- 29:20Unfortunately, they still go up for various reasons.
- 29:22Yeah.
- 29:23All right.
- 29:24Can I ask about pre-assessments?
- 29:26Yes.
- 29:26Yeah.
- 29:27So again, I've spoken to a few advisors from a few different licensees.
- 29:30There are some licensees that are requesting pre-assessments with every insurer.
- 29:35I know it's the biggest bugbear that I hear about from the insurers that for every pre-assessment case they're getting, for every 10, they're only getting one actual application.
- 29:44What sort of best practice do you think around what an advisor should be doing for pre-assessments?
- 29:49Yeah.
- 29:49I think advisor, this is where they're willing to apply their judgment, professional judgment.
- 29:55We don't mandate pre-assessment with every insurer because really it just burdens the whole system down.
- 30:01Yeah.
- 30:02But a sole advisor, look, you could have a early 30-year-old who have no health issue, clean skin.
- 30:10Yeah.
- 30:11no BMI issues, everything good, squeaky clean, then you probably could go a little bit easier on pre-assessment.
- 30:19Or you could have, you know, someone does have pre-existing health issue or whatever, then you probably will need to do a fair bit of pre-assessment.
- 30:26And from my experience, I find a lot of advisors, especially the experienced one,
- 30:31They know, you know, kind of which insurer, which underwriter favours or have more favourable read on certain conditions, medicals.
- 30:44And yeah, I wouldn't go the full market.
- 30:46That's a bit silly.
- 30:48Probably three or four to be reasonable.
- 30:51Yeah.
- 30:51So the one that I'd sort of spoken to the advisors about is you –
- 30:55quote up through Iris or Omnium, whatever it is that you use, and whatever comes out of the quote that you, like the insurer that you want to use, the first thing I'd do is be calling that insurer, running through a quick pre-assessment potentially over the phone or email.
- 31:06And if you're getting standard rates, we don't really need to do anything else, do you?
- 31:09Yeah, probably not.
- 31:11I mean, that then brings to the question of, you know, disclosure about, you know, reasonable care services.
- 31:19Oh, there you go.
- 31:20You know, misrepresentation.
- 31:22I want to ask then, applications.
- 31:24I said, yeah.
- 31:26Applications.
- 31:28Should advisors be doing them themselves?
- 31:30Should we be sending a URL link to the client or should we be getting the tele-underwriting from the insurer?
- 31:35If I tell you what I think, will you tell me what you do?
- 31:38Okay, I'll start.
- 31:40So as a general rule, I like to hand off the compliance to the insurer by using URLs or teleunderwriting as my default.
- 31:52And where I'm not doing that for a special reason, either it's a really large client or business,
- 31:56I don't know, there's circumstances that mean I have to do the application myself.
- 32:00I'm doing it with them and then I'm sending them an email afterwards to say, hey, here's a copy of your application.
- 32:05I need you to come back to me via email to say yes or no, this is incorrect, correct, etc.
- 32:11Yeah.
- 32:11How'd I go?
- 32:12Give it one part of your licensee.
- 32:14I think that is definitely best practice.
- 32:16Right.
- 32:16That's definitely best practice.
- 32:17Because if you look at what changed in 2021, industry has moved.
- 32:22We're no longer at the, oh, you must disclose any and everything that's relevant.
- 32:27Now we have moved towards have you take reasonable care not to make representation in answering the question the insurer asks you.
- 32:37So it comes down to quite specifically, you know, what the insurer is asking in the application form.
- 32:44You don't actually need to answer anything that's not asked.
- 32:48And then obviously in that process, they've got to be reasonable, take reasonable care.
- 32:55But then I think a common misunderstanding in the industry for many advisors, especially not the risky advisors, they feel that just because a client got something wrong equals to non-payment.
- 33:07Just because they didn't disclose the information, it becomes no claim.
- 33:12It's not quite like that, right?
- 33:13There's different tiers.
- 33:14There's, you know, non-fraudulent disclosure.
- 33:17There's just misrepresentation.
- 33:19There's actual fraudulent.
- 33:20And so I guess the point I would raise is it's not as bad as what some advisors feel.
- 33:28I feel some advisors shy away from insurance.
- 33:30They feel...
- 33:31They couldn't suss everything out of their client.
- 33:33And they worry that what if my client just deliberately didn't disclose anything and therefore that insurance is going to completely become void and then I'm going to end up with AFCA or in the court.
- 33:47It's perhaps not as simple, it's not as easy to lend that way.
- 33:51There's a lot of middle ground sometimes.
- 33:53As you know, the key is if the insurer had all the information, despite whether innocent or non-innocent disclosure, would the insurer still come up with the same terms?
- 34:05And if not, even if there's a loading, there's a statute formula to work out what that sum issue may be.
- 34:11Then that reduced the risk as well, right?
- 34:12So I think coming back to your question, so because now how the client answered that question there, the application form is absolutely crucial now.
- 34:23It's definitely smart to get the client to actually fill it out because that's their interpretation, their words.
- 34:31You don't want to be the advisor that interpreting it and then, you know, have anything lost in translation.
- 34:38But on the other hand, sometimes, look, there are clients who are just relatively not financially minded.
- 34:46They're not, you know, they're not at a...
- 34:50understanding that they get what the insurance is asking, then that's where some advisors do stepping help a bit.
- 34:57But you do want to really take the time to explain.
- 35:02Like risk advice is about not just about provide advice, it's about educating the client to understand.
- 35:08You've got to have the client understand
- 35:10the question they're being asked and answer them honestly to their best ability.
- 35:15No, you know, non-disclosure.
- 35:18But on the other hand, also about educating clients, understanding what are the insurable payment events.
- 35:25If you look at the recent AFCA cases in the 2026 years, like May, June, there's quite a lot of cases where it just come down to client thought, I'll get payment if I get cancer.
- 35:35Yeah.
- 35:36But then, no, you only get your trauma payment if you suffer an event that meets the definition of cancer.
- 35:43One millimeter.
- 35:44Or level three.
- 35:45Right.
- 35:46It's not.
- 35:47But then Clyde would think, oh, I thought I'd get paid if I get a heart attack.
- 35:51Yeah.
- 35:51Well, there's one.
- 35:52Troponin levels.
- 35:52Yeah, exactly.
- 35:54Yeah.
- 35:55But then it's the advisor job to actually explain.
- 35:57Blayhound, yes, that's broad, but deep down, it's the insurable terms that really matters.
- 36:05And if a client had those understanding, then again, you'll have a much lower chance of complaint.
- 36:11Yeah.
- 36:11Okay.
- 36:13Again, I'm going to lean on the 100 SOAs a week because I'm just blown away by that figure.
- 36:18Can I ask, are you seeing much TPD replacement?
- 36:21And I'm talking about the new products versus the old ones.
- 36:25Honestly, no.
- 36:27No.
- 36:27Not a lot.
- 36:28Okay.
- 36:28Not at the stage.
- 36:29Maybe we're a bit behind compared to others or maybe, yeah, no.
- 36:32No, so I'm yet to find someone that's done a fair bit of it, which is why I keep asking the question.
- 36:38No, I'm not seeing a lot.
- 36:40Yeah.
- 36:40All right.
- 36:41I find a lot of visors for those anecdotic ones I speak to, they're still on the fence.
- 36:47They're a little bit uncertain.
- 36:48I mean, look, all visors get out why insurers need to introduce those because it's literally, you know, what happened to IP?
- 36:56You know, how to change.
- 36:58Insurer lose a lot of money.
- 37:00Something got to change, right?
- 37:00Right.
- 37:01But then advisors are worried.
- 37:04They feel, I mean, quote, it's not my word.
- 37:07They're worried to put a claim, their view, inferior policy.
- 37:12Yep.
- 37:12And with the saving in premium, not as much.
- 37:16Yeah.
- 37:17Especially with mental health.
- 37:19Because if you look at claim stats, like some insurers saying up to one third are mental health, then as advisors feel, well, there's a high chance of claiming, right?
- 37:30But then...
- 37:31excluding her or have, you know, varied terms, mental health, then they worry.
- 37:35What if I didn't explain her well enough to the client?
- 37:38So it's not saying those policy accounts sell them.
- 37:41It's not saying there's anything wrong with it.
- 37:43It's about explaining, you know, what it means because each of them have their different features, right?
- 37:48And then the advisor worried that what if I didn't explain it well enough?
- 37:53And then it's new.
- 37:54And then the client later on come back going, hey, I thought I'm going to get X, but in there, I'm getting a little bit less.
- 38:00But they go, hey, I'd explain to you.
- 38:01But then, well, then it comes down to how well the documentation is.
- 38:06All right.
- 38:06Can I ask then, so you made the comparison there between income protection and TPD, right?
- 38:10So we are having to, sorry, a lot of advisors are replacing legacy IP with new IP.
- 38:16Yeah.
- 38:18This question is two parts.
- 38:19First one is, would APRA or the government be better off stepping in to put a handbrake on TPD like they did with IP?
- 38:29Because the current approach from the government has basically said, figure this out yourselves.
- 38:33Yeah.
- 38:33Personally, I think yes.
- 38:35Yeah, same.
- 38:36I think it'll be better.
- 38:38Like we need – sometimes I think insurer might even prefer that because too much you're leaving everyone to solve the problem themselves.
- 38:48It's not happening.
- 38:49Because advisors then always have a choice and advisors then are skeptical.
- 38:55Look, change is always painful.
- 38:56Don't get me wrong.
- 38:57No one likes to be told what to do.
- 39:00But at the end of the day, sometimes we do need to move fast.
- 39:03We do need cohesively.
- 39:04Otherwise, it just drags on.
- 39:06And in the end, everybody suffers.
- 39:08Yeah.
- 39:08Okay.
- 39:10All right.
- 39:10Follow-up question then.
- 39:11So the second part was IP, legacy to new.
- 39:16Tips, tricks, what are you seeing?
- 39:18Where are mistakes being made?
- 39:20Because, you know, again, 100 SOAs a week.
- 39:23Yeah, we do write replacement ones.
- 39:28Look, again, it comes down to you always got to come back to the client, right?
- 39:35You don't replace them for the sake of replacing.
- 39:37You got to go, well, why are we replacing?
- 39:39A client often comes in and goes too expensive.
- 39:42Just quickly, is there any other reason why they don't change apart from cost?
- 39:45Because the only time I've ever spoken to clients about replacement is cost.
- 39:51No, we've had, I've had twice, two advisors go nut the client for whatever reason, hating particularly insurer because their family member works for it or whatever.
- 39:59All right.
- 40:00So apart from hating an insurer for personal reasons, it's cost.
- 40:03It's usually cost.
- 40:04Yeah.
- 40:04It's usually cost.
- 40:05Yeah.
- 40:06Makes sense.
- 40:07Yeah.
- 40:08Replacing IP, if I'm a compliant, if you look at our order team, they obviously worry that
- 40:14You go from agree to indemnity, especially if a client's not in a stable income or there's changes.
- 40:23You know, there's worry.
- 40:24Has the advisor covered that?
- 40:25But on the other hand, it's also other terms because I often see they don't just change from –
- 40:36Agreed to indemnity.
- 40:37Three-tier definitions with the old... Yeah, yeah, they change all the other stuff.
- 40:41Has it been correctly explained to the client?
- 40:44So what...
- 40:44Okay, so in my mind, income protection, agreed value to indemnity, old policy to new policy.
- 40:50Yep.
- 40:51Like the really broad brush statement, but my statement would be for all the clients on the old policies, it's not a matter of if they replace to a new product, it's a matter of when.
- 41:02Right?
- 41:02So as the old policy premiums continue to climb, the premium differentials, I know it's 30% at the moment, it'll get to 40 to 50 to 60.
- 41:08It'll get closer.
- 41:08You will have to effectively replace it.
- 41:10Yeah.
- 41:14Is it something like, is there more going on at the licensee level or do you see continuous themes?
- 41:19Like how does an advisor go about replacing old to new, right?
- 41:24It's a really, so you talked to before about the deep, sorry, the risk specialist having a very deep knowledge.
- 41:29Most financial advisors that don't.
- 41:31And you talked about 20% where they had a back book and they're not looking at that book.
- 41:35They're not advising it.
- 41:36But when it comes to replacing, what are they going to do?
- 41:39Ah, that's a very good question.
- 41:42I think some of them, they will either refer the client on or they will actually sit down there and look at, you know, go through the advice process.
- 41:51You compare, you know, what other...
- 41:54Call out a PDS from 20 years ago and try to figure out the product differences.
- 41:58Yeah, that would be hard.
- 41:59Yeah.
- 42:00I'm not too sure, actually.
- 42:02I'm not too sure what they would do.
- 42:03Okay.
- 42:03Sometimes they will call me and then go, well, it's too hard.
- 42:06Just call to, let's go to someone else, another specialist.
- 42:11Yeah, yeah.
- 42:11I mean, this is why Whizzing a network, it's good as part of a large licensee.
- 42:15There's abundant good advisors that we can leverage and bounce ideas off.
- 42:20Yeah, good call out at the end there.
- 42:21It's a great licensee.
- 42:24Nice.
- 42:24All right.
- 42:25Well, thank you so much for coming on.
- 42:26This has been a really lovely conversation.
- 42:28I genuinely appreciate it.
- 42:30And I love that you sort of talked about, right, get your philosophy right, and it takes an hour, whatever it may be.
- 42:35Get your needs analysis right.
- 42:36Then be consistent in your methodology and have evidence.
- 42:41And 99 times out of 100, you're going to be absolutely fine.
- 42:44And don't be lazy.
- 42:45Lazy, right.
- 42:46Yeah, you know, just when I say don't be lazy, right, get your life-for-life quotes.
- 42:51If there's variation in terms, right, you put the applications through, all of a sudden come back with loading, exclusions.
- 42:59Well, the lazy way is just do an ROI, accept it, off you go.
- 43:03No, the non-lazy way is you actually need to go back to the advice.
- 43:07Does anything else need to change?
- 43:09Should we look at the insurer?
- 43:10Like it is more cumbersome.
- 43:12It is painful for the advisor, but that's the right thing to me.
- 43:14Yeah, brilliant.
- 43:15Awesome.
- 43:15All right.
- 43:16Thanks so much, Robon.
- 43:17Cheers.
- 43:17Cool.
- 43:17Thanks, man.
- 43:18Thanks.