Latest / Onramp Bitcoin Media / Digital Oil, Financial Freedom, and the Long Game for Bitcoin in Africa
Transcript
- 0:02It all comes down to computers communicating.
- 0:06The information superhighway can be a confusing mix of on ramps
- 0:09and off ramps. Bitcoin is worthless artificial
- 0:14gold. Is it still rat poison?
- 0:17Probably rat poison squared. We need to get into the world of
- 0:21OK, this is actually foundational technology.
- 0:24What the Internet of money? Does is it creates a single
- 0:27network which can do a microtransaction to a giga
- 0:33transaction. The Internet is going to be one
- 0:38of the major forces for reducing the role of gun.
- 0:42The one thing that's missing that that will soon be developed
- 0:46is a reliable E cash. All righty gentlemen.
- 0:53Welcome back to another episode of Final Settlement.
- 0:56Today is Monday, May 5th, 2025 very special episode.
- 1:00We've got a great guest on a bubble car, Nur Khalil, a friend
- 1:05of the show he's been on before so welcoming him back.
- 1:08Also an advisor to early riders, so very excited to chat through
- 1:12some some topical news that's been happening in the space over
- 1:16the past couple weeks and also just catch up with Abu.
- 1:18How you doing man? I'm.
- 1:20Doing good. Thanks again for having me guys.
- 1:23Yeah, we've got a, we've got a big list, Liam.
- 1:25Liam put together a list. I think let's just jump right
- 1:29into it. A good place to start is the
- 1:32Nigerian government passing some laws related to digital assets
- 1:36in Bitcoin. Liam, you want to preface this
- 1:39one and then we can kick it to Abu.
- 1:41Yeah, well, this was actually written by by you Abu.
- 1:46So you're going to be the one who's going to be able to speak
- 1:50to this the best. But recently President, I may
- 1:55butcher his last name, but the the Nigerian president signed
- 1:58into law saying that Bitcoin is a security in Nigeria.
- 2:04It sounds like this is, you know, not what many expected in
- 2:09terms of, you know, Bitcoin not being a security.
- 2:11We we know that based on, you know, everything that's
- 2:13happening here in the US, but it does offer some regulatory
- 2:17clarity for the digital assets ecosystem, you know,
- 2:21understanding how different founders and people in the space
- 2:25can operate. Would love to hear your thoughts
- 2:28Abu on you know the initial reaction by institutions,
- 2:32founders, everybody in the space over over in Nigeria till to
- 2:37this this regulatory ruling. Yeah, certainly.
- 2:41I think it'll be good to preface this with kind of an analogy to
- 2:45capture both the sentiment. Honestly, just the reality of
- 2:48the regulation on the ground for a lot of us is imagine you're in
- 2:51a restaurant and essentially have a bowl of soup that you
- 2:53want to request from the waiter to might bring you a spoon.
- 2:57Then rather than bring you a spoon, he brings you a knife.
- 2:59Now it's not impossible to still drink, you know, eat the soup
- 3:02with a knife, but just makes it very, very challenging.
- 3:05And at least some see it as the beginning of a very long
- 3:08conversation, pretty much. So essentially what's happening
- 3:11with this regulation. I think for a lot of us on the
- 3:13ground, especially over the years, I can definitely see
- 3:15personally talk from the regulators, It's been very
- 3:18challenging in the sense that there are a lot of things to
- 3:20grok because it's been very difficult given the increased
- 3:24amount of capital coming in from the South side of Bitcoin.
- 3:28There's assets based, whether it's stable coins, etcetera.
- 3:30So for a lot of them, they still have difficulty in
- 3:34disambiguating between Bitcoin and everything else.
- 3:36And I think that's kind of emblematic by reason why they
- 3:40bundled everything up. I think it's also positive in
- 3:43the sense that a lot of the stuff happening outside of
- 3:45Bitcoin because for a lot of Bitcoin is we're mostly
- 3:47concerned obviously with Bitcoin.
- 3:49But I think for the stability, generally speaking, of the
- 3:51digital asset space, especially here in Nigeria where there's
- 3:54quite a lot of fraud as well as individuals trying to scam off
- 3:56of the, I guess, the marketing and hype of Bitcoin.
- 3:59It's a very good cleanup that they've done essentially by
- 4:02wrapping everyone under a succinct law that kind of
- 4:05increases 3 things I see that very pertinent, which is 1.
- 4:08Making Ponzi use explicitly prohibited according to the ISA,
- 4:12which is the Securities Act that you're talking about.
- 4:15And then to also instituting fines and penalties up to
- 4:18present sentences as well for people engaged in policy
- 4:20schemes. Another one I think that's very
- 4:22interesting is also making distinction between the type of
- 4:26exchanges that we have here on the ground.
- 4:28Some are allowed to actually engage in specific assets, which
- 4:30might be just Bitcoin exclusively.
- 4:32So that essentially captures a lot of the fintechs here on the
- 4:35ground, as well as giving a latitude for some of these other
- 4:39exchanges that list stable coins, everything else really as
- 4:42one. And I think it's important to
- 4:43also note that despite a lot of people feeling which, you know,
- 4:47or that bucket that this is not acceptable regulation, it's
- 4:49definitely a first step given the fact that we haven't had
- 4:51regulation and this is the first time the government is actually
- 4:53accepting Bitcoin as an actual legitimate asset on the ground.
- 4:57So the challenge right now really for us is to unpack all
- 5:00the aspects of this regulation that doesn't fit Bitcoin, kind
- 5:03of move it into a better a better direction.
- 5:06But I say it's also important to note that under this law,
- 5:08technically, any exchange that also enlists A commodity would
- 5:12still be regulated by the SEC in Nigeria.
- 5:14So even if we were to regulate this as a commodity, if someone
- 5:17were to list this, essentially, they'll still fall under the
- 5:19same regulation. So I think a lot of unpacking
- 5:21that has to be done. I think for entrepreneurs, kind
- 5:24of split in between 2 buckets, 1 is those who fiercely believe
- 5:28that this is definitely bad regulation and the sooner we get
- 5:32to acting, moving into a better direction, the better.
- 5:35And on the other hand, a lot of folks definitely just see this
- 5:37as a good first step. I think you're going to see a
- 5:39mix between entrepreneurs trying to figure out exactly how they
- 5:43interposition themselves in the interim to be compliant with
- 5:46these regulations, especially on the QYCML side.
- 5:49Obviously, the implication for that will be higher costs,
- 5:51especially on the hiring side for folks to actually help open
- 5:53that up. And then on the other side,
- 5:55really I think for us it provides at least a small
- 5:58headway for them to kind of innovate and start building more
- 6:01efficiently as you know, Heritage mentioned in the space.
- 6:05Yeah, that that's a great recap. I think it's the analogy is a
- 6:08good one. It it's, it's not impossible,
- 6:12it, it helps maybe incrementally, but I think it's,
- 6:16there's a couple things to remember.
- 6:17One of them, and we see this in the US around capital formation.
- 6:20Like you need some kind of framework for capital to come in
- 6:23institutional capital, individuals to feel like they
- 6:26can get a return on their capital.
- 6:27Because this thing is not, you know, shadow band, which I think
- 6:30in a lot of countries outside of the US or specifically in the
- 6:33Middle East and North Africa might be.
- 6:37But it brings up an age-old like, it's kind of not fair.
- 6:41But it's like, do you want to make money or do you want to be
- 6:42right in the sense of if you want to be right, there's a
- 6:46natural way to do things in Bitcoin.
- 6:48You can talk about being money versus a currency or digital,
- 6:50but it's like, or do you want to actually just meet the market
- 6:52where they're at? And I, I've never, I've always,
- 6:54you know, as you are in the group here, we have a vast,
- 6:59vast, like wide range of group of friends.
- 7:03And they all come from different angles.
- 7:04And some want to be extremely principled, but sometimes being
- 7:07principled, even though it's right, it may not be the thing
- 7:09that is right at the moment when it comes to meeting the market
- 7:12and actually further in the cause.
- 7:13And so it seems like that a little bit from the outside
- 7:15looking in, it's like, look, something's better than nothing.
- 7:18And if you have no framework and everyone's looking over their
- 7:20head or afraid to like operate a business, will you need capital
- 7:23start to form? And then the other part of that,
- 7:26sadly is, as we know, you know, all cryptocurrencies will
- 7:29naturally trend towards 0 in Bitcoin terms.
- 7:31It's still like that capital. And again, you can make the case
- 7:35it's all just destroying capital.
- 7:37But we've seen this in the US actually, that's overhead and
- 7:40overhang that give like more clarity or more like a shielding
- 7:45for Bitcoin to do its thing before the market wakes up and
- 7:47realizing how like impactful it is.
- 7:49But also it brings in capital that is also used to build other
- 7:54infrastructure that will benefit Bitcoin.
- 7:56And we've seen that with like the blockchain initiatives in
- 7:58different states. They're never really Bitcoin
- 8:00initiatives. There's only so much Bitcoin
- 8:01capital that will invest, but there's plenty of crypto
- 8:04exchange capital. And so that also I think would
- 8:06be a beneficial by product of there's regulatory clarity now
- 8:09around crypto currencies and more capital is going to come in
- 8:11that capital naturally flow to the hardest asset.
- 8:14And over time the the, the market will be able to form in
- 8:17the right way. At least that's what it seems
- 8:19like from the outside, just based on what we've seen across
- 8:21the world. Yes, Sir.
- 8:24In the end, it's also important to note that it's under this
- 8:27regulation, Bitcoin isn't going to be taxable, at least for the
- 8:29time being. That's interesting.
- 8:34Is that like like cap gains in like income tax or how does what
- 8:39is that all securities that aren't taxable?
- 8:43Right now is a bit vague in terms of whether it would be
- 8:46taxed based on capital gains or personal tax, but there's
- 8:49actually nothing regards to taxation right now.
- 8:53Interesting. So is that is that kind of where
- 8:56you land on it Abu like this is better than what was the status
- 9:00quo. This is better than nothing.
- 9:01It's a first step in the right direction.
- 9:03Even though it's a, it's a crude, you know, knife versus
- 9:06spoon, first step is that is that kind of your, your take
- 9:09away from this? No, certainly and I can
- 9:12definitely tell you like kind of hard for the last couple of
- 9:14years has been definitely difficult managing the lack of
- 9:17regulatory clarity, but also talking to LP's as well as other
- 9:20entrepreneurs on the ground just trying to navigate it.
- 9:22So like I said, it's a good stop gap in the sense that the same
- 9:25way everything else is trying to lynch onto Bitcoin to both
- 9:28relevant as well as regulated in the similar light is the same
- 9:32way. I feel that Bitcoin will use
- 9:34this as a way to also launch itself into appropriate
- 9:37regulation. So think of it as like the whole
- 9:38basket of both crap as well as Bitcoin being bundled into this
- 9:42regulation and then just leaving this regulation specifically for
- 9:45things that are outright cons used to be properly regulated by
- 9:47capital markets. And the largest overseer of this
- 9:50is obviously the SEC area. So it's definitely an
- 9:53interesting Mong Kong where they'll have to have for the
- 9:55next possible 2-3 years, but I think is worthwhile.
- 10:00Yeah. Yeah, makes sense.
- 10:01We and we better barely gotten that.
- 10:04It's like when I was thinking about the securities law and I
- 10:07saw you post on LinkedIn, it reminded me of how we kind of
- 10:11get lost in, in our own kind of like system of feeling.
- 10:15You know, we we're like complaint here in the US of like
- 10:18how things are going and regulation.
- 10:20And the reality is like there's been market structure around
- 10:22Bitcoin as a commodity for, I don't know, maybe close to a
- 10:25decade now where we're still figuring out in other regions.
- 10:29But it's also very contentious here with the, I think it's the
- 10:32fit Act, which is ultimately figuring out the market
- 10:34structure where SEC, what the SEC will regulate and then what
- 10:37will be deemed A commodity. And that seems to be very
- 10:41contentious across both aisles on like, who's going to oversee
- 10:45what? So we're still trying to figure
- 10:46it out here in the US And that's after realizing that Bitcoin's a
- 10:48commodity, now they're trying to figure out if these other
- 10:51cryptocurrencies are commodities.
- 10:52So I think I still think we have a long ways to go across the
- 10:55world. A. 100% And I think the benefit
- 10:58for us is we don't have too many stringent regulation assets to
- 11:02begin with. So, and this was kind of a long
- 11:04time coming, given the fact that last year the SEC already
- 11:07started giving licenses to to exchanges.
- 11:09So kind of figured down the line, they'll likely be the ones
- 11:13regulating this. So it'll be really a battle of
- 11:15different regulators trying to pick apart different segments of
- 11:17the market. And I think that's going to be
- 11:19that's going to play into our favor, to be honest, in the
- 11:21sense that you have to take apart this whole large omnibus
- 11:25regulation that we have for Bitcoin and we'll see what fits
- 11:28were. So I guess, you know, the IRS
- 11:30here on the ground will also stay apart as well as the SEC as
- 11:33well as the CBN, etcetera. So it's definitely going to be
- 11:35an interesting next couple of years.
- 11:39Maybe sort of just extending on, on this a little bit, Could you
- 11:42talk a bit about, you know, just an update of, of Bitcoin
- 11:46entrepreneurship, entrepreneurship in Nigeria,
- 11:48Nigeria generally and, and more broadly in Africa.
- 11:51And you know, how how you're seeing this piece of regulation
- 11:55and how that's sort of immediately impacting sort of,
- 11:58you know, how you're thinking about businesses in your
- 12:00portfolio of recursive capital. And also just, you know, people
- 12:03building in, in the space generally, is this, is this
- 12:06impacting their day-to-day and how they're about to go about,
- 12:09you know, going to market with various products and services?
- 12:12Or is this, you know, is it kind of just a line in the sand now
- 12:16that there's a little bit more clarity to move forward on
- 12:19certain things? How?
- 12:20How is this impacting things on the ground?
- 12:22I guess is a better way to to phrase all of that.
- 12:25And for sure, I think certainly the the most immediate one will
- 12:28be unlocking of larger amounts of capital just flowing into the
- 12:31country. I think in the last, I think
- 12:32maybe 1824 months, a lot of the conversations for a lot of the
- 12:35entrepreneurs that will support as well as we talked to here on
- 12:39the ground has been attracting foreign investments or capital
- 12:41from other PCs outside of cursive capital.
- 12:44And the challenge has been a lack of regulatory clarity,
- 12:46which obviously makes a lot of sense already this region is
- 12:49seen as risk. So I think that lack of
- 12:52regulatory just increase that. I think now I'm given the fact
- 12:55that there is some clarity, I think you start seeing a lot
- 12:57more capital coming, say probably Q 12026 in terms of
- 13:03just. So I think what's interesting
- 13:08though on the ground for them is there's definitely been a battle
- 13:11in the last three years for a lot of in terms of this figuring
- 13:14out whether what they're doing is either legal or when's the
- 13:18next regulation that will come out of tax, government agency,
- 13:22clamp down on them. So I think now that everyone is
- 13:25aware where we need to go as an industry in terms of who the
- 13:28apex regulator is for our space, which is the Nigerian SEC, I
- 13:31think a lot of the entrepreneurs really are just having to figure
- 13:33out two parts. So on the KYCML side, but also
- 13:36on the capital side too. Because again, like I said, one
- 13:38of the consequences for this regulation is that likely favor
- 13:42a lot of folks that already are well capitalized in the ground
- 13:46will be some of the requirements for getting licenses from the
- 13:48SEC. And it's important to also note
- 13:50that there isn't exactly a crypto license as of yet for a
- 13:53lot of these exchanges. So still going to take some time
- 13:56before this materializes into actual costs on the ground for a
- 13:59complex. But I think for the time being,
- 14:00it's definitely going to be both the cost in terms of just the
- 14:03burden that will cost them structurally from adjusting
- 14:06these things all the way up to trying to figure out what the
- 14:08next regulation is and how they can position themselves.
- 14:10But like I said, it's going to be a lot of difficulty and a lot
- 14:13of discomfort for the meantime within.
- 14:16It's our job. I feel as both, you know, PCs as
- 14:19well as stakeholders on the ground to kind of move the
- 14:20regulatory conversation also including things like Bequim act
- 14:24to more well nuanced conversation as opposed to just
- 14:26Bequim being a security. Yeah, that makes sense.
- 14:30And maybe switching gears a little tying into the rest of
- 14:32the news we've been talking about the past probably 3 weeks,
- 14:34it feels like there's a fervor of in the Middle East region
- 14:40counting to Asia Pacific when it comes to specifically like the
- 14:44UAE, you want to end stable coins in the banking
- 14:46integrations that are happening. I believe Pakistan among one
- 14:51other nation, added Binance. And I believe it was CZ as
- 14:55advisors to their Sovereign council.
- 14:59How are you thinking about that from this legislation as well as
- 15:03just in the region, the flow of capital when it comes to stables
- 15:07and Bitcoin and just like overarching, what are you, what
- 15:10are you seeing? At least in the West, we've seen
- 15:12this kind of like new administration pop up and
- 15:15everything feels like it's, it's, you know, there's a lot of
- 15:18activity happening on the M&A. Obviously like in the West
- 15:22Tether feels like they're making a large entrenchment into
- 15:25different forms of liquidity and, and flow of funds.
- 15:29And then it feels like a little bit in the East you're seeing
- 15:31finance have a larger positioning.
- 15:33Just curious like what you're seeing and and all how that all
- 15:35ties together? It's interesting.
- 15:38I think so. There are a lot of dynamics.
- 15:40I think one of the large ones, which is just, you know, telling
- 15:44off of what you just said with regards to the Trump admin is a
- 15:46lot of the African countries that are just thinking
- 15:48geopolitics, right in terms of having better deal terms for the
- 15:51US. They are seeing the the stance
- 15:54of the US now being a lot more pro crypto, but also playing
- 15:57into our favor to a certain extent in the sense that a lot
- 15:59of these conversations are taking a lot more seriously on
- 16:01the government side leading up until the recent regulation that
- 16:04came out. I do feel like it played a huge
- 16:06part space pretty seriously and even revising the law that
- 16:10governs the SEC here on the ground, which is actually what
- 16:12this act does. I think what will be interesting
- 16:14to see is the conversation moving away now, which my
- 16:18opinion already has from kind of this more speculatory.
- 16:21We can ignore this too, OK? How are we going to organize the
- 16:25country in terms of our economics, whether it's treasury
- 16:27management all the way up to dealing with the whole stable
- 16:30coin situation? Because again, FX has been a
- 16:32huge issue for us here in Nigeria just in terms of both
- 16:35retreating into companies, but also making sure that we keep a
- 16:38reasonable flow between the Nara and the US dollar too.
- 16:41So stable coins definitely going to play a huge part in kind of
- 16:44the calculus in terms of both the regulatory side, but at
- 16:46least how the government is taking a look at structuring our
- 16:48finances, whether it's regulation with the Central Bank
- 16:51of Nigeria all the way up to some more regulation that will
- 16:53likely come as a result of this act.
- 16:55I think. And a more interesting dynamic
- 16:58that I'm yet to see happen is the conversation around Bitcoin
- 17:00mining and how that affects both our energy challenges here on
- 17:03the ground and maybe the positioning on the regulatory
- 17:06side toward Bitcoin, both in a favorable light as well as some
- 17:10more, some more material way. I think, yeah, the dynamic on
- 17:12the Trump admin being pro crypto is definitely going to play a
- 17:15huge advantage in our sense, both on the regulatory side and
- 17:18kind of entrepreneurs in Nigeria move.
- 17:20And I think, again, Bitcoin is going to play a huge role as
- 17:22well due to solving about the energy issues we have on the
- 17:25ground. So I say maybe those 3 dynamics
- 17:27will be very interesting. Obviously, Tether will likely
- 17:30make some more place here on the continent given the clarity that
- 17:32we're starting to see. The only thing I would say is
- 17:35other countries are looking to Nigeria now given we're
- 17:38technically on the forefront now of Bitcoin regulation or digital
- 17:40asset regulation. So I do hope they'll learn from
- 17:43the mistakes that we're making along as opposed to just taking
- 17:46on radiation that we have currently as the convenient
- 17:49security all the way up to other things I might pop up.
- 17:51Historically is that is that kind of the case, Do other
- 17:54countries in Africa look at what Nigeria does and sort of try to
- 17:58replicate it or is there some give and take in terms of, you
- 18:02know, they could do something different or you know,
- 18:04potentially superior to what was just inactive?
- 18:08I say it's a mix and I think the determinant is likely the
- 18:12structure of the country in terms of the regulatory bodies,
- 18:14if they mirror closely that I enjoy regulatory bodies.
- 18:17So Kenya has a good example where you know, the CBN
- 18:20traditionally just like Nigeria. Well, I say that Kenya Central
- 18:23Bank, just like Nigeria Central Bank, we're kind of leading
- 18:25regulation for a while all the way up to looking at the SEC.
- 18:28So I really hope that doesn't get mirrored.
- 18:30And I think an interesting development that recently
- 18:32happened is because the result of the announcement from HRS
- 18:35Grand State give a grant to the Africa Bitcoin Institute
- 18:39essentially which an interesting arm coming out of Africa.
- 18:43In terms of the regulatory side, I feel that would play a very
- 18:47interesting role if done right. In terms of crafting regulation,
- 18:50there's a lot more productive given, you know, taking a look
- 18:52at case studies projecting to governments and more formalized
- 18:55and organized way as opposed to done as like individuals from
- 18:58the ecosystem. Everyone hope everyone had a
- 19:00great weekend. We had a fantastic quick RIP
- 19:04with Abu Baker from Recursive Capital, touching on all things
- 19:07related to Bitcoin technology and also what he's doing on the
- 19:12investment side of the space. It was timely because Nigeria
- 19:15just had an update around their legislation and which gave some
- 19:18regulatory clarity into that side of the world, but then also
- 19:22touching on all things related to the topical, you know, point
- 19:27in the in the ecosystem around consensus core and the block
- 19:32size limit. I hope you guys enjoyed the
- 19:33show. A quick comment from on ramp.
- 19:37We have some insanely exciting things that we're going to be
- 19:39announcing later on this week in the market.
- 19:41If you want to see them first, I would encourage you to at least
- 19:44subscribe to our research. As you guys know, we offer the
- 19:47most robust custody solution in the market.
- 19:50No longer do you have to worry about do you have a hardware
- 19:52device that secures the majority of your Bitcoin or do you have
- 19:55to leave it on a third party exchange.
- 19:56Now there's multi institution custody where you can get the
- 19:59benefits of self custody segregated on chain of the
- 20:03ability, but also the ability to move those assets.
- 20:06If you're traveling, you don't have to take your hardware
- 20:08device, but you also don't have to rely on a third party
- 20:10custodian. There's going to be a lot more
- 20:13coming from our business over the course of the next couple
- 20:16weeks. One thing to call out because
- 20:18we've seen an uptick, you can self on board.
- 20:20So if you're interested in signing up, we don't necessarily
- 20:23want to talk to anybody or we just want to go through the
- 20:25onboarding flow. It's a pretty awesome you can go
- 20:28through. Relatively fast, what used to
- 20:30take me and my previous from 2 to 8 weeks to get somebody on
- 20:33board is now about two to 8 minutes.
- 20:36Yeah. Go to shoot us a note, Michael
- 20:37at honor@bitcoin.com or hello at honor@bitcoin.com if you want to
- 20:40get involved or if you want to get a sneak peek at what we're
- 20:42going to announce later on this week.
- 20:44Hope you enjoy the show. Got you.
- 20:49You mentioned something in there around mining, which I found
- 20:52interesting and, and going back to what you were saying
- 20:54previously around, you know, this piece of regulation in
- 20:58Nigeria and sort of lumping everything together.
- 21:00Do you see Bitcoin mining as an Ave. to basically distinguish
- 21:04Bitcoin like this is fundamentally different.
- 21:06There's a different consensus mechanism mechanism.
- 21:09There's a different, you know, way that this actually impacts
- 21:12society in a, in a really positive way.
- 21:14Do you see that as sort of a line of sight to better
- 21:18distinguishing like Bitcoin is, is very different than the rest
- 21:21of us? 100% and I think it's kind of
- 21:24two parts and one is the US side with you know the SEC, I think
- 21:28it was last year roof of work. Bitcoin mining is totally
- 21:31separate from everything else. I think we kind of lean into
- 21:34that as that kind of precedence given to some extent we do
- 21:38mirror US regulation a lot of the time just to be compliant
- 21:40obviously tell both bilateral agreements and things like that.
- 21:43But I think the more interesting angle really is the difference
- 21:47is very, very stark from just communicating to them that
- 21:50Bitcoin has no issue or has no decentralized etcetera.
- 21:53I think the more material we have seen that in auction is
- 21:55through Bitcoin for two reasons. One is the fact that it provides
- 21:59electrification from the mini great approach that we've been
- 22:03using and champion effective. There's no there's no off taking
- 22:08of that demand mission. So a lot of projects are just
- 22:11fading with a lot of loans and debt.
- 22:13So pretty much a lot of that I think will be helped out by
- 22:16Bitcoin mining coming into the continent.
- 22:17But two, I'd say once we achieve energy independence, which I
- 22:21think Bitcoin will play a huge role in doing, I think the
- 22:24conversation will stop. Being around Bitcoin isn't
- 22:27different from everything else. It's around how we can further
- 22:30kind of capture value from Bitcoin as an asset, as also an
- 22:34infrastructure, really as a continent and then moving away
- 22:37from looking at it as just one bundled up ecosystem.
- 22:40So I think we'll have a lot more nuance due to Bitcoin mining, in
- 22:42my opinion. Yeah, they're the piece.
- 22:44We we talked about it Evans book behind me.
- 22:47It's called the prize and it just breaks down.
- 22:49It's called the epic, epic quest for oil money and power and just
- 22:52breaks down from like the late 80s, eighteen 80s in Titusville,
- 22:56PA. I haven't fully gone through it,
- 22:58but it's the notion of we were talking about before this call
- 23:02started that like Luke Roman, Arthur Hayes and others all
- 23:05reference their hard money in the amount of barrels per oil,
- 23:09like a Troy oz or ABTC. And there's something to like
- 23:13bitcoins, you know, I know it's obviously digital gold, but
- 23:15digital oil in the sense that it's a proxy for oil and you
- 23:19know, whatever those units are, you can move them faster across
- 23:22the world. And then like AI and all these
- 23:25other things that you'll be needed from an infrastructure
- 23:27perspective, it just kind of like changes the dynamic from
- 23:30being a toy or something that, you know, everyone understands
- 23:33energy, artificial intelligence, compute servers.
- 23:37And saying that like this thing will be running through it, I
- 23:39think helps in that. But you said something earlier
- 23:42that sparks the thought of a consensus.
- 23:44And, you know, we don't have to go deep here, but I think it
- 23:47just happened coincidentally that there's this whole
- 23:50situation going on right now with core and updating and the
- 23:54block size. And, you know, you'll be able to
- 23:56at least summarize it better than we can, but would love to
- 23:58get, you know, maybe a layman's version of what's happening.
- 24:01And then any color you want to share?
- 24:03We don't to go deep on it, but just I think we'll, the big
- 24:05thing is most individuals have no idea what's going on.
- 24:07They're probably barely starting in here from something because,
- 24:10you know, on Twitter you're always a couple couple days
- 24:11ahead of before other people start catching on.
- 24:13But even by the time that happens, they're still don't
- 24:16fully grok like what's, you know, what's the, the discourse?
- 24:20And then also like what actually are the likelihood of any
- 24:23changes and what's the process around that?
- 24:26Yeah, sure. Like you mentioned, it's
- 24:27definitely a very dense topic. I can help you see I'm being
- 24:29trying to catch up as well, seeing if it might arise as like
- 24:32a piece just to help with folks. But so far in terms of what I
- 24:36would see is first and foremost, if anyone's looking for context,
- 24:39Noster is a much better source of signal for this conversation.
- 24:42Twitter just in cases there's a lot of this noise really coming
- 24:46from that. So in terms of looking at the
- 24:48sources, I'd say no Star 1st and going all to the GitHub all the
- 24:51way up to the meeting. This is very useful context, but
- 24:54the issue I find is so it's twofold.
- 24:56One, there's a conversation around censorship happening,
- 24:58which I think there are legitimate concerns in the sense
- 25:01that you don't want to have vague, vague laws, not
- 25:06necessarily laws, but big rules of participation on project or
- 25:10mirroring some of the mothers code of conducts with regards to
- 25:12other projects. Just because of the shared
- 25:14difference between bitcoins, what development community and
- 25:17just how it works as a project versus everything else, even
- 25:19including other open source products.
- 25:21I think there's definitely legitimate concerns around that.
- 25:24I think some of it is kind of a misunderstanding on both sides
- 25:27in terms of some of the corporals communicating more
- 25:30effectively what they're doing versus some of the reception on,
- 25:33you know, the communities. And I think with regards to that
- 25:36conversation, it'll likely be one of those things where we
- 25:40just have to have a more honest conversation around it and
- 25:42likely figure out what a middle ground is because it's going to
- 25:45be a larger and larger issue given the fact that they're
- 25:47going to such a huge, large, valuable asset that affects
- 25:50millions of lives around the world.
- 25:52So it's not a case where it's just a project, egos, etcetera.
- 25:55It's actually material. It's the difference between
- 25:57someone actually living in my opinion, versus most likely
- 26:00dying or finding themselves in such a challenging situation.
- 26:03So that's on the censorship side.
- 26:05I think the interesting angle is that all of that came as a
- 26:08result of some of the work from the opera turn it is happening.
- 26:12So just to keep it clean, Bitcoin is essentially guarded
- 26:14by two types of rules where I see two sets of policies.
- 26:18So one which a lot of people are familiar with is on the
- 26:21consensus side, which is what dictates things like, you know,
- 26:24the turn around million coins, etc.
- 26:25What constitutes A valid transaction, invalid
- 26:27transaction, etc. But at the same time, because
- 26:31this is a peer-to-peer network, so you want to make sure that
- 26:33you have a tight grip on exactly the type of data that's being
- 26:36sent, ensuring that things are not being sent that are large,
- 26:39which will increase the resource requirements for individual
- 26:41nodes, which will affect like decentralization.
- 26:44So there is a second level to this, which is called, you know,
- 26:47the standardness rules. And that kind of guides 3
- 26:50things. But 2 are more relevant to this
- 26:52conversation. So one is ensuring that there
- 26:54isn't spam just going around on the network.
- 26:56And two is ensuring that people don't make mistakes.
- 26:59Given the fact that there are a lot of a lot of kind of
- 27:02transactions that you can make that are technically valid from
- 27:04the consensus laws, but aren't necessarily recommended for
- 27:07average individuals because they could lose their money given the
- 27:09fact that it's as complex while it's unsupported.
- 27:11So you might end up most likely more oftentimes than not, like
- 27:15losing your your funds. So those are two aspects of how
- 27:19it's covered. Now, the conversation around
- 27:20Opera turn came as a result of the spam side.
- 27:24So ensuring that people aren't necessarily putting arbitrary
- 27:26amounts of data on chain. And the real way that was
- 27:29battled was introducing this operation code, which is the
- 27:32Opera turn itself. So the interesting angle is
- 27:34unlike other times where people are trying to put in data, they
- 27:37put in things like the TXO set. So just to, I guess, communicate
- 27:42that more effectively, is essentially the state that is in
- 27:45charge of keeping track of all ownership of bitcoins.
- 27:48And the network essentially gets blooted because people are using
- 27:51that as a mechanism to actually put that on chain as opposed to
- 27:54something opportune which allows you to prune it to AK.
- 27:56You can actually discard it if you're running a node.
- 27:58So that 10K doesn't affect individual nodes.
- 28:00It's really a case where if people want to store it, they
- 28:02can store it. If they don't want to, they
- 28:04don't need to. And the challenge with that is
- 28:06there has been a limit on the amount of data that can be sent
- 28:08through as well as number of upper turns per transaction.
- 28:13So really in terms of the data that we're talking about, think
- 28:16of a medium sized sentence in the English language is kind of
- 28:20the amount of data you can actually put that's pruneable.
- 28:23And the challenge is for a lot of people, they feel we should
- 28:26lift the restrictions on that to make sure that people have the
- 28:29opportunity to use this as the primary mechanism to put data on
- 28:32chain. In fact, it's pruneable,
- 28:34etcetera. But the challenge with that is
- 28:36at what point do you make that arbitrary or do you causing more
- 28:41issues with regards to relaying those transactions given the
- 28:43fact that it does have a cost on the network side to relay those
- 28:46type of transactions given the size.
- 28:47So there are conversations around that.
- 28:49But I see in general really without getting too much into
- 28:52the specifics on the technical side, the larger debate in my
- 28:55opinion is on 2 fronts or maybe 3-1 is what is the difference
- 28:59between laws that we want to govern on the consensus side
- 29:03versus on the standard S size. Because for a lot of people now,
- 29:07as a counter argument to those that are talking about the anti
- 29:09spam filtering, they are of the opinion that technically the
- 29:13standardness rules could be argued as a form of censoring
- 29:16transactions that are otherwise valid, even though, you know,
- 29:19that isn't necessarily the case. But it's an argument that's
- 29:21brought up as a counter argument to the anti spam crowd.
- 29:24And I think really the argument is, are we looking at getting
- 29:27rid of these standardness rules? And are we looking at
- 29:29integrating some of the standardness rules that we feel
- 29:31should be more on the consensus side?
- 29:33Are we just getting rid of all standardness rules and they're
- 29:36just keeping consensus rules? So there's that aspect of the
- 29:38debate, and then there's a larger overarching aspect of the
- 29:41debate, which is around Bitcoin is very, very difficult to
- 29:47navigate in terms of maximizing freedom, but also ensuring that
- 29:51practically speaking, people can participate in this freedom
- 29:54enterprise. So talking about resource
- 29:56requirements for running nodes, we're talking about the
- 29:58interaction between, you know, transactions getting related to
- 30:02minors versus around nodes, which standardness rules affect.
- 30:06So I think one other aspect that please, which is the third
- 30:09component in my opinion, is the rise of Bitcoin Defy, if there
- 30:12is such a category that you can define.
- 30:15And I think that's what's pushing the boundaries of these
- 30:17conversations to be had more materially than previous years
- 30:20in the sense that is Bitcoin a protocol for money or is it a
- 30:24protocol for data essentially? And for some of the folks in the
- 30:28ecosystem, they do feel that there is a middle ground in the
- 30:30sense that the status quo does lean into Bitcoin maintaining
- 30:34its core principle as a protocol for money, but allowing for a
- 30:38more, a less destructive way of putting data in a way that
- 30:42doesn't mess up with that core functionality.
- 30:44And that boils down into kind of 1/4 corollary in my opinion,
- 30:47which is how do we define what exactly is Bitcoin moving
- 30:52forward, even at the consensus level?
- 30:54Because there are some consensus rules that are a lot more I'd
- 30:58say defining of what Bitcoin is ontologically speaking versus
- 31:01other things like might be a bit more arbitrary.
- 31:04So for materially things like the 21 million coins consensus
- 31:08rule versus, you know, some other more minutiae details
- 31:11about how to verify transactions.
- 31:13So I think as long as two fronts, as long as we make sure
- 31:17that the anti spam filtering conversation doesn't devolve
- 31:20into we want to filter all the spam, but then we don't have a
- 31:23rigid definition of what spam is.
- 31:25Because then then I believe the other count that's, you know, in
- 31:29contestation with these guys do have a good argument, which is
- 31:33if you can't define clear enough what spam is, then technically
- 31:36that's going to end up in censorship.
- 31:38So I do believe there are legitimate concerns with regards
- 31:40to that. But one thing I say just to wrap
- 31:42up is I'm glad this conversation is being had at all these
- 31:46multiple levels. Just shows that the committee
- 31:47still cares about Bitcoin, in my opinion.
- 31:49I just feel we need to be a lot more honest and open about
- 31:52exactly what we're arguing versus some of the shoehorning
- 31:55that I've been seeing out some of the the clamor just, you
- 31:58know, core is acting crazy again, the develop developers
- 32:01are trying to call out Bitcoin. So I think it really hasn't come
- 32:04to you just have to internally sort this out as continue to end
- 32:08and it's just going to be even more.
- 32:10It's like this over time, meaningfully, it is Bitcoin
- 32:13versus what we feel should be Bitcoin.
- 32:16Yeah, appreciate you running through that.
- 32:19It's a very helpful context. I won't pretend to, you know,
- 32:23understand, not that not understand.
- 32:25Like I feel good about certain opinions I have.
- 32:28I don't have strong ones on this other than sharing a few, a few
- 32:33thoughts. One is guy small one is yes,
- 32:37it's it's amazing that people still care and it makes sense
- 32:40because this asset's never been bigger, right, $2 trillion.
- 32:42Like you said, it affects people.
- 32:43People actually could potentially die.
- 32:45Like that's how big money is and the impact it has on
- 32:49individuals. And Guy Swan had a great quote
- 32:51of like, Hey, you can say whatever you want, but we we all
- 32:53still care, which is which is kind of just nice to like to
- 32:57recognize. The other one that ties into it
- 33:00is I think there's something to you start to learn in life,
- 33:05whether you get older or run businesses that like the devil
- 33:09you know, sometimes better than the devil you don't.
- 33:11And this reminds me of this when it comes to like, you know,
- 33:14Bitcoin is working as money at least today.
- 33:17And these notions of well, second and 3rd order
- 33:19consequences are not always well understood or appreciated.
- 33:23And if we're going for money, that is something that I don't
- 33:25think like people discuss enough of like, well, if it's working
- 33:28today, I mean, and there's any chance it may not work tomorrow,
- 33:31we should all take a pause. I don't think that's fully like
- 33:33recognized by a lot of people. It's not to say things shouldn't
- 33:36change. It's just to recognize that at a
- 33:37very base level of like, what's the prize?
- 33:40And I think that the the best, if anybody's you know, listening
- 33:43to to look at John from Zaprite had a really great tweet.
- 33:51That was Bitcoin's not a simple database.
- 33:52That's that's the blockchain. Bitcoin is money, of which a
- 33:55simple database is just one small part.
- 33:57If this is truly your stance, you don't understand what
- 33:59Bitcoin is. And then Parker had a subsequent
- 34:02tweak. That said, this is a good
- 34:03framing. If you can't accept that Bitcoin
- 34:04is money and instead look it as only a simple database to store
- 34:07value, you're looking at to solve problems in different
- 34:09ways, which independent of that being a right frame and a wrong.
- 34:13I think that's like the crux of where a lot of this comes is
- 34:16like, is This is Money the only thing you're concerned with?
- 34:18Because everything else is a derivative of that.
- 34:20If you fix the money or are you trying to do multiple things?
- 34:22Because if you try to do multiple things, well, then
- 34:24you're always going to have trade-offs with the most optimal
- 34:27outcome for it to be money. And we have to agree almost
- 34:30like, what's the point of this thing?
- 34:32And so anyway, I think that's like at least my take on it's
- 34:34like, if it is, if it's working today and there's a chance it
- 34:37doesn't work tomorrow and we're all competing to be money and
- 34:39it's working to be money today, well, why would you do anything
- 34:41to it if there's not consensus around it?
- 34:43Yeah, there's, there's a couple. We could take this in a ton of
- 34:47different directions too. But one thing to understand also
- 34:50is that there is a spam mitigation policy in play right
- 34:55now, which is essentially just you have to pay minor fees.
- 34:58And based on looking at the mempool, I can look at it right
- 35:02now, there are less than 3000 transactions in it.
- 35:04And looking over the past day, a lot of the blocks aren't even
- 35:07full. So a lot of, it's really
- 35:09important to note that there's, I mean, you could always, it's
- 35:12all relative, but there's not a ton of demand for, you know,
- 35:16block space and inscriptions and storing data within the the
- 35:21blockchain. So that's just important to
- 35:24note. And it's not necessarily the the
- 35:27most biggest deal that is very existential at the at the
- 35:32moment, but it's telling just that there's a lot of very
- 35:36heated controversial opinions going on right now all across
- 35:39the space for something that, in my view, isn't all that big of a
- 35:43deal. And there will be much larger,
- 35:47you know, implications longer on whether it's quantum computing
- 35:51and etcetera. And, you know, the the fractions
- 35:54of people that care about different aspects of Bitcoin is
- 35:57going to significantly change over time as it gets larger till
- 36:00there's, you know, and, and there's overlapping here.
- 36:03But a lot of people just care about like lightning payments
- 36:06technology. Some only care about store
- 36:08value, some care about the, the defy etcetera on Bitcoin.
- 36:12They're, you know, some that I'm sure they're like doves out
- 36:16there that are, you know, funded by, you know, countries that
- 36:18actually want to see Bitcoin fail.
- 36:21There's going to be a lot of different fractions out there in
- 36:24terms of people who have different opinions about what
- 36:27Bitcoin should be. And you know, trying to please
- 36:31everybody isn't isn't going to work.
- 36:33Ever. Yeah, I mean, my my kind of take
- 36:35on all this going back 12 to 24 months, when I think a lot of
- 36:39this actually started to emerge as a discussion around
- 36:42inscriptions and ordinals. And now we've gotten to this
- 36:44point of an actual policy change proposal.
- 36:49But you know, going back over the past few years, my, my take
- 36:53has always been sort of like long term, I don't know if this
- 36:56really matters because I think non financial transactions get
- 36:58priced out ultimately. And so, you know, as you're
- 37:02alluding to Liam, like the sort of free market of transaction
- 37:07fees, we'll take care of this ultimately.
- 37:09But I do want to go back to 1 distinction and just a sort of
- 37:14question around clarifying what the change actually is being
- 37:18proposed. Because in my understanding,
- 37:21basically what's being proposed is, and I'll pull up a, a tweet
- 37:27that I thought captured some of some of this.
- 37:33But effectively, people can put arbitrary, arbitrary data on the
- 37:37chain today, but they do it through the witness data.
- 37:41And so I think what is being proposed, and please correct me
- 37:43if I'm I'm misunderstanding this all, but it's like we're saying
- 37:46just get rid of that limit so that instead of putting in the
- 37:51witness data, people can just put arbitrary data in op in op
- 37:54return. And it would be the the, you
- 37:57know, basically getting rid of the fences in this photo.
- 37:59Like, people are already putting data on chain.
- 38:03Is the thinking that, you know, this proposal would make it
- 38:07basically a cleaner, more efficient way of doing it by,
- 38:10you know, in some way opening the floodgates, you know,
- 38:13removing that fence, but making it more efficient on chain?
- 38:16Is that part of the argument? Am I understanding that
- 38:18correctly? Yes, certainly.
- 38:20I think this definitely captures it to a certain extent.
- 38:23So the change I believe from Peter Todd is proposing is kind
- 38:26of two fold. One is getting rid of again is
- 38:30on the proposal from the meeting list, but I don't know if the
- 38:33restrictions on how many of these type of operators, so the
- 38:36clean version of putting data on chain can be attached per
- 38:39transaction and also the actual limit on the data that can be
- 38:42attached to these these operating codes.
- 38:44So I think in a way it definitely is a case of
- 38:47expanding the the mechanism that's a lot cleaner or I should
- 38:52say the cleanest to add data on chain.
- 38:54But again, because of that change itself is why the
- 38:57conversation evolved or I guess progressed to, well, why do we
- 39:01even have opportune right now, like you mentioned, given the
- 39:04fact that people are still evading that.
- 39:05And that was a combo honesty that was had as a result of,
- 39:08well, actually at the time that opportune was proposed, I think
- 39:11by some other folks in the community.
- 39:14And the thinking really was we might as well make this as
- 39:17straightforward and with the least amount of consequences
- 39:20moving forward of affecting the chain with regards to persistent
- 39:23data being there versus prune data.
- 39:26I think it's just an extension of that conversation or maybe
- 39:28you could see a Part 2 to a certain extent of further
- 39:31increasing that scope to ensure that people we capture a lot
- 39:34more of that that's being dangerously done.
- 39:36But at the same time too, like they still wouldn't necessarily
- 39:40like people can still be able to put these transactions to
- 39:43minors. Again, even if you do increase
- 39:44the up return. It's really that with the
- 39:46change, the hope is just that this will be done cleanly
- 39:49through that. And that's why some of the
- 39:50conversations also been around just getting rid of the
- 39:54opportunity for at least a very small ground versus even just
- 39:58the standardness rules. I can't mention which play a
- 40:00part into this of why we even have anti spam filtering to
- 40:03begin with. So I think there are a lot of
- 40:05nuances here and there. There are a lot of dis analogies
- 40:07and pretty accurate analogies to at the same time.
- 40:09So I think over the coming weeks, you'll likely see a dying
- 40:13down of this conversation from just the share heat that has
- 40:16currently to something more technical, which typically
- 40:18happens. Of course, I propose a change.
- 40:20People go out, complain, shout, cause issues and then it
- 40:23revolves back into being fully technical again.
- 40:26I think likely two things will likely happen.
- 40:28Either this PR gets closed because it's controversial, or
- 40:31it gets too heated, or it's too much, maybe a source of signal,
- 40:35or it needs to be rescoped, or it could be jammed through and
- 40:38then cause us to even have more material conversations about
- 40:41what exactly is Bitcoin and what it should be.
- 40:44Because while this might just be a technical minutiae for a lot
- 40:46of the community, it's changes like these that could have a
- 40:50longer term effect with regards to undoing all the issues that
- 40:54will likely come as a result of a consequence of these type of
- 40:56changes being proposed or included versus just, you know,
- 41:00infighting between the committee members.
- 41:02Gotcha. Yeah, no, that that's super
- 41:04helpful. And I guess where my mind goes
- 41:06is like, so you know, as you articulated, this is a, this is
- 41:11a policy change, not a consensus change.
- 41:13And so in terms of sort of how the development community works,
- 41:20core and other developers, you know, can you sort of walk
- 41:23through the difference between sort of the amount of consensus
- 41:28roughly that one needs to push forward a policy change like
- 41:33this versus a consensus change? And why, you know, as you just
- 41:37articulated, like maybe it just sort of dies down, you know, it
- 41:40it doesn't get merged or they force it through.
- 41:43Can you like add color on like what that forcing it through
- 41:47would look like and what that means relative to like something
- 41:50that was an actual consensus change?
- 41:52And you know the difference in those two processes I guess is
- 41:55what I'm trying to get at. No, for sure.
- 41:58I mean, there's definitely a lot of context that I'll likely have
- 42:01to Butch just to convey this succinctly.
- 42:03But with regards to how changes get pushed through, it is a
- 42:07very, very dynamic process on the core project.
- 42:10It's not as straightforward as we have 20 AC KS, which is, you
- 42:14know, acknowledgments versus an AC KS disagreements and then
- 42:19seeing just materially what's the count and then just merging
- 42:22if each time there is a change depending on how complex
- 42:25depending on the bandwidth of folks reviewing it depends on
- 42:29that group of folks taking a look at that time.
- 42:31So whether it's consensus versus non consensus, the, the main
- 42:34distinction I would say is there's definitely a lot more
- 42:36scrutiny just naturally speaking if we're talking about consensus
- 42:38versus something like policy. And then at the same time too,
- 42:41there have been situations where, you know, I mean, this is
- 42:44more, more historical than pretty recent, where some
- 42:47changes that even though in retrospect might have been
- 42:50something that should have been taken not necessarily more
- 42:54seriously, but should have had a lot more eyeballs taken or taken
- 42:56a look at just get merged. And there are situations where
- 43:00things that might seem trivial, again, like something like this
- 43:03have just so many eyeballs looking at it.
- 43:06I think I said really that the difference is very dynamic.
- 43:09It's not black and white in the sense that this is exactly how
- 43:12it works each time, say it depends on a case by case basis,
- 43:15but or something like let's say Taproot, for example, there was
- 43:18already a consensus on the actual change itself.
- 43:21And ironically the biggest delay came from how to deploy that
- 43:24change. So there are kind of weird
- 43:26instances like that where there is agreement on the change
- 43:29itself, but maybe the mechanism of deploying that change or even
- 43:32sometimes just the change is agreed upon.
- 43:34And then so when I talk about the forcing it down the line, I
- 43:38mean kind of goes into the censorship question.
- 43:40So it could be a case where some of the there is noise really if
- 43:45you look at the pull request from people outside of Twitter
- 43:47or people who actually aren't contributors on the space which
- 43:49just created GitHub accounts just to comment.
- 43:52So if it's a case where everyone within that noise category is
- 43:57expanded and we have former contributors also being included
- 44:01as noise and then comments get deleted all the way up to the
- 44:05only thing remaining, essentially all the pro
- 44:06arguments for that change itself.
- 44:08Then that could naturally also swing some of the some of the
- 44:12maintainers or some of the folks on the ground that are reviewing
- 44:14this code is like, OK, you know, this isn't as controversial.
- 44:17So that's what I mean by like forcing it down the wind.
- 44:19I don't expect that'll be the case.
- 44:20I still have I what I say, I don't really say maybe trust,
- 44:25but I do lead into the competency and the level of
- 44:28vested interest that core developers also do have in the
- 44:31project. Because people also forget that
- 44:33these are folks that use Bitcoin on daily as well that also hold
- 44:35Bitcoin. So it's not like it's a random
- 44:37set of people that just care about the project for caring
- 44:39sake. So I think that's what we're
- 44:41leading into or I guess leading into in terms of the sorting
- 44:44itself out and and how the mechanism is or the process for
- 44:47making changes and accepting them emergency.
- 44:49Hey everyone, hope you're enjoying the podcast episode
- 44:52with Abu Baker. He always brings a ton of great
- 44:55insights and technical law knowledge to to show that maybe
- 44:59we don't always get into deep technicals.
- 45:02Quick word from on ramp. Want to let you guys know we
- 45:04have some big exciting updates coming forward in the coming
- 45:08days. If you want to sign up to our
- 45:09research to get a sneak peek, please do.
- 45:11And also we offer financial services across the board, not
- 45:15only multi institution custody. So if you're ready to self sign
- 45:19up, you can go through our self on boarding.
- 45:21That's something most people don't know, but once you on
- 45:23board, you're actually can get the ability to trade, lend
- 45:26against your Bitcoin, get a tax advantage Bitcoin account via
- 45:30your IRA, as well as set up inheritance.
- 45:32And it's all backed by Lloyd's of London with $100 million
- 45:35policy. If you're curious on what we're
- 45:37building, want to get involved, please shoot me a note.
- 45:39Love chatting with everyone, Michael at honor@bitcoin.com.
- 45:42Now on to the rest of the episode.
- 45:43Thanks. Yeah, thanks for running through
- 45:48that. I mean, I'm not I'll probably
- 45:49get crap for this. I don't agree with it, but I I
- 45:51can see where sailors stance on funding devs it comes from where
- 45:55he's like, hey guys, maybe we don't need all this money out
- 45:58there floating around with ideas on changes to the Bitcoin
- 46:00protocol. He likes how it work.
- 46:02He likes how it works today. And just describing what you
- 46:04just said, probably make his eyes closed over.
- 46:07No, I appreciate you running through.
- 46:08I think maybe switching gears, something I wanted to call out
- 46:11that you referenced in Q4 when you came on the show last was
- 46:16the interest in Bitcoin and stablecoins sitting next to each
- 46:20other. And I believe if that, if, if I
- 46:22recall correctly, there was that interest in seeing what that
- 46:25looks like. And I think that's something
- 46:26that we've been talking about more.
- 46:28You don't see a lot of Bitcoin companies sitting with, you
- 46:31know, infrastructure able to have BTC and stablecoins.
- 46:36But given, you know, this new administration, the new global
- 46:39flows that have come about Tether, you know, what we're
- 46:42talking about with, you know, whether it's treasury markets or
- 46:47exposure into the US markets. There was a report that came out
- 46:50from the Treasury Department that was actually pretty good
- 46:54from a, you know, government agency.
- 46:55This show, it shows that over the course of the next three
- 46:59years roughly, they expect stables coin supply to be up to
- 47:02$2 trillion. And then it also had some I
- 47:07think here referencing a little bit of the different markets in
- 47:11sectors that it would impact from, you know, tokenized
- 47:16deposits all the way to to CBDC's.
- 47:19We don't talk about the exact report, we'll link it to it in
- 47:21the show notes. But just curious Abu, as you're
- 47:23thinking about, you know you're, you're investing, you're looking
- 47:27at the global landscape in Nigeria as well as outside.
- 47:30How has that kind of progressed into our last discussion?
- 47:33What are innovative things you're looking at interested in
- 47:37when it as it relates to Bitcoin and then like digital banking
- 47:39around stable coins? Now for sure, I think we're
- 47:42definitely past the whole, you know, hesitation in the
- 47:46ecosystem with regards to stable coins because initially I know
- 47:49some of the conversations were around using Lightning, the city
- 47:53stable coins. And then that just materialized,
- 47:56I guess towards the end of Q4. Like you mentioned, the flows,
- 47:59pretty much the volumes kind of dictating exactly where the
- 48:01market is heading, which is that a lot of that really has been
- 48:04captured by stable coins as opposed to lightning, which
- 48:06makes a lot of sense. And it's a lot more practical
- 48:08really if we're talking about it more materially given the fact
- 48:10that we're just converting like I mentioned, I think and then
- 48:14the last time we spoke all the demand that traditionally would
- 48:16have gone to U.S. dollars into stable coins pretty much.
- 48:19So does make a lot of sense. I think what we're most keen on
- 48:22looking at in terms of the company side is infrastructure
- 48:25that like you mentioned, has the capacity to handle both Bitcoin
- 48:28as well as stable coins. But I think at least personally,
- 48:32outside of the kind of looking at it from the VC side is making
- 48:35sure that there still is that distinction made between the two
- 48:39as opposed to maybe blending them down the line in terms of
- 48:42how they work. Some of the engineering side
- 48:43about, you know, how these interactions should be dictated
- 48:46to. Because at the end of the day,
- 48:47as much as a lot of these flows are just being translated from
- 48:52stock kind of locked up, I guess liquidity from FX, it is
- 48:56important to note that there are still dollars essentially.
- 48:58So we're really looking at financial freedom etcetera and
- 49:01things like that. There still needs to be at least
- 49:03mentally in terms of mental models that a lot of
- 49:05entrepreneurs have of where they like to lead users in the either
- 49:10direction and kind of clarifying exactly what these assets are
- 49:13for users practically speaking, whether it's on self custody
- 49:16side or even if it's on some things like that.
- 49:18So as you're making those distinctions very, very clear
- 49:21and solid right now as well to make the space a lot more easy
- 49:24to navigate down the line for CV having even more complexity,
- 49:28both from the builder side as well as the entrepreneurs, the
- 49:30marketing, the language. Because I think language is
- 49:33very, very important in terms of how you communicate the products
- 49:35and services. And that kind of sets the
- 49:37expectation that community level or I guess at an ecosystem
- 49:40level, which could either make or break the trust people place
- 49:43in the asset itself and the builders and things like that.
- 49:46So say those are kind of things we're looking at on the BC side
- 49:49and kind of personally where I hope.
- 49:52Yeah, it's something I was thinking about.
- 49:55It's like on the the bookends, there's the infrastructure being
- 49:58laid, but it's like, how does it connect?
- 50:01And what I mean by that is like, so you have like cold storage
- 50:03solutions, whether it's on ramp or like collaborative custody or
- 50:06even self custody with like pure, you know, you hold in a
- 50:09hardware device. And then over here you have the
- 50:12way that you pay for goods and services globally.
- 50:15It can be in the US and you have, you know, whether it's
- 50:16Apple Pay cards and it's like, how do you as more of like, I
- 50:21think we're all here living in the future and people listening
- 50:23by holding larger and larger amounts of wealth and BTC and
- 50:26understanding it's different than a stablecoin or the US
- 50:28dollar. But we still live in a dollar
- 50:31denominated world where you have liabilities and how do you
- 50:34actually stay in BTC longer? But then ultimately can get to
- 50:38like some form of wallet that sits here that has some
- 50:41basically ability to convert to to USD or whatever the stable
- 50:45coin is when you're spending it. So you can stay in BTC the
- 50:48longest if you want, you can always move to dollars as well.
- 50:51But there's that connectivity doesn't fully exist yet.
- 50:55And there's and it makes sense because most people don't even
- 50:57know why they would want to hold the majority of their wealth TC
- 50:59and spend from it. But but we're going to that
- 51:01world and we're going to that world where and that's where
- 51:03like I kind of, you know, for have always thought like stable
- 51:08coins weren't as interesting until it just hit me like, well,
- 51:11the reason why stable coins have been interesting and
- 51:13specifically tethers because it's held global felt flows into
- 51:15BTC because it's digital. And so then you take that to
- 51:18every other capital market or every other consumer, you know,
- 51:22flow of funds. And then that actually applies
- 51:24across the board. If you can put stable coins, get
- 51:26your dollars in a stable coins, the next two, the the scarcest
- 51:29digital asset we've ever seen in Bitcoin, that's just going to
- 51:32further accelerate that transfer of wealth from dollars into BTC
- 51:36and then back and forth will naturally happen.
- 51:38And so yeah, I think that there's still a huge amount of
- 51:41opportunities that I've been thinking about to help bridge
- 51:44those gaps globally. A. 100% And I think maybe just
- 51:48taking the, the entire conversation into a, a neat boat
- 51:50would be there's nothing a lot we need to do on the regulatory
- 51:53side because that affects how governments permit a lot of this
- 51:57innovation, general spaces built on permissionless innovation.
- 52:01There are ways in which you can still maintain using Bitcoin
- 52:03outside of that, but just the sheer amount of people that
- 52:06would be affected by adversarial regulations, really why I would
- 52:10care about regulations. And 2 is really kind of taking
- 52:14off of the the sailor conversation broadly.
- 52:16Also the conversation around controversies recently.
- 52:19I think it's important to note for folks listening and watching
- 52:23as well that software generally isn't a thing where it's done or
- 52:28like other things in life, like software is either not
- 52:32maintained or maintained. So for something like Bitcoin
- 52:34that we're planning to have into the next couple of decades, it's
- 52:38very, very important to take it as software that needs
- 52:41consistent mean. It's not just for it to keep
- 52:43working as it is, but for it to even work better than previously
- 52:47what we've been enjoying and to kind of iron out what it is for,
- 52:49for Bitcoin to be Bitcoin for generations to come.
- 52:53And that leads into obviously diversifying funding for
- 52:56developers because as much as developers are integrity and
- 52:59competent, there are ways in which they can be influenced
- 53:02from funding. I have a lot of them
- 53:04concentrating in a single place, for example.
- 53:06When I say that conversation leads into things like we trust
- 53:08and the work that we do, I'm trying to distinguish between
- 53:12funding and dictating to the space, specifically funding and
- 53:15kind of enabling that. And kind of where we lean on
- 53:17that is ensuring that we pump out developers that are
- 53:21extremely competent, honest and have a high degree of
- 53:25philosophical understanding of exactly what Bitcoin is and how
- 53:28we can persist that into the next couple decades.
- 53:30So see, that's very, that's one of the things I think people
- 53:33should keep in mind when those conversations come up.
- 53:35And at least for capital allocators as well to kind of
- 53:38look at where they'd like to provide the most value is in
- 53:41case of funding companies, in case of maybe putting their
- 53:44stake in terms of funding developers or organizations that
- 53:47do this developer funding and kind of how they can think about
- 53:50these things. And lastly, really on the stable
- 53:52coin, the coin distinction, I think you put it very, very
- 53:55succinctly. It's making sure that we know
- 53:58what direction of the future we'd like to have a vested
- 54:01interest in, in terms of the infrastructure and kind of
- 54:03directly. So see how and how in the
- 54:07meantime we can graduate that more consciously and more
- 54:10realistically, practically as many jurisdictions as possible
- 54:13with the solely honesty we're just allowing for freedom to
- 54:16Canada. Yeah.
- 54:17Right now we have to contend with all the intents of freedom
- 54:20versus slavery or Fiat etcetera, as folks like to express.
- 54:23So see, there's other the main key points should be looking
- 54:28into these conversations across everything just discussed.
- 54:31Yeah, that's a great recap. And I think the thing that stood
- 54:34out there is about the developers and just like
- 54:37individuals coming up is remembering what, you know, at
- 54:40least Bitcoin is or, or explaining the importance of
- 54:43money. Because I think like when you
- 54:44conflate technology and, you know, iteration and because
- 54:48that's general, right for technology versus like money,
- 54:50they're fundamentally different. And I think that's probably like
- 54:52a substrate of what's lost in this discussion of optimizing
- 54:56versus thinking through from first principles.
- 54:59What are we trying to change? 100% So with that in mind,
- 55:03hopefully the folks can navigate as effectively as possible the
- 55:07ecosystem. But then again, that's the
- 55:09beauty of having a decentralized projects, all the opinions, all
- 55:12the folks around the world, it's healthy to check in everyone's
- 55:15bias season, also everyone's motivations where their head is
- 55:18at. So we all have to keep ourselves
- 55:20accountable. I love it.
- 55:23I know we had a shorter RIP today but we've grown our
- 55:25following so if you want anyone to figure out you know where to
- 55:29find you or want to show anything let let them know I
- 55:31know you. I think you may have closed the
- 55:33fundraising process already, but any updates around that would be
- 55:37helpful for people to know to find you.
- 55:38Get in contact. You know, for sure for on the
- 55:41fun side, definitely can reach out to us either on X or even
- 55:45our contact contact at RCRSV dot XYZ you're looking at.
- 55:48Personally, I dropped quite a lot of articles on forms you can
- 55:51take a look at that follow me on Auster as well as X.
- 55:54And other than that, I'd see just generally keeping tabs on
- 55:58what's happening in this part of the world.
- 55:59So specifically African rest of the global S because I feel it's
- 56:02going to dictate and kind of set the precedent for everywhere
- 56:05else in terms of innovation, regulation as well as where
- 56:07development. Love it.
- 56:11We need a recap. I want to talk.
- 56:13Been going on the gold rabbit hole and figuring out how that's
- 56:16going to flow. Flow with everything.
- 56:18We didn't even get to touch on that in China, so we'd have to.
- 56:21We need to get you back on at some point.
- 56:23Now for sure looking forward to that.
- 56:24It's a very interesting combo. We still have a lot of gold bugs
- 56:26on the ground so. Yeah, the guy's been here.
- 56:30They're tired of hearing about that for me.
- 56:32Michael loves his gold. He was.
- 56:33He loves his shiny rock. No, I just I the the angle is
- 56:38that gold and Bitcoin are going to persist much longer than both
- 56:40sides want them to or think is the is the angle the so tilt 2B
- 56:46TBD will part Part 2 with Abu coming soon I.
- 56:49Don't know if looking forward to it.
- 56:50Thanks again for having me guys. Thanks man.
- 56:52Thanks, I appreciate it. Later, thanks for listening to
- 56:56this week's episode of the show. If you found the information
- 56:59valuable, please share the episode with a friend or leave a
- 57:01rating on your favorite podcast app.
- 57:03All the links we discussed in today's show will be in the show
- 57:06notes inside your podcast app. Before we finish, a quick
- 57:09reminder that Onramp Media is for informational and
- 57:11entertainment purposes only, and nothing should be construed as
- 57:14investment or legal advice. Regardless of where you are on
- 57:17your Bitcoin journey, we'd love to hear from you.
- 57:19Visit onrampbitcoin.com contact to schedule a consultation with
- 57:24one of our private client advisors.