Latest / Deep Dive / The Real Reason Some Jobs Survive Globalization—and Others Don't
Transcript
- 0:00Imagine you're you're a highly trained computer scientist in
- 0:04Munich. OK, setting the scene right.
- 0:06You spent years getting your advanced degree, you write
- 0:09incredibly complex code, and you feel, you know, entirely secure
- 0:14in your career. Naturally.
- 0:15Meanwhile, the guy stocking shelves at your local grocery
- 0:18store is just terrified his job is going to be automated or
- 0:22shipped overseas. Yeah, that's the classic
- 0:24anxiety. Exactly.
- 0:25But what if the data showed that you, the highly educated
- 0:28engineer, are actually the one about to be replaced?
- 0:32And that the grocery store clerk is like, completely safe.
- 0:36I mean, it completely inverts the conventional wisdom.
- 0:39It really. Teds we have this deeply
- 0:41ingrained assumption that the global labor market operates on
- 0:45a very simple binary like high skill means you are protected
- 0:48and in demand, while low skill means you're just vulnerable.
- 0:51Right, they'll go to college so you don't lose your job
- 0:53narrative. Exactly.
- 0:55But the underlying mechanics of how jobs actually move across
- 0:58borders, they tell a completely different story.
- 1:01And that is exactly what we are tearing apart today.
- 1:05Welcome to this custom tailored deep dive built specifically for
- 1:09you. So glad to dive into this one.
- 1:12Yeah, we are looking at massive trolls of data from two major
- 1:16economic shifts to dismantle this oversimplified myth of the
- 1:20global labor market. It's a big myth to tackle.
- 1:22Oh massive. We'll be looking at a
- 1:24comprehensive a 15 year study tracking wage patterns and
- 1:28offshoring and German manufacturing.
- 1:30Fascinating stuff. And alongside that, a sprawling
- 1:33analysis of what happened when Australia tried to mass import
- 1:3610s of thousands of highly skilled accountants.
- 1:38Both of these situations really expose the fatal flaw in
- 1:42traditional dual labor market theories.
- 1:44Right, break that down for us a bit.
- 1:46So those theories assume the economy is neatly divided, that
- 1:50there is a privileged, secure primary market for the highly
- 1:53educated and a precarious secondary market for, you know,
- 1:56everyone else. The haves and they have nods.
- 1:58Yeah, but when you look at the granular tracking of real human
- 2:01beings moving through these economies, those neat divisions
- 2:05just shatter. They don't.
- 2:07Hold up. Not at all.
- 2:08The mechanisms determining who loses their job to offshoring
- 2:12and who actually gets hired when they migrate with a fancy
- 2:15degree. It's driven by factors most
- 2:17people never even consider. So if a fancy engineering degree
- 2:21in Germany doesn't protect you from the global reshuffling of
- 2:24tasks, what actually does? Well, let's look at the German
- 2:27study. Right.
- 2:28So during the period the study covers, yeah, from I think it
- 2:31was 1991 to 2006. Yep, that's right.
- 2:34Germany was a manufacturing powerhouse, but offshoring to
- 2:37Eastern Europe and Asia was accelerating really rapidly.
- 2:40Right. And the researchers realized
- 2:42that tracking entire factories moving abroad was no longer the
- 2:45right way to measure the impact on workers.
- 2:47Because it's not just about a whole building packing up.
- 2:49Exactly. The modern global economy
- 2:51doesn't operate by picking up an entire car factory in Stuttgart
- 2:54and dropping it another country. OK, so how does it operate?
- 2:58The fundamental shift in this research is viewing the labor
- 3:01market not as a trade in goods, but as a trade in tasks.
- 3:05Trade in task, yeah. A single job isn't a monolith,
- 3:08it is a highly specific bundle of tasks.
- 3:12To understand vulnerability, they mapped these tasks across 2
- 3:16vital spectrums, routine versus non routine and interactive
- 3:20versus non interactive. OK, let's unpack this because I
- 3:23want to push back on that, especially regarding the
- 3:24computer programmer example from earlier.
- 3:26Go for it. Writing complex code is highly
- 3:30non routine. It requires constant spontaneous
- 3:33problem solving, adapting to new logic structures.
- 3:37How could a company just RIP a highly complex, non routine job
- 3:40out of their headquarters and hand it to someone 5000 miles
- 3:44away without everything just, you know, breaking?
- 3:47It's a great question, but you are only looking at the
- 3:50complexity of the task, not the interactivity of.
- 3:52It the interactivity. Right, you are absolutely right
- 3:55that writing code is non routine, but is it highly
- 3:58interactive? I mean, I guess not always.
- 4:00Does that programmer physically need to be in the same room as
- 4:04the end user or the project manager to do their job?
- 4:06Usually the answer is no. Exactly.
- 4:08They can receive a brief, write the code in isolation and and
- 4:12send the finished product across the globe via the Internet with
- 4:16basically 0 friction. Wow.
- 4:18That makes their specific bundle of tasks highly vulnerable,
- 4:22despite the advanced degree and the complexity of the work.
- 4:25So the requirement for physical presence or like deep real time
- 4:29human friction is the actual shield.
- 4:32Precisely, an interactive task requires face to face contact or
- 4:36nuanced, localized interpersonal communication.
- 4:39Like a hairdresser. Yes, a hairdresser, a local
- 4:42trial lawyer, a physical therapist.
- 4:45It is incredibly difficult to offshore those tasks.
- 4:47Because you can't e-mail a haircut.
- 4:49Exactly. The German data mapped this out
- 4:52and found remarkable vulnerabilities that completely
- 4:55defy the standard skill label. The contrast in the lower skill
- 4:58bracket is fascinating here too, like the study points to a
- 5:01storekeeper. Right, a classic example.
- 5:03They might be considered low skill, yeah.
- 5:05And their daily work is highly routine, managing inventory,
- 5:08logging shipments that sort of. Thing very predictable work.
- 5:11Yeah, and because it's routine and requires very little complex
- 5:14interpersonal interaction, they are highly vulnerable to having
- 5:17their logistical tracking tasks centralized and moved off site
- 5:21or abroad. But then look at an assembler on
- 5:24a manufacturing line. Who's also classified as low
- 5:26skill. Right, but they might be
- 5:28surprisingly secure. Really.
- 5:30Why is that? The assembler is secure because
- 5:34even though their task has low interactivity, it has highly
- 5:38specific physical requirements that absolutely tie them to a
- 5:42localized physical supply chain. Oh, like you said before, you
- 5:45can't e-mail a chassis assembly. Exactly.
- 5:47The take away here is that your official title, whether it's
- 5:50Senior Software Engineer or Warehouse associate, means
- 5:53basically nothing. It's.
- 5:54All about the tasks. What matters is the precise
- 5:57composition of your daily tasks. Which naturally, brings us to
- 6:00the financial impact. If your tasks are the kind that
- 6:03can be, you know, boxed up and emailed across the world, what
- 6:07actually happens to your paycheck?
- 6:08The money side of this is where it gets really stark.
- 6:11Yeah, the researchers tackle this by separating the economic
- 6:14impact into partial equilibrium and general equilibrium.
- 6:18Right, two very different ways of measuring.
- 6:20And I think we need to define how they actually measured this
- 6:23before we look at the numbers. Good call.
- 6:26So they utilized a massive administrative data set that
- 6:29tracked the employment histories and daily wages of German
- 6:32workers over a 15 year. Incredible amount of data.
- 6:36Partial equilibrium is what happens when you isolate the
- 6:39data and only look at workers who managed to stay within their
- 6:42specific industry as offshoring occurs.
- 6:44So like staying in the auto industry?
- 6:46Right. If an auto company offshore some
- 6:48data entry tasks, but the data entry worker manages to keep a
- 6:52job within that same auto company, the wage impact is
- 6:56incredibly small. The numbers for that isolated
- 6:58group are almost negligible, like for a low skilled worker
- 7:01doing highly offshore able work, meaning low interactivity and
- 7:05highly routine tasks, they only lost about 32 euro cents an
- 7:08hour. Which doesn't sound like much.
- 7:11Right. Assuming a standard work year,
- 7:13that is a drop of roughly 390 to €480 a year.
- 7:17A tiny dent. And crazily enough, workers
- 7:20doing highly interactive tasks actually gained up to €225 a
- 7:24year. Presumably because they're
- 7:26localized, communication skills became more valuable as the
- 7:29broader supply chain became more complex.
- 7:32So looking purely at partial equilibrium, you might conclude
- 7:35that offshoring is practically harmless.
- 7:37A tiny wage cut for some, a slight bump for others.
- 7:40Nothing to panic over. Here's.
- 7:42Where it gets really interesting though, If the losses are that
- 7:45tiny, why is the fear of offshoring so pervasive?
- 7:48It's a huge political issue everywhere.
- 7:50Exactly. When a major employer announces
- 7:53they are moving operations abroad, entire towns panic.
- 7:57Is the public just, you know, economically illiterate?
- 8:00Or is this partial equilibrium view hiding the real damage?
- 8:04The partial view is essentially A statistical illusion because
- 8:07it assumes the labor market is static.
- 8:09Which it isn't. Not at all.
- 8:11The public fear is entirely justified, and the data proves
- 8:13that the moment you switch to analyzing the general
- 8:15equilibrium. The wider lens.
- 8:17Yes, this means zooming out and tracking what happens when
- 8:20workers are forced to move across different industries.
- 8:22OK. So if I am listening to this and
- 8:25I work in marketing, an industry completely unrelated to auto
- 8:29manufacturing, this study is saying my salary could drop
- 8:33simply because a bunch of displace auto workers decide to
- 8:36start applying for marketing jobs.
- 8:38That is the exact mechanism. Think of the National Labor
- 8:42market as a massive contained pool of water.
- 8:45If you drop a heavy boulder into the deep end, the water doesn't
- 8:49just rise in that one spot. The whole pool sloshes.
- 8:52The entire pool sloshes and the water level rises everywhere.
- 8:56When highly non interactive tasks are offshore to the
- 8:59manufacturing sector, those displaced workers don't just
- 9:02vanish. Right, they have to eat they.
- 9:04Flood into the service sector or logistics sector desperately
- 9:08looking for that matches their remaining skill sets.
- 9:11They increase the supply of Labor for those specific tasks
- 9:14across the entire economy. And we know what happens to
- 9:16price when supply drastically increases.
- 9:19Wage elasticity kicks in. Exactly, employers suddenly have
- 9:22a massive surplus of candidates capable of doing routine or non
- 9:26interactive tasks which completely destroys the workers
- 9:29negotiating power. It's a race to the bottom.
- 9:31The financial hit is no longer isolated.
- 9:33It multiplies. The data is brutal here.
- 9:37When the researchers accounted for this cross industry
- 9:39flooding, low skilled workers in the lowest interactivity bracket
- 9:43didn't lose $0.32 an hour. No, it jumped significantly.
- 9:47Saw a cumulative wage cuts of 1.31 euros per hour.
- 9:51That translates to almost €2000 lost every single year.
- 9:55And medium skilled workers suffered even more, losing up to
- 9:59€2460 a year. That is a massive chunk of
- 10:04change for an average family. It really is.
- 10:06The underlying reality that the German study proves is that the
- 10:09true threat of offshoring isn't just your specific desk being
- 10:13moved to another country, right? The systemic threat is the
- 10:16invisible flood of displaced workers from completely
- 10:19different industries, driving down the market value of your
- 10:22specific bundle of tasks. So if a high end degree doesn't
- 10:25protect you from the global reshuffling of tasks, what
- 10:28happens when an entire country tries to hack this system?
- 10:31Oh, this is the other side of the coin.
- 10:33Right, like mass importing degrees to fix a perceived
- 10:36problem. If we look at Australia, between
- 10:402005 and 2010 they ran a massive real world experiment on exactly
- 10:45this premise. The Australian situation test
- 10:47The exact same myth that a formal credential guarantees
- 10:51economic integration, just from the opposite direction.
- 10:54During that five year window, the Australian economy was
- 10:56absolutely booming due to the mining sector.
- 10:58Tons of money flowing in. Yep.
- 11:00And the government declared a severe skill shortage in several
- 11:03professions, particularly accounting.
- 11:06So they took action. They utilize an uncapped points
- 11:09based visa system. If you were young, spoke strong
- 11:13English, held a university degree, and your occupation was
- 11:15on the demand list, you basically accumulated enough
- 11:18points for permanent residency. The mechanism was designed to
- 11:21act as a surgical injection of top tier talent into a gaping
- 11:24hole in the economy. And because it was uncapped, the
- 11:27response was astronomical. Over 63,000 migrant accountants
- 11:31entered Australia in just five years.
- 11:33That is a staggering number of accountants.
- 11:35Right, But when you look at the outcome, it forces a really
- 11:38uncomfortable question, which is did Australia actually have a
- 11:41desperate, screaming need for 63,000 professional accountants,
- 11:46or is the very concept of a skill shortage entirely socially
- 11:50constructed? The research strongly indicates
- 11:53it is a socially constructed, heavily politicized metric.
- 11:57Oh so. Well, the government was relying
- 11:59on macroeconomic forecasting models to declare a national
- 12:02shortage, but the researchers went and surveyed the actual
- 12:07accounting firms on the ground. And what did they find?
- 12:09The microeconomic reality was entirely disconnected from the
- 12:13government's models. I mean, the government
- 12:15envisioned these gleaning corporate towers desperate for
- 12:19thousands of fresh university graduates to just crunch
- 12:22numbers. But the Australian accounting
- 12:24industry wasn't dominated by massive multinational firms with
- 12:28endless resources for training. What was it mostly?
- 12:31It was predominantly composed of small suburban firms.
- 12:34You know one or two stressed principles managing the tax
- 12:37needs of local hardware stores and bakeries.
- 12:39Just everyday small businesses. Yeah, and these suburban firms
- 12:43absolutely refused to hire entry level workers.
- 12:45They. Didn't want the fresh grads.
- 12:47Not at all. They didn't have the time, the
- 12:49budget, or the patience to train someone who just walked out of a
- 12:52university, regardless of where that university was located.
- 12:55They wanted someone who already had three to five years of
- 12:59specific localized experience, right?
- 13:02Someone who already knew the bizarre intricacies of the
- 13:05Australian tax code. Exactly.
- 13:08The macro policy was importing 10s of thousands of people for
- 13:13entry level professional roles that simply did not exist.
- 13:16It's like building a door to a house that isn't there.
- 13:19The government was using an accounting degree merely as a
- 13:22proxy. They were essentially filtering
- 13:24for immigrants who possess general numerical,
- 13:27administrative and business competence, assuming the market
- 13:30would just magically absorb them into high level roles.
- 13:32Which brings up the most glaring issue.
- 13:35If there weren't 63,000 professional accounting desks
- 13:38waiting for these migrants, where did they actually go?
- 13:41We have to follow the tracking data.
- 13:42Right. The researchers analyzed data
- 13:44from the continuous survey of Australia's migrants.
- 13:47It followed exactly where these individuals landed in the
- 13:50workforce. And the outcomes reveal a
- 13:53profoundly rigid sifting mechanism.
- 13:56It's not a free for all. No, the labor market isn't a
- 13:59fluid environment where the smartest person automatically
- 14:02gets the best job. It seems less like a meritocracy
- 14:05and more like AVIP club with a broken front door.
- 14:08That's a great analogy. Like your university degree gets
- 14:11you past the Border Patrol, the first bouncer.
- 14:14You are officially in the country, right?
- 14:16You're in the lobby. But once you step into the lobby
- 14:19of the labor market, there's a second, much more subjective
- 14:22bouncer guarding the elevator to the professional managerial
- 14:25jobs. And that second bouncer is
- 14:28sorting people based on criteria that have nothing to do with
- 14:31their actual accounting skills. The data shows how ruthless that
- 14:35second bouncer was. Let's look at the tiny fraction
- 14:37of migrants who arrived as employer nominated.
- 14:40Meaning what exactly? This means an Australian
- 14:42employer actively sponsored them for a specific pre-existing role
- 14:45before they even arrived. OK for that group they bypassed
- 14:49the lobby entirely. Over 90% of them successfully
- 14:52landed in professional or managerial accounting roles.
- 14:55Because they already had the golden ticket.
- 14:56Exactly. But for the vast majority, the
- 14:59former international students the family sponsored migrants,
- 15:02the independent skilled workers who just showed up with their
- 15:04degree and a visa, the elevator doors slammed shut that.
- 15:08Canine Entry. Only about 25% to 30% of them
- 15:11ever actually worked as accountants.
- 15:13Wow, So what happened to the other 70 to 75%?
- 15:16This is where the tracking data reveals massive trickle across
- 15:20and trickle down effects driven by employer biases regarding
- 15:23country of origin and gender. It's important to clarify here,
- 15:27the academic source isn't making a moral judgement or a political
- 15:30statement. Yeah, not at all.
- 15:31It is strictly analyzing the self reported hiring behaviors
- 15:35of Australian employers during this five year window and the
- 15:39demographic split in that data is really stark.
- 15:42It really is migrants from advanced English speaking
- 15:45countries like the UK, the US, Canada, South Africa.
- 15:48They had an 80% success rate finding accounting or managerial
- 15:52work. So they made it past the second
- 15:54bouncer. They.
- 15:55Did But highly educated migrants from China and South Asia faced
- 15:59an entirely different reality. The employers actively sifted
- 16:03them out. How did that practically happen?
- 16:07Was it just overt malice or something more systemic?
- 16:11It was largely driven by risk averse employer behavior heavily
- 16:15reliant on cultural familiarity. Meaning they went with what they
- 16:19knew. Imagine that suburban accounting
- 16:21principle looking at a stack of resumes.
- 16:24They see a degree from a Chinese university they have never heard
- 16:27of, and they see no local Australian references.
- 16:30They perceive it as a risk. Exactly.
- 16:32Instead of assessing the applicant's raw mathematical
- 16:35ability, the employer defaults to the perceived safe choice, a
- 16:39local applicant or an immigrant from a culturally similar
- 16:42background like the UK. So despite having the exact same
- 16:45technical qualifications, the very degrees that the Australian
- 16:48government demanded they have to get the visa, these migrants
- 16:52were pushed out of the top tier jobs and they had to survive.
- 16:55So they trickle down, they moved into clerical work, basic
- 16:58bookkeeping, or they abandoned the financial sector entirely.
- 17:01The gender data within this downward mobility is
- 17:04particularly telling. Yeah, sure, that.
- 17:06Women from China and South Asia who held accounting degrees
- 17:10frequently ended up working in retail.
- 17:12With an accounting degree. Right.
- 17:14And men from those same regions frequently trickled down into
- 17:17the transport and logistics sectors.
- 17:20They utilize their general numerical and administrative
- 17:22skills to function in lower tier jobs.
- 17:25Which triggers a massive ripple effect that circles all the way
- 17:29back to the general equilibrium concept we saw in Germany.
- 17:32The pool of water is sloshing again.
- 17:35Because these 63,000 highly educated migrants didn't just
- 17:40evaporate when they were denied professional accounting jobs.
- 17:43Still needed to work. They successfully competed for
- 17:46and secured middle order jobs, jobs that were absolutely not
- 17:51experiencing a skills shortage. They displaced the local
- 17:54workforce exactly By unleashing a massive wave of overqualified,
- 17:58highly credentialed workers who were systematically locked out
- 18:01of the top tier, the government inadvertently flooded the middle
- 18:05and bottom of the labor market. The boulder in the pool again.
- 18:08A migrant with a master's degree in accounting who is forced to
- 18:11apply for a basic payroll clerk position is going to beat the
- 18:16local High School graduate applying for that same entry
- 18:18level job. Almost every single time.
- 18:21The policy was intended to surgically fix a gap at the very
- 18:24top of the economy, but instead the rigidity of employer
- 18:28preferences turned it into an anvil that dropped onto the
- 18:31local entry level workforce. It proves that labor markets are
- 18:35inherently segmented and discriminatory.
- 18:37They do not operate purely on the logic of raw technical skill
- 18:41or formal credentials. They run on human factors.
- 18:43They went on a complex mixture of localized experience,
- 18:47cultural familiarity, and the specific daily tasks an employer
- 18:51needs completed without friction.
- 18:52We have covered a tremendous amount of economic theory and
- 18:55human reality today. What is the ultimate take away
- 18:58from these two massive data sets for you listening right now?
- 19:01It's a lot to process. Whether we are analyzing the
- 19:04mechanics of routine tasks being offshored from a manufacturing
- 19:08plant in Germany, or tracking highly educated accountants as
- 19:12they are forced down the ladder into retail jobs in Australia,
- 19:16the global labor market is never a clean equation.
- 19:19It's never as simple as they tell you.
- 19:21High skill does not automatically equal success, and
- 19:24a credential does not equal a shield.
- 19:26Your value in the modern economy is entirely dictated by the
- 19:30specific granular tasks you perform every single day.
- 19:33The actual things you do. Right.
- 19:35How much deep, localized human interaction does your work
- 19:38require? How vulnerable are your specific
- 19:41tasks to being unbundled and performed in isolation?
- 19:45Good questions to ask yourself. And how much does your industry
- 19:47rely on cultural context rather than raw technical output?
- 19:52Those are the factors determining your economic
- 19:53security, not the title printed on your business card.
- 19:56The water in the economic pool is constantly sloshing and the
- 20:00bouncers in the lobby are always changing the rules.
- 20:02So true. Which leaves us with a final
- 20:04thought for you to chew on as you go about your day, if
- 20:07technical skills are just a proxy and the actual tasks you
- 20:10do can be unbundled, repackaged and shipped across the world, or
- 20:14taken by a highly educated migrant who has been unfairly
- 20:18locked out of their own profession.
- 20:19Left. Right.
- 20:20What is the core, deeply human, unoffshorable value that you
- 20:24bring to your work everyday? Thank you for joining us on this
- 20:27deep dive.