Latest / Deep Values: Value Investing Deep Dives / René Girard: The Philosopher Behind Peter Thiel and J.D Vance; The Philosophical Architect of Silicon Valley and Politics
Transcript
- 0:00Welcome back to the Deep Dive. Today we're looking at something
- 0:03that honestly feels a bit like trying to reverse engineer the
- 0:06operating system of the modern world.
- 0:08Yeah, that's actually pretty good way to put it.
- 0:10Because we have a question today that on the surface it sounds
- 0:15like the setup to a really complex, maybe even slightly
- 0:19conspiratorial joke. Right, like a Riddle you'd hear
- 0:21at some incredibly niche faculty dinner party.
- 0:24Exactly. And the question is this What is
- 0:27the invisible thread that connects a Silicon Valley
- 0:29libertarian billionaire, specifically Peter Thiel, with
- 0:33the populist conservative vice president of the United States,
- 0:36JD Vance? And you know, before you even
- 0:38answer that, I think most people listening are going to instantly
- 0:41say, well, it's easy, it's money.
- 0:42Right. Or it's just the Republican
- 0:43Party. Or maybe.
- 0:44Just the fact that Thiel was Vance's mentor at a venture
- 0:47capital firm back in the day. The usual suspects, yeah.
- 0:50Yeah. But the research we're unpacking
- 0:52today, which is based on a really incredible analysis by a
- 0:55source known as Mr. Brain, it suggests that if you just stop
- 0:59at money or politics, you are completely missing the picture.
- 1:02You're looking at the symptoms, not the actual disease.
- 1:05The real connection isn't a bank account or a super pick, it's
- 1:08actually a philosopher, right? A single, somewhat obscure
- 1:12French philosopher named Renee Gerard.
- 1:15Which is wild to think about. It really is.
- 1:17And so the mission for our deep dive today is to unpack those,
- 1:20to prove to you that Gerard's ideas are not just some dry
- 1:23academic theory. They are basically a
- 1:26philosophical code. A code that explains pretty much
- 1:29everything. Yeah, why you compulsively
- 1:30bought that new iPhone, Why the massive tutoring industry in
- 1:34China collapsed literally overnight, Why Peter Thiel
- 1:37invested in Facebook when everyone else was saying it was
- 1:39just a silly toy for college kids.
- 1:41And even why political polarization, especially in the
- 1:43West, feels like it's spiraling into something genuinely
- 1:46dangerous right now. It's a framework that predicts
- 1:49tech waves and political winds with frightening accuracy.
- 1:53We are effectively looking at the playbook used by some of the
- 1:55most powerful people on Earth. It's a CHEAT SHEET for human
- 1:58behavior. It really is.
- 1:59It is now before we dive into the philosophy of desire, and
- 2:03I'm seriously not kidding, the potential apocalypse, we have a
- 2:06very practical tool we want to share with you.
- 2:08Because if we're talking about understanding markets, you need
- 2:11a thermometer. You can't just operate on high
- 2:13level theory. No, you absolutely have to
- 2:15ground the stuff in data if you are interested in where the
- 2:18market actually sits right now. Like is it overheated?
- 2:21Is it undervalued? Are we sitting in a bubble forms
- 2:25by the exact memetic desires we're about to discuss.
- 2:28You really need to track the total market temperature.
- 2:30And there is a specific tool for this that comes highly
- 2:32recommended in the materials we're looking at the track total
- 2:35market temperature. Welcome toach and download iOS
- 2:38App Buffett indicator from Apple App Store.
- 2:41It's a classic valuation metric famously favored by Warren
- 2:44Buffett, and having it right at your fingertips is key.
- 2:47Helps you separate the signal from the noise, which is exactly
- 2:49what we are trying to do with Gerard today.
- 2:51Exactly. OK, so let's open the file on
- 2:53this. We're looking at this deep dive
- 2:55analysis regarding Renee Gerard. And I want to set the stage here
- 2:58because when we say French philosopher, I think a lot of
- 3:01people listening might immediately tune out.
- 3:03Oh for sure. They picture a guy in a black
- 3:07turtleneck smoking a cigarette in a Parisian cafe, talking
- 3:11about how life is meaningless. Right, just meaningless on wing
- 3:14and baguettes. But that is not what this is.
- 3:16This is not abstract at all. This is the intellectual engine
- 3:20of Palantir, of PayPal, of the modern populist movement.
- 3:23So let's meet the godfather. Who on earth is Renee Girard?
- 3:27So Renee Girard was a historian and a professor of literature at
- 3:30Stanford University. And you're right, he wasn't a
- 3:32business guru. He wasn't out there writing The
- 3:34Seven Habits of Highly Effective People.
- 3:36He wasn't giving Ted talks on synergy or whatever.
- 3:38No, not at all. He was analyzing Shakespeare,
- 3:40Dostevsky, Crust, and the Bible. A little professor, Literally a
- 3:45guy analyzing fiction. A lit professor, but back in the
- 3:481990s he ran a very small, very private reading group at
- 3:51Stanford. We aren't talking about a
- 3:53massive lecture hall with hundreds of kids.
- 3:55We are talking about maybe 10 people sitting around a table.
- 3:58Digging into texts about ancient sacrifice and human envy.
- 4:02Yes, and one of the regulars sitting at that table was a
- 4:05young law student named Peter Thiel.
- 4:07Wow, the Peter Thiel like before PayPal, before the billion.
- 4:12The Peter Thiel. And this wasn't just a fun
- 4:14elective for him to blow off steam.
- 4:16Thiel later went on record calling Gerard Silicon Valley's
- 4:19most important thinker. Not Steve Jobs, Not Bill Gates,
- 4:23a French literary theorist. That is a massive statement.
- 4:26I mean, Silicon Valley's a place that worships engineers,
- 4:29physicists, people who build tangible things.
- 4:31Why a philosopher? Well, because.
- 4:33Teal realized something crucial. Engineering solves technical
- 4:35problems, right? But it doesn't solve human
- 4:37problems. And the absolute biggest problem
- 4:39in business isn't how do I write this block of code, it's what
- 4:43should I build that people will actually want.
- 4:46And maybe more importantly, how do I stop other people from
- 4:48destroying me while I build it? And that's where your art comes
- 4:51in. Exactly, if you look at teals
- 4:53business philosophy like the concepts he wrote about in his
- 4:55famous book Zero to 1 ideas like Competition is for losers or The
- 5:00relentless pursuit of monopoly. This always sounded to me like
- 5:03just contrarian tech bro hot takes.
- 5:05They sound like that, yeah, but they are.
- 5:07They come directly, almost verbatim from Gerard's
- 5:10understanding of human nature. Teals entire investment success
- 5:13is essentially A practical billion dollar application of
- 5:17Gerard's insights. So Palantir and Facebook, these
- 5:20massive successes are practical applications of literary theory?
- 5:23That's crazy. It really is.
- 5:25Teal used Gerard's map to navigate the entire business
- 5:28world. But the lineage?
- 5:29It doesn't stop with Teal, because Teal then took these
- 5:32exact ideas and introduce them to his protege.
- 5:34JD Vance. JD Vance and the source material
- 5:37here mentions that this went really deep for Vance.
- 5:40This wasn't just a casual book recommendation over coffee.
- 5:44Right, it wasn't just hey, read this for your career.
- 5:46No, it was foundational to his identity.
- 5:48The analysis claims that Gerard's thinking didn't just
- 5:51shape Vance's politics, it actually facilitated his
- 5:54conversion from Protestantism to Catholicism.
- 5:58It completely reshaped his worldview on how society
- 6:01functions, why the working class is angry, and what the ultimate
- 6:05role of religion is in holding it all together.
- 6:07You know, you think about a major political figure,
- 6:09especially a vice president, and you just assume their stance
- 6:12comes from polling data or focus groups or whatever the party
- 6:16platform dictates that week. But here we have a direct
- 6:19intellectual lineage from a theory of human desire straight
- 6:22to the White House. And that's exactly why we're
- 6:24doing this deep dive right now. This is an ancient history.
- 6:27The source argues that Gerard's influence is only going to grow
- 6:30in the coming decades, especially if the political
- 6:32faction that Vance represents remains powerful.
- 6:35We are effectively living in a world that is navigating by
- 6:37Gerard's map. Yeah, so we'd better learn how
- 6:39to read it, OK? Let's open the Mac then.
- 6:42We really need to understand the core mechanic here, which brings
- 6:45us to mimetic desire. This is the concept that
- 6:49explains why we want what we want.
- 6:51Right. And to understand this, you kind
- 6:52of have to throw out everything you think you know about your
- 6:55own free will. Well, that's a comforting way to
- 6:57start. Everything you know is a lie.
- 6:59I know it's rough, but Gerard's starting point is completely
- 7:03counterintuitive to how we live. We all like to think that desire
- 7:06is a straight line, that it's linear.
- 7:08OK, paint that picture for us. How do we think it works?
- 7:11OK, so I am the subject. The thing I want.
- 7:14Let's say it's a shiny new Porsche is the object.
- 7:17I see the Porsche, I look at it and I think, wow, it has great
- 7:20engineering, it's fast, the leather is nice.
- 7:22Therefore I want it. Subject pointing straight to the
- 7:25object. Exactly a straight line and.
- 7:27That feels true. I mean, I want a burger because
- 7:29I'm hungry and it tastes good. I want a specific car because
- 7:33it's a good car. Gerard says that is totally
- 7:35wrong. Completely wrong.
- 7:37He says that straight line is a lie we tell ourselves to
- 7:39preserve our own ego. We want to believe we are
- 7:42original. But he argues that desire is
- 7:44actually a triangular structure. A triangle.
- 7:46Yes, there are three points to it, not two.
- 7:48You have you the subject, you have the object you think you
- 7:51want, and then you have the Third Point which is by far the
- 7:53most important, which is the mediator, or you can call it the
- 7:57model the. Model.
- 7:58We don't. Actually desire the object
- 7:59itself. We desire it because someone
- 8:01else, the mediator, wants it or already has it.
- 8:04Wait, so. I don't want the sports car
- 8:05because of the car itself. I want it because what?
- 8:07Because George Clooney drives it?
- 8:09Or because my rich neighbor has one.
- 8:11Exactly. You are imitating the desire of
- 8:14the model. The object itself is just a
- 8:16totem, it's just a placeholder. What you really want is the
- 8:19identity, the status or the essence of being that the
- 8:22mediator possesses. This is.
- 8:24What he calls mimetic desire. Yeah, but the misos meaning
- 8:27imitation, right? We are, at our core, imitation
- 8:30machines. We look around constantly to see
- 8:32what other people want so that we know what we should want.
- 8:35We don't have an internal compass.
- 8:37We have a radar that pings off other people.
- 8:40The source? Material has some really
- 8:41fascinating examples to illustrate this, and the first
- 8:44one kind of blew my mind because it spans such a huge historical
- 8:48time frame. It compares historical beauty to
- 8:52modern influencers. Yeah.
- 8:53This is a brilliant way to visualize a very specific nuance
- 8:56of the theory, which is the distance of the mediator.
- 9:00Explain. That what does distance mean
- 9:01here OK so the. Source asked question Why do
- 9:03photos or paintings of king dynasty concubines provoke
- 9:06absolutely no desire or envy in US today?
- 9:08Right. I mean, they were considered the
- 9:10absolute peak of beauty and status in their time.
- 9:14But we look at them now and we feel nothing.
- 9:15We don't want to be them. We don't covet their lives.
- 9:18But a modern Instagram influencer that sparks immediate
- 9:21desire, envy, attraction, I mean.
- 9:24The obvious answer to that is just fashion trends change,
- 9:26right? Or just the fact that I don't
- 9:28live in 18th century China? Sure.
- 9:29But look deeper. The analysis suggests it's
- 9:32actually about your relationship to the mediator.
- 9:35In the King dynasty, those women essentially belong to the
- 9:38emperor. OK, the Emperor now.
- 9:40Think about the average person. The emperor is a God like
- 9:44figure. He is incredibly abstract.
- 9:46He is distant. You don't wake up in the morning
- 9:48as a regular person wanting to literally be the king emperor.
- 9:51The gap is just way too wide. He's not.
- 9:54A viable model for me. I can't imitate him because it's
- 9:56impossible. Exactly.
- 9:57Because you can't identify with the mediator, you can't mimic
- 10:00his desire. The triangle is broken before it
- 10:02even forms. OK, so.
- 10:04How does that contrast with the modern influencer think about?
- 10:07A modern influencer you see online, maybe they are dating a
- 10:10tech CEO or a wealthy socialite. The source mentioned someone
- 10:13like Wang Sukong in China or just a generic wealthy
- 10:16entrepreneur in the West. Right that.
- 10:18Feels a lot closer much? Closer, you can actually imagine
- 10:21that lifestyle. You can imagine having that kind
- 10:23of money, that kind of status. The mediator is just barely out
- 10:26of reach, but close enough to feel real because the model
- 10:30feels attainable. The desire for the object, the
- 10:33lifestyle, the clothes, the vacation becomes incredibly
- 10:36intense. So we.
- 10:37Only want things when we can actually see ourselves in the
- 10:40shoes of the person who has them or.
- 10:42When we desperately want to be the person who commands them.
- 10:45And this brings us to a second example from the text, which is
- 10:47about uniforms. Yes.
- 10:49The uniform attraction This is such a common cultural trope,
- 10:52right? People liking partners in
- 10:54uniform, police, military pilots, the.
- 10:56Psychology here is pure Girard, the source argues.
- 11:00It has nothing to do with the fabric or the cut of the suit or
- 11:03the shiny buttons. It's entirely about the
- 11:05hierarchy. How so?
- 11:06If. You are attracted to the
- 11:07uniform. The argument is that you are
- 11:09unconsciously imitating the desire of the superior officer,
- 11:12the one who commands that person in uniform.
- 11:14Wait. Break it down for me that sounds
- 11:16like 40 chess for attraction. It's.
- 11:17All a power dynamic. Think about it.
- 11:20The boss or the general highly values the soldier.
- 11:23By desiring the soldier, you are unconsciously aligning your
- 11:26desire with the ultimate figure of authority.
- 11:29You want to occupy the slot of the boss.
- 11:31You want to be the one who commands that is.
- 11:33Deeply psychological it. Is, and the craziest part, is
- 11:36that this mimetic target changes as we change.
- 11:39There's an anecdote in the sorts about a friend whose entire type
- 11:42of partner shifted completely as his career shifted.
- 11:45Oh. Right.
- 11:45The guy who went from academia to finance?
- 11:47Exactly. So when he was a young academic,
- 11:50his type was intellectual partners.
- 11:52He wanted women who look like professors, literary types, very
- 11:55bohemian. Why?
- 11:56Because his model at the time was the senior professor he
- 11:59wanted. To be the tenured Don, right so
- 12:00he. Desired what he thought the
- 12:02tenured Don desired. He adopted the values of his
- 12:05mediator and then. What happened?
- 12:06He switched to Wall Street. He got.
- 12:08A job in finance and suddenly, almost overnight, the
- 12:11intellectuals just didn't do it for him anymore.
- 12:13He started dating people who fit the corporate finance mold,
- 12:17professional suits, high power corporate vibes, status symbols
- 12:20because. His model changed.
- 12:22He stopped worshipping the professor and started
- 12:24worshipping the managing director.
- 12:26His. Career goal shifted, which means
- 12:27his identity goal shifted, which means his object of desire
- 12:31shifted to match the new mediator that.
- 12:33Is the real aha moment right there.
- 12:35It implies that our desires are not internal at all.
- 12:37They are entirely external. We are basically just walking
- 12:40mirrors reflecting what we think the cool kids are, the
- 12:42successful people want we are. Imitation machines.
- 12:45And once you understand that fundamental truth, you start to
- 12:48understand the entire global economy.
- 12:51Which brings us to the next massive piece of this puzzle,
- 12:54memetic desire in business and investing the economy.
- 12:57Of imitation marketing. Social trends, Stock bubbles,
- 13:00It's all just memetic desire playing out at scale.
- 13:03Let's talk. About tourism for a second
- 13:04because this is 1 where I feel personally attacked.
- 13:07The Internet famous spots, yes. We've all done it.
- 13:11You travel to a place not because it looks particularly
- 13:13comfortable or because the food's objectively the best, but
- 13:16because you've seen 500 people post about it on Instagram or
- 13:19TikTok. You.
- 13:20Aren't going for the actual experience, you are going for
- 13:22the badge. The crowd acts as the mediator.
- 13:25You want to prove that you are part of the in Group that goes
- 13:28to the specific place. You want to imitate the travel
- 13:30influencer lifestyle. The source also brings up luxury
- 13:34goods, and there's a really interesting cultural nuance here
- 13:37between Mutai Liquor and Remy Martin cognac in Hong Kong.
- 13:41This. Is a perfect example of how the
- 13:43model completely defines the market.
- 13:45It's not about the product. In mainland China, Kwaija Mutai
- 13:48is the ultimate undisputed status symbol.
- 13:51It's incredibly expensive and hard to get.
- 13:53Why? Because for decades the model in
- 13:56that society was the high-ranking government
- 13:58official. The official.
- 13:59Drank Mutai, right? So if you were a businessman or
- 14:02just upper middle class and you wanted to project power and
- 14:04success, you copied the official.
- 14:06You bought Mutai but in. Hong Kong, it's different, very.
- 14:09Different in Hong Kong, the historical model wasn't the
- 14:11communist official, it was the British colonial elite or the
- 14:15Western old money tycoon. And what did they drink?
- 14:18Cohen. Jacks Brandy.
- 14:19Exactly, they drank Remy Martin, so Mutai doesn't trigger the
- 14:24same massive mimetic desire in Hong Kong because the mediator
- 14:28is different. It has nothing to do with the
- 14:29actual taste of the liquor. It was purely about taste.
- 14:33Preferences would be more randomly distributed, but they
- 14:36aren't. Random they aren't.
- 14:37Random at all. They are tightly clustered
- 14:38around whoever the model is in that specific culture.
- 14:41It's. Literally about who you are
- 14:43drinking a toast to in your own imagination.
- 14:46Precisely. Now here is where Peter Thiel
- 14:49earns his billions. The source refers to this
- 14:52specific investment strategy as the imitation factory I love.
- 14:56That term the imitation factory, although it sounds a little
- 14:58manipulative. Oh it.
- 14:59Is highly manipulative. The core thesis is simple.
- 15:01The best businesses on earth are those that efficiently
- 15:04manufacture and distribute desire.
- 15:05OK, let's look. At the iPhone and Tesla, the
- 15:07source makes a really counterintuitive point here
- 15:09about their early days. The early versions of these
- 15:12products were actually kind of bad.
- 15:13They were. Deeply flawed.
- 15:14Think about the first iPhone. It didn't have 3G, it dropped
- 15:17calls constantly, there was no App Store, the battery life was
- 15:20a joke and the early Teslas, the panel gaps were so big you could
- 15:23literally stick your finger through them.
- 15:25The range anxiety was a massive real world problem from a
- 15:28purely. Utilitarian standpoint, if you
- 15:30just wanted a tool, a Nokia or a Toyota was objectively better.
- 15:34Much. Better, more reliable, way
- 15:36cheaper, easier to fix. So why?
- 15:38Did they win? How did they take over the
- 15:39world? Because they weren't being sold
- 15:41as utilities. They were sold as status symbols
- 15:44to a very specific, carefully chosen group.
- 15:47The innovators and the elites. The tech Bros.
- 15:51The Silicon Valley wealthy, these people became the
- 15:54mediators, so the. Strategy for a startup, if you
- 15:57follow Gerard, is don't sell to the masses first.
- 16:00Never. Sell to the masses first.
- 16:01That's the ultimate trap. You sell to the key influencers,
- 16:04the mediators. Once they are hooked and they
- 16:06are seen using the product, the masses literally have no choice
- 16:09but to follow. They must imitate if they want
- 16:11to claim that status for themselves.
- 16:13You create. The envy 1st and the sales
- 16:15naturally follow that's. The playbook and today social
- 16:18media is the ultimate perfected engine for this the.
- 16:21Source calls platforms like Instagram and Tiktok visualized
- 16:25desire tools. Think about what you're actually
- 16:28doing on those as they don't really sell content, they sell
- 16:31idealized lives. When you scroll Tiktok, you
- 16:34aren't just being entertained by a funny video, you are being
- 16:37relentlessly bombarded with models.
- 16:39Look at this person's perfect morning routine.
- 16:41Look at this person's insane vacation in Greece.
- 16:44Look at what they're wearing and the.
- 16:45Algorithm's powering this the algorithms.
- 16:47Are imitation amplifiers. They are mathematically designed
- 16:49to detect exactly what is sparking imitation in real time,
- 16:52What is getting likes, what is getting shares, what is making
- 16:55people pause. And then they scale that
- 16:57specific desire globally in 24 hours.
- 17:00So a company like Facebook or TikTok, they don't actually
- 17:03monopolize the video itself. Anyone can host a video.
- 17:05They monopolize the channel of desire transmission that.
- 17:08Is their true monopoly and that gives them almost infinite
- 17:10pricing power because if you want to sell anything in this
- 17:13modern world, you have to go through the tollbooth of the
- 17:16channel where desire is being actively manufactured.
- 17:18Wow. And this even applies to the
- 17:21massive AI boom we are in right now, doesn't it?
- 17:23Oh. Absolutely the mad rush to use
- 17:26ChatGPT and every other AI tool, the source argues.
- 17:29That is deeply mimetic too. How so?
- 17:32Because AI actually seems pretty useful.
- 17:34It is. Useful, but think about the
- 17:35psychology of the mass adoption. Are average people really
- 17:38excited about the architecture of large language models?
- 17:41No. No, they are terrified of being
- 17:43left behind. They see the tech elite using
- 17:46AI. They read articles about how the
- 17:47future proof worker uses AI. That idealized worker becomes
- 17:51the new model. So they.
- 17:52Rush to imitate that model exactly.
- 17:54It's FOMO, fear of missing out, which is just mimetic desire by
- 17:58another name. We aren't running toward the
- 18:00technology because we love it. We are running away from being
- 18:02the person who doesn't have it. That makes.
- 18:04Total sense. But here is where the deep dive
- 18:07takes a turn and things get a bit dark.
- 18:09Because if everyone wants the exact same thing, what happens?
- 18:12And what do you fight? We fight and that this brings us
- 18:14to Section 4, mimetic competition and the trap, right?
- 18:18Because if desire is triangular, if you only want what the model
- 18:22wants, eventually the imitator and the model are going to
- 18:24collide. They're going to.
- 18:25Bump into each other reaching for the same object, correct?
- 18:28And this leads to what Gerard calls the twinship of rivals,
- 18:31homogeneity, diversity. Disappears completely.
- 18:34Everyone wants the same prestigious job, the same house
- 18:37and the same zip code, the same exact credentials from the same
- 18:40universities. And when everyone in a society
- 18:42wants the exact same scarce resource, friendly competition
- 18:46devolves into a 0 sum death match.
- 18:48The. Source uses a very specific term
- 18:50for this, translating from Chinese evolution or in Chinese
- 18:54niwan niwan. It's a massive buzzword in China
- 18:57right now for a very good reason, but it absolutely
- 19:00applies everywhere in the modern world.
- 19:03The source uses the education system as the prime example, and
- 19:07frankly, it is a perfect illustration of Girard's concept
- 19:10of hell. Let's.
- 19:10Unpack that education example because I think every parent
- 19:13listening to this feels this dynamic in their bones.
- 19:16OK. Let's look at the setup.
- 19:18Parents don't typically cultivate unique, quirky skills
- 19:21in their kids anymore. They imitate the standard path,
- 19:23right? High test scores, elite prep
- 19:25schools, piano lessons, coding boot camps for toddlers, but.
- 19:29Why? Not because the kid genuinely
- 19:31loves playing the piano, but because that's what the
- 19:33successful neighbor is doing. The mediator.
- 19:35Again, if their kid is doing it, my kid has to do it or we're
- 19:38falling behind, right? But here's the trap.
- 19:41Since top university spots are mathematically fixed, it's a
- 19:44strictly 0 sum resource. What happens when everyone
- 19:47imitates the same strategy? You get endlessly escalating
- 19:50inputs. More tutoring.
- 19:52Less sleep, more stress, endless extracurriculars for.
- 19:55Absolutely no increase in total rewards.
- 19:58The source uses the classic standing up in a movie theater
- 20:01analogy. If one person stands up, they
- 20:03get a better view. But if everyone stands up
- 20:05because they imitate the first guy, nobody sees the screen any
- 20:08better. But now everyone is just
- 20:10exhausted and uncomfortable. That is exactly the outcome.
- 20:13Everyone is exhausted, immense resources are wasted, and no
- 20:17actual new value is created. It's just a meat grinder of
- 20:21competition. This.
- 20:22Is exactly what Peter Thiel means when he says his famous
- 20:24line competition is for losers, you know.
- 20:27That phrase always sounded so arrogant to me, like oh I'm a
- 20:30billionaire, I'm too good to compete with you peasants.
- 20:32But in this specific context, it actually sounds like a survival
- 20:34warning. It is a profound warning, Teal
- 20:37says, that if you compete, you are trapped in mimesis.
- 20:40You are fighting over scraps with everyone else who has been
- 20:42programmed to want the exact same thing.
- 20:45You lose your individuality. You become totally obsessed with
- 20:48destroying your rival instead of creating something new.
- 20:51So. What is the escape hatch?
- 20:53How did PayPal or Palantir escape the meat grinder?
- 20:55Innovation leading to monopoly How do you?
- 20:58Practically, do that you have. To step completely out of the
- 21:00triangle, you have to force yourself to want something that
- 21:02nobody else is even looking at yet.
- 21:04The path. As the analysis describes, it is
- 21:07to start with a tiny, distinct market.
- 21:09Think. About Facebook, it wasn't
- 21:11launched as a global social network to connect 8 billion
- 21:14people. It was just a directory for
- 21:16students with a Harvard e-mail address or Amazon.
- 21:20Jeff Bezos didn't start the everything store, he just sold
- 21:23books. You dominate a very small non
- 21:26competitive niche completely. You become a total monopoly in a
- 21:29pond that nobody else even cares about.
- 21:31And then? Once you have that, you expand.
- 21:32Then you expand. But you avoid the hot, highly
- 21:35competitive markets where everyone else is fighting each
- 21:37other. That's the only way to keep your
- 21:39profit margins and honestly your sanity, OK.
- 21:42So that's the business side of the theory.
- 21:44Avoid competition, build a monopoly.
- 21:47It makes sense. But what happens to the broader
- 21:49society when it doesn't escape? When the mimetic competition
- 21:53gets so intense and so widespread that it threatens to
- 21:56literally tear everything apart? That.
- 21:58Brings us to Section 5, the scapegoat mechanism.
- 22:01And this, this is where we really have to talk about
- 22:03violence. This is.
- 22:04Societal crisis management, right?
- 22:06Gerard argues that when mimetic competition peaks, when everyone
- 22:10is fighting everyone, what he calls the war of all against
- 22:14all, society builds up this intolerable, suffocating
- 22:17tension. Violence is just bubbling up
- 22:19everywhere. So.
- 22:20Society desperately needs a release valve.
- 22:22Unconsciously, yes, society spontaneously activates an
- 22:25ancient defense mechanism to save itself, the scapegoat.
- 22:28Walk us through this process, because it's wild to think about
- 22:31how a civilized modern society suddenly turns on a specific
- 22:34group step. One is simplification.
- 22:36You have these incredibly complex, deeply entrenched
- 22:39structural problems, like the economy is failing, inflation is
- 22:41rampant, or the education system is broken.
- 22:44These are incredibly hard, maybe impossible to fix quickly.
- 22:47But people are angry now. So unconsciously the society
- 22:50looks for a target. A target.
- 22:51To blame for all of it, yes. Step 2 is the sacrifice that
- 22:55chosen group is expelled, canceled, marginalized or
- 22:57literally destroyed. And step.
- 22:59Three-step. 3 is the most important part of the entire
- 23:02mechanism false peace falls piece.
- 23:05The setting release of tension creates a temporary intoxicating
- 23:08sense of unity. Everyone looks around and says
- 23:10we fixed it. The bad guys are gone.
- 23:12Everyone feels better. For a brief moment, the entire
- 23:15community bonds over the shared expulsion of the victim.
- 23:18The. Source gives 2 incredibly
- 23:21powerful modern case studies here to prove this isn't just
- 23:23ancient history, and the first one is the double reduction
- 23:26policy in China concerning the tutoring sector.
- 23:29This was a. Massive, massive event.
- 23:31The crisis was exactly what we just discussed with Nehwan.
- 23:33There was massive societal anxiety over education, class
- 23:37solidification. Parents were just freaking out
- 23:39under the financial and mental pressure.
- 23:41The pressure was boiling over to a dangerous level.
- 23:44So. Who became the scapegoat?
- 23:45The. Private tutoring companies the.
- 23:47Narrative became oh, they're selling anxiety, right?
- 23:50The media drum beat was they are destroying childhoods.
- 23:53They are blood suckers. Now notice what was completely
- 23:56ignored in that narrative? The actual structural issues of
- 24:00the exam system itself. The severe scarcity of top tier
- 24:03university spots, the intense cultural pressure.
- 24:07None of that changed but the. Sacrifice happened anyway,
- 24:09overnight. The entire industry was
- 24:11decimated by decree. Billions of dollars in market
- 24:14value wiped out in a flash. Hundreds of thousands of jobs
- 24:17gone. And the result.
- 24:19Did it work it? Worked in the Girardian sense.
- 24:22Parents felt a momentary release.
- 24:23They thought, OK, the government stepped in, The predatory tutors
- 24:26are gone, We can breathe. But did the underlying mimetic
- 24:29competition actually vanish? No, the source says it just
- 24:32immediately moved underground black market tutors charging
- 24:35even higher rates. Exactly.
- 24:37The fundamental problem wasn't solved, but the social tension
- 24:40was temporarily managed. That is the true function of the
- 24:43scapegoat. It's not about actually solving
- 24:45the problem, it's about solving the anger.
- 24:47Wow. OK, the second case study is
- 24:49probably closer to home for a Western audience.
- 24:51Immigration, yes. This is a classic textbook
- 24:54example of the mechanism at work in modern democracies.
- 24:57What is the underlying crisis Massive wealth gaps, The slow
- 25:01decline of the middle class? The brutal shocks of
- 25:04globalization and deindustrialization.
- 25:06People are hurting and they want answers and the.
- 25:09Scapegoat becomes the immigrant the.
- 25:10Narrative is brutally simple. They took our jobs, they took
- 25:13our welfare. They are the reason you are
- 25:15struggling. Again, completely ignoring the
- 25:17complex stuff that actually caused the issues like
- 25:20automation, tax policy, corporate outsourcing, because
- 25:23those. Things are boring, they're hard
- 25:25to understand and even harder to fix.
- 25:27Blaming a physical person is easy, and it's deeply
- 25:29psychologically satisfying, so the.
- 25:31Sacrifice becomes harsh, punitive, anti immigration
- 25:35policy which serves. To artificially unify an
- 25:37incredibly angry voter base, it creates an US versus them bond
- 25:40and the. Analysis notes a really telling
- 25:42statistical detail here. Often the geographic areas with
- 25:45the fewest actual immigrants are the most fiercely anti
- 25:47immigrant. Which.
- 25:48Perfectly preves. It's about the symbol, not the
- 25:51reality on the ground. The immigrant in that specific
- 25:54case is just a placeholder for everything that is going wrong
- 25:57in my life. This.
- 25:57Is a really powerful lens. I mean, it makes modern politics
- 26:01look less like rational policy debates and more like ancient
- 26:06primitive rituals. It is.
- 26:07Entirely ritualistic. It's archaic and honestly, if
- 26:10you are an investor, you really need to know how to spot the
- 26:13next sacrifice because if you are holding the scapegoat in
- 26:15your portfolio, when the mob comes, you are going to get
- 26:17crushed that. Brings us perfectly to Section 6
- 26:20investment risks and identifying skeeks how do we avoid holding
- 26:24the bag the. Source gives us a very clear
- 26:26checklist of signals. If you see these aligning, run
- 26:29OK. Signal number one crisis context
- 26:32is the. Broader society currently in a
- 26:34crisis. If people are economically angry
- 26:36and scared, they are actively looking for someone to blame.
- 26:40That's the baseline requirement. You need a stormy, highly
- 26:42charged environment for a lightning strike signal. #2 is
- 26:45visibility and isolation. This is.
- 26:47Crucial is the target. Highly visible and highly
- 26:50profitable, but politically isolated.
- 26:53Think about big tech or high finance.
- 26:55Everyone uses their products. Everyone knows they make
- 26:57billions of dollars, but nobody really loves them.
- 27:00They have very few real friends in Washington.
- 27:02They are perfect fat targets. Signal. 3 Simplification of
- 27:06guilt. Are the media and politicians
- 27:08reporting only negatives? If you see a company or an
- 27:11entire industry where the news cycle is suddenly 100% they are
- 27:14evil and 0% here is the value they actually provide to
- 27:17consumers, you need to run. The sacrifice is imminent, all
- 27:20nuances being actively stripped away to prepare the victim for
- 27:23the altar. And signal 4 the final nail
- 27:26moralization this. Is the absolute death nail?
- 27:29Is the attack being framed as justice versus evil?
- 27:31Because once a business or a group becomes a moral crusade,
- 27:35rational defense is impossible. You can argue with a tax policy.
- 27:38You cannot argue with justice. The source.
- 27:40Specifically points out Internet giants here, yeah.
- 27:43Whenever the economy slows down, Big Tech inevitably becomes the
- 27:46villain. Their monopoly power, their
- 27:48addictive algorithms, the intense 9996 work culture, it
- 27:52all gets bundled into a very convenient narrative of these
- 27:55guys are the root of the problem and.
- 27:57Interestingly, the source also advises applying this to
- 28:00geography. It does.
- 28:01It says to avoid investing in or even living in countries or
- 28:05regions where you, as the investor or the minority citizen
- 28:08are easily identifiable as the other.
- 28:11If you stick out, you are a prime candidate for scapegoating
- 28:14the second things go South. OK, so we have the mechanism
- 28:17laid out. Society builds memetic pressure,
- 28:19blames A victim, kills or expels the victim, and feels better.
- 28:23But here is where the deep dive gets really interesting and
- 28:26honestly, terrifying. Yeah, Section 7.
- 28:28The apocalypse, the eschatology. The source.
- 28:30Says the scapegoat mechanism is actually broken now.
- 28:32Why this is? Really, the genius of Gerard's
- 28:34later work, he argues that the scapegoat mechanism only works
- 28:38if the mob unconsciously believes the scapegoat is
- 28:40actually guilty. Give me an.
- 28:41Example to ground that OK. If a medieval village burns a
- 28:44supposed witch to stop of a plague, they have to genuinely
- 28:48believe she's actually a witch causing the plague if they
- 28:51secretly think, oh she's just a harmless old lady we don't like.
- 28:54Burning rare doesn't bring peace, it just brings crushing
- 28:57guilt. The magic doesn't work and the.
- 28:59Modern problem is that we know, yes.
- 29:01Christianity, and really all of modern history, have
- 29:04systematically exposed the mechanism.
- 29:07The story of Jesus, from a purely anthropological view, is
- 29:10literally the story of a scapegoat who is universally
- 29:13revealed to be innocent. That story is now deep in our
- 29:16cultural DNA. So today we know the minority
- 29:19group didn't cause the global economic collapse.
- 29:21We know the tech company isn't solely responsible for every
- 29:24teen's depression. So the.
- 29:25Release valve is broken, we can't vent the violence
- 29:28effectively anymore. Exactly.
- 29:29We try to skate goat someone but immediately half the country
- 29:32screams wait, that's unjust. So the cathartic unity never
- 29:35happens. The pressure just builds and
- 29:36builds and builds and this. Leads directly to the end times
- 29:39without the valve. Functioning society risks what
- 29:41Gerard calls unlimited violence, and this is where the politics
- 29:45of Teal and Vance really come into sharp focus.
- 29:48The political. Weaponization of the apocalypse,
- 29:49right? Both the far left and the far
- 29:51right have adopted this end times framework, whether they
- 29:54realize it or not. They feel the immense pressure
- 29:57building and they interpret it as the literal end of the world.
- 30:01Let's. Look at how the source frames
- 30:02the far left first. Keep in mind we're just
- 30:04analyzing the text here impartially, right?
- 30:06Purely based on the analysis, the far left argument is
- 30:09basically the current system. Capitalism is inherently evil
- 30:13and doomed. It cannot be reformed.
- 30:15It must be entirely destroyed to build a utopia.
- 30:18The ultimate enemy is the bourgeoisie, or the old world
- 30:21order and the far right. The specific Vance and Thiel
- 30:23connection their. Argument according to the
- 30:25framework is that the current order, globalism, liberalism is
- 30:28totally decadent and doomed. It must be aggressively
- 30:31dismantled to save Western civilization itself.
- 30:34The enemy is the global elite, the migrants, the institutional
- 30:37cathedral, the. Danger.
- 30:39Here the real danger is the justification it provides.
- 30:42Exactly. Because if you genuinely only
- 30:44believe the world is literally ending, then extreme measures
- 30:47become totally justifiable. You aren't just voting in an
- 30:51election, you are fighting the forces of total darkness.
- 30:54Violence, or at least extreme disruption, becomes necessary to
- 30:58save the world. Political.
- 31:00Polarization stops being hey, I disagree with your tax policy
- 31:03and becomes you are the active enemy of civilization that.
- 31:07Is the Gerardian nightmare scenario.
- 31:10Politics becomes a holy war without a God to stop it.
- 31:13It perfectly explains why everything feels so existential
- 31:16right now. Every election is the most
- 31:17important election of our lifetime because we are trapped
- 31:20in the medic rivalry without a functioning release valve.
- 31:23So. We have painted a pretty bleak
- 31:25picture here. We are basically imitation
- 31:27machines trapped in a 0 sum competition, desperately looking
- 31:30for scapegoats, and the mechanism to relieve the
- 31:32pressure is broken. So we are heading toward an
- 31:34apocalypse, Yeah. It's intense.
- 31:36Is there any good news in this philosophy?
- 31:38Well, there. Is Section 8 the missed message
- 31:40because? Gerard didn't just diagnose the
- 31:42disease right, he proposed a cure.
- 31:44He. Did he said the only way out of
- 31:46the apocalyptic cycle of envy and violence is to fundamentally
- 31:49change the model? Change.
- 31:51Who we imitate exactly? Instead of imitating our rivals,
- 31:54which mathematically leads to conflict, we should imitate
- 31:57Christ. And he didn't mean that in a
- 31:59purely religious everyone needs to go to church on Sunday way
- 32:02necessarily, no. He meant it structurally,
- 32:05anthropologically. Christ represents self
- 32:07sacrifice, the absolute refusal of violence and anti mimetic
- 32:11love. He is a model who explicitly
- 32:14doesn't compete with you for earthly resources.
- 32:16He refuses to play the game. He steps completely out of the
- 32:19triangle. But.
- 32:20Here is the massive irony of the elites, which the source points
- 32:24out this is. The real kicker of the whole
- 32:25analysis? Peter Thiel and the Silicon
- 32:27Valley crowd. They raid Girard.
- 32:29They understood the mechanics of this better than almost anyone
- 32:32alive, but the source argues they only adopted the
- 32:34instrumental parts they took. The monopoly part to make
- 32:37billions of dollars right they. Asked How do I avoid mimetic
- 32:39competition and get obscenely rich and the.
- 32:42Politicians they. Took the apocalyptic parts they
- 32:45asked how do I mobilize voters by telling them the world is
- 32:48ending and I'm the only savior so they.
- 32:50Essentially took the weapon but ignored the peace treaty.
- 32:52Beautifully said, both groups largely ignore the moral
- 32:56conclusion, which is love, humility and non violence
- 32:58because frankly, it isn't profitable and it isn't
- 33:01politically useful. You can't run a successful
- 33:03startup or a presidential campaign on the slogan.
- 33:06Let's all stop imitating each other and be humble the.
- 33:09Source ends this entire deep dive with a really stark warning
- 33:12about grand narratives. This is.
- 33:14Super important. The source warns us, especially
- 33:17people who grew up with grand narratives like historical
- 33:19materialism, to be very wary of theories that claim to explain
- 33:23absolutely everything. Even this Gerardium theory if
- 33:26taken too far because. Believing in inevitable
- 33:29destruction or on the flip side, inevitable utopia.
- 33:32It gives you a license to be a terrible person today it.
- 33:34Does it excuses awful behavior? If the world is ending anyway,
- 33:37who cares what I do? The analysis suggests the
- 33:40alternative is a pragmatic empirical approach.
- 33:43Just solve actual problems. Don't try to imminentize the
- 33:45eschaton. Don't try to actively bring
- 33:48about the end of the world just to prove your philosophical
- 33:50point. Focus on the.
- 33:51Reality right in front of you, not the grand apocalyptic story
- 33:53in your head. Exactly.
- 33:55Keep it grounded well. We have traced quite the line
- 33:58today from why do I want that specific handbag to why is the
- 34:02tutoring industry dead? To why is US politics so
- 34:06incredibly explosive right now? It really all comes back to
- 34:09Mimis the. Absolute key take away here is
- 34:12awareness. Just be relentlessly aware of
- 34:14who you are imitating and that. Brings us to our final thought
- 34:17for you to chew on. Are you?
- 34:18Actually making choices? Or are you just part of the
- 34:21Mimisis? When you buy that tech stock?
- 34:24When you vote for that populist candidate?
- 34:25When you post that perfect vacation photo, stop and ask
- 34:29yourself who is the mediator here?
- 34:31Who am I secretly copying? Because if.
- 34:33You don't know who the model is. You are just a puppet dancing in
- 34:35the triangle and. Puppets usually get tangled in
- 34:37the strings eventually on. That cheery note we do have to
- 34:40do our mandatory disclaimer. Full deep value research reports
- 34:44can be found in the description links All analysis is based on
- 34:47publicly available sources and may be subject to revisions or
- 34:50differing interpretations. All.
- 34:52Contents from this channel is for educational and research
- 34:54purposes only and does not constitute investment advice.
- 34:58Conduct your own due diligence before making investment
- 35:00decisions. If you want to access more
- 35:02advanced contents, welcome to subscribe on Deep Values dot AI.
- 35:06We will share our latest researches and the most advanced
- 35:09AI agent tools for our contrarian friends.
- 35:11Don't forget. To like this video.
- 35:12Much appreciated. Thanks for.
- 35:14Listening to this deep dive? See you next time.