Latest / Tech IPO Conversations with Fexingo: Public Software Companies and Capital Markets / How Post-IPO Lockup Expirations Create Opportunity
Transcript
- Lucas: Palantir is up more than 14 percent in the last five days. Shopify, up over 15. Those are eye-catching moves, and they come at an interesting moment for both stocks. Luna: Interesting how? I mean, both companies have been on a run this year, but 14 and 15 percent in a week is a lot. Lucas: It is a lot. And what's notable is that both stocks are trading near their post ipo highs. But the reason I bring it up today is that both are also approaching — or have just passed — major lockup expiration events. And the way the market prices those events tells you a lot about how sophisticated the investor base really is. Luna: Right, lockup expirations. So remind me — the lockup period is the time after an IPO where early investors and employees aren't allowed to sell shares, right? Lucas: Exactly. Typically 180 days, though it varies. The idea is to prevent a flood of insider selling right after the IPO, which would tank the stock. But when that lockup expires, suddenly all those insiders can sell. And the market knows that. So there's often a pre-expiration selloff as traders front-run the expected selling. Luna: And that's where Palantir and Shopify get interesting? Because their lockups have already expired, haven't they? Lucas: Palantir's direct listing in 2020 actually had a modified lockup — no traditional lockup, but there were insider trading restrictions. More recently though, Palantir had a secondary offering back in February this year, which created a new lockup on certain shares. That lockup expired at the end of April. So we're now a month past it, and the stock is up 14 percent. That's not what the textbook would predict. Luna: So the selling pressure didn't materialize. Why? Are insiders just holding? Lucas: Partly. But there's a deeper story. When a lockup expires, the market has already priced in a certain amount of selling. If that selling doesn't happen — or if it's absorbed by new buyers — the stock can actually rally. That's called a 'lockup expiration pop.' And it's more common than you'd think, especially for companies with strong fundamental momentum. Luna: So the expected selling becomes a head fake. The market braced for it, and when it didn't materialize, shorts got squeezed, or new buyers stepped in. Lucas: Exactly. And that's exactly what happened with Shopify. Their most recent lockup expiration was tied to the secondary offering they did in May of last year. That one expired in November. And since then, the stock is up close to 40 percent. The lockup expiration was essentially a non-event. Luna: But not all lockup expirations are non-events. I remember when Meta's lockup expired back in 2012 — the stock dropped something like 40 percent in the months after. Lucas: Classic case. Meta's IPO in 2012 was a mess — the stock was overpriced, the lockup expiration unleashed a tidal wave of insider selling, and the stock tanked. But that was a different era. Today, companies are much more deliberate about managing lockup expirations. They'll often structure them in tranches — so only a portion of shares unlock at a time — or do secondary offerings that create new lockups. Luna: So the market is smarter now. Companies are smarter. And investors have learned to distinguish between a lockup that's a real risk and one that's just noise. Lucas: Right. And the key variable is always: what's the underlying business doing? If revenue is growing, margins are improving, and the narrative is strong, the lockup expiration is just a speed bump. If the business is deteriorating, it's a cliff. Luna: That makes sense. So for Palantir and Shopify, the business momentum was strong enough to absorb any selling. And the lockup expiration became a buying opportunity for those who understood the dynamics. Lucas: Precisely. And that's the takeaway: don't automatically sell into lockup expiration. Look at the fundamentals first. If the company is executing, the lockup might actually be a chance to add to your position at a discount. Luna: And if you're an early investor or employee, you have a decision too. Do you sell immediately or hold? That depends on your conviction and your tax situation. Lucas: Exactly. And we've seen some companies where insiders sold aggressively — like Airbnb. After its lockup expired in August 2021, insiders sold billions of dollars in stock. But Airbnb's business was still recovering from the pandemic, so the selling made sense. The stock did dip, but it recovered over time. Luna: So it's not a one-size-fits-all. You have to look at the specific company. That's a lot of nuance for a topic that most people just write off as 'lockup expiration = bad.' Lucas: Which is why we're talking about it. Because the nuance is where the opportunity is. And speaking of nuance — the reason we can have these longer, detailed conversations without cutting to ads every few minutes is that we run this show ad-free. It's a choice we've made because we think the content speaks for itself. If you find these discussions useful for what you're building or running, and you want to support that choice, there's a simple way to do it. Luna: Yeah, we've never wanted to interrupt the flow with sponsorship reads. So if the show's valuable to you, the link is buy me a coffee dot com slash fexingo. No pressure, just a way to keep things independent. Lucas: Exactly. And we appreciate it. Now, back to lockups — there's another angle I want to explore. What about the companies that use lockup expirations as a deliberate strategy to create volatility? Luna: You mean like timing the expiration to coincide with good news? Lucas: Exactly. Some companies will schedule earnings calls or product launches right before or after a lockup expiration. The goal is to have positive catalysts that absorb the selling pressure. It's a way to engineer a smoother expiration. Luna: That's smart. So if you're an investor, you can look at the calendar and see: lockup expires in June, company usually announces something in May or June. Maybe that's a pattern. Lucas: Right. And we've seen that with a few companies. For instance, when Rivian's lockup expired in August 2022, they had just announced a partnership with Amazon for electric delivery vans. That news helped support the stock. But Rivian's situation was different because the lockup was massive — something like 600 million shares. Even good news couldn't fully offset that. Luna: And Rivian's stock is still well below its IPO price. So the scale of the unlocking matters too. Lucas: Absolutely. The percentage of float that's unlocking is a critical number. If only 5 percent of shares are unlocking, it's manageable. If it's 50 percent, that's a different ballgame. Rivian's was in the 20 to 30 percent range, which is significant. Luna: So investors should be looking at three things: the size of the unlock, the fundamental health of the business, and any planned catalysts around that date. Lucas: That's exactly right. And if you put those three together, you can make a much more informed decision than just selling blindly. Now, one more thing I want to touch on: the recent trend of companies doing secondary offerings that create new lockups. That's a way to effectively push the expiration risk down the road. Luna: Right, because when a company issues new shares in a secondary, those new holders usually have a new lockup. So the old lockup might expire, but the new one starts. It's like a rolling lockup. Lucas: Exactly. And that can actually reduce volatility because the market knows there's a schedule. Palantir has done that — their secondary in February created a new lockup that expired in April. And now we see the stock rallying. So it can be a positive signal if the secondary is taken as a vote of confidence. Luna: So the takeaway: don't fear lockup expirations. Understand them. They're not a death sentence; they're a data point. Lucas: And a potentially profitable one if you know what to look for. That's the kind of insight we try to bring every week. Thanks for listening, and we'll see you next time. Luna: Take care, everyone.