Latest / Columbus' Morning News / How can Ohio lower Property Taxes?
Transcript
- 0:00Speaker 1: All right on a Legacy Retirement Group dot com phone line.
- 0:02I want to spend a couple of minutes with Greg
- 0:04Lawson from the Buckeye Institute. Greg. A lot has been
- 0:08made of property taxes in the state of Ohio. There's
- 0:11been some legislation, there's state politics is involved here. Mike
- 0:15Dwine as a property tax reform working group trying to
- 0:19figure out how to lower property taxes in the state
- 0:23of Ohio. So it's a simple question, Greg Lawson from
- 0:26the Buckeye Institute with a complicated answer. I'm hoping you
- 0:29can kind of break it down and played English. How
- 0:32do we lower property tax in Ohio?
- 0:35Speaker 2: Well, sure, And that's the huge issue. I think we've
- 0:38talked before. We've got lots of Ohiolands that are facing
- 0:42historic property tax increases. It's really bad in terms of
- 0:46young families trying to buy new housing. It's really bad
- 0:49for especially fixed income seniors who have paid off their
- 0:53mortgage and are facing the risk of possibly losing their
- 0:57home because of property taxes, despite the fact that they've
- 1:00done everything right. So this is a massive issue. There's
- 1:03a group of folks at the grassroots level trying to
- 1:06do a constitutional amendment here in Ohio. They're gathering signatures
- 1:09as we speak to abolish property taxes. So what answer
- 1:14would be something like that? I mean, that's I think
- 1:17not the right solution because I think that we'll create
- 1:20all kinds of other challenges and problems. But that's how
- 1:23frustrated people are. And so I give the General as
- 1:27simply a lot of credit for trying to do some things.
- 1:29We were disappointed that Governor DeWine did some of the
- 1:32line item vetos in the budget, and we're going to
- 1:35be talking with this property tax working group that he
- 1:38has put together. And you know, there aren't simple solutions
- 1:42to this. It has to really kind of come in
- 1:44a number of different different ways. There's short term and
- 1:47long term stuff, because you've got to do something that
- 1:50takes away some of the immediate pain that I was
- 1:52just talking about, but you also have to do some
- 1:55things that are more long term, because this problem didn't
- 1:58just happen overnight.
- 1:59Speaker 1: Yeah, it's nickel and dime, it's death by a thousand
- 2:02paper cuts situation where it's all your property tax is
- 2:05going up one hundred and fifty bucks this year, which
- 2:08to a lot of folks doesn't really mean much. One
- 2:11hundred and fifty dollars spread out over the course of
- 2:13a year, not really gonna hurt me too much. But
- 2:16year after year after year, you start getting these increases
- 2:19Greg and it's like, oh my gosh, my property tax
- 2:21has gone up a thousand bucks.
- 2:23Speaker 2: Well, and it breaks a lot of folks backs. I mean,
- 2:25that's the reality that we're facing here. It's what's driving
- 2:28this effort to abolish the property tax. So it is,
- 2:32it's a problem. And so what you've got is there's
- 2:35a lot of very unique things about Ohio. First of all,
- 2:37we have a lot of local government. There's got many,
- 2:39many different layers of local government. Most of them have
- 2:43their own taxing authority and can put levies on the
- 2:45ballot and attached levies to home. So you have this
- 2:49kind of layering effect that has been built up over
- 2:52years where you have multiple different kinds of government doing
- 2:55property taxes, even the same unit of government, like especially
- 2:59school being the biggest example. You've got a lot of
- 3:03school levees on your home. It's not one levee, it's
- 3:06multiple levees. There's levees that go back probably fifty years
- 3:09that never come off. Then you've got the levees that
- 3:11you vote to renew. Then you've got the stuff for
- 3:14the new money. Then you've got capital bond levies on
- 3:17top of that a lot of times. So I mean,
- 3:19and that's just for schools, and so we have all
- 3:22of these things. So one of the things that we
- 3:24have really talked about, and I've been talking about this
- 3:26for years at buck Guy, is the first thing is
- 3:30there are some very specific ways in which certain property
- 3:33tax taxes operate that have created a problem where voters
- 3:38actually aren't necessarily voting for a lot of these tax increases.
- 3:42There are certain kind of things in law that protect
- 3:46in particular school districts, a lot of school districts. There's
- 3:51a very complicated way in which Ohio tries to keep
- 3:54inflation from hurting homeowners. And unfortunately, because of this recent
- 3:59inflation we had come out of COVID that kind of
- 4:01has broken and property values going up so much in
- 4:04recent years that some of those protections have broken down.
- 4:07And one of them really deals with school districts, where
- 4:10if you are at a certain level of taxation, they
- 4:15can capture all the value increases in someone's home in
- 4:19terms of the tax that is applied. And so that
- 4:22creates unvoted tax increases. So one of the biggest things
- 4:25that it can be done right away is we should
- 4:27eliminate these restrict or eliminate the ability for unvoted tax increases,
- 4:33because when that happens, voters aren't even getting the choice.
- 4:37All that I was talking about with all these layers,
- 4:39theoretically you had it where taxpayers at least at some
- 4:43point in history voted for those but we're seeing a
- 4:47situation now where in many cases that's not happening and
- 4:49it's putting extra burden on folks. So we need to
- 4:52take that situation very seriously because that's really one of
- 4:55the big drivers for the spike in many many cases
- 4:59around the state.
- 5:00Speaker 1: You don't get access to my money by if I
- 5:03don't get to say and that's that is as common
- 5:06sense as it gets. Speaking with Greg Lawson from the
- 5:08Buckeye Institute on how to reduce the property tax burden
- 5:13in the state of Ohio, and one of the things
- 5:15and we talked a little bit about this last week Greg,
- 5:17is eliminating the you know, the tax breaks from corporations.
- 5:21You know that they come in and they set up shop,
- 5:24they don't have any tax burden and that is all
- 5:26shifted towards families and small businesses and homeowners. So how
- 5:31we got to eliminate some of the tax abatements to
- 5:33some of these corporations. They got to come in and
- 5:35you know that they have all the money, they should
- 5:38pay taxes too.
- 5:40Speaker 2: Well, that's one of our other recommendations is the General
- 5:42Assembly really needs to look at these and put guardrails
- 5:45on tax abatements. There may be a few examples here
- 5:48and there with really distressed properties or something where nobody
- 5:51would ever do anything with that property, or maybe that
- 5:55makes sense, but we see these tax abatements happening, including
- 5:58a really high growing areas, especially in central Ohio, where
- 6:01we're just throwing out tax abatements right and left, and
- 6:04in all the reality, we probably don't need those tax abatements. Yeah,
- 6:08it's nice, I'm sure for developers to have. I get that,
- 6:11But every time you do a tax abatement, what you're
- 6:13doing is you're taking a particular piece of property off
- 6:16of the property tax roles, at least for a certain
- 6:18period of time while the abatement deal is going on,
- 6:21and that means that that tax burden at the local
- 6:24level is basically kind of set somewhere else, and it's
- 6:28on the people who don't get tax breaks, which means
- 6:31homeowners and smaller businesses that have been around for a
- 6:34long time. But aren't you know, the new sexy thing
- 6:37where you're going to build some big plant and get
- 6:39a ribbon cutting ceremony. So we've got to be able
- 6:41to tighten that up because that's diffusing the cost to
- 6:43other folks. So absolutely that along with some of the
- 6:46stuff house, some of the unvoted stuff is important. And
- 6:49I'll say this and this is this is kind of,
- 6:51you know, a third rail I think for a lot
- 6:53of local governments. But we got to talk about consolidation.
- 6:58When I was talking about all these layers of government,
- 7:01we really need to think about how many we have
- 7:03in Ohio, how many different taxes they need to levy,
- 7:06and we need to start figuring out how do we
- 7:08restructure some of our local government. For example, states in
- 7:12the South and out west, in particular states like North Carolina,
- 7:16which is a really hot growing state, like Florida, which
- 7:19is obviously we've got a much bigger population than Ohio,
- 7:22they have fewer school districts than Ohio does. And again
- 7:25I know this is a third rail, but we have
- 7:27over six hundred school districts. Many of these other states
- 7:30have under two hundred school districts, despite having either similar
- 7:34or even larger populations that Ohio does. You can't tell
- 7:38me that there's not ability to find cost efficiencies and
- 7:41ways to make things work better in Ohio when some
- 7:44of these other states, states, and in some cases are
- 7:46growing faster than we are are able to do.
- 7:48Speaker 1: It interesting, And it's just the bottom line, there's a
- 7:51lot of lot of different entities with their hands out.
- 7:54Their hands are in your pocket, they're in my pocket.
- 7:57Any family who owns a home in state of Ohio.
- 8:00It's just it's it's a bit of a mess right now,
- 8:04and we've got to find a solution. And you've got
- 8:06we got about ten of them. Where can people see
- 8:09all of your solutions? Is it Buckeye Institute dot org.
- 8:12Speaker 2: Yep, Buckeye Institute dot org. Check it out. It's where
- 8:16we've we've got the ten on there. We've got all
- 8:18kinds of stuff that we're we're doing on this. We're
- 8:20going to keep doing this. We're going to be talking
- 8:22to all the lawmakers, We're going to be talking to
- 8:24folks with the governor. And here's the critical thing I
- 8:27think folks at home need to call and keep make sure.
- 8:30I mean, legislators I think are pretty aware of what's
- 8:33out there. But we've got to keep putting the pressure
- 8:36back on because the one thing that really kind of
- 8:39concerns me is there's this effort to get into abolish
- 8:41property taxes. And that's a whole other conversation. So let
- 8:44me just say this. That's over twenty probably around twenty
- 8:47four billion dollars. That's more money at the local level
- 8:51ends raised by the state sales or state income tax.
- 8:53If that just went away, which it could, if this
- 8:56thing makes the ballot and passes, that is is really
- 9:00going to make it hard to fund local services people
- 9:02do want. But the problem is, if you don't do
- 9:05something about these property taxes that are hurting people, folks
- 9:08are going to feel mad, They're going to feel desperate,
- 9:10they're going to feel scared. This thing is a real thing.
- 9:13It could happen. And so what we're trying to tell
- 9:15folks is, let's do these other things. Let's get these
- 9:18reforms on things we should have probably done, you know,
- 9:21ten fifteen years ago, and would have had some real benefit.
- 9:25But we can't cry over spilt milk. What we have
- 9:27to do is be aggressive Today. There's a lot of
- 9:29reforms there, lots of local governments are gonna, you know,
- 9:32scream and yell and mash their teeth about it. But
- 9:35if we don't change something even bigger and more dramatic
- 9:39could be coming down the pike. And you know that's
- 9:42going to create a whole other set of challenges.