Latest / The Office Politics Podcast with Fexingo: Workplace Dynamics, Influence, and Getting Things Done / How the Contrast Effect Wins Office Influence
Transcript
- Lucas: So we're in the middle of a conversation about performance reviews this week, and I keep coming back to this one moment from a few years ago. I was in a review where my manager spent ten minutes talking about all the things I'd done wrong, and then said, 'But overall, you're doing fine.' And I walked out of there feeling relief, not frustration. Luna: That sounds like a relief because the bar was set so low. But that's also the contrast effect doing its work — you're comparing the final verdict to the negative stuff that came before. Lucas: Exactly. The contrast effect is when we judge something not on its own merits, but relative to what we just experienced. A $500 suit feels like a bargain after you've been shown $2,000 ones. A $50 bottle of wine seems reasonable after the $150 one. And in the office, it shapes everything from budget pitches to hiring decisions without us even noticing. Luna: And this is a show people support with a couple of dollars a month when it's helped them think through a career move or a tricky situation. Buy me a coffee dot com slash fexingo makes it easy. It's a small thing that genuinely keeps these episodes going. Lucas: Yeah, that's a real difference maker. Now back to that review — the manager's sequence wasn't an accident. It's a classic contrast frame: list the negatives, then give a moderate positive, and the positive feels bigger than it is. Luna: So if you're on the receiving end, you want to be aware of it. But for people who want to use it ethically, it's about sequencing choices so the best option stands out. Lucas: Right. And it's not just a review trick. Think about hiring. If you interview three mediocre candidates and then a decent one, that decent one looks like a superstar. I've seen managers fall for that pattern constantly. It's the reason some interviewers deliberately stack the order — they're not always conscious of it, but it happens. Luna: But does it actually change decisions? Or is it just a feeling? Lucas: It changes real decisions. There's a classic study from the 1970s where people rated a product more highly when it was presented after a worse version, even though the product itself was identical. And in pricing, it's the backbone of how B2B companies tier their offerings. You show the premium plan first, and the middle plan suddenly looks reasonable. Luna: So the order of presentation is a lever. But I'm wondering — is this the same as anchoring? We did that episode a while back. Lucas: They're cousins, but distinct. Anchoring is about the first number setting a reference point — that's the $2,000 suit setting the anchor. Contrast is about the comparison itself: you're not just anchored to a number, you're making an active comparison between two things you've just seen. In practice, they often work together, but contrast is more about the sequence of options. Luna: Let's get concrete. What's a real office scenario where someone can use contrast without being a jerk? Lucas: The classic is the budget pitch. You want $50,000 for a new software tool. If you walk in and ask for $50,000, your boss might push back. But if you present two options — the $50,000 one that does everything, and a $30,000 stripped-down version — the $50,000 one suddenly looks like the value play. You're giving them a comparison, not a demand. Luna: And if they choose the $30,000 one, at least you've framed the trade-off. But what about performance reviews from the employee side? Can you use contrast there? Lucas: You can, but carefully. If you're negotiating a raise, you can present your accomplishments in a sequence that highlights the biggest win last. Or if you're asking for a title change, you can frame it as a choice between two options — one title with a raise, one title without. That makes the raise feel like part of a package, not a single demand. Luna: I've also seen contrast used negatively — like when a manager inflates praise for a mediocre employee just to justify a smaller raise than they deserve. That's a dark side. Lucas: It's a real manipulation. The manager might say, 'You're doing great, but we only have budget for 2 percent,' when they've already planned to give you 2 percent all along. The positive contrast makes the bad news go down easier. That's why you need to be aware of the sequence and ask for the actual data behind the numbers. Luna: So the contrast effect is a double-edged sword. How do you spot it in the wild? Lucas: Look for the order. If someone shows you a range of options, ask yourself: is the one they want me to pick the one that looks good relative to the others? And if you're making the pitch, think about what comparison you're setting up. Are you showing your idea next to a worse one, or next to something that makes yours look worse? Luna: There's also the social side — like when a colleague always follows your suggestion with a slightly worse version, making theirs look better. That's a subtle power move. Lucas: That's a classic. It's not always conscious, but it's the reason some meetings feel like everyone's talking past each other. When you're aware of it, you can call it out without being confrontational: 'Interesting contrast. Let's evaluate both on the same criteria.' Luna: Okay, so what's the takeaway for our listeners? If they take one thing from this episode, what should it be? Lucas: Sequence is a tool. When you present anything — a proposal, a solution, even a request — you control the order. Put the option you want to win in a position where it shines by comparison. But do it with integrity: make sure the comparison is fair and the choice is real. Otherwise, you're just manipulating. Luna: And when you're on the receiving end, reverse-engineer the sequence. Ask yourself, 'What are they comparing this to?' That question alone can save you from a bad decision. Lucas: Right. So next time you're in a meeting and someone presents three options, don't just pick the middle one because it looks reasonable. Ask what the comparison is hiding. That's the contrast effect in action. Luna: And if you're the one presenting, think about how you'd feel if someone did that to you. Fair contrast builds trust; unfair contrast burns bridges. Lucas: Exactly. It's a tool, not a trick. Use it to make your best ideas visible, not to hide their flaws.