Latest / eMotors: Electric Revolution / LFP vs NMC Batteries: Which is Best for Your City EV?
Transcript
- 0:10When you buy a smartphone, like, you don't just look at the
- 0:12exterior design, right? You want to know if the battery
- 0:15inside is actually going to survive three years of daily
- 0:17abuse without dying by noon, right?
- 0:20Yeah. But with electric cars, buyers
- 0:22usually just ignore the chemistry under the floorboards.
- 0:25And it's really the only thing that dictates if a new EV will
- 0:28actually fit your lifestyle. So welcome to this custom deep
- 0:33dive. Glad to be here.
- 0:34Today we're taking a stack of automotive analysis comparing 4
- 0:38highly anticipated EVs. We've got the Renault 5, the
- 0:42Nissan Micra, Kia EV2 and the VWID Polo.
- 0:47And this is such a fascinating comparison because, you know,
- 0:50we've completely moved past that old horsepower era.
- 0:53Oh, for sure. Knowing exactly how your car
- 0:55stores and physically applies its energy is really the
- 0:59ultimate buyer's advantage today.
- 1:00Right. So to figure out how long these,
- 1:02I guess we can call them smartphones on wheels, how long
- 1:04they'll last, we have to look at the battery chemistry.
- 1:06And the sources reveal a huge split here.
- 1:09A massive divide. You have the VWIID Polo with its
- 1:1337 kWh battery and the base Kia EV2 at 42 kilowatt hours and
- 1:19both of those are utilizing LFP batteries.
- 1:21Which is just fantastic for longevity.
- 1:23I mean LFP's is this really rigid crystalline iron phosphate
- 1:27structure that well that is simply doesn't physically
- 1:30degrade or swell when crayon full of electrons.
- 1:32So it's. Tough.
- 1:33Super tough. It gives you over 3000 charge
- 1:35cycles, meaning you can safely plug it in and push it to 100%
- 1:38every single day. OK.
- 1:39Let's let's unpack this. Wait, so the cheaper base models
- 1:42with LFP batteries might actually outlast the expensive
- 1:45NMC ones if I just plug it into 100% every single night?
- 1:48What's fascinating here is, yes, cover.
- 1:51Intuitive, I know, but LFP is practically internal for city
- 1:54abuse. The downside is that it's
- 1:56notoriously heavy and pretty cold sensitive.
- 2:00Right, so lugging around a denser battery impacts
- 2:03efficiency. Exactly, but for a pure commuter
- 2:05car the trade off is often totally worth it.
- 2:07Now on the other hand around 5. The Nissan Micra and the top
- 2:10tier 61 kWh Kia EV2. Those all use NMC chemistry.
- 2:14Which is nickel, manganese, cobalt.
- 2:16Right. The denser nickel and cobalt in
- 2:19NMC batteries save crucial weight for city agility, and
- 2:23they perform way better in the cold.
- 2:26But you have to baby them. Meaning keep them between 20 and
- 2:2980% charge usually, yeah. If you push those denser metals
- 2:33past an 80% charge regularly, they literally swell up and
- 2:37physically stress the battery cells.
- 2:39So if NMC batteries are obsessing over saving weight to
- 2:42maximize range, you'd think these cars would use the exact
- 2:46same motor tech to squeeze out every mile.
- 2:48You would think so, yeah. But how they actually spin the
- 2:50wheels reveals another massive mechanical divide.
- 2:53Oh, absolutely. So VW and Kia use PSM permanent
- 2:57magnet synchronous motors. They are, you know, mechanically
- 3:00very simple and give you that instant punchy torque.
- 3:02You wanted a red light, right? But because they rely heavily on
- 3:06permanent rare earth metals, they suffer from magnetic drag
- 3:09at higher speeds. Here's where it gets really
- 3:12interesting. Imagine riding a bicycle with
- 3:14one of those old Dynamo lights rubbing against the tire.
- 3:17Oh, that's a great way to picture it.
- 3:18Right. Even when you're just coasting
- 3:20downhill on the highway, that permanent magnet is physically
- 3:23grabbing at the rotor. It creates constant mechanical
- 3:26resistance. Exactly.
- 3:27But the Renault 5 and Nissan Micra use EES electrically
- 3:31excited synchronous motors. They strip out the rare earth
- 3:35magnets entirely and use copper Electro magnets instead.
- 3:38And with those copper windings, it's basically like a dimmer
- 3:41switch. The car dynamically turns down
- 3:44the magnetic field when you hit the highway, which virtually
- 3:47eliminates that high speed drag. Like flipping the Dynamo off the
- 3:49tire. Exactly.
- 3:51Plus zooming out a bit, bypassing the mining of rare
- 3:54earth metals gives the EESMA distinct ethical and supply
- 3:58chain advantage. It's just far less reliant on
- 4:01volatile global materials. So what does this all mean for
- 4:04you? Looking at the whole picture,
- 4:06buying an EV means matching your unique daily habits to the car's
- 4:09chemistry. Completely.
- 4:11If you need massive car space like the polo's 435 liters and a
- 4:15battery you can blindly charge to 100% every night, the LFP
- 4:19setups make complete rational sense.
- 4:21But you know, if you need sheer range, the EV2's big 61 kWh
- 4:26battery and rapid 118 kilowatt charging is definitely the
- 4:30ticket. Right.
- 4:31And if highway efficiency and city agility are your
- 4:34priorities, the Renault and Micro's ethical Copper One
- 4:37motors and Google software are incredibly compelling.
- 4:41Just like a smartphone, don't buy a car without understanding
- 4:43the physics under the hood. Thank you so much for listening
- 4:46and learning with us on this deep dive today.
- 4:48And. I'll leave you with one final
- 4:49question to ponder. As global environmental
- 4:52regulations tighten, will the geopolitical advantage of these
- 4:55Copper One motors eventually force the entire auto industry
- 4:58to abandon permanent magnets entirely?