Latest / Free Cities Podcast / 174 - The Architecture of Spontaneous Order | Patrik Schumacher
Transcript
- 0:00Welcome to the Free Cities podcast. My name is Timothy Allen and this is the official podcast
- 0:17of the Free Cities Foundation.
- 0:30Hello and welcome to this episode number 174 of the Free Cities podcast,
- 0:36brought to you this week by two wonderfully Free City aligned sponsors.
- 0:42That's, of course, Veritas Villages and ArcPad.
- 0:46Veritas Villages are building off-grid freedom-oriented communities in Latin America.
- 0:52Click on the link in the show notes to inquire about their new project in Costa Rica
- 0:57and their other projects in Nicaragua and Panama.
- 1:00And if you're a Bitcoiner like me, well, you can spend your Bitcoin at a Veritas village.
- 1:06You can buy land and property with Bitcoin and you can mine Bitcoin with your energy self-sufficient house.
- 1:15www.veritasvillages.com forward slash free cities art pad.
- 1:19Also, they're planning a second iteration of their groundbreaking reef resort in the Philippines.
- 1:25this time off the coast of that's right prospera in honduras one of the most important free cities
- 1:32projects in the world you can purchase ownership in the prosper reef resort either outright or via
- 1:38fractional shares tinyurl.com forward slash arc pad if you would like to buy a piece of seasteading
- 1:46history there and also then benefit from the revenues and use of the arc pad resort as well
- 1:54of course. Right, I'm in planning and packing mode today. Off to the Freedom Festival in the
- 2:02UK this weekend. Lots of great speakers there and then straight on a flight to Prospera for the
- 2:07Liberty Acceleration Summit. After that, I'm going to be walking the talk, as they say, by, that's
- 2:15right, living in a free city for a month. I'm going to be based in the Doona Tower in Prospera
- 2:22for four weeks working from there and of course diving into the mechanics of daily life in one of
- 2:28the world's premier free cities can't wait for that experience it will be the longest i've ever
- 2:34been away from my children in one go but obviously i'm looking forward to seeing how things pan out
- 2:41i i see a future in positioning myself and my family in a free city probably a number of them
- 2:48in rotation if I'm being honest but who knows certainly I will know a lot more in six weeks
- 2:54times and I'll be informing you every week of how things are going right today's guest
- 3:00it's a great one it's very highbrow one as well Patrick Schumacher is one of the most influential
- 3:06architects alive right now he's a longtime partner at Zaha Hadid Architects a major theorist behind
- 3:15parametricism and a founder director of the aa design research lab in london i'll give you a
- 3:21quick uh definition of parametricism since we talk about it quite a bit in the show it's patrick's
- 3:27term for a 21st century architectural style driven by computational parametric methods
- 3:35this means forms are generated and continuously varied by adjustable parameters example site
- 3:43circulation program structure etc etc so buildings and urban spaces become more fluid more adaptive
- 3:51and interconnected but still coherent and legible as a unified system rather than just a pile of
- 3:57unrelated objects patrick's a bit of a free cities og google image search here is your best friend
- 4:05just search the word parametricism and you'll get to the brief pretty quickly right today's
- 4:11conversation well it's certainly not about what makes buildings pretty it's a free market critique
- 4:18of the built environment itself why housing is unaffordable why planning regimes kill the
- 4:25discovery process and why urbanism in places like the uk has become a politicized rent seeking
- 4:32machine instead of a competitive entrepreneurial one patrick's origin story is also very interesting
- 4:39He says that the 2008 crisis is what pushed him into Austrian economics and consequently full-on libertarianism.
- 4:47Then he followed the thread straight into free cities via Liberland, Prospera and Titus' book Free Private Cities.
- 4:54We get into his core idea that cities are a form of spontaneous order
- 4:59and that the job of architecture is not to impose a rigid blueprint,
- 5:04but to make the real network of human relationships legible.
- 5:08From there, we go deeper why he thinks parametricism is basically order emerging from complexity,
- 5:17why AI will actually accelerate the frontier rather than flatten everything into sameness,
- 5:23and why Patrick believes free cities should look like the 21st century,
- 5:28not nostalgic reenactments of the 19th century.
- 5:32That one's going to divide the community, I'm sure.
- 5:34right value for value people and comments this week unfortunately you're going to have to wait
- 5:40i'm recording these next two episodes uh way in advance because i'm too busy to do anything during
- 5:47my first two weeks on the road in honduras so you'll have to wait a couple of weeks for those
- 5:53sorry about that uh a quick mention the free cities conference talking of prosper is now just
- 5:59166 days away and this year's event well it's a huge one for the first time ever we'll be holding
- 6:08our flagship annual conference inside a real functioning free city but you already knew that
- 6:14didn't you in previous years we've gathered in europe we've done prague we did mulheim in
- 6:21switzerland and monaco back in the early days but this year prospera is ready to host us on the
- 6:27beautiful island of Ruatan in Honduras. This event is quickly becoming our most anticipated conference
- 6:35yet and we're expecting more international attention than ever before. What can attendees
- 6:41expect? Well all the things that made our Prague conferences so valuable, presentations and updates
- 6:48from more than a dozen of the world's leading free cities and seasteading projects. This includes
- 6:53projects like Ciudad Morazan, Varistas Villages, CryptoCity, ArcPad, Atlas Island, Liberland and many more.
- 7:01Obviously, they're just the stalwarts from the movement.
- 7:04But what makes this event a first is that you won't just be hearing about free cities.
- 7:10You'll be experiencing one firsthand.
- 7:14If you're short on time, the core conference program in Prospera runs from September the 3rd to the 6th,
- 7:21Featuring keynote talks, panel discussions, project presentations and plenty of opportunities for networking.
- 7:28Of course, that's a massive part of our events.
- 7:31Many a project has been dreamed up at a Free Cities conference.
- 7:35Let me tell you, my own included.
- 7:37We'll also have our famous VIP dinner and auction with Mr.
- 7:42Mark Edge for those who want to upgrade their tickets.
- 7:46But if you have a little bit more time, I strongly encourage you to arrive early.
- 7:51and take part in our optional activities on September the 1st and 2nd.
- 7:56These include a prosperous site tour, networking events with local businesses,
- 8:01snorkeling over Ruatan's famous coral reefs, chocolate tasting,
- 8:06visits to wildlife parks, championship beach volleyball and much more.
- 8:11We also offering a special day excursion to Ciudad Morazan which is another famous free city project on the Honduran mainland these trips will take place on the 2nd of September and again on the 7th of September So if you can extend your stay
- 8:28you'll have the rare opportunity to visit not one but two free cities in a single trip.
- 8:34Siudad Morazan has a very different personality to Prospera, which you will see if you manage to
- 8:39get there this really is a historic moment for the movement not only are we hosting our conference
- 8:46inside a functioning free city for the first time but the political winds in Honduras have recently
- 8:52shifted in favor of free cities with the election of a new president if you can make it this truly
- 8:59will be an event not to be missed and tickets well you think what's this worth thousands possibly
- 9:08no tickets start at 239 people what's not to like there but be aware prices increase
- 9:17after april the 30th so be sure to secure yours soon and start planning what should be the trip
- 9:24of a lifetime and also probably worth mentioning we're limit slightly limited on space compared
- 9:32to Prague. So this event will sell out, I would imagine. So don't sit around for too long. It's
- 9:40the kind of thing you need to plan and that includes many of the intricacies of getting
- 9:44to Roatan and visas and things like this. So start thinking about it now and start planning.
- 9:51Right on to the conversation. I would advise you to grab your most ergonomic seating apparatus
- 9:59and as you dream of a skylines shaped by feedback loops well just sit back relax and enjoy my
- 10:08conversation with patrick schumacher okay easy going yeah very easy going i mean i've got
- 10:26I wouldn't say I'm nowhere near an expert on obviously on architecture, but I did dive into your world of architecture.
- 10:39And it's a lot to take on board when you come from where I come from, which is, you know, period properties and etc.
- 10:47And things like that.
- 10:48This is my, but I am absolutely fascinated.
- 10:52And I source, I've got a lot of questions actually
- 10:56about the way you think about architecture
- 10:59because I thought I could see some things
- 11:04that don't make sense to me, if you sort of know.
- 11:06But we'll come to that.
- 11:07Tease them out, probe me.
- 11:08We'll come to that.
- 11:09Can we start with just how you got involved
- 11:12with the Free Cities movement?
- 11:13I know you've been dipping your toes in and out
- 11:16for quite a long time now.
- 11:17You've got connections with Prospera, with Liberland, with a lot of the projects.
- 11:21Yeah, that's absolutely right.
- 11:22So first of all, I became a libertarian through the 2008 crisis.
- 11:29And a lot of people shifted left, became anti-capitalist.
- 11:33But I had been there from the mid-80s into the mid-90s and moved out of that.
- 11:39So I wasn't going to be tempted back into left-wing ideology.
- 11:45So when I discovered the Austrian School of Economics, because the explanation of the crisis made a lot of sense to me.
- 11:52And people like Peter Schiff, you know, predicting it and somebody like Tom Woods explaining it.
- 12:01And then diving rapidly into picking up the readings, writings, and I discovered the Mises Institute and so on and the works of Rosbott.
- 12:11But I've already been familiar to some extent with Hayek's works.
- 12:14So that's where I started.
- 12:16And it applies beautifully to the built environment
- 12:19because in the development process, urban development process,
- 12:22we don't have much market process left.
- 12:24It's very, very heavily kind of controlled and regulated and politicized
- 12:29and to the detriment of development.
- 12:33It basically leads to some kind of paralysis.
- 12:35And in the end, the housing crisis, for instance, we have affordability crisis.
- 12:39It can be traced back to that.
- 12:40and it's all rent-seeking and it's rather than proper competition, entrepreneurship, discovery process.
- 12:49None of this exists in a built environment in the advanced countries, for instance, Britain.
- 12:55Now, so I was very intrigued when I – so I was a full-on libertarian,
- 13:00and also understood that it's very important in the urban development process to liberalize.
- 13:08I just heard about Liberland and being founded I was intrigued and more or less immediately
- 13:17in the first year of founding I flew to Prague and visited with Jelitschka the president and
- 13:25founder of Liberland and we had a whole afternoon on his roof terrace debating discussing and so
- 13:32So that's where I connected and then I went to also to visit Liberland.
- 13:40I mean, you couldn't go there, but there was a Liberland conference close by in Serbia.
- 13:46And Eric Brimman picked me up, was there at the time consulting WIT and New Way Capital trying to help WIT to negotiate deals.
- 14:00and so I met with Eric and we also learned about Prospera at the time and through that also came
- 14:10in touch with Titus and also he had just published a book around that time, Free Private Cities,
- 14:18which I was eagerly gobbling up and then I got involved with Eric. We were in parallel working
- 14:26with with with vit we did helped him to organize some architectural competitions and then we
- 14:32developed the metaverse for liberland i went to several of his conferences and i also connected
- 14:39up with eric and titus visited prospera and we did studies actually urban development studies
- 14:47for Eric and then also you know more detailed housing proposals with a very
- 14:57new concept of kind of market exploration through co-creation which is something
- 15:03you couldn't do in Europe because of the planning restrictions so that's yeah
- 15:08that's why I got into it and I was at the time also been going around speaking
- 15:14at many libertarian conferences,
- 15:17Students for Liberty in various places in the US,
- 15:20Liberty Con and so on,
- 15:22and met with people and became part of a network.
- 15:27So here's where I find it really interesting
- 15:32because you're the...
- 15:36Did you invent parametric design?
- 15:39Not parametric design.
- 15:40So I coined the phrase parametricism
- 15:43and recognizing that there's something very profound and fundamental called the new epochal
- 15:48style for the 21st century and that was my role and also so kind of canonizing to some extent what
- 15:55has been achieved over a number of years by that time it was nearly 15 years in some kind of wave
- 16:00a whole generation of architects investing in these new computational design concepts but also
- 16:07the physiognomy morphology of these compositions and urban plans became kind of radically different
- 16:15and new much more adaptive much more organic through the kind of techniques of integration
- 16:22adaptation and this coincided with the with the idea of the so-called urban renaissance where
- 16:29the period in the mid century there was this kind of sub greenfield factories sleeping cities and not much communication required in the city because everything was command and control planned through big corporates or the state and you have this kind
- 16:46of re and have this kind of flow back into the city with the beginnings of the knowledge economy
- 16:52through the computational and telecommunication revolution and so so that was in architecture
- 16:57meant more dynamism, more complexity, layering new onto old.
- 17:03And that developed some kind of new transitional styles.
- 17:08Postmodernism came out of that so-called deconstructivism.
- 17:11And I was involved with that, with Zaha Deed,
- 17:14was one of the major forces of so-called deconstructivism.
- 17:17And out of that developed something which I later, in retrospect,
- 17:21called parametricism, which is quite distinct,
- 17:23but I think much more long-lasting.
- 17:24So postmodernism had 10, 15 years, deconstructors in 10 years, and then primatism, we're now literally 30 years in.
- 17:33But the 2008 crisis took the steam out because what was great in the period up to that, there was much more dynamism development.
- 17:46You know, there was the remarketization of a lot of development processes.
- 17:50and you had phenomena like Dubai and Europe,
- 17:55a lot of booming cities,
- 17:59and that energized the whole field
- 18:02and gave also younger voices, new voices, work to do.
- 18:09And 2008 was a general moment of retrenchment,
- 18:13where you had the anti-capitalist flourish,
- 18:16where there wasn't work,
- 18:17where the schools of architecture also became kind of more politicized and anti-capitalist.
- 18:25And so that, in a way, took the steam out of this movement, Permettism, unfortunately.
- 18:30Because throughout the 90s and up to 2008, 9, 10, it was really, the field seemed to be converging on this.
- 18:38And, I mean, we kept going, and there's a number of other protagonists,
- 18:41the small hand of protagonists kept going, and we kept rolling out and maturing and developing.
- 18:45but it didn't deliver that kind of takeover of the field
- 18:50similar to what the modernists who started in the 1920s
- 18:55and into the 30s.
- 18:56Then there was a disruption of the Second World War
- 18:58but then post-war was rolling out throughout the 40s, 50s, 60s
- 19:03and transformed the physiognomy of that planet all over.
- 19:10And so that didn't happen with parametricism.
- 19:13So we got this kind of strange retrenchment
- 19:15going into retro styles, going into quiet, inconspicuous.
- 19:25And the field, the discipline itself,
- 19:28started more talk about social justice and sustainability
- 19:33and criticizing growth.
- 19:35There was, I call it also some kind of vogue takeover of the field,
- 19:40which hampered in a way the kind of optimistic, progressive,
- 19:48in a positive sense, let's say, technology-fueled advancement of urban life.
- 19:56So, okay.
- 19:58God, there's a lot there.
- 19:59There's a lot there.
- 20:00Did I hear that right?
- 20:02That parametricism came out of postmodernism?
- 20:05Yeah, it's a version.
- 20:07I mean, postmodernism injected some kind of degree of complexity,
- 20:12and there was this kind of idea of collaging motifs
- 20:14and integrating new over old,
- 20:18but it used traditional motifs.
- 20:22It was a kind of pop collaging with traditional architectural motifs,
- 20:26but you get something which is more lively and rich and varied
- 20:31than the modernism, which is this paradigm of endless repetition.
- 20:35And so postmodernism started to be more playful and versatile, but with historical motifs.
- 20:43Then deconstructorism picked up the kind of versatility and complexity build up, but no longer with historical motifs, but with more abstract geometric elements.
- 20:57And so that was, I thought, in advance.
- 20:59And they had additional, let's say, compositional opportunities, which postmodernism didn't have.
- 21:05And out of that, though, this wasn't, in my view, sustainable because it became very quickly too complex and illegible.
- 21:14These compositions, they became kind of, let's say, visual chaos, nearly.
- 21:20And so parametriism comes out of this ordering that chaos, but having the intricacy, versatility, adaptiveness of what we try to aim for in deconstructors.
- 21:30but with the new tools, computational tools,
- 21:33we could do something which was more coherent
- 21:35and more legible, let's say.
- 21:41Here's where when I was looking into all this,
- 21:45this is where my mind found a problem.
- 21:50And we should probably define parametricism before we go on.
- 21:53But basically, you've just said it there,
- 21:54parametricism was a way of creating order out of chaos
- 21:59in a way you've just described that's right but but i i got i was under the impression that
- 22:04parametricism is more about a spontaneous evolution of something it they they seem like
- 22:11they seem they seem or like you mentioned hayek and his spontaneous order yeah but they seem at
- 22:17odds with each other you've got this formal regime deciding what's what and then you've got a
- 22:23spontaneous order no okay i can resolve that first of all on the step back on a more general
- 22:29philosophical level, we looked at process of self-organization, spontaneous order, you know,
- 22:36complexity theory, chaos theory, the way, for instance, a complex formation of eddies and flows
- 22:42and happens when the water flows across some rocks. These are lawfully, but they're quite
- 22:49complex and rich and adaptive. And they're not invented. You don't impose. You allow the various
- 22:55parameters and influences to come together and have a kind of self-organization.
- 23:02And that's something which Hayek could also use that phrase, because he was interested
- 23:06in these processes of self-organization, complexity theory, like cybernetics.
- 23:12So I think there's the connection right there.
- 23:14Now, when it comes to the spontaneous order of the city, what I'm arguing is this.
- 23:21we need to allow entrepreneurial freedom.
- 23:26We need land use should not be described by any planning regime.
- 23:32I think that people come together into the city
- 23:35by seeking out very particular connections
- 23:39and a multitude of connections.
- 23:40And they have to find each other.
- 23:43There needs to be the degree of freedom to associate and self-organize
- 23:47what I call the co-location synergies.
- 23:50That's what you need, maximal entrepreneurial freedom.
- 23:54And then the role of the architect is not to impose a formal order preconceived,
- 24:01but to congenially articulate this emerging network of relations
- 24:07by making these underlying connections, affiliations,
- 24:14what belongs together more or less, legible by articulating that.
- 24:19organizing that spatially and articulating this.
- 24:22So when you come into a site and you say,
- 24:24I wanted to be here because I wanted to be close to some of these neighbors,
- 24:30and so you establish then not you come in with a preconceived form.
- 24:36You say I have to be adaptive because I want to make my entrances into my building,
- 24:41line up with the entrances of the neighbors I want to connect to.
- 24:45I also want to formally affiliate to the buildings perhaps they have There a certain geometry a certain path hitting my building I allow this to continue in that direction so that you see the building forms out of these relations
- 25:08And parametricism allows for that.
- 25:11And that's the spirit.
- 25:14So it is some kind of spontaneous order, but it needs to be articulated.
- 25:18The profession, as has been, wasn't able to do this.
- 25:23It had a very rigid vocabulary and insisted on proportion symmetry, a certain orthogonality, but often sides, for instance, are not orthogonal.
- 25:35So you can exploit with a pliable, amoeba-like kind of approach.
- 25:41You can fit yourself much better, and also if there are different levels coming to your building, you can mediate.
- 25:48So these moves mean that we can trace and make visible the spontaneous order which emerges and we're not imposing.
- 25:58Our view is that we have to trace, follow, articulate the affiliations and connections because that's why people come into the city, to have these connections, to be close to things they care about.
- 26:15but also to work together with things they choose to be next to.
- 26:20And sometimes if everything is kind of visually chaotic,
- 26:24you don't understand what functions together.
- 26:29But if you formally affiliate and pick up some of the materiality,
- 26:34some of the geometry, some of the alignments and directions,
- 26:38you can kind of intuitively read this environment better.
- 26:42And that's our idea.
- 26:44And also to give, you know, don't stuff, also internal relations.
- 26:51Don't stuff everything which needs to be accommodated into a preconceived box, internally preconceived.
- 27:00No, you allow the requirements to push the envelope, to structure the internal relations without preconceived geometries.
- 27:13so the metrics yeah that they're based on then they're preconceived right are they metrics well
- 27:21okay as in parametricism can i can i just explain can i tell you what i think i'll tell you what i
- 27:28think okay because i'm probably wrong but parametricism is um a design language based on
- 27:35algorithms so you choose some algorithms yeah and then that forms the uh framework for within
- 27:45which within which anything can spontaneously evolve yeah right so so there are kind of
- 27:51preconceived yeah there's always frameworks but not only in parametrize the point of parametrize
- 27:57is that the frameworks are more versatile pliable they have more input parameters but also i can
- 28:03choose to have many potential frameworks I could bring to bear. Compared to older styles, there's
- 28:09only one or two or three inverted commas frameworks to start with, and they have less
- 28:16pliability. So it's always comparative. You can't get away from what I call the formal a priori,
- 28:22the kind of framing set of categories, even when you describe something. You come with a language.
- 28:27The question is, is your language more versatile, expressive, subtle, adaptive, or is it more crude, simplistic, etc.?
- 28:38So my argument is, parametriism has a more advanced, meaning sophisticated, pliable, expressive language,
- 28:44also more tools to pragmatically adapt, it's not only a question of expression,
- 28:51of expression as our accommodation to pragmatic conditions which are more complex. I mean the
- 28:58previous in the old world, you know, life in various institutions was more static. Nine to five you
- 29:05come and sit always in your same cell. At lunchtime you go to the canteen and after lunch you go back
- 29:12and then everybody streams out and you don't need to have inter-awareness, inter-visibility,
- 29:17in continuous recalibrating you have maybe a few scheduled meetings and that's much more dynamic
- 29:24now particularly knowledge economy so every day you need to make sure that you take note
- 29:30of what all the other moving parts are you plug into and then you kind of roaming around you often
- 29:36have not as fixed desk you're roaming around in different settings detail at a space for instance
- 29:42and you have meetings meetings meetings with with internal external conditions you also right after
- 29:49work and in between work you have lunch meetings which are business meetings maybe outside
- 29:54networking after hours you go to the pub or go to an exhibition opening or conference
- 29:59so it is much much much more dynamic and interactive and therefore the settings
- 30:07you need to emphasize different things you need to emphasize that that you accommodate all these
- 30:12flows and relations that people also have more legibility of all the other things going on which
- 30:19might be relevant to them that's why we have opening up the section we have atria inter
- 30:24visibility into awareness and we have more kind of fluid and different settings you can quickly
- 30:29shift from one setting to another it's not closed rooms once you sit in the closed rooms and then
- 30:34you come open the door there's an empty corridor and you have to know where you're going but if
- 30:38you're an open bureau landschaft over many levels you get a sense what's going who's coming who's
- 30:43going and and what might be relevant to you and if you go to a Google campus that's what it's like
- 30:50actually at Google people have 20% of the time free used to have to freely associate set up
- 30:57teams set up projects because you can no longer come out and control from above it's moving too
- 31:04fast knowledge is dispersed work is self-directed so we are creating the environment for that
- 31:10and it's not corporate headquarters and factories on the green field which which just get follow a
- 31:18blueprint you know so it's continuously rewriting the blueprint and that's what we want to we want
- 31:24You want to accommodate that and express that and facilitate that.
- 31:29And of course, you have always some kind of, you come with a kind of systematic systems framework,
- 31:35but there are many competing ones and they update quickly.
- 31:39So there's not one frame which we stuff everything into.
- 31:47It's like the endless species of nature.
- 31:50None of them is arbitrary.
- 31:52they start arbitrarily but then they adapt, they evolve, they exploit a niche and things in nature,
- 32:01these species, they co-locate and synergize and feed off each other.
- 32:07And that's the way I see the world of the spontaneous order of the knowledge economy.
- 32:15Something we end up discussing a fair bit on this podcast in relation to free cities,
- 32:20because they tend to be located often in brand new places.
- 32:26Which I was interested to hear your take on that.
- 32:30Because when you look historically at a lot of cities,
- 32:32they amass around something, normally a resource,
- 32:36and then they seem to evolve over a period of time.
- 32:40One of the kind of potential problems with free cities
- 32:42is you kind of have to plant them in one place and make them.
- 32:47So do you think you can build a full city from scratch
- 32:50or do you think you have to sort of start it and then let the market decide
- 32:55what happens to the place? Yeah you definitely have to let the market come in
- 32:58but also you need to seed it with something of something which already has
- 33:02the rough general features I wouldn't start with a grid of 100 equal blocks I
- 33:07would start with something which is a default differentiation or range economies of scope so
- 33:13you can have small medium large enterprises but you also allow them to
- 33:17connect so you can kind of
- 33:19fuse blocks into allow for bridges etc. Yes you can fully invent on the drawing board but when you
- 33:31come to seeding a city and making first sketches you need to invite people to something which
- 33:39they can imagine but then there's something already you know there will be updates and
- 33:44and there will be transformations and flexibilities.
- 33:47You have to be very agile on that.
- 33:49And we can do that because we don't destroy the figure by making changes.
- 33:55If you become a very rigid, neoclassical, symmetrical, axial plan,
- 34:01if you adapt something, it will be out of whack and shows us a mistake.
- 34:07That's not the way we would design.
- 34:09So it's inherently flexible.
- 34:10We thought this through also with respect, for instance,
- 34:13something like Liberland or Prospera.
- 34:14So we're saying we can start in parallel with some kind of curated center.
- 34:21It just remains adaptable.
- 34:22Then we have other districts where we're trying to say, okay, come in,
- 34:27and we let the group of owners who started to invest,
- 34:32they can kind of arrange amongst themselves how to curate some rules.
- 34:37Because you might need some rules to contain negative externalities.
- 34:42but then you also should
- 34:44be proposing a kind of free
- 34:46for all where you come with
- 34:49the risk, I'm placing something
- 34:50here, I'm unrestrained but
- 34:52I therefore cannot control what happens next to me
- 34:55but I would trust that somebody
- 34:57next to me might
- 34:58be here because they
- 35:00want to have something to do with us so we'll be
- 35:02synergetic but you can't
- 35:05predict so there's a bit of more
- 35:07risk but also more opportunity in the free
- 35:08for all so I was
- 35:10opting for a kind of mixture of regimes in parallel,
- 35:15a central curated where the managers and owners,
- 35:19let's say the free cities investors,
- 35:25make propositions.
- 35:27And it is more predictable that you come in here
- 35:31and we were roughly in this environment.
- 35:33But then, of course, you also rely on the fact
- 35:35that it is being filled out by the planned kind of functions.
- 35:40And you wanted to say there will be a conference here,
- 35:42you have to actually find somebody who's hosting conferences,
- 35:45unless the city developer wants it himself
- 35:48to become a conferencing company or exhibition company.
- 35:51So there's the pros and cons.
- 35:53And the way we looked at it,
- 35:54we're saying we start on three or four fronts simultaneously,
- 35:57and then let's see what catches on.
- 35:59and then remain agile to adapt as we go along.
- 36:06So, yeah, it's definitely something which you can't do overnight.
- 36:09What is very important, though, is that you start with a critical mass.
- 36:13Everybody waits for everybody else to be there to have the network starting.
- 36:17So the network effects, like with any company which relies on network effects,
- 36:21a city is relying on it.
- 36:23The difficulty is to kind of bootstrap that out of nothing,
- 36:26particularly in a remote location.
- 36:27So that's why I think it's very important to have things like a metaverse version or to build a community ahead of settling.
- 36:35So there's relations, there's expectations, there's plans that have been shared and recycled.
- 36:40And we developed this tool of a co-creation virtually, a digital twin evolving, which you can already use for communications, for conferences like Liberland.
- 36:48The Liberland metaverse, for instance, played that role and wanted to play that role.
- 36:52and I think that's important because the difficulty is as I said yes it will always
- 36:58start relatively small but it has to be kind of rapidly grow to a certain extent that you're not
- 37:08isolated I mean the good aspect is that you also can be plugged in into a telecommunication network
- 37:14but you also want to have things happening at site and even if it's just to share certain
- 37:19facilities but also to have collaborators. So that's why I also thought it's important to try
- 37:24in the curation to target certain industries first where you feel and you know when you open
- 37:33a new building the same you can say I'm calling this a media center because I wanted to not
- 37:39randomly have any tenants which have nothing to do with each other. I want media companies here.
- 37:43So you have to play a little bit. I want to kind of reserve these for media companies,
- 37:47try to find and bring some media companies.
- 37:50That will then bring other media companies.
- 37:52And then you have something, you don't need to be very large
- 37:55to have critical mass of co-location and synergy.
- 37:58That's, I think, a strategy which I would emphasize.
- 38:00You need to kind of niche or have some kind of,
- 38:04in the world division of labor, some kind of specialization
- 38:08so that you don't need to have, you have 10 different seats
- 38:12which each of them lacks critical mass.
- 38:14and the relevance of these to each other is insufficiently strong.
- 38:20So that's the tough task.
- 38:22And sometimes you have to hold a little bit longer rather than giving up too quickly
- 38:27and it becomes a kind of random sampling of anybody who somehow feels too.
- 38:31Of course, so that's the kind of thing which I think Prosper has been doing that
- 38:37with respect to, for instance, crypto and certain things which make sense there.
- 38:44like innovative health tourism and health innovations.
- 38:51So I think that's important and that's the entrepreneurial task
- 38:56and we are very alert to that and we then help to support that as architects.
- 39:02We're not writing these briefs and programs.
- 39:05But I would highly recommend your point is very true that it will have to emerge
- 39:09and if for instance the health tourism takes are much more than the crypto which might have
- 39:15different requirements then then you need to also be able to pivot or recalibrate the priorities
- 39:25and let this emerge because we know blueprints into the long future
- 39:30are vulnerable particularly in such dynamic times. I'd like to take a couple of minutes
- 39:38just to tell you about what I think is one of the most interesting real-world freedom projects that
- 39:43we've come across recently. If you've been listening to this podcast for a while, you'll know that I'm
- 39:47always looking for things that actually exist, not the concepts, not the renderings, but real projects
- 39:53where people are already building the future. And this brings me to the Reef Resort, developed by
- 39:58the seasteading company ArcPad, founded of course by Mitchell Suchner, who many of you will remember
- 40:04was the winner of the Innovation Award at the 2025 Free Cities Conference.
- 40:09The Reef Resort, as far as we're aware, is the world's first operational seasteading resort.
- 40:14It's located just off the coast of Samal Island in the Philippines, where ArcPad currently operates.
- 40:2014 floating units available through Airbnb and other platforms,
- 40:24a project that has already hosted thousands of guests in both their accommodation and floating restaurant.
- 40:30now. Here's the development that will be especially interesting to listeners of this podcast.
- 40:35ArcPad is planning a second reef resort, this time off the coast of Prospera in Honduras,
- 40:41one of the most important Free Cities projects in the world. And construction is intended to
- 40:46align with the 2026 Free Cities Conference. So this is where the opportunity comes for you.
- 40:52You can now pre-purchase ownership in the Prospera Reef Resort. Ownership is available either outright
- 40:58or through fractional shares, allowing you to purchase from as little as 1% up to full ownership.
- 41:04Your ownership percentage determines your usage rights, your share of rental income from the
- 41:09eco-resort operations and your voting power in property decisions. This also gives you the
- 41:14opportunity, of course, to be part of a pioneering ocean-based development within the Free Cities
- 41:19ecosystem. Full units at the Prospera site start from $95,000, but with fractional ownership
- 41:25available you can participate at whatever level suits you if you'd like to explore this opportunity
- 41:31i included a link in the show notes where you can register your interest and access the pre information if you interested in free cities frontier living and the future of ocean communities then this is a chance to get involved at the
- 41:45ground floor. Seasteading is no longer just an idea. It's happening and now it's coming to prospera.
- 41:54So is it fair to say you still design using parametricism?
- 42:02Oh, yeah. Right. So is there is there a specific visual language to it then?
- 42:08Because when I think about at least my sort of limited knowledge of Zaha D buildings is, oh, they all look, they've all got that look, which is a parametricism look.
- 42:19So so does that mean a free city needs a specific architectural language?
- 42:23I what I think a lot of people appreciate, first of all, yes, because the look is not the immediate intent.
- 42:30the look is an outcome of a rational and adaptive process and it's not this interesting you can
- 42:37recognize it but it's at the same time more versatile than all the other styles put together
- 42:43it's a bit like you always will recognize whether a form is an organic form let's say or a natural
- 42:50form inorganic or organic rather than a mechanical form right even though the there's so many
- 42:58different natural emerged forms like inorganic or organic nature,
- 43:04you recognize this isn't an invented mechanical piece of equipment.
- 43:10So that's sometimes the puzzle where people think,
- 43:14oh, it's recognizable, that's why it's in inverted commas all the same,
- 43:17on a very abstract level, it is all the same, it remains recognizable,
- 43:19but it's like the infinite forms of nature.
- 43:22So it's much more versatile and rich in variation,
- 43:26although recognizable it has one label and it's not actually recognizable as zaha deed
- 43:34not to the extent i would say then i wouldn't be proud of that recognized as parametricism
- 43:43i'm proud of that it should be and there are many others who coming in since we're such a
- 43:47dominant mothership of this movement in terms of the large-scale operation will consistently work
- 43:52that. It is often kind of conflated and associated. But there are many other authors. And some of the
- 43:59major corporations also author projects like this, but not consistently. So I would say, yes, there
- 44:07is a language in the in the in the broadest sense. And also, it means that it gives a certain identity
- 44:14to a place.
- 44:16So what people dislike today
- 44:17is that there seems to be
- 44:20a lack of identity
- 44:22in different places.
- 44:24They all start to look the same,
- 44:25but if you look closely,
- 44:26it's not the same,
- 44:27but you can't get the gist
- 44:30or essence of the place.
- 44:32I call that garbage spill urbanization.
- 44:35If you spill out various
- 44:36cans of trash,
- 44:40they all have
- 44:41quite different ingredients.
- 44:44But as a field of trash, they all look the same.
- 44:48Because it is amorphous.
- 44:50It has no form, shape, order, logic you can hook onto.
- 44:55Even though the one has a Coke can and a milk carton and a crumbled paper,
- 45:00and this one has plastic pieces and no Coke, but smashed glass bottles.
- 45:07Because in the end, we respond to them, well, it's all equally white noise, disorder.
- 45:20And so that is where we have to a bit reflect what we think is sameness, what is difference.
- 45:28And we crave for identity.
- 45:29And with parametricism, it's very clear that we can build up, not preconceived,
- 45:34every town would evolve in a past-dependent way
- 45:38because it starts with certain conditions,
- 45:40certain materials, certain climatic conditions.
- 45:43There's something which gives it a particular identity.
- 45:45And if you work in paramedicine,
- 45:47you're meant to affiliate as things come together
- 45:51because they want it to be together.
- 45:54And they have a certain look and feel and sets of relations.
- 45:58This builds up.
- 45:59And this might also include ingredients which were there.
- 46:02You know, whether it was a valley, a river, an island, whether it's tropic climate or Nordic climate, all of these parameters and aspects will imprint.
- 46:14So you end up with recognizable places.
- 46:18Very similar, in a way, to the vernacular, where you had to, through the constraints and parameters and with less blueprinting, but evolving village forms, town forms.
- 46:30often they're concentric, not because somebody invented a concentric plan, because you start with
- 46:34some kind of fortification and then the first ring of houses around that, second ring, third ring,
- 46:40and then the whole thing is kind of locked onto a river on one side, so it has this asymmetry and
- 46:47orientation to one side. So these things evolve and in a way that's, parametriism does it too. So
- 46:54So the vernacular kind of settlement structures, they have not been planned, they are crew,
- 46:59but they have character and logic because there are certain regular parameters which imprint themselves
- 47:09and generate unity and the right variety relative to conditions.
- 47:15And that's the paradigm, of course, in today's world.
- 47:19We are operating on a different scale with more versatility,
- 47:23but the principle of let's say self-organization spontaneous order um is still there how does that
- 47:32fit in then i know in the free cities movement like titus is a good example there are a lot of
- 47:37people that idolize for example a european a beautiful european period city say something
- 47:44yeah and i i know that a lot of people wish to create to sort of recreate that mainly but say
- 47:53base it around a square use use period vernacular you know and what what do you think about that so
- 48:01my response to this is they're quite right to if i the different environments we pervade
- 48:07that there's something, a sense of place, a sense of coherence,
- 48:16versus that jumble of incongruent buildings which have no rhyme, no reason, no correlation.
- 48:25Because in the current world, it is actually failing of our discipline,
- 48:30but as well as the kind of randomness of a land use plan,
- 48:35where you have to build only can build this which is prescribed here
- 48:41and there is no therefore no immediate synergies
- 48:49but also the planners prescribe too much
- 48:52so you can't articulate then architects try to bring their own kind of
- 49:00relatively self-indulgent ideas
- 49:02and the discipline is quite fragmented
- 49:04I would also choose the historic city.
- 49:07As I said earlier, there's like the vernaculars, but also then the kind of later centuries where architecture was involved,
- 49:15but mostly involved only in the primary buildings.
- 49:18And the bulk of the building was still kind of tradition-bound building vernacular.
- 49:22These are more lovely, more places with more identity.
- 49:28And also, as I said, the convergence back to the historic centers, to the cities,
- 49:34this kind of more dense life is also better adaptive now.
- 49:38And also this idea of pedestrianized cities
- 49:41where you have to connect up and be in many places quickly
- 49:44than the greenfield and mechanically mass-produced sleeping cities.
- 49:50So the intuition is right.
- 49:53And if you had to choose with what available either this kind of concrete mega building or the garbage spill cluster
- 50:06I also would choose the historic city and center.
- 50:08And that's where postmodernism started.
- 50:12But it also wouldn't be, if you now compare what we could deliver,
- 50:18a kind of spontaneous order which is more adaptive to the actual needs.
- 50:25Because with the historic center, you have preconceived elements.
- 50:30They're nicely ordered, they create a nice ensemble and city,
- 50:34but still the buildings are too small,
- 50:37the buildings didn't have enough variety between buildings,
- 50:40and we can deliver variety between buildings without collapsing into garbage.
- 50:48We can make larger variety but have gradual transformation from one type to another or make them similar in interesting ways.
- 50:58So basically, because the attraction is going to the best we've got, but we have something much better we can deliver.
- 51:10That's my response.
- 51:12And so is it so would you say, is it impossible for the two to live, to coexist in the same place?
- 51:20Oh, yes. I mean, look, I would when I would make a new place.
- 51:23I mean, we're also learning from some of those features of the historic city.
- 51:28For instance, the focus on the on the void spaces, on the plazas and places and streets as spaces rather than only at the buildings and the in between has no shape.
- 51:38No, we also want to shape the space, the urban space, and not only the buildings as object.
- 51:44And sometimes the buildings as object have to retrieve, retreat into a framing surface to focus on the space.
- 51:51There's lessons we can learn.
- 51:53Also, the variety and the different types of cities are more monumental and more intricate with small alleys and small surprising plazas.
- 52:02And we can learn from that.
- 52:04But again, as I said, maybe we have to do it on a different scale.
- 52:07We have to do it with more variety.
- 52:08So there's no lack of learning and that was the whole period of postmodernism was about.
- 52:15I wouldn't recite, I mean, but there's things like lodgers,
- 52:21where you have between the street surface in the outdoor and the indoor, you have uncovered buffer
- 52:29zone, for instance. Features like this we can pick up on and when we did the City for Praxis,
- 52:34we have in Italy and Sicily.
- 52:37You also learn, you know,
- 52:38some of the features of the historical buildings,
- 52:40they are better adapted to climatic conditions.
- 52:43In the modernist period,
- 52:44we could just kind of do a glass box everywhere
- 52:47and inject mechanical power to heat or cool,
- 52:53whereas in the traditional architecture,
- 52:55you had to be more,
- 52:58you could you had to try to develop comfortable conditions without having mechanical
- 53:07burning through huge energy because you couldn't do that so you make things like
- 53:14um wind towers to ventilate out the heat you have shading covered place shades make the streets very
- 53:25narrow because they're shaded, self-shading and all the things we in the modernist period,
- 53:34a lot of these subtleties, adaptive subtleties were kind of left behind, not required. Now with the
- 53:42sustainability conscientiousness they're coming back but also they give character and identity
- 53:48and therefore you know in different climates where you are. In the tropical you have always
- 53:52these kind of roofs roof overhangs and oftentimes you don't even have enclosure you're not in closed
- 54:01spaces you're just covered and that because the wind whatever wind there is should breathe through
- 54:07freely and so we can work with these conditions but now on a different scale on a and and combine
- 54:14them with with different requirements so it is it is understood that there's this kind of draw
- 54:21being drawn to these oldest patterns and we can integrate them so I have this
- 54:27research paradigm learning from the vernaculars because we can learn how
- 54:31because there was been hundreds and thousands of years sometimes of of kind
- 54:35of incremental adaptation to climatic conditions and it's a bit like the
- 54:42biomimetic research where engineering solutions go out into nature because a
- 54:50A lot of organisms have developed intricate and surprising solutions to problems,
- 54:55which we can learn from.
- 54:57And similarly, I would argue, we're learning from the vernaculars
- 54:59and the historical architecture.
- 55:03Because we have to relearn it, because these were intuitively discovered
- 55:06through trial and error, and they're not written scientific analyses.
- 55:13But of course, we can't take it over one-to-one,
- 55:15because as I said, we have slightly different requirements now,
- 55:18particularly on this level of scale.
- 55:19But I feel, I think, and the responses we get with our work is that we, the kind of love and sense of comfort and energy people get when they walk into a historical city, we can solicit a similar response with our buildings and cities.
- 55:46Does parametricism ever come up with like columns, for example, or it does produce, because obviously they were solutions to problems from a natural scenario as well.
- 56:00The human mind is a natural scenario, isn't it?
- 56:02It's like, okay, we want a slanting roof.
- 56:04We want an overhang, right?
- 56:05We need to prop it up with something.
- 56:06We work with slanted rooms.
- 56:08There's drainage.
- 56:09There's also vaulting, a lot of vaulting.
- 56:12And the interesting thing is that when we do vaulting, in the old days, it was only possible if you have a full symmetrical condition.
- 56:22Because if you vault, you have the forces, you rely on equilibrium.
- 56:27If it is more of a freer form, an irregular form, then, for instance, traditionally they wouldn't know how to equilibrate this.
- 56:36And you have differential settlements, you wouldn't know how to dimension the foundation, the whole thing would crack up.
- 56:42Now we can use walls and we can make them more adaptive to
- 56:50site conditions, to the requirements of spaces and rooms. We don't need repetition and
- 56:57symmetry to the same extent.
- 57:00But we like walls. Walls are very efficient.
- 57:05Because everything is in compression and material is much stronger in compression.
- 57:08And so we have, that's contemporary research.
- 57:12So parametriism moved on to what I call tectonism, which is still parametricism,
- 57:17but it is absorbing many more, let's say, engineering, computational engineering logics and science,
- 57:27and more subtly integrate that as well.
- 57:30And these are often nice logics because they bring out typical forms which have a coherency.
- 57:39And also they relate back in a lovely way to some historical models.
- 57:44For instance, they have a vault and when you place the stones, there's a certain pattern.
- 57:50Or if you have kind of reticulations or ribs like in the Gothic vaults,
- 57:55this is actually quite efficient to make the overall structure lighter.
- 58:00but still equally stiff, and these ribs pick up a certain pattern
- 58:05and nearly give a kind of ornamental character to the space.
- 58:09So when we, in the stage of tectonism,
- 58:12affiliates even becomes even more akin to traditional structures Because what connects them is this idea of a
- 58:25adaptive discovery process except that now we have more degrees of freedom and versatility
- 58:32and they had there are more constraints in the old days but you know the gothic
- 58:36cathedral is a wonderful structure and the ribbing pattern is beautiful and but the the
- 58:43the bays repeat. So you're constrained to that. What if your church opens up and each bay and ribbing
- 58:52becomes larger and the profiles become deeper and the columns therefore become heavier,
- 59:00the forces become to the outside become larger. That's the way we would do it. So we have this kind of...
- 59:06And when you look back at a project like this you see ah, it's as beautiful, maybe perhaps more beautiful
- 59:13than the gothic because you can see the more intricate adaptive structure. The organism is
- 59:19more complex. If you compare a worm to a snake, the worm has an elegant form but it's segments.
- 59:27You don't know where's the front, where's the back, top, bottom. And the snake has this kind of
- 59:34nice tessellation which is very different on the bottom, the sides, the top.
- 59:38there is a front, the back and there's more intricacy and also superiority.
- 59:46You know, if you put the snake into a contest with the worm, we know who wins.
- 59:52And that's the way I would compare a more simple version of an architecture and a more sophisticated one.
- 59:59It looks the way it looks because it adapts better and is more optimized.
- 1:00:03For instance, if you look at the traditional walls and arches, they're semicircles.
- 1:00:08It's easier to install.
- 1:00:12But a parabolaid arc, inverted commas, not an arc, form is a much more optimized form.
- 1:00:21Really?
- 1:00:22Yes.
- 1:00:22But it's not symmetrical?
- 1:00:24The semicircle has problems.
- 1:00:26It's easier to make.
- 1:00:27That's why the compromise is then the kind of pointed arch.
- 1:00:32If you go from the semicircle arch to the pointed arch,
- 1:00:35you approximate more closely the parabuloid.
- 1:00:38But it's still not the optimal form.
- 1:00:41You find the optimal form if you take a chain and you hang it,
- 1:00:44and then you invert it.
- 1:00:46Okay, right.
- 1:00:47And that's not a semicircle.
- 1:00:49So we work with these more optimal forms.
- 1:00:52Now, they have a subtle, more elegance.
- 1:00:55You know, they're more optimized and they're more subtle.
- 1:01:02They're very coherent.
- 1:01:03They're mathematically organized.
- 1:01:05The physics generates them.
- 1:01:07And we are not hampered by the restrictions of the builders
- 1:01:13who might have been able to do a parabuloid,
- 1:01:16but it was also not, you know, how do you draw that?
- 1:01:19The semicircle, you just have a compass.
- 1:01:21They didn't know.
- 1:01:22And also, in the semicircle, you can make each of the stones the same in the paraboloid.
- 1:01:28The angle keeps changing, it's harder, and so on and so forth.
- 1:01:32So that's where we have this kind of, we're moving from the worm to the snake.
- 1:01:38But when you look back at the coherent design,
- 1:01:40there is this kind of Sagrada Familia, or the work of Gaudi in some of his later works,
- 1:01:47which has this character of the more sophisticated.
- 1:01:49you have to imagine stripping down all the ornament and crustaceans
- 1:01:53these are more sophisticated versions
- 1:01:55of let's say kind of basilica form
- 1:02:00already the first glimpses
- 1:02:02I'm going to go ahead and assume
- 1:02:05that you're using AI in a large way now
- 1:02:11and it must be an incredibly exciting prospect
- 1:02:14I mean I use it in a very simple way
- 1:02:17and it blows my mind continuously
- 1:02:19but in parametricism it must be the just unbelievable because and in fact um it must be
- 1:02:29working faster than than the whole office could work on this idea of emergent designs
- 1:02:38well yes there are different types of ai let's say of course we worked with um algorithmic and
- 1:02:45computational design, that was the biggest revolution.
- 1:02:48But what you can, and we had a lot of tools
- 1:02:52of form finding, the kind of physics simulations,
- 1:02:57as I said, the chain model inverted,
- 1:02:59but not only in the simple arc,
- 1:03:01a three-dimensional chain network.
- 1:03:03So we had all this.
- 1:03:04Now, when it comes to AI, the image AI,
- 1:03:06everybody was so excited about that part.
- 1:03:09Yes, you can accelerate, but you rely on the body of work
- 1:03:13to train up the AI.
- 1:03:14And some of the more sophisticated versions,
- 1:03:17which I call tectonism,
- 1:03:18there isn't enough out there for the AI to pick that up,
- 1:03:22but we have trained our own AI,
- 1:03:25feeding it with these examples,
- 1:03:29and then it can accelerate that.
- 1:03:30Yes, you can shortcut the form finding.
- 1:03:33And it is also lovely and creative,
- 1:03:35and you can interbreed different prompts
- 1:03:38and different references and images
- 1:03:40and allow it to kind of compose something more complex.
- 1:03:44But yes, it is relying on what has been out there.
- 1:03:49And so we also have to target and can train up the networks
- 1:03:52so that it can learn the most sophisticated versions.
- 1:03:57And then, of course, it speeds up enormously.
- 1:04:00Presumably, though, it can study nature in an infinite way.
- 1:04:06So in a way, there is a lot of un-mined data for producing parametricism.
- 1:04:13Absolutely. And an interesting way, if you step back superficially, it is really happening. If you Google AI and architecture, you can see where the desire is, what people would like to design and build. It's all parametricism, basically. 80% of it.
- 1:04:31in the real world you know the planning constraints the difficulty of the construction
- 1:04:36industry i mean our firm we're doing it but you need a bit of you still need a bit of a special
- 1:04:41occasion a slightly increased budget so um and then with all the constraints particularly in
- 1:04:48advanced countries where buildings should be inconspicuous there's always neighbors who
- 1:04:52complain there's always politicization so developers try to be as inconspicuous as possible
- 1:04:58So that hampers a little bit what is really happening.
- 1:05:03But what I love with the AI revolution is you can see where the desires are
- 1:05:08for all the young architects who play with that
- 1:05:11and all the amateur enthusiasts.
- 1:05:14They want something which looks much more like parametricism.
- 1:05:20So yes, that's very encouraging.
- 1:05:23But one also has to, you know, the shift from parametricism
- 1:05:27in this more sophisticated version of tectonism,
- 1:05:30requires higher coherency and rationality requirements,
- 1:05:35it's more particular.
- 1:05:37And yes, we can train it, but we have to train it.
- 1:05:41And you're quite right, you can also train it on natural formations.
- 1:05:47And that's just, yeah, it's very productive.
- 1:05:50But it's not an automatic because it relies so much on what you feed it with.
- 1:05:54And if you want something novel and different and we don't have enough to feed it with, then we have to first generate these samples to then let the network learn that.
- 1:06:06And that's what we're currently doing.
- 1:06:08I think that's my overarching experience with AI is that I often find myself using it to create a novel thing based on, you know, a series of parameters in a way.
- 1:06:25So it seems to be quite good at that.
- 1:06:26If you said, if you said like, you know, this is a bicycle and this is how you pedal it.
- 1:06:33Can you apply that to hot air balloons or something?
- 1:06:37It would know how to...
- 1:06:39It's just sort of like...
- 1:06:40Yeah, I think it's surprisingly creative
- 1:06:42and also the result has coherency.
- 1:06:47I mean, when we first discovered it,
- 1:06:49it was also very exciting.
- 1:06:51There was a bit of development process up to this
- 1:06:54where you can see some potential,
- 1:06:56but the results were incoherent.
- 1:06:57The buildings were not properly sitting.
- 1:07:02The perspective wasn't right.
- 1:07:03The light and shadow wasn't right.
- 1:07:05But that has been overcome.
- 1:07:07So now you get a kind of something quite novel and different, but you can see it's a building, it sits, it has a good orientation, light and shadow play on it in incredible ways.
- 1:07:19So you look at it, you could actually model it, so it's a coherent, an image of a coherent object.
- 1:07:26Wonderful, but it does, it lacks, most of these still lack the coherency of the kinds of objects we're designing,
- 1:07:33which have then not where you have to get these curves and rhythms.
- 1:07:42There's more interacting, there are more coherency requirements
- 1:07:47which the models have, they don't have enough resource to reproduce.
- 1:07:55And that's where we at the moment, where we are generating these sample sets.
- 1:08:02and generating synthetic data actually
- 1:08:06through various optimization algorithms
- 1:08:09which are computationally burden heavy.
- 1:08:14But once we've trained up the model,
- 1:08:18we can reproduce these results quicker,
- 1:08:26maybe not with 100% accuracy,
- 1:08:29but good enough to use and discover and generate options.
- 1:08:36So that's definitely an accelerating machine,
- 1:08:39but it's also, as you said, a creativity machine
- 1:08:42because you can mix in prompts.
- 1:08:45We would say, for instance, let's take a kind of system
- 1:08:51of walls and tensile structures but inject the fluidity of some kind of a landscape formation.
- 1:09:05So the model on the feeding images of two or three character types which usually
- 1:09:14had so far been separate domains and this kind of meshing and hybridization
- 1:09:21is a very nice technique of innovation.
- 1:09:25Also in nature, it's kind of recombination.
- 1:09:29And we had that by hand, we often were thinking like this.
- 1:09:33This is a concept we discovered
- 1:09:35and worked that heavily in the 80s and 90s,
- 1:09:37what you call generating hybrids, chimeras.
- 1:09:45But to do that by hand
- 1:09:49it's kind of quite clumsy and difficult do you think that um parametricism or tectonism
- 1:09:56will be the the next period of architecture because i i when i think about ai and i think
- 1:10:04about technology being able to produce these yeah designs this is now a reality and it wasn't
- 1:10:1225 years ago and it never was in historically ever so presumably the world of architecture will
- 1:10:20converge on i hope so it should converge i mean it's best practice i'm sure of that
- 1:10:26it shows that we how we flourished and grown and how many competitions we win
- 1:10:31the competitors not necessarily have the facility don't have the the rigor the tools i mean it's
- 1:10:38is hard to build up. We've been able to do it because we have, for 30 years, I have a direct
- 1:10:44relationship with a post-professional 18-month degree here at the AA in London, Architectural
- 1:10:51Association School of Architecture. We had 15 years of working with teams and a masterclass in
- 1:10:57Vienna, Yale, Columbia University, Harvard University, and not only me, many of our staff
- 1:11:02teach, for instance, with the
- 1:11:04University College London.
- 1:11:07These are our kind of
- 1:11:08research department. We have internal
- 1:11:11research departments, which is very
- 1:11:13unusual for
- 1:11:13architectural firm, but we are on the
- 1:11:17large side of firms. So we have
- 1:11:19about 10% working in research,
- 1:11:21people who are doing PhDs
- 1:11:23and writing scientific paper and reading
- 1:11:25scientific papers to translate
- 1:11:26into new algorithms. So with that,
- 1:11:29it's not so easy
- 1:11:30for everybody
- 1:11:32to imitate but it becomes easier and easier there are a lot of tools where plugins are made available
- 1:11:40endless youtube tutorials students can pick this up so it's spreading that's very important
- 1:11:46there's ways of allowing many and nearly everybody to participate in these skills
- 1:11:52and now with ai making it even easier also to write plugins and scripts
- 1:11:58so easy now with Gemini to do a web app and have an algorithm you don't have to know how to code
- 1:12:04so that will help enormously I think to converge and it will also converge because
- 1:12:10we need a more open discourse and be more critical of each other but the let's say
- 1:12:17functional pragmatic benefits so you can use AI to make an organic form but the tectonism form
- 1:12:26would be optimal.
- 1:12:28The materiality, so if you do something less rationally,
- 1:12:32first of all, you look at it, it's difficult to,
- 1:12:35it looks a bit kind of odd and amorphous and arbitrary,
- 1:12:39and the one which is optimized, they get a sense of,
- 1:12:41ooh, this settles, it's varied, but it also has coherency,
- 1:12:45but also it's maybe the material costs,
- 1:12:48the amount of cement you need is maybe 50%.
- 1:12:52the steel you need, the reinforcement is maybe down to 20%.
- 1:12:56And eventually this will come out as cost advantages.
- 1:13:01So I think the convergence will happen through that.
- 1:13:04The engineering disciplines are also now much more aligned.
- 1:13:09If you do a beam and you do a straight extrusion,
- 1:13:13there is a lot of excess.
- 1:13:16You would have to perforate it.
- 1:13:17It should swell in the middle if it's in bending
- 1:13:19and thickening in another direction at the edges.
- 1:13:24And the extrusion is only rational as long as it's mass-produced.
- 1:13:30But if you anyway laser-cut and robotically weld the piece,
- 1:13:36do the optimized version.
- 1:13:38And that means some of these rectilinear,
- 1:13:40and if you then have a beam in a building,
- 1:13:42they should all be kind of subtly different.
- 1:13:45and it is more beautiful, it is more economic and I would think that therefore
- 1:13:54unless there are barriers to continuous rationalization
- 1:14:01like planning or like a dysfunctional discourse where people insist
- 1:14:10no don't tell me what to do, don't criticize me, I like what I like
- 1:14:14I mean, this kind of attitude, a bit backward attitude in our field oftentimes.
- 1:14:18If these barriers would come down and a more market process, driven market process would do that, you would have this convergence.
- 1:14:28It's just making me think, actually, that because, I mean, it's hard to gauge this, but a lot of people say AI is moving so fast that, you know, in five years time, there's all kinds of people predicting very crazy things in five years time.
- 1:14:43I don't know whether it's true or not. It's very hard to gauge.
- 1:14:45But when you apply that to design and architecture,
- 1:14:50you can imagine that in the not too distant future,
- 1:14:54a computer could come up with the perfectly optimized design for any situation could it well i mean we still need an author to take responsibility to you know we are becoming yes
- 1:15:05we are we are not the ones who execute and make a hundred individual decisions on any corner
- 1:15:13we set up systems we set up metrics criteria of selection and we explore a much more wider range
- 1:15:22of options this way and we evaluate these options through metrics, through comparisons,
- 1:15:28we have evolutionary algorithms, yes, but you need expert interlocutors,
- 1:15:38which also translate the requirements of a client of a site into which systems are relevant.
- 1:15:45What are the priority criteria? Which metrics and what range of metrics? Do we optimize to 99%?
- 1:15:52and therefore compromise a number of other factors or is 90% good?
- 1:15:57There's kind of, let's say, decreasing, let's say there's marginal utility to go from 95,
- 1:16:06it's no longer worth it. So these are judgment calls and the judgment calls have to come from
- 1:16:13people who know and have been working with these systems. So these systems are very important. I
- 1:16:19I don't even see that we have shrinking staff.
- 1:16:22Because if you think about, same with the computational revolution,
- 1:16:25our productivity per person has been monumentally increased,
- 1:16:30but it didn't go into reducing staff and reducing, let's say,
- 1:16:36design fees relative to construction budget.
- 1:16:40Because investing more in design means you have less cost in construction.
- 1:16:47because you can read out all the clashes, you can optimize further.
- 1:16:53And also in terms of the benefits.
- 1:16:54So if you think of a cascade, the final value of a building is its utility,
- 1:17:00the benefit, what it facilitates and allows for.
- 1:17:03So for instance, a company like us, we would always go for the better building.
- 1:17:06The cost of leasing a building in the overall cost equation of a service firm,
- 1:17:14financial or architectural, engineering, anything,
- 1:17:17is relatively marginal.
- 1:17:19The real cost is staff and salaries.
- 1:17:23So if we stuffed our people into a building,
- 1:17:26which means they don't see each other, don't interact,
- 1:17:31we're missing the point just to save some bucks.
- 1:17:34But that's, and the construction cost,
- 1:17:38therefore, if you develop something more beneficial,
- 1:17:43and we can demonstrate this,
- 1:17:45it's worthwhile investing more.
- 1:17:47But relative to fees, so construction costs can still grow relative to other costs.
- 1:17:55Particularly if land costs come down, then we have a huge land cost politically created.
- 1:18:00But the planning cost, the design cost relative to construction costs could also increase for the overall equation be more beneficial.
- 1:18:09It will be more economical to invest more in design, particularly if we now have new tools where we can do more.
- 1:18:18I mean, for instance, the decisions which we are making for our clients or the clients can make on a basis of way more secure, way more tested with many alternatives.
- 1:18:28We give them also way more opportunity to appreciate what they might be getting.
- 1:18:35photo realistic immersive environment they can see what they get they can imagine will that work
- 1:18:40won't that work they get a bim model where where everything is kind of counted and where we where
- 1:18:46we can kind of change per market and see the cost implications so the the more investment in the
- 1:18:52planning process as i said also less delays on site uh because things don't fit and you have to
- 1:18:59to de-build, to rebuild, clash detection.
- 1:19:04There's so many elements of the productivity gains
- 1:19:07where it's worthwhile, which leads in a way
- 1:19:09to more design always is better.
- 1:19:15But you also have to have more design,
- 1:19:19just to think of more design makes no sense.
- 1:19:21You have to have more opportunity to improve.
- 1:19:25And that's what these new systems bring.
- 1:19:27So I'm very confident that we won't see slashing of staff, but everybody much more productive for the benefit of the product and for the overall cost benefit and particular cost benefit equation of these products.
- 1:19:45Something I've noticed with AI is I've already got a kind of form of fatigue about it.
- 1:19:54I'll give you an example.
- 1:19:55Yesterday, my wife's doing a new website.
- 1:19:58She makes very high-end sort of upholstery things.
- 1:20:01And she's doing a new website.
- 1:20:02She showed me.
- 1:20:02She said, look at this.
- 1:20:03This is amazing.
- 1:20:04I can point it at one of my pillows and say, put that pillow in another scenario.
- 1:20:09And I get all these free pictures.
- 1:20:11And my instant thought is, be careful.
- 1:20:13Because so can everyone else.
- 1:20:15And when you're trying to make yourself slightly different, if you're aiming at a very high-end market,
- 1:20:22it there's going to be i think there's going to be a sort of a bit of a revolution against this
- 1:20:29kind of stuff because people are going to notice it i already notice it i notice it in an email now
- 1:20:34if i if i get a whiff of the fact that an email that's sent to me is ai i ignore it straight away
- 1:20:39because i'm thinking that's lazy so i'm not but but but sorry to bite into it but but in but in
- 1:20:44your line of work it's going to become a very very deeply intricate part of the design process
- 1:20:51especially in in tectonism and you run the risk i suppose of having this kind of sameness
- 1:20:59because the ai is gonna is gonna conclude it's gonna do exactly what you want and it's gonna
- 1:21:05do the same for everyone it's gonna do exactly i'll dispute and that's not my experience it's
- 1:21:09actually more versatile because the conditions are never the same every building is unique for
- 1:21:13this respect to place and purpose and the previous paradigms couldn't make it so they were relying
- 1:21:20more in repetition and then stuff it in anyway. So I don't see that. Yes, there is more coherency.
- 1:21:29It's a bit like they're all proper organisms. And before you had kind of
- 1:21:36defunct or ugly or semi-resolved organisms, but we still have, we will have the endless
- 1:21:43forms of nature. So I wouldn't see sameness because if you rigorously do that, there will be,
- 1:21:52and you have more choices for instance now with these new tools like Xfigura,
- 1:21:57you're not relying on one model. You have all the models and you can combine them into a network
- 1:22:04and for each thing you choose a different model and so you have more calibration and we're just
- 1:22:12at a meeting yesterday somebody else developing a tool called verso where you where you really
- 1:22:18design workflows and the designer gets much more ability to select models to chain models to loop
- 1:22:25back with metrics into new prompts and and the structured so it becomes more sophisticated so
- 1:22:34there's always a curve where we onto the next thing where others just getting familiar with
- 1:22:39what has been rolled out. So I'm not worried that we are kind of, it's healthy to have good
- 1:22:45competition and that these things are easy for everybody means we're moving on to the next stage
- 1:22:49and we don't be lazy. I don't think that fundamental principle of a competitive alertness
- 1:22:55and continuous innovation changes. It isn't that, yeah, the AI tools keep evolving,
- 1:23:03the way you work with them, deploy them. We also have proprietary, let's say, networks,
- 1:23:07which we're training.
- 1:23:09And so it a lovely continuous race and it does allow for now which I endorse younger firms and newcomers to break in and catch some of the markets
- 1:23:27Now, their limitation is then in the realization.
- 1:23:30So they would then have to find somebody to, they can be in the front end, very competitive with us.
- 1:23:37In the downstream, they have no chance.
- 1:23:39We believe that we are more competitive even in the front end,
- 1:23:43because here's a small team with three, four people.
- 1:23:46Yes, they have the energy and they're young.
- 1:23:48They're just out of school.
- 1:23:49They can do it.
- 1:23:50But we have a research team of 15 people
- 1:23:52and they're also still very young
- 1:23:53and they have more resources
- 1:23:55and more stamina to focus on that.
- 1:24:00So I think this is, I'm excited by it.
- 1:24:03I'm not worried.
- 1:24:04We're at the head of the curve continuously
- 1:24:06and we'll stay so.
- 1:24:08Last question.
- 1:24:09We'll wrap up soon.
- 1:24:10Sure.
- 1:24:10Bring it back to the three cities.
- 1:24:12Yeah.
- 1:24:13because you are the most well you're a very prominent architect in the free cities movement
- 1:24:18you are there aren't many architects really but so i i'd love to hear your opinion on whether or
- 1:24:26not you think we need a um a kind of uh we need a uh like should you when you walk into a free city
- 1:24:38should you know it's a free city should you from from from the from the design of it should you
- 1:24:44understand ah i'm in a free city and should that be something that free cities you know use and
- 1:24:51connect with each other over because this isn't like this is a new well this is a new iteration
- 1:24:57certainly and it's a response to the old world as well it's a very good question i like this
- 1:25:02question i think my intuition is to say yes because there's something they share which
- 1:25:08which most places don't share.
- 1:25:13They basically have more chance with the outcome
- 1:25:17of an intricate self-organization process
- 1:25:23where degrees of freedom imply more degrees of rational choice
- 1:25:29and proper articulation of interests and purposes and value.
- 1:25:35And that will come through.
- 1:25:36And I think the parametricism-tectonism paradigm would come into play.
- 1:25:42But what we, in the real world elsewhere, it can't come into play sufficiently.
- 1:25:50It comes into play in one plot and next door something else.
- 1:25:56And that doesn't add up.
- 1:25:58I mean, we have one exception, a very rare exception,
- 1:26:01where we did a so-called unicorn island in Chengdu,
- 1:26:04where we did about a million square meter
- 1:26:06and designed 25 buildings on different scales
- 1:26:12and different programs, including residential offices,
- 1:26:14public spaces.
- 1:26:16And that's the kind of thing with many talents.
- 1:26:20That is unique and rare.
- 1:26:23But the private city could be like that,
- 1:26:27maybe even more diverse
- 1:26:29because there could be multiple authors coming in.
- 1:26:32The point here would be that the authors,
- 1:26:34the different architects will come into play.
- 1:26:37There should be at least a subset.
- 1:26:40They should be curated of being those who operate at the frontier of the field
- 1:26:44and not a random selection.
- 1:26:47That would be required.
- 1:26:48If you make a random selection and you bring a minimalist
- 1:26:51and then you bring a postmodernist and then you bring a neoclassicist
- 1:26:53and then you bring a high-tech person, you get a jumble sale.
- 1:26:58And that would make it indistinguishable from any other place.
- 1:27:02so that's what i i would feel so and and that means also that although the the the underlying
- 1:27:13programmatic order might be intricate and synergetic you don't sense it because you
- 1:27:20now have the high-tech building next to the the client of the high-tech building wanted to be
- 1:27:24next the client of the neoclassical building and they are next to each other fair enough
- 1:27:29but they wanted to be so close to each other and have things to do and things to share and maybe
- 1:27:34want to share space in front of them that you don't get a sense of and could you and could you
- 1:27:40marry a could you create two places one very much along parametricism lines another along a classical
- 1:27:50layout but still you know observing some of the traditions of of a growing city could they still
- 1:27:58Or would you still have the same understanding from that?
- 1:28:01Well, you could have somebody who wanted to have a range of classical.
- 1:28:05The problem is if you wanted to have a Renaissance,
- 1:28:08let's say Baroque-style layout,
- 1:28:10that was the first time you had these.
- 1:28:12Let's say the Renaissance style with the ideal city.
- 1:28:15They were pure geometric forms.
- 1:28:20If you work like this,
- 1:28:22then you end up with the problem of forcing everybody into a diagram.
- 1:28:30What might be more successful to have it more like evolve it like a medieval city
- 1:28:37which has more pliability and less preconceived structure.
- 1:28:43And there were the 19th century urbanists like Camillo de Cité
- 1:28:48who kind of described that and made that semi-conscious effort
- 1:28:51to do something which has more this adaptiveness and variety.
- 1:28:54Something else I could imagine, and you will get a sense of coherence
- 1:28:58and you get a sense of adaptive versatility.
- 1:29:01The only issue I would have with that is that it's still the range of variety
- 1:29:06which this would probably lead to is more limited.
- 1:29:12The range of scales you would allow to come in.
- 1:29:15So then you end up, for instance, with somebody who wants to have a bigger building,
- 1:29:19you end up where they
- 1:29:20you have five, six buildings
- 1:29:22facade wise but internally they're all
- 1:29:25connected. Now that's I find
- 1:29:27slightly disorienting. It's a bit like
- 1:29:28the Beatles movie where they
- 1:29:31all walk into a terrace house
- 1:29:33and then inside they have this huge
- 1:29:35connected pleasure land.
- 1:29:37Now when you come from
- 1:29:39the outside you don't notice that
- 1:29:41this is pleasure land and that
- 1:29:43what I find is a kind of
- 1:29:44legibility dysfunction
- 1:29:46and we could be more
- 1:29:49you could have an equally coherent thing
- 1:29:52but you would more realize
- 1:29:54and notice, it would become more transparent
- 1:29:56what are the different
- 1:29:57conditions and players
- 1:29:59in your city but without
- 1:30:01a sense of disjunction
- 1:30:03that would be
- 1:30:04so I don't quite believe
- 1:30:07I know that you know
- 1:30:08people in the libertarian movement
- 1:30:11and I explained it
- 1:30:13I don't blame them for going for the historical
- 1:30:15models because they have
- 1:30:17that sense of place, identity, and coherence.
- 1:30:21We have nothing else in the real world at this point to go for.
- 1:30:26I suppose we're...
- 1:30:26But we have visions and we have models.
- 1:30:30Unicorn Island, it's a cluster beautifully on a lakefront
- 1:30:35with startup companies.
- 1:30:40It's kind of incubated.
- 1:30:41It's called Unicorn Island.
- 1:30:43This is a place where they're supposed to generate unicorns.
- 1:30:46And I would say it's a good approximation.
- 1:30:49It's a first approximation, a vision,
- 1:30:51and it errs on the side of being
- 1:30:52maybe overly integrated and coherent.
- 1:30:55I mean, you say, but there's a lot of variation as well.
- 1:30:58There's versatility and unity and a sense of place.
- 1:31:03So I could recommend it.
- 1:31:04I would say, compare that to a historical place.
- 1:31:07What you find more exciting,
- 1:31:09where you could project the kind of knowledge economy
- 1:31:12hub you wanted to create.
- 1:31:14And I would say, if anything, what I'm really envisioning is something where you get a bit more variety still,
- 1:31:20particularly if you have to grow further, you would have.
- 1:31:24And that would be a multi-author, what I call a multi-author ecology.
- 1:31:27Because also multi-entrepreneurial ecology, a synergy cluster,
- 1:31:33which forms and emerges through kind of spontaneous evolution which needs these also needs not only the entrepreneurial decisions
- 1:31:46where to place and who to be next to and what internal offerings, but how do you articulate that and make that,
- 1:31:54that's where the expertise of architecture comes in, to really represent that and make it happen.
- 1:31:59and I've seen enough and we've made many experiments
- 1:32:06it would give you a sense of identity, sense of place, sense of coherence
- 1:32:13and you could say yes, this is one more of those free cities.
- 1:32:20I mean it probably would make sense because free cities are a frontier space
- 1:32:28that you should use frontier technology.
- 1:32:31You should be 21st century.
- 1:32:33I mean, my argument has always been
- 1:32:34the kind of freedom we're craving for and asking for
- 1:32:38and the degrees of economic freedoms we need now,
- 1:32:41we never needed them so badly
- 1:32:43because of all the opportunities
- 1:32:44we can exploit for those freedoms.
- 1:32:48And so the over-regulation,
- 1:32:53the politicization and planning
- 1:32:54was never a good idea,
- 1:32:57but it was relatively viable and feasible in the 1950s, 60s
- 1:33:02under mechanical mass production,
- 1:33:03where Kaplan itself structured itself into big bureaucracies.
- 1:33:08The market was squeezed out and substituted by relations of allocation
- 1:33:16within big vertically and horizontally integrated corporate agglomerates.
- 1:33:21I mean, that world is gone.
- 1:33:23And they then had built a kind of modernist company city, company development.
- 1:33:31And so that was different times.
- 1:33:35We have the computational revolution, the flexible specialization, network society.
- 1:33:41We need more degrees of freedom than ever before.
- 1:33:45And therefore, I think to express that, we should also express the frontier, 21st century, everything.
- 1:33:53and the 21st century everything we need degrees of freedom which we could which would never existed
- 1:33:58not even in the 19th century sometimes unhistorical about
- 1:34:01patrick thank you very much indeed yeah that's a lovely place to end i i kind of i'm i'm a i'm a
- 1:34:09sucker for for old style architecture but i fully understand what you're saying and that that an
- 1:34:16identity would evolve from that and it it is an important aspect of the whole movement is to have
- 1:34:23an identity so people know what yeah what this thing is and not only is the is the is the frontier
- 1:34:31appearing but the technology to create anything it appears i mean you talk about designing beams
- 1:34:39that have a little kink in the middle you know this would have been a mistake 50 years ago this
- 1:34:44is now something that you can actually print or you can design 3d printing for instance open up
- 1:34:51the design space before you could you just had to extrude a profile you know so so so that means
- 1:35:01the fabrication was constraining the forms and now you can optimize and then 3d print
- 1:35:08or laser cut and laser weld.
- 1:35:14You can make every, you know, in a cladding,
- 1:35:17you can make every panel different.
- 1:35:20So you can make a tessellation which registers
- 1:35:23the concave convex, the flat curve, the tight curve,
- 1:35:27where the elements become smaller,
- 1:35:28like the tessellation on an organism.
- 1:35:33And when you look at it, you can sense the intricacy,
- 1:35:36the intelligence.
- 1:35:46And I think that's,
- 1:35:47we sense that as something we respect
- 1:35:48and trust
- 1:35:53and want to be part of.
- 1:35:57You know, if you have,
- 1:35:58in front of two buildings,
- 1:35:59one is kind of thrown together semi-randomly
- 1:36:01and here's something which is intricate
- 1:36:03and kind of
- 1:36:05complex in order
- 1:36:08you say
- 1:36:08this could be
- 1:36:11dangerous, disorienting
- 1:36:14and this
- 1:36:17there's a sense of trust
- 1:36:18I think it's also
- 1:36:20and appeal
- 1:36:21what does appeal
- 1:36:22I mean the aesthetic sensibilities
- 1:36:23in a way kind of intuitive shortcuts
- 1:36:26and if you're well attuned
- 1:36:29and you have the right
- 1:36:30aesthetic sensibility
- 1:36:30similar to moral sensibility
- 1:36:32you're attracted to somebody
- 1:36:33who's a personality
- 1:36:34was functioning well, or a place, or an object. Seeing beauty meaning seeing
- 1:36:43performance, not calculating through analysis, just an intuitive. We're conditioned,
- 1:36:48we learned that. You've seen many things and you kind of in the end you know
- 1:36:52what is good for you, what works. You can read it off the form,
- 1:36:59you can read it of the superficial markers and that is this appeal.
- 1:37:03Every organism, we navigate the work aesthetically, world aesthetically always.
- 1:37:09What attracts us, what repels us? I mean it's very deep, very visceral,
- 1:37:13a nice smell, a disgusting smell. I mean they're actually signs of something else
- 1:37:19and if you extrapolate from this old sense of beauty, I mean you have to relearn
- 1:37:23the kind of aesthetic values,
- 1:37:30because now the things which are in the frontier of high performance
- 1:37:33look different.
- 1:37:35You have to learn to love them.
- 1:37:38And that's also something I reflect.
- 1:37:41And sometimes if you've read it to sensibilities
- 1:37:45from yesteryears, high performance,
- 1:37:49this nostalgia could hold you back.
- 1:37:52well i'm also thinking sorry i just keep thinking of things um we one of the things that i don't
- 1:38:01like about the world of mass production is when buildings are built because they're easy to
- 1:38:07produce because each thing right but but i i'm thinking about what you just said about having
- 1:38:12every single panel made one you know a one-off that can now be mass-produced in a sense so it's
- 1:38:20good use of of mass production i mean and and it's more optimal yes um for instance if you had shading
- 1:38:27elements brisole elements uh traditionally you say okay you just use the same element and the
- 1:38:34same pattern across all sides but west south to east they all need shading but different
- 1:38:44the sun comes in flat comes in steep because there might also be a building which so you need to
- 1:38:50So in particular view, it's along a curved wall.
- 1:38:54It will gradually transform and adapt and change.
- 1:38:57That's the rational thing.
- 1:39:00What is also good about it, when you come to the building,
- 1:39:02you can sense, it's like a compass on an overcast day.
- 1:39:07So there's the multiple advantages.
- 1:39:09There's materially more advantage.
- 1:39:11It's expressively more advantage.
- 1:39:13It gives you more sense of an intricacy,
- 1:39:15which is you're more attracted to and you should be
- 1:39:17because it's less crude.
- 1:39:18and therefore less wasteful.
- 1:39:23What is wasteful about the other shading
- 1:39:24is that you have excessive use of material
- 1:39:29and you have insufficient shading
- 1:39:33or too much shading
- 1:39:35and therefore it's too dark
- 1:39:37and you have to switch the light.
- 1:39:38I mean, so it's just crude.
- 1:39:42And so we can do more than...
- 1:39:45We're not stuck in this crudeness.
- 1:39:47but a lot of our colleagues haven't yet realized that.
- 1:39:52Or they don't have the compass seed.
- 1:39:54They're still stuck with this crudeness
- 1:39:56because that's all they've got.
- 1:39:58It would have been arguably too expensive.
- 1:39:59before it was too expensive yeah and even difficult to calculate yeah now we have scripts
- 1:40:05where we maybe we can simulate the sun exposure onto a surface that is a differentiation it could
- 1:40:13be a color map and then you can kind of align the script feeds into a variation of the louver
- 1:40:19automatically adapting the louver according to the sun exposure conditions
- 1:40:23and of course you have to set up the system so that's a choice the choice is not i'm decide
- 1:40:29deciding on each louver but I'm deciding on a way of measuring sun exposure, okay that's more or less
- 1:40:35given, and how I could, there are many many different ways in which I can make these louvers
- 1:40:42express them, individual elements, lines which go from horizontal to vertical, or shingle-like,
- 1:40:48or so these choices still remain and I can make it into the kind of 90% range of optimal in many
- 1:41:00different ways and then there's still creative choices which system to and I have another
- 1:41:05criteria by which okay I'm doing it but I'm doing it timber because in my neighborhood a lot of
- 1:41:11timber buildings I want to be kind of harmonizing with them and so I make this connection
- 1:41:18rather than, and I could have used stone, I could have used metal, they have different
- 1:41:23price points, but again, there's a range. So there's a lot of creative choices still too.
- 1:41:30And the choices are kind of which systems to apply and which kind of whether I should include the overshadowing of neighboring buildings for instance then suddenly the louvers thin out because I don need them here
- 1:41:46and then once the environment was built at least I'm encountering the facade and say
- 1:41:50why is this ah okay which gives you inference potential it gives you information you look at
- 1:41:58facade and you see what's around it represented in the facade. That's the kind of idea where I feel
- 1:42:06and now you don't have that because nothing has the decisions are arbitrary, disconnected,
- 1:42:14so they don't tell you more. I want everything you encounter to tell you more. The visible tells
- 1:42:19you about what is not yet visible but might empower you to know. So these are the kind of
- 1:42:24advantages of this way of working. And in nature you have that. Every dumb bird can find its way in
- 1:42:31an environment because where the water flows is where the vegetation is different. The north
- 1:42:39phase of a mountain is different from the south phase. The vegetation thins out and the rock crops
- 1:42:46up. And so you know what to expect where. And then in these conditions different creatures, flora and fauna
- 1:42:54adapt to these. And so this logic and coherence and the rule-basedness helps every creature to find their way.
- 1:43:02Whereas in a garbage pile there's no reason, rhyme or logic to follow.
- 1:43:09And so I want the city to be as intricately ordered so that everybody can orient And we are more bright and faster learners than birds
- 1:43:21It's the eternal battle between bottom-up and top-down, isn't it?
- 1:43:25It's fascinating to hear it in the context of architecture, though,
- 1:43:28because I see it in daily life.
- 1:43:33But it's great to think that you're actually trying to apply this to that field.
- 1:43:40Because it can be applied to every field or every job.
- 1:43:43You know, everything is a research effort.
- 1:43:46I mean, we're doing this with universities, with students,
- 1:43:52to explore it, to develop it.
- 1:43:54Then the next level is PhD explorations.
- 1:43:58Bring the argument.
- 1:44:00The next is internal research department.
- 1:44:02And then finally, 10 years later, we're rolling out some of that.
- 1:44:07so it's not instant
- 1:44:12but the pleasure is with the new tools
- 1:44:16AI and some of these ecosystems around grasshopper and plugins
- 1:44:19we do the research and not everybody has to go through it
- 1:44:24so it takes 10 years
- 1:44:28to develop but it maybe takes a year to
- 1:44:32condense into YouTube videos and plugins
- 1:44:36and then millions of end users can pick it up
- 1:44:41and get used to it within a few weeks, let's say.
- 1:44:45That's the way this spreads.
- 1:44:49Well I have no doubt it will spread Now you articulated it Many thanks for spending some time I need to go back away and digest this now
- 1:45:02Okay, great.
- 1:45:03Many thanks.
- 1:45:04My pleasure.
- 1:45:09All right, you made it to the end of the show.
- 1:45:12So I'm just going to go ahead and assume that you got some value out of this episode.
- 1:45:17If you want to help the show, please follow or subscribe right now.
- 1:45:22It takes only two seconds and it massively helps the show.
- 1:45:26If you want more, well, you can get bonus episodes and early access to all episodes on Fountain.fm
- 1:45:35by subscribing for the measly price of just, well, one venti frappuccino in Starbucks for a whole month.
- 1:45:44That's right, six bucks.
- 1:45:45or you can just support the mission by streaming sats on any of the value for value platforms
- 1:45:51like fountain or use the bitcoin and fiat donation links in the show notes we run this show on a
- 1:45:59tight budget as i'm sure you're aware so any additions to that or to the strategic bitcoin
- 1:46:05reserve will be greatly appreciated and one more thing if you know someone who'd love this episode
- 1:46:12share it directly with them that personal share beats every algorithm in the book
- 1:46:18all the links the community and the newsletter are in the show notes see you next week