Latest / CLEs You Actually Want to Hear / Who Owns an Invention Made in Space? IP licensing, AI inventorship, and the Emerging Space Economy
Transcript
- 0:03Hello, everyone, and welcome to the Beverly Hills
- 0:06Bar Association's production of Who Owns an Invention
- 0:09Made in Space? IP Licensing, AI Inventorship,
- 0:13and the Emerging Space Economy. I'm Adrian Sihand,
- 0:16chair of the BHBA's intellectual property law
- 0:19section, and I'm delighted to introduce our speaker
- 0:22today, Edward Kellner. Edward is a U .S. registered
- 0:26patent attorney and an adjunct professor of law
- 0:29at University of New Hampshire, UNH Franklin
- 0:31Pierce School of Law. where he teaches an advanced
- 0:34summer course examining the intellectual property
- 0:36challenges emerging from aerospace innovation,
- 0:40autonomous flight, and the commercial space economy.
- 0:43He currently serves as director, research contracts,
- 0:46and industry agreements at the University of
- 0:48Texas, Rio Grande Valley, and is the founder
- 0:51and principal of OORT Ventures, a firm specializing
- 0:54in space law, IP strategy, and Web 3. He holds
- 0:58an LLM in air and space law, a JD, an MBA, and
- 1:03an MS in global technology and development, and
- 1:06is a U .S. Navy veteran whose research and publications
- 1:09span space law, cultural heritage, human rights,
- 1:13and emerging technology governance. Thank you,
- 1:16Ed, for your service and for leading this presentation
- 1:19today. And now let's get started. Terrific. Well,
- 1:22thank you for that introduction, Adrian. It sounds
- 1:24so good. I think I just dropped the mic right
- 1:26now. Walk away. Welcome, everybody, either you're
- 1:30in the early evening if you're out on the East
- 1:32Coast or late afternoon if you're on the West.
- 1:35I am coming live from Sandia, Texas, which is
- 1:38about south central Texas. So we're in the central
- 1:42time zone. So let me see if I can pull up my
- 1:45slides and we'll get right into it. We're going
- 1:47to talk about outer space today. As we talked
- 1:49about, I have a background in outer space law.
- 1:52I took the LLM program at the University of Mississippi.
- 1:57And I think, let me make sure the share is working.
- 2:03Screen one. I don't want this one, screen two
- 2:08here. Let's hit that one. Content only. And optimize
- 2:18for video sharing. Let's go share. Can you guys
- 2:25see my... Well, it looks like we're currently
- 2:31seeing the share on the back end, the display
- 2:34settings, the notes. Here's the main one. Is
- 2:40that working now? Yes. Perfect. Oh, actually
- 2:43it looks like we're seeing a gray bar towards
- 2:46the bottom of the screen. Is there something
- 2:49in front of the application? That is the chat
- 2:52and all that. Let me see if I can move that further
- 2:53down. It's all the little buttons that come along
- 2:56with the Okay, there it goes that help a little
- 2:59bit Yes, okay. Well, if not, we can know is Eric
- 3:04goes down even more. So that's good So, oh Now
- 3:11it looks like the whole screen is blocked out
- 3:13Can we try to restart the screen share for now
- 3:15and perhaps share the application? Let me do
- 3:18that and move this part over a little bit Got
- 3:22another document up and that's probably what's
- 3:25causing problems. Let's go over. I don't want
- 3:31you there. OK, that's over there. Does that work
- 3:39now? Can you see it OK? I do see the majority
- 3:43of the PowerPoint if you want to proceed one
- 3:45slide forward. Whenever you're ready. OK, yeah.
- 3:50All right, good. So I will be reading from my
- 3:54prompt over here too, so I'll be kind of in and
- 3:55out of camera view. But let me see if I can get
- 4:00it to come back to the first slide. And let's
- 4:03begin talking about space law and how it relates
- 4:09to intellectual property. It's kind of interesting
- 4:12just to kind of start at the beginning is space
- 4:15economy is estimated in 2026 to be about $700
- 4:19million in revenue, and that's across commercial,
- 4:25international, and state -funded. It's supposed
- 4:29to grow to a trillion dollars within five years.
- 4:33So I want to begin with a client call because
- 4:35we're mainly attorneys and this is a CLA. So
- 4:39a research team has just announced a breakthrough
- 4:41aboard a commercial orbital laboratory. sort
- 4:45of like the ISS, but new ones that are coming.
- 4:47I think Blue Horizon, there's a company called
- 4:49Axiom in Houston, are building one. The scientists
- 4:52want to publish, the sponsor wants to file patents,
- 4:56the platform operator claims rights on onboard
- 5:00data, and the competitor is already asking whether
- 5:04it can license the process. Before advising anyone,
- 5:08I have to answer a deceptively simple question.
- 5:12Where did the invention legally occur? Traditionally,
- 5:15IP law assumes that we can identify a territory,
- 5:19a human inventor, a governing court, and accessible
- 5:22evidence. Space activity destabilizes all that
- 5:25assumptions. Technology may be designed in one
- 5:28country, launched from another, operated on a
- 5:32spacecraft registered to a third country, controlled
- 5:35through ground stations on several jurisdictions,
- 5:39and improved by an AI system. where processing
- 5:44occurs in the cloud. I want to emphasize this
- 5:48is already a practical issue for universities,
- 5:51pharmaceutical companies, satellite operators,
- 5:54and others. The legal work begins long before
- 5:56launch, before admission architecture, registration,
- 6:00funding, data flow, export controls. You have
- 6:03to determine whether the resulting rights are
- 6:06of value or merely theoretical. over to this
- 6:13one. All right. So when we look at this, let's
- 6:22pick a hypothetical. Let's call it Project Helix.
- 6:27It's definitely not something that's happening
- 6:30right now, but something that could, just to
- 6:31make an example and follow through with this.
- 6:36Real space is crowded. US universities and European
- 6:41pharmaceutical companies fund protein crystallization
- 6:45experiments aboard a commercial space station
- 6:48registered in Luxembourg. Japanese equipment
- 6:51performs the experiment. A Canadian scientist
- 6:54supervises portions of the work. A US -developed
- 6:59AI system changes the experimental parameters,
- 7:02and data moves through ground stations in several
- 7:05countries, including through satellites. The
- 7:08result seems to be promising treatment and discovery
- 7:11under microgravity conditions. Of course, in
- 7:14orbit, you have no gravity, basically, and you
- 7:18can do microgravity experiments that you can't
- 7:21do on Earth. So let me ask you, who owns the
- 7:24invention? If they come up with something here,
- 7:26let's say a cure for cancer. The likely candidates
- 7:29are the individual scientists, the university
- 7:34that that scientist works with or works for.
- 7:37The sponsor, which could be a pharmaceutical
- 7:39company in this case, the platform operator,
- 7:43where the research is taking place, an AI developer,
- 7:46or some combination of all those. So resist the
- 7:50temptation to answer immediately. The point is
- 7:53that none of the visible scientific facts resolve
- 7:56ownership. Before I could reach a conclusion,
- 8:02I would need to collect, let's say, employment.
- 8:05and invention assignments, maybe there are contracts,
- 8:08agreements, sponsored research agreements, that's
- 8:11something I work on for the university that I
- 8:13work for, government funding conditions, so if
- 8:16it was funded by NASA or some other government
- 8:19agency, this might be NIH or something like that,
- 8:24AI licenses, equipment supplier terms, material
- 8:28transfer, and data use agreements. the spacecraft's
- 8:31registry. Where is the rocket registered? Where
- 8:33was the spacecraft registered when it was launched?
- 8:37What kind of logs are there? Identity of humans
- 8:41who contributed to the claimed invention. I want
- 8:46to distinguish between inventorship from ownership,
- 8:49right? Inventorship is determined by patent law
- 8:52and cannot simply be reassigned by contract unless
- 8:56there's an assignment clause that you give to
- 8:58your company or maybe to the university. Ownership
- 9:02then flows through the employment obligations,
- 9:04so written assignments, funding rules, negotiated
- 9:07project terms. A sponsor may receive an exclusive
- 9:11license without being the inventor or the initial
- 9:13owner. A platform operator may control the data
- 9:18without owning a patent. These distinctions will
- 9:24recur throughout the hour that we talk about.
- 9:34Three legal systems collide. So something we
- 9:38have to understand, jurisdiction and sovereignty
- 9:41are very important, right? Territorial is very
- 9:44big and intellectual property, right? When you
- 9:46file a patent, you file a trademark, even file
- 9:49a copyright, it is done through the nation. You
- 9:53do it through the U .S. Patent and Trade Office.
- 9:56You do it through the EU Patent Office. China
- 9:58has a Patent Office. It's very territorial. The
- 10:03governing constitutional agreement, I would call
- 10:06it, or space law, is the 1967 Space Treaty. Now
- 10:13in 1967, there's basically only two people going
- 10:16to space, the U .S. and Russia. And it was all
- 10:20controlled by the individual governments, right?
- 10:21NASA was controlling, and Russia was controlled
- 10:27through the Russian government. Now, nothing
- 10:29with IP was never mentioned. But one thing that
- 10:32was mentioned, and we'll cover it a little bit
- 10:33later, was there is no sovereignty in space,
- 10:38necessarily. Just because we planted a flag on
- 10:41the moon in 1969 doesn't mean we own the moon.
- 10:45This isn't the colonial era of the Earth. where
- 10:49when Spain planted their flag, they claimed the
- 10:51territory of wherever in South America, Mexico.
- 10:54It doesn't work that way with space, not the
- 10:56way the treaty is set up. So it kind of throws
- 10:59things into a little bit of a tizzy when you
- 11:01talk about IP law, because they're primarily
- 11:04territorial. Rights are granted, defined, and
- 11:08enforced by sovereign legal systems. Even when
- 11:11international treaties harmonize procedure or
- 11:13there are minimum standards, there is no single
- 11:16worldwide patent it automatically governs every
- 11:19place where the technology can be used. The second
- 11:24system is space law. The foundational rules emphasize
- 11:28freedom of exploration, non -appropriation, state
- 11:31responsibility, and jurisdiction linked to registration
- 11:35of space objects. Those principles are designed
- 11:38primarily for relations among states during the
- 11:41area of government -led missions. not the routine
- 11:45commercial research involving startups, universities,
- 11:49or cloud services or supply chains that we're
- 11:50dealing with now. The most recent third system
- 11:54is the digital and AI governance, right? Data
- 11:58crosses borders nearly instantaneously. Software
- 12:01may be uploaded remotely. AI may generate for
- 12:05technical solutions without clear geographic
- 12:08point of creation. and cloud infrastructure and
- 12:11distributed technology make the location of the
- 12:15inventive process more difficult to isolate.
- 12:18So we come back to Project Helix. We cannot be
- 12:22solved by asking only which country's patent
- 12:24law applies. You need to understand how public
- 12:28international law determines jurisdiction and
- 12:30state responsibility. How national law defines
- 12:33inventorship and infringement. and how private
- 12:36agreements allocate data improvements and commercial
- 12:39rights. So space is not a legal vacuum. It is
- 12:52a vacuum though, but it's not legal vacuum. The
- 12:54phrase legal vacuum is memorial but misleading.
- 12:58The commercial space project may be subject to
- 13:00more laws, not less. International treaties can
- 13:03govern state responsibility. registration, cooperation,
- 13:08but national laws can govern patents, copyright,
- 13:10trademarks, export control, sanctions, and corporate
- 13:13conduct, especially for government -funded research.
- 13:17Launch and payload approvals add regulatory conditions.
- 13:22Platform terms and research agreements allocate
- 13:25private rights. And arbitration clauses and foreign
- 13:29provisions determine how disputes will be heard.
- 13:31The difficulty is that these rules are not necessarily
- 13:35point in the same direction. A launch date may
- 13:38regulate safety. The state of registry may retain
- 13:41jurisdiction and control over the spacecraft.
- 13:45The researcher's employer may claim inventions
- 13:47under the employment agreement, and a government
- 13:50sponsor may hold reserved rights. And let's not
- 13:54forget about the software provider or the AI
- 13:56provider that may prohibit certain uses of the
- 13:58AI model. Patents may exist in one country, but
- 14:01not another. My recommendation is to create a
- 14:06mission law map. It's kind of a different type
- 14:09of animal. I'd start with the actors, the physical
- 14:13assets, the data pathways, the funding sources,
- 14:17and the operational locations. When I can identify
- 14:20the legal connection attached to each, this prevents
- 14:24the common mistake of treating the spacecraft's
- 14:26registry and launch site or the client's headquarters
- 14:29as the only relevant jurisdiction. For Project
- 14:33Helix, the correct first deliverable may be a
- 14:37chart rather than a legal conclusion, party role,
- 14:40country, governing agreements, background IP
- 14:43that may be out there, expected IP out of what
- 14:48they do up there, and data access and regulatory
- 14:51status, just to name a few. Let me get to the
- 15:00document here. So Outer Space Treaty has many
- 15:07provisions, but for this presentation, I'm going
- 15:10to focus on four of them. Article 1 establishes
- 15:19the freedom of exploration and the use that outer
- 15:23space activities should benefit and serve the
- 15:26interest of all countries and all mankind. For
- 15:29this course, Article 1 raises a long -term policy
- 15:32question of how should exclusive IP rights coexist
- 15:35with broad access to the benefits of space research?
- 15:39It does not automatically invalidate patents,
- 15:42but informs the governance debate. Article 2
- 15:47prohibits national appropriation by sovereign
- 15:49use, occupation, or any other means. This key
- 15:52distinction is between appropriating territory
- 15:55and recognizing the exclusive right in the technology.
- 15:59A patent on drilling, and they're looking at
- 16:01doing that on the Moon, especially on the South
- 16:03Pole, let's say a pharmaceutical compound like
- 16:06we talked about with Project Helix, or a communication
- 16:09protocol, does not necessarily claim ownership
- 16:12of an asteroid or the Moon or any other orbital
- 16:15location. Nevertheless, an accumulation of exclusive
- 16:19rights over essential infrastructure could create
- 16:22a functional control that deserves policy scrutiny.
- 16:27Article 6 makes states internationally responsible
- 16:34for national space activities, including activities
- 16:37conducted by non -governmental entities. Those
- 16:40are the commercial entities. It requires authorization
- 16:43and continued supervision. For commercial projects,
- 16:46this means the private operator does not displace
- 16:49the state. Licensing and supervision remains
- 16:53important, and the company's conduct may have
- 16:56public international consequences. For instance,
- 16:59the satellites have been falling out of the sky
- 17:01every so often. Article 8 provides that the state
- 17:06on whose registry a space object is carried retains
- 17:09jurisdiction and control over that object and
- 17:12its personnel while in outer space or on a celestial
- 17:16body. This is a treaty hook that makes registration
- 17:20central to the IP discussion. I want to close
- 17:23on this point with a central tension. Patents
- 17:26depend on national legal authority, but outer
- 17:30space cannot be claimed as a national territory.
- 17:33The workable position is that jurisdiction over
- 17:37a registered object and recognition of rights
- 17:39and technology are not the same as sovereign
- 17:43over location through which the object travels.
- 17:50Oops, let me go back one here. I can make it
- 17:53go back. You lower this down and we'll go back
- 17:58one. All right good. So follow the spacecraft
- 18:07registration which we just talked about under
- 18:09article of eight. The state of registry retains
- 18:13jurisdiction control over the registered space
- 18:15object and the personnel on there. Registration
- 18:18there provides a legal anchor where ordinary
- 18:21territorial geographical is unavailable. It can
- 18:25affect licensing oversight and planning and access
- 18:29of evidence and potential reach of a national
- 18:31patent law. But I'd avoid saying that the registry
- 18:33automatically applies to law and every dispute.
- 18:37The law governing the patent assignment may come
- 18:39from an employment agreement or any other agreement
- 18:42they may have out there. The validity infringement
- 18:45of a national patent remains questionable outside
- 18:48of a national system. Data processed on Earth
- 18:52may be governed by the country where the processing
- 18:54occurs or by a contract. Government funding may
- 18:59create rights that follow the research, regardless
- 19:01of the station of registry. In Project Helix,
- 19:06Luxembourg registration is important for the
- 19:09station. It does not automatically determine
- 19:11where the U .S. universities own the researcher's
- 19:16inventions. whether the European sponsor receives
- 19:19an exclusive license or whether the Japanese
- 19:21equipment supplier owns improvements to its hardware.
- 19:26Registration also may change. Space objects can
- 19:30involve multiple launching states. Commercial
- 19:33arrangements may evolve. A well -drafted agreement
- 19:36should require disclosure of the registry, representations
- 19:39concerning the operator's authority, and notice
- 19:42of any proposed change. and a process for addressing
- 19:46the IP and regulatory consequences that may change.
- 19:57So with this void in the 1967 Space Treaty, individual
- 20:05countries have kind of stepped in and filled
- 20:07that void and said, as far as our spacecraft
- 20:10and our launching and what we do, We're going
- 20:13to make some laws about that. We can't enforce
- 20:16them against other people necessarily, but we're
- 20:19going to try to protect what is ours. So that
- 20:22is where section 105, which is one of the clearest
- 20:25examples of a national patent system extending
- 20:29beyond Earth. It generally provides an invention
- 20:32made, used, or sold in outer space in a space
- 20:36object or a component of any US jurisdiction
- 20:39or control. is treated as made, used, or sold
- 20:43within the United States for purposes of Title
- 20:4535. The exceptions are as important as the rules.
- 20:52The statute does not apply in the same way when
- 20:55an international agreement specifically provides
- 20:57otherwise and when the space object is carried
- 21:00on a registry of a foreign state under the registration
- 21:04convention. A foreign registered object can be
- 21:07treated as within the United States only if the
- 21:10international agreement between the U .S. and
- 21:12the state of registry specifically provide for
- 21:15that result. Let's say for our project Helix,
- 21:18the station is registered in Luxembourg. U .S.
- 21:21patent owner, therefore, should not assume that
- 21:23every act aboard the station will be determined
- 21:26to occur in the United States. Council would
- 21:29need to investigate the station's legal status,
- 21:32applicable international agreements, and where
- 21:35steps of any claimed method occur and whether
- 21:38relevant conduct also occurs in the United States
- 21:42through ground control, supply, or importation.
- 21:48The practical lesson I want to emphasize on this
- 21:50Section 105 is neither a universal space patent
- 21:53nor a complete enforcement solution. It's a jurisdictional
- 21:58bridge tied to the status of the space object
- 22:02patent drafting, biolink strategy, mission design,
- 22:05and registration analysis must be coordinated.
- 22:16The ISS model, which is the International Space
- 22:19Station, which is currently up there, I think
- 22:20it's going to be up there until the end of this
- 22:22decade, and then it's coming down. We may see
- 22:27some private space stations going up in its place.
- 22:31But when they put the ISS, of course, the ISS
- 22:34is the US and Russia. Half of it's US, half of
- 22:38it's Russia. It's useful because it kind of demonstrates
- 22:42how jurisdictional uncertainty can be reduced
- 22:44by assignment. In 1998, there was an intergovernmental
- 22:48agreement creating a layered system supported
- 22:51by agency memorandum and implementing arrangements.
- 22:55To address civil and criminal jurisdiction, operational
- 22:57responsibility, liability, and intellectual property.
- 23:01For purposes, Article 21 generally links activity
- 23:04on the flight element to the partner state of
- 23:07registry of that element. The model is often
- 23:10described as giving modules form of legal nationality.
- 23:13In other words, there's a Russian section and
- 23:15there's a US section. It does not transform the
- 23:19module into a sovereign territory, but it supplies
- 23:22a predictable rule for applying national IP law.
- 23:26The European elements include additional arrangements,
- 23:29reflecting ESA, which is the European Space Agency's
- 23:32multinational structure. It's a clever solution
- 23:36for a platform built by a limited group of governments
- 23:39through years of negotiation. It is less clear
- 23:42that the same structure will scale automatically
- 23:46to commercial stations, hosting dozens of private
- 23:50customers, leased modules, born payloads, autonomous
- 23:55systems, and cloud -based experiments. The transactional
- 24:00lesson I want to emphasize is not simply to copy
- 24:03the ISS model. It is to recognize that the ISS
- 24:07works because the partners negotiated jurisdictional
- 24:10rights and procedures before operations began.
- 24:14The commercial platform will need equally to
- 24:16deliberate to deliberate terms covering the governing
- 24:19legal environment, customer interventions, evidence
- 24:22access, and dispute resolution. So it's a good
- 24:25example, but You know, they really thought it
- 24:28through before they put the ISS up there. And
- 24:33it was basically two countries and then the European
- 24:36coming in after that. One mission, many jurisdictions.
- 24:42Let me walk you through what I think are seven
- 24:46locations on the slide. An inventive concept
- 24:50may originate in the United States. Components
- 24:52manufactured in Japan. The payload. launch came
- 24:57from New Zealand. The station is being licensed
- 25:00through Luxembourg. Ground commands may be transmitted
- 25:04from Canada and data processed through the EU
- 25:07and the United States. And the product may be
- 25:11sold worldwide. Each location can matter for
- 25:14a different reason. Manufacturing can create
- 25:16infringement or export control exposure. Launch
- 25:19and payload approvals affect the mission. Registry
- 25:24affects jurisdiction over the space object. Ground
- 25:27control may establish where method steps and
- 25:30performance and directed data processing affects
- 25:33trade secret, privacy, cybersecurity, and contractual
- 25:36rights. And commercial markets determine where
- 25:39patent protection and regulatory approval have
- 25:42economic value. I recommend the Patent Council
- 25:46and Mission Council work together. Patent claims
- 25:49should reflect where steps occur and who performs
- 25:53them. Buying decisions should account for the
- 25:56locations of competitors, manufacturers, control
- 25:59systems, and commercial markets. The method claim
- 26:03requiring a step performed only in orbit may
- 26:06present different enforcement challenges than
- 26:09apparatus system or software claims. The concise
- 26:12takeaway is the mission architecture, the IP
- 26:16strategy in the conventional country may be prepared
- 26:19without understanding the mission may protect
- 26:21the wrong conduct in the wrong place. Orbital
- 26:33flag of convenience. Now the flag of convenience
- 26:36is, you see this mainly in shipping with ships
- 26:41where they register the ship, what country, for
- 26:46flags of convenience. So company A owns a U .S.
- 26:48patent covering the propulsion control process.
- 26:52Company B installs similar equipment on an aircraft
- 26:55registered by a foreign state. The system remains
- 26:58dormant during manufacture and launch. The claim
- 27:01process only begins after the spacecraft reaches
- 27:04orbit and commands originate from several ground
- 27:07stations. Ask where the potential infringement
- 27:11for infringing has occurred. The U .S. patent
- 27:13is territorial, subject to specific statutory
- 27:16extensions and documents. Like Section 105, it
- 27:19may not directly, may not deem the activity aboard
- 27:22a foreign registered spacecraft to occur in the
- 27:25United States. But the analysis is not in there.
- 27:28Council should examine where the components were
- 27:30made and supplied, where software was loaded,
- 27:33and who directed the operation. Did it occur
- 27:37on U .S. soil? whether importation later occurs
- 27:40and whether inducement or contributory infringement
- 27:43theories are available. The flag of convenience
- 27:46concerns the operators may select a registration
- 27:49jurisdiction partly to reduce regulatory or IP
- 27:53exposure. The maritime analogy is imperfect but
- 27:57useful. Registry can become a commercial viable
- 28:00variable rather than a neutral administrative
- 28:03fact. For transactional counsel, address this
- 28:09risk through representation about registry covenants
- 28:13against charging it without consent, warranties
- 28:16regarding third -party rights, indemnities if
- 28:19needed, freedom to operate, analysis across the
- 28:22mission, and termination of repricing rights
- 28:24if the legal environment changes. For litigators,
- 28:28preserve evidence around the mission design and
- 28:31registry selection. Intent. may be relevant to
- 28:35certain remedies or related theories if it does
- 28:37not expand the territory or reach for the patent
- 28:40itself. And we have seen this. I mean, with launches
- 28:43from the Earth, you're closer to the moon, believe
- 28:47it or not, the nearer you are to the equator.
- 28:51So why do we have launch sites in South Texas
- 28:54here, Florida, Southern California? You also
- 28:58see launch sites being developed in like French
- 29:02Guiana in South America and other places closer
- 29:07to the equator. So if French Guiana doesn't have
- 29:12strong registry. requirements or export controls
- 29:15or anything else you could see maybe flags of
- 29:18convenience starting to move down there although
- 29:20their technology is is not as good as the space
- 29:23space centers are not easy to build on sites
- 29:25are not easy to build and it's not cheap to get
- 29:28a rocket moved down there they've tried a couple
- 29:31of those with the jungle and everything else
- 29:34going on it was very difficult to launch a spacecraft
- 29:36from that area at this time brazil has been trying
- 29:39to get more involved because of course they have
- 29:42a very large swath that the equator comes through
- 29:45Brazil. You cannot easily seize a satellite.
- 29:53What am I talking about here? On earth, patent
- 29:55litigation assumes that evidence, products, witnesses,
- 29:59assets can be reached. In orbit, the allegedly
- 30:03infringing system may remain physically inaccessible
- 30:06for years. Its operation may be visible only
- 30:09through telemetry controlled by the defendant.
- 30:12Software can be updated remotely, and the relevant
- 30:16configuration may disappear before discovery
- 30:18begins. Remedies create additional complications.
- 30:23An injunction that disables communications, navigation,
- 30:26or life support, or collision avoidance systems,
- 30:30it's a big deal with satellites right now because
- 30:31there's so many in low Earth orbit right now,
- 30:33may affect parties beyond the litigants. Interference
- 30:37with the active spacecraft could create safety
- 30:39risk and debris. Seizure is unlikely to be practical.
- 30:44Inspection may require costly mission resources
- 30:47and the cooperation of the platform operator
- 30:50and the state authorities. This doesn't mean
- 30:56that rights are meaningless. Courts may still
- 30:59award damages, each territorial assets restrain
- 31:03ground -based conduct, enforce contractual obligations,
- 31:07but arbitration may provide tailored procedures
- 31:09for platform operators can be required to preserve
- 31:12records or suspend the payload under certain
- 31:17conditions. The key is to design remedies that
- 31:20can be implemented safely in our earth wherever
- 31:22possible. I want to emphasize a drafting prospect
- 31:26to think about. I would advise council to not
- 31:30rely solely on the availability of ordinary litigation
- 31:33remedies. Contracts should create operational
- 31:37levers. Evidence rights, escrow or bond mechanisms,
- 31:41maybe insurance requirements, obligations that
- 31:44can survive the mission completion. The evidence
- 31:54is above the courthouse. A conventional audit
- 31:58clause often permits inspections of books or
- 32:01records at a party's place of business. This
- 32:05language is not enough for an experiment whose
- 32:09The size of evidence is on board a spacecraft
- 32:11or embedded in proprietary software up in a satellite.
- 32:15The agreement should identify what records will
- 32:18be generated and preserved. Telemetry, experiment
- 32:22logs, sensor outputs, software, communications,
- 32:26AI prompts and outputs, maybe chief and custody
- 32:30records, communication between the ground and
- 32:32the flight systems. Retention periods should
- 32:35reflect prosecution litigation timelines, not
- 32:38merely just the missions operations. I would
- 32:42define access, sorry, access carefully. Can council
- 32:47receive raw data or only summaries? Can an independent
- 32:52expert, can you bring in a third party to inspect
- 32:54a secure replica of the onboard system? Must
- 32:57the operator preserve a container, a biologic
- 33:00sample or some other storage? device to return
- 33:03it to Earth? Who pays for that retrieval? Can
- 33:06a party obtain emergency preservation if a dispute
- 33:10arises? What happens if cybersecurity or export
- 33:13control rules restrict disclosure? I also want
- 33:17to address authenticity. Timestamps, digital
- 33:20signatures, tamper evidence logs can establish
- 33:23what occurred and when. But for AI -based research,
- 33:27records should distinguish the model's output
- 33:29from human decisions that were adopted, modified,
- 33:32tested, and rejected. The key message I want
- 33:35to leave to you is that evidence architecture
- 33:37is part of the contract architecture. If access
- 33:41is not designated before the launch, the most
- 33:43important proof may be technology or legally
- 33:46unreachable. OK, now it gets even more prickly.
- 34:00We talked about how with space law, it's not
- 34:02very definitive. But who is the inventor when
- 34:05AI participates? Let me begin with a legal baseline,
- 34:09right? Under US law, only natural persons may
- 34:13be named as inventors. The USPTO's revised guidance
- 34:17issued in November 2025 states that the same
- 34:21inventorship standard applies to all inventions,
- 34:24whether or not AI was used. AI assistants are
- 34:27treated as tools. They are not named as inventors.
- 34:30There's a famous case over in Europe. Actually,
- 34:32I think it was Australia maybe that kind of upset
- 34:35that precedent. The answer does not make AI assistant
- 34:38inventions unpatentable. The relevant question
- 34:41remains whether one or more humans conceive the
- 34:44claim subject matter and satisfy the ordinary
- 34:47law of inventorship. The difficulty is factual.
- 34:51When AI system proposes as the structure changes
- 34:54the experiment or identifies useful results,
- 34:57what did the human contribute? Let's go back
- 35:02to Project Helix. The research team defined the
- 35:04therapeutic problem. An AI alerted temperature
- 35:08and crystallization conditions identified unexpected
- 35:10structures and proposed a new compound. A science
- 35:14recognized the results significance and modified
- 35:16the proposed compound and designated to a conforming
- 35:20experiment. or design a conforming experiment.
- 35:23Patent claims may reflect different contributions.
- 35:26Some may be supported by the scientist's conceptions.
- 35:28Others may present a more difficult record. I
- 35:32would not assume that the AI developer is an
- 35:35inventor merely because it created the tool and
- 35:38that the user is the inventor merely because
- 35:41it has entered the prompt. That doesn't necessarily
- 35:44get a pass muster either. Inventorship is claim
- 35:47specific and turns on contribution to conception.
- 35:50Ownership of AI training data and output are
- 35:53separate contractual questions. And of course,
- 35:56this is getting a lot of attention right now
- 35:59in the news because AI is developing faster than
- 36:02anticipated. And you're not sure of the consequences
- 36:06as that gets further and further out. Document
- 36:10the human contribution. I recommend the AI -assisted
- 36:14invention record. There is more detail about
- 36:18the conventional laboratory notebook. It should
- 36:20identify the human -defined problem, model and
- 36:23version used, and relevant training, and find
- 36:26tuning within the context of prompts and instructions
- 36:30to the AI model and human response about each
- 36:33output. I would record alternatives as well as
- 36:38successful tests. The scientist's selection,
- 36:42modification, and recognition of technology -significant
- 36:45results may be important to the inventorship
- 36:48analysis. Experimental validation may identify
- 36:52who designed the test, implemented the results,
- 36:55and connected them to the claim utility. The
- 36:59record should ultimately be mapped to the claims.
- 37:02A general statement that the team used AI is
- 37:05probably not enough. Pat and I would advise counsel
- 37:09to interview the researchers early, identify
- 37:11the concepts likely to appear in the claims,
- 37:15and determine which humans contributed to each
- 37:17of those claims. Correct inventorship is a legal
- 37:20requirement, and errors can create problems with
- 37:24prosecution, enforceability, ownership, and contractual
- 37:26problems, of course. I would balance the documentation
- 37:30with confidentiality and privilege, establish
- 37:33an internal process for secure records, controlled
- 37:36access, preservation, and legal review. An AI
- 37:39provider's terms should also be reviewed for
- 37:44the rights and prompts, outlogs, and confidential
- 37:47information. kind of what we've had to do with
- 37:49open source code when I first started working
- 37:53for a bank. The practical warning is to emphasize
- 37:58it's simple. Do not attempt to reconstruct inventorship
- 38:01months later. After publication, personal departures,
- 38:05model updates, and commercial success have changed
- 38:07the party's incentives and can cause much more
- 38:10difficulty. The patent is only one asset. Space
- 38:21projects generate an asset stack. The patentable
- 38:26invention may be only one layer. Other layers
- 38:29include flight software, AI models that we just
- 38:32talked about, training data, raw or process research
- 38:36data, telemetry, biological samples we talked
- 38:39about with the microgravity environment, new
- 38:41hardware designs based on how harsh space is
- 38:44and what can happen up there. Manufacturing know
- 38:47-how, of course. Negative results, regulatory
- 38:51data, and future improvements. Each asset may
- 38:54have a different owner and a different legal
- 38:56protection. Patent rights depend on inventorship
- 38:58and assignment. Software may be corrected by
- 39:01copyright, patent, or contract. Data ownership
- 39:04often depends primarily on the agreement rather
- 39:07than a general property rule. Trade secrets.
- 39:11remain reasonably secret measures, biological
- 39:14materials may be controlled through bailment,
- 39:17material transfer agreements, or regulatory obligations,
- 39:20depending who funded it. And of course, government
- 39:21-funded data may carry special rights and disclosure
- 39:24duties. For Project Helix, the sponsor may value
- 39:29exclusive access to the orbital data rather than
- 39:32the initial patent. The platform operator may
- 39:35claim rights to telemetry and aggregated operational
- 39:38data. The AI developer may seek the right to
- 39:41use interactions and improve a model. The university
- 39:45may need publication rights and continued research
- 39:48use of the data. These interests should be negotiated
- 39:51separately rather than collapse into one big
- 39:54single overall grant of all intellectual property.
- 39:59I would suggest each asset can be a barrier to
- 40:03entry. The answer may determine the license structure,
- 40:06evaluation, and diligence and enforcement strategy.
- 40:12As you can see, this compounds. It's a little
- 40:14more tricky as you move along. Let's talk about
- 40:18them. I give a quick brief on microbiology, and
- 40:21I think we're running OK on time, so I should
- 40:24be able to include some of this stuff. So let
- 40:26me explain science at a high level. Microgravity
- 40:28can reduce sedimentation and convection effects
- 40:31on crystallization. Protein crystals may form
- 40:35differently, and in some cases with different
- 40:38qualities, useful for structural analysis. Cells
- 40:42and tissues can behave differently in three -dimensional
- 40:45microgravity environments than in conventional
- 40:47two -dimension Earth -based cultures. These conditions
- 40:51may reveal biological pathways, target drugs,
- 40:54and material properties that are difficult to
- 40:57observe on Earth. The legal problem and importance
- 41:03follows the scarcity and reproducibility. If
- 41:07the relevant result depends on access to an orbital
- 41:10platform or experimental protocol, the return
- 41:15capability can become bottlenecks. A patent may
- 41:19protect the resulting compound or method, but
- 41:21access to the research environment can be equally
- 41:24important. So regulatory translation also matters.
- 41:28A discovery made in orbit must often be validated,
- 41:31reproduced, manufactured, and approved for use
- 41:33on Earth. Agreements can allocate responsibility
- 41:37for follow -up testing, regulatory submissions,
- 41:40or data integrity, or improvements that need
- 41:42to be made during terrestrial development. Let
- 41:44me return to Helix, our project Helix. Treatment
- 41:48is valuable not simply because it was discovered
- 41:51in space. But because microgravity produced the
- 41:54information unavailable through the parties existing
- 41:57on earth -based program that makes ownership
- 42:00access patentability licensing and benefit sharing
- 42:02that more consequential when it's done in space
- 42:06be able to reproduce that experiment and Possibly
- 42:10test it up there, too So one discovery seven
- 42:15claimants and we talked a little bit about these
- 42:19earlier So let's move to seven claimants. The
- 42:21individual scientist may be the inventor, but
- 42:25may have assignment rights through employment,
- 42:28like a university. The university may own employee
- 42:30inventions or may be obliged to report and elect
- 42:35title under government funding rules. Pharmaceutical
- 42:38sponsor may hold an option or an exclusive license.
- 42:42The funding agency may retain the license. reporting
- 42:45rights, and other statutory protections. The
- 42:48platform operator may own operational data and
- 42:52claim customer generated data under its terms.
- 42:55The AI developer may own the model and contractually
- 42:58regulate outputs. A foreign collaborator may
- 43:02have rights under some sort of joint research
- 43:04agreement or its own national employment law.
- 43:08I want to emphasize that inventorship and ownership
- 43:10are distinctive for us. I recommend a chain of
- 43:14title review before publication or patent filing.
- 43:17Obtain executed agreements from each potential
- 43:20inventor and reconcile inconsistent agreements.
- 43:24Confirm that the sponsor's license covers the
- 43:27field, territory, or verbal use. Determine whether
- 43:30the platform terms conflict with the sponsor
- 43:33research agreement. Review government and nonprofit
- 43:36obligations and address foreign law formalities
- 43:39that may appear. if the collaborators were employed
- 43:42outside of the United States. I also consider
- 43:47joint ownership possibly. In the United States,
- 43:50joint patent owners have significant independent
- 43:52rights, absence of agreement, while other jurisdictions
- 43:55treat co -ownership differently. A project should
- 43:59not drift into joint ownership by accident. Where
- 44:02possible, allocate ownership to one party or
- 44:05grant negotiated licenses rather than leaving
- 44:08prosecution and commercialization dependent on
- 44:10a fragmented group. So your terrestrial license
- 44:25needs an orbital upgrade. I like that. So let's
- 44:30start with the phrase worldwide license. On earth,
- 44:34parties often use it as a standard for all geographic
- 44:36markets, but does worldwide include low earth
- 44:40orbit, foreign registered spacecraft, the moon,
- 44:45a transfer vehicle or a commercial habitat that
- 44:48we may have on the moon soon? The answer is uncertain,
- 44:52though I would advise council not to rely on
- 44:55implications. I would define a licensed environment.
- 44:59Grant, the grant can cover Earth and outer space,
- 45:02specific orbits, registered space objects, hosted
- 45:05payload, commercial stations, lunar facilities.
- 45:09I mean, things that may not be there yet, but
- 45:11may be there if this is a 10 -year agreement
- 45:13that could be there within the next 10 years.
- 45:16Move it out to celestial bodies, because we're
- 45:18looking at asteroids and other things to possibly
- 45:20land on. Maybe someday the moon, if SpaceX gets
- 45:24what they want to do, they want to be able to
- 45:28develop rocket fuel on the moon with the water
- 45:31that may be down there and methane that may be
- 45:33down at the south pole of the moon. And to shoot
- 45:36a rocket from the moon, the moon's gravity, I
- 45:41think, is one sixth that of the world, of the
- 45:45Earth. So it wouldn't take as much fuel to shoot
- 45:49a rocket toward the moon because the gravity
- 45:53is much less on the moon. And you're actually,
- 45:55depending on what phase the moon is in, could
- 45:58be closer to Mars when they launch it. And of
- 46:00course, there are so many people working on so
- 46:02many different things. I just read an article
- 46:04about someone looking at nuclear energy, like
- 46:07they do for submarines. Would you be able to
- 46:10put nuclear engines on spacecraft where they
- 46:15wouldn't have to worry about running out of fuel?
- 46:19So very interesting stuff going on. So how would
- 46:23you define the licensing agreement? Of course,
- 46:25I would separately think about territory for
- 46:28field of use. So a pharmaceutical license may
- 46:30cover terrestrial human therapeutics that reserve
- 46:34space flight health applications. A satellite
- 46:37license may cover ground -based manufacture,
- 46:40but not autonomous use aboard another operator's
- 46:43constellation. A research license may permit
- 46:46experiments in orbit without getting commercial
- 46:48manufacturing rights. I address sub -licensing
- 46:52through mission parameters and platform operators.
- 46:55The licensee may need to allow contractors, launch
- 46:58providers, payloading integrators, astronauts,
- 47:02group station operators, and other regulators
- 47:05insurers to use the technology. These parties
- 47:08should be defined bound by confidentiality and
- 47:10limited to the mission protocol and purposes.
- 47:14A drafting rule I think would be identify where,
- 47:17by whom, and for what mission using which assets
- 47:21under which registry the licensed technology
- 47:24may be practiced. So 12 clauses that should survive
- 47:35the launch, right? The contract, the agreement
- 47:37isn't just for the launch for the spaceship to
- 47:40come up and for it to come back down. It's probably
- 47:43going to extend longer because you're moving
- 47:46payload. Let's say there is a space station up
- 47:48there now. moving payload up to the space station,
- 47:51but it may take them years until they use whatever
- 47:55was brought up there and develop a cure for cancer,
- 47:58let's say, or whatever they're going to develop
- 48:00up there. So I'm going to present a 12 launch
- 48:04readiness questions rather than 12 boilerplate
- 48:07language. First, choice of law and form. Identify
- 48:12the law governing the contract. Form for disputes
- 48:15and any issues reserved for the national patent
- 48:17officer courts. Consider arbitration, emergency
- 48:20relief, conjunctions, and enforcement against
- 48:24terrestrial assets. Second, spacecraft registration.
- 48:30Identify the current state of registry. This
- 48:33requires a license. Like in the US, you have
- 48:34to have a license. You have to have a launch
- 48:36license. You also have to have a payload license.
- 48:38Require notice and consent for changes. They
- 48:42allocate the consequences of a change in jurisdiction,
- 48:46which is what we talked about the flags of convenience
- 48:48issue. Third and fourth, background and foreground
- 48:51IP. List pre -existing technology, data, materials,
- 48:55and software know -how. Define what counts as
- 48:58project results and who owns them. Avoid circular
- 49:02definitions that treat every important development
- 49:06as both background and foreground. Fifth, AI
- 49:10-assisted inventorship require disclosure of
- 49:12the AI systems, preservation of the model, and
- 49:15prompt records, human contribution documentation,
- 49:19cooperation with inventorship determinations,
- 49:21and compliance with current patent office guidance.
- 49:25Six, data and telemetry rights. Distinguish raw
- 49:29data, processed data, operational telemetry,
- 49:32proprietary data, personal and regulatory, and
- 49:37aggregated platform data. A lot of different
- 49:39types of data up there. State who can access,
- 49:42use, publish, license, and retain such data.
- 49:46Seventh, patent prosecution. Allocating filing
- 49:50disclosures and decisions. Watch countries, claim
- 49:54strategy, control, cost, and better cooperation,
- 49:57abandonment rights, and enforcement. Include
- 50:00consultation rights where one party controls
- 50:03what the other bears commercial risk. Eight,
- 50:07improvements, defined improvements to the platform
- 50:09technology. Payload, AI models, compounds, processes,
- 50:13or mission methods. Decide whether ownership
- 50:15follows the improvider or the whoever owns the
- 50:20underlying asset and the negotiated field allocation.
- 50:24Nine, audit and evidence preservation, specific
- 50:27logs, telemetry included, software, samples,
- 50:30retention, independent expert access, and emergency
- 50:33preservation. 10th, export controls and sanctions.
- 50:37This is getting big now with kind of the space
- 50:40races now between the United States and China
- 50:42with the European Union, of course, right in
- 50:45there too. So allocate classification, licensing,
- 50:49foreign person access, any data transfer and
- 50:52use of compliance responsibility. So export controls
- 50:54are a big ITAR is another one of the big controls
- 50:57you have to watch. Orbital collaboration does
- 51:00not eliminate earth -based technology transfer
- 51:02restrictions. Seventh, emergency relief. Define
- 51:06what remedies are operationally safe. Consider
- 51:09suspension of ground commands, preservation of
- 51:12data, escrow, expedited expert or arbitrary decisions
- 51:16rather than unrealistic seizure of a satellite
- 51:19spacecraft or let's say space habitat on the
- 51:24moon. Mission failure, termination, de -orbiting.
- 51:28Address launch delay, loss of payload. Partial
- 51:33performance, data recovery, surviving IP rights,
- 51:35return or destruction of materials, insurance
- 51:38proceeds, and rights of replacement missions.
- 51:41As we've seen with the down here in Boca Chica,
- 51:45the Starship, which is going to be like a Mack
- 51:47truck moving things into space is had several
- 51:52aborted or missions that had to be blown up.
- 51:56They're just now kind of getting, I think the
- 51:58next one they want to send the Starship into
- 52:00orbit. And it's going to be kind of the main
- 52:03spaceship going forward. It's going to be huge
- 52:05and be able to take huge payloads up there and
- 52:07reduce the cost of taking payloads into space.
- 52:11SpaceX has done a really good job with the Falcon
- 52:13rockets out of Cape Canaveral. They've been able
- 52:17to fire those. I think they're doing two or three
- 52:19a week sending rockets up. But they're much smaller,
- 52:23the payloads. The Starship is much bigger. I
- 52:25think it has 23 engines underneath it. of the
- 52:28Saturn engines. So you can imagine firing 23.
- 52:32I've been within like 20 miles when it lifted
- 52:35off one time and it just shakes the ground and
- 52:38the sound is just amazing. I wish I could get
- 52:40closer. Maybe I can do that later on. So it's
- 52:44kind of an exciting field. All right. Winding
- 52:49down now. Heading into the home stretch. uh possible
- 52:55futures i see for space ip and of course it's
- 52:59still in its infancy it's it's growing the first
- 53:01model extends to national law through registration
- 53:04it's the most incremental each state applies
- 53:08its ip law to registered space objects supported
- 53:11by statutes such as section 105 in international
- 53:14agreements the advantage is familiarity the weakness
- 53:18is fragmentation inconsistent coverage and incentives
- 53:21for regulatory arbitrage And of course, if the
- 53:24Chinese are the other side, their IP system is
- 53:27definitely different than ours, the way they
- 53:30think about it and how they protect their IP.
- 53:33The second model is international or supranational
- 53:36space patent. A single filing could protect defined
- 53:41off -world uses across participating states and
- 53:44registered objects. This could reduce duplicative
- 53:47filings. And we require agreement on patentability
- 53:50standards, scope, ownership, enforcement, remedies,
- 53:53and treatment of non -participating states. As
- 53:55we talked about, you would not necessarily get
- 53:58China or Russia to agree to something like this.
- 54:01But you might, if you know anything about the
- 54:04Artemis Accords, that's the NASA's accords. I
- 54:07think we're up to 35 countries, maybe more. Every
- 54:13week or two, we get another country that becomes
- 54:14part of the Artemis Accords. So you might be
- 54:17able to get something put through them to agree
- 54:23to ownership if you're part of the Artemis Accords.
- 54:26And they are on the missions. The next Artemis
- 54:30mission will, I think, circle the moon a few
- 54:34times, maybe put a suborbital or lunar orbital
- 54:38system in place. And then, of course, the one
- 54:40after that will actually put people landing on
- 54:42the moon. I think mainly in South Pole and then
- 54:45with a visual, eventually they want to establish
- 54:47a colony there. So the third would be an IP registry
- 54:52or specialized dispute resolution authority,
- 54:55such as the WIPO, the World Intellectual Property
- 54:58Organization, UNASCO, which is the Peaceful Use
- 55:02of Outer Space through the UN, some sort of partnership
- 55:06or similar institution that records space origination
- 55:09inventions. establish priority evidence and publish
- 55:12model terms, facilitate licensing, and offer
- 55:15arbitration to technical panels. It could supplement
- 55:17rather than replace the national systems. Then
- 55:20I think the WIPO is working on this. I was there
- 55:22last year in Geneva to present a paper and they
- 55:26were talking about putting together, they wouldn't
- 55:29be the patent office. They're not going to circumvent
- 55:32the sovereign patent offices are out there, but
- 55:35they would be able to do more on an international
- 55:38scale. And the fourth model, of course, is where
- 55:42regulations are not there, is to fill those with
- 55:46contractual and industry governance models, platform
- 55:50rules, model agreements, interoperability standards.
- 55:54The likely future is layered in incremental modeling.
- 55:57National statutes and contracts will continue
- 56:00to do the most of the immediate work. Registries,
- 56:04specialized arbitration, and soft law principles
- 56:07and multilateral agreements may gradually reduce
- 56:10the largest gaps. The governance objective should
- 56:14be clarity without freezing innovation. We want
- 56:17to keep that moving forward. And we don't want
- 56:20to build a super rigid system just built around
- 56:23today's technology when we know things are changing
- 56:25very quickly. So let me just think of five rules
- 56:35of the road. space economy lawyer, which that's
- 56:39going to be a thing coming up. And it already
- 56:42is. Map the mission before choosing the law.
- 56:45Identify a reactor, asset, location, data flow,
- 56:49funding source, and operational step. Do not
- 56:51begin with the assumption that headquarters or
- 56:53launch site controls everything. Guidance number
- 56:56two, treat spacecraft registration as an IP issue.
- 57:00Registry can affect jurisdiction, statutory reach,
- 57:04and evidence access and enforcement require disclosure
- 57:07and address changes contractually. Rule three,
- 57:11document human contribution wherever AI is involved.
- 57:16Inventorship remains a human claim specific inquiry
- 57:19under US law. Observe the facts beyond personal
- 57:23models and memories do change. Rule four, contract
- 57:27the evidence access before launch. Telemetry
- 57:31logs, samples, software, and AI records may otherwise
- 57:34remain outside the practical reach of courts
- 57:36and council. And five, allocate ownership, data
- 57:39rights, improvements before the inventions exist.
- 57:43Once a breakthrough occurs, very ambiguous clauses
- 57:47become valuable and every participant's position
- 57:50hardens. Oops. Well, I see I'm almost out of
- 58:00time. So we'll end there. As you can see, space
- 58:02is kind of a new area, very interesting area,
- 58:05and there's going to be a lot of people working
- 58:08in this. I mean, I completed my LLM at University
- 58:14of Mississippi. They've got a LLM program in
- 58:16air and space law. It's all online, so it's very
- 58:19convenient. But a lot of my colleagues that I
- 58:21work with on different projects and different
- 58:23papers are also working on space law. Some on
- 58:29natural resources, who's going to own the minerals
- 58:32when we take it out of the moon. The human condition,
- 58:35I know people who are MDs who are looking at
- 58:38what does space flight do to the human body.
- 58:41Some people are looking at tourism because Blue
- 58:43Origin wants to put hotels up in the space station.
- 58:46So very interesting area. I hope that kind of
- 58:50helped kind of explain a little bit about what
- 58:52issues are affecting IP. these will all evolve.
- 58:56So thank you for your attention, and I appreciate
- 58:59everyone participating. And hopefully I see you
- 59:02out there. I am on LinkedIn. If you want to reach
- 59:04out to Ed Kolmer, my last name is spelled K -O
- 59:07-E -L -L -N -E -R. I am on LinkedIn. So if you
- 59:10want to send me an invite, I'd be more than happy
- 59:13to accept that. Thank you very much. I think
- 59:16I'm concluded. Is there anybody that else? I
- 59:18don't know if I can hear questions or not, or
- 59:21if you can send them through the chats. Let me
- 59:23see. I see some in the chat, let me see here.
- 59:30It talks about how you will receive your CLA,
- 59:34your materials. So I see all that in the chat.
- 59:37Okay, more here. Q &A, okay, I've got one here.
- 59:43My mind is blown. Nancy, thank you so much. Because
- 59:46when I first started doing this a couple of years
- 59:48ago, I was the same way. I grew up in the, I'm
- 59:52a child of the 60s, so. I remember John Glenn.
- 59:55I remember Neil Armstrong. I grew up in Ohio.
- 59:57So those guys would come to our high school and
- 59:59speak. And I had a lunchbox with Gemini or Apollo
- 1:00:04lunchbox. I can't remember. And then for years,
- 1:00:06it kind of languished, right? After we got to
- 1:00:08the moon in 69, we didn't do a whole lot after
- 1:00:10that. A couple missions up there with moon buggies,
- 1:00:12but we really didn't do. To 2015, when commercial
- 1:00:16entities started coming into it, all of a sudden,
- 1:00:19boom, it's exploding again. great area for you're
- 1:00:22looking for something to kind of dabble in. So
- 1:00:25thank you much for all your attention. And again,
- 1:00:30I look forward to seeing you on LinkedIn or somewhere
- 1:00:32else down the road. Thank you so much.