Latest / Engineering Influence from ACEC / The Market Edge – Designing for Resilience
Transcript
- 0:04Hello, and welcome back to the Market Edge podcast series created by Market
- 0:09Intelligence Committee members here at ACEC National that feature industry experts
- 0:14who address the most pressing issues to members today with a focus on market trends.
- 0:18This series is brought to you by the Engineering Influence Podcast with the
- 0:21American Council of Engineering Companies. My name is Diane O'Leary,
- 0:24and I will be your host today.
- 0:26Today's conversation brings together federal disaster policy and on-the-ground
- 0:30environmental engineering.
- 0:32Our guest spent years inside FEMA navigating the realities of hazard mitigation
- 0:36and disaster recovery, and now applies that experience to helping communities
- 0:39plant smarter, build safer, and adapt to climate change.
- 0:42This episode digs into the rising risks shaping where people live,
- 0:47how we build, and what it will take to fund resilience in an era of escalating natural hazards.
- 0:51So please join me in welcoming Shannon Riley.
- 0:55Thanks, Diana. So happy to be here today. Really excited for our conversation.
- 0:59Thank you so much for joining.
- 1:00So let's get to know a little bit about Jana. And so she is a resilience and
- 1:04climate adaptation business line manager for engineering firm and member Fawcett O'Neill.
- 1:09She helps communities across Northeast plan for and adapt to natural hazards.
- 1:14She previously worked on pre and post disaster hazard risk reduction at FEMA,
- 1:19as we mentioned before, serving as the hazard mitigation assistance policy branch
- 1:23chief. if that's a mouthful, and the Senior Climate Advisor for other grant programs.
- 1:27During this time, she represented FEMA on the White House Working Group for
- 1:31Nature-Based Solutions and the U.S.
- 1:33Coral Reef Task Force, guiding investments in nature-based solutions for risk reduction.
- 1:38She's also been deployed several times to disaster sites as a benefit-cost analysis
- 1:43and hazard mitigation subject matter expert,
- 1:46and worked as a staffer of the Senate Commerce Committee, guiding National Ocean
- 1:51and Coastal Policy for the Subcommittee on Oceans, Atmosphere,
- 1:54Fisheries, and Coast Guard.
- 1:55She received her PM in Environmental Studies from Connecticut College and her
- 1:59MS in Marine Resource Management on Climate Change and Coastal Hazards from
- 2:03Oregon State University. Oh my goodness, very impressive. So, yeah.
- 2:08I know when we first spoke, we had a very full conversation.
- 2:12So, I'm just going to get right into these member-specific questions. Great from ECEC.
- 2:18So first, let's jump in. Disasters are inherently bipartisan.
- 2:22Thank goodness everyone's affected. So can you tell us about what creative financing
- 2:26or cross-sector partnerships do you think hold the most promise for building
- 2:31resilience in this politically divided environment that we find ourselves in?
- 2:36Yeah, great question. Well, like you said, we know that disasters affect people
- 2:40and communities and those impacts last a long time.
- 2:43And so, you know, they're becoming so common that we really have to think differently
- 2:47about the way that we help people through those disasters.
- 2:50So I'd really love to see, and we're already seeing more partnerships between
- 2:55academia and researchers and the disaster response community,
- 2:59which I think is a really great opportunity.
- 3:01You know, there's a lot of great research that we see get lost in academia.
- 3:04And I think if we had better pathways to, you know, bring those communities
- 3:08together and help support disaster risk reduction and longer term resilience
- 3:13with students, with professors, with other members of that community,
- 3:17that would be really positive.
- 3:18And it would allow for more of those solutions to be implemented and scaled,
- 3:22and the public would really benefit.
- 3:24And I think that also would lead to some really great innovation and advancements
- 3:29for our engineering and planning communities about what we can actually do with
- 3:33communities who are in that space.
- 3:34And then the other side, of course, is the private sector, right?
- 3:37We're hearing a lot about how can the private sector get more involved or how
- 3:40can we look at those creative funding opportunities with reinsurance,
- 3:44with bonds, with all different kinds of opportunities.
- 3:47And I really hope that we see a shift with more involvement from that private
- 3:50sector. You know, we see a lot of benefit to the private sector from all the
- 3:54public investments in our infrastructure, in those hazard mitigation measures and overall recovery.
- 4:00But often the private sector isn't on the hook for any of that benefit.
- 4:04So I think, you know, thinking about the ways that we can get more involved
- 4:07with local communities, because we're members of our communities,
- 4:10too, right? Those of us who are in the private sector, those companies are in
- 4:14a location, they're in a community, their workers work there.
- 4:17And if, you know, our roads are flooded and we can't get to work or we can't
- 4:20get our health care, that has a huge impact.
- 4:22So I think it would be really great to see, you know, leaders at all levels
- 4:26really communicate and share stories of the importance of federal funding for disaster recovery.
- 4:32You know, getting involved in projects, encouraging volunteering or creative
- 4:36ways to participate and then really advocating for continued opportunities for
- 4:40that funding. and ways for the private sector to potentially help step in to
- 4:44fill some of those capacity gaps.
- 4:46So you brought up two really great points, and we're going to get into those
- 4:49a bit later in the community side as well as the private side.
- 4:53But you've seen disaster response and recovery from within. So where do you
- 4:57think the biggest gas still exists in these programs?
- 5:01And how can engineering firms help close those gaps?
- 5:04Yeah, I think there's really two key things and they probably aren't a surprise.
- 5:08It's money and capacity.
- 5:10So they're especially for, you know, our local communities, our rural communities,
- 5:14our most disadvantaged or in need communities.
- 5:16It is so hard for them to navigate these complex processes when they often are
- 5:23wearing multiple hats at their local community level.
- 5:26So I think and often what we see is those any of those communities that have
- 5:31less capacity are often really focused just on the response piece for disasters,
- 5:36but not that long term recovery, which which really is long.
- 5:41And so I think that our engineering and planning firms around the country can
- 5:45really be helpful within that space, advocating or encouraging.
- 5:50Filling that capacity gap to really think about that long-term picture and either,
- 5:55when possible, setting up for success about where we can take advantage of those
- 6:00long-term opportunities when disaster does strike.
- 6:03And then really thinking about
- 6:05what's needed long term, where can you get the most bang for your buck?
- 6:09Does it make sense to try to incorporate things like hazard mitigation and codes
- 6:12and standards upgrades and improvements in that recovery rebuilding?
- 6:16And most communities do not have that expertise in-house. They really need that
- 6:20from our engineering and our planning and our larger community here.
- 6:24And I think if we can be advocates for that and if we can help.
- 6:28Learn about the complexities of some of these processes and then really be able
- 6:32to step in and say like, hey, I've seen this work in other places.
- 6:35I think this type of project, this type of resiliency, this type of infrastructure
- 6:39strengthening would work really well here and really be a guide in some of that process.
- 6:45First one you mentioned there was funding. So for hazard mitigation,
- 6:49I understand this is kind of always a bit of a sticky spot.
- 6:52So what practical steps could states take to expand their access to these federal
- 6:56dollars to really create more opportunities for proactive risk reduction investments?
- 7:02Yeah, so I think on the planning side, definitely having states continue to
- 7:06encourage and provide funding if they can for updating hazard mitigation plans,
- 7:11which are still a requirement for accessing FEMA hazard mitigation funding.
- 7:15I think states can really help support, you know, the development of those local
- 7:18hazard mitigation plans, but also really think about how to make them more implementable.
- 7:23You know, we want to encourage local communities to be working across sectors,
- 7:26like not just with an emergency management community, but with other community
- 7:30partners, with other state agencies or local partners, and then thinking about
- 7:35multiple hazards, right?
- 7:36We're in a space where we're experiencing all different kinds of hazards in
- 7:39places where maybe we haven't historically before, like wildfire, extreme temperatures.
- 7:44And so identifying, you know, not only the hazards they've experienced,
- 7:47but additional hazards, and then really thinking about that full list of projects,
- 7:51you know, what's vulnerable, what needs to be updated, what...
- 7:55What's, you know, getting flooded or getting impacted already,
- 7:58and then thinking about what might in the future.
- 8:00And also thinking about like, what makes your community your community.
- 8:05So I think sometimes we get really hung up on like the physical stuff, right?
- 8:09Our infrastructure, our roads, our bridges, our buildings, but there could be
- 8:13other aspects of hazard mitigation funding that can support capacity building,
- 8:18can support natural infrastructure, can support the intersection of a lot of those components.
- 8:23And then, you know, I think the other thing that would be that's great,
- 8:26and we are seeing some states being able to do this, is with limited funding
- 8:30right now at the federal level, proactively looking for ways to continue whatever's out there already.
- 8:36So there's a lot of great, you know, scoping and design and planning projects that are underway.
- 8:41And so if states can help provide the funding and support, you know,
- 8:46maybe it's technical support, maybe it's grant management support,
- 8:48maybe it's financial support, to at least continue those pieces so we don't lose that momentum.
- 8:53And then when hopefully we get back to a point where there is these large grants
- 8:58or large federal dollars available, we have projects ready to go.
- 9:02And historically, that's been a huge problem. Like we have a disaster and they're
- 9:07just folks aren't ready to identify the projects that need help.
- 9:10They don't have an engineering firm. They don't have the plans,
- 9:13they don't have the designs.
- 9:14And so we end up, you know, in some cases, losing some of that opportunity when funding is available.
- 9:20So you touched on this from a state aspect, but what about community specific?
- 9:25Can you drill down a little further? Because we understand these cycles can
- 9:29be very unpredictable. Are there certain strategies that communities can use
- 9:33to plan long term in this uncertainty?
- 9:36Yeah, I think one of the things communities can think about is think about that wish list, right?
- 9:42I think what I've seen in my experience, which, you know, isn't what might be
- 9:47true everywhere, but I've seen a lot of the time communities waiting until there's
- 9:52a grant opportunity or a funding opportunity to come up with a project.
- 9:55And so I think having more communities, you know, think big picture about like,
- 10:00what's their capital improvement plan?
- 10:02What's their, what's their, what are their pain points?
- 10:05What's that, you know, bucket list of projects that they would like to see support on?
- 10:09And again, that's an area where I think the engineering and planning community
- 10:12can also really support, you know, can we help do that matchmaking for when
- 10:17funding is available rather than waiting until funding is there at the table?
- 10:21Because oftentimes that's too late, right? Like once the NOFO comes out or once
- 10:25that request for proposals comes out, a lot of the time there's pre-work that we have to do first.
- 10:30And I think that can be a really good partnership between, you know,
- 10:32communities, the private sector, the NGO community, hopefully with that state,
- 10:39you know, state and local support.
- 10:41Great answer. Great feedback there. So I'm going to transition us and pivot
- 10:45a little bit more about kind of the COVID-driven migration to the Sunbelt states and other places.
- 10:52How do you interpret people moving into what is termed these higher risk areas,
- 10:57especially in these coastal zones, even as we've got an increase in climate-related
- 11:02disasters and really the effects are intensifying?
- 11:05What does this mean for the long-term community resilience?
- 11:10Yeah, something I think that keeps many of us up at night when we're thinking
- 11:14about, you know, hazard risk reduction nationally and even internationally.
- 11:18So you're absolutely right. We've actually seen the trend of people moving to
- 11:21coastal areas even before COVID.
- 11:23So for a long time, we have, I think last I saw, over 40% of our population
- 11:27living in these coastal areas, which are inherently, you know,
- 11:30at higher risk of flooding, of coastal storms, of sea level rise.
- 11:34And I think it's part of human nature to have that optimism that like bad things
- 11:39won't happen to us, which is wonderful.
- 11:42It's a wonderful part of our society. But I think sometimes it leads to,
- 11:45you know, lack of risk consideration, right?
- 11:49Or not even knowing or exploring what you might need to think about when you
- 11:53move to a different area or different that may have different hazards than what
- 11:57you've either personally experienced or what you even know about.
- 12:00And so I think we, you know, we really need to think about the intersection
- 12:05between our, you know, development requirements, code requirements,
- 12:08and consider how to make natural hazard risks more transparent in our society. You know, I think,
- 12:14it's unfair to have that burden be on an individual or on the public.
- 12:18I think we can really find ways to still encourage development,
- 12:22still encourage, you know, growth and support the changes that we're seeing
- 12:26in these migration patterns without just continuing to add to the risk.
- 12:30Because that's a risk for all of our taxpayers too, right? That's a risk to
- 12:34our communities. That's a risk to our companies.
- 12:35That's a risk to our society because we are continuing to get these expenses
- 12:39without clear ways to manage them.
- 12:42And, you know, again, there's this disconnect, because I think people don't
- 12:45want to be told, right, you can't build a house there, or you can't have a seawall
- 12:48there, or you have to, you know, build this house, this more expensive house
- 12:53to a higher code and standard.
- 12:55But we know that return on investment really works for mitigation,
- 12:58or for codes and standards, you know, we know how to design for a lot of these hazards.
- 13:04And when we do it, it saves money in the long run. So I think also seeing like
- 13:08the business community, more state, local leaders advocating for that return
- 13:12on investment that we know and like helping people do some of that math.
- 13:16Like, hey, we know it's more expensive now, but we also know that for every
- 13:20$6, for every dollar invested in mitigation, we save $6 later.
- 13:25So like, that's a great return. We would all be making those investments if
- 13:29that was coming back to our bank account.
- 13:31And I think just putting that topic more present in people's minds would be
- 13:35really helpful and hopefully help ease some of that sticker shock up front about
- 13:40what some of these mitigation measures or different development patterns or
- 13:44more stringent codes and standards might look like.
- 13:47So, Janet, I've got a bit of an off-the-cuff question, and I hope you don't
- 13:51hold it against me, but I hope I didn't.
- 13:54I'm looking for hotspots. So our members want to know, are there any opportunities
- 13:59for them within the market that they don't know about?
- 14:02They're telling me there's RFEs out there, there's funding out there,
- 14:05especially in these coastal states for these resilience projects.
- 14:08But are there any other areas in particular that are trending right now?
- 14:12I think the other big one that we're seeing is heat and wildfire, right?
- 14:16So those are definitely emerging hazards. I think we're all hearing about them and seeing them.
- 14:21And that's where I think, again, some of that research community hasn't caught
- 14:25up with best practices or data sets that we can use nationally.
- 14:29That was certainly true at FEMA. Like for some of our tools and analyses,
- 14:33we were struggling to have the type of data and especially nationally available
- 14:38information that we need.
- 14:40And I think that is like absolutely at our forefront of need.
- 14:43So we're seeing more and more, you know, RFPs for studies about heat resilience.
- 14:48I think we're going to see more and more about how to how to navigate it,
- 14:51right, how to adapt, how to, you know, increase our infrastructure resilience,
- 14:54how to design infrastructure for high heat.
- 14:57You know, we've seen a lot of that coming out of the Southwest,
- 14:59but we're also seeing that happen in places that, again, historically haven't been very hot.
- 15:04So the Pacific Northwest, the Northeast, parts of the Midwest.
- 15:07So I think that's a really good place to think about as well.
- 15:10And to think about how heat impacts, heat and drought and wildfire can potentially
- 15:16impact other sectors of our community, right, that we might not be thinking about.
- 15:20So even if there's funding that's not resilience focused.
- 15:24I think thinking about these other hazards and incorporating those into other
- 15:27projects and other funding sources can also be a really good way to access funds,
- 15:32explore new markets and really help clients and communities deal with,
- 15:35you know, our current changing climate.
- 15:38Great feedback. So I'm going to loop us back around to the beginning where we
- 15:41were talking about the private side.
- 15:43There's this growing tension between real estate development and the need for
- 15:47transparent risk disclosures on these private properties.
- 15:50So how should states balance the benefits of economic growth with honest communication
- 15:54about natural hazard exposure, for example? Yeah, it's a real challenge.
- 15:59Again, of course, we want to have development and growth, and local communities
- 16:04need a robust tax base to pay for those community needs and services.
- 16:08So there's definitely that tension exactly as you described it.
- 16:11But in many cases, there is no requirement to disclose hazard risks,
- 16:16even if properties were flooded previously or were impacted by a hazard previously.
- 16:22And I was thinking about this because we have this ability for cars, right?
- 16:26You can look up the VIN and find out, you know, accident data,
- 16:30service history, type of use, ownership history.
- 16:33So why would we have that for cars and not the biggest purchase that often any
- 16:38of us will make, right? Our home.
- 16:40And so I think that's just a good perspective to think about,
- 16:43like, it shouldn't be a extra thing. It shouldn't be a special thing.
- 16:47It should just be commonplace in the same way we do an inspection of our home.
- 16:51We should know about, you know, the neighborhood. We want to look up the safety.
- 16:55We want to look up the walkability.
- 16:57And I think we were moving in a really great direction when,
- 16:59you know, Zillow and some of the other home sites had that some climate risk
- 17:03data available right on those websites.
- 17:06I know that's recently come off and I hope that we'll, you know,
- 17:10maybe see a continued support for that type of information.
- 17:14Because again, I don't, I think it's unfair to put that burden on the individual,
- 17:17on the homeowner, on residents to have to seek that information out.
- 17:22I think making it available, letting people then decide what they want to do
- 17:26about it or what they want to know about it is a much...
- 17:29Better situation to be in. And I think that's where I would love to see,
- 17:33again, states and, you know, state and local advocacy for trying to make that more transparent.
- 17:37And then on the flip side, maybe to deal with the concerns of like certain homeowners
- 17:42not being able to sell their home or areas with higher risk,
- 17:45really struggling to have any opportunities.
- 17:47I think that's a really great place to look at state policies,
- 17:51local policies, and hopefully eventually federal policies that,
- 17:54you know, expand our buyout programs, right?
- 17:56So if you have areas that are high risk, People don't want to have that data
- 18:01available because they know that their homes won't sell.
- 18:04But if we know that those homes are at risk, have flooded before,
- 18:07let's get them out of the landscape. Let's reduce that risk.
- 18:12Let's add in green space.
- 18:13Let's build in more hazard mitigation. And I think there's some states and local
- 18:17areas that are starting to do that, starting to have robust buyout programs.
- 18:21And I really hope we'll see more of that because I think that's a great way
- 18:24to try to reduce some of that inherent constant risk that we're experiencing.
- 18:29It's really interesting what you said about that information coming off of Zillow,
- 18:33because we actually recently used that in one of our market intelligence reports
- 18:36is the score that they're giving.
- 18:38Yeah. The houses and zip codes based on climate exposure and risk.
- 18:42I didn't know it had come off, so that'll turn some heads there.
- 18:47Yeah. I'm planning on interviewing someone from Zonda Homes,
- 18:50I believe, here next month. So I have to bring up that question as well to see
- 18:53what their feedback is. Yeah.
- 18:55I think we've got time for one more quick question. Great. It's kind of a bigger one.
- 19:00Let's look forward looking a little bit. So, you know, the natural disasters
- 19:04are only increasing from land use to infrastructure choices.
- 19:07You know, we're kind of making an impact there.
- 19:09How do you see the relationship between human impact and hazard severity evolving over the next decade?
- 19:16And just to close out, any other trends or tidbits our members should be aware of?
- 19:21Yeah, I think you really hit it, you know, the nail on the head earlier when
- 19:24we said like we really need to tip the scale to be more preventative.
- 19:28I think right now we've, and especially related to disasters and climate adaptation,
- 19:33we've really been responsive.
- 19:34So we are only making those big investments after something tragic and terrible happens.
- 19:41And that is costing us more and more money. And it's not all about money, right?
- 19:46So that often, that also is leading to a lot of human suffering, right?
- 19:49The closing of small businesses, people losing their homes, you know,
- 19:53companies going out of business. So thinking about ways that we can advocate
- 19:58for more preventative funding up front that ultimately does save taxpayer dollars.
- 20:03It's a much better investment if we're able to do some of these infrastructure
- 20:07improvements and consider multiple hazards, future hazards, the way we would
- 20:12with any other engineering project. Right.
- 20:14You know, we don't engineer something for today. We engineer a bridge for the
- 20:18next hundred years, you know, thinking about connecting project useful life
- 20:22to what we expect to see in the future when it comes to our climate and our environment.
- 20:27And then I think also.
- 20:29You know, in many cases, we know how to do this, right? Like we've done a lot of really great work.
- 20:34There's like great research, there's great engineering updates and investments
- 20:38in, you know, again, building codes and how to build out of harm's way and different materials to use.
- 20:44So we can still be in the places that we want to live, but we just need the
- 20:48political will and the money to be able to do that. And I think we can marry those two, right?
- 20:54We have like the opportunity for innovation. We have the opportunity for,
- 20:57you know, work again, working across sectors, like bringing resilience into
- 21:01sort of our traditional bread and butter, like transportation engineering,
- 21:05civil engineering, you know, wastewater engineering.
- 21:07Like anytime we're touching infrastructure or like part of our community,
- 21:12we should be thinking about, is there an opportunity to incorporate resiliency here?
- 21:17And I hope that, you know, will become our norm in the future.
- 21:20Well, Jen and Riley, I hope our communication staff is listening because you
- 21:25just had the quote of the day.
- 21:27We are not engineering for today. We are engineering for the next 100 years.
- 21:31So we've got to remember that one. Very insightful conversation.
- 21:36Unfortunately, that's about all the time we have for today. Thank you so much for being with us.
- 21:40Thank you so much for having me. It was great to talk to you.
- 21:43And I'm really excited to hear what listeners have to say.
- 21:47Awesome. Thank you to our listeners as well for tuning in to another episode
- 21:50of The Market Edge. I'm Diana O'Lear. See you next time.