Latest / Deep Values: Value Investing Deep Dives / [Q4 2025] UnitedHealth’s One Cent Profit Hides Value
Transcript
- 0:00Welcome back to the Deep Dive. It is Tuesday, January 27th,
- 0:032026. Today we aren't just looking at
- 0:06a company, we're looking at something that it resembles A
- 0:10tectonic plate of the American economy.
- 0:13If this thing shifts, the whole country feels it.
- 0:15It's true. We are talking about United
- 0:17Health Group ticker symbol UNASA, and the scale here is,
- 0:23well, it's hard to overstate. I was looking at the numbers
- 0:26before we started. This company touches the lives
- 0:28of roughly 150 million people, 150 million.
- 0:32That is nearly half the population of the United States.
- 0:35If United Health Group were a country, its revenue would rival
- 0:38the GDP of, you know, a mid sized European nation like
- 0:41Austria or Norway. Exactly.
- 0:43It is a massive engine. But, and This is why we're doing
- 0:45this deep dive today, even massive engines can sputter.
- 0:48We're looking at their Q 42025 earnings, which just dropped,
- 0:52and it's a fast story of contrast.
- 0:54It really is. On one hand, you have revenue
- 0:56numbers that are absolutely skyrocketing, but on the other,
- 0:58the profit for the fourth quarter, well, basically
- 1:00evaporated. It vanished.
- 1:01It's one of the most Doctor Jekyll and Mr. Hyde Ernie's
- 1:04reports I've ever seen. So our mission today is to
- 1:07unpack exactly what happened. Is this a stumbling giant
- 1:11that's, you know, losing its way?
- 1:13Or is this just a messy quarter that's hiding a massive buying
- 1:17opportunity? We're going to tear apart the
- 1:19numbers, look under the hood at their business model, which is
- 1:22way more complex than just insurance, and finally figure
- 1:26out what the stock is actually. Worth.
- 1:27We're going to strip it down to the studs.
- 1:29But before we get into the billions, we have a specific
- 1:32tool to help you track the broader market context.
- 1:35That's right, to track total market temperature, welcome to
- 1:38search and download the iOS App Buffett Indicator from the Apple
- 1:42App Store. And as always, we need to get
- 1:44through the legal housekeeping before we dive in.
- 1:47All analysis is based on publicly available sources and
- 1:50may be subject to revisions or differing interpretations.
- 1:52The content is for educational purposes only and does not
- 1:56constitute investment advice. Conduct your own due diligence
- 1:59before making investment decisions.
- 2:01If you want to listen to our full deep dive about this topic
- 2:04or access more advanced contents, welcome to join Deep
- 2:07Value Club membership or subscribe us on Apple Spotify
- 2:10Podcasts Channel, Deep Value Investing and Deep Values dot
- 2:14AI. All right, housekeeping done,
- 2:17let's get into the crime scene. We're looking at the full year
- 2:202025 and specifically this very strange fourth quarter.
- 2:25Hit us with the headline numbers.
- 2:26Let's start with the WOW number, the top line in revenue for the
- 2:29full year 2025. United Health Group brought in
- 2:31$447.6 billion four. 147 billion.
- 2:35That represents a 12% increase year over year.
- 2:38I want you to just pause and think about how difficult that
- 2:40is. Right when you are already
- 2:42generating $400 billion, funding another $50 billion in growth is
- 2:46mathematically incredibly hard. It's like a sumo wrestler
- 2:48running a Sprint. Right.
- 2:49Usually companies that size grow at GDP rates, maybe 2 or 3%.
- 2:54They're growing at 12. Precisely.
- 2:56The insurance division alone, United Healthcare grew sales by
- 2:5916%. So strictly speaking, the demand
- 3:03for their product is not the problem.
- 3:05The cash register is ringing off the hook.
- 3:07OK, so they're bringing money in the front door, but then you
- 3:11look at the bottom line for Q4 and it feels like someone left
- 3:15the back door wide open. This is the Ouch number GAAP
- 3:18earnings per share. That's the strict by the book
- 3:20accounting. Profit came in at 1 cent a
- 3:23penny, one single penny of profit on 113 billion of
- 3:27quarterly revenue. That is baffling.
- 3:29If I'm a shareholder, I'm looking at that penny and I'm
- 3:31panicking. Did they lose the money?
- 3:33Did they burn it? How do you make $113 billion and
- 3:36keep 1 cent per share? Well.
- 3:37They didn't lose it in terms of operations failing, but they
- 3:40spent a fortune cleaning up a mess.
- 3:42They took a massive $1.6 billion after tax restructuring charge
- 3:47in the quarter. 1.6 billion is a lot of cleaning up.
- 3:49What exactly went wrong? It's a kitchen sink.
- 3:52They threw everything bad into this one report.
- 3:55They sold off some underperforming units in South
- 3:57America, portfolio divestitures. They reorganized some internal
- 4:00operations. But the biggest culprit, the one
- 4:02that really hurts, is the fallout from the cyberattack.
- 4:06Right, the big hack. This is the change healthcare
- 4:09attack from back in 2024, right? We're still paying for that in
- 4:122020. Five we are.
- 4:13You have to remember that wasn't just a data breach where someone
- 4:16stole some emails. That attack effectively froze
- 4:19the plumbing of the US healthcare system for weeks.
- 4:23Doctors couldn't get paid, pharmacies couldn't process
- 4:26claims. Fixing that, paying out the
- 4:28claims, manually upgrading the security infrastructure, it cost
- 4:32them about $800 million in this quarter alone.
- 4:35So it's like having a pipe burst in your house, you have to pay
- 4:38the plumber, you have to replace the drywall, and you have to buy
- 4:41new carpets and just a massive one time cash drain.
- 4:44Exactly, and that's why management is telling investors
- 4:47don't look at the penny. They're pointing to the adjusted
- 4:50EPS. I always get skeptical when
- 4:52companies say ignore the bad stuff.
- 4:54Is this just financial engineering or is there some
- 4:58merit to it? In this specific case, I think
- 5:00there is merit if you strip out the cyberattack costs, which
- 5:04hopefully is a once in a lifetime event and the
- 5:06restructuring for selling off those foreign divisions.
- 5:09The adjusted EPS was $2.11 for the quarter, OK.
- 5:12And for the full year, adjusted earnings were $16.35 per share.
- 5:17So if the pipe hadn't burst, the house would still be generating
- 5:20rent. The underlying business is still
- 5:22profitable. Correct.
- 5:23The engine is still running. It just spent the quarter in the
- 5:25repair shop and looking ahead, management is confident they
- 5:29raised their outlook for 2026. They're forecasting revenue of
- 5:33roughly $439 billion, a slight dip because they sold those
- 5:38foreign divisions right. But they expect adjusted
- 5:41earnings to jump to over $17.95 per share.
- 5:44So they're signaling that the margins are going to snap back.
- 5:46They're telling the market the worst is behind us.
- 5:49Let's pivot to the business model itself because I think
- 5:52this is where people get confused.
- 5:53I think most people here, United Health and they just picture
- 5:57that insurance card in their wallet.
- 5:59They think, OK, they collect my premiums, they pay my doctor and
- 6:01they keep the difference. That is the traditional view of
- 6:04insurance and if that is all they did, this company would not
- 6:08be the monster it is today. So what are we missing?
- 6:11What is the real machine here? You have to understand that
- 6:14Unite Health Group is actually 2 massive distinct companies
- 6:18stitched together. You have United Healthcare,
- 6:20which is the insurance arm that brings in about 79% of the
- 6:24revenue. They have nearly 50 million
- 6:26members. Which is huge, but insurance is
- 6:28a low margin game generally. It is.
- 6:29The margins are tight and they're regulated.
- 6:32But the secret sauce, the real profit engine, is the second
- 6:35arm, Optum. Optum.
- 6:37I see that name everywhere now. Optum Urgent Care, Optum RX.
- 6:42Optum is the health services arm.
- 6:44It accounts for about 21% of revenue, but the margins are
- 6:47totally different. Optum is an insurance.
- 6:49Optum is the doctor, the pharmacist and the data analyst.
- 6:53Wait, unpack that for me. So United insures me, but they
- 6:57also own the doctor I go to. Yes, through Optum Health.
- 7:00And they own the pharmacy that fills my prescription.
- 7:03Yes, through Optimars. And they own the data company
- 7:07that processes the claim. Through Optum Insight, this is
- 7:10what we call vertical integration and it is their
- 7:13massive competitive Moat. It sounds, well, let's be blunt,
- 7:17it sounds like a conflict of interest.
- 7:19If the insurer owns the doctor, doesn't the insurer just tell
- 7:24the doctor to provide less care to save money?
- 7:27That is the regulatory concern, yes, and it's why the government
- 7:30watches them like a hawk. But from a purely business
- 7:33perspective, it's brilliant. Think about the Affordable Care
- 7:36Act, Obamacare. It capped how much profit
- 7:39insurance companies can make. Right, the medical.
- 7:41Loss ratio exactly. For every dollar of premium,
- 7:44they have to spend roughly 80 or $0.85 on care they can't just
- 7:47pocket. It right, the government put a
- 7:48ceiling on their profits. So what did United do?
- 7:51They said OK, if I have to pay $0.85 to a provider, I might as
- 7:55well pay my own provider. Oh, that is clever.
- 7:57It's an arbitrage. It is the money leaves the left
- 8:00pocket United Healthcare and goes into the right pocket
- 8:03Optum. It all stays in the house.
- 8:06And I imagine this gives them incredible power over pricing.
- 8:09Immense power. Take optomarks.
- 8:12They process over 1 billion prescriptions annually.
- 8:15A billion. A billion.
- 8:17When you're buying that many of anything, you can demand rock
- 8:20bottom prices from drug manufacturers, but you can still
- 8:23charge the market rate to the employers.
- 8:25That spread is pure profit. So it's a walled garden.
- 8:28A very profitable walled garden and increase these network
- 8:31effects. They have 1.5 million physicians
- 8:34in their network, right? If you're a big employer, say
- 8:37General Motors, and you want to buy insurance for your staff,
- 8:40you almost have to go to United, right?
- 8:42If you switch to a smaller insurer, half your employees
- 8:44might lose their doctor. The switching costs are
- 8:47incredibly high. OK, so the model is robust.
- 8:49It's a money machine, but we established at the top that the
- 8:52stock has been wobbly. It wasn't just the cyber attack.
- 8:55There are other things spooking investors, right?
- 8:58Yes, there were three main headwinds hitting them in 2024
- 9:01and 2025. The first was a utilization
- 9:04spike. Utilization.
- 9:06That's industry speak for people actually going to the doctor.
- 9:09Exactly. Think back to the pandemic
- 9:10years. Nobody got knee replacements,
- 9:12nobody got elective surgeries. People were afraid to go to
- 9:15hospitals. So we had a backlog of broken
- 9:18knees. A massive backlog and in 2024
- 9:21and 2025 the dam broke. Everyone came back for those
- 9:26surgeries at the same time. Which means United had to pay
- 9:28out a lot more claims than they expected.
- 9:30Right, their medical care ratio, or MCR, jumped to nearly 89%.
- 9:35That means for every dollar they took in, $0.89 went out the
- 9:38door. That compresses margins
- 9:40significantly. It's great for patients finally
- 9:42getting care, but it's terrible for short term profits.
- 9:44But that should be temporary, right?
- 9:46Once the knees are fixed, they're fixed.
- 9:48Theoretically, yes, That's the short term headwind argument.
- 9:51But the second issue was leadership, and this one rattled
- 9:54Wall Street. In May 2025, the CEO, Andrew
- 9:57Witty stepped down unexpectedly. Unexpectedly is a word investors
- 10:02hate. It implies chaos.
- 10:04It does. Usually succession at a company
- 10:07that size is planned years in advance.
- 10:09This felt abrupt. To stabilize the ship, they
- 10:12brought back the old guard, Steven Hemsley.
- 10:15He was the CEO years ago and was serving as chairman.
- 10:18It's like bringing the retired general back to the front lines
- 10:20because of the new guys aren't ready.
- 10:22That is a very apartment analogy.
- 10:24Hemsley is the architect of the Optimum strategy, so the market
- 10:27respects him immensely. But it raises questions about
- 10:30the future. You know who is next.
- 10:32You can't rely on the retired general forever.
- 10:34And the third headwind, I assume it involves Washington, DC.
- 10:37Always, the government is tightening the purse strings on
- 10:40Medicare Advantage. Which is the private version of
- 10:43Medicare that United runs. Correct.
- 10:45It has been a huge growth driver for them, but the government is
- 10:48changing the reimbursement rates for 2026.
- 10:51United expects a greater than $6 billion hit from those changes.
- 10:546 billion is not a rounding error.
- 10:56No, and deeper than that, you always have the existential
- 11:00fret. As long as healthcare costs keep
- 11:02rising, the political pressure for a single payer system or
- 11:05Medicare for All increases. If the private insurance market
- 11:09is legislated out of existence, Unh's business model evaporates
- 11:13overnight. That is the dark cloud that
- 11:15always hangs over the stock. OK, so let's recap.
- 11:19We have messy numbers from hacks and restructuring.
- 11:21We have a brilliant business model in Optum, but we have
- 11:24headwinds from utilization and regulation.
- 11:27Let's get to the bottom line, the investment case.
- 11:30Let's look at it through the lens of a deep value investor.
- 11:32Let's use the Buffett checklist from our source material.
- 11:34OK. If Warren Buffett were looking
- 11:36at UNH today, would he buy it? Let's start with valuation.
- 11:39Buffett likes cheap. Is UNH cheap?
- 11:42I'm looking at the price to earnings ratio, it's around 25
- 11:45X. Right.
- 11:46And if you use the depressed 2025 earnings, it's over 30X.
- 11:49Historically, deep value investors want to PE below 15.
- 11:53So it's nearly double the bargain price.
- 11:55It is the press could book ratio is 3.3 XA.
- 11:58Bargain hunter usually wants that under 1.5 S Strictly on
- 12:01price, it fails. It's expensive.
- 12:03But Buffett also famously said it's far better to buy a
- 12:07wonderful company at a fair price than a fair company at a
- 12:09wonderful price. Is this a wonderful company?
- 12:12That is the yes column. The quality metrics are stellar.
- 12:16Look at return on equity. The 10 year average is about
- 12:1822%. 22% for a company with almost half a trillion in
- 12:23revenue. That is absurd efficiency.
- 12:25Usually as you get that big, you become sluggish.
- 12:28It's the opto machine at work, and the cash flow backs it up.
- 12:32This business is a cash cannon. Free cash flow usually exceeds
- 12:36net income. Even in a bad year like this,
- 12:39they're generating over $16 billion in free cash.
- 12:42And I know from their filings they aren't just sitting on that
- 12:44cash like a dragon on a gold pile.
- 12:46No, they are what Charlie Munger would call cannibals.
- 12:49They eat their own stock. They have retired about 100
- 12:52million shares since 2015 via buybacks plus 16 consecutive
- 12:56years of dividend growth. They treat shareholders very,
- 12:59very well. So we have a high quality
- 13:01machine, but a high sticker price.
- 13:03Let's try to find the actual number.
- 13:04What is it worth? We have a discounted cash flow
- 13:06analysis from our sources. Right, DCF is just a fancy way
- 13:09of asking how much cash will this company generate in the
- 13:12future and what is that cash worth to me today?
- 13:16We have 3 scenarios. Let's start with a pessimist the
- 13:19sky is falling scenario. This assumes the headwinds we
- 13:22discussed, government regulation, utilization, size
- 13:26limits stop the growth permanently.
- 13:29So a flat line, 16 billion a year, forever.
- 13:32If they never grow again, the intrinsic value of the stock is
- 13:35about $172 per share. And it's trading around $284.
- 13:39Today. So if you think growth is dead,
- 13:41you're overpaying massively. You'd be buying a dollar for
- 13:43$2.00. OK, that's the bear case.
- 13:46What about the nominal scenario? This assumes they get past the
- 13:49messy 2025 and return to their historical trajectory.
- 13:53Historically, they've grown free cash flow at about 1011%
- 13:56annually. Is. 10% realistic?
- 13:57Can you really grow 10% when you're already half a trillion
- 14:00dollars? That is the big risk, but if you
- 14:02believe they can by squeezing more out of Optum or expanding
- 14:07into value based care, then the intrinsic value is around 458
- 14:11per share. Wait 458 and the stock is at
- 14:14284. Correct.
- 14:16That implies A roughly 38% margin of safety.
- 14:19That is a massive gap. Usually large companies are
- 14:22priced pretty efficiently. This suggests the market is very
- 14:25confused. It's the aha moment.
- 14:28The market is pricing UNH somewhere in the middle.
- 14:31It's saying we don't think you're dead, but we don't
- 14:34believe you can grow at 10% anymore.
- 14:36So the investment thesis is actually pretty simple.
- 14:38It's a bet on the machine. It's a bet on Steven Hensley and
- 14:42the vertical integration model. If you believe the cyberattack
- 14:45and the utilization spike were just one time glitches, you are
- 14:49buying a compounder at a significant discount.
- 14:52You're buying a Ferrari that's being sold at a Toyota price
- 14:55because it has a flat tire. But if you think the engine is
- 14:57blown, if you think peak insurance is here, you stay
- 14:59away. Precisely.
- 15:00At $284, you're paying for growth.
- 15:03If the growth doesn't materialize, there's no safety
- 15:06net. That is a fascinating setup.
- 15:08It's rare to find a blue chip stock where the bull case and
- 15:12the bear case are so clearly defined by a single variable
- 15:15growth rate. And that's what makes it a deep
- 15:17value candidate. In a weird way.
- 15:19It's not cheap because the company is trash.
- 15:21It's cheap because the market is uncertain about the future speed
- 15:24of the engine. So let's wrap this up.
- 15:26United Health Group Dominant scale wide Moat via Optim 2025
- 15:31was a messy year. Charges hacks, CEO shuffles, but
- 15:35the cash flow remains enormous. And the valuation offers a
- 15:39potential 40% upside if, and this is big if, if they return
- 15:42to form. I want to leave our listeners
- 15:44with a final thought to chew on. We talked about how United is
- 15:48betting big on owning the clinics and the data.
- 15:50They're effectively privatizing the management of U.S.
- 15:53healthcare. But here's the question.
- 15:55With political pressure mounting on healthcare costs, can a
- 15:58company this size continue to extract 20% returns on equity
- 16:01forever? Or have we reached a point where
- 16:04the sheer size of UNH becomes its own enemy, painting a target
- 16:07on its back for regulators? That is the multibillion dollar
- 16:09question. When you are the size of a
- 16:11nation's GDP, growth requires finding new frontiers, and in
- 16:15healthcare, those frontiers are often guarded by politicians.
- 16:18Something to Mull over. Thank you all for joining us on
- 16:22this deep dive into United Health Group.
- 16:25If you want to dig into the numbers yourself, check the
- 16:27sources. We will see you next time.
- 16:29See you next time.