Latest / Credit Union Exam Solutions Presents With Flying Colors / NCUA in Transition: What Hauptman’s Move Means with Bacino, Swann & McKechnie
Transcript
- 0:00Treichel: Hey everyone, this is Mark t Trico with another
- 0:01episode of With Flying Colors.
- 0:03As I mentioned in my emergency podcast earlier in the week, I've got a Allstar
- 0:08team of X-N-C-U-A folks to talk about.
- 0:12All things NCA, but particularly focus on the recent announcement of Kyle
- 0:16Halman going to the P-C-A-O-B and what that might mean, what it might not mean.
- 0:21On my screen, on the upper left, I've got Jeff Pacino.
- 0:24Jeff how you doing today?
- 0:26Good.
- 0:27Doing good.
- 0:28And Alonzo lower left hand corner.
- 0:30How are you today?
- 0:31Alonzo Swann: Fabulous, Matt.
- 0:32Treichel: All right.
- 0:33And John Ney lower right hand corner.
- 0:35You good as well?
- 0:37Alonzo Swann: Yes, sir.
- 0:38Treichel: All right guys.
- 0:38And Jeff, former NCUA board member currently runs Bino and Associates.
- 0:44Alonzo former examiner all the way up to regional director at NCUA
- 0:50currently works with the Federal Home Loan Bank of Atlanta and John Ney.
- 0:55John Ney, LLC.
- 0:57Helps credit unions negotiate the the world of Washington dc Anything
- 1:03else on your backgrounds you want me to throw you, you want to
- 1:05throw in there before we dive in?
- 1:08Geoff Bacino: You glossed over my NCA tenure,
- 1:10Treichel: oh, I did.
- 1:11Geoff Bacino: Deliberate.
- 1:11Treichel: Yes.
- 1:12It wasn't deliberate.
- 1:13I called you all NCA on the front end, but you were there during the
- 1:16corporate crisis and let's get more liquidity and Roman's burning stage.
- 1:22Geoff Bacino: Yeah, I'm glad you didn't say I was responsible
- 1:24for it, but yeah, I was
- 1:25about to say that.
- 1:26Are those two events not mutually exclusive, but they are.
- 1:30I was on the hill when the SNL crisis blew up and then I came to NCA.
- 1:35So you can draw your own conclusions,
- 1:36Treichel: it's just the pendulum.
- 1:38So guys, I was it last week?
- 1:40I got a little birdie, sent me an announcement of a press release that says,
- 1:45Hey, this is, didn't even say anything.
- 1:47They just sent me that and I saw Halman was leaving.
- 1:49And I thought, okay, when did, what else did I miss?
- 1:53Who's coming?
- 1:53And then shortly thereafter, Kyle Halman and NCUA came out with their
- 1:59statement and where's the statement here?
- 2:05To the brief statement said he's a appointment to the P-C-A-O-B.
- 2:12He says, I'm grateful to President Trump and Chairman Atkins for their faith in me
- 2:18and for the appointment to the P-C-A-O-B.
- 2:21Here's the word that, here's the sentence that says it all.
- 2:24I intend to remain in my role as NCA chair until my successor is appointed
- 2:28by President Trump and confirmed.
- 2:31By the US Senate.
- 2:34As I read that there, right now, I think the key word is intent.
- 2:38It's kinda like the word may.
- 2:39It's stronger than May, but it's not a definite.
- 2:42I'll throw that out there.
- 2:43But guys let's talk about.
- 2:45What this means for the process, what it means for the help, excuse me.
- 2:52The harper the ska lawsuits.
- 2:54Not necessarily who might be coming in, because that's always a crapshoot,
- 2:58but who wants to dive in first?
- 3:02Geoff Bacino: All right.
- 3:02Nobody raised their hand, I'll take it.
- 3:04First of all, this was not unexpected.
- 3:06Kyle's term expired back in August.
- 3:08And as I think we agree, you're not allowed to succeed yourself.
- 3:12Kyle's, Kyle was going to be going somewhere else.
- 3:15He'd been rumored as I know John and Alonzo and you, mark
- 3:19know, I've been rumored a couple places that he'd like to go.
- 3:22But the interesting thing about presidential appointments and
- 3:24politics, you don't always get to go where you wanna go.
- 3:27As I said, not unexpected.
- 3:29I guess the next thing, obviously, as you talked about intend to stay is
- 3:34what does this mean for credit unions and what does this mean for NCUA?
- 3:38And I think the first thing is.
- 3:40Obviously right now the president can appoint the chairman
- 3:43because the chairman's seat is the one that would be open.
- 3:46The other two, because of the slaughter lawsuit and the and Todd and Tanya's
- 3:50lawsuits, I think they've gotta, hold on.
- 3:53I don't think they could, I don't think they can fill those two yet.
- 3:56Basically because I contend to, if you do so and you lose the lawsuit, it
- 4:00creates a game of, NCA musical chairs.
- 4:03'cause I would assume that.
- 4:05If they win the lawsuit that Todd and Tanya will be at 1775 Duke Street
- 4:09the next morning saying, okay, we'd like to get back into our office.
- 4:13If you've already got two people in those offices, it's gonna be, as
- 4:16they like to say, a little awkward.
- 4:18I think, as I said, it was the natural progression as term was up.
- 4:21It's a nice landing spot for him.
- 4:23I think he's earned it and deserves it.
- 4:24But then for credit unions, I think you need to get, you
- 4:28need to get someone there.
- 4:29As the chairman before he would leave
- 4:33it.
- 4:34I've been in mentally dividing these appointments into kind of two lanes.
- 4:39The one that Jeff just described where Chairman Halman would
- 4:43be replaced by somebody.
- 4:45So that's one lane.
- 4:46And then you have the other that involves the other two empty seats.
- 4:50Just the way Jeff described it, and it's entirely, those two are entirely
- 4:53contingent on what the Supreme Court decides in the, in, in the Slaughter case,
- 4:59which is really about this Humphrey's executor 1930s obscure Supreme Court case
- 5:04that really decides whether a president can remove independent directors or not.
- 5:10That's been rumored to be that, that meaning the Supreme Court case, it's
- 5:16going to be decided between now and June.
- 5:19Somebody used to work for the Justice Department told me last week that they
- 5:23thought perhaps some more decisions would be handed down February 20th.
- 5:28So we're be, those of us who do this for a living, or at least in the
- 5:32amateur, amateur way, like I do try to I'm gonna have to be watching the
- 5:35Supreme Court website on the 20th to see if any decision is made, but
- 5:40that'll start the the dominoes falling.
- 5:42But back to the Halman.
- 5:45It's, Kyle has been serving in a holdover capacity.
- 5:50I don't, I, I don't believe he's ever said these words to me, but others
- 5:55on Capitol Hill who know him have said that he is a prime candidate
- 6:00for other regulatory positions.
- 6:02So this is a good one.
- 6:03And I think it's one that lends itself to a lot of the expertise
- 6:06he's shown on the board.
- 6:08To his next spot.
- 6:10Treichel: Alonzo Alonzo, I have a different, a follow up
- 6:13question for you, but any thoughts on what we've said so far?
- 6:16Alonzo Swann: Dito I agree with both Jeff and John.
- 6:18I think that's gonna happen.
- 6:19One thing I do expect just to add to it is that is an appointment for
- 6:24a replacement for Kyle any day now.
- 6:26So I think that'll happen.
- 6:27It may be waiting for that February 20th date.
- 6:30John, but I do expect it to happen real soon.
- 6:33Treichel: Then, and then we hear the name, and then it goes through
- 6:35that whole process of getting vetted and Senate approval.
- 6:40And so let's go on the assumption that by Friday we hear a name.
- 6:45What does that mean for the arc of possibly getting that person in there
- 6:49so that they can be chair so that Helpmann can go over to do what he's
- 6:54been selected to Do we, what are we talking 90 days, 60 days, 180 days?
- 7:01Geoff Bacino: That's a very tough question to answer because the
- 7:04senate has, is, or it's always tricky and somewhat contentious, but.
- 7:09The timeframe is gonna be very hard to guess.
- 7:12I wouldn't be surprised if nominees were not waiting until these early summer to,
- 7:19Treichel: And then you get into early summer, the other two positions are up,
- 7:22and you could see, you get into that.
- 7:25Does he put two R's in and not do the D, which you would never, even, those words
- 7:30would never even come out of my mouth.
- 7:32In a different administration.
- 7:34But in this administration, that's theoretically a possibility, right?
- 7:37Two Rs.
- 7:37And they just say, Hey, we're gonna skip the D.
- 7:39You could have all three come in.
- 7:41But it really is a cornucopia of who might come when, how many might come.
- 7:46And Alonzo, so my follow up for you as the staffer at NCUA, like me, when I think of
- 7:52these things, I think about, the agency just went down to 25, 20 7% of staff.
- 7:58The you got one board member instead of three.
- 8:01When you have three, you gotta count to two.
- 8:03When you got one, you gotta, you gotta count to one.
- 8:05But when that one's leaving, and you might have one, two, or three coming,
- 8:09and 27% of your most experienced staff left and you have 11 acting
- 8:14directors, when they issue, here's our leadership and 35% of them say acting.
- 8:19I've coined it as NCO a's a little bit in chaos.
- 8:22And it's good to get movement to where you might be going, but it
- 8:25just adds to the unrest of staff.
- 8:27Any take on that?
- 8:29Alonzo Swann: Like you said, counting one is a lot easier, particularly
- 8:32when that one's been there for a while and you're in sync with him already
- 8:35and he set his tone and it's not significantly different than what it
- 8:40has been from a staffing level except.
- 8:43Fair lending, maybe that lane.
- 8:45But I think it's steady as you go.
- 8:47I think NCA is adjusting definitely what I the reduction.
- 8:52It's not only a reduction, but it's a reduction in places that you lease
- 8:57could afford it, if that makes sense.
- 9:00And that's one of the dilemmas.
- 9:01So I really think you had a expertise gap right now.
- 9:05You get up to speed, everything is fine as long as the economy
- 9:10remains stable, if you will.
- 9:13I think that's a big deal as long as your larger credit unions
- 9:18remain stable, if you will.
- 9:21All that being said I think it's steady as you go.
- 9:24You just keep on going.
- 9:25Interesting thing, of course with Kyle is as his chief of
- 9:29staff is a key component as well.
- 9:31That's one of the, maybe Jeff and or John if with Sarah Bang there.
- 9:37I think that's very important for continuity purposes.
- 9:40If I were coming in particularly as a Republican, I think
- 9:43she's a key component in.
- 9:45Whether she'll stay over or whether she's going with Kyle.
- 9:48So those questions have to be answered as well.
- 9:50But I think just from a staff perspective your feeling with Kyle there, or
- 9:54not that talent drain right now, but you already got you, you already got
- 10:00a floor, so you know where it is.
- 10:02It's just keeping going there.
- 10:03But I am hearing that the expertise has.
- 10:07Treichel: You're hearing some of the same things I'm hearing and experience.
- 10:10Yeah.
- 10:11I get that.
- 10:11And on the Sarah Bank concept, it's like when Mike Reel departed and Mark McWaters
- 10:17came in and Sarah Vega transitioned creating a political appointee
- 10:21position where there was some holdover.
- 10:24And helping educate.
- 10:26'cause these board members are bright people when they come in, but
- 10:28sometimes they have to learn credit unions, sometimes they have to learn
- 10:31credit unions and how NCA works.
- 10:34Sometimes they have to learn those things and how government works.
- 10:37So that's a good point.
- 10:38And Jeff John, any thoughts on what Alonso added there?
- 10:43Geoff Bacino: I actually went back in the history books and looked at the
- 10:45very first three member NCA board.
- 10:48Which would've been, which was seated, I think 1980.
- 10:51And you mentioned Mark a minute ago that you could have the two
- 10:55Republicans and no Democrats.
- 10:57There actually has been a situation where the other party, if you
- 11:00will, has not been represented.
- 11:02First board had two Democrats and an independent the two Democrats of course
- 11:07were Larry Cannell, who was the former banking supervisor in Connecticut.
- 11:11A guy named Pa Mack, who was the chief of staff to a se senate Democrat,
- 11:18and then a guy named Harold Black, who was a professor of economics in
- 11:22Tennessee, who was an actual independent.
- 11:25So you didn't have any Republican representative on the first board.
- 11:29I'm not saying that's healthy or good, and I wouldn't condone it.
- 11:32And I think a balanced mixed approach is better for everybody, but it's
- 11:37not completely unprecedented to have.
- 11:41The parties completely shut out of the board.
- 11:43Like I said, I hope that I hope that by the time we do another one of these
- 11:47market to celebrate 4th of July, I hope we have a three member board and it's got
- 11:51two, and I hope it's got two Rs and 1D because that's the way you expect it when
- 11:55you have a Republican in the White House.
- 11:57But I, I don't, I.
- 11:59I know you don't have us on this podcast to say, I don't know, but I don't know.
- 12:04I will say that I'd be surprised.
- 12:06Here's a prediction.
- 12:07I'll be surprised if when the Senate decides to have hearings on nominees,
- 12:13I'd be surprised if they don't have the nominee for n NCAA's chair
- 12:18sitting next to chairman Houtman.
- 12:22When he's testifying about his new role.
- 12:24So in other words, EE they move in tandem.
- 12:27I would guess
- 12:29Treichel: That would be nice for the NCA person, right?
- 12:31Because they're not the main meal.
- 12:33They're more of the appetizer then?
- 12:35Geoff Bacino: Every they always do.
- 12:37They'll do all instead of, unless it's somebody like the Fed Chair
- 12:40or the Secretary of the Treasury, they'll do a whole bank of witnesses.
- 12:44Treichel: Yeah.
- 12:44And not having opinions.
- 12:45You reminded me of my favorite I shouldn't mention 'em 'cause they suck
- 12:49the Minnesota Vikings podcast where?
- 12:51Every Thursday they do reckless speculation, right?
- 12:54And they, the same guys have a Minnesota Timberwolves podcast with reckless
- 12:58speculation with Giannis on Puco.
- 13:02And I know I probably just said his name wrong, coming from
- 13:04the bucks to the Timberwolves.
- 13:05But my reckless speculation is that when we get to a board,
- 13:09there's either gonna be one r.
- 13:12Two hours or I, I just, I'm not contemplating the scenario I see
- 13:16where there's three, the reckless speculation is that Todd and Tanya win
- 13:19their lawsuits and Tanya comes back.
- 13:21So that's just, that's my reckless speculation.
- 13:23It's seven in the morning on Thursday.
- 13:26If it's Thursday.
- 13:26Geoff Bacino: That's a smart, that's a smart prediction.
- 13:29That's always possible.
- 13:31Treichel: That's my hail Mary.
- 13:32All right.
- 13:32Geoff Bacino: So you wanna mention John?
- 13:33If you don't mind, one quick.
- 13:34Yeah,
- 13:35Treichel: Yeah, absolutely.
- 13:36Geoff Bacino: I know we, ideally it works.
- 13:38I think these places work best with two of the party in power and one of
- 13:40the art of the party, or three, and then two, whatever the breakdown is.
- 13:44I think the party crossover is important.
- 13:47Having said that, over the last couple years, you could make a case that if
- 13:51you control the Senate, you really don't have to worry what party someone else is.
- 13:55In other words, if I say I'm a Democrat.
- 13:59And the White House is okay with that.
- 14:01And the Senate's okay with that.
- 14:03And I'm a Democrat, I've made this statement before.
- 14:05What if Donald Trump Jr.
- 14:07Was a registered Democrat in the New York primary, a Democrat?
- 14:10I'd say absolutely not based on everything else, my point is the kind
- 14:14of chaos you were mentioning earlier in the administration and the NCA
- 14:19could lend itself to someone saying, look, here's your three board members.
- 14:22In the Senate, if you got 51 votes right now because of what Harry Reid did years
- 14:26ago, you can approve all three of 'em.
- 14:28And again, the only really safeguard that you have that someone is
- 14:33a party of, the other power is the White House and the Senate.
- 14:36And since there's really no way for anyone in the Senate on the
- 14:39Democratic side to stop anything, you can nominate who you want having.
- 14:43Jeff,
- 14:44by the way Jeff lives in a state where you don't have to register by party.
- 14:47Jeff, if you say you're a Democrat, I believe you.
- 14:49If you say you're a Republican, I believe you.
- 14:52You say you're an independent.
- 14:53I believe you.
- 14:54I'm in state Maryland where you have to register by party, so they
- 14:57know all my neighbors know who I am.
- 15:01But John, if there were a demo, if there were a Democratic president and
- 15:04a Democratic senate, and I could, and I had enough ties, I could pawn you off as
- 15:07a Democrat, I know something you may not wanna be pawn off as who's gonna stop it,
- 15:11right?
- 15:12That's information.
- 15:13Again, it, there's your reckless prediction that, you nominate three of the
- 15:17same party, or you don't nominate anyone.
- 15:19That's a Democrat.
- 15:21But either way, I think the best thing for.
- 15:24Credit unions and NCA is to get this put behind them.
- 15:27And I think the first step is obviously to get someone to replace Kyle.
- 15:31He gets to move on and we get to move on as well.
- 15:35Treichel: Makes, go ahead,
- 15:36Alonzo Swann: Liza.
- 15:37Just to give you my, my thought
- 15:41and again, my thoughts are more on a regular continuum, if you will.
- 15:44Number one, I think if I were Betty Mann, I think the person who would be
- 15:48nominated for Kyle's position will be.
- 15:50A credit union person, if you will.
- 15:51It won't be a person we don't know.
- 15:53That's my prediction.
- 15:54Does that make sense?
- 15:55So it'd be an insider who knows credit union somebody who's been
- 15:58in credit unions, if you will.
- 15:59When we get back to two Rs and one B, if, and this is my personal opinion I think
- 16:06one of the dilemmas that anybody had, and is when you have a former chairman who
- 16:12now becomes a board member, Todd Harper.
- 16:15I say that because I wouldn't want that if I were the Republican.
- 16:18If I had, if I were coming in as a new chairman, I definitely wouldn't
- 16:22want the former chairman on the board.
- 16:25So I say that because I wouldn't mind Tanya as the third person.
- 16:30So I could see that scenario coming up to compromise, if you will.
- 16:36Treichel: That's that, that's an interesting take.
- 16:38That's that's better than reckless speculation.
- 16:40And of course, the former chairman who's led the agency,
- 16:43who knows how how the trains run.
- 16:46Who knows that what authorities the chair has and maybe how the other
- 16:50board members can throw kinks in that.
- 16:53And those where the bodies are buried is a different person to contend with.
- 16:56Power wise and just understanding wise,
- 17:01Geoff Bacino: I, I'm gonna violate my own self-imposed
- 17:04rule and say I have an instinct.
- 17:06This is slightly counter to what this is, counter to what Alonza just said,
- 17:10although when Alonza says something, I tend to give it a great deal of
- 17:12weight because I think he actually.
- 17:15He's talking about unlike myself and maybe Jeff.
- 17:17But I think this might be somebody who the Trump administration already knows
- 17:22and has appointed to something else.
- 17:24I'm not sure if they know or care if it's a person with who's from our industry.
- 17:29Maybe I'm wrong.
- 17:30Maybe there's somebody out there.
- 17:32In the credit union world, who is a very connected Trump person, but
- 17:36something in my spidey sense tells me it's going to be somebody who they
- 17:42know more than someone who we know.
- 17:44That's just a guess.
- 17:46Treichel: And sometimes people come back, right?
- 17:47Debbie Matts came back.
- 17:49Rodney Hood came back.
- 17:50And so there could be when you look when you go back at that chart of
- 17:54who's been here, who's been political appointees, you can you can look at
- 17:57a list and maybe come up with some names and go, aha, they might know this
- 18:00person, they might know that person.
- 18:01And without getting into specifics of course but you can look
- 18:04at those tea leaves and say, Hey, maybe that makes sense.
- 18:07And again, it could make sense.
- 18:09Geoff Bacino: Well, John brought up John brought up the initial board
- 18:11at NC Way, and again, if you look at, if you look at almost everyone.
- 18:17Up until a couple years ago, it usually consisted of people who I don't wanna
- 18:22say didn't know credit unions, but if you go back, even as far as someone
- 18:26like Ed Callahan, Callahan was the Department of Financial Institutions
- 18:29head in Illinois, new Credit Unions.
- 18:31But after that, then you've gotta go the next one up would've probably been Bob
- 18:34Swan and then Dave Chatfield, and then Dennis Dollar, myself, Gigi Highland.
- 18:44Metzker to a degree, and then it just stops.
- 18:48Okay.
- 18:48Didn't Friel have some kind of
- 18:50Yes, you're right.
- 18:50I'm sorry.
- 18:51Yes.
- 18:51Friel was the Department of Financial Institution, so thank
- 18:53Yeah.
- 18:53Yeah.
- 18:53But again, I pointed this out maybe during our last call or the one before
- 18:57that the board, right before the Trump administration fired two people,
- 19:01that board was made up entirely of capital, former Capitol Hill staffers.
- 19:06Okay.
- 19:07Which tells me that this, that an NCE appointment, which used to be something.
- 19:12People either took, if they didn't get something else, I'll allow Roger Jepson.
- 19:15But very few people, as I said, you gotta you take, Callahan, Jack, field
- 19:19Dollar, me and Gigi and Mike out of it.
- 19:24You got people who really didn't know the agency.
- 19:27And my, and Mark and Alonzo, you guys talk about when someone comes
- 19:29in, they don't know the agency.
- 19:31I think it's gonna be interesting to see.
- 19:33You know that if this trend continues.
- 19:37Because where Kyle is going, the P-C-A-O-B, the Public Company Accounting
- 19:41Oversight Board, that thing was created.
- 19:44Make sure I'm writing on this, John, with what piece of legislation was that?
- 19:49It was not Dod Frank.
- 19:50It was one, I think it was it HE the home.
- 19:53Oh no, I thought it was the one with the SEC stuff.
- 19:55Anyways, my point is.
- 19:57I looked at that position when I was at the finance board, but everybody then
- 20:01had all come from the hill too, because they know it was a great place to go.
- 20:04So my point is, moving forward with NCA Board nominations,
- 20:09are they gonna start to become.
- 20:12People who just understand that they're there and coming from the hill,
- 20:16which is again, great knowledge, but very limited credit union knowledge.
- 20:20Or will it start to be a little bit more spread out the way it's been in the past?
- 20:24I would take my, my, the board I was on, you've got Dennis dollar.
- 20:27CEO from Mississippi, Yolanda Wheat, Harvard and Stanford trained
- 20:31lawyer and me, who's been in credit unions in some form for a while.
- 20:35It's just, it's an interesting thing and I will just digress into this.
- 20:39Mark.
- 20:39I hope I don't step on your line here.
- 20:42If it if it were to change, to where the president has the ability.
- 20:46In other words, if the White House wins the slaughter court case and he can, he
- 20:50or she, whoever the president is, can fire board members, it's gonna set a
- 20:54real issue in place, number one as to whether someone would even take the job.
- 20:59Sure.
- 21:00More importantly.
- 21:01Number two, would someone take the job with, say, a year
- 21:03left in a president's term?
- 21:04In other words if that goes through and they try to fill
- 21:08a slot in this administration, people, okay, Trump's leaving in
- 21:112028 and it's 2027 or late 2026.
- 21:15Do you want, if you're from out of state, do you wanna move here to take this job?
- 21:19Knowing you could be out of it in January of 2029 if a democratic president
- 21:25comes in and says, you know what?
- 21:26See ya.
- 21:27What's gonna happen, I predict would be every agency on January
- 21:3221st of inauguration year is gonna be like, okay, see you.
- 21:35You gotta go.
- 21:36And that's gonna create some real havoc.
- 21:38And as I said, it will create some trepidation on the part of people who
- 21:43might be very qualified and wanna do it, saying, eh, it's not worth it.
- 21:46Treichel: It's gonna change the pool of who's interested.
- 21:48No doubt.
- 21:49Yeah.
- 21:49One way or the other.
- 21:50Geoff Bacino: Yep.
- 21:51Treichel: I wrote down a couple words here, so I wouldn't for forget them,
- 21:55but I, John, I you might, did you have any thoughts on what Jeff just said?
- 21:59I thought No.
- 22:00No.
- 22:00Okay.
- 22:00And the, the P-C-A-O-B being a good place to land when that little birdie sent me a
- 22:05note saying, Hey, look where Kyle's going?
- 22:07I, there was some reasons also put as to why it was a good place to go, and that
- 22:12was the difference in pay at that place versus being a board member at NCUA.
- 22:17But in this, so I, I got my Google machine out and I saw that they
- 22:21reduced the pay for the board members there by between 42 and 52%.
- 22:26As good as this job, as it used as, as good as it get, as it used to be.
- 22:29It's about half as good as it used to be too.
- 22:31So yet it still pays more than what the NCA Board does.
- 22:34There that popped into my head and then Jeff, when you were talking about
- 22:38if you have control of the Senate.
- 22:40So the light bulb that goes on in my mind then is, okay, so between now and
- 22:44midterms, there has to be some sort of resolution or no, midterms won't
- 22:49impact it 'cause that's the house.
- 22:50So nevermind.
- 22:50So they're, it's a long game, right?
- 22:53Geoff Bacino: Yeah, John.
- 22:54John will tell you've also got control of the Senate.
- 22:56I don't think the Democrats can win it, but it is up.
- 23:00I think they're gonna pick up seats, though.
- 23:02I think it'll make it, it'll be a closer margin, but I think a lot of this is
- 23:05gonna be resolved before November.
- 23:07I'd be surprised if there weren't.
- 23:09Treichel: Got
- 23:09Alonzo Swann: it.
- 23:09I agree with that.
- 23:10I agree with that.
- 23:13Treichel: Very good guys.
- 23:14So what else around the edges of this this particular topic do we wanna
- 23:18chat about and if nothing there?
- 23:20The general state of affairs of all things, all other things at CUA?
- 23:26Geoff Bacino: I'll give you a segue to that.
- 23:28I, I wanted to mention, I made a mental note to myself.
- 23:32We're on the cusp of the time when the NCA has to revisit the the
- 23:37interest rate ceiling, and you now have Chairman Haman's appointment and
- 23:44you also have the recent stir about interest rates, initiated by the
- 23:49president's tweet in favor of a 10% cap.
- 23:53I just wonder I'd actually like your everybody else's opinion.
- 23:56This all seems to mix together now in a very interesting fashion.
- 24:00You wonder what kind of pressures there are gonna be about resetting the policy,
- 24:06especially if the chairman now has an eye, he's not yet, not one foot out the door.
- 24:11'cause he's going to, he's pledged to serve in a full capacity.
- 24:15But you just wonder how everything affects everything else.
- 24:18It's like Earl Weaver used to say everything changes everything.
- 24:21Right?
- 24:23Treichel: And three run homers.
- 24:25Geoff Bacino: Pitching defense three run Homer.
- 24:26Yeah.
- 24:28Treichel: That, that's interesting.
- 24:29I have a couple thoughts on the interest rate thing, but Jeff Alonzo, I,
- 24:34Alonzo Swann: Agree.
- 24:34One of, one of the things I'm seeing my opinion is right now
- 24:38with that one person board.
- 24:40The items coming before the board are for lack of a better
- 24:44term, pretty non-controversial paying board members for daycare.
- 24:49Stuff like that.
- 24:50The interest rate ceiling is not non-controversial, so that'll be
- 24:56interesting to see if it's a one person board whether you do that.
- 25:00I think either John or Jeff mentioned earlier.
- 25:03That anything approved, obviously under that one person board,
- 25:06it may be subject to a lawsuit.
- 25:08Is that, am I remembering correctly, gentlemen?
- 25:12Geoff Bacino: I've made that assumption.
- 25:13I think so.
- 25:14And I think John had backed
- 25:15Yeah I think that's very good observation.
- 25:17Alonzo.
- 25:18Ed, go ahead.
- 25:20Alonzo Swann: So when, yeah, I don't know when that when the
- 25:22interest rate ceiling comes up,
- 25:24Geoff Bacino: March,
- 25:24Alonzo Swann: but that will be a timeline that you try to get.
- 25:27At least one other board member,
- 25:29Geoff Bacino: It'll be March.
- 25:30And you assume maybe they discuss it at the February
- 25:32board meeting if there is one.
- 25:35Treichel: And I'll say on the interest rates and I'll preface this with, I'm
- 25:39paraphrasing and this is roughly correct, but putting my executive director
- 25:44hat on in order to maintain it at 18.
- 25:48You have to be able to look at the period in time since the last time, and
- 25:53either reference stability or instability or rate increases of some sort.
- 25:57'cause I remember one time a big discussion where.
- 26:00Rates had only gone down yet.
- 26:01They wanted to keep it at 18 for obvious reasons.
- 26:05And they had to cherry pick like a two week period where rates blipped up as
- 26:09their argument to comply with the act.
- 26:11Adding that flavor to what might need to be done there is one thing.
- 26:17And and then general comment.
- 26:20The what.
- 26:22What we're seeing is mundane on the agenda, but what's happening by notation,
- 26:28vote on reorgs and things is huge.
- 26:31And the, I've talked about it here that I hear rumblings that offices are.
- 26:37Disappearing going away.
- 26:39This spot's moving over that spot.
- 26:41Yet they're not talking about it publicly, which I think is a bad precedent.
- 26:45And I think and I'm gonna get up on, on a soapbox here, there's
- 26:50been a general trend over the last.
- 26:533, 4, 5, 6, 7 years to do more by notation, vote and
- 26:57do less in the sunshine.
- 26:59And that's not good.
- 27:01And this, and then going back to the chaos of staff, right?
- 27:05You've got staff lost.
- 27:06A lot of their leaders, staff knows.
- 27:09This might be going away, this might be going away, but
- 27:11we're not saying it publicly.
- 27:13And then you get, that, that whole acting thing, right?
- 27:15When a third of your directors are acting you, you tend to, some people
- 27:20take actings and say, I got this job.
- 27:23I'm gonna do it.
- 27:23Darn it.
- 27:24Others say, Hey, I'm just a temporary I'm the third string quarterback.
- 27:27When the starting quarterback gets back.
- 27:30They're gonna wanna they don't want me to screw it up in these two games
- 27:33I'm gonna play, maybe we can win one, maybe we can lose the other.
- 27:36So that I threw a lot on the table there.
- 27:38You can you, any thoughts on any of that?
- 27:43Geoff Bacino: Still water's definitely a running deep at the agency.
- 27:45You're like you said, the board meetings are not that.
- 27:49That full of melodrama and action and a lot of substance on the,
- 27:54in terms of new regulation.
- 27:55But yeah, there isn't, I've heard the same things.
- 27:57I'm sure the other two gentlemen on the call have heard a lot of,
- 28:00from their friends at the agency.
- 28:03There's a lot of reshuffling and movement around and uncertainty.
- 28:07But I, I've said this, I think when you had us all together last summer I got
- 28:13a, I think I had a moment to say that, the basic blocking and tackling of what
- 28:17the agency is doing seems to be going, from what I hear from credit unions,
- 28:23the exam process continues to move.
- 28:25People are still angry at their a, an examiner sometime,
- 28:28and not angry other times.
- 28:29But I guess what I'm saying is the main mission of the agency is
- 28:32continuing to be fulfilled, obviously.
- 28:36To Alonzo's earlier point, as long as things say stay stable in the economy,
- 28:41Alonzo Swann: yeah,
- 28:41Geoff Bacino: things are gonna be fine.
- 28:42But yeah I think a lot of the internal I've heard some of the uncertainty
- 28:46about the internal machinations has started to affect morale in some spots.
- 28:51But I also notice a lot of people just have gone out the door so that
- 28:54it's not their problem anymore.
- 28:57Treichel: Very true.
- 28:57I said in my emergency podcast, don't worry, it runs itself right?
- 29:01Because there's these delegations of authority that establish, which
- 29:04is equivalent of the Bible, of what you can tell, what you can't do.
- 29:07And that's the blocking and tackling.
- 29:09And even though, and I, every time I talk about losing staff and the challenges
- 29:13of losing all that corporate knowledge, there's a lot of great people at NCA.
- 29:17That are now gonna have new opportunities, there'll be some
- 29:19efficiencies that come out of it.
- 29:21And hey, when you tell a credit union, you're gonna have 30% less
- 29:24examiners in your room for two weeks.
- 29:26That, that sp as a positive, right?
- 29:28Geoff Bacino: You talked about the notation.
- 29:29Vote.
- 29:29I gotta tell you, I will give you a 110% backing on that.
- 29:33I hated notation votes.
- 29:35And when I was at both NCA and then at the finance board, I would really fight like
- 29:39hell to say, look, unless it's fairly.
- 29:42Harmless, and something that's easy to do.
- 29:45I always wanted us to at least discuss it in front of the general public.
- 29:49The last NCA board meeting, John and I were the only civilians there.
- 29:52We were the only non NCA staff, I think if I read the room correctly.
- 29:55That's true.
- 29:56But you are right.
- 29:57They're gonna have to start to do some non-controversial stuff,
- 30:00and whether that's Kyle or his successor I think it's important
- 30:04that you start to set a precedent.
- 30:07Yes.
- 30:07Other than just taking reports and doing some, doing some kind of easy
- 30:11things that the chairman's gonna have to, I think, make some tough calls.
- 30:15And, with the interest rate, with the interest seal up in March, it
- 30:19looks he or she, if it's not Kyle is gonna have to make that call.
- 30:23I guess I would say.
- 30:24Man, I hope it's Kyle, because if that's the first thing you've gotta
- 30:28do when you're taking a job it's gonna make for a tough first week.
- 30:31You guys know what it was like to train us board members.
- 30:34It was not always easy and that first couple weeks, it is literally drinking
- 30:38from a hot fire hose as to what you can can't do, and what you know.
- 30:41Treichel: Said.
- 30:43Guys, we're we're running up against our clock final thoughts.
- 30:47Let's let's start with John in the lower right hand corner here.
- 30:52Geoff Bacino: I think that, again we've laid out and I,
- 30:54and a lot of the uncertainty.
- 30:56Uncertainty's been the watch word here at the agency for a
- 30:59long, for almost a year now.
- 31:02Uncertainty doesn't necessarily mean, instability.
- 31:04But I, 'cause I think that things continue, as I said
- 31:07a minute ago, to function.
- 31:08I think that here it is, early February, I think by by the spring we're gonna
- 31:15start seeing some certainty, at least when it comes to appointments.
- 31:18I think the interest rate ceiling issue will have resolved.
- 31:22Who knows, they're al always jokers in the deck.
- 31:25Who knows what surprises are gonna come.
- 31:26I will say that on the other side of the h the house where I do a lot of business of
- 31:32Capitol Hill credit unions have been very focused on the credit card issues and how,
- 31:37the presidents in two tweets essentially, continue, put all the focus on credit
- 31:43card in the 10% interest rate cap and then the credit card competition act.
- 31:48So those are things that are taking up a lot of oxygen in the congressional sphere.
- 31:53Treichel: Got it.
- 31:54And Alonzo, last thoughts?
- 31:56Alonzo Swann: Yeah, just on the reduction in staffing, and I gotta say this, I
- 31:58think what, I think the adjustment period will, and getting staff up to speed.
- 32:03I think it's happening right now.
- 32:05One of the disappointments that I had quite frankly, when we when
- 32:09NCA brought out merit was it was automating efficiency tool and the
- 32:15agency did not become more efficient.
- 32:18So basically what I say is we got the data faster.
- 32:21NCOA got the data faster got more of it, but instead of.
- 32:27Reducing or looking for other the efficiency of it.
- 32:30We more the agency more so dug deeper, if that makes sense.
- 32:35So instead of being, you got a more efficient digging where we
- 32:39were, so now we can dig deeper.
- 32:41I don't think that was necessary.
- 32:42So I think the reduction will actually put the efficiencies in place as intended.
- 32:48And you take out the reputation risk part of it just.
- 32:51We'll accelerate it, if you will.
- 32:53Treichel: Interesting.
- 32:54And the other merit the thing of merit that I think they could fix,
- 32:57going back what, where Aries was better than merit was the checklist
- 33:01that they shared with credit unions.
- 33:03They put that more in a black box and some of that transparency left.
- 33:06Jeff, final thoughts?
- 33:08Geoff Bacino: I guess as Kevin Bacon said, at the end of Animal House, remain calm.
- 33:14Exactly.
- 33:14And I just figured, pretty soon I think we're gonna have a new chairman
- 33:17and then I think shortly thereafter, once the slaughter case is decided and
- 33:21ruled upon, then I think you probably follow the other two after that.
- 33:25Frankly the back of the White House always continues working on these.
- 33:29If it's like this White House like any others, and I can't speak for
- 33:32it, but they're always working on the nominations and appointments.
- 33:34They know what's open.
- 33:35They know what's ready.
- 33:36They're talking to people.
- 33:37Ideally they're prepared for.
- 33:40They're prepared for what would happen if they win the case, what name or
- 33:44two names do they have to send up?
- 33:46I guess I would echo what John and Alonzo said, and that is, look, the agency is,
- 33:50I don't wanna say running itself, but I think they're continuing to do a good job.
- 33:53'cause I think they know what they do.
- 33:55The things we're hearing are under the surface.
- 33:58And frankly I just think I think some of this gotta give some credit.
- 34:01Getting, give credit to Kyle and to Sarah.
- 34:04For basically understanding, okay, this is our job now, this is how we keep it going.
- 34:08And I think whoever the next chairman is, ideally, I know we kinda made mention
- 34:12is to bring in Sarah along the way that the way that you know, Fri McWaters.
- 34:17Did with Sarah Vega.
- 34:18Maybe it's just in the name, you succeed yourself.
- 34:20But I think having someone that if it's not someone who knows credit unions,
- 34:24it's imperative that they have someone who knows credit unions coming in.
- 34:27'cause it's gonna start day one for whoever takes Kyle's place.
- 34:31Alonzo Swann: And just one more thing mark the agency is blessed,
- 34:34for lack of a better term, to have Larry Fazi on and Kelly Lake.
- 34:39Up in the executive director's spot.
- 34:40Now those are folk who came like me, like you mentioned, who was an examiner and
- 34:45came all the way up through the ranks.
- 34:46So they, they know the agency from the top to the bottom.
- 34:49Treichel: Yeah.
- 34:49There's a lot of corporate knowledge in that office, which can help
- 34:52help run the triage of how do we rebuild from the 27% down.
- 34:56And my last thoughts link back to something John said,
- 34:59the jokers in the deck.
- 35:01My dad played cards a lot.
- 35:02He played poker.
- 35:03He played all sorts of other exotic games and when we were sitting
- 35:05around the table he had this funny line that I always remember.
- 35:10If you asked him what was wild, he said nothing but the dealer.
- 35:15And maybe in the dealer.
- 35:16This, as we circle back to the board.
- 35:19Maybe the dealer's Trump in this instance because what he
- 35:22does can be viewed as wild.
- 35:24So
- 35:26Geoff Bacino: that's great.
- 35:27Treichel: All right guys thank you so much for your time.
- 35:30I know that we wanted to get this done quick and I appreciate
- 35:33you accommodating schedules to.
- 35:35To record this, I'm gonna go finish my coffee.
- 35:37Have a great Thursday.
- 35:38I'm gonna get this episode out today, and we'll get together soon.
- 35:41Thanks so much, guys.
- 35:42Alonzo Swann: Thank you.
- 35:43Take care, guys.
- 35:44Treichel: You got it.
- 35:44And listeners watchers, thank you for watching.
- 35:46This is Mark Trekel signing off with Flying Colors.