Latest / CLEs You Actually Want to Hear / Puerto Rico Tax Incentives: What Is Real, What Is Risky, and What Practitioners Need to Know
Transcript
- 0:03Welcome to Puerto Rico Tax Incentives. What is
- 0:06real? What is risky? And what practitioners need
- 0:09to know. I'm Philipp Beran, chair of the BHBA
- 0:12tax section and also principal at Hochmann Sorkin
- 0:16-Toscha Perez. And Hochmann Sorkin -Toscha Perez
- 0:18is sponsoring the tax section. Hochmann Sorkin
- 0:22is an advantage. Hochmann Sorkin -Toscha Perez's
- 0:26advantage is experience and eye for innovation
- 0:28and a genuine dedication to clients and families.
- 0:31and their business. In addition to their national
- 0:33practice in civil and tax criminal, tax controversies
- 0:37and related litigation in federal and state courts,
- 0:39the firm is also active and successful in handling
- 0:42other non -tax white -collar investigation and
- 0:45prosecution. I'm delighted to introduce our speakers
- 0:48today who join me for this presentation, Jorge
- 0:51Quilan and Jorge Owen Cuadros. Jorge Quilan CPA
- 0:57and serves as Puerto Rico tax director of CFO
- 1:00Associates LLC, where he works with businesses,
- 1:03business owners, multinational entities and high
- 1:06net worth individuals on Puerto Rico and US tax
- 1:09compliance, including matters related to Puerto
- 1:11Rico's incentive tax regime under Act 20, 22
- 1:15and 60. With more than a decade of experience
- 1:19in tax advisory, Hocher has navigated the intersection
- 1:23of US federal tax law in Puerto Rico's unique
- 1:26regulatory environment. Before joining CFO Associates,
- 1:31he served as international tax manager at Zee
- 1:34Strategic Group PR and as tax advisor at BDO
- 1:38Puerto Rico, USVI. He holds a BBA in accounting
- 1:44from the University of Puerto Rico, Rio Piedras.
- 1:48a U .S. international tax certificate from the
- 1:52AICPA, and a postgraduate diploma in transfer
- 1:55pricing from Middlesex University. Jorge Obencuarros
- 2:00is a partner at Pocopio, who advises multinational
- 2:03cooperation, defense contractors, investment
- 2:06funds, high -networth individuals, and family
- 2:08offices, particularly from Latin America, Puerto
- 2:11Rico, and Europe, on U .S. and international
- 2:15tax and trade matters. with a focus on imbalance
- 2:17structuring, cross -border planning, tariff exposure,
- 2:21and tax and trade litigation. Prior to joining
- 2:23Procopio, he serves in the U .S. Internal Revenue
- 2:27Service Office of Associate Chief Counsel International,
- 2:32where he helped draft the Guilty Regulations
- 2:34under Section 951 Cap A, and later as the IRS
- 2:39detailee to the U .S. House and Race, House,
- 2:42Race and Means Committee. contributing to international
- 2:45tax legislation, Puerto Rico, and territory matters,
- 2:50and the energy provisions of the Inflation Reduction
- 2:52Act of 2022. Hover has secured significant results
- 2:57for clients and IAS controversy matters, including
- 2:59penalty abatement and refunds exceeding $850
- 3:02,000 through escalation to the IAS Taxpayer Advocate
- 3:06Service. And now, let's get started. So, we start
- 3:20with the next slide. Oh, can you start with the
- 3:27framework and the history of the Puerto Rican
- 3:31centers? Thank you so much, Philipp and thanks
- 3:34to the Beverly Hills Bar Association for inviting
- 3:36us for this event today. So many of you have
- 3:39heard about Puerto Rico, maybe because you're
- 3:42in California, it could be because of the surfing.
- 3:44Some of you may have also heard about it because
- 3:46of the tax incentives it offers. But these incentives
- 3:49are not necessarily new. As a baseline matter,
- 3:54you can think that, assume this audience is attorneys,
- 3:58accountants, CPAs, tax advisers. We all know
- 4:01that if the U .S. subjects a U .S. person or
- 4:04a resident to tax if they perform services in
- 4:07the United States. So you have a barista making
- 4:11coffees down in Pacific Beach. They will pay
- 4:14federal taxes. I'm not advising in California,
- 4:17but they would potentially pay California taxes,
- 4:19federal taxes. If that same person provided services
- 4:22as a barista in Italy, because the person is
- 4:25a U .S. citizen, the U .S. would also tax it.
- 4:28But what happens when that person likes to serve
- 4:31and opens up a shop in Vincol on the west side
- 4:33of Puerto Rico that looks like the west coast
- 4:35in California? You know, the answer is not that
- 4:38clear. And the answer is not that clear because
- 4:41Puerto Rico is this unique situation, it's a
- 4:43unique political territory, it's a non -incorporated
- 4:46territory of the United States, and the facts
- 4:48matter. By way of background, Puerto Rico has
- 4:52been coming up more and more in the individual
- 4:54perspective since around 2012 when the island
- 4:57enacted some tax incentives. But why does it
- 5:00matter and why are we having this discussion
- 5:02today? Well, as we'll talk about in a few minutes,
- 5:06Puerto Rico has used a recipe that they had done
- 5:08for over 60, 70 years for big companies and since
- 5:122012 they enacted and extended that to individuals.
- 5:16So now folks who move to Puerto Rico, individuals
- 5:19could potentially receive significant tax benefits.
- 5:22So what happens and what is the context that
- 5:24we're dealing with? Again, if you're a US citizen,
- 5:27US resident, the US will potentially subject
- 5:30you to their tax regime. In addition, you could
- 5:33have California taxes as many of the folks in
- 5:36our audience may be advising clients who are
- 5:37residing in California. But as Puerto Rico being
- 5:40a foreign tweeted as a foreign territory, as
- 5:43a foreign jurisdiction for US international tax
- 5:45purposes, the rules change. So the US person
- 5:50will still be sorry to US federal income tax.
- 5:53The island will impose its own tax rules, local
- 5:56rules, which are completely separate and distinct
- 5:58from the US federal rules. And you have a complicated
- 6:01situation in which both overlap and both come
- 6:03together. And if they're not carefully assembled,
- 6:07if you're not carefully attacked or approached,
- 6:11you end up in a situation in which you have multiple
- 6:13taxes going into effect and not the outcome that
- 6:16we want. But what has happened in the last few
- 6:19years? For about 13 years Puerto Rico has enacted
- 6:22these benefits that Jorge will get into in more
- 6:24detail, but effectively if you move to Puerto
- 6:26Rico, you really move, you establish residency,
- 6:29again we're going to get into the details, this
- 6:31is just an overview, you can get outside of the
- 6:33federal income tax fisc of the individual and
- 6:36not be subject to federal income tax. Again,
- 6:38the caveat for California, because it is a very
- 6:41known taxing authority, you have to do a separate
- 6:44analysis for California residency that we've
- 6:47been talking to a little bit, and Phil is going
- 6:49to chime in in details. But you're subject to
- 6:52federal income tax as an individual, but you're
- 6:55excluded because you're a bona fide resident
- 6:56of Puerto Rico. And then you turn over to Jorge,
- 6:59who will tell you how Puerto Rico is going to
- 7:01tax that. Well, Puerto Rico is going to impose
- 7:03its own revenue code, which actually mirrors
- 7:041954 that's been subject to multiple changes
- 7:08since then, but it's based out of that code,
- 7:10so many of the principles are similar, and Puerto
- 7:13Rico will generally tax you under their own rules.
- 7:16However, since 2012, the island has extended
- 7:19these incentives. Basically, you can say, if
- 7:21you move to Puerto Rico and you comply with all
- 7:23these requirements, we'll give you a preferential
- 7:25tax rate. So what has to happen for this to come
- 7:29together? Well, you have to break residency in
- 7:32the United States. You have to meet the requirements
- 7:35in Puerto Rico. You have to look at your current
- 7:39state site situation, whether it's California,
- 7:42whether it's Florida, or it's Texas. Some of
- 7:44these jurisdictions are more complicated than
- 7:46others. In California, in particular, it's very
- 7:48hard to break residency. So it takes some time
- 7:50to plan and get into it with the proper precautions.
- 7:55So you might get calls from clients say, hey,
- 7:59I went to Puerto Rico for a trip and I heard
- 8:01about these incentives and I think I want to
- 8:03move down there. I'm actually looking for an
- 8:06investment banker to sell my business and we
- 8:08might get an offer by Q4. Can I just move down
- 8:11and exclude all the gain from federal income
- 8:14taxes and or California federal taxes? Well,
- 8:16it's not that easy. You might also get a question
- 8:19like, hey, can I just move there for one or three
- 8:22days and get the benefits? No, that's also not
- 8:25the case. Again, you have to break residency
- 8:28in the United States. You potentially have to
- 8:30break residency in your current state if it's
- 8:33a state that imposes income taxes. And then you
- 8:35got to make sure that you meet the Puerto Rico
- 8:37requirements if you are going to pursue a tax
- 8:40decree or the tax incentives. And moving to Puerto
- 8:44Rico with a lot of tax incentives and not necessarily
- 8:47a tax -efficient situation as the standard regular
- 8:51graduated tax returns in Puerto Rico are also
- 8:53pretty high. Thinking about Puerto Rico and what's
- 9:00the storyline here? So Puerto Rico has been doing
- 9:02tax incentives since 1947. Puerto Rico was an
- 9:07agricultural economy. And in the earlier years
- 9:10of the 50s, the US government decided to pivot
- 9:14Puerto Rico's economy into a more industrial
- 9:16economy. And since then, the US and Puerto Rico
- 9:20had worked in tandem to create incentives in
- 9:22which companies would be totally or partially
- 9:25exempted from US tax. and Puerto Rico taxes on
- 9:27income generated by a select number of companies
- 9:30who created jobs and invested in the island.
- 9:34So typically, the benefits were created to incentivize
- 9:37development locally, to foster jobs, build school,
- 9:41build parks, build roads. And that was the idea
- 9:44behind this thing. Again, that started in 1947.
- 9:47Through the years, and in particular in 1976,
- 9:51the U .S. Congress enacted was the Possession
- 9:53Tax Credit or Section 936 as many of you may
- 9:56have heard or known it's no longer in effect.
- 9:59But this provision effectively gave U .S. companies
- 10:03a tax credit in the United States for whatever
- 10:07their tax liability would be with respect to
- 10:10their income generated in Puerto Rico. So think
- 10:13about the biggest pharmaceutical companies in
- 10:15the world, the biggest manufacturing companies
- 10:18in the world. They bring They move operations
- 10:22to Puerto Rico. They hire 4 ,000 employees. They
- 10:25build schools. It's great for Puerto Rico. It's
- 10:27great for US citizens who live in Puerto Rico.
- 10:30And it's good for the economy because the companies
- 10:32can produce all these goods, whether it's medicine
- 10:35or manufactured items at a reduced rate. And
- 10:41then we're building a stronger United States.
- 10:44With time, the pharmaceutical companies started
- 10:47to relocate international property. and using
- 10:50the incentives to protect taxes or get more tax
- 10:56-efficient outcomes in search of property and
- 10:59other assets not associated or income not associated
- 11:04to investment on the island or employment, which
- 11:08led to the tension that happened for many, many
- 11:10years until eventually at the end of 1995, Congress
- 11:14repealed Section 936 with a 10 -year face -down.
- 11:18And why does it matter? Because that thing you're
- 11:21face -down, while there is no specific economic
- 11:24data that can prove this, could potentially have
- 11:27caused the bankruptcy of the island in 2012 that
- 11:32eventually led to this Act 2022 as we're talking
- 11:35about the tax incentives in Puerto Rico. So Puerto
- 11:38Rico had been doing incentives for the longest
- 11:40time. Again, it was the biggest companies that
- 11:43were doing this, the Merck's, Johnson & Johnson's,
- 11:45Eli Lilly's. and they were producing, I think
- 11:49there's a report that 17 of the 20 most prescribed
- 11:54medications in the United States were manufactured
- 11:56in Puerto Rico during all those years. So we're
- 11:59talking massive amounts of revenue. There was
- 12:01a lot of employment, a lot of investment in the
- 12:03island. The bond they get stripped, the island
- 12:06loses unemployment, many companies divest from
- 12:09Puerto Rico and the island suffers from a massive
- 12:13brain drain of most folks who are or many folks
- 12:16who are in the younger early stages of their
- 12:17career. So Puerto Rico reacts and Puerto Rico
- 12:20reacts by creating the Act 20 and Act 22, the
- 12:24Act 22 acts which basically incentivize individual
- 12:27investors to relocate to Puerto Rico and establish
- 12:30local operations that provides export services.
- 12:33So services to folks or other companies outside
- 12:36of Puerto Rico. with the idea that that's going
- 12:38to move the economy, there's going to be more
- 12:40work, there's going to be people going out and
- 12:41dining, there's going to be people buying properties,
- 12:43there's going to be people going to school, buying
- 12:46cars, and that's the background to where we are
- 12:49today. Jorge, can you talk us through what exactly
- 12:52Puerto Rico did? Sure Jorge, and thank you for
- 12:58the opportunity and to Beverly Hills Bar Association
- 13:01for having me here. So essentially, you know,
- 13:07Jorge has basically laid out the context to how
- 13:10these incentives are available. So, you know,
- 13:15first the vehicle to get it is the decree, which
- 13:18there's a common misconception that you get the
- 13:22decree and then basically you don't have to comply
- 13:25with anything else. Like, you know, getting the
- 13:27decree is just a step one. It is handled by an
- 13:32agency that is not the agency that collects the
- 13:35income tax in Puerto Rico, which is the Puerto
- 13:38Rico Treasury Department. We call it ASEAN. That
- 13:40is the equivalent to the Puerto Rico IRS. So
- 13:43the decree is the local incentive. It starts
- 13:46the analysis. It is handled by the Office of
- 13:49Incentives of the Puerto Rico Economic Development
- 13:53Department. And basically, it is anchored on
- 13:57the fact that you can meet the different federal
- 14:00tests related to residency. So the idea here
- 14:05is that even though it is based on the exclusion
- 14:10from Puerto Rico sourced income provided by the
- 14:14U .S. Internal Revenue Code section 933, it does
- 14:17not bind the IRS. It's a local filing, it's a
- 14:20contract actually between the individual or the
- 14:24company and the Puerto Rico government, and it
- 14:27has a specific clauses that that individual or
- 14:31company needs to comply. So what that also means
- 14:35is that, and I'll explain in a little bit more
- 14:37detail in the next slides, it does not prevent
- 14:41U .S. tax. And this is something that the IRS
- 14:43is looking carefully because you want to make
- 14:46sure that anything that appreciated before moving
- 14:49to Puerto Rico is still taxed by the IRS. Also,
- 14:55any source of income item that is sourced to
- 14:59the US, mainly interest and dividends that are
- 15:02being paid by US sources or payers are also taxed
- 15:09by the IRS. So, Puerto Rico won't tax it, but
- 15:13you have to be careful of what is actually sourced
- 15:16to Puerto Rico in order to make sure that you
- 15:19cover the federal tax liability associated to
- 15:22it. So now, I will get into a little bit more
- 15:28detail of what's actually in Deliquity. So here,
- 15:35the way I'm presenting it is that we're going
- 15:39to focus on the investors and the export services.
- 15:42I mean, Act 60 has a plethora of industries that
- 15:47it serves, but the ones that we're going to focus
- 15:50on, the ones that are attracting most of the
- 15:53activity right now, inbound to Puerto Rico is
- 15:56the investors and the export services. For investors,
- 16:00there is currently a regime in place until the
- 16:04end of the year. So it's the 0 % that's been
- 16:07available since the enactment of Act 22 back
- 16:10in 2012. That one is going to sunset at the end
- 16:13of the year. But remember that is on the appreciation
- 16:18after becoming a resident. Same goes with the
- 16:21interest and dividends. Those won't be taxed
- 16:24by Puerto Rico, no matter their source, but then
- 16:28they will be taxed by the IRS if they are U .S.
- 16:31sourced. It's the same concept. Now, the way
- 16:35I'm dividing it in the slides is that the new
- 16:39regime will apply for those who apply for a decree
- 16:44up on January 1, 2027. So it's the same concept
- 16:48with the 0 % post -Move capital gains. But now
- 16:52it will be a 4 % preferential rate. Then one
- 16:58thing to keep in mind, and based on what we've
- 17:00been discussing, is that anything that will be
- 17:04pre -move gains will remain taxable in the US
- 17:07when real. And then since Puerto Rico has a worldwide
- 17:12income taxation regime, these will also be taxable
- 17:17by Puerto Rico. you will have the ability to
- 17:21claim a credit for taxes paid to the US, so there's
- 17:24not going to be double taxation. But generally
- 17:28speaking, the Puerto Rico tax rates tend to be
- 17:30higher, so that it's not going to be a dollar
- 17:32by dollar credit. But good to keep in mind. Then
- 17:37those pre -move gains, if they are ordinary,
- 17:41if they are short -term gains, they are going
- 17:43to be taxed at ordinary rates in Puerto Rico.
- 17:45We're talking about 33 % max rate or capital
- 17:49gains exceeding $60 ,000 approximately. And then
- 17:55if it's a long -term gain, it will be taxed at
- 17:5815 % and it can be 24 % if that long -term gain
- 18:02exceeds $250 ,000. Then eligibility, basically
- 18:09it has also changed with the new regime that
- 18:12applies next year because it is broadening the
- 18:15basis of the individuals that would be subject.
- 18:18But right now, the eligibility is that you must
- 18:22not have lived in Puerto Rico between January
- 18:2417, 2006, and January 17, 2012. And again, that's
- 18:29for those who apply by the end of the year. And
- 18:33then if you apply next year, the blackout period
- 18:36is that you must not have lived in Puerto Rico
- 18:39for six years before your actual move to Puerto
- 18:41Rico. So again, it's an effort from the government
- 18:44to amplify the the benefit or the pool of investors
- 18:49that would be eligible. Then as to the validity
- 18:53of the decree, under the current regime, they
- 18:57are going to sunset on December 31, 2035. So
- 19:01once you get the decree, it is valid until then.
- 19:04And then for those who apply under the new regime
- 19:06next year, then it will be valid until December
- 19:0931, 2055. So as opposed to export services companies,
- 19:16Individual investors degrees don't have a term
- 19:19per se, but rather a sunset clause. And it can
- 19:23be extended if new legislation is enacted for
- 19:27it. Then as to the requirements per se, it's
- 19:34a 10 ,000 charitable contribution to a specific
- 19:37nonprofits. It applies upon the degree's second
- 19:40year. And there's a specific list of qualified
- 19:43nonprofits that need to be donated to, then the
- 19:48annual report, and this is the most critical
- 19:51compliance item. I mean, like, it is typical
- 19:56for the government to revoke your grant if you
- 19:59don't actually file those annual reports. So
- 20:03it's very important that you file them. And the
- 20:06same goes with export service companies. Can
- 20:10you go back to the prior slide, please, Suzanne?
- 20:14Sorry. Okay, so and then the last requirement
- 20:18for individual investors is buying a property
- 20:20in Puerto Rico. It doesn't need to be of a specific
- 20:23amount or type. I mean, although it has to be
- 20:28your primary residence. It's the use that you
- 20:30give to it that the government is looking for
- 20:32and they give you two years after the degree
- 20:35is approved to purchase it. So now in the same
- 20:41slide, Chapter 3 export services, This one doesn't
- 20:44have a new regime starting next year, so it remains
- 20:48a 4 % flat Puerto Rico income tax rate on net
- 20:51income from qualifying expert services. There
- 20:54could be a 2 % for five years if the company
- 20:57is a new small and medium -sized business, which
- 20:59essentially is a company that generates less
- 21:02than $2 million in gross revenues. The main requirement
- 21:05is that the services must be rendered for use
- 21:07outside Puerto Rico, so it cannot have any nexus
- 21:10to Puerto Rico. and it has to be consumed out
- 21:14of Puerto Rico. Then the way you can operate
- 21:18is through a Puerto Rico Register entity or an
- 21:21entity that is not Puerto Rico Register, but
- 21:23is authorized to be visited in Puerto Rico. Individuals
- 21:28also are eligible for the expert services, although
- 21:30it's not common to apply as an individual. Then
- 21:35the decree as to the term is for 15 years. and
- 21:39it can be extended for 15 additional years. So
- 21:42as opposed to the investors, it has an actual
- 21:46term that can be extended. As to the services
- 21:49that are eligible, we're talking about mainly
- 21:52virtually any service, including export trade
- 21:56companies. As to the requirements, it's one employee
- 22:01will be mandatory, so it's generous. If gross
- 22:04revenue exceeds $3 million, Then once again,
- 22:07the annual reports need to be filed by November
- 22:0915. That's super important. The filing fee is
- 22:12lower than for investors. And that annual report
- 22:16is going to gather all the requirements of the
- 22:20degree, including the different annual Puerto
- 22:23Rico tax filings and requirements. Because remember
- 22:25that this agency is only to maintain your degree.
- 22:29But then there's three additional agencies, namely
- 22:33the Puerto Rico municipalities, the Puerto Rico
- 22:36State Department and the Puerto Rico Treasury
- 22:38that is going to require annual findings as well
- 22:42in order for the grant to be in good stead. So
- 22:44there's always got to be more items to cross
- 22:47locally than federally in most cases. And then
- 22:52lastly, the accounting books need to identify
- 22:55the eligible service income. There are cases
- 22:57where there's non -eligible service income as
- 22:59well that needs to be identified. And again,
- 23:03that is a requirement that stems from those groups.
- 23:08So now, going to the decree compliance slide.
- 23:14Basically, the application is filed online through
- 23:17the incentives portal. And again, it's of the
- 23:20Office of Incentives that deals with the decrees.
- 23:23The filing fee is $5 ,005 for resident investors.
- 23:26It's lower for expert service entities, $1 ,005.
- 23:30the fee is paid simultaneously with the filing.
- 23:33So if the filing goes true, it means that you
- 23:36paid the fee. As to the timing of the decree
- 23:39issuance, it is issued within 12 to 18 months
- 23:42based on experience. And the decree, this is
- 23:46very important as well. You don't need to, I
- 23:50mean, not only you need to have the paper, but
- 23:52you actually have to formally accept it within
- 23:5460 days after receipt. Otherwise it becomes null
- 23:56and void. And again, it's part of the different
- 23:58clauses that are typical in the brands. Then
- 24:03likewise, in the case of investors, you have
- 24:06to notify the residency. We generally have a
- 24:09year after decree approval to make the move.
- 24:12And again, it's another formality that is needed
- 24:15for the decree to become effective. Expert services
- 24:19companies similarly need to notify the commencement
- 24:22of operations because that will determine when
- 24:25the different tax benefits will apply for income
- 24:29tax purposes, gross receipts tax purposes, personal
- 24:33property tax purposes. Those are the main ones
- 24:36that are going to or need to be consistent across
- 24:40the board in terms of when you actually commence
- 24:43operations. And once again, I cannot reiterate
- 24:47more than filing the annual reports is critical
- 24:49because based on experience, that's the low hanging
- 24:52fruit the government is looking for. And it's
- 24:56a commonality that grantees, in certain years,
- 25:00they fail to file their reports. So it is very
- 25:04important to keep that in mind. Jorge, while
- 25:07you're talking about these points, something
- 25:09comes to mind that I think we typically forget
- 25:13when we're talking to potential clients. Stay
- 25:15tight. To understand Puerto Rico, there is our
- 25:20Puerto Rico Treasury Department, which is the
- 25:22equivalent of both Treasury and the IRS. But
- 25:25there is this office, the Department of Economic
- 25:28Development and Commerce, which has been there
- 25:30for, again, over 50, 60, 70 years that handles
- 25:33tax incentives, as part of several other operations.
- 25:37But it's its own agency, and it works alongside
- 25:40the Department of Treasury, the Hacienda, in
- 25:42Puerto Rico, but it's a different agency. And
- 25:45you do have to work with all these stakeholders
- 25:47to get everything in order because it's not like
- 25:50some other jurisdictions in which you qualify
- 25:53for an incentive and you just file your tax return
- 25:56taking the benefit. These actually require proactive
- 25:59actions. You need to file the tax grant application.
- 26:03You have ongoing maintenance that you have to
- 26:05comply with and at the expense of not getting
- 26:08the benefits. And the Puerto Rican government
- 26:10has recently been more proactive. in revoking
- 26:13some of these grants if the taxpayer or grantee
- 26:16holder does not comply with the requirements.
- 26:18It is a legal binding agreement that the grantee
- 26:22enters into with the government and it's contractual
- 26:26in nature. So any reason to terminate the contract
- 26:29for non -compliance would be taken seriously.
- 26:34Certainly, Jorge. No, again, reading the decree
- 26:37once you get it is critical. and you need to
- 26:41act upon it because, again, just having an approved
- 26:43and signed decree is no guarantee of being able
- 26:47to get that benefit. You have to formally accept
- 26:49it, and then on an annual basis, you have to
- 26:52renew it, practically speaking. So, yes, that's
- 26:58the reality. So, Jorge, I'll let you take it
- 27:01from here again regarding bona fide residency.
- 27:03Yeah, and maybe I'll just add a few more points
- 27:06on that. So, the deed I can assume To the surprise
- 27:09of many, including myself, is in a very good
- 27:12position from a technical and technology perspective.
- 27:15Unlike the IRS, they have really modern systems.
- 27:17They have live information sharing. They are
- 27:20doing a lot of tracking of who is applying. They
- 27:24are also working in tandem with the Internal
- 27:26Revenue Service for anyone who runs afoul of
- 27:29any federal tax issues stateside. So while the
- 27:34island is in need for additional capital and
- 27:36it's been struggling financially, through our
- 27:39financial crisis for a decade or so, it is running
- 27:42a tight ship when it comes to the T -deck and
- 27:44when it comes to the Puerto Rico Treasury Department.
- 27:47So some folks find that surprising that everything
- 27:50is digital, everything is electronic. Or as you
- 27:52mentioned, you file this electronically. It is
- 27:55a good system and they have really good stuff
- 27:58running the operations on the island. One additional
- 28:01point that I do want to clarify, because we jumped
- 28:06in and pressed my fault. So when we had in this
- 28:09slide, the preceded this one, Act 60, it is because
- 28:12in 2019, the government of Puerto Rico, the Legislative
- 28:16Assembly combined all these different tax incentive
- 28:19provisions into what's called the Tax Incentives
- 28:21Code. So that's why we now have Chapter 2, Chapter
- 28:243. We have, I joke about this, but it's like
- 28:28a cheesecake factory with many of incentives.
- 28:30You have filming incentive, which are very relevant
- 28:32to companies and stakeholders in LA or Los Angeles,
- 28:38that you have incentives for movie, for musical
- 28:40performances, for expert services, you have grant
- 28:43for young new entrepreneurs, and the government
- 28:47just combined everything into a single code that
- 28:51would simplify its use. Again, prior to 2012,
- 28:55many of these provisions and benefits were only
- 28:58granted to a handful of companies, the biggest,
- 29:01most profitable companies, and it wasn't until
- 29:032012 that this changed. And that's actually one
- 29:06of the reasons it's become so sensitive from
- 29:09an IRS perspective. Before 2012, the people who
- 29:13were benefiting from these incentives were big
- 29:15companies that presumably were hiring folks on
- 29:18the island that were investing on the island.
- 29:21In 2012, when this pivots into individual investors,
- 29:25the number just skyrockets. And it only skyrockets
- 29:28with very wealthy folks who represent a lot of
- 29:32tax revenue for the US government. So the IRS
- 29:35has felt the change and the relocation of some
- 29:40of these individuals to the island. And it's
- 29:43drawn some scrutiny because although many folks
- 29:48are doing things correctly, there have been a
- 29:51number of known cases in which the IRS has found,
- 29:54along with the Department of Justice, cases in
- 29:56which the rules have not been followed, and in
- 30:00some cases even intentionally. when these events
- 30:04start showing up or coming up, there's been a
- 30:07lot of congressional oversight. There's been
- 30:09a lot of stakeholder oversight. There's been
- 30:11a lot of public protests against the situation.
- 30:15And then there's also folks at the IRS who have
- 30:18the responsibility to make sure that the rules
- 30:21of the eternal revenue quota are followed as
- 30:23they should. So that is a little bit of the background
- 30:25here as to why there is so much pressure into
- 30:29doing this right. And it works. the tax incentives
- 30:32of relocation, everything works if it's done
- 30:34correctly. And what that means is that you really
- 30:37meet the rules that we're going to talk about
- 30:39now, that you really look into the character
- 30:40of the income that you're generating, that you
- 30:42really go through the documentation and you keep
- 30:44everything properly documented. So what is the
- 30:50first area that you should all be thinking about
- 30:53when you're thinking about Puerto Rico? The first
- 30:56question you get I will be in the island in 183
- 30:59days and then I come back to my house in Laguna
- 31:01Beach. Doesn't work that way. The residency test
- 31:06under section 937 has three prongs. Presence,
- 31:10the tax home, and the closer connection. The
- 31:12presence test says that yes, you have to be physically
- 31:15present on the island for at least 183 days.
- 31:19And the general rules day for day, looking back,
- 31:22there's a proportionate rule that goes back one
- 31:25year back, two years back. but effectively you
- 31:27do have to go to the island. You might be surprised
- 31:31or maybe not but there are some folks who have
- 31:33insisted that they want to apply for tax benefits
- 31:36but they don't want to move to the island. It
- 31:38doesn't work and it doesn't work and if you even
- 31:41try that and you get caught the consequences
- 31:43could be very very bad. Several years ago the
- 31:47USVI had this platform in which they invited
- 31:52folks to move to the island And the IRS had a
- 31:55number of significant wins with those folks in
- 31:58those cases. And the main issue was that folks
- 32:00were not relocated to the USVI. So after those
- 32:04successful litigation and cases, they have that
- 32:07script already drawn up. And they're using the
- 32:10same rules and principles that they used back
- 32:12then for these battles. And the IRS has actually
- 32:16gathered more information. There's more information
- 32:18sharing at the moment. They have more resources
- 32:20from a technology perspective. There's information
- 32:23sharing with Puerto Rico. They have a really
- 32:26thorough ability to gather information. So you
- 32:29do have to be on the aisle. The second issue,
- 32:32the second prong is a tax home. Where do you
- 32:35have your primary place of business? Where are
- 32:36you providing services? If you have an office
- 32:40in Puerto Rico, if you are working from home,
- 32:42you have to prove that you've been there. You
- 32:43have to prove that you don't have a tax home.
- 32:46state side. It means that you're really engaged
- 32:48in a business and the tax home is defined as
- 32:51the place where you have your permanent place
- 32:52of business. The third one is potentially the
- 32:56most sensitive and complicated one. It's a closer
- 32:59connection. And why is it complicated? It's because
- 33:02there's not a single dispositive factor that
- 33:06will tell you whether you are a bona fide resident
- 33:08of Puerto Rico or you're not a bona fide resident
- 33:10of Puerto Rico. So the general case baseline
- 33:13scenario you move to Puerto Rico, you comply
- 33:16with the days, you do have your taxes in Puerto
- 33:19Rico, but if you're married, you have children,
- 33:22young children, and you own a house in Malibu,
- 33:25your wife stays behind, your kids are still in
- 33:27California, you still own that house, you're
- 33:29still part of the country club, you're part of
- 33:31the sailing club, and you only go to Puerto Rico
- 33:34for a couple of days working a co -work office,
- 33:39that is not going to be enough, and the IRS is
- 33:41going to strike that down. because you really
- 33:43have to move, you really have to demonstrate
- 33:45that your closer connection is to the island.
- 33:48You have to sever those ties. For instance, one
- 33:51question that I work with quite a bit with some
- 33:54clients, some of them are less attached to their
- 33:57homes. They feel that they have their kids raised
- 34:00in those houses. Ideally, you would want to either
- 34:03sell the property or rent it, not Airbnb, not
- 34:06VRBO, but send it a long -term lease that you
- 34:09don't have access. So if you do have access to
- 34:12the property, it creates a problem for your closer
- 34:15connection test. And again, one single factor
- 34:18is not going to be this positive, but you will
- 34:20have an issue. So what are the things that the
- 34:23IRS look at? Recent information document requests
- 34:27ask for a lot of information. They ask for your
- 34:30calendar. They ask for travel ticket dates. When
- 34:33were you on the island? Show me your flight tickets.
- 34:36Show me your records. Show me your credit card
- 34:37statements. Show me that you have signed up for
- 34:41a local club. Show me that you've canceled your
- 34:44clubs in the other where you formerly resided.
- 34:49Potential issues, closer connection. You were
- 34:52a partner in a US business that is a partnership
- 34:55and you're providing services from Puerto Rico.
- 34:58You are potentially still a partner in a US business.
- 35:01That is a problem. a big issue, your family stays
- 35:05behind and you visit them every other weekend
- 35:08for two days. So, assessing bona fide residency
- 35:13really requires that you sever your ties and
- 35:16move to Puerto Rico. And the biggest tool that
- 35:21you can have at this stage for your own protection
- 35:24is to have contemporaneous documentation. keep
- 35:28good records, work on memos that state when you
- 35:31were on the island, what you did, when you need
- 35:34your agreement, when you buy your property. And
- 35:36that's something we've been doing for a number
- 35:37of plants. And it's really helpful when you get
- 35:40a letter from the IRS, because in these cases,
- 35:44we're going to talk about in an enforcement section,
- 35:46there is an IRS campaign into folks who relocate
- 35:49to Puerto Rico. So what I tell folks is that
- 35:52whether you are going to be audited or examined
- 35:54or subject to an examination, it's When are you
- 35:56going to be serving to examination? And these
- 35:59processes usually take some time. So it might
- 36:01be a couple of years before you get back from
- 36:02the IRS. And the best thing to have is a memo
- 36:05that has all your facts, all the exhibits, all
- 36:08the documentation necessary ready to be delivered
- 36:10so you are proactive about any efforts. Can we
- 36:14go to the next slide? So again, important tools
- 36:18that you can do now is gather your travel statements,
- 36:21build a folder, build a file. When you move to
- 36:24Puerto Rico, It is typical that your family will
- 36:29stay behind, maybe finishing the semester, maybe
- 36:32waiting for you to get the house ready, maybe
- 36:34waiting for you to get a car, maybe getting some
- 36:37roots established before you bring them over.
- 36:40And that is fine for a little bit. But as more
- 36:43time goes by, it becomes more problematic and
- 36:45more risky. So think about, does it make sense
- 36:49that it's been three years and your family still
- 36:51lives in your former home, they're still together
- 36:53and you haven't broken that tie? Again, the financial
- 36:58statements are very important. Has your credit
- 37:00card been really used in Puerto Rico or are you
- 37:04making top transactions somewhere else? Ideally,
- 37:08you would get a bank account in Puerto Rico and
- 37:10you would use a local bank. You would actually
- 37:12get a local driver's license registered to go
- 37:16surrender your former driver's license, work
- 37:21from a... work for a local business, not have
- 37:24a working employment relationship with a U .S.
- 37:27company or U .S. partnership, and then keep good
- 37:29records, keep good records of everything. Let's
- 37:33see. We can move on to the next slide. So, phase
- 37:40one, let's call it baseball. First phase, you
- 37:44do prove that you're a U .S. Puerto Rico Bonafide
- 37:47resident. That by itself is just one third of
- 37:51the way. to get the benefits and being a defensible
- 37:54position with the Internal Revenue Service. The
- 37:57second thing you would want to do is assess your
- 38:01financial situation. And the way I approach this
- 38:04with clients and prospective clients, so once
- 38:08we determine that you are one of our residents
- 38:09of Puerto Rico, let's evaluate your current structure.
- 38:13How are you going to be subject to tax in Puerto
- 38:15Rico and in the United States if you keep your
- 38:19structure as it is? And to do that, you really
- 38:22have to go down into the details and you have
- 38:23to break down each of the items of increment
- 38:26assets to determine their character. And what
- 38:29are the character? Character could be services,
- 38:32could be interest, could be dividends, could
- 38:33be personal property gain, royalties, and sales
- 38:36from inventory. And they all have special rules.
- 38:40And one of the common situations that many advisors
- 38:43tripped on initially, when the rules became more
- 38:47popular and more people were relocating to Puerto
- 38:48Rico, under internal uh internal revenue code
- 38:52when a person sells personal property the sale
- 38:58is deemed at the residence of the seller and
- 39:02that is that is the rule if you move to mexico
- 39:04if you live in argentina if you live in norway
- 39:06if you go to belgium if you're in france if you're
- 39:10in australia but that is not the case if you
- 39:13move to puerto rico and you were a u .s resident
- 39:15or you are a u .s citizen before the move so
- 39:19for services the general rule is where the services
- 39:22perform. If you're providing services from Puerto
- 39:25Rico, those services, the income generated for
- 39:29those services will not be generally served to
- 39:31U .S. tax if you're a bona fide resident of Puerto
- 39:33Rico, and Jorge will work with you on establishing
- 39:35a structure that would maximize how they are
- 39:38taxed on the island. Interest. If you have an
- 39:42interest from, let's say, a bank in New York,
- 39:45it'll be interest sourced in the United States,
- 39:48subject to tax in the United States. which would
- 39:51make your failure to tax return included as your
- 39:53source income. However, if you have interest
- 39:56in a U .S. company than a Puerto Rico company,
- 39:59it would be for topical source. Dividends is
- 40:03a really interesting one and it's important because
- 40:05part of the typical structuring for Puerto Rico
- 40:07incentives involves dividends from an expert
- 40:10services company to an individual investor resident
- 40:13of the island, which are generally eligible for
- 40:16tax incentives. but if you do receive a dividend
- 40:19from a U .S. corporation, that dividend will
- 40:23be typically U .S. source income. I'm going to
- 40:27leave personal property gain for last. Royalties,
- 40:30you generated this code. It's very helpful. It
- 40:33will tell us how to solve the math on the most
- 40:36complicated issues and it'll solve many illnesses.
- 40:40It'll be sourced where the IP is used. It'll
- 40:43be sourced if it's yours in Puerto Rico for an
- 40:46expert service company. it'll be Puerto Rico
- 40:48source. If you are licensing that IP to a company
- 40:52in Beverly Hills, it'll be California source
- 40:55income, US source income, so to the United States.
- 40:58Inventory produced property, that'll be dependent
- 41:01on special rules for inventory, depending on
- 41:03where it's manufactured, what goes into the work,
- 41:05be 50 -50. There are other special rules for
- 41:08that. But then going to personal property, which
- 41:11becomes one of the most important items of income
- 41:14when folks are evaluating relocation to Puerto
- 41:17Rico. The typical question that I've gotten maybe
- 41:21a dozen times in the last 12 months, I am about
- 41:24to sell my business. I want to move to Puerto
- 41:26Rico very soon so I can take incentives on all
- 41:31the gain. It doesn't work like that. And it doesn't
- 41:35work like that because there's a special rule
- 41:38that applies, again, if you were a resident of
- 41:41the United States, which will tell you any pre
- 41:43-move gain will be resourced rather than Puerto
- 41:47Rico as a US source gain. And then you can make
- 41:51an election depending on the asset to treat it
- 41:53as if it's a marketable security, you could get
- 41:57a mark to market the gain and then identify the
- 42:01pre -move and the post -move. If it's not a marketable
- 42:04gain, there's an allocation that we'll touch
- 42:07base and discuss in a little bit, but we can
- 42:08move to the next slide. So when looking at the
- 42:13character and when looking at the items of income
- 42:17to determine whether this makes sense and whether
- 42:19it works, you need to determine who performed
- 42:22the services, where decisions were made. We have
- 42:26a number of fund stakeholders considering moving
- 42:30to that, and whether it's investors, whether
- 42:32it's fund managers, you need to determine where
- 42:35the decisions were made. And it could have different
- 42:38consequences If the fund is a US fund and the
- 42:42person is in Puerto Rico, you potentially cause
- 42:46the fund to be treated as having a trader business
- 42:48in Puerto Rico. One key point here, Puerto Rico
- 42:51does not have any tax treaties, so you wouldn't
- 42:53be establishing a permanent establishment. It
- 42:55would be a trader business and it would follow
- 42:57similar principles than the principles used by
- 43:00the Internet of Revenue Code in the United States.
- 43:02But similarly, you might want to be careful that
- 43:05you're not treating or creating a Puerto Rican
- 43:08fund as having a trade or business in the States.
- 43:12A very, very important point, especially when
- 43:14you're looking at expert services. If you are
- 43:17providing expert services to a related party,
- 43:20an entity that you also own or that you have
- 43:23an affiliation with, are those payments priced
- 43:26at the same price that someone who's not related
- 43:29would price them? Are they arm's length? For
- 43:31that, you should and probably should very likely
- 43:35get a transfer pricing report, get a pricing
- 43:37study. Make sure that the terms are what some
- 43:40other people would pay for the same transaction.
- 43:44And then substance over four. The IRS will follow
- 43:47the substance. If you call something a license,
- 43:51a royalty, it has to be supported by the treatment
- 43:54that you're giving it. Again, red flags, it has
- 43:58to happen. It can be paper only. You can't keep
- 44:01the same ties. One thing that I've seen on a
- 44:04number of occasions, you seek advice of a tax
- 44:07advisor, but the advisor doesn't specifically
- 44:10address your facts or your situation, which becomes
- 44:13less valuable in the case of an examination from
- 44:15the IRS. And then it's good to be proactive and
- 44:18contemporaneous. It loses the value when things
- 44:22are done retroactively. Okay, next slide, please.
- 44:28So going to the baseline for, we can go one more.
- 44:33Going to the rule for personal property tenure
- 44:36look back rules. So if you're moving to Puerto
- 44:38Rico and you do have personal property, again,
- 44:41let's think about stocking a business that you're
- 44:44about to sell. If it's not marketable, it's not
- 44:47publicly listed, you don't have a market value
- 44:49for that. You could elect to treat the gain per
- 44:53rata. Puerto Rico source was a US source based
- 44:55on the proportionate days if you tell that as
- 44:58a resident of Puerto Rico versus your entire
- 45:00holding period. If it's marketable, you can market
- 45:03the value as of the date you established residency
- 45:08in Puerto Rico, and that'll be relevant for your
- 45:11analysis. It is the rule. The IRS has actually
- 45:15issued a number of guidance after this has become
- 45:20an issue, and it's now very clear that this is
- 45:23the position on the government. despite some
- 45:26questions that might exist. And Philipp, do you
- 45:28want to comment a little bit on how this comes
- 45:30into effect for crypto? Yes, who knows me knows
- 45:35that I can talk about crypto forever. So I will
- 45:38keep it short. But if we are going to the 10
- 45:42year look back period is one of the stepping
- 45:44stones always. But if we are going to the next
- 45:47slide to the crypto slide and The first start
- 45:51you're doing is you're starting with a character
- 45:53before you even start with sourcing. Crypto is
- 45:56property, and we know that since 2014. But that
- 46:02only begins the analysis. So the 2014 -21 notice
- 46:06that says crypto is property does not tell us
- 46:09what kind of property it is. So that only begins
- 46:12the analysis. The text result depends on whether
- 46:15the item is a sale gain, ordinary gain, service
- 46:19income, mining income, staking rewards, you name
- 46:24it. So let's start with sales. It's the typical
- 46:28sale of properties that the talker just explained.
- 46:32If the taxpayer sells Bitcoin, the first instinct
- 46:37is of course personal property gain under 865A,
- 46:41generally sourced by seller -residents. But Puerto
- 46:45Rico cases require the overlay of 937. and especially
- 46:49Treasurer Regulation 137 -2. So you have to have
- 46:54the pre -move crypto and that's the one of the
- 46:57most common audit traps. So the taxpayer who
- 47:00held crypto before becoming a Puerto Rico resident
- 47:03cannot simply move and sell and tweet the entire
- 47:06gain as Puerto Rico source. That's the 10 year
- 47:10look back period. And now you have to determine
- 47:14whether crypto is a marketable security or other
- 47:17property. A few years ago, it might have been
- 47:22more clear that it was other property by now,
- 47:25especially with all the crypto ETFs and the expansion
- 47:30of centralized exchanges. Some of the crypto
- 47:34looks more and more like marketable securities.
- 47:37What is a marketable security? That means financial
- 47:40instruments and foreign currency which are, as
- 47:43of the date of the distribution, actively traded.
- 47:48And even so, digital assets are not traded on
- 47:53any name, which is called an established financial
- 47:55market, under 1092. And you have the list of
- 48:03what is an established financial market on Treasury
- 48:06Regulation 1, 1092 -D -1A. And this list does
- 48:15not mention centralized exchanges. But it's not
- 48:18conclusive. So now is the question, does a centralized
- 48:22exchange look like one of these financial markets
- 48:25that are described there? The other question
- 48:29is if decentralized exchanges are looking like
- 48:32these markets. At least centralized exchanges
- 48:35look more and more like these markets these days.
- 48:38So there is an argument, but you have to make
- 48:41a token by token determination these days if
- 48:45you want to move for that. There is then the
- 48:49move date valuation that is not optional. You
- 48:52have the staking rewards that are not sale proceeds.
- 48:55We have revenue ruling 2023 -14 and the recent
- 48:59partial case that basically treats staking rewards
- 49:03as income when the taxpayer has dominion and
- 49:06control. So for Puerto Rico purposes, that creates
- 49:10a separate timing character, especially a source
- 49:13issue. The question is, where was the search
- 49:16performed? Right now, there's no clear guidance
- 49:22from the IRS how to treat that for staking where
- 49:25the service is performed. It could be the node.
- 49:28It could be the sellers or the service providers
- 49:30residence. You have to make that determination.
- 49:34And for these, especially for crypto, for these
- 49:37character and sourcing, document it. Document
- 49:41it when you determine it and put it in your audit
- 49:43file. You have mining. um, similar analyze like,
- 49:50like active income. You have lending defies that
- 49:53require protocol level analysis. You have NFTs
- 49:56that may not be as simple as capital assets.
- 50:00Um, so the IRS wants to, and one, one other point
- 50:06for your, for your audit files, the IRS wants
- 50:08native, uh, data. So just having a coinly report
- 50:12doesn't, doesn't cut it. Just puts the native
- 50:16data, meaning the exchange, the CSV file from
- 50:19the exchange in your audit file for later audit.
- 50:23But Jorge, Kielan, how does Puerto Rico treat
- 50:26it? OK. So Puerto Rico, in one of the last iterations
- 50:33of Act 60, added cryptocurrency as a legible
- 50:39asset, specifically under the definition of other
- 50:42assets. in the law, so they are certainly eligible.
- 50:46But then, as you mentioned, Philip, what is subject
- 50:49to the 0 % is the post -move appreciation. So
- 50:54that pre - and post -move analysis needs to take
- 50:57place in order to make sure that we cover the
- 51:01U .S. tax liability on that pre -move appreciation.
- 51:04And also, there may be a balance in Puerto Rico,
- 51:10sorry, subject to Puerto Rico tax if we cannot
- 51:14apply a full tax credit for yes tax pay on those
- 51:17premium appreciations. Then the staking, mining,
- 51:23and rewards income, we need to be careful on
- 51:27how we analyze each of the income streams because
- 51:31not everyone is going to be eligible for the
- 51:34capital gain treatment. So Puerto Rico under
- 51:37Act 64 investors is sheltering capital gains
- 51:44from the disposition of cryptocurrency and again
- 51:46has made cryptocurrency eligible for the investor
- 51:52benefits but not all income streams are eligible
- 51:56and also we can see under the export services
- 52:00regime if one of those different income types
- 52:04given they are taxed at ordinary rates could
- 52:09be structure as a service instead of the capital
- 52:15gain regime or the ordinary regime that applies
- 52:18in the U .S. So once again, just same as it goes
- 52:23with the different types of investments, we need
- 52:26to make sure what could be eligible for capital
- 52:30gain truth. And then Puerto Rico also one critical
- 52:35distinction and it goes along the lines of what
- 52:37Jorge has been discussing is that in order to
- 52:40be able to claim the investor benefit, when you
- 52:44realize that capital gain, you need to have a
- 52:46degree in good standing, right? Because it does
- 52:51not apply to you automatically if you just move
- 52:53to Puerto Rico. Again, you need to go through
- 52:56an application process, a vetting process internally
- 52:59by the Office of Incentives, and also the different
- 53:04tax agencies that are available in Puerto Rico.
- 53:09Next slide, please. Pivoting a little bit to
- 53:16another common flag pattern that we receive quite
- 53:19often, in particular from the West Coast, is
- 53:22funds. If you had a fund, stateside fund investing
- 53:26in the US, stateside US, typically you would
- 53:29potentially have a number of limited partners
- 53:30who could potentially be investing through an
- 53:34entity of some sort, maybe their own LLC, maybe
- 53:36an investment vehicle. but in many cases you
- 53:39will have a manager who will be acting as a general
- 53:41partner and in many cases these roles are under
- 53:47the standard structure carried on by an individual
- 53:49that could potentially be doing this as an LLC
- 53:52or just disregarded or under their own name as
- 53:56an individual. This creates significant risk
- 53:59if the individual who is the fund manager relocates
- 54:03to Puerto Rico and there are several complexities
- 54:06with this move. The first one is for the fund,
- 54:10to the extent that the fund manager is making
- 54:12decisions from Puerto Rico, it could be deemed
- 54:15as if the fund were engaged in a trader business
- 54:17in Puerto Rico and the income generated for the
- 54:21fund could potentially be subject to tax on the
- 54:23island. And if the fund does not have a tax incentive
- 54:26decree, it could be a pretty high tax bill. Second,
- 54:31for the fund manager, It is not as simple as
- 54:37maintaining the current structure because it
- 54:39would affect its bona fide residency analysis.
- 54:42The one thing that in some cases is doable is
- 54:46that the fund manager establishes a management
- 54:50company that provides fund management services
- 54:54to that fund. And then potentially you could
- 54:56work with Jorge to make sure that the services
- 54:59are eligible and there's a good transfer pricing
- 55:01report in place. and that fund manager provides
- 55:04services to the fund in something that's an honest
- 55:06transaction, properly documented, and then the
- 55:10distribution that'll be for services to the individual
- 55:12are eligible for tax incentives. The risk becomes
- 55:17additional because some funds do not, well, the
- 55:22risk could become, the risk could increase when
- 55:26it is not clear. whether the services performed
- 55:31by the manager are a gain on sale of the investment
- 55:34or for services. And in some cases, they'd rather
- 55:38not have services income because the potentially
- 55:40tax in Puerto Rico under general ordinary tax
- 55:43rates, but it could potentially not work that
- 55:46it is truly a sale on an asset if it's appreciated
- 55:50before the move. So in the case of fund structures
- 55:54partnership carried interest in particular, there
- 55:57has to be a lot of work done. And this is actually
- 56:00one of the areas most litigated by the IRS or
- 56:03in which the IRS has had some of the bigger victories.
- 56:07And in fact, it has issued a guidance. There's
- 56:10a CCA and there's another memo addressing the
- 56:14treatment of sales by partnerships. And there's
- 56:18notes saying how it affects similarly to as corporations.
- 56:23when one of the owner shareholder's partners
- 56:25or members is a resident of Puerto Rico. It says
- 56:29in effect that it doesn't matter that the partnership
- 56:31was a US partnership or a USS for the sale will
- 56:35be treated as if the US individual residing in
- 56:37Puerto Rico sold it and it's subject to the same
- 56:40personal property sale rules resourcing the gain
- 56:43from Puerto Rico to United States. So again,
- 56:45lots of attention here. This is just a flag.
- 56:47I'm not sure, Phillip, if you want to add anything
- 56:50on this point. No, just if you see it in the
- 56:55news, it's caught a lot of attention recently.
- 57:04Jorge, do you want to talk us through reporting?
- 57:07Sure. So international reporting overlays. This
- 57:15is a typical pitfall because when you think about
- 57:19Puerto Rico, and to see that it's a U .S. territory,
- 57:24you don't actually think that investing in Puerto
- 57:26Rico from a federal standpoint can look as investing
- 57:30in any other foreign jurisdiction. And at the
- 57:36same time, Puerto Rico LLCs, which is a typical
- 57:41vehicle used, by default is taxed as a corporation
- 57:45for U .S. tax purposes. What we're trying to
- 57:49convey through this slide is that when you encounter
- 57:55Puerto Rico, don't treat it as purely domestic
- 57:58planning. There's almost always going to be an
- 58:03exception to the rule or a particular rule. And
- 58:07one example is this, the check the box regulations
- 58:11don't work the same way as they work in the US.
- 58:16If you want a Puerto Rico LLC to be considered
- 58:20disregarded or a partnership, depending on how
- 58:22many owners it has, you have to check the box
- 58:25for that Puerto Rico LLC. So with this, what
- 58:29we're trying to convey is that any time a Puerto
- 58:33Rico entity is involved, proceed with caution
- 58:37and think of it from the lens of an international
- 58:40entity, not actually a domestic entity. So For
- 58:45example, depending on the ownership, it could
- 58:47be deemed a controlled foreign corporation, especially
- 58:49when you have a majority U .S. owner. It can
- 58:52trigger super F inclusions or guilty inclusions.
- 58:57Essentially, that Puerto Rico corporation is
- 58:59doing business in the U .S. on behalf or the
- 59:03owner is doing business in the U .S. on behalf
- 59:05of the entity. That creates income effectively
- 59:09connected with a U .S. trader business and that
- 59:11can trigger the punitive tax regimes that would
- 59:14normally apply to international operations. Then
- 59:19by the same reason, the different forms, the
- 59:225471, the 8865, 8938, F bar, and for 8898 to
- 59:28mention some should be checked because again,
- 59:31it is required for entities, international entities
- 59:35doing business in the US. Also, the withholding
- 59:39provisions also need to be looked at carefully
- 59:42because those would apply to any foreign jurisdiction
- 59:46in terms of any payments made to owners of foreign
- 59:51entities. And lastly, the trading safe harbors.
- 59:56When it comes to crypto, the IRS current position
- 1:00:00is silent as to whether crypto falls under the
- 1:00:04trading safe harbor. So that's another area that
- 1:00:07when they set up crypto structures, and Philip
- 1:00:09can certainly vouch for this, you need to make
- 1:00:14sure whether you can take a position under the
- 1:00:16trading safe harbor, especially for potential
- 1:00:19X60 individual investors. So again, it's just
- 1:00:23a typical pitfall that when you see Puerto Rico
- 1:00:26and think of it as a US possession, it is in
- 1:00:30practice, it doesn't behave that way. It behaves
- 1:00:33more as an international jurisdiction. So proceed
- 1:00:37with caution there. We're running out of time,
- 1:00:42so I'll say from an enforcement perspective,
- 1:00:44there is a lot of enforcement. There is an active
- 1:00:46IRS audit campaign looking into individuals who
- 1:00:50have relocated to Puerto Rico. And it is very
- 1:00:54important to be proactive about seeking good,
- 1:00:57competent advice. And it really takes a team.
- 1:00:59It takes a US advisor. It takes a good CPA. It
- 1:01:01takes a good Puerto Rico council as well. and
- 1:01:04the sooner you start with the planning and you
- 1:01:07get on the documentation, the safer you will
- 1:01:09be. Again, it's not if you're going to be out
- 1:01:11of it, it's when. Philipp, I'll turn it to you.
- 1:01:15And I can just second that. Choose wisely your
- 1:01:21local advisor. You're really depending on them
- 1:01:25for a lot of things, not only communicating with
- 1:01:27the Hacienda, but also timely filing, understanding
- 1:01:31the different rules. One other aspect, if you're
- 1:01:37new to that, you might want to look at the four
- 1:01:39-year materials. I hope I have put that down
- 1:01:45there. If not, reach out to me. I can send you
- 1:01:48the link for the four -year materials. But it's
- 1:01:51basically hundreds and hundreds of pages of IIS
- 1:01:54training materials. The GAO report from last
- 1:01:58year, very helpful to understand, especially
- 1:02:01that the IIS focused on the 2021 tax year. and
- 1:02:05now was pressured or forced to also data match
- 1:02:10the other years that Hacienda provided. So there
- 1:02:13will be an influx in newer cases, certainly.
- 1:02:17And there is a DOJ that is focused on these cases.
- 1:02:20There's Senator Biden, who has an eye on these
- 1:02:24Puerto Rico cases. There's the IRS campaign for
- 1:02:26Puerto Rico. There's also an IRS LAPNI campaign
- 1:02:29for crypto. So that's a double risk. And one
- 1:02:35thing I can't focus enough on is the form 8898
- 1:02:39for all advisors out there where people who move
- 1:02:42to Puerto Rico have to fill that form. And if
- 1:02:45I'm correct, also, if you're moving back, you
- 1:02:48have to fill that form. Don't forget it in the
- 1:02:51first and last year. And Jack, I'm sorry that
- 1:02:56we couldn't comment on your planning, your virtual
- 1:02:59law firm in Puerto Rico already. If you send
- 1:03:03us your email address, we will get to your questions.
- 1:03:06And with that, I will close. Thank you to everyone.
- 1:03:09Thank you to Auche and Auche. And reach out to
- 1:03:13them if you have any questions. Thank you so
- 1:03:16much.