Latest / Migraine Relief Code with Dr. Amelia Scott Barrett, MD / Understanding POTS and Its Connection to Migraines with Dr. Lauren Natbony, MD
Transcript
- 0:00Hello.
- 0:00Hello.
- 0:01Welcome to the Migraine Relief Code podcast.
- 0:05I am so excited about our guest tonight.
- 0:08We have doctor Lauren Natbeni with us who is literally the person who wrote the book on
- 0:15integrative medicine solutions for migraines.
- 0:18So she just has an amazingly vast storehouse of knowledge in her brain, and we are gonna tap
- 0:25into that and, learn everything we can in the time that we've got.
- 0:31So one of the more interesting things I think that people have been talking a lot about in
- 0:38the migraine community recently is POTS.
- 0:42So POTS stands for postural orth ostatic tachycardia syndrome, and it's a type of
- 0:49dizziness.
- 0:50And so many of us have dizziness with our migraines that I wanted to start off by talking
- 0:56about this a little bit just to make sure everybody understands what it is, what you do
- 1:01about it, how you know if you've got it.
- 1:04So, doctor Naponi, let's, dive right in.
- 1:07What are some of the symptoms that people get when they're having POTS?
- 1:13First of all, thank you for having me.
- 1:15And I I love this topic and love the question because, yeah, everyone has dizziness, but I
- 1:20think it's really obviously hard to figure out what causes it.
- 1:23So POTS by definition means that your heart rate increases when you stand.
- 1:29So if you're laying down and then you stand up, your heart will start pumping really, really
- 1:33quickly, and your heart rate will shoot up.
- 1:36Usually, we look at a threshold of about 30 beats per minute after standing up.
- 1:41But as a patient, what you're really looking for is signs that you're just more comfortable
- 1:46laying down than standing up.
- 1:47So something called orthostatic intolerance, meaning that every time you're up and doing
- 1:52something, you're feeling dizzy, lightheaded, faint, foggy, and that should feel better when
- 1:57you're laying down.
- 1:59So it really is more of this positional very, very positionally based dizziness.
- 2:04So anyone that comes to me and says, I just wanna be in bed all day.
- 2:07Right?
- 2:07I just prefer just to stay.
- 2:09Laying down, I feel better.
- 2:10When I get up, just everything starts to feel dizzy and not so well, I'll be thinking about
- 2:16POTS.
- 2:17Interesting.
- 2:17Okay.
- 2:18So, you know, one thing I'm wondering here is how can you tell the difference between that
- 2:22and maybe dehydration?
- 2:24I mean, I think everybody with migraines has gotten the memo that you have to stay hydrated,
- 2:28and I know we all try really hard, but, you know, despite our best efforts, sometimes a
- 2:33little bit of dehydration happens anyway.
- 2:35Maybe you've been sick or had a fever or whatever.
- 2:38You know, it sounds like it the symptoms do kind of overlap based on what you're
- 2:42describing.
- 2:43Oh, absolutely.
- 2:44I think the difference is is that dehydration can cause what looks like POTS.
- 2:49Because if you're dehydrated, your blood is not flowing as well because your blood volume is
- 2:54not as big to sort of pump the fluid up to your brain.
- 2:59So POTS, by definition, though, is an autonomic dysfunction, meaning that the nervous system,
- 3:04the autonomic nervous system, isn't functioning appropriately.
- 3:08So, usually, when you stand up, the normal thing is our blood pressure shouldn't really
- 3:14change, and our heart rate should initially go up a little bit, but then but then come down,
- 3:19just sort of reequilibrate.
- 3:21So what happens with POTS is it's an inappropriate expression of that.
- 3:25Dehydration can be a secondary cause of POTS.
- 3:28If someone is super dehydrated, let's say you ran a marathon and you are really dehydrated,
- 3:34depleted, laying in bed, you can look like you have POTS.
- 3:37Absolutely.
- 3:38On testing, on symptoms, yes.
- 3:40But POTS, by definition, has to be going on for more than three months.
- 3:43It is more of a chronic syndrome, not just a symptom that happens from something like
- 3:49dehydration.
- 3:50Oh, okay.
- 3:51So that's a big way to distinguish it.
- 3:54It's gonna be there all the time because it's a problem with your nervous system.
- 3:58It's not just, you know, a day here, a day there where you stand up and you feel like your
- 4:02heart's beating out of your chest, like a,
- 4:04I don't know,
- 4:05or something.
- 4:06Okay.
- 4:07And it's not
- 4:08a point.
- 4:08So post COVID, so a lot that's where I feel like POTS became sort of more well known is
- 4:13that if we look at long COVID, POTS dysautonomia is actually one of the hallmark
- 4:18symptoms, and it is a chronic continuous issue.
- 4:21Yes.
- 4:21It can get better.
- 4:22It can get worse.
- 4:23There are things you can do.
- 4:24Like, aggressively hydrate can definitely be helpful, but it's it's a syndrome.
- 4:29Like, migraine is a syndrome.
- 4:30It's not necessarily going away.
- 4:32Got it.
- 4:33Okay.
- 4:33So is there anything about COVID that makes POTS more likely?
- 4:39That's a great I feel like I could go on a whole rabbit hole with that.
- 4:43But so COVID, like other viruses, can attack the autonomic nervous system, and that
- 4:50basically is what we saw.
- 4:52I I feel like I I remember this.
- 4:53I remember when COVID first started because I was like, this is gonna bring POTS into the
- 4:56forefront because what it is doing is it is causing this dysregulation of the autonomic
- 5:01nervous system.
- 5:02And it is exactly what we were seeing in patients with POTS from non COVID causes
- 5:09beforehand, but really brought to light this sort of process of autonomic dysfunction, more
- 5:15headache, fatigue, chronic fatigue that comes along with it in addition to the dizziness.
- 5:20I would say feeling exhaustion post exercise malaise, like, really just, like, cannot stand
- 5:25up, get out of bed, is really very potsy.
- 5:28Like, it it kinda goes along with this whole syndrome.
- 5:31And I think some of that post exertional malaise after COVID can be due to the direct
- 5:36effect of the virus on the mitochondria, the energy producers in our cells, so people can
- 5:41really feel wiped out from that too.
- 5:43Yeah?
- 5:43Yes.
- 5:44So I think it definitely all goes together.
- 5:46Yeah.
- 5:47Are there other things like COVID that can damage the nervous system and cause POTS, or
- 5:52can it just sort of happen out of the blue if you've been having like, is it worse and people
- 5:57are having really bad migraines, or can it happen to anybody?
- 6:01Who's who's at risk for it?
- 6:04Yeah.
- 6:04So POTS is is a syndrome.
- 6:05So look at
- 6:06it as an umbrella, and there are different causes.
- 6:08So you have viral causes, absolutely, but autoimmune.
- 6:12So looking at someone who has an autoimmune disease, they might be more at risk for POTS
- 6:18because of the nerves that the autoimmune disease can target.
- 6:24So dysfunction with the nerves can cause it as can actually dehydration and deconditioning.
- 6:29So someone who has, let's say, been in a hospital bed recovering from surgery for a
- 6:33while and is just deconditioned, They can develop POTS.
- 6:37Obviously, that is a more recoverable, with Mhmm.
- 6:41With time and exercise, but that we would call a hypovolemic type of POTS, meaning they are
- 6:46intravascularly volume depleted, and their muscles are not pumping strongly enough to be
- 6:51able to get that blood back to their brain.
- 6:55And then the third type that I see most often with with migraine is what we call the
- 7:00hyperadrenergic POTS type, meaning this sympathetic over activation where your fight or
- 7:05flight is just going all the time.
- 7:07And that happens more with people who are more hypermobile, like our patients with with Ehlers
- 7:12Danlos or who have, mast cell activation syndrome who just are a more I know it's like
- 7:20we're just sympathetically dominant and have migraines.
- 7:24So in those in those patients, I find that there is not no.
- 7:28There's not, like, a link, like, an autoimmune link, but it is sort of this phenotype that
- 7:32goes along with hypermobility and, migraine.
- 7:35You know what?
- 7:36And I feel like I see a lot of that in the students in my courses.
- 7:40I do a ton of testing on people.
- 7:42Part of that is genetic testing.
- 7:44And some of the common patterns that we find, which we are also seeing in the genome wide
- 7:49association studies, are abnormalities in the serotonin pathways, which, of course, that's
- 7:54your calming down system.
- 7:56So if you have an abnormality there, you're gonna be prone to anxiety.
- 8:00We also see abnormalities in ADRA two b, which is one of the genes involved in our fight or
- 8:05flight system.
- 8:07And, you know, those genetic variations are a lot more common in the chronic migraine
- 8:13community.
- 8:14And I sort of think of it as it's almost like your brain is just it it it it's just in
- 8:19overdrive all of the time.
- 8:21That's what I say.
- 8:22Your brain is
- 8:22constantly running away from a tiger.
- 8:24The tiger is chasing me all the time, and I'm constantly away.
- 8:28And that's where I look at it as these are the patients who are exhausted but can't sleep.
- 8:31Like, if someone comes to me and they're like, I am so tired, but, like, I just can't fall
- 8:36asleep.
- 8:36I'm thinking, okay.
- 8:37This sympathetic overdrive, what is driving it?
- 8:40Is this person who does this person have an autonomic dysfunction?
- 8:43And in patients who have chronic migraine, I feel like more than we recognize really do.
- 8:49And then focusing on correcting that really helps the overall picture when nothing else
- 8:54seems to.
- 8:55Yeah.
- 8:56Yeah.
- 8:57And in the functional medicine community, the you know, people will call this adrenal
- 9:01dysfunction or adrenal fatigue.
- 9:04In mainstream medicine, we tend to look at it more as, you know, hypothalamic pituitary axis
- 9:10dysfunction, that kind of thing.
- 9:12So I think we're all trying to describe the same thing, and, basically, what it means,
- 9:17exhaustion.
- 9:18Yep.
- 9:20All of those things are happening.
- 9:21It's just how you're looking at the the pathway.
- 9:24So Yeah.
- 9:25And it's so hard.
- 9:27It's so difficult because there's so many things that are that are involved.
- 9:30And I find that these patients are the ones who are really, really suffering, and we're not
- 9:34always giving them the tools they need to get better.
- 9:37So
- 9:37Exactly.
- 9:38Exactly.
- 9:38You can take away the migraine pain, but you don't take away the rest of it.
- 9:41Yeah.
- 9:42Exactly.
- 9:42It's like a whack
- 9:43a mole.
- 9:43You could take away one thing, but everything else
- 9:44Whack a mole.
- 9:45Yes.
- 9:45I always call it whack a mole.
- 9:46Like, I get better, and then something else pops up because it's a system wide problem, not
- 9:51just
- 9:51targeting
- 9:52one one symptom.
- 9:54Yeah.
- 9:54I love that.
- 9:55So if somebody thinks they if somebody is listening and they think they might have POTS,
- 9:59what does it look like to get tested?
- 10:02You go to your doctor.
- 10:03You say, I'm dizzy when I stand up.
- 10:05I feel like my heart's beating out of my chest.
- 10:07I think I might have POTS.
- 10:09What tests are they gonna order?
- 10:12So, actually, there's something you can do at home.
- 10:14Most basic test is a sit to stand test.
- 10:16Remember when I said that if you're going from lying to standing, your heart rate should
- 10:21increase.
- 10:22So in my office, I have patients lay down, just lay down, relax for, like, five to ten minutes,
- 10:27and then I have them stand up, and I check their blood pressure and heart rate at
- 10:31intervals, usually, like, at one minute, three minutes, five minutes, and ten minutes.
- 10:34And what I'm looking for is that the heart rate goes up by 30 beats a minute within the first
- 10:41ten minutes of standing.
- 10:42There are other metrics there that I can I can look at to sort of differentiate other things,
- 10:45but that is the diagnosis of POTS?
- 10:47And if you have a three month history of orthostatic intolerance, meaning you don't like
- 10:52being upright.
- 10:53So let's say you're at home right now and you're like, don't know.
- 10:56I would say you can lay down.
- 10:58You could take a blood pressure cuff, a blood pressure cuff that also has the heart because
- 11:01usually it measures heart rate and blood pressure.
- 11:04Lay there and then stand up and stand there.
- 11:07And at one minute, press it.
- 11:09Three minutes, press it.
- 11:10Five minutes, press it, and record the numbers.
- 11:12And if the heart rate goes up by more than 30 beats per minute, there is something there that
- 11:17can be better tested.
- 11:19You can take that to your doctor, and the formal test is a tilt table test where you're
- 11:24actually tilted back and forth on on a table.
- 11:27You don't always need that.
- 11:28That's more of a confirmatory test.
- 11:30The screening is this active stand test.
- 11:33And I will say, while I do it, I for every patient that comes into my office, it takes
- 11:39time.
- 11:39And for most doctors who have ten minutes to see a patient altogether, doing this is
- 11:43sometimes time intensive.
- 11:45So that's why some of the encourage patients do it at home with the caveat that if you're on
- 11:49medications that affect blood pressure, it's not going to necessarily be as accurate.
- 11:54So
- 11:56yeah.
- 11:56I bet especially a beta blocker like A beta blocker, you can't.
- 12:01Yeah.
- 12:02Because those will slow down your heart rate, so you might not notice.
- 12:06That's amazing.
- 12:07That is a super empowering tool.
- 12:09Thank you for sharing that.
- 12:10I didn't know you could just do that at home and get a a a decent answer to this question.
- 12:15That's fantastic.
- 12:16So with my patients, when we're trying to monitor how they're doing, like, what is
- 12:19the metric that, you know, if someone's getting better?
- 12:21It's if we're reducing the heart rate with standing.
- 12:23So I will have them take logs and do it at home to track progress.
- 12:27So I find that we don't necessarily communicate enough that is that the official, like,
- 12:34diagnosis?
- 12:35No.
- 12:35But is it really helpful for tracking how somebody is doing?
- 12:38Yes.
- 12:38Yeah.
- 12:39Yeah.
- 12:39That makes a ton of sense.
- 12:40I love it.
- 12:41Are there is there anything else?
- 12:42I love morning hydration and electrolytes.
- 12:46So I if you take the amount of water that your body needs, you know, which is approximately
- 12:52body weight in pounds divided by two, drink that number of ounces in fluid a day, and then
- 12:57just drink half of that amount in the morning as soon as you wake up with some electrolytes
- 13:02to keep it in your bloodstream.
- 13:04I feel like that helps so many people with dizziness in general.
- 13:07Now I don't know if it help would help for POTS in particular.
- 13:11It may just help the people who are dehydrated.
- 13:14I don't know.
- 13:14What are your what are your thoughts on that?
- 13:15I recommend everyone in the morning, like you said, doing a hydrating solution.
- 13:21So doing water with electrolytes.
- 13:23For POTS, really, the mainstay of treatment is aggressive salt and fluid.
- 13:29So you want the salt to help the fluid go into the blood vessels, increase the intravascular
- 13:33volume so we get more blood flow.
- 13:36So we usually say aim for at least two to three liters of water a day, but I like your
- 13:39recommendation as well.
- 13:41And then salt loading for POTS.
- 13:43Again, I'm gonna preface this by saying salt loading, if you don't have pots, can cause
- 13:47other issues.
- 13:48So it's not that everyone should salt load, but, doing at least three grams of sodium per
- 13:56day and increasing that all the way up to ten grams of sodium a day based on symptoms is the
- 14:01mainstay of treatment.
- 14:03So if we take two teaspoons of salt and put it in a salt shaker and sprinkle it on our food
- 14:09throughout the day, we'll be getting over four grams of sodium a day, which is sort of that
- 14:15minimum for patients with POTS.
- 14:17That's kind of an easy way if you like salt.
- 14:19If you don't like salt, then I start doing salt tablets or electrolyte drinks.
- 14:24But very easy to see.
- 14:26Even if you do a small salt trial and say, okay.
- 14:28I'm gonna salt my food with this amount for a week.
- 14:33Increase my hydration.
- 14:34Let's see how let's see how I feel.
- 14:37You'd be surprised.
- 14:38I've had patients come in that just say they feel so much brain fog and fatigue.
- 14:42I have them salt load, and they're like a new person.
- 14:44So that is something that is I feel like that's definitely the first step, using compression.
- 14:51So compression basically compresses externally our vessels to make them make the blood flow.
- 15:00So wearing compression stockings, abdominal binders all can be helpful.
- 15:06And then the most important actually is graded exercise.
- 15:11So what happens with POTS is, like I said, your lower extremities are not pumping blood back up
- 15:19to the brain efficiently.
- 15:20We need those muscles to start pumping more effectively.
- 15:24So doing graded exercise programs, there's ones online.
- 15:27I like the CHOP Levine protocols.
- 15:30Basically, talks about starting with exercise in a recumbent position, then gradually doing
- 15:35it when you're seated upright.
- 15:37It gives exact metrics on here's what you should do for warm up, then five minutes of
- 15:41cardio, and then we're gonna work first on leg exercises to strengthen leg muscles.
- 15:45And it basically walks.
- 15:46It's an eight month program, so it's not like it's something that short.
- 15:50But the patients who complete these programs are the ones who get better long term because
- 15:54you're fixing the underlying dysfunction that is contributing to the problem.
- 15:59So far far using medication is a good adjunct, but the pathway always has to include the
- 16:06aerobic reconditioning
- 16:08on the answer side.
- 16:09So I would imagine that if you feel dizzy every time you stand up, you really have not been
- 16:13exercising in quite some time.
- 16:15So that's the piece of it that you're kind of trying to fix, get your mitochondria back, get
- 16:21your endurance and stamina back in a very slow, easy to tolerate kind of way, even so much so
- 16:26starting lying down.
- 16:28Kinda like one.
- 16:29Okay.
- 16:30So lots of fluid, lots of salt, like, literally a couple teaspoons a day on your food, and some
- 16:36very gentle exercise.
- 16:38Love it.
- 16:38That's great.
- 16:39And, you know, I'm curious about one thing.
- 16:41There are a lot, there are people out there who recommend salt for migraine.
- 16:47Do you think that this is how that's working?
- 16:52Has to be.
- 16:52I I I feel like it has to be working on relative, like, hypovolemia, basically
- 16:58increasing your overall blood volume.
- 17:00It has to.
- 17:01I don't
- 17:01see any other way that salt would work for migraine except increasing cerebral perfusion
- 17:05pressure, meaning you are allowing more blood and more oxygen to go to the brain.
- 17:11Yeah.
- 17:12Do you feel like you see that the salt itself helps the pain?
- 17:16Because I feel like I I see more that it helps the dizziness when stand up and, like, all the
- 17:21other stuff, the brain fog, the low energy, all the other stuff that goes along with migraine,
- 17:26but I don't know about the pain.
- 17:28What what is your experience?
- 17:29So there's migraine migraine, and then you have POTS type of headache.
- 17:33So, usually, the headache that comes with POTS is more of this coat hanger headache.
- 17:37I look at it like a coat hanger that's pulling down the back of your head that your head feels
- 17:41very heavy.
- 17:43And it's hard to differentiate necessarily from a migraine, but most migraine patients that
- 17:47also have POTS have different types of pain.
- 17:50Sure.
- 17:51And I do find that the second half of the day headache we call it the second half of the day
- 17:55headache because it's not there in the morning, comes on later in the day.
- 17:58That is your classic POTS headache.
- 17:59The longer that you're upright, the more your sort of brain relatively is sagging because it
- 18:06doesn't have enough volume surrounding it to float, and that's causing this pull on the back
- 18:10of the brain, and it's causing pain.
- 18:12And I think with a lot of patients with chronic migraine, because they have baseline pain with
- 18:18exacerbations, it's really hard to tease apart what is what.
- 18:23So I will say in my patients with migraine who also have POTS, it's the baseline pain that
- 18:29goes away.
- 18:30No.
- 18:30The migraine attacks themselves don't, but that underlying nagging pain, the neck pain, the
- 18:37heaviness gets a lot better, and, also, they're able to be up not get that second half of the
- 18:44day when everything just feels terrible and the pain is worse.
- 18:47Yeah.
- 18:47Yeah.
- 18:48Okay.
- 18:49Interesting.
- 18:49Yeah.
- 18:49So part of the headache, not the episodic migraine necessarily, but more the baseline
- 18:54headache can respond to these measures when you start treating your POTS.
- 18:58Super fascinating stuff.
- 18:59You know what's what's coming to mind is as we're talking about this, you know, these are,
- 19:04people who get symptoms when they stand up.
- 19:07I would imagine that there are a lot of people in the CSF leak community saying Yeah.
- 19:13I get pain when I stand up too, which is a totally different mechanism.
- 19:18Yeah.
- 19:19Can you just speak to that for a minute?
- 19:22So I
- 19:22think anyone who has orthostatic or meaning symptoms of headache when you're going from
- 19:27laying down to standing up, We always have to rule out a CSF leak, but I find that I kinda
- 19:33know when I'm worried about a CSF leak, if there's risk factors, if there are things that
- 19:38would really sort of predispose this person to a leak, but it is a pathway I go down.
- 19:43Sometimes I don't I don't know.
- 19:44And that's why we have to rule out or evaluate for a leak before we say it's POTS.
- 19:48But, interestingly, one of my colleagues who is amazing and does a lot of the autonomic
- 19:54function testing, On the testing itself, the tilt table on the autonomic testing, she can
- 19:58usually tell by interpreting different metrics if it's coming from a leak versus if it's
- 20:05coming from POTS based on the differences in the perfusion pressures.
- 20:09No way.
- 20:10Really?
- 20:10So, actually, yes.
- 20:11Because what happens with a leak is it's sort of the same thing.
- 20:14You're looking at you're not getting enough blood flow to the brain because of the leak.
- 20:20The same thing with POTS is you're not getting enough blood flow to the brain, but it's
- 20:23because you don't have enough circulating blood volume.
- 20:26So your the end result is the same.
- 20:28The cause is different, but there are subtle metrics to help determine that on official
- 20:34tests, which I think is super cool.
- 20:36Oh, yeah.
- 20:37Because it's a noninvasive test.
- 20:39Yep.
- 20:40You know?
- 20:40Because, you know, back in the day, in order to diagnose, you know, a real CSF leak, what do
- 20:45you have to do?
- 20:45Well, you have to cause another leak.
- 20:48You know?
- 20:48Do a tap.
- 20:49Document the low pressure.
- 20:50And then, of course, things got better, and we could see some characteristic findings on
- 20:54imaging and, you know, better imaging came along, and so there became better ways to
- 20:58diagnose it.
- 20:59But it's this totally paradoxical thing that, basically, you have a tiny hole in there
- 21:03allowing CSF to drain, and what do you do?
- 21:05Make another one to see if that's the type diagnosis.
- 21:09And the pain piece is so prominent when people stand up when they have a leak.
- 21:14It's not that their heart's racing or they feel dizzy.
- 21:16Like, it hurts.
- 21:18Hurts.
- 21:18Yep.
- 21:19That's the big thing that they're talking about.
- 21:22So yeah.
- 21:23Yeah.
- 21:23Okay.
- 21:23Good.
- 21:24Thanks for kind of pointing out the differences between, those two syndromes.
- 21:28It's hard.
- 21:29I feel like even for neurologists, we all do this all the time.
- 21:31That is probably the hardest thing.
- 21:34Leak and to differentiate positional headache is really challenging.
- 21:37So
- 21:38Yeah.
- 21:39It is.
- 21:39Well, maybe, hopefully, some people listening, we can kind of raise awareness and, you know,
- 21:44help them help them understand and know what to what to push for because, you know, the
- 21:50experience for most people with headaches is they go into their primary, and they've got a
- 21:54headache, and nobody has enough time.
- 21:56And so sometimes the whole story can't even come out.
- 21:58So I really feel like it's important to empower the people who have those symptoms with the
- 22:04information that they need to really take charge of
- 22:07their own health care.
- 22:08I agree.
- 22:09That's why I say if you can jot like, as I said, if you do the testing yourself at home,
- 22:12if you jot down blood pressures, I always say if you come armed with the data and present the
- 22:16data in in the cohesive package, it's much easier to get answers, and it empowers you to
- 22:21to basically be able to be advocating for yourself.
- 22:24Yeah.
- 22:25Yeah.
- 22:25And then even if your doctor is totally fried, not thinking, end of the day, whatever whatever
- 22:31it is, rush for time, I don't know, then you can still make sure you get you get plugged
- 22:35into the the right pathway.
- 22:38And thank you so much for sharing your expertise, with us here.
- 22:42Many, many thanks.
- 22:44Really appreciate you taking the time to come and share.