Latest / Consumerpedia / 77 - Amazon Floods Search Results with Ads
Transcript
- 0:01No doubt about it, Amazon is convenient.
- 0:04Instead of visiting a bunch of stores or websites, you can shop
- 0:08in one place for nearly anything and have it delivered in days.
- 0:12But all too often, Amazon steers its customers towards items it
- 0:15gets paid extra to promote. Search results are now cluttered
- 0:19with ads. I'm her Weisbaum, the consumer
- 0:22man, a contributing editor at checkbook.org.
- 0:25Welcome to Consumerpedia at checkbook.org.
- 0:28We're the nonprofit that helps consumers select services, avoid
- 0:32trouble, and save money. Because we don't accept any
- 0:35advertising or take money from any business, we recommend you
- 0:38can rely on checkbook.org to be completely independent and
- 0:41objective. Now here's the host of
- 0:44Consumerpedia America's consumer expert, the consumer man Herb
- 0:48Weisspaum. So you want an electric
- 0:51toothbrush? When Checkbooks researchers look
- 0:53for one on Amazon, 15 of the 1st 25 items that popped up were
- 0:58sponsored listings. So what's the deal with all
- 1:00these ads? Can you still trust Amazon to
- 1:03show you the best products and prices?
- 1:06Here to talk about this? Kevin Bressler, Checkbooks
- 1:08executive editor, who spent days searching Amazon for products
- 1:12and counting ads. Hello Herb, How are you?
- 1:14Good, so you're shopping, but now we can call the research.
- 1:18I can tell you it was not a pleasant experience having to do
- 1:21all this work. You know, I spent most of my
- 1:23time using the very advanced analytic tool of counting.
- 1:27It was very complicated, but Amazon actually made it quite
- 1:30more complicated. And then it was really hard for
- 1:32me to determine, you know, what was and what wasn't an ad.
- 1:35And we'll get to that in a minute.
- 1:37So you're a regular Amazon shopper.
- 1:38I guess you weren't surprised by what you found with all these
- 1:41ads. Yeah, I guess I'll somewhat
- 1:43guiltily admit that I use Amazon a lot, and the reason is it's
- 1:46just so darn convenient. I mean, my kids will text me
- 1:48something that they need and if it's something I'm willing to
- 1:51buy, I don't have to move an inch.
- 1:53I just hit buy it on my phone and it shows up the next day.
- 1:56And when I've had problems, it's been pretty easy to get stuff
- 1:59returned or to get a replacement sent quickly.
- 2:02And the same is true for, you know, when I need something
- 2:04like, you know, just yesterday, we need a more laundry detergent
- 2:07just clicked and it shows up later that day or the next day.
- 2:10But when I'm ordering from Amazon, I know I'm not always
- 2:12getting the best deals. And over the last few years,
- 2:15I've noticed that what I see when I search on Amazon, it's
- 2:19increasingly what Amazon wants me to see.
- 2:22And often what it wants to me to see is just a ton of ads.
- 2:25It's not necessarily the lowest price item or the highest
- 2:28quality item. It's what Amazon wants to show
- 2:31me. So in the great checkbook
- 2:33tradition, you did a study. Yeah.
- 2:35So I put together a list of 50 products that are often sold by
- 2:38Amazon, and then I searched the site for each to see how much
- 2:41advertising is affecting what I see these days.
- 2:44Yeah, I didn't want my shopping history to affect results, so I
- 2:47did all my searches using a computer that I don't often use.
- 2:50And I also searched using Firefox's private browsing
- 2:53option. I did all these searches in a
- 2:55single day. And the idea was, you know,
- 2:58again, I don't want my own shopping history to affect what
- 3:00Amazon's showing me because a lot of what Amazon is doing
- 3:03these days with ads is showing you stuff that it thinks you
- 3:07might want to buy based on data it has on you.
- 3:10So for the first round of searching for these 50 products,
- 3:13I did generic searches. So for example, you know, I
- 3:16looked for an electric toothbrush without specifying a
- 3:19brand or a color or anything like that.
- 3:22So for each of those items, I looked at the 1st 25 products
- 3:26Amazon showed me and then use the very sophisticated, as I
- 3:29mentioned, analytic tool of counting to see how many of
- 3:32those 25 products were ads. And what what I found was that
- 3:36on average, about half of the 1st 25 items Amazon displayed as
- 3:4154% were paid placements. And for all the 50 products I
- 3:45searched for, the top two to five items offered by Amazon
- 3:49were always ads. Every single search had ads at
- 3:52the top. And for a few of my searches
- 3:55though, more than 70% of the 1st 25 items Amazon showed me were
- 3:59sponsored items. So then I had a second round of
- 4:02searching, and so for each of the 50 products, this time I
- 4:06included a brand name in my search term O.
- 4:09For example, instead of Justice looking for electric toothbrush,
- 4:12I looked for Oral-B electric toothbrush.
- 4:15But being more specific, it didn't do much to reduce the
- 4:19number of ads I saw on average. Still 44% of the 1st 25 items
- 4:25Amazon showed me, they were still ads, and among them, 35%
- 4:30weren't even items that were related to the brands I searched
- 4:33for. Often the brand I wanted didn't
- 4:35show up until the 5th or 6th spot on the list.
- 4:38That's a lot of ads. Amazon is doing this because of
- 4:41Ka Ching. They're making a lot of money
- 4:43this way. Yeah, I mean, I guess there's
- 4:45two ways of you're looking at this.
- 4:46You know, one way is to be generous toward Amazon and and
- 4:50recognize that, you know, like any other retailer is trying to
- 4:53maximize its sales revenue. Every retailer does that.
- 4:57When you search for something on Amazon or at any retailer who
- 5:00wants to sell you something, that's the goal is to sell you
- 5:03something. Not to show you stuff you don't
- 5:05want to buy, but to show you stuff you might want to buy.
- 5:08The whole point of The thing is to make a sale.
- 5:10And I think this is a really important note that we should
- 5:14make. All of the ads Amazon showed me
- 5:17and all of the items in my search results were relevant
- 5:20items to my search. This is crucial.
- 5:23And in all fairness, I think it's something that Amazon
- 5:25clearly has worked very hard on. So, you know, when I search for
- 5:29electric toothbrushes, it never showed me ads for watches or
- 5:32even for toothpaste. So it has done a good job of
- 5:35refining search and showing us stuff that are directly related
- 5:40to our search terms. But you know, the more skeptical
- 5:43way to look at this, you know, look at the fact that Amazon is
- 5:47showing us so many ads, is that it's doing that because it makes
- 5:50more money. The problem is that this
- 5:52strategy, it just makes for a more miserable shopping
- 5:55experience. I mean, when we're on Amazon or
- 5:58any other site and we search for something, what we expect to see
- 6:01are the best items related to our search.
- 6:04And then in the case of Amazon, we want to see the highest rated
- 6:06items of the lowest priced items.
- 6:08And you know, Amazon definitely is now focused more on showing
- 6:11us stuff it gets paid extra to promote rather than showing us
- 6:15the very best items related to our search.
- 6:18You know, I don't show up on Amazon anywhere nearly as much
- 6:20as you do. I really do.
- 6:21I go on the site and it's, this is hodgepodge.
- 6:23My mind wants to explode when I look.
- 6:25I don't know how you can have so many types of laundry detergent
- 6:29or so many types of toilet paper.
- 6:31And it's amazing that the companies are able to exist on
- 6:33the site with so many options for people, but they're making
- 6:36the money by selling and selling ads.
- 6:38So this is kind of the double edged sword of Amazon.
- 6:41On one hand, it's incredibly convenient, it ships fast,
- 6:45returns are quick. I mean, it's very reliable,
- 6:48especially when things are being fulfilled by Amazon itself.
- 6:51And you can buy anything on there, right?
- 6:53I mean, you don't have to like shop at 8 different stores or go
- 6:56to 8 different websites to buy stuff.
- 6:58You can get all in one place. That's the whole point of the
- 7:00thing. But on the other hand, there's
- 7:02so much available for sale on Amazon.
- 7:05You know, we really rely on it, that company to show us the best
- 7:09stuff, show us the stuff, you know, that's going to work best
- 7:12for us. And instead, these days, I think
- 7:14you could easily argue is that Amazon's controlling that
- 7:17environment in terms of what happens in our search results.
- 7:20And it's clearly favoring companies that are paying it
- 7:23extra. And do we have any idea how many
- 7:25gazillions of dollars Amazon makes from these ads?
- 7:28Yeah, so no one but Amazon knows how much money it's making off
- 7:31these ads, and it ain't sane. It wouldn't tell us and as far
- 7:34as I know hasn't told anyone else.
- 7:37But clearly it's doing this though because it's a way to
- 7:40make more money. It wouldn't be doing it
- 7:42otherwise. Absolutely.
- 7:43You know, you and I had several conversations while you were
- 7:46designing this study and then while you were writing the
- 7:48article about it. And I remember that one problem
- 7:50that you had was determining what's an ad and what isn't,
- 7:54because Amazon just uses so many labels.
- 7:56This is another big change that Amazon has made is that they
- 7:59just throw a lot of different terms at us.
- 8:02So many that I had to actually consult with Amazon about what
- 8:05each one meant. You know what is an ad and what
- 8:07isn't? Ads on Amazon are almost always
- 8:09denoted with the word sponsored and that label is placed
- 8:12somewhere in the vicinity of each listing.
- 8:16The problem is Amazon uses tiny Gray lettering to disclose those
- 8:20ads, that little sponsored word. And you know, most of the
- 8:23listings they show us, even sponsored ones, they look
- 8:26otherwise look identical to non ad listings at the top of most
- 8:30search results. And then sometimes also in the
- 8:32middle of them, you'll also see flashy ads, which these days
- 8:36often include video. And there's no wonder because
- 8:38Amazon now operates its own ad agency to produce that stuff.
- 8:43And of course, it charges sellers extra to run those
- 8:46flashy ads. But these days, Amazon throws
- 8:49around a lot of other labels. I saw things like Bestseller
- 8:53Today's deals. Customers frequently viewed,
- 8:55brands related to your search inspired by similar searches,
- 8:59New arrivals trending now. And as Amazon told me, these
- 9:03labels, they don't denote ads. Those labels are driven by its
- 9:07own algorithms. They describe that as it's a
- 9:09website feature, not something people pay for.
- 9:12But the problem is, because our search results now are so
- 9:15cluttered with so many labels, it's difficult to determine, you
- 9:19know, what's pay for play versus what Amazon just thinks we might
- 9:23like or something that Amazon has added to its website as a
- 9:26feature. The thing that was really
- 9:28confusing is that Amazon often groups listings into a box
- 9:32bordered by a thin little Gray line, and it puts a single
- 9:35little sponsor label way off to the left.
- 9:38That often made it really difficult for me to spot.
- 9:41Oh no, it's not just that this one thing's an ad.
- 9:44It's all five of these items are an ad.
- 9:46So bottom line, do you think Amazon is providing proper
- 9:50disclosure about what's an ad and what is it?
- 9:52So it's credit. Amazon at least does use that to
- 9:55tiny, but it uses a small sponsor label.
- 9:58You know, these days, many companies, they're not even
- 10:00disclosing what is and isn't an ad.
- 10:03All these social media influencers are constantly
- 10:06raving about products and hotels they say they've been to and
- 10:09restaurants and stuff. And, you know, they rarely
- 10:12bother to mention that they're getting paid to say these nice
- 10:15things about them. And sometimes they don't say
- 10:16anything at all. They just say they pretend like
- 10:18it's something they like and don't tell their viewers that
- 10:21they got paid $1,000,000 to say nice things about it.
- 10:24And when you go to a grocery store, you likely don't know
- 10:26about the financial relationships between
- 10:28manufacturers and stores in terms of, you know, what's on
- 10:31special and what's at the end of aisles and that, you know,
- 10:34manufacturers bid against one another for the best placement
- 10:37on shelves. So, you know, there's all types
- 10:39of paid promotions these days that consumers don't know about.
- 10:42South, at least Amazon is putting that label there.
- 10:45They are at least saying, hey, this thing was a sponsored
- 10:48placement. But it's clear that Amazon isn't
- 10:51abiding by all the rules. The FTC, it requires online
- 10:55sellers to prominently disclose ads using borders or shaded
- 10:59boxes and clear text labels. They say basically like you can
- 11:03use any method, but it has to be noticeable and understandable
- 11:07consumers. And I think really, you know,
- 11:09many of the listings in Amazon search results, they comply only
- 11:12partially with the FTC's requirements.
- 11:14I mean, it doesn't highlight ads using the different shade.
- 11:17It uses really thin borders to separate groups of ads from from
- 11:21non ads. And that little sponsor label, I
- 11:23mean, it's tidy, It's barely noticeable.
- 11:26And again, each of the items you're seeing, I mean, there are
- 11:29some flashy ads, but for the most part, the paid placements
- 11:32in Amazon search look like all the others except for that tiny
- 11:36Gray sponsored label. For listeners who shop on Amazon
- 11:39regularly, you probably know about the Amazon overall pick.
- 11:43So is that an ad or legit? Kevin's going to talk about that
- 11:46next. I'm Herb Weisbaum, the consumer
- 11:48man, and this is Consumer Pedia powered by checkbook.org.
- 11:53If you like what you hear, we hope you'll consider being a
- 11:56consumer PDS supporter by using the link at the bottom of the
- 11:59show notes to make a small contribution each month.
- 12:02This is consumer pedia. So almost all of Amazon search
- 12:07results spotlight one overall pick, which the company insists
- 12:10merchants cannot pay for. Kevin, is that overall picking
- 12:13out or is it really what they say?
- 12:15No, it's what they say. I mean, they say it's purely
- 12:17algorithm driven. No one can pay for it.
- 12:19Couldn't find anything on their site to where, you know, if
- 12:21you're a merchant, you could pay for it.
- 12:23And I hope it's not something the companies can pay for
- 12:26because I do rely on it pretty often.
- 12:28I mean, it's supposed to be this feature of Amazon's website that
- 12:31identifies high quality items, those that get favorable ratings
- 12:34from buyers and, you know, items that aren't returned very
- 12:37frequently and then and stuff that's bought often.
- 12:40But you know, here's what really annoyed me.
- 12:41In our tests, Amazon shoved down below several ads.
- 12:46This algorithm driven best pick. On average, I found it appeared
- 12:51in the eighth spot when I was searching for stuff, and usually
- 12:55in that eighth spot, on average it was trailing 7 different ads.
- 13:00So in some of the searches I did its overall pick, it didn't even
- 13:02show up until the 10th or 12th spot.
- 13:05And when I searched for dog food, Amazon's overall pick
- 13:08didn't show up until after 25 other ads.
- 13:12What's really annoying is that then I did a whole third round
- 13:16of searches, and this time I searched specifically for
- 13:19Amazon's overall pick, and on average that overall pick and
- 13:23those searches didn't show up until after four or five ads.
- 13:27And sometimes it didn't show up until after 9 or 10 ads.
- 13:31So Amazon's saying, hey, we have this, you know, helpful site
- 13:34feature that we've created. This overall pick, no one can
- 13:37buy it. It's purely algorithm driven.
- 13:39We're really trying to identify what might be the best thing for
- 13:42you to really simplify the shopping experience.
- 13:44But then, Oh yeah, we're also not going to show that to you
- 13:47until after four or five ads and sometimes 8 or 10 ads.
- 13:49Let me quote that good old Rock'n'roll song.
- 13:51Money, Money, Money, Money. Yeah.
- 13:54Did you find that using filters did help you a bit?
- 13:57Weed out a lot of the ads? Yeah, You know the big take away
- 14:00here is that filter are your friends on Amazon O, When we
- 14:04searched for a specific brand, it didn't really remove all the
- 14:07ads. But when I punched in a specific
- 14:10brand and then after I got my search results, I used Amazon's
- 14:15filters. For example, I asked to filter
- 14:17out anything that wasn't Adidas brand or Oral-B or blue.
- 14:21I wanted a blue sweatshirt as opposed to not saying what color
- 14:24sweatshirt. When I put in those filters,
- 14:27most of the ads, not all of them, but most of them did go
- 14:30away. And I did see greatly improved
- 14:33search results in terms of relevant to what I was looking
- 14:36for. So since doing this project,
- 14:38when I'm shopping on Amazon, I've used its filters whenever
- 14:41possible and it really help does help declutter my results, you
- 14:46know. The question, of course, is why
- 14:48doesn't Amazon produce such clean search results when you
- 14:51ask it to show you a specific brand or specific size or color
- 14:55in the first place? You know, I think we know the
- 14:58answer, right? I mean, it's getting paid more
- 15:01from those ads it's showing us. And therefore it just can't
- 15:04resist showing them to us, even though, you know, it does have
- 15:07this kind of parallel goal of showing us stuff that we might
- 15:10actually want to buy that's relevant to our search.
- 15:12I think Amazon is really having a difficult time here trying to
- 15:15decide, you know, do we want to show them a lot of ads that
- 15:18we're getting paid extra for, or do we want to show them stuff
- 15:21that we know they're going to want to buy?
- 15:23And I think those two goals have been really blended together.
- 15:27But right now, ads are coming out on top.
- 15:29Clearly Amazon isn't alone on there's a lot of websites we
- 15:31visit do the same thing. Yeah.
- 15:33And, you know, this is one of the things Amazon told us, which
- 15:35is, hey, you know, you're picking on us.
- 15:37Everyone's running ads. I mean, advertising's
- 15:40everywhere. We're a retailer.
- 15:41Of course, if we have an opportunity to make extra money
- 15:44off advertising, we're going to do that.
- 15:45We'd be dumb not to. And these days, when you search
- 15:48for stuff on on dozens of websites, especially for those
- 15:52from major retailers, you're going to run into ads a lot like
- 15:55what Amazon showed us. We checked out, you know, CVS,
- 15:58Home Depot, Lowe's, Target, Walgreens, Walmart, they're all
- 16:02showing ads now. And the ads are very clearly
- 16:06being driven by your own personal shopping history on
- 16:10those websites. But the ads on those websites,
- 16:12they have not taken over the entire search results as they
- 16:16have with Amazon. I mean, it's not even close.
- 16:18If you're on Best Buys website for example, and you're you
- 16:21know, the 1st 25 items, it'll show you a couple of them will
- 16:25be sponsored on Amazon. You know, on average we're
- 16:28finding, you know, 1213 out of 25 were ads.
- 16:32You know, that's getting to be something annoying with Google
- 16:34searches. You used to get what you wanted
- 16:36and now there's all these sponsors links up there and you
- 16:38got to be really careful you're clicking on the right thing.
- 16:40Yeah. But I mean there is a difference
- 16:41here though, right? I mean, Google exists as an
- 16:43advertising vehicle. That's, that's its whole revenue
- 16:46plan. And you know, it may be that
- 16:48when you first started using Google, you didn't expect to see
- 16:51all these ads. You expected to see clean search
- 16:53results, clean and relevant search results, But you know,
- 16:55it's morphed into an advertising vehicle.
- 16:57And the same is true of Twitter and, and Facebook and everyone
- 17:00else. Their whole revenue model is to
- 17:02show you ads and, and to show you personalized ads if they can
- 17:05get a hold of your data. Amazon, I think is different.
- 17:08Amazon has always said no, we're a marketplace here, and anybody
- 17:11can participate in our marketplace so long, as, you
- 17:14know, they can prove to us so they're not selling counterfeit
- 17:16goods, for example. It's a very different mechanism
- 17:19for revenue. Amazon's a retailer.
- 17:21Its goal is to show us stuff that we might want to buy and to
- 17:24make a sale. But now more and more, Amazon is
- 17:28gravitating more toward trying to get extra money from people
- 17:32who were willing to pay it extra to promote their stuff as
- 17:35opposed to just showing us the best things in search.
- 17:38I still don't think it's worth mentioning here that Amazon does
- 17:41a really good job with search results.
- 17:44It does. A lot of what we saw were ads,
- 17:46but again, at least they were relevant ads.
- 17:49And Amazon says you can't buy up your place in our search
- 17:53results. A lot of our stuff sponsored,
- 17:56but you can't bid up the way you can on Google.
- 17:59If you search for a plumber on Google, if you put in plumbers,
- 18:02it's going to show you up top sponsor listings from people who
- 18:05did to be there, they had to compete to listed first in
- 18:09Google search results. That's not necessarily the way
- 18:11it works on Amazon, although clearly Amazon has a vested
- 18:14interest and showing you a lot of ads because it's making extra
- 18:17money off of them. We should point out the federal
- 18:19government is suing Amazon, claiming the company did illegal
- 18:22things that drove up prices. We're going to talk to Kevin
- 18:25about that next. I'm her Weissbaum, the consumer
- 18:27man. And this is Consumer Pedia
- 18:29powered by checkbook.org. Consumer.
- 18:33Pedia Fast Facts When Jeff Bezos started Amazon in 1995, it only
- 18:39sold books and was run out of his home garage in the Seattle
- 18:42area. According to Business Insider,
- 18:44the company was originally called Cadabra as an
- 18:47abracadabra, but the company's lawyer said the reference to
- 18:50magic was too obscure and when said out loud, Cadabra could be
- 18:54mistaken for cadaver. So Bezos went with Amazon.
- 18:57The idea was the site selection of books would be vast and wide,
- 19:01just like the Amazon, the world's largest river.
- 19:03Bezos did have other names in mind.
- 19:05Business Cider says he still owns the domain.
- 19:07For one of them, type relentless.com in your browser
- 19:11and you'll be redirected to Amazon.
- 19:13And here's a fun fact. When he was a reporter at CBS
- 19:16News, Herb did one of the first network stories about Amazon.
- 19:20He later admitted at the time he couldn't understand why anyone
- 19:23would want to buy books online. Just for the record, Amazon now
- 19:27has 310 million active users worldwide.
- 19:30About 80% are from the US. Amazon selling practices are now
- 19:37being challenged in a potentially huge lawsuit filed
- 19:40by the Federal Trade Commission. The government is accusing
- 19:42Amazon of acting like a monopoly, and a federal judge
- 19:45recently ruled that the case can move forward.
- 19:48Kevin, what's the latest here? Yeah, so the FT CS lawsuit,
- 19:51it's, it's about more than just ads.
- 19:53It's alleged that Amazon has violated antitrust laws and done
- 19:57so for several reasons. One of the things the government
- 20:00has alleged is that Amazon forces third party merchants to
- 20:04have their stuff sold. And delivered by Amazon.
- 20:07You know, basically the FTC is saying that Amazon is just so
- 20:10big that manufacturers and merchants, they have to sell
- 20:14there. They, they don't have a choice.
- 20:15But once they're on Amazon, it, and this is according to the
- 20:19lawsuit I'm quoting, extracts enormous monopoly rents from
- 20:23everyone within its reach. End Quote.
- 20:25The FTC argues that Amazon is degrading the customer
- 20:28experience by replacing relevant search results with ads, which
- 20:32is again what we found. And it's doing so solely because
- 20:36it pays to do so. Amazon makes more money doing
- 20:38that and therefore that's why it does it.
- 20:40The FTC also said that Amazon biases its search results and
- 20:45ways that, you know, sellers must participate and pay Amazon
- 20:48more just to get noticed at all. The FTC says that in in many
- 20:51cases, sellers must hand off to Amazon close to 50% of their
- 20:56revenue. And it also alleges that Amazon
- 20:59uses anti discounting measures that punish other sellers if
- 21:03they offer items for lower prices elsewhere.
- 21:05And I think that's probably among all of them, the most
- 21:08serious allegation. Yeah.
- 21:09The FTC is saying basically that Amazon it squashes sellers if
- 21:14they don't offer their best possible prices when selling on
- 21:17Amazon and then to even get noticed on Amazon, they have to
- 21:21pay the company extra to get their stuff promoted and noticed
- 21:24at all. That's that's where Amazon might
- 21:26run into trouble if the FTC can prove those charges.
- 21:29So this lawsuit was brought under the Biden administration's
- 21:33Federal Trade Commission, very aggressive against tech
- 21:35companies and what it believes are companies are acting in a
- 21:38monopolistic way. The question is, will it be
- 21:41dropped by the new Trump administration?
- 21:43Well, you know, I think it's possible.
- 21:45There's no way to know yet. He hasn't really commented on it
- 21:48yet. But but in terms of this lawsuit
- 21:50against Amazon, 17 states join the lawsuit.
- 21:54So, you know, the new Trump White House, you know, won't
- 21:57necessarily be able to get those states to drop it and most of
- 21:59them won't. So I think the case can move
- 22:01forward. The question is, you know, what
- 22:04will happen if Amazon loses the lawsuit.
- 22:07It has said on its own that this lawsuit would cause it to have
- 22:10to charge higher prices and have slower deliveries.
- 22:14And you know, I hate to say it, but it might have a point there
- 22:17if it has to give equal weight and search results to 3rd party
- 22:20companies. You know, this whole marketplace
- 22:23that Amazon promises people that doesn't really exist.
- 22:26It definitely favors its own stuff or at least make sure that
- 22:29it's undercutting its competitors on its own side on
- 22:32price. But if it has to increase its
- 22:34prices or, you know, I'm not sure how much that helps
- 22:37consumers, I just don't know. I mean, I find on my own that
- 22:40getting stuff directly from Amazon is usually faster and
- 22:44better than when I buy on that site from a third party seller
- 22:48that's delivering it on its own. I think returns when I'm buying
- 22:51something that's delivered and fulfilled by Amazon tend to be
- 22:54easier also. But I don't think it's such a
- 22:57bad idea to force Amazon, you know, to give me a better way or
- 23:01easier way to filter out other results or to compare items and
- 23:04get prices more easily. You know, if Amazon is, in fact,
- 23:08forcing sellers on its site or punishing them for offering
- 23:12lower prices elsewhere, I think that's a big problem because,
- 23:15you know, people should be able to shop for price on other
- 23:18sites. You know, there should be a
- 23:19competitive marketplace out there.
- 23:20And not everything being determined by what Amazon says.
- 23:23Oh, that's the price you have to charge for this item.
- 23:26So before we go, we need to remind everyone listening that
- 23:29when you shop online, you've got to be careful.
- 23:31Companies are increasingly manipulating you into paying
- 23:34them more, and often in very subtle ways.
- 23:36Yeah, exactly. Amazon and all major sellers
- 23:39these days, they're often using our own data against us.
- 23:43And they may not just be data they've scooped up, it's data
- 23:46that brokers have out there. I mean, it's just the Wild West
- 23:49right now in terms of consumer data.
- 23:52They can tap into all sorts of resources, buy trade data, and
- 23:57we have usually little to no idea what's involved in that.
- 24:00And so, you know, in this case, Amazon and other companies, if
- 24:04they think they can nudge us and to pay more, they're going to do
- 24:07it, even if it means making it more difficult to shop on their
- 24:11websites. Well, they don't seem to have a
- 24:13problem with that. If there's more revenue to be
- 24:15had by even creating a more miserable experience for us, in
- 24:18this case, we found that that doesn't seem to matter so much
- 24:21to them. I think the key is that you can
- 24:23no longer trust that you'll be shown the best thing for you on
- 24:27Amazon or anywhere else online. You know what I do?
- 24:29I I get a piece of paper and a pencil, make a list and I
- 24:32actually get in a car and drive to a store and buy everything at
- 24:35once and then bring it home and it's instantaneous delivery.
- 24:38Well you know this is the benefit of being semi retired
- 24:40her. I did it when I was working full
- 24:43time. Come on.
- 24:46But anyway, I know, I know where the marketplace is moving, so
- 24:49we've got to just got to deal with that.
- 24:50And I live in Seattle, so I live in Amazon land.
- 24:53Exactly. You can read Kevin's full story
- 24:56all about this Amazon flood search results with ads on our
- 24:59website, checkbook.org. Kevin, thank you for doing all
- 25:03this shopping. So those of us listening didn't
- 25:05have to do it. And by the way, Kevin shopped
- 25:07for dog food, but he does not have a dog.
- 25:09Let's make that very clear to everybody.
- 25:11That's right. This is not necessarily things I
- 25:13needed, no. Be well, talk to you soon.
- 25:15Thanks Sir. Before we go, here a few other
- 25:17consumer Pedia podcasts you might want to check out #32
- 25:21Grocery delivery services and #49 Shop Like a Pro.
- 25:26Well, that's it for this time. We hope you'll rate this episode
- 25:29and follow us on Apple Podcast, Spotify, or wherever you listen
- 25:32to your podcasts. Remember, we release new
- 25:35episodes every other Thursday. Another way you can support this
- 25:39show is to follow us on Consumer Pedia on Facebook and Instagram
- 25:43and My Consumer Pedia on X Formal early Twitter.
- 25:46I'm Herb Weisbaum. Thanks for listening.
- 25:49Consumerpedia is a public service of checkbook.org.
- 25:52We're a unique nonprofit that helps you save money and make
- 25:55smarter choices. You can count on Checkbook to
- 25:58help you find the best services and avoid the worst with local
- 26:01ratings that are accurate and unbiased.
- 26:04If you live in or around these seven cities and haven't joined
- 26:07Checkbook yet, check us out Boston, Chicago, Philadelphia,
- 26:11Seattle, San Francisco, Minneapolis, Saint Paul, and
- 26:15Washington DC. To get your free 30 day
- 26:18subscription, go to checkbook.org/consumer Pedia.
- 26:21If you like what you've heard, we hope you'll become a
- 26:23supporter by using the link at the bottom of the show notes to
- 26:26make a small contribution each month.
- 26:29Consumer Pedia. Empowering consumers to save
- 26:32money and make smarter choices.