Latest / CLEs You Actually Want to Hear / Don’t Get SLAPPed Around in Civil Court: How to Recognize and Handle Anti-SLAPP
Transcript
- 0:03Welcome to Don't Get Slapped Around in Civil
- 0:08Court. How to recognize and handle anti -slap
- 0:12issues. I'm Lori Kripmark, the vice chair of
- 0:15the Beverly Hills Bar Association litigation
- 0:17section. I'm a certified family law specialist.
- 0:20I'm delighted to introduce today's speaker, Brendan
- 0:23J. Begley. Brendan is a shareholder at Weintraub
- 0:27Tobin. In litigation, Brendan has worked on class
- 0:31actions and managed entire cases, including conducting
- 0:35witness interviews, preparing and responding
- 0:38to written discovery, arguing related motions,
- 0:42taking and defending scores of depositions, while
- 0:45prevailing on numerous anti -slap and dispositive
- 0:49motions. He has mediated many cases and second
- 0:52chair trials to successful verdicts. At the appellate
- 0:56stage, Brendan has handled both briefing and
- 0:59oral argument before all appellate courts from
- 1:03the California Court of Appeal to the U .S. Supreme
- 1:05Court. And now let's get started. Take it away.
- 1:10Thank you, Lori, for the very kind introduction.
- 1:12And thanks to the Beverly Hills Bar Association
- 1:14for giving me this opportunity. And thanks to
- 1:17all of you who are joining me today. I want to
- 1:21make sure, let's see, you can all see my screen.
- 1:24Yes. You know, I want to start with a standard
- 1:27disclaimer. I'm going to entertain questions
- 1:30once I get through maybe halfway through the
- 1:32presentation where I kind of give you all the.
- 1:35nuts and bolts about how anti -slap works and
- 1:37things to look out for. And after that, we'll
- 1:40go into some hypotheticals, but it would be unfair
- 1:42for me to launch into the hypotheticals without
- 1:45answering some of your questions first. And so
- 1:47as long as it's understood, like all these MCLEs,
- 1:50right, that I'm not giving you specific legal
- 1:52advice about a particular case, but we're just
- 1:54talking about hypotheticals to kind of illustrate
- 1:56and promote understanding of how this area of
- 1:59law works in general. So to get that started,
- 2:02you know, my vanity compels me to talk about
- 2:05me for a little bit. So you know why I might
- 2:08be somebody who knows a little bit about this
- 2:11area of law. When I was in, before law school
- 2:14and part of during law school, I worked as a
- 2:16newspaper reporter and I wrote some newspaper
- 2:19stories about a fire department that was making
- 2:21a transition from kind of a volunteer organization
- 2:25to a professional organization. And you know,
- 2:27they had some growing pains along the way. But
- 2:30this fire department was used to just nothing
- 2:32but positive publicity, you know, like they rode
- 2:35in the fourth of July parade and the Dalmatian
- 2:37sat on the truck and didn't bark or what have
- 2:39you. And so when they started, you know, getting
- 2:41some kind of critical press from me, they got
- 2:45really mad and they hired a lawyer who went to
- 2:47a law school that taught him a really good lawyer
- 2:50knows how to cuss, how to yell and how to insult
- 2:53and how to try to intimidate and bully. And so
- 2:57like he he threatened me consistently, multiple
- 2:59times with all kinds of lawsuits. And I was what
- 3:02you call a stringer. I wasn't a full time employee
- 3:05for the newspaper. I was trying to prove myself.
- 3:06So I was like an independent contractor. They
- 3:09bought my stories for me for like a dollar an
- 3:12inch. Even back then, I would have starved if
- 3:14that's the only job I had. So I was kind of frightened.
- 3:17You know, I couldn't afford to hire any of you
- 3:19or myself as a lawyer to defend against a lawsuit
- 3:23like that. So I had some sleepless nights thinking
- 3:25about You know, did I corroborate that? Do I
- 3:29have facts to back it up? Do I have any typos
- 3:31if they're going to sue me for in my article?
- 3:34But a judge I clerked for nicknamed me Babylon
- 3:35Brendan, so I wasn't going to back down. I kept
- 3:39on writing my stories and you know he didn't
- 3:42sue me. My stories were accurate and you know
- 3:45they didn't like them but so what. After I got
- 3:47out of law school and I started practicing I
- 3:49discovered the anti -slap statute and oh my goodness
- 3:52I thought if this statute had been around when
- 3:55this guy was threatening me I wouldn't have lost
- 3:57one minute of sleep. I still would have you know
- 3:59been careful to make sure my stories were accurate
- 4:01but I wouldn't have worried because I would have
- 4:04said, well, go ahead and sue me because if you
- 4:06sue me, we're going to file an anti -SLAP motion
- 4:08and you're going to pay my attorney's fees for
- 4:11defending against your strategic lawsuit against
- 4:15public participation. That's what a SLAP is,
- 4:17a strategic lawsuit against public participation.
- 4:21So anyhow, what I really love and adore about
- 4:23this statute ever since I discovered it way back
- 4:25in like 2000, 2001, was that and remains that
- 4:31it's an anti -bully statute. If you're able to
- 4:36use an anti -slap motion successfully, you and
- 4:38your client are going to be thrilled. If you
- 4:40find yourself in the crosshairs of a solid anti
- 4:44-slap motion, you're never going to forget it.
- 4:48suffer some discomfort and so my presentation
- 4:51here is really to help you all see not only how
- 4:54to bring an anti -slot motion or what kind of
- 4:56situations you should file an anti -slot motion
- 4:58but also hopefully and maybe even more importantly
- 5:01how to draft your complaints your petitions your
- 5:04legal actions in a way where you don't get hit
- 5:07with an anti -slot motion or at least if you
- 5:09do you knew it was coming you got your ducks
- 5:12in a row and you'll be able to deal with it appropriately.
- 5:15So me, me, me, enough about me. What do you think
- 5:18about the fact that when I discovered this statute...
- 5:21I found a way to expand it from the classical
- 5:24kind of defamation kinds of claims and infliction
- 5:28of emotional distress claims into employment
- 5:31law. And I got a published decision out of it
- 5:33in 2007, Virgos v. McNeil. Well, you might think
- 5:37as much me as the woman in the picture thinks
- 5:39of that guy. So let's move on from there. And
- 5:42I'll tell you what's more important is not so
- 5:45much what I did, but how to recognize claims
- 5:48that could trigger and make you vulnerable to
- 5:51an anti -slap motion or claims that are filed
- 5:54against your client that you can attack through
- 5:56an anti -slap motion. And so that's the two things
- 6:00I really want to focus on is how to avoid pleading
- 6:04a claim that can get you in trouble and how to
- 6:07recognize a claim that can lead you and your
- 6:10client to a really good outcome at a very early
- 6:12stage of the case. Let's focus on some things
- 6:17I'm not going to talk about in this discussion.
- 6:20I'm not going to focus too much on whether or
- 6:21not it's good policy. As you can tell, I'm a
- 6:23bit of a fan because I found ways to use it effectively.
- 6:26Not only in filing anti -slap motions, but listen,
- 6:29my colleagues here at my firm come to me and
- 6:31say, we're thinking about drafting a complaint.
- 6:34What do you think about this? Because they've
- 6:36heard me talk about anti -slap and they have
- 6:37an idea of what can get you in trouble. And we've
- 6:40been able to draft complaints that have avoided
- 6:43anti -slap scrutiny. So I'm not going to talk
- 6:46about whether or not it's good policy. I tend
- 6:48to think it is, but at the same time, I acknowledge
- 6:50there's been a lot of misuse of it out there.
- 6:53And so, you know, we're not going to go into
- 6:57a detailed analysis of the exceptions to the
- 6:59anti -SLAP statute, but they're out there. The
- 7:02anti -slap statute is section 425 .16 of the
- 7:05codicill procedure. The exceptions are just one
- 7:08page over in section 425 .17. So if you think
- 7:12you have a potential anti -slap exposure or you
- 7:17might be looking to file an anti -slap motion
- 7:20against something filed against your client,
- 7:23turn the page to 425 .17. Have a look at those
- 7:26exceptions. I'm also not going to talk about
- 7:29slapbacks except to tell you basically what they
- 7:31are. There's a lot of misunderstanding out there
- 7:33about what a slapback is. But if you file a slap
- 7:37lawsuit against somebody, say malicious prosecution,
- 7:42well, let's say anything, any kind of lawsuit
- 7:45that you file that turns out to be a strategic
- 7:47lawsuit against public participation and it gets
- 7:50bounced out by an anti -slap motion, that anti
- 7:53-slap motion got the other side their attorney
- 7:56fees. and that's it. But it's possible, in fact
- 7:59even maybe likely, that because your claim got
- 8:02thrown out by an anti -slap motion, it was not
- 8:05only anti -slappable, but it was also frivolous
- 8:09and therefore subject to malicious prosecution
- 8:12liability. And so that means the other side can
- 8:16file a lawsuit against you and your client alleging
- 8:19malicious prosecution. And after everything I
- 8:21tell you today, if I didn't tell you about slapback,
- 8:23you'd think, ah, A malicious prosecution claim
- 8:26is per se protected by the anti -slap statute.
- 8:30If somebody files a malicious prosecution claim
- 8:32against me, I can file an anti -slap motion against
- 8:34them. Well, that malicious prosecution claim
- 8:38in the scenario I've described is a slapback.
- 8:41It follows a successful anti -slap motion, which
- 8:44is really going to decrease your ability to anti
- 8:46-slap. that malicious prosecution claim. So that's
- 8:50what a slapback is. A slapback is a malicious
- 8:52prosecution claim that follows a successful anti
- 8:55-slap motion. All right, so we're not going to
- 8:59go into a lot of detail about that. We're not
- 9:01going to assess claims that don't enjoy prom
- 9:051 protection because they the speech or petitioning
- 9:10activity was illegal as a matter of law. There's
- 9:13a California Supreme Court case that discusses
- 9:15this, Flatley v. Morrow. And by the way, I want
- 9:18to say all the cases that you see in the slide
- 9:20presentation are summarized in the handout materials,
- 9:24so don't feel like you have to scribble down
- 9:26case names before I run to the next slide. They're
- 9:29all in there with a little synopsis. So Flatley
- 9:33V. Morrow, Flatley was the guy, Michael Flatley,
- 9:36who was in Riverdance, that popular Irish step
- 9:39dancing performance. I had a cousin who was the
- 9:42only person in the world who told me when I was
- 9:44younger, she thought I looked like him and everybody
- 9:46else wants to say Conan O 'Brien. I'd rather
- 9:48be Michael Flatley, but all right, there's that.
- 9:51We're not gonna talk about these kinds of claims.
- 9:55The Flatley decision is very, I don't know, dense,
- 10:00but it covers it quite a bit. The takeaway is
- 10:02it's very rare that you're going to be able to
- 10:04say something isn't protected at Prom 1 because
- 10:07it's per se illegal. You're going to understand
- 10:10more about that as I get further in the presentation,
- 10:12but we're not going to talk about that little
- 10:15wrinkle so much. We're also not going to do detailed
- 10:18discussion about anti -slot motions in federal
- 10:21court. You can file them there. There are some
- 10:25wrinkles to that. You don't get the discovery
- 10:27freeze and some other stuff, but anyhow, you
- 10:29just need to know you can do them there too.
- 10:33Also, some things we're not going to talk about.
- 10:35We're not going to, I'm not going to cover detailed
- 10:37how to's, how do you file it. I'm not going to
- 10:40do what to do's if you get hit with one, except
- 10:43say, I'm going to say right now there's two prongs.
- 10:46Don't make the rookie mistake of just arguing
- 10:48prong one. This isn't protected activity. Take
- 10:51the second step and show that your claims have
- 10:53a likelihood of success. You're going to hear
- 10:55me talk about the two problems quite a bit. So
- 10:57that's an initial preview. We're not going to
- 11:00do what abouts in connection with attorney fees.
- 11:03If you win an anti -slot motion, you get attorney
- 11:05fees. If you lose, the other side is only going
- 11:08to get attorney fees if your anti -slot motion
- 11:10was frivolous. So I'm not going to go into that.
- 11:13How do you file the motion? What kind of declaration
- 11:15do you need with it? Does the load star apply?
- 11:17We're not going to go into all that. We're also
- 11:20not going to do detailed ONOs about the discovery
- 11:22freeze, although I am going to talk to you about
- 11:24it a little bit to emphasize why you really should
- 11:27care about this statute and anti -slap remedies.
- 11:31We're also not going to talk about the immediate
- 11:33right to appeal. That's probably one of the more
- 11:35controversial things about anti -slap. That's
- 11:38where most judges really bristle as the immediate
- 11:43appeal. We're not going to talk about whether
- 11:45or not that's good or bad. You just need to know.
- 11:47that immediate appeal can have consequences for
- 11:50your case. And let's talk about why. Let's first
- 11:53talk though about why do we even have this law?
- 11:56Well, you know, the very beginning of 425 .16
- 12:00says it's because there's been a disturbing increase
- 12:02in lawsuits brought to chill -free expression.
- 12:05The classic kind of anti -slap, you know, a classic
- 12:09kind of slap case that I suppose motivated the
- 12:13anti -slap statute would be somebody wants to
- 12:16build some kind of thing in your neighborhood,
- 12:19some kind of commercial enterprise, and maybe
- 12:21it pollutes, maybe it's going to diminish the
- 12:25ability of small businesses to stay afloat. Maybe
- 12:28it's going to have environmental impact, maybe
- 12:30it's going to have noise pollution, who knows?
- 12:33Lots of different people might want to. Circulate
- 12:37petitions against the building of this and go
- 12:39to the zoning commission and go to the city council
- 12:41and go to the board of supervisors and say, we
- 12:44really don't want this in our neighborhood. And
- 12:46so the commercial enterprise goes out and files
- 12:49a lawsuit, not because you've really defamed
- 12:51them by circulating this petition activity, not
- 12:54because you've really caused them any financial
- 12:56damage, but just because they want to shut you
- 12:58up. They do not want you to cause any problems
- 13:01with this thing getting developed. They don't
- 13:03want you to jeopardize it at all, even though
- 13:05everything you're doing to jeopardize their project
- 13:07is First Amendment protected. They can still
- 13:10sue you for it, and then you have to march all
- 13:12the way through discovery, maybe a demur at the
- 13:15beginning, a summary judgment motion, and then
- 13:18possibly a bench or a jury trial. you know that's
- 13:21I don't have to tell you all that's very expensive
- 13:23you know we're talking about easily six figures
- 13:25right to march all the way through that high
- 13:27six figures I think in a lot of cases so you
- 13:31know a person who's engaging in that kind of
- 13:33petitioning activity is likely going to say uncle
- 13:35I'll settle with you big company dismiss your
- 13:40lawsuit against me and I promise I won't go circulate
- 13:42these petitions anymore and so for the cost of
- 13:45you know nickels and dimes to them they have
- 13:48squelched a lot of free speech and petitioning
- 13:50activity. So the legislature passed this statute,
- 13:53and it says if somebody sues you for something
- 13:55that compromises your free speech and petitioning
- 13:59activity rights, you're going to be able to file
- 14:02an anti -slap motion at the beginning of the
- 14:04lawsuit to test how strong of a claim it is.
- 14:07And if it's not strong, the court's going to
- 14:09throw it out, and they're going to award you
- 14:11your attorney fees for the inconvenience. The
- 14:15statute also says at the very beginning, this
- 14:18section is to be construed broadly. That's because
- 14:20when the statute was first enacted, like in 1992,
- 14:24it was toothless and courts were construing it
- 14:27very narrowly and finding a lot of stuff to be
- 14:29unprotected that really should be protected activity.
- 14:33And so the legislature amended the statute roughly
- 14:36in 1998 and said it's supposed to be construed
- 14:38broadly. Because of the immediate appeal, I think
- 14:41a lot of appellate courts are still not very
- 14:45open to the idea of constraint as broadly as
- 14:47the legislature, in my opinion, intended. And
- 14:51so there's still a lot of constraints on it.
- 14:53Well, why else should you care? You know, okay,
- 14:56your case isn't a big, you know, a big company
- 14:59trying to build something in the neighborhood.
- 15:01Why should you care about anti -slab? Well, because
- 15:03it's expanded a lot since then. As you're going
- 15:05to see in my presentation, there's a lot more
- 15:08kinds of claims that are covered by anti -slab.
- 15:11But for the claims that are covered, when you
- 15:13do see an anti -slap motion, I think you should
- 15:15care a little bit about this discovery freeze.
- 15:18It's in section 425 .16 G, and it freezes all
- 15:22discovery pertaining to the slap claim. Now,
- 15:26there might be other claims in the lawsuit that
- 15:28are not so related. I think if there's any overlap
- 15:31at all, a judge is going to say, yeah. it's subject
- 15:34to the discovery phrase because I don't want
- 15:36to see a whole lot of discovery motions until
- 15:38they work that stuff out. If there's overlap
- 15:40at all, don't waste our time and the taxpayer's
- 15:42money trying to sort out discovery disputes.
- 15:44Go settle the anti -slap dispute first. All right.
- 15:48Well, you're thinking, I'm not going to need
- 15:51that much discovery, so I don't really care about
- 15:55that. Well, what you should care about too is
- 15:58you're not going to get the discovery you might
- 16:00need to defend against the anti -slap motion.
- 16:03you know you just filed a lawsuit based on what
- 16:05your client told you but your client might not
- 16:07have all the evidence you need to support that
- 16:09you might need to get that discovery and if you
- 16:11lose hey have a look at this slide right you're
- 16:14going to pay attorney fees and you know i mean
- 16:17sometimes judges give you your haircut but i've
- 16:18seen anti -slap attorney fees that court appellate
- 16:21courts have approved extend way into the six
- 16:23figures commonly they're around 20 or 30 thousand
- 16:27dollars i saw one recently where somebody called
- 16:29me and got hit with a $3 ,000 attorney fee award.
- 16:33I said, don't appeal. It's going to cost you
- 16:36way more than $3 ,000 to prosecute the appeal.
- 16:39Just be thankful they didn't hit you for more.
- 16:42So if the party who files the anti -slap motion
- 16:45wins, they are going to get attorney fees. The
- 16:47only question is, can they show a reasonable
- 16:50number of hours and that their rates were reasonable?
- 16:53That's going to be the only question. They are
- 16:54entitled to fees. If they file an anti -slap
- 16:57motion and lose, you can only recover your attorney
- 17:01fees for opposing their anti -slap motion if
- 17:04their anti -slap motion was frivolous. And so,
- 17:08okay, frivolous is going to depend a lot more
- 17:13on prong one. And I know you're eager to hear
- 17:15about the two prongs. And so I'm going to get
- 17:16to that very quickly. Prong one is you have to
- 17:20show that the claim against your client arises
- 17:24from activity protected by the anti -slap statute.
- 17:26There's four different kinds of things that are
- 17:28expressly protected. I'm going to talk about
- 17:30all of them in a minute. If the anti -slap motion
- 17:33shows that the claim against your client arises
- 17:36from protected activity, that triggers prong
- 17:38two, where the plaintiff or plaintiffs have to
- 17:41show a likelihood of success. Now, if the anti
- 17:46-slap motion fails at prong one, the likelihood
- 17:48of The anti -slap motion being frivolous is going
- 17:52to be higher. If it fails at prong two, probably
- 17:55not so high because it's the other side. The
- 17:58plaintiff's burden to show likelihood of success,
- 18:00the party filing the anti -slap motion does not
- 18:02carry that burden. It's tougher to say that their
- 18:06motion was frivolous. There's this case out there,
- 18:11City of Rockland, the Legacy Family Adventures.
- 18:14That was a recent case that hit. included award
- 18:21of attorney fees for an anti -slot motion the
- 18:24court said was frivolous. There's also City of
- 18:26Alhambra. I commend both these cases to you for
- 18:29your consideration on that topic. Why else should
- 18:33you care about anti -slot? You got a discovery
- 18:36freeze, you got the prospect of attorney fees
- 18:39looming out there. Well, there's also this immediate
- 18:41appeal that I talked about. That's probably the
- 18:43most controversial thing from a judge's perspective
- 18:46because the appellate courts feel like they've
- 18:48become backlogged. with all kinds of appeals.
- 18:50Normally, you have to wait for the end of the
- 18:52case before you can appeal. But here, these antiseptic
- 18:54motions are coming out before anybody's even
- 18:56propounded interrogatories are taken into deposition.
- 19:00So you might think, well, so what? I've handled
- 19:03appeals before. Well, if you have, then you know
- 19:06an appeal is going to take over a year. And that
- 19:08discovery freeze is going to remain in place
- 19:11during that whole time. So, you know, maybe eventually
- 19:14you're going to triumph, but it's going to be
- 19:16a long way before you get there if you pled your
- 19:19claim in such a way where it triggered an anti
- 19:20-slap motion. And so if you can plead your claim
- 19:23in a way that it doesn't, you're going to, you
- 19:26know, get to where you want to be or where you
- 19:27hope to be a lot faster. All right. So what kind
- 19:34of claims are, look, the kind of claims that
- 19:36right away red sirens should be going off in
- 19:39your head, red, you know, alarms should be going
- 19:41off, red alert, red alert. A malicious prosecution
- 19:43or abuse of process claim. This is really as
- 19:46close to per se protected by the anti -slap statute
- 19:49as anything. I honestly think it could be malpractice
- 19:52not to file an anti -slap motion to challenge
- 19:55a malicious prosecution or abuse of process claim.
- 19:57You'll see why in just a minute. Defamation claims,
- 20:00very common. Now listen, that's not to say all
- 20:02defamation claims are subject to the anti -slap
- 20:05statute, but I would bet There's probably a plurality
- 20:09of antislapped motions that were successful,
- 20:12the challenge defamation claims, you know, that's
- 20:15probably one of the most common claims that gets
- 20:17hit by antislapped. Interference with contractual
- 20:20relations perspective economic advantage is also
- 20:22very common, as is infliction of emotional distress.
- 20:26Now that's a cause of action that alleges either
- 20:30negligent or intentional infliction of emotional
- 20:33distress, not just a prayer for relief, let me
- 20:36recover my emotional distress damages. It's got
- 20:38to be a claim that arises out of protected activity.
- 20:41And so it has to be a claim, a cause of action,
- 20:45say an infliction of emotional distress. Sometimes
- 20:47people will dress up these malicious prosecution
- 20:49claims as an infliction of emotional distress
- 20:51claim and not call it malicious prosecution,
- 20:54but it's there. It's the same difference. So
- 20:58if you see any of these kinds of claims, you
- 20:59should really be thinking, I should think about
- 21:02anti -slap. How's anti -slap going to impact
- 21:05this claim? Maybe not at all, but I at least
- 21:07got to think about it and walk through the process.
- 21:10Well, there's also been emerging claims. Like
- 21:12I said, it's not just limited to those defamation
- 21:15and interference with prospective economic advantage
- 21:17claims. It's expanded. I take the credit of the
- 21:21blame. I helped expand it into employment discrimination
- 21:24claims that Virgo's claim was an employment case.
- 21:28Breach of contract and breach of implied contract
- 21:30cases also have been known to give rise to successful
- 21:34anti -slot motions. You can bring an anti -slot
- 21:37motion in an arbitration, even if you didn't
- 21:39file it first in court. If you file a demand
- 21:41for an arbitration, there are ways to get the
- 21:44arbitrator to hear your anti -slot motion. I
- 21:46don't know if arbitrators are as likely to grant
- 21:48them. As judges, I haven't done an arbitration
- 21:52where it was triggered, but there is published
- 21:54appellate decision that says that's how it works.
- 21:57Real estate disputes, maybe even inverse condemnation
- 22:00and imminent domain cases. Probate petitions
- 22:05to disinherent in accordance with the no contest
- 22:08clause. Those are really going to be covered.
- 22:12I'm just going to stop to explain why that is
- 22:14briefly. If you're suing somebody for something
- 22:19they did in court, which is exactly what a malicious
- 22:22prosecution claim is, that's going to be protected
- 22:25by anti -slap. And if you're filing a petition
- 22:27to disinherit somebody under a no -contest clause,
- 22:30it's because they've contested the will or the
- 22:34trust in court. That's protected activity under
- 22:37the anti -slap statute. Entertainment law claims,
- 22:40particularly these designee claims. If those
- 22:43of you, I'm sure there's a number of you who
- 22:44are entertainment lawyers out there. on my webinar,
- 22:47on my presentation today. These DESNI claims,
- 22:51for a long time, they were kind of not so protected
- 22:54by anti -SLAPP, but just in the last couple years,
- 22:56the California Court of Appeal issued two different
- 22:58decisions that really resurrected them. So DESNI
- 23:01claims are very well in the anti -SLAPP arena
- 23:03now. Family law cases, especially renewals of
- 23:07domestic violence restraining orders. I don't
- 23:10want to sound like I brag, but I saw this coming,
- 23:12you know, like six, seven years ago. and now
- 23:14just a couple years ago there is a published
- 23:16appellate decision out there about how it works
- 23:18in that context. It's kind of a unique case so
- 23:21it doesn't have broad applicability but it does
- 23:23signal, it does kind of confirm my intuition
- 23:26that DVROs can be challenged if somebody's trying
- 23:29to renew the domestic violence restraining order
- 23:31based on what the person to be restrained did
- 23:34in court. That's probably going to be covered
- 23:37by anti -slap. and also civil actions against
- 23:40litigants and their attorneys for litigation
- 23:42related statements or conduct, you know, either
- 23:45in trial or even in connection with enforcing
- 23:48judgments. All this stuff is, you know, triggering
- 23:51activity that's protected by the anti -slab statute.
- 23:55All right, so now you're wondering, how does
- 23:56it work, Brendan? Don't keep us in suspense.
- 23:58You told us about these two prongs, but you didn't
- 24:00go into detail, so tell me more. Well, The statute
- 24:04doesn't really expressly say anything about two
- 24:06prongs, but courts have interpreted to say there
- 24:08are two steps to the anti -slap analysis. And
- 24:11so it's because it says that a cause of action
- 24:14arising from protected activity is subject to
- 24:18a motion to strike, which is prong one, unless
- 24:21at prong two, a court determines that the plaintiff
- 24:25has established there's a probability that the
- 24:27plaintiff will prevail on the claim. And so in
- 24:30making that decision, it's not like a demurrer.
- 24:33It's sort of like it, but it's not like it because
- 24:34with a demurrer, you can't file declarations.
- 24:37With an anti -slap motion, either side can file
- 24:39declarations. Courts have said you cannot file
- 24:42one with your reply brief. I don't think that's
- 24:45the best reason decision, but that is kind of
- 24:48what the courts are saying right now. No other
- 24:50court has, no other published decision from a
- 24:53court of appeal has disagreed with that holding.
- 24:59So, prong one, you know, well, let's talk about
- 25:03logistics first and then I'm gonna go back and
- 25:05we're gonna talk about two prongs a lot more.
- 25:07You have to file it within 60 days of service
- 25:10of the complaint. Now, as I highlighted in red,
- 25:13the court has discretion to give you more time
- 25:15to do it. When I first started filing these motions
- 25:1720 years ago, I think courts were more likely
- 25:21to give you that little extra leeway. I think
- 25:23a lot less so now. I think. Our courts have become
- 25:27deluged. We don't have enough judges. They're
- 25:30kind of behind. They're trying to keep up. And
- 25:33if they don't have to decide something because
- 25:35you didn't file something on time, I don't think
- 25:37they're going to be as eager to let it sit. So
- 25:40I'd say when you get that complaint right away,
- 25:43you should be thinking about, does anti -SLAPP
- 25:45apply to this case? 60 days seems like a long
- 25:48time until you're at day 58, and you're only
- 25:51looking at it then. Now, court is supposed to
- 25:55hear the case within 30 days of service of the
- 25:57motion unless the docket conditions require a
- 26:00later hearing. It's almost always going to be
- 26:03the case. I've never heard maybe once or twice
- 26:05I've had an anti -slap motion heard within 30
- 26:09days. It's almost never. I had one, a recent
- 26:13one, I think it took about six months after I
- 26:16filed the anti -slap motion before we actually
- 26:17had the hearing. Now the discovery freeze does
- 26:21apply during that whole time. So the case is
- 26:23kind of sitting idle, but, you know, both parties
- 26:25might want to get the thing going and get to
- 26:27figure out what's going to happen next. So you're
- 26:29going to be waiting for a while. All right. What
- 26:31is the complaint? We know, well, Brendan, I do
- 26:34family law. I do probate. They don't have complaints.
- 26:36They have petitions. Well, for purpose of antislapped,
- 26:39a complaint is a cross -complaint, a petition,
- 26:43a plaintiff includes a cross -complaint and a
- 26:45petitioner. A defendant is a cross -defendant
- 26:46and a respondent. So take it from me, courts
- 26:49have construed these terms very, very broadly.
- 26:52I mean, that's right there in the statute, but
- 26:54this Shepard case that I cite here says even
- 26:58an arbital form. That's not a complaint. That's
- 27:00not a petition. It's kind of a demand for arbitration.
- 27:03They say, no, that triggers it. You can file
- 27:05an anti -slot motion there, too. So it's not
- 27:08just routine civil actions. It can go into probate,
- 27:11family law. So far, it cannot extend into criminal
- 27:14law, but I don't think it'll go there. other
- 27:17things that it can get into. Now, there's a 60
- 27:22-day deadline. You should be thinking about it
- 27:24right away. If they file an amended complaint,
- 27:27it's only going to restart that 60 -day deadline
- 27:29if they allege something new in the amended complaint
- 27:33that wasn't in the original complaint that leads
- 27:35to anti -SLAP scrutiny, that alleges some activity
- 27:39that's arguably protected by the anti -SLAP statute.
- 27:43So California Supreme Court decided this case
- 27:45just A few years back, Newport, again, all these
- 27:49cases were in the handout, so you don't have
- 27:50to scribble them down before I advance the slide.
- 27:54All right, so two steps. You heard me say it
- 27:56a few times now. By the end of this presentation,
- 27:58you should be thinking about the two steps and
- 28:00the first step in particular. Okay, that should
- 28:03be one of the big takeaways. There's two steps.
- 28:06The first step is you have to establish a challenge
- 28:10claim arises from protected activity. And the
- 28:13second step If the defendant shows that the claim
- 28:17against him, her, or it arises from protected
- 28:20activity that shifts the burden to the plaintiff
- 28:24to show at the very early stage a likelihood
- 28:27of success without the benefit of discovery,
- 28:30you can get discovery. I'm not going to go into
- 28:32detail about that. If you file an ex parte application
- 28:34right away and you can prove I need this discovery
- 28:37and there's nowhere else I can get it, even then,
- 28:41courts might not be so generous about it. They
- 28:43might really constrain the discovery you're gonna
- 28:45get. And a lot of time, they're gonna deny it.
- 28:48If you wait until you file your opposition brief
- 28:50insanity discovery, you're too late. Okay, so
- 28:54assuming that the defendant shows the pronged
- 28:57one arises from protected activity, it shifts
- 29:01the burden to the plaintiff to show a likelihood
- 29:03of success. And that's this California Supreme
- 29:06Court case is very important, Burrell, it kind
- 29:08of changed. a few things that had been thought
- 29:11widely before. Some say for the better, some
- 29:14say for the worse. We'll talk about that in a
- 29:16minute. The second step is a summary judgment
- 29:20-like proceeding. So you get to file declarations
- 29:22and you don't have to prove conclusively you
- 29:25have a likelihood of success if you're the plaintiff.
- 29:28All you have to show is there's a tribal issue
- 29:30of fact, basically. If there's a conflict, you're
- 29:34the plaintiff and you say, He did say these things
- 29:36are defamatory and false, and my client was harmed
- 29:39by it. And he says, no, I never said them. Or,
- 29:42well, they weren't really damaged that badly
- 29:45or something like that. Well, that's just a tribal
- 29:47issue of fact. There's a conflict in the evidence.
- 29:49The court is not going to weigh conflicts to
- 29:52resolve. They're going to say, well, all right,
- 29:53there's a tribal issue. We're going to let the
- 29:55claim proceed. So if you're defending against
- 29:57an anti -slot motion, don't forget there's two
- 29:59prompts. Don't just challenge prong one and say,
- 30:02it's not protected. It doesn't arise out of protected
- 30:04activity. Take the second step and show that
- 30:07your claim has a likelihood of success. All right.
- 30:12Well, how do I recognize an anti -slap problem?
- 30:17Now, I know I need to be thinking about this
- 30:19prong one. If prong one is there, I'm going to
- 30:21have to figure out how to get past prong two.
- 30:24Well, the statute sets out the four different
- 30:27kinds of activities that are protected. And so
- 30:30it's right there in some division E. And so E1
- 30:33says, any written or oral statement or writing
- 30:38made before legislative executive or judicial
- 30:41proceeding or any other official proceeding authorized
- 30:44by law. There's a few of them. Peer review proceedings
- 30:48in a hospital to decide if a doctor should retain
- 30:51his or her privileges. That is an official proceeding
- 30:54authorized by law, but we're talking about courtroom
- 30:56stuff now here. And so, you know, somebody makes
- 30:59a written statement that in front of the legislator,
- 31:02a city council, county board of supervisors.
- 31:05An administrative proceeding, you know, these
- 31:07are all official proceedings authorized by law.
- 31:10If you're getting sued for something you said,
- 31:12or submitted to 1 of those things per se. Well,
- 31:16I shouldn't say per se is protected by the anti
- 31:17slap statute. The claim is going to get thrown
- 31:20out unless the other side can show a likelihood
- 31:22of success at step two. What else is protected?
- 31:26Well, E2 says not only things you actually say
- 31:28in one of those official proceedings or writings
- 31:31you submit in one of those proceedings, if you're
- 31:33talking about them, if you're talking about an
- 31:36issue that's under consideration in an official
- 31:38proceeding, but you're doing so outside the proceeding,
- 31:41that's also protected. It's a little bit like
- 31:44the litigation privilege in section 47. of the
- 31:48civil code, but it's not quite, well, it's a
- 31:51little broader. The privilege is actually a little
- 31:54bit narrower because the privilege you actually
- 31:56have to have a litigation purpose in mind. Whereas
- 31:59this, if you're just talking about it, it's not
- 32:01to achieve your litigation goals. You're just
- 32:03talking about an issue under consideration in
- 32:05an official proceeding that's protected by the
- 32:08anti -slap statute. You've conquered prong one.
- 32:11The other side is going to have to show likelihood
- 32:13of success at prong two. What else? Well, subdivision
- 32:19E3 says any written or oral statement made in
- 32:22a place open to the public or in a public forum
- 32:26in connection with an issue of public interest.
- 32:29And then you have subsection four that says any
- 32:32conduct and furtherance of the exercise of the
- 32:35constitutional right of petition or free speech
- 32:37if it's in connection with an issue of public
- 32:41interest. All right, so the first two prongs,
- 32:43anything that happens in court, or related to
- 32:45something in court, going to be protected. Three
- 32:48and four, well, something that's not going on
- 32:51in court at all, but it's a matter of public
- 32:53interest, or it's conduct that furthers some
- 32:57kind of activity regarding a matter of public
- 33:00interest. Well, I think jurisprudence has made
- 33:03E4 kind of overcome E3, and I'll talk about that
- 33:07in a second. But first, let's talk about what
- 33:09is a matter of public interest. There's a lot
- 33:11of cases out there that talk about this. Some
- 33:14of them are going to give you really good guidance,
- 33:17but if you put a couple of them together, sometimes
- 33:19things get cloudy all over again. So you know
- 33:21you got the C -Lig V infinity broadcasting case.
- 33:24That's a really good example. He had a TV reality
- 33:28star who these two radio guys, these radio jocks
- 33:32talked about and she sued them and she said they
- 33:36defamed her. And so they filed an anti -slap
- 33:37motion and they said, well, you know, her participation
- 33:40in that shows a matter of public interest, and
- 33:42the court of appeal agreed. But then you have
- 33:45this Bernstein case that says, well, a defendant's
- 33:47celebrity status on its own is not sufficient
- 33:50to render anything the defendant says or does
- 33:52subject to anti -stab protection. Now, some folks
- 33:55get a little confused by what I'm trying to say
- 33:58about this other case, this consumer justice
- 34:00case. Let me just say at the outset, I'm not
- 34:03saying anything about a woman's breasts are a
- 34:05matter of public concern, okay? Don't misunderstand
- 34:07me. But this case says, a dietary supplement's
- 34:11ability to enlarge women's breasts as an allegedly
- 34:14safer alternative to surgery is not a matter
- 34:17of public concern. So listen, I'm not saying
- 34:21again that a woman's appearance should be a matter
- 34:25of public concern. I'm saying if a woman is considering
- 34:28a surgery or some other alternative, and there's
- 34:32a whole lot of women out there that are thinking
- 34:34about these two alternatives, I'm not sure that's
- 34:38not a matter of public concern, but the court
- 34:40said it's not. And so I'm not sure if that's
- 34:44less of a public concern than whether or not
- 34:46some reality star performed well on a reality
- 34:49television series, but that's just how I sit.
- 34:52The point is there's a lot of different things
- 34:53that can be a matter of public concern. There's
- 34:55tons of cases out there about it. Be prepared
- 34:57to do some reading. You know, if you think you're
- 35:00talking about a matter of public concern, it
- 35:01doesn't have to concern the whole be a concern
- 35:03to the whole state or even the whole city. A
- 35:06homeowners association election as a matter of
- 35:09public concern for that people who live in that
- 35:11homeowners association. There's a public public
- 35:13decision out there about that. All right. Is
- 35:18subdivision subdivision E4 is broader than E3
- 35:22because it doesn't require a public forum. And
- 35:25so this Terry V. Davis community church case
- 35:28to me kind of says, you don't really need a public
- 35:32forum at all. And so E3, as long as you're talking
- 35:34about something that's a matter of public concern,
- 35:36you can be doing it one on one. It's a water
- 35:37cooler at the office and it's probably still
- 35:40going to be protected by the anti -slab statute.
- 35:42Maybe not quite that far, but this Terry kind
- 35:45of this Terry case does kind of minimize the
- 35:49public forum requirement a little bit. Okay,
- 35:53so. If you get into an E4 case, you know, you're
- 35:56kind of, there's not a lot of cases out there,
- 35:58but there is one that is very much worth considering
- 36:01this film on com inc, the double verify case.
- 36:06It, it, it strives to kind of set out what is
- 36:09matter of public concern and how closely does
- 36:12that concern have to apply to what's alleged
- 36:14in the complaint. I could do a whole one hour
- 36:17presentation about this one case. So I'm not
- 36:19going to go into a lot of detail about that.
- 36:21You just need to know if you're suing somebody
- 36:24for something that might be considered a matter
- 36:25of public concern, or if your client is being
- 36:28sued for talking or writing or doing anything
- 36:31to further something that could be a matter of
- 36:33public concern, you should be thinking about
- 36:36antislapped scrutiny and reading some of these
- 36:38cases. All right, what if somebody alleges both
- 36:43protected and unprotected activity? A defamation
- 36:46claim, you allege they defend me in court. on
- 36:50the witness stand. And they also defamed me at
- 36:52the grocery store talking about something that
- 36:55didn't have anything to do with the court case.
- 36:58All right, so you've got a mixed cause of action.
- 37:00It used to be that if the plaintiff can show
- 37:03that they can establish defamation claim at prong
- 37:05two, then the whole anti -slap motion gets denied.
- 37:09But this Barral case said, no, you don't do that.
- 37:11You focus on the allegation that gives rise to
- 37:14prong one. It arises out of protected activity.
- 37:19If the plaintiff cannot show liability on that
- 37:23allegation alone, then that allegation gets stricken
- 37:25basically. The other allegations might still
- 37:27survive, but the defendant has prevailed on the
- 37:30anti -slap motion and can recover attorney fees
- 37:32for striking just that one allegation. Depending
- 37:36on how big those attorney fees can be, they can
- 37:38amount to leverage to get the plaintiff to dismiss
- 37:41the rest of the claims in exchange for compromising
- 37:45or waiving the recovery of attorney fees. All
- 37:50right, so the definitional focus of anti -slab
- 37:54is it's not limited to defamation, it's not limited
- 37:57to malicious prosecution, it's not limited to
- 37:59interference with perspective economic advantage
- 38:01or infliction of emotional distress. It can cover
- 38:04just about anything, so long as it arises out
- 38:08of E1, E2, E3, or E4. If it alleges somebody
- 38:13is liable because they said something in court,
- 38:16either in writing or orally, are because they
- 38:19said or wrote something about an issue that's
- 38:22under consideration in court or an arbitration
- 38:25or a legislative proceeding or any other official
- 38:28proceeding, or they're getting sued because they
- 38:32said or wrote something about a matter of public
- 38:35interest or a matter of public concern, or they
- 38:39engaged in some kind of conduct that's really
- 38:42somehow tied to a matter of public interest to
- 38:45further free speech and positioning rights. Well
- 38:47then, Prom 1 is triggered and the anti -slap
- 38:51motion, the anti -slap statute applies. It doesn't
- 38:54matter if it's family law, probate law, arbitration,
- 38:58any kind of civil claim, real estate, business,
- 39:02contract, tort, whatever. You're probably going
- 39:05to be looking down some anti -slap problems,
- 39:08anti -slap engagement. All right. So I want to
- 39:12pause now. I told you I would when I get a little
- 39:15over halfway through and you have an understanding
- 39:17of how the statute works a little bit to answer
- 39:20questions before we go into these hypotheticals.
- 39:22So let me glance and see if we have. Do I happen
- 39:26to know if the legislative intent of the California
- 39:29anti -slap statute contains any reference to
- 39:32heated series of litigation among members of
- 39:34the bar in the Central Valley, as covered in
- 39:36the 60 Minutes interview of Ed Friedberg by Charlie
- 39:39Rose, aired on national TV during the 90s. Ed
- 39:42Friedberg probably dealt with a lot more anti
- 39:46-slap statutes than almost any attorney I know.
- 39:49For those of you who don't know him, Ed was a
- 39:51very successful businessman who, according to
- 39:54the Wall Street Journal, if I'm remembering correctly,
- 39:58was so angry at his second wife's attorney and
- 40:03his second divorce that he went to law school
- 40:06and decided he was going to sue lawyers for bad
- 40:08behavior and was wildly successful at it. He
- 40:13filed a lot of malicious prosecution claims,
- 40:16which per se are going to be covered by anti
- 40:18-SLAP. He also filed a lot of legal malpractice
- 40:22claims. I can't say they're never covered. I'd
- 40:26say though they're not nearly protected by anti
- 40:29-slap as malicious prosecution claims. Isn't
- 40:33it now in the trial court's discretion to grant
- 40:36an anti -slap motion? Well, they sort of have
- 40:39discretion. Attorney fees are definitely in the
- 40:41trial court's discretion. But on appeal, if you
- 40:44say the anti -slap motion was wrongly granted
- 40:46or denied, that's not an abuse of discretion
- 40:49standard. That is a de novo standard. And so
- 40:52attorney fees are in court's discretion. Whether
- 40:55or not to grant the motion, not so much. Would
- 40:59you please expand on Bassy holding some emails
- 41:03from the basis? Yes, that's in my handouts. That
- 41:07is the case that deals with domestic violence
- 41:10restraining orders. Those emails and their protected
- 41:12status, some went one way, some went the other.
- 41:16I'm afraid that's a little more than I have time
- 41:19for. If you want to contact me after the presentation,
- 41:21I'd be happy to talk to you about that there.
- 41:25Does a denied anti -slap set the tone for a motion
- 41:29for summary judgment later? No, I don't believe
- 41:31so. An anti -slap motion, it gets granted or
- 41:34denied on one particular kind of basis. You probably
- 41:39better have new information, though, if you're
- 41:41going to file a motion for summary judgment that's
- 41:44based on the stuff that was already you know,
- 41:47adjudicated in anti -slap motion. If there's
- 41:49a tribal issue of fact in the anti -slap motion,
- 41:51it's very likely on MSJ, the trial court's gonna
- 41:55find another tribal issue of fact, unless you
- 41:58have something new and you can combat that. Renewal
- 42:02of DVR and anti -slap. Okay, I'll cover that
- 42:05really quickly. I think it's in the hypothetical
- 42:07also. You get a domestic violence restraining
- 42:10order, and you know, it lasts for three to five
- 42:13years typically, and then you can renew it. If
- 42:16you're the protected party, you can go back to
- 42:17court and renew it. You go back to court to renew
- 42:19the restraining order and your allegations say
- 42:23only when I got the last restraining order, my
- 42:26ex stood there in court and said he didn't do
- 42:29any of these things. He said that I'm making
- 42:30stuff up. He lied and he resisted it. He resisted
- 42:34the restraining order and so therefore he's still
- 42:37a threat to me because he's not acknowledging
- 42:39that these things really happened. or he filed
- 42:42an appeal, better yet. He filed an appeal challenged
- 42:44in domestic violence restraining order. Those
- 42:47are all protected conduct. That is protected
- 42:50under anti -SLAP E1. You're talking about things
- 42:52he said or filed in court that's protected under
- 42:56E1. Eddie Mahoney, can you explain what conducted,
- 43:03lended to application of the anti -SLAP success?
- 43:06Well, I'm not going to get to the hypotheticals.
- 43:08You all have a lot of really great questions.
- 43:10So Eddie Money was a rock and roller who, may
- 43:13he rest in peace, had a lot of great hits that
- 43:15got me on the roller skating rink whenever they
- 43:18played Two Tickets to Paradise. He had a drummer
- 43:21who was with him all those years and his drummer
- 43:23got cancer and they went on tour and Eddie didn't
- 43:27take his drummer on tour with him and his drummer
- 43:30sued for employment discrimination, basically
- 43:33failure to accommodate disability discrimination,
- 43:36and Eddie Money filed an anti -slap motion and
- 43:39prevailed because that's First Amendment choice.
- 43:41If he's on a stage, he gets to decide who's going
- 43:45to be on stage with him because he's trying to
- 43:47send a message out to the world and he gets to
- 43:49control that message. It's a very nuanced case,
- 43:51but that arises under a matter of public concern
- 43:54sort of analysis. That's like an E3 or an E4
- 43:57analysis. Party A files a civil rights lawsuit
- 44:01against Party B. B's attorney takes actions in
- 44:04court, which Party A believes are retaliatory
- 44:06for filing a legal claim. If Party A files a
- 44:09suit against Party B for retaliation, Anti -slap,
- 44:15how does anti -slap handle claims alleging retaliation?
- 44:18Well, retaliation in that scenario to me sounds
- 44:21like a malicious prosecution claim being called
- 44:25a retaliation claim. You're suing somebody for
- 44:28what they did in court. It's protected under
- 44:30prong one. Prong one, you're suing them under
- 44:32425 .16E1. You're suing them for things they
- 44:36said and did in court. They have an anti -slap
- 44:38motion. They might be able to assert a privilege
- 44:41at Prong 2 and succeed on the anti -SLAP motion.
- 44:45Are there jurisdictional issues to be aware of
- 44:48prior to beginning an anti -SLAP issue? Deadlines
- 44:51to meet and confer requirements? No, there is
- 44:53no meet and confer requirement. You don't have
- 44:55to meet and confer on an anti -SLAP motion. You
- 44:59have a 60 -day deadline to file the anti -SLAP
- 45:01motion that's not jurisdictional, but in my personal
- 45:05experience, it's anecdotal. but I think courts
- 45:08are less and less likely than they were 15 years
- 45:10ago to give you an extension of time to file
- 45:13your anti -slot motion, so be aware of that.
- 45:18Okay, does anti -slot apply in federal court?
- 45:20Laugh out loud. Yes, but we're not going to talk
- 45:23about that. It does apply. A recent case holds
- 45:30that a request for domestic violence restraint
- 45:31and order filed in a pending dissolution case
- 45:33is a motion in that case. Okay. But the domestic
- 45:38violence prevention act allows one to file a
- 45:40request for such a restraining order, a separate
- 45:42case. Oh, boy, this is kind of a long question.
- 45:48Listen, I'm going to ask you, Suzanne, I'm going
- 45:52to ask you to call me about this afterwards.
- 45:54I think it's a great question, but I really want
- 45:57to focus on things that are going to help people
- 45:59understand sort of in basic terms, everything,
- 46:01and this is kind of nuanced. So I'm going to
- 46:03try to get that. If you call me or email me,
- 46:06we'll set up a time. We're going to talk about
- 46:07this. All right. I think that covers all the
- 46:12questions. And so now I'm going to jump into
- 46:13hypotheticals. And if there's, I got a lot of
- 46:16them. I got more than we have time for, but I'll
- 46:19probably try to stop early and see if there's
- 46:20one or two more questions I can answer. So moving
- 46:23to the hypotheticals. Hypothetical number one,
- 46:29virtuous vixen, VV is plucked from obscurity
- 46:31to compete in a popular reality television show.
- 46:36You heard me talk about this already a little
- 46:37bit. She openly appears on a few episodes before
- 46:40she's disqualified. Two widely heard radio talk
- 46:44show hosts, let's call them Russ Lowbrow and
- 46:47Halfless Spurned, discuss Vivi on the air and
- 46:49they explain why they think it was right to disqualify
- 46:52her. Spurned calls Vivi a skank, while Lowbrow
- 46:56reports that people are saying that she's a member
- 47:00of both Antifa, the Proud Boys, and Nambla. Wow.
- 47:06What a membership. VV sues Lowbrow and Spurned
- 47:10for defamation. All right, if Lowbrow and Spurned
- 47:13file an anti -slot motion, will they prevail?
- 47:17Okay, so listen, I know you'd have to type your
- 47:19answers, and so we're probably not going to have
- 47:21a lot of time for typing answers. And so let
- 47:24me just try to, we'll cut to the chase, right?
- 47:26Instead of keeping you in suspense, they probably
- 47:29will prevail on prom one. And really, that's
- 47:31what my presentation is about. If you're seeing
- 47:33a PROM 1 problem, you should think about how
- 47:36to recraft your complaint so that you don't get
- 47:39in the anti -slap trouble. On the other hand,
- 47:41if you get a complaint and you see a PROM 1 issue,
- 47:44we're off to the races. You're going to freeze
- 47:46discovery. Not only are you going to freeze discovery,
- 47:48when the other side has to show a likelihood
- 47:50of success, they're going to have to give you
- 47:52probably the best evidence they have to avoid
- 47:55having their claim dismissed. You're going to
- 47:56get all kinds of free discovery without propounding
- 47:58one interrogatory. trying to synchronize your
- 48:03deposition so that you get to the questions in
- 48:05the right order and get the aha at the end. You're
- 48:07gonna get that right out of the gate. All right,
- 48:10so they'll probably prevail on prong two. We're
- 48:12not gonna talk, like I said, a lot about prong
- 48:14two, but skank is kind of an opinion rather than
- 48:19a demonstrably false fact. Lowbrow might have
- 48:23a harder time because membership in one of those
- 48:26organizations is probably provably false. true
- 48:29or false. So this ceiling case covers that. Again,
- 48:33it's in your materials. So prong one, red alert,
- 48:36right? You got to think about how am I going
- 48:38to beat prong two if I'm going to keep this allegation
- 48:40in my complaint or petition. Number two, Prim
- 48:44plaintiff propounds written discovery to Dastardly
- 48:47defendant in a breach of contract case. Dastardly's
- 48:51discovery responses reveal facts indicating that
- 48:53he may have used misrepresentations to induce
- 48:56Prim to enter the contract. Based upon those
- 49:00discovery responses, Prim moves for and obtains
- 49:02leave to file an amended complaint to include
- 49:05a fraud claim. Prim's amended complaint alleges
- 49:08that he discovered the fraud through dastardly
- 49:10responses to written discovery. Okay, based on
- 49:15this, can dastardly file an anti -slap motion?
- 49:19You notice strike the fraud claim from the amended
- 49:20complaint, and let's assume the 60 -day deadline
- 49:23is fined as an amended complaint, it's new. Well,
- 49:27that's an unfair trick question, everybody. Yeah,
- 49:29you can always file an anti -slap motion. The
- 49:32question is, are you going to be tagged for filing
- 49:37a frivolous anti -slap motion? If you file a
- 49:40frivolous one, you're going to be on the hook
- 49:42for attorney fees. Now, as I said earlier in
- 49:44the presentation, if you can beat prong one,
- 49:46you're probably not going to face liability for
- 49:50filing a frivolous anti -slap motion, even if
- 49:53you lose at prong two. Now, here the claim in
- 49:57question was merely triggered by information
- 49:59that was developed in discovery. The discovery
- 50:02proceedings themselves are not a fact that has
- 50:06to be proven to establish liability. Now, you
- 50:09might have to prove that you discovered the fraud
- 50:13only because of the discovery responses, because
- 50:15they might have been barred by the statute of
- 50:17limitations, but because you didn't know about
- 50:19them, you got the discovery rule. you know that
- 50:24doesn't that makes it a little more cloudy I
- 50:27haven't seen a case that addresses that but if
- 50:30you're just learning something from discovery
- 50:32you don't even have to allege it in your complaint
- 50:34really you don't have to say I found this out
- 50:36through discovery unless you're trying to stay
- 50:38within the statute of limitations. So that's
- 50:40a good example of thinking, do I really need
- 50:42to keep this? Because if you do, you're going
- 50:44to face an anti -slap motion, but maybe you can
- 50:46beat it at prong two. You just have to have your
- 50:48ducks in a row and figure out, do I need to get
- 50:50other evidence to beat the anticipated anti -slap
- 50:53motion? Hypone number three. Prim plaintiff propounds
- 50:57written discovery to dastardly defendant. Sounds
- 51:00familiar. In a breach of contract case this time.
- 51:03Dastardly, snarky, and insulting discovery responses
- 51:06deeply trouble PREM. Based on those snarky and
- 51:10insulting responses, PREM files a separate lawsuit
- 51:13asserting an infliction of emotional distress
- 51:15claim. This new lawsuit alleges that reading
- 51:19those snarky insults caused PREM emotional distress.
- 51:23Can Dastardly file an anti -SLAP motion to strike
- 51:26the emotional distress claim? Well, you're all
- 51:29gonna... you know, you remember from the trick
- 51:31question last time, you can always file it, so
- 51:34you're not going to fall for it this time. Yeah,
- 51:36Brendan, we know you can always file it, but
- 51:38the question is, can it be prong one? Can it
- 51:41surmount prong one? In this case, I think such
- 51:45a motion is more likely to succeed because unlike
- 51:48the previous one, it's protected litigation conduct.
- 51:51You're answering a discovery response. That's
- 51:53litigation conduct. That's E1. If it's not E1,
- 51:56it's definitely E2, but I think discovery responses
- 51:59are going to be in E1. And so it's protected
- 52:01litigation conduct that gives rise to alleged
- 52:03liability. And we're not going to talk a lot
- 52:06about PRONT2, but Section 47 of the Civil Code
- 52:09comes up a lot in these cases, the litigation
- 52:11privilege. I think that conduct is likely privileged
- 52:14there, too. Hypothetical number four. Good Citizen
- 52:21Choo Choo Train Company is a non -governmental
- 52:24nationwide railway. You know, I'm going to skip
- 52:29that one to get some other ones that cover stuff
- 52:32that is more, I don't know, help you understand
- 52:37how Intestop works a little bit better. That
- 52:38one's a little nuanced. Here, let's talk about
- 52:42Desney a little bit. I'm using some names of
- 52:44some lawyers that work at my firm just for fun
- 52:46in case any of them are watching. Jessica Marlowe
- 52:49develops an idea for a reality television show
- 52:51called Brendan's Big Adventure. It's about a
- 52:54nerdy appellate lawyer who rides his clunky bike
- 52:57around Sacramento. He's looking for anti -slap
- 52:59appeals and he meets attorneys along the way
- 53:01who are more interesting and sensible. Some of
- 53:05you out there might be old enough to remember
- 53:06Pee Wee's Big Adventure. Jessica visits Hervé
- 53:09Studios to discuss the idea. After she fulfills
- 53:13Hervé Studios' request to draft a more developed
- 53:15screenplay for the pilot, They enter an agreement
- 53:18to try to launch a show that if they can find
- 53:20financing, shockingly, that financing never materializes.
- 53:25All right, well, Hervé Studios later partners
- 53:27with big -time film financer Wayne Kazan, and
- 53:31they're going to make a successful show called
- 53:33Zee Smith's Big Adventure. Zee Smith happens
- 53:36to be a lawyer here too, gee. Well, it's about
- 53:39a dapper lawyer who swerves his snazzy electric
- 53:42car into bike lanes around Los Angeles, shouting
- 53:44slurs at nerdy appellate lawyers who are riding
- 53:46on the bike lane. Well, Jessica gets no credit
- 53:50or money from Hervé Studios in connection with
- 53:52Zee Smith's big adventure, which is a big success.
- 53:55And she files a Disney claim against Hervé Studios
- 53:57alleging breach of implied contract. In other
- 54:00words, she's claiming that Hervé Studios impliedly
- 54:03promised but failed to compensate and credit
- 54:05her if they used any element of Brendan's big
- 54:08adventures in one of their projects. How good
- 54:11of a chance does Hervé Studios have of getting
- 54:13past prong one of the anti -slap stand challenge
- 54:16to this Disney claim? Well, Before last year,
- 54:22not so good of a chance, but now a very good
- 54:24chance. The California Court of Appeal came out
- 54:27with a couple of cases. The one I commend to
- 54:29you that's cited in your materials is Norman
- 54:32v. Ross. It resurrected these desolate kinds
- 54:35of claims and said, yeah, they're covered by
- 54:37anti -slap because it's a matter of public concern.
- 54:40Basically, E3, these TV shows that's First Amendment
- 54:44protected activity, you're putting this creative
- 54:46stuff out there. And so, you know, there's a
- 54:48lot that goes into the creative process, and
- 54:50so it's probably going to be covered by anti
- 54:52-slap. Got time for maybe one more. Let's give
- 54:56it a shot. Discriminatory defendant, a public
- 54:59entity, fires, sorry, files, no, they fire, sorry.
- 55:05Discriminatory defendant, a public entity, fires
- 55:07protected class plaintiff from his job after
- 55:10discussing at a formal but closed -door board
- 55:13meeting whether to promote protected class plaintiff
- 55:16or terminate him after he complained about misuse
- 55:19of public funds and sexual harassment by his
- 55:22slimy supervisor. PC files a lawsuit alleging
- 55:25employment discrimination, harassment, and retaliation.
- 55:29Do any of these claims allege conduct that is
- 55:31arguably protected in the prong one analysis?
- 55:34Real fast, prong one. Is statement said in court?
- 55:37No. Is it a statement about a matter under consideration
- 55:43in a you know, in an official proceeding, gee,
- 55:47maybe, you know, it's a public entity and it's
- 55:51a formal meeting, but it's a closed door board
- 55:54meeting. That could be an official proceeding,
- 55:56right? And so, well, let's see. Public employment
- 56:00aspect does tend to make claims more susceptible
- 56:02to anti -slap attack under E1 and E2 because
- 56:05it's an official proceeding, at least potentially.
- 56:10You know, there's two cases that govern this,
- 56:12both, well, one of them is mine. One of them
- 56:14is California Supreme Court case that kind of
- 56:16go hand in glove. Virgos, my case, Virgos says,
- 56:20you know, yeah, a public employee who's processing
- 56:23these grievances and adjudicated them is engaged
- 56:26in, you know, protected conduct under E1 and
- 56:29E2. And the Parkview Board of Trustees kind of
- 56:35adds some nuance to that, but some direction
- 56:37also. It's difficult to convince courts that
- 56:41employment matters are of public concern if it's
- 56:43private sector, especially. So if it's just a
- 56:47routine garden variety, employment dispute, this
- 56:50Rivero case, in my opinion, does not take into
- 56:55consideration the broad application it should
- 56:57have. I think it construes protected activity
- 56:59a little narrowly than I would have if I were
- 57:01the judge. But it's out there. It's not been
- 57:03reversed. So you need to know about it. Okay,
- 57:09let's see. I got to get to the 130 mark so you
- 57:11all get credit, so I'm going to try one more.
- 57:13I don't see any questions in the Q &A, so I'm
- 57:15going to keep going so that we get you all the
- 57:18credit you need to endure my presentation. Discriminatory
- 57:22defendant, a television broadcaster, refuses
- 57:25to hire a protected class plaintiff as a meteorologist
- 57:28and instead hires a younger female for the job.
- 57:31Just down the street in Media Land, Tommy Tone
- 57:33Def defendant, a rock star, fires his recently
- 57:36cancer -stricken percussionist, afflicted drummer
- 57:39Aldo. Sounds like something we already talked
- 57:42about a little bit. PC plaintiff and ADA plaintiff
- 57:46file lawsuits against DD and TDD alleging age,
- 57:50gender, and disability discrimination. If discriminatory
- 57:54defendant and Tommy Tone Def defendant file an
- 57:58anti -slap motion to strike. Will they be able
- 58:00to show that any of those claims arise from protected
- 58:03conduct? I kind of already told you about this
- 58:05one. Yeah, most likely. You have the Hunter case,
- 58:09which is the meteorologist case decided by the
- 58:12Court of Appeal. And you also have Simmons v.
- 58:15Mahoney. You might not recognize Mahoney. That
- 58:18was Eddie Money's real name. And if he stayed
- 58:20in the hotel, you'd have to call and ask for
- 58:22Edward Mahoney's room. But Eddie Money, that's
- 58:25the Eddie Money case where he fired a strimmer.
- 58:27You also might want to look at Wilson v. Cable
- 58:30News Network again in your handout so you don't
- 58:33have to scribble it down. That's California Supreme
- 58:35Court case. California Supreme Court has talked
- 58:37twice about employment law anti -slap. So that's
- 58:41an active part of anti -slap. I see two questions
- 58:44in there before we try to tackle another hypothetical.
- 58:48Let's see, does first amendment, first amendment,
- 58:52sorry, first amended complaint trigger antisap
- 58:54all over again, only if the protected conduct
- 58:57was not alleged in the original complaint. If
- 59:00the amended complaint includes a new allegation,
- 59:03the 60 day time limit starts ticking again. Sometimes
- 59:07if they file a first amended complaint, within
- 59:09the 60 -day time limit. They're realleging that
- 59:12same thing. Yeah, if you're in the 60 -day deadline,
- 59:15if I untest that motion, go for it. Oh, let's
- 59:20see. Jack Russo, you, isn't discovery stay during
- 59:24an appeal now in the trial court's discretion?
- 59:26Well, it's in the trial court's discretion whether
- 59:28or not, you know, the claims overlap. If a new
- 59:31case came out and I'm not aware of it, I'm going
- 59:34to have to go take a look at it. But my last
- 59:38Recollection was the California Supreme Court
- 59:40case in that. Vivian was it? I'm trying to remember
- 59:44the name of it. It's in your handouts. It begins
- 59:45with a V and it says the discovery stay remains
- 59:49in place during the appeal. Forgive me if there's
- 59:52a new case that I've overlooked. The trial court
- 59:55has some discretion to say whether or not that
- 59:58the claim, you know, the. The discovery in question
- 1:00:01is covered by the claim that's challenged by
- 1:00:03the anti -slap. But if it's related to that claim,
- 1:00:06discovery is going to stay frozen during the
- 1:00:07appeal. You said Supreme Court only has two anti
- 1:00:10-slap and employment suits. Do you mention these?
- 1:00:13Yes, they're both in your handouts. One of them
- 1:00:14is on this last slide. Wilson v. Cable News Network.
- 1:00:19And one of them is on the prior slide. Parker.
- 1:00:22Let's see, what was it? Park v. Board of Trustees.
- 1:00:29We're right at the 130 mark right now, so I'm
- 1:00:31not going to start another hypothetical. You
- 1:00:33guys got full credit. All the other hypotheticals
- 1:00:37are in there if you want to read them and get
- 1:00:38some ideas about how it might apply to some of
- 1:00:40your cases. If you have any questions, follow
- 1:00:44up questions, by all means, please call me or
- 1:00:46email me. I am happy to talk about anti -SLAP
- 1:00:49all day long. You'll spare my girlfriend from
- 1:00:51having to listen to me talk about it to her.
- 1:00:53With that, I'm gonna conclude. I wanna thank
- 1:00:56you all for coming. And remember, be on the lookout
- 1:00:57for prong one. Thanks so much.