Latest / No Way Out / Decoding Market Dynamics: How Relative Sentiment Transforms Investment Strategies with Ray Micaletti
Transcript
- 0:21Mark McGrath: so ray, we're both pittsburgers, we're both from pennsylvania.
- 0:24Mark McGrath: I'm clad appropriately for tonight's orange bowl and but tonight may not be the orange bowl.
- 0:28Ponch Rivera: You know that or because of well you need to talk to future moose and go hey mood, future moose, moose, what?
- 0:34Ponch Rivera: What should we talk about?
- 0:35Ponch Rivera: Not current moose?
- 0:36Ponch Rivera: Well, it's true, yeah, yeah, you could talk, we can.
- 0:39Ponch Rivera: By the time this pump the bull.
- 0:40Mark McGrath: I guess the story is ray ray went to notre dame, like many great Pennsylvanians goes on to Notre Dame to do wonderful things.
- 0:47Mark McGrath: So by the time this is published, one of us will have eaten their words by then.
- 0:53Mark McGrath: So it's either the Penn State fan or the Notre Dame fan.
- 0:56Mark McGrath: So we'll see.
- 0:57Mark McGrath: And, as I told you, you're the third Princeton alum we've talked to this week and the second Princeton PhD Very elite company that we surround ourselves.
- 1:08Mark McGrath: Not bad for a Marquette grad and a Colorado grad.
- 1:11Ponch Rivera: No, I went to the University of Phoenix, okay.
- 1:15Mark McGrath: So, ray, relative sentiment is your calling card as it comes to investing.
- 1:21Mark McGrath: We'll cover a lot of areas, but why don't you give us, from a high level, what the hell is relative sentiment?
- 1:26Ray Micaletti: Sure.
- 1:27Ray Micaletti: A relative sentiment is an investment factor that looks at how institutions are positioned in the market or how they feel about the market relative to how retail traders are positioned in the market, how retail traders feel in sentiment surveys about the market.
- 1:41Ray Micaletti: If you compare those two sentiments the institutional sentiment to the retail sentiment you get what I believe to be more information than if you just looked at each of those in a standalone fashion.
- 1:54Ray Micaletti: There are various measures of sentiment.
- 1:56Ray Micaletti: People are probably familiar with the AAII, the American Association of Individual Investors.
- 2:00Ray Micaletti: There's the National Association of American Investment Managers.
- 2:04Ray Micaletti: You have put-all ratios.
- 2:05Ray Micaletti: You have various other fear and greed that you can see, but they co-mingle both how investors are feeling and how retail is feeling.
- 2:14Ray Micaletti: However, there's a lot of research academic research, empirical research that shows that institutions tend to have better outcomes in the financial markets than retail traders.
- 2:24Ray Micaletti: So if you can find out how institutions are leading relative to retail traders, you might be able to take advantage of those better opportunities, better outcomes, by aligning yourself with the institutions.
- 2:35Ray Micaletti: Now, real quick.
- 2:37Ray Micaletti: I'd like to say that it's not the case that retail traders always lose in the financial markets.
- 2:42Ray Micaletti: Imagine a casino where the slot machines never paid out.
- 2:46Ray Micaletti: You wouldn't have any customers and there wouldn't be anyone there for the casinos to exploit.
- 2:50Ray Micaletti: So small traders do win occasionally.
- 2:52Ray Micaletti: It keeps them coming back and playing, which allows the institutions to exploit them over the longer term.
- 2:58Mark McGrath: So I think, Panch, when we look at OODA Loop's sketch, it sounds to me like when we're fusing the institutional sentiment with retail sentiment.
- 3:06Mark McGrath: Ultimately, we're trying to enhance our orientation such that we can get better implicit guidance and control on what we're observing out in the capital markets.
- 3:24Ponch Rivera: That's the big thing, and if the comparison is that institutions are going to outperform the retail investors on average, then that doesn't mean that you don't have a lot of weak signals inside of the retail investors that you can leverage.
- 3:32Ponch Rivera: And I think that's what Ray can kind of look at too is when you identify what those weak signals are in the retail community.
- 3:38Ponch Rivera: I can think of a couple of things.
- 3:39Ponch Rivera: Back in the day, about three, four years ago, with GameStop right, they had a little bit of advantage over some of the institutions and I think they broke one of the institutions on that.
- 3:46Ponch Rivera: So it's not a binary thing.
- 3:49Ponch Rivera: However, it probably does lean more towards the institution, and I think in the past we've talked about using sense-making capabilities of the OODA loop and other tools out there to explore how we can get better insights into what's happening across the board.
- 4:03Ponch Rivera: And I'm curious I don't know if you can share this, but how do you collect insights both on the retail side and on the investor side?
- 4:11Ponch Rivera: What is it that you capture?
- 4:14Ray Micaletti: So there's three particular data sets that I look at.
- 4:16Ray Micaletti: And one is the commitments of traders report, which is a snapshot of how institutional investors, hedge funds and speculators and retail traders are positioned in the various financial markets commodities, currencies, equities, bonds, basically all the futures and options contracts.
- 4:32Ray Micaletti: So that's a weekly snapshot of how those investor classes are positioned.
- 4:37Ray Micaletti: So that's a big input into the measures that I use.
- 4:39Ray Micaletti: Another one is there's a company in Germany called Centix and every week they send an email out to institutional investors and they send an email out to retail investors and they ask them how do you feel about these markets Equities, bonds, currencies, commodities how are you positioned?
- 4:56Ray Micaletti: Do you have more risk on less risk on?
- 4:57Ray Micaletti: How do you feel about the economy six months out?
- 5:00Ray Micaletti: How do you feel about it today?
- 5:01Ray Micaletti: So it collects all this information and it has an institutional index how the institutions feel about the various markets and how retail feels about various markets.
- 5:09Ray Micaletti: So that's another input that I use.
- 5:11Ray Micaletti: I compare those two indices to each other.
- 5:13Ray Micaletti: And then a third piece of information that I use that isn't strictly relative sentiment, because it's looking at solely what small traders are doing, but it's the daily sentiment index.
- 5:24Ray Micaletti: It's this index that's been published since the 80s by futures trader Jake Bernstein, and he's actually the one that I was paraphrasing when he said that the small trader doesn't lose all the time.
- 5:34Ray Micaletti: He has to win some time to keep them coming back.
- 5:37Ray Micaletti: So that was the wisdom of Jake Bernstein, and so that is a daily measure of how small traders feel about various futures markets.
- 5:45Mark McGrath: So those three inputs are-.
- 5:46Mark McGrath: How's that collected?
- 5:46Mark McGrath: How do they just buy their actual like looking at volume and I don't even know how that's collected.
- 5:53Ray Micaletti: I imagine Jake might have his methodology listed on his website.
- 5:57Ray Micaletti: I don't know if he does.
- 5:58Ray Micaletti: It could be a proprietary thing, but there's actually a lot of information in that data set, a lot of cross-asset information.
- 6:04Ray Micaletti: So one interesting thing is that if you're looking at equities, some of the more predictive signals for equities is how do retail traders feel about commodities?
- 6:13Ray Micaletti: Because when retail traders are extremely bullish on commodities, that means commodities have generally gone up because retail traders follow price.
- 6:22Ray Micaletti: Well, if commodities have gone up a lot, such that retail traders are extremely bullish, that's inflationary.
- 6:27Ray Micaletti: So you have these inflationary headwinds that hit stocks.
- 6:30Ray Micaletti: On the other hand, if retail traders are extremely bearish on commodities, it means that commodities have gone down.
- 6:37Ray Micaletti: You might be having growth slowdown or even deflation, and so there's basically, on a zero to 100 scale, that's what the daily sentiment index is for these various futures markets.
- 6:48Ray Micaletti: If you look at certain commodities on that zero to 100 scale, if they're below, say 25, bad for equities.
- 6:55Ray Micaletti: If they're above, say 75, bad for equities.
- 6:57Ray Micaletti: But in that 25 to 75 zone, very good for equities.
- 7:01Ray Micaletti: It's like the sweet.
- 7:03Ray Micaletti: so you have like Goldilocks versus inflation and deflation.
- 7:08Ponch Rivera: I'm just curious, is it more of a leading indicator or lagging indicator that?
- 7:10Ponch Rivera: I mean, I'm leaning towards lagging, but if movement in a price is bullish, you know, and I'm a retail investor and I jump on the bandwagon, I would call that lagging.
- 7:19Ponch Rivera: You know, I didn't anticipate that.
- 7:20Ponch Rivera: I'm just kind of jumping in with everybody else.
- 7:22Ponch Rivera: Anticipate that, I'm just kind of jumping in with everybody else.
- 7:24Ponch Rivera: And if you ask me as a retail trader that why are you doing this, I'll be like, well, because everybody else is, and I'm just excited as this momentum moves up, I'm with it.
- 7:31Ponch Rivera: So in my mind that would be a lagging indicator.
- 7:34Ponch Rivera: I just kind of want to see where you stand with that.
- 7:37Ray Micaletti: Yeah, so it does look over the recent past.
- 7:40Ray Micaletti: So I look over the last few days.
- 7:42Ray Micaletti: It's not like looking back three weeks or anything like that.
- 7:44Ray Micaletti: It's a very short-term indicator but it seems to have predictive power of going out, say, a week, two weeks, et cetera, in terms of how equity markets behave when commodity retail sentiment is in certain orientations.
- 7:58Ponch Rivera: Now that makes sense.
- 7:58Ponch Rivera: Thank you, I was just kind of thinking through that.
- 8:00Ponch Rivera: Let me ask you this what other indicators are you looking at other than I?
- 8:04Ponch Rivera: Mean?
- 8:04Ponch Rivera: Should a trader be looking at other than just relative sentiment, anything else?
- 8:09Ray Micaletti: Well, I think that there certainly Relative sentiment.
- 8:13Ray Micaletti: It doesn't end with relative sentiment.
- 8:14Ray Micaletti: I mean people should be looking at an array of indicators, ones that I particularly like from the standpoint of having an idea of what the market might do over the next few days.
- 8:25Ray Micaletti: The next week or so is for equities anyway mean reversion indicators.
- 8:27Ray Micaletti: There are certain short-term mean reversion indicators that are very predictive of what the market will do, especially if relative sentiment is bullish.
- 8:36Ray Micaletti: So the sweet spot is when institutions are bullish on the market relative to retail and the market's oversold.
- 8:42Ray Micaletti: So basically, institutions are buying that dip or they're bullish and the market's dipped.
- 8:47Ray Micaletti: That's usually a good entry signal to get long in the market.
- 8:50Ray Micaletti: Conversely, if the market is overbought but institutions are bearish on the market, that's a good time to possibly lighten up your equity exposure or potentially get short.
- 9:00Ray Micaletti: Now that's for equities For other asset classes like, for example, gold, silver.
- 9:05Ray Micaletti: Now that's for equities For other asset classes like, for example, gold silver, say, mining stocks.
- 9:21Ray Micaletti: They tend to be more what's called.
- 9:23Ray Micaletti: Instead, they're oversold.
- 9:24Ray Micaletti: You want to be long them once they cross, say, to 50.
- 9:27Ray Micaletti: If it's a zero to 100 indicator, when it crosses 50, that's when you want to get long gold get long, silver et cetera.
- 9:34Ray Micaletti: So you kind of want to follow the trend in certain assets and you kind of want to buck the trend in other assets so long as institutions are still bullish.
- 9:44Ponch Rivera: I'm wondering what a zero-day options done to this type of thinking.
- 9:47Ponch Rivera: Has it accelerated it or dampened it?
- 9:51Ray Micaletti: That's a good question.
- 9:52Ray Micaletti: I do think that with the rise of zero-day I'm not an authority here so I don't claim any expertise, but talking to traders who do say option market making it essentially you increase the options positions and then that increases the amount of hedging that the market makers and the dealers have to do.
- 10:09Ray Micaletti: So for the longest time now we've had very big what's called gamma exposure, which means that when the market goes down the options dealers have to buy and when it goes up they have to sell.
- 10:20Ray Micaletti: So it kind of lends some stability to the market.
- 10:22Ray Micaletti: And then there's occasionally times where we have a negative gamma situation.
- 10:26Ray Micaletti: Where the market goes down the dealers have to sell, so they're exacerbating the fall, and when the market rises they have to buy and it exacerbates the rise.
- 10:34Ray Micaletti: So I guess whenever the zero-day options lead to positive gamma you have a little bit more stability.
- 10:40Ray Micaletti: Whenever it leads to negative gamma, you have a little bit more of an unhinged market that can kind of move a little bit beyond what people expect.
- 10:47Ray Micaletti: But that's a little bit outside of my expertise.
- 10:51Mark McGrath: Do you do it quantitatively, or do you have an override?
- 10:56Mark McGrath: Or when you're looking at these indicators, do you just try to take the emotion out of it and mitigate your human factors?
- 11:06Ray Micaletti: Absolutely.
- 11:06Ray Micaletti: You know the funds that I manage.
- 11:09Ray Micaletti: I manage an ETF in particular.
- 11:11Ray Micaletti: It's all systematic and so I have five different relative sentiment indicators.
- 11:17Ray Micaletti: They all range from zero to 100, and each represents a desired equity allocation.
- 11:23Ray Micaletti: So indicator one might have, it might be, say, 37%, so it wants 37% equity exposure in a portfolio.
- 11:32Ray Micaletti: You average those five indicators.
- 11:34Ray Micaletti: Whatever that is, that's my equity exposure.
- 11:38Ray Micaletti: If it's like currently right now, at 63%, 63% tends to be on the bullish side when relative sentiment is between 60 and 80.
- 11:46Ray Micaletti: The market's had very good outcomes in the past.
- 11:48Ray Micaletti: For December it was below 50.
- 11:50Ray Micaletti: It was in the mid 40s.
- 11:52Ray Micaletti: That's usually a bad, not so great, outcome for the market.
- 11:55Ray Micaletti: The market was a little bit down in December and small caps got crushed, energy stocks got crushed, so there was a little bit of a bloodbath under the hood.
- 12:02Ray Micaletti: But whatever that average is, that's my equity allocation.
- 12:07Ray Micaletti: And then for the remainder of the portfolio, I also have relative sentiment models for gold, for the dollar, for long duration bonds, for commodities.
- 12:14Ray Micaletti: I apply those and see what the desired allocations are for those other assets and you have this multi-asset portfolio driven by relative sentiment, where you're trying to align yourself based on what the smart money is doing relative to retouchers.
- 12:29Mark McGrath: Generally, keeping it from your vantage point, keeping it systematic, reduces the things that cause most investors, or many investors, their problems.
- 12:39Mark McGrath: Absolutely the psychology you talk about going back to the casino right, like that feeling of oh I could win and I got to get in there and I got to get on it, fear of missing out, confirmation bias, recency bias, et cetera, et cetera, et cetera, et cetera.
- 12:53Ray Micaletti: So we're going into December.
- 12:54Ray Micaletti: December is historically the strongest month of the year.
- 12:57Ray Micaletti: You have the Santa Claus rally.
- 13:09Ray Micaletti: You tend to have a rally in December and we had all this exuberance on the election and my signals were saying you don't want to be too long.
- 13:13Ray Micaletti: Equities they were in the 40s, so I had an underweight to equities and I'm like man, the market's going to be up 3%, 4%, 5% this month.
- 13:19Ray Micaletti: I'm going to miss out because my signals are saying this, but you got to do it and so you know you stick to the signals.
- 13:26Ray Micaletti: And it did turn out that the market actually was down in December, which was somewhat of a surprise.
- 13:31Ray Micaletti: So I would say that these indicators are much more astute about the market than I am personally, like left to my own devices.
- 13:37Ray Micaletti: If I had to guess you know what's going to happen I would systematically underperform these indicators.
- 13:48Mark McGrath: They've also written about.
- 13:49Mark McGrath: We've had discussions too about how relative sentiment could be fused with an approach like trend following.
- 13:51Ray Micaletti: Yes, so trend following is a great strategy.
- 13:54Ray Micaletti: I mean, it's time-tested, it has the nice quality that you will never ride something down to zero, because you always get out once it goes below a certain trend, right.
- 14:03Ray Micaletti: But there are two weaknesses that trend following has, namely and I'm thinking of the canonical trend following, like if you're above the 10-month moving average or below the 10-month moving average, which is the 200-day moving average.
- 14:15Ray Micaletti: Essentially, I'm not saying that's the best example of a trend following strategy or the best-.
- 14:20Mark McGrath: Yeah, just as a hypothetical example.
- 14:23Ray Micaletti: Yeah, so, as a hypothetical example, that type of strategy has two weaknesses.
- 14:26Ray Micaletti: One, it stays in the market too long after the market's topped.
- 14:30Ray Micaletti: So the market goes up, it tops and you ride it down until it trips the trend and then you get out.
- 14:36Ray Micaletti: The other weakness that it has is that it stays out of the market too long after the market's bottom, waiting for the market to indicate a positive trend again for you to get back in.
- 14:47Ray Micaletti: So those are the two weaknesses of trend following, and relative sentiment perfectly complements it, in the sense that relative sentiment is institutions versus retail.
- 15:00Ray Micaletti: Retail buys high and sells low.
- 15:02Ray Micaletti: So institutions do the opposite they buy low and sell high.
- 15:07Ray Micaletti: And if you look, whenever the trend is negative, whenever momentum is negative but institutions are buying the dip, relative to retail, the market has its greatest returns of any time period.
- 15:19Ray Micaletti: It annualizes like 30%, 40% over a five, six, seven, 10-week period, you have these very violent rallies out of the bottoms.
- 15:26Ray Micaletti: Whenever momentum's negative but institutions aren't buying the dip, you have the worst annualized returns for X.
- 15:33Ray Micaletti: Basically, you don't want to catch a falling knife if institutions aren't buying that knife.
- 15:38Ray Micaletti: And I can give you a little example of how I came to realize this.
- 15:42Ray Micaletti: Let's do it.
- 15:44Ray Micaletti: So back in 2015, I had kind of put together these, some of these not all of them, but a few of these relevant sentiment strategies had developed in 2014.
- 15:53Ray Micaletti: And it was running them in 2015 alongside all kinds of other indicators.
- 15:58Ray Micaletti: Like I had two dozen indicators One was relative sentiment, the other ones were momentum and value.
- 16:02Ray Micaletti: So in September of 2015, the market had just sold off about 10%.
- 16:07Ray Micaletti: All of my indicators were bearish, except for relative sentiment.
- 16:11Ray Micaletti: And so I was bearish because, the way of the evidence, if you have 23 indicators that are bearish and one that's bullish, you're going to be bearish.
- 16:19Ray Micaletti: Right, the market rallied 10% in a straight line over the next few weeks and I thought, oh, that's interesting.
- 16:25Ray Micaletti: Fast forward six months.
- 16:27Ray Micaletti: It was February of 2016.
- 16:29Ray Micaletti: The market had sold off another 10% and all of my indicators were bearish, again except for relative sentiment.
- 16:34Ray Micaletti: The market rallied 10% in a few weeks and then it just kept going and I said, wow, that is interesting.
- 16:41Ray Micaletti: Both times, relative sentiment was bullish when everything else was bearish and the market took off.
- 16:45Ray Micaletti: So I went back and systematically looked historically.
- 16:48Ray Micaletti: When a momentum's negative and relative sentiment is bullish, what happens?
- 16:51Ray Micaletti: You have these incredible equity rounds, and that's when I sort of most other, my interest in most other indices have just are indicators and started looking solely at relative sentiment and building up more relative sentiment indicators.
- 17:03Ray Micaletti: But yes, it very much complements trend following.
- 17:08Ray Micaletti: So the market's had, I think, 9% or 10% corrections since the 90s 10% or more corrections If you look at all of those corrections and you look at where the market was at the peak and what allocations relative sentiment had versus what trend following had.
- 17:23Ray Micaletti: So at the peak, trend following is always 100% invested in equities.
- 17:27Ray Micaletti: Relative sentiment tends to be about 50% invested in equities.
- 17:30Ray Micaletti: At the peak.
- 17:31Ray Micaletti: Then you fast forward to the trough and trend following is out of the market.
- 17:36Ray Micaletti: Relative sentiment is increasing its equity allocation.
- 17:39Ray Micaletti: It went from 50% at the peak to 60% at the trough on average, and then it keeps raising its equity allocation weeks after the bottom, whereas trend following is very slow to get back into the market, even at the market's bottom.
- 17:53Ray Micaletti: So if you look from peak to trough to recovery, relative sentiment outperforms trend follow.
- 17:58Ray Micaletti: When you look outside of those periods when the market's in a strong uptrend, trend following outperforms relative sentiment.
- 18:03Ray Micaletti: So a combination of the two.
- 18:05Ray Micaletti: What you tend to see is that it has thinner tails and you have less regret in terms of you have a lower tracking error to a perfect foresight strategy where imagine you had a crystal ball and you could see one month forward and you could see which strategy outperforms relative sentiment or trend fall and you switch to that before it happens.
- 18:25Ray Micaletti: So that's the perfect strategy.
- 18:26Ray Micaletti: If you had perfect foresight, a combination of relative sentiment and trend following has a much lower tracking error to that perfect strategy than either trend following or relative sentiment alone.
- 18:38Ray Micaletti: So there are periods where, if you're just doing relative sentiment, you feel bad because trend following is outperforming and there are periods where, if you're just doing trend following, you feel really bad because trend following is underperforming.
- 18:48Ray Micaletti: But if you do a combination of both, you don't ever feel euphoric but you don't ever feel despondent.
- 18:54Ray Micaletti: It's sort of like just you know you go about your business.
- 18:57Ray Micaletti: You have this nice diversification.
- 18:59Ray Micaletti: They complement each other.
- 19:00Ray Micaletti: You have thinner tails of your distribution.
- 19:02Mark McGrath: It's you know, it's kind of a sweet spot to be in, as opposed to trading only relative sentiment or only trend fall.
- 19:13Mark McGrath: Yeah, I mean punch.
- 19:14Mark McGrath: Sometimes I, when I think of uh, because I'd read race paper and we've had these, he and I've had these discussions I mean, I think cheng chi like I think of john boyd talking about having a.
- 19:21Mark McGrath: You know you can't have one approach on its own, you have to have two.
- 19:25Mark McGrath: You have an orthodox and an unorthodox, a conventional and unconventional and I wonder if they complement each other in that way, ponch.
- 20:32Mark McGrath: The other thing it made me think of was the conversation we just had about strategy from unrestricted warfare.
- 20:38Mark McGrath: Yeah, by parsing activities, two sets of activities at the Golden.
- 20:46Ponch Rivera: So let me throw this at you, mark.
- 20:47Ponch Rivera: So when we talk about the direction of travel in a complex environment, you run multiple probes, right?
- 20:51Ponch Rivera: Yeah, so in this case, you can run trend following and relative sentiment as probes to figure out what's going on, and I think that's what Ray did a nice job describing.
- 21:00Ponch Rivera: There are probes and the idea is, in a complex environment, you probe sense, respond.
- 21:04Ponch Rivera: Right, you got to get some confirmation of the direction of travel you're on.
- 21:08Ponch Rivera: Something else is popping to mind In a cockpit, you have multiple instruments that tell you what's happening, right?
- 21:14Ponch Rivera: Some are more important than others based on context, right?
- 21:17Ponch Rivera: So you don't want to be looking out inside the cockpit to look at your VSI when you're well you do when you're landing on a carrier, but you don't want that when you're flying low.
- 21:26Ponch Rivera: You want to be looking outside, right, looking outside to avoid running into anything on the horizon.
- 21:31Ponch Rivera: So that context matters.
- 21:33Ponch Rivera: And I think what's popping up in my head, going back to your point about strategy, is and what Ray just said if there was a map, if there's something that gave you an idea where the attractor states are combining multiple approaches, and I think what I'm hearing from Ray is that relative sentiment is going to give you maybe more of a leading indicator of a turn than a trend following.
- 21:54Ponch Rivera: A trend following is going to tell you yeah, you're climbing up a mountain right now or you're climbing higher.
- 21:59Ponch Rivera: It's your VSI, right, your vertical speed indicator.
- 22:01Ponch Rivera: So what's more important to me is knowing where we're going to turn, right.
- 22:07Ponch Rivera: If I have a map and a tractor map, they do not exist right now, as far as I know.
- 22:12Ponch Rivera: We're trying to figure that out.
- 22:14Mark McGrath: So because we do know several naval aviators that are in capital markets, so could we say you know, trend following is I'm in the groove.
- 22:22Mark McGrath: Relative sentiment is I got my LSOs down there telling me the different things that they see from their different perspectives.
- 22:28Mark McGrath: Yeah, that could be it.
- 22:29Ponch Rivera: But it's like flying a low level or flying, you know, we don't have a map.
- 22:38Ponch Rivera: We're trying to figure out where we're going and create that map while we're flying.
- 22:40Ponch Rivera: A better approach is to have some type of map and the complexity theory says we have attractors, right Attractors, and then we get that from music, we get that from geometry.
- 22:46Ponch Rivera: It doesn't confirm anything.
- 22:50Ponch Rivera: It says we expect something that happened here, but it doesn't say what's going to happen.
- 22:53Ponch Rivera: Right, and I think that's a very important thing when we think about music too.
- 22:58Ponch Rivera: Music we can intuitively know when something's going to change.
- 23:03Ponch Rivera: We just don't know what it is right or when exactly right.
- 23:07Ponch Rivera: Well, you know when it's going to happen, because music has a pattern, but it doesn't mean it's going to change in the way.
- 23:11Ponch Rivera: You don't know which direction it's going to change.
- 23:14Mark McGrath: It may not change at all.
- 23:15Ponch Rivera: Right, it just may be the same thing repeated over and over.
- 23:17Ray Micaletti: What do you think, ray?
- 23:18Ray Micaletti: Well, I think the analogies that you're coming up with, I think they make sense.
- 23:23Ray Micaletti: The one that you mentioned where you kind of have your perspective of people on the ground or kind of giving you a different perspective.
- 23:29Ray Micaletti: That is the case.
- 23:30Ray Micaletti: You know, trend following can be entirely 100% long equities.
- 23:35Ray Micaletti: But if institutions are selling, that rally market tends to stall out, tends to start going sideways and start drifting lower.
- 23:41Ray Micaletti: So, in that sense, when momentum's negative but institutions are bullish, relative to retail market goes up.
- 23:50Ray Micaletti: So in that case, relative sentiment's giving you more information than trend following.
- 23:55Ray Micaletti: Whenever trend following is positive and bullish and institutions are bearish, market tends to stall out.
- 24:02Ray Micaletti: So, again, sentiment's giving you more information than trend following in those examples, whenever they're both aligned.
- 24:08Ray Micaletti: So relative sentiments bullish, that trend following's bullish, market tends to coast.
- 24:12Ray Micaletti: It tends to have good outcomes, but not the best but good ones.
- 24:15Ray Micaletti: And then, whenever they're both bearish, you tend to have very bad outcomes.
- 24:19Ray Micaletti: So in that case, knowing what relative sentiment is telling you tends to give you more information than what trend following is telling you.
- 24:27Ray Micaletti: But like directional, more, more directional information, more directional information tends to give you more information than what trend following is telling you, but Like directional, more directional information.
- 24:33Ray Micaletti: More directional information.
- 24:34Ray Micaletti: The one nice thing about trend following is that, again, in an end of the world scenario, you won't ride anything down to zero unless there's a big gap in the market and the gap's low and you don't have a chance to trade out of it.
- 24:45Ray Micaletti: But presuming that's not the case, you won't ride anything down to zero where it is the case that institutions could be wrong and they might be buying a dip and the market could continue to dip, so there is that possibility.
- 24:58Ponch Rivera: Now.
- 24:58Ponch Rivera: So it's the fusion of these things.
- 24:59Ponch Rivera: I think that's where you're going to have the most success, and I don't do this at the moment.
- 25:03Ponch Rivera: By the way, we do look at gamma quite a bit on the daily side.
- 25:06Ponch Rivera: That doesn't mean that's the way they're going to move when we get to options.
- 25:10Ponch Rivera: We do look at some indicators.
- 25:13Ponch Rivera: I subscribe to some folks that look at price volume and volatility.
- 25:16Ponch Rivera: I use some stochastic from that, but again, that doesn't tell you that there's a turn coming.
- 25:21Ponch Rivera: It just tells you you're heading in a direction and when that wall pops up it's too late.
- 25:26Ponch Rivera: You already hit it right.
- 25:27Ponch Rivera: So these are confirming indicators.
- 25:30Ponch Rivera: So think about this.
- 25:31Ponch Rivera: Multi-sensor integration is what we want in aviation.
- 25:34Ponch Rivera: I want to know how to put many sensors downrange and not just trust one of them, but trust the coherence of them.
- 25:42Ponch Rivera: All right, and that's the key.
- 25:45Ray Micaletti: So I can give you an example of how that relates to relative sentiment.
- 25:48Ray Micaletti: So, if you flash back to October of 2022, that's when the market bottomed most recently but leading up to the middle of October, everybody was bearish.
- 26:00Ray Micaletti: Goldman Sachs was bearish, ubs was bearish, morgan Stanley Bank of America everyone was bearish, everyone expected an imminent recession and nobody wanted to touch equities, except for institutions who were basically backing up the truck in September and October of 2022.
- 26:17Ray Micaletti: And not only were they getting long equities, they were getting short the dollar.
- 26:21Ray Micaletti: And so if you look not only at equities, how they were positioned in the dollar, how they were positioned in equities, it was giving you the sense that, okay, we're probably going to have a change in trend.
- 26:31Ray Micaletti: The smart money was preparing for a soft landing when everyone thought the world was ending.
- 26:37Ray Micaletti: And then, if you flash forward from October of 22 to July of 2023, on July 29th 2023, the New York Times, wall Street Journal and Financial Times all had articles individually about the soft landing that had emerged that no one was forecasting nine months earlier, except for the smart money.
- 26:56Ray Micaletti: If you look at my Twitter page, the pinned tweet is from October 10th 2022.
- 27:04Ray Micaletti: And a lot of people were comparing 2022 to 2008.
- 27:07Ray Micaletti: They were saying, oh, this market's going to fall off a cliff, it's going to keep going lower.
- 27:11Ray Micaletti: And I said, well, we're seeing a lot of comparisons to 2008,.
- 27:15Ray Micaletti: But in 2008, institutions were bearish equities and bullish the dollar, whereas now, in 2022, they're bullish equities and bearish the dollar.
- 27:24Ray Micaletti: So let's see what happens.
- 27:26Ray Micaletti: And, sure enough, the dollar fell, equities rallied.
- 27:28Ray Micaletti: And so to your point about you know, seeing the coherence of you know, if it were just equities, well, maybe it would have been a short-term thing, but it was equities and the dollar and what happens.
- 27:38Ray Micaletti: So they were positioning across multiple assets for a soft landing and whether or not we are going to get one or add one or that's another discussion altogether, but it was enough of a perception that eventually seeped into the market to allow the market to rally and for the smart money to profit.
- 27:55Ponch Rivera: So a lot of retailer investors are fixated on equities and options and, if I understand everything correctly, if you look at the holistic everything in the market as a flow system and you're going back to your point about the dollar maybe the dollar and the yen it's flowing.
- 28:08Ponch Rivera: Money's always flowing in a direction, so if you're getting relative sentiment on the dollar yen, that's an indicator for what could be coming too right.
- 28:16Ray Micaletti: Absolutely, absolutely.
- 28:17Ray Micaletti: Some of the biggest and most predictive things for equities are not how smart money's positioned in equities directly, it's how they're positioned in crude oil, how they're positioned in nat gas, how they're positioned in the two-year bond, the dollar, the yen, the 30-year bond.
- 28:33Mark McGrath: Yeah, so it's very much Unpack that right, Because those things have more exposure and more connections to more things right In the broader economy.
- 28:41Ray Micaletti: Yes so one of the big projects that I'm working on now.
- 28:44Ray Micaletti: So I know that there are a lot of people that have a macro framework where they look at growth and inflation and you have four quadrants.
- 28:50Ray Micaletti: You have positive growth or negative growth and you have inflation is increasing or decreasing.
- 28:55Ray Micaletti: So you have these four quadrants and different assets and sectors do better in different quadrants.
- 29:00Ray Micaletti: So I've always had trouble implementing that myself, because the question is are you looking at rear view at what the growth is?
- 29:08Ray Micaletti: Are you looking at what the forward growth is?
- 29:09Ray Micaletti: How many quarters are you looking forward rear view at what the growth is?
- 29:10Ray Micaletti: Are you looking at what the forward growth is?
- 29:10Ray Micaletti: How many quarters are you looking forward?
- 29:11Ray Micaletti: What inflation are you looking at?
- 29:13Ray Micaletti: What measures?
- 29:13Ray Micaletti: I've always had trouble implementing that, but what I've had success implementing is looking at growth and inflation relative sentiment.
- 29:21Ray Micaletti: So if you look at commodities and equities, I consider those to be indicative of growth.
- 29:27Ray Micaletti: So if institutions are bullish on equities, bullish on certain commodities, that means that growth is likely increasing.
- 29:34Ray Micaletti: Then I look at inflation or liquidity-related relative sentiment.
- 29:39Ray Micaletti: How are institutions positioned in things that are related to liquidity the dollar, the yen, the two-year bond, et cetera, and the Fed funds, futures, the Euro, dollar and I combine those.
- 29:50Ray Micaletti: If growth relative sentiment's bullish and liquidity relative sentiment is bullish, assets of all stripes tend to do well.
- 29:58Ray Micaletti: If one or both of those is not the case, then assets tend to struggle.
- 30:02Ray Micaletti: Now it just so happens that about 60% of the time you're in that good quadrant and then the other 40% is distributed over the bad quadrants.
- 30:11Ray Micaletti: But yes, it's not only how the smart money is positioned in a certain asset directly.
- 30:17Ray Micaletti: How are they positioned in other assets.
- 30:19Ray Micaletti: If you're looking at gold, how the smart money is positioned in silver, how they're positioned in the dollar, how they're positioned in the Euro, has a lot of effect on what gold does.
- 30:28Ray Micaletti: How they're positioned in the two-year bond has a lot of effect on what equities do.
- 30:31Ray Micaletti: So there's a lot of cross-asset relationships, positioning relationships that affect these.
- 30:38Ray Micaletti: So this is empirically true.
- 30:41Ray Micaletti: But it's also not some crank in his basement, Ray Micheletti, telling you this.
- 30:45Ray Micaletti: There's actually a paper that was in the Journal of Finance in the year 2000 by some people that were talking about if you want to predict equities, you also have to look at how the institutions are positioned in bonds.
- 30:57Ray Micaletti: And if you want to, if you want to predict, you know, coffee futures, you have to look at how they're positioned in cocoa futures and things of that nature.
- 31:04Ray Micaletti: There's a lot of these.
- 31:06Ray Micaletti: They're called cross cross-edge pressure forces that have an impact on different assets.
- 31:12Ray Micaletti: So it's tunnel vision.
- 31:16Mark McGrath: It's a broad, holistic thing Like you don't have to know why something's happening, you just have to know, like the why is.
- 31:30Mark McGrath: Oh, okay, now I know, but it doesn't matter because I can just track the metrics.
- 31:33Mark McGrath: I don't have to second guess that, because isn't that where, when we start to wonder, well, why did that happen?
- 31:39Mark McGrath: That's where we're starting to put thinking that doesn't necessarily help with investment outcomes into the scenario.
- 31:46Ray Micaletti: I agree.
- 31:46Ray Micaletti: So it's nice to have a model that's transparent and you know why it works and when it's not going to work and what its weaknesses are.
- 31:53Ray Micaletti: But by the same token, if you have a pattern that repeats itself and repeats itself and you can demonstrate that, even when adjusted for the number of different strategies that you might have tested, that it's still highly significant, then at some point you kind of just have to trust it if you're a systematic investor, so I'm with you.
- 32:10Ray Micaletti: I'm sort of oriented as opposed to why exactly this is working.
- 32:14Ray Micaletti: So long as it has high statistical significance when adjusted for data snooping and it's robust.
- 32:21Ray Micaletti: You know, like if you change your factor just a little bit it doesn't materially change the result.
- 32:28Ray Micaletti: So if you can change your parameters, you can change your indicator a little bit, and the results are still very robust and it's highly significant, then I think at the end of the day that's typically what matters most.
- 32:38Mark McGrath: When, if ever, do you apply a subjective judgment in the contrary to what the indicators would say, or you just wouldn't do that?
- 32:45Ray Micaletti: I really wouldn't do that.
- 32:46Ray Micaletti: When I was sort of cutting my teeth in this industry, I was at Fortress Investment Group and people might be familiar with Mike Novogratz, the Bitcoin investor.
- 32:58Ray Micaletti: He was the hedge fund manager.
- 33:00Ray Micaletti: He was the guy who started Fortress' liquid market hedge fund.
- 33:03Ray Micaletti: He was always saying if you trade models, you got to trade the model.
- 33:07Ray Micaletti: You can't start overriding the model.
- 33:08Ray Micaletti: You just have to trade the model.
- 33:09Ray Micaletti: You just have to trade the model.
- 33:12Ray Micaletti: Especially if you're part of a larger portfolio.
- 33:14Ray Micaletti: You've been slotted into that portfolio based on the characteristics of your model and when you start overriding those characteristics, then all of a sudden you don't fit into that portfolio any longer.
- 33:25Ray Micaletti: So I've had it drilled into me that you have to follow the model and what have you?
- 33:30Ray Micaletti: But that's also why it's important to have models that aren't total black boxes, because I think the hardest thing about model investing is sticking with a model when it's not working, because you don't know is this going to work again?
- 33:50Ray Micaletti: Why was it working to begin with?
- 33:51Ray Micaletti: Should I shut it down?
- 33:51Ray Micaletti: But if it's a model that's simple, makes sense, transparent, you know why it works, why it doesn't work, what its weaknesses are, then you have the confidence to stick with it when it might not be working.
- 34:00Ponch Rivera: So From the perspective of the OODA loop, this is great.
- 34:02Ponch Rivera: So I'll throw some complexity through here as well.
- 34:04Ponch Rivera: We have to learn how to separate decisions from outcomes, right, because sometimes your model can be perfect and you're going to have a horrible outcome, and that doesn't mean you need to fix the model.
- 34:12Ponch Rivera: However, within the OODA loop, we have orientation, which is a generative model, meaning it's a learning model.
- 34:17Ponch Rivera: It has to adapt to the external environment.
- 34:19Ponch Rivera: So the idea here is you do want and this also connects to what is known as implicit guidance control you kind of want that muscle memory built in.
- 34:27Ponch Rivera: You want to take the biases out, the heuristics out from the human side, if you can and there's some research that says you don't need to do that you need the intuitive piece, which is built off of experience, by the way.
- 34:40Ponch Rivera: So implicit guidance control is experience.
- 34:43Ponch Rivera: Here you have it.
- 34:43Ponch Rivera: You have a generative model.
- 34:44Ponch Rivera: Some are good.
- 34:46Ponch Rivera: You brought up a model that has four quadrants in it, um, that has policy growth and inflation built into it.
- 34:53Ponch Rivera: That reminds me of a swat analysis, right, swat analysis, a two by two or however you want to look at it.
- 34:58Ponch Rivera: That's not a good way to map the world, but it's a better model than not having one right.
- 35:03Ponch Rivera: It's a better model than than just kind of winging it out there.
- 35:06Ponch Rivera: The oodle loop tells us, and boyd's work in plexity Theory you need a model of the external world and we also know that all models are wrong.
- 35:14Ponch Rivera: Right, all maps wrong.
- 35:15Ponch Rivera: The map is not the terrain and all that.
- 35:16Ponch Rivera: What's important here is, you know we would take all of these insights to generate a model and test it and operate off of it and try to take the human out of the system the best we can.
- 35:27Ponch Rivera: There will be times when you'll need a judgment call and, like I said, we're looking for coherence in a lot of these signals.
- 35:33Ponch Rivera: If you will, that'll give us a higher probability of a positive trade, meaning bearish or bullish, whichever direction the market's going and how we set our positions up.
- 35:43Ponch Rivera: We want a higher P sub K, a higher probability of kill, right?
- 35:49Ponch Rivera: So in fighter aviation I have a weapon that comes off the rail and I know it has a piece of cave about 80%, maybe 70%.
- 35:57Ponch Rivera: Sometimes I have to shoot twice, right, I know that one shot's not going to give me what I need.
- 36:02Ponch Rivera: So how do you mitigate risk against that?
- 36:04Ponch Rivera: Well, you don't put all your eggs in one basket, right?
- 36:06Ponch Rivera: You don't do that.
- 36:07Ponch Rivera: Maybe you have some cash on the side, maybe your portfolio is set up where it's 3%, 2%, whatever it may be, but the bottom line here is there are so many great lessons we can borrow from complexity theory, which is fed into John Boyd's OODA loop that helps people understand these things that, hey, you do need a generative model of the external world.
- 36:28Ponch Rivera: And, by the way, the three of us have a generative model.
- 36:32Ponch Rivera: They're all different.
- 36:33Ponch Rivera: It's called orientation.
- 36:34Ponch Rivera: Different institutions have a generative model.
- 36:37Ponch Rivera: It's whomever builds the best model is going to win, and I think that's what you're trying to do, right, ray?
- 36:46Ray Micaletti: Yeah, I mean I'd love to have the best model.
- 36:48Ray Micaletti: I keep working in that regard.
- 36:50Ray Micaletti: I don't ever reach that position, but the market's always changing.
- 36:53Mark McGrath: Let me compound what Ponch said the best model that's the closest aligned to what's actually going on Because you could have a model filled with plenty of Princeton PhDs at long-term capital management and that's misaligned from what's actually going on you're going to get, you're going to miss outcomes.
- 37:12Ray Micaletti: Or you can look at the Fed and all those egghead economists in the ivory tower cutting rates and then markets rates shot up after they started cutting rates.
- 37:21Ray Micaletti: Yeah, exactly.
- 37:27Mark McGrath: There's only what?
- 37:27Mark McGrath: 700 of them.
- 37:28Ponch Rivera: So they can't get a rate, they don't buy coffee, they don't buy tea, they don't buy eggs.
- 37:31Mark McGrath: It's unreal.
- 37:32Mark McGrath: Well, that goes back to what?
- 37:33Mark McGrath: So now we're back at unrestricted warfare again.
- 37:36Mark McGrath: Remember Ponche?
- 37:37Mark McGrath: Talk about fuzziness.
- 37:38Mark McGrath: You're not going to see this stuff with empirical precision and empirical precision is also something that Boyd said.
- 37:45Mark McGrath: Because of the existence of empirical precision, there's no way out of the world of reorientation.
- 37:51Mark McGrath: So we have to constantly keep revising, updating, revising, updating, creating, destroying, creating, destroying, to make sure that our model is as closely connected to reality as possible, understanding that it's always going to be, as the Chinese officers say, in Unrestricted Warfare it's always going to be fuzzy, it's never going to be exact.
- 38:09Mark McGrath: As an example, does equilibrium exist?
- 38:16Mark McGrath: Yes, would you ever know when you're in it?
- 38:17Mark McGrath: Never, it's impossible to know that.
- 38:18Mark McGrath: So I just I don't know, just throwing that out there as a thought, if you'd add anything to that, ray.
- 38:22Ray Micaletti: I mean, I think that the sentiment that I took from what you just said was that the market opens every day.
- 38:29Ray Micaletti: So, no matter what you've kind of done up to this point, you got to keep going.
- 38:34Ray Micaletti: You know, you have to keep managing money, you have to keep making the adjustments, because the world is constantly changing, constantly shifting, and you can't just kind of rest on what you might've done over the past, you know, a few months, or the past year.
- 38:46Ray Micaletti: You continually have to keep moving forward and keep managing the portfolio.
- 38:52Mark McGrath: So, yeah, yeah, it's almost like, rather than having a plan, you always have to be planning.
- 38:58Ponch Rivera: Yes.
- 38:59Mark McGrath: Exactly.
- 38:59Ponch Rivera: Yeah, and that's what we tell folks is it's not the plan that matters, it's the art and science of planning right, it's adapting to the external environment and, like I said, the connections between what John Boyd has given us and others is phenomenal, because in a complex world, in a VUCA world and Mark said it already you have to update and go through the world of reorientation all the time.
- 39:19Ponch Rivera: If you're not doing that, you're going to get your ass kicked and I think a lot of folks, even today on Wall Street, are not doing that quite well.
- 39:27Ponch Rivera: And can you just?
- 39:28Ponch Rivera: I don't know if you have the numbers off the top of your head, but what's the chances of a retail investor or an institution actually beating an index like an SPX or something like that?
- 39:38Ray Micaletti: I don't have those numbers off the top of my head, but I know that you always read how it's a very small number of funds or investors that actually beat the market, and I certainly think that would be even fewer retail traders that have beaten the market.
- 39:55Ray Micaletti: And to your point about Wall Street possibly not adapting to a vehicle world, I think we're probably people.
- 40:05Ray Micaletti: 2008, 2009 is a distant memory.
- 40:08Ray Micaletti: 2020 lasted for a month and a half and then the market was off to the races.
- 40:14Ray Micaletti: I feel like we're going to be in a trend, in a phase shift, a phase change here pretty soon, where everyone's been accustomed to buying the dip for the last 15 years and it's gotten to the point where valuations are at the worst level of all time even worse than the dot-com bubble by certain measures that have high correlation to future returns.
- 40:36Ray Micaletti: We also have a situation where the equity risk premium is extremely negative.
- 40:39Ray Micaletti: So the 10-year bonds are offering you 4.7%, where the equity return over the next 10 years again based on these indicators that have strong correlation to the future returns is even it's negative.
- 40:50Ray Micaletti: It's like 0.5% annualized return versus 4.7% annualized return of the 10 years.
- 40:56Ray Micaletti: So you're getting almost minus 5% negative equity risk premium if you hold equities relative to holding bonds, and I don't think bonds are going to be that great of an investment.
- 41:07Ray Micaletti: With sticky inflation.
- 41:08Ray Micaletti: Bonds are probably going to have negative real returns.
- 41:11Ray Micaletti: So I think we're the prime outcomes in the future the next five, certainly the rest of this decade, but possibly into the next decade gold, silver, energy stocks, material stocks, equity rates, things that do well in a highly inflationary environment.
- 41:26Ray Micaletti: And I think if you look at I saw a few charts recently where, of course, so retail traders of the last 40 years the highest percentage of them now thinks that the market is going to be up over the next 12 months.
- 41:39Ray Micaletti: So every year they say they ask retail traders, consumers, what probability do you think the market's going to be up or down?
- 41:46Ray Micaletti: Then they aggregate that information and they say, okay, 30% of the population thinks the market will be up in 12 months.
- 41:52Ray Micaletti: 40% think it'll be up.
- 41:54Ray Micaletti: Now it's like 56, 57% of consumers think that the equity market will be higher 12 months forward.
- 42:00Ray Micaletti: That's the highest percentage of all time.
- 42:03Ray Micaletti: So what I think has happened is and it was a brilliant psyop is that we had this AI narrative, that basically told the retail investor because they watch CNBC, they get the research reports from the various banks that AI was going to be this panacea.
- 42:21Ray Micaletti: It's going to be this utopia All these earnings, these firms are going to make trillions of dollars, and so that all became priced into the market.
- 42:30Ray Micaletti: And anytime the market dipped, you had a White House that was selling down oil to keep inflation low.
- 42:36Ray Micaletti: You had a treasury that was issuing debt on the short end to keep the long end stable so that equities could rise, and you would have fed that anytime the market would fall, they would jawbone it higher or they eventually cut rates.
- 42:49Ray Micaletti: So you had all this institutional support for the market.
- 42:51Ray Micaletti: You had this AI narrative, and it's gotten to the point where I think retail traders don't think that the market can fall.
- 42:58Ray Micaletti: Yet here we are with the worst valuations of all time.
- 43:00Ray Micaletti: Here we are with the market up 50%, when earnings expectations have gone up maybe two or 3%, and so you have this big vacuum that's been created where I think you could have a very negative outcome in the next several years.
- 43:11Ray Micaletti: And because they've been inculcated with this narrative of AI, they're probably going to buy that dip all the way down.
- 43:17Ray Micaletti: And so I think it was this massive psyop that's going to end with retail holding the bag as they typically do, and they're going to buy that dip all the way down until they finally sell.
- 43:28Ray Micaletti: And I think the final sell will be when baby boomers, who have been inculcated to the belief that the market always comes back, they'll have this realization like the market isn't coming back and now my retirement is completely destroyed, so I have to sell and salvage what I can.
- 43:44Ray Micaletti: That will probably be the last rush of selling and then the market will rise from there, but that might be 60 to 80% lower in equities.
- 43:52Ponch Rivera: Yeah, Wow.
- 43:53Ponch Rivera: I mean, there's an opportunity here that we could see a parabolic rise in the market and then that massive crash, or we could see that crash here soon, we don't know.
- 44:01Ponch Rivera: And that's the whole point of this.
- 44:01Ponch Rivera: There is no what's that saying?
- 44:03Ponch Rivera: Prediction is hard, especially about the future right, yeah, absolutely.
- 44:06Mark McGrath: Well, it's also what's the one from the big short where it says it's not what you don't know that gets you into trouble, it's what you're absolutely positive of.
- 44:13Mark McGrath: That just isn't so positive of that just isn't so.
- 44:16Mark McGrath: Yes, that's Mark Twain.
- 44:16Mark McGrath: Yeah.
- 44:17Ponch Rivera: Mark Twain yeah, it's weak signal detection and I think, when you look at what you're doing, you're using the human-centered network to make sense of the environment, right, and that's important, I mean.
- 44:27Ponch Rivera: To me that's a great indicator of what's happening.
- 44:29Mark McGrath: There are other factors.
- 44:31Mark McGrath: I wonder about no-transcript.
- 45:03Mark McGrath: This kind of goes back to the reason to be systematic If I can be systematic in something but I also have to maintain the correct human orientation of how I view markets to understand what money actually is, what capital actually is, what actually causes business cycles.
- 45:20Mark McGrath: Only from my own edification, but it seems to me that those like I guess the biggest one that you probably encounter is what's the definition of risk?
- 45:27Mark McGrath: I would say that's the chance of the permanent loss of capital.
- 45:30Mark McGrath: Most look at risk as a volatility definition, like some kind of definition of getting a whipsaw which is not, which is not the classical definition of risk.
- 45:39Mark McGrath: And then I guess the other thing I wonder about is if you don't have a good definition of money and you don't have an understanding that prices are, are signals, that those signals are distorted?
- 45:48Mark McGrath: You're making decisions.
- 45:50Mark McGrath: You're making observations, decisions, actions and learning off of poor signals, oraligned or inaccurate signals, which also leads you to ruin.
- 46:00Ray Micaletti: Like price controls.
- 46:02Mark McGrath: Yeah.
- 46:02Ray Micaletti: You know, if you don't allow the market to kind of give you the information like, hey, this is rising in price, so hey, entrepreneurs are going to go create more supply to take advantage of that, and then that brings prices down as supply comes online.
- 46:15Mark McGrath: So I agree, you know when it comes to One of my favorites, and you know, I used to be an investment wholesaler, working with brokerage, with advisors inside of brokerage houses, and they would tell me the definition of inflation is the rise in prices.
- 46:29Mark McGrath: What's it caused by?
- 46:30Mark McGrath: Really, consumers control the prices of money.
- 46:36Mark McGrath: They control rates Really.
- 46:38Mark McGrath: Or you say what's your definition of risk?
- 46:41Mark McGrath: Well, volatility.
- 46:43Mark McGrath: I don't want it to be within so many standard deviations, but you only lose if you sell.
- 46:48Mark McGrath: You only lose money if you sell.
- 46:52Ponch Rivera: Yeah.
- 46:52Ponch Rivera: So to me, risk is just an increase of surprise, right?
- 46:55Ponch Rivera: I mean, risk can be positive or negative, it's just our job is to minimize surprise, right yeah, generate mismatches for our opponents, minimize surprise for ourself, and that's what the orientation, implicit guides, control the policies, the plans, the way we do things.
- 47:10Mark McGrath: Well, go back to what you said, ray.
- 47:11Mark McGrath: You say institutions try to buy low and sell high, and this is one of the famous open secrets of the market when they're buying low, who's selling low?
- 47:21Ray Micaletti: It's the retail.
- 47:23Mark McGrath: Exactly, it's retail when they're selling high.
- 47:26Mark McGrath: Who's buying high?
- 47:27Mark McGrath: You know, because every buy is a sell and vice versa.
- 47:31Mark McGrath: Exactly, and like you tell people that they would look at you like you were speaking.
- 47:35Ray Micaletti: Klingon.
- 47:36Ray Micaletti: Yeah, and when you think about it, retail traders are told how to feel about the market by the people that they're competing against in the market or the CNBC, blaring in their ear all day long.
- 47:46Ray Micaletti: Right.
- 47:46Ray Micaletti: So if you read Barron's Magazine, the institutional guy who's telling you about XYZ stock, he's already bought that stock and so when you rush Monday to buy this great deal, you're basically putting money in his pocket and he doesn't have any skin in the game anyway.
- 48:02Ray Micaletti: Exactly so you know, you have institutions that are basically leading retail around by the hand, telling retail how they should feel, how they should think, what they should do, what they should buy, what they should sell.
- 48:10Ray Micaletti: It's basically the wolf in sheep's clothing that's leading the sheep around.
- 48:15Ray Micaletti: It's a permanent, structural advantage for institutions.
- 48:19Ponch Rivera: Let me challenge that.
- 48:20Ponch Rivera: I want to challenge that for a second, and I'm going to ask Mark to do this for us.
- 48:22Ponch Rivera: Okay, so that may have been the case years ago, where today we now have a network of retail traders, right?
- 48:31Ponch Rivera: So, Mark, walk me through and I'm going to throw you on the bus here.
- 48:35Ponch Rivera: Mark, that's fine.
- 48:36Ponch Rivera: Tell me how the retail trader can use a network to outperform the institutions.
- 48:43Ponch Rivera: Is it possible?
- 48:45Mark McGrath: Well see, the challenge that I'd have back is that's assuming that's my goal is to be the institutions.
- 48:53Mark McGrath: I don't know that it would necessarily be my goal.
- 48:56Mark McGrath: We could have a whole nother show on this.
- 48:59Mark McGrath: I have journal notes and journal notes of almost 20 years as an observer, as an investment wholesaler, going into brokerage houses and watching this stuff and going through.
- 49:10Mark McGrath: I started in 05 and going through all that in 07, 08 and a pandemic, everything.
- 49:15Mark McGrath: And you start to wonder.
- 49:18Mark McGrath: These assumptions are made like I have to beat the index.
- 49:21Mark McGrath: Well, what's the index?
- 49:22Mark McGrath: Well, the index is passive.
- 49:23Mark McGrath: What does that mean?
- 49:23Mark McGrath: Well, it's just the market.
- 49:24Mark McGrath: Really, standard and Poor's didn't decide to tell you that it's this much percent of Microsoft, or does that stuff happen organically?
- 49:32Mark McGrath: So I think a lot of the fundamental starting points of how people look at markets, how people look at capital, how people look at price signals and stuff, their fundamental starting points, are completely misaligned.
- 49:43Mark McGrath: The only reason they believe that the index is the market is because they've been programmed to think that it doesn't mean that it is.
- 49:49Mark McGrath: The S&P 500 doesn't occur in nature.
- 49:54Ponch Rivera: We are the market.
- 49:55Ponch Rivera: Are you saying that?
- 49:56Mark McGrath: That goes back to what we've been talking about with sacred geometry.
- 49:58Mark McGrath: Yeah, we're organic, we're part of the ecology, we're part of the environment, we're thinking sentient beings and we all act to our own, based off our own observations, decisions, actions within complexity as it unfolds and when we're told.
- 50:13Mark McGrath: Like the other podcast we were recording earlier, a lot of that is shaped in the medium that we're exposed to, be it social media, be it TV, satellite, radio phones, wherever we're getting our stuff.
- 50:25Mark McGrath: But that doesn't mean it's reality, right?
- 50:30Mark McGrath: Because, ray, add in on this I mean, the greatest investors of all time probably don't watch Kramer.
- 50:34Mark McGrath: They probably don't read Barron's of all time.
- 50:37Mark McGrath: Probably don't watch Kramer.
- 50:38Mark McGrath: They probably don't read Barron's.
- 50:39Mark McGrath: They probably aren't looking for stock picks from some send-away I pay a guy this much per month or whatever.
- 50:46Mark McGrath: They're probably doing something systematic and looking on things that we can actually know, we can know volume, we can know price and that's it.
- 50:55Ray Micaletti: Right, and two things, or at least one relative sentiment, can be looked at as an implied fundamental indicator.
- 51:02Ray Micaletti: So one of the advantages that institutions have is that every year they hire new armies of CFAs, mbas, phds, and they set them loose on trying to figure out the trajectory of the economy, the trajectory of corporate earnings, and they expend a lot of resources to figure that out.
- 51:16Ray Micaletti: And then they take positions in the futures and options market that reflect their conclusions of that study.
- 51:23Ray Micaletti: And now, not every institution is going to get it right all the time.
- 51:26Ray Micaletti: But if you look at their net positioning, like which way are institutions leaning relative to other institutions, to kind of give you sort of like the aggregate institutional position, that kind of gives you heads up as to how the institutions think the macro landscape is going to evolve.
- 51:43Ray Micaletti: And some of those inputs to their research could very well be inside information.
- 51:49Ray Micaletti: Because, if you're an institution, you talk to corporate CEOs, you talk to the Fed, you talk to ex-Fed governors.
- 51:55Ray Micaletti: You talk to lobbyists, you talk to politicians.
- 51:57Mark McGrath: Yeah, on the golf course or at the squash courts.
- 52:00Ray Micaletti: Exactly, blackrock was the institution that was doing the Fed's buying of bonds in.
- 52:06Ray Micaletti: COVID right.
- 52:07Ray Micaletti: So I'm sure there was information diffused in the BlackRock and to the trading desk about what was happening there.
- 52:16Ray Micaletti: And if you look at what the institutions were doing in the futures and options market in February and March of 2020, they basically were selling in late February and then they bought back heavily on March 20th, which was one week which was like three days before Powell came out and said oh, we're going to start buying bonds.
- 52:34Ray Micaletti: So there must have been some type of diffusion of information amongst the elite institutional establishment to get them buying back right a couple of days before the very bottom.
- 52:47Mark McGrath: I was at the club last weekend and you wouldn't believe what Chaz said about this Exactly.
- 52:54Ray Micaletti: It's like George Carlin said.
- 52:55Mark McGrath: George Carlin said you don't have to have a formal conspiracy, when everybody went to the same school and they're all hanging out and they go to the same country clubs and everything else.
- 53:05Ray Micaletti: Exactly yeah, when I used to work at Fortress Investment Group, every week we would have ex-Fed governors Slatney that are consultants now would come in and tell us what the Fed was thinking, because they still had friends in the Fed, right, the Fed was thinking because they still had friends in the Fed, right?
- 53:19Ray Micaletti: So the average retail trader in his basement doesn't have access to that type of information stream.
- 53:23Ray Micaletti: And so I think, yes, there are going to be retail traders that probably are very contrarian in their trading, that do well, but I think the bulk of retail traders are going to have a very hard time out-competing the institutions that have these permanent, deep-seated structural advantages.
- 53:40Mark McGrath: Potch.
- 53:40Mark McGrath: What was John Boyd?
- 53:42Mark McGrath: What did he consider to be the greatest insults you could hurl at him?
- 53:46Mark McGrath: Expert analyst, an analyst, or an expert, or an analytical expert.
- 53:50Mark McGrath: That was the worst was analytical expert, but Wall Street's full of them.
- 53:54Mark McGrath: Yeah, I mean, they're full of analysts that can tell you they can break everything down.
- 53:59Mark McGrath: Well, boyd said that's not enough.
- 54:01Mark McGrath: You have to have synthesis.
- 54:02Mark McGrath: If I can't synthesize something and create something novel, there's no way.
- 54:07Mark McGrath: I mean the strategy that you've built, you've analyzed, and then you've synthesized that to a higher purpose and you have it directionally towards something.
- 54:14Mark McGrath: And then the expert, which there's plenty of those on, not just Wall Street but in every, every discipline.
- 54:20Mark McGrath: They're know-it-alls.
- 54:21Ponch Rivera: Yeah, and Mark, let me try this on you.
- 54:23Ponch Rivera: Yeah, going back to this, you can't change a system from within.
- 54:25Ponch Rivera: So if you think about an analyst who's an expert, they're part of that system, right, correct?
- 54:31Ponch Rivera: So they can't see what they're part of.
- 54:34Mark McGrath: I would agree with that.
- 54:35Mark McGrath: Yeah, and I mean, this is the other thing.
- 54:37Mark McGrath: I used to hand people Destruction and Creation to read it, and they could never get no wait, I'm not in the system, I have my own.
- 54:43Ray Micaletti: Can I ask you guys a question as experts?
- 54:46Ray Micaletti: No, no, don't call us experts, we're students.
- 54:48Ray Micaletti: Yeah, we just got done telling you don learning, you're constantly learning, you don't feel like you know enough and you're constantly striving for more knowledge, always, that's the maxim.
- 54:59Ray Micaletti: Do you think that the US and the establishment falls into that category that we just talked about?
- 55:04Ray Micaletti: They are in the system.
- 55:05Ray Micaletti: They can't see where their weaknesses are in terms of the US empire trying to oppose its values on the rest of the world, the rest of the world having a backlash to that, possibly, the US having lost its military advantage versus Russia and China.
- 55:18Ray Micaletti: We used to project power through aircraft carriers, but our aircraft carriers are vulnerable to hypersonic missiles that Russia and China have.
- 55:25Ray Micaletti: And yet, yet, yet the US establishment keeps warmongering.
- 55:29Ray Micaletti: They keep escalating in Ukraine.
- 55:31Ray Micaletti: They keep, you know.
- 55:32Ray Micaletti: Now Trump is talking about possibly preemptively striking Iran.
- 55:36Ray Micaletti: You know Sable rattling over Taiwan.
- 55:38Ray Micaletti: Do you think that the US elite doesn't see their potentially imminent downfall?
- 55:44Mark McGrath: Yes, and it's not limited to them.
- 55:46Mark McGrath: So everybody is going to have their own orientation of the world, which, in turn, is going to implicitly guide and control how they observe, decide, act and learn.
- 55:54Mark McGrath: They're not unique.
- 55:56Mark McGrath: What Boyd would say is that we have to continuously challenge assumptions.
- 56:01Mark McGrath: And what you've described is characteristic of a excessively bureaucratic hegemon.
- 56:08Mark McGrath: And even though we might be the biggest one, it doesn't mean that there's not other ones out there.
- 56:13Mark McGrath: And the idea is, in those types of environments, like what Ponch was just saying, you can't determine within the system its own nature and character.
- 56:23Mark McGrath: You have to be outside of the system.
- 56:24Mark McGrath: And the more that you try to determine the nature or character of a system within itself, you're only going to create more confusion and disorder, and that's what Boyd said.
- 56:30Mark McGrath: So Boyd analyzed and then synthesized three things entropy, uncertainty and incompleteness.
- 56:36Mark McGrath: And then synthesize three things entropy, uncertainty and incompleteness.
- 56:40Mark McGrath: That's exactly what his remedies and came up finally with OODA Loop Sketch of how you try to disassociate yourself with the system that you're within so that you can look without, such that you don't become obsolete, irrelevant, declining all the things that we see.
- 56:52Mark McGrath: I asked Sean this, sean Ring that we had on a few X Live broadcasts.
- 56:56Mark McGrath: We were talking about the Barings Bank trade, if you remember the rogue trader with Nick Leeson.
- 57:04Mark McGrath: He did a lot of damage in and of itself with the trades that he had, with the losses that he incurred.
- 57:10Mark McGrath: The reality was, or, and the reality was that culture there allowed that to somehow happen, unguarded, unsupervised or whatever it is, and that probably suggests to me that this had been going on for a long time, and not necessarily the crime that he committed or the trades that he did or the losses that he incurred which, by the way, happened with a quote-unquote active God right with the earthquake in Japan.
- 57:34Mark McGrath: It probably suggests that there was a long drawn decline that suddenly ended, and I forget who says like with bankruptcy, you know it's gradual at first and then sudden, and I think that's in a lot of these cases.
- 57:47Mark McGrath: With anything that's hegemonic, whether it's a company, a bank, a country, an empire, a civilization that if it's not breaking its models and reinventing itself, then you're in a lot of trouble.
- 57:58Mark McGrath: We had General Petraeus that we published yesterday and he was talking about how Netflix, when it originally beat Blockbuster, is not the Netflix that we have today, because it does keep smashing its models and reorienting and reimagining itself as time goes forward.
- 58:14Mark McGrath: What would you add to that Ponch?
- 58:16Ponch Rivera: You just talked about destruction and creation there.
- 58:18Ponch Rivera: You don't want, you don't want your opponents upsetting your own model.
- 58:21Ponch Rivera: You want to do it yourself, and that that the only way to do that is go outside your system.
- 58:25Mark McGrath: I'm going to disrupt myself, yeah, yeah, or think of this way, ray.
- 58:28Mark McGrath: Like a lot, a lot of companies, civilizations, cultures we don't want to put, we want to criticize and point out what everybody else is wrong with them.
- 58:37Mark McGrath: We don't want to hold the mirror up to ourselves.
- 58:39Mark McGrath: You know, and you can't make we had a guest on earlier you can't make any change unless you create that discomfort within yourself to to make the right decisions and actions, to to to actually actually change.
- 58:51Mark McGrath: So that's why that's why I don't think there's like one style of investing per se, because things are always changing.
- 59:01Mark McGrath: I mean, how many times for the last, however many years, have you heard Bitcoin, this, bitcoin, that and the bad, bitcoin, this and the good, and all the naysayers are sitting there looking at it at 100 grand or whatever it's hit.
- 59:11Mark McGrath: They're like, well, yeah, it's just a fluke.
- 59:13Ray Micaletti: It's a bubble.
- 59:13Ray Micaletti: That is an interesting debate.
- 59:15Ray Micaletti: What do you guys follow on the Bitcoin?
- 59:16Ray Micaletti: A fluke, it's a bubble.
- 59:18Ponch Rivera: That is, uh, an interesting debate.
- 59:19Ponch Rivera: What do you guys follow on the bitcoin?
- 59:21Ponch Rivera: Uh, so I was anti-bitcoin a while ago, uh, wouldn't touch it.
- 59:23Ponch Rivera: And then it just became clear that, hey, if it's a bubble, you can still make money off a bubble, and then if you can get in and out of it, so you could.
- 59:30Ponch Rivera: So you got, you know, a couple people that are buying it and holding it forever and you're like, okay, that that may work out for you, I don't know.
- 59:36Ponch Rivera: And then there's folks you know, like Bart's, saying, hey, he's giving us the attractor points on it and says, hey, buy it between here, look at it, here, it should bounce back down to this level.
- 59:45Ponch Rivera: And I'm like, okay, we'll kind of monitor that.
- 59:58Mark McGrath: And we're also using some of the stuff from the classical definition of money that I learned in the austrian school of economics.
- 1:00:04Mark McGrath: It's no secret that inflationary paper a fiat currency is.
- 1:00:07Mark McGrath: I mean, the track record of that from from the age of empires to now, it's never been good, um.
- 1:00:13Mark McGrath: So the intent to actually have sound money, it's certainly adm, and that would be my pro and from my perspective of like why I think Bitcoin's cool.
- 1:00:23Mark McGrath: I also like the technology of blockchain because with, with, with the visible public ledger you know I'm not going to know it's you and you're not going to know it's me, but we can all see that the transaction was legitimate, because no one's going to be able to crack a code of solving complex math equations in a nanosecond, so we can have a trustless system, which is good because you know the business.
- 1:00:46Mark McGrath: There's so many things that have lived past their shelf life, that are on beyond life support.
- 1:00:52Mark McGrath: It's almost like they're corpses with sunglasses on some of these systems that Bitcoin would eradicate.
- 1:00:58Mark McGrath: I don't know what percent, but it has to be at least an 80, 20, like 80, 80, 80 percent of the of the uh things like processing and other things.
- 1:01:06Mark McGrath: Just you could be probably eliminated by the blockchain technology, which I also thought was cool.
- 1:01:10Mark McGrath: The only thing that I always kind of harbored is not a doubt, but like a concern was you know, know one EMP and the lights go out.
- 1:01:17Mark McGrath: Where's your Bitcoin, you know?
- 1:01:20Mark McGrath: So I never saw Bitcoin as superior to something like gold or silver, but I didn't see, I didn't think it would be exclusive, like you still shouldn't have.
- 1:01:29Ponch Rivera: I would never think you could have Bitcoin, the volatility and something that people argue is a store of value the day, the day we're recording this.
- 1:01:34Ponch Rivera: In the last three days, I think bitcoin is down almost 10.
- 1:01:37Ponch Rivera: Right, that's.
- 1:01:39Ponch Rivera: That's a pretty big move in three, three days.
- 1:01:41Ponch Rivera: The dollar didn't move 10 in the last three days.
- 1:01:43Ponch Rivera: I don't think so right now, but it's again.
- 1:01:48Ponch Rivera: My view is I shifted my view on it.
- 1:01:50Ponch Rivera: Uh, I don't like it to hold it.
- 1:01:52Ponch Rivera: Uh, I'll trade it.
- 1:01:54Mark McGrath: That's it I mean you can't use it everywhere, yet you know, like it's still.
- 1:01:57Mark McGrath: I mean you can there use it everywhere, yet you know, like it's still.
- 1:01:58Mark McGrath: I mean you can.
- 1:01:59Mark McGrath: There's etfs for it, there's, there's, there's all kinds of things with bitcoin.
- 1:02:02Mark McGrath: And back to the institutional imperative.
- 1:02:04Mark McGrath: Right, like so, people, institutions, were saying no, no, no publicly, but what were they doing behind everybody's back, you know?
- 1:02:12Mark McGrath: Or what were they doing in private?
- 1:02:13Mark McGrath: I mean, they're buying the crap out of bitcoin.
- 1:02:15Mark McGrath: Yeah, exactly, and that's like that.
- 1:02:19Mark McGrath: Those sorts of things like don't you think, like those are never going away, like there's going to be something that replaces bitcoin or something, some new thing most likely, and an institutional crap all over it, and then they'll, they'll, they'll do it.
- 1:02:31Mark McGrath: They'll say one thing publicly and do another thing privately.
- 1:02:34Mark McGrath: I think what will?
- 1:02:35Ray Micaletti: be interesting.
- 1:02:35Ray Micaletti: I've been bullish Bitcoin for the longest time and thought and would always talk to people.
- 1:02:40Mark McGrath: What's your appeal?
- 1:02:40Mark McGrath: Tell us that.
- 1:02:41Mark McGrath: Share with us your Cuéntanos today.
- 1:02:43Ray Micaletti: Cuéntanos so I started looking at it in 2015 and I kind of bought into the things that people say.
- 1:02:50Ray Micaletti: Where it's trustless thing.
- 1:02:51Ray Micaletti: It kind of circumvents the need for central banks and for intermediaries and what have you.
- 1:02:58Ray Micaletti: And I kind of felt like we had a system, especially in the mid-2000s, in 2010s, where incentives were just so misaligned.
- 1:03:06Ray Micaletti: I felt in this country we had the dot-com bubble burst and we didn't really properly take the necessary medicine.
- 1:03:14Ray Micaletti: We lowered interest rates to 1%, then we blew another bubble and then that bubble burst burst and we didn't really fix anything.
- 1:03:19Ray Micaletti: We just said, okay, you don't have to mark your garbage bonds to market and you could hold them for 40 years, and so it didn't really fix anything, but it kind of allowed the market to rally again and I don't feel like I think we just compounded all these monetary and fiscal mistakes.
- 1:03:35Ray Micaletti: And I felt like Bitcoin was a way around that.
- 1:03:38Ray Micaletti: And I would always talk to people that were even more into it than I was and I said can't governments just shut it down?
- 1:03:45Ray Micaletti: Can't this happen or what have you?
- 1:03:47Ray Micaletti: And they would always say, well, it's so decentralized, how are they going to shut it down?
- 1:03:50Ray Micaletti: How are they going to ban it?
- 1:03:52Ray Micaletti: If certain countries use it like El Salvador, I believe, is using it, it and you have human capital that flocks there because of it It'd be hard to shut it down.
- 1:04:00Ray Micaletti: They have satellites in space that can keep the network running in case we have power outages, things like that.
- 1:04:06Ray Micaletti: So that was all good, but now I'm starting to have some doubts again, and those doubts are like what if we do have a global bust?
- 1:04:14Ray Micaletti: Will Bitcoin have positive correlations to equity markets and risk on assets and will it crumble as well?
- 1:04:21Ray Micaletti: Or will the correlations break?
- 1:04:25Ray Micaletti: And if we have a situation where the Federal Reserve is flooding the market with liquidity, trying to stem the bust, will Bitcoin do well while everything else does bad?
- 1:04:37Ray Micaletti: So I'm sort of like in this region where I did not have doubts before, I now do have doubts.
- 1:04:44Ray Micaletti: Yeah.
- 1:04:45Mark McGrath: I thought, like I still think, that Bitcoin is still a piece of one piece of a much larger pie, and that was the technology of blockchain and the promises that it held of getting rid of a lot of archaic legacy systems, not even just around investing, but also things like medical records and other stuff, that it does have that digital permanence again, assuming the lights are on, um, that does have that digital permanent permanence.
- 1:05:11Mark McGrath: That's, uh, unable to um to be defrauded.
- 1:05:16Mark McGrath: One.
- 1:05:17Mark McGrath: Do you remember, uh, or is she still around Caitlin Long?
- 1:05:19Mark McGrath: I mean, she's a big Bitcoin blockchain advocate.
- 1:05:22Mark McGrath: I believe that she was from Morgan Stanley and I remember listening to a podcast of hers where she was talking about what's it?
- 1:05:31Mark McGrath: The Deposit Trust?
- 1:05:33Mark McGrath: What is it?
- 1:05:33Mark McGrath: Cc, dtcc, the Deposit Trust, clearing Corporation, I think Clearing Corporation, and that there was a case in delaware's chancery court.
- 1:05:42Mark McGrath: Of course, everything happens in delaware because that's where all the companies, or many of the companies are, are registered.
- 1:05:46Mark McGrath: I forget the company, but basically it had, you know, a million outstanding shares, but like 120 million legitimate claims to 100 million shares.
- 1:05:58Mark McGrath: So there's a disparity that it all come from brokerage houses holding stock for benefit of and name only, not in street name, and it added up that these additional shares that were never issued were still legitimate.
- 1:06:20Mark McGrath: Legitimate and and and and bitcoin not bitcoin, but blockchain technology as a public, anonymous, unhackable ledger, whatever would literally eradicate all that.
- 1:06:25Mark McGrath: Then you think all that apparatus, all the jobs, all the families, all the connections, all that other stuff would, would go away and that's probably why who knows why it's not there.
- 1:06:34Mark McGrath: But just to think of that, that there's so much legacy stuff that's so bulky and unnecessary that's out there, that these technologies that already exist are here to get rid of it that's crazy, absolutely.
- 1:06:46Ray Micaletti: We could certainly streamline things and you know, just for, like, house deeds and things of that nature to have on the blockchain, where yeah of wills.
- 1:07:15Mark McGrath: Why do we need these things?
- 1:07:16Mark McGrath: These things could all be digitally archived like that, and this entire pork barrel could go away tomorrow.
- 1:07:22Mark McGrath: Save the taxpayers a ton of money.
- 1:07:25Mark McGrath: What do we need these things for?
- 1:07:27Mark McGrath: You needed one, I guess, back in ancient England in the borough system or whatever but what do we need that for in modern urban planning or whatever Interesting stuff?
- 1:07:37Mark McGrath: Let's wind down and bring it home with this.
- 1:07:39Mark McGrath: So what are the types of things that you read outside of the market intelligence, things that you do to inform your investment decisions.
- 1:07:46Mark McGrath: But what are some of the who doesn't read?
- 1:07:48Mark McGrath: I used to read a lot of books, a lot of books.
- 1:08:02Ray Micaletti: A lot of it was mathematical stuff, a lot of it was sort of neuroscience and cognitive things of that nature.
- 1:08:09Ray Micaletti: But then, you know, basically since the great financial crisis, my reading is just confined to essays and blogs and things of that nature.
- 1:08:18Ray Micaletti: When I read a book, I feel like I should be studying the market, I should be coming up with new indicators, new strategies.
- 1:08:24Ray Micaletti: I can't relax and read a book and so I'll read like the first couple of chapters of a book, put it down and go back to you know sort of my thing where I'm working and looking at the market.
- 1:08:35Ray Micaletti: But you know, reading.
- 1:08:36Ray Micaletti: I like to read a lot about geopolitics, the state of the world, because that's very impactful on the markets.
- 1:08:43Ray Micaletti: So those are the types of areas that I'm interested in outside of the markets.
- 1:08:48Ray Micaletti: I like music, I like to practice piano, things of that nature, but when it comes to reading books, I've never liked fiction.
- 1:08:55Ray Micaletti: I'm always a nonfiction guy.
- 1:08:57Ray Micaletti: Join the club.
- 1:08:58Ray Micaletti: There's a few exceptions.
- 1:09:00Ray Micaletti: I look forward to the day where I can kind of dial down my intensity in the markets, where I can actually start reading.
- 1:09:07Ray Micaletti: I have a whole bunch of Kindle books that I bought and want to read that.
- 1:09:11Ray Micaletti: I hope to get to at some point.
- 1:09:13Mark McGrath: What about Ponch?
- 1:09:14Mark McGrath: What's your take on fiction?
- 1:09:17Ponch Rivera: I don't read it.
- 1:09:18Ponch Rivera: Yeah, my kids, do you look around my office?
- 1:09:21Ponch Rivera: I don't have a single one in there.
- 1:09:23Mark McGrath: I have one over there and it's Steven Pressfield, and historical fiction is about the only fiction that I can stomach, and I also say it is kind of fantasy.
- 1:09:32Mark McGrath: Yeah, I am random, I mean, again, I'm not a randroid, but I did like Fountainhead and Atlas Shrugged and I think that there's a lot of pertinent things that you can kind of see unfolding to an extent out there.
- 1:09:43Mark McGrath: But, like you, I also find too like you know, we were just talking about John Petraeus, about his book Conflict.
- 1:09:48Mark McGrath: I mean that's a nonfiction book that reads as exciting as any other, or even John Boyd's biography.
- 1:09:54Mark McGrath: You know that's an exciting book.
- 1:09:58Mark McGrath: My favorite I talked about it the other day was Chaos by Tom O'Neill.
- 1:10:01Mark McGrath: I mean that'll keep you up at night, but yeah, that's interesting, interesting stuff.
- 1:10:06Mark McGrath: And you're coming at us.
- 1:10:07Mark McGrath: Live from beautiful Puerto.
- 1:10:10Ray Micaletti: Rico.
- 1:10:10Mark McGrath: Yeah, so that's when we met.
- 1:10:12Mark McGrath: I was down visiting my ancestral homeland, ireland being one, puerto Rico the other.
- 1:10:17Mark McGrath: I met you in Puerto rico from our mutual friend.
- 1:10:19Mark McGrath: You saw my son catch his own fish and eat it that's right, that was a good time house things down in the south of our.
- 1:10:27Mark McGrath: Well, puerto rico is still our country.
- 1:10:29Ponch Rivera: It's on the other side of the gulf of america, but that's yes it is.
- 1:10:33Ray Micaletti: I saw I don't know if you saw this trump uh tweet the other day or it was actually the new y Times their cover.
- 1:10:40Ray Micaletti: It said you know we have the Monroe Doctrine.
- 1:10:43Mark McGrath: Yeah, it was New York Post, New York Post.
- 1:10:45Ray Micaletti: Yeah, it said the Donro Doctrine.
- 1:10:46Ray Micaletti: Yeah, we had Greenland and Canada and Panama and the Gulf of America.
- 1:10:53Mark McGrath: It's going to be a wild four years.
- 1:10:54Ray Micaletti: I mean, it hasn't even started and it's going to be a wild four years.
- 1:10:57Ray Micaletti: I mean it hasn't even started and it's going to be pretty exciting.
- 1:11:01Mark McGrath: I don't care what your political persuasion is.
- 1:11:03Mark McGrath: One of the most entertaining things to do in New York City is to get a New York Post.
- 1:11:07Mark McGrath: It never disappoints.
- 1:11:09Mark McGrath: You know a lot of people won't read it.
- 1:11:11Mark McGrath: They'll read the Daily News because you know the Daily News is left and the New York Post is right and the right is really for both of them.
- 1:11:17Mark McGrath: When they use words, you know like the sicko, like the sicko was dragged off the subway.
- 1:11:25Mark McGrath: You know like they, like some of the language is just like.
- 1:11:27Mark McGrath: It's so entertaining and interesting.
- 1:11:27Ray Micaletti: It's very much down to earth.
- 1:11:28Ray Micaletti: It's very much related.
- 1:11:29Ray Micaletti: It's like what we would say to each other if we're talking about someone who you know did XYZ on the subway.
- 1:11:34Mark McGrath: So, yeah, I mean, God forbid you're playing for a New York team and you're having a slump because they absolutely just eviscerate people.
- 1:11:42Mark McGrath: They light them on fire.
- 1:11:45Ray Micaletti: It's entertaining just for that, you know.
- 1:11:47Ray Micaletti: What's entertaining is that every year the New York media thinks that the New York sports teams have this birthright to do well Every year.
- 1:11:52Ray Micaletti: And when they don't do well, then they lambaste them.
- 1:11:55Ray Micaletti: But everyone from the outside is like why did you think they were going to do well?
- 1:11:59Ray Micaletti: And they lambaste them.
- 1:12:00Mark McGrath: But everyone from the outside is like why did you think they were going to do well?
- 1:12:02Ray Micaletti: They had no business doing well because they have a bad team.
- 1:12:04Ray Micaletti: The Jets have a bad team.
- 1:12:05Ray Micaletti: The Giants have a bad team.
- 1:12:07Ray Micaletti: There was no variety of hope for either of them.
- 1:12:09Ray Micaletti: Yet whenever they don't perform, the media comes down on them as though they had these unlofty, unrealistic expectations.
- 1:12:15Ray Micaletti: But that was when I was in school in New Jersey in the 90s.
- 1:12:20Ray Micaletti: I noticed that it's like you know the Jets they had, I think, rich Coat tight at the time.
- 1:12:25Ray Micaletti: They were like 1-15 every year, but every year the New York media acted like they were going to go to the Super Bowl until like week eight, and then they realized it wasn't happening.
- 1:12:34Ray Micaletti: And then you know it's crazy.
- 1:12:37Mark McGrath: It's ridiculous, especially in baseball, when the Yankees captain, aaron Judge, doesn't perform.
- 1:12:43Mark McGrath: I mean, you pick your poison.
- 1:12:45Mark McGrath: New York Post, daily News, whatever, it is absolute entertainment and we'll get one and we'll be at a coffee shop and we'll just be like, okay, who can find like the best article with like the most just abrasive, nasty language?
- 1:12:58Mark McGrath: It's so good.
- 1:13:00Mark McGrath: But but anyway, I don't think anything exists in finance to your point.
- 1:13:03Mark McGrath: You have to go to blogs or essays to find things.
- 1:13:05Mark McGrath: I don't think there's like.
- 1:13:07Mark McGrath: There's like a tabloid barons that, like you know, the bum was trading, that you know, like the insider trading bum, you know like none of that, none of that type of stuff that would, that would beg for a interesting business model.
- 1:13:19Ponch Rivera: Yeah, certainly would that sounds like unusual whales when they pick up on what's going on in walser.
- 1:13:24Ponch Rivera: Uh, yes, dc.
- 1:13:25Mark McGrath: Yeah, that's what I'm saying.
- 1:13:26Mark McGrath: Like there's those things that exist but there's not like a, like a, like a tabloid sheet that you could pick up with like a sensational headline.
- 1:13:35Mark McGrath: You know that says something I don't know.
- 1:13:38Mark McGrath: Again, that's the value of Twitter, I guess.
- 1:13:40Mark McGrath: Or sorry, x, you know that's the value of those things.
- 1:13:42Mark McGrath: But anyway, all right, ray, tell us the website, bring us home here.
- 1:13:46Mark McGrath: Where should we look to get more information and how do we keep in touch and follow your work at your company?
- 1:13:53Ray Micaletti: Sure, really simple.
- 1:13:54Ray Micaletti: Our website is relativesentimentcom.
- 1:13:56Ray Micaletti: One word.
- 1:13:56Ray Micaletti: You could follow me on Twitter.
- 1:13:58Ray Micaletti: It's at relsententech R-E-L-S-E-N-T-E -C.
- 1:14:02Ray Micaletti: That's basically the bulk of where I post information.
- 1:14:05Ray Micaletti: I have a free weekly newsletter.
- 1:14:07Ray Micaletti: If you're interested in what smart money is doing where you should start looking to possibly add exposure or reduce exposure, feel free to sign up at relativesentimentcom.
- 1:14:15Ray Micaletti: It comes out every Monday morning Tell you what their smart money is doing in equities bonds, gold, silver commodities, et cetera.
- 1:14:23Mark McGrath: I'm a subscriber and I love it.
- 1:14:25Mark McGrath: It goes in the inbox, as Ray says, once a week, I guess.
- 1:14:30Mark McGrath: I guess Ponch.
- 1:14:30Mark McGrath: I was just talking about Sean Ring and his rude awakening That'll.
- 1:14:34Mark McGrath: That gives us some pretty colorful language in the markets and things like that.
- 1:14:37Mark McGrath: But yeah, I recommend RST.
- 1:14:40Mark McGrath: It's a really good read and it's a great perspective to look at markets.
- 1:14:44Mark McGrath: So, ray, thanks for coming and helping us reorient around the way we look at capital markets through the lens of relative sentiment, and we'll see you again soon.
- 1:14:54Ray Micaletti: Thank you very much, guys.
- 1:14:55Ray Micaletti: I had a pleasure and I'll speak with you guys soon.