Latest / Bad Decisions Podcast / #75 How AI Is Transforming Filmmaking & VFX with Nikola Todorovic
Transcript
- 0:00Hi. And I directed that demo and we
- 0:01launched it. I thought it was trash.
- 0:03I thought our product is shit. I was like nobody's going to
- 0:05want to use this. We had about 500,000 people on
- 0:08the wait list and we're like, we can't let everybody in.
- 0:10One thing in particular that stood out to me, and it was a
- 0:13phrase that you used which was permissionless storytelling.
- 0:16Why is permissionless storytelling so important to
- 0:19you? I was born in Bosnia, doing
- 0:21Yugoslavia at the time, and I was obsessed with storytelling
- 0:23and filmmaking. You know, I think film was kind
- 0:25of escaped to me during that period as a teenager.
- 0:28You need something to escape when you're in a certain
- 0:30environment that you don't completely understand.
- 0:31That's why I like storytelling so much.
- 0:33It's like a very personal, private conversation, almost
- 0:36like a therapy. How did the first idea of Wonder
- 0:38Studio and Mother Dynamics came into your head?
- 0:40We had Spielberg on board and Russo Brothers started.
- 0:43We were like, all right, this is great.
- 0:44This is our mission. Storytelling is too expensive.
- 0:46Not everybody can do it. There's a lot of talented people
- 0:48out there that have good stories to tell.
- 0:50How do we make them easier to tell stories?
- 0:52If it wasn't for us saying yes to jobs that we didn't know how
- 0:55to do, but we were curious enough to figure out, we
- 0:58wouldn't be fucking here. For someone who's in interested
- 1:00in filmmaking, what kind of material do you have to
- 1:03recommend to them? Really.
- 1:04Spielberg said that if you want to be a good director, you
- 1:06should like. Whoa, whoa, whoa.
- 1:10Come on, man. Nicola, welcome to the Bad
- 1:14Decisions podcast. Thank you for having me guys and
- 1:18good to see you. Of course, man, it's a pleasure
- 1:20having you. We have met a long time ago.
- 1:23Actually, this is not the first time we're speaking.
- 1:26We met once digitally. First time being recorded, so we
- 1:30got to be careful. Well, you know.
- 1:33Technically for us, people already know more about us on
- 1:36this podcast. And right, I have to be careful.
- 1:39Yes, so, so just saying, man, I think, I think we're safe,
- 1:42right? Yeah, I hope so.
- 1:45But this is like the first time you're right recording a podcast
- 1:49professionally, like a professional setting.
- 1:51But we met one time digitally, and I'll let Fawad explain that.
- 1:55Story Oh my God, that was that was such a accident.
- 1:58So I think it was Wonder Dynamic.
- 2:00It was released just early beta and we were trying to make a
- 2:04short film at that time. And then we were using a trial
- 2:08mode on Wonder Studio. And then we went out of credit.
- 2:11So I went to the Discord server. I started talking to people on
- 2:14the Discord and then I was talking to this mod.
- 2:17I thought it was a mod in the beginning his name was Nicola.
- 2:20I went and started looked him up and then I realized he's the Co
- 2:23founder of the company. And then gave.
- 2:26Us he gave us free credit so he could we could finish our short
- 2:29film that's. Amazing.
- 2:32Yeah. That was during our, when we
- 2:33first launched, we did the closed beta and we started that
- 2:36discord just kind of just, you know, see, oh man, it was such
- 2:40an early day of generative AI that it was even at that point
- 2:44it was even hard to get GPUs like it was so it was so new.
- 2:47So that's why we're like, all right, we had about 500,000
- 2:49people on the wait list and we're like, we can't let
- 2:51everybody wait. Wait, did.
- 2:53You say, did you say 500,000? Yeah, we get half a million
- 2:57people on the wait list. This was March 2023 and we were,
- 3:01you know, we're a start up and there's quite a bit of
- 3:03processing power in the background.
- 3:04So we're like, if you let everybody in, we're going to go
- 3:06bankrupt. A.
- 3:07Little bit Yeah. Holy.
- 3:10Shit, so I was on Discord because I was, I was on Discord.
- 3:12I'm like, let's start, let's do it like couple months of just
- 3:15letting people in just to see how we scale this.
- 3:19You know how we can optimize it because we didn't really
- 3:21optimize the, you know, the back end of it for that scale.
- 3:25And so yeah, that's what I saw you guys.
- 3:27And and also funny thing, we have multiple Nicolas in my
- 3:30team. Oh yeah.
- 3:32Yeah, yeah, because there's another Nicola that was also on
- 3:34this court. So it was always, it was funny.
- 3:37But that's insane. I mean, what we really loved at
- 3:39that moment is how involved you guys were as the team and the
- 3:43guys who founded the company with the actual product.
- 3:46And it showed the amount of care and love you guys have for what
- 3:49you're building. And that's when me and father
- 3:51looked at it. She was like holy shit, we're
- 3:52actually talking the the founder, the Co founder of this
- 3:54company and we ended up making our short.
- 3:57You saying that? Yeah.
- 3:58No, absolutely man. And you know, we ended up making
- 4:00a very quick film for YouTube, which people love because at the
- 4:03time when you guys launch, I remember how insane what you
- 4:06guys had built was and we couldn't wait to get our.
- 4:08Hands I remember the trailer, the trailer when it dropped, it
- 4:11was really, really crazy. Yeah, it was.
- 4:13It was. It had a.
- 4:14Lot of people thought that we faked it.
- 4:16Yeah. I think it's because we just,
- 4:18we're in stealth mode for so long.
- 4:20We started early with it. You know, when we started, there
- 4:23was no term Gen. AI and we really spent 3-4 years
- 4:26building without wanting to release until we think it's
- 4:29ready. And, and that's why when we
- 4:32launch people like no way this is real.
- 4:35So we started letting people in. They're like, OK, this is
- 4:37actually real. You know, it was one of those
- 4:39funny times. But I appreciate you saying that
- 4:41because I think for me, that period was really important to
- 4:45be super involved because you can have certain ideas about
- 4:49your product you're building, but until you really see people
- 4:51use it and talk to them and you're not going to get the
- 4:54feedback online in comments. You're going to get best
- 4:56feedback when you actually communicate with people
- 4:57one-on-one and they're going to honestly tell you, oh, I hate
- 5:00this, but this is great or you need or we need this, etcetera.
- 5:03So we really used that period to kind of learn and it was super
- 5:06helpful talking to you guys that early on.
- 5:08It's like, OK, I get it, every artist is different.
- 5:11I'm an artist myself, but I'm going to think my pipeline error
- 5:14and you know, approaches some things going to be different
- 5:17than than most people or someone else.
- 5:19Appreciate that. And we will get into the very
- 5:23detail of the entire launch and everything.
- 5:25I, I think it's quite fascinating, but I'm going to go
- 5:28back to why I even started talking about this.
- 5:31I mentioned that we met first digitally and then we met
- 5:34physically in person at SIGRAF Vancouver just about a couple of
- 5:38weeks or maybe just a month or two months ago.
- 5:41And we were at the Autodesk event where you and Ty were on
- 5:45the panel and you guys were both speaking.
- 5:47And there's one thing in particular that stood out to me
- 5:51and stuck with me until this day that we have discussions about.
- 5:53And it was a phrase that you used which was permissionless
- 5:57storytelling. And for me, what that means is
- 6:02the ability for anyone to tell any story without the friction
- 6:06of other people's opinions, without the approval of other
- 6:09people, without the friction of a budget or a crew.
- 6:13It's your ability to just go and tell the freaking story that is
- 6:16in your mind. Why is permissionless
- 6:20storytelling so important to you?
- 6:23To me personally, I, I, I was always, I mean, first of all, I
- 6:28was, I was born in Bosnia. The English Slavia at the time
- 6:30lived in Croatia. You know, we as a, as a kid, we
- 6:34refugeed to Croatia and the refugees to Serbia.
- 6:38And I was obsessed with storytelling and film making.
- 6:40You know, I think film was kind of escaped to me during that
- 6:42period. Hard in general, say film and
- 6:44music, you know, as a teenager, you need something to escape
- 6:48when you're in a certain environment that you don't
- 6:49completely understand. But it's a difficult one, right?
- 6:52That's why I like storytelling so much.
- 6:54It really it's like a it's like a very personal, you know,
- 6:58private conversation, almost like a therapy, right.
- 7:01But I was always so frustrated of the dream of even as a kid
- 7:05when I was telling people, you know what, I'm going to move my
- 7:07one day to Hollywood and I'm going to work in film industry.
- 7:09And it's like, you know, you're an award turn kite.
- 7:11Yeah. Good luck with that.
- 7:14Yeah, I was like, good luck. Yeah, good luck.
- 7:16I remember my high school, you know, I was trying to get to to
- 7:22US and obviously it was very hard to afford.
- 7:24My family couldn't really afford to send me.
- 7:27But but I remember last day of high school, professors were
- 7:29asking like, oh, what university are going to?
- 7:32And I wasn't even close to, you know, maybe figuring this out or
- 7:35getting to school in the US. And I was saying I was, you
- 7:37know, kind of depressed because all my friends had like, you
- 7:40know, picked universities, they, they could go to, etcetera.
- 7:42And I remember I, I was just like, no, I'm just gonna say it
- 7:45out loud. You know, it's, it's gonna
- 7:46become true because I believe this is gonna happen.
- 7:48And I said it loud and literally like professors start laughing
- 7:50because like, you know, how you gonna do that?
- 7:53So Long story short, it took me so long to 1st end in the US and
- 7:57then break into the effects industry.
- 7:59And you know, I directed 2 short films when I first got here that
- 8:03that had some success. And yeah, I saw early on how,
- 8:06how gate cab this industry is. And then you realize it's not
- 8:10gate cab because there's someone like at the door, you know,
- 8:13saying you can't come in. It was gate cab because the
- 8:15economics behind it are are are are are so hard, right?
- 8:18So challenging. You know, like if you if you
- 8:21want to make a movie and get your money back.
- 8:23Just such a such. Unpredictable market, right?
- 8:25It's very different than tech space, for instance.
- 8:27That's why, you know, investments in the in, in, in
- 8:30film are, are more difficult to find in, in a tech space.
- 8:35And it really comes behind, you know, the cost of making this
- 8:38film. That's why it's so hard and it's
- 8:39populated, you know, in certain parts of the world, right?
- 8:42You have to, if you wanna make a film, you have to also be not
- 8:45just a good artist, but you have to be a good salesperson cuz you
- 8:47gotta go meet that producer page, the product, etcetera.
- 8:50And most artists I know are not really great salesperson.
- 8:52They're just brilliant artists, right?
- 8:56So that's why I think this democratization of of
- 8:58storytelling, it's not a novel idea, right?
- 9:00Some of the great film makers throughout the history have been
- 9:03speaking about it. It's just that tech hasn't been
- 9:05there yet. And I think this is the first
- 9:08time we're seeing with the AI movement that really is coming
- 9:11down to, you know, you can make what you want and you can
- 9:15compete. And that's one side of it.
- 9:17So it was, you know, it was very personal for me.
- 9:20And the other side of it is I spent a lot of time working in
- 9:23indie films and indie films definitely on the VFX side.
- 9:26You stay away. You always sacrifice your vision
- 9:29either when you're writing or when you're in production trying
- 9:31to go in post production. You have to avoid so many
- 9:34creative choices because you're like you can't afford it, you
- 9:37know? So I mean, the edit films back
- 9:38in the day, you could never even think about doing green screen
- 9:41or doing something that needs roto, you know, because you
- 9:44can't, you know, it's like $510,000,000 film, you know,
- 9:48obviously now it's changed, but about 10 years ago, very
- 9:52different. So I guess, yeah, that, that,
- 9:54that to me, I, I'm a big believer storytelling should not
- 9:57be tied to socioeconomic status or, you know, or location where
- 10:02you're live or you're born. I think the best story should
- 10:05just be the best stories and reach the masses, right?
- 10:08And unfortunately the reality is not that right?
- 10:12So a lot of a lot of great storytellers never, never
- 10:16breakthrough that first stage, which is really, really hard.
- 10:19And I think that's very sad because we have brilliant
- 10:22artists and because of this lack of economics or lack of
- 10:25connection, lack of network or the geographical location, they
- 10:29are not able to tell their stories.
- 10:31A lot of people think that if I want to tell a good story, I
- 10:33should go to USA. Lot of people think that if I
- 10:35want to tell a good story, I need a crew.
- 10:38That was true probably 10 years ago.
- 10:40But now with all these tools that we have, we can see that,
- 10:43you know, the flow animation was made with a very small team
- 10:47within Blender and we have other examples that are really, really
- 10:51coming out. But I want to go back.
- 10:52When you were making your own short films and you saw this
- 10:56barriers, how did the first idea of Wonder Studio and Modern
- 10:59Dynamics came into your head? It was really sort of an
- 11:06accident. Well, first how it happened.
- 11:08So Thai Sheridan was my Co founder.
- 11:10Thai and I met on the film set a long time ago, about 2013,
- 11:13became really close friends, became kind of best buddies and
- 11:17we started writing together. And then we're kind of really
- 11:23suckers for these stories that are set in near future small
- 11:28town rural America, but with the new technology.
- 11:31So we were writing something about that with with new kind of
- 11:34robotics, but set in, you know, near future in a small town
- 11:38middle America and and we started writing it.
- 11:42And as we were writing, we realized, OK, this is $100
- 11:44million. There's yeah, there's no way
- 11:47we'll be able for our first feature that we want to make.
- 11:50No way. We'll get a budget for it.
- 11:52And obviously you're Ty's an established actor and producer,
- 11:55but even at his level, it's like getting $100 million.
- 11:57Like you could have a handful of directors that can do that,
- 12:00right? Just prior to that, I was
- 12:05working on an ad and we were doing, we were doing kind of
- 12:09early days of 360 in VR video. We were stitching certain
- 12:13things. And then I started looking into
- 12:15it and I called Ty and I was like, hey, we should do
- 12:18something with it. This is this new tech, we should
- 12:20look into it. So we made this experience where
- 12:22you can switch from 2D stream into 360 and into 3D.
- 12:27And then we partnered with this other startup where we were
- 12:31building experience. This is very early, this is
- 12:32about 2017. You watch a show, think of a
- 12:35culture and drama and you have, you know, obviously live actor,
- 12:39but then the switch happens without you knowing in a digital
- 12:41version of that actor that is actually a conversational piece.
- 12:45So you can ask the question and it would answer and would branch
- 12:48the narrative. This is before ChatGPT at all.
- 12:51This is before ChatGPT, Yeah. And obviously, cognitive AI just
- 12:56wasn't there yet, right? There's no ChatGPT.
- 12:58So the cognitive, the LLMS were so early, you know, they
- 13:01started, we're working it and just kind of building their own.
- 13:04And you know, we had that piece of switchability and it was an
- 13:07insane demo and we showed it. Sometimes we showed people and
- 13:11they were just in disbelief. Some people, you could see the
- 13:13fear in their eyes. They're like, I don't like this,
- 13:15you know, cuz it was the face, not just the voice, it was the
- 13:19face, right, That you didn't know.
- 13:20But as we were doing that, we both time and I realized this is
- 13:25cool, but we're not really that interested in interactive
- 13:28content. We're more interested in
- 13:29learning a narrative, but we used AI to do this solution and
- 13:34for generating scene, etc. That's when we said, OK, let's
- 13:37pivot, let's drop everything. We'll keep this tech.
- 13:39It's good. We still own patents on it.
- 13:41But let's look, how do we use AI to tell this film that we're
- 13:45writing? And that's when we started
- 13:46looking deeper into kind of that technology around it and
- 13:50computer vision and obviously generative AI, early days of it
- 13:53and all of that. So I'd say like one of some of
- 13:56these things kind of happen as you leap into things without,
- 13:59you know, it's kind of without a fear.
- 14:01And then you're like, you know, you got to be, you got to be
- 14:03open to pivoting. And we were very lucky as a
- 14:05startup. We were lean, we were running
- 14:07lean. So we're not, you know, raising
- 14:09hundreds of millions of dollars that we're not allowed to pivot.
- 14:12We were lean. So we're like, all right, if we
- 14:14didn't do this or this or this, we wouldn't get this idea.
- 14:17And so that's how I started. How big was the team at the
- 14:20start? Man, at the beginning, maybe it
- 14:24was like 4 or five of us when we did that pivot, Yeah, when we
- 14:28did that pivot, probably around 10, I'd say.
- 14:30And self funded or you started raising?
- 14:34That when we pivoted, when we did a pool pivot, we already had
- 14:38a seed round. But before that we did friends
- 14:41and family and self funded. Yeah, yeah.
- 14:43But we didn't raise much at the beginning.
- 14:46And then we did our seed round, which was led by Founders Fraud,
- 14:51Mac Ventures, Samsung and few others.
- 14:55And we were so fortunate with our investors, I gotta say.
- 14:59They give us complete freedom. We were very, very careful.
- 15:02Yeah, We didn't want to take the money just for the sake of it,
- 15:05and we didn't want to blow up a valuation just for the sake of
- 15:08it. That's what I do see with a lot
- 15:09of start-ups. You get in this mindset of
- 15:12competition of what your valuation is.
- 15:14Yeah. And your customer doesn't care.
- 15:15They don't know what seed or serious A or serious B is or
- 15:18what your valuation is, right? They're just scared, like, is
- 15:21this product good enough? Yeah.
- 15:22And so it's kind of a Silicon Valley trap where these founders
- 15:26are just competing, you know, who's going to have a higher
- 15:28valuation, but then the market just always lags behind it.
- 15:31It's a different, it's a different philosophy than what
- 15:34we had, you know? Learning 3D VFX and animation
- 15:37should not take you years. That's exactly why we designed
- 15:41the Ultimate Unreal Engine program, which is our best work
- 15:44yet. This is our masterpiece, which
- 15:46is going to take you step by step from beginner to pro in
- 15:49Unreal Engine in just 14 days. And by the end of it, we'll get
- 15:53to create a beautiful cinematic short film just like this.
- 15:57We'll take you step by step through pre production, planning
- 16:00out your scenes to setting up your environments using
- 16:03photorealistic assets really quickly.
- 16:06We. Will teach you modelling,
- 16:08texturing and animation. We'll even teach you how to use
- 16:10meta humans to create beautiful digital characters that look
- 16:14real. We will teach you AI workflows
- 16:17to speed up your process. We'll teach you how to set up
- 16:19your lights so that your scenes look cinematic.
- 16:22We'll teach you how to use cameras inside Unreal Engine to
- 16:24set up beautiful shots. Animate the camera not just
- 16:28digitally, but using virtual production techniques like using
- 16:32your phone to move the camera in the scene, which is super.
- 16:35Fun. We will teach you motion design
- 16:37tools so you can create an amazing title sequence at the
- 16:40end. We'll teach you simulations as
- 16:41well, like cloth destruction and particles.
- 16:45And you learn all of this in 14 days.
- 16:47And for those of you who are listening to this podcast, we
- 16:50have a very special price. Use the code podcast in the link
- 16:55below this video and you will get 3, $300 off from our
- 16:59Ultimate Unreal Engine program. And to make it a no brainer for
- 17:02you, if you hate the course and you hate our teaching style,
- 17:06we'll give you our money back because we've never had a single
- 17:09person say that before. You can even go to our Discord
- 17:11community and check with our members what they think about
- 17:14the course. And by the way, Speaking of the
- 17:16Discord community, we have 24/7 support for all of our students,
- 17:21which means if you ever have any issues while learning, you can
- 17:24always contact us. We'll respond.
- 17:27Get it solve. Even if the problem persists,
- 17:30you can send us your Unreal Engine files and we will fix it
- 17:33for you. Send it back to your Never
- 17:35stuck. And the reason why we're so
- 17:36proud of this 24/7 support is because most courses don't
- 17:40actually offer that. So if you're learning and you
- 17:42get stuck, it's over and you're lost so farad.
- 17:47Click on the link below this video and use the code podcast.
- 17:51PODCAST, in case you didn't know.
- 17:54Let's get back in what is now Autodesk Flow Studio is, of
- 18:00course a tool that ourselves and many other artists are using,
- 18:04and it has so many features that can be very helpful if you're
- 18:07trying to tell stories. But I imagine in its early days
- 18:10it wasn't this, right? I'm sure you've faced thousands
- 18:14of challenges along the way. Lots of days where you thought
- 18:16this shit's not going to work and there's no way this is going
- 18:19to actually happen. I want to go to one of those
- 18:21days, probably the worst one that you can remember, and I
- 18:26want to see what what lessons you've learned from that day.
- 18:30Yeah, I'd say this one of the biggest lesson before I go to a
- 18:35specific day, one of the biggest lesson we learned is hiring is
- 18:39crucial. And I always say in a new
- 18:42technologies, hire people not that tell you they know all
- 18:47this, hire people that are curious and almost like I'm
- 18:51almost kind of not aware of how difficult something is because
- 18:54they don't know. What they're getting into, I
- 18:57love that. Song.
- 18:58Yeah, really, 100 percent, 100%. And I'll tell you, Alexander
- 19:02Reich, who was our CTO, who, who, you know, who's always
- 19:05still with us, but now we've got a choir.
- 19:06But he was CTO during Wonder Dynamics days.
- 19:10You know, he was a young kid out of college, So smart, brilliant.
- 19:14And me and him, when we look back, we're like, we had no
- 19:16idea. It's good if we do.
- 19:18If we did, if we did, we probably wouldn't start.
- 19:20That's the problem. Like you start calculating too
- 19:22much in advanced and then you get kind of, you know, frozen
- 19:27and or no, this is so difficult, nobody can solve it.
- 19:30So I say those are just, we had a lot of those specific days.
- 19:35That's why we, we built for so long because we would hit
- 19:38certain milestones. And the difficulty of this is
- 19:40that it's extremely visual, the results, right?
- 19:44So for instance, here I'll give you an example.
- 19:47We didn't want to just launch with the motion capture
- 19:49solution. We wanted to have that live
- 19:51action end to end, you know, where I provide you, you know,
- 19:54camera track and lighting and all of this.
- 19:56But then I also composed that in a live action shot, right?
- 20:00But as we were doing on our motion capture solution.
- 20:04We realized most of the stuff we were doing really breaks when
- 20:09you try to do like really complicated camera moves.
- 20:11So even like figuring out how do I do this is, you know, 2018
- 20:15nineteen. If I do a wide shot, yeah, that
- 20:17works. But if I do wide and close up
- 20:19and I spin around the character, etcetera.
- 20:21I remember first time we did that, it looked like crap.
- 20:23The character would like raise the arm and float in the screen
- 20:26and it was it was really difficult to solve.
- 20:30And then there's, you know, there's days where you kind of
- 20:34go three steps forward or one step forward in six months and
- 20:38then you go backwards 4 steps cuz you hit a roadblock in a
- 20:41day. And then you just like pure
- 20:43depression and you have to fight it.
- 20:45I personally, I was very interested in this subject even
- 20:49before I started the company. And we were trying to do this
- 20:53documentary with a good friend of mine who is number 2 tennis
- 20:57player in the world, Tommy Haas. And we, I was, I was following
- 21:01Tommy and filming him a little bit towards the end of his
- 21:03career with the idea of like, hey, what makes someone
- 21:05successful? Is it nature or nurture?
- 21:07How much is environment and how much is just talent, right?
- 21:10Interesting. And I started reading so much
- 21:13about it. And one thing I learned is most
- 21:15people when they tell you when they succeeded, they're very
- 21:18nostalgic. So they tell you about this
- 21:20perfect scenario of AI just worked so hard and I believed in
- 21:24myself and you know, I just kept fighting through, which is all
- 21:27true. But they don't tell you about
- 21:28those days where they're like so depressed, they think they're
- 21:30not worth it. You can't do it.
- 21:32It's, you know, it's too hard, I should create, etcetera.
- 21:35So when I did this kind of research, I went and tried
- 21:38reading and finding people that were like talking about those
- 21:41days. And what I learned is there's so
- 21:44much more of those days. It's just there's this quote, if
- 21:48you ever you ever watch this kind of fake commencement
- 21:52speech, always wear sunscreen. I don't know if you ever seen
- 21:54that on YouTube. I haven't.
- 21:55If not, I will. I will tell your listener to
- 21:57look it up. It's called always wear
- 21:58sunscreen. And there's a quote from there
- 22:01that goes like, you know, be careful on on whose advice you
- 22:05take, because advice is kind of form of nostalgia.
- 22:08It's like taking a painting out of trash and taking, peeling off
- 22:12the bad parts, the trash like banana and something and what it
- 22:15is and then presenting that painting.
- 22:16Look how great I am, right, But that's, that's you know, that's
- 22:19why I think you know, for me, it was so important.
- 22:22I knew that I can't being from Eastern Eastern Europe, I knew I
- 22:27tend to be negative and I'm a perfectionist.
- 22:28So I tend to like be extremely hard on myself.
- 22:31So I surround myself with people that balance that either people
- 22:34that work with me or mentors that are extremely positive.
- 22:37So when I drop and I can recognize that I dropped with
- 22:40that kind of hope and, you know, mentality of like, you can do
- 22:42it. I'll go see my mentor.
- 22:44His name is Bob Schwab. And you know, we do one dinner
- 22:47and I like leave the dinner and I'm like.
- 22:48OK, I'm good. Back in the dinner, Yeah.
- 22:51Right. I can do this.
- 22:52Yeah, exactly. Dude, first of all, there's a
- 22:55there's a lot of things that I have to decode and I love them.
- 22:58First of all, we talk. No, no, no, no, you asked me.
- 23:01What? It's a good thing.
- 23:02It's a great. Thing.
- 23:02It's a great thing. The reason why I'm saying I want
- 23:05to decode it is because there's so much interesting things.
- 23:07Not that it's a bad thing. First things 1st, we always talk
- 23:11about what you said. You said it so beautifully.
- 23:14We always say this when you're looking at people for advice,
- 23:17especially on YouTube, all these people you look up to be very
- 23:20careful because they themselves do not remember all of the
- 23:23things, right. They sometimes forget half of
- 23:26the things that they went through.
- 23:27You're right, they do talk about the hard work and the pain, but
- 23:30then the the specific feeling that they might have had on
- 23:33specific days that was pushing them to almost give up.
- 23:37That stuff is not being talked about enough and you can never
- 23:40feel that through a YouTube video 100.
- 23:41Percent and even when you asked me that question, I was like, oh
- 23:44man, let me remember. And it's so hard to remember.
- 23:46I think sometimes you also to survive in this space, whether
- 23:50it's a startup or a film industry, you kind of have to
- 23:52force yourself to not linger in those moments.
- 23:57You know, it's like I'm a tennis player, right?
- 23:58I grew up playing tennis. And if you listen like best
- 24:00tennis players at work, like Djokovic or Federer, they talk
- 24:02about why they're so mentally strong.
- 24:05They don't stay in that past moment too long.
- 24:07They kind of forget about it really quick.
- 24:09So I think it's subconscious. You also do that as a founder or
- 24:12as an artist. You're like, I gotta forget.
- 24:14But I agree with you. I'll give you an example.
- 24:16When we launched our close, when we launched the demo, OK, You
- 24:20say demo is great. Yeah, Ty and I directed that
- 24:22demo. And when we finished it, when we
- 24:25launched it, I thought it was trash.
- 24:27I thought our product, I thought our product is shit.
- 24:30I thought like everything's terrible.
- 24:32I was like, nobody's going to want to use this.
- 24:34We wasted four years of our lives.
- 24:36You know bro, it's so similar. So similar sometimes.
- 24:42I'll tell you a very small example.
- 24:44There is a video that you're about to post.
- 24:46Pharos looks at the video and said, What is this garbage that
- 24:49we're going to post? It's not going to work.
- 24:51Don't even show it to me. I don't want to see it.
- 24:53You post it yourself. And funny enough, we post that
- 24:56video. That's the best performing video
- 24:58we ever. Had I know, man, it's so funny.
- 25:00It's. Crazy.
- 25:01It's all about pushing and not giving up and just going.
- 25:06I think that one matters most. Yep, I agree.
- 25:09I They say most people quit when they're the closest to some sort
- 25:13of success. Because you don't see it.
- 25:15Yeah. There's an image of that.
- 25:16This is what I learned. Yeah, there is an image of.
- 25:18This is what I learned. I'm sorry, the delay, it's guys
- 25:21just saying we're not trying to talk over each other.
- 25:23There's delay on life. Please go ahead.
- 25:24I will remember the image. People, it's Nicola's fault.
- 25:29We, we, we established that. But I was tired.
- 25:34I always my Co founder. We kind of realized, you know,
- 25:38when it's the hardest and you have this feeling that you
- 25:40almost want to quit, it's someone testing you.
- 25:44Someone's like testing you. Like, I'll give it to you.
- 25:47But like, let's see, let's see if you're gonna push through
- 25:49this. You know, it's a kind of mindset
- 25:51that both time and I said, all right, this is good.
- 25:53Like it's really hard. We're even thinking about
- 25:56quitting, but there's a reason for it, right?
- 25:59And honestly, it happened every single time.
- 26:02Like we fought it through. We're like, all right, give it
- 26:04two more weeks, man. Give it two more weeks.
- 26:05Something, something's up. We don't know what it is.
- 26:07We don't understand why we're going through this.
- 26:09But. And every time we did, we give
- 26:10it two more weeks and we push two more weeks.
- 26:12Like some, you know, some opportunity showed up or some
- 26:16success happened and you're like, all right, OK, Let's not
- 26:20ignore this feeling before, yeah.
- 26:21Do you even get better at that or no?
- 26:23It's a constant battle. I think you get better at it the
- 26:26more you do it, for sure. I think you just got to remember
- 26:30that those feelings pass. Yeah, it's like it's a
- 26:33perspective thing. You got to zoom out and kind of
- 26:35zoom, you know, get that bird's eye view and be like, why, what,
- 26:38why am I really in this position or why am I feeling like this?
- 26:42And and they remind just to me personally, I know that those
- 26:45feelings last couple of days and I just need to remind myself
- 26:48like, all right, I give it two days because you just know,
- 26:50you're, you know, maybe you're emotional.
- 26:51Maybe you're just, like, not seeing the perspective you need
- 26:53to see, you know, and you push for a couple more days and then
- 26:57and you wake up that morning and you're like, why did I even
- 26:59like, why did I even allow myself to think like this?
- 27:01It's insane. Yeah, right.
- 27:04Dude, I. It's so true.
- 27:06Fucking. Belatable therapy session for us
- 27:09right now. We're supposed to talk about.
- 27:13Trust me, people want to hear about this stuff more because
- 27:16every time we have deep conversations like this, you
- 27:18just have to go and read the comments after we post this,
- 27:21you'll see yourself how many people relate to this because
- 27:24let's be honest, no matter if you're Elon Musk or someone I'm
- 27:28not trying to be, let's say I'm I don't want to name anyone Elon
- 27:32Musk and someone at the bottom all the way down, right?
- 27:36We're all humans at the end of the day.
- 27:38We all feel the same exact emotions.
- 27:41For some reason, we think that the people at the top do not
- 27:44feel those emotions and we think they've conquered them.
- 27:47No, I don't think they've conquered them.
- 27:49They just learned, as you mentioned, that it's normal to
- 27:51have these feelings and they just let those days pass until
- 27:55something good comes along again.
- 27:56And then they use that to feel themselves up.
- 27:58For you, that could be, you know, having a tennis match or
- 28:01meeting up with your mentor or actually finding some success
- 28:04in, you know, looking at one of the new features that you guys
- 28:07are making. You just need to keep looking at
- 28:10growth and eventually build momentum so that you can feel
- 28:14like you're making progress and then get to that.
- 28:18You know, the state, but the the cycle is always going to be
- 28:21there, man. Always whatever, doesn't matter
- 28:23what you do. I think one thing that is eye
- 28:26opening for me is I don't know. I always say my philosophy is
- 28:30like everything's perspective in life.
- 28:31You just got to like, remember what you're comparing it with.
- 28:35Don't compare it. You know, like as they say,
- 28:37comparison is like the enemy of happiness.
- 28:40But if you go into perspective, you're comparing it with
- 28:43yourself prior. Don't compare with another
- 28:45person. Compare with yourself 10 years
- 28:46ago and be like, OK, if I talk to myself 10 years ago and they
- 28:51see me now, what would they say? And they see me stress over a
- 28:54small detail, but I'm in this position, they'll be like,
- 28:57you're an idiot. Like why are you stressing over
- 28:59this small thing? Look where you are. 10 years ago
- 29:00I was stressing if I'll be able to live in the US in the 1st
- 29:03place, right? Yeah, so.
- 29:05But we forget it. We forget it, man.
- 29:08We are so forgetful for good and bad reasons, right?
- 29:11You forget the bad stuff, which is great, so that you're not
- 29:13living with so much pain. You also forget the good stuff.
- 29:16You forget that there was a time for you.
- 29:18You dreamt of living in the house you live in now, But then,
- 29:20now that doesn't matter anymore. Because you want bigger things.
- 29:22You want a bigger house, you want a better fucking car.
- 29:25It's always the case. Yeah.
- 29:27OK, I'll end with this. This is really a quote I like.
- 29:30There's a book by Robert McKee called Story Structure.
- 29:32It's kind of a Bible for script writing, right?
- 29:35And I used to write a lot. And he talks about one of the
- 29:38biggest problems of life is like scarcity.
- 29:42There's not enough time, there's not enough love, there's not
- 29:45enough food, there's not enough. And he said at every stage he
- 29:49talks about it from a standpoint of a protagonist in a film.
- 29:52He's like, you know, at any stage of your life, you're going
- 29:54to have a certain goal. And let's say, you know, you
- 29:57don't have a shelter. You, you know, you would die to
- 29:59have an apartment and you get that and now you don't have a
- 30:02job, right? Or let's say first, first one is
- 30:04obviously, you know, kind of food, right?
- 30:05And then shelter. And now you get a job and you're
- 30:08surviving. You're good, but you know,
- 30:10you're not have to reach your career.
- 30:12And so now you really want to focus on your career and you get
- 30:14the best job in the world you want.
- 30:16But now you spend all all your time focusing with that.
- 30:19Now you don't really have love, right?
- 30:21But now you want to find love. Let's say you find love you, you
- 30:23know, find love with your life. You have best job in the world.
- 30:27You, you, you don't have to worry about financials.
- 30:29You like cheat it all. And then you look up with sky.
- 30:31You're like, what's the meaning of life?
- 30:32What are we? Doing with this planet, right?
- 30:36So it's always, it's always going to be something, right.
- 30:39I think for me, I was very fortunate.
- 30:40I, I started at like 16 years old to teach tennis.
- 30:43My dad was a tennis coach. So, you know, we, we, we grew up
- 30:46really poor, but tennis is, you know, you're surrounded by
- 30:50wealthy people. So as a kid, I was, I was kind
- 30:53of immersed in this Country Club atmosphere as a, as a, you know,
- 30:56as a kind of staff as service, right.
- 30:59So you, you know, you kind of live into that community a
- 31:02little bit and then you realize these people are not really
- 31:05happy as, as you thought from the outside.
- 31:08You like, if I just achieve this, I'm going to be happy.
- 31:10So it was that was kind of like a good thing for me to
- 31:12experience early on. So you don't have to push
- 31:15yourself for wrong reasons. You know?
- 31:17That's why I like art, because through artists that I know,
- 31:20especially in our industry, really are not doing it from
- 31:22fame or fortune. They're doing it because they
- 31:24have this dying story they have to tell.
- 31:26It's almost like a mission you're born with.
- 31:28You're like, I have to give my point of view or I have to tell
- 31:31this story and hope it's going to inspire someone.
- 31:33Like I was inspired when I was younger.
- 31:35To me, that's kind of like talk about meaning of life.
- 31:37To me, that's kind of the meaning of life.
- 31:39Yeah, absolutely. We solved it guys.
- 31:41We didn't let me achieve that. Another thing that you mentioned
- 31:45that was in the beginning about hiring that hire someone that
- 31:49maybe they don't understand or they don't even calculate the
- 31:53amount of risk they're taking or the complexity of the project
- 31:56that they're undertaking. And sometimes it's very true.
- 32:00When I look back at ourselves and I see that, Oh my God, if I
- 32:03sit down and I calculate the actions that we did one year
- 32:06ago, it doesn't make any sense. But we did it because we didn't
- 32:09really think about the outcomes and the possibilities.
- 32:11And I think what you said is super important about hiring.
- 32:14If you get someone who's curious, who's willing to work
- 32:17hard, they can't really solve your problem.
- 32:19But as if you get someone experience they would just say
- 32:22no, it can't be done and that's it.
- 32:24Yeah, for sure. And I think it's the bias.
- 32:26And also I would say be careful of people that can promise you
- 32:29that they know it all. Like, Oh yeah, we could do I
- 32:32know how to solve this. I like as you said, curious,
- 32:38smart, hard working people over someone who has the insane
- 32:42resume. Nothing against the insane
- 32:43resume, but you know someone, especially in the new, the
- 32:46problem we had to solve was very specific.
- 32:49We got into combination of generative AI, computer vision,
- 32:54you know, traditional CG and software development.
- 32:58So it was almost impossible to find someone.
- 33:00This was 2018, 17 to find someone who knows all those
- 33:04fields. So what time I went out and we
- 33:06said, OK, we will have to have different departments.
- 33:09We'll have to have them work together.
- 33:11But you know, someone like Alexander, you know, to lead
- 33:15that, we said, OK, you know, he knows CG, he knows AI.
- 33:21You know, maybe he needs to grow a bit on soft air.
- 33:24But you know, 3 out of 4 is really good.
- 33:26But he's so curious and he's not someone who's who's.
- 33:30And you know, I hope he watches this.
- 33:31I don't give him enough praise. We really were like, OK, we need
- 33:37someone and our team in general, RIT and some of their team is
- 33:40like this. They gotta be open to like, OK,
- 33:42admit, I don't know. Like, I don't know this because
- 33:45a lot of times you have this fear and you have to fake it
- 33:48till you make it. But then you don't ask
- 33:49questions. And I was just talking to
- 33:51someone the other day. To me, that's being foreign.
- 33:54Foreign is a good thing because I can ask what is that?
- 33:56Because they can be like, oh, is it an English thing or, And you
- 34:01know, and you can be like, no, it's just, I don't understand
- 34:03that word. And then they explain to you
- 34:05what it is and it's great. But I, you know, I, I, I, I, I
- 34:09kind of learned a lot of young people are scared to ask or say
- 34:12when they don't know something. And then that blocks you from
- 34:14learning more about that subject.
- 34:16You don't know because you're worried, like, OK, if I say, I
- 34:18don't know what that means, they're going to think less of
- 34:20me or you have that imposter syndrome.
- 34:22So you're scared, right? And so that's why I, when I was
- 34:25hiring, I was looking at that always in interviews.
- 34:28I'm like, I need someone who's OK to say when they don't know
- 34:30something, but also someone's going to go on and Google it and
- 34:34research it, you know? And, and I'd be, you know, and
- 34:36funny enough, this all started our company cuz I said yes to 1
- 34:41project where they asked me to do something and if I know much
- 34:46about it and I was in a desperate need for money.
- 34:49So I said yes. And I had three or four days to
- 34:53learn it. And it was a small gig.
- 34:54It was a 2 day project, right? And I was like, OK, I have three
- 34:58days. I can learn anything in three
- 35:00days when it comes to visual effects, at least enough to talk
- 35:02about it. And then I'll figure out to
- 35:03solve it in the process. Cause VFX is like problem
- 35:06solving on the spot. Like it's always a new problem
- 35:08you have to solve, right? And so that actually led me to
- 35:12discover the 360 and VR before everybody.
- 35:15That led me to start a thing with Thai and then jump into AI
- 35:18and all that. Like one day, honestly, it was a
- 35:20one phone call, one day opportunity.
- 35:23That was just a 2 day thing that turned into a 2 month thing just
- 35:27because I was like, all right, you know what I'll I'll take
- 35:29that leap. I I know I can learn it bro so.
- 35:32Yeah, I, I don't know how many times I have to say this, but
- 35:35that's so fucking relatable. I'll explain.
- 35:37So if it wasn't for us saying yes to jobs that we didn't know
- 35:41how to do, but we were curious enough to figure out, we
- 35:43wouldn't be fucking here. We wouldn't even be on this
- 35:45podcast. I'll explain.
- 35:47Unreal Engine. How do we get into that?
- 35:48Right? Because a lot of our content
- 35:50revolves around Unreal Engine. A lot of our client work we've
- 35:52used Unreal Engine 4 and we recently done 2 courses for
- 35:56Unreal Engine and teaching the world how to use the software.
- 35:59And. We started learning it because
- 36:01there was this, I'm not going to name them, this guy who was
- 36:06working with an artist who wanted to create a digital
- 36:08avatar. And he was like, oh, cool,
- 36:09that's fine. How do we do that?
- 36:10We don't know how to make one. Meta humans are there.
- 36:13We can use Meta humans. OK, we'll take the job.
- 36:16We're going to learn Meta humans in a week and figure out how to
- 36:19use this software and the rest is history.
- 36:21We never worked with that artist, by the way.
- 36:23They never ended up hiring us. We learned the Unreal Engine as
- 36:27a result and then started becoming so good at it.
- 36:30We started working with clients, got paid for that.
- 36:32We started making videos about it.
- 36:34Our YouTube channel grew, our Instagram grew.
- 36:36And I honestly thank that artist who I've never worked with for
- 36:40pushing us to go into that field.
- 36:41It's always about having the balls to and under courage to
- 36:45say yes, but also have the commitment and the dedication
- 36:49and know how to go and find out how to solve it.
- 36:51Yeah, yeah. Yeah, you can't just fake it,
- 36:53say yes and just be like, I'll show up.
- 36:55Yeah. Yeah.
- 36:56But no, I, I mean, props to you for being, you know, I had a
- 37:00mentor who I say like, you know, here's the circle of comfort and
- 37:04here's you. You got to be in a uncomfort
- 37:06zone because if you're comfortable, you're not really
- 37:08growing. So I think you were
- 37:11uncomfortable to say no, to say yes to that, but you were like,
- 37:14OK, the more I work, the more comfortable I get.
- 37:17You know, it's funny that when we become comfortable, and
- 37:19usually it happens after the project is done, we become
- 37:22stressed, We tell each other they are too comfortable
- 37:25something. Something is awesome.
- 37:26Something is awesome. We're relaxing.
- 37:28Too nice. Yeah, we are too relaxed.
- 37:30You slept an hour extra today. This is not normal going.
- 37:33Well, not something is done. Why not nothing?
- 37:36Oh my God, I have that same. I have that same thing.
- 37:39I was talking to my friend, but he's like, he's driving.
- 37:41He's like, I don't know, I'm doing too well now.
- 37:43I don't like it. I don't like it.
- 37:46Something bad's gonna happen. I don't like it.
- 37:49And it's, you know, it's. I think it's just an alarm
- 37:51system in our brain that is so used to being in discomfort
- 37:55because it knows from past patterns and behaviors that
- 37:59whenever we are in discomfort, eventually we get a reward for
- 38:02it, right? And then when we're too
- 38:03comfortable, oh, that's not a good zone to be.
- 38:05And it's great. It's happy, but I'm not going to
- 38:08see much growth compared to when I'm in discomfort.
- 38:10Allow me to go back a little bit.
- 38:12In our conversation, you said that you were shooting a
- 38:14documentary and researching the topic of nurture versus nature.
- 38:19I always found that topic incredibly fascinating.
- 38:22I haven't done as much research as you.
- 38:25What was the answer? Here, I'll give you a I'll give
- 38:30you a thing. I, I, I got surprised of how
- 38:34much more the environment had influenced over everything else,
- 38:38which I always believed strongly on it.
- 38:41I believed in like surrounding yourself with the people that
- 38:44you admire in a small circle. You know how they say you're
- 38:47like an average of your, you know, 5 or 10 closest people.
- 38:52There's a study, you know, the, the kind of genetics or DNA was
- 38:56a theory, right? And there's a lot of studies
- 39:00today by scientists that are basically saying the kind of
- 39:06atoms or DNA you have, your own body at 7 is not the same as
- 39:10your 20. Meaning they discovered that the
- 39:17kind of DNA changes based on environment.
- 39:19If they freeze it or they put it in a hot environment or they put
- 39:21it like certain atoms, there's, there's specific studies that
- 39:25show that because of our atoms regenerate all the time and
- 39:28change the dot changes based on the environment.
- 39:31So kind of on the DNA level, the belief of genetics and genes is
- 39:38not as clean or clear as we like to think.
- 39:41We like to think like you're just, you know, genetics, you're
- 39:44like your parents, you can't help yourself.
- 39:45This is what happens, right? Yeah, I think partially it's
- 39:48obviously true, but it's also worth human.
- 39:50You can change and you're affected by that environment and
- 39:53you're change. So I don't know.
- 39:55I've always been maybe a little bit too naive of you know of
- 40:00someone who does believe that it's it really comes.
- 40:04By certain actions that you do and this outside force or
- 40:07whether it's genetics or something, you can learn how to
- 40:10get through it right. You just have to maybe work
- 40:14harder on certain things. If you know yourself well,
- 40:16right, you know what your flaws are and you're like, all right,
- 40:19I have this because, you know, let's say my parents have it or
- 40:22someone has it and I know, you know, just don't give in to that
- 40:25excuse. That's what I learned.
- 40:26Like you can, it's easy to like use that as scapegoats and be
- 40:29like, it's just the way, you know, I am and my bloodline is
- 40:32and be OK, you know, so I don't know, but it's interesting
- 40:37enough. I, I think majority of, of, of
- 40:41people we spoke to and you know, as I was digging deeper into
- 40:45that research, you know, there's a, there's a, there's a really
- 40:49good book, I forgot the name of it, but the creator of Breaking
- 40:52Bad was talking about how I think it's called, how they made
- 40:57it, but it's focused on just the negative, just the negative.
- 41:01I found this book, just the negative parts of their success,
- 41:05like people just talking about like, it's really focused on
- 41:08like not not making it pretty. And he was talking about how
- 41:11when he sold Breaking Bad to AMC, all of his friends were
- 41:15like, tapping him on shoulder be like, yeah, at least you sold it
- 41:17because the AMC at the time was not known.
- 41:19So it was kind of like where the shows go to die.
- 41:22So people were like, you know, yeah.
- 41:24So. And he was talking about how he
- 41:26was so hard on himself that, you know, it took him 10 years to
- 41:30write something because he would think about it so much that he
- 41:34would have always this block of perfectionism.
- 41:37And then he realized if he just wrote 2-3 pages a day, he could
- 41:41have had, you know, dozens and dozens of scripts completed in
- 41:45that period, but he couldn't because he was so hard on
- 41:47himself during that period. And that's interesting to hear.
- 41:50You're like one of the best TV writers in history, in recent
- 41:53history, had that same issue for 10 years.
- 41:55And you're like, wow, that guy doubted himself so much that he
- 41:58couldn't even write, you know, And then you realize like, you
- 42:01know, so I think it's very, to me, it's very encouraging when
- 42:04you hear super successful people, including, like, you
- 42:08know, some of the greatest directors in the world that I
- 42:10can't name. But I spoke to, you know, tell
- 42:12you that they basically feel like they're gonna throw up
- 42:14before every project. And you're like, no way.
- 42:16Come on. You're like, you know, yeah.
- 42:18And so that's that's very interesting to see that, you
- 42:21know, it does not change. They just may be very much
- 42:26better, you know, at fighting through it and use and using
- 42:30that fear to as a motivation, as a instead of you can do two
- 42:35things from fear, right? One, you can freeze and stop,
- 42:38you know, creating or you can use it to fuel you.
- 42:42And I think the most people that I know that are very successful
- 42:44in the creative space, they use it to fuel them.
- 42:47And that to us, because they're constantly in action to us.
- 42:50We think they don't have that fear cuz look at them, they're
- 42:53just doing right. So we think like, no, don't I
- 42:55have that, It's just me, it's just me.
- 42:58But most creatives I know, no, no, they're just, they just put
- 43:00it into work. They don't let it, you know,
- 43:02freeze them. So it's very interesting, like
- 43:06it's, it's helpful when you hear that you're like, all right, if
- 43:08it happens to to them, you know, it's like, OK, it's fine.
- 43:12It's fine that it happens to me, right?
- 43:13It's, it's very true. And when you mentioned that you
- 43:16talk to all your mentors, I think you learned a great
- 43:19lessons from them because I, I heard you talking about them
- 43:22like a few times during this podcast.
- 43:24And I think having having that anchor who tells you these
- 43:26things and you know, you're finding out, for example, you
- 43:29can push more or you can work hard there.
- 43:31How did you manage to find all these mentors for yourself?
- 43:36I was very, I mean, first of all, I'm a curious guy, so I
- 43:39asked a lot of questions when I meet new people.
- 43:42But also the tennis thing was very helpful.
- 43:45As I was doing visual effects on the weekends, I, I started
- 43:48giving tennis lessons to, to, to people.
- 43:51And, you know, tennis was fortunate to get me into these
- 43:54circles where a lot of successful people in
- 43:56entertainment industry. And so I learned like, don't ask
- 44:00for favors. Don't be like, hey, you know, I
- 44:03need something from you, you know, spend time and ask
- 44:06questions to show that you just want knowledge transfer.
- 44:10And I always tell young people in their 20s, in early 20s
- 44:13especially, like being young is your superpower.
- 44:15It's extremely scary because you want to figure out your career,
- 44:18especially trying to break in a film industry or tech industry,
- 44:21very hard industry to, to succeed in, but most successful
- 44:26people when they're in the 70s, etcetera, that, you know,
- 44:29achieved a lot of things they wanted to.
- 44:31You have this natural thing for leaving a legacy.
- 44:35And if they have a sense of, oh, this kid just wants knowledge,
- 44:39you know, and they like you, they see you're hard working,
- 44:41they'll want to transfer that even like subconsciously, you
- 44:45know. So to me, that was super
- 44:48important. I surround myself, a few
- 44:49mentors, one of them, Bob Swabs, been mentoring me for about 13
- 44:53years, not just on, you know, work stuff, but private stuff as
- 44:57well. I moved here by myself in the
- 45:00US. So, you know, didn't know a lot
- 45:02of people. Sometimes I slept in people's
- 45:04spare bedrooms to college. I had families that took me in
- 45:07that I lived in and it kind of, I guess naturally I gravitated
- 45:10to find like some people, as you know, to, to kind of like guide
- 45:14you with advice. But I also learn, learn early
- 45:17on. It's like, all right, you, you
- 45:19cannot, you know, pardon my language, but like one of my
- 45:22mentors told me like, don't believe your own bullshit.
- 45:25And it took me a while to realize what he means by that.
- 45:28But then I also realized like where I grew up in a part of the
- 45:30world, you've had these kind of guys that are so strong, strong
- 45:36of a present that nobody is brave enough to like question
- 45:41them. And then you start believing
- 45:43your own bullshit. You start thinking everything
- 45:45you say is the truth. I know everything.
- 45:47I'm the smartest cuz nobody's questioning it, right?
- 45:50And so you know, that's. Dangerous this.
- 45:53Yeah, very dangerous, Yeah. And then having this kind of
- 45:57advice and finding mentors that are older that you'll be like,
- 46:00all right, They know, like I always say, like, you know, if
- 46:02you play a life is like, you know, let's say life is like a
- 46:05video game and you have 8090 levels and you're on a level 22,
- 46:09you're 22 years old. Once you want to talk to someone
- 46:12who's 70, you're like, hey, what'd you do at this level?
- 46:14Like how do I get next one you know?
- 46:17It's a good way to put it, yeah. You would always do that right
- 46:20if it was as simple as like a video game.
- 46:21But we don't. We don't look at it that way in
- 46:23real life. 100% you'll go on YouTube and try to find someone
- 46:27who's went through the game and be like alright.
- 46:32I want to take it to something that you mentioned earlier,
- 46:38which is features in In Wonder Studio Flow, Autodesk Flow
- 46:43Studio. And one thing that you've also
- 46:45mentioned in another podcast that was quite interesting to
- 46:48me, which is when you guys were thinking about all these
- 46:51features that you want to add in and you were excited about it.
- 46:54Of course, not all of them were easy to achieve.
- 46:57And so I remember specifically you mentioned that you had to
- 47:00hold back some of these features.
- 47:02And also you had to hold back from launching too early so that
- 47:05you can pack in enough interesting features so that
- 47:07when you launch, you're going to have the interests of people and
- 47:11you're actually providing a lot of value.
- 47:13And I think that's really cool because 2025 we're seeing a kind
- 47:18of a different environment in the world because of the way AI
- 47:22is moving. Very specifically I'm talking
- 47:25about the Neo launch or the Neo announcement.
- 47:27Did you see that one? The robot?
- 47:30Yes, yeah. Oh, yeah.
- 47:31OK, perfect. I had a I had a bet with my Co
- 47:34worker and he's sending me to prove me wrong in my bet.
- 47:37I'll tell you a bit. OK, So it might be similar, I
- 47:39don't know, maybe the bet is, you know, related to what I'm
- 47:42going to talk about. But Marcus Brownlee released a
- 47:44video of him talking about the robot.
- 47:47And what he mentioned was that about 80% or 90% of everything
- 47:51they showed was teleoperated action.
- 47:53So someone using AVR to control the robot and there was only two
- 47:57actions, which is opening the door and grabbing the cup, which
- 48:01was actually autonomous. And yet they're hyping this up
- 48:04and making many people believe that this is actually ready and
- 48:08this is going to be as exciting as they say it is going to be.
- 48:10Whereas the truth is when it's when it's going to launch,
- 48:13you're going to have random people with cameras in your
- 48:16house technically operating things.
- 48:18And I'm not sure how many people will be excited about that right
- 48:21now. Whereas if he was purely
- 48:23autonomous, right? So now we're getting that.
- 48:26That's just one example, but there's so many tools,
- 48:28especially in the creative space that are now launching without
- 48:32features that are actually helpful.
- 48:34But there's just this fancy video at launch and this fancy
- 48:37website and they promise you all of these different things that
- 48:40they're going to do and then they launch and none of that is
- 48:43true. And then people get pissed off
- 48:45because you get all of these AI powered features and 90% of the
- 48:49time they don't work. What are your thoughts on this?
- 48:51Because when you guys launch, when we tried your product,
- 48:55you're like, holy fucking shit, it works.
- 48:56This is actually what they're showing and it actually works.
- 48:59And you guys were doing a bunch of complex things, whereas right
- 49:01now that's not actually the case in 2025.
- 49:04Yeah, I'll tell you this. There's a code I heard which is
- 49:08if you're not embarrassed of your first like alpha version or
- 49:12first launch like you, you launch too late.
- 49:15So that's a philosophy inside of Silicon Valley, a little bit of
- 49:17like on one side, don't be too perfectionist because you're
- 49:21never gonna be ready. You know, the thing about a
- 49:23movies, like movies not finished, it's released.
- 49:25Yeah. Because if you, that's why we
- 49:26have producers. If it's only up to a director,
- 49:28they will edit it forever, right?
- 49:30Yeah. Yeah.
- 49:30You know, producers, like, no, this needs to happen.
- 49:33That's the kind of nature of creative work.
- 49:35Like you're never, you know, you guys.
- 49:36Yeah, Yeah, yeah. We we have, we have those roles.
- 49:39We have this role in the company, so we know that, yeah.
- 49:42I like that. So that's on one side and I
- 49:46understand that, but I think what's going on in the AI space
- 49:49is people are fighting for mindshare.
- 49:50So they're fighting for branding, They're fighting for
- 49:53like, let's get first so people know our logo and they know our
- 49:56brand. Like with Neo, maybe it's not
- 49:58ready now, but in five years you'll still know what Neo is,
- 50:01right? Obviously sometimes goes too
- 50:03far, they go too early and then it hurts them already and it
- 50:06helps. I'm not saying that that's the
- 50:08case with this company. I don't know, but I see it as
- 50:10well in generative AI space. I mean, you see companies
- 50:13launching everyday packing, you know, open source model that you
- 50:16know, they didn't add anything, they just wrapped something and
- 50:18release it. But sometimes it works right.
- 50:20Sometimes they'll start that and they'll get some momentum and
- 50:23then build something useful eventually.
- 50:24It's just not that first version.
- 50:27I'm more on the opposite side. I honestly do like I have to
- 50:31fight, fight my perfectionism. We were lucky because we started
- 50:35early. We saw the space way earlier
- 50:37before someone else. Like if we discovered at the
- 50:38same time, you know, it'll still take a long time to build
- 50:41because it's a really hard, we have, you know, our live action
- 50:44thing has about 25 models, you know, and a lot of them we have
- 50:48to build from scratch. So it takes time.
- 50:52I think it's a consequence of the race.
- 50:53And then if people are trying to fundraise, you know, and it's
- 50:56fresh and you want to release now because you need to get
- 50:59users so you can go talk to ECS, etcetera.
- 51:02So kind of half is like decision of the founders, half is the
- 51:05market navigating it. I'm obviously not a fan of
- 51:09releasing something that doesn't work just so you can, you know,
- 51:12get branding, good branding recognition.
- 51:15But it's a bit of a yeah, I see it too.
- 51:17I see it more often these days than than than not.
- 51:20I mean, the explanation of Marcus was very similar to what
- 51:24you said. I mean, even with AI, especially
- 51:26because you need training, right?
- 51:28And they're going to use all of those information to train and
- 51:30become a better company. But ultimately as the end user,
- 51:35it sucks because now we're getting all of these half baked
- 51:37products around us that we have to we have to deal with until
- 51:41they become better. Yeah, it's just not there yet.
- 51:44Obviously the robotics that are a whole different beasts, right?
- 51:46Generative AI is not there yet. Completely right.
- 51:48It's getting better. Every variation is getting
- 51:50better and people are playing with it.
- 51:52That's why there's, you know, so much interest in it because we
- 51:54know once he gets editability gets there, because really what
- 51:57that's the big problem. That's why we build it in 3D
- 52:00space. What we did with Flow Studio,
- 52:01because I'm a, I'm a big believer.
- 52:03I have to move certain things. It has to be multimodality.
- 52:06I can't just prompt because I can't prompt performances.
- 52:09It's impossible to describe a emotion, right?
- 52:11You have to drive, you have to drive it with a certain active
- 52:14performances, right? It's impossible to like even
- 52:17look at it. When you look at the film set,
- 52:19you do 5-10 takes. You know, Fincher does 50.
- 52:22But if you do certain, yeah, you do certain takes because it's
- 52:27hard to communicate to an actor your vision and then the actors
- 52:30trying to do their own interpretation of it.
- 52:33And you want the vision to collide.
- 52:34And then sometimes, you know, there's a lot of people on set,
- 52:38and so you want to sync and get the performance you want.
- 52:40So I think that's why for us, you know, I'm a big believer
- 52:44that multimodality and like, OK, I'm going to have certain things
- 52:46from performances like actors, I, I will want to be able to
- 52:50move my camera into this space or to edit my animation in 3D
- 52:54space. Because you can't, let's be
- 52:55real, you cannot edit animation into this space.
- 52:57I cannot edit the camera into this space.
- 52:59I just can't. I'm seeing solutions in the
- 53:01market at trying, but you're like, you can't draw into this
- 53:04space how you want that move to be possible, right?
- 53:07Same with lighting, right? I can navigate light, but I want
- 53:10to move that light in 3D space. So that's why we approached it
- 53:12in a sense, like give me a shot. I'm going to use a lot of these
- 53:15models and I'm going to break it apart in all the elements that I
- 53:18need. Element of character, the
- 53:20element of environment, the element of lighting, animation,
- 53:23camera, all this and then control each individual element.
- 53:26Where I don't see yet is that editability.
- 53:29You know, generation of it is getting really good, but the
- 53:33editability is not getting. And we know in a creative space,
- 53:37especially like high level with the series directors, they're
- 53:40all about the details, right? They're all about iteration
- 53:43details. Iteration details until you find
- 53:45what you're looking for completely so I think that's a
- 53:48that's a research issue in a generative space and that's why
- 53:51we're seeing a lot of how big products because you're seeing a
- 53:55research block that hasn't been sold yet.
- 53:58Robotics. I had a bet with my Co worker,
- 54:02you know, I told him that I think humanoid robots will be
- 54:04like next iPhone in 10 years, most people will have one, you
- 54:07know, and he's the, you know, he's like, no way.
- 54:09Absolutely not. And so when this Neo think we
- 54:12bet $100 in 10 years, right? And this Neo thing came out and
- 54:16he's sending me so many and I'm like, hold on man.
- 54:22It's like I got 10 more years. I got 10 more years ago.
- 54:25This is just version one. But yeah, I don't know.
- 54:29It's one of those things like where you see some of the
- 54:32greatest things we use now. The first versions were not
- 54:36great, right of it. If someone is judging the first
- 54:39Internet views now, they would be like, I never want to use
- 54:43this. And people thought a lot of
- 54:44things on releases of some major technologies that are fat,
- 54:48they're not going to work, etc. Down to color TV and color TV
- 54:53came in. People were like, what?
- 54:54Why would anybody want this? You know, even radio, I mean, so
- 54:58many of major no brainer innovations.
- 55:01We were, we were, you know, when they came out, we were thinking
- 55:04like, you know, there was. Someone that was saying oh this.
- 55:07Is a fad, Yeah. Nobody's going to use this.
- 55:10I mean, even, I don't know, it's like talkies film, right?
- 55:13They said. Why would someone want to hear
- 55:15people talk in a film? Right.
- 55:17Before you know when from silence we went to talkies.
- 55:20So kind of same same, same thing.
- 55:22So I think give it time. I'm, I'm, of course it depends
- 55:26on the founders and the company, but I don't know, I'm very
- 55:30optimistic about AI and where it's going, especially in the
- 55:33film space. I, I saw one of your podcast
- 55:35guests say something that I really liked.
- 55:37And he said, like, we're so focused about, you know, these
- 55:39companies will cut jobs. Instead of 100 people, there's
- 55:42going to be 5 of them. And, and he said like, but you
- 55:44look in it from a bad perspective, which is a
- 55:47perspective of like, but now 5, four of your friends and you can
- 55:50do the same thing, right? You don't need this big company.
- 55:52And I like that. I, I, you know, I thought that's
- 55:54like, that's the point of democratization, right?
- 55:56You don't want to, as you mentioned earlier, that
- 55:58permissionless storytelling. That's, that's for me, it's the,
- 56:04it's not going to be a smooth transition, right?
- 56:06The, the, the, the, it's going to be a big hit for, for a lot
- 56:10of people in the industry. But to me, it just expands the
- 56:13amount of people that can do this, you know, and then the
- 56:17irony of this all is, and I understand it, like as as an
- 56:21artist and VFX supervisor for many years.
- 56:23And the irony is this. The promise of AI is always, you
- 56:26know, if you read Asimov books from back 70s and 50s, the
- 56:31promise was always the AI will come here so we can make robots
- 56:34that can do things that we don't like, that are not creative, so
- 56:37we can just do creative stuff. The first wave of AI was the
- 56:41creative, Yeah. Why it always happens like that?
- 56:45That's the irony, man. That's the irony.
- 56:48So it's like, OK, And that's why I understand like you.
- 56:50Know. But what do you make of that?
- 56:52Yeah, I think it's the, I think it's the big focus of we're just
- 56:58gonna stop. Like meaning like, OK, so now
- 57:02and I, I said this many times. So for instance, example, it
- 57:06takes three years to make a film.
- 57:07It costs 200 million. Let's say we cut it down with
- 57:10this new technology that I can now take that same shot and I
- 57:13can do it in 2-3 days. You're telling me that if I
- 57:16spend something to 2-3 days that people are going to pay and go
- 57:18to theaters to watch that? No, we're going to think that's
- 57:21lazy. It's just the new ceiling.
- 57:22We're moving the ceiling on more, right?
- 57:24A new starting point. We just don't know what that
- 57:26next level is. So for me, for me, it's like
- 57:31it's so early. It's going to push us to push
- 57:33storytelling more. Just like you cannot, OK, go
- 57:36back to the era of silent films when we switch to talkies, talk
- 57:40to someone. Let's say you go back in time,
- 57:42you talk to someone, you show them Avatar and be like, let me
- 57:44explain to you how this was done using computers and, and
- 57:47rendering and, and, and, and they'll be like, what are you,
- 57:50what are you talking about? It's.
- 57:51Incomprehensible to them, it's. Incomprehensible.
- 57:54That's not film. That's not storytelling.
- 57:55What are you showing? This is not art.
- 57:57We just don't know what that future is, and it hurts us.
- 58:00Change hurts us. Change is not comfortable.
- 58:02We always fight it as a society. But to me, the ultimate truth
- 58:07is, hey, storytelling's too expensive.
- 58:11Not everybody can do it. There's a lot of times that
- 58:13people out there that have good stories to tell, how do we make
- 58:16them easier to tell stories? How do we get, you know, someone
- 58:20who has a small crew to do what only studios can do?
- 58:23That's how when time I started we were like, all right, this is
- 58:25great. This is our mission is let's get
- 58:27indie film makers to do what the studios can do.
- 58:29Cuz it used to be like this. Indie films cannot touch VFX,
- 58:32only studio people can. Now it's same with distribution,
- 58:36for instance. And then that change, you've got
- 58:37YouTube, etcetera. Now people are releasing all the
- 58:40all the news. We're listening podcasts more
- 58:42than we're watching certain shows on TV, right?
- 58:44That's where we get our news from.
- 58:45So distribution flipped, it changed, right?
- 58:48And then but you still had this cost of production that's so
- 58:52high. So production now is going to
- 58:54change. So now you have open and
- 58:55distribution that kind of democratized and then you have
- 58:58democratized production that everybody can do.
- 59:01To me, the next thing is going to be breaking through the
- 59:02noise, which is marketing. Who controls marketing dollars?
- 59:05There's gonna be gatekeeping all of it.
- 59:07There's always gatekeeping in history.
- 59:08It just moves through different channels, which is fascinating
- 59:12to me. And so I think.
- 59:14But to me the beauty is like, all right, now you have your
- 59:17amateur indie studio. It will what?
- 59:20Amateur they can do will change. They'll be able to do what Indy
- 59:24could do. Indy is gonna be able to do what
- 59:26studios could do. But studios are not gonna stop
- 59:28and say OK, we're dead now. No studios are gonna push it
- 59:31further and they're gonna figure out only we can do this much
- 59:35because the tech board, the tech ceiling is here.
- 59:37So we'll push it even more and we'll get 100 people and we'll
- 59:41work for three years. We're gonna do something that
- 59:42you can't do in a week. And then we're like, yeah,
- 59:45that's I'll pay for that, right? That's what people forget that
- 59:48that's what always it always happens throughout the history,
- 59:50right? We didn't like other thing and
- 59:53I'm rambling, but this is to me always fascinating.
- 59:56The the the studios were a consequence of the technology
- 1:00:01and and most people don't know this original first studios were
- 1:00:06in New Jersey. They were made by Edison
- 1:00:07company, right? Edison back in the day because
- 1:00:11he had licensing and invention and patterns on camera.
- 1:00:14He had patents on nickelodeons, which were theaters that cost
- 1:00:17the nickel to go see, right. So when you were making a movie
- 1:00:21and obviously film, right? So when you're making a movie,
- 1:00:23you had to license the camera, you had to, you had to get
- 1:00:26distribution from Edison Company.
- 1:00:28So as a, as a filmmaker, you basically were, you know, have
- 1:00:32mercy of, of, of centralized figure at the time.
- 1:00:35Thomas and Edison, the producers at the time got tired of that
- 1:00:40and they said, OK, they found a small town Hollywood in, in, you
- 1:00:45know, in California, which was a farmland.
- 1:00:48And they went and bought a big, big portion of it and said,
- 1:00:51we're going to film there because the weather is nice.
- 1:00:52We can film on the beach, we can do desert, we can do snow.
- 1:00:56But most importantly, people think they just moved because
- 1:00:58the weather. Most importantly, they moved
- 1:00:59here because they realized, OK, the judges in California are a
- 1:01:03little more forgiving on the licensing thing.
- 1:01:06We're going to go and shoot Indy.
- 1:01:07We're going to shoot out of the union because there was the
- 1:01:09union, right? We're going to shoot Indy by the
- 1:01:11time we're done shooting because back in the day, you know, it's
- 1:01:14early 1900s, back in the days for them to get from New York to
- 1:01:18to LA or Hollywood at time took them so long that by the time
- 1:01:23they were there, they were already done shooting.
- 1:01:26And then the judges, then the judges in California were more
- 1:01:30forgiving and they didn't want monopoly like the New York had.
- 1:01:33So the Hollywood studios, first studios were actually the indie
- 1:01:37producers that were escaping the monopoly at the time of
- 1:01:41technology. And this is one of those things
- 1:01:42that people don't really either forgot.
- 1:01:44They don't talk about it. But I always found it so
- 1:01:46fascinating. I'm like, all right, we're so
- 1:01:47against technology in this industry, but we should just be
- 1:01:50against who holds the technology.
- 1:01:52Is there a control of it? Can I get access to it?
- 1:01:55Can everybody get access to it? Are you gatekeeping the
- 1:01:57distribution, Are you gatekeeping the production,
- 1:02:00etcetera, right. So we'll see what that next wave
- 1:02:03is, but it is, it is a wave, no? I don't think people forgot.
- 1:02:06I think people don't know. I didn't know that story.
- 1:02:08I mean, I understand the concept of gatekeeping, but what you
- 1:02:11just said, the concept of the ceiling, absolutely beautiful
- 1:02:16because I forget to look at that sometimes myself.
- 1:02:18And the fact that right now every part of the flow has been
- 1:02:23democratized to some extent. I mean, we talk about the
- 1:02:25distribution a lot. We teach the production part.
- 1:02:28That's the Unreal Engine bit that we teach.
- 1:02:29But we're always shouting to our audience, which is made-up
- 1:02:33majority of artists to talk about their work, to shout about
- 1:02:38their work. Like the fact that you can post
- 1:02:39your fucking short film right now on YouTube and get a million
- 1:02:42views if it's good enough. It's insane.
- 1:02:45You're getting a million people to watch it and it can happen
- 1:02:47overnight. Literally, you make something
- 1:02:50overnight, you can get a million views if your work is good
- 1:02:52enough. We've seen those stories time
- 1:02:54and time again. And the fact that that is even
- 1:02:57possible is insane. And the fact that so little
- 1:03:00amount of people actually use it.
- 1:03:02Again, I think it's not just some people have forgotten, some
- 1:03:05people don't even know. So that's why the concept of
- 1:03:08this podcast is so interesting is because we get to have deep
- 1:03:10conversations like this and hopefully people listen to the
- 1:03:13story that you just mentioned and feel a little bit of
- 1:03:16blessing. Because I feel like in 2025, a
- 1:03:18little people, a lot of people have fear mongering going on
- 1:03:21with, you know, all of these different evolutions of tools,
- 1:03:24but understanding that it's actually giving us the power and
- 1:03:28allows us to do things that we couldn't do.
- 1:03:32It goes back to that perspective, which is like, all
- 1:03:34right, you can focus on it with like this is going to, you know,
- 1:03:40ruin everything, arts done taking jobs.
- 1:03:43Or you can be like equal playing field.
- 1:03:46You're telling me I can compete with this person now?
- 1:03:49That's amazing. We all start from the same line.
- 1:03:52The race is like the same, OK, this is great, right?
- 1:03:55That's how I see it. Obviously we have to be
- 1:03:58responsible in building it, right.
- 1:04:00We do all the copyright issue and I hope we don't end up in
- 1:04:03the future where we're generating whole films just
- 1:04:05prompting and we don't have real actors.
- 1:04:07We just have synthetic actors. I I think that would be a
- 1:04:09failure. But but you know, on the side of
- 1:04:13like creatives accepting and, you know, picking tools that
- 1:04:16work for you, You know, I think you cannot, you can't just speak
- 1:04:22about it and stick to the old methods.
- 1:04:26Obviously that's your style, you know, like you're doing
- 1:04:28something in the style, you know, stick to your style.
- 1:04:31But I I think you're going to get left behind.
- 1:04:34I think just focus on it from a positive standpoint, which is
- 1:04:38like you can do way more and you can go, you know, get seen
- 1:04:41discovered way more. I mean, for instance, like just
- 1:04:43even silly thing of you want to make a film and you want to do
- 1:04:48something for pitching, you just make a short thing that you show
- 1:04:51that you can direct. You know, you use giant TVA, you
- 1:04:53show you can direct, you can make certain things in your
- 1:04:55living room and you know, film performances, you know, take
- 1:04:59those performances and put it in certain characters that you want
- 1:05:02to build. You know, it's much easier to
- 1:05:06get seen like that then, you know, just for instance, trying
- 1:05:10to do it traditionally. I I think the whole point of our
- 1:05:13creative industry, and this is back to one of my mentors told
- 1:05:16me he early on, he told me he's like, you know, don't be like
- 1:05:19every other schmuck sitting on a bench waiting for your
- 1:05:21opportunity. He said, you know, be creative
- 1:05:24in your business approach as you are in your creative, which is
- 1:05:27your writing or let's say your CG artist or animator or
- 1:05:31director. And that's why I see a lot of
- 1:05:33times like you, you see these creative people, they're so
- 1:05:35creative on that side, but they approach the the kind of
- 1:05:39corporate letter or let me meet someone, a producer, let me like
- 1:05:43hope someone will give me money to make film.
- 1:05:45The ones that are breaking through is the one you talk
- 1:05:47about, you know, kids that go out and make things on YouTube
- 1:05:49get discovered and someone calls them because they're like, I've
- 1:05:51seen that. Oh my God, I've seen that short
- 1:05:53film. It's incredible.
- 1:05:54How'd you do that? Right?
- 1:05:55So, or they just, you know, they found a super.
- 1:05:58So there's not, there's not one formula in our industry.
- 1:06:00That's the beauty of it, right? And the formula is changing
- 1:06:03daily. And we like to think people up
- 1:06:06in time, talent agency or studios have it all figured out.
- 1:06:09If I'm only a part of that community, it'd be easier, you
- 1:06:13know, All right, I'll have someone to come, you know, and
- 1:06:16they'll, you know, as soon as they meet me in this group,
- 1:06:18someone's going to come and solve all my problem and be
- 1:06:21like, no, they're also trying to figure it out, you know.
- 1:06:23So I think you kind of, to me, these opportunities don't come
- 1:06:29often in our lifetime when these industry shifts are happening
- 1:06:33because the people, the establishment is also learning
- 1:06:36at the same pace you are arguably you're, you're learning
- 1:06:39quicker than the establishment because the establishment is
- 1:06:42busy maintaining that as they're catching up with new things,
- 1:06:45right? So this is your opportunity to
- 1:06:47be like, look at, you know, look at this pipeline I put together
- 1:06:50or look at and I always tell artists, yes, you're an artist,
- 1:06:54you're not an engineer. But don't be against going on a
- 1:06:57website to and watching a YouTube video on a research
- 1:07:00paper that might help you discover a tool or an open
- 1:07:04source that you might put in like the, the back to that first
- 1:07:08project that I said yesterday, I didn't know.
- 1:07:11I ended up making a pipeline I didn't know nothing about that
- 1:07:13ended up, that's why I ended up getting hired for more months.
- 1:07:16And that's how I ended up getting an idea cuz I was, you
- 1:07:19know, curious and I was digging deeper outside of what my job
- 1:07:22responsibility was cuz I had to solve a problem.
- 1:07:25And that's why the effects are kind of always first that gets
- 1:07:29hit with these changes cuz our naturally our industry is the
- 1:07:32combo of the two, right? You guys know, well, it's like
- 1:07:36whatever, you're gonna always, there's so many different
- 1:07:39pipelines. They always gonna hit a
- 1:07:40roadblock on a new project that you have to discover some new
- 1:07:44tool or combo of new tools, right?
- 1:07:47And then you kind of you, you become PD yourself in a way,
- 1:07:50right for a second. No, it's very true because we
- 1:07:53always tell our audience also to experiment and experimentation
- 1:07:56is super important. Sometimes the experimentation
- 1:07:58might lead nowhere, Sometimes you learn a great deal,
- 1:08:02sometimes you might end up you partnering with someone else.
- 1:08:05So going especially in 2025 with all the tools that you have at
- 1:08:08your disposal, most of them are also free.
- 1:08:11You can just spend some time, allocate some time.
- 1:08:14OK, I'm going to do some research.
- 1:08:15The same thing happened to us when we were, we discovered
- 1:08:19Wonder Dynamics back and I think 3-4 years ago was let's try it
- 1:08:22out. We, we didn't, we saw the demo,
- 1:08:24demo was cool, let's try it out. We saw many other demos.
- 1:08:27We tried the other tools, some of them work, some of them
- 1:08:30didn't. Some of them we are still using
- 1:08:32until today. So I think as an artist it's
- 1:08:35really important. Use everything at your disposal,
- 1:08:38learn and experiment. That way you can see how you can
- 1:08:41grow. Yep, 100%.
- 1:08:43Be open to it. You can discover new things.
- 1:08:45And yeah, no, I agree. No, I, I, I think we did the
- 1:08:51same. You know, one thing when joining
- 1:08:53Autodesk is there was really important going back to like
- 1:08:55that scale issue as a startup, one of the things that Autodesk
- 1:08:59did for us is open the free tier.
- 1:09:01And that was important for us because there's a startup, you
- 1:09:03know, having a free tier, you're always like, how will I handle,
- 1:09:06you know, the spike? Who's going to pay for that free
- 1:09:082 year? Yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah, exactly.
- 1:09:10So that was something that we really aligned with Autodesk
- 1:09:13from the get go. They really believed in our
- 1:09:15vision. They give us that freedom and
- 1:09:16they're like, you know, we'll stand behind you guys.
- 1:09:18We think we love the mission you guys are doing etcetera.
- 1:09:20So it's, it's, it's nice to see right when you have a big
- 1:09:24company like that, you know, share that and Diana Colella,
- 1:09:28who runs media entertainment on Autodesk, you know, she like
- 1:09:32from the get go, she's like love the mission more than anything.
- 1:09:34Like we want to support that mission.
- 1:09:37And, and, and, you know, to, to to a founder that's, you know,
- 1:09:41one of those things you you're always scared of, right, You're
- 1:09:43scared of like letting go of that control because you're
- 1:09:46thinking, oh, a big company, you know, they'll, they'll change
- 1:09:48too much or, or their goals are different.
- 1:09:51They just care about revenue, etcetera.
- 1:09:52Right. So that was very, very
- 1:09:55refreshing and obviously makes my, makes my job much more
- 1:09:58enjoyable, you know? We wouldn't understand what
- 1:10:02you're talking about if it wasn't for the fact that we
- 1:10:04attended SIGGRAPH working with Autodesk ourself.
- 1:10:07And what's really funny is that when you're talking about how
- 1:10:10you didn't want to give up control, I mean, our scale of
- 1:10:14what I'm going to talk about is way smaller than, you know,
- 1:10:17talking about big companies coming and working together.
- 1:10:20It was just a simple presentation.
- 1:10:21But even in that presentation that we did with Autodesk, I
- 1:10:26quickly realized that these guys are different than the other big
- 1:10:28companies because when we were going up on stage to give our
- 1:10:31speech, usually when you're giving speeches with other
- 1:10:34companies, they would come and tell you, OK, don't talk about
- 1:10:36this, don't do that, do this. And when we went and we told
- 1:10:39them, OK, we're going to be talking about XY and Z, they
- 1:10:42were like, OK, that's cool. Yeah.
- 1:10:43They're like, do you guys have any comments, feedback?
- 1:10:45They were like, no, not really just, you know, just do do
- 1:10:47whatever you guys want to do. We watch your videos.
- 1:10:49Your videos are cool. Just go and talk about what you
- 1:10:50want to talk about. And so that moment I was like,
- 1:10:52holy shit. OK, usually for the smallest
- 1:10:55sponsors that we get on our channel, like they usually come
- 1:10:58and want to change things up. So we're like, no, thank you, we
- 1:11:00don't want sponsors. But when he came to, yeah, when
- 1:11:04he came to us giving the talk for Autodesk, they didn't change
- 1:11:07anything. So from that little point, I
- 1:11:10understood, OK, these guys are cool.
- 1:11:12But of course for you it's a little bit of a different story.
- 1:11:14You guys are talking about managing an entire company.
- 1:11:17I want to know what's the evolution been like?
- 1:11:18So yes, it's been, it's been good.
- 1:11:21But if you can get into the details of what is the vision
- 1:11:24for Autodesk close Studio right now, I would love to hear that.
- 1:11:28Yeah. No, the vision always kind of we
- 1:11:31had a really North Star to follow.
- 1:11:33I think it's important to be agile right in this space.
- 1:11:35It's moving fast, but you need to have a North Star.
- 1:11:38And our North Star is what I talked about earlier.
- 1:11:40For instance, we started with a live action, obviously we had to
- 1:11:44market it as like, hey, put CG characters in your live action
- 1:11:47shot, right, Which you guys saw. But really what was it?
- 1:11:49It was a foundational technology for us, which was, hey, can I
- 1:11:53take as much information from a shot as possible that I can
- 1:11:56actually reconstruct it in 3D space and I can control it.
- 1:12:00That was the the foundational thing.
- 1:12:01And that's the long, long vision for us is that multimodality of,
- 1:12:05you know, can I, I'm going to use Gentivi to create a
- 1:12:09character and I'll use Gentivi to create a world.
- 1:12:12But I want those to be very different models so I can
- 1:12:15control and get in a 3D space. So the vision has always been, I
- 1:12:19have my shot, I'm gonna go in and mix and match.
- 1:12:23I can take one video to drive my camera.
- 1:12:25I'll take another source to drive my performance.
- 1:12:27Maybe I'll do a source to drive my lighting.
- 1:12:30Maybe I'll prompt the camera a little bit.
- 1:12:32And then I want to kind of scene assembly that and I'm able to
- 1:12:35jump in that scene. And then I don't like how this
- 1:12:39leg looks. I'm going to raise it up a
- 1:12:40little bit. So really it's always been a
- 1:12:42combo of of this, you know, I have this diagram that we really
- 1:12:46follow in a company, which is that multimodality with a bunch
- 1:12:50of different circles that are combining, which is, you know,
- 1:12:54if I had to simplify it, you know, how can I control?
- 1:12:58So obviously separation of elements, that's a big one,
- 1:13:01right? I got my camera just like we do,
- 1:13:03right? Just like in the real world, I
- 1:13:04have my actor, I have my character, I have my lighting, I
- 1:13:07have my camera moved, etc. How can I drive each of those?
- 1:13:12I can drive it. I can drive it with a video.
- 1:13:15I can drive it from a store, right?
- 1:13:16That's the source of video. I can drive you to prompt or I
- 1:13:21can drive it by manipulating it. So those are kind of three,
- 1:13:24right? So we approached it in the sense
- 1:13:25of like, I don't want to just build a solution that just
- 1:13:27prompt. I don't want to build a solution
- 1:13:29that's only just video driven. I want to build a solution that
- 1:13:32has all those separation of elements, but then I can pick
- 1:13:35and choose how I want to control each of those of elements.
- 1:13:39So that that that was always our goal.
- 1:13:40That's what stayed in 3D space. 3D space is much harder to solve
- 1:13:44than this 2D text to video approach.
- 1:13:46It's read from a research standpoint.
- 1:13:48It's much harder to solve and it takes time and we knew it will
- 1:13:51take time. That's why we approach to that.
- 1:13:52You know, we just had to mark it as like live action because how
- 1:13:55do you explain this back in 2003?
- 1:13:58You're trying to do, you know, like they're like, what are you
- 1:14:00talking about? What's next to video, right.
- 1:14:01So on that side, I think for us, like we're big believers in 3D
- 1:14:05space. That's why Autodesk was such a
- 1:14:08no brainer partnership and acquisition, you know, by us and
- 1:14:10joining the company because they're obviously a leader in
- 1:14:123D. They always have been.
- 1:14:14So for us, we, we, you know, we really want to build this modern
- 1:14:17version of the tools where I can, where I can have very
- 1:14:20intuitive ways of doing it. But I'm such a big believer in
- 1:14:25that 3 dimensionality and separation of elements.
- 1:14:28I think, I think that's crucial right now.
- 1:14:29We're trying to put it all in a like 1 big model or one big
- 1:14:33world model, but that multi modality, it's crucial.
- 1:14:37And I think when you mentioned about having control in the 3D
- 1:14:40space, that is a part I think for artists would be super,
- 1:14:43super powerful and I would put powerful aside.
- 1:14:46It would be super enjoyable to work with.
- 1:14:49I can see for us creating short film while prompting and I can
- 1:14:53see his face after the 10th prompt is like I want control.
- 1:14:56Yeah, I get frustrated. Yeah, I I want to have.
- 1:14:58Control. Yeah, I want to enjoy.
- 1:15:00I want to enjoy creating my creation.
- 1:15:03That's I think one thing that people forget.
- 1:15:05Yes, even if you do text to video or text to movie, you just
- 1:15:09prompt and a movie comes out. But every single artist, when
- 1:15:12they go behind the computer or when they're doing something,
- 1:15:15the joy of actually solving a problem, the joy of actually
- 1:15:18creating, that helps them a lot. That motivates them a lot.
- 1:15:22And I think what you guys envision reduces the friction of
- 1:15:26the labor work or the manual work, but the joy of creation
- 1:15:29will still be there. If there was an award, if there
- 1:15:33was an award for figuring out the way to empower artists and
- 1:15:36not replace them, you guys would probably get that freaking
- 1:15:38award. Well, I appreciate, no, I
- 1:15:40appreciate that we spent I, I'm not going to lie, we spend a lot
- 1:15:43of time on it. Obviously ties, you know, from
- 1:15:45industry me, we had Spielberg on board and Russo brothers.
- 1:15:48So we were like, we got to do it very responsibly.
- 1:15:51But also back to what you said is we, we went through that
- 1:15:57approach and then we said, OK, AI is not going to be able to do
- 1:16:00it all. There's no way.
- 1:16:02So that's why our, our, the way we did it now until we can
- 1:16:05control it all instead of Blue Studio, we said, let me give you
- 1:16:08the 3D files, Let me give you the animation data, Let me give
- 1:16:11you the blender, the Maya, the unreal file.
- 1:16:13So you can go into that scene and, and edit it because it was
- 1:16:16like we didn't want to build a black box.
- 1:16:18That's what my big issue with a lot of tools today is that it's
- 1:16:21a black box. You get results, you try to
- 1:16:23refine, but you're really in a black box.
- 1:16:25So for us, until the I get there, we said, let me give it
- 1:16:29to me in the DCC I'm used to so I can go and push it because you
- 1:16:33know, it's that 2080, right, 8020 rule, right, where you
- 1:16:37know, 80% you can do really quickly, but then 20% takes you
- 1:16:41more than 8080% time. So the, the for, for us, it was
- 1:16:47very important, like, all right, don't build a black box, get to
- 1:16:49all the other. And we learned that as when we
- 1:16:51were doing that close beta, we also did a movie with the Russo
- 1:16:54Brothers. And it's a big budget of film
- 1:16:58and all the artists that worked on it, we worked really closely.
- 1:17:01And we had our artists internally also, but we
- 1:17:04literally went to them and said, OK, here's the output that I'm
- 1:17:09giving you. What other elements do you need?
- 1:17:11Because we're collecting so much with these models, we can open
- 1:17:13it up. And we literally had artists be
- 1:17:15like, OK, great camera track. I need animation data.
- 1:17:17I need you have the lighting compositing for that's great.
- 1:17:20They're like, I need a character pass, I need an alpha mask.
- 1:17:23Give me that. So that's how we decided what
- 1:17:24our exports will be, right? Because it was kind of guided by
- 1:17:27the artist that worked at a really high level.
- 1:17:28And we're like, OK, I understand now.
- 1:17:30If you need to push this to the final pixel, we need that data.
- 1:17:34I think that's what makes your product so special because you
- 1:17:38had it guided by the artists, not blinded by simply just, oh,
- 1:17:43I want to make an AI powered tool or I want to make some
- 1:17:46money. It's more about what do these
- 1:17:47artists actually want on a day-to-day basis.
- 1:17:49We're going to figure out the features based on that, and that
- 1:17:52clearly shows and. I'm going to have to bring you
- 1:17:55to some of my sales meetings. Would love to, would love to
- 1:18:00join, but but also I think it's just exciting what you guys are
- 1:18:03doing, to be honest. That's why we love the podcast,
- 1:18:05because we get to talk to interesting people like
- 1:18:07yourselves and and and pick your brain.
- 1:18:11I do want to. Leave and talk about life,
- 1:18:12meaning of life. And the meaning of life.
- 1:18:14Actually, that's so important. Purpose of life, of course,
- 1:18:16guys, of course it was deep. If you're enjoying this
- 1:18:18conversation, we just wanted to remind you that we come back to
- 1:18:21you every single Tuesday with another episode of the Bad
- 1:18:25Decisions Podcast. It will be available on YouTube,
- 1:18:28Spotify and Apple Podcast. Now back to the conversation.
- 1:18:31I do want to ask like a personal selfish question.
- 1:18:34You. Brought up a book which is
- 1:18:36called Story Structure, right? Yes, story structure, McKee.
- 1:18:41Yes. So for someone who's interested
- 1:18:43in film making, in storytelling, what kind of material do you
- 1:18:46have to recommend to them? Oh yeah, I think learning screen
- 1:18:54writing, if you don't want to be a writer, to me is very helpful
- 1:18:59for any artists, just like they say, like if you want to be a
- 1:19:02good director, you should learn animation.
- 1:19:04I really Spielberg said that because it's like you kind of
- 1:19:06learn the animation, you understand the pace, you
- 1:19:08understand the framing of the camera, you can play in the
- 1:19:11digital world. That's why Jenny is also good
- 1:19:13play in a digital world to learn how to frame a shot.
- 1:19:16So when you go and said you know how to frame a shot, you know
- 1:19:18the pace, etcetera. Being an editor makes you a good
- 1:19:21director. Being a writer makes you a good
- 1:19:23editor. Like when you write your editing
- 1:19:25in your head and you're directing in your head, right.
- 1:19:27So I think for me, I'm a big fan of screen writing.
- 1:19:31I would also say screen writing's so hard.
- 1:19:34I would argue screen writing sometimes could be hard when
- 1:19:36starting a company and this. Is maybe because whoa, whoa, OK,
- 1:19:40no, come on. This is me just being one of
- 1:19:44those perfectionist writers that it's hard to finish the script.
- 1:19:47But no, jokes aside, I'd say like Story Structure by Mickey.
- 1:19:52I swear by it. I think it's one of the best
- 1:19:53books not just for screen writing but also kind of.
- 1:19:55He has some good philosophical message in life.
- 1:19:59Save the Cat also great book for screenwriters.
- 1:20:01A lot of people use it. Hero's Journey.
- 1:20:06That's something a lot of people follow.
- 1:20:10Oh, Down and dirty Pictures. I would read that book.
- 1:20:12Down and Dirty Pictures. Yeah, great, great book.
- 1:20:17It's about Indies in the 90s and how it started the whole kind of
- 1:20:22movement of Tarantino and the first films and how the indie
- 1:20:25broke through. Fascinating read because you can
- 1:20:27kind of see like how how the how the industry change happened
- 1:20:31back then, which is going to happen soon for us with all
- 1:20:34technology advancement. Love that one.
- 1:20:38I mean, just watch a bunch of tutorials on the things you want
- 1:20:40to know, like watch, you know, bad decision podcast.
- 1:20:45Thank you. Thank you.
- 1:20:46Love that. Yeah.
- 1:20:46Yeah. But no seriously, I think I
- 1:20:48learned visual effects when I was 12 years old watching video
- 1:20:51copilot and Andrew Kramer because I couldn't afford a
- 1:20:54camera. But I had Internet connection
- 1:20:56and I would download, you know, through a slow dial up
- 1:20:59connection these tutorials and watch them.
- 1:21:01And that's how that's how I learned early days and visual
- 1:21:04effects, you know, which obviously, you know, became my,
- 1:21:08my kind of life work, you know, but it started as a silly
- 1:21:12tutorial that my father at times said I'm wasting time.
- 1:21:14And why am I constantly online and watching this stupid video?
- 1:21:17You know what I'm saying? So you can't explain to your
- 1:21:20parents what this is. They don't understand that our
- 1:21:22industry has other jobs. Like for them, it's a pipe dream
- 1:21:25and it's a waste of time. And you can't be an artist.
- 1:21:28You know, artists are hungry, you know, you know, the whole
- 1:21:31stereotype, stereotypes. Let me see what else on the
- 1:21:35there's a lot of it. I I know it's escaping me, but
- 1:21:39yeah, these for screen writings I think are amazing.
- 1:21:41And I used to go to a lot of kind of, there's a lot of online
- 1:21:45stuff you can find, you know, conferences.
- 1:21:49I'll say this, one of the best exercise that I've gotten from
- 1:21:52one of my professors on, on trying to learn filmmaking is to
- 1:21:56do this exercise. OK, you got me.
- 1:21:57Remember, watch a movie, but don't just watch it.
- 1:22:01Take a take a sheet of paper, pause every shot, change and
- 1:22:05write what the shot was. So stop it, say OK, wide
- 1:22:09establishing, write what a shot was, and then go cut to this and
- 1:22:14stop the movie. And you're basically are
- 1:22:16exercising directing by watching a movie and breaking down every
- 1:22:20shot to see what frame it is, what the action is in the shot.
- 1:22:23You don't have to go too deep. You could just be like, all
- 1:22:25right, I see what they did. OK, They went from right, they
- 1:22:27went to close up, they went to two shot back to profile.
- 1:22:30Like you'll, you'll start to get the patterns of the of the
- 1:22:33language and the film making language because it's all about
- 1:22:35that juxtaposition of combo of multiple shots.
- 1:22:39Make a sequence that tells you the story and each, you know,
- 1:22:42good director is so good at timing it.
- 1:22:43And then you can write to pay like, you know, 10 seconds on a
- 1:22:46close up. Cut to this, cut to that.
- 1:22:48That exercise is so good. But obviously you can't be lazy
- 1:22:52to do it because like you got to pause the movie and one movie
- 1:22:54will take you 5 five hours. Yes.
- 1:22:56But honestly, it's like that's the beauty of our, of our
- 1:22:59industry is that you can go and rewatch everyone's work and then
- 1:23:02just like analyze it and watch it and analyze it and stop it
- 1:23:05and see, right. And you can reverse engineer it.
- 1:23:07I I do that sometimes in my mind, I do the lazy 1 and it
- 1:23:11doesn't work if the movie is really fast-paced.
- 1:23:13We were watching James Bond the other day and I was watching the
- 1:23:16fight scene. I was like so impressed by
- 1:23:18Casino Royale's fight scene. I was just pausing it one time
- 1:23:22to see how they did the fight scene, just so if you were to
- 1:23:25recreate it in Unreal Engine, I'll know where to place my
- 1:23:27cameras and really sell the effect.
- 1:23:29Especially when you're doing it in 3D, you have similar
- 1:23:31problems. I mean, in real life you kind of
- 1:23:33want to protect the actors. In 3D, my actors hands might be
- 1:23:36like this. I want to hide it.
- 1:23:37So technically speaking, I was trying to break down and decode
- 1:23:42that sequence in my mind. However, I didn't have a sheet
- 1:23:45of paper. But if you do that, what you
- 1:23:47just said, I can imagine how much better you will be at
- 1:23:51storytelling. You didn't have the one film.
- 1:23:54Yes, yeah. One thing I've been fortunate to
- 1:23:56be on some of the cute sets, as fortunate is to shadow, you
- 1:23:59know, some really big film makers.
- 1:24:02And what I learned is big films are nothing but a scale of a
- 1:24:06short film. It's a short film, but on a
- 1:24:09much, much longer and more people, but fundamentally does
- 1:24:13not change. Fundamental doesn't change.
- 1:24:15Fundamental is like, how do you communicate your vision?
- 1:24:18How do you get the actor to do certain things and get them, you
- 1:24:22know, get really that performance from the actor you
- 1:24:25want as a director. And also, you know, balance the,
- 1:24:28the, the take advantage of, of the, of the artistry that the
- 1:24:31actor brings. And then believing in, in, you
- 1:24:35know, in the people you hired. Just like, you know, making a
- 1:24:37company, you want to hire good people.
- 1:24:39Same with the film you want to hire very talented.
- 1:24:42That's what I learned as well as like you sometimes think you
- 1:24:45have to do it all. And then you realize these
- 1:24:47people are just also like, they found the best cinematographer,
- 1:24:49the most talented cinematographer, right?
- 1:24:52The sound mixer is incredible, right?
- 1:24:53The actors, you know, the casting, you know, as Crusaders
- 1:24:56said, it's 80% of your film is casting.
- 1:24:58But it's not just casting actors, like, you know, it's
- 1:25:01casting your crew. So I don't know, I think it's
- 1:25:06easy, as they say, like, you know, if you're a consumer, you
- 1:25:11know, creates to grow, consumed to die.
- 1:25:14It's like I tried to fight that. We all fall in distraught with
- 1:25:17social media. You get in doom scrolling,
- 1:25:19you're just consuming and you're consuming or consuming.
- 1:25:22Creating can be a you can consume as a former creative
- 1:25:26like that exercise. I'm consuming a film, but I'm
- 1:25:28not just like mindlessly consuming.
- 1:25:30I'm actually breaking it down. I'm trying to understand.
- 1:25:33I'm looking into it. And then today there's unlimited
- 1:25:36amount of resources on any, as you mentioned, like fight scene,
- 1:25:38James Bond. You can go online and find
- 1:25:40behind the scenes or a bunch of it.
- 1:25:42You can read forums on it and you know, if you're a young
- 1:25:44person emailed the crap out of these people that worked in
- 1:25:47these films back in the day, they will have coffee or zoom
- 1:25:50with you. I promise you if you bother
- 1:25:52them, if you bother them enough. I always tell people I'm super
- 1:25:55busy, but anybody that emails me 10 times when I'm really busy
- 1:25:58and I have time, I'm like all right, this person is so
- 1:26:00persistent. I'll tell you a story.
- 1:26:02One of my mentor that I mentioned a lot, he's first job,
- 1:26:06he couldn't get to this guy he really wanted to work with and
- 1:26:09he had like $3000 to his name. He ran to the Billboard for one
- 1:26:13day across the guy's office and wrote Dear Mr. My name is would
- 1:26:17love 15 minutes. Of are you serious?
- 1:26:20And that worked, Yeah. That worked.
- 1:26:23He ended up getting job. He ended up getting job with
- 1:26:24him. That's his first job.
- 1:26:26He ended up becoming self-made billionaire, you know, many
- 1:26:29years after. Yeah, this guy's brilliant.
- 1:26:31Bob Schwab, who's been mentoring me.
- 1:26:33So like, that's the creativity in the business aspect.
- 1:26:35It's like he's crazy, you know, put all his money rent
- 1:26:37available. But that guy at the time was
- 1:26:39like, who's this crazy kid that rented a billboard?
- 1:26:42Yeah, let me give him a comment. Let's see who the guy is.
- 1:26:46You have some respect for that person because they're going
- 1:26:48outside. What anybody else would do just
- 1:26:51to try to get your attention. 100% yeah.
- 1:26:54So that's why I say like with young people, like you'd be
- 1:26:56surprised. These people are just busy.
- 1:26:58It's not that they're snobby. They don't want to talk to you.
- 1:27:00They're busy. So find a way to bother and be
- 1:27:02persistent. Be be respectful, but be
- 1:27:04persistent. You know, like it's like the
- 1:27:06Instagram people that like say day one of you know, trying to
- 1:27:10get a. Oh yeah, day one of emailing
- 1:27:12Nicolla to get a response. This is day two of them.
- 1:27:15If you get a shit ton of e-mail after this that's don't blame us
- 1:27:19bro, not. At all.
- 1:27:21Not at all. That's fucking insane.
- 1:27:23You're absolutely right about it.
- 1:27:24I love that you shared that story because it just shows that
- 1:27:27if you're persistent, if you want it bad enough, you can get
- 1:27:31it. You might piss some people off
- 1:27:32along the way, but it doesn't really matter.
- 1:27:34I mean at the end of the day you have your personal goal and be
- 1:27:36selfish about it. 100% yeah, put your put yourself first in that
- 1:27:41goal in a sense of like obviously be respectful, but
- 1:27:44sometimes we care too much about like I already emailed that
- 1:27:47person. I want to double e-mail them,
- 1:27:49but you don't realize. I realize it now how busy
- 1:27:54insanely you can get and you can miss it.
- 1:27:55When I was younger, I saw that as a sign like I'm just not good
- 1:28:00enough. I'm not there yet.
- 1:28:01I'm imposter syndrome. I shouldn't bother these people
- 1:28:04and you know, I'm wasting their time.
- 1:28:06But then you realize no, like, you know, it's like they're
- 1:28:09either too busy or they actually want to see you, you know, not
- 1:28:12be that easy for you if they want to figure out another way
- 1:28:15of you to do it. And I will always even in hiring
- 1:28:19when I had people I hire like that someone who's so
- 1:28:22persistent, then I'm like, OK, this person really cares.
- 1:28:25Because also I would rather hire someone that really cares so
- 1:28:28much versus someone that is like, you know, I have 10 other
- 1:28:33options. Sell it to me.
- 1:28:35I don't know if I'm into this, but like convince me.
- 1:28:37And I'm like, I'm no, if you're not passionate about it.
- 1:28:40One of the questions I always ask in interviews, I say, if
- 1:28:43money is no issue, you know, what's your dream job?
- 1:28:46What would you do? It's a stupid question, right?
- 1:28:48But I really see they tell me about their passion and it
- 1:28:50doesn't have to be like, oh, my passion is to work for wonder
- 1:28:53dynamics or other desk. No, as long as they mention
- 1:28:55something that's in the creative field, I'm like, yes, this
- 1:28:57person care about solving this problem or they care about this.
- 1:29:00That's great. That aligns right in a sense.
- 1:29:03So always because money you can, you can motivate with money.
- 1:29:07You can motivate with stock options, but you cannot motivate
- 1:29:10and recreate passion, right? And I'm not I'm not like trying
- 1:29:13to say like, oh, you're going to just work for passion.
- 1:29:15You know, you got to get crap and sell.
- 1:29:16You just work for passion. No, no, obviously you'll need to
- 1:29:19be super cappy with your package and financially stable,
- 1:29:22etcetera. But you know, two people at the
- 1:29:25same level and this person has a lot of passion for they do.
- 1:29:28That person is going to fight through those days when you
- 1:29:30everybody wants to quit, quit, right?
- 1:29:32That's what you want. Exactly, dude, absolutely, man.
- 1:29:35It's you. You can train skills, but you
- 1:29:38cannot train character. I'm not your parents, I'm not
- 1:29:41here to, I'm not trying to teach you how to behave and you know,
- 1:29:44to be interested in a specific thing.
- 1:29:46And that's why for us as well, hiring has been difficult.
- 1:29:50I'm going to be honest, I'm going to look at you.
- 1:29:52I know you're Farah's handling most of that and I I can see the
- 1:29:56pain in his eyes when you're mentioning.
- 1:29:57What do you realize after you go through a lot of people is that
- 1:30:00you really want to look at the character.
- 1:30:03Initially you start looking at skills and resume all that.
- 1:30:06I've done this, I've done that, I have this amount of
- 1:30:07experience. But then you start hiring those
- 1:30:09people. But then it comes to character.
- 1:30:11You realize people who actually have a very good character, who
- 1:30:14are passionate, who are curious. Those are the one who actually
- 1:30:17go and learn something that they don't know, and they solve the
- 1:30:19problems that you never thought is going to be fixed. 100
- 1:30:23percent, 100%. And I think I had this also.
- 1:30:29OK, this is the start up mode. So I can tell you what our
- 1:30:32approach was. I had a trick as the final
- 1:30:34trick. I had a trick because we start
- 1:30:36up, we're getting stock options. I would offer people higher
- 1:30:39salary, lower stock options, or a little bit less of a salary,
- 1:30:44small, small amount, but more stock options.
- 1:30:48Everybody that went to lower stock options but a little bit
- 1:30:53higher salary, even if it's like a hundred $200 more on a monthly
- 1:30:56level, it didn't work out. It really didn't work out.
- 1:30:59So I used that as the final Test, usually when I in the.
- 1:31:02Community. Yeah, no, really, it's like, it
- 1:31:06it it was very consistent with that.
- 1:31:08And that that that kind of helps me that that test helped me
- 1:31:11understand it. I was like, OK, yeah.
- 1:31:13Because, yeah. Like, if you don't have someone
- 1:31:15who believes I've been on film sets where half of the crew is
- 1:31:18like, yeah, this. This.
- 1:31:20This movie is garbage. Yeah.
- 1:31:22Yeah. There's so many films where,
- 1:31:23yeah, I mean, because the crew has to make a living, right?
- 1:31:25So they can't pick and choose only films they believe in,
- 1:31:29right? Like especially these days, man,
- 1:31:30so many people are out of out of work and you know, in
- 1:31:33entertainment industry, unfortunately, because there's
- 1:31:35not enough being filmed, especially here now, right?
- 1:31:38So you can't go and pick only what you what you want.
- 1:31:41But in a tech space, in tech space, you have more, you know,
- 1:31:45like I can pick what you know, what I believe in.
- 1:31:47And when you have a team that half of them don't believe in
- 1:31:50what you're building, I can guarantee you it's going to be
- 1:31:52much harder for the other half. That was 11 and the other one I
- 1:31:55had was I always ask yourself a question or we spend so much
- 1:31:58time at work, right? So much of our life time.
- 1:32:01I've always said like let's not hire people.
- 1:32:02We've had no asshole policy. But we also said because you
- 1:32:06know you need one toxic person to ruin self.
- 1:32:08Ruin everything? Yes.
- 1:32:09Easy. It happens.
- 1:32:10It happens, right? But we also said, OK, will,
- 1:32:15will, will we want to hang out with this person after hours?
- 1:32:18And will the rest of the team want to go out and get a beer
- 1:32:20with this person? And if the answer is no, we
- 1:32:22wouldn't hire them. And it's so important.
- 1:32:25It's so important because it's, it's kind of like accountability
- 1:32:28thing because you know, like our team is so close, you know, they
- 1:32:32go, they're getting, they'll hang out, they spend a lot of
- 1:32:34time together because, you know, when 1 is relying on another,
- 1:32:37they're not doing it because Oniko is going, you know, get
- 1:32:39mad and yell at us. They're like, I don't want to, I
- 1:32:42don't want to mess this guy up because I really care about this
- 1:32:44person. Let me make sure we achieve this
- 1:32:46well, because it's not just me, it's it's, it's her, it's him
- 1:32:49right on the side. So.
- 1:32:51Well, thank you so much for sharing that because it it
- 1:32:54matters a lot, not just to us because we are actually in the
- 1:32:57hiring phase, but I think a lot of artists also have to deal
- 1:33:00with that at some point. A lot of artists are trying to
- 1:33:04bring in a team together so they can create something.
- 1:33:06And it's very important to find the right people.
- 1:33:08And I think all of the things that you mentioned before this
- 1:33:11can help people find that. Nicola, I have to say, this
- 1:33:15conversation has been absolutely incredible.
- 1:33:18We are so honored to have you. It's been insane.
- 1:33:22And we want to say thank you for one, supporting us on Discord on
- 1:33:26day one when you guys launched. And you know, to this day,
- 1:33:30having this conversation, it's been a pleasure.
- 1:33:33Likewise, man, no, it's been so great following you guys and the
- 1:33:35journey you guys been into. I've been a big fan.
- 1:33:38I'm glad we got to find a time to do this and thanks for
- 1:33:41letting me talk philosophy, you know, I need it, you know, just
- 1:33:43stuck it over work, you know, so.
- 1:33:46No, we can't wait to do this podcast in person with you and
- 1:33:49hopefully we will meet one day again like in Dubai, LA.
- 1:33:52Wherever we do, we do the next episode in.
- 1:33:54Person, I need an excuse to go to Dubai, you know, so.
- 1:33:56So let's make that happen. Yes, yes we will.
- 1:33:59We will take you around as long as I get my tennis lesson.
- 1:34:03You said that already. I gotta I gotta try that.
- 1:34:07Dear, dear dear. I love it.
- 1:34:08Thank you again guys, so good seeing you.
- 1:34:10Absolutely, man. Thank you so much.
- 1:34:11And for everybody watching and listening, thank you so much.
- 1:34:14We'll see you guys on the next episode.
- 1:34:15Until then, Ciao. Thank you guys so much for
- 1:34:19watching and listening to another episode of the Bad
- 1:34:21Decisions podcast. Our goal is to bring this
- 1:34:24conversation in front of millions of people, and
- 1:34:27therefore we have one little request from you because if this
- 1:34:30conversation helped you, then you can help other people hear
- 1:34:34it too. The way you can help is by
- 1:34:36leaving a five star review on Spotify and Apple Podcast and
- 1:34:39follow us on Spotify and YouTube.
- 1:34:42That's it. We'll see you guys next week on
- 1:34:44Tuesday. Thank you.