Latest / The Psychology Undergrad Podcast / The Debate Over What Counts as Mental Illness
Transcript
- 0:00Welcome to the psychology undergrad. So usually,
- 0:04you know, when we talk about a medical diagnosis,
- 0:06there is this expectation of absolute precision.
- 0:09Oh, yeah, like total certainty. Right. Think
- 0:12about an x -ray for a broken leg. You look at
- 0:15the film, you see that jagged white line right
- 0:17across the tibia, and the doctor just points
- 0:19at it and says, you know, there it is. That is
- 0:21the problem. It's binary. Like, it's either broken
- 0:24or it's not. It's clean. And frankly, I mean,
- 0:27it is deeply comforting. As humans, we desperately
- 0:30want things to be visible. We want our suffering
- 0:32to be neatly categorized. Absolutely. But step
- 0:36into the world of human behavior, neurodevelopment
- 0:38and psychological distress, and suddenly, well,
- 0:41suddenly that X -ray machine is completely useless.
- 0:44Yeah, it really is. We are looking at a diagnostic
- 0:47landscape that is incredibly murky. So, for today's
- 0:50discussion, we are stepping fully into our roles
- 0:52as two passionate psychology undergraduate students,
- 0:55and we're grappling directly with the foundational
- 0:57texts and theories of our field. And the central
- 0:59question we are tackling today is massive. I
- 1:02mean, how should we actually conceptualize and
- 1:04treat so -called abnormal behavior? Right. Is
- 1:07psychopathology a measurable biological reality
- 1:10that is best categorized by the DSM -5 and treated
- 1:13with medical interventions? Or is abnormality
- 1:16simply a social construction, like... a humanistic
- 1:18response to oppressive environmental conditions.
- 1:21Well, I will be arguing for the biological model
- 1:24and the objective clinical utility of the DSM
- 1:26-5. My position is that psychological disorders
- 1:29have real physiological roots that require structured
- 1:32diagnosis and medical treatment. Okay, and I
- 1:35will be arguing for the postmodern social constructionist
- 1:38and humanistic view. I plan to make the case
- 1:40that mental illness labels are highly subjective
- 1:43constructs and that... You know, what we call
- 1:45abnormal is often just a natural reaction to
- 1:47an unhealthy world. We have to start with the
- 1:50physical reality of the human brain, though.
- 1:52I mean, abnormal behavior isn't just a philosophical
- 1:55abstraction. It is neurochemistry. It is genetics.
- 1:58Well, sure, biology plays a part, but... But
- 2:01because of that, the Diagnostic and Statistical
- 2:03Manual of Mental Disorders, the DSM -5, is an
- 2:06absolutely essential tool. And for our fellow
- 2:08undergrads looking for a memory aid for the exam...
- 2:10Think of the DSM -5 as the Dictionary of Symptoms
- 2:13and Medicine. The Dictionary of Symptoms and
- 2:16Medicine. Okay, I like that. Right. It gives
- 2:19professionals a standardized language. You need
- 2:21that language to diagnose accurately, to bill
- 2:24insurance so people can actually afford care,
- 2:26and to formulate targeted biological treatments.
- 2:29I mean, I understand the appeal of a dictionary,
- 2:31but I see the act of defining human behavior
- 2:33very differently. But consider how humans develop
- 2:36their belief systems, right? Specifically through
- 2:38James Fowler's theory of faith development. Oh,
- 2:41okay, bringing in Fowler. Yeah, look at his mythic
- 2:43literal faith, which is stage two. A person in
- 2:45stage two relies on structured, rule -based,
- 2:48and literal truths provided by an authority figure
- 2:50to make sense of the world. Why? Because the
- 2:52unknown is terrifying. Right, they need that
- 2:54safety. Exactly. There is a profound psychological
- 2:57safety in having a doctor give a tangible name
- 3:00to your invisible pain. Just as a person in stage
- 3:03two needs that concrete structure to navigate
- 3:04morality, the medical model relies on strict
- 3:07diagnostic criteria to make sense of the sheer
- 3:09chaos of human suffering. It organizes complexity
- 3:12into actionable, treatable reality. But, okay,
- 3:15but what if that structure is a complete illusion?
- 3:17I look at this through the lens of Carl Rogers'
- 3:20humanistic approach and postmodernism. From this
- 3:23perspective, abnormal behavior isn't a biological
- 3:27defect at all. You don't think so? No. I mean,
- 3:30it is actually a natural, healthy response to
- 3:32an unhealthy environment that places conditions
- 3:35of worth on a person. Conditions of worth, right.
- 3:38Yeah. When society or your parents tell you that
- 3:41you're only worthy of love if you act a certain
- 3:43way, you disconnect from your true self in order
- 3:45to survive. That resulting disconnection is exactly
- 3:48what the medical model pathologizes. But you
- 3:51cannot just ignore the severe biological symptoms
- 3:53that accompany that distress, though. You are
- 3:55assuming those symptoms represent a universal
- 3:57truth. Postmodernism is like a kaleidoscope.
- 4:02Think about how a kaleidoscope actually works.
- 4:04Inside the tube, you have these little unchanging
- 4:07pieces of colored glass. Those represent human
- 4:09behaviors, emotions, and traits. They just exist.
- 4:13But the mirrors inside the tube, those represent
- 4:15society's rules, expectations, and cultural norms.
- 4:18OK, I follow you. So when you turn the dial,
- 4:21the pieces of glass don't change, but the mirrors
- 4:23shift. Suddenly, the exact same behaviors are
- 4:25reflected differently. one configuration is deemed
- 4:28beautiful or normal. You turn the dial to a different
- 4:31era or culture, the mirrors shift, and that exact
- 4:34same configuration is labeled chaotic or abnormal.
- 4:37The abnormality isn't in the person, it's in
- 4:40the mirrors. But that implies diagnosis is entirely
- 4:43arbitrary. It often is. I mean, if we link this
- 4:46back to Fowler's frameworks, my view aligns much
- 4:49closer to conjunctive faith stage five, or universalizing
- 4:52faith stage six. The later stages. Right. These
- 4:55advanced stages embrace multiple realities and
- 4:58paradoxes. They recognize that the map is not
- 5:00the territory. To illustrate just how arbitrary
- 5:04the map can be, think of the color therapy analogy
- 5:07from our text. Oh, right. The color analogy.
- 5:09Yeah. Imagine a society where liking the color
- 5:12red means you are mentally healthy. And liking
- 5:14blue means you are mentally ill. If you prefer
- 5:17blue, doctors diagnose you, they drug you, and
- 5:19try to force you to like red. It sounds absurd,
- 5:22but that is exactly how socially constructed
- 5:25diagnostic labels operate. They enforce conformity.
- 5:28I mean, come on. The DSM -5 is not some rigid
- 5:31draconian color wheel enforcing conformity. Isn't
- 5:34it? No, it is a living, evolving document that
- 5:37reflects our best scientific understanding. Its
- 5:40evolution proves that it is self -correcting.
- 5:42For instance, the shift in the DSM -5 to a single
- 5:45-axis system was revolutionary. Removing the
- 5:47axes, yeah. Right. By removing the old axis too,
- 5:50it stripped away the stigma of placing personality
- 5:53disorders and intellectual disabilities in a
- 5:55separate, isolated category. That old system
- 5:58falsely implied they were untreatable character
- 6:00flaws. Okay, but stripping away one layer of
- 6:03stigma doesn't excuse the fact that the entire
- 6:05system is built on categorizing and patholizing
- 6:07human deviants. But the modern system explicitly
- 6:10captures context. The DSM -5 uses Z -codes to
- 6:13account for psychosocial and environmental concerns.
- 6:16Z -codes are just a band -aid. A Z -code isn't
- 6:18just a footnote. It is an actual alphanumeric
- 6:21code entered into a patient's medical file. If
- 6:23a clinician uses Z59 .0, they are formally diagnosing
- 6:26homelessness. They are legally and medically
- 6:29documenting that the patient's environment is
- 6:31a primary factor. Okay, but... And furthermore,
- 6:33the manual includes dimensional assessments like
- 6:35the HOODIS 2 .0, the World Health Organization
- 6:37Disability Assessment Schedule. It doesn't just
- 6:39ask if you feel sad. It asks about your practical
- 6:42mechanism of living. Can you get dressed? Can
- 6:45you maintain a friendship? It forces the clinician
- 6:47to measure functional disability, capturing the
- 6:49whole picture of a patient's reality. Listen,
- 6:51no matter how many Z codes you add to the file,
- 6:54the foundational act of diagnosing remains dangerous.
- 6:58Have you considered the famous 1973 Rosenhand
- 7:00study on being sane in insane places? The hospital
- 7:04study, yeah. Right. Researchers sent completely
- 7:06healthy fake patients into psychiatric hospitals.
- 7:09Their only symptom was claiming they heard a
- 7:11voice say the word, thud. That was it. And because
- 7:14of the error, they were admitted. They were institutionalized
- 7:16and diagnosed with schizophrenia. But the real
- 7:19dangers would happen after the diagnosis. Once
- 7:21they were labeled, the mechanism of a self -fulfilling
- 7:24prophecy took over. Which means everything they
- 7:26did was viewed as a symptom. Exactly. Every normal
- 7:29behavior they exhibited was pathologized. When
- 7:32the researchers took notes on their clipboards,
- 7:34the hospital staff documented it as patient engages
- 7:36in writing behavior, like a supposed symptom
- 7:39of their compulsive illness. Thomas Sassen, our
- 7:42dealing, argued this beautifully. Mental illness
- 7:44is often a normal response to stressful, oppressive
- 7:47social forces. Well, William Glasser talked about
- 7:50that, too. Yes. Glasser viewed these so -called
- 7:53pathologies simply as a client's clumsy attempt
- 7:55to meet their basic human needs. When you slap
- 7:57a label on someone, you enforce tunnel vision
- 8:00on the clinician. Everything the patient does
- 8:02is viewed through the lens of the disease. Okay,
- 8:04but the Rose and Hinstedi was a product of the
- 8:06early 70s, when diagnostic criteria were incredibly
- 8:09vague. The modern DSM -5 requires rigorous, sustained
- 8:13symptoms over time. But what is the alternative
- 8:15here? Let me go back to my x -ray analogy. Okay,
- 8:18let's hear it. If someone is suffering from acute,
- 8:21paralyzing depression, you cannot just start
- 8:22physical therapy, which in this case is counseling,
- 8:25until you accurately diagnose the fracture and
- 8:27provide a cast. In psychiatry, that cast is often
- 8:30medication. Without the diagnostic label, we
- 8:33are treating blindly. If we don't name the disorder,
- 8:35how do we research it? How do we know which interventions
- 8:38actually work? But the moment you accept that
- 8:40rigid diagnostic label, it dictates the treatment.
- 8:43If you label a complex human emotion as a biological
- 8:46disease, the only logical next step is a chemical
- 8:49cure. Which brings us to psychopharmacology.
- 8:53The problem with your broken leg analogy is that
- 8:55a bone is a physical object you can see. True.
- 8:57The mind is not. Contextual healing is what people
- 9:00need, not chemical casts. But the empirical evidence
- 9:03for psychopharmacology is undeniable. Because
- 9:06many of these disorders have proven genetic roots,
- 9:09biological interventions aren't just an option.
- 9:11I mean, they are a necessity. A necessity? Yes.
- 9:14Look at the efficacy of SSRIs for major depressive
- 9:17disorder. When a patient is in the throes of
- 9:19a severe episode, when their neurochemistry is
- 9:22so depleted they cannot physically get out of
- 9:24bed, talk therapy is impossible. Medications
- 9:26rapidly stabilize the brain's neurochemistry.
- 9:29If they work as intended. Right. In for our fellow
- 9:32undergrads, I use the acronym AMAAS to track
- 9:35the five pillars of this stabilization. Antipsychotics
- 9:38and mood stabilizers create that essential baseline
- 9:40for severe conditions like schizophrenia or bipolar
- 9:42disorder. Then you have antidepressants and anti
- 9:45-anxiety agents to regulate serotonin and GABA.
- 9:47And finally, stimulants. Ah, stimulants. Which
- 9:51we hand out constantly to children who simply
- 9:53have trouble sitting still in a classroom designed
- 9:55for compliance. But look at how they work. It
- 9:58seems paradoxical to give a hyperactive person
- 10:00a stimulant, but we have to understand the biological
- 10:02mechanism. ADHD isn't an overactive brain. It
- 10:06is an understimulated frontal lobe. Right, the
- 10:09dopamine deficiency. Exactly. The brain is starved
- 10:12for dopamine, so the person is constantly moving,
- 10:15constantly seeking external input to stimulate
- 10:17themselves. The medication provides that dopamine,
- 10:20wakes up the brain's executive function, and
- 10:21allows them to self -regulate. That isn't enforcing
- 10:24compliance. That is giving someone control over
- 10:26their own mind. You focus on the intended effects,
- 10:29but you are completely glossing over the mechanism
- 10:31of the side effects. We are talking about extrapyramidal
- 10:34symptoms, or EPS. Well, obviously side effects
- 10:37exist. But they are severe. When you use antipsychotics
- 10:40to block dopamine receptors in the brain to stop
- 10:42hallucinations, you are also blocking dopamine
- 10:44in the basal ganglia, which controls movement.
- 10:47That causes severe muscle spasms and motor restlessness.
- 10:50Prolonged use leads to tardive dyskinesia, involuntary
- 10:53movements of the face and tongue that can persist
- 10:55long after the drug is stopped. The medical model
- 10:58treats the symptom, but it often poisons the
- 11:00patient's nervous system in the process. Every
- 11:02medical intervention has risks. But you have
- 11:05to admit, the risk of untreated severe mental
- 11:07illness is far greater. I disagree. The medical
- 11:10model loses the person in the pursuit of treating
- 11:12the biology. Look at the tragic story of Ellen
- 11:14West from our textbook. Carl Rogers discussed
- 11:17her case to highlight exactly this failure. Her
- 11:20story is really heartbreaking. It is. She was
- 11:23a woman who felt a profound emptiness. She was
- 11:26forced by her family to abandon the man she loved
- 11:28to marry someone else. Her severe eating disorders,
- 11:31including taking up to 60 laxatives a day, were
- 11:34a desperate, agonizing attempt to assert control
- 11:37of her life that had been entirely co -opted
- 11:39by others' conditions of worth. Which, I would
- 11:42argue, is a severe psychiatric emergency requiring
- 11:45immediate medical intervention. But how did the
- 11:47medical model actually respond? A parade of dispassionate
- 11:51doctors examined her. They diagnosed her with
- 11:53melancholia, then severe obsessive neurosis,
- 11:56and finally schizophrenia. Because they were
- 11:58trying to find the right treatment. No, they
- 12:00debated the labels endlessly. But they completely
- 12:03ignored her subjective reality, her soul, her
- 12:06true self. The diagnoses just isolated her further.
- 12:10She eventually died by suicide because he was
- 12:12treated as a biological puzzle to be solved instead
- 12:15of a suffering human being who needed to be seen.
- 12:17She didn't need a chemical cast. She needed contextual
- 12:20healing. Ellen West's story is undoubtedly tragic.
- 12:25However, it underscores why we need more precise
- 12:27medical and psychiatric care, not an abandonment
- 12:30of it. Her doctors failed because they lacked
- 12:32the sophisticated diagnostic and pharmacological
- 12:35tools we have today. I question the universality
- 12:37of the models that prescribe those tools, though.
- 12:40The biological model, and the DSM historically,
- 12:43operates on the assumption that what is normal
- 12:46in Western male -centric society is biologically
- 12:49universal for all humans. It is inherently biased.
- 12:53I mean, the field has evolved significantly past
- 12:55that. Has it? Think about developmental psychology.
- 12:59Carol Gilligan famously criticized Lawrence Kohlberg's
- 13:01theory of moral development for this exact reason.
- 13:04Oh, the ethics of care versus justice orientation.
- 13:07Yes. Kuhlberg studied mostly boys and concluded
- 13:10that the highest stage of moral development was
- 13:13based on an individualistic justice orientation,
- 13:16you know, focusing on rules and individual rights.
- 13:19Gilligan pointed out that women often operate
- 13:21from an ethics of care, prioritizing relationships,
- 13:25interconnectedness, and empathy. Right. His model
- 13:27was cute. Colbrigg's model pathologized or undervalued
- 13:31the female perspective simply because it didn't
- 13:32match his male baseline. The DSM has historically
- 13:36done the exact same thing to non -Western cultures,
- 13:39labeling perfectly normal cultural expressions
- 13:41of distress as psychiatric anomalies. That used
- 13:45to be true, but the authors of the DSM -5 explicitly
- 13:48recognized the danger of cultural bias and implemented
- 13:50a mechanism to correct it, the Cultural Formulation
- 13:53Interview, or the CFI. The CFI, yeah. This isn't
- 13:56just a suggestion. It provides clinicians with
- 13:58a structured method to understand the values,
- 14:01experiences, and influences that shape a client's
- 14:03specific worldview. And a good way for our listeners
- 14:05to remember this is the phrase culture filters
- 14:08in, C -F -I. It ensures that the client's cultural
- 14:12context filters directly into the diagnostic
- 14:14process. I appreciate that culture filters in,
- 14:17Mnemonic, I really do, but does an interview
- 14:19guide really change the rigid diagnostic codes?
- 14:22It absolutely shapes how they are applied. The
- 14:25DSM -5 now officially recognizes culturally patterned
- 14:27symptoms. Take a taque de nervios, which translates
- 14:30to an attack of nerves in Latin American cultures.
- 14:33Okay, let's look at that. If a Western clinician
- 14:35sees someone experiencing sudden shouting, uncontrollable
- 14:38crying, trembling, and a feeling of heat in the
- 14:41chest after a family funeral, their rigid training
- 14:43might lead them to misdiagnose a panic disorder
- 14:45or even a brief psychotic break. But the DSM
- 14:48-5 explicitly contextualizes this. It explains
- 14:51that this is a recognized, culturally sanctioned
- 14:53expression of acute distress. It is not a pathology
- 14:55in that context. The medical model is highly
- 14:58capable of evolving to include subjective cultural
- 15:00realities. Identifying a cultural syndrome as
- 15:03a recognized exception still implies that the
- 15:06Western diagnostic criteria are the default standard
- 15:09of human reality. It still operates on a fundamental
- 15:12power dynamic. How so? The clinician retains
- 15:15the ultimate authority to define reality for
- 15:17the client, rather than co -constructing reality
- 15:20with them through language and narrative, which
- 15:22is what the postmodern approach demands. The
- 15:25mirrors in the kaleidoscope are still being controlled
- 15:27by the psychiatric establishment. Well, let's
- 15:30summarize where we've landed on this. From my
- 15:32perspective, the necessity of the biological
- 15:34model, the diagnostic clarity of the DSM -5,
- 15:37and the targeted use of psychopharmacology are
- 15:40indispensable. When someone is in acute distress,
- 15:43when their neurochemistry is actively working
- 15:45against their survival, we need a structured
- 15:48empirical system. We need the dictionary of symptoms
- 15:51in medicine to provide effective standardized
- 15:53relief. Without the medical model, we are leaving
- 15:56the most vulnerable people to navigate a hurricane
- 15:58without a compass. And to summarize my stance,
- 16:02the humanistic and postmodern imperative is that
- 16:04we must treat the person, not the label. When
- 16:07we rely too heavily on the DSM and medications,
- 16:09we risk treating the biological symptom while
- 16:12completely ignoring the oppressive social, cultural,
- 16:14and environmental forces that actually shape
- 16:16the behavior. We must remember that reality is
- 16:19a kaleidoscope. We have to honor the subjective
- 16:22narrative of the soul, ensuring we don't inflict
- 16:24harm to rigid, stigmatizing diagnoses that force
- 16:27conformity. You know, despite our deep philosophical
- 16:31differences, I think we both completely agree
- 16:33on the ultimate goal, the alleviation of human
- 16:36suffering. Oh, absolutely. We are just fundamentally
- 16:39divided on the mechanism. Are we best serving
- 16:41humanity by treating the biological hardware
- 16:43of the brain or by deeply engaging with the narrative
- 16:46software of the soul? And perhaps the most mature
- 16:48way to view this tension is through the lens
- 16:51of developmental psychologist Robert Keegan.
- 16:54He describes the highest level of cognitive development
- 16:56as the interindividual stage. In this stage,
- 16:59a person is capable of holding multiple, even
- 17:02seemingly contradictory, truths simultaneously.
- 17:05They can embrace the paradox without needing
- 17:07to resolve it into a simple binary. Right. An
- 17:10interindividual thinker can acknowledge that
- 17:12a person might have a severe biologically driven
- 17:14chemical imbalance that requires an SSRI. while
- 17:17simultaneously recognizing that their depression
- 17:19is deeply exacerbated by a toxic, socially constructed
- 17:23environment that requires humanistic narrative
- 17:25therapy. Both realities can coexist. Exactly.
- 17:28There is so much more to explore in this source
- 17:30material regarding human development, diagnosis,
- 17:34and the way we construct reality. We aren't going
- 17:37to declare a winner here today. As developing
- 17:39psychology undergrads, our job isn't to shut
- 17:42down the debate, but to let the tension between
- 17:44these perspectives sharpen our own clinical judgment.
- 17:47We leave it to you, our listeners, to draw your
- 17:49own conclusions. But the next time you look at
- 17:52human behavior, ask yourself, are you staring
- 17:55at a jagged white line on an x -ray, or are you
- 17:58trying to read a map in a city where the streets
- 18:00are constantly shifting? Thanks for joining us
- 18:03on this edition of The Psychology Undergrad.
- 18:06Keep questioning the text.