Latest / I Love You Keep Going with George Haas / When 'having it all' feels empty. What gives? Pt. 2
Transcript
- 0:01You're listening to the I Love You, Keep Going podcast with
- 0:04George Haas. For more information, please
- 0:06visit our website at www.medigroup.org.
- 0:10That's www.m ETTAGROU p.org. So welcome everybody.
- 0:22This is I love you keep going. It is August 15th, 2024.
- 0:28It's 7:38 PM Pacific Daylight Time, and what I wanted to talk
- 0:34about was the the feeling of having arrived at the end of
- 0:40your goal, but it it not meaning much to you when you get there.
- 0:45And really what this is a the conversation around secondary
- 0:50and primary exploration, but it is also a conversation about how
- 0:55much pressure to achieve you received when you were a child
- 1:00and what that pressure was really about in the beginning of
- 1:05exploration. There's an encouragement that we
- 1:10require to really develop the capacity, which is when it when
- 1:17it really begins. You might say that the the
- 1:22origin of it is at around 18 months old, although there's
- 1:27lots of things that happened before that.
- 1:29But at about that age, you developed the capacity to
- 1:34recognize that you actually have an agenda that is independent of
- 1:39your caregiver's agenda and that there are things that you like
- 1:43to pursue and investigate that's different from theirs.
- 1:47And in a collaborative relationship with a caregiver,
- 1:51you learn to make accommodations for your caregiver's agenda and
- 1:59they make accommodations for you.
- 2:01An example of that might be you say that you're hungry and then
- 2:06your caregiver says, let me make you something.
- 2:08And you recognize that the gesture of them making something
- 2:13for you will take a certain steps in order to say, make a
- 2:18sandwich. And and you'll recognize that
- 2:23they've understood what your request was and now you have to
- 2:27wait for them to be able to make the sandwich and give it to you
- 2:30before you can eat it. Is that making sense?
- 2:34But this is also true of the kind of exploration that you
- 2:39might like to do. So at about a year old, you get
- 2:48enough strength in your legs to stand up on twos, but you don't
- 2:52really have much of A sense of balance.
- 2:55There's a period of crawling, of course, where you can get around
- 2:58pretty quickly. Lucy is barking.
- 3:03I'm gonna put her outside. Lucy, you can't.
- 3:28Yeah, Lucy's having trouble collaborating with my agenda to
- 3:35give this talk. Close the door.
- 3:44Yeah, we don't hear her at all actually.
- 3:47You don't? Nope.
- 3:49All right, I'll let her back in the sometimes Lucy decides that
- 4:04there's a mouse. She proceeds to track it, which
- 4:08is the current phase we're in. The way that a child expresses
- 4:20the things that matter to them, to their caregiver, which is a
- 4:23process of learning to explore. The child goes out and finds
- 4:27something. They gather it and they bring it
- 4:29back to the caregiver and they show it to the caregiver with an
- 4:33expression of their interest in it.
- 4:36And then depending on how the caregiver reacts to that, are
- 4:39they engaged? Are they delighted that the
- 4:42child has done this? Are they curious about what the
- 4:45child has brought? Are there, are they interested
- 4:49in the child's explanation about what it was that was appealing,
- 4:53about the thing that they found? Do they then give it back to the
- 4:56child and then encourage the child to go off and find
- 5:00something else? This is the process of that Or
- 5:07does something else happen and, and kids who are neglected, the
- 5:10the the parents are not interested really in what the
- 5:13child discovers or they don't want the child to explore in the
- 5:18way that the child explores in their directive of what the
- 5:21child should be paying attention to.
- 5:24And sometimes the there can be a shaming aspect to that.
- 5:32The, the, the, the things that the child expresses hold on
- 5:59the other day, Lucy ran full speed into the screen door and
- 6:08knocked it off of its, its wheels and, and, and actually
- 6:15probably hurt herself in doing it and was very surprised that
- 6:19it, that it was there at all. And now she's very apprehensive
- 6:21about coming in and out of doors.
- 6:23And you, you almost have to take her through them because she
- 6:25can't figure it out yet. So part of this process of
- 6:40exploration is being encouraged to go and find something out,
- 6:43finding it out, and then coming back and expressing what you
- 6:47find out to the caregiver. In the beginning, Obviously it's
- 6:51the caregiver in secure systems that the interest of the child
- 7:00is really celebrated with a sense of delight and in insecure
- 7:04and disorganized detachment outcomes.
- 7:07That isn't what happens. Often with dismissing people.
- 7:11You'll notice that the primary exploration is hidden.
- 7:14They don't really express it to anyone because there's some
- 7:19aspect of it being devalued in the family system.
- 7:24And in order to preserve it, they keep it private so that
- 7:32when they form relationships with other people, that primary
- 7:35aspect of the exploration is not expressed in the relationship.
- 7:41And there isn't been a process of normalizing the the pursuit
- 7:45of those particular ideas. And so they can be associated
- 7:51with the anticipation of rejection or an anticipation of
- 7:55shame. If they are expressed in people
- 7:59who grow up to be preoccupied, the the exploration is inhibited
- 8:04quite a bit. So whereas people who grew up to
- 8:08be dismissing can explore and and do explore, people who are
- 8:12preoccupied tended to be quite inhibited around this.
- 8:18And that comes in two directions. 1 is that the
- 8:23caregiver requires the proximity of the child, and so each time
- 8:27that the child tends intends to make a foray to discover
- 8:31something that the caregiver interferes.
- 8:34It's often coached in language of protection.
- 8:37It's too dangerous to do that. You have to stay close.
- 8:40I I don't that doesn't seem like a good thing.
- 8:49Another aspect is that the child recognizes that the parent is
- 8:56dependent on them for emotional regulation, and if the child
- 9:00separates from the caregiver and they returned, the caregiver can
- 9:05be in a state of emotional dysregulation that is more than
- 9:09the child can manage. And so the child becomes
- 9:11inhibited from separating from the caregiver so that they don't
- 9:16come back to an adult who's so dysregulated that it's
- 9:20frightening. Disorganized people.
- 9:25Often the pattern of exploration and the discovery of that is the
- 9:30path through which they're exploited or harmed.
- 9:35And so that exploration piece becomes quite fraught.
- 9:42And then also because the disorganized person can't really
- 9:48regulate themselves reliably so that they can consistently
- 9:54pursue something when they get to be adults, that dysregulation
- 10:00causes them to fall out of more complex explorations than just
- 10:05happen individually. Christian.
- 10:12George, in in your description of the, the preoccupied like
- 10:16limiting exploration, do you think it's there's like a
- 10:25necessary involving component in the parents mind state in that
- 10:29kind of limiting the exploration 'cause I I could imagine, I
- 10:35could imagine a way in which parents might kind of limit
- 10:37exploration if they really did like if there actually was some
- 10:41kind of danger where that might still have a sort of secure
- 10:46flavor to it. Or maybe they just like maybe
- 10:49there's an extra step of it becomes involving or do you
- 10:53think that sorry, it's not like a super clear question, but.
- 10:58Well, I think that it is the duty of the caregiver to keep
- 11:02the child safe, and they should be, you know, fierce in keeping
- 11:08the child safe. And often children who have
- 11:14parents who are not attentive find themselves in situations
- 11:18that they shouldn't because of that, and there is no one to
- 11:22protect them. But that is different than a
- 11:28child who is safe and wants to go explore and it's inhibited
- 11:33from doing that. So an example of that might be
- 11:37that when the child wants to be picked up, you pick them up, and
- 11:39when the child wants to be put down, you put them down.
- 11:44And an example of where that would be inhibited is the child
- 11:46wants to be picked up. And so you pick them up and when
- 11:49they want to be put down because you're more comfortable having
- 11:53them close to you, don't put them down.
- 11:55And when they resist that, you overwhelm them physically with
- 11:59your strength and prevent them from resuming their exploration.
- 12:06And you'll notice when that happens, the child will put up
- 12:10an effort. But when they're clearly
- 12:12overwhelmed, they give up. And that's really what what that
- 12:17process is. They give up doing it because
- 12:19they're not permitted. And if that happens over and
- 12:22over again and in in preoccupied households in a way that's
- 12:27unpredictable for the child, the child just doesn't do it after a
- 12:31while. OK.
- 12:33That makes sense. Because they don't develop the
- 12:37that that rudimentary capacity to explore.
- 12:41The older they get, the harder it is to begin that journey.
- 12:49Often times when you have caregivers that put a lot of
- 12:53pressure to achieve on, they're putting pressure to achieve on
- 12:57the things that they think matter.
- 13:00And there often isn't a looping in of the child as to what
- 13:03matters to the child so that the the child is actually engaged in
- 13:09pursuing something that has primary meaning to them.
- 13:14They're engaged in something that has secondary meanings is
- 13:18the gathering of time, energy and resources, which are
- 13:25important, right? If you're a child is entirely
- 13:29dependent on your caregivers providing for you and they are
- 13:33directing you towards something, you don't really have much of A
- 13:37choice about whether or not you do it.
- 13:41They are in control of that. And depending on how they
- 13:45leverage the control, you know, sometimes it's just you have to
- 13:48do this. It's, it's a requirement and
- 13:52there's a level of expectation in the performance.
- 13:55Or they support something and don't support something else.
- 13:59So you in, in the child position can choose to attempt to do it
- 14:06on your own, but not really be able to succeed at doing it.
- 14:10Or you can go with what they're willing to support.
- 14:13And so you end up in, in the direction that they want.
- 14:18And this is really the the conundrum that when you learn to
- 14:24pursue secondary exploration, because you get the support for
- 14:29that, but you don't get support the primary exploration.
- 14:33You get good at secondary exploration, but secondary
- 14:37exploration, that gathering of time, energy and resources
- 14:40doesn't really produce a sense of meaning in, in being alive.
- 14:48It doesn't really address that whole piece.
- 14:52And so you can get good at gathering, you can get good at
- 14:56material resources, you can get good at the kind of
- 15:04relationships that are transactional trauma bond.
- 15:09But one of the things that carries secure, functioning
- 15:12relationships is the sharing of primary exploration, the synergy
- 15:18that comes from those expressions.
- 15:21You go out and find something out about the world and you
- 15:25come, you bring it back to the relationship.
- 15:27And in the expression of it, if the primary explorations are
- 15:31aligned enough, they get a benefit not only in supporting
- 15:35you, but also from what you find out, which supports them and
- 15:40their exploration and their discovery.
- 15:43And then when they come back and they express it to you, you're
- 15:46aligned enough, you get the benefit both of supporting them,
- 15:50but also what they find out is useful to you as you move
- 15:54through life. So I like to call that a
- 15:57travelling companion. You go through life together,
- 16:00pursuing the things that really mean something to you and have
- 16:04the support that you need actually to take risks.
- 16:09It's one thing to take risks for time, energy and resources, and
- 16:13another thing to take risks for primary meaning.
- 16:19This is a meditation community. And so really one of the things
- 16:23that we might consider talking about is the, the risk taking in
- 16:29practice to discover the, the, the spiritual things that
- 16:33provide meaning in life, to go for the, the consistent practice
- 16:40over time that leads these insights into the nature of the
- 16:44human condition and to free us up from being trapped in.
- 16:51But in the West is quite common a fearfulness about really
- 16:56engaging in life, understanding that it's a short window and
- 17:02that death is at one end of it and reliably at one end of it.
- 17:07In fact, so reliable is it that nobody escapes it when you get
- 17:17caught up in the secondary exploration and you don't
- 17:20address either side of that equation.
- 17:23You don't address the fear that arises when you really move into
- 17:27life and really understand the nature of it.
- 17:30And then the nature of connection, the nature of
- 17:34intimate expression and the the freedom to be authentically
- 17:38yourself, you withdraw from that engagement of life.
- 17:46And mainly the way that we think about that is that we think that
- 17:49we can do it later. But the only way that we can
- 17:53think that we can do it later is if we deny the reality of death
- 17:56because there is no later, if you include that.
- 18:05And so that piece where you really go into the nature of
- 18:09this, the, the sense of self in spiritual practice.
- 18:13Of course, there's the these early insights, the nature of
- 18:21self and no self in the Theravada view.
- 18:25Mudit. So the the pursuit of primary
- 18:30exploration, you're saying that people someone does not pursue
- 18:35it because there's initial fear involved when pursuing primary
- 18:40explorations. Otherwise it's a dead giveaway
- 18:43like I like something, Why am I not doing it like.
- 18:47Well, in each gesture toward the discovery of meaning, there is a
- 18:56lot of potential outcomes. There is the fearfulness of even
- 19:03doing it and then the fearfulness of whether you can
- 19:06manage it or not. The fearfulness of what you'll
- 19:09find out, fearfulness of how it might change the understanding
- 19:15of your life and, and what you're, how it's been operating.
- 19:22All of those things, which is why you need support.
- 19:27All of those things are dysregulating emotionally.
- 19:30And if you don't have the capacity within yourself to
- 19:33regulate it and you don't have people around you to regulate
- 19:37that, the distress of that is enough to to get you to curtail
- 19:42the level of risk that you're willing to take.
- 19:46Is that making sense? This is very important.
- 19:49I didn't realize that the primary exploration comes with
- 19:52this aspect of fear, baseline emotion that needs to be
- 19:58supported by somebody else. Well, you want to be brilliant,
- 20:03really brilliant at regulating yourself and you want to have a
- 20:06wide range of skills and regulating yourself.
- 20:09But you also need to accept that if you're going to take big
- 20:12risks, you're, it's ordinary to find yourself in a situation
- 20:16where you can't regulate yourself.
- 20:18It's beyond your capacity, even as brilliant as you are at doing
- 20:23it. And that's when you have to have
- 20:25the, the social network around you that will catch you.
- 20:29And they need to be reliable so that you don't worry about it in
- 20:34the moment when you need to take the risk to find meaning.
- 20:38If you're worried about whether or not you can manage the
- 20:41outcome of it, it inhibits the, the, the level of risk you're
- 20:45willing to take. Does that make?
- 20:48Sense sample we can give on the risk aspect is it money like
- 20:54because somebody will leave his job and do something that he
- 20:56likes and he's. Well, there's that.
- 21:03Trying to think of something. I'm thinking of my my earlier
- 21:18meditation life. Well, let's say theoretically at
- 21:28the moment that you could take stream entry if you weren't
- 21:37willing to just fall into it. Shinzen used to say that.
- 21:44I said to Shinzen then stream entry was like standing at the
- 21:48edge of the pool and then just falling in without resisting it.
- 21:54And he said, it's more like you stand there in the water in the
- 21:57pool comes out and surrounds you and you don't resist it.
- 22:02But in the moment that you see that happening, can you just
- 22:13open into it and not resist it at all?
- 22:15Or does the fearfulness creep in and then the fearfulness shut
- 22:21down the whole process of it? Is that making sense?
- 22:25Too abstract. Earlier along the path when you
- 22:38move from an AP event, that arising and passing event where
- 22:43you really see the dissolution of the entire inside of the
- 22:47sensing experiences. And then you move into
- 22:51dissolution, which is the dissolving of the sense barrier
- 22:55between inside and out. And it's just a lot of energy.
- 23:00Often the thing that shuts that down is fear.
- 23:04You become really frightened by not being able to locate any
- 23:08sense of the physical body. And it completely shuts down the
- 23:13experience of that. Another aspect of where the
- 23:19fearfulness might come in is in the, in the dissolution of this,
- 23:25the the somatic side centers. When you have these big
- 23:31eruptions of energy releases, really startlingly intense
- 23:36releases of energy, you can either allow it and just go with
- 23:43that huge expansion of energy, or you become frightened by the
- 23:48intensive energy and it shuts down the whole process.
- 23:52Is that making more sense? In that case, the fear, it does
- 23:58arise, it it shuts you down, but you have somebody to talk about
- 24:01like your teacher or whatever, you will go back and share what
- 24:06happened and he or she. And then the next time you
- 24:11notice that it's about to happen, you're not fearful
- 24:15because you feel a sense of support.
- 24:19I see. Or you have the experience of it
- 24:24being fearful and shutting down and then recognizing that it was
- 24:29manageable with the support that you have.
- 24:32And so the next time it happens, there isn't that automatic
- 24:35response and fear. But let's take something more
- 24:40mundane. An authentic expression arises
- 24:44in the mind and right after that a spike of abandonment terror
- 24:51arises that if you were to express yourself authentically,
- 24:55clearly through the aspect of right speech, but if you were to
- 24:59express yourself authentically, you risk abandoned, being
- 25:03abandoned by the person that you're in relationship to.
- 25:06Do you continue with the authentic expression or do you
- 25:11moderate or spin it with something that's inauthentic
- 25:15because you can't make the risk of the authentic expression.
- 25:26And then there's also the relationship with yourself.
- 25:31We get very attached to our identity.
- 25:34Our identity is often firmly involved in our secondary
- 25:39exploration. And we tend to favor the
- 25:43secondary exploration, which it supports our, our, our, our
- 25:47sense of who we wish the world to respond to us, who we wish
- 25:51people to see us as. And then the primary exploration
- 25:57arises in somehow in the constellation of our
- 26:03conditioning. It's not valuable.
- 26:06So we don't really pursue it because it is contradicts the,
- 26:15the, the sense of self that we've developed.
- 26:18This is very, if we talk about it in a Western psychological
- 26:24frame, Masterson said that the we developed the false self so
- 26:29that when we're involved in family systems where there isn't
- 26:33an interest in who we are authentically and there isn't an
- 26:36interest in what skills we actually have and what interests
- 26:40we actually have. And it's mainly focused on
- 26:44secondary inflation. We develop a false self to
- 26:48accommodate all of that. And The thing is that that false
- 26:52self gets highly developed because we're we're developing
- 26:56the skills that are necessary to meet all of those
- 26:59qualifications. And the primary self, the
- 27:03authentic self, the real self doesn't get all that attention,
- 27:09doesn't get all of those resources, doesn't get all of
- 27:11that training. And so you have a kind of goofy,
- 27:16immature, undeveloped sense of authenticity that doesn't come
- 27:22with the Polish of the of the false self.
- 27:26Is that making sense? And so to take the risks in that
- 27:31sort of unpolished way that often is necessary when you
- 27:34begin to really move toward the pursuit of primary meaning, it
- 27:42feels awkward, it's clumsy. You.
- 27:45You don't feel good at it, Christian.
- 27:50I, I might give like for, for any number of artists.
- 27:55Like there's some people that have performance anxiety and
- 27:58maybe they are actors or musicians and they end up not
- 28:01pursuing their craft because it's too stressful for them to
- 28:05be on stage. Or even like writers or artists
- 28:09that maybe they've gotten to a certain point where they're
- 28:13ready to publish or they're ready to have like a gallery
- 28:17show or something. But they they might do things to
- 28:20self sabotage because of the fear of being seen and judged
- 28:23for their like sort of authentic artistic expression is too
- 28:27scary, right? And so like that would be maybe
- 28:31in kind of an example that makes sense to me at least.
- 28:36I would call that the fear of success.
- 28:38But, and I'll talk about that in a second, but another thing that
- 28:41happens to artists in particular is that they find a, a way of
- 28:49expression that becomes popular and they find a, a way of
- 28:56expression that's culturally valued.
- 28:59And each time they move into a different exploration, it's not
- 29:04greeted in the same way. And so they just begin to limit
- 29:08the expression into the the repetition of making the same
- 29:14expression over and over again. And so we would call that a
- 29:17branded artist that consistently produces the same kind of work,
- 29:23which is in the the market economy of art, very valuable.
- 29:28Because in order for an artist's work to be liquid in terms of
- 29:33easy to buy and sell, there has to be hundreds of pieces or
- 29:37thousands of pieces, which means they have to make so many of
- 29:41them. Whereas on the experimental side
- 29:43of art where you're making these inquiries into things that
- 29:48actually are matter to you, the the directions keep changing and
- 29:57the, and the amount of work that's made in each direction is
- 30:01limited. So it doesn't lend itself well
- 30:05to these international markets. And at the extreme end of the
- 30:09branded artist, of course, is the artist themselves just
- 30:13sitting in the museum, which you see more and more of.
- 30:20George, would you call that? Makes me laugh.
- 30:23Would you call that more of the sort of avoidant flavor?
- 30:28I, I guess I, I, I could see it as that, you know, it's hard to
- 30:37know, but it is, it is a sensitivity to I, I really liken
- 30:44it. And the way that I divide it in
- 30:46my mind is to think of that as spectacle and art is a different
- 30:51kind of exploration. And we're we're very aligned to
- 30:56spectacle in our culture. So Secure People also feels the
- 31:03fear of publishing or whatever that is.
- 31:05But he has the ways to self regulate and the people.
- 31:11Well, it's in the quality of the work.
- 31:14Do you, do you make work that's very representative of the
- 31:16authentic interests that you have and the authentic meaning
- 31:19that you find and in, in the range of reaction to the world
- 31:25that we live in? Or are you more oriented around
- 31:31the, in the West, the very narrow range of what's
- 31:36permissible to discuss? So if you, if you find that you
- 31:41keep confining your expression to that very narrow range, it,
- 31:47it tends to have more access to the, to the culture than if you
- 31:51don't accept those limitations. And people's work would do that
- 31:57are simply not included in the in the the main cultural
- 32:01discussion because they don't confine themselves to what's
- 32:06permissible to discuss and. So do you find the people who
- 32:12have transitioned to secure attachment move more towards art
- 32:17based a creative based meaning? I don't think that that's true.
- 32:24I think that in our culture, artists sort of at the peak of
- 32:30what is supposed to be creative. But I think that the axis of the
- 32:35creative self, the activation of the creative self in the pursuit
- 32:40of things that are meaning, meaningful is a huge range.
- 32:46And that I, I mainly talk about spiritual exploration, spiritual
- 32:56discovery as the creative because of the type of community
- 33:03that this is. But I think that the range is
- 33:09really unlimited in terms of what you can engage in.
- 33:13But what you're what the discovery there is that it
- 33:16really is the activity itself is meaningful.
- 33:22You derive beyond a pleasure, an engagement that is enriching in
- 33:30in your understanding of the nature of the life that you
- 33:33have. This one short precious, that's
- 33:40Mary Oliver would say this one wild and precious life.
- 33:43What are you going to do with your one wild and precious life
- 33:49that you derive a sense of fulfillment and having been
- 33:52alive? Now, obviously in our culture,
- 33:57immortality is the thing. So as an artist, you make an
- 34:00iconic work that's put into a museum that lasts for
- 34:05generations. As a business person, you put
- 34:09your name on 87 buildings so that you're remembered for at
- 34:14least 100 years or 50 years. How long does a building last?
- 34:22You attempt to affect the body politic in a way that then you
- 34:28can be remembered. You know, our we in the in the
- 34:33West, we mainly have a history of people who went to war and
- 34:40won. It's a very narrow range of what
- 34:44what is important. I'm going to imagine that
- 34:49there's a whole possibility of things that have happened that
- 34:53have been important that aren't valued in these kinds of
- 34:59cultural narratives that we have.
- 35:02So I don't think that you should limit yourself to the pursuit of
- 35:07something that has cultural value in it if it isn't
- 35:12meaningful and it falls then just into the secondary
- 35:16exploration, which is the gathering time, energy and
- 35:20resources. You know, to to have a deep
- 35:23spiritual practice, for instance, it's not highly valued
- 35:26in our culture. And to put the time, energy and
- 35:29resources into that is often baffling to people that don't
- 35:34have an activation of their creative self in the direction
- 35:40of making these kinds of discoveries.
- 35:47On the other hand, I think they're fantastic things to to
- 35:51know and have spent, you know, what is it 50 years about now in
- 36:00the pursuit of the maybe a little longer that making sense.
- 36:09It's going to. Say thank you for saying this.
- 36:12Meditation is also something a big part of me and all this time
- 36:16I've been thinking of how it's not, I think not culturally, but
- 36:23it's, I think my mind is the culture that culturally that
- 36:25it's not enough for me to do. And even though I do it
- 36:34everyday, but it's not something like what I find it deeply
- 36:37meaningful, yes, but there's this expectations of the
- 36:42secondary and primary being mixed in the same buckets.
- 36:46It's hard to sometimes. Yeah.
- 36:52But most of us don't end up in a in a situation where our means
- 36:57of providing for ourselves and the things that are meaningful
- 37:03are remunerative and provide that.
- 37:06Most of us are going to be in a dance of flowing resources into
- 37:13secondary exploration and flowing resources into primary.
- 37:17We're gathering the resources in secondary and flowing them in
- 37:20into our primary exploration. We we aren't a culture that
- 37:28really considers primary exploration as so important.
- 37:33We're really mainly focused on secondary exploration.
- 37:39Is there any other culture in the world which does?
- 37:43Well. It's all the same.
- 37:48Well, it really is heading that way since it's become a world
- 37:52culture rather than more individual culture, right?
- 38:01I would, I would think that part of the dilemma that we're in now
- 38:08is this, this, you know, the adjectives for this, the gross,
- 38:14insane, unconscionable inequality that we're facing
- 38:20means that there that it's so difficult just to manage the
- 38:26secondary side of exploration, just to gather the resources to
- 38:30survive, that there isn't really much bandwidth beyond that in
- 38:35order to develop the capacity for primary exploration.
- 38:46So the answer is no, there isn't any culture.
- 38:48Well, some cultures value education, you know, if you get
- 38:59higher up into the world in terms of the distribution of
- 39:04resources where there isn't a need for work, isn't a need to
- 39:12to provide that, that it, it comes in a life where you've
- 39:16already made enough of that so that you don't have to attend to
- 39:20that. That would open a window of
- 39:22exploration for people. And so in that in those places,
- 39:28I think there often is a a value to it.
- 39:32Certainly in academic circles there is some range of pursuing
- 39:39things that have meaning, but you also see the academic world
- 39:43filled with people have entered into places of study because of
- 39:47the the pressure to achieve. So in the broader culture, it's
- 39:56oriented toward this very narrow range of things that are
- 39:59valuable and you really need to to go only for those.
- 40:05So that if you are what's meaningful 2 falls outside of
- 40:08that narrow spectrum, it's not valued.
- 40:12We have a term for it which is called hobby.
- 40:20Your hobby. It's a I've always heard it as
- 40:24pejorative if you ever heard it as not pejorative.
- 40:28We've changed that in my. Mind that's amazing or the
- 40:38weekend you know it. I'll give you an example when I
- 40:47moved to New York in 1975 it was the there was a big recession
- 40:53that was happening and inflation was at about 15% a year, which
- 40:59was pretty staggering and New York City, Manhattan.
- 41:09We used to say New York, but we only meant Manhattan.
- 41:13The outer boroughs were too far away below 14th St. there was a
- 41:1940% occupancy of the building so most of the upper floors of the
- 41:23buildings were empty and the and they were very inexpensive in
- 41:28comparison. I rented a loft on 11th and
- 41:33Broadway in in Manhattan which was renting for $0.25 a foot and
- 41:41that meant that 1400 square feet of loft space was 175 a month.
- 41:53We could all work two days a week in that environment and pay
- 41:58our bills. And that left five days a week
- 42:01to actually pursue things that were meaningful.
- 42:03And so you, you have in New York during that time, this
- 42:08incredible burst of creative activity that really doesn't
- 42:14happen now because of the, the cost of things and how much time
- 42:19has to be dedicated to the gathering of resources.
- 42:26And that changed the, the fall of Iraq was the really, the, of
- 42:33Iran was really the, the beginning of that and the, the,
- 42:38the beginning of that real shift out of a more equal tax system,
- 42:47the, the gutting of the, the protections on the banks that
- 42:54were put in after the depression.
- 42:58So that, that speculation engine that produced so much
- 43:02consolidating of the money happened then.
- 43:05And then it wasn't that you could work two days a week and
- 43:08afford the place that you were living.
- 43:10It's that you, you had to work seven days a week and, and still
- 43:14it was difficult to manage. And as a result of that, that
- 43:18whole moment of creativity just came to an end because nobody
- 43:24could do it any. So that's really part of this
- 43:29equation to how can you put yourself in a position where you
- 43:33have the resources that are necessary then to be able to
- 43:36pursue the things that you want to be able to get good at, to
- 43:43discover, to know, OK, why don't we do some practice?
- 43:54All right, let go of the meditation.
- 44:00Sorry, can I take 60 seconds for you to repeat the the self
- 44:03thing? Yes, it is true that things are
- 44:06appearing and disappearing. And there's if you.
- 44:11If you back the self off so that the self is, you're instructing
- 44:15the self to do nothing, not to direct anything, not to control
- 44:19anything, not to cause anything. What you begin to notice is that
- 44:23that whole activity of attention being drawn to different sense
- 44:28objects happens independent of the sense of self.
- 44:31Actually the sense of self is not in charge of that.
- 44:34It's a, it's a just a, a sensing by product and that the
- 44:38unconscious, the deeply unconscious condition, body,
- 44:42mind activity is what's causing it.
- 44:46But it feels like the sense of self is thinking once it's
- 44:50identified, the sense of self is thinking about it.
- 44:55It's me who was thinking because it's related in my past.
- 45:00And are you controlling it? Are you controlling the thought
- 45:04that you have? Not the initial, but the.
- 45:10Once I've caught it then I am. It feels like I am.
- 45:13OK, so to practice more and each time you notice that the the
- 45:20self is engaging something, back it off.
- 45:22Don't give it permission to do that.
- 45:25Yes, that's the practice, yes, but I I didn't Yeah, maybe
- 45:29you're right. Maybe it's the even every the
- 45:32progression of the thought the self is not creating it.
- 45:37Yes. The self is experiencing it, but
- 45:40it's a witness. It's not a doer, A cause or a
- 45:44controller. The creator, so with.
- 45:49That you think you are? Yes.
- 45:51It's the audience, it's not the performer on the stage.
- 45:56Even when it's identified. Yeah.
- 45:59Even after the. OK, that's interesting.
- 46:03Yeah, it's just watching. It's really just there to stop
- 46:06you from doing something dumb. Too bad it doesn't work better.
- 46:21Thank you very much. So we have Christian.
- 46:28I was, I was noticing today kind of like a sense of irritation no
- 46:32matter where I was. And I, I guess I wasn't always
- 46:36noted noting it because there was a lot of time spent in field
- 46:42space, whether that was more in like the body.
- 46:47But then I realized that the kind of irritation was
- 46:50accompanying me what when I noted something in Herespace or
- 46:54in C space as well. So then that kind of brought my
- 46:57attention to like. What level of dukkha was it?
- 47:03It was manageable. It was.
- 47:05Well, you know, Dukkha 3 levels 1 is old age, sickness and
- 47:10death. So the body is painful, the body
- 47:12isn't cooperating with you're scattered and unconstituted.
- 47:17That's the first level. It was the nothing is how I want
- 47:21it to be. Right, the third level, the
- 47:24constant unbroken irritation that nothing is the way that you
- 47:28want it if you were in charge of anything.
- 47:30Which is the other part of that, right?
- 47:38Yep. Sorry, so the intention when we
- 47:43say to search for the self, you know, at least in Dan's
- 47:46teachings, we talk about you search for the self.
- 47:48So this searching is also not my.
- 47:56The answer is that there is that no self that you can find that's
- 48:01constant, ongoing, locatable, positionable, permanent.
- 48:07But it's there, but it's not solid.
- 48:10It it, it is when you really investigate it, it arises based
- 48:15on the conditions of the present moment.
- 48:17And every time the conditions of the present moment change, the
- 48:20consolation of the sense of self changes with it and.
- 48:25Where do you put see here the self and see here feel because I
- 48:29feel I'm not sure which one I should feel.
- 48:32The consolation of self in that frame is going to be focus in
- 48:37plus feel out. So internal visual thinking,
- 48:42internal auditory thinking, emotion in the body, and the
- 48:46felt sense of the body create the sense of self.
- 48:51Oh, I know. It's just one OK.
- 48:54That what what you meant. Yeah, but you experienced it.
- 48:58But you can just say feel. I know the sense of self is here
- 49:02right now, right? And you can really break it into
- 49:07that auditory and visual thinking and the emotional and
- 49:12physical sense of the body come together and create the self
- 49:16experience. Fascinating.
- 49:24Because I mean, if you break it into seeing focus in, focus out,
- 49:31it doesn't really without that physical quality of the body
- 49:35doesn't really produce a strong sense of self.
- 49:39Oh, for me, emotion feels enough.
- 49:42To create but. Yeah, I don't know.
- 49:49But the solid sense of self, I I think really requires that that
- 49:57body piece Good. We have a level 2 coming up in
- 50:05September. Otherwise all of the classes
- 50:09have already begun for the remainder of the year.
- 50:15We have a couple of half day workshops.
- 50:17I'm starting to do these workshops on exploration, which
- 50:22is the topic of tonight, but we'll go into it in, in, in in a
- 50:26deeper way and then begin to explore meditation path to
- 50:30toward it. I'm going to do the first one, I
- 50:36think is it, I don't know what it is, but it's coming up.
- 50:41Look, it's in September on the 21st and then in October, the
- 50:51second one is on the 26th. And I'm going to actually talk
- 50:57about my own exploration in photography, which I I find one
- 51:02of the central sources of meaning for me and how that
- 51:07developed so as an artistic expression versus just an an
- 51:15expression of meditation. Thank you for coming.
- 51:20I really appreciate your practice.
- 51:21Ioffer the teaching freely. But I do hope that if you if you
- 51:25have the capacity, you can make a donation.
- 51:27There's a link on the website to do that.
- 51:30I hope to see you soon on the path.
- 51:32Thank you. Bye.