Latest / Psychology In Seattle Podcast / Cheating, Self-Aware, Kirk Transference, and Dumping Clients
Transcript
- 0:00So Bob emails, what do you say? Yeah? This first emails from
- 0:03anonymous patron. She writes, this is a question for you and Bob.
- 0:07If he's available, are you available? I'm available? Right. Regarding betrayal
- 0:12trauma, I recently discovered my boyfriend cheated on me was someone we know.
- 0:17He said it was a one off thing, but it clearly took some organizing.
- 0:21Yeah. And then through this I discovered that he was talking with his
- 0:24ex wife after previously he would be telling me I only talk with my ex
- 0:28wife every few months, but they're actually talking every couple of days. So
- 0:33basically he admitted he was having an emotional affair with her. Yes, none
- 0:37of these behaviors line up with who I thought I knew him to be at
- 0:41all. I feel so scared about his request to move forward together with him,
- 0:46because one, I'm not sure if he can change in Two, how
- 0:49does one start to cultivate trust with a partner after something like this? That
- 0:53are that avoid being controlling? I think you know she's saying, I want
- 0:58I have an impulse, I guess to say you can't talk to any women
- 1:02for the rest of your life or something that right controlling? But I don't
- 1:03want to do that. So how do I cultivate trust? I'm scared this
- 1:07might just be who he is and it will happen again, and I'm already
- 1:12in so much pain and feel so ashamed. Thank you for all you do
- 1:17for all of us. So, Bob, what do you think? Well,
- 1:19I'm very sorry. I think it's some of the worst pain that humans
- 1:23go through. Is this kind of betrayal sucks? The two thoughts I have
- 1:27are trying to be as brief as I can. The field have to be,
- 1:32Bob, it could be as lengthy as you know. Well people like
- 1:34it when you talk. Well, this might take a bit. Then,
- 1:38in order to cultivate trust, there has to be a couple of things to
- 1:42happen. One of them is you both have to understand what actually got injured.
- 1:48So like betrayal of trust, Yes, that's a very way to talk
- 1:52about it, but what actually inside? What meaning does your body? Does
- 1:56your heart make of that kind of betrayal? And that has to as I
- 2:01understand it, You'll need to describe that both for yourself and for him.
- 2:06Could be very interesting, surprising, very intimate thing to do, and only
- 2:09if he's absolutely available to hear it, so you might need a might be
- 2:15good to have a therapist to accompany you in that particular journey. So that's
- 2:20the first thing, and I know I'm saying it, but so the thing
- 2:23is is like to touch that. It's like, beneath my shock, beneath
- 2:27my horror, beneath my outrage is some exquisite pain and whatever that exquisite pain
- 2:32is needs to come to the surface and be expressed to the other who you
- 2:38will actually need to see remorse. Like it's not enough for them to say
- 2:42I'm sorry, Like it actually has to show up in their face. And
- 2:45I think that that has a biologic component to it, Like humans just need
- 2:49to see that the other person really really cares and is in pain over the
- 2:53pain that they caused. That's the first bit, and then the second bit
- 2:57is to understand what the hell is going on here that he's cheating with this
- 3:00person that you know and then still talking to his ax like, hey,
- 3:04he's not a bad person, it's a heat right, yeah, not a
- 3:07bad person, but but what's up that he's doing that? Like what's he
- 3:12doing opening on these windows to other people and clearly having doors for you?
- 3:16Like something driving that that doesn't make him a jerk face, but it wouldn't
- 3:21be safe if that isn't understood, and if your relationship could probably possibly be
- 3:28a resource for whatever needs he's trying to get met by talking to you know,
- 3:32and going outside your relationship. As Kirk has said before, and I
- 3:38often think about it'll probably never go away entirely, and it doesn't have to.
- 3:43And the difference between I think the difference between couples that survive this stuff
- 3:46and couples that you know suffer from it is how willing are both people to
- 3:51when it comes around again, if it's in five months or five years or
- 3:53five decades, when it visits, how do they handle it. The person
- 3:58that got hurt has to know that it's absolutely okay that the wound got evoked
- 4:02again for whatever reason, maybe an anniversary, maybe a drove, has to
- 4:05a restaurant in your town or something, who knows whatever it is that evokes
- 4:10it. And the other person that did the betraying has to recognize that this
- 4:14does not mean that they're the bad guy. You'll never live it down.
- 4:16It means that they have a golden opportunity to provide love and support for somebody
- 4:19who's in fucking agony. So yeah, yeah. The only thing I'll add
- 4:25to that is often society or even people that you talk to an automas patron
- 4:30will give the impression that you're supposed to figure this out right away. No,
- 4:35no, and if you know, it depends on the circumstances. But
- 4:39if you think that it's worth actually giving it some time to figure out the
- 4:44relationship is worth it, or there's enough indication like this might work out or
- 4:46something, then you just have to know that there's almost no way. Even
- 4:51if he were a complete open book and said everything that was going on and
- 4:56he was very self aware, it would still take a lot of time for
- 5:00you to figure out what's going on for your relationship for him to recover.
- 5:03You know, in all likelihood, in light of what Bob is bringing up,
- 5:06it's like, well, what's going on with him? There's a chance
- 5:10that this is like a twenty five year old, twenty five year journey that
- 5:13the two of you go on where there's lots of twists and turns, So
- 5:17you just won't know, and that's okay. It sucks to not know.
- 5:23Now if that's a deal breaker and you just don't want to take that risk,
- 5:27and you don't want to take that time. You don't want to spend
- 5:30five years exploring something only to find out that he is quote unquote just like
- 5:35that, or doesn't really love you, or his issues are too big,
- 5:40or he doesn't want to work on those issues, or or you've fallen out
- 5:43of love with him sufficiently that it's not worth it you. If you don't
- 5:46want to spend that time, then you know, pulling the pluged down.
- 5:49There's nothing wrong with that, But it sounds like you're maybe contemplating trying to
- 5:56see if this can work and just get a good therapist understand what we're talking
- 6:01about right here when there are many therapists understand it, and settle in for
- 6:06a good two to three years of therapy before you can really you know,
- 6:10you can evaluate along the way. There'll be a little milestones, you know,
- 6:14two months in, six months in they'll be milestones where you can think,
- 6:17like, have we progressed a little bit? Do I see signs that
- 6:19he is this what's going on here? But you won't really know until you
- 6:26go through that. Yeah, another just hearing it. I'm so sorry,
- 6:30Yeah, yeah, yeah. It's so devastating to love someone and give it
- 6:35to someone and to believe that someone is what they say, to believe someone
- 6:41is what you want them to be, what they say they are, the
- 6:45way they present to you, and then to find out that not only cheating,
- 6:48but that for a long period of time. You know, I've talked
- 6:53about this before, and when was I When was I talking about this in
- 6:57a reaction video? I can't remember? But the mind screw that it does
- 7:01to people is Okay, wait, because it's one thing if you had a
- 7:06fling one night or something. It's something if it's going on for years.
- 7:11Where okay? Wait, So when we had that romantic dinner, right,
- 7:15were you texting her then? Right? Were you thinking about her? Then?
- 7:18Right when you said I was the only one and you only talk to
- 7:23your ex wife every few months and you kissed me that warre we made love
- 7:28that one time? Was that false because there's a falsehood to what you were
- 7:33doing? Then? Is anything true? Are you ever honest? Are you
- 7:38ever telling the truth? So, yeah, it's it's really a mind screw.
- 7:42And then you start thinking, can't I trust anybody? Yeah? Is
- 7:45everyone lying to me? Is that sucks? How do I know? Right?
- 7:49There's no way to know I'm not discovering you are fundamentally have been lying
- 7:55to me for a long time. Yeah, and I thought I could trust
- 7:59you more than I could trust anyone else. Therefar I can't. It really
- 8:01fucks you up. And people stop cheating, stop lying, stop cheating,
- 8:05stop lying, figure shit out, go to therapy, break up, but
- 8:09don't deceive, don't fuck around. You get one chance on this planet.
- 8:15Don't fuck it up and fuck it up for other people. Yeah, fuck
- 8:18it up for yourself. Don't suck it up for other people. Don't suck
- 8:20it up for yourself. But if you're gonna suck it up for someone,
- 8:22fuck it up for yourself. Don't suck it up for everyone else. And
- 8:24you know, it's not only just me yelling at people of that, but
- 8:30also you know, shaking fist at society, which is that I wouldn't be
- 8:33surprised if a good number of cheaters have friends and people online that's say like,
- 8:39oh, you deserve to speak your truth or to get your needs met,
- 8:43or you know, because there's usually justifications that people have. You know,
- 8:46she if she won't have sex with me anymore, or something like that,
- 8:48and it's like, uh, you know this idea of this sort of
- 8:54noble cheating, I think is a phrase, you know, like that's crazy
- 8:58good for you kind of a thing. Hey, people do get deserved to
- 9:01get their needs met, so great, but you don't gotta lie to do
- 9:05it. Like, if they're really your needs, then let's put the cards
- 9:07on the table and say this is my declare it, this is my need?
- 9:13Yeah, yes, break up and find some break up. Yep,
- 9:15that's fine. Yeah. The thing, the thing that's in one of the
- 9:18things that's injurious to people is my partner is now no longer predictable. I
- 9:22don't know. I don't know what they are. I don't know what they're
- 9:24doing. I don't even know who they are. I don't know what's going
- 9:28on in their heart. Yeah, you know, so much of a relationship
- 9:31and the connection has to do with mentalization. What has to do with Ye,
- 9:37I have a reasonable idea, you know, I reasonably I have reasonable
- 9:41confidence in my conceptualization of what is going on in your heart that you like
- 9:46me and love me and look out for me and prefer me or whatever.
- 9:50And to have that get get flipped on its head, then, you know,
- 9:54because we always you know, we talk about communication and showing your love.
- 9:58Well, if someone quote unquote showing their love but you know it to
- 10:03be lying to you, it's not love. You're not receiving love. You're
- 10:07receiving this shadow of love. So you don't want to screw it that.
- 10:11You don't want to live a life that makes other people question your ability to
- 10:16communicate to them what's going on in your heart, because if if no one
- 10:20trusts you, then no one's going to want to be with you, right
- 10:24and even when you're trying to build a connection, they won't trust it,
- 10:28even if you're legitimately trying. The other thing I want to say about this
- 10:31is devices. If you've cheated on somebody, give them your fucking devices.
- 10:35Just let them look as often as they need to. Don't have shit to
- 10:39hide, and just give it up. Nobody's privacy is that big a fucking
- 10:43deal that you can't because believe me, what will happen is they will get
- 10:48zero relief from looking at your device because when they don't find anything, they're
- 10:52going to freak out because not finding stump is worse than finding stuff because now
- 10:56you're like in the dark. So just don't find it and don't lege confused.
- 11:00What are you saying. I'm saying that when a person gets caught cheating
- 11:03and the person that got cheated on wants to see the devices. You know,
- 11:07let's say that that they they're on the street now, or they're not
- 11:09doing it anymore, they broke off the relationship and they're just okay, I'm
- 11:13devoted, I'm committed, and it's the real thing. Then when that person
- 11:16has a fucking insecure moment at eleven thirty on a Thursday and they need to
- 11:20see the goddamn device, just give it to them. And what will happen
- 11:24is they'll look and they won't find anything. And not finding anything is not
- 11:28a relief. It just means, fuck, maybe I don't know where to
- 11:30look. Maybe you've got some fucking email that you don't tell me about,
- 11:33or a burner phone or some shit. Their brain will come up with some
- 11:35way in which you are lying, and they'll be more freaked out by looking.
- 11:39But at least initially they have to look. They just have to,
- 11:43and you know, fuck it, fine, give them the goddamn device.
- 11:46Nobody's privacy. I hear this about oh you normally privacy, blah blah blah
- 11:50blah, fucking bullshit. You're fucking privacy, man, Fuck your privacy.
- 11:56You gave that up. And let's face it, if you really want to
- 11:58help somebody, if you really love that person and not only just for your
- 12:01own well being and welfare, want the relationship to survive, and fucking give
- 12:05up the goddamn device because think about what you just did to them. You
- 12:09just undermined all their confidence in you, and rightfully so, because you undermine
- 12:13all the goddamn confidence in you. So so everybody has this thing about well,
- 12:16it's my device, you know, it's my phone, nobody to give
- 12:20fuck you, no, fucking give the goddamn thing up and let them look
- 12:24in fact, offer it, don't wait and don't grudge it. Just here.
- 12:28Yeah, why don't we look together? Yeah? Why don't I just
- 12:31sit with you while you don't find anything and I can love you while you're
- 12:35in pain? Like, why the fuck not? Golly well, well,
- 12:39there's a cultural and there's a cultural notion that I think is dominant that informs
- 12:46that resistance that it's my privacy. And I think that where it comes from
- 12:52is from a couple of sources because I'd never thought about this, but before
- 13:00there were devices, like with my parents when I was a kid, my
- 13:03parents had no privacy because it wasn't possible to have privacy because everything was out
- 13:11there. There was one telephone in our house. Maybe you have a diary,
- 13:15yeah, maybe maybe, But my parents didn't, so nobody you don't.
- 13:20And I'm thinking there's a comfort to that, right and a connection annoying
- 13:26someone. We're all on page here like there's you don't have an avenue to
- 13:30privacy. Well not only that, but you're in each other's lives. You're
- 13:33truly yea into do you get to have some privacy? Sure? Could you
- 13:39have a private conversation with someone? Could you do something with someone else?
- 13:41But anyway, but yeah, I think that it comes from a couple places.
- 13:46One is that there's a lot of people who grew up with parents who
- 13:48were trying to invade their space with their device. You and I didn't grow
- 13:52up that way, and so I think it kind of ingrains this notion of
- 13:56like, it's my right to have privacy and okay, But I think another
- 14:01avenue towards this cultural notion is that you have some partners who are paranoid unreasonably
- 14:07and are demanding to have access to another person's phone when there's no indication of
- 14:13infidelity that's happening, and they it's abusive, right, It can even get
- 14:20to that level whether the abusive person will be like, you have no privacy.
- 14:24I'm going to get into your control of this. I'm going to spy
- 14:26on you. I'm gonna put software in your foote. You know. So
- 14:30there's this, there's this heuristic, the shortcut people have around people deserve their
- 14:33privacy and in those situations, Yeah, I don't know about the teens,
- 14:37it's debatable, but but certainly form abuse victims they deserved their privacy. Oh
- 14:43hell yeah, So I think that it all gets sort of translation into yeah,
- 14:48because yeah, absolutely that I think your frustration comes from a frustration that
- 14:54I've often expressed on this podcast that if you cheat and you truly want to
- 15:00recover, which often is the case when people are in my office, the
- 15:03cheater wants to gain trust back, and yet they resist every possible avenue or
- 15:09measure that could be taken to build that trust back, including not ending the
- 15:13fucking cheating. Right occasionally, but let's say they do that. Yeah,
- 15:18and you know, we talk about the topic of access to phone or email
- 15:22or something, and you know, I'm never forcing a client to do that,
- 15:24but it is something that I might throw out there as a possibility,
- 15:28and you know, if the cheater has a hardline on that, there's other
- 15:33ways that we can do this. But why would you not? Thus there's
- 15:35a really compelling reason, like, well, my dad talks with me a
- 15:39lot about his issues and I don't want that to be out there. Or
- 15:45I have a friend who this, or I have a job that is a
- 15:48top security clearance thing, top secret security client. Yeah, but that's not
- 15:54usually the case. It's usually just like, but I don't want to give
- 15:58up. I don't want to. Yeah, And it's it's like, well,
- 16:02you paid the crime, you got to do the time, dude,
- 16:04like you should. You should be champing at the bit to actually give them
- 16:10access. I get to help you, right, I get to. And
- 16:12also I have to do is hand you this piece of metal. Right,
- 16:15That's that's easy, right here you go, Yeah, yeah, and you
- 16:18get to get relief from it and we get to care about you. Well,
- 16:22right, I mean, come on, right, that's a no brainer.
- 16:25Yeah. But there's also a lot of other cultural notions around people holding
- 16:30on to the past. And you know, the cheater goes to their friends
- 16:33or goes online and talks about the situation they're going to get. A lot
- 16:37of people are being like, your therapist is making you do what you know,
- 16:40there's a lot of pro cheater culture in our culture. I'm not online.
- 16:47I'm really glad I'm not online. Well, it's a reflection of our
- 16:49culture. Y. Yeah, if you are around the the water cooler in
- 16:52the nineties, it would be a similar conversation, you know. Anyway,
- 16:57I'm not around the water cooler. Yeah, you're pretty cut off from I
- 17:04am, human beings aside from your clients, me and your wife. All
- 17:11Right, I say, of break, can we get back more emails?
- 17:12What do you say? Okay, we're back from the break. So patron
- 17:19Crystal from California, She says, I have a question for you and Bob.
- 17:22I was recently watching an interview on YouTube or the INTERVIEWEE let's call her
- 17:26Kate was talking about her experience in therapy. So Kate's on YouTube talking about
- 17:30therapy, and Kate says that her therapist once told her that she was too
- 17:36self aware and that there was nothing she the therapist could do to help her.
- 17:40So the therapist says, You're Wow, You're You're just too self aware?
- 17:44Is nothing more I can do? In the YouTube video, Kate was
- 17:48saying that basically in therapy, she would say this thing happened to me as
- 17:52a kid because of this, so now I do this and this. So
- 17:56the Kate person had a lot of self arness is to how her present behavior
- 18:02relates to her childhood traumas and that sort of thing. Great, Kate said
- 18:07she appreciated that the therapist was upfront was saying that she didn't know what to
- 18:11do with Kate. Kate didn't continue seeing the therapist after this, and it
- 18:15was insinuated in the YouTube video that the therapist may have even terminated with her
- 18:18because of this you're too self aware thing. And so Crystal from California goes
- 18:26on, I've had a similar issue, and at times I also feel too
- 18:32self aware for therapy, like I already know what my bad coping mechanisms are
- 18:37and why I have them, so therapy just isn't helpful sometimes. I don't
- 18:41think this is an uncommon sentiment, though, and I think hyper self awareness
- 18:45can be a trauma response itself. Have you ever dealt with a client who
- 18:49was too self aware? What do you do when therapy doesn't seem to be
- 18:53working for a client. Would you ever terminate with a client over something like
- 18:56this, Bob, I'm thinking about. Oh, back when I was young,
- 19:03I used to see this really lovely man and I didn't get to see
- 19:07him very long because it was right before I left the clinic where I was
- 19:08working, so maybe a few months. And he was smart, smart,
- 19:11smart, like went to one of those like MT kind of schools, smart,
- 19:15like really smart. And he'd talk and I would be overwhelmed because he
- 19:21could talk circles around me. And I'm not a dummy, right and I
- 19:23know how to put a nanim verb together. But I used to get like
- 19:26just sort of overwhelmed. And so occasionally what I'd say to him is,
- 19:30well, you know, you're a lot smarter than me, so can you
- 19:32just tell me what I'm gonna say? Just do my end too. We'd
- 19:37have a laugh about it, and so, okay. So I don't I
- 19:41don't buy this notion of too self aware. I don't even know what that
- 19:44really means. I mean, I think it's great if you're psychologically minded and
- 19:48you are self aware and you're able to you know, look at yourself.
- 19:52Maybe you know, like step back a bit and look at yourself and see
- 19:56and see, you know, even validate, see how your behavior makes sense.
- 19:59But I don't think that's why, at least the people that I see,
- 20:02that's not why they're coming to therapy. They're not coming to therapy because
- 20:04they're too self aware or that's not a symptom of a problem. And it
- 20:08sounds like it's kind of a cognitive intellectualization of I don't know what growth maturity
- 20:15or something. I don't know. What's it like to be in the presence
- 20:18of the other and be seen and cared for. That's what I'm interested in.
- 20:22So what I'm curious about with Kate is what was what about that element?
- 20:26Because maybe the therapist was intimidated, maybe the therapist was scared, or
- 20:30maybe the therapist thought their job was to teach, you know, maybe that's
- 20:33a part of our job. I guess occasionally that's something. I mean,
- 20:36I wouldn't want to rule it out entirely on the one hand, But on
- 20:40the other hand, I can do therapy with people that are very self aware
- 20:45and offer something really useful, which is care. You're very self aware I
- 20:51am. You might be the most self aware client in the city limits of
- 20:56Seattle, Shy. Yeah. I haven't seen anybody else at the meetings,
- 21:00and yet you're still in therapy and will be for a long time. Yeah.
- 21:04Probably. So what is the agent of change in your therapy? It's
- 21:08care and how does that change? What's the change? I go to therapy
- 21:18every Tuesday at nine, and when I show up, I'm coming in there
- 21:22forgetting that he actually likes me and cares about me, and that I honestly
- 21:26God, last week I said to him, I don't know why I sit
- 21:27down here and I feel like I'm going to be lectured to or talk down
- 21:30to by my dad. And I told him some story, but that was
- 21:33coming to mind about some crappy thing that happened between me and my dad when
- 21:37I was nineteen or eighteen or whatever, a long time ago, and I
- 21:41forget that he doesn't do that. I don't know why that is, Like,
- 21:47I wish I could have more object permanence about the fact that my therapist
- 21:51cares about me. Well, it's kind of the problem you have object permanence
- 21:55with your dad. Yeah, I do, right, I do, And
- 21:56it's the negative kind of object, permanence, in the expectation of whatever in
- 22:00so therapy for me is chipping away at that that I'm actually not there to
- 22:07perform. I'm not there to impress. I'm not there to be even be
- 22:11self aware. I'm there to be loved and to try to remember. And
- 22:17only through that experience will you remember. And only through that experience will you
- 22:22not have that transference, will you not have that assumption. Only through the
- 22:27experience can you counteract the millions of interactions you had with your dad. Can't
- 22:33think your way out of that one, You just can't. Yeah, you're
- 22:36very self aware of that. I am. You know that You've been back
- 22:38and forth. You've you've talked about it with him, with yourself, with
- 22:42me, with others. You know, the whole ballowax. You're what too
- 22:48self aware means. But you're very self aware, and yet you're still in
- 22:52therapy and it's still helping you change. Right. So, for Crystal,
- 22:56I guess I'm thinking, why don't you just if you're in therapy, why
- 23:00don't you just talk about what it's like to be in therapy and be self
- 23:03aware? If that's what it is like. I noticed that I'm aware of
- 23:04this, Okay, great good, and what's going on between us right now,
- 23:07what's happening here in our relationship. But I'm a I'm a believer in
- 23:11attachment oriented psychotherapy. You know, not all therapists believe in that or do
- 23:17that. And you know, I think that there's a place for CBT.
- 23:21Yeah, there's a place for that, and it's great. You know,
- 23:22that's fine, evidence behind it, and good CBT therapist is not without care,
- 23:27I hope. I don't think they are, though maybe some of them
- 23:30are. I don't know, it doesn't matter. In my opinion, that's
- 23:34not where I should restate. I think for a lot of things that's not
- 23:37sufficient. And attachment oriented oriented therapy is curative, yeah, and it depends
- 23:45what we're trying to cure. Well, So to go through your email,
- 23:48Crystal, you say that Kate was too self aware and that in therapy she
- 23:55would say this thing happened to me as a kid because of this, you
- 23:59know, I was abused by my dad because my dad was abused as a
- 24:03kid. So now because of that, I was abused. Now I will
- 24:07see abuse where it's not really happening, or I will become abusive or something
- 24:11like this, yeah, and yeah, that's very self aware. Yeah,
- 24:14I can't imagine what being too self aware would look like, like somehow you've
- 24:19your brain has burst out of your head or something, and how can you
- 24:23be there's no such thing as being too self aware? The therapist trying to
- 24:26communicate in that it's other other than rejection. But it also implies that you
- 24:32shouldn't be that self aware, like you you should stop with your self awareness
- 24:37before a certain threshold, because if you do too much self awareness, it's
- 24:42a bad thing. I think literally there are people who believe that, and
- 24:47I think some therapists might believe. Apparently this one did. Yeah, there's
- 24:52a possibility to the therapist just felt inept. Yeah that's what that's my guest.
- 24:56And it's just like, you're annoyingly self aware. You're more self aware
- 25:00than I could even imagine giving you and so that's annoying to me. So
- 25:03I'm going to say you're too self aware. Also, there's a shaming of
- 25:07therapy and self awareness and our society, and so I think people will say,
- 25:11you know, you think too much, People say you know, I
- 25:14over and that's it depends on the situation. But often what I'll hear or
- 25:19what I'll evaluate when people say that someone is overthinking or they they self overthinking,
- 25:26is that they are thinking about something that's scaring them and they are backed
- 25:30into a corner and they don't know what to do, so they're thinking about
- 25:33it a lot. And to imply that the individual just should just stop thinking
- 25:38about it is somehow denying human reality of emotions and stuff and denial of emotions,
- 25:44and so I think it's kind of it sounds like it's kind of in
- 25:47that camp. But the way that Crystal you're talking about this Kate person is
- 25:52that Kate seemingly didn't need therapy because they're at least the way you depicted it.
- 25:59There was a thing that Kate was saying, I, even though I'm
- 26:03aware of it, I still have this issue, you know. So Bob
- 26:07would say, even though I'm aware that my abuse childhood history affects my perception
- 26:14and ability to absorb love from other people, even though I'm aware of it,
- 26:19I still will fall into that mindset, and I need to go through
- 26:23the mindset to counter it with a corrective experience so that I can internalize that
- 26:29and actually believe and trust that not only leve will happen, but that it's
- 26:33safe to open myself up and I need to go through that. It sounds
- 26:37like for this Kate character there wasn't anything like that. They might actually have
- 26:41succeeded in therapy such that they're self aware and now they're tasked with just enacting
- 26:47that self awareness and there isn't anything beyond that, or at least that's noticeable
- 26:52to Kate. But Crystal, the way you talk about therapy is that you're
- 26:56very self aware, but therapy isn't helping. You say, I already know
- 27:00my bad coping mechanisms and why I have them, and so Crystal, I'll
- 27:04just say that's great. Over time, I've really tried to develop a foundational
- 27:10understanding of the agent of change on therapy and in a nutshell, and I've
- 27:14said this before, there are two pillars of therapy. One is self awareness,
- 27:18in one is corrective experience or healing. For everybody, self awareness will
- 27:22help to differing degrees, and it depends on the situation. But self awareness
- 27:27is only half of the equation. The other half is actually having the corrective
- 27:32experiences that will change your personality and your reactivity as such that you won't have
- 27:37the need for self awareness in the moment, you know, Like with Bob,
- 27:41let's say, I don't think this will happen, but let's say that
- 27:45in five years you have enough corrective experiences such that you don't have any reactivity
- 27:51to getting close to people, or you have the normal amount of reactivity.
- 27:55Then you wouldn't necessarily need the self awareness of why you might react in a
- 28:00distorted way based on your past abuse history, because it doesn't come up.
- 28:06It doesn't come up. Yeah, So the self awareness and the corrective the
- 28:10self awareness leads to the ability to frame your experiences in a corrective way such
- 28:15that you can change the personality and heal such that you don't need the self
- 28:19awareness anymore. I mean, you always need some self awareness entah. Yeah.
- 28:23Anyway, so I'm guessing that you just haven't met the right therapist.
- 28:30The other possibility is that you haven't presented the right problem to the therapist.
- 28:34The other possibility is that, I think, as Bob was sort of alluding
- 28:38to with the MT guy, is that and I've worked with clients like this
- 28:42too where and there's no indication of this directly, Crystal, But narcissism is
- 28:47a thing. It's a protective measure of I am superior to my therapist or
- 28:53I don't really need help. So with the people with narcissistic you know they're
- 29:00on the narcissisi spectrum that I've treated, they will have reached a point in
- 29:03their life where they're at such a crisis that they know they need help.
- 29:07There's something going on with them, and so they end up in therapy.
- 29:10But when they sit down, of course, they transfer and they're they're scared
- 29:14and they're worried, and they have a lot of issues as children reaching out
- 29:19for help and they were rejected over time, and so it's hard to tolerate
- 29:26the action of therapy where they're actually just handing themselves over and interacting in a
- 29:30close way with their therapists. And so for a long while, the client
- 29:34will stay in therapy because they know they want to be there, but they'll
- 29:37keep the therapists that are arms length. And one of the ways that there's
- 29:41different styles of narcissm, but one of the styles is to pontificate and to
- 29:45appear smart, to appear like you don't need anything like that. I don't
- 29:51know about you, Bob, but the counter transference that all feel with someone
- 29:55in this camp is I will slowly start to feel like I don't matter and
- 30:00that I'm a terrible therapist. I'll even kind of throw stuff out there and
- 30:03that Kyle will be like, yeah, that's not really the issue anyway,
- 30:06moving on, and you know, they just galloped down the road and it's
- 30:10like, I'm not even there, you know what I mean, And I'll
- 30:11start to feel bad. I'll start to get hurt. I'll get start to
- 30:15get angry. And when I noticed that, I'm like, oh, okay.
- 30:18And then I know that the transference and the counter transference, I know
- 30:22the trauma. That's how they felt when they were growing up, and so
- 30:25it gives me a way forward. I don't necessarily do something with it right
- 30:27away, but it gives the ability to frame it. So you know,
- 30:30there's a possibility if someone came to me and said, so, I'm in
- 30:34therapy and it doesn't usually work for me, but and I'm you know,
- 30:37I've been told I'm too self aware for therapy, and so I don't have
- 30:42a lot of confidences is going to work, but I'm hoping that it will
- 30:45work. I would on the list of my short list of hypotheses would be
- 30:51that the person has a protective part of their personality that pushes people away in
- 30:56this way and tries to appear that they're independent and don't need any help.
- 31:00So yeah, and along these lines, I think what you're getting at,
- 31:04Bob, is someone coming to you. Know. I've done this before too,
- 31:07I'm sure you have, and I've framed it this way, so I
- 31:11don't require self awareness at upfront. So a client could come to me and
- 31:15I can try to work on self awareness. But if it doesn't seem to
- 31:18work, or the child, or it's a child like they're five, and
- 31:22there's not a lot of diagrams that they're gonna absorb about countertransference and abuse in
- 31:30this certain thing, sure I will forego self awareness for the other pillar,
- 31:33which is corrective experience. It helps if they're self aware because then they can
- 31:37actually do things in the moments and frame things in a more corrective way for
- 31:41them. But it's not necessary. You can do only corrective experiences with people
- 31:45and have that result and change for them, you know what I mean.
- 31:49I was just thinking about this this man. I really liked him. I
- 31:52really liked him a lot, and he had been through several therapists in the
- 31:56clinic, and I used to approach our meetings with empty hands. He could
- 32:00dismiss me, I used to We used to joke that he could crush me
- 32:02with his iron boot of intelligence. Being empty handed and not needing him to
- 32:12do anything for me, I think was really helpful to him. It gave
- 32:15him a space and some freedom. And I only saw him for a few
- 32:19months, and at the end he said to me, he said, you're
- 32:24the best therapist I had here. And I said, well, thank you,
- 32:27and then he laughed and he's like, I'm not saying you're a good
- 32:30therapist. I'm just saying you were the best. So I laughed with him
- 32:37because it's really funny, you know. And it was also his way of
- 32:39keeping distance. But it's like he could reach for me with his back to
- 32:44me and his hand out. He could stick his hand back behind him to
- 32:46try to reach for me, and that was the best he could do.
- 32:50And I accepted that and that was fine. Good guy. Really, I
- 32:53think about him very fondly. Darcis just a guy, but good guy.
- 32:55Yeah, yeah, all right, take a break, all right, back
- 33:04from the break annual anonymous patron. She says, lately, I've been listening
- 33:08to a lot of episodes with you and Bob where he gets vulnerable with you,
- 33:13which inspired me to write this email in your most recent patron Q and
- 33:17a on YouTube. I do these YouTube live streams and people ask questions and
- 33:22the comment section and I'll answer him on the air. I asked a question,
- 33:25so she asked a question. It was about the difference between flaws,
- 33:29shame and effectiveness schema. So just chiming in here, I coined, I
- 33:34think this term flashame in relation to OCPD obsessive coostal personage order that I think
- 33:42at the you know, for borderline it's abandonment trauma, and I think for
- 33:46OCPD the chreous flashing that you've been shamed for being flawed in some way.
- 33:52You've been criticized and rejected because of that. And so she's saying, I
- 33:57asked about what's the difference between flash same and defectiveness schema. It was something
- 34:02I had been wondering about for a while because I can identify with both,
- 34:07but I assumed I am likely just confusing one for the other. So just
- 34:13chiming in because I think this goes to another topic. But the way I
- 34:16would answer that today and I hope I answered it this way in the moment.
- 34:21I can never know is that there's a differences. It can result in
- 34:24the same you know, if you are flamed for if you're flamed for shots,
- 34:30if you're shamed for having flaws as a child, then you can develop
- 34:34a defective eschema, meaning that you believe that you're defective at your core and
- 34:37there's really nothing that can change that, and you just have to hide it.
- 34:40If people really knew you, they would see just how worthless and rejectable
- 34:45you are. But that's only one avenue of that trauma. Another avenue is
- 34:51to say, I'm going to be perfect, and I can achieve that.
- 34:55You can also have both, but they're they're different, you know what I
- 35:00mean? And might flow shame might somewhere with OCPD deep down? Is there
- 35:06an inherent element of some deep down imperfection that you have to you have to
- 35:12mask. Yeah, you could word it that way, but in in description
- 35:15and in narrative and in vibe, it's a it's a different experience. Bob,
- 35:19You have defectiveness schema. You believe that you're defective deep down? Correct?
- 35:23Yeah, why don't you answer it that way? Because it's fun.
- 35:30I was like, did we don't talk about that? Thought? Yeah?
- 35:36Whereas I have flaw shame, I'm I'm perfectious. Now you might also be
- 35:39are you perfectionists as well? I have my moments, yeah, yeah,
- 35:44but I don't have defectiveness schema. I don't believe deep down that I am
- 35:49unlovable or rejectable. I don't see that in myself because I wasn't treated in
- 35:53that way. So would you say that you're not mindful or vigilant about a
- 35:59flaw being revealed or if it only comes up if one happens to surface,
- 36:05you know, be flubb a note on your guitar or something. Well,
- 36:07it's different to be seen as being flawed or to make a mistake than to
- 36:15be inherently deep down to believe, like at my core regardless of what I
- 36:20do. Like I guess, with flaw shame, it has more to do
- 36:22with action and observation than it has to do with baseline. You're just disgusting
- 36:28of gross and self perception or dirty or nothing or something. Um those Now
- 36:35might some people kind of word them similarly, Yeah, I can see them.
- 36:38Yeah, but as someone who has a mild case of flaw shame and
- 36:44definitely does not have defective a schema. I could say that they are not
- 36:47one and the same. Yeah, um, so she goes on. The
- 36:52thing is I never participate in Q and a's online out of fear. I
- 36:58overcame this fear by minding myself of your compassion, but as soon as I
- 37:02hit send, I felt an enormous way of a panic and shame. I
- 37:07felt like my question was extremely stupid unintelligent, showing that I know nothing about
- 37:13this topic. I also felt guilty about selfishly posting my question and expecting you
- 37:16to spend time on it. Looking back on it later, your answer was
- 37:21very helpful and interesting, and I appreciate it a lot, But at the
- 37:23moment, all I could hear was that you were judging me for being stupid
- 37:28and looking down at me. Just j I mean here, I would never
- 37:30think that it's just like not a thing I would think. Ever, you
- 37:37appreciate that people are interested and want to talk about this stuff and are curious
- 37:42like you and enjoy you know. Yeah, fitting I'm like thinking everything's I'm
- 37:46stupid, But I would never think that about someone that wrote in like that.
- 37:52Yeah, from your podcast, I have learned enough to know this is
- 37:57this likely has little to do with reality thinking I'm stupid and comes from my
- 38:00childhood traumas. But I would really appreciate it if you could tell me how
- 38:06you experience such questions so I can actually internalize it. I think it might
- 38:08be a valuable corrective experience for me. Just jam in here. Yeah,
- 38:14well, anonymous patron. When I'm at my sort of cruising speed, which
- 38:19isn't my best speed, I am not really thinking about the personality of the
- 38:24person asking the question, because live Q and A there's this, you know,
- 38:30a scrolling live stream chat that's just going by very quickly, and I'm
- 38:35trying to think on my toes, and so I'm in my own head,
- 38:37trying to be of service to the audience, and so I read a question
- 38:42and there's no time in my or space in my brain to contemplate what your
- 38:47personality is or if you're stupid or smart or anything. I'm just like,
- 38:52I'm flying by the seed of my pants. So that's my cruising speed at
- 38:55best. Though, when I hear a question like that, I imagine the
- 39:00individual has one or both, and I feel bad for that person, and
- 39:04I also feel very especially a question like that, because I would suspect that
- 39:08you learn those concepts from me, So you're like connected to me, you've
- 39:14been with me. You're like a not really but kind of like a student
- 39:19or supervise that has contact with me, someone that's in my life, someone
- 39:22that says, what's the difference between flash am and defective schemead that there's so
- 39:27much implied contact that we've had, and that closeness feels good to me and
- 39:35extremely gratifying that because that's really one of the best experiences that you can have.
- 39:39I guess you can have this as a therapist as well, but I
- 39:43think it's more likely to show up as a professor that and maybe when you
- 39:45were actually when you're doing the DBD classes, you would probably have this.
- 39:49So there'd be a point where the student in your class would ask a question
- 39:54or say something to someone else in the group that would indicate that they have
- 39:59really absorbed orbed what you have been trying to get across to them, and
- 40:01they believe it. They've internalized it. It's theirs now, and your language
- 40:07or you know, your terms, things that you know that they did not
- 40:09have prior to entering the class. They are now using themselves. They're comfortable
- 40:15with it, they believe in it, they understand it, they get it,
- 40:17they're using it in a way that is helpful to themselves. You know,
- 40:22how did that feel when that would happen? Oh? Is there higher
- 40:25higher praise? Yeah? I don't think there is. You know, when
- 40:30you live inside the mind and heart of another and that they're grabbing hold of
- 40:34something that they find useful and helpful. Yeah, that's fantastic. Yeah,
- 40:38that's how whoever, I forgive me anonymous patron, that's how they sound.
- 40:44They've done that. It's fantastic, right yeah, and take care of themselves
- 40:46because they deserve it, right, So, you know, at best,
- 40:51that's how I'm thinking. Yeah, So I hope that is a corrective experience
- 40:55for you, patron. The other thing I'll say, then, nomous patron,
- 40:59is, let's say, in this weird, bizarro world, I did
- 41:01think you were dumb. That's not on you, that would be on me.
- 41:05Yeah. Just because someone thinks you're dumb, which happens, does not
- 41:08mean you are dumb. So that's another part of this corrective experience is for
- 41:14me to tell you, as a corrective experience that you don't have to listen
- 41:17to anyone say anything about you. You don't have to regard anything anyone says
- 41:22about you or believes about you, even if you don't know they You know,
- 41:24you think I think they think I'm stupid. Maybe there's even indications even
- 41:29if I were to say that you're stupid, that does not matter, because
- 41:32that is on me. I'm the stupid head, I'm the dumb one.
- 41:37I'm the hostile one. I'm the unfair one. Not you. You are
- 41:39not blended with other people's thoughts of you. You are your own thing,
- 41:44your own pillar of awesomeness that has nothing to do with what other people think
- 41:50of you. You can regard it, and it's hard not to let it
- 41:52in. But even if someone did think you're stupid, that's you know,
- 41:55It's sort of like, at best, if I'm on this streets or in
- 42:00public and some toxic mail calls me a pussy or something, at my best,
- 42:05I'd be like, well, that's on you. I feel bad.
- 42:08You know, internally, at least, I'd be thinking my manhood or my
- 42:14worth as a human being is impervious to your random attempt at insulting me.
- 42:19It's it doesn't affect me. I'm strong enough, I know myself enough illogical
- 42:22for me to even think you would know who I am based on this road
- 42:25rate insident or something. So now I'm not usually like that because it's hard
- 42:30to be that way. But going on, I also just want to think
- 42:34you and Bob, while writing this email terrifies me. I will send it,
- 42:37which I never would have done before I started listening to the podcast.
- 42:40You also helped me developed a lot of awareness for my issues. So thank
- 42:45you very much, right on, very well, thanks for writing in.
- 42:47Yeah, alright, one more email here. Bob eg upper Tier Patron Arizona
- 42:54from Arizona. She says, from twenty nineteen to twenty twenty one, I
- 42:59had a wonderful therapy. It was the most secure and corrective experience I have
- 43:02ever had, particularly with a mail. At one point towards the end of
- 43:07the relationship, I made a mistake. I told him I was planning on
- 43:09having skin removal surgery to remove ten pounds of extra skin after massive weight loss.
- 43:15He asked me directly, how much does it cost? So, just
- 43:17chiming in here, what do you think about a therapist asking a question like
- 43:22that? Oh? I don't know what to think about it. It sort
- 43:24of depends on, you know, were they just sort of interested and curious,
- 43:29was there something on their mind around money or you know whatever. So
- 43:32I don't really know what to think right so far, I don't have an
- 43:36opinion. Yeah. Same. I trusted him from the depths of my heart
- 43:38and told him the number. It was a high number, but I saved
- 43:42up the money for years and desperately wanted to feel comfortable in my own skin
- 43:45and prevent skin infections. A few months later, he announced that he was
- 43:51no longer accepting insurance, but he was going to work with every client and
- 43:54that no one would be abandoned for financial reasons. So, okay, I
- 44:00have had this transition. Did you make this transition? I can't say I
- 44:06did it like that, but I did make this transition from taking insurance to
- 44:08not taking insurance. Yes, and it sucks because it makes things less affordable
- 44:14to people. But if we as clinicians are going to make a living and
- 44:19pay our bills and maybe have a tiny retirement fund, then this is kind
- 44:24of the way to go. The problem is is that there's not enough funding
- 44:28and tax money spent on people getting access to therapy. It's not our fault
- 44:31for trying to actually have a career and not living week to week or month
- 44:37to month anyway. So yeah, And one of the worries that we have
- 44:42as therapists when we do this is that for some of our clients who we
- 44:45care about, it will be hard for them to afford us because they'll be
- 44:49going from a ten twenty dollars copay to maybe using out of network, which
- 44:53may or may not even work, and so they might be going from twenty
- 44:58dollars a week to seventy five dollars a week or maybe even two hundred dollars
- 45:02a week, and for many therapists, And it sounds like her therapist said
- 45:08that he would work with people and say, like, you know, if
- 45:13you can't afford two hundred, we'll bring it down to what you can afford.
- 45:15It kind of sounds like that's what he was saying, yea, But
- 45:19ultimately he didn't work with me. So I've read this email previously and it's
- 45:22a little hard for me to tell exactly what happened, but let me continue
- 45:27reading. Sure, I can't help, but wonder if he wrote me off
- 45:30as being wealthy because I could afford that surgery and therefore with someone who would
- 45:36ultimately cave and pay up in order to bask in the only secure relationship that
- 45:39I had ever known. So just send me in here. I read this
- 45:44email a bunch of times, and I kept trying to figure out what might
- 45:49have happened based on I'm trying to read between the lines of like, what's
- 45:51the detail here, because I have a hard time believing that he just said
- 45:55I'm going to charge two hundred dollars an hour. That's my fee and she
- 45:59was going twenty two hundred and she couldn't afford two hundred and at our time
- 46:05that he was just like, well, because you had that surgery and you're
- 46:07a rich person, screw off or something. So I don't know, but
- 46:12I think there's a fifty percent chance, based on what we're hearing that what
- 46:16might have happened is that he said this to her and all of his clients,
- 46:21and he felt bad about putting clients in that situation. And she presented
- 46:27him She's like, well, I can't afford X, but I can't afford
- 46:31why, so is it okay? If? Or maybe even can I just
- 46:35keep it at my copay? And he maybe immediately said, well, actually,
- 46:40I can't go down that low. My fee schedule's gonna be my lowest
- 46:46price will be seventy five or something like that. And she couldn't afford that,
- 46:51and so he had to terminate with her. And so either he misspoke
- 46:54when he said I'm going to work with all clients regardless, or he didn't
- 46:59really it that way, and he kind of said it in a way that
- 47:01made her believe that no matter what, he would try to make it work
- 47:05with it. Because that's quite a statement, like if someone came to me,
- 47:07I would never recommend that they say that to all their clients because you
- 47:12know, if they said that to me, I'd be like, so,
- 47:14are you prepared to see a client for thirty or zero dollars? There?
- 47:16Because what if the client their co pay, they lose the ability to even
- 47:21pay that Coinciding with you, you know, switching away from insurance, are
- 47:24you prepared to see five clients at pro bono or something because there's a possibility
- 47:30that can happen. And if so, then okay, great, because you're
- 47:31really opening yourself up to you know, what you want to say as I'm
- 47:35switching away from insurance. And for those of you who might have a hardship.
- 47:38Let's talk about it. And I have a fee schedule here based on
- 47:42your income, and if that doesn't work, then unfortunately I will give you.
- 47:45You know, you could say I'll give you five pro bono sessions,
- 47:49but we have to actually trans transition to another therapist. To pretend you don't
- 47:52have limits is just silly, yeah, because it's just going to happen.
- 47:55You know. I'm guessing that he switched away from insurance because he wanted to
- 48:00make more money to begin with. So to set yourself up for failure with
- 48:06less money, yeah, is not a good idea. And maybe they didn't
- 48:09think it through. Whoever that there is, maybe right. They were scared
- 48:14and they felt guilty, and a lot of therapists do feel guilty about money,
- 48:16and where I Yeah, and I was guilty of that, Like I
- 48:21wouldn't even gather the money. I would just put it off and put it
- 48:24off, and then people would have these enormous balances, and then I had
- 48:30clients that didn't pay those balances, and I just said, well, that's
- 48:35kind of on me. Thousands and thousands of dollars. You know, I'm
- 48:38pretty good with a lot of the professionalism of our profession. But that's just
- 48:43one of them that I just had. Everyone was always better than me and
- 48:46that anyway. Yeah, so I think something happened there and she couldn't really
- 48:53afford or he changed his mind later and said, well, actually, I
- 48:58guess I did say I'd work with everyone, but that's really true, and
- 49:00then he terminated with her, or they agreed to terminate because of the financial
- 49:07problems. That's what I think, because I think if he just rejected her,
- 49:09like you're a wealthy son of a bitch and I'm going to get rid
- 49:13of you, she would have mentioned something like that. So I'm guessing it
- 49:15had something to do with that. Okay, could be the therapist didn't know
- 49:16their limits until they crossed them. Yeah, yeah, right, I mean,
- 49:20nobody knows their limits until they crossed them. Right. Also, you
- 49:22could change your mind. You could in the in the moment say I'm willing
- 49:25to work with everyone, and then six months later you're like, actually,
- 49:30I don't want to do that. Yeah that's okay. Yeah, it's not
- 49:32great business to set up that expectation. But and maybe you could be liable
- 49:38for something like that, But I don't imagine that panic about Yeah, Yeah,
- 49:44like McDonald says, you know, we're gonna charge a dollar for a
- 49:49burger, and then later on they say we're raising the price. Now,
- 49:52if McDonald says something like we are never raising our price above a dollar,
- 49:58then you know, then you have a problem. But yeah, and maybe
- 50:01the therapist did that, I don't know. Yeah, but the leap that
- 50:05the client is making is that the reason why it broke down was because she
- 50:08told him how much her surgery, her surgery costs, and she's concluding that
- 50:15it's because of that, which there's at least in the email. There's the
- 50:17email. Yeah, we can. So she asks, was it ethically questionable
- 50:22for him to ask me how much I paid for the surgery? I have
- 50:24been permanently scarred by this experience. Okay, so is it ethical that he
- 50:29asked the question? Yeah? Yeah, there's nothing wrong with that question.
- 50:31And if you're in therapy with somebody and something like this comes up, you
- 50:35get to talk about it, right, like it feels weird for you to
- 50:37know, or you know, like that feels invasive if that's the case or
- 50:42whatever, or are you terminating with me because because because of that? Yeah,
- 50:46do you have some impression about how much money I have. Yeah,
- 50:49and this is in the context of what she's saying as a wonderful therapist who
- 50:54was very secure, So we could guess and say that he's not this condition
- 51:00ving Machiavellian a hole probably so uh yeah. I will say though that if
- 51:06I if I heard a clip from a therapy session of a colleague or a
- 51:09supervise and I, you know, it sounds like immediately that's the question asked,
- 51:15I would ask the clinician, why did you ask that question? I
- 51:17would say it's a bad question of bad what was the impulse there? Because
- 51:22if there was a clinical reason that I'd be okay. And then I might
- 51:24say, well, you didn't really make that very clear because the way it
- 51:29came across it sounded like you were just kind of curious, or it could
- 51:34come across wrong, because you know, you get into topics like that.
- 51:37Plus like for this individual, the body shame or the the the life goal
- 51:45of getting the body that feels right to them is a big emotional deal for
- 51:50them. And for you to just micro ask a question like that of how
- 51:53much does it cost? You know, it's it's like someone's telling you about
- 51:57how they were abused as a kid, and you're just like what outfit was
- 52:00your dad wearing at the time, Like, well, what does it matter?
- 52:04Well, I don't know. I'm just curious. You know, it
- 52:06derails people, So I don't know what's going on there. But maybe there's
- 52:09a justification, like, well, I know the therapist could say that,
- 52:13I know that she really struggled with money, and we had actually talked about
- 52:17how sometimes she would overspend and so that. But I could, honestly,
- 52:22given the context, see a therapist saying, yeah, I don't really know
- 52:24why I asked that question. I was just kind of curious because I was
- 52:28watching this show about about those kinds of surgeries, and I'd heard that they
- 52:30were really expensive, and I was just kind of curious, like how much
- 52:35does something like that cost? Because it's probably is it a lot of money?
- 52:38Are we talking like fifty grand? Or are we talking like two grand?
- 52:42Like what are we talking about? You? Like, you can imagine
- 52:44the therapist just being kind of and maybe the therapist was that loose. Maybe
- 52:46the therapist is that kind of therapist where they're just kind of more casual in
- 52:51their questions, which you know, Amy, so to answer your question based
- 52:54on your description patron, was it ethical, Yeah, it's not unethical going
- 53:00on. I have been permanently scarred by this experience. I still cry about
- 53:05it. Having this is two years ago, the termination, I still cry
- 53:08about it. I have intrusive thoughts every day, and I feel trauma.
- 53:12Well, I feel trauma. I feel the trauma well up in my throat
- 53:15whenever I think of him. I have been considering filing a complaint with the
- 53:20board. For me to feel this way after more than a year, something
- 53:22went terribly wrong. But I don't know if an ethical violation of substance occurred.
- 53:28Any thoughts, But I don't hear an ethical violation. I hear a
- 53:31lot of pain about what sounds like an abrupt termination in a sense of rupture.
- 53:37But and yes, of course you can finally complaint. That is absolutely
- 53:42You're right. I don't know that, based on what's here, that an
- 53:45ethics board will do much. Yeah, I'm not saying that they should.
- 53:49I don't know if they should. Depends on the c depends on the circumstance.
- 53:52But yeah, I mean, termination is a flashpoint for complaints being honored
- 53:59by license to board or in a court of lab When you're being sued.
- 54:04You know, It's one of those things that I had to kind of learn
- 54:07as time went on that when we terminate with clients, we have to really
- 54:10make sure we're doing it right, that we're buttoned up, and if there's
- 54:15a rupture that you try to minimize that as best as you can. And
- 54:19because once you terminate, if the rupture grows, which it sounds like it
- 54:24has with this client, then you're not there to counteract it or help with
- 54:29it at all, and harm can occur and a year or two later,
- 54:34the client can end up having a balloon so large that they end up taking
- 54:37action against you. So making sure that you terminate well also around suicidality and
- 54:43that kind of thing. But anyway, yeah, yeah, First off,
- 54:46it sounds like you're suffering greatly from the loss of that relationship, and it
- 54:50sounds weird, but I would recommend going to therapy to help recover from that
- 54:53loss. It sounds weird, but we've given that recommendation to other people before.
- 54:59I mean, it sounds like you, patron, you have relational traumas
- 55:01around abandonment or abuse or something denial of a secure relationship, and this relationship
- 55:08was very valuable to you and to lose it as devastating. You might even
- 55:12say it's the one secure relationship that you had and to have that end based
- 55:16on how you perceive, at the very least, putting aside the surgery that
- 55:21you went through, at the very least, he wasn't willing to lower his
- 55:24fee such that you could continue to see him. You know that hurts.
- 55:29Yeah, that hurts. That's rough. Yeah, I mean that, And
- 55:30it is something to think about for you clinicians out there, because if I
- 55:34were in that situation, if I had a client that I thought there was
- 55:37a twenty percent chance that no matter what I did in a termination, if
- 55:42I did everything perfectly, that the client two years later would be traumatized by
- 55:46this break, I personally would not terminate. I would see that client pro
- 55:51bono because I would say to myself, why am I on this planet if
- 55:55not to do that good? Why did I become a fair rapist? Yes,
- 56:00it sucks that I have to bite the bullet monetarily, but you know
- 56:05I'll make up for it in this other way. You know, I won't
- 56:07budge with these other clients about this sort of thing, or I'll make sure
- 56:10that I have a fee structure such that I can pay my bills, you
- 56:13know, and learn whatever I needed to learn based on this, you know
- 56:17circumstance like maybe their their fee is too low. It can general their fee
- 56:22is too low and they don't have room in their practice per pro bono.
- 56:24Oh that's important learning. So if I'm going to keep a client pro bono,
- 56:28then set it up so that the rest of my practice can support that,
- 56:31right, Yeah, And so that's me. But if someone said I
- 56:37can't really do that, I wouldn't fault them. It just sucks. It's
- 56:42just one of those things, one of those unfortunate aspects of the profession of
- 56:45being a therapist. You know. Sometimes you move, or you get sick,
- 56:50or you want to change careers and you shut down your practice. And
- 56:54if you're the sort of therapist like Bob and I, then you're going to
- 56:58have these attachment oriented clients that no matter what you do, it's it's going
- 57:02to be a huge loss for them. That's going to involve a lot of
- 57:06grief. So it sucks, and you deserve to recover from it. And
- 57:10if you found a therapist, for example, and you did develop a good
- 57:15enough secure attachment with that other therapist might even be deeper who knows, and
- 57:19you heal to some extent from that previous therapeutic relationship. You know, a
- 57:23couple of years time, you could be better off than you ever were.
- 57:27You know, It's this isn't like you're doomed and there's no hope in sight,
- 57:32you know. So it sucks, and I'm sorry that that happened.
- 57:37As Bob said, you could find on a plane if you went to But
- 57:40I doubt the board would investigate ed. Even if they did investigate it,
- 57:45I'm guessing that he could provide an acceptable explanation as to well why he changed
- 57:50his fee or why he terminated, And even if they did sanction him,
- 57:53which would be really a long shot of some way, it would probably be
- 57:58minimal given what CC board sees. This is not the sort of thing like
- 58:02having sex with a client or that sort of thing. So even if they
- 58:07did find in your favor, they would probably only quote unquote scentence him to
- 58:13an ethics training or probation for a year or something. So you just have
- 58:17to consider that whether it would be satisfying to you. You know, sometimes
- 58:22you can work into it, like I demand an apology on the other hand,
- 58:27you can just directly complain to him. I find that a lot of
- 58:30people don't consider that. Yeah, you can write a letter and just mail
- 58:35it to him or email it to him and be like, and just just
- 58:37tell them what's going on. I did not appreciate it when you did this,
- 58:40And you know, maybe that will provide some satisfaction. Maybe it won't.
- 58:45Maybe he'll apologize, maybe he won't. Maybe he'll defend himself. Maybe
- 58:49I don't know. Maybe he'll give corrective information, like it didn't have anything
- 58:52to do with the money that you saved. Maybe that maybe that person is
- 58:58even proud of you for looking to yourself in this way, saving your money
- 59:00which probably wasn't very easy to do this thing, and recognizing your own need.
- 59:05It's like, that's what stood out to me in this story, is
- 59:07they saved their money so that they can look after themselves and take care of
- 59:10this thing. I think that's really freaking cool. It's really cool. Yeah,
- 59:15So this it sucks, and it's normal to want, especially when you're
- 59:22that hurt, you're that angry. It sounds like you might be angry that
- 59:27you want someone to, you know, get their just dessert or something,
- 59:30and it isn't really usually possible, at least scenarios. But I'm guessing,
- 59:37as Bob is pointing out, what you want is validation from us and maybe
- 59:42from him. Imagine if that could happen. You know, there's a risk
- 59:45there if you send the letter and he just doesn't reply or defends himself,
- 59:49could make it worse. So you know, again, talk with the therapists
- 59:52about that, right, all right, Well that does it's for that episode
- 59:54of Psychology and Seattle. Bob. Yeah, we have a lot more emails.
- 1:00:00It's funny. So and one of our more recent episodes last month,
- 1:00:04at the end of the episode, I was like, hey, we finished
- 1:00:06all the emails, and someone emailed in or commented or something, and they're
- 1:00:10like, wow, so Kirk doesn't have any emails. Let's start sending you
- 1:00:15emails. I want to be clear, only the emails that are in the
- 1:00:17Bob documents were completed. The email documents that I have are you know,
- 1:00:24a lot longer. Yeah, there's only a I would say one out of
- 1:00:30every forty emails is applicable to Bob and me. So I have a lot
- 1:00:36more emails than that. Plus, you know a lot of even Bob applicable
- 1:00:39emails keep coming in. So anyway, and along these lines, I just
- 1:00:45want to remind everybody that we are now at a place as a podcast where
- 1:00:49it's not possible for us to answer everyone's emails, and that sucks. Yeah,
- 1:00:53And I know the feeling. I know. I've been there. I've
- 1:00:59emailed up podcast or I've left a voicemail for a podcast, and when they
- 1:01:04don't, I think about the wording. I try to make it as heartfelt
- 1:01:07and as I try to prove that I'm a true fan, and to get
- 1:01:13nothing back it sucks. Ye. What I'll say is the average podcasts doesn't
- 1:01:19reply to anybody email or podcast was Oh yeah, Oh I didn't know that.
- 1:01:24Oh yeah. Like the fact that we even reply verbally or through email
- 1:01:30to anybody is kind of rare. I mean, there's some content providers that
- 1:01:35are just constantly replying to everybody on TikTok or something. But but I will
- 1:01:38say that I feel some solace in that I'm doing better than a lot of
- 1:01:43others. You know, Like I was talking to the very first psychology podcaster,
- 1:01:47doctor Dave, and did you ever listen to this podcast? Because you
- 1:01:52know somebody I was asking him when I was interviewing him, I asked him,
- 1:01:58I don't know how we got to this topic, but I said,
- 1:02:00well, aren't you interested in what your listeners think? You know, aren't
- 1:02:06interested in their thoughts or their questions. And he just had immediate is nope.
- 1:02:13And I just thought, yeah, you know, I think a lot
- 1:02:15of content providers they just just not interested. Yeah, I mean, I
- 1:02:21guess I don't know. I can't relate to that. So I've always been
- 1:02:24interested because I want that relationship, that contact. You know. I don't
- 1:02:29want to just talk into a microphone and have it go out. I want
- 1:02:31to want there to be an exchange, yeah whatever, there can be a
- 1:02:35human and exchange. Yeah, and so anyway, so I take some solace
- 1:02:40in the fact that we do some of it, but you know, and
- 1:02:43I get it. There's sometimes when I'll skim an email and I don't even
- 1:02:47have time. You know. It's funny. There's another YouTuber that I watch.
- 1:02:52He repairs guitars. T Woodford is his handle and name, and he
- 1:03:00just repairs old acoustic guitars and electric guitars for forty five minutes. And he
- 1:03:06has this very soothing voice, and he'll talk about things and I just watch
- 1:03:08him and I just love it. And he said one time, he's like,
- 1:03:14I get a lot of emails inquiring about fixing people's guitars from all over
- 1:03:17the world. And the truth is is that of the inquiries I can't get
- 1:03:22to because of time. But also it's economically not feasible. Someone will have
- 1:03:27a two hundred dollars guitar from you know, they live in Europe and I'm
- 1:03:31in Canada. For them to ship it to me, it would be like
- 1:03:35two thous I don't know, some inordinant amount of money for me to do
- 1:03:38work that they could just take down to their local shop and they could do
- 1:03:43the work. Like you don't, you don't, don't ship it to me,
- 1:03:45for that's that's not good for you. And so he has all this,
- 1:03:52you know, all these responses that he has to tell people. He
- 1:03:53feels obligated to reply. And so he did the math and he's actually counted
- 1:03:58how many emails he gets in a year, and he says that he gets
- 1:04:00x amount per year. And he's like, on a good day, let's
- 1:04:03say it takes me two minutes to reply to an email, to think about
- 1:04:06a response and type it out and data DA and if when you calculate that
- 1:04:11out, it equals um like a month and a half of full time job
- 1:04:15work, because you know, what do you think about, Okay, it
- 1:04:18just takes two minutes to reply and right, but when you add up all
- 1:04:25of the emails and you know, getting into the mindset sitting down, it
- 1:04:29adds up, you know. And so I want to say that because when
- 1:04:32when he was saying that, I was like, I never had thought about
- 1:04:36that's the reality that I go through and I get way more emails than this
- 1:04:41guy does and I can't reply in two minutes. You know. There's so
- 1:04:45much involved in what people are asking of me, and so I just want
- 1:04:50to put out there. And I've said this before, but I just I
- 1:04:54just I'm reminded of people feeling hurt that we don't get to their emails,
- 1:04:58and I it's partly my fault because I kind of set up that expectation in
- 1:05:01the past. That's like, I will do that because I was committed to
- 1:05:04that, and you could. I could, but I can't, and it
- 1:05:08sucks. So I'll be reading an email and I'll be thinking, this is
- 1:05:12such a heartfelt, interesting email, and I don't have time and I think
- 1:05:17I answered it in a previous episode, so I'm just gonna put it aside.
- 1:05:23It pains me to do that. And I know some people like,
- 1:05:27well, just reply, And I'm telling you, I wouldn't be on this
- 1:05:30microphone right now. I wouldn't have time to do that if I did,
- 1:05:32if you did, And it brings a tear to my eye because I know
- 1:05:36how that feels, you know. And I know no one's just no one
- 1:05:40thinks that I'm their special podcaster, like they're the only one emailing in.
- 1:05:45But I don't know. I just want everyone to when people reach out,
- 1:05:47you'd like to be able to reach back. You just yeah, it's just
- 1:05:50you know, you would just want to yeah. Yeah. And also like
- 1:05:56you know, these individuals are spending hours listening to us. N't spend two
- 1:06:00minutes to apply. I mean, I apparently I can't well two minutes or
- 1:06:04half an hour or whatever it would take to reply in the way that you
- 1:06:08want, because you don't want a half asset, And you're just letting us
- 1:06:11know that it's you just reach it's beyond your limits anymore. Yeah, it
- 1:06:15ain't used to be, but now it is. Yeah, I'm sorry.
- 1:06:18I mean maybe I'll get canceled on the internet and my numbers will plumb it
- 1:06:23and then then I could go back to answering it. So for people out
- 1:06:26there, you know, one motivation to get me canceled from me? Do
- 1:06:29you know what canceled means? I do? Oh, just plotting how to
- 1:06:32do it because you're staring at me with a blank stare and I'm just thinking,
- 1:06:38O, see what would it take? Hey, I did my seventh
- 1:06:43cameo this morning. Oh yeah, I wasn't. It was really nice,
- 1:06:47you know, like what I get requested to do a little bit of encouragement
- 1:06:50or whatever, and happy to do that, and does it feels it's nice?
- 1:06:55I mean it feels a little weird because you know, I'm not used
- 1:06:57to, you know whatever, talking into the camera or whatever. But but
- 1:07:00no, it's nice and I'm glad that I can. I can do that.
- 1:07:02And the feedback I've gotten, not much feedback, but a little bit
- 1:07:06I've gotten is you know that people are happy to get those from me.
- 1:07:11The reviews on cameo Yeah yeah, yeah yeah. So and then you know,
- 1:07:14I told Colleen about it and I said I was joking. I said,
- 1:07:16well, next time we fight, you can request the cameo. She
- 1:07:20said, yeah, I'll buy a cameo from me. You'll have to say
- 1:07:23what I want. And I say, well, if that's true, then
- 1:07:26really I'll be buying it and community property state. No. Yeah, so
- 1:07:31I don't know. I actually could happen she might request the cameo. It's
- 1:07:34funny. Yeah, yeah, I was at the beginning. When Cameo first
- 1:07:40came out, I had a typical reaction, which is like, oh,
- 1:07:44there's all these like D list celebrities that are struggling with their careers, you
- 1:07:47know, people that aren't getting roles anymore, and they're I don't know,
- 1:07:51these online prostitutes essentially, that are trying to eke out some level of fame
- 1:07:58or some level of income, and you're just like us, kind of sad,
- 1:08:00you know. I remember thinking that in the beginning. Then when Cameo
- 1:08:03reached out to me out of the blue and said, hey, you should
- 1:08:06be on Cameo, I was like huh, and I just thought no.
- 1:08:11And then and then I thought, well, I don't know, maybe let's
- 1:08:15let's do an experiment for a month and see how it goes. And then
- 1:08:18when I started doing it, I realized the magic of it, the way
- 1:08:23that it feels, you know, the way that I think about it is
- 1:08:26that I would love to do a cameo for everyone that wanted one for free.
- 1:08:30Occasionally that would happen in the past. Someone would email in and say,
- 1:08:33like, oh, my wife loves you. Can you give her a
- 1:08:36birthday blurb that you know, record one and send it to me and in
- 1:08:42your podcast style and then I'll play it for her. And you know,
- 1:08:45i'd do that sometimes, Yeah, but what the way, So I wish
- 1:08:49I could do that for everybody, because I know what it's like to get
- 1:08:54a cameo from someone that you love. You know, like um Taylor Rap
- 1:09:00from the La Rams. He used to play for the U dub Huskies as
- 1:09:03a as a defensive back and he's half Asian, so I think he's great.
- 1:09:12Yeah, I was a defensive back and anyway, so I got a
- 1:09:15cameo from him. My friend got me a cameo from right, and I
- 1:09:18was just delighted. But it's so dumb because it's like, I know,
- 1:09:23he doesn't really know me, but it's just it feels it's just delightful.
- 1:09:26Anyway. Yeah, so I would love to do it for everyone, But
- 1:09:30I can't with time, so I kind of consider the fee to be this
- 1:09:33barrier of entry kind of a thing. You know. It's just like limits
- 1:09:38the number of requests that I get so that it is manageable. Yeah.
- 1:09:43And also baby people make sure that it's a special enough event instead of just
- 1:09:48like tell me that I'm a tell me good morning today or something. So
- 1:09:55you know that that's kind of the way I think about it. About it
- 1:09:57makes sense, and yeah, pretty cool. Please started to realize just how
- 1:10:01nice it felt to be able to give to someone in this way, you
- 1:10:06know, to try to maybe it's a little piece of advice, or I'll
- 1:10:11write a song or something, and oh that's nice. Yeah, I mean
- 1:10:14it's just you know, a little quick jingle or something like someone just asked
- 1:10:17for a cameo this morning, and so I'm looking forward to doing that.
- 1:10:23You know. It's a little kind of a bright moment. Yeah, I'll
- 1:10:25say, though, I have to be in the right mood, Like there
- 1:10:28are some spans of time, like a few days where I'm just not in
- 1:10:31the right mood. You know, you gotta be chipper. It's true,
- 1:10:35Like I never do him on the spot. I always let him percolate.
- 1:10:40And then I always make sure I shower and shape other thing, like,
- 1:10:44you can't look like a slob. No, no, somebody's no, I'm
- 1:10:46not gonna do and and and in the meantime, I think about what they
- 1:10:50said and I really so you you germinate? Oh yeah, for sure.
- 1:10:55And then and then usually I record like ten versions of the thing and then
- 1:11:00really, no, that was dumb. No, no, no, I
- 1:11:01was looking around place or no, you flubbed the word there, wow,
- 1:11:04No, you know, I don't write it down. I just like we
- 1:11:08can get a sense about what I want to say, and then you know,
- 1:11:11eventually i'll do a version that I think is you know, worthy of
- 1:11:14being sent and has says what I wanted to say. And and that's a
- 1:11:16lot of labor, my friend. Yeah, it's like ten minutes, fifteen
- 1:11:19minutes whatever, it's fine, yeah, yeah, worth it. Yeah.
- 1:11:23So yeah, and you know, I imagine I'll get faster as time goes
- 1:11:26on. So yeah, but um, yeah, at the beginning, when
- 1:11:29I've fristed him, yeah, it would take me like an hour to do
- 1:11:31one can right right right, But now I can do it pretty quickly.
- 1:11:35Yeah. Yeah, so but that'll happen. Sometimes I'll be like three minutes
- 1:11:40in and i'll flub something a start right yeah yeah, Or sometimes my phone
- 1:11:46for whatever reason, craps out and I'll record, I'll record the whole thing
- 1:11:51and it won't go through, and I'll be like, it's kind of weird
- 1:11:57to like start over, start over, getting and act like it's the first
- 1:12:00time kind of a thing. Is all right, Bob, Well that doesn't
- 1:12:03for that episode. Everyone please take care of yourself and get the therapy that
- 1:12:10you need, because you deserve it.