Latest / The Film Hobbyist / Wake Up Dead Man (2025): Subverting Subversion
Transcript
- 0:11Come on in and spend some time with the film
- 0:14hobbyist. My name is Lydia, and I love movies.
- 0:31We're sitting here on the swing of my front porch.
- 0:36It's a wooden bench suspended by chains from
- 0:39the portico, where we can enjoy the sounds of
- 0:42the breeze but be sheltered from the chill. Today
- 0:46is overcast and damp. It rained last night, and
- 0:51it will probably rain later today, but for now,
- 0:54everything is green and refreshed, the kind of
- 0:59spring day that is best enjoyed with a cardigan
- 1:02and a cup of tea. Last Sunday was Easter, an
- 1:08odd sort of holiday in American culture. For
- 1:12all the ways that the Christian calendar and
- 1:14American tradition line up, this one sort of
- 1:17comes and goes without too much fuss. If you
- 1:21have a kid, you might go to an Easter egg hunt
- 1:23or take a picture with the Easter bunny. Maybe
- 1:27you have an Easter basket. But Valentine's Day
- 1:30has more cultural pomp than this. Easter generally
- 1:34comes and goes without much notice at the box
- 1:37office either. There's usually some kind of religious
- 1:41-themed film, made for the Christian market,
- 1:45often by the Christian market, but it doesn't
- 1:48make too much of a splash in the cultural conversation
- 1:51as a whole. Last year, though, we actually got
- 1:56an Easter -themed and set movie for a widespread
- 2:00audience. and it released on Thanksgiving, of
- 2:04all things. That would be Wake Up, Dead Man,
- 2:08written and directed by Rian Johnson, the third
- 2:12of his Benoit Blanc knives -out mysteries. Rian
- 2:16Johnson is a pretty interesting filmmaker. He's
- 2:20from the same school of directors as Quentin
- 2:24Tarantino, Wes Anderson, and Edgar Wright, these
- 2:28postmodern filmmakers who build a pastiche of
- 2:32old styles and genres to create something new.
- 2:37Tarantino obviously pulls most from kung fu,
- 2:40westerns, blaxploitation, and crime. Edgar Wright
- 2:44from horror and action. Wes Anderson from 60s
- 2:48and 70s cinema, the films of Hal Ashby especially.
- 2:52But Johnson has less of a distinct visual style
- 2:56and more of a distinct storytelling angle. Johnson
- 3:02loves subversion and irony. His first film, 2005's
- 3:09Brick is an old -school, hard -boiled detective
- 3:13story, complete with a morally complicated protagonist
- 3:16and a femme fatale, all performed in mid -20th
- 3:20century cadence. Except the whole movie takes
- 3:24place in a contemporary California high school.
- 3:27That hard -boiled detective and femme fatale?
- 3:31Teenagers. The plot of this film is layered and
- 3:36twisty and gritty enough to belong to a neo -noir,
- 3:40too gritty for the Hays Code era, but the fact
- 3:44that these are kids talking like Humphrey Bogart
- 3:47and Lauren Bacall adds a whole layer of irony,
- 3:51putting the movie at arm's length. The teenagers
- 3:55take everything deadly seriously, but there's
- 3:58even a scene where the protagonist has a negotiation
- 4:01with a local drug kingpin at the kitchen table
- 4:05of his suburban house while his mom serves them
- 4:09milk. It adds a bizarre moment of levity to an
- 4:13otherwise serious story. And Johnson loves that
- 4:18kind of distance, to throw a joke in what should
- 4:21be a serious moment. In the right project, this
- 4:25is magical. In the wrong project, well, that's
- 4:31how you get The Last Jedi. Much has been said
- 4:35about Johnson's Star Wars movie. I'm not going
- 4:39to go too much in depth here. I will say briefly
- 4:43that I don't think it's the worst Star Wars movie
- 4:46ever made. Rise of Skywalker is an abomination.
- 4:50and that some of its imagery and thematic discussion
- 4:54is really, really interesting. Unfortunately,
- 4:58it's a mess. The good stuff is undercut constantly,
- 5:03some of its thematic material doesn't work at
- 5:06all, and most of the problems come down to one
- 5:09issue. Star Wars must be sincere. The premise
- 5:16for Star Wars is inherently silly. As film essayist
- 5:20Patrick Willem says, this is a movie about space
- 5:24wizards intended for children. It's space opera
- 5:29with over -the -top themes and drama, and it
- 5:33works because it takes itself seriously. If you
- 5:38subvert it, if you treat it with irony, it all
- 5:41falls apart. And so the problem with The Last
- 5:44Jedi is that it is both trying to make a Star
- 5:48Wars film and subvert a Star Wars film, and that
- 5:52just doesn't work. And thankfully, it doesn't.
- 5:59Instead of a Rian Johnson Star Wars trilogy,
- 6:02we got Knives Out. A 2019 whodunit introducing
- 6:08Daniel Craig as Benoit Blanc, a flashy detective
- 6:12with an over -the -top southern accent, a love
- 6:15for bizarre idioms, and a passion for show tunes.
- 6:20Knives Out is a sumptuous film, with really showy
- 6:24filmmaking and an incredible ensemble of memorable
- 6:28characters played by phenomenal actors. It is
- 6:32delightful. And it really showed that Johnson
- 6:36has a mastery of the whodunit genre. Which makes
- 6:41sense. Mysteries are entirely about subversion.
- 6:48If, when a story starts, you already know who
- 6:52is going to die, and who is going to kill them,
- 6:55and how they're going to do it, and how they
- 6:58get caught, well, goodness, where's the fun in
- 7:01that? The delight of a mystery is the way it
- 7:05uncovers these things in order to surprise and
- 7:08astonish. And a surprise is a subversion of expectation.
- 7:14If you think the maid killed the lord, and then
- 7:18you discover it was actually the princess and
- 7:21that she was secretly his ex -lover, well, that's
- 7:24a subversion. And a good subversion is one that
- 7:28is a well -built surprise that conveys meaning
- 7:31in its twist. The mystery genre, and even the
- 7:37whodunit genre, contains a lot of variation.
- 7:40This means that every Benoit Blanc film can be
- 7:44wildly different in tone and style, and that
- 7:47each film can also do incredibly interesting
- 7:50things with how its stories are told. Knives
- 7:54Out subverts the traditional whodunit formula
- 7:57by telling us who did it at the end of Act 1.
- 8:00The rest of the movie is more interesting and
- 8:03complicated as a result. Glass Onion, the sequel
- 8:08to Knives Out, essentially shows the story twice,
- 8:11replaying the film from a different perspective
- 8:14after a midpoint reveal, giving a lot more context
- 8:18and intrigue. And because the mystery genre welcomes
- 8:22subversions, delights in it even, both of these
- 8:25innovations make the films more at home in the
- 8:29genre. Frankly, Rian Johnson could continue to
- 8:33do weird and interesting whodunits for the rest
- 8:36of his career and be completely embraced by both
- 8:39mystery fans and film critics. Because he isn't
- 8:43just telling fun stories. He's also telling thematically
- 8:48rich ones. Knives Out and Glass Onion aren't
- 8:53just subversive in storytelling, they're also
- 8:57subversive in theme. Knives Out tackles the topic
- 9:01of generational wealth and its corrupting influence
- 9:04on human character. Its protagonist is the daughter
- 9:08of an undocumented immigrant, and it is entirely
- 9:11about flipping those class dynamics on their
- 9:15head. Glass Onion is a satire about tech multibillionaires,
- 9:20influencers, and industry disruptors. How all
- 9:24this flash and self -made aggrandizing is just
- 9:28a distraction from their hollow centers. Again,
- 9:32this commentary is at home within the mystery
- 9:35genre, the whodunit specifically. Have you ever
- 9:39heard the phrase, the butler did it? It's an
- 9:42old joke about a trope that the butler will always
- 9:46be revealed as the murderer of the wealthy victim,
- 9:49because it is quite frequently a wealthy victim.
- 9:53It is a statement about class. There has always
- 9:58been some anxiety among moneyed individuals over
- 10:02the fact that they are served by an army of lower
- 10:04-class individuals in whom they must trust. and
- 10:08who could also just kill them or steal from them.
- 10:11And the whodunit genre puts that anxiety out
- 10:15in the open. What if your servant is trying to
- 10:19kill you? Or what if it is instead the demure
- 10:24nobleman? What evil could wealth and class hide?
- 10:29This genre has always had a political streak
- 10:33of social commentary. Ryan Johnson made that
- 10:38part of the Benoit Blanc package. Knives Out
- 10:42is in direct conversation with the political
- 10:45climate of Donald Trump's first presidential
- 10:48term. Glass Onion takes place during the COVID
- 10:51shutdown. Topical political conversation is always
- 10:56going to be a part of these films. So I have
- 11:02to admit. I had concerns leading up to the release
- 11:06of Wake Up Deadman. Not necessarily with the
- 11:11film itself. The initial trailers indicated that
- 11:14this film would be a gothic mystery, all dark
- 11:18forests and old churches. If you'll recall, while
- 11:22I have a complicated relationship with horror,
- 11:25in that I am intrigued by its thematic content
- 11:28while having an incredibly low scare tolerance,
- 11:32I love gothic stories. There are many reasons,
- 11:37but chief among them is the sublime, that dark
- 11:41thrill of old buildings and unexplained phenomena
- 11:45and dark stormy nights. Gothic storytelling and
- 11:49mystery have a long, close -knit relationship.
- 11:54A key feature of the genre is the reveal of dark
- 11:58secrets, which quite frequently play out as a
- 12:01mystery. The popular novels of Anne Radcliffe,
- 12:04published in the late 18th, early 19th century,
- 12:08feature the pursuit of supernatural intervention,
- 12:12always revealed, Scooby -Doo style, to be the
- 12:16result of human design. And so the prospect of
- 12:20a sublime drenched whodunit from Rian Johnson
- 12:23struck me as very exciting. No, what concerned
- 12:29me... was the clear church setting of the film.
- 12:34Knowing that a feature of these films is a critique
- 12:38of American societal and political institutions,
- 12:41a subversion of cultural values, it was pretty
- 12:46clear to me that this film would be critiquing
- 12:49Christianity. Now, to be clear, There is much
- 12:54to critique about American Christianity, whether
- 12:57that is the history of abuse in the Catholic
- 13:00Church, or the misuse of scripture to support
- 13:03the institution of slavery, or televangelists
- 13:06and their greed and manipulation of the vulnerable.
- 13:10There's much to critique currently with how comfortable
- 13:14certain American Christian thought leaders are
- 13:18with cozying up to power. And, funnily enough,
- 13:23That critique can come from the text of the Bible
- 13:26itself. It's been really interesting recently
- 13:29to watch people who eschew religion and especially
- 13:33resent Christianity discover the 25th chapter
- 13:37of the book of Matthew, where Jesus tells a story
- 13:40about how on the day of glory, he will judge
- 13:44all the nations based on if they fed the hungry.
- 13:48welcomed the stranger, and looked after the sick
- 13:50because whatever you did for the least of these,
- 13:54you did for me. Likewise, when you look through
- 13:58American history, you find that the text that
- 14:02was read in bad faith to support slavery also
- 14:05inspired enslaved Black Americans to escape to
- 14:09freedom, like the people of Israel fleeing slavery
- 14:12in Egypt. You will also find that the American
- 14:17Catholic Church has had a long relationship with
- 14:20workers' rights, civil rights, and other social
- 14:23programs, all based in biblical, theological
- 14:27thought. In other words, the history of American
- 14:32Christianity is complicated and nuanced, even
- 14:37in the current moment. But the portrayal of Christianity
- 14:41on film has a tendency to be less so. There are
- 14:47lots of reasons why. The culture of American
- 14:50evangelicalism doesn't really understand art
- 14:54for art's sake. There's a streak of practicality
- 14:58that allows for art wrapped around a sermon,
- 15:01but little else, which means filmmakers who grow
- 15:05up in that cultural context will frequently understandably,
- 15:10hold resentment toward it. Then there are the
- 15:14culture war frustrations, which I don't need
- 15:17to get into here. Very little of this is actual
- 15:21persecution. Much of it, as I said, is justified.
- 15:26But it does get old after a while. I'm a Christian.
- 15:33I love Jesus. And I care about the actual words
- 15:38of the Bible. They are very important to me and
- 15:42have had a huge impact on how I live my life
- 15:46and care for my community. I also support films
- 15:51like Spotlight and The Magdalene Sisters, which
- 15:54are honest about abuse in the church, and I think
- 15:58the portrayal of American Christian culture in
- 16:01Saved and EDA is a valuable part of the social
- 16:04conversation. But that's not all Christianity
- 16:08is, by a long shot. So while I knew Wake Up Dead
- 16:14Man would be an excellent mystery, I also knew
- 16:18that Rian Johnson, who went out of his way to
- 16:21criticize religious institutions in The Last
- 16:24Jedi, would be using this story to subvert and
- 16:28criticize Christianity's relationship to American
- 16:31culture. But I forgot an important factor. As
- 16:38I said earlier, The Butler Did It was once an
- 16:42effective trope, bringing to light class anxiety.
- 16:46But that was so long ago that we actually don't
- 16:50have record of it. Incredibly quickly, it became
- 16:54such a common twist that it ceased to be subversive.
- 16:58There was no commentary on class anxiety. It
- 17:02was just an eye roll. Frankly, if you tried to
- 17:06do a Butler did it reveal today unironically,
- 17:09your story would be dismissed. Maybe you could
- 17:13do it with a wink. but it would be hard to do
- 17:16it while genuinely commenting on anything. In
- 17:20the same way, portraying a Christian who's a
- 17:23hypocrite or an antagonist is so common in film
- 17:27that there's no surprise. In 2023, in response
- 17:31to an episode of the TV show The Last of Us,
- 17:34actor Rainn Wilson, a practitioner of the Baha
- 17:38'i faith, tweeted that as soon as one character
- 17:40started reading from the Bible, I knew that he
- 17:43was going to be a horrific villain. Could there
- 17:46be a Bible -reading preacher on a show who is
- 17:49actually loving and kind? What do you do when
- 17:53a twist, a good moral Christian, is actually
- 17:56being a terrible person? is so common that it's
- 18:00no longer a twist. What happens when the subversion
- 18:05becomes the mainstream? Why, as Rainn Wilson
- 18:10commented, you approach the subject with goodness
- 18:14and sincerity. a young Catholic priest who is
- 18:25sent by his bishop to be the assistant pastor
- 18:27at a small congregation in upstate New York under
- 18:31Monsignor Jefferson Wicks. Wicks is exactly the
- 18:36sort of figure one would expect in a story meant
- 18:39to critique and subvert religion. He prominently
- 18:43displays four out of the seven deadly sins, although
- 18:46I could make a case for both gluttony and sloth.
- 18:49And if he wasn't played with relish by the Oscar
- 18:52-nominated Josh Brolin, he would be a fairly
- 18:56stock character who has appeared in dozens of
- 18:59religiously -themed films. Wicks is known for
- 19:03lambasting sermons where he targets individuals
- 19:06in the congregation and heaps shame and rage
- 19:10on their person and story in order to cast them
- 19:13out and build a twisted, wagon -circling inner
- 19:17ring of parishioners. He is, in a very real sense,
- 19:22a representative of many of the problems with
- 19:25American Christianity. Father Judd, on the other
- 19:30hand, is, in his own words, young, dumb, and
- 19:35full of Christ. He genuinely believes the words
- 19:40of Jesus and wants to follow in his steps. In
- 19:44the film's opening scene, he describes how Jesus
- 19:47came to heal the world, not fight it, with arms
- 19:52outstretched, not clenched into fists. Words
- 19:57that so resonated with my husband and I. That
- 20:00we had to pause the film and stare at each other,
- 20:03open -mouthed, flabbergasted, at a movie ostensibly
- 20:07made by an atheist for stating what we understand
- 20:11about our religion so positively. This isn't
- 20:17to say that Wake Up Dead Man is meant to be an
- 20:20evangelistic sermon. Counter to Father Judd is
- 20:23Detective Benoit Blanc himself. who wastes no
- 20:27time explaining that he's a committed atheist,
- 20:30who believes the Bible is a collection of fairy
- 20:33tales perpetuating harmful stereotypes, and that
- 20:36there is nothing he would rather not do than
- 20:40attend an Easter service. As a figure of the
- 20:44rational, a character whose knowledge and perspective
- 20:47is meant to be completely trusted and respected,
- 20:51He offers an excellent countermeasure to Father
- 20:54Judd's genuine belief in Jesus' love, sustaining
- 20:59grace, and call to compassionate care. But Father
- 21:04Judd is our primary protagonist, the character
- 21:09from whose point of view we see the story. He
- 21:14is flawed. We could have a long, entirely separate
- 21:18conversation of his sins and what they relay
- 21:21about many Christian institutions, but he is
- 21:24also genuinely repentant, willing to own his
- 21:28wrongs, confess to them, and accept their consequences,
- 21:32which makes him even more of a compelling character
- 21:36to see in a mainstream movie. Johnson also uses
- 21:42Judd's faith to provide this film's structural
- 21:46mystery subversion, his innovation on the genre.
- 21:51Deep into this film, after a long buildup, we
- 21:56begin to realize the actual puzzle at the heart
- 21:59of this story. This prompts a search and a quick
- 22:04-paced sequence of brainstorming and discovery
- 22:06that we, as an audience, are swept up into, excited
- 22:11to see what will be discovered. And then the
- 22:15momentum halts abruptly so that Father Judd can
- 22:21care for and pray for a woman in distress. She
- 22:26is alone and she is struggling. and she needs
- 22:31wisdom, compassion, and attention. And here,
- 22:38Johnson uses this sequence to critique Blanc,
- 22:43and also the audience, to subvert the whodunit
- 22:48genre itself. Murder mysteries are inherently
- 22:54stories of evil, greed, and human depravity.
- 22:59But it's so satisfying to solve a puzzle that
- 23:03investing in the genre requires a certain level
- 23:08of desensitization. We can lose sight of the
- 23:12genuine brokenness and the need for compassion
- 23:15and care in all the delightful twistiness. Rian
- 23:20Johnson, a lover of irony, an expert at subversion,
- 23:25takes the time to recognize that when subversion
- 23:29becomes expected, the best subversion is to embrace
- 23:34sincerity. Now, I don't think Johnson's films
- 23:40are going to ever become Spielbergian, hearts
- 23:43-on -their -sleeves kinds of movies. But I appreciate
- 23:47his willingness to follow his stories where they
- 23:50need to go, to challenge himself. To not hold
- 23:55things at an arm's length, but to fully embrace
- 23:59them. Johnson once was, in his own words, a Southern
- 24:05California youth group kid, who didn't just go
- 24:09to church because his parents made him, but genuinely
- 24:13believed. As he describes it, he grew out of
- 24:18his faith. And the conversation between Benoit
- 24:21Blanc and Father Judd is a debate he often has
- 24:25with himself. This story was one that meant something
- 24:30to him personally. And for someone who has reveled
- 24:34in subversion and irony, never missing the opportunity
- 24:39to take the audience out of a story for a joke
- 24:42or just a bit of distance, to be so honest a
- 24:47storyteller? Well, I can't wait for the story
- 24:53he has next. Thanks for coming.