Latest / The Great Retirement Debate with Ed Slott & Jeffrey Levine / S1 Ep17: GRD017: To Convert Or Not To Convert Pt. 1
Transcript
- 0:00Intro: Hi, I'm Ed Slott, and I'm Jeff Levine.
- 0:02And we are two guys who just love to talk about retirement and taxes.
- 0:06Look, our mission is simple to educate you, the savers, so that you can make
- 0:10better decisions because better decisions on the whole lead to better outcomes.
- 0:14And here's how we're going to do that.
- 0:15Each week, Jeff and I will debate the pros and the cons of a particular
- 0:20retirement strategy or topic with the.
- 0:23Helping you keep more of your hard-earned money.
- 0:26Yeah, but we won't know which side of the debate we're taking until we flip
- 0:29a coin winner of the coin flip gets to pick which side of the debate they want
- 0:33to argue, and both of us will have to argue in favor of our respect positions,
- 0:38whether we agree with them or not.
- 0:40At the end of each debate, there's going to be one clear winner you, a more
- 0:45informed saver who can hopefully apply the merits of each side of the debate
- 0:48to your own personal situation to decide what's best for you and your family.
- 0:52So here we go.
- 0:53Welcome to the Great Retirement Debate.
- 1:02Jeffrey Levine: Hello everyone, and welcome back to
- 1:04the Great Retirement Debate.
- 1:05Ed, how's it today?
- 1:07Ed Slott: It's going great.
- 1:08I have a great topic, actually.
- 1:10We're going to break one of our usual rules on this one.
- 1:14Uh, we generally stay away from politics and religion, but this will be a religious
- 1:20thing to convert or not to convert.
- 1:22Jeffrey Levine: Oh yeah, there are definitely some people who feel pretty,
- 1:25pretty feel pretty passionate about that.
- 1:27Conversion is a religion for some.
- 1:30Oh, wow.
- 1:30All right.
- 1:31Big topic today at a meaty topic.
- 1:33Uh, I, uh, I get to, I guess I get to pick the coin flip again today.
- 1:36So I'm gonna go with tails once again.
- 1:38Ed Slott: Ahh, Here we go.
- 1:41What is it?
- 1:42Uh, tails again.
- 1:43You're on a winning streak from the last few.
- 1:45And just so we're clear, convert, we're talking about converting
- 1:48your IRA to a Roth IRA, which may be a religion for some people.
- 1:52Jeffrey Levine: You know, this is one of those things, Ed, that
- 1:54has, uh, lifelong ramifications.
- 1:57We're talking about taking an account that, uh, as you often
- 2:00say, is forever taxed, uh, to an account that is never taxed.
- 2:04I can't help it, Ed.
- 2:05I, I am gonna, you know, I, part of me wants to, to leave you with the,
- 2:09uh, the option to convert, but, I gotta argue in favor of conversion.
- 2:12I'm gonna leave you with the don't convert argument on this one.
- 2:16I'm sorry, but I think you're getting the short end of the stick today.
- 2:18Ed Slott: Oh, yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah.
- 2:19Everybody knows I'm a big Roth fan, but again, there's two sides to everything,
- 2:24and that's the purpose of what we're doing to give you the pluses, the minuses,
- 2:27the benefits and drawbacks so you can make the decision that's best for you.
- 2:32Nothing is all black and white.
- 2:34Some things are gray.
- 2:35There's no decision even with my favorite decision to convert to a Roth.
- 2:39There are reasons not to.
- 2:41Jeffrey Levine: Such as?
- 2:42Ed Slott: All right.
- 2:43So i'll start it.
- 2:44Nobody wants to pay the tax.
- 2:46Okay.
- 2:46Uh, , if your hand starts shaking when you find out what it's going to
- 2:51cost, and you do have to pay the tax when you convert from an IRA to a
- 2:55Roth IRA, that's what we're talking about from Forever Tax to Never Tax.
- 2:59Everybody wants to get to the Promise Land, never tax, income tax free for life.
- 3:03But there's a price of admission.
- 3:05There's no question.
- 3:06The Roth IRA is the best retirement account to own.
- 3:10The only question is how much are you willing to pay for it, like anything else.
- 3:16So, uh, that's one of the reasons some people just don't like
- 3:20paying tax before they have to.
- 3:22In fact, Jeff, you and I as CPAs both know, we were both
- 3:26trained as accountants to never.
- 3:28Ever.
- 3:28Pay a tax before you have to always defer, defer to put it off.
- 3:33So here, uh, you, you can defer and keep deferring it and you
- 3:37won't have to pay anything upfront.
- 3:40Uh, if you don't convert.
- 3:42Jeffrey Levine: Well, that's a good argument.
- 3:43Ed Slott: One arguement for not converting.
- 3:44I have others.
- 3:45Jeffrey Levine: All right, well, well, we're good.
- 3:46It's gonna take more than that Ed, to, to win this argument cause I got
- 3:49a lot of ammunition on my side today.
- 3:50In fact, you know, you talked about deferring, deferring, deferring,
- 3:54which is, which is great, but you don't get to do that forever.
- 3:57There's a time when, whether or not you wanna defer, you don't get to choose that.
- 4:02It's time to pay the piper.
- 4:03Such a time is called the required beginning date, that is the time
- 4:07when you need to start taking required minimum distributions.
- 4:10And as we sit here today, Ed, you know that's, that's recently changed.
- 4:14The Secure Act took us from age 70 1/2 to age 72.
- 4:18More recently, secure Act 2.0 moved that back to 73 for roughly
- 4:23the next decade, then to age 75.
- 4:26But even at that age, many people still live beyond it, you know, into their
- 4:3080s, 90s, and sometimes even beyond that.
- 4:33And at all those more advanced stages, people must begin taking required
- 4:39minimum distributions from their IRAs, even if they're still working.
- 4:43If the money is in an ira, it doesn't matter whether you're
- 4:46working or whether you're not.
- 4:47You must take required minimum distributions from your IRA accounts.
- 4:55And here's the thing, some people are so good at saving.
- 5:01And so bad at spending, that they end up with a lot more money than
- 5:06they ever thought they'd have and that they ever would need.
- 5:10Now admittedly, this is a very first class, uh, problem
- 5:13to be dealing with, right?
- 5:14I have too much money and too much income.
- 5:17But for some folks, once those required minimum distributions kick in, Between
- 5:22those distributions that they have to take between their social security
- 5:27income, between their interest and dividends and capital gains they
- 5:31may have from taxable investments.
- 5:33For some folks, God forbid, a pension, you know, something like that, will all
- 5:39of these individuals and these incomes come together and they can pour somebody
- 5:43into a much higher tax rate in retirement when they're not working and not earning
- 5:48than they ever had while they were working and actually trying to make a living.
- 5:53Ed Slott: Uh, yeah.
- 5:54You mentioned one thing.
- 5:55I wrote that down.
- 5:56How do you spell that word?
- 5:57You said pensions.
- 5:59What was that?
- 6:00Jeffrey Levine: It's this, uh, it kind of, uh, like you know how the
- 6:04dinosaurs were a historical artifact?
- 6:06Well, pensions came along shortly after the dinosaurs ended.
- 6:11Ed Slott: Yeah.
- 6:11Right.
- 6:11Jeffrey Levine: And much like the dinosaurs, they went away
- 6:13very quickly in kind of a flash.
- 6:15Yeah.
- 6:16Yeah.
- 6:17Very few people that.
- 6:18Ed Slott: It was a check.
- 6:18I don't understand.
- 6:19These companies, they just gave X employees money every month
- 6:23for the rest of their lives.
- 6:24They weren't even working anymore.
- 6:26All right.
- 6:27Jeffrey Levine: Then the internet came along and everything went away.
- 6:29Ed Slott: Yeah.
- 6:31Yeah.
- 6:31Alright, so here's some other reasons you may not want to convert and to be
- 6:34clear, and Jeff has to agree with this.
- 6:36Uh, we're not that he has to, but I think he will.
- 6:39We're not talking about all or nothing.
- 6:42A conversion can be partial conversion, so there's some middle point, you
- 6:46know, uh, maybe smaller conversions.
- 6:49I'm not talking about whether to convert all or nothing.
- 6:52Some people think that, that's why I wanted to make that clear.
- 6:55So here's an example of somebody who might benefit from not converting.
- 6:59So, For the people who think or maybe are thinking they're hearing this, I should
- 7:03convert everything and then I'll never pay tax on any of my retirement money, as Jeff
- 7:07said, and I'll never have those horrible RMDs required minimum distributions.
- 7:12But if you normally give to charity, There's a great provision called
- 7:16qualified charitable distributions.
- 7:19It's one of the best provisions in the tax code not used nearly enough where
- 7:23if you are giving to charity, and I'm not saying, give all your money to
- 7:26charity for a tax benefit, if that was the case, give all your money away.
- 7:30You'll never pay taxes and you'll be broke.
- 7:32I'm talking about if you're already giving money.
- 7:35The whole key to doing the best you can with retirement savings is to get
- 7:41that money out at the lowest possible tax rate with a qualified charitable
- 7:46distribution where you take from your IRA and you do a direct transfer to
- 7:52a qualified charity, you are getting that money out at 0% tax rates.
- 7:57If you converted everything and you still wanted to do that gifting, you
- 8:01wouldn't have any money to gift that you could get a tax benefit out of.
- 8:05Most people get no tax benefit.
- 8:08Actually more than 90% according to IRS statistics get no tax benefit of the
- 8:14gifts they're giving to charities cause most people take the standard deduction.
- 8:19Now to qualify for a QCD.
- 8:22Not everybody qualifies, but IRA owners that are aged 70 and a half or older
- 8:27and IRA beneficiaries 70 and a half or older do qualify and if they're 70.
- 8:33Oh, here's a question for you, Jeff.
- 8:35A tough one.
- 8:36Uh, if they're 70 and a half, are they also over 65?
- 8:41Jeffrey Levine: Mm.
- 8:42Let's see.
- 8:42Ed Slott: All right.
- 8:43Time's up.
- 8:43Sorry.
- 8:44Jeffrey Levine: Ah, I lost it.
- 8:45Ed Slott: All right.
- 8:45So obviously if you're 70 and a half, that means it's even more likely you
- 8:50won't take the standard deduction because you get the extra standard
- 8:53deduction for being 65 or over.
- 8:56So, uh, this is a way to get that money out to, uh, to fund charitable
- 9:02gifts that you were making anyway.
- 9:04And you get better than a tax deduction.
- 9:06You get an exclusion from income.
- 9:08Now, if you converted everything, you wouldn't have that opportunity
- 9:12to get the money out at 0% tax rate.
- 9:15So if you are, uh, you normally give, and I have to believe most
- 9:18people give now that it's hard to tell from tax returns now that most
- 9:22people take the standard deduction.
- 9:24But when I was doing tax returns where before the tax law, that changed a lot
- 9:29of that where more people itemized.
- 9:31I would always ask people, did you give to charity?
- 9:34100%.
- 9:35Oh yeah.
- 9:36Gave, I gave, you know, I don't know.
- 9:37Everybody said nobody ever said they didn't give.
- 9:40So I gotta believe most people give or they just say so on their tax returns,
- 9:44Uh, so, uh, if you're doing that, I wouldn't convert money you
- 9:49intend to give another reason.
- 9:51Well, I'll let you chime in.
- 9:52I have more reasons not to convert.
- 9:54I can't believe the, the words that are coming outta my mouth here.
- 9:56Jeffrey Levine: That's, well, it's, uh, you know, you mentioned
- 9:58something about the IRS and the IRS gets to implement tax policy.
- 10:03But they don't get to make tax policy that is done by Congress.
- 10:08And, uh, if we've learned nothing else in recent years, it is that Congress,
- 10:13uh, can change things kind of, uh, you know, at the snap of a uh, uh,
- 10:20snap of fingers at the drop of a hat.
- 10:22Congress can change the rules and one of those rules is what the tax rates are.
- 10:27And today I know what the tax rates are.
- 10:29I know what my tax rate is today.
- 10:32I don't know what that is going to be in the future.
- 10:35And if we look at things like our national deficit, our national debt.
- 10:40Our, uh, our promises that we've made to individuals for social security and
- 10:45for Medicare and for all these other things, crumbling infrastructure.
- 10:50I mean, at some point the question becomes will Congress have to raise tax rates?
- 10:56And in fact, you know, you talked about the tax cut and jobs act a
- 10:59little bit, the, the tax cut and jobs.
- 11:02Lowered taxes or you talked about in terms of the standard deduction,
- 11:05how very few people today itemized.
- 11:07But one of the other things it did was it lowered rates for
- 11:10about three quarters of Americans.
- 11:12Now that's true at all income levels, right?
- 11:15Not just the ultra wealthy, but people in more modest income brackets on
- 11:19average, saw their tax rates fall.
- 11:21And on top of that, uh, if we look at when that is set to expire, it's
- 11:26just a few years from now in 2025.
- 11:30Now, I don't know about you, Ed, but whenever someone asks
- 11:32me, will something be extended?
- 11:35In other words, will Congress take action to keep things
- 11:38like these lower rates in play?
- 11:40The odds are if I, if you force me to take a side, I'm always going to take
- 11:44the under on congressional action.
- 11:46Betting on Washington Gridlock and nothing happening is always the better bet.
- 11:51Now doesn't it always happens.
- 11:53Sometimes people in Washington actually do something and they pass laws.
- 11:56But if you're gonna make me take an over or under, I'm gonna take
- 11:59the under, which means the tax cut and Jobs Act rate changes go away.
- 12:03People across the country, regardless of your state, even high tax states
- 12:08like New York and California where the salt deduction cap really hurt.
- 12:11On average, each state will see its individuals and its, uh, its
- 12:16residents see lower tax bills, again, at all income levels.
- 12:19And if you're going to see, excuse me, higher tax bills
- 12:21because the lower rates go right.
- 12:23And if those lower rates go away and you're paying a higher tax
- 12:26rate down the road, well, wouldn't I rather pay a lower rate today?
- 12:30And again, all of that is assuming that just the expiration occurs.
- 12:35That doesn't even consider Congress going in there and actually saying,
- 12:38Hey, all those things that we just talked about, the deficit, the, the,
- 12:42the debt, the promises, the crumbling infrastructure, all of these things that
- 12:46we need to do to improve the country.
- 12:49We're not gonna raise taxes at all.
- 12:50I find it hard to believe that today isn't one of the lowest rates that we will
- 12:54see in our lifetime, if not the lowest.
- 12:57Ed Slott: They're historically the lowest rates.
- 12:59And you should always get, uh, like I said, the, the fundamental
- 13:02principle of all taxation.
- 13:04Always, especially when it comes to IRAs, always pay taxes at the lowest rates.
- 13:08Jeffrey Levine: Well, Ed.
- 13:10We covered a lot today, and you know, we always say there
- 13:12are two sides to every coin.
- 13:14I'm not sure this coin has fallen yet.
- 13:16There seems to be more to debate here, in fact, so much more.
- 13:20This is such a, a meaty topic.
- 13:22I, I think we're gonna have to pick it up again next week and keep going.
- 13:26What do you say?
- 13:27Ed Slott: Yeah, the, I like the coin on edge.
- 13:29It reminds me, I don't know if you're an old Twilight Zone fan, but remember
- 13:33that one episode with a coin, A guy flips the coin and he's on edge.
- 13:37It's on, it stands up, and that's the whole episode.
- 13:40I do remember that, although the one I remember most of course is pig face.
- 13:45You know that...
- 13:46All right, well, let's not go there, anyway, it is on edge and we're
- 13:49going to continue this, whether to convert or not to convert.
- 13:52And again, as we always say, this is to provide you information,
- 13:55both sides of the issue.
- 13:57So we'll see you next time.
- 13:58Part two, on whether to convert or not to a Roth IRA on the Great Retirement Debate.
- 14:04Outro: Jeffrey Levine is Chief Planning Officer for Buckingham Wealth Partners.
- 14:07This podcast is for informational and educational purposes only, and should
- 14:10not be construed as specific investment accounting, legal or tax advice.
- 14:13Certain information mentioned may be based on third party information,
- 14:16which may become outdated or otherwise superseded without notice.
- 14:19Third party information is deemed to be reliable, but it's accuracy and
- 14:22completeness cannot be guaranteed.
- 14:24The topic discussed in corresponding arguments are those of the speakers
- 14:27and may not accurately reflect those of Buckingham Wealth partners.