Latest / Onramp Bitcoin Media / Flash Forward: From Monetary Asset to Everyday Money
Transcript
- 0:02It all. Comes down to computers
- 0:04communicating. The information superhighway can
- 0:08be a confusing mix of on ramps and off ramps.
- 0:11Bitcoin is worthless artificial gold.
- 0:16Is it still rat poison? Probably rat poison squared.
- 0:19We need to get into the world of OK, this is actually
- 0:22foundational. Technology.
- 0:24What the Internet of Money does is it creates a single network
- 0:29which can do a microtransaction to a giga transaction.
- 0:36The Internet is going to be. One of the major forces for
- 0:40reducing the role of gun, the one thing that's missing that
- 0:44will soon be developed is a reliable E cash.
- 0:52All righty. Welcome back to Final
- 0:54Settlement. Today is June 2nd, 2025.
- 0:58Today on the show I'm joined by my Co host Liam and Michael and
- 1:02a very special guest, Pierre Corbin, CEO and Co founder of
- 1:05Flash portfolio company of of early riders.
- 1:08Very glad to have Pierre back on the show.
- 1:11How you doing, Sir? Hey, yeah, Hi, everyone.
- 1:14Thanks for having me back here and doing really good.
- 1:17Still recovering from from your Vegas trip I would imagine.
- 1:20Yes, yes. Jet lagged, perhaps?
- 1:22Jet lag, can't sleep all night only and it's horrible because
- 1:26you know, so I live in Poland, right?
- 1:28And the sunset, sorry, sunrise is at about 4:00 AM.
- 1:32So going to sleep because of jet lag when it's already day out is
- 1:36makes it just harder. But yeah, I think recovering
- 1:41slowly. Guys, I think I figured out the
- 1:43the hack is so for next year, we probably don't go to the
- 1:47conference again, especially 'cause Vegas, but we have folks
- 1:50on from that. We're in Vegas right after and
- 1:53then the following week to recap and talk because we had this
- 1:56really great recap with Tim on or Thursday that came out Friday
- 1:59and the comments were really like helpful or insightful and
- 2:03that they like to be able to recap it and not necessarily
- 2:06have to go through the travel. So Pierre, if you're going to be
- 2:08there, maybe we'll, we'll have you on a year from now and
- 2:10we'll, we'll recap what the latest is going on.
- 2:13Sure, sure. Happy to.
- 2:15So yeah, maybe maybe diving in there Logical place to start.
- 2:19Pierre, was it your first time in Vegas or have you have you
- 2:21been there before? No, no, first time in Vegas.
- 2:24It's a very, very funny place. Feels like just a, a resort all
- 2:29around. I was surprised that there's
- 2:30over 2 million people living there.
- 2:32That's that's crazy. But it did remind me quite a bit
- 2:34of Dubai, to be fair. And I spent quite a bit of time
- 2:37in Dubai. So yeah, I mean, it was, it was,
- 2:40it was just more of a pure holiday vibes, whereas Dubai is
- 2:45more real life as well. Yeah.
- 2:47So what any any sort of key takeaways from from the week
- 2:51discussions you had any any alpha you want to leak different
- 2:54different conversations with with folks?
- 2:57Yeah, so I mean, you know, generally speaking, it is a lot
- 3:00of what at least my feed shows on Twitter when it comes to the
- 3:03conference, a lot of, you know, as we call shit coining not just
- 3:08Bitcoin focused topics, which I mean, you know, it's fine.
- 3:11I guess there's a bit of everything.
- 3:12At least it brings people over to to these topics.
- 3:14But I mean, yeah, generally speaking, you know, everyone has
- 3:17the opinion That's of course Bitcoin won.
- 3:20And and I agree that Bitcoin won.
- 3:21I even talked, you know, with the.
- 3:23So he's he's an old friend, he's called Clement and he's the
- 3:26person that leads the Bitcoin community in Bulgaria.
- 3:31And he said that he's he feels missionless without a mission
- 3:36anymore because Bitcoin kind of won.
- 3:38And and he he can really get this vibe in at at the
- 3:42conference. But, you know, I think what
- 3:45matters is not Bitcoin that now the US government is trying to
- 3:49push because this is all full custody Bitcoin.
- 3:52Let's not forget what Bitcoin is actually trying to solve, which
- 3:55is the fact that, you know, you can be responsible of your own
- 3:58money and not, you know, be dependent on on a third party,
- 4:03which, you know, is what's both. I mean, us together, early
- 4:07writers on ramp flash. We're we're working on of
- 4:10course. So, yeah, I was there a lot
- 4:12trying to push people as to, yes, wait, this isn't real
- 4:16Bitcoin. This is just the equivalent of
- 4:18the traditional financial system on a new asset class.
- 4:22But yeah, let's not, let's not lose the the mission here.
- 4:26But yeah, the conference is a bit all over the place when it
- 4:29comes to that. Yeah.
- 4:30It's a little unfortunate. I don't know who you reference,
- 4:33but who said that? Because it kind of reminds me,
- 4:37share with me, it's like the parallel, you know, when people
- 4:38say if you're depressed, just go help somebody else out.
- 4:41Like if somebody depressed, they're thinking about
- 4:43themselves too much versus you just go out in the world and
- 4:45then that'll go away. It's very similar to like that
- 4:48notion. It's like maybe it's figured out
- 4:50for the individual. But when you think about from
- 4:52store value for 8 billion people or payments that we talked about
- 4:55and being able to receive across the world, there's still like an
- 4:58insane amount of work to be done.
- 5:01And then one of the things that stood out, I think it wasn't
- 5:04until after the conference, and I think it was Jack's mom,
- 5:07Brooke Waller's, I think she had a tweet that was showing the
- 5:112000 or 10 years ago, whatever that was, 2015 with Antonopoulos
- 5:16sitting in Texas blockchain or Texas Bitcoin conference.
- 5:20And he said 10 years from now, there'll be 30 to 50,000 people,
- 5:23similar how the Internet was. And it was kind of prescient
- 5:25that that stood out there. The the only other thing to
- 5:30share about the the Vegas stuff, I guess it makes sense in this,
- 5:33in the from a continuity perspective because we've all
- 5:35been to like Miami and Nashville and the crazy amount of
- 5:38logistics and travel versus being able to be in a like
- 5:40consolidate area, you know, definitely helps.
- 5:42And I think the infrastructure from Vegas independent of kind
- 5:46of the, the feedback vibes that it reels off.
- 5:48Yeah. One, yeah, I think it's just a
- 5:53good, good. No, I'm just saying, yeah, it's
- 5:57just really big. And and to be fair, it was very
- 5:59well organized, right? So I think being able to
- 6:01organize something at such a big scale is, is quite, quite
- 6:03impressive. I mean, I didn't attend JD
- 6:06Vance's talk. I didn't feel like lining up at
- 6:095:30 AM, but I hear, I hear it was it was very packed.
- 6:14I did arrive right afterwards and just as everyone was exiting
- 6:18the the main room, it was, it was pretty crazy.
- 6:21But no. So organization was was on point
- 6:23though, that's for sure. Yeah, Well, maybe there was a
- 6:28few sort of announcements. It's it's funny because there
- 6:31was, you know, obviously a lot of focus and talk about Bitcoin
- 6:35treasury companies and, you know, mostly looking at at
- 6:38Bitcoin as a store value reserve asset.
- 6:41And I think that's also been a lot of the rhetoric from, you
- 6:44know, the JD Vances of the world, you know, the government
- 6:46policy, policy makers, the way they're looking at Bitcoin.
- 6:50But at the same time, there was also, you know, a number of
- 6:53announcements and progress and development on the payment side
- 6:56of things and things. And that's sort of, you know,
- 6:58where you spend most of your time focused.
- 7:01Pierre, I'm curious what you made of some of the
- 7:02announcements on that side of things.
- 7:05You know, Square had a few announcements around rolling
- 7:07out, you know, accepting payments for for all their
- 7:10merchant terminals. There was another very
- 7:12interesting announcement around, you know, some of the, the work
- 7:15that they're doing on Lightning specifically in their routing
- 7:17node that's generating A9 9.7% annual yield.
- 7:22Curious what what you made of some of the, you know, medium
- 7:25exchange type announcements that happened, which I think given
- 7:28the crowd there, you know, very tradified focus, it probably
- 7:31some of it got lost in the sense that there is all of this focus
- 7:34on Bitcoin treasury companies and, and as you put it, you
- 7:37know, not real Bitcoin. So curious what what you made of
- 7:40all that? Yeah.
- 7:42So I think definitely the announcements by Square, at
- 7:46least to me, we're the most relevant, the most important
- 7:49ones because you know, everything else we've kind of
- 7:51already heard before. Having a strategic Bitcoin
- 7:54reserve is kind of the thing to do right now, which is just
- 7:58interesting to observe. And I feel it becomes less and
- 8:01less, you know, mind blowing compared to when micro strategy
- 8:05started doing it. So yeah, it just feels like a
- 8:09very trendy thing. And and it even kind of gives
- 8:11the vibe of this is, you know, it could be an event around this
- 8:15that like will point to the end of the Bitcoin bull run, which
- 8:19which would be kind of, I mean, just speculating here, but yeah.
- 8:23And but but essentially, I think there's two things around around
- 8:26payments that I think are pretty interesting.
- 8:29First of all, when it comes to Square, I think the fact that
- 8:33they're now integrating Lightning payments for all of
- 8:35their merchants. This is just amazing simply
- 8:38because of course it makes the Lightning Network more
- 8:42accessible. All of these merchants are now
- 8:44people that will also have direct access to Bitcoin.
- 8:47This will of course encourage more people to spend in Bitcoin
- 8:52and I think this is generally good news all around and for for
- 8:55the entire industry and for the payments industry as well.
- 8:58You know, a lot of the feedback that we get is that most people
- 9:03when they buy Bitcoin, they first go on some Coinbase and
- 9:06then as they get educated, they go and look for other options
- 9:10that can protect their funds better.
- 9:11Like I suppose that's also how it works with with on ramp and
- 9:14the same thing is true with payments, right?
- 9:16A lot of people, they start with the basic ones that everyone,
- 9:19the big names that everyone understands.
- 9:21But then as they get get more educated and some data,
- 9:24sometimes it's leaked here and there, some funds are lost here
- 9:27and there and they kind of want to start looking at other
- 9:31options. And this is where, you know,
- 9:33Flash is a very logical next step for for such companies.
- 9:37So I mean, I think generally speaking, Square accepting like
- 9:39link payments, that's very welcome.
- 9:42Now, another one that I think is pretty interesting is the fact
- 9:45that there are a lot of payment solutions out there that are not
- 9:49like square. Square is, you know, fully
- 9:51regulated, fully follows all of the regulations that are needed
- 9:56when it comes to custody and KYC, anti money laundering
- 10:01processes, all of this. And there are a lot in the space
- 10:03that are custodians and do not do that.
- 10:06And it's just interesting to observe and kind of, you know,
- 10:09raises the question, what's what's going to happen next?
- 10:12I know you know, Steak and Shake, for example, they, they
- 10:17were at the conference as well. They had a booth, they're using
- 10:20a, a competitor of ours that is based out of, they're based out
- 10:23of Dubai. They don't KYC, they don't AML.
- 10:27So, you know, big, big question mark as to how long they're
- 10:30going to be able to run this business this way with US
- 10:34customers given the regulations that that are coming.
- 10:37I mean, of course, you know, at this stage regulations in the
- 10:39US, the only thing we know of is the Genius Act that at this
- 10:43stage only regulates stable coins, but often times shows how
- 10:48the rest of the industry will will be regulated, which I mean,
- 10:52I think is the logical way of approaching it.
- 10:54If you're a custodian, you need to have custodian processes,
- 10:58which makes sense because you're a risk for individuals.
- 11:01And so, you know, with the all of this knowledge and seeing all
- 11:05these businesses that are accepting payments through these
- 11:07rails, sure, it's easier and you're sure, you know, they're
- 11:12good options. But as these recognitions come
- 11:15into play, I think these, this environment can, can change for,
- 11:18for them as well, which, you know, from Flash's perspective,
- 11:20just strengthens exactly what what we're doing, because the
- 11:23whole goal is no intermediaries and not having to rely on, on
- 11:28other custodians where it's not needed essentially.
- 11:32And I think payment is not needed when it comes to holding
- 11:36custody of of user expense. I mean, rather custody of user
- 11:40funds is not needed in the payment space, right.
- 11:44Yeah. I don't know if maybe you have
- 11:46some reactions when it comes to that.
- 11:47I do have some extra thoughts when it comes to the whole
- 11:49Lightning Network thing of Square.
- 11:50Yeah, go. Ahead I was just.
- 11:54Going to say it's it's really bullish too just because we've
- 11:58we've really seen a ton of focus on Bitcoin treasury companies,
- 12:01but this is really great for just like companies that want a
- 12:04Bitcoin treasury and then it doesn't need to necessarily be
- 12:07the full focus of their entire company.
- 12:09But like to Michael's point earlier, like Bitcoin is not
- 12:13like some like very fringe idea where nobody understands you
- 12:19know, if it has any value at all.
- 12:22It's just now in kind of in I guess maybe phase two of like
- 12:27how to optimize your exposure to it of, you know, how to optimize
- 12:32payments, what to do as like a company if you want to integrate
- 12:36it into your business. Do you hold it?
- 12:38Do you just, you know, it seems like Steak and Shake maybe just
- 12:41goes the route of, you know, liquidating it and that's the
- 12:44option that Square gives you once you accept it for payment.
- 12:47But even with that, there are many times going to be reduced
- 12:50fees and quicker settlement. I don't know exactly what Square
- 12:53is going to offer like that, but it seems like that's just
- 12:57significantly better than the merchant side.
- 13:00And it does just give additional exposure and, you know,
- 13:04education from very well respected players who can allow
- 13:09for different exposure from a number of different people.
- 13:13So I mean, I don't see how this is anything but, but really
- 13:16exciting for a number of different, you know, aspects and
- 13:19and yeah, and that's kind of before we even touch on the
- 13:24rotting side. Yeah.
- 13:25So just just a note, stick and shake, they're not using square
- 13:28though stick and shake uses speed.
- 13:31Mm. Hmm.
- 13:37Sorry, I don't know if I'm so I was going to bring up Pierre.
- 13:42The I hear the notion of the non custodial and I think there's a
- 13:47delicate balance because let's say it's Steak 'n Shake or
- 13:51whoever and they don't know who their counterparty is and they
- 13:53use the easiest route and then they get rugged.
- 13:55Whether they get rugged because of regulation or they get rugged
- 13:57because wherever their custodial wallet is, the problem with that
- 14:00is independent. If we agree if it's right or
- 14:03wrong, like that's the easy route and it's the tooling that
- 14:06vertically integrates to make it very simple.
- 14:07In the same way Square you log in, you have a bank account, it
- 14:10accepts it to it, you know the payments and then it sweeps and
- 14:13takes the fee and it's pretty straightforward.
- 14:15It gives you some invoicing and other tooling.
- 14:17So how do you think about that experience?
- 14:19Because there's some part component of value add that you
- 14:22can bring your own custody setup.
- 14:24And there's the other part where the vast majority of people
- 14:26won't want to think about that. They'll naturally either want to
- 14:29bring in the Bitcoin auto convert or sweep into a robust
- 14:32custody solution. Looking at their partner, their
- 14:35partner that they're using it as their source of truth or kind of
- 14:38advocate to come into the space. Like how do you think about that
- 14:40ease of access and the like a balance?
- 14:44Yes, I think because I don't have any problem with custody
- 14:47and in fact I think custody is, yeah, very welcome when it comes
- 14:51to holding funds. And especially I like you know,
- 14:54the more hybrid models with like most institution custody like
- 14:57you guys offer. But it's really when I, when I
- 15:00say that custody is something that shouldn't happen, it's in
- 15:04the payment side of things. We, we don't need, you know, the
- 15:08an intermediary when it comes to actually facilitating payments,
- 15:11right? This is what, what we're working
- 15:12at solving at flash. So it's, it's really when it
- 15:15comes to that. Now, you know, at this stage,
- 15:18well, we know we have the technology and we're, we're
- 15:20developing and developing the use cases for it.
- 15:22It's really more a matter of making sure that these custodial
- 15:26solutions can plug into these environments more, more easily
- 15:29in order to facilitate the non custodial payments.
- 15:35But you know, just to simplify the non custodial part, it's
- 15:37really about no intermediaries, right, Because there there can
- 15:40be custody on both sides of where the Bitcoin comes from and
- 15:44where it's going. It's just that in this
- 15:46transaction there shouldn't be an intermediary because the tech
- 15:50allows us to do it. I mean, after all, you know, the
- 15:53white paper is about peer-to-peer electronic cash
- 15:56system. So it's about making sure that
- 15:58we remove these intermediaries in the payment because I think
- 16:03for new people coming into the space and it makes perfect sense
- 16:07to look for custodial solutions that have, you know, I don't
- 16:11know for just more secure solutions, not relying on your
- 16:14own individual security when you may not be familiar with all of
- 16:18these processes and the right, the right way of doing it.
- 16:21I mean, I know that the first time as an individual that I
- 16:24took proper custody of my funds, that that was an entire first,
- 16:28first step to take, right? And it's, it's it's not an easy
- 16:31one because it, I mean, it makes you feel very responsible all of
- 16:34a sudden. And, and it's also counter
- 16:36intuitive because the concept of custody doesn't really exist
- 16:41outside of the world of Bitcoin or, you know, even thinking more
- 16:44wider crypto, because everyone is just so used to custody and
- 16:48everything that is payments and holding your your money in in a
- 16:52bank account. So, so that's why, you know, I
- 16:55maybe prefer just you saying no intermediaries when it comes to
- 16:59the payment side of things. And, and essentially, yeah, I
- 17:02think, you know, when it comes to Square, it's easier if you
- 17:05come to to try speed, it's easier, although I mean, try
- 17:08speed again, I think is, is easier because they don't
- 17:10require KYC and they don't have all of these processes because
- 17:14we're still in this Gray area of regulation.
- 17:16Square, of course, does require all of this.
- 17:18And, and you know, many businesses are, are, are fine
- 17:21with that, which which makes sense.
- 17:23And Square are custodian, temporary custodian of of these
- 17:26payments and allow to, you know, directly either off ramp or just
- 17:33also hold it in Bitcoin directly through their other services,
- 17:36which is interesting to see. I mean, they did part of block,
- 17:39they did release bit key, which is a hardware wallet.
- 17:44But that is I think, you know, the next step will be how do
- 17:46they integrate this nicely and the rest of of their tools.
- 17:51Yeah. We don't we don't ever get to
- 17:54talk about bit key. We don't have to do it here, but
- 17:56I just nobody talks about in the lexicon or like in the the the
- 18:01Twitter space. These are a lot of people
- 18:02spouting none of those people have ever onboarded thousands of
- 18:05people in like real significant capital.
- 18:08And what that product is, is the is pure too much money and too
- 18:12many smart people sitting in a room ideating on what the market
- 18:15wants versus building it like this is that's fundamental to
- 18:18the thing. It's like it's for nobody when
- 18:20you really break it down, because everyone will say it's
- 18:23for somebody else or their grandparents or whatever.
- 18:25It's like, if it's for your grandparents and they're going
- 18:27to put significant wealth and they don't understand it and you
- 18:30can't recover, like how much wealth would you put?
- 18:32And if it's not for the hardcore person, like who is it for?
- 18:35It's for really nobody. And nobody really says that
- 18:38because they've never had to sit on calls and walk people through
- 18:41and the dongles and the recovery and the questions that are
- 18:43asked. No serious person is putting
- 18:46significant capital on a big key multi sig setup.
- 18:48So then it's like, what are you doing here?
- 18:51Yeah, yeah, it's AI. Personally didn't choose, but
- 18:54yeah, I did hear many people say that it's it's the hardware
- 18:58wallet that they think is the easiest to use and so on.
- 19:00But I don't know. I personally, I, I didn't use it
- 19:03myself. It's got a nice design, I guess,
- 19:05but yeah, it feels good. There's no screen.
- 19:09There's no screen. Yeah, yeah, yeah, I agree.
- 19:12I agree. But but I mean, of course the
- 19:14the the point is for you to be able to use it through their
- 19:16app, right. So it's just there as an
- 19:18external signing device. Yeah, but but I don't know, it
- 19:23doesn't feel. The fascinating part is like we
- 19:25space, we stay so close to the space.
- 19:27The past two weeks. It just came out.
- 19:29Ledger Live had a, a malicious, you know, software download,
- 19:32whatever. Like so how they're not gonna
- 19:34come up with a different app or a side load.
- 19:37You can get somebody's phone overnight, swap out the app.
- 19:39And then there's so many different attack vectors.
- 19:41If you aren't able to see it from an external device, which
- 19:45goes back to then it's just for fun.
- 19:46And if it's just for fun, just put it on a single, say, cold
- 19:48card and call it a day. Yep.
- 19:50Yeah, I know. It's more secure and you can see
- 19:52it, yeah. Yeah, definitely.
- 19:53I mean, in the end, you have to be able to validate including
- 19:57from the device that you're sending to the right address as
- 20:00expected. Because yes, the attack vectors,
- 20:02if you don't see all of a sudden, I mean, yeah, you can,
- 20:06you can really get trapped easily.
- 20:09Maybe maybe just circling back to, to the payment side of
- 20:13things and for, for maybe folks in the audience who who haven't
- 20:17heard about Flash specifically, Pierre, maybe if you could give
- 20:21sort of just a brief overview of what what Flash does.
- 20:24And then I'll pull up this this write up in Bitcoin mag from a
- 20:28couple weeks ago. And you know, maybe just talk
- 20:31through some of the some of the things you guys are working on
- 20:34with Flash 2 point O and and sort of the road map in general.
- 20:39Yeah, sure. So essentially at Flash, you
- 20:42know, what we found is that there's really good technology
- 20:46at the protocol level that allows us to interact with
- 20:48wallets in a pretty novel way that unlocks a couple new
- 20:52features that didn't exist in Bitcoin until now.
- 20:56One of them is direct debit, essentially where we can just
- 20:59easily interact with with wallets.
- 21:01So we have a set of different tools, you know, for content
- 21:05creators, for in person commerce, for e-commerce
- 21:09platforms such as subscriptions, so automatic recurring payments
- 21:13and all of these features and actually invoicing took we just
- 21:16launched invoicing last week I believe and we're going to be
- 21:21pushing this some more as well. So every single tool that we
- 21:24have is just through basic communication with the user
- 21:31wallet and allows us to make sure that we are not an
- 21:35intermediary in the payment, which means that there's there's
- 21:37no KYC, it's free to get started.
- 21:40And essentially, yeah, it's a it's a we believe the easiest
- 21:44and fastest option to get started with with Bitcoin
- 21:46payments. Again, with this the, the, the
- 21:51truly revolutionary side that we are trying to to push is the
- 21:57fact that if you are a payment processor, you no longer need to
- 22:02hold custody of merchants funds. We can just facilitate these
- 22:06peer-to-peer transactions, which of course reduces the time
- 22:11transactions end up in the merchants pockets, the fees that
- 22:14merchants have to pay as well as the general user experience that
- 22:19it is to get started. So, yeah, so that's kind of what
- 22:22what we're, we're up to and we have very big set set of tools
- 22:27and, and the, the more recent one that we we want to push is
- 22:31invoicing. Now, of course, in the
- 22:33traditional Fiat world, invoicing tools are usually free
- 22:37and, and, and so that that's how we're going to be releasing also
- 22:40our invoicing. So starting next week, it'll be
- 22:43completely free for any freelancer to come over flash
- 22:45and over it's flash creates invoices and then to to their
- 22:49employer for for whatever kind of job they're they're doing.
- 22:52And we won't take any transactions fee for that.
- 22:55This will just depend on the network fees and what wallets
- 22:58you use. So we also have a, a wallet that
- 23:01is right now in beta. So it's still in test flight.
- 23:04And next month we hope to be able to release it on the app
- 23:08stores. So for self custodial, again we
- 23:10do not want to hold anyone's money such anyone's money
- 23:14whether you know the wallet that they earn too or even how they
- 23:20earn in this flow of payments. Right.
- 23:22Yeah, it's a, it's an insane, you know, tool set or there's a
- 23:27lot of tooling and a lot that's been added.
- 23:29I was looking over yesterday curious Pierre, like how would
- 23:31you, is it a fair categorization?
- 23:34There's like 2 parts to the business in the sense that
- 23:37there's like merchant tooling, somebody can onboard, get access
- 23:41to these robust different tool sets for integration to like Woo
- 23:44commerce, Shopify and then create the invoice naturally
- 23:48figure out curious on like exactly the flow around custody
- 23:51because that's still the thing that I like harp on is if
- 23:54there's not a direct version of what they can do that's robust,
- 23:57that's a point of friction in my mind.
- 24:00But then the second part is around Noster Wallet Connect and
- 24:03bringing a whole layer of other native aspects to payments that
- 24:08have historically not been there when it comes to subscriptions
- 24:11and pooling. And is that fair to separate
- 24:13them or I know they merge in some respects, but I feel like
- 24:16they kind of have two different either use cases or areas of
- 24:21your business that are like from a technology stack?
- 24:24Yeah. So definitely, I mean at the
- 24:27heart of it all is always Nostril wallet connect because
- 24:29this is the tech that we use to be able to interact with
- 24:32wallets. Now if you think of it in the
- 24:34most basic way, it's just a a shared API among all compatible
- 24:41wallets, which is now becoming quite the standard as most new
- 24:44Lightning wallets are releasing with master wall connect
- 24:48integrations and essentially it allows it to directly
- 24:50communicate with the wallet. So how it works is whatever
- 24:53check out you have, so it can be our e-commerce checkout for
- 24:57example. Well, then the the user, the
- 25:00customer is redirected to our hosted checkout page and there
- 25:03we will show a Lightning QR code.
- 25:06So a payment request we're about also to really sell.
- 25:09So support for on chain payments, so that we both on
- 25:12chain and Lightning paid to the same wallet.
- 25:14And essentially these payment requests that appear on screen
- 25:19are generated by the merchant wallet directly.
- 25:22So it is not a payment that goes to one of our wallets and we
- 25:26redirect, it's a payment that will go directly to the
- 25:28merchant, which increases a lot of yeah, security for, for, for
- 25:32the merchant and also allows to create this direct relationship
- 25:35in fact, between the customer and, and the brands they're,
- 25:38they're buying products from. And, and this is true for
- 25:41everything. Now, one thing we're, we're also
- 25:44making a lot of changes thanks to Noster walk night is through
- 25:48back end payments. So if you think of traditional
- 25:50payments in the Bitcoin space, there is usually a QR code and
- 25:53you have to scan the QR code from your phone and you have to
- 25:56confirm the transaction. And this is how the funds are
- 25:58sent. Well, Nostril Wall Connect
- 26:00allows us to manage a lot of this in the back end.
- 26:02And this is how we do it. The subscription, so
- 26:03subscriptions is 2 sided. There's the site that is the
- 26:06merchant site, which of course, you know, in the end, the tool
- 26:09that we have is for merchants to be able to monetize through
- 26:12automatic recurring payments, whether it's daily, weekly,
- 26:15monthly, we have a bunch of options there.
- 26:18And then of course there's the consumer side, which is how
- 26:21customers can subscribe to these platforms, right.
- 26:24And when it comes to the, the flow of payments, in that case,
- 26:28essentially we do the exact same thing, except that we
- 26:31communicate using nostril wall connect in our back end.
- 26:33So the, the, the, the exact user flow is he arrives on our
- 26:39subscription checkout page, he chooses his plan depending on
- 26:42what the merchant set up. And when he chose his plan, he
- 26:47needs to verify his e-mail address pretty basic kind of to
- 26:50effect. And then instead of scanning AQR
- 26:52code to make a payment, he has to connect his wallet.
- 26:55And in connecting his wallet, we create a, a, a connection that
- 27:00that we store that has a set budget.
- 27:03We cannot charge more than what the user authorized us to to
- 27:06charge. And then from the in, in our
- 27:09back end, we will generate a lightning payment request from
- 27:13the merchant wallet. The user never sees it.
- 27:16And then using the nostril wall connection of the customer,
- 27:19we're going to pay that invoice that was generated by the
- 27:21merchant. So we're also facilitating A
- 27:24peer-to-peer transaction. But the actual transaction
- 27:27doesn't happen in the front end. It is purely in the back end.
- 27:31And then of course, how how do we get paid in in the process is
- 27:34leveraging the same direct debit approach is after the merchant
- 27:38got paid well, then we can trigger a payment from his
- 27:41wallet to ours. And so the flow is the same is
- 27:43rather than, you know, interacting with the merchant's
- 27:47wallet directly, we interact with the flash wallet, we
- 27:50generate a payment request and then we get the merchant to pay
- 27:53this in the back end, right. So there's, there's two back end
- 27:55payments that happen, allowing us to not be an intermediary in
- 27:59the flow of funds. We really just take a service
- 28:02fee because all of this happened through through our platform,
- 28:05which is I think the way forward, of course, for payment
- 28:09processors because it is so easy to do and is, is instant now
- 28:13compared to the fact that it was impossible up until now.
- 28:17Now it has just become, well, not necessarily easy, I'm not
- 28:20going to lie, but it became possible at least.
- 28:22And, and so we're, we're unlocking these Tuesdays.
- 28:25And I think it goes beyond just subscription goes beyond
- 28:29merchants. I think it can go to all kind of
- 28:33peer-to-peer payments in any platform.
- 28:36And and I think that's that's what we're going to start seeing
- 28:39little by little. Yeah, let's let's talk about
- 28:45some of like you're interesting, it could be even be like
- 28:47moonshots. But to back into that where
- 28:50you're thinking where it can go is your reference had been
- 28:53historically impossible. So the first thing my mind went
- 28:57to anybody listening or here is like if you don't use it was
- 29:00like Molvad and some of the VPN providers that require Bitcoin
- 29:04payments, you generally end up like tapping out unless you're
- 29:06going to, you know, if you're going to pay in Bitcoin because
- 29:08every month you have to reset it or you can pay for like 3
- 29:11months. But then my mind when it went to
- 29:14well, what other use cases or globally that somebody wants to
- 29:19accept Bitcoin on a reoccurring basis and that they never did.
- 29:22So they either just didn't offer to a segment of the market or
- 29:24never opened up Bitcoin because you would imagine you'd probably
- 29:27lose, you know, a conversion rate if somebody goes and signs
- 29:30up for Bitcoin for one month and then you never see them again
- 29:32because they just didn't. That's because that's what would
- 29:33happen with me with multiple VPN providers.
- 29:37But then it kind of ties into this notion we've talked about a
- 29:41little bit before of it's like the the growth of the Internet
- 29:45was around like Metcalf's law, which is the Ethernet or like
- 29:48amount of connectivity. And then Moore's law, which is
- 29:51lowering the cost of, you know, semiconductors and just
- 29:53technology and those together is what, you know, kind of created
- 29:56the modern day kind of like proliferation of technology.
- 29:59And then if you take that to where we're at today, it's AI
- 30:03and Bitcoin, where AI is the version of Moore's law, you can
- 30:06do more with less. And then Bitcoin is, you know,
- 30:08the Metcalf's law, you're able to, you know, basically connect
- 30:10everyone that hadn't been. So you take all those together
- 30:14and this is what kind of leads to where do you think?
- 30:15What are some interesting examples of whether it's what
- 30:19you're referencing with Nostril wallet connecting the
- 30:21connectivity that just hadn't been done before or it's not
- 30:24even haven't been done before. It's like just opens up more of
- 30:27a market where somebody could have been in Poland and only
- 30:29offered there because they couldn't get a U.S. bank account
- 30:31or couldn't offer their goods and services, their technology
- 30:33stack to U.S. citizens. Latin America now just
- 30:36completely change. What are you seeing or thinking
- 30:39about? Yeah.
- 30:41So I mean, I think the use cases can can go really quite crazy
- 30:47moving forward because, you know, nostril wallet connect, of
- 30:49course, makes these these things easier and more interoperable.
- 30:53Especially I think this is the more important part is the fact
- 30:55that it's interoperable and and of course can allow the
- 30:59automation of payments in South custody.
- 31:04So without intermediaries, which means it removes friction of,
- 31:07you know, needing KYC on the bunch of platforms and so on.
- 31:10But also it's microtransactions, right?
- 31:12So the fee that we take if someone is selling, you know, a
- 31:15product that is $1.00's worth, but we can still capture a fee
- 31:19because we're talking of microtransactions and, and I
- 31:21think this is the concept that can scale really big time.
- 31:26So you know, I guess, I guess we must have spoken about that The
- 31:31so Flash was a spin off of a previous project that we were
- 31:34working on called Nosteret's originally horrible name.
- 31:38But essentially what we were working on was leveraging AI
- 31:43Noster and Lightning payments. And the way we did that was
- 31:46essentially, and we have created an entire chatbot that was that
- 31:49was built off of that, where for each API request that was done,
- 31:57we would then send a lightning invoice through an SDK.
- 32:01And then a back end payment would happen directly and the
- 32:04response of that API would be sent only if the lightning
- 32:07invoice was paid. And you know, this is in fact
- 32:11how we started really using Noster Wall Connect.
- 32:14And when we realized the power of it because all of a sudden,
- 32:17you know, we were originally using 2 technologies in the
- 32:19lightning space and lightning addresses and, and Noster Wall
- 32:22Connect. We had them both together and
- 32:25the lightning addresses issued as a platform that is trying to
- 32:29coordinate payments is that there is no way to for you to
- 32:34capture a fee without taking custody of user response, right?
- 32:38And and this is when we realized actually we solved this problem
- 32:42with Noster Walk connect. And when the, the week we saw
- 32:45released Noster eggs, we also thought we should change and
- 32:48this is when we should move on to flash.
- 32:51But that's also when I told my Co founder, OK, but I think
- 32:54right here is the moment where you should like take the
- 32:56decision of moving away from lightning addresses and focus
- 32:59only on Noster walk connect, because that's the only real way
- 33:04to take a a feat for every single transaction that we can
- 33:09simplify the flow for without ever holding custody of users
- 33:12funds, right. And so if we were to recreate
- 33:16this entire API payments platform, which we, you know, do
- 33:20plan on recreating, then we would do it using Nostra walknet
- 33:24because it is so much easier. In fact, you know, and I don't
- 33:27want to get too technical either, but there's this a big
- 33:30project called L4O2 that is essentially doing that created
- 33:33by Lightning Labs. And I think it's just a
- 33:38complicated way of doing it. You have to lock up some Bitcoin
- 33:41and give temporary access to a third party so that he can just
- 33:45take this Bitcoin whenever he. Needs.
- 33:49From this locked up Bitcoin, essentially, it's not what I
- 33:52consider a direct debit kind of way of working.
- 33:54And and I think the way forward is through this direct debit
- 33:58feature that nostril wall can without needing to lock up some,
- 34:02some Bitcoin because I mean, I don't know if I'm using a
- 34:04certain API and sure, I know that there's X amount of
- 34:10transactions that are going to happen.
- 34:11I don't necessarily want to lock up more Bitcoin than I need to
- 34:15and I in fact don't want to lock up any Bitcoin in theory, right,
- 34:19I should be able to just really have a pay per use experience.
- 34:22The moment you lock up some funds, it's not pay per use
- 34:25experience anymore. And Nostra Walk Connect allows
- 34:27us to really create these paper uses experiences, pay per click
- 34:31experiences all the way. And so I think it can apply to
- 34:35the way AIAPIS&AIS communicate between one another through
- 34:40these endpoints. I think and this is kind of a
- 34:43recurring theme that we've heard a lot in the Bitcoin space that
- 34:46lightning is going to be. And so Bitcoin through lightning
- 34:49is going to be the money of AI agents.
- 34:53I think this is true because there is no more efficient
- 34:56payment network out there that allows for such small all
- 35:00transactions. But I think it's true also for
- 35:03advertisements. We created a proof of concept
- 35:06last year that allowed for a direct pay per click, literal
- 35:10pay per click, unlike today where you go on Google Ads or
- 35:16any of such alternatives and you have to pay directly.
- 35:20So again, you kind of set the budget, but you prepaid it and
- 35:24then little by little it's going to be charged for supposedly
- 35:28clicks. You just see dashboards that are
- 35:30communicated to you. Well, what what we had built is
- 35:33essentially A literal pay per click where you connect your
- 35:37wallet to a Noster wallet connect and you authorize a
- 35:40certain budget, but you don't pay for anything.
- 35:42There's a maximum amount that you will commit for this ad
- 35:46campaign that you have, but it will only be charged when there
- 35:51are actual clicks, which is the right way of doing it and making
- 35:54sure that again, there's no intermediaries in the payments
- 35:57and no one is there to take your funds when they shouldn't.
- 36:01And you know, I think this this one is a really big one.
- 36:04I have a personal story that maybe I told you guys.
- 36:08So the first thing I did in Bitcoin was a Bitcoin
- 36:10documentary, right? And it's on YouTube, the great
- 36:12reset in the rise of Bitcoin. And so it buzzed quite a bit.
- 36:16And so very quickly I was able to monetize the channel, which
- 36:20as soon as I could, I did for this you need I think about
- 36:23350,000, No 3, 1/2 thousand followers and maybe 150,000
- 36:28views, something like that, 200,000 views.
- 36:30And so I monetized and I had to wait for a certain threshold
- 36:34before I could withdraw it, right?
- 36:36That's already, you know, it shows what the limits of certain
- 36:39custodians and intermediaries are.
- 36:41And the moment I wanted to withdraw these funds, I wasn't
- 36:45allowed to. Google blocked me.
- 36:50They shadowed and my channel. They locked my account.
- 36:53I couldn't monetize anymore. And essentially, it took three
- 36:56months of back and forth between Google Pay and YouTube saying
- 37:01it's their fault. No, it's their fault.
- 37:02No, it's their fault and impossible for me to get my
- 37:05funds back. And I think, you know, that's
- 37:07the kind of things where had I been paid directly to my wallet,
- 37:12there would be no problem. I wouldn't have any problem with
- 37:14my channel and with YouTube at all.
- 37:16So you know that that's the kind of problems that that I think
- 37:19can can be sold directly thanks to these micro transaction pay
- 37:23per clicks, direct debit environment, while YouTube could
- 37:28still earn because they could still trigger payments from my
- 37:31wallet directly. So I think these are the kind of
- 37:33use cases that are completely new and that's that we're going
- 37:36to see moving forward. But you know, it's going to take
- 37:40a bit of time. Of course, Bitcoin has to
- 37:42properly become the standard Internet money between
- 37:45developers. I think this is essentially what
- 37:48needs to happen. Developers that are not from the
- 37:50Bitcoin space to also adopt it and then they will start using
- 37:53it and how they pay each other. Hey guys, hope you're enjoying
- 37:57the podcast with Pierre. It was a great one.
- 37:59Just wanted to share a quick word from On Ramp about our
- 38:02private client services. A lot of clients come to us with
- 38:05significant balances and they're hoping to get a white glove
- 38:08treatment, whether it's via our onboarding process, helping and
- 38:12moving assets from a collaborative custody or single
- 38:15hardware device or a third party exchange like a coin base.
- 38:18We support with all of that and much more, whether it's a
- 38:21virtual family office, access to private equity in the Bitcoin
- 38:25space, VR fund, early riders, and also the Guild network,
- 38:29which really brings together world class professionals
- 38:31globally that are looking to either collaborate, build
- 38:35companies in the space, advise companies, or just share
- 38:38professional experience as it relates to this new monetary
- 38:42order that's being shaped before us.
- 38:44If you'd like to learn about any of that, you can reach out to me
- 38:47at Michael at honor@bitcoin.com or if you want to reach out to
- 38:50the group at hello at honor@bitcoin.com.
- 38:52Now back to the rest of the show.
- 38:55Yeah, that's fascinating. I think slight, slight pivot
- 38:59from this, but I think another theme, you know, if we just
- 39:02think about the conference and, and sort of all the activity and
- 39:05adoption that's been occurring recently, there's been a lot of
- 39:08talk about stable coins. I think the, the last time that
- 39:11we had you on the show, Pierre, we were talking about, you know,
- 39:14Tether had just announced that they were going to bring Tether
- 39:17to the Lightning Network. I'm curious to get your thoughts
- 39:21updated. Thoughts on one sort of like
- 39:24user proclivity to use stable coins instead of like actually
- 39:29spending sats and where you see that sort of evolving or
- 39:33developing as as Tether in particular gets more involved on
- 39:37the Bitcoin lightning side. And and also just general
- 39:40thoughts on, you know, what were the conversations from last week
- 39:44around people building around stable coins as opposed to just
- 39:47building around sats of Bitcoin? Before Pierre, before you jumped
- 39:53in, we have about 30 minutes and like I, I don't know where Brian
- 39:56else wants to go and Liam, but I've been fascinated recently
- 39:59about this, the stable coin proliferation And I know you had
- 40:02a background in your consulting days and looking at flow of
- 40:04funds and interchange. So if you need to start from
- 40:07this top. Just curious in general like
- 40:10your thoughts around stable coins, how they fit into this
- 40:12global landscape and you know, if you want to jump directly to
- 40:15Brian, but we can spend some time here because I do think
- 40:17there's a lot to cover. We're seeing a lot happening in
- 40:20the banking system in the US and then also globally to to touch
- 40:22on and curiously at your thoughts.
- 40:25Yeah. So I mean, generally speaking, I
- 40:27think stable coins have, they're a great bridge for people to get
- 40:31into this space because you can allow people to spend, interact
- 40:37with U.S. dollar equivalent stable coins.
- 40:40I'm thinking mostly U.S. dollar because there are some other
- 40:42stable coins, but I don't know, they're not really used that
- 40:45much. It's yeah, there isn't the same
- 40:47liquidity. So I think USDT is what matters,
- 40:50USDC as well, but mostly USDT is, is kind of the, the gold
- 40:55standard of stable coins. And, and I think, I mean,
- 40:58they're great to, yeah, bridge the gap that exists between the
- 41:02traditional world and the Bitcoin world.
- 41:05And their utility is essentially what we're seeing, right?
- 41:08A lot of third world countries, they want USDT because it allows
- 41:11them to save in dollars, which is the currency everyone wants
- 41:14to save in as opposed to, you know, every other currency
- 41:19losing value faster than the US dollar, because these are the
- 41:22General Dynamics. So everyone wants U.S. dollar.
- 41:25Not everyone can get U.S. dollar, but everyone can get
- 41:27USDT and I think this this is very, very interesting.
- 41:30So being able to see this environment grow is very
- 41:36important. Now, one thing to keep in mind
- 41:38is of course, the fact that holding USDT is not holding
- 41:41Bitcoin and the, the US dollar loses value slower than any
- 41:46other currency, but it still loses value.
- 41:49And you know, holding Bitcoin. If someone is thinking more long
- 41:54term is, is kind of the, the approach.
- 41:56I think that that makes more sense.
- 41:58And when it comes to also bringing this into the Lightning
- 42:00network, I mean, it's the most efficient payment network, the
- 42:03most private and that is really growing in, in the Bitcoin
- 42:08space. Anything can be added now to
- 42:11Bitcoin. Anything can be added to the
- 42:13Lightning network thanks to Taproot Assets.
- 42:16Now tether sure they're announcing and renouncing and
- 42:18renouncing that's when will it come out?
- 42:22I'm I'm not quite sure hopefully pretty soon.
- 42:25I think, you know, maybe they're trying to align this with some
- 42:28of their other investments as well.
- 42:30Like, you know, they put a bunch of money inside of Rumble
- 42:36recently and the they are announcing their wallet that
- 42:41will be both Bitcoin and USDT wallet.
- 42:43So I don't know, maybe they're, they're, you know, waiting to
- 42:45make sure that the use case can be integrated there directly to
- 42:49make it boom. But but I mean, I welcome it to
- 42:53be honest. I think it's it's it's a good
- 42:55move because it will simplify the onboarding to Bitcoin as
- 42:59well on the most efficient payment network that exists
- 43:04right now in in the world. So yeah, I think it's just
- 43:10interesting to see and interesting to see how their
- 43:13entire model is going to work compared to sending Bitcoin over
- 43:18the Lightning network. Because there is the concept of
- 43:20liquidity on the lighting network where all the, the nodes
- 43:23where these payments they hop through, they need to have the
- 43:26liquidity of the transaction that is going through the nodes.
- 43:30So is this going to work with USDT?
- 43:33Because there, I mean, no node currently has USDT on Lightning.
- 43:37So is every single node going to have to also add this in order
- 43:41to be able to be a node that routes these payments?
- 43:45I don't know, Maybe they're going to use sats underneath to
- 43:48be able to pay for the routing of these payments.
- 43:50But then problems, I think user experience problems might come
- 43:55into play where you know, if you've ever made a transaction
- 44:00on any other blockchain that uses USDT.
- 44:04So for example, I tried paying once developer in USDT over Tron
- 44:09because Tron is the cheapest network right now to pay through
- 44:13USDT. Well, it's, it's a bit of a pain
- 44:15because sure, one thing is to have USDT and you can make this
- 44:19transaction, but to be able to do it well, you need to actually
- 44:23have Tron. I do not care for Tron at all.
- 44:27So you know, I'm OK buying the USDT, I'm trying to send it, but
- 44:30just buying Tron in order to be able to make this transaction
- 44:34very, very painful. And you know, for people that
- 44:37just want to be able to spend in USDT if they need, if they face
- 44:41the same user experience problem because all of a sudden they
- 44:44need to have USDT and they need to have Bitcoin, it means that
- 44:47they need to also go buy Bitcoin when they might not care about
- 44:50it, right? So you know, the question is, is
- 44:52this something that will be solved by the USDT routing of
- 44:56payments or will it be sold by the notes themselves and how
- 45:00they route these payments? That's that's the kind of
- 45:02question I still didn't get an answer to because I mean, yeah,
- 45:07we didn't have let's say main net, so production ready version
- 45:13of USDT transactions over the Lightning network.
- 45:17So question mark there to be honest, but but I think it's,
- 45:20it's pretty exciting, especially that what I feel is missing in
- 45:24the world of USDT payments and we're facing this at Flash as
- 45:28well. So you know, our wallet is, is
- 45:29using the liquid network and it means that, you know, there's a
- 45:33bunch of assets that are available in liquid.
- 45:35I don't care for most of them, but there is USDT and and that's
- 45:41cool because you know, we could offer already today and we
- 45:43wanted to offer USDT balances and supports directly inside of
- 45:48Flash. But the issue is that who us who
- 45:53uses USDT on liquids? No one literally, right?
- 45:57And so then in order for us to allow merchants to be able to
- 46:01accept payments in USDT this way, well then it means that we
- 46:04would need to allow for the conversion from different USDT
- 46:07from other block chains into USDT on liquid.
- 46:11But then how do you do that without introducing custodial
- 46:15solutions, which we are trying to stay away completely because
- 46:18there are solutions out there like Site Shift.
- 46:20Site Shift is great, very well integrated with the Liquid
- 46:22Network as well. And we'd be able to do that.
- 46:24But they are temporarily holding user funds and I think could be
- 46:30categorized in the future as money transmitters and it would
- 46:34put at risk our entire platform and users that do not interact
- 46:39with it at all do not care. They would also have the KYC
- 46:41through us, which is, you know, what we're trying to to stay
- 46:44away from. And I think stable coin on
- 46:46Lightning maybe could be the opportunity to simplify this
- 46:50because just like a lightning, I think is going to grow as being
- 46:54the payment network that links all of the different Bitcoin
- 46:58networks because they all have their their benefits right on
- 47:00chain is the ultimate that you want to be able to use liquid, I
- 47:04think is great in order to be able to start with a 0 balance.
- 47:07And Lightning is is a great solution for instant payments,
- 47:10but also to swap in full atomic swap.
- 47:14So again, no, no custodials in these kind of interactions
- 47:20directly from one network to the other, Lightning being at at the
- 47:24heart of it. So you know, is there potential
- 47:27for stable coins on lightning to solve this problem between the
- 47:32lack of interoperability of all of these chains?
- 47:36I think the potential is there, but but we'll see.
- 47:40Yeah. I mean, I guess there's two
- 47:44there's two aspects I when I think about stable coins, I
- 47:46think of and maybe for this topic we focus on like the
- 47:50individual and peer-to-peer. I think there's the other
- 47:52version, which is B to B and the opportunity that the stripes and
- 47:55large companies are are after and they're not going to be
- 47:58transacted on lightning or any or Tron for I guess TBD what
- 48:02that looks like, But I don't know if I've ever heard and I'm
- 48:06curious like Liam and and Brian, if you ever heard a good because
- 48:10even Liam, I'm sorry, Pierre, you sharing like if there's a
- 48:13great reason to put stable coins on lightning and like where that
- 48:17goes. The the best I had heard was
- 48:19ultimately the state between both nodes, not having to go
- 48:22back to the blockchain. If you're using it for like AI
- 48:25agents and you're having like Tether, like in dollars be able
- 48:28to be used and they're going to be, it's going to be so fast
- 48:30that you're not going to want to settle on a Tron or whatever.
- 48:33That's like what I've heard. I don't know if that's true or
- 48:35not. This is like above my pay grade.
- 48:37The thing that I will share that kind of doesn't make sense is
- 48:41like is this notion of inflation and people want stables versus
- 48:46bitcoins volatility. It's like a bitcoins volatility
- 48:48is pretty much in your favor. And if it's against you, well,
- 48:53you're, it's into relative or context to what's it against you
- 48:56and your local currency, right. And so it's more of like if you
- 49:01just obfuscate that it's Bitcoin you're holding and so you have
- 49:03AUS dollar price and then the number of sats.
- 49:06Why aren't people just holding sats?
- 49:07Because the thing that we didn't, I didn't mention is the
- 49:09counterparty risk of the, the other stablecoin you have,
- 49:12whether it's the blockchain or the, you know, whoever's holding
- 49:15the stablecoin or issuing it. So all that gets bypassed.
- 49:18It almost feels like just like an education thing where people
- 49:20are just like, why am I holding stables versus just buying this
- 49:23at, so that being done with it and, and reducing all of that.
- 49:25And that's a much global liquid network.
- 49:27Well, there are two things there that I think are worth pointing
- 49:31out. One is the privacy of the
- 49:32Lightning Network versus the other chains.
- 49:35And you know, it's interesting to see Palmer Luckey invested in
- 49:40a different stable coin that has no product market fit.
- 49:43Like all these defense guys just understand that like the flow of
- 49:46capital and like understanding the data of every user is
- 49:51definitely something that's of strategic importance, especially
- 49:53for, you know, a stable coin issuer that's going to be buying
- 49:56U.S. Treasuries.
- 49:58And then number 2 with respect to, you know, just holding S
- 50:03versus USDTI, completely agree, But I've also, you know, been in
- 50:07Bitcoin for a little bit of time, understand this deeply.
- 50:11Most people are just they're very risk adverse and think
- 50:15that, you know, Bitcoin just is way too volatile for them.
- 50:19I understand definitely the, you know, working capital needing at
- 50:23least some amount of USDT if you're in one of these countries
- 50:26where you have, you know, specific costs that you need to
- 50:29meet every month and Bitcoin could potentially be too
- 50:31volatile. But yeah, every time you have
- 50:33excess savings, it just makes sense to automatically sweep
- 50:37them into Bitcoin as long as you have enough capital that you can
- 50:41meet your working capital needs. I think that there is just so
- 50:44much education that needs to be done.
- 50:45And a lot of this is just like focused on the US where we have
- 50:49a bunch of savings, but you know, in the emerging countries
- 50:53where this isn't necessarily or there's not quite as much
- 50:57education, but there's more demand for these stable coins.
- 51:00It's just not quite there yet. Yeah, those are good points that
- 51:04like, I didn't, you know, discounted that Tether has a
- 51:06global brand like the dollar now.
- 51:08And so you're much more likely to trust Tether than the trust
- 51:11Bitcoin if you're in an emerging market for a lot of people.
- 51:15And so then if businesses are holding larger amounts of
- 51:18treasury balances. And then the other side of that,
- 51:20I didn't even think about that from the Andrel side, but that
- 51:22makes sense that there's just like Orwellian, you know, we
- 51:24sell Palantir and Trump or whatever this past weekend.
- 51:26Like these guys if they want to see into how the flow of funds
- 51:30are happening. That's an interesting dynamic
- 51:32when it comes to USDT over lightning versus versus over
- 51:37like the like on the blockchain. Yeah. 100%.
- 51:41Go ahead, Pierre. Yeah.
- 51:42So again, that's supposedly right because we don't exactly
- 51:46know how, how this is going to work, right.
- 51:49And so supposedly we'll be just as private for USDT over
- 51:54lightning as as Bitcoin is over lightning.
- 51:58But but we don't know that yet. That's that's kind of the the
- 52:01thing because, you know, there is also regulation around stable
- 52:05coins coming to the US And that's yeah, a big question as
- 52:09to how this will be handled and, and how this actually, because
- 52:15you know, there, there will be always privacy in how the
- 52:18routing of these payments happen over the lightning network.
- 52:21But it, it won't be SAT moving around the lightning network.
- 52:25The lightning network will be the the communication layer to
- 52:29forward these transactions. So we still need to see exactly
- 52:33what does it look like in terms of privacy that the, the, you
- 52:37know, whoever is initiating the transaction and whoever is
- 52:39receiving this transaction. And I, I don't know this yet,
- 52:43you know, but it. Makes sense.
- 52:45It's like Tor, it's whoever the nodes are that are you're coming
- 52:47in and out or where you're going to have the vulnerabilities and
- 52:50it's pretty that's going to be like Tether running the nodes.
- 52:54Yeah, essentially. Our agencies that just, you
- 52:57know, are looking to understand. I think at this point they're
- 53:00pretty much the same. So we're we're getting there.
- 53:02Yeah. Now, I mean, I know that there
- 53:04is of course a lot of work that is being done in the lightning
- 53:07space, but you know, that's where I don't know how this
- 53:10applies to USDT, but there is a lot of work being done in the
- 53:14lightning world to make sure that more privacy is added than
- 53:18what currently exists. The goal being that the routing
- 53:22nodes don't know who is the end recipient and who sent this
- 53:28Bitcoin originally. They just know who came before
- 53:31and who the funds are going to after.
- 53:33So this is great. If a similar model can work in
- 53:36USDT, well then yeah, I think I think we'll be good.
- 53:39But but again, it's it's not SAT flowing over lightning, it's
- 53:43USDT flowing over lightning. So I suspect it'll work in its
- 53:49own way with Tether at the middle of it.
- 53:52The the beauty of all this is like, and I think we all
- 53:55directionally agree, like, the cat's out of the bag.
- 53:57It runs with the Internet, right?
- 53:59The Internet's out. Free information will flow.
- 54:01And so I think that's why I get excited or I think about stable
- 54:05coins is it's just a gateway. We saw like a small example with
- 54:09Tether and Bitcoin and the pair and what it allowed people to
- 54:12get into BTC that now this is becoming, again, it's very
- 54:16Orwellian, but it's also opening up the aperture of the average
- 54:19individual that money is digital.
- 54:22And so the thing we didn't touch on here is like if somebody's
- 54:25coming in digital, then they can get into lightning.
- 54:27Well, then it goes back to the E cash component.
- 54:29And if you have all these different aspects that are
- 54:31starting to tie together because the cats out of the bag when it
- 54:35comes to stable getting access to Bitcoin in the same way of
- 54:38Lightning getting access to E cash or a proxy dollar, like
- 54:42entrepreneurs going to figure it out.
- 54:43Because the common thing you mentioned, the genius act is the
- 54:47banks and giving yield back. And like they don't historically
- 54:50do that. And that's like a thing that
- 54:51they're trying to put in or keep out, but it's like this reality
- 54:54that we live in a global market. So somebody's going to find
- 54:56somewhere to give you back a percentage.
- 54:58And that's where free competition comes in.
- 55:00It's just it kind of ties into the tether and like you're going
- 55:03to back your stable coin with BTC because it's the pragmatic
- 55:06thing to do if you're going to, you know, rely on it to hold
- 55:09your dollar peg. And so that free market example
- 55:13similar what's going to come over to Lightning and E cash and
- 55:17somebody can figure out a way to keep a static dollar, they're
- 55:19going to have credibility and then part of that is going to be
- 55:23privacy baked in. And then it just that's where
- 55:26we're at. It's just going to take some
- 55:27time. Yeah, yeah.
- 55:29And we don't exactly know what it's going to look like at this
- 55:32stage. But I mean, I think I'm quite
- 55:36hopeful, I guess maybe naive, but yeah, hoping that it it's
- 55:40only going to bring more adoption to the Lightning
- 55:42Network and and more liquidity as well, right?
- 55:44Because of course it's in tethers interest to make sure
- 55:49that the Lightning Network is more used and and you know, and
- 55:53actually I think it's pretty interesting when we're talking
- 55:55about yields and all of these different elements.
- 55:58When, you know, you mentioned earlier, Brian, the announcement
- 56:02that Square made about exactly 9.7 yearly yield on the
- 56:11transaction fees they take on the lightning network.
- 56:14I mean, to be honest, I was shocked when I heard that this
- 56:17like, isn't this so much cooler as a strategic Bitcoin reserve
- 56:21strategy than just holding it on some, you know, wallet and
- 56:25sleeping? Like at least it can be put to
- 56:28use directly on the lightning network generate yield while,
- 56:32you know, being secure and locked up in multi stick
- 56:36contracts for you. I think that's, yeah, it's
- 56:38pretty. Maybe something Maybe.
- 56:39For folks who don't understand what I have on the screen here,
- 56:42can you break down kind of what this means and why it is sort of
- 56:46an important step in the progress of Lightning Network
- 56:50generally? Yeah, sure.
- 56:52So essentially Cash App is integrated with the Lightning
- 56:58Network and they get quite a few transactions on the Lightning
- 57:02Network. Now for the Lightning Network to
- 57:04work again, there's different nodes and transactions just hop
- 57:08from node to node until they reach their destination.
- 57:12You don't know how many nodes it might go through.
- 57:15It depends on, you know, the node itself that you're
- 57:17connected to and so on. And So what nodes need is
- 57:23liquidity because when a payment goes through your nodes, you
- 57:27need to have the same amount that you're receiving to be able
- 57:30to forward it. And then when the transaction is
- 57:33settled, then all of this liquidity gets settled backwards
- 57:37as well. It all happens pretty much
- 57:39instantly. So it's very, very simple.
- 57:41But every node needs this liquidity.
- 57:43Now Cash App they have 184 Bitcoin that is locked in the
- 57:48lightning network it's multi sick contracts.
- 57:50So it's you know Bitcoin that is Unchained that is just locked
- 57:53with multi sick contracts so that this Bitcoin is essentially
- 57:56available through the lightning network and it avoids the double
- 57:59spending problem and essentially for each single transaction that
- 58:02is routed note and that that's optional, in fact, in how you
- 58:05set up your note, but you can take a fee for routing this this
- 58:10transaction and it's just a few SAT's or you know, depending on
- 58:13the notes that the price can go up.
- 58:14You can set it however you want. And so cash, obviously they're
- 58:18taking a fee and this fee means that because their Bitcoin is
- 58:23locked up in this multi step contract, so it's available in
- 58:26the Lightning network whenever a transaction happens, their
- 58:29liquidity is being used. Therefore, they take a fee for
- 58:32the usage of this liquidity and it allows them to earn 9.7% on
- 58:37the Bitcoin that is locked up, which is pretty crazy because I
- 58:40mean, what kind of instruments give you 9.7%?
- 58:44And in theory, this number can only grow over time if they keep
- 58:49on increasing the amount of transactions that happen on
- 58:52their notes and the amount of liquidity that they have through
- 58:55it. So I think it's just very
- 58:57interesting because rather than the strategic Bitcoin reserves
- 59:00where people just lock up Bitcoin on, you know, an on
- 59:03chain address. Well, instead they can lock it
- 59:07up and give access to more liquidity on the lightning
- 59:10network and get a really nice yield along the way.
- 59:15So I think that that was one of the mind blowing facts that came
- 59:19out of the conference for me last week.
- 59:22No, I, I totally agree. And and so on this chart, as you
- 59:25reference, you know, it's the 9.7 for the routing node.
- 59:28And then below that are sky savings rate, which I believe is
- 59:31just a high interest savings account at 8.1, USDC on Ave. at
- 59:374.2, which is D5 platform, federal funds rate 4.1 and then
- 59:42Eats taking below that. So yeah, it's pretty remarkable
- 59:45that this is outpacing other forms of yield importantly,
- 59:48without any sort of, you know, lending or rehypothecation to
- 59:51generate that yield. So yeah, super fascinating.
- 59:55This reminds me a little bit of it's definitely not apples to
- 59:58apples, but if we were looking back at either like search, like
- 1:00:01search with Google or like hosting services like via AWS in
- 1:00:06the sense that. This is only going to
- 1:00:10proliferate because there's a notion of like, I don't even
- 1:00:12know how real because they were working on this stuff for a
- 1:00:13while, but like ambos and whatever AI deal to help and
- 1:00:16route. But there's a notion of, well,
- 1:00:18that's going to compress and you know, Square is just closest to
- 1:00:22the money and they route so they have a high, but it's actually
- 1:00:24the opposite. It goes back to the whole Jevons
- 1:00:26paradox and like the more utility in use is going to drive
- 1:00:28more. And like ultimately I think it
- 1:00:31comes back to this notion. It's interesting that the square
- 1:00:34guys, I do a lot of stuff, but whoever's in that circle, they
- 1:00:36also have like really bad takes because I think they're on the
- 1:00:38against sats versus like the Bitcoin or whatever.
- 1:00:42And it's like the notion of very few people are going to start to
- 1:00:46interact with bitcoins, they're going to interact with Satoshis
- 1:00:50and sats and this proliferation of lightning is going to help
- 1:00:53with that. Whether it's exchange is built
- 1:00:55on lightning or E cash or how we like peer-to-peer via media
- 1:00:59advertising and sats are just going to be natural, just how
- 1:01:02sense were. But then this angle is everyone
- 1:01:05can potentially going back to the AWS or Google, like anybody
- 1:01:08can become a rowdy node and can invest heavily there and start
- 1:01:11to like part capital, especially if they're close to financial
- 1:01:13services. And so that's just the point of
- 1:01:16like as we get more demand and interest for Bitcoin and
- 1:01:18lightning on other layers, this is just going to actually grow.
- 1:01:21And then that's where that kind of quote, UN quote risk free
- 1:01:23rate of return comes in is that nothing's risk free, right?
- 1:01:26People don't blow up because they're going to just like mess
- 1:01:28up the the nodes and infrastructure because that's
- 1:01:31possible, but it gets as close if you have reputable players
- 1:01:34setting up these channels that can return a, a, a rate of
- 1:01:37return. Yeah.
- 1:01:39And So what I think is interesting is how is, is this
- 1:01:43at all actually going to apply to USD T on Lightning?
- 1:01:48And is it an opportunity for stable coin issuers to also
- 1:01:53increase their yield directly by providing liquidity for these
- 1:01:58USD T transactions on on Lightning?
- 1:02:02I have no idea, to be honest, because again, I don't have
- 1:02:04enough understanding on how exactly these things are are
- 1:02:07being routed. But that that I think would be
- 1:02:11pretty interesting to to see as well.
- 1:02:12Simply, you know the the interest that could come for
- 1:02:18stable coin issuers to also provide more liquidity on the
- 1:02:21Lightning Network, including in Bitcoin, in order to be able to
- 1:02:25make sure that all these stable coin payments are as efficient
- 1:02:27as possible. Yeah, I mean, I'm assuming
- 1:02:30Lightning Labs has something because like I know we're all
- 1:02:34the we're kind of walking around the dark here.
- 1:02:36But I feel like Lightning Labs and the implementation around
- 1:02:40these nodes has described some, some of like how that because
- 1:02:43there's an implementation, right that you would need to run.
- 1:02:45And then this where it ties into like what is your Lightning node
- 1:02:49route outside of just Bitcoin? And is it, you know, Tether, is
- 1:02:53it real world assets and what does that look like?
- 1:02:56And then how are you incentivize, I think is you
- 1:02:59still need the adoption of that? Yeah.
- 1:03:04Well, it's all very fascinating. Were you going to go somewhere?
- 1:03:09No, I'm good. OK.
- 1:03:12All right, well, we a little over an hour here, maybe a good,
- 1:03:15good place to wrap, where can people learn more about Flash
- 1:03:18Pierre, where should people download the beta wallet,
- 1:03:22etcetera? Yeah, so I mean, the easiest
- 1:03:25place to learn more is on our website, paywithflash.com.
- 1:03:29From there you can also access our wallet and join the beta
- 1:03:32testers. Of course, also follow us on
- 1:03:35Twitter. You can find us also easily from
- 1:03:38from our website. In fact, I recommend following
- 1:03:41me as well because I talk a lot about the the stuff that we do.
- 1:03:44And generally speaking, yeah, we're pretty excited about
- 1:03:47what's coming at Flash. We're last week actually, we
- 1:03:50were the payment processor for the Bitcoin Film Fest in, in
- 1:03:54Warsaw. And so we had a bunch of use
- 1:03:56cases. Well, we're going to have quite
- 1:03:57a bit of content coming out regarding that because our point
- 1:04:01of sale was used, our plug insurance were used, our store,
- 1:04:04it was just a lot, a lot of stuff there.
- 1:04:06So we're pretty excited about it.
- 1:04:08And yeah, and a lot coming in the in the following weeks, of
- 1:04:12course, invoicing tool for free, we're going to have Unchained
- 1:04:16payment supports and our wallets fully released as well.
- 1:04:20So yeah, pretty excited for Pro. It's coming in fresh.
- 1:04:24Beautiful. Yeah.
- 1:04:24I would encourage if anybody's individual or business that just
- 1:04:28wants to test it out or needs to accept Bitcoin and wants to spin
- 1:04:31up an invoice, it's really robust tool and easy to get set
- 1:04:35up. So yeah, check it out.
- 1:04:38Yeah, and you can also just write to
- 1:04:40medirectlypierre.corbin@paywithflash.com if you have feedback or need
- 1:04:44help getting started. Happy to support everyone.
- 1:04:48Beautiful. Well, thanks for joining Pierre.
- 1:04:50Always, always fun to chat and lots to look forward to.
- 1:04:54Thanks a lot guys. All right.
- 1:04:57Thanks. Everyone, thanks again for
- 1:05:00tuning in to another episode of Final Settlement.
- 1:05:02We had an awesome episode with Pierre Corbin, Co founder and
- 1:05:05CEO of Flash. We touched on the Bitcoin 2025
- 1:05:09conference, some of the announcements that were made and
- 1:05:11then how they relate to his business flash and what they're
- 1:05:14seeing on the merchant and cross-border payments flows.
- 1:05:18Quick word from Onrim. As you all may know, we are the
- 1:05:21trusted Bitcoin partner for Bitcoin holders that are looking
- 1:05:24to secure generational wealth. I have it pulled up here.
- 1:05:27If you're listening on the POD, an Onrim dashboard basically
- 1:05:30showing some of the easy examples of how folks use this
- 1:05:33today, whether it's seamless setting up inheritance for
- 1:05:36multiple beneficiaries or being able to buy and sell Bitcoin
- 1:05:40through the dashboard. And then ultimately the multi
- 1:05:42institution vault, which is what underpins everything out of on
- 1:05:45ramp. Again, multi institution,
- 1:05:48multiple institutions that are regulated working on behalf of
- 1:05:52the client to protect their assets.
- 1:05:54The key concept here is that each institution works on behalf
- 1:05:58of the client, not on ramp, to move funds requiring multiple
- 1:06:02permissions, including video verifications with multiple
- 1:06:04institutions. That all comes with $100 million
- 1:06:08warranty insurance by Lloyd's of London.
- 1:06:12If you'd like to learn more, I'd encourage you to schedule a
- 1:06:14consultation or reach out directly.
- 1:06:16We have some really interesting ways we're onboarding folks.
- 1:06:18And if you're just not ready for multi institution custody, I
- 1:06:20would encourage you to check out On Ramp Trade which has no fees
- 1:06:24for trading until October. Againthatsonratbitcoin.com Look
- 1:06:29forward to speaking with you and hope you enjoy the show.
- 1:06:32Thanks for listening to this week's episode of the show.
- 1:06:35If you found the information valuable, please share the
- 1:06:37episode with a friend or leave a rating on your favorite podcast
- 1:06:40app. All the links we discussed in
- 1:06:41today's show will be in the show notes inside your podcast app.
- 1:06:44Before we finish, a quick reminder that Onrat Media is for
- 1:06:47informational and entertainment purposes only, and nothing
- 1:06:50should be construed as investment or legal advice.
- 1:06:53Regardless of where you are on your Bitcoin journey, we'd love
- 1:06:55to hear from you. Visit on rampbitcoin.com/contact
- 1:06:58to schedule a consultation with one of our private Client
- 1:07:01advisors.