Latest / Legally Speaking with Michael Mulligan / Amicus, a sunken sailboat, and an administrator tries to buy a home
Transcript
- 0:00Adam Stirling: this time for legally speaking, joined as always by michael maligan, barrister and solicitor, with maligan defense lawyers.
- 0:05Adam Stirling: Morning, michael, how we do it.
- 0:06Adam Stirling: They're going to be great.
- 0:08Adam Stirling: Always good to be here, always interesting topics on the agenda.
- 0:12Adam Stirling: I'm looking at the first story here and I know just enough latin to know what the word for friend is.
- 0:18Adam Stirling: But the question is, what is an amicus and what do they do?
- 0:23Michael Mulligan: yes, indeed, we got some clarity on this point from the supreme court of canada, uh in in including the fact that the plural of amicus are amicine, uh and uh and amicus would be certainly did to somebody who's a friend of the court, somebody who's a lawyer appointed to assist uh the court in some way.
- 0:41Michael Mulligan: Uh, and the background of this case involved uh man who is charged with uh a double murder to counts of first-degree murder.
- 0:50Michael Mulligan: Uh, and the man was obviously troubled uh and there was some concern about whether he was fit to stand trial, but ultimately, after uh uh assessments of that, he was determined to be fit.
- 1:03Michael Mulligan: However, uh he refused to have a lawyer represented.
- 1:08Michael Mulligan: He insisted upon representing himself, which, I should say uh is a protected right in canada, right, you don't force lawyers uh on uh to act for somebody uh if a person doesn't want that uh, that I should say, along with a few other surf.
- 1:25Michael Mulligan: Key decisions in a criminal case are always decisions for the accused person uh to make, and it that sort of you to the part of our tradition of individual autonomy in the adversarial system.
- 1:37Michael Mulligan: Right, and a person can decide do they want to have a lawyer and what lawyer do they want to have right uh, and the person is also free to make themselves key decisions in a criminal case, like do they want to be guilty or not guilty?
- 1:51Michael Mulligan: Uh, what kind of trial do they want to have?
- 1:54Michael Mulligan: Uh, do they wish to testify?
- 1:56Michael Mulligan: Things like that are all decisions for uh accused person to make.
- 2:00Michael Mulligan: And this man refused to have counsel uh, and so that led to uh the trial judge uh appointing, in this case, amicai.
- 2:10Michael Mulligan: He started by appointing uh one lawyer to help the man in the jury selection process.
- 2:17Michael Mulligan: Uh and the lawyer did that uh, but then the trial started and things started to go off the rails.
- 2:23Michael Mulligan: And they were going off the rails because of uh how this man was conducting his own defense.
- 2:29Michael Mulligan: Uh, he would uh refused to ask questions of witnesses, uh, but instead uh would uh do things.
- 2:37Michael Mulligan: I get up and start expressing theories about kicks, conspiracy theories involving the fb.
- 2:42Michael Mulligan: I, the u s army in mind, control uh interrupting the judge, yelling and screaming uh and on uh.
- 2:49Michael Mulligan: Eventually, he wanted getting removed repeatedly from the courtroom and put in another room with a video link where the judge, on apparently sixty occasions at the mutus microphone, when you just wouldn't stop yelling or being disruptive of the trial process 60, you said 6-0?
- 3:06Michael Mulligan: 60 times.
- 3:09Michael Mulligan: The judge directed that the microphone be turned off because he was yelling, I guess, into the through the video system, wow, and that wasn't allowing the case to proceed.
- 3:19Michael Mulligan: And the judge was concerned that the man get a fair trial despite all of this, and so the judge appointed another amicus, and the amicus was directed that he was not the man's lawyer, but he was there to like, do things like ask questions of the witness or witnesses, and that was, I think, significant is that the lawyer wasn't acting for the man.
- 3:43Michael Mulligan: In fact, the man didn't want to even meet with the lawyer, right?
- 3:46Michael Mulligan: I think on a one occasion he might have, but the lawyer wasn't there to be the lawyer for this man who didn't want a lawyer, right?
- 3:55Michael Mulligan: Nonetheless, the judge had appointed this amicus to try to present an alternative to the crown theory of the case, so that the jury could come to a fair outcome, right To ask questions of the witnesses and present, perhaps, a different version of what might have happened for the jury to consider.
- 4:14Michael Mulligan: And then, at the closing, what happened is this man started to make a closing submission, but it had absolutely nothing to do with the case.
- 4:24Michael Mulligan: He just got up and started ranting about the FBI, the US Army and Mind Control, and the judge eventually said look, that's it, you can't do that.
- 4:34Michael Mulligan: And the judge didn't ask the amicus to make some alternative closing submission and so on that fact pattern, the man was convicted of both counts.
- 4:44Michael Mulligan: The case wound up in the Supreme Court of Canada.
- 4:47Michael Mulligan: And so the Supreme Court of Canada was asked well, what is the role of an amicus?
- 4:51Michael Mulligan: What should they be doing?
- 4:52Michael Mulligan: Was this fair or are there a miscarriage of justice here?
- 4:55Michael Mulligan: And should the amicus have been doing more Like, should they have been taking the role of being the man's lawyer?
- 5:04Michael Mulligan: And the Supreme Court of Canada concluded first of all well, there were certainly all kinds of very challenging circumstances and irregularities caused by the man's behavior.
- 5:15Michael Mulligan: Nothing that went on here amounted to a miscarriage of justice, pointing out that there's broad discretion for a trial judge to try to make things right and try to have a fair proceeding, as this judge was clearly trying to do in a challenging circumstance.
- 5:31Michael Mulligan: And further, they pointed out that an amicus is not the person's lawyer Right.
- 5:39Michael Mulligan: You can't force a lawyer on somebody who doesn't want one.
- 5:42Michael Mulligan: If somebody insists on representing themselves, that's their right.
- 5:46Michael Mulligan: And the judge, the Supreme Court of Canada concluded that there is broad discretion to give amicus different roles, like, initially, the trial judge appointed somebody to help with the jury selection Right, because the person just didn't know what was going on or how to do that.
- 6:05Michael Mulligan: And then the Supreme Court of Canada also found it was appropriate to do what the judge did here, which was to have somebody who was asking at least some relevant questions of the witnesses, but that it wasn't necessary that that person then take on the role of pretending to be the person's lawyer, who didn't want a lawyer.
- 6:24Michael Mulligan: That didn't not.
- 6:26Michael Mulligan: Doing that didn't result in a miscarriage of justice or an unfair trial for this man who was screaming and yelling and talking about mind control.
- 6:35Michael Mulligan: And so the result of it is the two convictions for first degree murder stand.
- 6:41Michael Mulligan: There's no need for a new trial.
- 6:43Michael Mulligan: And we've got now some further light shed on what is the role of an amicus, what can they be required to do, what are they not required to do.
- 6:53Michael Mulligan: And, broadly speaking, the Supreme Court of Canada concluded that there is really broad discretion right.
- 6:59Michael Mulligan: This is, of course, a human process and there isn't a single role for what that person is required to do and that judges can appropriately like this judge did tailor what that sort of friend of the court is there to do in terms of trying to ensure that the trial is fair.
- 7:18Michael Mulligan: But whatever they're doing, it doesn't turn them into the lawyer for the accused person, who doesn't want one right.
- 7:25Michael Mulligan: They're there to try to make sure the process is fair and, like in this case, maybe ask some questions or point out things that might be relevant, but they're not there to take over for a person who doesn't want them taking over.
- 7:37Michael Mulligan: So that's what an amicus or, in this case, amicai are all about.
- 7:42Adam Stirling: All right, let's take our first break.
- 7:44Adam Stirling: Legally speaking on CFAX 1070 with Michael Mulligan from Mulligan Defense Lawyers will continue right after this.
- 7:49Adam Stirling: Back on the air here at CFAX 1070s.
- 7:52Adam Stirling: Legally Speaking continues with Michael Mulligan from Mulligan Defense Lawyers.
- 7:56Adam Stirling: Up next, michael, the BC Court of Appeal upholding a $5,000 award regarding a municipality and the disposal of a sailboat.
- 8:05Adam Stirling: What happened here?
- 8:07Michael Mulligan: Yes, indeed, I must say this has some resonance, because we do have these issues or these boats from time to time that appear to be sort of abandoned or washed up or that kind of thing, and so it's worth knowing what the proper procedure is when there's a boat that is wrecked and maybe plucked out of the water or disposed of, and when you can and cannot do that.
- 8:28Michael Mulligan: In this case, it arose from Bowen Island and it was a man who owned two sailboats One was more to Bowen Island and the other one he was out sailing on.
- 8:37Michael Mulligan: There was a storm.
- 8:39Michael Mulligan: One of the vessels that was moored there broke away from its mooring and people were concerned.
- 8:45Michael Mulligan: It was looking like it was going to run up on maybe another war for cause some damage, and so the municipality got contacted and the municipality did the correct thing in terms of contacting and this is under the Kennedy, the Canada Shipping Act the receiver of wreck.
- 9:02Michael Mulligan: There is a person who is the designated receiver of wreck.
- 9:06Michael Mulligan: It's a federal appointment and I must say it's one of those things where if you go into a grade two class and ask everyone who wants to be a what do you want to be when you grow up, you will have a number of firefighters and police officers, you will have no one who sticks up their hand and says I want to be the receiver of wreck, but there may be an opportunity there.
- 9:23Michael Mulligan: And so the receiver of wreck is contacted and say, hey, we've got this.
- 9:27Michael Mulligan: Boat is broken free, it looks like it might be causing some damage and in fact things are worse.
- 9:34Michael Mulligan: The boat sank.
- 9:35Michael Mulligan: So now what?
- 9:36Michael Mulligan: Well, the receiver of wreck, who you're required to report these things to, told the municipality yes, you may go and recover the wreck.
- 9:43Michael Mulligan: So the municipality hired a barge and, I guess, a crane or something to pull it up, and they pulled this sailing or this sailboat up off the floor of the ocean, uh, and they then chopped it up and disposed of it, uh, in bins.
- 10:00Michael Mulligan: Now that's where things went a little haywire, because when you recover a wreck, you can't just throw it away.
- 10:06Michael Mulligan: There's an obligation to tell the receiver of wreck hey, I got the wreck.
- 10:11Michael Mulligan: And then it's up to the receiver of wreck to decide what should become of it, right, uh, how much money should you get for your recovery efforts and how should that be disposed of, or what ought to happen?
- 10:21Michael Mulligan: And the municipal government, in the form of the Bowen Island municipality, didn't do that, and so they got sued.
- 10:30Michael Mulligan: And the man sued the uh, the municipal government, the Bowen Island municipality saying hey, you destroyed my sailboat, um, and you didn't have permission from the receiver of wreck.
- 10:41Michael Mulligan: And he succeeded because indeed they didn't have that permission.
- 10:45Michael Mulligan: But the issue then became how much money is he entitled to for the sailboat that got thrown in the garbage?
- 10:51Michael Mulligan: Uh, and the man didn't come with what you would often have, which would be like a survey or some professional estimate of what the boat was worth.
- 10:58Michael Mulligan: He had sort of his own personal estimates of things that included things like how many hours of work he put into the boat and how much sentimental value it had, uh, and furthermore, he calculated the value he did the man of $95,000, including his labor and efforts, and then a bunch of other things, which is significant, including things like the upholstery and the clothing and the bedding and presumably food and electronics and other things that were on the boat.
- 11:26Michael Mulligan: And what the judge the judge and now the court of appeal concluded first of all is that the loss of some of those things wasn't caused by the municipality throwing the hulk away in the garbage, because the things like the upholstery, clothing, bedding, food, electronics, whatever else was on there, would have been destroyed when the boat sunk.
- 11:50Michael Mulligan: And the municipality didn't sink the boat, they just got rid of the carcass.
- 11:56Michael Mulligan: They pulled it up off the floor of the ocean, and so the value shouldn't include things like the stuff that was already destroyed through no fault of the municipality.
- 12:06Michael Mulligan: But there would have been other things on the boat, like tools or you know some portion of the boat which would have been maybe the sales rate, which wouldn't have been destroyed by getting immersed in water for a period of time.
- 12:19Michael Mulligan: And furthermore, the court and the court of appeal pointed out a couple of things that were problematic with the man's self-valuation of all these things, including there was no evidence that the time he spent lovingly working on the boat increased his value.
- 12:33Michael Mulligan: Moreover, there was a more fundamental problem, which was that in an earlier case, where it was in his interest to do so, he claimed that he didn't own the sailboat.
- 12:43Michael Mulligan: He claimed that his sister owned the sailboat, but now he should have said no, no, no, that was mine.
- 12:48Michael Mulligan: And so the trial judge and the court of appeal pointed out well, you can't have it both ways.
- 12:53Michael Mulligan: And so that cast some doubt on, I suppose, the man's claims about value.
- 12:59Michael Mulligan: And so the result of all of that is that the trial judge awarded him not $95,000, but $5,000 for the things that he found were thrown away without the receiver of rec giving permission.
- 13:12Michael Mulligan: And the man appealed that to the court of appeal unsuccessfully, and the court of appeal said no, the trial judge made appropriate decisions in the case and findings a fact and there was nothing improper in any of that, and so the trial judge's decision has been upheld.
- 13:29Michael Mulligan: So the takeaways there the important takeaways include that if you're a municipality or indeed a person who winds up in some circumstance with a wrecked boat, you can't just do with it as you please.
- 13:46Michael Mulligan: You are required to report that to the receiver of wreck and then take directions.
- 13:51Michael Mulligan: Now I should also say that once you do that, once you start recovering the boat and report it to the receiver of wreck, it also compels you to take any measures with respect to the wreck that the receiver of wreck directs.
- 14:04Michael Mulligan: So you've taken on a bit of a burden there.
- 14:06Michael Mulligan: When you decide you're going to get yourself a barge and a crane and haul up the sailboat that's on the bottom of the ocean you may wind up with some direction from the receiver of wreck.
- 14:18Michael Mulligan: That might be expensive or inconvenient and, depending on what that thing is worth, that may be a challenging undertaking.
- 14:25Michael Mulligan: So when you're looking out there and wondering why doesn't somebody just come and deal with this boat that's come up on shore, or that boat down the gorge or whatever it might be, bear in mind there is a whole legal structure around it and if you don't do as the receiver of wreck directs, you may find yourself on the hook for at least the value of the boat.
- 14:45Michael Mulligan: So that's the case of the sunken boat and the Bowen Island misspality.
- 14:51Adam Stirling: You know, I can see why people just sort of leave these wrecks where they are and not want to get involved after all that.
- 14:57Michael Mulligan: I think that's the.
- 14:58Michael Mulligan: The must be the legal equivalent of the advice in criminal cases.
- 15:03Michael Mulligan: Don't talk to the police and you're the suspect in a criminal case.
- 15:06Michael Mulligan: I suspect you're probably getting some similar advice if you speak to an expert in marine law Don't touch the wreck.
- 15:13Michael Mulligan: You may find yourself in court.
- 15:18Adam Stirling: Up next, the administrator, it says here, of an estate applies to court to permit her to purchase the property owned by the estate.
- 15:25Adam Stirling: Hmm, I have some concerns about that.
- 15:27Adam Stirling: What happened?
- 15:29Michael Mulligan: Indeed, and you should have concerns.
- 15:30Michael Mulligan: You got a good legal antennae.
- 15:32Michael Mulligan: So the issue here was there was a fellow who passed away who had three kids, and the person who passed away did not have a will.
- 15:41Michael Mulligan: The fellow who passed away owned, didn't have a lot of assets, but did have a modest property which might be worth.
- 15:49Michael Mulligan: The most recent estimate was $284,000.
- 15:53Michael Mulligan: So did a older manufactured home on it and two acres in Port McNeill.
- 15:58Michael Mulligan: That was the description of it.
- 16:00Michael Mulligan: And because the man didn't have a will, one of the daughters applied to for a grant of administration to be able to manage the, the estate right to distribute it and the.
- 16:12Michael Mulligan: As is required when somebody dies in test state like this, the requirement would be to equally divide the assets amongst the, in this case the three children of the man.
- 16:24Michael Mulligan: So that's what was being done.
- 16:25Michael Mulligan: He didn't have a spouse.
- 16:26Michael Mulligan: Now the problem arose because the property was in not great repair and so the daughter who was appointed as the administrator, uh, first of all tried to sell it and they she listed it for sale for $185,000, but the best offer they got was 155, which they didn't accept.
- 16:45Michael Mulligan: The problems were with sewage system, water and this, and that that daughter then moved into the property Things.
- 16:52Michael Mulligan: Now you just got to start asking yourself what are you doing?
- 16:54Michael Mulligan: The daughter moves into the property and then spend several years working on it, fixing it up and doing things to it, and then the daughter decided that she wished to purchase it, but she wanted to purchase it for less than the than assessed value.
- 17:08Michael Mulligan: She'd made improvements to the property.
- 17:11Michael Mulligan: This is where the trouble arises, and the trouble is that when you're an administrator like that just like somebody who's an executor, where a person had a will, that person has what's called a fiduciary duty to the beneficiaries you need to make decisions which are in the interests of the beneficiaries, not in your own interest their interest, right, um?
- 17:32Michael Mulligan: And there is a well settled principle that a trustee like that um can't engage in what would be referred to as self dealing, like purchasing property from the estate that they're managing, because it's pretty obvious what kind of a conflict that amounts to.
- 17:49Michael Mulligan: Right, if you were setting the value and purchasing it.
- 17:53Michael Mulligan: That's kind of incompatible with being the person who's acting for others, right, uh?
- 17:58Michael Mulligan: And so there is a process whereby there could be an application made to a judge for permission to engage in what amounts to self dealing, and that's what the daughter tried to do here.
- 18:10Michael Mulligan: And so she made this application.
- 18:12Michael Mulligan: And then she made the argument to the court was well, look, I've done all this work on the property.
- 18:15Michael Mulligan: Yes, I lived there but didn't pay rent, uh, but on the other hand, I spent all this money fixing up the sewage system and fixing up the water and paying the mortgage.
- 18:26Michael Mulligan: There's two more of those standing.
- 18:27Michael Mulligan: She paid those for a period of time.
- 18:30Michael Mulligan: And so her argument is well, look, you should give me permission to purchase the home, uh, for what amounted to something like $100,000 below the most recent assessed value of it because of the work that was done.
- 18:45Michael Mulligan: And the judge concluded no, there's just no basis to to do that.
- 18:48Michael Mulligan: Right, when you're an administrator or an executor, you are, uh, you have this fiduciary relationship to make decisions that are in the best interest of the beneficiaries.
- 18:57Michael Mulligan: Now, she happens to be one of the three beneficiaries, but it's got to be in everyone's interest.
- 19:02Michael Mulligan: Now, there's an exception to that.
- 19:03Michael Mulligan: All of that, if everyone agrees, like if everyone's competent adult or a person who's adult's fully informed.
- 19:10Michael Mulligan: If the other two sisters in this case said look, yes, we appreciate all the work that you've done there.
- 19:15Michael Mulligan: We understand that we might be able to sell it for more, but the place would have degraded me worthless If you hadn't done all the work on it.
- 19:22Michael Mulligan: We agree, right.
- 19:23Michael Mulligan: If they agreed, that's okay, as long as it's their competent and fully informed.
- 19:28Michael Mulligan: But here they weren't agreed, right?
- 19:30Michael Mulligan: They're saying no, no, I don't want it sold for this lower amount.
- 19:34Michael Mulligan: And so the judge refused the administrator's request to do so, but did point out that it's not as if there's a circumstance where there would be some serious unfairness to the person who was acting as the administrator, because what should happen is that the property should be sold for market value, right.
- 19:58Michael Mulligan: Listed People can make offers and purchase it, and then at the end of the process, there can be for an administrator like that, a process of passing accounts where a judicial official could determine whether, the how much money the administrator should be given for their work administering the estate right.
- 20:22Michael Mulligan: And so in that context, the administrator would be able to come with, for example look, here are my receipts for my payment of the mortgage For the past three years, right.
- 20:33Michael Mulligan: And here's my bill for fixing the water system.
- 20:36Michael Mulligan: And here's what I did for the sewage system, right.
- 20:39Michael Mulligan: Here are all my accounts and it would be possible in that context for there to be an order that the administrator be paid for the expenditures and preserving and fixing up the property and indeed an administrator could get permission to be paid for all of their time and work engage in all of that.
- 21:04Michael Mulligan: So it's not as if there isn't some process to avoid sort of the unfair or unjust enrichment of the other beneficiaries, right?
- 21:13Michael Mulligan: But the court pointed out that they're just that fact that that may occur at some point in the future doesn't authorize the reduction in the value of the property and to allow compensation in that way.
- 21:28Michael Mulligan: So the overall picture here for people that take away is that if you find yourself operating in one of those ways, as an administrator or as an executor, you need to remember that in all things that you're doing you need to make decisions which are in the best interests of the people you're doing that for, not for yourself, and in that regard it's sort of similar to what you know, for example, a lawyer would do when they're acting for a client, or a doctor is doing when they're treating somebody right.
- 21:58Michael Mulligan: Those are also examples of where there's a fiduciary obligation and the decisions being made need to be decisions made in the best interests of the beneficiaries, or the client or the patient, or whatever it might be, and not decisions which are intended to somehow benefit the person who's acting in that fiduciary capacity.
- 22:20Adam Stirling: Well, that's the case of the administrator trying to buy the house, michael Malgen, in the second half of our second hour every Thursday here at CFAQ 1070,.
- 22:28Adam Stirling: Legally speaking, pleasure is always Michael, until next week.
- 22:30Adam Stirling: So much, have a great day, all right, you too.
- 22:33Adam Stirling: Bye now.