Latest / Sex Within Marriage Podcast : Exploring Married Sexuality from a Christian Perspective / SWM 157 – Why Sex Gets Derailed Right Before It Starts
Transcript
- 0:43Hello and welcome to the Sex Within Marriage podcast. I'm JD from UncoveringIntimacy.com and we help Christian couples build intimacy and strengthen their marriage.
- 0:52From time to time I get questions from our anonymous Have a Question page. There's a link to it in our show notes if you have a question.
- 0:59I received this one a bit ago and I thought it would be good to answer it in its own post because it's a feeling that's common to a lot of marriages.
- 1:06I've heard the same complaint with very minor variations from many husbands and some wives.
- 1:12And like this person who asked it, if you don't know what's going on, it can lead to some bad assumptions.
- 1:17Maybe this has happened in your marriage. Here's the question.
- 1:21Am I going crazy or is my wife subtly sabotaging things?
- 1:24I've often pointed out to my wife that there's a clear distinction in how she approaches our plans based on whether it's something she really wants or if it wasn't her idea.
- 1:32I've seen her move mountains and leap over obstacles in some areas of our life together.
- 1:36But in others, she's a never-ending font of potential issues, problems, and risk.
- 1:42They seem reliably separatable into categories of what she really wants and what I possibly want more.
- 1:49One area I see this and is making me feel like I'm going crazy is our sex life.
- 1:54If we're going on a holiday and she wants to have lots of sex, she will plan ahead, bring outfits, lube, and be very vocal about it.
- 2:00It's great. Fantastic even.
- 2:02If it's a regular day we've scheduled sex, she won't exactly say no, but the likelihood of some kind of ailment popping up just on time is about 75%.
- 2:12Tiredness, tummy slash digestive problems, a slight cough or cold, just enough to be a dampener.
- 2:17I particularly enjoy going down on her, but upon approach, she will just mention some things wrong.
- 2:24Some version of I haven't washed up yet or I had an upset stomach earlier.
- 2:28I like to make out, but after the first peck, she'll say something like,
- 2:32not too much though, I'm getting some sniffles yesterday.
- 2:35More so, in the past, she would just physically behave like someone who would rather not be touched,
- 2:40almost as a knee-jerk reaction to my affection.
- 2:44It's just too much of a coincidence that when we're getting intimate,
- 2:47she will bring up the most off-putting topics in a way that perfectly sabotages the mood for me.
- 2:52Sometimes it'll just be something completely unrelated and left field.
- 2:55We do talk a lot, so I don't think it's a case of just needing more time to offload.
- 3:00We spend an abnormal amount of time together,
- 3:03talk at multiple points through the day, and usually a lot in the evenings too.
- 3:06I know she really likes to talk, and I'm willing to be a listening ear, but help me out here.
- 3:11I have raised this with her. She has previously denied it happens at all.
- 3:14She has admitted it now when I've pointed it out in the moment.
- 3:18She has explained some particular situations.
- 3:20She has apologized.
- 3:21She rejects my rationale that it has anything to do with desire or attraction.
- 3:26All this leaves me none the wiser as to how to move forward.
- 3:30She thinks it shouldn't be a blocker, but for me it is.
- 3:32It completely turns me off, and it leaves me feeling like a man she's trying to distract herself from or manage,
- 3:38rather than a man she's into.
- 3:41Is that just the plight of being a husband?
- 3:43When women have affairs with some guy they desire,
- 3:45do they ever bring up weird, unrelated issues right before they get intimate?
- 3:49I know you can't confirm if I'm imagining it, but is this something a lot of women do?
- 3:54Am I out of touch as a husband?
- 3:57To expect that our only scheduled time to be intimate may not be the time to talk about an ingrown hair or pest control incident.
- 4:04Am I expecting too much of a choreographed encounter if I think we should both be at least trying to make it appealing?
- 4:10Okay, so like I said, I've heard this time and time again, and you've done what most people do in the same situation.
- 4:18You've set up this binary choice when there are other options, including what is probably going on.
- 4:23And the way it's framed, you can't win.
- 4:26Either you're going crazy, in which case you lose, or your wife is being malicious, in which case you also lose.
- 4:31And this is a bad way to frame things, particularly because neither are likely to be true.
- 4:38I doubt that you're crazy.
- 4:39I also doubt that your wife is malicious.
- 4:42Malicious spouses are actually pretty rare in my experience.
- 4:45I did post your question in our supporters forum, and unsurprisingly, both husbands and wives says this sounded very familiar.
- 4:52They experienced it too.
- 4:53The husbands tended to resonate with a frustration.
- 4:55In addition, the wives tended to resonate with a sense of shame or guilt because they know they've exhibited the same behavior.
- 5:02Although, I want to again point out that I've seen this dynamic with the roles reversed as well.
- 5:08And because it's so common, this alone tells us something important.
- 5:12If it's a very common experience that consistently shows up across so many marriages, then it's likely not malicious.
- 5:18That's far more consistent with an autonomic response of some sort,
- 5:22because even the spouses who feel embarrassed that they behave this way don't know how to stop it or why they're doing it.
- 5:29That doesn't mean that these wives, or husbands in some cases, are actively trying to sabotage their sex life.
- 5:34In fact, if they're in my forum, they're at least sex positive and more likely trying to improve this part of their marriage.
- 5:41And yet, what you're describing is extremely common.
- 5:43So, if it isn't madness, and if it isn't malice, what is actually going on?
- 5:48And almost everything you describe points to one specific brain system.
- 5:52It's responsible for disgust, avoidance, and disease protection.
- 5:56Central primarily in a region of the brain we call the insula.
- 6:00And if you're wondering where this is in the brain, head over to the blog post, there's a picture of it.
- 6:05The insula is a cortical region deep in the brain, heavily connected to the prefrontal cortex,
- 6:10which is the part right behind your forehead, and the limbic system.
- 6:14Its job is survival, not moral judgment, not relationship evaluation, or health.
- 6:19This is just survival of itself.
- 6:21And the insula monitors internal bodily states and external contamination risk.
- 6:27It tracks things like hygiene and cleanliness, smells and tastes, bodily fluids, signs of illness,
- 6:32and internal sensations like nausea, fatigue, congestion, and discomfort.
- 6:36When the insula detects anything that might increase the risk of infection or physical harm, it produces an aversion response.
- 6:46It's not fear exactly, but it's a subtle signal that tells them to avoid this, whatever the thing that's setting it off is.
- 6:53That signal can show up as thoughts, feelings, urges, or verbalized concerns.
- 6:59And here's the part that's really confusing to you and many others.
- 7:02Sexual arousal changes insula activity.
- 7:05So when arousal increases, then dopamine-driven reward circuits ramp up.
- 7:10Motivation and approach behavior increase, prefrontal inhibition relaxes, and the insula's disgust signaling is muted.
- 7:20And this is not just a guess.
- 7:22Research shows us that sexual arousal and disgust responses interact in the brain,
- 7:27and that arousal tends to dampen natural disgust reactions.
- 7:32The insula, which helps process both bodily feelings and disgust-related signals,
- 7:37is part of a broader network that changes its activity when sexual arousal increases.
- 7:42There's a study on that effect.
- 7:44I'll link to it in the show notes and in the blog post as well.
- 7:47And this is why people willingly engage in behaviors during sex that would otherwise feel uncomfortable,
- 7:52unclean, or even disgusting outside of an aroused context.
- 7:57The system that normally says this could make you sick is temporarily dialed down,
- 8:02or actually changes functions.
- 8:05So with that in mind, look at the pattern being described.
- 8:07When intimacy begins before arousal is established, so when they're just starting,
- 8:12the insula's aversion mechanism is still fully active.
- 8:15Its job is to scan for problems.
- 8:18When it finds one, it speaks up.
- 8:19It's as if her brain has been asked,
- 8:21is there any health-related reason we shouldn't have sex right now?
- 8:25And off it goes, searching for anything that might qualify.
- 8:28Things it might not have noticed earlier suddenly come into the foreground,
- 8:31because the system has been inadvertently prompted to look for them.
- 8:35That's why the objections are so reliably in the same category.
- 8:39I didn't shower.
- 8:40I had a stomach issue earlier.
- 8:41I might be getting sick.
- 8:42I don't feel clean.
- 8:43Not too much.
- 8:44I had sniffles.
- 8:45These are not random mood killers.
- 8:47These are exactly the kinds of things the insula is designed to notice when it's operating
- 8:51in its avoidance role.
- 8:53Now, once you're aroused, those same signals either never appear or don't feel important
- 8:59enough to mention.
- 9:00That's why the same woman can plan an elaborate sexual encounter in one context and then seem
- 9:04almost hyper-aware of bodily imperfections in another.
- 9:08In one context, that internal question never gets asked.
- 9:11In the other, it does.
- 9:12If it is asked, the answer is so quiet, it doesn't even register.
- 9:16So the difference is not attraction.
- 9:18The difference is mental context.
- 9:21Is the insula doing its primary job of disgust avoidance, or has it switched to its secondary
- 9:25role?
- 9:26And for a long time, it was assumed that the insula shut down during sexual arousal.
- 9:31But fMRI scans show that this isn't true.
- 9:33The insula remains active.
- 9:35It just changes what it's doing.
- 9:36Instead of scanning for risk, it is retasked to track things like bodily pleasure, arousal
- 9:42related sensations, heart rate, warmth, genital sensations, emotional intensity.
- 9:47In short, it switches from should we avoid this to what is happening in the body right
- 9:51now.
- 9:52And that's because the insula isn't just a disgust avoidance center.
- 9:56It's not just trying to avoid getting sick.
- 9:58It is an entire body awareness hub.
- 10:00So it doesn't merely stop blocking arousal.
- 10:03It actually contributes to it by amplifying bodily sensations and emotional intensity.
- 10:07And this is why I'm constantly telling husbands that they need to learn how to turn on their
- 10:13wife's brain.
- 10:14Mental arousal for women is critically important.
- 10:16If you're trying to generate desire using only physical touch, you're doing this on
- 10:21hard mode.
- 10:22The body is only one part of the system.
- 10:25When the brain becomes aroused, dopamine signaling increases, particularly through the nucleus
- 10:29accumbens.
- 10:30And at the same time, the prefrontal cortex, that part right behind your forehead, becomes
- 10:34to quiet.
- 10:35And part of that, the medial prefrontal cortex handles social self-evaluation and reputation
- 10:41management.
- 10:42This is where thoughts like, what would people think if they knew I did this?
- 10:45Or good girls don't like sex.
- 10:46That's where those thoughts tend to live and where they get generated.
- 10:49And then you have the dorsolateral prefrontal cortex.
- 10:52And it handles long-term consequence monitoring.
- 10:55Much of the messages that many women receive growing up about our sex lives lives here.
- 11:02Basically, like don't have sex because bad things will happen.
- 11:05Pregnancy, STDs, STIs, loss of approval, loss of God's love.
- 11:09Even when those reasons are no longer relevant, like when you're married and a child is perfectly
- 11:14fine, those pathways can still be very hard to override.
- 11:19And then you have the anterior cingulate cortex, which manages conflict between desire and values.
- 11:25This is where the, it feels good, but it might be wrong.
- 11:28Tension shows up.
- 11:29That sense system also quiets during arousal.
- 11:32So in short, when arousal increases, all the functions we tend to lump together as inhibition,
- 11:38they decrease.
- 11:39The brain shifts from scanning for risk and judgment to focusing on experience.
- 11:45And this shift can be so dramatic that it almost feels like a different personality has emerged.
- 11:50Some wives feel deeply unsettled by this afterwards.
- 11:53They kind of come down from arousal and those inhibitory systems come back online.
- 11:59Then they struggle to reconcile how willing, enthusiastic, or adventurous they felt the
- 12:04night before.
- 12:04That discomfort can lead to them feeling embarrassed, ashamed, or even scared.
- 12:09And in that state, it can feel a lot easier to believe that they were tricked, pressured,
- 12:13coerced, or anything rather than to accept that their own brain simply operated differently
- 12:18in a different context.
- 12:19So while they may have been even eagerly asking for certain things the night before, the next
- 12:25morning they feel conflicted because all the judgment, risk assessment, and damage control
- 12:29systems are back online.
- 12:31And if someone doesn't understand that it's possible to operate very differently in two
- 12:36mental states and still be the same person, then that internal conflict becomes intolerable.
- 12:41And when internal conflict becomes unbearable, we often push it outward and then blame our spouse
- 12:46instead because that feels easier.
- 12:49But there's no need for that.
- 12:51She wasn't coerced.
- 12:52She wasn't tricked.
- 12:53She simply had a different perspective in a different neurological context.
- 12:57One system was temporarily down-regulated while another was up-regulated.
- 13:01And that shift produces a very real change in responses.
- 13:05And those responses are often what we interpret as personality.
- 13:08It's still the same person, it's just a very different context.
- 13:12Now, for the husband side in this case, this lands like intentional sabotage because the
- 13:19timing is impeccable.
- 13:20As soon as you bring up sex, suddenly she doesn't feel well when she's never mentioned it before,
- 13:26or remembers she didn't shower, or any of the other myriad reasons.
- 13:29The information appears precisely when it will have the strongest dampening effect on your
- 13:34desire.
- 13:35And it's because the insula is being prompted just then by your initiation.
- 13:39And that's what kicks off its system check to see if there's any reason not to engage in sex.
- 13:44And if you start looking for reasons, you're probably going to find them.
- 13:48But from her side, it often probably feels like honesty or even responsibility.
- 13:52Her brain is saying, before this goes further, you know, you should know whatever it's going
- 13:57to tell her now.
- 13:57And again, the problem is that you're trying to jump into sex without switching mental context
- 14:02for her first.
- 14:04You need to get that insula to switch into arousal awareness mode rather than why shouldn't
- 14:09we do this gatekeeping mode.
- 14:12And this is why telling someone to just relax or just get out of your head almost never works.
- 14:17Trying to override or make the insula switch gears with willpower usually increases anxiety,
- 14:22which further activates the insula, while also increasing cortisol, which decreases dopamine,
- 14:28which is what is needed for arousal.
- 14:31In short, just telling her just relax is going to do the opposite.
- 14:35That's why these situations often spiral instead of resolve.
- 14:39Now, knowing what's going on in the brain can be helpful.
- 14:42It can help us understand our spouse better, recognize that this isn't malicious behavior,
- 14:46but rather a good system that's just getting in the way sometimes.
- 14:49It can help us give our spouses grace when we feel hurt, ignored, or disconnected due to
- 14:53its hijacking of their libido, but also gives us clues as to what approaches might work better.
- 14:59If the problem is that the disgust avoidance role is active before arousal has had a chance
- 15:04to switch its function, then the solution isn't trying to willpower your way through it because
- 15:09it's a subconscious system and they don't like to be ignored or overwritten.
- 15:14Instead, you need to change your order of operations.
- 15:16And scheduled sex gets blamed for a lot of things it doesn't actually cause, but scheduled
- 15:21sex can absolutely work.
- 15:23For many couples, it is the only way intimacy happens at all.
- 15:26And what doesn't work is treating the scheduled time as the starting line instead of the finish
- 15:32line or not giving enough time to ramp up.
- 15:36If a couple has barely interacted all day or communication has been purely logistical, as
- 15:40many of us have during the day, then the scheduled time itself needs to include warmup.
- 15:46You cannot expect arousal to switch on instantly just because the clock says it's time now to
- 15:51have sex.
- 15:52That warmup does not have to mean flirting all day or maintaining constant sexual energy,
- 15:57though when that's possible, that definitely helps.
- 16:00Like when you're on vacation, it simply means that desire usually needs a transition period.
- 16:04You need time to connect.
- 16:06You need time to switch gears.
- 16:08You need time for arousal to arrive before intimacy is expected.
- 16:12Sometimes that means she is intentionally doing things that she already knows will help her
- 16:16move towards desire once the window opens.
- 16:18Other times it means he takes the lead during that scheduled time by slowing things down,
- 16:22reconnecting emotionally, letting arousal build instead of rushing towards the outcome.
- 16:26Um, the point is not that intimacy needs to be manufactured all day long, though, again,
- 16:31that definitely helps.
- 16:32The point is that sex, if sex is planned after a long gap in connection, that plan needs to
- 16:38include space for desire to switch gears in the insula and other parts of the brain.
- 16:43Scheduled sex works best when it includes a runway, not when it assumes a cold start will
- 16:48somehow work this time.
- 16:51As an example, we have a pretty standard Friday night ritual and our brains like rituals.
- 16:56We each shower, so we feel clean, which already takes out a lot of that insula monitored
- 17:00objections.
- 17:01We observe Sabbath, so we don't work Friday nights to Saturday evenings, which means there's
- 17:05nothing we're expected to do.
- 17:07No jobs to complete, no work deadlines to worry about.
- 17:10We try to shut out the world on Sabbath, so we don't watch TV, movies, et cetera.
- 17:15Instead, we pick a book that helps us focus on our marriage and we use it as a starting
- 17:19point for deep conversations.
- 17:21My wife reads while I listen and massage her.
- 17:24And this helps the insula switch over, not only because it includes some non-sexual touch,
- 17:29although it tends to get more sexual as we progress, but also because we tend to talk
- 17:34about intimate subjects, which makes us feel connected, bonded, and safe with each other.
- 17:39Friday nights almost always end well because we are intentional about manufacturing a context
- 17:44that works for us.
- 17:46And you are more than welcome to steal that routine if it works for you.
- 17:49I hope that helps.
- 17:50Now, if you have a question that you'd like to have answered, you can submit it on our
- 17:55anonymous Have a Question page.
- 17:56There's a link in the show notes as well.
- 17:58If you're listening to this and you don't get our emails or didn't read our emails, as
- 18:01about half the people on our list don't, you may be interested in the last post that
- 18:06I did.
- 18:07I didn't do a podcast about it, but it's basically a workout routine to get you ready
- 18:11for Valentine's Day.
- 18:12If you ever thought, hey, I want to work out, but you lack the motivation, if being
- 18:18better at sex is a good enough motivation, there's a workout routine to make you better
- 18:21at sex.
- 18:22They are workouts specifically designed to help you with the things that you do during
- 18:27sex.
- 18:28So lots of things like pushups and hip thrusts and squats and things like that.
- 18:34We already have a few people who said that they joined the challenge.
- 18:36I'm trying to do it myself.
- 18:37And if you want to join in, join in, you can find that and all of our other resources
- 18:43at www.uncoveringintimacy.com.
- 18:46And that's it for today.
- 18:48Talk to you next time.