Latest / Energy Voice – Out Loud / Road to ADIPEC 3: Financing the way forward
Transcript
- 0:04Welcome to the last episode in this Road to Adipec series by
- 0:07Energy Voice. I'm Ed Reid, hosted by ADNOC.
- 0:10Adipec brought the entire energy ecosystem together to advance
- 0:13discussions and champion intelligent choices to build
- 0:16sustainable systems that deliver energy to more people, more
- 0:20affordably and with lower carbon intensity.
- 0:23Anapec was held under the theme Energy Intelligence Impact and
- 0:26with the idea of helping to build resilience and scale
- 0:28intelligence solutions to accelerate inclusive global
- 0:32progress. We recorded this episode at
- 0:35Anapec held in Abu Dhabi at the beginning of November.
- 0:37I caught up with Lydia Rainforth of Barclays and Paddy Lowe of 0
- 0:41to dig into some of those big questions around investment and
- 0:44capital allocation. So Lydia, I'm going to start
- 0:50with you. There's been a little discussion
- 0:51around energy transition, energy addition.
- 0:55Does the Middle East look different from Europe?
- 0:58I think it does in the sense that there's a lot of energy and
- 1:01it's cheap energy. And one of the advantages that
- 1:05the Middle East has is an abundance of both oil, gas, but
- 1:10also the renewable side and around nuclear ability to on
- 1:14that side as well. Where for Europe, I think we've
- 1:18run for a number of years on cheap Russian gas and we're
- 1:22having to find ways to replace that import USLNG and stop
- 1:27building an industry around winds, around solar that we
- 1:32haven't had to do for a while. And so it's that relative cost
- 1:37for me is a really important thing that policy makers in
- 1:40Europe need to deal with. But also here there is an
- 1:43advantage. Paddy, do you do you see that
- 1:45that's a question around sort of regional variations around cost
- 1:48around essentially around our own approaches?
- 1:51I think the, the really special thing we notice about the Middle
- 1:54East is, is in our world of synthetic fuels which have lots
- 1:59of different names, E fuels, powder, liquid, etcetera.
- 2:04So now we see these fuels as really the, the, the final full
- 2:08solution for the energy transition in liquid fuels
- 2:13because they will scale to all demand and they will become as
- 2:17cheap as fossil fuels in due course.
- 2:20So this is the solution that needs to be promoted and
- 2:24developed and invested in. And and the unique thing about
- 2:28the Middle East is it isn't faced with the distraction of
- 2:32biofuels. So I, I'm going to dis biofuels
- 2:37quite a bit here. Bring it, bring it.
- 2:38I love it because you know, they are, they are the the low
- 2:42hanging fruit, the short term solution around liquid
- 2:45sustainable fuels. But in reality, they won't scale
- 2:50anywhere close to what's needed to replace all fossil fuels,
- 2:54even just in aviation, let alone in all the other sectors that
- 2:58will need high density liquid fuels.
- 3:01And there are all sorts of other problems with biofuels.
- 3:03They won't become cheaper because essentially they're an
- 3:06agricultural product. I'd rather call them Agri fuels
- 3:09to be honest, rather than biofuels.
- 3:11It sounds more genuine. There's problems with land use
- 3:15and they're not even fossil free.
- 3:17You know, they, they come at typically, you know, 50 to 70%
- 3:21reduction rather than 100%. So we need to promote E fuels as
- 3:24a, as a solution and because there's no bio waste here and
- 3:30very limited agriculture, certainly not to spare to make
- 3:33fuel. The Middle East isn't sort of
- 3:35challenged by that distraction and can move straight into
- 3:39synthetic fuels from solar, you know, abundant solar resource, a
- 3:44lot of uninhabitable land. In fact, I think the number, if
- 3:49I've got this number right, about 1/5 of Saudi Arabia turned
- 3:53to a solar farm, would make all the oil we use on Earth today as
- 3:59synthetic. So, you know, that's a big area,
- 4:03but it's not as an unreasonable area if you think of, you know,
- 4:08replacing the entire fossil fuel industry with synthetics.
- 4:13I mean, I think, you know, we've seen a lot of interest, I think
- 4:15in in synthetic fuels particularly.
- 4:17And I feel like it's one of those things that governments
- 4:19can push and, and it feels like there was a while when the sort
- 4:23of the big oil majors were thinking about it as well.
- 4:25And now they seem to be backing away from it and they're moving
- 4:27more towards oil and gas. And you know, you know, as part
- 4:30of the sort of the energy transition, you know, we've seen
- 4:32them sort of, you know, back pedalling on the, on those kind
- 4:34of ideas. Do you think that that is going
- 4:38to be a problem for the, for the, for those kind of energy
- 4:42transition ideas? If there's, if there's less
- 4:44money kind of going into it, there's less innovation, if
- 4:46there's less growth, does that slow the trajectory overall?
- 4:50Well, it does of course. And I think, you know, we've
- 4:52seen a general slow down in the last year or two around
- 4:56investment in sustainable energy, which is disappointing,
- 5:01you know, because the, the, the climate change problem is not
- 5:05going away. It's moving towards us at a
- 5:08rapid pace. But on the good side, I think
- 5:11what we've seen, you know, 0 is now 6 years old.
- 5:14And we've seen, let's take the aviation market, which is the
- 5:18the most easily arguable case for needing synthetic fuels.
- 5:22Not that it's by no means the only one, by the way, think of
- 5:26ships, for instance, or agriculture itself.
- 5:29But we used to go to conferences, aviation
- 5:33conferences, and they were talking about electric
- 5:34aeroplanes six years ago. And then they started talking
- 5:38about hydrogen aeroplanes. And then they saw the light on
- 5:42that. For meaningful aviation, you
- 5:44need a liquid hydrocarbon. And they moved into our, you
- 5:49know, bio Staffs and but now the conversations are about ESAF
- 5:55because ESAF used to be something some wild idea that's
- 5:59never going to happen because it's stupidly difficult and
- 6:02expensive. Now that is the main
- 6:04conversation at aviation conferences.
- 6:07So, so that conversation is going really well.
- 6:11It's just the overall investment in this space is not where it
- 6:15should be. But I see that as hopefully
- 6:17temporary. And when the money comes back,
- 6:19it will come to the right place. Lydia, do you think that
- 6:23question around money going to the right place is that, is that
- 6:26happening? Are we seeing that?
- 6:26I feel like oil majors in some ways are like, I sometimes watch
- 6:30my son playing football and he's seven years old and all of it,
- 6:34all of everyone on the pitch runs in the same place.
- 6:36And it feels a bit like that's what the oil majors are doing at
- 6:38the moment. Do you think am I being unfair?
- 6:40That's that's a great image. And if we take a step back, oil
- 6:43companies have been really poor at allocating capital through
- 6:47time. And typically, if you're
- 6:50investing $100 million, you probably end up writing down
- 6:54about half of that through time. So that's not great for
- 6:57shareholders. So we've really had to have a
- 6:59rethink about how do you look at those capital allocation
- 7:02processes. And ultimately, we still, we
- 7:06talked a lot at this conference about energy addition rather
- 7:08than energy transition. We're still not in that phase of
- 7:11replacing things. And it turns out the oil and gas
- 7:13companies are better at the moment at understanding oil and
- 7:17gas and how do you actually deliver those projects and how
- 7:20do you deliver them cleaner rather than trying to do new
- 7:24things that they haven't, that they still don't know exactly
- 7:26where they are. Is that better left to companies
- 7:28like 0? Probably.
- 7:30And the other part of this is there's a lot of changing
- 7:33regulations. So one of the companies, Total
- 7:37Energy, has recently pulled back on some biofuel investments
- 7:41because the rules around Co processing changed.
- 7:44Such simple changes in regulation really then can have
- 7:47quite a big impact on how you do things.
- 7:49But right now there's a need for new oil and gas investment, and
- 7:55that is international. It's Middle East.
- 7:57It's not the US anymore. And that's I think what's
- 7:59changed and where you're doing low carbon spending, it needs to
- 8:04be done right and it needs to be done with that say sort of where
- 8:07can it make the most difference where in the past there's Paddy
- 8:10talked about hydrogen side of it.
- 8:12That's probably been an area that they've just written off
- 8:15straight away. I mean, maybe, maybe.
- 8:16Total heard Paddy's thoughts about biofuels and they came
- 8:21round to his way of thinking. But but Paddy, I mean the thing
- 8:25about that kind of question around kind of competing for
- 8:27capital. Do you think that that sectors
- 8:30like ESAF are, are, are well positioned for is, is, is, is
- 8:35there still opportunity for you? To receive capital, yeah.
- 8:38Oh, absolutely enormous amounts. No, there's a lot of work to be
- 8:41done. You know, in, in our sector,
- 8:44there are still barely one or two E fuel plants running in the
- 8:50world today. So even though this is the
- 8:53solution for scale and for cost parity with fossil fuels, the
- 8:58amount of investment has really been quite poor overall, I would
- 9:02say. And the biofuel sector has has
- 9:05been sucking up a lot of that, that funding both on the capital
- 9:08side and also on the revenue side.
- 9:10You know, so there's, there's a, there's a huge sort of obsession
- 9:14with buying voluntary SAF credits both in the commercial
- 9:20space and in, in, in business, private aviation.
- 9:25And that money, you know, I'd rather see it going to something
- 9:28that has a solution that really has legs.
- 9:31I suppose on that question around sort of allocation of
- 9:33capital, do you think that you are you competing for capital
- 9:36with with say oil projects or oil companies?
- 9:40Absolutely. We're now competing with AI as
- 9:42well, of course. Yeah.
- 9:44I mean, I've been a little bit unkind to buy there, haven't I
- 9:46earlier, But I've started being like that because I used to be
- 9:50far more neutral and generous. But now I'm realizing painfully
- 9:55that, you know, they are sucking up a lot of capital because it's
- 9:59seen as the sort of easy solution.
- 10:02And you know, if I were really cynical, I might say there are
- 10:05those who like that solution because it delays our solution
- 10:11which they know would replace the the root of the problem and
- 10:16the root of the industry, which is still got a lot of cash
- 10:19underground if you got more drift.
- 10:22And, and, and Lydia, I suppose there's a kind of a question, it
- 10:24feels like there's a question between sort of a short term
- 10:27versus a long term way of looking at the world.
- 10:30I feel like this was the oil majors with their sort of, you
- 10:32know, looking at the oil and gas projects kind of core
- 10:34competencies that makes sense for them and for their
- 10:37shareholders. But it feels like also there is
- 10:39this kind of question around, you know, how we get to a
- 10:43decarbonized world, right, which I think everyone kind of sees
- 10:45the need for. Are we getting it right?
- 10:48Is are there are there better ways to to to find the sort of
- 10:51capital for that sort of longer term need?
- 10:55Some of it is probably going to be private equity.
- 10:57What has been disappointing, I think from a listed company, so
- 11:03the companies where you can buy and sell shares on the Stock
- 11:06Exchange is that shareholders haven't rewarded that low carbon
- 11:12investment. The idea that something is going
- 11:14to start making money next decade from 2030 onwards, that's
- 11:18too far away. I'm only going to reward you
- 11:20when it's when we actually see the money.
- 11:22And so companies that have had narrower focus on just oil and
- 11:28gas have actually done better in terms of share price performance
- 11:31than the companies that actually have invested on that longer
- 11:33term framework. And that's then driven capital
- 11:36away if you're a management team.
- 11:37So I go actually my shareholders are asking me not to invest in
- 11:41that long term side of it. So they're really trying to then
- 11:44go, how do we balance it? And you've then got companies
- 11:48who can access private equity who have a much longer term
- 11:52view. And so I think some of this is,
- 11:54is the capital market structure right to incentivizing the
- 11:58investment part and I'm not convinced it is right now.
- 12:01That feels like a big kind of question around like how is
- 12:03capitalism working? That I feel is a sort of a
- 12:06deeply philosophical one that we could we could really dig into.
- 12:09But Patty, I'm just going to just going to end up with you
- 12:11just just thinking about what you said about, you know,
- 12:14capital around investors. What's the future for 0?
- 12:17Have you got plans to go go public?
- 12:20Are you, are you, are you what? How?
- 12:21How do you? How do you see this playing out?
- 12:23Yeah. I think eventually we would like
- 12:25to list. I think one thing we noticed is
- 12:27actually the the the general population that is the, you
- 12:31know, the person on the street gets so excited when they
- 12:34understand what we do. The passion and the enthusiasm
- 12:38is incredible. And I think, you know, you can
- 12:40attract that in a public listing public market where it's more
- 12:46difficult to raise capital at our stage, which is sort of pre
- 12:50revenue in the in, in the capital markets, which what I
- 12:55have learnt over the last six years is that the the, the
- 12:59people that sit on capital are incredibly risk risk averse.
- 13:04I mean frighteningly so. It's quite unbelievable actually
- 13:08how reluctant and even how by their, their actual policy and
- 13:13their regulations, they're not allowed to lead investments in,
- 13:16in, in new innovations. So we and many other companies
- 13:21suffer from that. But you know, we're doing well.
- 13:24We step by step one next step would will be a commercial
- 13:28prototype plant and and then we take it from there.
- 13:31But going back to to Lidia's point also, I think, I think one
- 13:34of the gaps is, is, is in government, actually in
- 13:37governments who are not pushing harder to make this work.
- 13:43You know, I mean, I mean, UK, which is perhaps one of the
- 13:46better territories for support still in our view gets it really
- 13:52quite, quite badly done because, you know, limited grant money,
- 13:57huge gaps between the grants. So, you know, what are you
- 14:00supposed to do in, in that time? And, and not not really
- 14:05investing in home technology. And they could be the ones that
- 14:11they're expecting the private sector to make this energy
- 14:14transition happen. And of course, the private
- 14:17sector has to make money, has to pay dividends for pensions, all
- 14:23the things that, you know, Lydia was referring to.
- 14:26So it's it's a free market. And This is why you need
- 14:29governments to make the right things happen.
- 14:32And, you know, there's a huge challenge for the planet around
- 14:35the energy transition. And, you know, this is what COP
- 14:38is supposed to do. And, and could, I think play a
- 14:42stronger part in, in, in, in, in pushing through obligatory
- 14:47policies perhaps across the across all states.
- 14:52So yeah, I think there's some work to do there.
- 14:56Thank you, Betty. Thank you, Lydia.
- 15:00Thanks for listening to this Road to Adepec episode and
- 15:02series. We're looking forward to Nexus
- 15:04Adepec already, which is due to be held from the 2nd to the 5th
- 15:07of November 2026. But for now, I've been Ed Reed.
- 15:11Thanks for listening.