Latest / Change My Relationship / Spiritualizing Hurts Hurting People
Transcript
- 0:00You're listening to an audio recording by Change My Relationship, featuring
- 0:04licensed marriage and family therapist and author Karla Downing.
- 0:08These audios are designed to provide you with practical solutions
- 0:11based on biblical truths for all your relationships.
- 0:20Spiritualizing hurts.
- 0:23Hurting people.
- 0:25Spiritualizing means that you are
- 0:27responding to a situation
- 0:30with only one Bible verse or one
- 0:36Bible principle, and ignoring the rest of them.
- 0:40And you're looking at just one spiritual aspect,
- 0:45and it is kind of trivializing
- 0:48the person's experience, the person's feelings, the person's pain.
- 0:54So here are some examples.
- 0:56Oh, just trust God.
- 1:00Pray about it.
- 1:01Do you think the person hasn't prayed about it?
- 1:05I'll pray for you.
- 1:07And that's sort of your exit out of this difficult conversation,
- 1:11or your way of just saying to the person, oh, okay, I'll pray for you.
- 1:15But not addressing the real problem.
- 1:17God won't give you more than you bear.
- 1:20You can bear, you know.
- 1:21So in other words, that's that scripture where it says that
- 1:26in any temptation that God will provide you a way out.
- 1:29That's not really talking about this.
- 1:31It's not talking about pain and trials.
- 1:34It's saying that God doesn't tempt you.
- 1:37That you are not trapped from things, that God's not putting you in that situation,
- 1:44but so God won't give you more than you can
- 1:46bear, is basically saying to the person what it's saying.
- 1:50Well, this isn't really that bad because you know, you can handle it
- 1:53because God wouldn't have given you the situation if you couldn't handle it.
- 1:58I'm going to tell you, I've spent a lot of time talking to people
- 2:01about their life problems and their relationship problems,
- 2:05and I have seen situations that are more than people can bear.
- 2:10And sometimes people crumble under the situations that they've been given.
- 2:15Sometimes it is too much for somebody because there are a lot of very,
- 2:21very difficult things that people have endured
- 2:23and have to endure in this world
- 2:27that has lots of bad things.
- 2:30The next one, God works out everything
- 2:33for good or for your good or for his good.
- 2:36So in other words, oh, you'll make it.
- 2:38God's going to work all of this for good.
- 2:40Now, all of these things can be said to people
- 2:45with.
- 2:45They have scriptural precedent, scriptural background.
- 2:48They're based on scriptural principles or on a scripture, but the problem is
- 2:52how you use them. Okay.
- 2:55So basically you're saying, okay, good is going to come out of this.
- 2:57Quit complaining.
- 2:59Quit telling me how bad it is or how much you hurt or expecting any kind
- 3:02of, support because this is all going to work for good.
- 3:07Be grateful.
- 3:08It could be worse.
- 3:10Ouch. That is kind of painful.
- 3:13You know.
- 3:14Wow. So, in other words, don't complain because it could be worse.
- 3:18It could always be worse.
- 3:19I don't care what situation it is, it can always be worse.
- 3:23You need to forgive.
- 3:25So your person is telling you some excruciating pain in a relationship
- 3:30or something that somebody has done to them,
- 3:32and you come back with, you need to forgive again, truthful,
- 3:36but not the right time to tell the person that the person needs to forgive.
- 3:42God will give you the strength to go through it.
- 3:44Oh, he will.
- 3:46That's true.
- 3:47But again, to say that when you're spiritually using it
- 3:51and not addressing the person's real pain could be in itself more painful.
- 3:56Remember the title.
- 3:58Spiritualizing hurts hurting people.
- 4:02Spiritualizing actually causes people in already
- 4:06painful circumstances to feel more pain.
- 4:11Next one.
- 4:12Well, depression is a sin.
- 4:14You know you have the joy of the Lord
- 4:18again.
- 4:19Hurtful, painful and not true.
- 4:23Depression is a biological neural,
- 4:27biological state that can come from an imbalance in your neurotransmitters
- 4:33that can even come from physical illnesses.
- 4:38So it's not true.
- 4:39And people don't always feel joy
- 4:43when they, quote unquote, should be feeling the joy of the Lord.
- 4:47Some times they're in some really deep, dark valleys.
- 4:51Think of David in the Psalms saying, where is my hope?
- 4:55I don't have any hope.
- 4:57I'm like destitute. I want to die.
- 5:00I mean, this is horrible.
- 5:02I feel like God's, doing all these bad things to me.
- 5:06There's all kinds of things I hope my enemy dies These are times
- 5:10that even Bible giants have gone through.
- 5:16Next one.
- 5:17You aren't stressed. You're blessed.
- 5:19So kind of discounting that person's
- 5:22feelings, that person's experience.
- 5:25If the person says they're stressed, they're stressed.
- 5:28And no matter how many blessings they have in the midst of that,
- 5:32if they're feeling stressed, that's real for them.
- 5:35The next one be content in everything.
- 5:38Again, scriptural but not appropriate.
- 5:41Be content and everything means you need to just get over it.
- 5:45Be content in this situation.
- 5:48Again, the person is not telling you about it.
- 5:51For you to come back with a platitude,
- 5:54with spiritualizing that causes more pain.
- 5:59God will provide all your needs.
- 6:01Yes, but sometimes in different ways than we think we need.
- 6:06Sometimes we still experience great lack of our needs.
- 6:12Sometimes it's going through a very dry, dark season.
- 6:17So again, hurting that person by just saying pretty much be quiet.
- 6:23I'm done with you.
- 6:24God's going to take care of it. Don't worry about it.
- 6:26But I'm going to walk away and not think about what I might need to do,
- 6:30because God's gotcha.
- 6:32God's going to take care of it.
- 6:34And the next one, it must be God's will.
- 6:37Remember Job, Job with his just his really useless friends
- 6:42that kept saying things to him like that, like, oh, Job you must have sinned.
- 6:47You must have done something really, really bad to bring all this stuff on you
- 6:52and into your life.
- 6:53Like, come on, Job, what was your sin?
- 6:55Remember, they kept saying that again,
- 6:58not helpful, not accurate necessarily.
- 7:02Right.
- 7:03So who knows?
- 7:05Lots of things happened to us.
- 7:06Yes. Did they filter through God's permissive will? Yes.
- 7:10But are we affected by sinful people in a sinful world?
- 7:14Absolutely.
- 7:16And again, not helpful
- 7:19spiritualizing and minimizes the person's pain by responding
- 7:23with the simple answer that appears to care without taking the time
- 7:28to understand what the person needs or what the person is going through.
- 7:33It basically tells the person, I don't really care.
- 7:37I'm kind of done with you.
- 7:38This is my one response to your whole problem.
- 7:42And I'm going to walk away and I'm going to be okay.
- 7:45It kind of masks concern with an exhortation
- 7:50that kind of brings a little judgment with it.
- 7:53A little bit of, oh, you're overreacting or oh,
- 7:56you're making too big a deal about it or this is not a problem.
- 8:00It's just a spiritual thing, or God's going to give you everything you need.
- 8:04Okay.
- 8:04And it definitely does not take time to consider.
- 8:07What does this person need?
- 8:08And can I help this person?
- 8:11Now, we cannot help every person that comes in our path.
- 8:15It's impossible.
- 8:16But there are situations
- 8:20in which we can do something without.
- 8:23Maybe we don't have the money to help a person, but we can listen.
- 8:27We can give the person some type of response that lets him know
- 8:31we actually get it.
- 8:33We care, and even if we don't get it,
- 8:36we care enough to listen and to say, I'm sorry that you're going through that.
- 8:40That sounds really, really hard.
- 8:42That sounds really painful.
- 8:44That sounds really difficult.
- 8:46Maybe I don't get it because I haven't been in that situation,
- 8:49but geez, that sounds really awful. And
- 8:54spiritualizing hurts
- 8:55because it doesn't hit the person.
- 8:59It doesn't meet them where they're really, really at.
- 9:03The Bible does have a lot to say about our lives.
- 9:06There's a lot of truth.
- 9:07There's a lot of principles in the Bible and a whole bunch of scriptures.
- 9:11But you need to listen to
- 9:15what the person is going through and to understand, to find out
- 9:18what does a person really need and what may God want you to actually do.
- 9:23For this person to actually do something that minimizes the pain
- 9:29rather than adding to the pain, we don't want to do that.
- 9:33So you if you think about this, John
- 9:36James tells us that faith without deeds is is dead.
- 9:40And so basically you're throwing out a platitude
- 9:44or some spiritual little nugget there,
- 9:47and yet you're not doing something to actually care for the person.
- 9:52Now, there are some scriptures that go along with that, for you to think about.
- 9:57And one of them is Romans 12:15 and it says, rejoice with those who rejoice.
- 10:02Mourn with those who mourn.
- 10:04So basically, it's to kind of mirror this person's
- 10:09experience, to mirror what they're going through.
- 10:12If they're rejoicing, we can rejoice with them.
- 10:14But if they're mourning, we can't just give them some nice
- 10:17spiritual platitude and walk away like everything's okay.
- 10:21The next one is Proverbs 25:20, like one who takes away a garment on a cold day.
- 10:26So it's like taking somebody's coat
- 10:28when they're in the snow and saying, Now I'll walk ten miles to go home.
- 10:32Or like vinegar poured on a wound
- 10:35is one who sings songs to a heavy heart.
- 10:38So if you're going to sing a song of a nice little spiritual
- 10:43nugget to somebody who has a heavy heart, and you're just going to be like,
- 10:47everything's okay, God's going to take care of you.
- 10:50It's all going to work for good.
- 10:51Okay, I'll pray for you, then, what are you doing?
- 10:55Okay. You are actually.
- 10:57That's like taking away somebody's garment on a cold day by doing that.
- 11:01The next one, is the ones I referred to
- 11:04in James James 2:15-17.
- 11:07Suppose a brother or a sister is without clothes and daily food.
- 11:12If one of you says to them, oh, go in peace, keep warm
- 11:16and well fed, but does nothing about their physical needs.
- 11:20What good is it?
- 11:21In the same way, faith by itself it
- 11:25if if it is not accompanied by action, is dead.
- 11:30So that's a perfect example right out of Scripture.
- 11:33If the person needs food and the person needs clothing
- 11:38and you say, go, be blessed, keep warm, well-fed, I'll pray for you.
- 11:42And the person doesn't have those things that didn't do any good.
- 11:47Don't deceive yourself. That wasn't helpful.
- 11:50And 1 Timothy 5:23 I love this one because Paul
- 11:54writing the letter to Timothy gives him some very practical advice.
- 11:58He says, stop drinking only water and use
- 12:01a little wine because of your stomach and your frequent illnesses.
- 12:05He stops to writing all this stuff
- 12:09about spiritual things and about Timothy's walk with the Lord, and he addresses
- 12:15something really real, like just like we would in our relationships today.
- 12:20And he just says, okay, you've got some stomach problems.
- 12:24Go ahead and drink this wine,
- 12:26which was very watered down back then, very, very low alcohol.
- 12:29But he says this might help your stomach.
- 12:32Okay, so it's not I'll pray for your stomach.
- 12:34God will make your stomach better or God is giving you the stomach problems.
- 12:39He's going to work everything for good, but you know what, Timothy? No.
- 12:43How about try this?
- 12:44Okay, so he is attending to Timothy's real need.
- 12:48So Scripture has a lot of ways of responding to people's problems
- 12:55and spiritualizing
- 12:58it at the wrong time, in the wrong way, and not addressing
- 13:01a person's real needs is actually hurtful.
- 13:05Don't spiritualize and hurt hurting people
- 13:09more than they're already hurting.
- 13:13Thank you for watching this video on Change My Relationship.
- 13:16I hope that you will check out my website and that you will look at the,
- 13:21studies and books and other materials that I have for you.
- 13:26This is my book Change My Relationship: 365 Daily Devotions for Christians
- 13:31in Difficult Relationships, it will give you all kinds of scriptural truths
- 13:35and really help you in to navigate those difficult relationships.
- 13:40Thank you for watching. God bless.
- 13:43Thank you for listening to Change My Relationship.
- 13:46We hope you will subscribe to these podcasts and share them with your friends.
- 13:50Karla would love to hear from you.
- 13:53She welcomes ideas for a future podcast, as well as your feedback
- 13:57on how the podcasts have helped your life and relationships.
- 14:00You can email her at.
- 14:02karla@changemyrelationship.com
- 14:05For more information on Change My Relationship and Karla
- 14:09Downing's ministry, including her books, studies, devotionals, podcasts
- 14:14and YouTube videos visit changemyrelationship.com.