Latest / CLEs You Actually Want to Hear / Current Developments in Property Tax and City Taxes
Transcript
- 0:03Welcome everybody. to our September meeting of
- 0:09the tax section. I am Michelle Weiss. I'm the
- 0:11past tax chair, and I'm currently on the board
- 0:15of governors of the Beverly Hills Bar Association.
- 0:17So welcome. And thank you for joining us for
- 0:20current developments in property tax and city
- 0:22taxes. Before we get started, I just want to
- 0:25give a thank you to our tax, our perennial tax
- 0:29section sponsor, Hoffman -Salkin -Tasha -Perez
- 0:31PC. The Hoffman -Salkin, Tasha Perez PC Advantage
- 0:36is experienced and eye for innovation and a genuine
- 0:39dedication to clients, their families and their
- 0:41business. In addition to their national practice
- 0:44in civil tax and criminal tax controversies and
- 0:47related litigation in federal and state courts,
- 0:50the firm is also active and successful in handling
- 0:52non -tax white collar investigations and prosecutions.
- 0:56And now I wanna move on to introducing our speaker
- 0:59today. I'm very excited to listen to Gregory
- 1:03Broge, who's a partner at Agilat, Poly, IU, Matariz,
- 1:09and Broge, I hope I did not butcher those names,
- 1:12where he has specialized solely in California
- 1:14state and local tax matters since joining the
- 1:16firm in 2009. A graduate of Florida State University,
- 1:21summa cum laude, Phi Beta Kappa, and UCLA. Law
- 1:24School, Greg began his career at Latham and Watkins
- 1:27before becoming a partner at his current firm
- 1:29in 2016. He has been consistently recognized
- 1:32as a super lawyer and a frequent speaker and
- 1:35an author on state and local tax issues. Before
- 1:38we start the program, just a few housekeeping
- 1:40notes. You should see a link to the program materials
- 1:45in the chat. I think you also got an email with
- 1:47it. And you should be receiving your CLE certificate
- 1:50by the end of the day. And with that, Greg, I'd
- 1:53like to hand it off to you. All right. Thank
- 1:56you very much. I'm going to share my screen to
- 2:02get this started and to swamped again. So that
- 2:09should get everything going. The one thing I'd
- 2:18like to say ahead of time is there is like a
- 2:22Q &A function on this Zoom. If anyone wants to,
- 2:32I like questions during, so if I was like giving
- 2:35this presentation in person, I like when hands
- 2:37go up and everything, it's better than just hearing
- 2:38my voice for an hour straight. So if anyone has
- 2:41any questions or wants to talk through anything,
- 2:46put it in the Q &A and I'll try to address it
- 2:50when it's appropriate to address it. So that's
- 2:54the way if you want to get in contact with me
- 2:56to contact me. Hopefully everyone's seen the
- 3:01presentation and we'll get started on this. We're
- 3:06going to be doing you know, some recent developments,
- 3:09just kind of brush through a couple of the just
- 3:12basic property tax things that I like to start
- 3:15all property tax presentations with just because
- 3:18they're very important, they're main deadlines.
- 3:21And then we'll get to some of the more recent
- 3:24updates. So with that, let's see. Yeah. So Prop
- 3:3013, that's what we all work with out here in
- 3:33California. That's our lovely system. enacted
- 3:38in 1978, rolled all assessed values back to March
- 3:421, 1975. And then those assessed values could
- 3:46only increase by the lesser of 2 % or the inflation
- 3:50factor. So it's never more than 2%. Some years
- 3:53the inflation factor was less than 2%, including
- 3:56in 2010, it was actually negative. Except if
- 4:02you get a reassessment. Now, a reassessment can
- 4:05occur upon a change in ownership. whether that's
- 4:08a purchase, someone's death, the entering into
- 4:11a long -term lease of 35 years or more, a legal
- 4:15entity change of ownership. All of those things
- 4:17are going to cause a reassessment of the property
- 4:20to its fair market value as of that change of
- 4:24ownership date. In addition to that, a property
- 4:28is also reassessed upon the completion of new
- 4:31construction. When you have new construction,
- 4:35only the improvements are reassessed. The land
- 4:39keeps its baser value unless you also did new
- 4:42construction to the land, which could be grading
- 4:45or something like that. New construction has
- 4:48its own definition, and it's kind of squishy.
- 4:52You'd have a whole presentation on what is or
- 4:54what is not new construction. But if you add
- 4:57square footage, you build a new building, you're
- 5:00going to get reassessed fair market value as
- 5:02of that new construction. So what are some of
- 5:08the things you need to keep in mind to prop 8?
- 5:11You get your prop 13 value, which was the prior
- 5:14slide. That's your base year value, your trended
- 5:16base year value. That's your prop 13 value. You're
- 5:19supposed to be taxed upon the lesser of your
- 5:23prop 13 value or fair market value. So when prop
- 5:2713 was enacted in early 1978 and November's 1978,
- 5:33Proposition 8 was enacted to confirm that you
- 5:36are supposed to be taxed on the lesser of the
- 5:38trend of base year value or fair market value.
- 5:41So if you believe that your property has declined
- 5:43in value, maybe you bought a house a few years
- 5:46ago, houses in certain areas have declined as
- 5:49interest rates have gone up, et cetera. Maybe
- 5:51you bought a hotel in 2018 before COVID. Your
- 5:55hotel might have been worth a lot less than $21
- 5:57and $22. You get to follow what's called a decline
- 6:02in value appeal and say, hey, we want to be taxed
- 6:04on our fair market value, which we believe is
- 6:06less than our trended venture value. How do you
- 6:11do that? Well, there's a couple of things that
- 6:13are very important in property tax. The assessment,
- 6:16the appeals deadlines are jurisdictional and
- 6:20really, really matter. So we're currently in
- 6:23the regular assessment period. The regular assessment
- 6:25period opens up July 2nd of each year and then
- 6:30closes either September 15th or November 30th,
- 6:33depending on the county. Every year the State
- 6:36Board of Equalization publishes the list to say
- 6:38what counties are the September 15th counties
- 6:40and what counties are the November 30th counties.
- 6:44Most of Southern California, LA County included,
- 6:48it's in November 30th deadline. Ventura County
- 6:50is September 15th. A lot of the Bay Area, San
- 6:54Francisco, Alameda are September 15th deadlines.
- 6:59So you just want to check every year. The regular
- 7:01assessment is generally when you're filing a
- 7:03decline in value appeal. Or if you missed filing
- 7:06one of the next ones, supplemental or escape
- 7:08that are on this chart, you can challenge whether
- 7:12or not a change of ownership occurred or challenge
- 7:14a base year value via the regular assessment
- 7:16if you missed filing on the supplemental or escape
- 7:18assessments. If you do that, you only get prospective
- 7:22relief. But it is a way to challenge something
- 7:28that you may have missed. Why may you have missed
- 7:31it? Well, for bills and notices that come outside
- 7:37of the regular billing period. Everyone's regular
- 7:41bills are due December 10th and April 10th of
- 7:44each year. Supplementals or escapes can come
- 7:47at any time. Supplementals and escapes are issued
- 7:51when you had a reassessable change of ownership
- 7:53or completion of new construction, the supplementals
- 7:55for that specific date, and then escapes are
- 7:57for any years that escapes a taxation. So if
- 8:00it took the county three years to reassess a
- 8:03property after a change of ownership, you'll
- 8:05get a supplemental and then two years of escape
- 8:07bills. These have different appeals periods,
- 8:11fairly short appeals periods. They're 60 days
- 8:14from the date of mailing of either the notice
- 8:18or the bill. And again, it depends upon the county.
- 8:23Supplementals in Orange County, it's the notice.
- 8:27Supplementals in LA County, it's the bill. So
- 8:30it's very important you know which one. And the
- 8:33bill is usually easier to get. If people get
- 8:35a bill, they usually react. Sometimes when people
- 8:38get the notice, your client might just get it
- 8:40and say, I don't even know what this means and
- 8:42just kind of put it in the garbage. And then
- 8:43if the bill comes, you know, 60 days later, and
- 8:48then they wait a few days to get it to you, all
- 8:50of a sudden they've missed their appeals period.
- 8:52So it's very important to get appeals on file
- 8:55timely from whether it's the notice or the bill
- 8:59depending upon the county to add further confusion
- 9:03to the appeal deadlines. With escape assessments,
- 9:08there's something that's called a notice of proposed
- 9:11escape assessment, which comes prior to the notice
- 9:15of enrollment of escape assessment. The notice
- 9:17of proposed escape assessment is if you file
- 9:21on that and the notice of enrollment has not
- 9:23been issued yet, the state board takes the position
- 9:25that you have a premature and therefore void
- 9:28filing. So I can't stress it up. It is very important
- 9:32that you timely appeal these things, but you
- 9:35timely appeal the correct document. Appealing
- 9:39the incorrect document can lead to losing your
- 9:42rights and losing your refund rights for that
- 9:44specific time period. Okay. So there wasn't too
- 9:55many legislative updates this year. They did
- 9:59pass some laws on the parent -child, but really
- 10:07specifically related to people who were affected
- 10:09by the fires. They extended their deadlines.
- 10:17to file for the claims, both the homeowners exemption
- 10:20and the parent -child claim. If you were affected
- 10:28by the fires, it extends your deadline to file
- 10:31those claims. Usually, you have to file a homeowners
- 10:33exemption claim for Prop 19 within one year of
- 10:37the transfer. You do not have to file a homeowners
- 10:40exemption if you're under Prop 58. And then you
- 10:44have to file your claim within three years. These
- 10:47extended things from when you get the bills.
- 10:50And so it allows people, or notice, excuse me,
- 10:55the supplemental or escape notice. So it allows
- 10:57people to react from when they actually got reassessed
- 11:00instead of from the moment in time when the change
- 11:02of ownership happens, which is helpful because
- 11:05a lot of times people don't even know a change
- 11:06of ownership happened. I get so many calls. all
- 11:09the time of, well, I got reassessed, but I don't
- 11:12understand nothing transferred. It was in my
- 11:15parents' trust. My parents died, but the trust
- 11:17still owns it. So there's been no change of ownership.
- 11:20Remember, for property tax, we look through trusts.
- 11:22When the trust doors die and the trust becomes
- 11:24irrevocable, there's a change of ownership unless
- 11:27you can apply for some type of exclusion. So
- 11:29this is just to benefit people that might have
- 11:32had... more important things on their mind dealing
- 11:36with the Palisades fire and the Eden fire than
- 11:41filing a parent -child claim. I have one question.
- 11:49Have there been any changes to the proportional
- 11:51transfer rule? The answer is no. The proportional
- 11:57transfer rule is the same rule that it's That
- 12:02has always been. If you transfer property to
- 12:04an entity or out of an entity, the only way you
- 12:09avoid reassessment is if the ultimate ownership
- 12:12stays the same. The only potential change came
- 12:15from a Supreme Court case that came out maybe
- 12:18two years ago, maybe 18 months ago, something
- 12:24like that, where they said for corporations,
- 12:28In order to be proportional, all stock needs
- 12:30to match, not just the voting stock. That wasn't
- 12:33a change to the statute. That was just an interpretation
- 12:35by the California Supreme Court. So I think I
- 12:41answered that. OK. Another thing that's not going
- 12:47to probably affect a lot of people, for exemptions
- 12:53in property tax, You have to, and for the welfare
- 13:01exemption specifically, there's different types
- 13:03of exemptions. Some are use exemptions. If property
- 13:07is used for college purposes, it's exempt. Doesn't
- 13:11matter who owns the property, just if it's used
- 13:14for collegiate purchases, it's exempt. There's
- 13:16certain ownership percentages, right? If a property
- 13:18is owned by a governmental entity in their jurisdiction,
- 13:21it's exempt, right? And then there's exemptions
- 13:24that are based upon ownership and use, the welfare
- 13:28exemption being the most common. In order to
- 13:31get a welfare exemption, you need an exempt owner,
- 13:34and you also need an exempt use. AB 1485 passed
- 13:42a new law that said a property that's owned by
- 13:46an Indian tribe or it's wholly on subsidiary,
- 13:48and that used to be the issue. And the property
- 13:51used exclusively for these kind of very specific
- 13:54reasons, right? preserving plants and animals,
- 13:58tribal traditional knowledge, open space, et
- 14:01cetera. There you can get an exemption from property
- 14:07tax for those uses. Again, fairly limited and
- 14:11only for a limited period. It only runs until
- 14:132033. Interestingly, the legislature cannot create
- 14:18exemptions in property tax. All exemptions have
- 14:22to be constitutional. But what the legislature
- 14:25can do is they can interpret exemptions. So that's
- 14:30presumably what is being done, is they're interpreting
- 14:32the welfare exemption to allow for those Indian
- 14:36tribes. There was also exemption changes to some
- 14:44of the calamity claims. Obviously, there was
- 14:46a A ton of calamity claims due to the Palisades
- 14:52fire and the Eaton fire. They also confirm that
- 14:56you can keep the exemption, the homeowners exemption,
- 14:59if your house was destroyed by the fire. That
- 15:02was always tough and a little confusing, because
- 15:04in order to have the homeowners exemption, it
- 15:05needs to be your principal residence. It's hard
- 15:08for something to be your principal residence
- 15:09when it burned down, but also a lot of things
- 15:12tie off of that homeowners exemption. They clarified
- 15:17that and the law. So those are kind of the legislative
- 15:21updates. Again, not a lot of excitement there
- 15:26with the legislature. What is kind of a recent
- 15:32flurry, though, of property tax cases? I was
- 15:36actually a little nervous about two weeks ago
- 15:39coming into this, because I'm like, oh, boy.
- 15:42I agreed to do this, but hardly anything has
- 15:45come out. What am I going to talk about that
- 15:47I didn't talk about last year that's new? And
- 15:50then all of a sudden, a recent flurry, Jeffrey
- 15:54Prang, the LA County Assessor, was very busy
- 15:56because a recent flurry of cases, all involving
- 15:59him for the most part, came out right beforehand.
- 16:03Now, a decent amount of them are unpublished.
- 16:06So obviously, if it's unpublished, it's not presidential
- 16:09and cannot be relied upon. The first case is
- 16:18actually a case that just got decided and just
- 16:23was determined. It's an interesting case that
- 16:30has a very long and tortured history. And unfortunately,
- 16:36because of How do I put it, generally? Maybe
- 16:43not understanding the issue very well by the
- 16:46Court of Appeal in two different Court of Appeal
- 16:49cases, they're going to extend the tortured history
- 16:52of this case even further. So this case involves
- 16:57the valuation of Time Warner Cable's taxable
- 17:01possessory interests and the public right of
- 17:03ways in LA County. So the public right away is,
- 17:09it's just outside my window, you see streets
- 17:12with the telephone poles on it, and that's where
- 17:16they are allowed to lay their cables to provide
- 17:20telephone service, internet service, and cable
- 17:22TV service. That creates, anytime you have a
- 17:28private interest in tax -exempt government land,
- 17:31it creates what's called a taxable possessory
- 17:32interest, which is a legal fiction made up by
- 17:35the courts years and years ago, back in the 1800s,
- 17:38to tax these things as if they are truly real
- 17:41property. And there's no debate that this was
- 17:44taxable at this point. The debate was as to the
- 17:50value of the property. Now, this case involves
- 17:54The value of Time Warner's cable possessory interest
- 17:57going back to 2006, that's the data value, is
- 18:01a change of ownership that happened in July of
- 18:042006. The case originally proceeded to an assessment
- 18:10appeals board hearing in 2010, so 16 years ago.
- 18:17it went up to the Court of Appeal. And the main,
- 18:20there was a bunch of issues there, what the proper
- 18:22term would be, whether or not, what the proper
- 18:28rental rate should be, whether or not they're
- 18:33intangibles. and whether or not evidence supported
- 18:38the decision of the board. So it went up. The
- 18:41superior court, the board determined everything
- 18:44for the assessor. The assessor came in. They
- 18:46actually issued a raise letter, raised the value
- 18:48that they had previously enrolled. And the board
- 18:51said, we're good with you, assessor. Everything
- 18:52you did, we're going to agree with. It then went
- 18:56to the trial court. And the trial court said,
- 18:59no, the board did almost everything wrong except
- 19:01for one thing. And then it went to the Court
- 19:05of Appeal. And the Court of Appeal in 2010 issued
- 19:08an opinion that was originally published. And
- 19:10the two major issues were, hey, what's the right
- 19:13rent? And in a taxable possession interest, the
- 19:17way that both parties valued it is on the economic
- 19:20rent method, which is the private entity pays
- 19:26a rent, for lack of a better term, to the government
- 19:31agency. That rent to the government agency, less
- 19:34any government expenses, in this case there were
- 19:37nominal expenses, is then either capitalized
- 19:45or via discounted cash flow to determine what
- 19:48the value of that taxable possession interest
- 19:50is. Now, interestingly, in California, the rent
- 19:56is capped by law for these type of companies.
- 20:02You cannot charge a rent on the receipts related
- 20:06to the internet. You cannot charge a rent on
- 20:09the receipts related to the telephone. What they
- 20:12can charge is they can charge for the right to
- 20:15use the public right away and for the right to
- 20:18do business, which is issue number two in this
- 20:20case. The most the government can charge is 5
- 20:25% of cable TV revenue for the right to provide
- 20:29internet, telephone, and cable TV services. That's
- 20:34both a federal law and then there is California
- 20:38law about the internet and telephone that they
- 20:40say, we don't want any rent being charged for
- 20:42the right of ways to do this. So originally,
- 20:46the trial court and the original trial court
- 20:49setting said, hey, if you have this cap, then
- 20:52that's it. You can't ever have a rent higher
- 20:54than 5%. And the court of cable revenue and the
- 20:58court of appeal said, no, We don't think by law
- 21:02it can only be 5 % as maximum. We don't know
- 21:06if people are paying more for these and subleases
- 21:09or if there's an open market to get these. No
- 21:12evidence has been put in. So we're going to remand
- 21:15it back to the board for evidence because the
- 21:18assessor's valuation, which was 5 % of TV revenue
- 21:21and internet and telephone, they didn't have
- 21:23any evidence to support that. They just made
- 21:25it up and picked a number out of the air. In
- 21:28addition, because that rent is for both the real
- 21:32estate and the right to do business, the board
- 21:34originally did not remove any intangible value.
- 21:39And whenever property tax, you can only tax the
- 21:42real property. You can not tax intangible property.
- 21:46And so it was sent back to the board. And that
- 21:51was a 2014 court of appeal decision. Now, interestingly,
- 21:56it was then depublished by the California Supreme
- 22:00Court. So the Supreme Court looked at it and
- 22:02said, this should not be published. And they
- 22:04de -published it. And so it no longer was citable
- 22:08as precedent for anybody else. But as law of
- 22:11the case, it was binding on the remand case.
- 22:15So it went back to the assessment appeals board
- 22:18and only on those two issues. What's the correct
- 22:23rent? And what is the intangible right to do
- 22:32business value. How do you remove that? And interestingly,
- 22:38both parties kind of dug in. Time Warner presented
- 22:4125 comparables for public right of ways in California,
- 22:48including public right of ways for the exact
- 22:50same public right of ways that were being valued,
- 22:52where Verizon and AT &T had signed agreements.
- 22:56to get the rights to the public right away, and
- 22:59they were paying 5 % of TV revenue for the right
- 23:02to provide TV, cable, and internet. 24 of them
- 23:06were at 5 % of cable revenue. One was at 0%.
- 23:09Anaheim signed a deal with AT &T where they said,
- 23:13you don't have to pay us anything. That's the
- 23:14rent. It's zero for the right to provide this
- 23:16stuff. The county assessor said, well, we're
- 23:20going to just stick with our 555, but we can't
- 23:23get to that data using California data. So we're
- 23:26gonna use we're gonna go outside of California
- 23:29and for 2006 valuation of property in LA County
- 23:35they used a Court of Appeal decision from Illinois's
- 23:42from 1986 about a Chicago fee for telephone from
- 23:481986 that was either 2 % or 5%, they used 5%.
- 23:52Then they used one from Tucson from like 1992.
- 23:56And then they used a couple from Oregon, charges
- 23:59that were closer in time, the early 2000s, that
- 24:03were based upon a law that was determined to
- 24:06be an illegal extraction from the cable and companies.
- 24:11And then they had a bunch of posts. 2006 ones,
- 24:16going all the way like 2015, 2016, like 10 years
- 24:19past and said, well, we get to look at those
- 24:21two, even though the laws that we're supposed
- 24:23to be looking at it based upon what a willing
- 24:24buyer and willing seller would know as of the
- 24:27valuation day. They also then just didn't remove
- 24:30any intangibles. They said they removed 5%, but
- 24:34half the time it was below 5%. So their actual
- 24:36recommended value didn't remove any intangibles,
- 24:38even though the court of appeals specifically
- 24:40said they had to do that. And the taxpayer did
- 24:44remove intangibles and they did it based upon
- 24:47well you have the right to do business that allows
- 24:50you to market your services there's a return
- 24:53on your marketing that you get and so the value
- 24:56of that return on the marketing is the is equivalent
- 24:58to the right to do business and that is the amount
- 25:01that we're going to remove went to the board
- 25:05and the board decided almost 100 % with the taxpayer.
- 25:10They said, yeah, OK, 25 comps, 24 of them are
- 25:13at 500 in California for the same area. We're
- 25:16going to go with that. And we're going to go
- 25:19with the taxpayers' intangibles, but we're just
- 25:21going to kind of cut them in half. No real apparent
- 25:25reason, but they just said they're going to cut
- 25:27them in half. And so they gave them 50 % of what
- 25:30they asked for on the intangibles. It went back
- 25:34up. The assessor appealed the decision to the
- 25:38Superior Court. The taxpayer cross appealed on
- 25:41that there was no evidence to support the cutting
- 25:43of the intangibles by 50%. It went to the Superior
- 25:47Court again for the second time. And the Superior
- 25:50Court decided 100 % for the taxpayer. They said,
- 25:55yep, evidence in the record supports 500. Intangibles,
- 26:00you got to take them out. And by the way, there's
- 26:02no evidence to support a 50 % cut. remand back
- 26:06to determine what the proper intangible amount
- 26:08is based upon the taxpayer's methodology. The
- 26:15assessor then appealed back up to the Court of
- 26:18Appeal. And this is where we had a mess. And
- 26:24it was interesting, in my opinion, the Superior
- 26:26Court and both instances got it right. And both
- 26:29instances, the Court of Appeal made a mess of
- 26:32things. The first instance was a really interesting
- 26:35deal because there was a split decision, two
- 26:39to one, in the first court of appeal decision.
- 26:42And what we found out later, what we all found
- 26:45out later, is that the presiding justice who
- 26:49wrote the opinion was allegedly, I stress allegedly,
- 26:54sexually assaulting the dissenting justice. And
- 27:00so there might've been some tension on that court.
- 27:02I mean, it's allegedly, so who knows, but there
- 27:03might've been some tension on that court that
- 27:05presiding justice was eventually removed from
- 27:07the bench. One of the only times in history that's
- 27:08ever occurred. That's the opinion we were stuck
- 27:11with. And so we go up to the court of appeal
- 27:15and they start off the oral arguments and well,
- 27:18this is based upon a case that got the published.
- 27:19Can we even publish our decision? Like that decision
- 27:23presumably might've been wrong, but it's still
- 27:25law of the case and we have to follow it. And
- 27:28they said on the right to do business, they agreed
- 27:31entirely with the taxpayer and said, yeah, you
- 27:33got to take it out. Marketing's a valued expense.
- 27:36Assess your what you were doing. It's nuts you
- 27:37didn't even take anything out. Why are you even
- 27:40complaining? But then they went to the comps
- 27:44and this is where they felt constrained and they
- 27:47read the prior opinion in a very narrow way.
- 27:51And they said, well, we knew in the prior opinion
- 27:53that the law in California was no one could charge
- 27:56more than five percent of cable revenue for this
- 27:59possessory interest. But we said it didn't have
- 28:02to be five percent. So even though it's not explicit,
- 28:06which it's supposed to be explicit if you want
- 28:08to follow it, we think a logical interpretation
- 28:10is that you couldn't use California comps. So
- 28:15essentially, They said we have to value a California
- 28:18possession interest, which by the law way, the
- 28:21law specifically says you have to value it subject
- 28:24to any government enforceable restrictions. They
- 28:28said, well, because California has this government
- 28:31enforceable restriction, we don't think you can
- 28:34use California comps. So we actually think what
- 28:36the assessor did maybe wasn't the worst thing.
- 28:39You should go out of state to see what all this
- 28:42stuff is. The problem is, and what they didn't
- 28:44realize is, even though they were told this,
- 28:46every state has government restrictions on what
- 28:49you can charge for the public right of ways.
- 28:51And so some states are zero, just pure zero.
- 28:55Other states are like 5 % like California. Some
- 28:58states are 3%. Some states are 1%. It's all over
- 29:01the place. But they're all government enforced
- 29:03restrictions. So for some reason, the Court of
- 29:05Appeal thinks it's better to use comps from non
- 29:10-California, different jurisdictions, totally
- 29:13different taxing. scenarios that also are related
- 29:17to government restrictions as opposed to California's
- 29:20government restrictions. It's kind of a head
- 29:23scratcher of a decision, no idea how it's going
- 29:26to be dealt with on remand. But you get, you
- 29:29know, in all honesty, in property tax, you get
- 29:31a lot of head scratching decisions sometimes
- 29:33from the courts because it's hard for, it's a
- 29:36nuanced area and, you know, it's not always fully
- 29:39understood all that way. So an appeal from 2006,
- 29:44we're now in 2026, and it's no closer to being
- 29:47resolved. So a 20 -year ongoing case. It'll be
- 29:51interesting to see how that happens and what
- 29:53happens on remand. It's brand new, so both sides
- 29:56can still try to appeal it to the Supreme Court,
- 29:59although it's an unpublished decision, so. I'm
- 30:02not sure the Supreme Court will care too much
- 30:04about it. So we'll all have to keep in mind and
- 30:07see what happens, see if it ends up going up
- 30:10a third time, who knows. All right, another one,
- 30:15Prang v. Assessing Appeals Board, County Number
- 30:174. So this was, and by the way, when it's Prang
- 30:23v. Assessing Appeals Board, that generally means
- 30:25that the assessor lost at the board. when it's
- 30:28a taxpayer versus the county of Los Angeles,
- 30:30that generally means that the taxpayer lost the
- 30:32deport. So something to just keep in mind when
- 30:34you see these case names, it kind of gives you
- 30:36a sense of who was the party who felt like they
- 30:39did not get the decision that they wanted at
- 30:42the assessment appeals board. So Prang v. assessment
- 30:47appeals board number four, this dealt with one
- 30:49Wilshire, a building downtown, which for lack
- 30:56of a better term is like a data center hotel.
- 31:00It's where a bunch of carrier hotel where you
- 31:05have servers and everything for data for all
- 31:08that software and all that energy to go through,
- 31:10right? The property was purchased. I shouldn't
- 31:15say the property that the property and some of
- 31:17the intangibles at the property related to the
- 31:20business operating at the property were purchased.
- 31:25for $437 .5 million. And that's what the assessor
- 31:31enrolled the property at. They put the property
- 31:35on the roll at that value. When they put it on
- 31:42that value, the taxpayer challenged it and said,
- 31:51No, there's significant non -taxable and tangible
- 31:55value that was paid for because of this peering
- 31:59premium and all those other elements. Now, the
- 32:03case didn't really get into that because the
- 32:06assessor, when the assessor loses at the board,
- 32:08they file a petition for administrative mandamus.
- 32:13It's under 1094 .5 of the Civil Procedure Code.
- 32:18And when the taxpayer loses, just for your knowledge,
- 32:21you file a suit for refund under a different
- 32:24section of a section of the Revenue and Taxation
- 32:26Code, 5140 and 5141. Sessors is a civil procedure
- 32:31code, 1094 .5. So this went to Superior Court.
- 32:36And at Superior Court, the taxpayer filed a motion
- 32:41for judgment on the completings, which is kind
- 32:43of similar to demur, to say, hey, substantial
- 32:46evidence supports the board's decision. And so
- 32:51you shouldn't overturn it. Again, this is related
- 32:57mostly to the intangible issue that was also
- 32:59in the prior case that the board cannot value
- 33:02intangibles. And oh, I forgot to mention at the
- 33:05board, the board did give a significant reduction.
- 33:08They found out about $78 million of non -taxables.
- 33:12The taxpayer asked for even more. They were closer
- 33:14to like 200 million. But the board still gave
- 33:18a significant reduction off the base year. And
- 33:19this is a base year case. So that $78 million
- 33:22is savings for that year and for every year into
- 33:26perpetuity. So it's big dollars. That's like
- 33:28a million bucks of tax and capitalize that at
- 33:31a 4 % cap rate. You're talking about some significant
- 33:34savings. This is more of a procedural issue.
- 33:39There was no judgment as to the merits or anything
- 33:44else other than like, the court of appeal said,
- 33:47and that's why I think it's unpublished. They
- 33:48said, look, it wasn't really appropriate. The
- 33:51standard that was done for the motion for judgment
- 33:53on the pleadings, you have to look at the entire
- 33:56record, not just the pleadings and not just the
- 33:59board's decision. You have to look at the entire
- 34:02record when reviewing a case under the substantial
- 34:05evidence standard. And so essentially, It wasn't
- 34:10a proper way to pursue this on the judgment for
- 34:14the pleadings. What they should have done is
- 34:15just go on to, quote unquote, trial. Now trials
- 34:20in property tax cases rarely involve new evidence
- 34:23or witnesses. They can on specific legal issues.
- 34:27But generally, the record you make at the assessment
- 34:30appeals board is your record. And the trial is
- 34:33on that administrative record, usually briefs
- 34:35ahead of time and then oral argument before the
- 34:38judge. I think this will, in my opinion, I think
- 34:41this will get remanded back to the trial court.
- 34:44They will have that quote unquote trial. They
- 34:47will likely find that substantial evidence supports
- 34:50the board's decision. And we might never see
- 34:54this case again, because I'm not sure they'd
- 34:56appeal a substantial evidence decision up to
- 34:58the board. County will try to argue is they will
- 35:02try to argue that this is a legal issue that
- 35:04needs to be reviewed to know, though, because
- 35:07somehow the board made a legal error when determining
- 35:10their intangible value. I think that'll be probably
- 35:13be a pretty tough case to win for the county.
- 35:16I think substantial evidence will eventually
- 35:17be the day. But this is more of a, you know,
- 35:21the how you proceed under these things. And I
- 35:24understand the thought process. Maybe they can
- 35:26short circuit it and go for this judgment on
- 35:27the pleadings. But I think There's been some
- 35:30other case law where people have tried to go
- 35:31for summary judgment and property tax cases,
- 35:33and none of them have ever worked very well.
- 35:35You generally want to actually have your quote
- 35:37unquote trial based upon the full administrative
- 35:40record before the judge. So another case, this
- 35:49is one where the taxpayer loss So here, you had
- 36:00a high end house, fairly high end house, bought
- 36:05for, I mean, just slightly, I guess, 110 million.
- 36:09So right in the medium range, I guess, for LA
- 36:11County now. Spot in an off market sale. And the
- 36:18assessor originally put on the full 110 million.
- 36:26The taxpayer appealed and said, hey, we overpaid
- 36:30for all these reasons, off market sale. The real
- 36:34value of the property is 36 million. And here's
- 36:39our appraised value at 36 million. The assessor
- 36:45appraised the property at 105 million at the
- 36:48hearing. and the board found 103 million. So
- 36:54a reduction, $7 million reduction off of a purchase
- 36:58price, but obviously not nearly what the taxpayer
- 37:03wanted, or they were trying to get it down to
- 37:0536 million. In California, a lot of people think
- 37:12that when you buy a property, you get reassessed
- 37:15at your purchase price. That is not true and
- 37:19is not the law. The law is that you get reassessed
- 37:23at fair market value. Now, in an open market
- 37:27arm's length transaction, where there's no exigencies
- 37:30on either buyer or the seller, the purchase price
- 37:34is presumed to be the fair market value. It's
- 37:38just a presumption. It can be overcome by evidence.
- 37:41It's not even all that strong of a presumption
- 37:43legally. But it is a presumption. In this case,
- 37:47because it was an off -market sale, there was
- 37:50no purchase price presumption. So it wasn't presumed
- 37:53that $110 million was the fair market value.
- 37:57Instead, you had to prove the comparable sales.
- 38:04There's three methods of value, cost approach,
- 38:06income approach, and comparable sales. For houses,
- 38:09it's almost always a comparable sales, unless
- 38:11it's like a brand new. building, then they might
- 38:13use a cost approach. But generally, it's going
- 38:15to be a comparable sales approach. There was
- 38:19a couple interesting things in there in this
- 38:23decision. Again, this is an unpublished decision.
- 38:26So unless it gets publication at a later date,
- 38:30this again is not something that can be relied
- 38:32upon as presidential, excuse me. But I do like
- 38:37looking at unpublished decisions, because they
- 38:38cite other cases. And sometimes you find law
- 38:40there. But also, you kind of get a sense of how
- 38:43courts are thinking, and how things were argued,
- 38:46and everything like that. Now, when you have
- 38:49these kind of high -end, unique homes, it's really
- 38:52hard to find comps. And it's really hard to value.
- 38:56And that's why you'll see things listed at crazy
- 38:58numbers and sell for way below that. Because
- 39:00it's... They're just not easy to know what the
- 39:04value is, and it's hard to use comps. It's not
- 39:06like it's a track home up in Santa Clarita, where
- 39:09you have the same home over and over and over
- 39:12and over again, and they all sale, and you're
- 39:14like, okay, well, they're all selling for 750
- 39:17grand, so that must be what these values are.
- 39:21So the court here made clear that, hey, they
- 39:26might not be the best comps. yeah they might
- 39:28not be great they might not be super similar
- 39:30but at some point you just have to deal with
- 39:32what you deal with and that's from another case
- 39:33mid -state theaters that is published two you
- 39:37have to make adjustments the taxpayers appraisal
- 39:40didn't make adjustments for certain things in
- 39:43their appraisal sometimes you get appraisers
- 39:46who will fight you on this they're like i don't
- 39:48make adjustments in my appraisal because they're
- 39:50so thumb up in the air who the heck knows they're
- 39:54so subjective You know, so I just see what they
- 39:57say up right, and then I conclude to evaluate.
- 40:00Well, that might be fine in the real world. It's
- 40:03not okay in property tax world. Property tax
- 40:06world, you need to know, you need to make adjustments.
- 40:10It's what rule four mandates. And even if the
- 40:12adjustment's zero, you got to put it in there
- 40:14and explain why you didn't make an adjustment.
- 40:18So a zero percent adjustment's fine. as long
- 40:20as you considered it and didn't make an adjustment.
- 40:22What you can't do is just not show that you didn't
- 40:24make any adjustments for location. You don't
- 40:26have it in your comp sales grid. So there's certain
- 40:28things that are just very important to do. The
- 40:31one thing I found is interesting is they allowed
- 40:33them to use off -market sales when using the
- 40:38data. That's kind of interesting because you're
- 40:42supposed to be coming to a market value and an
- 40:46off -market deal You don't know what happened.
- 40:49It wasn't marketed. It wasn't put to the market.
- 40:51It may be well below market. It might have been
- 40:53a sweetheart deal between people who were elated.
- 40:57It might be well above market because it was
- 40:59the neighbor who bought it. And we had a guy
- 41:02once on a certain beach in Malibu that he just
- 41:06wanted the house next door. And he didn't care
- 41:09really what the value was. He wanted it because
- 41:11he owned the house on one side and he owned the
- 41:14house on the other. And if he got the one in
- 41:15between, he could build this huge compound. And
- 41:18so it was worth more to him than anybody else,
- 41:20but that wasn't the market value. And he just
- 41:22kept going. And the person who owned it didn't
- 41:25want to sell. And so he just kept upping his
- 41:27price, upping his price until the folks were
- 41:29like, that's too good of a deal. OK, you got
- 41:32it. Here's their house. So I thought it was a
- 41:35little strange that they allowed off -market
- 41:37sales in. I didn't think the Court of Appeal
- 41:39fully thought that through. because there's just
- 41:43so much that you don't know about what was going
- 41:45on and that you might not ever know with an off
- 41:48-market sale. At least with a market sale, it
- 41:51was put to the market, right? And people had
- 41:56a chance, there were brokers involved, and you
- 41:58had a chance for things to happen. An off -market
- 42:01deal, you just don't know. So I wasn't a huge
- 42:04fan of that portion of the opinion. The rest
- 42:06of it... you know, it just kind of is what it
- 42:09was. Once you lose, you're kind of stuck on some
- 42:12of these things when it's a factual issue because
- 42:14of the standard review in court. So this is another
- 42:24case which is actually published, so one that
- 42:30you can rely on. This was all the rage when COVID
- 42:35hit. I must have, the phone never stopped ringing
- 42:40about calamity claim. Can we file a calamity
- 42:42claim? Can we file a calamity claim? Calamity
- 42:45claims are generally obviously for the Eaton
- 42:47fire, for the Palisades fire. When property burns
- 42:53down or floods or anything like that, you get
- 42:56to get a calamity claim which reduces your property
- 42:58taxes, which makes sense because if your house
- 43:02burned down, you're not able to use the house.
- 43:04It does make sense to get a reduction on those
- 43:08claims. Now, when COVID hit, what happened? Well,
- 43:15we had government mandated shutdowns in March
- 43:19of 2020, where certain property types, depending
- 43:23on the whims of our health department and our
- 43:27government, were not able to be used. So it was
- 43:33as if they burned out. right? Because we can't
- 43:36use our property because the government refuses
- 43:38to let us use it. Now, this happened in March
- 43:42of 2020. By January 1 of 2021, a lot of the restrictions
- 43:48might still be there, but they weren't completely
- 43:51shut down like they were in the beginning of
- 43:53COVID. And so you weren't getting you weren't
- 43:58able to get a traditional reduction in tax. because
- 44:01it didn't span a lien date. If COVID would have
- 44:04happened in December of 19, and everything was
- 44:07shut down by government mandate on January 1
- 44:10of 2020, you could have just filed a Prop 8 decline
- 44:13in value. But because we're on this lien date
- 44:15system, and when it hit, and when all these shutdowns
- 44:18occurred, people weren't able to file Prop 8s
- 44:24based on it, especially not any time, because
- 44:27a 2021 Prop 8 you can't file on until the fall
- 44:29of 21. That was 18 months away from just being
- 44:34able to file for any decline when these properties
- 44:37were bleeding cash because they weren't allowed
- 44:40to operate, but they still had to pay their rent
- 44:43or pay their loans or do anything else. So I
- 44:50see a question in the chat. I'll get to it in
- 44:52one second after I come to this case. So a lot
- 44:56of people... want to say, hey, well, we have
- 44:59a government mandated disaster. We have restricted
- 45:03access. So we meet a lot of the definitions of
- 45:08section 170. Let's file calamity claims. Now,
- 45:13a lot of people came to me. I said, look, there's
- 45:14this Slocum case that came out years ago about
- 45:179 -11 that's maybe not completely directly on
- 45:22point, but is almost pretty close on point that
- 45:25says, hey, you kind of need physical damage in
- 45:28order to get a calamity claim. So I think you're
- 45:31going to end up not getting a lot of relief.
- 45:35And so a lot of people I talked to, we didn't
- 45:37end up filing it. Or if we did file it, we did
- 45:39it for purposes of delaying property tax payments
- 45:42as the law can give you. But we were never expecting
- 45:47to get a benefit. Bramall challenged it and they
- 45:53said, hey, we think we should have gotten a calamity
- 46:00claim. We meet all the definitions and it doesn't
- 46:03necessarily say that you have to have physical
- 46:06damage. And the court of appeals said, no, I'm
- 46:11sorry, you're out of luck. The while there was
- 46:16a virus while there was a government Disaster
- 46:19and everything like that because you didn't have
- 46:21the physical damage to the property the human
- 46:25-to -human virus transmission is not a physical
- 46:28property damage You are not able to get a calamity
- 46:32evaluation Calamity claim does not apply to you.
- 46:35I remember the plane Ray a mall that was an enclosed
- 46:37mall, right? Malls that were enclosed were completely
- 46:39shut down, right? You could not go into them.
- 46:42You could not use them They're completely shut
- 46:44down. So they weren't able to use their property
- 46:46whatsoever, but they weren't able to get calamity
- 46:51relief. That's kind of how I always thought it
- 46:56would come out. It makes me feel better that
- 47:05I didn't give people bad advice. I do want to
- 47:08mention one thing I forgot to mention on the
- 47:10prior case. One of the issues here too is the
- 47:12assessor person who did the value didn't testify.
- 47:15That happens a lot in LA County where the person
- 47:17who does the value doesn't actually testify.
- 47:19And the person who testified just kept saying,
- 47:21well, I don't know, I don't know, I don't know.
- 47:23And the taxpayer was like, hey, we didn't get
- 47:26a proper opportunity to cross examine because
- 47:29the person who did the appraisal didn't show
- 47:31up. The court wasn't very sympathetic. They said,
- 47:35hey, you could have subpoenaed up there. That's
- 47:36up to you. Now, that's a case of the court of
- 47:39appeal not knowing how it actually works. You're
- 47:41down there. You don't know that the assessor's
- 47:43person is not going to show up. They just don't
- 47:45show up. And you'd have to then postpone your
- 47:48case to try to subpoena them to get them there
- 47:50because they're not always just there in the
- 47:52office. And you had all your experts come. You're
- 47:54all ready. And just because the assessor doesn't
- 47:56show up, You then have to postpone the case So
- 47:59I felt like the court appeal wasn't as sympathetic
- 48:01as they maybe should be because they didn't fully
- 48:03understand how things operate down at the assessment
- 48:05appeals board So I didn't get a couple questions
- 48:08Does the 35 year lease rule apply to a 25 year
- 48:13lease? No options that parties voluntarily extended
- 48:17for another 16 years in year 19 of the original
- 48:21lease No 35 year lease you need at some point,
- 48:28a remaining term of 35 years or more. If you
- 48:32have a 20 -year lease, no options, and in year
- 48:3419, you extend it for another 16 years, you've
- 48:37never had a lease that had a remaining term of
- 48:3935 years or more. There's actually a case in
- 48:42the transfer tax area that is specifically on
- 48:45point, which interprets the property tax rules.
- 48:48It's McDonald's, it might be county of Stanislaus,
- 48:51but it's some county up north. The answer is
- 48:56no, that would not be a 35 year plus lease. Someone
- 49:01said supplement or sign a new lease instead of
- 49:04extending the original lease. I'm not sure what
- 49:07a new lease is. Oh, a new lease instead of extending
- 49:09the original lease. Well, if you sign a new lease,
- 49:12that's just a new lease. So if it's less than
- 49:1435 years, it's less than 35 years. Remaining.
- 49:21All right. Let's move on to the next case. And
- 49:29this case is crazy. Has nothing to do with really
- 49:34anything you're ever going to cite to or anything
- 49:37like that. So for those of you who don't know,
- 49:42the assessor prior to Jeff Prang, the last elected
- 49:46assessor prior to Jeff Prang, I should say, was
- 49:49John Nogess. Nogaz, I think they had a trial
- 49:56a few months ago. I'm not sure if the trial ended
- 49:59or what the result of it was. But there was some
- 50:03allegations of bribes and people getting certain
- 50:09benefits for money, where a guy at the office,
- 50:13Scott Schenter, and another guy, Ramin Solari,
- 50:15again, this is all alleged, where maybe money
- 50:19was going back and forth in order for um, receiving
- 50:23reductions and, um, uh, you know, we're magically
- 50:29values would drop by 50 % overnight. Um, and,
- 50:33and who the heck knows? And, you know, it reached
- 50:36up where, you know, charges were filed against
- 50:40no gas and filed against some other people, uh,
- 50:43uh, Mark McNeil and some others in the assessor's
- 50:46office about, uh, whether this was going on or
- 50:49not, whether it was going on or not. I don't
- 50:52know. And if I did, who knows what my opinion
- 50:58is right or wrong. But it's certainly rocked
- 51:02the assessor's office for years. This case came
- 51:06up because a property was reduced before a board
- 51:09hearing for a November 2007 transfer, where it
- 51:14was significantly reduced from 7 .7 to 3 .7.
- 51:19And at the board hearing, they said, hey, we're
- 51:21going to reduce the value from 7 .7 and also
- 51:24apply it to the April 2007 transfer as well.
- 51:29Well, it was later determined that maybe or maybe
- 51:31not this was a part of one of the fraudulent
- 51:34kind of deals. And the assessor then realized,
- 51:36hey, that November 2007 transfer wasn't actually
- 51:39reassessable. So we could just get to reverse
- 51:41that change of ownership. And we didn't have
- 51:44a, quote unquote, board decision on the April
- 51:472007 one. So we're going to reinstate that $7
- 51:50.76 million value for the April 7, 2007 purchase.
- 51:59Kind of crazy that they did this so long after
- 52:01and like that. This is the one that they targeted
- 52:04in 2023 the board said no our decision in 2010
- 52:082010 13 13 years earlier was binding You don't
- 52:11get to re -enroll a new value This case had a
- 52:17lot of procedural issues it went to the Superior
- 52:21court and the lawyer for the taxpayer said hey,
- 52:26they didn't file timely you had to file much
- 52:28earlier. The lawyer for the taxpayer was wrong.
- 52:32The assessor has six months. It's really clear.
- 52:34But unfortunately, the Superior Court kind of
- 52:35bought into that. So there's just all this mess
- 52:37with all the procedural stuff because the Superior
- 52:40Court got the wrong deadlines. It got confused.
- 52:43A lot of times when you go to court where the
- 52:44assessor wins, because it's a 1094 .5 administrative
- 52:48mandamus, the courts and judges get confused
- 52:52and think like, The law that's developed separately
- 52:56for 1094 .5 applies. When it's not, it's the
- 53:00property tax rules still apply. That's the rules
- 53:02that matter. And so it finally went all the way
- 53:06up to the court of appeal, and the court of appeal
- 53:08said, no. One, you weren't barred on the administrative
- 53:14mandamus, so they sent that back. They got that
- 53:16correct. A traditional mandamus under 1085 wasn't
- 53:20the correct one. There was no abuse of discretion.
- 53:23So it's remanded back to the Superior Court to
- 53:26proceed under the administrative mandamus rules
- 53:30as to whether or not the assessor should be able
- 53:34to invalidate a board decision and re -enroll
- 53:37a much higher value based upon maybe some alleged
- 53:40fraud. This one's not quite as bad as the 06.
- 53:45case for the Time Warner, but it's pretty close.
- 53:48This is 07 valuation. So only a year later. So
- 53:52LA County has some appeals that are pretty, pretty
- 53:55dated. This is obviously on publish because it's
- 53:57never going to have much presidential value to
- 53:59anybody else, but it is kind of a little bit
- 54:01interesting. I did have another question from
- 54:04Skip. Do you have any comments about the constitutionality?
- 54:08of the proposed city of LA parcel tax. Now, I
- 54:12haven't looked at that. In all honesty, I don't
- 54:14get involved in parcel taxes that much. I do
- 54:16specialize in property tax, but I don't like
- 54:18to get involved in kind of the 218 parcel tax
- 54:22stuff. It's just not something that interests
- 54:24me a lot. So I generally don't do a ton in that.
- 54:26So unfortunately, I don't have a great answer
- 54:29on that. I am gonna skip these next two. I can
- 54:35come back to them in a second, but I don't have
- 54:36a ton more time. These are just about pace ones.
- 54:41The main thing, maybe I won't skip entirely,
- 54:42but the main thing here is you really got to
- 54:45know how to exhaust and when to exhaust and what
- 54:50to do. As I said, in most property tax cases,
- 54:52you have to go to the assessment appeals board,
- 54:54but not all property tax cases. For exemption
- 54:59cases, you do not go to the assessment appeals
- 55:01board. Instead, you have to file a claim for
- 55:04refund and go to court. In this case, the Morton
- 55:07case and the Berg case, both issues had to deal
- 55:10with that the taxpayers didn't properly exhaust
- 55:13their administrative revenues. And if you don't
- 55:15exhaust your administrative revenues, in this
- 55:17case, they didn't file a timely claim for refund,
- 55:20you are going to be thrown out of court. So if
- 55:23you are doing something when it comes to really
- 55:25any tax in California, you have to make sure
- 55:28you exhaust your administrative revenues. Now
- 55:33the one city tax case that I wanted to just briefly
- 55:37touch on because it was interesting and This
- 55:40I think is actually a pretty helpful case. It
- 55:42is going to be published It doesn't have the
- 55:44full numbers yet because it literally just came
- 55:45out. That's why it's a Lexus site right now Carson
- 55:49audited to Soro Who's now marathon for their
- 55:56oil refinery and city of Carson and Generally,
- 56:03for city tax cases, unlike property tax, there's
- 56:06the Government Claims Act, which says what you
- 56:10have to do to get to court, which is generally
- 56:11pay the tax, file a claim for refund, and then
- 56:13it's either denied or deemed denied after a certain
- 56:17period of time, then you file a suit for refund.
- 56:20Some cities have enacted administrative revenues.
- 56:24Like the city of LA has administrative revenues,
- 56:26an assessment review officer, and a border review
- 56:29hearing for city tax cases and for transfer tax
- 56:31cases. Carson had enacted these administrative
- 56:36remedies. And Tesoro didn't go through them.
- 56:39They filed a claim for refund. They went to court.
- 56:42And the city said, hey, they demurred and said,
- 56:44hey, you failed to exhaust. And you didn't get
- 56:55to go, excuse me, you failed to exhaust. So you
- 57:00didn't get to go to you didn't you don't get
- 57:02to go to court you're thrown out That was their
- 57:06argument. They went up to the Court of Appeal
- 57:09And the Court of Appeal said no the government
- 57:12claims act is what controls And because the Government
- 57:16Claims Act controls, cities cannot create their
- 57:20own mandatory administrative things. They can
- 57:23create them. You can still go. And sometimes
- 57:25they're helpful to go. I've resolved a lot of
- 57:27cases at city administrative levels, but they're
- 57:29not mandatory. You can't make it mandatory. The
- 57:33Government Claims Act preempts these cities from
- 57:37doing something outside of this. And the Government
- 57:39Claims Act was done to have uniform rules throughout
- 57:42the state when you're suing. counties and cities.
- 57:47And so because that preempts everything, you
- 57:50couldn't create these extra levels that Tesoro
- 57:52had to go through. And so Tesoro is now is going
- 57:55to be allowed to proceed under their suit for
- 57:59these business license tax that Carson alleged
- 58:03do. I think with that, we have like a little
- 58:07over a minute left. I don't know if there's any
- 58:09other questions. or anything else we want to
- 58:13deal with. I think we're good. This was great.
- 58:19Thank you so much, Greg. We really, really appreciate
- 58:21it. Always appreciate your presentations on property
- 58:24tax. You are the property tax guys, if I'm concerned,
- 58:28even though I do it also a little bit, but you
- 58:32are the guy. So thank you so much for your presentation,
- 58:35your time, really appreciate it. Thank you everyone
- 58:37for joining us. You should be getting your CLE
- 58:39certificate by the end of the day. And with that,
- 58:43goodbye and have a wonderful rest of your day.