Latest / Her Moment: Female perspectives on life, culture & society / Why I Painted My Mother’s Silence: Healing Through Art Therapy | Her Moment
Transcript
- I used to think that if I just spoke loud enough, I could drown out the silence my mother carried like a second shadow. It wasn’t until I picked up a charcoal stick and let my hands do the talking that I finally heard her. Let’s unpack that for a second, because it’s heavy. Growing up in my house, we didn’t talk about feelings. We talked about schedules. We talked about who was picking up dry cleaning or whether the neighbor’s cat looked underfed. Emotions were treated like inconvenient luggage—something you only brought out when absolutely necessary, and even then, you kept it tightly packed and out of sight. My mother, bless her heart, had mastered the art of the polite nod. She would smile at dinner parties, pour the wine with steady hands, and never once mention the grief she lost when her own mother died when she was twenty-two. That loss sat in our home like a piece of furniture we all agreed to ignore. A large, ugly sofa in the middle of the room that nobody sat on but everyone tripped over. I spent my twenties trying to fix this by talking. So much talking. I became a journalist, a writer, someone whose job was to extract stories from people who wanted to hide them. I thought if I could articulate the pain, dissect it with precision, I could heal it. I treated trauma like a puzzle to be solved. But here’s the thing: you cannot solve a feeling with logic. You can analyze it, sure. You can name it. But you cannot think your way out of a wound that lives in your body. And mine? Mine was full of static. Full of the echo of things left unsaid. I felt fractured, like a mirror that had been dropped and swept back together, still holding the shape of the cracks. It happened on a Tuesday. Just a regular, gray, boring Tuesday. I was sitting across from my mother at her kitchen table, watching her stir tea she wasn’t drinking. The spoon clinked against the ceramic. Clink. Clink. Clink. And suddenly, I couldn’t take it anymore. Not the tea, not the spoon, but the performance of normalcy. I started crying. Not a polite cry. A real, heaving, ugly cry that shook the windows. I told her I was tired of being strong. I told her I was tired of carrying the weight of a history I never lived. She stopped stirring. She looked at me with these wide, terrified eyes, as if I had just confessed to a crime she committed decades ago. She didn’t say anything. She just reached across the table and held my hand. Her skin was paper-thin. Cold. In that moment, I realized that words were failing us both. My words were too sharp, too demanding. Hers were too scarce, too guarded. We were two ships passing in the night, using flashlights that didn’t reach each other. I needed a new language. Something softer. Something that didn’t require me to explain why I hurt, but simply allowed me to show where it hurt. I didn’t know it then, but I was standing on the edge of a door I hadn’t known existed. A friend of mine, a woman who has always seemed to have a direct line to wisdom, suggested art therapy. I laughed. I actually laughed in her face. Me? An adult woman with a master’s degree and a career, making scribbles on paper? Please. I assumed it was for children or people who couldn’t handle their business. But desperation is a powerful motivator. So, I went. I walked into a small studio filled with the smell of turpentine and dried clay. There were easels everywhere. Canvases stacked like leaning towers of Pisa. The therapist, a gentle woman named Elena, didn’t ask me what was wrong. She didn’t ask for my backstory. She handed me a block of soft, black charcoal and said, 'Just make a mark. Any mark.' I stared at the white canvas. It felt blindingly bright. Aggressive. I wanted to run. But then I thought of my mother’s cold hand. I pressed the charcoal to the paper. It snapped. I pressed harder. A jagged, dark line tore across the white space. It wasn’t pretty. It wasn’t balanced. It was angry. And for the first time in my life, my anger had a place to live that wasn’t inside my chest, crushing my ribs. Elena watched me work. She didn’t judge the mess. She didn’t try to interpret it for me. She just stayed present. That presence was a gift. It was the first time I felt seen without having to perform for anyone. Over the next few months, I returned to that studio every week. It became my sanctuary. I learned that art therapy isn’t about creating a masterpiece. It’s about externalizing the internal. When I couldn’t find the words to describe my anxiety, I mixed blue and black paint until it turned into a stormy gray. I smeared it across the canvas with my fingers, getting dirty, letting go of the need for control. When I felt lonely, I worked with clay. I built walls. Tall, thick walls. Then I knocked them down. Again and again. Each time I rebuilt, I made the walls thinner. More permeable. It was a physical metaphor for emotional opening. Tell me more about how that felt. Because it changed everything. I started noticing patterns in my art that mirrored patterns in my life. I noticed I always painted circles when I felt safe. Triangles when I felt threatened. Squares when I felt rigid and stuck. My hands knew what my mind refused to admit. This wasn’t magic. It was neuroscience meeting intuition. By moving the trauma from my nervous system onto the page, I created distance. I could look at it. I could examine it. I could change it. The art became a container for my pain, allowing me to hold it without being consumed by it. It was like putting my chaos into a jar, sealing it, and placing it on a shelf. I could visit it. But I wasn’t living inside it anymore. One day, I brought a piece of my art home. It was simple. A watercolor wash of soft purples and greens, with a single, bold red line cutting through the center. I didn’t explain it. I just set it on the kitchen table. My mother looked at it. She traced the red line with her finger. For a long time, neither of us spoke. Then, she whispered, 'That looks like the road to my mother’s house.' I froze. I had never asked her about that road. I had never asked her about her childhood home. But somehow, my subconscious had found the image she couldn’t voice. In that moment, the bridge was built. Not with words, but with color. We sat there for an hour, looking at paintings. She showed me sketches she had done as a young girl, hidden in a drawer. Drawings of birds with broken wings. Drawings of houses with no doors. We weren’t fixing the past. We were witnessing it. Together. For the first time, I saw her not just as my mother, but as a wounded child herself. And she saw me not as her daughter, but as a fellow traveler in the dark. Now, I want to be clear. Healing isn’t a straight line. It’s a spiral. You circle back to the same wounds, but from a higher vantage point. Some days, I still feel the urge to suppress. Some days, the old habits of silence creep back in. But now I have tools. I have the charcoal. I have the clay. I have the permission to be messy. Art therapy taught me that imperfection is not failure; it’s humanity. It taught me that my voice matters, but so does my silence. So does my brushstroke. So does my breath. If you are carrying generational trauma, if you are holding onto pain that doesn’t feel like yours but lives in your bones anyway, please consider finding a creative outlet. It doesn’t have to be painting. It could be gardening. Cooking. Dancing. Writing poetry. Singing in the shower. Find something that allows you to express what words cannot. You don’t need to be an artist. You just need to be willing to show up. To show up for yourself. To show up for your history. To say, 'I am here. I see you. And I am ready to begin.' Thank you for letting me share this with you. Be gentle with yourself today. And remember, it’s okay to make a mess. It’s okay to create. I’m Heidi Ashman, and I’ll be right here whenever you need a moment. Take care.