Latest / Automotive State of The Union / Painter Back as TrueCar CEO, Old Used Cars Are In, AI In The Freelance Economy
Transcript
- 0:00Good morning. It is Thursday, October 16th. This is the Automotive State of the Union. I'm Paul Jay Daly. It's Kyle Mounts here. Today, we're talking about Scott Painter is back with TrueCar.
- 0:09Old used cars are in and the freelance economy. Here I go. Curious on that one. You really wanna know who I is. I mean, it's been the freelance economy for a while. They just called it something different.
- 0:19No need to repeat. Well, yeah. Well, we'll get to it, get to it. We'll get to it. I know, we'll get to it. It's a good one. Look, we have a few things.
- 0:25Uh, we dropped a new Auto Collabs episode, I Wouldn't Buy a Car From Me. This GM helped Ford redesign their showroom with JB Burnett on the Ford Signature Store, the first Ford Signature Store in the US.
- 0:36We got a sneak peek. We give a sneak peek of it on the podcast. You can go to Auto Collabs, search it on Spotify or Apple Podcast- Anywhere... or go to our YouTube channel, and you can see it.
- 0:46You get a p- sneak peek at this new signature series store that Ford, uh, is dropping, and here's a hint, it doesn't suck. [laughs] Doesn't suck at all. Really good. Yeah. I know. Uh- It is a dope...
- 0:56I'm telling you what, they went... They did a thing. Kudos, Ford. All in. All in, all in. We also have a, a SOTU Edge webinar coming up. We want you to sign up for it because it's gonna help you save money.
- 1:06[laughs] This is, uh, how you move vehicles profitably and fairly between your stores and your group, keep all your GMs and manage- sales managers happy. They cracked the code.
- 1:15We're gonna be with Patrick Janes, uh, of vAuto, and Paul Golias of Modern Auto Group, who is kind of the quarterback in that group, making sure everything gets where it needs to go and everybody is happy. There you go.
- 1:27Go to asotu.com- There you go... and sign up for that so you can be there. All right, we have some news. We wanna get in and out today, make sure you get the news and we get going.
- 1:35But here, TrueCar's founder, you remember him, former CEO Scott Painter, he is back nearly a decade after his controversial exit. He is leading a $227 million investor group to take the publicly traded company private.
- 1:52It's a bold move- Wow... aiming at restoring TrueCar's dealer relationships and market relevance. His syndicate, Fair Holdings LLC, includes investors from dealer data- dealers, data, fintech, and mobility sectors.
- 2:02It's a great group. He'll return as CEO once the all-cash transaction closes in late 2025, pending shareholder and regulatory approval. I bet they go through pretty okay.
- 2:12The deal follows a year-long strategic review by TrueCar's board, looking for a sustainable path forward after layoffs and a bunch of, uh, leadership turnover.
- 2:20Their stock surged 62% on the announcement, closing at $2.40. Painter emphasized collaboration. He said, "Partnerships and brand alignment are central to creating value for both dealers and customers."
- 2:31It's such a wild thing. It's like, "Hey, we're gonna buy you guys all out." Everybody's like, "Yeah, I'll take some of that money," you know? So the stock surges 62%. That's pretty...
- 2:40That's, like, a, like, wh- uh, what a wild mechanism. It's almost like, "Ah, just kidding. We're gonna keep it" [laughs] you know? Yeah.
- 2:46I, I remember when all that Twitter stuff was going on, and, like, the price was going up and down. And then, like, at some point it locks in. You know, it's probably already there. It just locks in. Yeah, exactly.
- 2:53And, uh, look, I'm, I'm really curious to see what happens. We know a lot of people at TrueCar, and we know they've been working really hard to try to develop new products, bring value to dealers.
- 3:01And, uh, they've been, they've been hanging on and trying to introduce new things, so Scott Painter obviously has some sort of vision for the company.
- 3:06Um, he obviously thinks it's a, a value price, right, where it is right now, and he sees a lot of upside. Um, he's no idiot, right? Like, he's like, "I can grow this company." No. Uh- "We can grow it privately."
- 3:15Scott's no idiot. He, he, he proved he can do, uh, a lot with that brand and that company once. Um, you know, obviously a bit of a controversial exit where he went afterwards.
- 3:24Uh, but I, I think that, you know, dealers over the last two, three years especially have, as we've seen pricing stability happen in the market where, where people know, like, "Oh, that's the price that I'm gonna get.
- 3:35That's the price I'm gonna pay," uh, brands like TrueCar are winning. And there's a lot of... I mean, we just know so many people in there in the executive and upper-level management, um, uh, side of the, the business.
- 3:47Like, we know they're pushing the boundaries. Uh, they're attempting to bring, like, some of the best products that, that auto's trying to see right now, um, from a marketplace perspective.
- 3:56And, uh, so I thi- I think this is a great move and, and we'll see what it does over 2026. But as long as they listen to dealers, I think they're gonna be up.
- 4:03Yeah, I think also the ability TrueCar's gonna have to make changes and maneuver without pub- Quickly... without public scrutiny. That's right. Right?
- 4:10Now they're gonna have a little bit more runway to actually make broader changes without, you know, shareholder meetings and the public, you know, banging down their doors to, like, push revenue.
- 4:17So I'm, I'm excited to see what happens. Speaking of revenue. Oh. Segway. Time. [upbeat music] All right. CarGurus' Q3 2025 quarterly review shows that when it comes to cars, old is in. Ah.
- 4:32Despite economic pressure, auto sales are holding steady, but buyers are opting for older, cheaper vehicles to keep monthly payments more manageable.
- 4:39Used vehicles under $30,000 drove 72% of used retail growth over the past year. Nearly half of the listings in that range were over seven years old and averaging $13,600.
- 4:51Uh, director Kevin Roberts says shoppers are split between value seekers buying older cars and wealthier consumers driving luxury growth. Wow, a real split in the top and the bottom of the market.
- 5:00Dealers may even- Dro- oh, yeah. [laughs]... 60 million fixed ops to meet demand and keep aging cars running.
- 5:06California, Florida, Texas, and Virginia lead the nation in used cars under $20,000, each of those taking up 30% or more of the listings.
- 5:15Roberts noted, quote, "Buyers are increasingly accepting six-figure mile cars to keep payments within reach." Yeah, I think this, this story isn't so much about old. The story is about price point here. Cheap. Yeah.
- 5:27Uh, this is, this is all a, like, affordability question. Wild to me that California, Florida, and Texas would lead in a percentage of vehicles under 20,000, 'cause you would think of those as higher priced markets.
- 5:41Um, but obviously when you get that many people around, uh, you understand that, "Hey, we've gotta have, we've gotta fill the affordability gap."
- 5:49Um, you know, this is, this is gonna be a question that we continually struggle with, and, and this is where I think that service departments can lean in and continue to captureThe resale market and, and, like, keep customers coming back because if you have more of those 100,000 mile cars staying on the road and you're looking to transition those people into newer model years as they grow or, or grow, you know, grow in their career paths and get into a different affordability matrix, like, understanding people wanna buy these cars, they're gonna need to service them.
- 6:22How do I capture that business in the used car business and then move them into new car purchasing or, or newer model years as they grow in their careers? Super important for dealers.
- 6:30I mean, I think we're just seeing that market be more of what it is, right? It's another indicator that that bifurcated market that Jonathan Smoke's been talking about for 18 months is alive and well.
- 6:40Speaking of alive and well- Stop. Segue. Time. Freelancers seem to be alive and well.
- 6:46Maybe- Freelancers are alive and well, but AI is reshaping the whole economy in that, in that sphere, creating both opportunity and uncertainty for side hustlers.
- 6:55While tools like ChatGPT help freelancers work faster, they're also undercutting pay, originality, and client perception of value. Mm-hmm.
- 7:03Freelancers are saying due to a recent, uh, in a recent study that AI boosts efficiency but drives down earnings. Writing jobs fell 2% and income dropped 5% on Upwork after ChatGPT's release.
- 7:15AI lowers the barrier to entry, flooding the market with cheaper, quote, "Good enough work that makes it hard for top tier talent to stand out."
- 7:23Clients increasingly expect AI level output for less, with some even replacing human contractors, obviously, with automation tools.
- 7:30Washington University Professor, uh, Chang Hui noted that high quality doesn't really protect freelancers. You know, I mean, this is gonna be more and more.
- 7:41Like, we've talked about this so many times, and we've seen it so many times. We've leveraged tons of AI tools so many times, and for us, it hasn't been about, like, reducing the size of its staff.
- 7:52It has been about more strategically adding staff and being able to add capacity without more people. Obviously, that cuts into the work that we would be shipping out to freelancers 'cause they're the first to go, right?
- 8:02For sure.
- 8:02When there's a freelancer, and especially as these AI tools get more sophisticated, if you're a writer right now, I think you really have to understand the value in you being a writer is business savvy and not necessarily writing ability because understanding how to put multiple pieces in a business together into words- Yep...
- 8:20is actually where the brilliance is gonna come in, not being able to draft really long bits of copy and things like that, so- The writing is context... as these tools get better, it's gonna keep going. Context. Yep.
- 8:29Right. The human- You having context, you having the ability to edit, put the human touch on it, those things are gonna be...
- 8:35A- and really, that's, that's for design, that's for anything that it has to do with these, like, faster tasks, right? How do I provide context and inc- and increase the level of human touch, uh, on the final product?
- 8:46Without a doubt. And the requirement now for anyone who is in the middle, any mediocre writer, any mediocre designer, they are the ones that are most at risk, right? Mm.
- 8:56So it's like either up your level, pay attention, get better so that you can beat the robots, or you're probably gonna need to find something to do or be willing to live with a lot less money because it's kind of a commoditization of especially writing.
- 9:10Commoditization of writing is here. So, um- Connor, you gotta stay- You gotta stand up. You gotta do the things, but it's possible.
- 9:16The cool part is it's possible, and now the people who lean in are actually gonna be able to... more valuable. Yeah.
- 9:22And I think that those people, everyone's gonna be willing to pay top dollar for- I think you're right... because the precision of what you get for those hours and that time is gonna be more, uh, much more.
- 9:31So if you're a freelancer, focus on value, not output. I guess that's the moral of the story. [upbeat music] There you go. Moral of the story is over. Value, not output.
- 9:38You have, you have an entire day in front of you, if you're listening to this in the morning. We can go out and take care of the people around you, get better at your job, and guess what?
- 9:45When you do all those things, everything takes care of you. It's kind of how it works.
- 9:50[upbeat music]