Latest / Before you say yes / Ep 1. You're not a mind reader: Before you say yes to sharing your financial life
Transcript
- 0:02Before you say yes, ask yourself, what are my boundaries? And then communicate them. Before you say yes, verify. And for me, that is verifying the person you are with, the information that is coming at you, the feelings that you have. But verify because we don't know what is real and what is not anymore. And we have to do that to protect ourselves.
- 0:28I'm Catherine Fitzpatrick. I'm a former senior bank executive now working with companies, governments and regulators to change the way financial products are designed. This podcast is about financial consent, what to check, what to ask, before you share your money, your accounts or your digital life with someone you love. So before you say yes to sharing your financial life, listen to this.
- 0:54I'm Angelique Wan. I'm co-founder and CEO of Consent Labs. We're a not-for-profit working to end sexual violence in Australia, specifically how sexual violence is experienced by young people. We do that through the delivery of preventative education, focusing in on consent and respectful relationships education programs. So how did you come to this work?
- 1:16I didn't really see anything happening in the Australian landscape that looked like consent education and particularly not education that was led by young people and built for young people. What I had experienced in high school, and I wonder what your experience was, Catherine, was an education curriculum that felt really out of touch or really out of date with the experiences that I was sort of navigating as a young person. And I,
- 1:43I really wanted education that was strengths-based, that was obviously age-appropriate, but that gave young people the ability to make informed choices. It gave them knowledge. And when I didn't see that in Australia, I sought out to create that with my co-founder, Joyce. And...
- 2:05It's been a whirlwind. We've educated 185,000 people across Australia in about five years. Amazing. So can you tell me a little bit about when you're teaching consent? What are the concepts of consent? And how do you talk about that with young people? Yeah.
- 2:23So we use a model called affirmative consent. And what affirmative consent looks at is the fact that consent is given freely. It's given voluntarily. So an absence of pressure or threats or coercion. It's enthusiastic and it's ongoing. Okay.
- 2:43It's essentially acknowledging that you're not a mind reader. No one is a mind reader. And that in order to understand what someone else is wanting or what someone else is open to, you have to ask a question and you have to check in. Is that the kind of language that you use or what kinds of things are you in a practical sense saying? How do you know? How do you stop being a mind reader? Yeah.
- 3:05So consent goes hand in hand with boundaries. Boundaries are how we communicate what we are and what we're not comfortable with. Boundaries are a personal thing and they can relate to a range of different things. For example, you can have boundaries around money, which I know we're going to get to. You can have boundaries around your intimate relationships. You can have boundaries with your friends in terms of how you spend your time, your emotional investment. Yeah.
- 3:35And it's really about firstly, understanding for yourself personally, how you feel about doing something. Are you comfortable or are you not comfortable with doing something? And then communicating that to the person that you might be doing it with. So we always encourage the use of an I statement instead of a you statement. Boundaries are about expressing how you yourself feel about something. You're not trying to
- 4:02impose something on someone else or tell them how they should be feeling. But I think probably the biggest thing that I would recommend is asking open-ended questions. If you're trying to understand how someone else is feeling about doing something or about a subject, asking questions like, how do you feel about
- 4:24going for a walk on the beach. How do you feel about opening a joint bank account? Can I ask, have you ever tried something like this before? Those types of open-ended questions are how we encourage a conversation that's not laden with, you know, judgment or shame. And if you have those two things, then it's hard to have a productive conversation. Yeah. How do you feel about going
- 4:54I feel the same way. Yeah. Okay. So that makes a lot of sense. It's really practical. What could it look like if you're having that conversation around money? Yeah. I mean, I think consent and the concept of boundaries absolutely applies when it comes to issues around finance or money. Again, in any relationship, whether that's an intimate relationship or also with a friendship, we talk about this with young people, you know, in terms of
- 5:23how much is normal to spend for birthday presents? As an example, that can often go unacknowledged and can create a little bit of awkwardness when it's not discussed up front. So encouraging young people to have these conversations with their friends. Another one is how do you both feel about
- 5:42you know, say, for example, you go out for lunch or for dinner, do you split the bill 50-50? Do you get it this time? Your friend gets it the next time? How can we have these conversations up front to make sure that you're both on the same page? Yeah. So what are the conversations when you are talking about, say, sharing, you know, who's paying for food or how much should we pay for presents? What are the other sort of money conversations young people are stepping into that they're trying to navigate?
- 6:11I mean, for example, getting their first job and all of the questions that come with that, you know, setting up your bank account, your tax file declaration, like that's confusing, talking about superannuation perhaps. And then how do you actually think about saving and spending that money and sort of figuring out perhaps how to budget or where your comfortability around spending versus saving thresholds sort of sit?
- 6:39And how would they open that up? I mean, I think it can be done a couple of different ways. It is sometimes helpful if there is a prompt, such as an event where, you know, you are moving in together. I think that's a nicer segue into starting a conversation. So, hey, this is a really exciting, you know, milestone for us in our relationship. Before we do this, like I'd love to have a conversation about,
- 7:06X, Y, Z, how we want to share the cost of our utilities, for an example, how we want to cover the cost of our rent, whose bank account is it going to come out of, is it a joint account? I think, yeah, hinging that conversation off of an event or a milestone can feel like an easier way in.
- 7:25if you don't have an event like that, either using, you know, something that you might have seen on TV or on social media as an opportunity to start a conversation like, hey, in this TV show, these characters were just navigating this conversation and made me realise we've never actually had the chat about this. Or I was listening to this podcast and they were talking about, you know, money conversations. And I was wondering how we both felt about that
- 7:53So I think sometimes, you know, using, yeah, something that you sort of seen around you as a spark for that conversation can feel like a bit of a more natural way to bring up a conversation if you are feeling a little bit uncomfortable because you've never talked about it before. It does bring me to a point that you said when we started the conversation about free and informed and enthusiastic and no pressure. What are those red flags look like?
- 8:22We get asked the question a lot, what does a healthy relationship look like? Which kind of alarms me a little bit that that's not
- 8:32I guess young people don't have a good sense as to what they should be striving for. And, you know, we'll sort of have conversations around the fact that it's really healthy to have a level of independence, as an example. You know, perhaps to have your own friendship circle, to have your own stream of income, um...
- 8:53I think when the other person isn't open to having a conversation or there's an immediate sense of a dismissal of your feelings or an invalidation of your feelings or an element of you feel like they might not be completely truthful, if there's also a sense of,
- 9:16them not respecting your independence. Particularly when it comes to money, you know, you have a right to understand how your money is being used. If you've got a joint bank account, for an example, you have a right to understand how, you know, those joint funds are being used and allocated and you should both have access to those accounts. And so if there's, you know, any questioning of, um, or lack of information sharing about that, I would sort of consider that a red flag. Um, yeah.
- 9:45If there's any sense of coercion, pressure or threats about how you should be spending your time or your money, that's another red flag. It does strike me that a lot of people when they're getting into relationships where they are sharing money and bills...
- 10:02people tend to fall into it a little bit too. Oh, I'll just put my name on the energy bill, that sort of thing without necessarily thinking about the consequences. You can do the same thing in intimate partner relationships. We fall into it and then go, oh, actually that wasn't exactly what I meant or what I feel comfortable with. And then trying to unpick it a little bit is a bit tricky as well. Do you tackle that?
- 10:23Yeah, I think that's a fantastic point, Catherine. So consent can be revoked or withdrawn at any point in time, just because you've said yes to doing something and, or maybe you've done it before, doesn't mean that you're necessarily, you know, in the mindset or feeling comfortable with doing it again. And you should know that at any point you can say, hey, this actually doesn't feel good anymore, or I think I've changed my mind, or do you mind if we take a pause?
- 10:51and you can withdraw your consent. Knowing what to say is one thing and understanding why we don't say it is something else.
- 11:04Here's what nobody puts in the financial literacy books. The emotional state that makes you fall in love, hopeful and focused on the future and all in, is the same state that switches off your critical thinking. Not because you're naive, not because you should have known better, just because that's how the human brain works.
- 11:26Hi, my name is Tracy Hall. I am a speaker, an author, an educator and an advocate for scams, fraud and victims specifically of intimate fraud. I had an incredibly challenging life experience back in 2017. I woke up one morning to find my boyfriend of almost 18 months being arrested on a Crime Stoppers video for swindling 15 Australian victims out of $7.6 million dollars.
- 11:55And in that moment, I discovered that he wasn't the person he said he was. He was, in fact, a completely, well, he was a criminal, essentially. And I didn't know his real name. I didn't know anything about him. And in the process, I discovered that he had stolen my life savings. So I became a victim of intimate fraud. She met him on a dating app, like most people do now.
- 12:19Well, you're right, because when I found myself separated at the age of 40 and wanting to get back into the dating scene, when I got married, dating apps didn't exist. So, you know, I went into the apps and I guess you trust the system that is built around the experience
- 12:38and you connect based on certain things like age or location or interests or whatever it might be, and then you start chatting. And initially it's in the app and then you move off app, and that's sort of how the relationship progresses. Yeah, and I remember you saying nothing felt strange at the time. It was a series of very, very reasonable steps that ended up with you having been fleeced for so much money, your life savings. Yeah. Yeah.
- 13:08Can you talk through how that unfolded for you? It was really slow. And I would describe the relationship as a slow burn. And quite often when we are warned about people that may not have good intentions, there are things like, be careful of the love bombing. You know, be careful of the love bombing.
- 13:28And, you know, too much too soon, too much over communication about how much you're adored before they even get to know you. And with Hamish, it was very different. It was a very, very slow and methodical building of a relationship and building of trust. And that was partly because I didn't have time to spend a lot of time with him. But I think also too, he was very, very calculated in the way that he
- 13:58I did transfer my full 22 years of career superannuation into a fund that I believed was in my name because of all the false documentation he gave me, but in fact went into a trading account of his. So, it was, you know, I describe it like death by a thousand cuts. It was every conversation
- 14:19that matched. It was every handhold, it was every eye glance, it was every authentic piece of communication that we had that felt so real that in fact was completely fabricated and false. The thing that I like to talk about is the psychological tactics and behaviours
- 14:39that are used to manipulate and deceive people into being victims of scams and fraud or handing over their life savings. And they are things like, a scammer's main aim is to get you into a heightened emotional state so that you actually have less access to your logical thinking. And those things are things like love. In the case of Hamish and I, they were excitement. I was excited about a future situation.
- 15:03Fear, hey, mum, scams are all based on fear or authority scams and hope. They are the main things. And if you look for those in any scam, you'll be able to find those. And then if you apply some urgency when you're already in a heightened emotional state, then your rational and critical thinking is very much offline. So you're likely to do something that you wouldn't ordinarily do.
- 15:27And then you have all of the psychological glitches or brain glitches, I like to call them. And they're things like authority bias, confirmation bias, similarity bias. And they are things that, you know, for example, Hamish, I had a similarity bias. He looked like me. He sounded like me. We had similar values and morals. He wanted the same things as me. You know, we grew up in the same era in Australia. So he mirrored me.
- 15:54So what do you do with that? If the emotional state of falling in love is exactly the state that makes you vulnerable, how do you protect yourself without destroying the joy of it? In those heightened states where we're looking forward to the future, we're hopeful, we're excited and we're in love, we don't think that anything's going to go wrong. And I always kind of say, you know, you don't have to lose your life savings to a con man to be financially vulnerable.
- 16:21We can be financially vulnerable at many, many points in our lives. And what I like to say is keep your critical thinking cap on. Don't be skeptical. Don't be cynical. Just be critical in your thinking. Ask the questions. Quite often, especially when it comes to money, money is still quite taboo.
- 16:39It's really sometimes feels icky to talk about. It's something we steer away from, specifically when we're in love. We don't want to dampen the love with a conversation about money. But unfortunately, that puts us in a vulnerable position because if we don't ask those questions, if we don't lean in deeper, if we don't know where things are at
- 17:00then we are financially vulnerable. And so I would say, ask the extra questions, be bold, be boldly curious about what's going on. Don't be afraid to have the conversations. And I am encouraged by some of the conversations I hear the younger women having now, but do not be afraid to have the conversations. It's almost like hope for the best, but plan for the worst. When you're in love, you know, when you're in the best part of your relationship, you
- 17:27Having a conversation that says, if this doesn't go the way that we hope that it does, what does that mean? Where are our agreements up front so that there are no gray areas or messy bits at the end? Now, I don't think a lot of people have those conversations. If your partner shies away from that or shuts it down or is not interested in having that conversation, then I would say that's a huge red flag. And that's something that you need to address. And it's best to address it
- 17:56There's two things I wanted to pick up there because I've heard you talk about red flags and how hard they are to see when you're in it. Yeah. Can you tell me a bit about that? There is this beautiful saying that says, when you're wearing rose-coloured glasses, all the red flags are just flags. And it is so true because you want to see the best in everyone. Your critical thinking is offline.
- 18:20Is there anything that you would do differently now that you've learnt about over time as you've processed what happened to you? Are there things that maybe you might have done differently to verify the information or to delve a little bit deeper? Yes, I would have done a reverse image search.
- 18:42Explain to me what that is. Yeah, so reverse image search is where if you have a picture of something or someone, you can put it into a platform and see where that image shows up elsewhere on the internet. And then so, for example
- 18:58This man presented himself as a man by the name of Max Tavita. So if I had to put a picture of Max as I knew him into a reverse image search, there was a very deep history of him on the internet. But it wasn't Max Tavita. His name was Hamish McLaren. And that would have popped up.
- 19:16So it essentially trolls the internet and finds every example of an image that is of that person or the likeness of that person. And then it pulls up the website or, you know, the social media profile or whatever it might be. And then you can go and investigate and verify that. So had I have done that, and to be honest, I don't know if the technology existed back then. This is something that's quite new. But I would have discovered very, very quickly that that was Hamish McLaren and not Max Tavita. Yeah.
- 19:45So, that's one thing I would have done. Certainly with the documents that he presented to me, there are companies or platforms that you can go to and put documents in and see whether they have been falsely generated or AI generated. It does cost a little bit of money. Now, that's a tricky one because when you don't suspect anything.
- 20:09that you are being fooled or deceived or manipulated in that way. Why would you even think to do that? But there are technologies around that. And the other thing I would say is meet friends and family as quickly as possible because on both sides, because your friends and family can verify the person that you're with and then you can verify the information that they are presenting to you via their friends and family.
- 20:35Tracy identifies three things everyone should be building, financial literacy, digital literacy, and what she calls trust literacy. And I'd love to talk about trust literacy as well, because I think that is the third pillar in that series that we could all build.
- 20:54be teaching and learning more about. But in terms of financial literacy and digital literacy, the biggest thing is taking agency because all the information is out there. But in terms of digital literacy, it is really understanding how to use tools that can actually verify the information that is coming out, whether that's reverse image searches, whether that's making sure people have a digital footprint. It could be even using
- 21:20chat GPT to check whether the information coming at you is legitimate or not. Again, it's having the conversations. Financial literacy, it is about taking agency and not just letting the other person in the relationship take the lead. And it's okay if you don't execute it, but you can't outsource the education. Like you must know what's going on because again, you don't have to lose your life savings to a con man to be vulnerable in this position. If your partner
- 21:47has a major health issue or unfortunately passes away, then you find yourself financially vulnerable again. So there are lots of different things. And then when it comes to trust literacy, I think it is really important that we learn how to trust. And I don't think we're ever taught.
- 22:05It is this natural thing that we believe that we have this internal intuition about the personal, the information that is being presented to us. And unfortunately, with AI and with master manipulators and coercion and control, it rarely comes in waving a big red flag. It sneaks in as care and concern. And let me help you with that. And that is the coercive and insidious nature of these types of behaviors because we can't spot them.
- 22:35And so if we are more in tune with how to trust and why we trust and the reasons we do trust, then I think that helps us on that journey as well as the other more practical tools.
- 22:50My takeaway from Angelique and Tracy, you're not a mind reader. The only way through is a conversation and an education. So you can give consent that is free and informed and enthusiastic. Because the way we share money, bills and accounts and digital life at the start matters for your future self. So before you say yes to sharing your financial life, do this.
- 23:14Start with yourself. Know your boundaries. Communicate them. Ask an open question, not do you want a joint account, but how do you feel about a joint account? The answer will tell you everything. And remember, you can change your mind. Saying yes once doesn't lock you in. Financial consent isn't a contract. It's an ongoing conversation because love shouldn't cost you freedom.