Latest / Automotive State of The Union / Carvana’s Wild Ride Continues, 25% of Loans Have Negative Equity, The Gen X Factor
Transcript
- 0:00[upbeat music] Good morning. It is Monday, Monday, August 4th. This is the Automotive State of the Union. I'm Paul Jay Daly. It's Kyle Mounts here today.
- 0:08We are talking about Carvana's wild ride, negative equity in high income houses, and the Gen X factor. The Gen X factor. It's actually the, it- Right...
- 0:19I mean, I'm right on the, I'm o- I'm on the line, but I'm Gen X, believe it or not. Look, the, nobody- But the pictures, but I do not really- Nobody's bingo card- I know...
- 0:27nobody's bingo card this morning said, "These guys are gonna talk about Gen X." No. Never. But this, it's worth talking about.
- 0:33I, I will say that the picture they put of Gen Xers in this article- [laughs] I don't identify it with it at all. [laughs] I was like, "Huh?" You're like, "Skrrt. That's Gen X? I don't know about that."
- 0:47It's like in one of those demographic surveys when they, like, loop you in with a much higher age bracket. And you're like, "Come on." Yeah "You couldn't have put one in the middle?" Yeah. Right?
- 0:54Just- Make me feel a little better? You put that in the middle, not the [laughs] It's messed up. I know. We just got through, uh, uh, the first of a five Saturday month, so, um, I know dealers out there happy.
- 1:04Everybody's selling over the weekend. Had great weather in most of the country, so- Yep... it, you know, it all, it all adds up. It adds up. Yeah.
- 1:11Hey, we have a quick, uh, QuickShot webinar this week, getting back on track with these, Driving Loyalty With Data with Shane Wilson and Levi Beatty.
- 1:18This is Wednesday, so two days from now, on the 6th at 2:00 PM, so, uh, with our friends CarRX. These are always so much fun and so- They're great... uh, educational, and, you know, we're just having fun.
- 1:29We have fun while learning something. So you know how webinars work. Go to the website, asoto.com, register, and you can have the recording, or we prefer and hope that you can join us live.
- 1:39But, you know, retention, close to our hearts. Let's talk about retention, everybody. Let's talk about it every day, everybody. Yeah, it's all about retention.
- 1:44I mean, loyalty, retention, and the data needed to, to use that. So I've, uh, we've, we've seen the deck. We know what the, the general conversation is. You're not gonna wanna miss it. Yeah.
- 1:53Taking care of the customer you have is, like, a little cheaper than finding a new one, don't you think? Way cheaper. [laughs] All right, let's talk about some news.
- 2:00Uh, what once seemed like a dying online used car startup, you know who we're talking about, they're roaring back. Carvana's share price hit an all-time high last, uh, late July, up over 10,000%- [whistles]...
- 2:15from December of 2022's bottom, while short sellers have now racked up $7.4 billion in losses betting against the company. So basically, Q2 sales, uh, were staggering. $4.84 billion, up 42% year over year. Goodness.
- 2:31Retail units sold up 41% year over year. Wholesale units up 44% year over year. That's crazy. Their net income is up to $308 million.
- 2:42That's net, folks, with record profit margins across the board, including a record gross margin per unit at $7,426, $7,426- That's crazy... per unit gross revenue.
- 2:54Uh, traditional peers have seen some gains by comparison. AutoNation is up by 80%. Lithia is up by 44%. CarMax actually down 7% in the same period. Ooh.
- 3:04Uh, CEO Ernie Garcia III called Carvana, quote, "The fastest growing and most profitable automotive retailer." He's just putting that out there.
- 3:12Uh, this is Dave Mazza, CEO of Round Hill Financial, said, quote, "This rally is one of the most spectacular recoveries in modern market history." The only story here is the fact that I didn't buy in at $4.
- 3:24That's every dealer and everyone listening to this, or everybody that bought in and, like, sold. But I'm dumb. No, you would've sold way before now. I would've sold way before.
- 3:32There's nobody- That, for s- I mean, I would love to see the list of people that bought in 2022- That bought and held... and held. It's a real short list. There's like- It's gotta be... Ernie Garcia II.
- 3:42[laughs] Ernie Garcia [laughs] I don't know if they bought them, but they were holding them. Um- But- So yeah, I mean, obviously this is a story.
- 3:48Not, I mean, the, the, in the reports talking about, you know, when the tariff news came out and all this, like Carvana obviously saw- Yeah... a disproportionate share of that increase.
- 3:58Yeah, the, I mean, the used car market right now is hot. It doesn't matter where you're at.
- 4:02And for someone that's learned how to create efficiencies in auctions, I think the Adesa purchase came at what everybody l- at what it looked like, oh, that's, that was their demise.
- 4:14I think it was actually the thing that, like, really brought, like, brought them through, right? You create pipelines for success, for reconditioning.
- 4:23You know, the reason why they have such high GPU is because of their reconditioning pipelines and their ability to finance so many of these customers, and their, and then their ability to meet customers where they're at.
- 4:34Mm-hmm. I mean, this is just, it's just a model that we have to look at if we're, uh, uh, for the industry. And it stands to reason why CarMax is losing ground, because Carvana is eating their lunch.
- 4:45The most direct competitor. That, that's my opinion. I would, if I, if you look at, like, the pump in, pump out market share, if you could do that between Carvana and CarMax, I bet that's- Mm... where the loss is.
- 4:53Interesting. You know, I had a, a, a kind of a painful conversation with a friend a couple weeks ago. They were saying that, um, you know, they sold their last two cars to Carvana. They called around, right?
- 5:05They called local dealers. Yep. And they were like, "I don't know. Carvana gave me a number that was a little bit lower, actually." Right? A little bit. But they were like, "We'll be there today to pick it up."
- 5:15He goes, "A guy showed up with a flatbed to my driveway, handed me a check, and left." And so they- Transparent, fast, and easy...
- 5:21so they bought their next vehicle from Carvana and said, "I'm not gonna, unless it's a new car, I'm never buying a vehicle a different way again." How do you argue with that? Mm.
- 5:30I mean, like, every dealer has the capability- Can't argue with that... of picking up a car in a driveway in a local place that day with a check. In, in my opinion, it's, it's all about stopping being precious. Yeah.
- 5:41You gotta stop being precious with your vehicle values, with, with your people's time, with, with anything like that. Brian Kramer- You know? Brian Kramer's ringing the bell as you're saying that. I don't know.
- 5:52[scoffs] Come on. A lot to talk about, but, you know. There's the, there's another side to the conversation, too. We're not gonna just say, like, "Yeah, just be like Carvana."
- 5:58Don't be like Carvana, but in some ways be a lot like Carvana. Yeah. I guess that's what we're sayingYeah. Everyone wants to be like Apple and then Chick-fil-A. Carvana's just one of those ones that's got it right. Yeah.
- 6:09Sp- [laughs] I don't know. Speaking of negative equity- What's up? I mean, we're kinda talking used cars. Segway time. [upbeat music] There's a lot of negative equity going around.
- 6:16A growing share of US car buyers are finding themselves stuck in negative equity with Edmunds reporting the average underwater loan balance at $6,700 in Q2. Whoa. One of the highest levels seen in years.
- 6:2926.6% of new car trade-ins were upside down. That's a four-year high. Wow. Average negative equity climbed to 6754, which is up $500 from last year. Nearly one in three underwater trade-ins carried 5 to $10,000 in debt.
- 6:45Dear goodness. The average monthly payment hit 915 a month, which is a $159 above the industry average.
- 6:53Edmunds even Drury warns, quote, "Many are at risk of getting stuck in a cycle of debt that only grows harder to break over time."
- 7:00This is a story that's like, I, I think is kinda still unfolding 'cause there's still enough, um, you know, disposable income in the marketplace to, you know, in, in a certain tier of buyers to kinda overcome this.
- 7:13But this is one that, you know, it's, it's, it's like an undercurrent story that nobody's really paying attention to that I think over the next, like, two years, if there's not something solved, and w- uh, either by interest rates or by loan terms or, or something in the market that allows for this- Mm-hmm...
- 7:33segment of the market to kinda, like, recoup, maybe, maybe its lease rates come into a place where negative equity can be consumed and, and, and buyers get more in a regular payment cycle. Like, it's gonna be hard to,
- 7:47hard to not see 2008 in this one. Yeah. You know? I, I mean, what is this? 2025, and so we're starting to see the t- probably, man, a lot of people were pushing 60, 72 months during the COVID time, right? Oh, 72, easy.
- 8:02Yeah. So, I mean, we're still- There were 84s coming out all over the place. Yeah, there were. We still have a couple years of this, you know? Yeah.
- 8:08I, I, I think we still have a couple years, but fortunately, um, credit scores are doing well still. Um- Yeah...
- 8:15and, you know, there's enough incentive money, and I think banks enough eager to make loans that we're at least able to, like, maybe not kick the can, but, like, maybe, like, nudge it forward a little bit.
- 8:25And I think also- Well, and I, and I still always go back to Jonathan Smoke's bifurcated market. We, two years ago, heard about that. Um, h- uh, heard him start talking about that a lot, and you still have this.
- 8:36You still have this issue where so much of the market is sidelined- Yeah...
- 8:40due to interest rates, due to affordability, and the market that's continued to keep it strong is the one that has income, that has disposable income, and that can meet these payments.
- 8:52Um, so it's still, like, we're, we're borrowing time, but this, this luck will run out, in my opinion. Uh, speaking about some of the demographic with the most disposable income. Oh. Segway time. There he is.
- 9:07[upbeat music] Because you know that Millennials and Gen Z always grab the headlines, but new research shows that Gen
- 9:14X, those born between nin- 1965 and 1980, may be the most inf- influential consumer group of the next decade. Wow. Gen X is set to remain the world's highest spending demographic all the way through 2033.
- 9:27In 2025 alone, they're projected to drive 507 billion in food and beverage sales, 80 billion in beauty, and 42 billion in alcohol. Nearly 40% use AI a- assistance for shopping recommendations- Whoa, I'm one of those...
- 9:41defying tech-averse stereotypes. So actually, they're- [laughs]... they're using it more. I mean, if you talk to Todd Caputo, he's all over that stuff. Gen Z is not tech-averse. No. That's weird.
- 9:50I mean, like- Well, it's not tech-averse. It's tech, eh, you know? [laughs] Like, the older part of Gen Z gets weird with tech. I mean, yeah. [laughs] That's true. Here's, here's an interesting one.
- 9:5972% of this gener- generation prefers name brands over private label, bucking the store brand trend.
- 10:07Uh, "Gen Xers are the gatekeep- keepers of trillions in spending, effectively serving as the CFOs of three generations," said Wolfgang Feiler of World Data Lab, the one that put this study together. This makes sense.
- 10:20Private label, when Gen Xers grew up, was, like, the worst thing ever. Yeah. Right? Private label was a signal that you just didn't have any money, right? Yep.
- 10:29And then Millennials and Gen Z, like, private label become, became a thing, right? Like, when Kirkland Signature sweatshirts are selling out, right?
- 10:36Because the pu- the ability to share and create social trends changed a lot. You know, like you said, younger Gen Z, I mean, like, you look at, I- I'm sorry, Gen X.
- 10:43You look at Gen X, it's like they founded all the platforms that everyone's spending their time on. That's right. Right? Yep. So it does make sense.
- 10:49Um, but I mean, they, they've, that, that generation has, did, did really well. It's surprising to me they're most influential group through 2033. Well, the, I mean, you think about this.
- 11:00This is, this is the ex- these are the executives. Th- these are the people that have made it. They've made their money. They're, they're, they've, uh, they also understand saving and spending habit trends. Yeah.
- 11:11Um, so that's, that's where I think, like, you get a, a bunch of different, like, things contributing to what we were just talking about: disposable income, ability to spend.
- 11:23Um, you know, the, the, you've, you've grown in life, so you probably got an elevated work status, uh, all the, all the things like that.
- 11:32Um, Nathan actually just, uh, remembered we were talking to Aaron Keating at Public Policy Day, and the, the average new car buyer we're seeing be a higher and higher age, uh- Yeah, hold on. Don't tell me yet.
- 11:46What do you think right now? What do you think the average age of a new car buyer is? Just put a number in your head. Average age of someone coming in to buy a new car. Okay. Tell them what it is, Kyle.
- 11:58It's, it's, like, in the mid-60s. I think it was 63, she said. How about that? Not what you thought likely. Not what you think.
- 12:05You would think in that, in that, like, late 30s, 40s, something like that, people that are aspirational, but old- older, uh, older ages buying those new cars. Anyone bo- born between what?
- 12:14Like 19- And that's why Carvana's winning in the used car game. Oh, we just went full circle. Whoa. All right. Listen, it's Monday. You got a fresh week in front of you. It's just a great week. It's summertime.
- 12:25We got five Saturdays this month. Get out there. Take care of some of the people. Make some business improvements. We will see you here first thing tomorrow.
- 12:32[upbeat music]