Latest / Kentucky Tonight / K-12 Education Policy
Transcript
- 0:08Kentucky. Tonight I'm Renee
- 0:09Shaw, and we thank you so much
- 0:11for joining us this evening.
- 0:12Education continues to be a
- 0:14primary focus for state
- 0:16lawmakers during this 2026
- 0:18Kentucky General Assembly
- 0:19session, as lawmakers continue
- 0:21working on a two year spending
- 0:22plan for the state. What should
- 0:24public education funding look
- 0:26like, and what are the concerns
- 0:27about the first draft released
- 0:29by House Republicans? Should
- 0:31school based decision making
- 0:33councils established during
- 0:34education reforms back in 1990
- 0:36be replaced by advisory
- 0:38councils? Should Jefferson
- 0:40County's school board hand over
- 0:41some of its power to the
- 0:43superintendent? There are bills
- 0:44dealing with recruitment,
- 0:46teacher and administrator pay,
- 0:48financial transparency and
- 0:49leadership development, and the
- 0:51governor and House and Senate
- 0:52Democrats continue to push for
- 0:54expansion of pre-K. Last week,
- 0:56we spoke to four key
- 0:58legislative leaders about
- 0:59education. Well, tonight, the
- 1:01perspective from four education
- 1:02advocates in our Lexington
- 1:04studio. We're glad to have
- 1:05doctor Robbie Fletcher,
- 1:06commissioner of the Kentucky
- 1:07Department of Education, Maddie
- 1:09Shepherd, president of the
- 1:11Jefferson County Teachers
- 1:13Association. And Mike Harmon,
- 1:14state outreach director for the
- 1:16Commonwealth Policy Center. And
- 1:18joining us by video call from
- 1:20Richmond, Virginia. Richard
- 1:22Innis, education analyst with
- 1:23the Bluegrass Institute for
- 1:24Public Policy Solutions. We, of
- 1:26course, want to hear from you
- 1:28tonight. You can send your
- 1:29questions and comments by X.
- 1:30Formerly known as Twitter, at
- 1:33Pub Affairs KET. Send an email
- 1:34to KY Tonight at Keturah or use
- 1:37the web form at Keturah Julie
- 1:40Raque Adams KY tonight. Or you
- 1:41can simply give us a call at
- 1:43one 800 494 7605. Well, welcome
- 1:47to all of our guests, both here
- 1:48in the studio and to Mr. Innis
- 1:50there in Richmond, Virginia.
- 1:51We're so glad that you can join
- 1:53us by video call. Thank you all
- 1:54so much. Well, let's just get
- 1:56started right. With an overall
- 1:58blanket question. I'll start
- 1:59with you, Commissioner. What
- 2:01should public education funding
- 2:04look like in the state? Are you
- 2:06pleased with where you have
- 2:08left off in the previous budget,
- 2:10and what would you like to see
- 2:12as lawmakers craft this new
- 2:14budget for the upcoming
- 2:15biennium?
- 2:15>> I think if you look at House
- 2:17Bill 500, there's some changes
- 2:18that need to be made. First of
- 2:20all, if we look at
- 2:21transportation, one of the
- 2:22things that's missing in that
- 2:23is there's a $40 million
- 2:25reduction in and transportation
- 2:28from fiscal year 25 to fiscal
- 2:29year 24, and that's the
- 2:31baseline for the upcoming year.
- 2:33If you look at the inflation
- 2:34and the change in busses, I
- 2:35think if you look at a bus in
- 2:37the cost when I first became
- 2:38superintendent, you're looking
- 2:39at a 72 passenger bus, probably
- 2:41around $70,000. Now that same
- 2:44bus is $161,000. So and those
- 2:47and those costs continue to
- 2:48rise also to within within the
- 2:51budget. We really feel like
- 2:52that those school systems that
- 2:54made the made the push for that
- 2:56nickel tax to get that
- 2:57equalization, that language is
- 2:59not in there.
- 3:00>> So what does that mean for
- 3:01those who are hearing that and
- 3:03they've heard it, perhaps that
- 3:04lexicon for a long time, but
- 3:06they have very limited
- 3:07understanding. Help us
- 3:07understand.
- 3:08>> One of the things that that
- 3:09in order to get equalized
- 3:11funding, a district has always
- 3:12been charged with passing what
- 3:13we call an equalization or a
- 3:14nickel tax. And once you pass
- 3:16that nickel tax, then whatever
- 3:17you come up with locally is
- 3:19matched, if you will not dollar
- 3:21for dollar, depending on what
- 3:22your property values are for a
- 3:24poor district, that would be a
- 3:25larger percentage for a for a
- 3:27more property rich district,
- 3:28that would be less, but still.
- 3:29Yet in order to get your
- 3:31bonding potential where it
- 3:32needs to be, you have to have
- 3:34that matching fund. So for a
- 3:36district that went on the
- 3:38promise of, hey, we're going to
- 3:39make sure that we have that
- 3:41those nickel funds, that
- 3:42matching funds, it could be the
- 3:43difference between a school
- 3:45versus just a renovation
- 3:47project. As a matter of fact,
- 3:48now, other things that we're
- 3:49always advocate for is an
- 3:52increase in base SEEK. We feel
- 3:53like that's needed, especially
- 3:54with the cost of inflation. We
- 3:56really believe that our
- 3:57teachers need to be paid more.
- 3:58We think that especially if you
- 4:00look in Tennessee with our
- 4:03Tennessee next year, there will
- 4:04be a $50,000 beginning salary
- 4:07for teachers in the state of
- 4:09Tennessee. That's going to be
- 4:10very difficult to recruit
- 4:11teachers, especially on the
- 4:12border.
- 4:13>> What's the average in
- 4:14Kentucky for average?
- 4:15>> I think the average starting
- 4:16is probably in the low 40s,
- 4:17probably around 4344. I don't
- 4:19have that number in front of me.
- 4:21Miss Shepherd may have that, I
- 4:22know, but I think it's in the
- 4:23in the low 40s, I would say
- 4:25some districts as low as 38,000
- 4:27and others may be more
- 4:29depending on where you are in
- 4:30the state. But again, to
- 4:31advocate for that, those funds
- 4:33but and also to making sure
- 4:34that our students have the
- 4:35materials that they need. So
- 4:37baseline SEEK funding also when
- 4:38it comes to transportation,
- 4:40which is a part of that SEEK
- 4:42funding and also that equal
- 4:43equalization, nickel
- 4:45equalization.
- 4:45>> Well, we know that Protect
- 4:46our Schools advocacy group has
- 4:48said, and I think there's even
- 4:50a call right now happening
- 4:51during the show, which we
- 4:52encourage them to kind of hold
- 4:54off for another 50 minutes or
- 4:55so that they are meeting about
- 4:58what they consider to be an all
- 5:00out assault on public education
- 5:02in Kentucky that is embodied in
- 5:03House Bill 500, which is the
- 5:05House Republican budget plan.
- 5:06Do you see it that way? And
- 5:08what are the flaws in that
- 5:10document as it currently stands
- 5:11right now?
- 5:12>> Absolutely. First, thanks
- 5:14for having me here, Renee. I
- 5:16would first start to answer the
- 5:18question by reiterating
- 5:20everything Commissioner said
- 5:21about HB 500. We need
- 5:25investments in public schools
- 5:27rather than continued
- 5:29disinvestment in public schools.
- 5:31I would just repeat that we
- 5:32need continued investment in
- 5:34the base SEEK fund to adjust
- 5:36for inflation. The cost to
- 5:38operate a school has continued
- 5:40to increase over the past 5 to
- 5:4310 years. The cost to buy a bus,
- 5:45which every school needs. The
- 5:46cost to buy a Chromebook, which
- 5:48every school needs, the cost to
- 5:49pay a teacher a competitive
- 5:51rate so we can recruit and
- 5:52retain the best teachers to put
- 5:54in front of Kentucky's kids.
- 5:55Like those costs have continued
- 5:57to rise, and if we don't
- 5:59increase and invest the SEEK
- 6:01funds, we won't be able to
- 6:02educate Kentucky's kids and
- 6:03compete at those levels. I'd
- 6:05also agree that we need to
- 6:07fully fund transportation, and
- 6:10legislators need to come
- 6:11through on that promise. But
- 6:13the question that you asked
- 6:15pertains to the provisions in
- 6:17the bill that put limits in
- 6:21place to what a school district
- 6:24can fund in terms of our
- 6:26insurance. This will not only
- 6:28decimate the insurance. What
- 6:31what a school employee, not
- 6:33only teachers, but bus drivers
- 6:35are able to pay on their
- 6:37paychecks. But state employees
- 6:39across all of Kentucky, we're
- 6:41talking corrections officers,
- 6:43social workers, state troopers.
- 6:45So this is, of course, an
- 6:46assault on public education
- 6:47workers. But it's also an
- 6:49assault on people that are
- 6:50public servants across the
- 6:51state. So we need that taken
- 6:53out of of the bill as well.
- 6:55>> And just to kind of
- 6:57illuminate more of what you're
- 6:58saying, as House Bill 500 now
- 7:01stands, which even the the
- 7:02budget chairman, Jason Petrie,
- 7:03says this is a first draft. It
- 7:05places a 5% cap on employer
- 7:07health plan contributions per
- 7:09year for members who were in
- 7:10these these public systems. So
- 7:12we'll see where that goes. Mr.
- 7:15Harmon, how do you see it? Are
- 7:16you as displeased with this
- 7:18first draft of House Bill 500
- 7:20as your other fellow seatmates
- 7:22here tonight?
- 7:22>> I was 13 years in the House,
- 7:24and what I always knew was the
- 7:26whether it was the governor's
- 7:28budget or whether it was the
- 7:29House budget or whether it was
- 7:30the Senate budget, those were
- 7:32always the beginning place.
- 7:33Those will not be the ending
- 7:35place. Now, you know, as
- 7:37concerned. Certainly we do need
- 7:38to look for an increase a
- 7:39little bit in SEEK. I mean, if
- 7:41you look, since the Republicans
- 7:43have been there, there's always
- 7:44been some sort of increase. We
- 7:46can debate whether it's
- 7:48sufficient or not, but there
- 7:49has been increases with the
- 7:51Republicans came in, they were
- 7:53the first group to actually
- 7:54come in and fully fund the
- 7:56pension arcs for the teachers
- 7:57to make sure that they were
- 7:59taken care of in that regard.
- 8:01The other thing that I would
- 8:02say is that we should look at
- 8:04other ways for funding, in
- 8:08addition to the general fund
- 8:09budget, for instance, you know,
- 8:11in the quote unquote, one big
- 8:13beautiful bill, there were some
- 8:15educational choice options
- 8:16there if we opt in and some
- 8:18people are saying, well, we
- 8:19shouldn't opt into that, but in
- 8:21reality we should, because that
- 8:24allows individuals to give up
- 8:25to $1,700 to a nonprofit. And
- 8:28some of that, yes, will be used
- 8:30for private schools, but it can
- 8:33also be used for public
- 8:36education.
- 8:36>> So a school voucher system
- 8:38or.
- 8:38>> School voucher.
- 8:39>> System, scholarship tax
- 8:40credits.
- 8:40>> You know, there's a big push
- 8:41for universal pre-K. We
- 8:42wouldn't do universal pre-K.
- 8:43But if you're pre-K had tuition,
- 8:47you know, maybe not for
- 8:49everybody, but, you know,
- 8:50tuition, you could use some of
- 8:52those if it was set up properly
- 8:53to be used for public schools
- 8:55as well as well as after school
- 8:57programs. And yes, some of the
- 8:58money will go to private school,
- 9:00but that's okay. It's coming
- 9:01out of federal dollars. It's
- 9:02not coming out of state dollars.
- 9:04>> Voters have said they don't
- 9:05really want to go that route.
- 9:07Right.
- 9:07>> This is a this is a federal
- 9:09program. And the difference is
- 9:10when I was in the House, there
- 9:12was a big push for us to adopt
- 9:14expanded gaming. And it was
- 9:15always said, well, it'll help
- 9:17the kids and we know it. You
- 9:18know, it hurts Kentucky more
- 9:20than it would help the kids.
- 9:21But part of the argument was,
- 9:23well, the money will go outside
- 9:24of the state. Well, the way
- 9:26this bill, this federal bill is
- 9:27written, if Kentucky doesn't
- 9:28opt in, that doesn't stop
- 9:29somebody from taking $1,700 and
- 9:31giving it to an out-of-state
- 9:34one that actually did opt into
- 9:35it. So it's important for us to
- 9:37make sure that every dollar
- 9:38that is available, we can make
- 9:40sure not just for public
- 9:42education, but education in
- 9:44general.
- 9:44>> Have you been talking to
- 9:45some of your former Republican
- 9:48colleagues about putting forth
- 9:49such an idea, putting it in
- 9:51bill form?
- 9:52>> Well, actually, there is a
- 9:53bill form House Bill 88. TJ
- 9:56Roberts has a bill. I don't
- 9:56know whether it will move or
- 9:58not move, but it is one of the
- 10:00things that we should look at
- 10:02as additional options when
- 10:03there is so few educational
- 10:05dollars out there, any
- 10:06additional educational dollar
- 10:07that we can get, you know,
- 10:08whether it's public or private,
- 10:10we know that some of that will
- 10:11make it into the public if it's
- 10:13set up correctly.
- 10:15>> Richard Innes, how do you
- 10:16see things, sir?
- 10:18>> Well, first of all, I'm glad
- 10:20that we've heard about House
- 10:21Bill 88. So it's when we're
- 10:22looking at and all the comments
- 10:25that Mr. Harmon made are
- 10:27absolutely on target. Kentucky
- 10:29is basically going to be giving
- 10:31away money to other states if
- 10:33they don't jump in on this,
- 10:36because you can take your
- 10:38$1,700 and send it up to Ohio
- 10:41or another state that's opted
- 10:42into the program. As far as the
- 10:45overall budgeting concerns go,
- 10:47our expert on financing,
- 10:50Professor John Herron from the
- 10:52University of Kentucky, issued
- 10:53a report about two years ago
- 10:55called K-12 in Kentucky A
- 10:57Summary of Facts and Trends,
- 10:59and it's available online at
- 11:02Blue Grass Institute. And a
- 11:04couple of things he found in
- 11:06here are not what people are
- 11:07commonly hearing. Overall, the
- 11:10funding increase in real
- 11:12dollars from. 2013 to 2022 was
- 11:2024%. And after adjusting for
- 11:23inflation from 1990 to 2022,
- 11:25we've seen a 122% increase in
- 11:28total funding. Now, where that
- 11:31money is all going is certainly
- 11:34not going to the teachers.
- 11:36Average teacher salaries after
- 11:38inflation. Professor Garin
- 11:40found rose very little, only
- 11:43about 1.8 times higher than
- 11:45they were back in 1990. But the
- 11:47per pupil funding overall was
- 11:5120 or 2.22 times higher. So
- 11:53we're getting a lot more money
- 11:54in the system now than we did
- 11:56back when Kerr started. But
- 11:57where is it going? And
- 12:00Professor Garin can answer some
- 12:01of those questions with his
- 12:02report. So we have concerns not
- 12:06so much about is the total
- 12:08amount that we're spending on
- 12:10education inadequate, but are
- 12:13we spending it in the right
- 12:14places and how do we adjust
- 12:16that?
- 12:16>> Well, let me ask
- 12:17Commissioner Fletcher, are
- 12:19those dollars and those
- 12:20increases? Is it going to help
- 12:22with student outcomes? Has it
- 12:24been helping with student
- 12:25outcomes? What's the evidence
- 12:26that more money over this
- 12:27period of time that John Guerin
- 12:29has studied is actually paying
- 12:31off?
- 12:32>> Well, I will say, first of
- 12:33all, that Mr. Harmon would
- 12:35point out something. He's very
- 12:37he's absolutely correct. We are
- 12:38at as far as record highs, as
- 12:41far as numbers that we're
- 12:42getting per pupil now. But if
- 12:43you look at when we talk about
- 12:45where's the money going, if you
- 12:47look at our state test scores
- 12:48in Nape, and also if you look
- 12:50at our our actual state
- 12:51accountability scores, we
- 12:52increase in almost in every
- 12:53area and, and across the board.
- 12:56And then in writing, I think we
- 12:58stayed a little flat, but
- 12:59everything else was an increase.
- 13:00And we're at the highest levels
- 13:02that we have for state testing
- 13:03at this point as we've been
- 13:05nape also, again, some of the
- 13:06highest scores actually since
- 13:08Covid, we've had some of the
- 13:09highest scores we've had since
- 13:10Covid. It's gone into that also,
- 13:12but also to let's reiterate, if
- 13:14you look at just within the
- 13:16past 12 years, the cost of a
- 13:17bus going from 70 some thousand
- 13:19dollars to $160,000, I can tell
- 13:23you that money is going in
- 13:24places where, for example, for
- 13:26that inflationary cost. Now, I
- 13:28will say many districts will
- 13:29will point and make it a point
- 13:31to, okay, you have to make a
- 13:34decision. When inflation goes
- 13:35up that much, are you going to
- 13:37put it to teacher salary? Are
- 13:38you going to put it to
- 13:40materials for students? Are you
- 13:41going to put it to a
- 13:43transportation or are you going
- 13:44to put it to safety? But again,
- 13:46we're very thankful, very
- 13:47thankful for the investments
- 13:48that our legislators have. And
- 13:49it has increased. And we would,
- 13:50but we're lobbying for an
- 13:52additional increase to meet
- 13:53with that inflation.
- 13:53>> What's the additional
- 13:54increase you're lobbying for?
- 13:55>> Well, we'd love to see. And
- 13:57we'd always lobby up to around
- 13:595000 per student, you know. But
- 14:00again.
- 14:00>> It's now at what, 4248 48.
- 14:02>> I'm sorry, $44,586 per
- 14:05student. Now, of course, that
- 14:07depends on your district. You
- 14:08know, every single district is
- 14:09going to be different based on
- 14:11the add ins, whether it be from
- 14:12home hospital, whether it be
- 14:14from Ell populations, whether
- 14:15it be from high poverty areas.
- 14:17So, you know, the add ins and
- 14:18then the local effort. And then
- 14:20if you look at that, how it all
- 14:21goes together, not one single
- 14:23district gets the same amount
- 14:24of money per student, but
- 14:25that's the base amount that you
- 14:27work from. So again, I do want
- 14:28to applaud that the that our
- 14:30legislator has increased, they
- 14:31have increased that base pupil
- 14:33amount. But again we need it to
- 14:35increase to make sure that we
- 14:36can afford the busses and
- 14:37things of that nature. Our test
- 14:39scores are improving and we're
- 14:40thankful for that. Well, I want
- 14:42to thank our teachers for the
- 14:43hard work, the students for
- 14:45their hard work. But again, we
- 14:46are seeing those improvements
- 14:47across the board.
- 14:48>> Mr. Ennis.
- 14:49>> I have to disagree about the
- 14:50test scores. Part of the
- 14:52problem was that some slides
- 14:54that KDE developed for the
- 14:57state board in December were
- 14:59not created properly. They
- 15:02failed to take account of the
- 15:05statistical sampling errors
- 15:06that are present in all the
- 15:08data, and which sometimes mean
- 15:11that a small increase in scores
- 15:13is not statistically
- 15:15significant. And so Nate cannot
- 15:17confirm for us that small
- 15:19changes absolutely did occur.
- 15:21In fact, the slides the board
- 15:23saw in December, if they had
- 15:25been properly annotated, would
- 15:27have made it clear that only
- 15:29Nate fourth grade math showed a
- 15:32statistically significant
- 15:33increase in scores from 2022 to
- 15:372024. Now, the Act, the longest
- 15:41running program that we have,
- 15:43that's giving us a trend line
- 15:44on Kentucky education tells a
- 15:46very, very different story. We
- 15:49started testing 11th graders
- 15:50with the Act back in 2008, and
- 15:54up through 2017, we were seeing
- 15:56nice increases in the Act
- 15:58composite score. However, after
- 16:022017, the Act composite score
- 16:04has been on the skids and that
- 16:06started before Covid. And by
- 16:09the way, if you look at the
- 16:10Nape scores, allowing for that
- 16:12statistical sampling problem,
- 16:14the nape scores are lower
- 16:17recently by a statistically
- 16:19significant amount than they
- 16:20were back around 2015 2017, the
- 16:23same time that the act started
- 16:26on the skids. Our latest Act
- 16:29score is only for composite is
- 16:31only 18.1. That is lower than
- 16:35the score we got way back in
- 16:382008. So we have some problems
- 16:41now. We did show progress on
- 16:42the Kentucky, Summit and
- 16:44assessments, but in most cases
- 16:46it was small and the Nape could
- 16:48not confirm that progress for
- 16:50elementary or middle schools in
- 16:51most cases. And I have got a
- 16:53report out about this slides or
- 16:55issued in December that anybody
- 16:57can access. Again at Blue Grass
- 17:00Institute. Org, it's called
- 17:01evaluating Kentucky's
- 17:02assessment results data
- 17:05emissions and governance. And
- 17:08this talks about the slides
- 17:09that were used in December. I'm
- 17:10working on a follow on that.
- 17:12We'll talk about the additional
- 17:14problems that showed up with
- 17:15slides that the board saw in
- 17:19their 4th February 2026 meeting,
- 17:22but the Act looking at high
- 17:25schools absolutely does not
- 17:27confirm rises in Kentucky
- 17:29Summit assessment scores.
- 17:30>> So I want to bring in the
- 17:32commissioner to to answer that.
- 17:33He takes issue with some of
- 17:35those progress reports. What
- 17:37say you?
- 17:38>> Well, when it comes to you
- 17:40can't compare the act with
- 17:41Kentucky Summit of test
- 17:42Kentucky summative test is
- 17:43content mastery, whereas an act
- 17:46is what is the progress towards
- 17:49your adaptive, your aptitude
- 17:51towards college readiness. So
- 17:52now I will say that we've had
- 17:54some ups and downs in the Act.
- 17:57But now as far as last year, I
- 17:59think we had a 0.1 decrease. If
- 18:01you want to talk about distinct
- 18:03decrease, the statistical
- 18:04significance. But now again, I
- 18:05can say we didn't slide. If you
- 18:07look at the the statistical the
- 18:10statistical significance of the
- 18:12math increase, we're very happy
- 18:13about that. But if you look at
- 18:15it as compared to other states,
- 18:16we are increasing when we're
- 18:18compared to other states as we
- 18:19move forward. So again, you
- 18:21can't really compare an Act
- 18:22score with the Kentucky
- 18:24summative assessment because
- 18:25the summative assessment is
- 18:26about content mastery, whereas
- 18:28the act is college readiness.
- 18:30Now would we want higher scores?
- 18:32Absolutely. I will agree with
- 18:33Mr. Ennis that we want higher
- 18:35scores for our kids. We have
- 18:36that progress. But if you look
- 18:38at all the slides, including
- 18:39the I think we had a slide deck
- 18:41of well over 100 slides for the
- 18:43one in February. You're more
- 18:44welcome to look through all of
- 18:46those. But again, as straight
- 18:47analysis, I don't see any
- 18:49statistical statistical issues
- 18:50that we can see.
- 18:51>> That I want to come back to
- 18:53you real quickly before we move
- 18:54on to other topics to talk
- 18:56about the difference between
- 18:57content mastery versus college
- 18:58aptitude. There is a difference
- 18:59there and a distinction.
- 19:02>> There is a difference. The
- 19:03key is, is the Kentucky
- 19:06summative assessment. Cut score.
- 19:08Set points where it needs to be.
- 19:10And an answer to that comes out
- 19:13of a report that Act
- 19:15Incorporated did back in 2006.
- 19:16The question they were asking
- 19:18then is when we all asked. And
- 19:21that is what skills do kids who
- 19:24are not going on to college but
- 19:27want to get into living wage
- 19:28careers, generally
- 19:29apprenticeship type programs?
- 19:31What skills do they now need in
- 19:33order to succeed in those
- 19:35non-college TRACK living Wage
- 19:37Careers Act very firmly found
- 19:40after talking to business and
- 19:41industry, that business and
- 19:43industry said we need the same
- 19:45skills. Basically the college
- 19:48entrance need. So the idea that
- 19:50there's somehow a difference
- 19:51between Casey and Act, I fully
- 19:55agree. The problem is the KSA
- 19:58is measuring something that
- 19:58doesn't relate to what our kids
- 20:00need anymore, and we need to
- 20:01fix that.
- 20:02>> All right. Thank you for
- 20:03that. We do want to pivot to
- 20:05another perspective. And that's
- 20:07the school governance issues.
- 20:08And there have been several
- 20:10bills, several meaning a few
- 20:11that have already been filed
- 20:12and discussed and acted on and
- 20:14advanced already in this
- 20:15lawmaking session of the
- 20:17Kentucky General Assembly. And
- 20:18I want to start with the site
- 20:19based or school based decision
- 20:21making councils. And the
- 20:22question came and it was
- 20:23answered in a committee last
- 20:24week. Senator Aaron Reed has a
- 20:26bill, Senate Bill 152, that
- 20:29would actually transfer the
- 20:31decision making power that was
- 20:32once closest to students,
- 20:34parents and teachers by the SB,
- 20:36DMs, from the SB, DMs to
- 20:39advisory councils. And I want
- 20:41to ask you, Commissioner
- 20:42Fletcher, what are your
- 20:43thoughts about that? And for
- 20:44those who wonder, well, what
- 20:45did those site based decision
- 20:46making councils do, were they
- 20:48effective and did it actually
- 20:49advance student achievement?
- 20:50What would you say to that? And
- 20:52if changing it, would it make a
- 20:53difference?
- 20:54>> I'd like to see the research
- 20:55behind what what would be the
- 20:57cause to move from the school
- 20:58based decision making model to
- 21:00a advisory council model? I
- 21:03think if you look at the
- 21:05success we've had with our
- 21:06local economy, I think the
- 21:08decisions need to be made
- 21:10locally. So when you have that
- 21:11school based decision making
- 21:12model, the people that are
- 21:13making the decisions are the
- 21:15ones that are closest to the
- 21:16students. So when you have that
- 21:18model, I think that's where we
- 21:19need to stay. Now, I do think
- 21:21that Senator Reed, I think he's
- 21:22got he's put some thought and
- 21:24effort into this. I respect his
- 21:25decision. But just so happened,
- 21:26I believe that it's best to
- 21:28have a school based decision
- 21:29making council to make that
- 21:30policy for that local school.
- 21:32Now, there has been changes
- 21:33over the years. For example, a
- 21:35principal, when a principal
- 21:36selects a teacher, that's
- 21:38through consultation. So the
- 21:39principal already has final
- 21:41decision on who's hired as a
- 21:43teacher. Also too, there's been
- 21:45changes as far as how the
- 21:46principal selected before the
- 21:48superintendent was just one
- 21:49vote. Now the superintendent
- 21:50actually has it's basically a
- 21:52consultation model where the
- 21:54council will come together and
- 21:55make consultation, and then the
- 21:57superintendent selects who is
- 21:59that next principal. So there's
- 22:00been some changes over the year.
- 22:02But overall with that local
- 22:03policy in my opinion, are best
- 22:05made with those people that are
- 22:07at the school on the ground,
- 22:08boots on the ground, next to
- 22:10the kids.
- 22:10>> I want to ask miss Shepherd,
- 22:12what do you think about this
- 22:13measure?
- 22:14>> I would agree with
- 22:15Commissioner Fletcher's
- 22:15position that the decision
- 22:16making needs to lie with those
- 22:18closest to students. Sbmm is
- 22:21often made up of the principal,
- 22:24parents and teachers that work
- 22:25directly in the school. But the
- 22:28real issue here is that we we
- 22:30continue to try, you know,
- 22:33small solutions to try and get
- 22:36better student outcomes when
- 22:37the reality is we need more
- 22:39funding. We're not going to get
- 22:41better student outcomes like
- 22:42the ones that Mr. Ennis or
- 22:44Commissioner Fletcher or, you
- 22:45know, all of the teachers in
- 22:47Kentucky are seeking without
- 22:49investment in public schools. A
- 22:51recent Change Research poll
- 22:52found that 70% of Kentuckians
- 22:55want more investment in public
- 22:57schools. We're not going to get
- 22:58a teacher in every classroom, a
- 23:00bus driver on every bus and the
- 23:02best, most highly trained
- 23:04teachers in every classroom. If
- 23:05we don't have competitive wages,
- 23:07we're not going to bet or get
- 23:09the the highest quality
- 23:11technology in every class.
- 23:12We're not going to get the
- 23:14environments and experiences
- 23:16that will prepare our kids to
- 23:17compete on the global stage. If
- 23:20we're not going to talk about
- 23:22the real solutions, and that is
- 23:24investment in public schools.
- 23:26>> And also, does that
- 23:27translate to meaning more
- 23:29investment in public educators
- 23:31themselves? What should pay
- 23:33look like for Kentucky
- 23:35educators?
- 23:35>> Well, right now and
- 23:37Commissioner Fletcher alluded
- 23:38to this earlier. According to a
- 23:41National Education Association
- 23:43survey of average educator pay
- 23:46across all 50 states, Kentucky
- 23:48ranks in some of the lowest.
- 23:49We're in the low 40s. When you
- 23:51look at average educator pay
- 23:53across the state. And so for us
- 23:55to be able to pull in educators
- 23:57from not only Kentucky but
- 23:59across the country, we have to
- 24:01be able to compete with states
- 24:03across the country. And so
- 24:05raising that educator pay so
- 24:06that we are able to recruit and
- 24:08retain not only within the
- 24:10education profession, but
- 24:12across all professions, is
- 24:13something that we have to do to
- 24:15be able to put the best
- 24:16teachers in front of Kentucky
- 24:18students.
- 24:18>> Mr. Harmon, I want to go
- 24:20back to the school based
- 24:21decision making councils.
- 24:22You've you've been around or
- 24:23you were around a long time in
- 24:25the legislature and you're very
- 24:26familiar with this.
- 24:27>> And during my time there, it
- 24:28was just as commissioner said,
- 24:30there was always that struggle.
- 24:31Of course, the site based
- 24:32councils came around right
- 24:34before I got there, and there's
- 24:35been a struggle ever since. I
- 24:36know when I was in there, there
- 24:38was look, just you said to have
- 24:40the more power with the
- 24:41superintendent and then some of
- 24:42it with the principals. And
- 24:44from that standpoint, we have
- 24:46seen a lot. Now, Aaron Reed's
- 24:47bill, specifically, Senator
- 24:49Reid's bill specifically, there
- 24:50was a Senate committee
- 24:52substitute which blunted a
- 24:53little bit of the concerns, if
- 24:54I remember correctly. But no,
- 24:57we're we're ever changing. And
- 24:58I always believe that. I agree
- 25:00that it does need to be the
- 25:02closest to you. But I also
- 25:04agree that we need to make sure
- 25:05that we have avenues of
- 25:07accountability. And of course,
- 25:08your closest accountability is
- 25:09your school board and your
- 25:11school board, because they are
- 25:12elected by the general public
- 25:14to make sure that they they
- 25:16have they're now the site base
- 25:17council themselves. Like I said,
- 25:19we've seen multiple changes and
- 25:21some of the original concerns,
- 25:22especially for the
- 25:23superintendent. I think
- 25:24sometimes the superintendent
- 25:26had some concerns about having
- 25:27his hand ties and all. We
- 25:29always kind of related to like
- 25:30being the head coach. If you
- 25:32hired a head coach of, you know,
- 25:34UK, you wouldn't bring him in
- 25:35there and not let him pick the
- 25:37assistant coach. And that's
- 25:38kind of what we felt like when
- 25:40I was back.
- 25:40>> So you favor Senate Bill 152,
- 25:42Senator Reid's bill.
- 25:43>> The way with it, the way
- 25:45that it has been changed. Yes,
- 25:46I would be in.
- 25:47>> Favor of it. I want to go to
- 25:49Mr. Innis to get his
- 25:51perspective on this.
- 25:51>> Yes, actually, I did a
- 25:53report on school based decision
- 25:54making back in 2018. And again,
- 25:57school based decision making
- 25:59policy. A closer look is up on
- 26:01the Blue Grass Institute. Org
- 26:03website. And talking about the
- 26:07research that Commissioner
- 26:08Fletcher said he wishes was
- 26:10there, we agree with him
- 26:12because we found out that
- 26:13research on the effectiveness
- 26:14of the school based model all
- 26:17but stopped years ago. There
- 26:19hasn't been any recently other
- 26:20than my report, but we found
- 26:22some things in that report that
- 26:23were pretty disturbing.
- 26:26Basically a very strong
- 26:28indication that parents aren't
- 26:29really interested in school
- 26:30based councils based on the
- 26:33percentage of parents that vote
- 26:34in the school based council
- 26:36elections for the parent
- 26:38representatives. And I ran the
- 26:40recent figures from data that's
- 26:41up in the department's website
- 26:43a day or so ago. And in 2025,
- 26:47Commissioner, there were four
- 26:5144,786 votes cast by parents
- 26:54for school based council
- 26:55members. However, the end of
- 26:57year student membership for
- 26:58that year was over 630,946
- 27:02students. So those votes only
- 27:05account for about 7.1% of the
- 27:07students. Now, that's not going
- 27:08to be an exact 1 to 1
- 27:11relationship, but very clearly,
- 27:13the parent interest compared to
- 27:14the number of kids in school is
- 27:16pretty doggone small. And the
- 27:18reason for that is by law
- 27:20school based councils have
- 27:21always been under the control
- 27:22of the teachers. The the
- 27:25percentage of parents on a
- 27:27school based council, by law,
- 27:28is always going to be less than
- 27:3150%. Parents don't have any
- 27:32control with school based
- 27:33councils and based on the way
- 27:34they vote, I think they know it.
- 27:36So yes, it's time for a change.
- 27:38And we did a part change when
- 27:40we said we want to get the
- 27:42curriculum in the hands of the
- 27:44superintendent, where better
- 27:45expertise of the district wide
- 27:49level can choose a curriculum
- 27:50so that you will have
- 27:52consistent education in every
- 27:54school in that district, at
- 27:55least. And we need to go
- 27:57further with that based on
- 27:58these latest voting figures
- 28:00that tell me that parents still
- 28:02are just disinterested.
- 28:03>> Commissioner Fletcher, I'll
- 28:04give you a chance to respond.
- 28:06>> I think that when you talk
- 28:07to parents, it depends on the
- 28:09district. And I think that one
- 28:10of the things that we hear from
- 28:12our legislators, we want more
- 28:13and more parent involvement,
- 28:14that's a big push, is how can
- 28:16we have more and more parent
- 28:18involvement. So if if we really
- 28:21minimize, if you will, the the
- 28:24authority of the site based
- 28:25council, then I think that
- 28:26we're taking more, more away
- 28:28from that parent involvement.
- 28:30So we believe and I think our
- 28:32legislators, I think people
- 28:33across the Commonwealth believe
- 28:34we need more and more parent
- 28:35involvement. I don't think that
- 28:37this step with school based
- 28:38decision making is that step to
- 28:40to increase parent engagement.
- 28:42>> So. So would you have more
- 28:44parents or more than 50% of
- 28:46parents on the site based
- 28:47council?
- 28:47>> I wouldn't have an issue
- 28:49with it being 50 over 50. Yeah,
- 28:50not at all. Personally, I now
- 28:52because I've worked with a lot
- 28:53of great parents. So, you know,
- 28:55as far as the 32I do, I do like
- 28:57the fact that the, the, the
- 28:59teachers in the, in that
- 29:00building has the ability to
- 29:01make the decisions because they
- 29:03have maybe a little more
- 29:04background, but I would have no
- 29:05issue with it being 50 over 50,
- 29:07to be honest. But with that
- 29:08being said, with under what is
- 29:10now, I don't see a reason to
- 29:12move away from where we are now,
- 29:13just like Mr. Innes said, the
- 29:15research just isn't there to to
- 29:16promote this change.
- 29:17>> So another governor's issue,
- 29:18Senate Bill one, which is the
- 29:20top priority of the Senate,
- 29:21this is Senate President pro
- 29:22tem David Givens bill that
- 29:24would transfer power from the
- 29:25elected board of Jefferson
- 29:26County Public Schools to the
- 29:28district's superintendent. When
- 29:29it comes to day to day
- 29:31operations and other things,
- 29:32miss Shepherd, even the
- 29:33superintendent, Doctor Brian
- 29:34Yearwood, when he testified,
- 29:35said he doesn't need this
- 29:36authority, doesn't want this
- 29:38authority, and doesn't think it
- 29:39would be a good idea. What say
- 29:41you? You were vocal about that
- 29:42particular measure, as I recall.
- 29:44>> Well, much like the bill
- 29:46that that we just talked about
- 29:47with SB 152, Senate Bill one is
- 29:51another bill that follows the
- 29:53pattern of taking away local
- 29:55control and centralizing it.
- 29:57This bill would limit how often
- 29:59the board can meet. It would
- 30:00narrow the school board's
- 30:02authority require a
- 30:04supermajority to overrule a
- 30:06decision of the superintendent,
- 30:08and all of these things
- 30:10together reduce the role of the
- 30:12democratically elected school
- 30:13board. It reduces the school
- 30:15board into symbolic oversight
- 30:18rather than the real
- 30:22representation that Kentuckians
- 30:22deserve in their democratically
- 30:24elected officials. It
- 30:26concentrates authority. It
- 30:27reduces transparency. And right
- 30:30now, the bill is targeted at
- 30:31Jefferson County. But the the
- 30:35criteria is such that this
- 30:36could be another district some
- 30:40other time. And it it limits
- 30:42every community's right to
- 30:44self-governance. And we all
- 30:46need to be really sensitive to
- 30:49this pattern of removing a
- 30:51community's ability, the
- 30:53people's ability, Kentuckians
- 30:55ability to govern themselves,
- 30:57and the continued pattern to
- 30:59concentrate power with one
- 31:01person.
- 31:01>> Well, to your point about
- 31:03perhaps this sets a template
- 31:04for other school districts down
- 31:05the road. Senate President Pro
- 31:07Tem David Givens did say that
- 31:08this really is concerning
- 31:10Jefferson County, because
- 31:11Jefferson County faces unique
- 31:13challenges and needs a
- 31:14different kind of governance
- 31:16structure than other districts.
- 31:18Commissioner Fletcher, are you
- 31:19concerned that this would gain
- 31:21steam and would not just be
- 31:23relegated to Jefferson County,
- 31:25but then could be replicated
- 31:27elsewhere?
- 31:27>> I'm never in favor of having
- 31:29a legislation towards one one
- 31:31particular district. I think
- 31:32that, again, I would love for
- 31:34us to look at if we need to
- 31:36make changes, let's make
- 31:37changes across the Commonwealth.
- 31:38But with that being said, if
- 31:39you look at, I think that I
- 31:41will give Senator Gibbons some
- 31:43credit. He took a lot of time
- 31:44in trying to talk about the
- 31:46complexity and the needs of
- 31:47Jefferson County as compared to
- 31:48other, other districts. You
- 31:49know, the first eight pages
- 31:51talks about the differences
- 31:52between the first 11. But on
- 31:54the other hand, to look at the
- 31:56changes in the tough decisions
- 31:58that Doctor Yearwood and the
- 32:01the school board has already
- 32:03started making, they've started
- 32:04making some tough decisions,
- 32:06working together to move
- 32:07forward. So again, when when
- 32:09the man himself, Mr. Doctor
- 32:11Yearwood, says, I don't need
- 32:13this authority, it would be
- 32:14hard for me to say, okay, let's
- 32:15give him that authority because
- 32:17they are working together as it
- 32:18is to move forward. So and
- 32:20again, I would not want to see
- 32:21this to to make a head of steam
- 32:23to move forward either.
- 32:24>> How do you see it, Mr.
- 32:26Harmon?
- 32:26>> Well, I mean, from the
- 32:28standpoint, I'm not as familiar
- 32:29with Senate Bill one as I need
- 32:31to be. But from what I have
- 32:33seen and what I have read, I do
- 32:35have concern about creating a
- 32:36bill that that basically
- 32:37targets one school district,
- 32:39you know, but some of the
- 32:41things down in there may be
- 32:43very, very helpful. But I also
- 32:45would like to keep as much
- 32:46power in the school boards as
- 32:48possible, both for picking a
- 32:50superintendent and. But you can
- 32:52also argue the other side that
- 32:53once a superintendent is picked,
- 32:55you know, they should have a
- 32:56little more free rein to be
- 32:57able to develop. But if the
- 32:59superintendent himself doesn't
- 33:00want it, then, you know.
- 33:02>> If I may, if I.
- 33:03>> Yes, yes.
- 33:04>> One of the things that in
- 33:05order to make real change in a
- 33:07district, you have to have
- 33:08transparency and trust. Again,
- 33:10I think by keeping it as is,
- 33:13we're protecting Doctor
- 33:15Yearwood, really. And the
- 33:16reason for that is if if one
- 33:17person are making these huge
- 33:19decisions, then there's less
- 33:21trust. If there's more people
- 33:22that's making the decision,
- 33:23that's working together, then
- 33:25you're able to make real change.
- 33:27That's when we are able when we
- 33:28have that trust, transparency,
- 33:30transparency and of course,
- 33:32collaboration as we move
- 33:32forward. So thank you for
- 33:34letting me add that.
- 33:35>> I think a school district
- 33:36operates best, like our
- 33:37government, when there's a
- 33:38three legged stool and each of
- 33:40the three legs holds up the
- 33:42school district, you have the
- 33:43superintendent, the school
- 33:44board and the community that
- 33:45has an investment in the
- 33:47overall well-being and the
- 33:49success of the public school.
- 33:51If any one of those legs
- 33:53becomes, you know, has too much
- 33:55authority, then the stool is
- 33:56not balanced. And so allowing
- 33:59all three of those to have the
- 34:02ability to work together and
- 34:03have a trusting relationship is
- 34:06the best way to have a
- 34:08successful, collaborative,
- 34:10transparent school district.
- 34:12And this bill would create the
- 34:14conditions for that stool to
- 34:15become unbalanced.
- 34:16>> And one of the other
- 34:17provisions of SB one, as we
- 34:19discussed last week, was
- 34:20legislative leaders, is is it
- 34:21allows the superintendent to
- 34:22have $250,000 of, I would just
- 34:24say, a petty cash fund without
- 34:26having to get board approval.
- 34:27What is the wisdom in that,
- 34:28particularly when this district
- 34:29faces a hefty over $150 million
- 34:32budget deficit at this time? Do
- 34:34you understand that?
- 34:35>> I would again, the more
- 34:37people that can be a part of
- 34:38that decision, the better. You
- 34:40know, I wouldn't want that
- 34:41decision. I I'm a former
- 34:42superintendent. I would not
- 34:43want that that much authority
- 34:44as a superintendent to make
- 34:46that type of decision. I would
- 34:47want the input from the board
- 34:49and also others in that room to
- 34:50say, okay, we want to make sure
- 34:52that we're making the best
- 34:53decision for kids.
- 34:54>> Yeah. Mr. Ennis, I'll give
- 34:56you a chance to kind of weigh
- 34:57in on this topic before we move
- 34:59on.
- 34:59>> I think we're the most
- 35:01interesting things about this
- 35:02bill, which was already
- 35:03mentioned, is the fact that the
- 35:05massive number of problems in
- 35:06Jefferson County are outlined
- 35:08in the first eight pages. I
- 35:10don't recall seeing another
- 35:11bill ever go into that much
- 35:15justification for what then
- 35:17follows with the proposed
- 35:18changes. The Jefferson County
- 35:21problem is very severe. It's
- 35:23been going on ever since Kira
- 35:25began. We're not coming up with
- 35:27answers. Maybe this is
- 35:29something we need to try as a
- 35:30new approach. And I think what
- 35:33Senator Givens is trying to say
- 35:34to the Kentucky Supreme Court,
- 35:36who undoubtedly will get a
- 35:37chance to look at this if it
- 35:38goes through, is we have so
- 35:41many problems, you can't limit
- 35:42us from trying something
- 35:44different, whether this is the
- 35:45right answer or not, that
- 35:47remains to be seen.
- 35:48>> And I think Senator Givens
- 35:49would say the reason why he
- 35:51made that justification is
- 35:54because of what the Supreme
- 35:55Court did. Right? To kind of
- 35:56help keep it constitutional.
- 35:57>> So to your point, Renee,
- 35:59this is actually not any
- 36:01different from a previous bill
- 36:02that was enacted. And many of
- 36:04the things that are listed in
- 36:06this version were born out of
- 36:09the things that happened in
- 36:11JCPS while the previous version
- 36:13was implemented. I mean, the a
- 36:15lot of the financial woes that
- 36:17JCPS is experiencing and the
- 36:21transportation crisis that
- 36:22happened several years ago
- 36:24happened while the previous
- 36:25version was implemented. So we
- 36:28tried this solution. It didn't
- 36:30prevent many of the issues that
- 36:32then manifested. So we should
- 36:35try different solutions. And
- 36:36fully funding public schools is
- 36:38one we haven't yet tried, and
- 36:39that one might be one for us to
- 36:41explore.
- 36:42>> And on that point about this
- 36:44governance and the power of
- 36:46school boards, etc. should
- 36:48school boards in Jefferson and
- 36:49Fayette County, this is a
- 36:50different bill. Senate Bill 114
- 36:51be appointed rather than
- 36:53elected.
- 36:56>> I'll start with that.
- 36:57>> You'll start.
- 36:58>> With that again. Local
- 36:59authority. You know, in order
- 37:01to have transparency, in order
- 37:03to have trust, in order to have
- 37:06a positive outcomes, you have
- 37:08to have everyone working
- 37:09together, in my opinion. So if
- 37:11you look at someone appointing
- 37:13the school board, whether it be
- 37:16Jefferson Fayette or Lawrence
- 37:17County, Graves County or others,
- 37:19you're taking that control out
- 37:21of the local vote, the local
- 37:23voter. So again, they need to
- 37:24have that authority to say,
- 37:25these are the people that we
- 37:27want on our school boards.
- 37:28These are the people that we
- 37:30want to be there. Again, I
- 37:31think that Senator Gibbons, I
- 37:32give he's a friend of mine. I
- 37:34think that he's put a lot of
- 37:36work into this. But on the
- 37:37other hand, too, I really
- 37:39believe that in order to have a
- 37:40true change in culture, you
- 37:42have to have that buy in from
- 37:43the local local community, the
- 37:45local voter.
- 37:45>> Okay. Any other comment on
- 37:47that, Mr. Ennis, do you care to
- 37:48make one more comment before I
- 37:50ask Mr. Harmon for his.
- 37:51>> I'm not so sure that pulling
- 37:53authority away from the local
- 37:54boards is the way to go. I
- 37:56think what the legislature
- 37:57needs to look at is increasing
- 37:59the accountability for boards
- 38:01that are not performing. We
- 38:04should certainly have elected
- 38:06boards, there's no question
- 38:07about that. But what happens
- 38:09when they don't perform? What
- 38:11happens when we have a
- 38:12situation in Jefferson County?
- 38:13We don't have a good system
- 38:15right now where the state Board
- 38:18of Education or the legislature
- 38:20or whatever can take a look at
- 38:23a system that's clearly got
- 38:24major problems and say, we need
- 38:26to replace this board because
- 38:28it's dysfunctional. I think
- 38:30that's where we really need to
- 38:31go.
- 38:31>> All right.
- 38:32>> I truly believe we should
- 38:34still have an elected school
- 38:37board. If there's concerns
- 38:38about whether the school board
- 38:39is capable of doing it. I know
- 38:41there's a bill, Senate Bill 71,
- 38:43that passed an increase. It's
- 38:46not huge amount, but it creates
- 38:47some additional education for
- 38:48school board members, which if
- 38:50you're going to be in education,
- 38:52it's always good to be
- 38:53continually educated on how to
- 38:55to do the job that you've been
- 38:56elected to do. But it
- 38:57definitely should be elected.
- 38:58>> Because we're going to take
- 39:00a break from that stuff. To go
- 39:02to a question from Jeff Sims in
- 39:03Caldwell County about AI, he
- 39:05says ChatGPT use among school
- 39:06age children, particularly
- 39:08teenagers, has seen rapid
- 39:09growth, with approximately 26%
- 39:11of U.S. teens aged 13 to 17
- 39:13reporting they've used the tool
- 39:15for schoolwork as of early as
- 39:16of 2025, according to the Pew
- 39:18Research Center. He says as AI
- 39:20use continues to rise, will
- 39:22physical school attendance
- 39:23continue to decline in the
- 39:24Commonwealth as the option of
- 39:26homeschooling or other paths
- 39:28expands? Interesting question.
- 39:31>> Very interesting question.
- 39:32And I'll start with that one.
- 39:34If one of the things that we've
- 39:35actually brought forward with
- 39:36with Senator Givens, we talked
- 39:37we met with him last week to
- 39:39talk about, you know, a network.
- 39:41How do we take our digital
- 39:42learning coaches that we have
- 39:43in place and then also include
- 39:45AI specialists, AI teacher
- 39:48specialists that can say, you
- 39:49know, how are teachers using AI
- 39:51to make their jobs easier? But
- 39:53more importantly, how are they
- 39:55also allowing students to use
- 39:57AI to produce content, whether
- 39:59it be written or video, but
- 40:01also to how are they using AI
- 40:02in industry and the career
- 40:04fields, but also how to program
- 40:06the computer science aspect of
- 40:08actually programing AI. So I
- 40:10think that if we look at we
- 40:11need to strengthen our network
- 40:13and have some funding there as
- 40:14it relates to AI and how we're
- 40:16using that in the classroom and
- 40:17making sure our students have
- 40:19the opportunity. Because I tell
- 40:20teachers all the time, I'll
- 40:21never believe that a teacher
- 40:23can be replaced by AI, but you
- 40:25can be replaced by a teacher
- 40:26that is using AI. Yeah,
- 40:28definitely.
- 40:28>> Right. That's that's a good
- 40:29point. Well, the AI task force
- 40:31that has been in play for a
- 40:32little while, Senator Amanda
- 40:35Mays Bledsoe and Josh Bray,
- 40:36they've been working on this.
- 40:37Do you anticipate legislation
- 40:39to be filed when it comes to AI
- 40:41use in the classroom?
- 40:44>> I think there's a
- 40:45possibility. I think we're
- 40:46still trying to figure out
- 40:47what's happening with at the
- 40:48federal government or what
- 40:49we're allowed to do and what we
- 40:51can't do. But with that being
- 40:53said, I do. I would expect that
- 40:54hopefully we can get some
- 40:56allocation there to directed
- 40:57towards AI and education, and
- 40:58that's something that we'd like
- 40:59to see moving forward.
- 41:00>> What are the concerns you're
- 41:02hearing about from parents,
- 41:03teachers, students about AI in
- 41:04the classroom?
- 41:04>> I mean, of of course,
- 41:06they're broad concerns about
- 41:08the use of AI in the classroom
- 41:10and how it might be used for
- 41:11good or evil, and replacing
- 41:15educators, of course. But on
- 41:16the attendance question, I, I
- 41:19did want to use that question
- 41:20to talk about HB 257, which is
- 41:23the proposal to improve and
- 41:26modernize our assessment and
- 41:27accountability system and put
- 41:29an emphasis on the types of
- 41:31learning experiences that bring
- 41:33kids to school. One of the
- 41:35terms that is that you'll see a
- 41:38lot in that bill. And in the
- 41:39United We Learn work is vibrant
- 41:42learning experiences. Kids come
- 41:44to school if they're
- 41:46experiencing learning and
- 41:49environments where they feel
- 41:51capable, where they're
- 41:53experiencing social networks, a
- 41:54sense of belonging, and where
- 41:56they're becoming better
- 41:57versions of themselves, and an
- 42:00emphasis on vibrant learning
- 42:01experiences where they're
- 42:03learning to go out into the
- 42:04real world. They're setting
- 42:06goals about what their life
- 42:07might be like after school.
- 42:09They're getting to collaborate
- 42:10with students and work with
- 42:11community partners. All of
- 42:13these sorts of things are
- 42:14becoming an even bigger
- 42:15emphasis than they already are
- 42:17in Kentucky, and it's those
- 42:18types of learning experiences
- 42:20that are going to draw kids
- 42:23into school and increase
- 42:25attendance, whether AI is a
- 42:26part of that or not, I'm sure
- 42:28it will be. I'm sure teachers
- 42:29will use AI as assistants to
- 42:32magnify and multiply what a
- 42:34teacher or what a student is
- 42:36able to do, but I think the
- 42:38real answer about attendance is
- 42:40are kids engaged? Do they want
- 42:42to be there? Do they feel like
- 42:43they're part of a community?
- 42:45And as long as we are able to
- 42:47create experiences where the
- 42:48answer to that question is yes,
- 42:50then they will come to school.
- 42:51We will have attendance. I
- 42:52don't think it will have as
- 42:54much to do with AI.
- 42:55>> Commissioner.
- 42:56>> Again, thank you so much for
- 42:57bringing up House Bill 257 and
- 42:59as a matter of fact, I think
- 43:01Mr. Ennis also gave us a good
- 43:02segue earlier. Our kids are so
- 43:04much more than a test score.
- 43:05Now, granted, our our test
- 43:07scores are higher than they've
- 43:08been since Covid. Let's let's
- 43:09be very clear about that again.
- 43:11Mr. Anderson, I may disagree
- 43:13about some statistical analysis,
- 43:14but they are the highest
- 43:15they've been since Covid. Now,
- 43:18with that being said, we're
- 43:20looking for two parts in House
- 43:22Bill 257. And I think it's a
- 43:23phenomenal step forward. First
- 43:25of all, we still have math,
- 43:27science, social studies and
- 43:28reading as the foundational
- 43:29part for that CSI calculation
- 43:31or for the red, blue, green and
- 43:34yellow rating system. We still
- 43:36have that in there, but we also
- 43:38are moving from the element of
- 43:40change, comparing two groups
- 43:41from one to another to having
- 43:43an individual student growth.
- 43:45The most important indicator
- 43:46that for a school, in my
- 43:48opinion, is where did you get
- 43:49the child and where did you
- 43:51take them? That's why growth
- 43:52has to be a part of it. And
- 43:54that's just one part. The other
- 43:55part is the local
- 43:56accountability piece, just like
- 43:57what Mr. Innis said earlier,
- 43:59our kids need so much more.
- 44:01They need foundational reading
- 44:02and math skills. Absolutely.
- 44:04Without a doubt. You'll never
- 44:05hear me say otherwise. But they
- 44:06also need to be communicators,
- 44:09collaborators. They need to be
- 44:10creative thinkers. They needed
- 44:11to be global learners. And
- 44:14that's what this second piece
- 44:15is. It's about local
- 44:17accountability. Our kids need
- 44:18those durable skills, just like
- 44:20the data that we're talking
- 44:21about earlier. They have to
- 44:22have those durable skills. They
- 44:23have to have grit and
- 44:25persistence to be able to be
- 44:26successful. That's what 257
- 44:28takes a step towards. Yes, we
- 44:30still have the one piece where
- 44:31we're looking at CSI
- 44:33calculation, and we're also
- 44:34looking at color ratings. And I
- 44:36have some other points about
- 44:37color ratings, but that will
- 44:38come at a later time. But on
- 44:40the other hand, we also have
- 44:42that local accountability where
- 44:43we want kids to have the
- 44:44vibrant learning opportunities,
- 44:45where they're doing defenses of
- 44:46learning, project based
- 44:48learning, where they're doing
- 44:49defenses of learning, where
- 44:50they're doing passion projects.
- 44:52You know, I'll give you a good
- 44:54example if you want to look at
- 44:55a a good project based learning,
- 44:57there's so many of those across
- 44:58the state. And I hate to
- 45:00mention one because there's
- 45:01thousands, but if you go to
- 45:02Madisonville, North Hopkins,
- 45:03they just finished a recently a
- 45:06freight box challenge where
- 45:07they finished a medical office.
- 45:09They framed the inside of an
- 45:10office in their geometry class,
- 45:12carpentry class, their AG class.
- 45:14And now that box sits in
- 45:17Liberia, Africa. You heard me
- 45:20correctly. That is the only
- 45:21medical office in that
- 45:23community in Liberia, Africa.
- 45:25And it was built in
- 45:26Madisonville, North Hopkins.
- 45:28That is a vibrant learning
- 45:29experience. And there's
- 45:30hundreds of those. That's the
- 45:31best thing about being
- 45:32commissioners to see that
- 45:33happen. House Bill 257 is a
- 45:34step towards making sure our
- 45:36kids have more and more vibrant
- 45:37learning. And just like Mr.
- 45:39Ennis said earlier, our kids
- 45:40need more skills when it comes
- 45:42to that workplace, and that's
- 45:43what this is about.
- 45:44>> And on the AI specifically,
- 45:46it's it's interesting. Of
- 45:47course, I was the guy that
- 45:48years ago said I didn't want a
- 45:50kid to have a calculator until
- 45:51he was in third grade, because
- 45:53you got to build that math.
- 45:55Chris I was a math guy. I
- 45:57jokingly always say, I graduate
- 45:58with a triple major in math,
- 46:00statistics, and theater. That
- 46:01way I knew the math, knew the
- 46:03stats, what I didn't know, I
- 46:04just act like I knew. So
- 46:06politics, it worked out very
- 46:07well. But you know, it's
- 46:08important to get those
- 46:09foundational items, the math,
- 46:10the the writing, the, you know,
- 46:13all of it, all of reading,
- 46:14writing, arithmetic that we
- 46:15always talked about. And for me,
- 46:17the more you use tools, it's
- 46:18important. We have to learn
- 46:19tools. We have to get into the
- 46:21modern age, but we also have to
- 46:23build those structures where
- 46:24we're thinking about it and
- 46:25understand why they work
- 46:26beforehand. And AI is
- 46:28interesting. You know, I was I
- 46:29was going to write an op ed and
- 46:31I had a certain categories I
- 46:33was going to do, and I did
- 46:34write it separately myself. But
- 46:36just for the fun of it, I keyed
- 46:38into one of the AI's. I said,
- 46:39right, this AI under these
- 46:41parameters and put it in the
- 46:42voice of former auditor Mike
- 46:44Harmon, and it spit out one
- 46:45that was a little different
- 46:46than what I had wrote. But it
- 46:48it could have been something
- 46:49that I could have written. And
- 46:51I read that to my wife and she
- 46:53said, I thought you wrote that.
- 46:54So I do understand it's going
- 46:56to be a challenge, but it's
- 46:57going to be a great tool. But
- 46:59we also have to be careful. And
- 47:01of course there's some
- 47:02situations, they're putting
- 47:03some parameters. But in some of
- 47:04the AI's sadly have led kids to
- 47:06take their life. And so we have
- 47:08to be careful. It's like with
- 47:10anything it can be used like a
- 47:11brick, it can be used to break
- 47:13a window, or it can be used to
- 47:15build a school. It's just a
- 47:17tool.
- 47:17>> Yeah. Mr. Ennis, your
- 47:18thoughts on AI?
- 47:20>> I think the AI question is a
- 47:22very serious one, and I'm glad
- 47:26that House Bill 257 was brought
- 47:29up in relation to it, because
- 47:31there's some issues with that
- 47:32that get into this AI
- 47:33discussion as well. I read a
- 47:35very interesting paper on
- 47:37Substack just recently called
- 47:39Privileging the Already
- 47:40Privileged, and it discusses
- 47:42how these student centered
- 47:46approaches, the demonstration
- 47:48projects, and all of that
- 47:49actually work to privilege the
- 47:52already privileged. But they
- 47:53don't work well for kids who
- 47:56aren't privileged, and this has
- 47:57been known for a long time. You
- 47:59can go back and look at
- 48:00research from an extensive
- 48:02program called Project Follow
- 48:04Through, which actually started
- 48:05in Lyndon Johnson era and was
- 48:07the most heavily funded
- 48:09research project on education
- 48:11ever attempted. And what they
- 48:14found was when they looked at
- 48:15about ten different programs,
- 48:17most of them based on
- 48:19progressive education theories,
- 48:20but one based on what's called
- 48:22direct instruction. It was
- 48:24direct instruction that ran
- 48:26away with the best performances
- 48:28of all of these models. And the
- 48:30reason, in part, was the direct
- 48:33instruction model is the one
- 48:34that helped the minorities and
- 48:36the disadvantaged students the
- 48:38most. So I have a lot of
- 48:40concerns about House Bill 257,
- 48:44and I'm not sure it's the right
- 48:45time to be doing that bill in
- 48:47the first place. For one thing,
- 48:49here we go again, changing a
- 48:53accountability system built
- 48:54around what we currently call
- 48:56the Kentucky summative
- 48:57assessments, which only started
- 48:58in 2022. And we're going to
- 49:01change it again right at the
- 49:03time when we really don't know
- 49:04if we're recovering from Covid,
- 49:06I can promise you and I can
- 49:08show you the data if anyone
- 49:09wants to challenge me that. If
- 49:10you look at Nape, if you look
- 49:12at Act, we are in much worse
- 49:14shape now than we were back
- 49:16around 2015. 2017 time frame,
- 49:18much worse shape than we were
- 49:20then. That's not a question.
- 49:22That's a fact. And right now,
- 49:26at this time, the department
- 49:28already has changed from using
- 49:31the act, which gives us a 18
- 49:34year long trend line. And we're
- 49:35going to start using the SAT.
- 49:37We're throwing out the longest
- 49:39trend line of performance we
- 49:40have on Kentucky schools. It
- 49:42makes no sense. Worse, I'm not
- 49:45sure that the S-a-t was adopted
- 49:49properly. The Department of
- 49:50Education did it on its own and
- 49:52negotiated the contract. The
- 49:54state board was never involved,
- 49:56and other agencies that are
- 49:58supposed to be involved with
- 49:59changes to the Assessment
- 50:00Accountability Program,
- 50:02specifically the Office of
- 50:03Education Accountability and
- 50:06the education, Assessment and
- 50:08Accountability Review
- 50:09Subcommittee, were not involved
- 50:10either. I looked through the
- 50:11subcommittee's minutes going
- 50:13back well before this action
- 50:14took place. There was no
- 50:16discussion. I called OCA and
- 50:18got confirmation they had never
- 50:20been involved either. And so
- 50:22here we go, dropping a very
- 50:24important test with a lot of
- 50:25important trends. And House
- 50:27Bill 257 is interesting because
- 50:29it has the changes the
- 50:30commissioner wants, but it's
- 50:32interesting in that bill, you
- 50:34will find the wording of the
- 50:36requirements for the college
- 50:38entrance test to be used as
- 50:39part of Kentucky's assessment
- 50:40program. It says we're going to
- 50:42have English reading, math and
- 50:45science. Well, I got news for
- 50:47you. The S.A.T. doesn't test
- 50:49English as a specific subject,
- 50:51and it doesn't test science as
- 50:53a specific subject either. I'm
- 50:55told the SAT says, oh, well,
- 50:56we're going to create a SAT
- 50:58grade for you based on what we
- 51:01got out of English and or. I'm
- 51:03sorry, get out of reading and
- 51:06writing and math. But I don't
- 51:08see how you do that without
- 51:10biasing those subjects towards
- 51:12science and away from other
- 51:14areas that kids who are good in
- 51:17literature, programs and so
- 51:18forth could do very well with
- 51:19with the reading program, but
- 51:20might not do so well if they
- 51:22have to read a scientific item
- 51:24and then answer it.
- 51:25>> So I want to I want to bring
- 51:27in the commissioner to talk
- 51:28about that. Thank you for
- 51:30bringing up the segue to we
- 51:31know that is state law, right?
- 51:33Did that require the move from
- 51:34the Act to the SAT? And what
- 51:36was the process by which that
- 51:38contract was entered with the
- 51:40S.A.T.
- 51:40>> When we went through the
- 51:42process that we had to go
- 51:43through was it's a procurement
- 51:45process. So state law says we
- 51:46have to have a college
- 51:48admissions irradiance exam. So
- 51:49what we did was we went through
- 51:51the procurement from the Office
- 51:52of Finance, the cabinet, and
- 51:54then followed to the t the what
- 51:56we were supposed to do. You did
- 51:57have that SAT came in with a
- 52:00lower bid. So if you're looking
- 52:01at two different systems,
- 52:02you're looking at approximately
- 52:06$150,000 per year difference.
- 52:07So there is a it was a
- 52:09procurement then also too, if
- 52:10you look at the the quality,
- 52:12you look at the adaptive test
- 52:14with the SAT was also another
- 52:16part that made this again was a
- 52:18better test. Now this was the
- 52:20same process that was used to
- 52:21give A.C.T. act was actually in
- 52:24statute as act. The American
- 52:27College Test was called that
- 52:28the act was in statute. You had
- 52:30to use the act. And then in the
- 52:332016 or somewhere in that
- 52:34neighborhood, there was a
- 52:35change in the law to say that
- 52:37you could that had to be a
- 52:38college admissions test. So
- 52:39that means now you bid it out.
- 52:41So if you go through that
- 52:43bidding process through
- 52:44Procurement Act one it and then
- 52:46and that contract was finished,
- 52:48we went through the procurement
- 52:49process again. And now Saturday
- 52:51one. Now I will say, if you
- 52:54look at what the act again is
- 52:57not a part of KSA, it is one of
- 53:00the transition readiness
- 53:01measures. You can also get
- 53:04college if you get a college
- 53:05certificate. I'm sorry, an
- 53:07industry certification. If you
- 53:08get college readiness scores,
- 53:09which you can also get on the
- 53:11SAT and you get 18, 19, 20. I
- 53:13think where the benchmarks for
- 53:14Act, then you could be quote
- 53:16unquote transition ready. It
- 53:18was never a part of KSA proper
- 53:20except well, I'm sorry. Rewind.
- 53:22It used to be a part of KSA
- 53:24years ago. It was the science
- 53:26test. But the science reasoning
- 53:27does not measure science
- 53:29content. KSA does. We have a
- 53:32science KSA exam now. The SAT
- 53:35does a science analysis score.
- 53:38So if you look at how the Act
- 53:40does science reasoning, you
- 53:41read passages and you look at
- 53:42data analysis and you make
- 53:44interpretations. So my question
- 53:45back is how is it any different
- 53:47to read a reading passage that
- 53:49has science content in it to
- 53:50make interpretations about
- 53:52science scores any different
- 53:53than what the science reasoning
- 53:55was? They're not the exact test.
- 53:56I'm not trying to say they are,
- 53:58but he is right. It is an
- 54:00interpretation score. Science
- 54:01analysis. They're not. There's
- 54:02not a specific science section,
- 54:04so it is a shorter test. With
- 54:06that being said, you know, if
- 54:08if you want to have the same
- 54:10act every year, then it should
- 54:11have just stayed act and
- 54:13statute. But it didn't. It
- 54:15changed.
- 54:16>> And this is saving the
- 54:17department. How much money. By
- 54:18going with the.
- 54:19>> It could save us well over a
- 54:21million, million dollars over,
- 54:22over the next few years of the
- 54:24contract. If we go the full
- 54:25nine years.
- 54:26>> We only have just a couple
- 54:28of minutes left. I'm going to
- 54:29ask if other panelists have a
- 54:31comment about the switch to the
- 54:32SAT. Does it matter to you?
- 54:34>> I think I would just
- 54:35reiterate the message that
- 54:36Commissioner Fletcher gave
- 54:37earlier, which is that our kids
- 54:38are more than test scores.
- 54:40>> Mr. Harmon.
- 54:40>> I like a constant baseline,
- 54:42but I also understand, you know,
- 54:44when we're talking about
- 54:45funding and appropriations, you
- 54:47know, if there's a way to save
- 54:49money and you're following
- 54:50procurement laws. As a former
- 54:51auditor, we like to follow the
- 54:53procurement laws than I do
- 54:55understand.
- 54:56>> Last question, and this is
- 54:57coming from Tom Miller from
- 54:58Owen County. And I'm going to
- 54:59have miss Shepherd answer this
- 55:01question. How does the teachers
- 55:02union influence school board
- 55:03members in Jefferson County and
- 55:05Fayette County? But you are
- 55:06part of Jefferson County in
- 55:07regards to endorsements?
- 55:09>> Well, much like any
- 55:11constituent, teachers unions
- 55:14have the ability to pool their
- 55:16resources to endorse a
- 55:17candidate.
- 55:19>> Any comment about further
- 55:20comment about that, Mr. Harmon?
- 55:22>> Well, you know, from the
- 55:23standpoint I do like anything,
- 55:26it's an election cycle and
- 55:27everybody has the opportunity
- 55:28to pick who they want to pick.
- 55:30You know?
- 55:31>> Well, it's been a really
- 55:32good discussion. I thank you
- 55:33all for being here. Education
- 55:35has been the dominant issue so
- 55:37far in this legislative session.
- 55:38But we'll talk more about what
- 55:40lawmakers can still do in the
- 55:42remaining days. And next time
- 55:44on Kentucky tonight, we will
- 55:45talk about the midpoint of the
- 55:46session, which will be a little
- 55:48bit beyond. When we come to you
- 55:49next Monday night, we'll have
- 55:51legislative leaders to be with
- 55:52us next Monday night to talk
- 55:53about where things stand and
- 55:55where they see it going. Our
- 55:56coverage of the 2026 Kentucky
- 55:58General Assembly continues
- 55:59every weeknight on Kentucky
- 56:01Edition, which we hope you'll
- 56:02join us for at 630 eastern, 530
- 56:04central, and, of course, Bill
- 56:05Bryant and a team of working
- 56:07journalists in Kentucky discuss
- 56:08the news of the week on comment
- 56:09on Kentucky Friday at 8:00
- 56:11eastern, seven central, right
- 56:13here on KET. Thanks so very
- 56:14much for watching. I'm Renee
- 56:16Shaw and I'll see you tomorrow
- 56:17night on Kentucky Edition. Take
- 56:18good care.
- 56:35It was a very good
- 56:36one, though.
- 56:37>> It was a good one.
- 56:38>> So if you're going to do one,
- 56:40I mean, make it big, right? Go
- 56:42big or go home.
- 56:43>> Go big or.
- 56:44>> Go home. Yes. Thank you.
- 56:45Dick, I'm sorry we didn't get
- 56:47to come back to you, but
- 56:48because you can't see the timer,
- 56:50I needed to get out on time. Or
- 56:52else the next program gets mad
- 56:53at me. So I'm sorry I