Latest / Politics with Paul / Politics with Paul #26: What Really is a Political Independent?
Transcript
- 0:01Welcome back to another edition of the politics with Paul podcast with your host, Paul Reeder.
- 0:09Today, we're going to talk about political independence.
- 0:13Two main parties are obviously Democrats and Republicans, but recent decades have shown an
- 0:19increase in the number of voters that identify as independent where they issue both of the
- 0:25main parties.
- 0:27Alongside that has been a general rise in dissatisfaction with both the Democratic and
- 0:32Republican parties over the past couple decades.
- 0:35Gallup polling results have recently said 58% of respondents said a third party is needed to
- 0:41do an adequate job of representing the American people.
- 0:45Now some of you watching this may have such a bill of gripes, but whether you are democrat,
- 0:50republican, independent, or whatever the case may be, there is a lot that's misunderstood
- 0:56about independents, who they are, what they think, why they think the way they do, how they
- 1:02behave in elections, and so on.
- 1:05That's a large part of why I wrote my book, why independents rarely win elections and how they
- 1:11could become more competitive.
- 1:14One such misunderstanding, which I discussed in chapter two, is what really is an independent?
- 1:21For today's podcast, we explore that question.
- 1:24How do we define an independent?
- 1:27How do different states define independence in voter registration?
- 1:30How many independents are there in The United States?
- 1:35And so on.
- 1:35So let's get into it.
- 1:42First or hang on.
- 1:44First of all, basic definition of an independent.
- 1:48It's one of those questions that seems quite straightforward, but it really isn't.
- 1:53You can ask five different people what being an independent is, and they can give you five
- 1:59totally different answers.
- 2:01Does the definition include third parties?
- 2:03So libertarian, green, constitution.
- 2:07So we're just saying, are they just independent of the two main parties?
- 2:11So they're just not Democrat or Republican.
- 2:13Does an independent mean that they don't have a party at all, so we're not even a third party?
- 2:18We are exclusively no party whatsoever.
- 2:21Do we say that?
- 2:23What about people who call themselves independent Democrats or independent
- 2:27Republicans as there have sometimes been throughout US election history.
- 2:32You go back into congressional election history from decades past.
- 2:38Every once in a while, you see people that identify as independent Democrats or
- 2:42independent Republicans.
- 2:43It was also Minnesota that for a time, the Republican Party briefly changed their name to
- 2:49independent Republicans.
- 2:51Well, not briefly.
- 2:52It was for, well, maybe, like, something like twenty years.
- 2:56But, what about them?
- 2:59Do they count as independents?
- 3:01Also, there are some third parties that are named some variation of independent party or
- 3:07independence party, and sometimes voters will register with those parties mistakenly when
- 3:13they're just trying to register as no party at all.
- 3:16They just see the independence didn't think, oh, that's what I'm supposed to register as.
- 3:19But, really, they were just trying to find no party whatsoever.
- 3:25You also gotta remember that there's a difference between independent, independent,
- 3:30and moderate.
- 3:32It is a difference because one refers to partisanship and one refers to ideology.
- 3:38Talked before in the past about how Republicans, yes, typically are conservative,
- 3:42but they're not always conservative, and not every conservative is a Republican.
- 3:48Democrats, Democrat and liberal is not the exact same thing, although they're very
- 3:53correlated.
- 3:54It's a similar thing with independents.
- 3:56Not all of them are moderate.
- 3:58In fact, for some of them, their voting history and their views on political issues actually
- 4:05indicates that sometimes lean more heavily to either the democratic or republican side than
- 4:10an actual Democrat or Republican is actually towards that side.
- 4:17And people also have varying reasons for why they why they identify as an independent.
- 4:23Maybe they really are independent.
- 4:25Maybe they are super middle of the road, very centrist.
- 4:29They just or they don't know what exactly the two parties are really about, so they just go
- 4:36as an independent just because it's just easier for them to do that.
- 4:42It could be a disaffected Democrat or Republican that thinks their, quote, unquote,
- 4:46normal party, the one that you would typically expect a conservative or liberal to identify
- 4:52with, is too far to their side.
- 4:55Maybe they think Republicans are too far to the right or that Democrats are too far to the left
- 4:59even though they would normally side with one of those parties, or they think their side is
- 5:05not far enough to their side of the spectrum.
- 5:09Maybe they actually think the Republicans are not far enough to the right, or they think that
- 5:14Democrats are not far enough to the left.
- 5:17And candidates specifically might go independent because they couldn't win their
- 5:21party's primary for whatever office they were running for.
- 5:25You see that maybe not frequently, but you see a decent amount every so often.
- 5:31So all sorts of things to account for when you're talking about how we define an
- 5:36independent, not just for voters, but for people who run for office, people who win in
- 5:43elected office, people who campaign, all sorts of factors that go into it.
- 5:47So there's really not a clear cut, okay.
- 5:51This is what an independent is because it means different things to different people just like
- 5:56being a Republican means different things to different Republicans sometimes, or being a
- 6:02Democrat means different things to some Democrats versus others.
- 6:07We have a tendency to think that words in politics have a specific meaning when sometimes
- 6:15they don't, or some people try to tell you that it should be a specific meaning that they
- 6:22support while others might not support that meaning themselves.
- 6:29But now how does each state define independence?
- 6:33We're talking about states that register voters by party affiliation.
- 6:37In the previous episode, I mentioned that there are currently 30 states that track voters party
- 6:43affiliation.
- 6:44The other states just register voters, and then that's it.
- 6:46They're just they're just registered.
- 6:49Obviously, in reality, they are typically Democrat or Republican or independent, but
- 6:55they're just not officially registered as one when they register to vote.
- 7:01And all the states that do register voters by party affiliation, they're they all have at
- 7:07least one designation for being what we would consider independent.
- 7:12For nonparty voters, different labels for people of no party.
- 7:16For the most part, they mean the same thing, but there are a couple of exceptions.
- 7:22So Alaska has nonpartisan, which means you registered and you said you have no party or
- 7:28that you're not of any party.
- 7:29And then there's also undeclared, which basically just means I'm registered to vote.
- 7:34I'm not gonna tell you who I'm, affiliated with.
- 7:37I'm not even gonna say that I'm not affiliated with the party.
- 7:40I've just registered, and that's it.
- 7:42So they don't take that extra step of declaring themselves as nonpartisan.
- 7:46They've just registered.
- 7:48California uses unknown and other.
- 7:52Iowa says no party.
- 7:55Kansas, unaffiliated.
- 7:57Massachusetts, unenrolled.
- 8:00And then South Dakota uses independent, and several other states use one or more of those
- 8:08designations themselves.
- 8:10Those are just a few examples of names that you see for people that are not affiliated with a
- 8:16party.
- 8:17There's also NPA in Florida.
- 8:19No party affiliation for, is a short or the abbreviation for no party affiliate.
- 8:27And then for third parties, that if we consider third parties as also independent, it depends
- 8:33on each state's requirements for the formation of third parties.
- 8:38The level of support among voters for that party's formation to become ballot qualified.
- 8:43Ballot qualification means that you can list candidates on the ballot under that party
- 8:50affiliation.
- 8:51So if the Libertarian Party is ballot qualified, it's the most common third party
- 8:55that you see.
- 8:56That means candidates can be listed as libertarians on the ballot.
- 9:02Otherwise, they gotta be a write in or they gotta be a party that is ballot qualified.
- 9:08Now states' laws, requirements could be simply filling a petition to become an organized
- 9:14party.
- 9:15They have to might have to reach a certain threshold of registered voters that say, I am
- 9:21this party.
- 9:23They might need a certain level of support in elections or several other possibilities that
- 9:30there can be.
- 9:32And and parties can also gain or lose ballot qualification status.
- 9:37Democrats or Republicans are the only ones that appear in all 50 states and DC.
- 9:42Even in states where they're they're the Democratic Party or the Republican Party are
- 9:46very weak, they are ballot qualified.
- 9:48Democrats in Wyoming, they exist.
- 9:51Republicans in Hawaii, they exist.
- 9:54And then you also have, we alluded to earlier, some form of ballot qualified independent party
- 10:01or independent party in some states.
- 10:03They have some variation of that name, and you can find those in states such as Connecticut,
- 10:10Florida, Louisiana, Minnesota.
- 10:14And, again, at least a few of those voters mistakenly believed they had to register as
- 10:19that party to be considered not with a party.
- 10:23Think about how we define the independent and what being an independent actually is.
- 10:30Now how many people are registered as independents?
- 10:34Since not every state registers voters by party affiliation and the ones that do sometimes only
- 10:41make public updates of registration counts intermittently, we can't know the exact number
- 10:46of independents at a given time or Democrats or Republicans for that matter.
- 10:52So whatever body, government body handles voter registration numbers, be they a county level
- 11:02election administrator or supervisor of elections or the secretary of state for a
- 11:08state, they have they don't necessarily update every single day.
- 11:14So there's there's some that do, but some of them might only update every month or every,
- 11:21every single, major election that happens, and they so they might only update for primaries
- 11:27and generals instead of throughout the months.
- 11:29It really just depends on where you go.
- 11:31So you can't just go at one point.
- 11:34There's no way to have a repository where you say, okay.
- 11:37This is the exact number of Republicans, Democrats, and Independents that are registered
- 11:43at this moment in time.
- 11:44You can't do that.
- 11:45You can get as close as you possibly can, but it's it's never gonna be a % accurate.
- 11:52But you can at least look at registration numbers for the states that do track party
- 11:57affiliation even though they're unlikely to be representative of the whole country.
- 12:02Several weeks ago or so on this podcast, I talked about how party registration numbers had
- 12:08shifted for some states from the 2020 to the twenty twenty four presidential election.
- 12:15Though, because of differences in how often states publicly update their numbers, Don't
- 12:21know exactly how many voters were eligible to vote in the twenty twenty four election even
- 12:26though those states do track party evaluation because, again, they don't they only
- 12:32intermittently update those numbers.
- 12:36But the numb number of independents based on voter registration around the twenty twenty
- 12:41four election, I tried to get as close as I can based on what seemed to be the most close to
- 12:47numbers, for the date of the election.
- 12:51And keep in mind that these numbers are combining both nonparty and third party voters.
- 12:58So that's the definition I'm using here.
- 13:00Though third party voters make up only a small percentage of these independents.
- 13:05Vast majority of them are gonna actually be no party or unaffiliated or whatever that state
- 13:11uses to to indicate that somebody is an independent.
- 13:14So states that had a plurality of independent voters in the twenty twenty four election,
- 13:19there were nine of those.
- 13:20That was Connecticut, Iowa, barely, Maine, Nevada, New Hampshire, New Jersey, North
- 13:27Carolina, Oregon, and Rhode Island.
- 13:30And then there was a majority of independent voters in Alaska, Colorado, and Massachusetts.
- 13:36So those were three states.
- 13:39Other states where there are more independence than Democrats, but not more than Republicans.
- 13:44We had six states that fit that bill, Arizona, Idaho, Kansas, South Dakota, Utah, and West
- 13:51Virginia.
- 13:52West Virginia.
- 13:55And states where there were more independents than Republicans, but not more than Democrats
- 14:01were in California, Delaware, and New York.
- 14:03So there were three of those states.
- 14:05And then some states where independents actually made the smallest proportion, so they
- 14:11were a smaller proportion than both the Democratic and Republican parties, Florida,
- 14:16Kentucky, Louisiana, Maryland, Nebraska, New Mexico, Oklahoma, Pennsylvania, and Wyoming.
- 14:25And, again, that's just for these states that actually track their voters party affiliation.
- 14:30That's can't really say for sure how many independents are in other states.
- 14:36You might look at public polling data.
- 14:40But, again, that's not a fully exact percentage or those are not fully exact stats on the
- 14:49number of independents in those states.
- 14:51But speaking of that public polling data on independence, polling organizations such as
- 14:58Gallup track party affiliation of citizens.
- 15:02They survey them and ask them, you know, what what they what they identify as.
- 15:07And Gallup's poll is probably the most well known one, and they need to do this in part
- 15:13because, like we said before, not every state tracks party affiliation.
- 15:17So they try to gauge the country at large how the percentage of people that identify as
- 15:23Democrat or independent or in, Republican.
- 15:28And political campaigns also do it to measure the divide in party affiliations in their
- 15:33electorate they are appealing to so that they can craft campaign strategies and tactics.
- 15:38But going back to Gallup, annual numbers here, and they've been measuring this since 1988.
- 15:46There's also quarterly measurements, but for this exercise, just gonna go by what the yearly
- 15:53trends Gallup said they were for both democ for democrats, republicans, and independents.
- 15:59So the specific question in the poll was, in politics, as of today, do you consider yourself
- 16:06a republican, a democrat, or an independent?
- 16:09Now in polling, question wording is vitally important because it can just changing one or
- 16:17two words can completely shift how that poll's results show.
- 16:24And you also gotta be careful of trying to tweak that question over time because it can
- 16:30change their results even if you make a little bit of a difference in how you word it.
- 16:35For example, in politics, as of today, maybe somebody is just, like, one day there's they're
- 16:43very sick of their party, and they say, you know what?
- 16:45I'm an independent, even though they technically didn't actually change their
- 16:49registration.
- 16:51So just little things to keep in mind.
- 16:52Not saying that the wording of this question is wrong.
- 16:56It's just something to keep in mind.
- 16:58And, also, saying, do do you consider yourself a Republican, a Democrat, or an independent?
- 17:03That's not specifically measuring third parties, so you would assume that in this case,
- 17:08third parties are considered independent.
- 17:12Independents in the Gallup poll have almost always been a higher percentage than both
- 17:18Democrats and Republicans, and they've at in each year, have at least been tied with the
- 17:24lower percentage of the two main parties.
- 17:26So maybe it's not as much as Democrats in one year, but it's tied with Republicans.
- 17:31In another year, it might be not as much as Republicans, but it might be tied with
- 17:36Democrats.
- 17:36And, specifically, from 02/2009 to 2024, independents have been at least 37% each year
- 17:45and 43% in specifically in 2023 and 2024.
- 17:52However, Gallup also asks a follow-up to the party ID question.
- 17:59If independent, other party, unsure, or no answer, as of today, do you lean more to the
- 18:07Democratic Party or the Republican Party?
- 18:10So this is where you get a lot of independents who say they are or we call them they don't
- 18:15necessarily say it themselves, but in the in in the biz, we call them Democratic leaners or
- 18:22Republican leaners.
- 18:24And the Gallup numbers for that from 2014 to 2024, initially consistent showing of more
- 18:31democratic leaners than republican leaners.
- 18:33But since the end of 2022, it's been much more often more Republican leaners than Democratic
- 18:40leaners.
- 18:41More Republican leaners than Democratic leaners in seven of the last nine quarters of the year,
- 18:48including quarter four of twenty twenty four.
- 18:52But not you're not necessarily a huge difference between the two.
- 18:57So it's it's it's it's not a lot of independents that are specifically saying,
- 19:03nope.
- 19:03I'm not I'm not I'm not even gonna say that I'm leaning one way or the other.
- 19:09But, you know, you're also going by, you know, what exactly these these people recall.
- 19:17And if they lean towards democratic or republican party, how often often do they lean
- 19:23towards republican or democratic party?
- 19:25Again, some independents actually vote more like a republican or democrat than some
- 19:30democrats or republicans do, but, of course, that's not always the case.
- 19:36As for famous independent candidacies in Us history for this section, independent is gonna
- 19:43be considered non party and third party.
- 19:45And I'm just gonna highlight some of these because I wanna demonstrate the range of what
- 19:51an independent can be depending on who you ask.
- 19:56We have maybe the most famous.
- 20:03Yeah.
- 20:03Well, not maybe not one of the definitely one of the most famous, probably maybe not the most
- 20:08famous.
- 20:09Third party candidacy actually comes from a person who previously was president, Teddy
- 20:15Roosevelt.
- 20:16He was the republican president from nineteen o one to nineteen o nine, and he really tutored,
- 20:24mentored William Taft as his protege, and Taft was supposed to basically carry the torch for
- 20:32Roosevelt's agenda, and he won in nineteen o eight.
- 20:36However, Roosevelt was very dissatisfied with Taft's record and felt he did not carry on his
- 20:44own legacy well enough.
- 20:45And so he ran as a progressive candidate, sometimes nicknamed the bull moose candidate.
- 20:51And so he took a lot of would be Taft voters away from William Taft, and he split the vote
- 20:57to the point where Democrat Woodrow Wilson won pretty handily.
- 21:02Teddy Roosevelt actually got more electoral votes than William Taft did.
- 21:08He won 88 electoral votes, and he won 27.4% of the popular vote.
- 21:13So it's hard it's hard to say for certain, but had it not been for Roosevelt's third party
- 21:18bid, William Taft might have won reelection, and who knows, maybe Woodrow Wilson never
- 21:24becomes president later on.
- 21:28The most probably the most famous third party or independent candidacy, third party or no
- 21:36party, that's probably Ross Perot, specific particularly his nineteen ninety two election
- 21:43campaign.
- 21:44He was a quirky Texas billionaire who made a lot of waves in that election, and his Perot's
- 21:52views you know, we had Teddy Roosevelt here who was a Republican president.
- 21:57Perot's views on issues included both typically conservative and typically liberal stances.
- 22:04For example, he was pro choice regarding abortion, but he also supported the death
- 22:08penalty.
- 22:09So, yeah, on the abortion side, typically a liberal stance, but on the death penalty,
- 22:16typically a conservative stance.
- 22:18He did not capture a single electoral vote.
- 22:21His vote was to diffuse amongst the populace, but he did receive 18.9% of the popular votes.
- 22:30Now did he swing the election one way or the other?
- 22:34Can't really be sure because he really pulled a lot of both would be George h w Bush votes who
- 22:41was the incumbent in that election and also some votes that would have been for democrat
- 22:46Bill Clinton who did go on to win the nineteen ninety two election and then would win
- 22:50reelection in 1996.
- 22:52But Ross Perot's popular vote percentage was the highest for a third party own or no party
- 22:59candidate since Teddy Roosevelt, so sort of a callback to that candidacy.
- 23:07And the last couple examples are going to be actually US senators.
- 23:11So we have Bernie Sanders and Angus King who are current US Senators, Bernie Sanders being
- 23:16for Vermont and Angus King being for Maine, and both caucus with Democrats and definitely lean
- 23:24more to that side, especially Bernie Sanders.
- 23:26And Sanders had, in fact, he did run for the 2016 Democratic nomination for US president.
- 23:35Sanders used to be the mayor of Burlington, Vermont in the nineteen eighties when there was
- 23:40a you started to notice that real shift from Vermont being a more Republican state towards a
- 23:47more Democratic state, And he was also a long time member of The US House prior to being in
- 23:53the US senate, and he's been in the US senate since 02/2007.
- 23:57Angus King, meanwhile, he was the governor of Maine from 1995 to 02/2003, then eventually ran
- 24:03for US senate and won in 2013.
- 24:06He's or excuse me.
- 24:07He won 2012, started serving in 2013, and so he's been in the chamber ever since as well.
- 24:14And this really just goes all all of these examples, Teddy Roosevelt, Ross Perot, Bernie
- 24:23Sanders, and Angus King, just really goes to show how independence can run just a whole
- 24:30spectrum in of independence in terms of parties they affiliate with or have affiliated with in
- 24:36the past and their ideologies.
- 24:38So you ask each one of those guys.
- 24:42Well, I mean, can't ask Teddy Roosevelt or Ross Perot now because they pass.
- 24:48But, you know, if if you were able to ask all of them, all four of those guys, what being an
- 24:54independent is, probably get four different answers much like you could with four random
- 25:01independent voters might get four different answers too.
- 25:05So that's just to give you an idea of just how different the or how how how difficult it can
- 25:13be to truly define what an independent is.
- 25:16When you have a democrat and you have a republican, yes, there's differences, but but
- 25:22within the republican party and differences within the democratic party, we had an episode
- 25:27about that.
- 25:28But you you get a general sense of what they're about because of that party label.
- 25:35Because independence, the label is rather nebulous.
- 25:40It's really hard to inherently get a sense of what that candidate is about.
- 25:46So just some things to keep in mind.
- 25:49Not there's not necessarily a right or wrong answer to what an independent is, But, yeah, it
- 25:57is it is something to keep in mind just how difficult it can be to define it.
- 26:01But that's it for the main topic of the podcast.
- 26:05We've got another random fact of the day for you.
- 26:08And that random fact of the day is, did you know that US Senators and some states governors
- 26:16were previously chosen by state legislatures?
- 26:22So it's a little more well known that US Senators were once chosen by state
- 26:26legislatures.
- 26:27Originally, the framers of the constitution had set it up so that US Senators were appointed by
- 26:33the state legislatures, And that was until the seventeenth amendment was ratified in 1913,
- 26:39changing it so that US Senators were chosen by popular vote similarly to the US House.
- 26:48It was one of a couple of US constitutional amendments that passed during the progressive
- 26:53era in US history, which was a time of major economic and political reforms as well.
- 27:03But the term lengths for US Senators stayed at six years.
- 27:07Now for governors, this is much lesser known that some governors also were once chosen by
- 27:13state legislators.
- 27:14Not every state did it.
- 27:15In fact, quite a only a few actually did that.
- 27:20There are, in fact, seven states that use this method at some point in time.
- 27:25You had Delaware prior to 1792, Louisiana before 1845, Maryland before 1838, New Jersey
- 27:34before 1844, North Carolina before 1836, South Carolina before 1865, and Virginia before 1851.
- 27:45So it had died out.
- 27:46The practice had died out to have governors appointed by state legislatures by the mid
- 27:53eighteen sixties.
- 27:54And Kentucky governors in 1792 and 1796 were also not elected by popular vote, but they were
- 28:03elected through a specially elected body of electors instead of the state legislature.
- 28:08So they were a a different system than even those states were.
- 28:15So just interesting little little tidbits here and there.
- 28:19So you when you look back at, US election history, there's some kinda wacky compared to
- 28:27today, some really wacky, methods of, just political administration in general, but
- 28:37nonetheless fascinating.
- 28:38So that is gonna do it for today's podcast.
- 28:41As always, thank you so much for listening.
- 28:43Please like, comment, subscribe, share these episodes with people you know.
- 28:50Links in the show notes.
- 28:52I have the my Facebook, my LinkedIn, my my book, which I, had just referenced earlier, and
- 29:03there's part of a huge reason why I even did this episode.
- 29:08Just gives you a taste of what's to come in the book.
- 29:11It's available on Amazon and ebook and paperback format.
- 29:15Why independence rarely win elections and how they become could become more competitive and
- 29:22and several other links in the show notes as well.
- 29:26So as always, thank you so much for listening, and until next time, take care.